Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Conversations

Conversations artwork

toxic tumblr w/ Jane Song

Aug 27, 202631 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is part 7 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl online is an independent platform that reports on what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to them. The weekly stories that you read on Wednesdays are written by me, based on what the web feeds me, and filtered through my lens. This series is an attempt to bring in diverse experiences of digital girlhood to you. In this episode, I am joined by Jane Song, and we talk about our experiences on 2010s Tumblr and how it influences our lives still. Some things we talk about here: * My article breaking down the love-hate relationship we all have with Tumblr * Rayne Fisher Quann’s note * Tyler Feder website: https://www.tylerfeder.com/ Special shoutout to my sister, Azha, for editing this conversation. If you’d like to fund my work on here, here’s the tip jar. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.girlonline.in

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Girl Online, a space where we discuss what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to us. I am Abha Ahad, the girl behind Girl Online. This is part 7 of an 8-part series of conversations I had with fellow culture experts from around the world. In each episode, we dive deep into a specific subculture these experts have been tracking for years. Today we have with us Jane Song. Jane works in marketing and is the writer-executive director of the Jane Institute,

SPEAKER_01a think tank dedicated to the study of cultural mechanics. She was awarded a Purple Heart in the direction of Swiftree Conflict of 2012.

SPEAKER_00Hi Jane, welcome to Girl Online. Hi, thanks for having me. What are we discussing today? Today, we're going to be talking about the legacy that the 2010s Tumblr has left on us as socially conscious women. When did you join Tumblr? I joined Tumblr in 2010 or 2011 and pretty immediately gravitated towards the fandom side of stuff. In my real life, I was really into Harry Potter and Glee and Taylor Swift and Tumblr just gave

SPEAKER_00the opportunity to explore every single interest I had. There was just this endless supply of content that I could consume, and there was just no barrier to entry there. The way you participated was, if you're into it, you can just be a consumer all day long and just reblog stuff. You didn't even have to make anything. It was honestly fun enough to just look at people's gif sets of the yellow motif in Parks and Rec or whatever it was.

SPEAKER_00I was a very active reblogger for quite a while. And I think I kind of fell off around 2015, 16. Had a couple of spurts on and off. But yeah, my start was in the early 2010s. I was right in the middle of all the action, I think.

SPEAKER_01That is quite similar to my journey as well. I think I joined Tumblr in 2012 and I was active till 2017, which is when I went to boarding school and then did not have access to any of my devices. And when I actually came back to like the internet, Sometime in mid-2019, so many things had changed. Tumblr had gone through a lot of changes. And in general, I think Tumblr and social media at that time, 2010s, is a lot different from how it is now because it did not have... Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And if I were to create a fan page now, I think there will be some kind of like a growth aspect to it. But on Tumblr, it was more about community. Well, I did care about how many likes my edits were getting or how many likes my collages were getting. But it was more about a community factor. We made so many friends there. And something very interesting from the notes that you sent over was the whole social justice warrior kind of feminism that was really active on 2010's Tumblr. I personally was a little aware of it all and it did teach me what feminism is.

SPEAKER_01It did teach me what being gay is, what being queer is, all of that. But I'm based in India. So I believe Tumblr and the SJW days of Tumblr had more real life political sort of effect in the US and the West more than it did in South Asia or India. So I'm really interested in what you think about that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was quite curious actually about what that scene would have looked like in India at the time, especially because I think the part of Tumblr that I engaged with was all in English and part of the Anglosphere. I'm assuming that most people I saw on Tumblr were Americans, but I think with the high level of English fluency around the world, I mean, it's honestly, it was kind of hard to tell, especially because people were pretty private about their real identities. But I will say, I think the 2010s,

SPEAKER_00late 2000s were definitely a turning point in terms of LGBTQ awareness. Even if you look at television at the time, like shows like Glee and Modern Family, I think, first of all, they were quite successful shows, but I think they surprisingly did play a role in changing the way that Everyday Americans thought about gay rights. I think there was a really big message at the time. The line that everyone said was, you know, love is love. And I think there was a big part of portraying gay relationships that were kind

SPEAKER_00of functionally not that different from straight relationships. I think because there's a lot more queer visibility in the West, there's also a lot more different types of queer relationships that are explored. But at that time, since in America, gay marriage was... I would say that was kind of like normie, liberal. Emerald Tumblr person.

