This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.stevevladeck.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01We are live. That is Steve, uh, Vladek on the other end. Sorry, we're slightly late. We had, uh, we had some technological difficulties, but, uh, you're like Steve Vladek, is that the Agnes Williams sesquicentennial professor of federal courts at Georgetown law school? And yes, in fact, that is Steve Vladek, the sesquicentennial Agnes Williams fellow. Um, he is also for people who are, uh, regular viewers of these things. I, Steve is, uh, And I mean this in the best possible sense, my crutch, because when I need to understand something that's going on in
the courts or the
SPEAKER_01Constitution, I always reach out to Stephen. He is incredibly gracious. So yesterday on Sunday, I read a huge piece in The New York Times that if you have not read, I would recommend it is called The Inside Story of Five Days That Remade the Shadow Court. Secret memos obtained by The New York Times illuminate the origins of the court's now routine shadow docket rulings on presidential power. And I thought, wait a minute, I know someone who knows a lot about the shadow docket because in 2023, Steve Vladek wrote The Shadow Docket,
how the Supreme Court uses stealth rulings to amass power and undermine the
SPEAKER_01republic. There is literally no one... better suited to explain the New York Times story, why it matters, than Steve Bladick. And so he's super busy, but managed to make time for me, which I'm hugely grateful for. And by the way, and I should have mentioned to the top, Steve writes in invaluable substat called one first if you have not subscribed in tens of thousands of you have please do it is well worth your time all right so steve let's first of all
thank you second of all thank you for what we worked out our we worked out our technological difficulties um tell me why don't you walk people through if they haven't read the story walk people through what's new here and then i want to i
SPEAKER_01want to go broader
SPEAKER_00I will say, Chris, first of all, it's great to be back with you. I will say, yes, things are very busy, but at least I don't have to watch any baseball since the Mets have lost 11.
SPEAKER_01Now, have you heard the stat that since Zoran Mamdani hugged Mr. and Mrs. Mets, they have lost 11 straight games?
SPEAKER_00I know. So back to the fact of that. So we have known I mean, we knew about this rule and when it happened. Right. So in February of 2016, there was this unsigned, unexplained five to four ruling from the Supreme Court that blocked President Obama's clean power plan. And it was a bit of a bombshell at the time, Chris, because, you know, the court had granted emergency relief before. I mean, this was not the first time ever. And no one, contra some folks on the right, no one is saying this was the first time. But we had never seen the Supreme Court
SPEAKER_00intervened like this, basically where the court was blocking a nationwide federal policy, Chris, before any lower court had reviewed any of it. And Steve, can you just explain to people emergency relief? So, you know, historically... litigation takes time. And so, you know, separate from who's going to win at the end of the day, there's often this really important question of what is the status quo going to be while the lawsuit challenging the thing works its way through the courts.
SPEAKER_00Usually, right, Chris, when we're talking about emergency relief, some lower court has done something. You know, a district judge somewhere enjoins a policy and the question is, should the Supreme Court, you know, stay the injunction? Should it let the injunction, should it let the policy go back into effect? What was novel about the Clean Power Plan case was that the only thing that had happened in the case is it had been filed in the federal appeals court in Washington because this kind of case goes right to the appeals court. And then the federal appeals court had denied sort of this
initial request for emergency relief.
SPEAKER_00They had said, we're not going to block this right away. It's too soon. Let's Let's take some briefs. Let's actually figure out what's going on here. Got it. And it was at that juncture that the Supreme Court back in February 2016 jumped in. We knew that happened.
SPEAKER_01That was a documented thing. They released that very cryptic statement. Right.
SPEAKER_00And I think, you know, I and some others have suggested not that that was first, but that it really marked in some respects an inflection point because you can really see on the far side of that intervention in February 2016, the court becoming much more willing, Chris, especially during the first Trump administration to grant not just that kind of emergency relief, but other kinds. Like it wasn't that it didn't exist before. It was that it wasn't common before. Right. And this is really, in some respects, a harbinger of what has become a far more common,
SPEAKER_00dominant and important part of the Supreme Court's work ever since. So that was the backdrop. And then what what we got on Saturday, thanks to this really remarkable reporting from Jody Cantor and Adam Liptak in The New York Times. Chris, we got the internal memos.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, this is like inner sanctum stuff. I mean, anyone who's ever covered the Supreme Court, it's very challenging to get anything out of that. But go ahead, Steve.
