This is part 6 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl online is an independent platform that reports on what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to them. The weekly stories that you read on Wednesdays are written by me, based on what the web feeds me, and filtered through my lens. This series is an attempt to bring in diverse experiences of digital girlhood to you. In this episode, I am joined by Philomena Stone, and we talk about TikTok’s spiritual baddies and the irony of not embodying the values of a movement you claim to represent. Special shoutout to my sister, Azha, for editing this conversation. If you’d like to fund my work on here, here’s the tip jar. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.girlonline.in
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Welcome to Girl Online, a space where we discuss what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to us. I am Abha Ahad, the girl behind Girl Online. This is part 6 of an 8-part series of conversations I had with fellow culture experts from around the world. In each episode, we dive deep into a specific subculture these experts have been tracking for years. Today we have with us Philomena Stone. Philomena is an East Coast-based writer and novelist in progress.
SPEAKER_01You can find her on TikTok at Philomena Stone and on a substack, Two Hours to No Order. Hi, Philomena. Welcome to Girl Online.
SPEAKER_00Hi, thank you so much for having me. What are we discussing today? I really wanted to talk about a particular subject that had first been brought by an article, an essay I ended up reading a couple of weeks ago by an acquaintance of mine. It was called Cockroach Rape Machine. And as a Hawaiian writer and activist, she was dissecting essentially one of the many ways in which that old-fashioned eat, pray, love archetype canonized by Elizabeth Gilbert back in 2006 in her memoir of the same title tends to assume nowadays the many ways it's mutated
SPEAKER_00in this digital age in part thanks to social media. And when I started reflecting on this topic, I was kind of Intensely disappointed by how many different variations of the fetishist came to mind. And immediately afterward, reading this article on my TikTok feed, I was assaulted by a variety of different videos in which people claim to be usually white American women, claim themselves spiritual baddies.
SPEAKER_00And this type struck me as far more self-conscious than even the previous Xenex sort of way that this is derived from. You know, we've got white women in Brandy Melville Priscilla yoga pants and teal colors. And, you know, they're listening to whatever music affirmations or manifestation, whatever's in their wired headphones. And they're doing that tree pose. They're always a bit lopsided. Their form is terrible, by the way. Drinking matcha and saying things like namaste, bitch, and just... Appropriating a variety of different globally Southern spiritualities
SPEAKER_00and aesthetic signifiers without truly even coming to appreciate what any of that entails. I mean, the first thing that sticks that stuck out to me, at least about all of these videos was the fact that They never truly come to any definitive value system. It is never the first thing they talk about. It certainly isn't even the last. You never even really come to understand what they grounded themselves within. They just reference All of these sorts of vague 90s era wellness ideas,
SPEAKER_00they pantomime, they borrow the vocabulary and it never does become clear exactly what they're working towards and why they've been inspired. Have you come across anything quite like this on your feed?
SPEAKER_01Not on my feed, but I actually have some insights into this. I was actually thinking about this yesterday because I am a pagan. I am not I am a pagan and I just have my own practice and I like to work with lots of gods. I like to work with gods from different pantheons and I like to read about it. Almost 90% of the books that I see recommended on this topic are written by white women. When I go to read these books, and don't get me wrong, these people are great.