SPEAKER_00The graphics with a cartoon girl with armpit hair, that came a little bit after, but I'd say those were all grouped in together. As much as people talked on Tumblr a lot about performatively hating men or performatively hating white people... I think a right-wing person would see that as being like, oh, this is very violent language and they hate men and they wish men would disappear. But I mean, I think it was just people airing their grievances and most people were pretty normal.

SPEAKER_00Did it spill over into real life? But I think like something man-hating had a million likes. I don't think a million women were out here saying like, I wish I could stab a man or whatever. Absolutely.

SPEAKER_01So to just clarify a little bit, when I say, you know, I grew up on Tumblr, but using Tumblr, it's not as common, the whole Tumblr girl, sort of a girlhood, very common in India as So, yeah. It's a very upper middle class urban experience, which is my experience.

SPEAKER_01So definitely not the overall general Indian experience. But until the late 2010s, gay sex was criminal in India. It was decriminalized only in the late 2010s. So I can see a little bit of an analogous sort of like a political evolution. It is very interesting because even when I was growing up, I was also like an angry feminist, right? And I'm still an angry feminist. But I would say Tumblr did and the people that I engaged with

SPEAKER_01on Tumblr did form some of my very initial political identity. It did give me the language to talk about a lot of things. And there was sort of like the stereotypical feminist kind of an archetype like you were talking about. But yes, I agree with the fact that no, it doesn't mean like if I say I want to kill a man, it doesn't really mean I want to kill a man.

SPEAKER_00It was more of a euphemism, right?

SPEAKER_01As I grew up, I did grow out of a lot of the things that I believed in back then. I think when I was growing up gentle, equality was like one of the biggest causes that I stood for. But as I grew up, I think perhaps... Perhaps like class and climate activism is like sort of what I feel more called towards. And that's not to say that gender equality is not a valid goal. It is. But I feel like class also has a lot to do with that.

SPEAKER_01I would also say that growing up on Tumblr, my idea or my political identity was very removed from the on-ground reality in India. I grew up thinking of myself as closer to some of the American people. I was interacting with on Tumblr than some of my peers, which is very interesting. I know that there is a lot of Tumblr nostalgia and then sort of like bashing going on online at the moment. And there was sort of like remembering 2016, 2016 is back, sort of a trend that was going on.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yes.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Like, oh, here's a picture of me from then. And yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think Tumblr is very crucial to 2016 online culture. There was a lot of Tumblr conversations as well. And a lot of people were talking about, and rightfully so, and I've reported on this, about the toxic aspects of Tumblr, the toxic communities there. Thankfully, I have never really interacted with any of them. It never came on my feed because again, what you find on Tumblr has to do with the kind of people that you follow on Tumblr. It was not very algorithmic as such. What was your experience with quote-unquote toxic Tumblr?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I feel like I was always following so many blogs because it was a chronological timeline and you were shown exclusively the people you followed. And so there really wasn't a lot of room in what I was searching, which was like so specific, like fandom specific blogs that I didn't really come across a lot of pro-Anna or violent sexual content. I think if you're running a fandom blog, you actually really get penalized for that.

SPEAKER_00They're like, hey, that's not on theme. You need to tag NSFW when you, you know, I think people were kind of very conscious about their curation. And so the risk of coming across content that was like unwanted was Not super likely. And there also wasn't like this pipeline from, oh, you start with Harry Potter, but then suddenly you're looking at porn or something like that. That wasn't very common. To be fair, I guess there's like an erotic fan fiction pipeline maybe.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, I was not super engaged with it. Of course, I only knew about these things secondhand via people on Tumblr on text posts or something would talk about it. I'd learn these keywords, I guess, and then, you know, look into it. But I think I was too brainwashed by social justice to, like, appreciate any of the pro-Anna stuff, you know? It was like, they were keeping me healthy. And what reminded me of that was a note from Rainfisher Kwan talking about how,

SPEAKER_00you know, she was in a kind of a dark place during the 2010s, you know, self-harm or Eating disorder and things like that. But because she was so Involved in this, you know, 2010s like woke social justice scene that really kept her safe because she was like, uh-uh, I can't look at this. This is not woke, not for me. And I would say I had a similar, I mean, I was just really self-righteous about it. I was like, oh, like you think you're so cool.

SPEAKER_00You know, you're not actually, I'm studying hard so that I can be your boss one day. Oh, yeah. Yeah. I was also a girl boss, like a teenage girl boss.

SPEAKER_01For sure. And yes, that is a very interesting point, because with all the 2016 nostalgia, there is also sort of like a revisionist history where people are like, oh, Tumblr was so toxic. Everybody on Tumblr had an eating disorder and all of these. But as it is now, Now, the pro-Anna, pro-aching disorder communities were still a fringe group on Tumblr. It was still looked down upon. It was still very taboo back then as well. But when I read some of the commentaries online, it makes me feel like everybody believes that on Tumblr,

SPEAKER_01everybody had an eating disorder. Everybody was romanticizing it, which is not really the case. And those communities are still very active. The erotic fandom communities and pro-Anna communities are still very active

SPEAKER_00on Tumblr, by the way. I mean, I also think that communities like the ProAnna community was, I would imagine they were pretty invested in staying hidden, especially because they got, I feel like hashtags like that got banned by the app or, you know, that these kinds of like crackdowns are happening quite a lot. And there's also, at least like in terms of online stuff. Eating disorder culture, there was a definite gatekeeping that was going on. So that's even more motivation for that community to have stayed to themselves.

SPEAKER_00You know what? But I think I do see that there could be a link in the fandom sense. It was part of the Lana Del Rey American Horror Story starter pack. I can see maybe if you were into One Direction, maybe it's not as likely that these things would overlap.

SPEAKER_01I am looking at the website that you had shared, tylerfeeder.com. And it is so interesting. It's very beautiful. I'll share it in the show notes for people to watch it. But yes, what were your experiences on SJW Tumblr or how would you say Tumblr radicalized you specifically?

SPEAKER_00I think that Tumblr had some good, funny, rhetorical posts that were pro-woman, pro-gay, pro-trans posts. They introduced a lot of concepts in a way that were funny and accessible. If there was any sort of radicalizing moment, I would say it was the death of Leela Alcorn. She was a trans girl, she was a teenager, and she died by suicide after leaving, I think, a note on Tumblr explaining her reason.

SPEAKER_00After she died, her death became kind of a big news story, I think, relative to a lot of other I think one thing that kind of stood out was the fact that her parents still had sent her to gay conversion therapy or something of that kind and they're religious and they did not acknowledge her as a trans girl after her death. They referred to her by her dead name. And I think really it was how clearly Leela articulated the pain that she was in.

SPEAKER_00And I think her desire for her death, not to just be a statistic, but to really... She was conscious of the way she did become a martyr for trans people. Her pain and the way that she had to suffer, that definitely... Okay, these are marginalized groups of people who should be protected emotionally, mentally. This is a cause that is worthy of our concern.

SPEAKER_00There was also in the 2010s a big culture of the significance of a single story. I believe this was a Facebook page, Humans of New York, featured everyday New Yorkers. There was kind of a conscious effort on social media that people made to... I guess just try to cultivate more empathy like that was kind of an actively stated goal. And I think even via fiction through these like real life stories, I think a lot of people kind of had their hearts softened to people

SPEAKER_00who were not like themselves.

SPEAKER_01Yes, I think Tumblr did definitely give me sort of that kind of diversity, right? In terms of understanding that there are a lot of people around the world who are very unlike me but are also very cool and As I was growing up as like a preteen teen, I did not have many friends in school, but I did have a lot of friends online and I felt really accepted by them. And it was sort of this alter ego as well, right? When you were on Tumblr, you could be the person that you don't really have to conform to anything

SPEAKER_01that you do in real life. It was a very teenage experience

SPEAKER_00as such.

SPEAKER_01So back when I started my career, I started out as a writer for BuzzFeed. And in one of my earliest articles for BuzzFeed was 33 things I learned from being a One Direction fan. And it's all about the skills that I gained by just being in the fandom, like, you know, video making or editing stuff. Fact checking, writing, a lot of these skills that I use today as an academic and as a journalist, it all comes from my fandom days.

SPEAKER_01And I think that can also be said for Tumblr. It also came from my days on Tumblr and Instagram. I never wrote on Wattpad, but definitely consumed a lot of content there. So what did Tumblr give you?

SPEAKER_00I think it gave me, similar to you, it definitely gave me permission to really passionately love the things that I loved and to just dive into my interests as deep as possible. I don't know. I feel like I just know so much useless stuff. Like I feel like I'm human IMDB sometimes because of fandom Tumblr. So there's that aspect. I also kind of started to try to find my voice as a critic through Tumblr.

SPEAKER_00I would read critical essays about A Song of Ice and Fire slash Game of Thrones on Tumblr. And then I would read that and then I would, for school and stuff, like when we had more sort of loose, free writing type of assignments, I'd be like, okay, and now I'm going to write about how Sansa Stark's story represents rape culture. And it's like, did anyone care? No.

SPEAKER_01But I think that did definitely impact me.

SPEAKER_00Just the injustice of misogyny and rape culture really hit me hard when I was 15. Not because I experienced violence myself, but just reading rhetoric on Tumblr, reading books, consuming media where there was some degree of adjacency or something I can latch onto. I don't know. I just kind of saw everything through that lens. I do believe that was in part because of Tumblr. That's more on my fixations. I don't know if that made me a better... Anything.

SPEAKER_00I think maybe it actually did hone my sense of justice and it gave me at least a sort of broader awareness of the world outside of my immediate family and community. But it definitely still was generally limited to an American context. As much as it has influenced my politics, I think I've had a lot of room to grow and develop some degree of nuance from there. Yeah, I did definitely get these tools and vocabulary, you know, concepts like intersectional feminism.

SPEAKER_00I wouldn't have learned that anywhere if not for Tumblr. Absolutely, yes.

SPEAKER_01A lot of terms to explain how I was feeling. I was introduced to a lot of You can say SJW terms but important terms very young rather than compared to my peers and just like a little bit of a sidetrack but I think a couple of months ago I got a DM from one of my subscribers who's like a very young And I realized everything I'd done to grow my Substack is basically lessons from my Tumblr days.

SPEAKER_01I had come on Substack, yes, to share my views and like report on stories that I want to report on and everything. But I had also seen this from day one, I had seen this as like a community building experience, like a community building initiative, because that's what I've learned. That's what was the best years of my best time on social media. So to answer that person andSubstack exists because I had some of my best days on Tumblr. I honed a lot of skills there. And moving on from that,

SPEAKER_01this is not very common in India or this is not very relevant to the Indian political environment. But as somebody who is on the Anglosphere internet and as somebody who is constantly exposed to American politics and I do that voluntarily... Because it's interesting and just because it's just bombarded in my face all the time. I am just constantly listening to these anti-woke sort of culture. And that being a unifying factor for a lot of people on the right

SPEAKER_01that you know like woke has gone too far. And when they say woke, I am reminded of the SJW sort of activists on Tumblr in the heydays of Tumblr. And I think it's one of the first breeding grounds of woke. What are your thoughts on that? Somebody who lives in the US, knows from the US, what's your thoughts on that? Woke and American politics in JW, all of that.

SPEAKER_00I feel like it is safe to assume that a lot of woke culture came from Tumblr. I think your fav is problematic is probably one of the most notable examples of what a normal person would dislike about woke culture. Like a very nitpicking... I

SPEAKER_00think sometimes it's useful. I do think sometimes it's having that account, knowing about a history of behavior. I would say maybe if you are in the entertainment industry could be pretty useful because you can say, hey, I don't want to work with a person who repeatedly says derogatory things about I simply don't want to work with that person. I think that's actually a pretty fair argument to make.

SPEAKER_00I'm getting a little sidetracked here about the your fav is problematic because I'm thinking about the accountability that the everyday person has, I feel, is kind of limited, I'd say. Yes, we are watching. The accountability that the everyday person may have is still quite limited relative to Film executives or producers or, of course, like, yeah, maybe like don't go to a Chris Brown concert because that is money directly in that man's pockets. But if your friend is playing that person's music in their car, it's like, I don't know.

SPEAKER_00It's 0.002 cents in that guy's pocket, I guess. I mean, it adds up. But at the same time, I mean, this was a take that I heard recently on the That Good Noticings podcast. I was like, yeah, I mean, sometimes these things are... I think the idea of accountability is fair, but I do think in terms of, I don't know what people are calling woke 1.0, my personal problem with it is that it took like a super American lens on oppression. They totally ignored the fact that oppression is It happens in other nations

SPEAKER_00and it's not only ever just white on non-white violence. There's so much more complication. Deep-seated enmity between ethnic groups woke in a lot of ways. Maybe it wasn't enough. I think maybe they did have to learn about the Rwandan genocide. And if we had taken a more global lens... I think that's a fair thing to acknowledge. But I think it was like, kind of communicate to people in the wrong way.

SPEAKER_00And then When someone would be like, I'm white, I don't feel privileged, then, you know, the typical SJW would be like, well, that's not my responsibility to teach you. It's like, well, what was the point then?

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. It was very unforgiving, right? It expected people to be perfect and was very unforgiving of anything far from perfect. And none of us are perfect. I feel like it also led to a sort of like discouragement of discourse, right? I am not going to take the time or effort. I am a marginalized person, so you shouldn't expect me to spend energy to teach you about something. No regard for debate. And I'm so glad you mentioned this.

SPEAKER_01The SJW sort of liberal or maybe leftist activism in the US is of course based on the US's complicated racial and political history. And there is a sort of kind of thing that I see on Substack also these days. A lot of things I talk about is through my lens as an Indian. It is not, of course, going to make sense to somebody in the US because my history with race, with caste, with gender,

SPEAKER_01with All of this will be very different from whatever is going on in the US. And this is a very interesting divide that is happening in Kerala's transgender community. I'm from Kerala, it's a southern state in India. In the US, there is a whole the quote-unquote trans women are women sort of activism, right? I don't know if to call it activism or not and probably I'm going to get cancelled for this. But I feel like in the US, if you don't believe that a trans woman is transgender, A woman just like a cis woman is, you're transphobic.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've definitely heard. It can definitely come across that way, depending on where you are, yes.

SPEAKER_01In Kerala, we've obviously had transgender people for obviously centuries and transgender people have always been a third category, right? Like an umbrella. And I am not sitting here and saying that no, they've not faced any oppression. Oh, we've all been like so happy from the start. No, they are one of the most oppressed communities even in Kerala or India as well. And it is only very lately that they are getting the sort of representation and limelight they are with social media and everything. The young people,

SPEAKER_01the young trans folks here have sort of started parroting the narrative in the US that, you know, we are also just like women. Again, I'm not saying they are not women. Of course, I believe in somebody's right to live as the gender identity that speaks to them the most. There is a lot of debate here in the transgender community where the older trans people are like, yes, we are trans people, yes, we are trans women, but we are not women. There is a different womanhood. Trans womanhood is different from cis womanhood,

SPEAKER_01which is a very like mainstream take here, even within the transgender community. It's getting like imported here. The US way of thinking where it's like, you know, trans women equals cis women in every aspect because gender is a myth, sort of that. And that's creating a lot of divide here. One of the ways where US politics and US SJW activism can affect communities around the world, even though we don't live there, As we are nearing towards the end of this recording, a last question is, how do you view your days on Tumblr?

SPEAKER_01Was it toxic? Was it liberating? And I know it's very difficult to put a label to it, but the whole Substack ecosystem that is discussing Tumblr is very eager to put a label on it. You know, Tumblr is a mix of all of these things. It was toxic, it was liberating, it was a bunch of different things. What was your specific experience?

SPEAKER_00I would say I was marketed to a lot by fans. It kind of exposed me to a lot of new media that I wouldn't have found otherwise. And that's in large part due to fan labor and zero part due to the television network's marketing. There's a part of me that's like, man, was this all a waste of time? I think because in my home life, I was really grilled hard about wasting too much time on the internet. So I'm like, part of me definitely does believe that.

SPEAKER_00I think maybe it was like the cost I had to pay for internet literacy. It had to happen some way or another. And now I have a certain fluency and I would say maybe this was a hard earned fluence. You know, even when my mom deleted my blog, I think more than once. I'm hard broken for you. It was pretty sad. I actually don't have access to my original stuff anymore. I'm like, dang, I was really an addict. Like I got punished hard and then I kept going back.

SPEAKER_00And I think, yeah, I guess it was fun. That was the closest thing I had to fun in those years.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I don't think my parents had any idea what I was doing on the internet, which just looking back, that was really irresponsible of them. I had like sort of censored access to the internet because I came back from school around 1.32 in the afternoon and my parents were not home till 6, 7 in the evening. So I had a good four, five hours to like sort of do everything without anybody knowing about it. My only limitation was how limited the data that I would have to spend. So I think I had access to 3 GB of data in a month.

SPEAKER_01That's how much my dad would like recharge. I had like a pen drive, sort of a net center, we used to call it. So that was recharged like 3 GB per month. So that was the only limitation I had. And, you know, back then you did not need all that data to surf the internet, but it was not a waste of time. I just want to reassure you that it's not a waste of time because I'm sure a lot of the skills that you learn just being on Tumblr, you use that in your daily life every single day.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, maybe Tumblr taught me how to be a funny person. I don't know. Maybe, you know, it's a skill you constantly have to flex and you have to be exposed to cool stuff to get a sense of humor.

SPEAKER_01Yes, closing words, Tumblr made us cool.

SPEAKER_00It kind of did. I wouldn't be the same. I'm like, I don't know who I'd be without it.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Jane. Thank you so much for joining me today. This was such a wonderful conversation. I'm so excited to share it. Yeah, thank you so much for having me today. This has been Girl Online. I will see you next week with yet another deep dive into what we're all doing online. If you enjoyed this episode, consider buying me a coffee at buymeacoffee.com slash abhaahad.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. usernames w/ Azha Ahad

    Sep 1, 202618 minAudio

    This is part 8 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. conspiritual baddies w/ Philomena Stone

    Aug 17, 202627 minAudio

    This is part 6 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. the year of the bride w/ Jade Hurley

    Aug 10, 202632 minAudio

    This is part 5 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. reclaiming girlhood w/ Victória Oliveira

    Aug 3, 202625 minAudio

    This is part 4 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. men's rights (women's wrongs) w/Smizzo

    Jul 27, 202626 minAudio

    This is part 3 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode