Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Conversations

Conversations artwork

men's rights (women's wrongs) w/Smizzo

Jul 27, 202626 minAudioEpisode 3
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is part 3 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl online is an independent platform that reports on what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to them. The weekly stories that you read on Wednesdays are written by me, based on what the web feeds me, and filtered through my lens. This series is an attempt to bring in diverse experiences of digital girlhood to you. In this episode, I am joined by Smizzo, and we talk about how women have been looksmaxxing since the beginning of time, the male loneliness epidemics, and the performance of girlhood online. Special shoutout to my sister, Azha, for editing this conversation. If you’d like to fund my work on here, here’s the tip jar. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.girlonline.in

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Girl Online, a space where we discuss what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to us. I am Abha Ahad, the girl behind Girl Online. This is part three of an eight-part series of conversations I had with fellow cultural experts from around the world. In every episode, we dive into a specific subculture or a trend these experts have been tracking for years. Today we have with us Smizo. Smizo is a London-based writer from Iraq and she unpacks cultural commentary and the Middle Eastern diasporic experience on our Substack.

SPEAKER_01Hi Smizo, welcome to Girl Online.

SPEAKER_00Hi, thank you so much for having me.

SPEAKER_01What are we discussing today?

SPEAKER_00There's so many things to discuss today. So I think what we're going to discuss today is girlhood online and how I like view it in my head is we'll say that they're trends and they're constantly coming and going, but I'd like to look at them as like avatars that women can kind of wear. Do you know what I mean? We've got like your clean girl aesthetic. We've got like lobotomy chic or whimsy and all of these things. Where does that stem from? Where does that come from? And what kind of messages are underpinning those aesthetics that are coming out at

SPEAKER_00a rate that I don't think any human being can really keep up with?

SPEAKER_01I think initially when, you know, when we started doing these aesthetics way back when, let's say 2010s, that's when I started being online. I'm sure aesthetics existed before that. Yeah. But that's when I started being online. And it used to be this cute little thing you can subscribe to, you can unsubscribe. It was just fun. But lately, I feel like aesthetics have started being archetypes. 100%. I recently wrote an article about it. It's about like identity formation. The article is called What's Your Core?

SPEAKER_00You know.

SPEAKER_01And I'm talking about all these cores, like grandma cores, so many cores. The question is, what is your core? At the core of your being, who are you? Like, if you keep subscribing to these things that keep changing every three weeks... How do you end up understanding who you are as a person? That was like the key of that article. The format of years, right? Your teenage and like your 20s. You go through so many phases. I had a dungry like phase. I was always wearing dungries. I do not know why I don't anymore.

SPEAKER_01There was a phase and you do all of these things and there was variety. If I do something, it's based on my, you know, what I want to do and then somebody else is doing something else. It was not this curator sort of a thing where the internet decides, oh, this week, everybody around the world is going to do this thing.

SPEAKER_00It's just this authenticity has taken out the question when it comes to femalehood. When you were like talking about girlhood online and I'm thinking about this really performative nature of, But then I was kind of reflecting and thinking, oh, it's capitalism and social media. But I think it's actually always existed, if you think about it. Maybe not in the way that it is now of these cores and these aesthetics that are so easy to ascribe to. You know what I mean? Like this little bundled up package that you

SPEAKER_01can pick and form a Pinterest

SPEAKER_00mood board over. But I think inherently to be a woman is to perform anyway. Like that's the inherent nature of femaleness. Anytime I kind of write about social media, I always think it's really important to go back to like, there's this book called Society of the Spectacle by Guy Dubois. I don't know if you've heard of it before.

SPEAKER_01I haven't, but I will link it out in there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I think it was written in the 60s or 70s. Don't quote me on that. I think it was written in the 60s and 70s. And he was a socialist and he was very worried about how capitalism, he literally used the words, will colonize our social lives in a form that it will become less about authentic connection with each other. And it will become... I was like, whoa, that's so true. Like this guy got it nailed on head, like look at social media. And then I was like, actually, let me think about it.

