Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

First One

First One artwork

Live with Steve Vladeck on the Supreme Court USPS opinion

Sep 15, 202630 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Hi, everyone. Harry here. Big Supreme Court opinion and doesn't get any better than being able to talk to Steve Vladeck at that time, Georgetown prof and general Supreme Court smarty guy. Steve, thanks as always for being here. We've just had a few minutes to digest the opinion, but to me it's sort of interesting. It gets pretty technical and arcane pretty quickly when you get past the top line.

SPEAKER_02Let me just start here before we try to dive into the weeds a little. How big a deal is this opinion? The administration's always going for emergency applications. This one seemed to be of unusual focus. How important in the scheme of things do you assess this as being?

SPEAKER_00You know, it's the right question, Harry. I think the problem is that the answer is going to depend on what happens next. I think it's really important that the Supreme Court tonight That should mean that we don't see interference with mail-in voting this cycle. But Harry, I think the real question is, what about in 2028? And, you know, I think that's,

SPEAKER_00If anything, the signs are worrisome in the other direction, partly because of Justice Alito's dissent and partly because of Justice Kavanaugh's very brief concurrence where he suggests that he thought that the Postal Service has statutory authority to issue a rule like this. So I think, Harry, it's a big deal in that it preserves the status quo for now and is not going to inject all of this chaos into mail-in voting, which, by the way, is underway in some states. Right. But, you know,

SPEAKER_00in that respect, like the good news may have a relatively limited shelf life and the big fight, I think, is still to come.

SPEAKER_02All right, fair enough. And there are two leaves that we can get into. I want to just take, this is an opposing view, but I want to stress why I thought it was so important. I think in general, even focused on the midterms, the strategy of the administration, Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And the midterms.

SPEAKER_00Again, it's the biggest bullet to dodge for now. And I think you're right, and it's worth not glossing over the punchline. And the bullet was dodged. Does this mean that this is, The last we're going to see of efforts by this administration to mess with how at least some people vote, right, in November, you know, I don't think so. Of course not, right, yeah.

SPEAKER_00But I will say, I mean, the one thing I'm heartened by in, you know, because let's be the majority wrote very little, right? There's like a one, there's one real sentence and it's not even really that much analysis. I'm heartened a bit by one part of Justice Kavanaugh's concurrence, which is that the reason why he concurred was that he thought it would be arbitrary and capricious to put this rule into effect so close to the election. Um, We haven't heard that before from Justice Kavanaugh.

SPEAKER_00And, you know, that gives me at least some hope, Harry, that like he would be similarly willing to leave in place district court injunctions against other 11th hour mishigas by the Trump administration, right? So, you know, it's part of the problem, Harry, is there are so many moving parts because we don't know what else the administration might try. It's a big setback for the administration for now. But I think, again, the for now is doing a lot of work here.

SPEAKER_02So true. And the bag of tricks is really big and going to get even bigger. But, okay, I want to get to trying to tease out those tea leaves. But let's just start with the majority. First, it's a per curiam or an unsigned opinion. And there are two sentences. The government is unlikely to succeed on the merits of its challenge to the preliminary injunction. And the equitable factors applicable for obtaining emergency relief do not favor a stay.

SPEAKER_02Let me just ask you about that first sentence. Do we know that that means, since only Kavanaugh, Alito, and Thomas identify separately, that six members of the court have opined at the stay level, but that on the merits... There's a challengers would be likely to show that the government lacks authority on the substantive issue to promulgate the rule. Or is that an over reading?

SPEAKER_00I think the fact that that sentence is in the order, Harry, is a big deal. I don't know about six, but I do think that at least five justices must believe that for the court to have written that. And I'm pretty sure Kavanaugh is not one of them, right, given what he wrote in his concurrence. And so that leads me to think that there are five justices other than Justice Kavanaugh Who believe that on the merits, the government is not likely to win. And, you know, Harry, I can, I can, I, I,

SPEAKER_00the first five I can think of, right, are the three Democratic appointees, the Chief Justice and Justice Barrett. You know, I think the interesting question is, where's Gorsuch here? But we don't know. So, yes, I think you are right. When you say we don't know, sorry to

SPEAKER_02interrupt you. We don't know. For all we know, it's only five. Is that right? Because of the way it's given? You know, where, where would Gorsuch be if not here?