SPEAKER_00No, I mean, you're right. And that's important. I mean, so we got 16 pages of memos. I think a total of seven memos from six justices that really gave us like a peek behind the curtain into what had happened and how the court had gone from a particular intervention we had never seen before to, you know, the ruling that we all saw 10 years ago. And, you know, I mean, there's a lot to say about the memos. There's a lot to say about The New York Times having the memos. To me, Chris, the top line is the role of Chief Justice Roberts.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Right. Instead of just saying, like, I'm not going to do this, it really is Roberts in his first memo who says, oh, hey, guys, this is a real problem. We should step in. And when Justice Stephen Breyer responds and says,
what about this more modest compromise? It's Roberts who fires back and says, no, we have to go the whole nine yards.
SPEAKER_00Right. So this really is a story about John Roberts, you know, Mr. Balls and Strikes. Yes, famously. Right. Actually being like the moving force behind this, if not novel, certainly unusual type of intervention.
SPEAKER_01And how unusual, Steve, because, you know, you see these things and people are like, well, of course, The New York Times is going to hype it up. But how unusual is it to see this? These are, these are memos sent between the justices, just to be clear. These are, these are not, you know, this is sort of how, for me, at least the thing I found fascinating was like, this is how they actually interact. Right. I mean, we, we don't really have a lot of insight into that. How unusual is this sort of thing?
SPEAKER_01Because you, you have said, we'll never, you famously said you're quoted in the New York times piece saying, you know, uh, Until these papers get released, we'll never know how the hell this happened. And here we are. How unusual is it, I guess, is the question.
SPEAKER_00I think it's highly unusual from a timing perspective. Not from a we saw the memos perspective. So let me let me break those apart. Right. Which is we typically, Chris, do at some point get access to the justice's private papers.
SPEAKER_01I did not know that.
SPEAKER_00OK. But it's usually long after they have. Yes. served with dies. So my line back in February about how we won't know until our grandkids can see the papers, that's because that's often when we get papers today. So right now, I think the most recent papers we have public access
to are some of Justice O'Connor's papers from before Justice Thomas joined the court. Because that would be the window before which there was any current justice on the court.
SPEAKER_00That's 1991, right? And so it's not that we would never have seen these papers, Chris. It's that you and I would have been very gray yes even more than i am yes and then my daughters tell me i am um you know like one day we would have learned all this stuff it is it is incredibly unusual to learn this stuff now um while you know so many of the justices who were actively involved in the behind the scenes stuff aren't just still alive chris they're still on the court and i i okay i have a million questions
SPEAKER_01How, as someone who followed this closely, you wrote an entire book about the emergence of the shadow docket. We're going to talk about that. How surprised are you by what is in the memos or was it sort of what you expected? As you point out, like for me, again, novice. Roberts is clearly the central mover in this, and I don't know this, you'll know this, is clearly establishing precedent whether he intends to do so or not,
SPEAKER_01because we know what's come in the last decade, right? How is this sort of when you saw that in February 2016 and you were like you flagged is like, well, that's odd. Is this sort of what you thought the back room talks look like? It's so rare that like you said, it's so rare that in like real ish time we get some sense of like, oh, oh, that's actually how it went. Like, tell me when you saw this, were you surprised? Not surprised.
SPEAKER_00Disappointed. Okay. That's a good parent answer.
SPEAKER_01I'm not angry. I'm just disappointed.
SPEAKER_00I guess, I mean, Chris, what it comes down to is I had suspected for most of the time that I've been working on this topic, which really goes almost all the way back to 2016, right? I had suspected that this was about what was happening. And by this, Let me be clear. By this, I mean a very brief, relatively summary exchange of memos. And indeed, part of why Will Bode coined the term shadow docket back in 2015 was to reflect the idea that it's not only happening in the shadows, but that what's actually happening is itself pretty shadowy.
