What would a socialist economy look like? Sam Gindin stresses the importance of establishing the feasibility of an alternative socialist society for the development of a strong socialist movement. He presents a vision of a future socialism, and poses important questions that a socialist society will have to figure out. In this episode members of DSA’s National Political Committee (NPC) discuss Sam Gindin's essay. José La Luz is a lifelong labor organizer and campaigner with roots in the New Left in the late 60’s and early 70’s. He was a founding member of DSA after joining DSOC prior to the merger with NAM in the mid 80’s. He is the most senior member of the NPC (in age) adding a multigenerational presence to the national leadership. Sofia Cutler is a member of North New Jersey DSA, and has been a member of the DSA National Political Committee since 2021 as part of the Bread and Roses Slate. She is a rank-and-file member of Unite Here Local 33. Justin Charles is a member of North Brooklyn DSA, and has been a member of the DSA National Political Committee since July 2020. DSA NPEC Curriculum https://dsa-education.pubpub.org/modules DSA’s Leadership and Structure https://www.dsausa.org/about-us/structure/ NPEC Curriculum on Sam Gindin’s "Socialism for Realists" https://dsa-education.pubpub.org/pub/what-is-socialism/release/6#reading-c-socialism-for-realists-abridged-by-sam-gindin Credits: Producer: Elton LK Logo by Michaela Brangan Sound Engineer & Opening Music by Casey Stikker Additional Assistance, including content by Palmer Conrad Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Elton LKThis is Class , an official podcast of the Democratic Socialists of America National Political Education Committee. My name is Elton LK. We're discussing Sam Gindin's Socialism for Realists. This text differs from anything else in our curriculum. Everything we've discussed on the podcast up to this point covers labor history or socialist theory. In Gindin's piece , he starts to speculate what a socialist economy could look like. It is impossible to know what would and would not work in a socialist economy, but Gindin argues we must start to propose positive solutions. We cannot simply criticize capitalism forever. This episode was recorded in May, 2023. Daphne handed over the responsibility of host to me. We're talking once again with José, Justin, and Sofia from the NPC. I recommend reading Sam Gindin's, socialism for realists for yourself. That's the best way to appreciate this discussion. We have an abridged version in our curriculum on the DSA impact website. Link is in the show notes, but reading the essay is not essential for appreciating this episode. What you need to know is that the Soviet Union's economy failed to deliver the prosperity and freedom promised by communism. The reasons for this are many, but the complexity of effectively managing a centralized planned economy proved more difficult than the communists expected. Sam Gindin proposes a decentralized hybrid economy with both room for the free market and for economic planning. Decentralized economic planning allows local workplaces and communities to manage limited resources and environmental protections. And one last thing in this discussion, Jose says , Gindin's essay not only creates the occasion for us to discuss with our comrades what socialism will look like, but it also provides an opportunity for us to discuss how socialism will be won . Many within DSA joined the organization because we believed socialism could only be won through democracy, not violence. But there are those that fear that even if we could elect enough socialists into office to implement socialism, the ruling class that is the capitalist class would not play fairly. The capitalists would break the rules, even turn to violence if necessary in order to hold onto power. We have the terrible example of Salvador Allende in Chile , for example. Though the material conditions have changed, this debate has a long history within the socialist tradition. This divide among our ranks has the possibility of causing a split within our organization. It has in the past split organizations. For this reason, among others, it is important that we address this topic directly. Today's episode is about Sam Gindin's vision of what a socialist economy could look like. So we will have episodes committed to the path to socialism in the future where we can handle it in the nuance and care that it requires. Okay, let us turn to our guests. Welcome, Sofia, Jose, Justin. Sofia, the premise of the text is that socialists have gained a lot of traction by critiquing capitalism, but eventually the socialist movement is going to have to propose positive solutions to actual economic problems. How do you think DSA should strategically approach this concern?
