Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Conversations

Conversations artwork

the year of the bride w/ Jade Hurley

Aug 10, 202632 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is part 5 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl online is an independent platform that reports on what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to them. The weekly stories that you read on Wednesdays (which I admittedly haven’t been super consistent on but I am trying xD) are written by me, based on what the web feeds me, and filtered through my lens. This series is an attempt to bring in diverse experiences of digital girlhood to you. In this episode, I am joined by Jade Hurley, and we talk about heterosexual relationships, the societal pressure to get married and discuss whether all this celebrity wedding content is making it cool to get married young again. Special shoutout to my sister, Azha, for editing this conversation. If you’d like to fund my work on here, here’s the tip jar. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.girlonline.in

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to Girl Online, a space where we discuss what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to us. I am Abha Ahad, the girl behind Girl Online. This is part 5 of an 8 part series of conversations I had with fellow culture experts from around the world. In each episode, we dive deep into a specific subculture these experts have been tracking for years.

SPEAKER_01Today we have with us Jade. Jade Holly is a writer, teacher, abortion fund worker and abiding feminist historian. She's based in Chicago and writes about the intersection of whiteness and feminism, labour, artificial intelligence and global politics. Hi Jade, welcome to Girl Online.

SPEAKER_02Hey, I'm so happy to be here. I am so happy you reached out to me. I love your work. So I'm really pumped to talk about girls online.

SPEAKER_01I can't wait. Thank you. I am so glad you heard. What are we discussing today?

SPEAKER_02Well, so we know like the manosphere. And I feel like I want to talk about something that isn't necessarily specific because That is like a through line that I've been gathering from my positionality as someone who lives in the United States. Just like this trend that is between a couple of different trends and that kind

SPEAKER_02of see what's happening. I love you. I feel like we as women in 2026 understand the problem.

SPEAKER_02We're intellectualizing the problem and like we're complaining, we're lamenting with each other as we should. There's all these different definitions of like how to be a woman now and how to specifically engage with men. But I think we're only intellectualizing the problems like We're not solving it.

SPEAKER_02So I'm not victim blaming. I think that all of us are like victims to patriarchy, like regardless of gender. Like I really do think that we're in a really interesting position in 2026. We're like women outnumber men like in med school classes. Like, all of a sudden, like, if you have a biology degree, that's not an easy way.

SPEAKER_02Like, okay, you can get a job from that. Maybe like 20 years ago, you could. That's because it's become a feminized career. So we have all this technical power that's also being stripped away from us. And we're going online to talk about it and complain about it and lament and build community. And like discuss our shared victimhood or possible future victimhood but we're only talking about it but we're not making the decisions to interrupt or like we're not taking the risks that are needed to interrupt it and And

SPEAKER_02that is what I want to talk about. And like this loop and I keep thinking of it as like this loop of victimhood and entrapment of like seeing this all as we are trapped, which is true. We're not climbing out of it. We're not finding the ways to climb out of it. And I don't really know how to do that. But that's what I would love to talk about.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Despite the world being really difficult. To live and process at the moment, I absolutely believe that we need to constantly be working towards as a community, not individually. I'm not talking about hustling and all that. But as a community, we should have hope. I love the sort of narrative self-reflective writing that goes on here. It's very important. But it's also just...

SPEAKER_01And so interestingly enough, the first time I came across the term womanosphere, it was in The Guardian, I think the UK publication, it was to specifically talk about Right wing women like the TPUSA girls or candor servants and all of these people.

SPEAKER_01And at that time, we discussed this in like our group chat as well, the girl online group chat. The term women who are being used to talk about these people did not sit right with me. Because one, just because it's women saying these things doesn't make it a women's thing or I'm not a choice feminist. I do not believe if a woman says that it just automatically makes it a feminist choice. And Candice Vaughan saying make him a sandwich is definitely not a feminist thing. So the idea that the term womanosphere was used to talk about these people,

SPEAKER_01it just did not sit well with me because I just think that they are still the manosphere. Like, yes, the talking minds are still the manosphere. Just because women are saying some things doesn't make it different. Women has been perpetuating misogyny for like centuries. So like, we don't need a different term, womenosphere for them. But lately, the term womenosphere is being used for women influencers. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Want a woman who is going to take care of herself. Men want a woman who is just going to stay hot and all of these things. You need to stay hot to keep your man down. Those were their talking points. But these talking points are like, if a man is going to use you for your beauty, then you're going to have to use him for your money. And initially, you know, when I was younger, those talking points, it's like, yes, you know, that was how I would see it. But now I do not know because polarization is never the answer.