That there's not the kind of full-throated deliberation that we tend to think about
SPEAKER_00when we think about what goes into, say, a merits decision from the Supreme Court. When the justices have had months of debate, when they've had in-person oral argument, when they've discussed the case together at one of their conferences, right? I had always assumed that none of that was happening here. I had written that I suspected that it was very impoverished. Here's the proof in the pudding. And so I guess, you know, Folks who had responded to me had said,
SPEAKER_00no, I'm sure that they're actually doing quite a lot behind the scenes and they're really actually taking these issues seriously and deliberating them fully. And I think the memos just belie that. And I think they really sort of stress that this was the 16 pages of back and forth analysis is all we got to block a major, major nationwide policy.
SPEAKER_01I want to talk more about the shadow docket. And there's a question in here, and you mentioned this obliquely, but I want to get into it. So Andrew Steele says, Sarah Isker, who we both know, rejoined that the first use of the shadow docket related to Texas anti-abortion measures in 2014 2014, 2015. Is that right? That's not my recollection. So can you talk about, you did say this was not the first time emergency relief had been used, but you said it's an inflection point. Can you explain just a history of that,
SPEAKER_01both where we were before then, what happened then, and then where we are now?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, without boring everybody to tears.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I was going to, that was assumed. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So There's so much to say about how Sarah Isger portrays all of this history that I will save for another time. The short version is, no, what happened in 2016 wasn't first, right? I mean, as I note in the book, what we think of as modern emergency relief in the Supreme Court really dates all the way back to the early 20th century. Early 20th century, okay. And it was handled almost always by one justice acting on their own. And so that necessarily limited what would happen in one of
those rulings, right?
SPEAKER_00A justice might let a particular action keep happening against They might block a particular action. Those were the sort of the fact that it was one justice tended to limit the scope of the rulings. And the court reflecting that, Chris, didn't do it very often. Got it. If a case was a big enough emergency, they would just take it on the merits. and give it the full nine yards of process.
SPEAKER_01And when you say on the merit, Steve, that means what we typically think of, which is there's oral arguments. There's a month-long process that goes into it. Is that a fair?
SPEAKER_00Exactly right. And there's full review versus this cryptic truncated review. The shift toward more and more full court truncated emergency review happens in the 1980s, Chris, but only in the context of the death penalty. And so there are tons of examples in the 1980s and 1990s and 2000s of the Supreme Court granting emergency relief in capital cases where, yeah, that's the emergency docket. And Chris, those cases are big deals to the people who are involved, but they don't have statewide or nationwide.
SPEAKER_00That's right.
SPEAKER_01Pardoning someone or putting off the death penalty. Right. It does not set precedent in any meaningful way. power plan is not the first example, although neither is Isger's Texas abortion example. The reason why the clean power plan case was an inflection point was because,
SPEAKER_00Chris, it was a new type of intervention. So as opposed to saying, hey, the district court in Texas blocked part of Texas's new abortion law. The federal appeals court unblocked some of it. We're going to re-block some of it. Instead of this vertical back and forth with lower courts in a case about one state's law— Here's the Supreme Court reaching out before anybody else has to set a what Justice Kavanaugh today would call a nationally uniform interim answer
on whether the Clean
SPEAKER_00Power Plan can go into effect. And the answer was no. And so that's novel, Chris, in two respects. One, the very particular lawyerly, nerdy type of relief, a stay of administrative action. The court had never done that before. But even for the non-lawyers, it was novel in that you hadn't seen the court basically step in on a question of nationwide policy application before the lower courts had done even a modest amount of litigation. And so, no, were there emergency rules before 2016?
SPEAKER_00Of course there were. This was still something different, as everyone seemed to understand at the time, except Roberts. I mean, Kagan even says in her memo that we see, like, this would be unprecedented. She's right. Can I ask a quick clarification? Rehabilitate that it's not unprecedented now.
SPEAKER_01Does Roberts not know it or not care? Because I don't think anyone, whether you like John Roberts or not, he's not a dumb man. He's clearly a very bright man as it relates to the law. So does he... That's what I can't answer this, Steve, but it's like, does he know he's setting present? Like, could he imagine? I want you to talk about this in a minute, but could he imagine what has happened between 2016 and 2026 with emergency relief in the shadow docket? Or would it have been very difficult for him to imagine that
this being the seed
SPEAKER_01that germinates into what we have now? I think it would have been very difficult for him to imagine that the emergency
SPEAKER_00docket today would look like what it looks like today. And I think if he knew that, he might very well have moved a little differently in 2016. Yeah. But I mean, just to make the point, right? I mean, so in 2016, right, this was the only ruling during that entire term in which the Supreme Court blocked an Obama administration policy, right, without full review, without plenty of review. Fast forward to the Biden administration, where it seemed to happen every month, or the Trump administration,
where the court has one of these major questions about a nationwide policy
SPEAKER_00seemingly every six weeks or so. That's a big uptick. To the broader point, though, about did he understand it was news? I guess my short answer is probably Chris, but not as much as maybe he should have. And some of that might also be because if you go back and read the Obama administration's brief about why the court shouldn't have stepped in, It was written like it was written from the perspective of obviously you're not going to step in.
And so it actually sort of pulled its punches a bit on just how unprecedented it
SPEAKER_00would be on just like it says these things, but it's a it's a relatively like, you know, we're pretty confident, you know, you're not going to you're not going to totally right.
SPEAKER_01OK, I want to take a quick pause and I want for people who have joined and thank you, everyone, for who has joined. I want to make sure everyone knows we're talking to Steve Ladek, Georgetown law professor, my friend, author of the one first substack, which if you want to be smarter about the Constitution, the courts, the law. you absolutely 100% need to subscribe. Follow the tens of thousands of people who haven't. And specifically, and Steve has noticed this, has referenced this a few times. Steve wrote a book in 2023 called The Shadow Docket, how the Supreme Court uses stealth rulings to amass power and
undermine the
SPEAKER_01republic. We are talking about that book and his knowledge in light of The report in The New York Times on Saturday, about 16 pages worth of memos about the internal workings of this very specific energy act that the Obama administration was trying to put in place. So, Steve, let's talk about—we've talked about this before, but I think for people who are new to this, talk about the growth of the shadow docket from this— To where we are now, because you and I have talked many times over about how this
has just become,
SPEAKER_01even since you've written the book, it's become even more. I mean, there is a whole I feel like you were on the leading edge of this is that this is going to become a bigger and bigger and bigger thing. So please, please kind of talk about how it's been used more and more and more.
SPEAKER_00So let's just start with numbers, right? I mean, so there's both quantity and quality, Chris. And so to the quantity point, so the Obama administration, which is in office for, you know, eight years, seeks this kind of emergency relief, I think it was a total of four times. So either it's somewhere between, I don't know, Obama and Bush together, it was eight. I can't remember what the word.
SPEAKER_01Obama and Bush for 16 years.
SPEAKER_00Right. Eight times in 16 years. Right. Right. The Trump administration in its first 15 months in office this time is up to 34. And, you know, these cases, it's not just a volume point, Chris, the qualitative impact. So, you know, the Trump cases have been, you know, Can President Trump kick transgender service members out of the military? Can he cut the Department of Education in half? Can he refuse to spend billions of dollars of mandatory appropriations? Can ICE continue engaging in what certainly looks like racial
profiling when it's doing
SPEAKER_00immigration stops? Can, you know, the administration require all transgender or non-binary individuals to have a passport that reflects their biological sex at birth? I mean, these are cases that have really much broader impact, right, than what we saw before. So it's a combination of more and more and more of these. That's right. And bigger and bigger effects. And just one data point. So last term, you The court decided 31 cases, Chris, on the merits docket.
SPEAKER_00So with the full review in which the justices were not unanimous. So, you know, the sort of the non-technical boring cases, the cases where the justices were actually divided. They also granted emergency relief 31 times. So we've reached numerical equivalents for cases on the merits docket that aren't just unanimous, easy decisions by the court and emergency interventions by the justices. That was unheard of when the Clean Power Plan case came out. That term,
SPEAKER_00I think the total number of emergency interventions was six or seven, and almost all of those were in death penalty cases.
SPEAKER_01Is... Is this the exploitation of a loophole, Steve? Is this how the court is supposed to work? Is this the natural evolution of an organic body through time? I mean, look, I'm generally speaking, I would rather have the full... particularly to your point, these are not one-off cases with very little impact. These are, these have lasting, these are big policies. I mean,
SPEAKER_01this can be how much, how much leeway does the executive branch have versus the legislative branch? These are constitutional questions, right? But is it, I mean, what I wonder is you said it is both shadowy in that it doesn't, it happens in the shadows, a little bit off the stage, but also shadowy in its, kind of approach yeah it like how do you what do you make of this because i mean if it's basically the same number of decisions as the what i'll call the traditional
route for the supreme court i wonder if if we talk in three years if we're both
SPEAKER_01still lucky enough to be doing this do we We see more emergency relief cases. I mean, it's certainly the growth line looks quite clear.