Sofia CutlerI think it's really important that DSA members have these conversations and debates about what socialism would look like. We don't actually do it very much, and that really struck me as I was reading the piece. I think that there is a tendency to wanna really just focus more on the immediate organizing, especially on the American Left. It's something I noticed in the United States, and there's a great article by Doug Henwood and Liza Featherstone called Action Will Be Taken. Um, that talks a little bit about some of the anti-intellectualism on the American left, and I think it's partly a symptom of, of the weakness of our Left that, you know, we haven't had to grapple with governing and so forth, and we can often slip into direct action. Or even like on the flip side, like just a lot of progressive electoral opportunism that maybe doesn't think as much in the long term , um, about building working class power. And so I think the Gindin piece is really challenging us to sit down and think deeply and, and very realistically too, very pragmatically about where we're going. And it's not gonna be necessarily the land of, of milk and honey. There's gonna be scarcity. People are gonna have to do some socially necessary labor, but it's gonna be a society where , um, the economy and investment decisions are gonna be made in a, in a democratic manner. At the same time, I think something really important for us to consider in DSA is his point that it's not gonna be an entirely planned economy. We're gonna have some markets, obviously not labor markets, where people are gonna have to sell their ability to work. Um, but they will exist. And, and it's impossible to have some central planning board that's gonna make you know, the perfect plans and figure everything out. There's gotta be some room for experimentation for new inputs , uh, that some markets can provide. And it's gonna be messy a little bit and experimental because it's, it's not a utopia. Utopias are spaces beyond politics and , uh, politics will still exist under socialism, especially if it's gonna be democratic , uh, especially if we're gonna be managing and balancing different interests of workers and consumers and planners. So, back to, to DSA, I think we really need to talk about that because these aren't just these abstract questions. They really do have some influence on the here and now. Like how you imagine socialism looking like is going to inform your strategy. Is it gonna be a very centrally planned, top-down society? Then you're probably gonna take that kind of an approach to building your organization. Is it gonna be a more, you know, decentralized worker, self-management? You're gonna maybe take a more cynicalist approach. So I li I like Gindin cuz he offers something in the middle and really pushes us to, to think about these questions which aren't fully, totally abstract. And they, they do come up like in one-on-one conversations with, with people who are new to socialism, even canvassing at the door . Sometimes people are like, well, how is this gonna work? Like, what are we all gonna be forced to work? Like I think having some of these answers in your back pocket are, are important , uh, so people think you know what you're talking about. And finally, I think thinking about what socialism will look like is important for how we want our electeds to govern. What kind of legislation we wanna push for, how do we get closer to deifying the labor market to getting more worker control. I think the vision that Gindin outlines is kind of a guiding star.
Elton LKJosé, we've heard a lot of anti-communist propaganda about the failures of Soviet central planning, specifically the long lines for basic resources, reduced choices and black markets. We at DSA in DSA reject anti-communist propaganda, but want to learn from the past. Some socialists have responded by arguing that there's still a role for the free market within socialism, while others, such as Gindin at least significantly argue, Soviet central planning is not the only approach to a planned economy. How do you think DSA should think about this debate?
José La LuzOne of the reasons why comrade , uh, Gindin , uh, who was , uh, for many years the chief economists of the , uh, Canadian auto workers and one of the pivotal figures in the transformation of the Canadian Trade Union movement, eh , when his union was led by , uh, uh, Bob White, who was perhaps one of the most progressive , uh, Canadian , uh, eh , trade unionists in in recent times. Eh , one of the very reasons why , uh, Sam , uh, wrote this piece is precisely because , uh, of the , uh, failures of the , uh, one party state , uh, centralized , uh, bureaucratic five year plan , uh, Soviet model , uh, we which , uh, you know, trigger the collapse, eh , of the Soviet , uh, economy, eh , and did not achieve , uh, the goals that , uh, the , uh, revolution has stated, eh , in terms of , uh, eh , having , uh, a higher standard of living for the , uh, Russian working class. Uh , so he , uh, eh , in a very , uh, clear , uh, and , uh, coherent , uh, way presents , uh, plausible argument, eh , about , uh, the necessity of spending time thinking seriously , uh, about this question of , uh, eh , what will be, you know, the socialist , uh, model, eh , that , uh, eh , we should , uh, eh , adopt, eh , and , uh, you know, he's quite candid about the fact that , uh, as Sofia was saying , uh, this would be messy. Uh , but perhaps more importantly, he introduces , uh, the notion which is not his own, eh , of , uh, democratic , uh, planning and worker control, eh , which , uh, suggests that , uh, eh , this will be a , a multi-layer, you know, system where different sectors, eh , will engage in the planning, eh , and , uh, he actually envisions, eh , a role for , uh, eh , multiple , uh, political parties , uh, which is quite , uh, interesting , uh, and , uh, because it suggests, you know, competing , uh, interests. And he also lives , uh, you know, the necessity of , uh, preserving , uh, fundamental , uh, eh rights, eh , under liberal democracy, eh , that , uh, workers themselves, you know, fought for , uh, historically such as , uh, you know, the right to vote , uh, which is , uh, one of the most important , uh, rights achieved precisely by the , uh, by the European working class , uh, and by the working class , uh, throughout the world, including right here , uh, in America. Uh , so this is an important conversation , uh, that , uh, comrade Gindin is inviting us to engage, and DSA should take it very seriously. But it also begs another , uh, interesting question , uh, and that is , uh, we in DSA do not have a unified , uh, position on the question of how will capitalism end in America? Eh , that is, what is the path to socialism? Eh , will it be a parliamentary , uh, a path, eh , which suggests that , uh, perhaps at some point we will elect a majority of , uh, people in the United States Congress that will take us, you know, to an next , uh, stage where in fact , uh, public ownership will become, you know, the norm , uh, uh, in terms of , uh, the way the economy is run. Uh , I myself , uh, you know, have , uh, strong doubts because this is not just any capitalist class. This is the American capitalist class. It's the most powerful capitalist class in the planet. It's not only the ruling class in America, it is arguably the ruling class in most of the world, eh ? And so, you know, the question is, will the capitalist class abolish itself? You know, as we navigate, you know, elections , uh, you know, in Congress, eh , and , uh, states and , uh, municipal legislatures, will they remain, you know , uh, a quiet, you know, observing, you know, this process of us, you know, a asserting power and achieving power. I doubt it very much. Uh , if anything, I think , uh, this will be one of the most violent , uh, upheavals , uh, you know, in the history of humankind , uh, as we approach the possibility, eh , of , uh, the multiracial, the American multiracial working class achieving power, there's questions of , um, racial oppression and white supremacy that need to be addressed in that transition. There's questions of the lack of unity of the class precisely because of the racial and national colonial operation. I mean, I come from a homeland, eh , where the question of , uh, colonialism hasn't been , uh, decided, you know, that's gonna be a fight, eh , and I there suggest it's not gonna be a fight that's gonna be fought only in my homeland. But, you know, hearing that diaspora where we happen to live , so, you know, these are all critical questions. If there is war , uh, as we , uh, witness, you know, the threat of , uh, nuclear , uh, proliferation again and war and war of aggression, eh , what would be the role that the American working class place will lead to ordinate itself historically, as had happened before, you know, to the interest of the , uh, eh imperialist , uh, you know, capitalist class, eh , and fight against , uh, other, you know, oppress and other workers , uh, across, you know, the planet . I mean, all of these are questions that are out there, and we haven't had one conversation that I'm aware of since I came back into active life, into this thing called DSA that I helped to , uh, found back in the early eighties about , uh, the path to power. So we need to engage in this , uh, discussion as much as we engage in the discussion that comrade Gindin has invited us to engage, which is , uh, what kind of , uh, socialism. The other thing is , uh, uh, when we speak about , uh, us being socialist, I am a scientific socialist. I am a Marxist , uh, but I don't know that , uh, many other socialists within DSA , uh, consider themselves , uh, scientific socialist Marxist. Uh , you know, we have different schools, eh , uh, within , uh, DSA. We have trust case , we have left communists, we have social reformers, we have liberal progressives, eh , god knows you , we have anarchists , uh, anarco-cynicalist, eh , you know, we have all of these tendencies and we're gonna have to come up with a synthesis, eh , uh, uh, uh, uh, uh, you know, that addresses the question of the path to power to having a unified position on the path to power and having a unified position on what kind of socialist society do we wanna build. I don't think a lot of our comrades would be supportive of the centralized, bureaucratic, inefficient, Soviet five-year plan model , uh, that led to the collapse of the Soviet Union. I don't, I haven't heard too many Orthodox communist , uh, uh, within DSA these days . So maybe I haven't looked around enough. You know, there might be some, who knows. Uh , so , uh, you know , these are questions that we're gonna have to grapple with very seriously .
Elton LKSo, José, I , I hear you're saying the Soviet planning, many within DSA probably have no interest in replicating that. Maybe there's some interest in, in achieving what Gindin describes, for example. But what needs to happen is that we have some kind of discussion within DSA to start to understand what, what it is that we can all be working towards.
José La LuzPrecisely, precisely. And given the fact that comrade Gindin is not very far from us , uh, it will be interesting to actually invite him to engage in some of these conversations. There are other labor economists, Marxist labor economists like comrade Gindin, who are proposing , uh, very many of the same , uh, approaches , uh, you know, in Latin America. There are several that , uh, I am familiar with. Uh, Sofia and I met a couple , uh, in some conversations we had , uh, with , uh, sister parties , uh, you know, in the, the , in the southern part of the hemisphere across Europe. Uh , and it will be very interesting, I, I hope, eh , and Justin has made , uh, a very interesting proposal. And that is that those of us who became , uh, members of the national political leadership of the organization are invited to remain active in playing some kind of a role , uh, perhaps in some of these conversations. Uh, I would love to do that, and I hope that Justin drafts that , uh, resolution and it is adopted by the convention , uh, because , uh, you know, how can we squander , you know, the accumulated knowledge and wisdom of many cameras that have preceded us, you know, in the national leadership of DSA that have , uh, you know, a variety of approaches to this very question that we are discussing here Elton, you know, I, I certainly wanna remain , uh, relevant , uh, and I hope I can be invited by Sofia and Justin , who I know intend to get reelected as member of members of the National Political Committee. I, I will , I see Justin . Uh , Justin has been two terms, I think , uh, I know I I couldn't do it. I am barely, you know, able to , uh, do these things , uh, what we're doing here, this , uh, tonight. So, yes , um, I, I, I I absolutely think that's the case , uh, Elton , yes.
Elton LKUh, well, thank you. So Justin , uh, Gindin identifies a number of real problems socialists will have to solve as the working class takes power. They're not small problems, and there are many, many more that we could discuss. How can the socialist movement begin tackling these problems today?
Justin CharlesSo, you know, some of what I, I , I thought was really interesting in , in the piece was when Gindin was talking about how do you, if you have any kind of a market, if you have workplaces, we know that capitalism necessitates competition. If we have a variety of workplaces, firms that are making the things that we need to, to, to , to , to , to live in this society, how do we, how do we make it so that we're not, you know, kind of recreating the same kind of dynamic that we have within capitalism that necessitates competition, that necessitates, that somebody loses? And I think that also gets that kind of like, what is it like to, to , to , to exist in a workplace as a worker? Um, what hierarchies exist in workplaces? What kinds of kind stratification exist in workplaces and divisions of labor? I think often when, when I've heard socialists talk about what it's gonna look like to have a socialist society, a socialist economy, it can feel like science fiction. And I think there are very real social problems that will, you know, that, that we'll have to deal with. For me , the, those , those , those problems though, as we can kind , I mean, the , the best thing we can do in the here and now to, to set us up ourselves up to be able to deal with those problems , um, is, is, is one, you know, to, to organize our workplaces and not just organize our workplaces in the sense that like, okay, we wanna elect a slate to union leadership, or we want to get a really good contract and we want to negotiate a really good contract. Those are important things, parts of being in a union. But I think really what this piece talks about is like, what, what it looked like to democratize workplaces such that, you know, a worker is just not, is not just a , a figurative cog in a machine, but a worker is, you know, a thinking, fighting subject. You know, that the , the working class, I mean, you know, we say we say this all the time, but like, we make it all happen. So like, if we make it all happen, like if we had the power to decide how everything ran, what would that look like for us? It's interesting because, you know, it talks about if you take away all of that kind of, the , the fear of, you know, the loss of a job, all of the, the , the threats that come with competition, that opens up, I think, space for, you know , uh, the kind of the kind of workplace and , and , and therefore the kind of society in which people can learn things and people can teach other other people things. Well , what's been interesting to me in, in , in my experience in , in the labor movement is, is like I, I mean, you know, I've , I've , I've organized the union in my workplace. I , I was on the organizing committee. I was, you know, talked to a lot of my coworkers. I'm on the bargaining committee now. The , the capacity is one's has to develop. And doing that kind of organizing, like you develop a lot of different kinds of skills. And I think giving more people that opportunity, you know, so , so that , that , that kind of experience doesn't necessarily like waltz off itself off in the , in , in a , in an organizing committee or a bargaining committee, but like every worker , um, playing a role in deciding how that workplace operates. Um, and then if you move up a level, because we're talking about, you know, sectors and how the economy is planned through these sector , uh, these sectoral, you know, unions I suppose, or councils as a replacement for the kinds of, like, ministries that you would see in a , in a , in a , in a parliamentary government , um, allows people to like really get their, get their hands around the whole of society in a way that like, we just don't, we know our little bitty slice of the world and the management of the rest of it is just stuff that like happens over there somewhere. Um, but what we're talking about is people having a stake in , uh, and I think being able to control their lives in , in a way that we never , we never have before, which is exciting, I think. Uh, so the , the , the thing that we can do now, and not just in the labor movement , but I think like even in our community organizations, but like the practice of democracy that I , that I talked about before, that we just don't know anything about. Really, really digging into what it means to practice, you know, self-rule in all areas of our life, I think is the best practice we can get, you know, before we ultimately get to winning socialism.
Elton LKThis is Class, an official podcast of the Democratic Socialists of America National Political Education Committee. My name is Elton LK. Thank you to Casey Stikker for sound engineering theme, music and editing. And thank you to Palmer Conrad for administrative help. If you're inspired by anything we've been talking about, if you think the system is rigged and democracy is the solution, join DSA, become a member. I put a link in the show notes to DSA's website. If you're already a member of DSA, please share this podcast with your local chapter. Class is intended to be a resource for chapters and members to articulate, apply and share socialist theory with DSA and the wider working class. Also, remember to rate and review us on iTunes or your favorite podcatcher. As you know from listening to other podcasts, this is an important way to get out the word about Class.
This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and...
We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election,...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...
In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...