SPEAKER_00So I guess let me say, let me start. We know for a fact that there are two public assets, right? Alito and Thomas and Alito, right? We know for a fact that at least five justices think the government's likely to lose on the merits. And we know for a fact that Kavanaugh isn't one of them. Right? So those are the three things we know. From that, we can glean that it was either 6-3 or 7-2, but we can't be sure about which one.

SPEAKER_00But Harry, the critical point that I hope folks understand is that sentence is unusual. We don't usually see the court say that. Unless it is saying more. It is rare to see the court write a sentence that basically pours cold water on the merits without telling us why. Usually they tell us either less or they tell us more. And that to me, Harry, is a message from whoever those five or six justices are, right? That they are not gonna, you know, that they think this case is a loser.

SPEAKER_00Now, I will say, you know, lots of media reports are saying it was seven to two. Um, It might have been. But, you know, this is just one of the quirks of dealing with any of these rulings that the Supreme Court hands down through orders, which is you can't be sure unless you can account for all of them. And we can't here. So I don't mean to get lost in the weeds here. At least six justices, right, voted for the stay. We know that because we know five signed on to the order plus Plus Kavanaugh, right?

SPEAKER_00And that's a big deal because that suggests, Harry, as I was saying, that like I think more attempts by the administration to meddle in the election might provoke similar reactions from this court. And we had no reason to believe that. We had not seen this court really put its thumb down and say, no, President Trump, we're not going to let you do this kind of, you know, late breaking election moves. That to me is probably the biggest upside, right, of what the court did tonight.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I want to say we maybe had slight. I talked about this last week. The Missouri case, 9-0. They all agreed. To me, it portended a focus on something I think may well have happened here, which is they not only say they're legislated. You're likely to lose on the merits, but they say the other factors, and you're right, they didn't have to write anything, and they often don't. So here, both points were made, you're likely to lose, but all the other stuff, and without going too deeply into it, because I want to get into that. The question you're framing is the most important.

SPEAKER_02We had briefs come up here and a series of scholars that said, forget about the merits. The balance of equities, which is one of the four things that the administration would need to show to reverse things, now are overwhelmingly in favor of the challengers because it would be bedlam for to actually apply this rule now, and that's all you need to know. Many prominent scholars, your colleague Marty Lederman said it, and I think, and I also thought the Missouri case maybe suggested that all

SPEAKER_02of them were somewhat focused, and we'll get to even Alito in a moment, but on this very strong practical problem that merits aside, man, what a mess to let this go through now.

SPEAKER_00So I agree with all of that. I'm sure you're not surprised to hear me say that. Harry, as you know, like one of the biggest issues So I guess what I want to say is like, I found that

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Harry, which makes you wonder, what have they been doing for the last 18 months?

SPEAKER_02Well, that's right. I mean, how can, and they really have been, I think, slipshod in several of these factors. All right, so look, the two headlines, I will reiterate what we've said so far, pretty damn important, but only for 2021. And both statements made, a majority of the Supreme Court says, you're not likely to prevail on the merits, administration, plus the other factors weigh against you. So that's really pretty solid for now. And I think we can say,

SPEAKER_02based on this, we're not going to see any other huge upending of all the bowling pins going into the election. Little things, yeah. But let's now go to your point. And I want to start here. And everyone, this does get a little inside baseball unavoidably, but we're going to keep it at the level, I think, the most sort of clear level. But I want to start here. Alito and Thomas say, hey, well, first,

SPEAKER_02Alito and Thomas do not say, let me, in fact, serve this question up to you independently, Steve, to see if you agree. Do not say four square, the authority is there. They say, these guys don't have standing. And this claim has to be presented to be overwhelmingly clear. But they literally disavow. They never say flat out in contradiction to the sentence we identified in the curt first paragraph that the Postal Service could flat out do this

SPEAKER_02under any standard of review. Am I right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I think that's a fair reading of the opinion. I do think that they are much more generous in how they interpret the relevant statutes to the Postal Service's authority than, you know, I think is deserved. But Harry so, I think, is Kavanaugh. I mean, Kavanaugh seems to be saying that he's not convinced it's beyond USPS's statutory authority. What is stunning about the election Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Here comes Alito saying, no, the equity is totally cut in favor of the president. Like, it is really striking because it is so transparently clear that if the president had a D in parentheses after his name, Alito would not find the equities remotely persuasive. And, you know, I don't think anyone's especially surprised, Harry, to find Alito and Thomas on this side of this case. But it is really, really... Striking to read what it looks like to twist yourself into a pretzel in order to try

SPEAKER_00to get to, you know, rationalizing voting for a state in this case.

SPEAKER_02I mean, I got to agree on this point because it had really been served up in the past. They have been slipshod. They've let irreparable harm be, oh, well, the government can't put its policy into action. That can't be irreparable harm. But here there's a focus. And They look like crackpots. I don't want to be too focused on it even, but no balance of equities here. They do it only for a couple sentences, but it really is just a kind of announcement that maybe with those two anyway,

SPEAKER_02anything goes. Let's go back to Kavanaugh. Well, go ahead. Sure.

SPEAKER_00Just really quickly. I mean, I think, like, again— Anything goes at least in the service of granting emergency relief to President Trump. That's pretty damn close to anything goes, right? That's how things will calm down. I agree. I mean, they didn't dissent in the Missouri case on Thursday, right? I take that friendly amendment, but that's a very big statement. Agreed. But, you know, I wonder, Harry, again, to go back to the thing, I wonder if the dissent was so thick Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I don't know, but I mean, Harry, let's be real. No one was ever counting on Thomas's or Alito's votes, right, against the Trump administration.

SPEAKER_02That's right. Yeah. And even more, they were counting on almost anything goes. Right.

SPEAKER_00So you're right to go back to Kavanaugh's. I think that's the more interesting question.

SPEAKER_02And by the way, I read Kavanaugh's as pretty clearly not endorsing those two statements that you're— I invoke as a concur, you know— And his last sentence says, I'm the bottom line with you, but don't count me in on those two sentences. But look, this gets a little fine-grained, but what Alito and Thomas, one of their sort of tenets of their opinion in saying, and they cobbled together These guys don't have standing.

SPEAKER_02This has to be broader. But they specifically assert that the APA does not provide a cause of action here for the state attorneys general to try to dispute what they're calling the statutory claim of Congress. I just want to be clear. Kavanaugh says the exact opposite, right? He is saying in his concurring opinion, this would be arbitrary and capricious under APA review and therefore implicitly

SPEAKER_02at complete loggerheads with Thomas and Alito, or is that overstated?

SPEAKER_00I think it's a little overstated. So I think, you know, you and I talked about this before. I think the justices are often... I'm sorry, go for it. Right, got it. I think what he was trying to say is that there is and should be a valid procedural objection under the APA to the final rule, but not a valid substantive like ultra-virus claim against the final rule, right?

SPEAKER_00I think what he's trying to say is that like had the rule been adopted in a Yeah. Right. That it happened in a way that was likely to produce chaos on the ground. And I guess, Harry,

SPEAKER_00all I'll say to that is that is actually quite classical equities balancing, right? Like that he won't bring himself to say it because he has been so critical.

SPEAKER_02That's the alternative, right? In saying the words APA, he's really saying balance of equities by any other term. But Steve, even I'm not pushing back as much as asking that. Even if it's just the procedural part of the APA, it's the APA. Do Thomas and Alito not say you can't get there with the APA, that funnel is unavailable, and Kavanaugh gets there with the APA. Is that fair?

SPEAKER_00Yes, but Harry, he gets there with the APA already. Right. Right. Then what happens when the administration wants the same rule,

SPEAKER_00but now it doesn't have the procedural problems of the APA? So there's the question of whether the APA even applies to the Postal Service that Kavanaugh, I think, jumped over. You know, all of this is just to say that I think there's a lot to still be resolved in the litigation in this case. And I think the reality is that this is going to be a big fight come next year. 100% fair. But it's a big fight that will happen next year. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00But it's a big fight that will be next year, not this year.

SPEAKER_02I totally, yeah. 100% fair. And part of the fight, it's clear if you look carefully at the Alino-Thomas opinions, will be who brings the case? Will we actually be in one of these, you know, constitutional Mobius strips or knots where, oh, it could be illegal, but nobody can actually challenge. Right. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Does a Democratic-controlled Congress defund the Postal Service's ability to enforce this rule?

SPEAKER_02And do they have to go to the mat in that way? Okay, so let's get paranoid at the end. It's a good day. I thought they, as I say, dodged a big bullet, but let's go to your concrete concerns. First, let's take a step back. I mean, every time this has come up and you can read, I thought the very thorough and methodical district court opinion, the basic thing is, You got to be kidding. This is for the states, a little bit for Congress, zero for the executive.

SPEAKER_02And even the Alito opinions seem to be suggesting somehow they could try to massage out authority from Congress. So let's play it out with all the sort of exigencies and chaos removed. And we are now in next summer. And so what about that? What is the possible, I'll put it a different way. Can this court,

SPEAKER_02and starting a sentence that way, like when your children ask you, can any is, you know, very open-ended, but how can this court green light this exercise of authority and would it necessitate? Necessarily depend on some kind of construction of what Congress had done in such and such a statute or, you know, indulge a little bit more, at least just for argument's sake,

SPEAKER_02the concrete battle on the merits that will ensue once the immediate hubbub of it's too late balance of equities is off the table.

SPEAKER_00So I guess I want to say two things. I think the first is if this case gets to the Supreme Court cleanly on the merits, I still think there are at least five votes to hold that the U.S. Postal Service doesn't have the authority to issue the rule that it issued. And I think that that's the import of the second to last sentence of that of the majority's order. Yeah. I also think we should indulge the possibility that the case never gets to the court

SPEAKER_00on the merits, either because the administration comes back in January and tries something different, like a modified rule that tries to find different authority arguments, I don't know about changes in lower or heightened, but just like, you know, we're probably going to live in a very different political reality come January

SPEAKER_00than we're in today. And I have to think that that's going to have some influence on Right. Right. Right. Right. Right. Well, I think maybe given the opposite.

SPEAKER_02Okay, so let's close it out with this. I mean, you know, it's funny, but I'm going to go back to 1950s and the steel seizure case. But in particular, if the Congress has changed, we know that the argument for this kind of authority would be at its lowest ebb, really, really, really weak. So the Congress wouldn't need simply to withdraw funding. It could just somehow in one way or another say,

SPEAKER_02we don't think you have this authority to do this. And that should, in theory, is that fair, change how the court goes about

SPEAKER_01deciding the merits come next summer? I'm not here silent.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm not. Sorry. Uh-oh. You're good. You're good. Okay. So, I mean, yes, Harry, I think that could matter. But again, I mean, I think the court has already signaled that it doesn't think the Postal Service has the authority now. And so, you know, the question is, does the administration try to do something to shore up the foundation for the rule between now and next summer? But again, I mean, I don't want to lose the forest for the trees, right? The forest here is that the Supreme Court I think quite rightly,

SPEAKER_00but also to some degree surprisingly, has shown itself actually willing to assert itself against Trump in the context of elections. And we won't know what the flashpoint is for the next one of these cases. But to me, it is remarkably heartening that I think we can count to five without Kavanaugh and six with Kavanaugh. To not pull a stump like this, at least this close to the elections again. And so, you know, it's a, Harry,

SPEAKER_00it's a different case when we're talking about, you know, a year and a half out from the elections, right? Versus, you know, as people are starting to vote. And I think the justices, you know, you and I have worried that the justices have not sufficiently calibrated themselves to this moment. And here tonight, we have a ruling that seems very well calibrated to this moment.