SPEAKER_00It's hard to imagine. It's hard to imagine that we see more because I don't even know how the court would have the capacity for it. I guess, Chris, I think there are a couple of different things to say, and I want to try to separate out three points. Right. So the volume by itself, I think, is not necessarily an indictment. Right. You could imagine a set of. You mean the number, just the number of cases being sought for emergency relief. That's right. And so, you know, if you had a series of lower courts that were behaving badly, right, or if you had sort of a body of cases where just the Supreme
Court needed to
SPEAKER_00clarify the law and hadn't clarified the law yet, right, you might actually be able to construct a narrative for why We need the Supreme Court to step in quite so often and quite so early. The volume itself is not the problem. The problem is twofold. One, that the court is intervening, Chris, usually without explaining itself. Yes. And two, that the court's interventions without explanations have this way of looking deeply unprincipled and have this way of looking like the justices are
playing partisan
SPEAKER_00political favorites. tie this to Saturday's reporting. I mean, one of the things that's really striking about the Roberts memos is that he goes out of his way twice to talk about the harm that letting the Clean Power Plan remain in place will inflict on industry.
SPEAKER_01The cost and those sorts of things.
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's right. And, you know, whatever. I mean, let's assume he's right just for the sake of argument. He never mentions the harm to the government that would result from blocking this regulation, let alone, Chris, the harm to the environment. Now, you and I and folks who are watching us might all balance those harms. differently. That's fine. What is striking about Roberts's memos is that he doesn't even acknowledge them. Chris, when so many of the Trump cases have turned on the idea that
any time the executive
SPEAKER_00branch has stopped from doing anything, it's irreparably harmed. And so, you know, it's the problem of the lack of explanation and the apparent hypocrisy, where the best defense against the hypocrisy would be the explanations we're not getting, right? Would be, hey, here are the principles.
SPEAKER_01I, oh, I want to note, Jackie Kurt says, Steve, thank you for your one first this morning in this discussion. I will say if you have not read Steve's piece, he sent it to me this morning. I read it at 630 this morning. You should, because it gives you, while I think this discussion is quite worthy, if this discussion sparks interest, go read that, because I think that is really, really, really important. So, Steve, what is, as someone who watches this stuff really closely... knowing what we know today versus what we knew on Friday.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Roberts has, I'm fascinated by Roberts in that he is, he, he has played equal parts hero and villain. I feel like in societally for the left and the right. And, and he's been touted as kind of, well, he's the deciding vote and he, he, is the one who is keep constraining Trump's worst instincts, or he is the one who is allowing Trump's worst instincts, you know, as it relates to some of the more recent rulings.
SPEAKER_01What is this knowledge that you now have? Walk me from 2016 till now. Does it change your perception of that decade of the court and in Roberts in particular? Because obviously as a chief justice, he has significant influence. I mean, what should we take from it? You said your biggest top line was Roberts is... aggressive push. And as you just noted, focusing on the harm being done to companies and kind of ignoring and ignoring, by the way, like Kagan saying,
SPEAKER_01we are setting precedent here. This is dangerous. Like, what is it? How does that color Roberts's time? Or maybe it doesn't.
SPEAKER_00No, I think it does. I mean, I think this should disabuse folks of the John Roberts committed institutionalist narrative. Maybe there are times where he votes in a way that doesn't seem consistent with his ideology, but behind the scenes, like it is real. I mean, I mean, Chris, what really happened here? What really happened is John Roberts was pissed off because he thought that the Obama administration had pulled a fast one on the court.
SPEAKER_01That they were trying to end run the court effectively.