SPEAKER_00Maybe for being a man, yes, but for being a woman. It's always been about perception because I think if you think about femaleness or femininity is a performance, it's the antithesis of what it is actually to be a woman from period pains. Giving birth is the most, if we're going to talk about feminine, palatability, softness isn't giving birth like the complete opposite of that. Period pains is the complete opposite of that, the way our hormones fluctuate here, there and everywhere. You know, the ideal of femininity in itself is the most unfemale thing in existence.

SPEAKER_00So interesting that I initially was like, capitalism and these archetypes and et cetera, et cetera, is all because of internet culture. But actually, I just think it's a patriarchal society and now it's been put in a capitalist structure.

SPEAKER_01For sure. In my notes app, I have this note titled, Men get to exist, women have to perform.

SPEAKER_00Always.

SPEAKER_01And I do not know when I conceived that thought. I think it was in the gym. When I see like the women around me, you know, they are very conscious of themselves. You just like, you do not want to take up too much space. You want to do it well. You want to relact the weights. You want to do all of those things. And the man next to me is grunting like he's giving birth.

SPEAKER_00And they don't give a shit.

SPEAKER_01And they don't. And I was like, we're constantly thinking about this performance and constantly thinking about how we are being perceived. I started journaling like four or five years ago. And initially, in my initial years of journaling, I used to write it as if I'm writing it for somebody else. It was not for myself. It was not to write down those thoughts. But the idea was that if at some point somebody finds this journal, this needs to be like an entertaining tale for them. And it's just we're constantly performing for the person in our heads.

SPEAKER_00That's so interesting. And even I feel like that oftentimes with writing of like, I need to remember that I'm doing this for myself and I need to recenter because that's when the good stuff comes out. But I think women really outsource and hyper-focused and hyper-vigilant on perception because that's how society has always put us in that kind of box of submission to be palatable to the male gaze or for the patriarchy, etc, etc. There's always a shrunken form which is always not good.

SPEAKER_01Which is also my problem with again I'm sorry for like referring back to my previous articles all the time but I've written this article called the female gaze doesn't exist because you know one there is no singular feminine experience like there is for So if there is a female gaze, it would just not be to be not looked upon. Is that clear?

SPEAKER_00Even there's types of archetypes and things that seem like they are anti-patriarchal, like, let's say, lobotomy chic, okay, like Charlie XCX, you know, this numbed woman. It's still a performance. You're still suppressing your emotion. You're still muting yourself. It might be a little bit more garish, but it's still a shrunken version of a woman who occupies a certain type of body type that is again shrunken. No voice, you just look a bit fed up. It's still catering, again, to a male gaze and patriarchy.

SPEAKER_00So even though it might seem like it's the antichrist to, let's say, the clean girl, it still operates in the same mechanics.

SPEAKER_01That is so correct. Yes. You cannot counter something with creating like another checklist of things that you need to do to be there.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. It's just unrealistic expectations. It's still unattainable. And they're made there to make you feel like shit. Can I swear on this podcast? Sure. And women hating themselves is a great money-making machine. So...

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Which is also my problem with choice feminists, right? Because we all wear makeup. I wear makeup, you wear makeup. But makeup is not a feminist thing to do. It's a tool of patriarchy.

SPEAKER_00No, it's still a performative thing. It's still a form of attempting to edit yourself.