SPEAKER_01Their books are great. It's a great guide to understanding. But when I read these books, those books do not have any, and I'm not saying this categorically, like no spiritual book written by a white woman can have any meat. That's not what I'm talking about. Most of the books out there, they don't have any value system. And that is when I sort of started thinking about it, how in the West, spirituality is an individual practice. It's not supposed to be an individual practice. It's supposed to be a collective practice. It's supposed to be a community practice, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And on that note, I mean, one of the most bizarre things that I'd encountered when sifting through all the content at one point that one could consider of this genre was this, God, not at all atypical these days, fixation on being materialistic and being a spiritual body. One of the main sentiments I kept running into almost verbatim was, When you're materialistic, but also a spiritual baddie, cue a montage of, again, white women in yoga pants pretending to meditate while wearing Chanel sunglasses
SPEAKER_00or something like that. And I found the weaponization of that, not the weaponization, excuse me, the mentioning of materialism, especially alongside either visually or verbally or in written form, things like smoking and drinking and other things typically associated with female degeneracy when done by women, especially insidious because It in large part opens the door for weaponization of certain feminist arguments because if you as someone who would be one of their detractors enters their comment section or,
SPEAKER_00you know, post anything to your own platform essentially saying, hey, actually these two things can't. I think that can't coexist because materialism essentially is the antithesis of what a variety of different spiritual practices kind of bristle. An argument that I think hasn't necessarily been culturally relevant for at least 20 or so years now, which is the whole good girls can do bad things too, bad girls can do good things too sort of narrative. I think that they end up weaponizing the historical and general perception
SPEAKER_00of female spending to make critics issues and arguments seem like the product of sort of Madonna whore dichotomy related issues rather than just simply a general desire to rebel against overconsumption and to not have these spiritual practices captured by the same kinds of people who end up perpetuating consumerist values.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And it's not just in the West. It's here in India as well. Spirituality has become a performance. And to me, to be spiritual, to engage in these practices means a lot of different things. It means being spiritual. Compassionate, being passionate, you know, and the actually most spiritual people I've seen are people with a lot of passion and compassion for the world and people around them. And also they have a strong moral core.
SPEAKER_01The eat, pray, love kind of spirituality essentially just strips down the spirituality of any discomfort, any actual work required, any work you need to do by yourself or the tough conversations you need to have. It strips itself of all of that and just makes it like another way of consumption. And we have reached that place in life where the antidote to anything is more consumption.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, this kind, I mentioned earlier that this kind felt even more self-conscious than the latter because it feels so directly, it feels like such a direct response to anti-consumerist arguments, anti-consumerist backlash, and the types of people who will almost immediately, regardless of whether or not the person in question is guilty, I used that in air quotes here, of this particular offense or not, there is a kind of person who will still immediately see someone do a haul, immediately see someone wearing something that they're able to recognize as, say,
SPEAKER_00Quite exorbitantly expensive and go, actually, I'm not going to engage with you because you are nothing but a materialist. You are a baffin individual. You are a shill for Azhara and H&M, etc. I do think that audiences are coming to regard consistent displays of consumption as deeply impersonal, which is why I think these spiritual baddie types especially tend to cling on to the whole smoking, drinking, all these other forms of things typically, again, associated with female degeneracy as... I don't know, more grounding activities, things that also legitimize the inclusion of female spending.
SPEAKER_00Of course, this is regardless of whether or not one's purchases are thought to be mass produced junk. I mean, even the vintage creators who are regularly doing hauls and just talking about products within any capacity are likely to Right. Right. Right. I think this is primarily because of the audiences who are likely to level
SPEAKER_00that anti-consumerist criticism, or at least audiences that they think are likely to find themselves at least indifferent towards this whole display when these things are included, because these things are perceived as slightly less important. Slightly more removed from the sterile inhumanity of capitalism's value system. Though, of course, our relationships to those things are still influenced by it. These are all actions and activities that facilitate some people think to be more meaningful form of human connection, not as reliant on class envy to fuel mainstream interests specifically.
SPEAKER_00And of course, while the implications of How one participates in, you know, a more archetypal version of that form, drinking with friends, smoking with friends, doing all that, is reliant on, of course, things like race and class, all of that. I think having a true to cultural script experience with this, with any of those things, is far more accessible to the average person than the influencer level of consumptions that this whole thing tries to bridge. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely, yes, I agree on that. I don't know if you've come across these kind of spiritual hall content where just a basket full of crystals and all kinds of herbs and just tons of stuff. As a practitioner myself, my altar is a garden I'm growing on the back, like in the terrace of my home. That is my altar. And I see this content and sometimes I feel I'm not doing things right. I mean, what do you mean spiritual hall?
SPEAKER_00To answer your question, regrettably, yes. I'm not a practitioner of any spirituality or religion. But still, of course, because I am a 20-something girl, occasionally these things come across my four-year age. Well, the first thought that typically comes to mind is, do you absolutely need all of this to build your altar, to practice whatever it is you're interested in? Is this all absolutely necessary, second of all? And perhaps this is a feature of my lack of belief, of my atheism and my general detachment from the practices of spirituality,
SPEAKER_00except for in this sort of
SPEAKER_01That's right.
SPEAKER_00How do you convince yourself, one, that this in fact holds some level of spiritual meaning? And two, how do you then project beliefs onto it in full earnestness without niggling in the back of your mind, oh wow, this kind of feels just a little bit fake to me. This definitely feels more like pantomime.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I think it has to do with the spirituality gurus as well, right? It's almost seen as a build your own bear kind of a situation, go to these different cultures, pick and choose what you want and do it, right?
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01This is company I once came across on Instagram, this brand. It's Christian Yoga Apparel.
SPEAKER_00This reminds me of two things, Christian energy drink brands, which are apparently a thing, and also tuning forks. It's become increasingly less clear to me since Googling exactly what they're meant to do. Why the hell anyone would think this integral to their practice? Because they themselves will acknowledge, oh, there are a variety of different ways you can align yourself with a circuit frequency. I don't believe that. But if you are someone who does, okay, why are you going out to buy a $50 tuning for? Why are you not seeking that out through more embodied means?
SPEAKER_00If you are someone who believes frequencies are energies and energies are associated with different emotions or different psychological state of mind, waving something that could also hypothetically be found in a giant utensil drawer probably won't guide you towards whatever you're seeking.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I think it's also because a lot of people don't put in the work to understand these practices that they are taking part in. I recently wrote an essay called Deconstructing Manifestation Talk. And I'm basically breaking down the whole, the idea of manifestation that is shared across TikTok. And I'm somebody who believes in manifestation. I have done that for myself. But it's actually a tool that is supposed to aid you in your self-growth. The end of most spiritual practices is self-growth and community.
SPEAKER_01That is it. So you are not tuning into a frequency to magically change your life. Fueling into a frequency so you can feel better. But if you don't feel better within, how are you going to feel better with the frequency? It makes zero sense.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, as someone who in preparation for this podcast spent two hours of my life that I will regrettably never get back, sifting through a lot of spirituality girly, for lack of a better term here, content. If I were someone who was looking for I would be absolutely lost. And I am sympathetic to people, to the audience. And I'm not even sure how aware of this they are perpetuating ideas
SPEAKER_00that are blatantly contradicted by the foundational text they don't know they're pulling from. So, I mean, for example, I saw this one girl claim that you could be a hedonist and be Buddhist.
SPEAKER_00And granted, it's been quite a long time since I've read any text, but I'm thinking to myself, so many of the things that Buddhism aims to guide you towards. Are the direct antithesis of hedonism according to basically any sense of that concept not referenced in the colloquial, not exactly definitionally true fashion that some people can be susceptible to.
SPEAKER_01So I was thinking to myself, No, you really can't. You actually really can.
SPEAKER_00You really can. And the most grating thing about being one of those people who argue that, because there were quite a few people, quite a few practitioners of Buddhism and other spiritual practices in the comments that said things to the effect of, actually, no, hedonism, as you seem to be presenting here, at least, is kind of something that would probably be looked down upon by, you know, people who are legitimately trying to work towards the more traditional interpretation of Wholeness, according to the spiritual practice.
SPEAKER_00And folks in the comments, not even the creators themselves, but those aligned with the creators' beliefs, evidently, were saying things to the effect of, you can't keep X, Y, Z, and G, Y, and X. And I just lost my mind. I was just thinking, Words, ideas, concepts have definitions. You are not aligned with that definition and that's okay. You are not practicing this according to the traditional sorts of texts and that's fine, but you don't have to be a part of everything.
SPEAKER_01So true. And, you know, that brings me back to the first point that I mentioned as I was going through these spiritual texts written by these white women. And as I said, there is no meat. A lot of these practices have rules and regulations. But when I read these books, they're like, you know what, it's okay. Nobody needs to be perfect. You can do this however you would. No, you can't. Yeah. You can not do a spell however you want.
SPEAKER_00That's not okay. I mean, I feel like this is one of those ideas that started in good faith, but unfortunately were bastardized by this particular demographic in that I've read and I've heard from a lot of practitioners themselves that you should always aim for a gradual progression towards X, Y, and Z. If you don't get it right the first time, that's all right. If you don't get it right the 15th time, that's equally fine. It's about maintaining a level of discipline. And now, unfortunately, or at least within this particular context, a lot of these people are doing what I'm going to call here the joy is
SPEAKER_00an active resistance approach when it comes to working towards whatever ideals are pedestalized within certain spiritual practices.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I agree. I think it's also because the world is so chaotic. We are all feeling a little hopeless. Fascism is rising on almost every part of the world. And, you know, you don't have answers and spirituality feels like a nice escape. And, you know, if somebody tells me that if you write this thing out 555 times, this thing will come true. Yes, that seems like really decidable. But you're not going to get a job by writing out, I have a job 555 times. You have to apply.
SPEAKER_01You need to... You need to practice. You need to interview. And when you mentioned the thing about the frequencies, right, that is also because fundamentally people don't understand how these things work. They hear a thing or two. Have you read the Substack newsletter Body Type by Mikla Jameson? Oh, yes. But admittedly, I haven't read one of her new essays in a while. Basically, what she said is you start doing anything, you pick a book about that topic and you read it and then, you know,
SPEAKER_01progress and you get started and then you progress to another book and do it. I think what is happening right now is all of These people who have never read a book, who've never done any sort of exchange with primary reading materials, I don't know, they've seen like 10-20 TikToks and articles and Instagram Reels and they feel like they know it. And it is the same kind of, you know, a weird game of Chinese whisper. The first creator bastardizes some aspect of a concept. The next creator bastardizes it even further. And by the time it reaches your ears, you think writing something out 55 times is manifestation.
SPEAKER_01That's because you have never really read the material
SPEAKER_00where this concept comes from. They also love to bastardize psychoanalytic concepts to hell and back. But instead of insert specific theory established by psychologists or other professionals here, at least 50 years ago, They replace that with frequency or they replace that with some vague notion of the mind not defined enough in their videos to offer them plausible deniability.
SPEAKER_00If someone says, well, actually, this is a very... Very harmful concept to perpetuate because X, Y, and Z, Z, Y, and X. Not everything one thinks is what they genuinely believe. Something along those lines. And of course, this is something I've come across a lot with respect to very awesomeness. Steer ideas shared online about, in which some people have said things to the effect of, God, I'm going to try to call it verbatim, but I don't think I'll be successful. You know, every negative belief you have is actively being projected out into the world.
SPEAKER_00And I thought to myself, this is really harmful for someone with OCD to hear. This would be absolutely devastating. This might lead someone to pick up a knife and slit their wrists. And I understand what they were getting at, but their approach to it was so uncompassionate and so binary that, honestly, they didn't need to post that. You could have kept that to yourself.
SPEAKER_01The concept actually comes from this modern neo-paganism type guru, I think his name is Neville Goddard. And any weird spiritual thing, something that is so rigid, something that doesn't make sense, you go back, it's by a white man.
SPEAKER_00I remember first hearing about this and I was kind of in disbelief as to why so many people were captured by it. Well, maybe not disbelief and maybe not even a why sort of thing, but I just thought to myself, well, yes, but also it isn't this deterministic. Do we not need a couple of asterisks here? I was kind of waiting for a variety of different people to go well. But, however, and then they expanded to something just the slightest bit more true to most people's lived experience and not as almost fatalistic, but it is.
SPEAKER_00It never came about. It never came about, at least not back in that sort of 2021, 22 era where so many women were selling you dark feminine e-books and trying to teach you how to essentially become movie caricatures of femme fatales. And I was just thinking to myself, I'm going to uninstall the app.
SPEAKER_01Yes, and that's something I reported on a couple of weeks ago and something I actually was hoping to discuss with you, especially because you're based in the US. So in these cults of divine feminine, they have this talking term, which is basically that the men's hormonal cycle is a 24-hour cycle and the women's hormonal cycle is a 28-day cycle because we have a menstrual cycle and how we need to do everything according to a menstrual cycle. Initially, yeah, okay, please go on.
SPEAKER_01And then this, you know, sort of went into and you need to protect your hormonal health. You shouldn't take anything synthetic. The birth control pill is just going to, you know, mess up with your hormonal health. And yes, there are negative side effects to the birth control pill, but it's extremely dependent on person to person. And for me, when I was on the birth control pill, it was just the best years of my life. And I came off it because I have diabetes and I had to like, you know, find other ways to deal around with it. So this is an example of how like this classic new age wellness-y trope eventually trickles down into sort
SPEAKER_01of like...
SPEAKER_00It always ends there. And even if you're not one of the people perpetuating this nonsense, even if you are the sort of voice of reason saying, hey, this is one framework, this is one tool, one concept that you can use to help better understand yourself and your body. And to help make you aware of concerns that perhaps you might want to consult your primary care physician about, they are just completely overtaken either with respect to the broader conversation we have about these things as genres or algorithmically by these bad actors, by these ghouls who are then saying,
SPEAKER_00who are then either intentionally or unintentionally writing false ideas about what is and isn't harmful for the female body.
SPEAKER_01So many of these con-spiritual influencers that I had initially started tracking from 2020, 2021, and some of them had good content. It was interesting, you know, creating their own food and they're doing this and that.
SPEAKER_00And lately, I think after the 2024 elections. Yes, it was a 2024 election in which Trump unfortunately claimed victory.
SPEAKER_01Around that time, I saw a lot of these influencers, you know, going down this path and my thoughts are spirituality and all of these practices that you individually pick and choose and kind of like... Build your life around and build your content and Instagram avatar around. These come from pagan practices. It arises in opposition to Christian nationalism. It arises in opposition to this sort of rigid structure.
SPEAKER_01And if you're going to use these principles to go back to that same structure, I don't know, I think you never actually understood the principle. Like, I think this is just, we are just talking and going in circles right now. But yes, you never understood the principle and then you Taking this principle to bastardize,
SPEAKER_00it's heartbreaking for me. It also enrages me. I mean, one of the most interesting things about this type of creator, because I don't really think I've ever at least knowingly followed any wellness influencers, so to speak. But of course, The larger ones occasionally come up on my For You page and my Reels page and have throughout the years on only a few occasions. What I found most devastating about it all is that they never did end up transcending themselves. They are always working towards a cutscene. I'm not a part of their target audience, but I do have to wonder if these people ever do lose a kind of credibility
SPEAKER_00when they are perpetually responsible. Unfolding and never arriving at anything, at any conclusory state, we'll call it, final enough to finally suggest confidence in oneself or this idea
SPEAKER_00that they've achieved something akin to confidence. Does it not begin to seem and feel to the audience like stagnation? And for the viewer who's been with them for the duration of their journey, who say followed this hypothetical individual in 2022 and continue to now in 2026, is it not any less convincing?
SPEAKER_01Adding to what you just said, and as we are nearing towards the end of the session, one thing I want to leave everyone with is that if these gurus are selling you anything, take whatever they are saying with a grain of salt. Next, another thing... To start with anything, pick a book and read. Do not go by what is going on TikTok, what is going on Instagram. Pick a book and read. And yes, terms have meanings. Nobody is gatekeeping things in the sense that,
SPEAKER_01you know, your refusal to educate yourself is not necessarily others gatekeeping things. In terms of meanings, practices have meanings. You cannot just pick and choose and just do whatever, just remix everything, right? You're not like DJing this, right? You can't do that. Thank you so much for joining me today.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for having me.
SPEAKER_01This has been Girl Online. I will see you next week with yet another deep dive into what we're all doing online. If you enjoyed this episode, consider buying me a coffee at buymeacoffee.com slash abhaahad.
This is part 8 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...
This is part 7 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...
This is part 5 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...
This is part 4 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...
This is part 3 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...