This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01We are live. Um, my friend Steve Ladek, um, is here. Uh, I, I was saying to him before we came on what, uh, how much I enjoy talking about, uh, uh, the Supreme court with him because I learn a lot like selfishly. It's great for me because I learned a ton about it. Um, Steve is the author of one first, which is an invaluable sub stack. Uh, if you don't subscribe in thousands, tens of thousands of people do, but if you don't subscribe, you should one first, um, He also is,
SPEAKER_01and I always say this because this is my favorite, his title at Georgetown, my alma mater, is the Agnes Williams Sesquicentennial Professor of Federal Courts, which is a totally badass. I want to be the sesquicentennial anything. agnes williams sesquicentennial professor of federal courts that's his official title and steve and i were just talking about this long before people started talking about the shadow docket at the supreme court steve vladek wrote a book that came out in may 2023 called the shadow docket how the supreme
court uses stealth rulings to amass power and undermine the republic if ever there was a book written
SPEAKER_01in 2023 that is relevant today it is that book so i would urge people and in the uh when i when i publish this full conversation out i will link to that book but i and of course to one first and to other steve's other work but all right so steve i want to let's let's talk about i always say the most the most important thing about the news is those first three letters new let's talk about briefly yeah last night the state of the union four justices came and including Amy Coney Barrett and John Roberts,
SPEAKER_01who were appointed by Republicans, Amy Coney Barrett appointed by Donald Trump, who voted against Trump on tariffs. And that is that we are going to talk a bunch about the tariff ruling as well as the sort of the docket, the rulings to come. That's going to be the bulk of this. But what did you make of who came and he, Trump, sort of greeted each of them, shook their hands and made a I always say the bar is so low for Trump to like be civil. People are like, he was totally civil. He basically said that that terrible ruling.
It's like, well, he didn't say I'm going to come to Amy Coney Barrett's house and murder her.
SPEAKER_01So he was civil. It's like, well, OK, so tell me, give me a little of your thought on that. And maybe if you have a little bit of the history of, you know, it's a weird thing, the Supreme Court being at the State of Union.
SPEAKER_00Go ahead. Yeah. I mean, so it used to be actually more common for almost all of the court to go. And then, you know, starting with President Obama publicly criticizing Citizens United at the State of the Union. It was 2011 or 2012, but one of those years. And Justice Alito making a lot of news because of his facial expressions in response, right? Like, I think that really changed the dynamic. Um, where now, you know, the chief justice goes, Chris, cause he's the chief justice. And, you know, I think he'd use it as sort of institutionally necessary for
him to be there. Um, and I don't, I don't really sort of know how the other justices decide whether to go or not.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I think Justice Kagan goes fairly often. Um, I think Justice Barrett is relatively new, so I think maybe the allure hasn't worn off. You don't usually see Sotomayor Jackson, especially when it's a Republican president. You don't see Thomas ever.
SPEAKER_01And Clarence Thomas can go, right, yeah.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, I don't know that it's that big of a deal. I think the more interesting question... is about his comments in his press conference on friday yes and especially when he you know went after the families right of the justices who are in the majority they should be ashamed right and especially the republican appointees in the majority right two of whom were among the four just so of the four justices who were there half of them were the ones who should be ashamed um you know in any other usual is
SPEAKER_01that steve
SPEAKER_00Insane. I mean, right. I was about to say in any other administration, that would have been a huge scandal. And in the Trump administration, it wasn't even the headline from Friday. Yeah. And so, you know, I guess it's interesting that, you know, I don't know what, if anything, he said to the four of them. I doubt he apologized for what he said on Friday. Yeah. Right. I mean, everything we know about him would suggest he did not. Yeah. Right. But, you know, I mean, we're seeing already, Chris, efforts, especially by folks who are more publicly defensive of the court than I am, to try to sort of portray Friday's ruling as some massive
repudiation of Trump,
SPEAKER_00as like, you know, some dramatic shift in the court's relationship with President Trump and the executive branch. And I guess my overall reaction is like, it's a little early. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's what I love about talking to you is because You were never on the, you and I talked a few months ago, and honestly, I reference our conversations all the time because I say, look, I'm not a Supreme Court expert, but Steve Waddick is, and I trust him. And he says the idea that the Supreme Court three months ago had already proven that they're in Trump's pocket and will do whatever he says is not borne out yet. And so I want you to expand on the idea that the Supreme Court has now borne This ruling means that that too may be overblown.
SPEAKER_00Go. Yeah, it's almost like people are overreacting in both directions. No. I know, right? In 2026, say it ain't so. So I guess the short thing I would say, Chris, is it's worth looking at the whole field. And the whole field here is not just the tariffs case. I mean, the tariffs case was the very first ruling about the Trump administration that had reached the court on what we would call the merits docket, which is to say, you know, full review, full briefing, full oral argument, 170 pages worth of opinion.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. And so, you know, that's why I think some nuance here is called for that. The court has been, I think, incredibly beneficial and willing to enable a lot of what President Trump has done
SPEAKER_00over the last year. Chris, a lot of which is, you know, hugely impactful, whether it's, you know, downsizing the Department of Education, whether it's kicking transgender individuals out of the military, whether it's, you know, pocketing four billion dollars. in foreign aid funding that Congress said he had to spend. Those are enormous rulings, even if they are, from the court's perspective, interim rulings. So the folks who are cynical about the court say, look at how much the court's already done for Trump. OK, he lost one case. What to do?
The folks who are Pollyannish about the court say, no, the court has some other project.
SPEAKER_00The project is not reflexively ruling for Trump. It's doing other ideologically charged things. And here I am saying, you know, maybe it's a little bit of both. Right. Maybe it's a court that has been far more willing to enable Trump than it would have with regard to any other president. And there's plenty of data to support that. And a court that still has some lines it won't cross even for Trump. Right. Yes. Right. And, you know, I mean, just Chris, really quickly, just to, you know, I know we're going to talk more about coming attractions,
but like the court has three other big Trump cases already in front of it to decide
SPEAKER_00on the, you know, after oral argument this term. Two of them have already been argued. That's Trump versus slaughter, which is the big case about whether the president can fire without cause heads of agencies, even when Congress has required cause. Right. The Lisa Cook case about whether even when he needs cause, the president can just make up cause. And then the birthright citizenship case, which is going to be argued on April 1st. Yeah. You know, Chris, as you and I sit here on February 25th, my best guess is he wins slaughter and he loses the other two.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, what will that mean? So you'll get headlines that say, mixed bag for Trump from the Supreme Court or, you know, I think this was in the New York Times, Supreme Court declares independence from President Trump. And my reaction is like, no, like it's actually, you know, the court has actually done more for Trump than it's done for any prior president. It just hasn't done everything. Right. And we should be able to say both of those things in the same.
SPEAKER_01Can let's I want to talk about that. Let's talk first and coming attractions. I'm very interested in because you always highlight things that I didn't even I mean, I know birthright citizenship, but things that to pay attention to that I didn't even know to pay attention to. But can we talk about the tariff ruling? Let's just talk about the tariff ruling in and of itself. It seemed to me as a very much a layman listening to and reading the coverage of the oral arguments. The court was quite skeptical. I would have been very surprised if they had ruled.
Oh, yeah, he can use this emergency statute to do what he's doing on tariffs.
SPEAKER_01Is that right? I mean, did you expect this outcome? Did you expect a 6-3? Did you think it could have been 9-0? Did you think it was going to be 5-4? Let's talk about the merits of that case and what we thought was going to happen versus what did happen. And then let's talk more broadly.
SPEAKER_00So I guess my best advice, Chris, about oral arguments is it really depends on which justice you're taking the signals from. There are justices who don't hide their cards very well. And I'll put Neil Gorsuch in this category. Frankly, I think you can put all three of the Democratic appointees in this category. And I think you can put the chief in this category, right? Yeah. You know, at the oral argument in November. Yeah, I heard, Chris, the same thing you did, which is I heard a lot of skepticism from the chief and from Gorsuch.
The trickier justices to predict based on oral argument have been Barrett and Kavanaugh.
SPEAKER_00And, you know, so I walked out of oral argument, Chris, relatively confident that Trump was going to lose because I was relatively confident about the chief justice and Gorsuch. And that was enough to get to five. We have plenty of examples in the last few years of Kavanaugh and Barrett looking like they're going one way to argument and then coming out a different way. Interesting. So really, I go sort of justice by justice. So I was confident Trump was losing.
SPEAKER_00My best guess on the vote count, Chris, was actually 7-2. I thought Kavanaugh would be with the majority. He wasn't. But yeah, I really do think that the the vibe here was a loss. And so in that respect, I don't know that I'm that surprised that this was the result we got on Friday. Or, Chris, that it took as long as it did, given that we had 170 pages worth of opinions.
SPEAKER_01I have heard people say, and these are people of varying knowledge of the court, if it was anyone else, it would have been 9-0 against. What do you make of that?
SPEAKER_00Maybe. I mean, like maybe. I mean, and this goes back to the problem, which is, you know, it's we are so used to talking about the court, Chris, as if it were a monolith. Right. And it's not. It's it's it's nine people. So I do think I mean, I wrote this in my newsletter on Friday. I really do think that all three of the dissenters and that's, you know, Kavanaugh who wrote and he was joined by Thomas and Alito. Yeah. needed to do more in their dissent to explain why this case was different from President Biden's student loan debt forgiveness program.
SPEAKER_00Right. Because the fight, the real legal fight in this case was about something called the major questions doctrine, which is a relatively new approach to interpreting statutes that is in vogue among the more conservative justices. Right. And the idea, Chris, is that instead of trying to figure out what Congress meant when it used an ambiguous term, like in this case, regulate importation. Right.
SPEAKER_01Tariff is not even in the statute. The word is not even in the statute.
SPEAKER_00So normally, right, you would think, right, that the sort of – The question would be, well, what did Congress mean through this ambiguous language? Did it mean to include something that's not expressly mentioned or not? The major questions doctrine takes that interpretive debate off the table and says if it's a question of vast economic or political significance, ambiguity is fatal. And we will assume Congress did not authorize the program unless it expressly does.
SPEAKER_01So it has to say you can do this. And if it doesn't, the assumption has to be you can't do this. And that was the and that was the lever by which the court struck down a bunch of
SPEAKER_00things the Biden administration did. Right. The student loans, the clean, not the sorry, the good neighbor ozone pollution regulations. I mean, right. The CDC eviction moratorium, the OSHA vaccination or testing mandate. I mean, a lot of stuff. And the dissenters, the Thomas Alito Kavanaugh dissent, says this is different because this case is about foreign relations and national security. Well, Chris, the statute that President Biden's student loan debt
forgiveness program was based
SPEAKER_00on was also a national security statute. It says during a time of war or national emergency, the secretary of education may blah, blah, blah. So, you know, I think part of the concern here is that folks can find lots of charges of hypocrisy and inconsistency, not just from the three dissenters, but there have been efforts also to accuse the Democratic appointees of being hypocritical, that they voted for most of those Biden programs and voted against this one. I wrote my whole newsletter on Monday about why I think that's not a persuasive
SPEAKER_00charge, but I understand why people are making it. The real headline, though, is your question, Chris, shouldn't this just have been 9-0? I think the problem is that we're at a moment in the court's history where very, very few of these cases are 9-0. When a president loses 9-0, it's usually not on the merits. It's usually on some kind of procedural ground that was like an off-ramp for the justices.
SPEAKER_01I think that's so it's in some ways the court reflects where we are. We're not really a unanimous country on almost anything anymore. And let me use your mention of what you wrote in your newsletter just to plug your newsletter. Again, Steve has a gigantically successful. And the reason it's successful is because it's so good. newsletter called One First on Substack that if you care about what we are talking about today and you want an informed, thoughtful perspective, please, if you don't already, go subscribe. It's terrific.
SPEAKER_01Steve, when we talked a few months ago, one of the things I kind of took and wrote down and circled and underlined was by this summer, we will have a lot better sense of what Donald Trump's second term will look like. People like me focus so much on, well, let's see if they win back the House and the Democrats win the House in the midterms, which does matter. But the court certainly has a lot to say. So I want to talk broadly about that.
I want to start, though, with a narrow question, which is, do you buy the idea that The majority opinion written by John Roberts on the tariffs was the first in a potential series of ways in which the court is reclaiming the co-equal branches of
SPEAKER_01government for the legislative branch, even if the legislative branch won't do it itself. No. Okay, good. Thank you. That's easy.
SPEAKER_00I mean, there's a column, I think, in The Atlantic from Monday that was written by Sarah Isger that basically makes this argument that the court, the real project of the Roberts court is trying to rein in the president so that it can re-empower the legislature. So I will sneak preview, Chris. This is actually what I'm writing about in my newsletter tomorrow and why this is completely bananas. It's completely bananas. And it's bananas for a couple of different reasons. It's bananas, number one, because this court has done more to expand executive power than
any other court in
SPEAKER_00the history of the Supreme Court. And that's, you know, I mean, the Trump immunity case, I think, is an example of that. Right. The fact that in slaughter, I fully expect the court to overrule this 1935 precedent called Humphrey's executor and clear the way for the most robust vision of the so-called unitary executive theory of presidential power we've ever seen. Like, Chris, those are two pretty big data points all by themselves. Yeah. But the other part of this is, you know, the claim about
SPEAKER_00the sort of re-empowering Congress. I mean, look at the last year, right? This is the court that allowed President Trump to engage in a pocket rescission of $4 billion of mandated foreign aid funding. This is a court that has not enforced a whole bunch of statutory constraints on the executive branch. I mean, You know, if we were re-empowering Congress, we wouldn't be kneecapping Congress left and right. And so I think I think what it really comes back to and to pivot to what you asked about where we are in the summer is this is a court that is
deeply committed to
SPEAKER_00sort of two overlapping projects. One is executive power, especially when it's a Republican president, but even maybe sometimes when it's not. But to Chris's judicial power. They're not re-empowering Congress. They're empowering themselves. And, you know, this is like all of those nerdy administrative law cases from a couple of years ago where the court was taking power away from agencies. It wasn't giving it to the people. It was giving it to judges. Right. Right. So judges can decide what's reasonable. Right.
SPEAKER_00And so when I think about the three big cases we have left from Trump, right, for the Supreme Court this term, so slaughter, cook and birthright citizenship, right? Slaughter is going to be a huge win for executive power.
SPEAKER_01And that is just revisit. Explain to me the difference. Birthright citizenship, I think everyone knows that Donald Trump is basically saying just because you were born in this country does not make you does not guarantee that you are a citizen. It's in the Constitution. I feel like he's going to lose.
SPEAKER_00It's in the constitution. It's the subject of an 1898 Supreme court decision. That decision was codified by Congress in 1940. But other than that, Chris, it's right.
SPEAKER_01I mean, who the hell knows? But so, but I do, I think most people, even if you follow the court only a little, have some understanding of that one, but can you talk about different talk about cook and slaughter? Cause those are the other two cases and they're similar, but not the same.
SPEAKER_00Yes, exactly. So, um, The basic premise, the basic fight here is, can there be any independence within the executive branch? Can Congress create, Chris, independent or quasi-independent agencies? And the way Congress did this historically was by creating executive branch agencies, Chris, where the president would pick the heads, but where the heads could only be fired for cause. And the whole idea of for-cause removal was that,
SPEAKER_00like, we'd be pretty deferential, Chris, about what cause is, but you can't just fire them for political disagreements.
SPEAKER_01Right. You can't fire them because they're a Democrat and you're a Republican or vice versa.
SPEAKER_00100%. Exactly right. And so what that meant was that there were a handful of agencies where the idea was we want folks who are going to be real experts and not just patrons or partisan hench people. That's right. Right. Because there's some it's under the theory that there is some inherent value in
SPEAKER_00Experienced bureaucrats who are at least to some degree, Chris, insulated from the whims of the political moment.
SPEAKER_01Right. OK. Right.
SPEAKER_00Right. And so, listen, not every I mean, this was never a view that was applied to cabinet agencies. Those were always viewed as part of the executive. Right. The White House. But, you know, the Federal Trade Commission or the National Labor Relations Board. Right. These sort of external agencies. So that had been, you know, that was basically a core premise of how Congress structured agencies throughout the 20th century. And it's been sort of chipped away at by conservatives for the better part of the last 40 years.
But it was really only when Justice Kennedy retired in 2018 that you finally had
SPEAKER_00five justices for the strong view, Chris, of what people like me call the unitary executive theory. And that's the argument that the president must be able to exert direct political control over anyone who exercises, quote, executive power, unquote. And on that theory, statutes that create for cause removal limits are unconstitutional. Because they violate the president's ability to do exactly what you just said.
SPEAKER_00So slaughter, slaughter is the big case. Slaughter is the case that's basically, should the court overrule this 1935 precedent Humphrey's executor or not? And, you know, that oral argument was in December. And Chris, again, back to sort of tea leaf reading from oral argument. I think everybody... walked out of that oral argument, convinced that the court is going to overrule Humphrey's executor and that the question is just going to be quite how far do they go? So independent agencies are gone. What about the civil service, right? What about, you know, line government employees who have civil service protections
against being removed
SPEAKER_00from at will. Um, right. Like that's, you know, that's an open question,
SPEAKER_01but so that would be obviously slaughter slaughter is, is specifically about exactly what you just outlined. Does the president have the ability to get rid of anyone at a quasi independent agency within the administration for any reason whatsoever?
SPEAKER_00And even if Congress has said, no, you can't, right? Like, are statutes limiting the president's ability to do that unconstitutional? And I think the court's going to say yes. Now, part of why, right, part of why the sort of – Part of why this theory had not been adopted earlier is because there was this whole argument out there that there are some agencies, and the leading example was always the Federal Reserve, that just have to be independent, that it would cause economic chaos.
SPEAKER_00Oh, Steve. Yeah. Right. I know. For a long time, that was a thing. I know. Right. So but so, Chris, what's striking about this is like people like me had thought that that was going to be the reason why the court never quite got all the way up to overruling Humphreys executor because there was no plausible way to distinguish the Fed and the court wouldn't undermine the Fed. Well, last summer, we got a preview. When the court issued one of those emergency application orders in a case called Trump versus Wilcox, and it allowed the president to temporarily remove,
SPEAKER_00although we all know it's really permanent, Kathy Harris from the National Labor Relations Board and Gwen Wilcox from the Merit Systems Protection Board, And then there's like a throwaway sentence in the two-page order where the court says, of course, the Federal Reserve is different for reasons. And the reasons, by the way, make no sense. But, you know, hey. So that's how we get to Lisa Cook. So Lisa Cook is a member of the Federal Reserve Board. And, you know, presumably the one agency that's going to come through –
SPEAKER_00this whole mess with still a modicum of independence. And so instead of removing her without cause, President Trump, you know, claimed that he had cause for removing Lisa Cook, which was these, you know, deeply dubious claims of mortgage fraud that she had signed.
SPEAKER_01She had said that this is the thing in Virginia. She had said that she she lived in a home, even though it's clear that it seems clear to me that it was a clerical mistake and it was quickly corrected. But yes, that's That was the call of stipend.
SPEAKER_00That was the theory. So lower court said, listen, whether or not that's cause, right, Ms. Cook is entitled to a hearing before you can remove her where she can adjudicate whether this, you know, whether this is real and whether it's sufficient. And the Supreme Court was asked by the Trump administration to let him fire her anyway while that process worked out. And the Supreme Court, Chris, back in December, deferred – A ruling on that application pending an oral argument, which it had in January.
SPEAKER_00And that argument, again, reading tea leaves, did not go well for Trump. So, you know, I think what we're looking at here is, Chris, a sort of a mixed verdict where the court in slaughter is going to do the big thing. And say, yes, to all the independent agencies, 100 percent, except the Fed. And that cook. The court's going to say something small about how if you're in this one small bucket of still protected by four cause removal cases, you actually are entitled to meaningful process before you're fired.
SPEAKER_00Right. That's my best guess. And, Chris, there are people out there who will say, look. Right. Trump won one and he lost one. Yeah. Right. Mixed bag. Right. And I will respond and say, I mean, yes, he won the war and lost a teeny little battle. Right.
SPEAKER_01Because to your point, and I think this is really important, slaughter has a much broader impact than Cook. Right.
SPEAKER_00Slaughter is why. Just by nature of the case. Right. Slaughter is why the president can tell the Bureau of Labor Statistics to make the labor statistics whatever he wants them to be. Right. Slaughter is why the president can tell, I don't know, the SEC to not actually enforce securities laws against his buddies. Like, you know, this is a huge reaching. Yeah. Right. Versus a carve out for the Federal Reserve that's good for that train only.
SPEAKER_01I want to go back to something you said, Steve, and you said this is the, talking about the tariffs, the 31st ruling by the Supreme Court in a Trump-related case since 2025. Yep. And this is also maybe a function of plugging your book about the shadow docket, but are those shadow docket cases as well? Like, how do we get to 31? Because I try to follow the court relatively closely, but explain that because I think most people, I mean, I certainly am like, wait, there were 31 cases.
trump related cases and i talk to you every few months about this and i still feel so explain to people give us a little more context on that and then i want to end i'll give a for a for people who want to uh a dessert promise at the end of this we're going to end on is samuel olito going to retire but before we get to that i want to i want to tell me explain to me that 31 trump related course cases rule it
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So the first 30 were all emergency applications. And that shadow docket? That's the shadow docket. So really quickly, right, for the folks who are not well-versed in this. So it takes time for a case to get from the beginning of the litigation to a full decision on the merit from the Supreme Court. Chris, we're often fighting over what the rule should be while the case is pending. So if you're challenging a government policy, should the policy be blocked for the whole duration? Right. Or should it go into effect? And that's so that's emergency relief.
SPEAKER_00The Trump administration has been remarkably successful. I mean, this was true during the first administration, but it's true at a much higher clip during the second in taking a lower court rulings, blocking policies and And getting stays from the Supreme Court that put those policies back into effect for the duration of the appeal. And, you know, there's a lot of folks, Chris, try to sort of downplay these rulings. They say they're temporary, they're interim, they're not as important as, say, the tariffs ruling. Right. And I think the problem is, is that it really depends on the specific ruling.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, when when the court says, yes, President Trump, you can downsize the Department of Education, people lose their jobs. Right. And the department stops doing stuff when the Supreme Court says, yes, President Trump, you can kick every transgender service member out of the military.
SPEAKER_01People get kicked out of the military.
SPEAKER_00People get kicked out of the military. Right.
SPEAKER_01It has real-world implications.
SPEAKER_00And the problem is that we are seeing more real-world effects, right? It's not just the volume, Chris. It's the qualitative impact. And so this is why, you know, I don't think... It's quite right to equate each of those 30 cases with the tariffs case. But they're worth a lot more than nothing in this conversation because what they're doing is they are enabling the president to continue to exercise power that in many cases lower courts have said he can't.
SPEAKER_00And that may not, Chris, have long-term doctrinal effects if the court comes back in three years and says, oh, that was actually unlawful. But it's three years. But it's three years and a lot could happen in three years. I mean, you don't need me to tell you that.
SPEAKER_01No, I mean, that's I would just recommend this for people. And again, I will link to this. But Steve wrote a book in 2023 that was a New York Times bestseller called The Shadow Docket, How the Supreme Court Uses Stealth Rulings to Amass Power and Undermine the Republic. Donald Trump, Steve and I talked about this the last time we talked, but Donald Trump has used the shadow docket in emergency relief at a Steve just mentioned this, but at a much more aggressive clip. than any past president. And I think people, because it's somewhat Supreme Court nerdy,
SPEAKER_01I think people kind of, it's like redistricting in my world, Steve, people, well, in your world too, people, people overlook it because it's like, eh, lying drunk, but it has massive implications. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Massive implications, Chris, and just to, you know, without getting us down another rabbit hole, and for the first time over the last seven months, the court is now saying these orders are also precedential, right, where the real world effects are now being sort of backstopped by what the lawyers would call doctrinal effects. which is to say, you know, lower courts in other cases are now being expected to take these, you know, temporary, not fully briefed, not argued rulings and give force to them in other cases.
So, you know, the pitch here is just is not that these are more important.
SPEAKER_00It's that they are also important. Yes. And that we cannot tell a full story.
SPEAKER_01And they get so much less attention. I mean, it's just not, you know, the tariff case gets a massive amount of coverage. But there are 30 other Trump-related cases that have already been, if not decided, at least litigated in some way with consequence.
SPEAKER_00One super visible real-world example, right, is the ICE raids case. So in September, the court had a case called Vasquez Perdomo. about a district court TRO in Los Angeles, a temporary restraining order that was blocking ICE from stopping and arresting folks just based on their skin color, whether they spoke English with a heavy accent, where they congregated and where they were. Those could be plus factors, Chris, but it wasn't enough to just have one of those. Right. And in an unsigned, unexplained order, the court put that TRO on hold.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Right. But like it is a powerful sign of the real world impact these rulings have that it was not long after that ruling in September that we saw Operation Midway Blitz in Chicago and that we saw the ramp up in Portland and then
ultimately the ramp up in
SPEAKER_00Minneapolis. And I think, you know, that's the problem of trying to tell a monolithic story of the Supreme Court is that these things are all happening at the same time.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. That's exactly right. I think we have a tendency to react to the one big thing while there's literally 30 slightly smaller things going on. Okay. I want to end on this because this is always the thing that gets people's juices flowing the most. The two oldest members of the Supreme Court are Clarence Thomas, who is 77 years old, and Samuel Alito, who is 75 years old. I think you'll know this, but I think Roberts is the third oldest. He's 71. although he looks exactly the same basically as he looked in 2005 he must have a picture of himself in his house that's aging while he stays the
same but his hair his hair's a little more gray it's grayer it's grayer and slightly more sparse but man i would love to age that little in 20 plus years um okay so i saw you quoted in a usa today paste let's talk speculation interestingly to me at least has centered
SPEAKER_01on alito who is the younger of the two thomas and alito I saw you quoted in USA Today piece about Alito. Give me your sense on what, obviously, for people who don't understand, very quickly, the Republicans control the Senate right now. There is not a 50-50 chance they lose the Senate, but there's also not a 0% chance they lose the Senate. And in fact, those chances are probably going up rather than going down as the public
SPEAKER_00environment grows. That's the key. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_01So how does Alito land in this? I think liberals are still and may always be shell-shocked by what happened with Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Talk about sort of Alito. And then if you can, Steve, can you talk about why we don't talk about Thomas as much for retiring?
SPEAKER_00Let me do Thomas first because I think that's easy. My confidence interval for Thomas is a lot higher, which is that he's not retiring this summer. And I think that's true for two reasons. The first is he has long said, not always publicly, but in places where it's been repeated, that he wants to die on the court. But separately from that, I also think he really wants the longevity record. Thomas is, as of right now, Chris, about two years away, two years and a couple of months from breaking the all-time
longevity record for a
SPEAKER_00Supreme Court justice, which currently belongs to Justice William O. Douglas. Um, who served Chris from 1939 to 1975. Um, which is Thomas is going to break that guy on it so long in 2028. He's been on the court, you know, a long time. Um, but the, by the way, the crazy thing about the Douglas thing is Douglas was succeeded by John Paul Stevens. So that seat had two people in it from 1939 to 2010. Um,
SPEAKER_01Um, it's like being the Steelers coach.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's crazy. Okay.
SPEAKER_00So that's why, so that's why I think whatever the politics of the moment, that's why I think Thomas is not going anywhere right now.
SPEAKER_01That makes sense.
SPEAKER_00I would have said, I said as recently as the fall, I said, I would have been really surprised by an Alito retirement this year. Um, you know, from his perspective, he has the votes, right? He's in charge. You know, he will never be more significant and have more of an effect on things than right now. Um, But I really think that the shifting political tides are going to be deeply felt in his chambers. And, you know, the sort of you mentioned not 50-50, but I would say there's I think people are talking about the
Senate a heck of a lot
SPEAKER_00more now than they were three months ago. Oh, 100 percent. And, you know, those conversations are also conversations Alito's aware of. So the real clue to me, Chris, and this is why I'm a little more than 50-50 on Alito retiring, is he has a book coming out. Right. He is writing a book that is being released, I think, by an imprint of Basic Books in October. Early October. October is a very strange time to release a book if you're
planning to go on a book
SPEAKER_00tour and you're an active Supreme Court justice. Because October is when the court comes back from its summer recess, sits on the bench for two weeks, and is actually probably the second busiest month of the term compared to June. So, you know, I don't think that proves that Alito is retiring. For folks who are looking for other clues, he has hired clerks for next year, although that has not historically been a clue. Right. But, you know, I would say that I would put the odds somewhere around 60,
40, maybe even 65, 35. And Chris, the more the political tides shift toward the Democrats, I think that number goes up.
SPEAKER_01So quickly on that. John Roberts has, you know, I think largely failed in this, but one of the things that John Roberts tried to do, and he talked about this a lot during his confirmation hearings, you know, in 05, was it 05, Steve? Yeah, yeah. Okay.
SPEAKER_00September 05. By the way, the first month of my teaching career. Oh, interesting. Yes, my career and John Roberts' career.
SPEAKER_01The court is in a political entity. The court exists outside of politics. Like, You and I, I think, have talked about that a bunch of times. But is it Why did Ruth Bader Ginsburg could have looked at the exact same things that you suggest Samuel Alito is looking at and drawn a very similar conclusion and didn't? Is it a difference between liberal justices and conservative justices? Is it a difference between it? Like you said, I love what you said.
SPEAKER_01I wrote down the court is not a monolith. It's made up of nine people. Is this just they're different people? And so they see things differently. Is that like, how do you land on that?
SPEAKER_00I think that's a combo. First of all, they're very different people. And Chris, different people have different views about, one, their own mortality, right? Two, just how willing they are to run the risk, right? Whatever is true of your actual votes and your actual jurisprudence, if you don't conceive of yourself as a political actor— then maybe you don't think of it the same way, right? I mean, John Paul Stevens retired not because of politics. He retired because he stumbled while he was reading his,
he verbally stumbled while he was reading his dissent in Citizens United from the
SPEAKER_00bench and became convinced that it was time to go. Yeah. Right. Like they're human beings. These are human beings. And but Chris, part of them being human beings also leaves me to be a little agnostic about sort of placing blame. Like I think Justice Ginsburg made a deeply terrible miscalculation. But you know, not the first time. I mean, Brennan retired, right, during the presidency of George H.W. Bush. They're good. Marshall retired during the presidency of George H.W. Bush. Like they're,
SPEAKER_00you know, Marshall, by the way, who actually like survived, he lived until like two days after I think Clinton was sworn in, right? So, you know, part of this was that I think it's a relatively new approach to think of this purely in partisan political advantage terms and part of its personalities. And I think, you know, we can't, We shouldn't undercount and undervalue how much the idiosyncrasies of the justices' individual personalities drive, Chris, not just this decision, but a lot of what they do.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I always say that about politicians. Don't treat them like pawns to be moved around a chessboard. They are human beings because people will be like, you treat it like it's high school. I'm like, they treat it like it's high school. It's a lot of personalities and who likes who. And this one didn't campaign with me in this way. Like they are human beings. They are thin skinned. They get offended. They have certain images, self images of themselves. Can you, can you, what is Alito's vibe? What, what is like for people who don't know,
SPEAKER_01like what, when you say personalities matter, what, what is his personality?
SPEAKER_00It's interesting because I actually think in person he's quite affable. And, you know, he and I have had actually a couple of very pleasant exchanges in our lifetime. Our last exchange was, I think, he and I agreeing that we could at least root against the nationals together. Because I said because I had said to him, Chris, that as a Mets fan, I don't imagine you and I are ever going to get along. And so he held out the opposition to the Nationals as an all.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. Enemy of my enemy sort of situation.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think, you know, I think the best theory on Alito is one that I associate with my friend Leah Littman, who teaches at the University of Michigan and who hosts the Strict Scrutiny podcast. And Leah's theory of Alito is that he was, for the early part of his career, a fairly non-extreme product of the Reagan conservative legal movement. And that what really changed was sort of he got to the Supreme Court in 2006 and he lost a lot.
SPEAKER_00Um, right. Like this was still, this was still the Anthony Kennedy court. This was the court that, you know, rules that there can be habeas review at Guantanamo. This is the court that legalizes same sex marriage. This is the court that, I mean, you know, the sort of that it was a bit, I mean, that really was a mixed bag, Chris, like Kennedy really would go back and forth, but if you're Alito, you know, you're losing to Kennedy a lot. And I think the theory is that this, um, I don't know, sort of generated long held, deeply ingrained frustration and anger and,
SPEAKER_00you know, a desire to sort of, I don't know, stick around long enough to get the wins back.
SPEAKER_01I was going to say, yeah, see yourself win. Everybody likes to win. Supreme Court justices included.
SPEAKER_00And so it really is, in some respect, a culture of grievance that I think is, you know, I'll say, I mean, I hear that everybody likes to win. It seems like in a pluralistic country with a non-justice bench, right? You shouldn't, you know, no one's well served by one person winning all the time. Nope. I agree.
SPEAKER_01I agree. I always take your... One of the things I really admire about you is you are measured. You are not... This is the greatest court of all time. This is the worst court of all time. This ruling is the biggest thing in the world. So when you say 60-40, maybe 65-35, leaning toward a legal retirement, I mean, I take that quite seriously. And that obviously would be a... Um, well, depending on when he did it, and I don't know if you have a thought on timing, but depending on what he did it,
SPEAKER_01they would have to try to really rush it through given where they are.
SPEAKER_00Not, not, not the sort of the Barrett speed. Um, right. Right. Um, you know, I think, I mean, I think a sort of a June announcement, which has been the norm, at least in recent years, probably, especially if the White House already has a list, um, you know, is not a crazy timetable. Okay. Um, you know, if the, even in, I mean, Chris, even in 2018, when the Kavanaugh confirmation process got understandably slowed down by the Christine Blasey Ford stuff,
SPEAKER_00he was still confirmed by the end of October, which is, you know, which, which on that timeline would be before the election. And, and, and, you know, presumably you wouldn't have that repeating this time. So I, you know, I don't know that Alito's retiring. I think The only thing that I think will tip the scales for me, Chris, is how the political tide shift. If it really does look even more like some of the primaries, for example, like if Ken Paxton beats John Cornyn. Totally. Right. If you if you have sort of seats that the Republicans thought were safe that now become vulnerable in the general.
SPEAKER_00Maybe that's the thing that tips the scale. But otherwise, I think we're going to be guessing.
SPEAKER_01And I love let's end on that. I love that. I think one of the reasons Steve and I get along so well is we both understand that the Supreme Court doesn't exist outside of politics and politics doesn't exist outside of the Supreme Court. These the these justices are perceiving what is happening in the they are not they are not walled off and separated from all media. Right. I think it's a really important and that's circle that is if the political environment shows tangible signs of eroding. even further on Republicans. Maybe that's the thing that kind of tips Alito's hand.
SPEAKER_01Steve Vladek, I've promoted this before. I will continue to. His Substack called One First is absolutely outstanding. I know a lot of people... already subscribed to it or on this chat if you if you do not you should uh trust me and i want to recommend uh the book that steve wrote about the shadow docket more more relevant now literally than ever before maybe even more relevant than the day it came out steve probably more people know about the shadow docket uh it's called the shadow docket how the supreme court uses stealth
rulings to amass power and undermine the republic i if you want to understand how the court is working
SPEAKER_01and what it means for executive power and Donald Trump. But executive power more broadly, you should read it. Thank you. I know you're busy. Thanks for taking the time, my friend.
SPEAKER_00Always a pleasure, Chris. Thanks so much.
SPEAKER_01And thanks to everybody who joined us today.
As I noted in Monday’s post, the Harvard Law Review’s annual Supreme Court issue, including my Foreword - “The Court Against the Courts” - came out last week. On Thursday, November 20, I sat down with Harvard law...
In this episode of “First One,” the (fairly irregular) podcast companion to the “One First” newsletter, Steve sat down with Karen Vladeck (a lawyer-turned-legal recruiter and the founder and managing director of...
On Tuesday morning, Cristian Farias and I got together for a quick Substack Live to discuss the goings-on in the Missouri redistricting case - including what happened in the Eighth Circuit on Monday and what’s likely to...