SPEAKER_01Exactly my point. So that's not to say that you were a bad person or you shouldn't be doing that. It's still good being a feminist. It's good to acknowledge that some things you do is not feminist choice or is not and you are still subscribing to the page. We exist in patriarchy. Some sort of internalized misogyny with us. And we all are tools of patriarchy. So I wear makeup. And it is because I am taught that the beauty standards are a certain way. And when I say I don't subscribe to it, I would say that if there is somebody else who doesn't subscribe

SPEAKER_01to those beauty standards, I'll be kinder to them. I am not going to ask them to like fit or not anything. Yes. But I don't have that kindness towards myself. So I do some of these things. So repackaging, skincare and beauty and all sorts of these things as self-care. I do not subscribe to that narrative. And whatever problems I have with Clavicular and the whole Luxemaxing movement he makes. One good thing I like about it is that Clavicera doesn't say

SPEAKER_00that he's doing it for himself.

SPEAKER_01He doesn't say that I am looks maxing because I want to be my best self. He's saying that I am looks maxing so I can get laid or I am looks maxing because I will get more attention. And I like that. I welcome that. At least. What are your thoughts on the looks maxing? Where do we start?

SPEAKER_00I think it's really interesting that looks maxing is like taking people by like such a shock factor when really like this has existed. Like Clavicular just got a nose drop and everyone's like, oh my God, like women haven't been doing that for how long? Like we haven't been looks maxing since like time. And the second it becomes a male thing, it becomes really weird. And they're injecting themselves with like Chinese black market growth hormone. I don't know if you've been on these Luxmaxing forums. Like they are wild. Like Clavica is just the tip of the iceberg. It's just women have been Luxmaxing since the dawn of time.

SPEAKER_00Now it's a problem because men have gone a bit AWOL with it, crazy with it. Do you know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01That is such an interesting perspective because like, you know, we talk about the Victorian age and the gossets and like all of these things. So yes, you're right. And Chinese foot binding.

SPEAKER_00But also like, okay, I'm a woman now and I'm entering into my 30s and there are more women that are doing Botox and fillers than there are not. Like, but if a man does that, a few more eyebrows are raised, you know? Also, the one thing I thought was really interesting is this narrative of men's mental health. All of a sudden, this is becoming an issue. All of a sudden, you're caring about men's bodies and how they feel. When have we ever had that discussion with eating disorders and all of these things that have come about from a media circus that is constantly...

SPEAKER_00So in regards to kind of this look-smacking narrative of when that came out into the public consciousness, the media really wanted to come out with this men's mental health, concerned about men's mental health, and that never existed in the realm of... of female even though if you look through probably any women's magazine it's giving you tips and tricks on how to look better whether that's you know soft maxing or hardcore maxing or whatever stupid terms these men want to put on things and no one care less about women's mental health and eating disorders and how

SPEAKER_00that would have affected our bodies or body dysmorphia or No one cared. But now there's one man on the internet that's doing it for clout. Like that is what he's doing this for. Now people want to have a discussion and a frank discussion to be serious about something that never existed when this has been women for the longest period of time.

SPEAKER_01Yes, suddenly when men are handed like a checklist of things to do to be decidable for women, suddenly when people on the internet are saying that you need to do all of these things to be decidable to women, it's very difficult, right, for them to accept because women's desire has always been taken for granted. Why would I have to look like Like, you know, a certain way for you to love me. It's just annoying. Another thing, like when you were talking about men's mental health, just like a segue, this has nothing to do with the topic we're discussing. But in India, we have a new penal code. And in that new penal code, rape against men...

SPEAKER_01So when it came out, a lot of women's rights activists came forward and said that, you know, There is a problem with this penal code. This is not okay. And no men's rights activists speaking about it. There is a growing men's rights activism sort of like thing going on in India right now. I think all over the world, right? There is a rise in all of these. I don't want to sound corny.

SPEAKER_01So we also have these groups in India. And there was very less conversation about it. And I was really surprised because if you're a men's rights activist, you really need to be speaking about this, right? This is the time for you to speak up. And lately, the past Say six months, we've had really gruesome rape cases being reported. It's like gang rapes and little children being raped by like, it's all gruesome. It's gotten just like really bad. There is really a rape epidemic in India going on right now. I don't want to trivialize any kind of sexual assault by saying but the cases

SPEAKER_01that we're seeing right now are so gruesome and anytime you can go on twitter and twitter since Elon Musk is just a shit show but anytime you see a women's rights activist speaking about this there are men in the common what about rape against You need to pick. You need to decide. Do you care about men's rights or are you just anti-women's rights, right?

SPEAKER_00They're just anti-womens, right? It just puts women in a position, again, of begging for that archetypal form of femininity. Shrunken, palatable, quiet. That's it. That's what it's edging towards. You know what I mean? Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. That's terrible. But I'm not surprised. I'm not surprised at all. Also, I'm kind of surprised that that narrative is starting to sneak onto Substack as well, which I hate. It was my safe space. And then there's freaks in some of the comments.

SPEAKER_00I'm like, this wasn't written for you anyway. This isn't for you, girl.

SPEAKER_01I think few months ago, there was this real problem with people finding these like women and girlhood substracts and commenting like really wild things. And why are you a 40 year old man coming and commenting on something about teenage? Something about... Like, what is your problem? I had somebody comment, like, shut the fuck up in one of my articles. It was a very random article about slangs. And I was talking about why did LOL and LMAO become so popular when ROFL did not.

SPEAKER_01And it's such a benign article. There is no hot take here. It's just that I am curious and I like going down these rabbit holes and I am just interested in these things. It was in all caps. It was so violent. And I obviously deleted that comment. But bro. My first like

SPEAKER_00subsect that got a bit of traction was on marriage and I've done two bits on marriage of me hating on marriage. I just want to actually come out and say, like, I probably actually would get married myself, but I just hate, again, it's about the performative nature of it all and how I feel like getting picks or the pick me, the choose me, that getting married is becoming a little bit that. And it's, again, another avatar of femininity, like how grand and how big was your wedding or your engagement ring and are you woman enough?

SPEAKER_00In those comments, I had men being like, don't get married, like evolution will have its way with you or like people literally like death threats. Because I was saying like, fuck getting married to a bum. Like you. Men on the internet. You should do a bit on that.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I mean, I am going to title this conversation as Men's Rights with Smizzo.

SPEAKER_00Look, and then I think what people don't also realize, we've gone on a tangent, like this was not my initial thing at all. I think the thing is that what people don't realize is feminism works in the benefit of men also. Like it is about the quality of the sexes. I am not having rigid gender roles suits nobody. Like it is not helpful or healthy for you. For me to have to ascribe to femininity, which is, in my opinion, forced upon women far more than masculinity, is forced upon men. But besides the point, toxin masculinity and the ideals of masculine, of suppressing emotion, of being hard all the time.

SPEAKER_00Like feminism is against that too. Like we're fighting on your corner as well.

SPEAKER_01Every single issue that a men's rights activist has, I can explain to you in three sentences where that is a problem of patriarchy. You have a problem with increasing suicide among men. Let's talk about the mental health crisis.

SPEAKER_00Let's talk about it. But no, I met a guy once who was like, it's because of women, because there's the male loneliness epidemic. Let's unpack male loneliness epidemic first and fucking foremost.

SPEAKER_01You know what? Like, yeah, I'll find

SPEAKER_00that corner. But like, I have to fix it. It's my fault. It's my fault.

SPEAKER_01Okay, let's just take a scenario, right? If these men are lonely, technically the women should also be because the problem is that men and women are not couples. Exactly. Who gives a shit though if it's women are lonely?

SPEAKER_00Let's also then analyze the ideal of like a bachelor versus a spinster. Let's unpack that. The crazy cat lady where it's like he's a player. Let's unpack that. I mean, it's just a double standard. But Exactly what you said if there's a male loneliness epidemic then it's going to be affecting women by an equal value. The fact that men don't have community, the fact that men don't have social bubbles and social circles, the way that women have had to build. I'm sorry that you're lonely and I'm sorry that you're isolated, but you can't keep telling women to lower their standards into the depths of hell

SPEAKER_00to settle with you. I don't know if you saw the Stephen Bartlett podcast. It absolutely infuriated me where this man was like, well, how are we going to wet these lonely men off? As though like women have to succumb and like do the dirty work. I'm not doing that.

SPEAKER_01Why don't three or four of these lonely men get together and do something fun? Legit, like go on a boys holiday the way me and my girls are going to Mykonos.

SPEAKER_00You guys do the same. But then actually that being said, let me tell you a story though. I didn't like this. I went on a date with a guy once and he was giving ex incel and then I was like, I will never see you again. And he was like, he was a writer. And I was like, oh, okay. Interesting. He was like, what do you write about? I was like, oh, I write about feminism,

SPEAKER_01pop culture, da, da, da.

SPEAKER_00And he's like, oh, I write about feminism too. I was like, okay. Amazing. Men and women's spaces, Slay. We love that for you. Okay. I was like, okay, so like what kind of feminism do you write about? Like how did you get into all of that? Like what? He's like a big like bell hooks. I mean, that's the red flag in and of itself and that's the only feminist literature they've ever read. Well, I go to this like men's support group. I'm like, these support groups are starting to pop up and I'm not against that. I don't think that's like the worst thing in the world for men to support each other.

SPEAKER_00But what do they do? They go and they discuss feminism without speaking to a single female. All together, men in a room and they like scream and do these like rituals together. And I was like, what the hell? They exist online. Like you can search it like these male support groups and they go into the wilderness and like cry. The hell? Why are men having groups talking about my rights and my body? You want to learn about feminism? Speak to women.

SPEAKER_01When you were saying that, I was just thinking about this. So I do not know if I'm pronouncing this correctly, the Bechdel test. And a lot of conversation, a lot of discourses has happened about this test. And like, you know, again, women are always performing. So we are again performing. Sometimes when I have these conversations with my female friends, I sometimes think, oh, is this conversation passing the Bechdel test? And more often than not, it is. We have a lot of things to talk about. But one funny thing about all of these manosphere influencers is that if they had

SPEAKER_01a Bechdel test, none of these conversations are going to pass that.

SPEAKER_00It's a rough time in discourse of the split between men and women has never been larger. Men more to the right, more women to the left. I wrote a bit on it called, even in terms of religion, men are going flocking back to conservative religion, more women are going to spiritual practices, a lot of them to witchcraft, actually, which I think is super interesting. But then you have the odd kind of outliers that Of like, you know, people trying to shove like the trad wife movement and making that a thing again. I sometimes do think, and how to say this out of being controversial,

SPEAKER_00but sometimes it's women that uphold the patriarchy and these ridiculous ideals just as much as men. Femininity and womanhood is oftentimes policed by women.

SPEAKER_01As brown women, I think we feel that even more.

SPEAKER_00The aunties is part of our lives.

SPEAKER_01I have an auntie in my head.

SPEAKER_00I have a million. There's so many of these, you know, these aunties and these policing, but we all have these little aunties in ourselves sometimes, whether subconsciously or consciously, this kind of tick box of what we need to perform and what we need to adhere to, whether we realize it or not.

SPEAKER_01A hundred percent. I always say this, if my strongest critique is dead, it means I am dead.

SPEAKER_00It's true. Harshest on ourselves. This was also going to be one of my initial original points. It was about the British class system and how much it reminds me of the policing in women's spaces and the anti-culture that sits within all of us. I don't know if you've ever watched the film Soul Burn.

SPEAKER_01I haven't. Oh, you should. It's a good one.

SPEAKER_00Add to your list. In the UK, it doesn't matter how wealthy you are, class cannot be bought. And a lot of class is based on these silent hidden rules of etiquette that no one will tell you what these rules are, but they exist nonetheless. So like I went to a very like white upper class university and it was the shock of my absolute life. And I feel femininity has that. There's all these unspoken rules that we can't keep up with. And either you're in the know or you're not in the know. Also, a lot of these female archetypes and archetypal forms are classist in themselves.

SPEAKER_00Clean girl aesthetic. They will always try and vouch for old money over new money. How everyone's obsessing over Dua Lipa at the moment. Why? Because she's giving that hint of old money in her aesthetics and in her vibes. Anyway, I was rambling there. But basically, I think girlhood is these unspoken rules of etiquette. Even sometimes we might not really like to know what these rules are. That is impossible to keep up with. In my opinion, like all the Middle Eastern aunties at a wedding, they're eyeing up every single And then it's on the internet,

SPEAKER_00which is even worse because there's so much like data to synthesize and women to aspire to or to hate, you know, when it becomes a messy concoction.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I remember this discourse in early days of my Substack career. It was late 2024. There was a boom in these girlhood writers and there was just so much romanticization of womanhood and girlhood and everything. And I was reading so many of these authors and at the point I had to like take a step back and really think about it. Is womanhood all like sunshine and rainbows? No. No.

SPEAKER_00I'm sorry to everyone on Substack who loves a little whimsy moment. I despise whimsycore. I despise the word whimsy because that's exactly what it gives. It's like this cottagecore, like soft. I think I hate this because like I'm the complete opposite. Like I'm an angry Iraqi woman. Like I don't know what side of girlhood they're on but mine's not that whimsy.

SPEAKER_01And initially when I started seeing this Bimsy core, what reminded me of was like the whole Manic Pixie Dream Girl sort of archetype in these films. And have we not read those essays on how the Manic Pixie Dream Girl archetype was problematic? I think as we move to like conclusion of this podcast, this conversation, I do not know whether to call it a conversation or a podcast because I feel like if we call it a podcast... It's going to become like a real thing and I have to do it like consistently.

SPEAKER_00I'm a firm believer and never make obligation of anything or else it takes fun out of it. So don't do that.

SPEAKER_01This is a conversation. So as we near the end of this conversation, my takeaway from this conversation is that stop performing for the people in your head. You can start slow, just maybe stop doing it when you're all by yourself. Then maybe amongst your closest people, then maybe against more because life gets so much easier when you can do that.

SPEAKER_00And also like I'm a fan believer and I say this and there's like a bit of writing I do that's a little self-helpy and reflective. Authenticity is like your birthright. You were given all those things that are unique and wonderful about yourself because it's probably your skill set, your passions, the things you're supposed to give on this planet and on this earth are those things that aren't found in other people. And I despise assimilation. I despise like people trying to live up to a certain ideal. And I personally find nothing more refreshing than a girl that just knows herself

SPEAKER_00and doesn't give a shit. These little bubbles that they try and put us in, it just shrinks us regardless of what kind of message it's trying to convey. Fuck that. Stop giving these people your money and these marketing posts because that's what this all is. It can be hard to find who you are, but make that your life journey because it's important. And I think being authentic is, like I said, it's your birthright. You really should make a concerted effort to be authentic because when you're authentic, you're encouraging other people to probably also follow suit. 100%.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for joining me today.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for having me. I had the best time.

SPEAKER_01This has been Girl Online. I will see you next week with yet another deep dive into what we're all doing online. If you enjoyed this episode, consider buying me a coffee at buymeacoffee.com slash abhaahad.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. usernames w/ Azha Ahad

    Sep 1, 202618 minAudio

    This is part 8 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. toxic tumblr w/ Jane Song

    Aug 27, 202631 minAudio

    This is part 7 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. conspiritual baddies w/ Philomena Stone

    Aug 17, 202627 minAudio

    This is part 6 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. the year of the bride w/ Jade Hurley

    Aug 10, 202632 minAudio

    This is part 5 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. reclaiming girlhood w/ Victória Oliveira

    Aug 3, 202625 minAudio

    This is part 4 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode