Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Conversations

Conversations artwork

boy pussy w/ Monia Ali

Jul 20, 202623 minAudioEpisode 2
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

This is part 2 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl online is an independent platform that reports on what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to them. The weekly stories that you read on Wednesdays are written by me, based on what the web feeds me, and filtered through my lens. This series is an attempt to bring in diverse experiences of digital girlhood to you. In this episode, I am joined by Monia Ali, and we talk about MLM romance and our weird relationships with them. The quality of the recording is a bit poor as we recorded through Substack. But until I can afford a subscription to a recording platform, we will have to make do with it. Special shoutout to my sister, Azha, for editing this conversation. If you’d like to fund a recording platform for me, here’s the tip jar. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit www.girlonline.in

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Welcome to Girl Online, a space where we discuss what women are doing on the internet and what the internet is doing to us. I am Abha Ahad, the girl behind Girl Online. This is episode 2 of an 8-part series of conversations I had with fellow culture experts from around the world. In each episode, we dive deep into a specific subculture these experts have been tracking for years. Today we have with us Monia Ali. Monia is a fandom native and investigative culture critic.

SPEAKER_01Her work is interested in the devolution of fan culture and communities, contextualizing the rights of stans and industry interference. Hi Monia, welcome to Girl Online.

SPEAKER_00Hi, thank you for having me.

SPEAKER_01What are we discussing today?

SPEAKER_00Okay, so today there's been a lot of talk online about straight female desire and particularly spurred on by Phoebe Maltz-Bovey's book, The Last Straight Woman. And I followed her work for a really long time and And I've always thought it was really interesting the way that female desire, not necessarily straight, but just desire for men in general, is expressed in a lot of fandom spaces. And especially the hint of feminization that is often happening. Recurrent, like this trope of turning male characters more feminine

SPEAKER_00and giving them socially coded feminine traits and physicality and all of that stuff and how that seems to be an expansion of that desire. And I wonder if that has to do because feminization is the only framework we have for someone being consumable, if that's You know, the correct way of putting it, like someone who can be consumed. Yeah. And I've been thinking a lot about that lately. And I'm very happy to talk about it with someone because even when I write on it,

SPEAKER_00I'm like, am I just imagining things? Am I just all up in my head?

SPEAKER_01No, I don't think you are imagining it. It's for sure something that I have also been noticing. When you say consumption, right? I was also thinking about when Bridgerton came out with the story for season 4, season 5, right? How do I say it?

SPEAKER_01Right. So when it's the story of two lesbians, they can't do that self-insertion, which is why they do not enjoy it as much as a heterosexual love story or even a gay love story.

SPEAKER_00It's hard to know because there's so much self-insertion happening even when we're talking about Slash or Yaoi or whatever we're calling it these days, male-male pairings. The self-insertion is very present there as well. The Bridgerton thing is so interesting because I am not happy. I'm not happy that they changed, that they turned it into a lesbian story either as a book reader. But I would have loved Eloise to have been a lesbian. She's like book six or something like that. And I've seen that a lot. Just because I think her dynamic would have been better suited for that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's been a lot of conversations about that. And it's so interesting because women seem to oftentimes not like female characters, really look down on feminine traits, and yet they will impose them on their favorite characters. There's that whole trend of like, he is... He's a woman to me and baby girlifying men. That he's a woman to me is a very interesting perspective as well because it is somehow suggesting that seeing a certain male character as a woman gives him more depth. It cleanses those feminine attributes by the fact that it's

SPEAKER_00a man that's being given them, if that makes sense at all.

SPEAKER_01That is very interesting when you say that femininity is a desired trait when it's a man, but not when it's a woman, right?

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Why do you think so? Like, why is that?

SPEAKER_00It's so strange. I don't know. I don't know. And also there is this thing like... A lot of the problem that I have with writing about fandom and fan communities is that I'm hyper aware that you cannot claim that everyone does something for the same reason. So there are so many different reasons, right? So I can only speculate on what some of the angles are. I'm the director, I'm the cameraman.

SPEAKER_00And there can be this idea that a lot of people eroticize gender polarity and they like seeing complementary dynamics in that way. So they like to impose that. There's also, again, this idea of A lot of times, because you'll see this with ships, right? Where you start to see a trend of their sexual dynamics where one has to be the top and one has to be the bottom. And that is what it has to be because this one. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And then of course, then there's the people that actually always prefer the masculine coded one. But it's just so interesting. I think it probably has a lot to do with our internal, the ways that we see things, which we're drawn to and which role we prefer to look at. But it's tough. There was a poll. There was a poll on Tumblr that asked like, when you say he is a woman to me about an ostensibly cis male character, what do you mean? And while the majority of people say, I don't say this. That's what we're 50% of people say. I don't say this. So that's already interesting, right? We see it a lot, but that's not necessarily the majority of people that do it, right?

SPEAKER_00And then it's like almost 13% say, I view the character as a trans woman or otherwise trans femme. So we can see that that is probably a projection type thing. You want to see that type of representation. But then there's people saying, I don't think the character is a woman, but he has girl vibes. I don't think the character is a woman. I'm just saying I like him, which is interesting. Like, oh, saying you like someone is saying that they're a woman, which again brings us back to the fact that they often don't like female characters, though. So how does that work? But yeah.

SPEAKER_00And I don't know. I don't know how explicit it is. You don't want this podcast to be because there are some quotes that I'm like, these things are pretty crazy the way that sometimes people talk about how they will feminize them. And they're very much just like, listen, we're all feral people and we're just using these characters for our feral, horny purposes. And it's like, okay, but it still says something about culture at large. It says something about how we interact with tropes and how we interact with characters. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01What effect does it have on the consumption and in terms of the kind of content they consume? And by that, I mean the content that gets produced, right? If there are consumers for one certain kind of content, then that is what gets produced more. So do you see that turning up in terms of creation as well?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, especially in fan fiction spaces and fan art, you'll see things get very exaggerated very quickly. And I feel like I'm always like a wet blanket because I'll see something start to happen and I'll be like, oh no, I see where this is. Like we're at the stage where it's fine. Everyone is just being cute, making jokes. And I'm like, I know that everyone here is just having fun, but I have been in fandom for so long and I've been online for so long that I already see like where it's going. And then three months later, you're like, yeah.

SPEAKER_00If we look at something recent like Heated Rivalry Fandom, there's a group of fans for Connor's story that have turned him into this stand-in for a woman. He's so caretaking and he's so feminine and he's so soft. And you're just like, but you don't know this person. And then you have the others. And it's overly simplifying just. Right? Because you want everything to just be so consistent in one specific way.

SPEAKER_01Would you see this as a response to the manosphere as well? Since manosphere is out there saying that, you know, real men are X, Y and Z, I see a sort of counterculture movement where women are actively coming online and saying, no, that is not what we want. That is what men think what we want. No, this is what we want. So would you say like that has something to do with what we're seeing in this particular phenomenon?

SPEAKER_00Yes, I would say so. Definitely. But it's weird because I don't know how much of it is reflected in reality. Do the women who impose heteronormative standards on their slash ships, like, do they want a more feminine guy or not? Like, I don't know if they actually do in reality is also part of the thing. But it is very true that the manosphere has no idea about what women want. So funny. And I always think about that with fandom spaces in general, because and also the discourse in general that has now been saying like,

SPEAKER_00well, women never desire men in general, like at all. And it's like, yeah, it's clear you've never been in fandom, because it's also not just the stereotypical moments. Bill Hader had tons of people that were just dying over him.

SPEAKER_01I am unaware of, could you give us a little context?

SPEAKER_00Bill Hader is an actor. He was on SNL and there's a really famous meme of him dancing from SNL where there's this like this kooky music.

SPEAKER_01Yes, popular WhatsApp stickers.

SPEAKER_00And like Tumblr had these whole communities that people were super attracted to them. It feels so rude to call out specific men that I personally don't. But like to me, it shows like a wide array. Like let's say like Dan and Phil, the YouTubers, they also have lots of fangirls who are like obsessed with them. And I don't see it. But also I feel like it's good that it shows that women have such a varied taste that they can feel that strongly about different types of men. But yeah, it's almost like, you know what else it makes me think of?

SPEAKER_00I don't know if you remember this or saw this, but there was a project that drew male superheroes the way that female superheroes are often drawn. Like this over-sexualized, like, ooh, butt-popping and like, oh, turning around to like show off. I don't know if it was like Spider-Man specifically that they used a lot of male characters, I feel like, just to show like how different it looks and how you're like, well, ridiculous. Yeah. Right. Right.

SPEAKER_01Thank you for like dissecting this for us. So, so articulated. I love it. Thank you for like bringing this topic to us. I'm sure our listeners will definitely enjoy this. As we move towards the end of the segment, do you have any closing thoughts?

SPEAKER_00Great question.

SPEAKER_01I do know that there's been a

SPEAKER_00lot of... Yeah. True. True. True.

SPEAKER_00I'm just saying this is what it does look like right now. Like this is what how people are expressing themselves, right?

SPEAKER_01I think that criticism is a little stupid because people do all sorts of things and those reasons doesn't necessarily have to be politically correct. Yes, of course, you cannot get rid of misogyny by removing I mean, you can, but that's not the point. That's counterproductive. But that also doesn't mean that the readers, like the normal users, normal consumers of this kind of content don't want an out from their daily life where they face a lot of misogyny.

SPEAKER_01So to be wanted to be treated well by your partner in sort of that kind of self insertion kind of way. I think that is fair. I think I think it's a little bit of a coping mechanism, but I think that is fair.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I do think there is a difference. This maybe is a hot take. I feel like it might be. I don't know. I do think there is a difference between the women who are drawn to gay men and the men who fetishize lesbians. Like I do genuinely think there is a difference. Not that one is better than the other, but I think there's different motivations going on. Because, for example, it's very interesting how lesbian shows and movies don't have very large male audiences. They're not interested in watching shows that will explore their lives.

SPEAKER_00Whereas the women will watch like a show about gay men because they want to see the like emotional lives of the men like they're interested in the men beyond just the sex and then maybe they'll go right pick where there is sex or not like it doesn't seem to be ridiculous. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01In terms of when we talk about men who fetishize lesbians, I personally think there is a kind of self-insertion there as well because the content that is created specifically talking in terms of pornography, lesbian pornography and men are the primary consumers of that. But the way it is done and structured and created, there is space for self-insertion, right? So the man can think about getting pressured by two women rather than one. So it's not the women pleasuring each other. Whenever I see lesbian pornography, I feel like there is a man in the room.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_00No, 100%. Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt you.

SPEAKER_01No, no, please.

SPEAKER_00I was just going to say, like, from what I've heard, and again, like, I'm old at this point, so I feel like I've seen these arguments so long. From what I've heard and what I've seen, a lot of the men that like lesbian pornography and like to imagine lesbians see it as, and then I come in and they're going to be like, oh my God, finally, oh my God, there was a dick here. Like, I love women, but like, oh my God, finally we'll have real sex now. And it's going to be so fulfilling. And this isn't everyone again, but like the majority of the women who are drawn to gay men seem to be like, again, that thing of like, oh, I'm observing. Like I'm not involved.

SPEAKER_00They're not joining in. Their fantasy is not joining in and being embraced. It's watching. Like it's watching. And if you look at

SPEAKER_01something like the

SPEAKER_00old show Queer as Folk, which is a favorite show of mine, it's It's tough these days because even though I was very criticized, it is much closer to gay culture and how gay men behave, written by gay men and directed by gay men and all of that, with a lot more like open relationships and age gaps and just like very sex-focused. Like, yeah.

SPEAKER_00You know, it's 10 years. Like, are you really just only hooking up with the one guy? Like, that's not very likely for a gay bisexual man who has access, who is very attractive, has status, like, you know, who has access to a lot of other people. But the romance is the idea that you're only really connected to that one person. So there's a difference. I think a lot of gay men feel like it delegitimizes their real life and their experience. And I think that's a valid complaint. But I'm just interested in

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would say so.

SPEAKER_00Everything blends together, though, which becomes so complicated. I used to think it was much easier to separate fiction from reality, but nowadays, even fan fiction becomes mainstream published, and then it becomes a film, and then it's broadcast,

SPEAKER_00and then it's like, oh, this is the established new reality, and it becomes so hard. I think that's a bigger problem than just this issue as well. I guess I wish people were just slightly more curious about why they like what they like, because it can be revealing, and it can lead you to understand yourself and your own desires more, I would say.

SPEAKER_01I think we should make merch that says that. You know, think more on, I don't know, it's not a very catchy thing to put on like a t-shirt. Interrogate

SPEAKER_00your desires.

SPEAKER_01Yes, interrogate your desires. That's a better wording. But I know it can come to a point where you kind of like sort of self-introspective thinking can get out of hand.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01But in terms of understanding yourself, it's a great starting point. I also think people need to take criticism, especially in fan communities, less personally.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01And this kind of introspection could make fan communities a lot less toxic the way they are now.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I think a lot of that is a problem because of, you know, the internet infrastructure in general makes it so hard for any type of discussion and nuance to even exist. But if we talk about like explicit form of feminization that I noticed that I was like, this is very interesting slash strange, if I'm allowed to say. And once again, I'm like, I'm sorry if this is too explicit for you, but the rise of what is referred to as boy pussy. Have you heard of this? Have you seen this? I have not.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. But they just are like, well, we'd rather him have a pussy because that's how we want to see it. And it's so interesting. I took a screenshot of the fandoms that have the most of that on AO3. And it's like, it seems to have started in K-pop. BTS, Stray Kids, and My Hero Academia Anime.

SPEAKER_00But then also Stranger Things, Marvel, One Direction, of course, always popping up in there. Supernatural, Formula One, Harry Potter, Genshin Impact. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00As much as I'm like confused by this trend, part of me is also like, OK, but I remember when women would say I can only read male male fiction and smut because girl parts are disgusting and I don't want to be exposed. I don't want to read about it.

SPEAKER_00But it's like a fascinating development, I'll say.

SPEAKER_01I'm still wrapping my head around the whole concept.

SPEAKER_00I'm sorry.

SPEAKER_01There is so much mental gymnastics. Man, but not a trans man. That is very interesting. Thank you. Thank you for illuminating me with that. I will definitely look into it more.

SPEAKER_00Just bringing shock fandom things to the skylight.

SPEAKER_01Thank you so much, Monia. That's been a fascinating conversation.

SPEAKER_00Thank you for having me and letting me, you know, waffle on.

SPEAKER_01This has been Girl Online. I will see you next week with yet another deep dive into what we're all doing online. If you enjoyed this episode, consider Buy Me A Coffee at buymeacoffee.com slash Abha Ahad.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. usernames w/ Azha Ahad

    Sep 1, 202618 minAudio

    This is part 8 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. toxic tumblr w/ Jane Song

    Aug 27, 202631 minAudio

    This is part 7 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. conspiritual baddies w/ Philomena Stone

    Aug 17, 202627 minAudio

    This is part 6 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. the year of the bride w/ Jade Hurley

    Aug 10, 202632 minAudio

    This is part 5 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. reclaiming girlhood w/ Victória Oliveira

    Aug 3, 202625 minAudio

    This is part 4 of an 8-part series of conversations with culture experts from around the world. In each of these episodes, we dive deep into an online subculture or trend that they have been tracking for years. girl...

    Credit the people on this episode