SPEAKER_00And his evidence for that was a blog post and a BBC. news you know a bbc report and it's like um he's entitled to those opinions but to take those opinions and turn them into we should drop everything and block this thing um i think really does sort of bespeak a willingness to um Not just call balls and strikes, Chris. Right. But actually to to play a little bit of almost Calvin ball, if you will. Totally. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Make up making up the rules.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's right. And so, you know, I don't know. I think there are plenty of folks who already had that perception of John Roberts. But I really do think that, you know, the next time. I mentioned Sarah Isger, like she's on her book tour right now talking about how the court isn't as ideologically divided as people think and that the justices are nine people just doing their best and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And it just seems to me that every day we are confronted with evidence to the contrary, whether it's Clarence Thomas's deeply, you know, anti-progressive speech last Wednesday at the University of Texas or,
SPEAKER_00you know, this. Right.
SPEAKER_01I mean, yeah, a lot of Supreme Court news lately, Steve.
SPEAKER_00And Chris, that's a story unto itself. Yes, totally.
SPEAKER_01Speak on that. I think that's so important. Yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_00Why is this coming out now? Why is Clarence Thomas giving that speech now? Why did Justice Sotomayor, in my view, actually cross a little bit of a line with Justice Kavanaugh? And I think... Back to sort of how we're not usually privy to what's going on behind the curtain. Seems like there's some pretty nasty stuff going on behind the curtain right now. And that we are in for, and it's not hard, Chris, to predict, given what's before the justices right now, which of the cases are really dividing them. You know, the Louisiana redistricting cases,
which are in many respects a referendum on whether we can have an interracial
SPEAKER_00democracy, a multiracial democracy.
SPEAKER_01Those are the Voting Rights Act cases, correct?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_01And that is still undecided and would, would political, for my world, would have a gigantic impact, but yeah.
SPEAKER_00And I think just institutionally, Chris, would be the court itself going back on a move it made 40 years ago to give the Voting Rights Act teeth. And so, you know, I think part of what we're seeing is that in some respects, the bloom is off the rose and we are seeing publicly different Flash points for how divisive and divided the court is internally. And I think that's, you know, not good for anybody. But I also think it ought to push rather aggressively against
efforts to create this narrative that the court isn't as political as people think and that the court
SPEAKER_00isn't as divided as people claim. You know, all signs, Chris, are to the contrary.
SPEAKER_01Which is so fascinating because, you know, for people who don't know the whole balls and strikes reference, John Roberts very famously described his role in his confirmation hearings as that was his role. And it's he has spent, I feel like his entire, you know, what it's has he been chief justice for 20 years? Oh, five. Is that right?
SPEAKER_00Earlier, maybe this is this is 20. So he celebrated his 20th anniversary as chief justice last September.
SPEAKER_01So that is his effort, I would say, broadly speaking to the public, maybe not the legal community, but to the public has been we are not political. We are not involved in the political. And that, to me, was the most interesting thing, because your point is he in this in these memos, he literally cites a blog post. It was like me writing a memo. it's just an interesting for that guy. I like how you put that. The idea of committed institutionalist is probably not, which, which by the way, John Roberts himself has done a lot of work to try to polish that.
SPEAKER_00And Chris, one more thing about the blog post point. So again, right? Like, The point is not that there's only one correct way to look at these cases. Right. The point is that the indictment is of the justices behaving inconsistently because the same John Roberts, who in February 2016 wants to base the court's intervention on public statements by two EPS. officials is the John Roberts who writes the majority opinion two years later in the travel ban case that refuses to look at President Trump's public statements. What he has said, exactly. That's right. Because he says,
SPEAKER_00you know, what government officials say publicly is not the same thing as the policies they've adopted. And it's like, you can believe that, but you have to believe that consistently, right? It cannot be that what Republicans say doesn't actually shape the policy, but what Democrats say does. Totally. problem with the shadow docket, which I think folks who are criticizing people like me or who are saying there's nothing in the in those memos here are all missing. Right. The problem is not that the court is doing these things.
SPEAKER_00The problem is how. Yeah. And the problem is that the court, the how is masked. by the court's refusal to explain itself, not just because, Chris, those explanations are depriving us of understanding what happened, but, Chris, the explanations would themselves be the basis for insisting when a different president's in office that they should receive the same treatment.
SPEAKER_01And I will add from just a public perception perspective, the reality is that the Supreme Court, and this is true of many institutions, the Supreme Court's trust level among the public has never been lower. And when there are more and more things like this, like you said, 31 plenary decisions, 31 emergency relief decisions, you are adding to the mystery. The explaining yourself is the best defense in many ways, and they are not taking it.
SPEAKER_01I see a lot of people in the comments. I'm going to sum it up because I don't want to read any one because a lot of them are similar. But a lot of the questions are what what can be done about this? You know, I know people talk about expanding the court. I know people talk about term limits. I will say as a layman, those feel very far fetched to me. What is the. I mean, this is a relatively recent problem, right? It's like you said, yes, emergency relief has been sought before, but eight times in the 16 years of Bush and Obama versus 34
times in the 15 months
SPEAKER_01Donald Trump has been president, it seems to suggest to me that this is a growing issue that might need to be addressed. What do you... What can what can reasonably be done? I know I see a lot of people saying we need to expand the court. It's like, well, I'm not saying that that might not be a solution. I'm saying what is what are the practical, pragmatic things that might happen or aren't there any?
SPEAKER_00So, I mean, I guess I would say I'm a little biased because I literally just finished my manuscript for my next book, which is about all of this. Yeah. The short version is I think the shadow docket and the court's behavior is a symptom of a broader disease. And I think the justices' ethical kerfuffles are symptoms of a broader disease. And I think the broader disease, Chris, is that the Supreme Court today is not accountable. to the other branches and does not think it is or ought to be accountable to other branches in a way that had never been true historically.
SPEAKER_00And I say historically like as recently as the 1980s. And so to me, the real problem here is how do we make the court more accountable to And I don't think changing the personnel is the magic bullet here. I think the way you make the court more accountable is by trying to sort of restore the idea that the court is not just six Republicans and three Democrats, that the court is an institution of government and should be in conversation with the other institutions of government. And that the less it is actually, Chris,
in the long term, the harder it will be. for the court to do its job because you mentioned how unpopular the court has become.
SPEAKER_00The court's power, as you know, comes from its popularity. It comes from the sort of- People trust it, right?
SPEAKER_01That they are neutral. You might not agree with each ruling, but they are perceived- before 10 years ago, at least, to be neutral or smart, neutral arbiters.
SPEAKER_00Right. We might not agree with the principles, but we agree that they are principles. Correct. Yes, exactly right. The problem is that the court today is under no pressure from its supporters or from Congress or from really, frankly, much of the American people to live up to that ideal. And I think we changed the conversation, Chris, by changing how we think and talk about the Supreme Court, by having conversations like like the one you and I are having right now, by getting folks to join us in saying the court's behavior is
problematic,
SPEAKER_00not just because I don't like the results. That's right. We focus too much on the result and not enough on the process that reaches the
SPEAKER_01result, which is, I think, what this time story reveals. This process, again, to my non-lawyer, non-constitutional expert, non-professor mind, this process feels... insufficient for the reach of what it is created. That's how I guess I would put it.
SPEAKER_00No, that's as well put, right? That, that, that we, that the more the court is doing, the more we expect the court to do. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Exactly.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And, and I think that that's the lesson here that I think a lot of us had already suspected. Um, But I guess I'll just say it seems to me that there's two pieces here that folks should take away from this conversation. Right. The first is the process matters. Right. Like whatever you think of the Clean Power Plan, whatever you think of, you know, the Trump cases, the court's legitimacy comes from our folks. faith that the court is actually following a process. And so, you know, even if you're not sure about the results, the notion that we want the court to explain itself more should not be controversial.
SPEAKER_00And the second piece of this, Chris, is, you know, it is a very common trope on the right these days to say the court is fine because it's not in the bag for Trump. Right. And so, yeah, right. People point to the tariffs case and to the possibility. I think the likelihood is going to lose the birthright citizenship. And they say, look, the court is neutral in principle because it's not giving Trump everything he wants. Those are not the same. Correct. Right. And so I guess my encouragement is folks should be paying more
attention to how the court's doing its business and folks should be paying attention to whether like the court is behaving consistently or whether the justices are just doing what they
SPEAKER_00want when they want. Because the latter may be sort of something that produces satisfying results, Chris, in a random subset of cases. It is not in the long term a good thing for our separation of powers.