SPEAKER_02Mm hmm.

SPEAKER_01The answer can never be man versus woman. The answer can never be like, you know, the gender war thing, right? Yes. And it doesn't help anybody. No. As the human race per se, it doesn't help anybody. It's not adding anything to our society. We also need to de-radicalize the girls into thinking that the manosphere is everybody believes in things. And I don't know, I am going to sound like not all men and I don't believe that. You know, if I see a random man on the street, I am going to be scared.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, of course. But how do you see that distinction? How do you think we can talk to young women or we can talk to women sort of pink pilled? I think they say that. Yeah. Call it pink pilled. And how can we de-radicalize them, so to speak?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I feel like the thing that I often think about first when there's any kind of like generalization of women, like all women do this, like this is the womanosphere, this is this thing. And this is honestly, it sounds so obvious, but like when I was studying women's gender and sexuality studies in undergrad, I think one professor said this and I was like, oh, you're so right. Where she was like, you know, women are half of the global population. How on earth are they expecting all of us to agree? And I think this is something that happens with like feminism

SPEAKER_02in like especially electoral politics, like the women's vote, women voting. Even right now, when talking about the womanosphere, a lot of that is driven and created by white women in the United States and in Britain, who have a very specific background as well of upwardly mobilizing. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And taking that little piece and applying it to all women, I think that there's A, like a little light bulb that goes on and be like, oh, like I am one of 50% of the population and I believe in women's liberation. And also there's There's a very real possibility that like not all women feel that way and also that not all women, A, date like me and try to create relationships like me, have the same relationship to men as I do because I think a lot of the pink pilling, like I'm saying all this. I think there's a reason why women have always been revolutionaries.

SPEAKER_02Women lead the charge in a lot of the most controversial, most detrimental, most possibility of change movements in the world. It's always women to the front for a reason. In some ways, men are naturally submissive, but that's like a conversation for another day. Not to generalize, but that is something I've seen from societal conditioning. But I think that there's a freedom to being like,

SPEAKER_02I am one of many, but that also means that there's... I feel like I'm thinking a lot of bell hooks here and like what bell hooks talks about and like... Like feminist theory from margin to center of like, you know, the very specific experience of men are enemy men are evil men are only are subjugators really comes from like the upper class white culture specifically.

SPEAKER_02Because when you're in a movement, like I'm thinking of myself as like, okay, I am a union organizer. I've worked and organized in labor before. No permanent friends, no permanent enemies is like a routine saying in the labor movement of like, okay, like we're working. We're working together. We both want to get a raise. You're pissing me off. You're being sexist. You're being racist. Like, whatever it is. And, like, we actually have no choice but to figure this out enough so that we can win the raise that we want. So we can win...

SPEAKER_02And so I think that there is a sense of freedom and like A, understanding your own positionality. And like if you are like from like that group, which like parts of me are as well, I've been taught that like men are always my enemy and men are never going to be like in solidarity. But what are some examples in my life that are totally different? And I think a lot of the women in the womanosphere are the Candace Owens of it all. But also I'm thinking about there's a lot of marriage propaganda going around right now in this womanosphere. And I would include like people like there's this woman in San Francisco.

SPEAKER_02Well, she's really from San Jose and I'm from that area. So I'm like I have beef with that. But she's like calls herself to Carrie Bradshaw of San Francisco. And like she is like marrying an Uber driver life coach in like a three month time lineup. And also I'm thinking like Eli Rallo who like used to be this girl with like who wrote a book who wrote these lists like about dating and she just had like this big blowout wedding like patriotism nationalism coded like in New England. Stuff like that, those women who I think are on the more like,

SPEAKER_02quote unquote, liberal side, like of the womanosphere, who are still selling us something, who are still like marriage propaganda, and like making sure to be married as soon as possible, there may be men in my life. I think of my little brother. I think there is some freedom there, though that is really scary,

SPEAKER_02especially to think about because we've also been taught to fear men as we should. There's a lot of leftist men or feminist men who are abusers who do hurt us. But the truth is that women can do that too. Women can do that as well. So I think there is a level of freedom.

SPEAKER_02Girl, nothing is free. Nothing from a man is free. You think he's paying your rent. You think he's getting you a gift. You're going to have to pay it back in some way and it might not be the way that you like. That is like my biggest advice to young women all the time. Girl, nothing is free from a man. It's going to come back around and you're going to pay for it.

SPEAKER_01Just see how. 100%. I think the pink pill movement has some fissures now with what has been going on with the wizard list because she was one of like the face of the pink pill movement or the femosphere, womanosphere movement and the whole controversy that is going on. I am from India. I am from an upper middle class sort.

SPEAKER_01Of a background and growing up I had 100% believed that gender and gender equality is the prime fight like that is it but as I grow older and as I see the world I think class is Of course.

SPEAKER_01And I think that is a larger issue. And, you know, like being an intersectional feminist, I also think if I was given like a wish to like remove one type of inequality, I think it would have to be class first. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, it would have to be a takedown of capitalism. Because also, like you're saying, like picking and choosing, like if we fight capitalism, women's status goes up. Like there are so many statistics here in the US where like women in unions make like 25% more than women without. And that is like technically, it's not a gender neutral at all, but like you would think, okay, this is class based, this is like workplace based, but it has a direct impact. When fighting white supremacy, something that also always drives me crazy is I think it's like, well,

SPEAKER_02yeah, if you're fighting white supremacy, who do you think that benefits women? And I, for the record, was the same way where I feel like my little political awakening as a young person, even very, very young, was always centered around gender.

SPEAKER_02I was always thinking about being a woman versus being a man, what it means to do these things. And then as I grew, I feel like it had more of an understanding. It's like, oh, okay, like kind of no matter what I'm doing, like if I am against war, I am helping my fellow woman. If I am against for-profit health care. I am helping my fellow woman. If I am against like racist and classist policies like the Hyde Amendment in the United States, that directly helps women in my communities. And I don't think that the womanist fear is almost like a result of the fact

SPEAKER_02that we've treated women. Feminism and gendered issues as so separate from everything else. And I think because like feminisme comes from the French, it feels like I'm like it's been taught to us is this like white women's game or European women's game. And it's like really just not. It's

SPEAKER_01just not.

SPEAKER_02Feminism existed far before the French put a name to it.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Moving on to like the main topic that we want to talk about, you know, the main segment of this conversation, which is marriage as the opioid of the masses.

SPEAKER_02The floor is yours. So like to kind of dictate like why I think about this a lot. So I'm 28. I am single. I am very happy to be. That's what I'm saying.

SPEAKER_02The vibe is very like, you're 25, hurry up. You're 26, hurry up. A lot of people who I've grown up with have very recently gotten married, like within the last two years. And this is normal, like in the US, that is the culture here. Like, okay, 26, you're I'm gonna start seeing it. Like a lot of people want to have children before 30, et cetera, et cetera. And everyone's timeline is different. I'm proud of everyone for following their timeline. However, that is all happening in for like me personally at like my age.

SPEAKER_02So something is happening in the culture. We're like, we'll keep calling it like the year of the bride. Bridal looks are very big. I mean, obviously, like we have like the Taylor and Travis of it all. And like, because this is audio, my eyes are rolling really bad. Just everybody knows. But like there's a Taylor and Travis one. There's Dua Lipa's wedding, which it feels like people are treating as this like antithesis of like, oh, one is like classy and foreign and well read and one is like the opioid of the masses. I personally believe both are actually, but that's like a whole other thing.

SPEAKER_02Like even thinking about like the drama just came out. There's even the film like Maggie Gyllenhaal film, The Bride, which is like the Bride of Frankenstein remake. My bestie Tina, Sabrina Carpenter, has been wearing bridal looks like at her concerts, like all of these fashion helmets. There's a lot of bridal content. And as I mentioned, there's this woman in San San Francisco, who made an entire series about her finding a husband.

SPEAKER_02She found a husband, married him within a year of meeting him. Eli Rallo, this girl who used to be the signature single girl who got a book deal out of her list, she now had this gigantic wedding. And there's so much wedding media and... I think it's for a reason, especially here in the United States. It's only been four years since Roe vs. Wade was overturned. That is a humongous tool to ensure that we stay connected to partners that maybe we don't want to be connected to. Abortion access and birth control access are gigantic tools in the fight

SPEAKER_02against domestic violence and the fight for just the ability to determine your own life. And I think the fact that wedding media is so big right now, four years after While here in the US, the Trump administration is actively trying to restrict IVF and certain kinds of birth control, including IUDs, treating them as abortifacients. Same with Plan B. They're trying to restrict abortion pill access. And the Heritage Foundation, the machine behind Project 2025 and everything happening in the United States,

SPEAKER_02wrote up this gigantic report on like 250 years of America. How do we improve the family in the next 250? They're talking about deprioritizing women's jobs. They're talking about ensuring that like women act as though they're the subspecies of a family unit and like family units are like strongly two cis heterosexual families with two parents with two children and like keeping this image. Pushing us toward marriage, pushing us toward partnership with men, pushing us toward

