SCOTUS Talk with Chris Cillizza and Steve Vladeck!
47 minAudio
This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01hey everybody i am thrilled that i get to do this occasionally my favorite i didn't tell steve this but my favorite Substack live to do is with steve we do it once every i don't know two six weeks two months or so because i learn a lot you know it which is really nice so you are looking at steve vladeck who among many other things is the agnes williams sesquicentennial professor of federal courts at the georgetown university he is also the author of one first
SPEAKER_01a absolutely terrific Substack that if you have not checked out uh you need to on all things supreme court and constitution related uh he is a a a gigantic resource i think for anyone who is interested in this stuff and i get steve to come back by uh by uh praising him over the moon no but it is i i believe every word of it um
SPEAKER_00all right so steve i also i mean it it it also helps that like the mets are not watchable
SPEAKER_01so i have all yes i i sent my i sent my uh my friend jed donnie who who is the other who i went to college with who's the other prominent very long-suffering mets fan other than you that i know i sent him a thing about the mets payroll versus wins it's really uh i mean because the the nationals are obviously in the nl east with the mets so i see a fair number of mets games and i mean you got an all-star in juan soto i guess i mean between the mets and
SPEAKER_00the supreme court june was a lot of fun for me yeah really a busy time
SPEAKER_01so i reached out to steve last week and i i you know after the the court ended uh it's it's session i said hey let's let's do uh let's do a look back and a look back and a look forward so steve let's start with a look back and let's start at like the 50 000 foot level right we can go into individual cases and you're so good on that feel free to take this where you want but i do want to start the 50 000 foot level what do we three months ago when you talked we talked you said look what happens
SPEAKER_01in these next three months is going to tell us a lot about sort of the court executive power trump and what he can do so tell us what you think we've learned based on the judgments that we got the rulings that we got
SPEAKER_00uh what have we learned um i think we learned chris something that a lot of us already knew which is that on almost all of its biggest cases and its most important cases this is a court that is defined by its political and ideological composition um you know just just right off the bat i mean the the supreme court handed down i think 55 or 56 rulings this term um the most common lineup other than nine nothing was six three and
SPEAKER_00the most common six three lineup was the six you would expect so you know this term there were 13 different rulings in argued cases that had all six republican appointees in the majority and all three democratic appointees in dissent that's more than twice as many as last term when we already spent a lot of time talking about how political this court is so you know that's I think point number one point number two and I think this is where you've seen some friction in the commentary at over
SPEAKER_00the last week is you know there are a lot of folks who are inclined to be very defensive of the court who point very very quickly to the big losses president trump suffered this term and
SPEAKER_01that was me i will i mean i i said look you know on tariffs and on birthright the things it seems i wasn't getting names most no it's fine i'm i look i always say to people i don't have a monopoly on good ideas and in this case or right analysis that's why i wanted to talk to you go ahead
SPEAKER_00so i mean right you said tariffs and birthright citizenship i would add um the illinois national guard case um from december i would add um the lisa cook case even though that was a very very small loss and even though that's a numerator not a denominator um trump won a bunch too
SPEAKER_00but two i also i don't think that the only question about this court is whether it's completely in the bag for trump i think you know there's as you know as well as anybody there's meaningful daylight between trump and the sort of heart of the conservative legal establishment yes and i think that you know the fact that that showed up a couple of times this term doesn't tell us that the court is somehow less conservative than we thought it just tells us it's not quite as trumpy exactly that's well as maybe we feared
SPEAKER_00and i'll just say and even and chris and even then i mean look at the cases i mentioned right so tariffs illinois national guard birthright citizenship and cook birthright citizenship cook and mail-in ballots chris those were all five four um yeah right on the at least on the constitutional question in birthright citizenship so you know not a trumpy court but only by the thinnest of margins yeah do you
SPEAKER_01when you look at this steve i think the you're right the the two analyses i see is from the left is okay well they didn't do everything trump said but they did a lot of what he said and then from the right and i want you to talk to this is those sons of bitch amy coney barrett and brett kavanaugh you know aren't with us as much as they should be we need more justices like thomas and alito right like tell me the left piece of it gets a lot of attention i feel like we don't talk enough about the right piece
SPEAKER_01of it can you talk about that a little bit yeah i mean
SPEAKER_00so it is wild you know i i mean i i pay a fair amount of attention to how the right wing media ecosystem talks about the supreme court um and it is wild just how quickly the knives came out for justice barrett last week week chris based solely on the mail-in ballots ruling um which honestly was you know to me a relatively easy statutory interpretation case with no broader constitutional implications um meanwhile right meanwhile she's in dissent in Cook.
SPEAKER_01even though to your point i just let me put a pin in that even though to your point and i think the the point you make about there is you said meaningful daylight between donald trump and the heart of the conservative legal establishment that's so true right donald trump is not a conservative in any meaningful way particular vis-a-vis the court right amy coney barrett saying the statutory sort of you know the the what the law says is what the law says on mail-in balloting is actually quite
SPEAKER_01a conservative legal view correctly it's not what donald trump agrees with but that's not the same thing go ahead sorry to interrupt you
SPEAKER_00no no that's that's all that's all right chris and and i guess what i would just say is um it's interesting because you know the average person who sees both of these media ecosystems might say oh well then the court must not be that bad if everyone's angry at it it's like right it's the uh it's the it's the old judge who says you know well both sides are mad at me i must be right no sometimes both sides are mad at you because you're completely wrong right
SPEAKER_01and that's by the way the old reporter defense well if the left and the right are mad at me i must be doing something right it possibly but also you could be totally wrong right that's the problem right
SPEAKER_00or you could just be out on a out on a lark um yeah and so i guess you know this is what complicates any effort to distill the current supreme court which is you know there is a large group of folks on the right who think that the own that basically every ruling must come out the way that makes sense for them politically or else it's invalid and there are a large tranche of people on the left who think every ruling is basically invalid anyway um right and so you know trying to find nuance in this conversation where it's like actually the court's doing a lot
SPEAKER_00of to my view right deeply flawed problematic in some cases unprincipled things it's hard to cut through that noise because people assume it's either everything or nothing and it's like well what if it's just like more than it should be
SPEAKER_01well let's i want to pull on that that thread what and you've for people who have seen us talk before you've talked some about this but i you know i always i always want to be mindful the fact that people may be new to this talk about talk about what you think this uh term of the court told us to your point about some of the things they're doing that may be more problematic long term but the people to your point about like i i think of the mail-in balloting ruling in your world is the way i think of the gulf of america thing
SPEAKER_01in my world do i think it's do i don't really give a shit what they call it gulf america i think it's dumb i don t think it has any real implications i think he's doing a ton of other things that are much more concerning but that gets a
SPEAKER_00well so so i mean this is a great it's a great setup because the mail-in ballots ruling came down last monday right so the second to last day that we got decisions from the court um across monday and tuesday there were seven rulings um and if we just sort of bracket the very nerdy technical fourth amendment case for a second right the other six were all i think ideologically charged in some i mean the fourth one was two but in ways that i think would take too long to explain um yeah so think about how much attention the mail and ballots ruling got chris in contrast to tuesday's
SPEAKER_00decision in nrsc versus fec coordinated party expenditures case where you know i would argue that's probably the most important campaign finance ruling out of the court since citizens united itself yeah um and you have a 6-3 majority again the usual suspects striking down federal laws limits on coordinated party expenditure something near and dear to your universe than mine but something that as you know it's a huge deal yeah and it's something the court had specifically upheld in 2001 um right and so
SPEAKER_00so you have you know on consecutive days again bracketing mail-in ballots you have the court in the slaughter case right ditching this 90 year old precedent to allow president trump to fire you know almost every senior executive official who he wants and the very next day you have the court scrapping a 25 year old precedent right as a way of sort of clearing the way for more coordination when it comes to expenditures between candidates and the national parties and so you know those are enormous deals that maybe just aren't quite as visible
SPEAKER_00and immediately obvious to the person on the street and so they don't get as much attention
SPEAKER_01yeah i i totally uh agree i mean i would say in the same way that i know the court would say they didn't undo the voting rights act with the louisanna versus cali ruling i would i would suggest that they did right uh this that that ruling on the nrsc the coordinated uh limits uh i think effectively undoes it's one of the last things that undoes mccain feingold you know i mean it's been it's been whittling away but it's it's similar okay i do want to talk to you steve
SPEAKER_01before i want i definitely want to talk about going forward too but before we do that i do want to talk about by the way you were right in terms of your predictions of of how the court would rule you said you they would find against trump on birthright citizenship against him on cook on the excuse me on the uh fed board of governors case but with him on the broader independent agencies so you you you were right on a lot of these big cases can we talk about and i always say people love to point out
SPEAKER_01when you're you or i people love to point out when you're wrong so i like to point out when you were right um let's talk about the birthright citizenship case i want to talk about birthright citizenship um because that felt like the big one that was so the biggest one people paying attention that was outstanding what if anything surprised you i know you you had said from the start it's very unlikely they're going to do this but what surprised you if anything
SPEAKER_00so i mean chris i got one big thing wrong um and and i actually got it wrong twice which is in both the birthright citizenship case and i'm gonna throw in lisa cook too although we'll talk more about the former um you know i walked out of the oral arguments in those cases pretty convinced that they wouldn't be close um and you know part of why i was so confident about the predictions the last time you and i spoke was because you know my read of the oral arguments in both of those cases with that was that they were lopsided um and so you know you might recall with tariffs i was like somewhat confident
SPEAKER_00with lewis but the argument was not as one-sided and so i you know it was harder to be sort of emphatic about that um these arguments chris ended up not accurately telling us where the court was going to end up because both of those cases were much closer than the arguments were so you know birthright citizenship i walked out of it thinking it was seven to two with alito and thomas being the dissenters and you know and and and you know the the sort of trump ended up with gorsuch and kavanaugh on
SPEAKER_00the constitutional question kavanaugh go out of his way right to not to it so kavanaugh writes this opinion concurrent in the judgment where he says i agree that the executive order is unlawful because it violates the statutes congress has written um chris the typical justice would stop there and say so i don't have to reach any bigger question kind of goes out of his way to say but in a hypothetical world where congress were to pass this as a statute I don't
SPEAKER_00um of assuming that the oral arguments really are predictive because you know yeah we got the results right but actually that we got the margins wrong and you know both of those cases ended up being much nearer run things
SPEAKER_01than i expected yeah uh last one on the current court what's the what was the biggest decision when i say biggest i don't mean one that got the most attention what is the decision and feel free to go nerdy here steve if you want what that's why we got john what is the decision that you believe will have the the biggest impact uh out of the cases that the 55
SPEAKER_00or 56 cases that they ruled on this year
SPEAKER_01can i cheat and give you two answers of course that's like a classic reporterism let me let me answer that
SPEAKER_00in two ways go ahead i well i'm gonna call it a tie um so so let me start with immediate human impact so for immediate human impact um the temporary protected status cases um under the caption mullen versus doe because what that rule to sort of nutshell for folks who who don't have these cases committed to memory this is about whether uh president trump can cancel or otherwise revoke temporary protected status for individuals from countries with really really bad current conditions without having to sort of dot
SPEAKER_00the statutory i's and cross the statutory t's and in the haiti case chris in a context in which president trump has says all kinds of pretty openly racist stuff
SPEAKER_01about haiti yeah i mean he that is one of the places he referred to as a shithole country in his first term
SPEAKER_00correct so um that ruling right where the court says in general federal courts can't review statutory challenges to tps decisions and where the court sort of said there was no constitutional problem with trump's racism um right that ruling will immediately affect um you know 350 000 haitians who go from not being subject to immediate detention arrest and removal to you know being subject to that um it'll affect about 6 000 syrians but chris if you apply to all of the countries
SPEAKER_00where the administration's acted against tps it's 17 countries and more than 1.5 million people so for immediate human costs it's very hard to top that um for long-term like separation of powers costs i also think it's a no-brainer i think it's slaughter um you know the sort of
SPEAKER_01and explain to people what one that was just very quickly sorry so slaughters
SPEAKER_00the agency's case and so this is the case where president where the court said all of these statutes that say presidents cannot remove federal trade commissioners or securities and exchange commissioners or federal communications commissioners without cause that all those statutes are unconstitutional and in the process the court overruled this 91 year old precedent that had unanimously held otherwise um chris is a huge deal for two reasons one it clears the way for trump to just go completely after the top of
SPEAKER_00the federal bureaucracy not just cabinet departments but every agency uh asterisk except for the federal reserve see lisa cook right right but every agency now you know is going to be sent to the direct political control of the president and let's let's take a beat to talk about why that matters take the merit systems protection board an agency no one outside of washington has ever heard of correct um right this is an agency that exists chris as you know for the sole purpose of providing some kind of independent um mechanism
SPEAKER_00to adjudicate workplace disputes within the federal government on the theory that we don't want the people who are on one side of the workplace disputes to control the agency that adjudicates the workplace disputes not crazy seems
SPEAKER_01to make sense
SPEAKER_00okay that agency is now subject to the president's immediate complete control and indeed the new york times reported last week on how this administration has influenced the mspb and put a thumb on the scale on some pretty big questions basically to whitewash chris some of the unlawful employment practices right that the government's engaged in so that's a real world example how it's going to matter but there's a second level on which slaughter is going to matter which is the theory the majority embraced to get there the so-called unitary executive theory opens the door for trump to go after
SPEAKER_00almost every other for long-term structure of government you know slaughter is i called it in one
SPEAKER_00of my posts in my newsletter a nuclear bomb um even though it may not we may not feel those effects immediately and for short-term human consequences i don't think you can top
SPEAKER_01the tps cases yeah okay i want to one other one from the comments uh i do want to raise this andrew steel says calais in his mind which is for people who don't know is the uh well you you describe you're going to describe it better than me calais versus louisiana what talk about that one what why
SPEAKER_00that didn't make your top two so i mean only because i mean so chris one of the problems of covering the supreme court in this day and age um is that you know every day is is is the super bowl um right which is right
SPEAKER_01which is covering politics
SPEAKER_00yeah that's right which is say like calais is an enormous ruling and in any other term would have been the defining ruling of the term and in this term you know maybe is fifth um yeah and and that's not because it's less important it's because the court is sort of you know suffused with all of these high importance cases um really quickly so in calais the court held that to show a violation of the central provision of the voting rights act section two plaintiffs have to show that a state drew its congressional districts this is in
SPEAKER_00the specific context of redistricting with the intent Chris of diluting black votes and not just the effect and so right it's not enough to show that a state like Louisiana drew its maps in a way that will dilute black votes you have to persuade a federal judge that that was the reason why they did it and in an era of widespread partisan gerrymandering yep it's very easy for a state like louisiana say no no no we weren't diluting black votes we were diluting
SPEAKER_00democratic votes and oh what a coincidence that there's this parity in large swaths of central louisiana um yep that is a huge deal overlay on top
SPEAKER_01of one another right correct
SPEAKER_00so listen that's it was a huge deal the day it came down in april it became an even bigger deal because the supreme court over the next five weeks went out of its way to put that ruling into immediate effect so that it could be exploited and used during this election cycle and chris i think it would have looked different if the court had done the exact same thing in calais and then told everyone to wait until 2028 yeah um
SPEAKER_01well we saw tennessee tennessee alabama i mean they they all moved off
SPEAKER_00after calais right um and louisiana um and louisiana right right so i think there are sort of two sets i think there's a substantive problem with calais which is gutting the voting rights act which congress i think could to some degree fix although how much so i think is a messier question but chris i think the other part of calais the procedural stuff is the zeal with which again the six republican appointees really bent over backwards and in some cases like inconsistently applied their own rules to get that decision
SPEAKER_00on you know immediately on the books in a way that would be operable this cycle where you know had the court just sort of shown any restraint the substantive part of the ruling might not have bitten as sharply mm-hmm
SPEAKER_01right even if they had said we're ruling on this but nothing can be nothing can go
SPEAKER_00into place until it's too late for the cycle right which which by the way is that is that is the justification the court has deployed over and over and over again to justify pausing lower court rulings in lots of cases that benefited democratic voters and so right what what you and i know is the purcell principle and so the the notion that the purcell principle would just get thrown out the window in a series of cases that oh you know what a coincidence happened to benefit republicans um is part of why the court ends up looking bad chris even if
SPEAKER_00the justices aren't actually acting in bad faith like that's that's the problem here
SPEAKER_01the the changing of the louisiana filing deadline and primary state versus federal i mean the kind of stuff that went on i know the they do it because the average person doesn't follow it close enough right and so it's just like man well maybe we'll get a little bad press but the idea of like well this is we're going to move this here and move this here and you have to file a different district i mean it's it's appalling okay um well and and
SPEAKER_00and alabama's worse i mean like i i don't want to go like 10 rounds on on alabama like like the procedural machinations that the Supreme Court engaged in, in the Alabama case are even harder to defend than what happened in Louisiana. Just to put a cap on it.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Let me pause there for a minute and say that we are talking to my friend Steve Vladek who is... The author of One First, a tremendously, I think, insightful and useful newsletter on Substack that you absolutely should subscribe to. He is also my favorite title so I read it all the time. The Agnes Williams Sesquicentennial Professor of Federal Courts at Georgetown, my alma mater. So, I mean, I love Steve even when he was at UT but I love him even more now that he's at Georgetown.
SPEAKER_01let's go for let's talk going forward steve and i see a bunch of questions in the chat about this what let's start basic what do we know about the next session right well by the way for people who are wondering about retirement talk we will do retirement talk at the end we will do dessert at the end um what do we know about the next session in terms of what they're going to take up and what what what what are the birthright citizenship like things that we're going to be talking about
SPEAKER_00so um the court was also busy last week adding cases to its docket so it's filled out chris probably about a quarter of its docket for next term maybe maybe the next term opens in the october into the fall yeah yeah the the first monday in october um got it right um and you know there are some um excuse me there are some hot button cases there already um the last week the court added the big second amendment case that a lot of folks have been waiting for about ar-15s
SPEAKER_00and whether bans on semi-automatic firearms are consistent with the second amendment as the supreme court now understands it the court added another important case about transgender medical care so the court seems perfectly happy for the third term in a row to get into the midst of the the culture war fight over transgender discrimination um there's a there are some important uh religious liberty and property rights cases lurking in that pile but you know chris what i would say is there are no trump cases or
SPEAKER_00at least no big trump cases yet um that will change and you know just to sort of a couple of things that i think are on their way you know uh remember the alien enemies act um right uh that case you know one of these days the en banc fifth circuit is going to decide that um right um which at the at which point whoever loses will come to the supreme court will appeal um yep there is you know this is something i think folks may not appreciate there is a massively important circuit split now over
SPEAKER_00the trump administration's uh bond policy um for undocumented immigrants the trump administration changed its interpretation of federal immigration law last summer basically so that no matter how long you've been in the country if you're out of status you are an arriving alien and so if you're arrested you can be held without bond um chris this is the central legal basis for most of the immigration raids we've seen across the country and it has led to an insane number of lawsuits because they have to be brought on
SPEAKER_00a case-by-case basis um pro public has been tracking this politico has been tracking this i think we're up over 3500 of these cases um and there's now like a eight-way circuit split on whether the trump administration is right um that's going up next term but just to sort of to jump but to jump ahead i actually think the the real two categories of cases that are going to fall on the court sometime next january or february um are what the house what democrats are going to do in a world in which they've retaken
SPEAKER_00the house come january and the two flashpoints that you know better than anybody are going to be subpoenas and appropriations and there's going to be a ton of litigation where recipients of congressional subpoenas are going to try to fight them and where trump is going to either refuse to spend money congress has appropriated or he's going to try to spend money congress hasn't appropriated and the house is going to sue him um and those are going to be enormously important sets of questions that won't get
SPEAKER_00to the supreme court chris on the merits next term because the you know they probably won't even ripen until january or february um but you know this is this is a supreme court that loves its emergency docket and i could see that being a very very important tranche of cases that comes down sometime in the spring and i
SPEAKER_01i i do want to spend before we go to retirement watch i do want to spend a minute because you have been i mean you wrote an entire book about this before i think anybody knew about the emergency and shadow docket but Can you talk about how that played out in this last term? And again, I want to be mindful. I don't want people to feel like they're left out because they don't know. Give us a quick breakdown of what the shadow docket is, but because you appointed that that is something that the Trump administration is using in ways no one else has used.
SPEAKER_01So can you do a couple minutes on that, Steve?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. so just just to you know the the quick and dirty version is the shadow docket is a term that just captures everything the supreme court does other than these big fancy merits rulings that we've been talking about for much of the last half an hour um but the the slice that we're talking about right now chris is emergency applications this is when a lower court rules one way and the party that lost appeals but chris as you know the appeal takes time and so the emergency application is hey supreme court in the 18 months to two years it's going to take for this case to get to you can you have the sort of the status quo on the ground be
SPEAKER_00that i'm gonna win correct let's act as though i won right right so trump says lower court blocked me um right can you let me keep doing the thing they said was unlawful until i appeal it to you and until you've resolved the appeal so um just to sort of be very clear about the time in in his first really 10 months in office and that was a period that sort of um overlapped the end of the 2024 term and the beginning of the 25 term trump filed more of these requests
SPEAKER_00than any president ever had before including first term trump um right and he won most of them and so the court really like went out of its way over and over and over again in the calendar year 2025 basically um right to enable a lot of what trump was doing chris without conclusively resolving its legality Yes, right.
SPEAKER_00there's been like less of this sort of hair on fire emergency litigation but chris second i think doj is also pulling some of its punches like which is to say like cases trump is losing where doj is saying we're not gonna go right to the supreme court because we're not sure we have the votes um right that that there are that there are cases where maybe a year ago they would have tried and now they're not trying um hard to figure out sort of how you prove that but it does seem like at least the trump side of the emergency docket has quieted down just in terms
SPEAKER_01of pure volume just the volume of the cases that they're seeking emergency relief
SPEAKER_00for that's right but the rest hasn't i mean so the court had still been right so i mean we talked briefly about the post calais cases yes so in the redistricting context um we saw a very very active court the texas case right the nicole maliotakis case from new york um louisiana alabama right virginia um california like that was that was very busy and that was not super uncontroversial so that was very busy um the court had a really important parental rights ruling on the emergency docket
SPEAKER_00in march in california called mirabelli um so we're it's this interesting thing where the emergency docket has not been quite as much of a lightning rod as it was last year but chris it couldn't have been worse like right last year was
SPEAKER_01the apex right those stats are just remarkable and you you turned me on to them about the use of the emergency docket by the administration seeking relief i mean it's it's not linear growth it's exponential growth i mean it's it's really a they clearly figured out that this was a way that they could kind of get what they want and they pursued it extremely it's a it's like he said it literally could have been pursued more aggressively so the fact that it wasn't
SPEAKER_01doesn't really tell us all that much
SPEAKER_00i think that's right i mean it tells us so so it would have been very hard to keep up the pace that we had last summer i mean you might remember last summer chris like every week there was a major emergency docket case about trump um and there was a period last year where i think they won 24 in a row um which is
SPEAKER_01a pretty nice like winning streak yeah although i didn't like this one
SPEAKER_00as much um right um that so it has quieted down but it's quite to say it's quite a down chris is to say it's returned to like late first trump administration levels um which is still a much busier and much more active emergency docket than the court had until really the late 2010s and so it's it's so true
SPEAKER_01of everything it's i always tell people if you need to understand trump's impact look up the term overton window because his ability to move the level of what is considered quote-unquote normal or acceptable is remarkable in political rhetoric and i mean in in in this case but chris back to
SPEAKER_00where we started i mean think about birthright citizenship right so you know 15 years ago um trying to sort of rewrite birthright citizenship was a non-starter i mean you know there is a law review article from 2006 or 7 um by a then relatively unknown former thomas clark named jim ho um about just how crazy the arguments were coming out of the far far far right in the bush administration to try to scale back birthright citizenship um you know i hate that this is true
SPEAKER_00but trump got four votes in the supreme court on whether you know our vision of birthright citizenship is required by the constitution four justices said no that doesn't happen without you know everything trump has done to shift the conversation on that and i think you know that is that's the real sort of overarching theme of the most recent term just because trump didn't win the judgments right doesn't mean he didn't win the issues and you know the votes he got in lisa cook's case the votes he got
SPEAKER_00in birthright citizenship chris the votes he got in tariffs um the votes he got in the national guard case like even when he lost he got more votes than any president should have um and you know that's a sign that the court really is now i think split a bit between the justices who really are inclined to just go with trump and the justices who still have at least some commitments that aren't just uh you know what the immediate head of the republican party thinks they should be um
SPEAKER_01let's talk about composition of the court so we obviously every time we talk we talk about the the two oldest justices are clarence thomas and speculated as a retiree more frequently than thomas i ask you this every time we talk where are we now steve i i mean are we now too late are we not too late given we're
SPEAKER_00not we're not yeah yeah we're not too late in any form i mean chris they got amy coney barrett through the entire process in three and a half weeks in 2020 right i mean um if amy coney barrett's proof of nothing else it's proof that it's almost never too late um yeah you know if the president and the senate are willing um yeah but right and indeed as you and we as you know we had a bit of a false start um yeah last tuesday and just
SPEAKER_01when we thought we had enough supreme court news we got the false report ultimately that alito was retiring
SPEAKER_00i mean so i was you know i was in the cnn uh bullpen right and we were we were we were starting to wind down our immediate headline coverage of the three major rulings the court handed down and then npr goes up with alito's retirement and we're all like oh my god back to work so right but i guess two things are true um the first is um you know sam alito is not following a calendar like he will do what he wants to do when he wants to do it um and so i would not assume that just because we haven't heard from him yet doesn't mean we won't okay but right chris
SPEAKER_00but um there's a reason why in recent times justices who have left the bench voluntarily have announced their retirement no later than the last week that the court is sitting um and that's to buy time for the president to vet yeah um yeah right i don't know that samuel alito cares about those sort
SPEAKER_00of process um niceties but there's there are reasons why you know briar said he was leaving you know around that point kennedy in 2018 on the very last day of decisions so i think with every day that passes the odds go down even further okay alito um for thomas the odds are zero i mean the interesting okay yeah is this because he wants to break
SPEAKER_01the 10-year record
SPEAKER_00yeah so he is i mean i think it's for two reasons i think one he really wants to break the tenure record in february of 2028 he will pass justice william o douglas as the longest serving justice in the court's history amazing um which is a remarkable data point um especially when you consider like the other names on that list john paul stevens john marshall um right stephen field i mean um but also i mean you know chris he has told folks that he doesn't ever want to retire from the court period i mean he has at one point he's reputed to have said um
SPEAKER_00the only way i'm leaving the court is horizontally um so you know i guess it's just it's it's a larger point that i think alito was always the more likely retirement yeah candidate which is not to say likely and i think the likelihood is going down and down the npr false report notwithstanding
SPEAKER_01is there any anyone
SPEAKER_01is there any stealth i mean i feel like there's a hundred senators there's only nine justices so we probably know more about each of their plans but is there anyone you'd be like hey take a look at this
SPEAKER_00so only chris let me press only because for the other six the answer is there's a 0.0 percent chance yes i will say that there's one for whom there's like a 0.01 percent chance um and that's john roberts um oh interesting but but again again only because 0.001 percent don't clip it up
SPEAKER_01and say steve said john roberts is retiring right right but explain why is there a point zero zero one percent chance i mean he is
SPEAKER_00after thomas right the longest serving current justice um longer than alito right he he was he he joined the court about four months before alito did um you know he had a really big term i mean chris there were 24 cases where the court split six three or five four and roberts was in the majority in 22 of them wow um so you know but but you know but his job has gotten so much harder because one
SPEAKER_00the justices basically are not getting along at all um two he has to deal with trump right uh and the the conflict i mean whatever else you might say about trump trump does not make john roberts life any easier um right three he has to deal with the entire federal judiciary much of which is very mad at him because it believes he hasn't done enough to push back against trump not on substantive law chris but on all these attacks right against lower court judges yep um this guy's a terrible judge like the true social stuff yeah um and you know and
SPEAKER_00so you know there's a universe in which you know if i'm john roberts maybe i'm like peace out i don't need this job right exactly i've had a good career right ironically right the flip side may be that he wouldn't want trump to replace him um right have the choice to replace
SPEAKER_01a chief justice
SPEAKER_00right and so you know i this is why like i i hate this conversation because i think the odds are so low to begin with but if we're going to talk but but you know um the the the three trump appointees aren't going anywhere right the three democratic appointees are not going anywhere right um and so that just leaves roberts and i think you know the odds are incredibly long but i wouldn't say that there are zero zero zero
SPEAKER_01um i said i would take 45 minutes of your time i've taken 42 minutes and 22 seconds of your time which means we're going to end on this i named steve vladeck the general manager of the new york mets what do you do to fix the mets problems for people who don't follow baseball it is one of is it the highest payroll in mlb steve it's certainly among among the most the mets are in last place in the nl east what does steve vladeck do as
SPEAKER_00a mets we're not chris i mean you're being very kind we're not just in last place in the nl east i think we have the worst record in the national league i believe that is the case yes it certainly was the case the last time i looked oh wait i'm sorry we're a half game ahead of the rockies congratulations what what do i do um the history of the new york mets success chris is a history of homegrown pitching yes and and i think
SPEAKER_00that um i mean doc goodin right um jacob de grom um right um you know tom siever um nolan ryan um i mean i can i could do this for a while um we have gotten away from that and and you know you look at the mets pitching staff this year and like you know what one of those starters was actually a mets prospect who was developed by the mets farm system um you know i'm sort of in the hope that i don't have to win immediately like my first priority is rebuilding a pipeline
SPEAKER_00of young pitchers because when the mets have been good historically it has started and it has like been defined by the pitching not the not not the you know sort of mercenary free agent style not the yankee approach right that's right yeah that's right um and even if that team chris won't win a world series it will be a lot more fun to watch
SPEAKER_01that's it's so interesting you say the fun to watch thing i'm obviously a nationals fan and i will say like i think they're one of the really good stories this year here's the thing they're not gonna i don't think they're gonna make the playoffs i don't i don't they're they're certainly not gonna win the world series this year i'd be stunned but they are fun to watch i am someone who does watch every game now do i watch every inning of every game i mean it's on you know i don't know that i watch every inning but but it's i even when we lose we are competitive and i feel like watching the mets is just depressing
SPEAKER_01at the moment like win or lose you're kind of like we won that one but
SPEAKER_00so my just this is maybe too too much information my my usual work i'm on karen teases me to knowing about this is like you know once the kids are down right like i'll get my laptop out and i'll put you know sny gary keith and ron on of course right and and i'll watch the mets in the background um chris i can't do it like it makes you yeah it makes you pisses you
SPEAKER_01off
SPEAKER_00um and and even even gary who is like the you know the the sweet like even gary is like every night like just you could hear it in his voice he's like subtle but devastating in his critiques of this franchise um and so you know the good news is that it's freed up all this extra time for me
SPEAKER_01to work um exactly you don't have a two and a half hour time commitment every night
SPEAKER_00i really don't i really really don't i mean karen karen likes to say that like she can tell how the mets are doing by how much i'm watching them
SPEAKER_01and she knows they suck because i haven't been steve vladeck uh professor george on law uh author of uh one first which i again i cannot recommend highly enough i also steve put your book on the shadow docket uh in the the chat for people who are interested in buying it again steve was on the shadow docket before most people heard of the shadow docket so check that out and i'm always thankful for your time for folks who know i have steve on every
SPEAKER_01as honestly as much as i can get him on a busy guy um i'm very thankful for your time thank you to everyone who joined us either live or watching it one first and go check out that shadow docket book steve the met season can't get worse so i hope it gets better
SPEAKER_00Thanks, Chris. I mean, there's only one way to go from here.
SPEAKER_01That's exactly... Oh, it's always the darkest right before it goes completely pitch black, Steve. Always remember that.
SPEAKER_00Love ending on that note. Thanks, Christ.
As I noted in Monday’s post, the Harvard Law Review’s annual Supreme Court issue, including my Foreword - “The Court Against the Courts” - came out last week. On Thursday, November 20, I sat down with Harvard law...
In this episode of “First One,” the (fairly irregular) podcast companion to the “One First” newsletter, Steve sat down with Karen Vladeck (a lawyer-turned-legal recruiter and the founder and managing director of...
On Tuesday morning, Cristian Farias and I got together for a quick Substack Live to discuss the goings-on in the Missouri redistricting case - including what happened in the Eighth Circuit on Monday and what’s likely to...