SPEAKER_02Great. And I want to almost end on that in exclamation point, but let's go one more hardening because even your time, I understand you always have to worry what could be around the corner with this court. But again, as of today, five are saying, and at least five are saying, you will lose on the merits. And presumably, if this came about before, unless the merits have really changed, Pretty good day, yeah?

SPEAKER_00I mean, you know, it's a pretty good day. It says a lot about where we are, and I think a lot of folks were surprised. I will say, I am not, Harry, surprised by this ruling, and I'm not surprised by what happened in Missouri. I mean, two things can be true at once. This court has done a lot of, to my view, problematic things on the emergency docket, including but not limited to benefiting President Trump. And there are still justices who are committed to at least what they believe is

SPEAKER_00the rule of law. And you and I might draw that line in a very different place than those justices do. And they may be wrong a lot. But that's not the same thing as saying they're completely in the bad for Trump and will do whatever he wants. And I think it's nice to have reminders of that. The harder question, Harry, is then what are the rationales for the cases where they're behaving differently? Is it really just because this was about literally messing with a federal election?

SPEAKER_00And everything else is coached. Like, you know, this is the same court that just let him, you know, do his thing with the ballroom. And so what explains one and not the other? And I'll say, you know, I think one can make the case that there's a big difference between letting Trump build his ballroom and letting Trump mess with voting. And, you know, I don't know that the law supports that distinction, but better that distinction than none at all.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, there's such ultimate existential questions here that you feel like the consequences, even apart from the fine points. And I do want to say both you and I, and we were far from unanimous, there were people on the other side, were pretty sanguine that something like this could happen. Anyway, it has. Great talking to you in the aftermath. And yeah, I think for the midterms, You know, this is probably dead, but as you say, many, many other little irons in the fire.

SPEAKER_00Steve Vladeck. To quote Uncle Max from Princess Bride, mostly dead.

SPEAKER_02Right, exactly. As you wish, Mr. Vladeck. Okay. Thank you so much. Hope to talk to you soon about this and other stuff. And everybody, by the way, Steve had to like take time off while he's traveling, talking to judges. So really, really a great service to the Fed heads of the world. Thank you so much. And talk to you later.

SPEAKER_00Thanks, Harry.

SPEAKER_01Thanks for joining us, everybody.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Court Against the Courts: A Conversation With Jack Goldsmith

    Nov 20, 202637 minAudio

    As I noted in Monday’s post, the Harvard Law Review’s annual Supreme Court issue, including my Foreword - “The Court Against the Courts” - came out last week. On Thursday, November 20, I sat down with Harvard law...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The new Democratic majorities -- and the Courts, with Chris Cillizza and Steve Vladeck

    Nov 11, 202648 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. First One: A Run on the Bank—Why Weil Fell

    Nov 10, 202640 minAudio

    In this episode of “First One,” the (fairly irregular) podcast companion to the “One First” newsletter, Steve sat down with Karen Vladeck (a lawyer-turned-legal recruiter and the founder and managing director of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Missouri Mess: Live with Cristian Farias and Steve Vladeck

    Sep 22, 202619 minAudio

    On Tuesday morning, Cristian Farias and I got together for a quick Substack Live to discuss the goings-on in the Missouri redistricting case - including what happened in the Eighth Circuit on Monday and what’s likely to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Live with Joyce Vance & Steve Vladeck: Trump v. California

    Aug 25, 202623 minAudio

    This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe

    Credit the people on this episode