SPEAKER_01I think I see Ellen Evans saying process matters. Yes, process matters in all of these things. You know, just because the outcome, one of the things that makes me crazy, Stephen, it's not your world, but people, pollsters towards the very end of campaigns will just kind of finagle their results to look like what the final result is. How you arrive at that matters. What is your methodology that gets you there? Because that is the thing that sustains. Anybody can be like, oh, oh, this is going to be a blowout. Let me make the numbers look like a blowout.
SPEAKER_01It's process matters. If we just focus on outcomes and you say, oh, well, the court's not bad because this outcome is one I agree with. That is not how we build and maintain trust in institutions. The Supreme Court isn't good when they rule on tariffs and bad when they rule on presidential immunity. Just as one example. That's not how it works. That's not how it should work. I think a lot of people on the right and left see it that way. And this is why I think it's so important for us to keep having
this conversation, because what I find so important about Saturday's story is it is a real sort of opportunity for folks who aren't super Supreme Court nerds and for folks who haven't maybe clerked on the Supreme Court to understand just how impoverished the
SPEAKER_00process is and why that unto itself is a problem. Yeah. you know, is it the biggest story in 2026? No. But is it a sort of further piece of evidence that the Supreme Court is unhealthy and that we should all be invested in thinking about how to make it healthier?
SPEAKER_01That's a great way to put it. Yeah, I think that's a great way to put it. I would say when people ask me about Congress or the presidency, unhealthy is the way I describe it. And that has not really to do with Trump. It has to do with kind of the broader, like, How we are getting to where we are getting as opposed to who we focus so much on the people. And I think the court is like that. You focus on the people and the personalities. OK, I'm going to let you go very quickly and I'm going to have you back if I can when we get some of these. But Louisiana voting rights cases,
SPEAKER_01birthright citizenship, anything else, usually by the end of June, we have all of it. Anything else big? I mean,
SPEAKER_00the nuclear bomb for the administrative state is Trump versus Slaughter, which is the unitary executive case. That's right. That's right. You know, it might be helpful, Chris, to think about the Stephen Miller agenda versus the Russ vote agenda. Okay. Right. It's going to be a bad term for the Stephen Miller agenda in the Supreme Court. By the time we're done, it could be a very good term for the Russell vote agenda. Yeah. And I think that's going to be part of the story.
SPEAKER_01And we will talk. We will talk more about that because Steve is a very sought after commodity always, but especially when the court rules. So I've he and I have gone back and forth about finding a time for him to come on and talk about that. So we will. The one I have the eye on, obviously, is the Voting Rights Act case, because like you said, I mean, it's a huge issue. It's a huge issue. It could reshape the partisanship of Congress, particularly in the South. But, okay, Unitary Executive, Birthright Citizenship, Voting Rights Act cases.
SPEAKER_01Those are three big ones we'll keep an eye on. Again, Steve Vladek is my friend, and he is an absolute mensch because I literally emailed him yesterday and said, hey, can you come on and talk about it? So he did. One first is the name of his sub stack. Again, if you don't follow it... Educate yourself. You don't have to agree with Steve. I always said this. You don't have to agree, but educate yourself so that you know what is happening to our institutions in our country. And the court, I think, may well be the most important of those. Also, if you're interested in the shadow docket, look,
the shadow docket isn't getting it. less important is getting more important steve in 2023 again ahead of the curve new york times bestseller the shadow docket how the supreme court uses stealth rulings to amass power and undermine the republic if you want to understand the next three ish years of how donald trump approaches the legal system read the book it's as
SPEAKER_01simple as that uh Steve, thank you for taking time. Everyone, thank you for joining, whether live or on tape. Go to one first and go buy Shadow Docket. Trust me, make yourself smarter. Support smart people writing smart and thoughtful things. Thank you, Steve.
SPEAKER_00Thanks, Chris. Great to see you. All right, man.
As I noted in Monday’s post, the Harvard Law Review’s annual Supreme Court issue, including my Foreword - “The Court Against the Courts” - came out last week. On Thursday, November 20, I sat down with Harvard law...
In this episode of “First One,” the (fairly irregular) podcast companion to the “One First” newsletter, Steve sat down with Karen Vladeck (a lawyer-turned-legal recruiter and the founder and managing director of...
On Tuesday morning, Cristian Farias and I got together for a quick Substack Live to discuss the goings-on in the Missouri redistricting case - including what happened in the Eighth Circuit on Monday and what’s likely to...