SPEAKER_02Not only a partnership of men, but a partnership with a man that you can't get out of. If you have a kid with a man, you're done. But the idea from the Heritage Foundation, from Trump, from these policies are, okay, let's take away all options. She's stuck. She's trapped. Just like we're saying this entrapment media. And I do think as well that like the stuff that's being put out on social media in this womanosphere is an indoctrination just as much as like the movies that are coming out in the media that's coming out. Because like you see all this bridal shower content where it's like it's Perfect bridal shower with all the lilies and

SPEAKER_02the perfect tablescape. You have the perfect dress. You have so many Instagram photos. That is propaganda. That's an indoctrination site. I've been to a couple of bridal showers now. That is an That's an indoctrination site. You stop calling a woman by her name and you start calling her a bride. That's not my bride. That's my bestie. I've known her way longer than she's been a bride.

SPEAKER_02And these are indoctrination stations. And I think the aestheticization of it all and it being very Pinterest-y and cool and Instagram-able and TikTok-able and all these trends, it's selling something to you. And it's selling you a marriage where you just don't complain. And it's just there's too much going on around it where I'm like, this is not cool. Like I love say yes to the dress. I love wedding content. Like I always loved what I love wedding drama. Like, this is not about not liking weddings.

SPEAKER_02This is, oh, women are getting married in my community and younger and younger and younger. And they're more and more excited about the content of it all, like the bridal shower, but they have wedding content influencers, like everything. And then I always wonder, like, what is it like when you go home, though? Like, what is it like to, like, hang out with that man? After all the Instagram, what is it like?

SPEAKER_01I hope it's fun because I worry, you know? I come from an Orthodox Muslim community and I'm not a practicing Muslim. I do not subscribe to the values of the religion, but my community is still my community. So everybody that I grew up with got married before they were 22, right? And it's so normal here.

SPEAKER_00My cousins are all married and I'm only 25, right?

SPEAKER_01People don't even ask my parents about like when is she getting married anymore because they're like, oh, I think she's just, you know, she's too old. Thankfully, my parents, they do not live in the place where the community is from and they have like sort of moved from there and they have like a little more profile. So that is where my community is. But the rest of India in general, women are prioritizing their career over marriage and all of that. But lately, there is a resurgence of people. We are a culture with child marriages.

SPEAKER_01Women have way less autonomy than the West, right? Yes. And the feminist movement and women having equal rights and women actually standing up to it. So we have great reproductive rights so far. Yes. Yes, you do. We count on y'all. But we have wearless Autonomy to excise those rights.

SPEAKER_01The way that we are brought up, the way that we're conditioned. So when I grew up, I have never seen a romanticization of women getting married young. It was my mother got married when she was 20 and she has She has been against that from the beginning. And then, you know, she completed an education. She got a really good job. She did all of that. She has a really great career, right? You know, so millennial women in India, they have prioritizing their career. They have been prioritizing other... Other pursuits and individual pursuits over marriage and family.

SPEAKER_01And we are talking about a culture where women still need to fight for their ability to go out and work. We are in a culture where men's masculinity feel threatened when their wives are working outside of homes. So it was very, very important for Gen X and millennial women to sort of pave that way. The past couple of years, there is a romanticization of getting married young.

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_01And getting married young when I was growing up was never a romanticized thing. It was always shown as like an undesirable thing, at least among women. And then now there is Spend a day with me, 21 year old wife. It definitely came from the West. I think the romanticization, it definitely came from the trad wife and all of that. A lot of trends get taken over without that cultural nuance, you know? Yeah. So I do blame the US for this trend. And a trend I'm seeing right now,

SPEAKER_01the comment section of these videos are still, you know, your content gives me the strength to wake up in the morning and go to work and all of that. The comment section is not yet been filled like that, but it's just time, right? So there definitely is a romanticization of young marriage and everything that you talked about, marriage being the opioid of the masses and how 2026 is being considered the year of the bride. Yes, definitely. It's so much more than an aesthetic. And I just have so many issues with marriage and weddings specifically being seen as

SPEAKER_01a woman's kind of a thing. Like weddings are for women, right? But marriage in the traditional sense of it doesn't benefit women. Not at all. Marriage is the way even the poorest man can get a live-in maid. Yes. So the whole aestheticization, the purple washing of marriage and the wedding industry is something that I've always thought about and it getting mainstream. Yeah. And

SPEAKER_02even in like these liberal circles, like this is going to like American weddings where like American weddings and like Indian weddings have like their own distinct cultures, traditions. Oh, my God. Beautiful woman in the room. And there's this thing that I never understood, maybe just because I haven't been to a ton of weddings,

SPEAKER_02I don't have that many friends who are married, where there is this vibe of like, ooh, okay, that's the most beautiful woman in the room. Like, you... You shouldn't be coming to slay. You should be coming knowing that, like, that's the most beautiful woman in the room. And like, maybe you shouldn't wear all your jewelry. Maybe you shouldn't do it. Which I'm like, to me, I'm like showing respect to someone is I come to slay. I am coming being like, no, your occasion She's worthy of my best shit. Like, let's put all of it on. But I have learned slowly that there is,

SPEAKER_02and I guess I'm speaking specifically about like East Coast of the United States, predominantly white weddings. There is this It's like debutante. It's like this debut and it's her moment. And everything after that is downhill. And that I think is something That's something really interesting. And like the fact that people will come out for weddings, people will fly out for all these events. But like when a woman becomes a doctor, are all her friends coming to celebrate her?

SPEAKER_02No, not necessarily. When she has a gigantic like even like success in her personal life, she crochets a beautiful quilt for three years. No one's coming to throw a party for her. Even like I'm like thinking like when I graduated with like my master's degree, only one of my friends came. But and that's not anything to my friend. But when someone gets married, everybody goes. And there is such a difference, I think, in like the prioritization of it. And to your point as well, that's why I'm like very pro prenup.

SPEAKER_02Like for this reason, I'm like, oh, like this cyst. Yeah, that's a system where you're about to combine your assets with a man, you're gonna get a tax break, right? But by and large, because of like the cultures that be and the history that be, yeah, you are gonna be a live-in maid and he now and control your assets and your money and lets you have a prenup in a separate account, which is very stigmatized. And okay, you have your big debut and you're beautiful for a night and it's amazing and you feel great. What happens afterward?

SPEAKER_02And that's where like I really do think like I don't believe necessarily that religion or faith is the opioid of the masses. I do think that marriage is one of them, Taylor Swift and football or some other ones in the U.S. I could talk about that forever, but I don't want to talk about that right now. But yeah, it's a salve of being like, oh, this is my nightmare. To be the most beautiful, to have the best relationship, to do the best thing, which is very individualistic, very American, very, very, very Western. And I completely see and agree that like that is the export being sold like every day.

SPEAKER_02Everywhere else, like my family that like doesn't live in the US, there is also a rise in young marriages, despite the culture not being that. And like even not even marriages, but like living in with your boyfriend, becoming essentially his wife. And then later on, maybe you get the moment because the marriage itself isn't as important in their culture. But yeah, there's a lot of like romanticization that didn't used to be there in places that are not the US or not the West. That is very interesting to me.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. This has been so interesting. Is there anything else you want to add?

SPEAKER_02So there's a lot of entrapment media going around right now, especially in the horror and thriller genre here in the US. And I'm thinking about, so Obsession just came out, Gap. And I just want to know and I want to like ask people listening to think about the fact that like after the film Get Out, which is a commentary on like the very real consequences in history of like chattel slavery and enslavement in the United States of black people.

SPEAKER_02Why are there so many films that center white women being trapped, usually in an essentially sunken place by a man that either will end with her, spoiler alert, killing him or something, but Why is that happening over and over again? Like horror, in my opinion, and thriller is like the opening society's nerves right now. Like what is going on for people? What is the concern? And I just want people to pay attention to like the women led or the women centered. So what are we going to do?

SPEAKER_02Absolutely. Thank you so much for joining us today, Jade. I had such an interesting time talking about this topic and

SPEAKER_01This has given me so many things to go back and like think about. Maybe there is a couple of essays coming out of this conversation from both our ends. But so interesting. Thank you so much for joining today.

SPEAKER_02Thank you for having me and thank you for letting me literally ramble. I appreciate it.

SPEAKER_00This has been Girl Online. I will see you next week with yet another deep dive into what we're all doing online. If you enjoyed this episode, consider buying me a coffee at buymeacoffee.com slash abhaahad.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. usernames w/ Azha Ahad

    Sep 1, 202618 minAudio

    This is part 8 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. toxic tumblr w/ Jane Song

    Aug 27, 202631 minAudio

    This is part 7 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. conspiritual baddies w/ Philomena Stone

    Aug 17, 202627 minAudio

    This is part 6 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. reclaiming girlhood w/ Victória Oliveira

    Aug 3, 202625 minAudio

    This is part 4 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. men's rights (women's wrongs) w/Smizzo

    Jul 27, 202626 minAudio

    This is part 3 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode