We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election, their chapter’s races, and what our movement’s obligations are in this moment, when more people than ever before are looking to the left as a real political alternative. Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hi comrades, welcome to CLASS, the podcast of Democratic Socialists of America's National Political Education Commission, or NPEC. My name's Michaela, and I'm a co-chair of NPEC and a member of North New Jersey DSA. Before we dive in, a reminder that CLASS is available on all major podcast platforms. Please consider becoming a DSA member by following the link in the podcast description. You can also send us a message about the episode and sign up for Red Letter, NPEC's monthly newsletter using the provided links. They're calling it a blue NAMI, but what's moving those big waves?
SPEAKER_02A socialist surge. DSA has had a great election season. More than 150 Democratic Socialists and ballot initiatives endorsed by local and national DSA won by election day last Tuesday. Over 75% of nationally endorsed candidates won, which is an outstanding result. Some races are still being counted right now. Chapters across the country are sending six new and eight total Congress people to Washington in January, as well as dozens into state houses, city governments, and county administrations.
SPEAKER_02We will have well over half our races won when all is said and done. Millions of Americans are choosing to write DSA's ticket over mainstream Democrats, and millions more are decisively rejecting the MAGA right and Republicans and demanding more from the political system. We can also see in these results that many of the non-DSA progressive Democrats and even moderate Democrats have unified around basic affordability and often explicitly class forward language, talking about reigning in billionaires and waging class warfare on the side of working people.
SPEAKER_02This would have been laughed at. Oh, wait, it was laughed at during the Obama era. All over the country, ordinary people are realizing that yes, workers deserve more. Anti-war, anti-genocide, anti-ICE, anti-tech broligarchy messaging is winning too, even in GOP strongholds like Texas, South Carolina, and Georgia, despite the literal billions that the ruling class has poured into these elections and the toxic media, both mainstream and online. We're seeing the tide turn unmistakably against the fascistic tendencies that have caused so much economic and social pain.
SPEAKER_02Even though the Blue Wave carries big contradictions and establishment Democrats like Hakeem Jeffries are already signaling moderation, we have an opening. DSA's shown that we have the juice to fight for our demands and can build our power up and overcome the limitations set by liberal democracy. We live out, then we critique, then we synthesize and figure out what we do next together. That's the DSA way. Here to help us with that work are three dear comrades and cadres socialists in office from the fabulous electoral powerhouse of Louisville DSA.
SPEAKER_02JP Lenninger is Louisville's District 6 Metro Councilman, elected in 2024. Liz Everhart is a member of the Jefferson County Soil and Water Conservation District Board of Supervisors, also elected in 2024. And public school teacher and union member Robert Lavertis Bell is the representative elect for District 43 of the Kentucky State House, smashing his primary in May to confirm his win officially last week.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to class, Robert, Liz, and JP.
SPEAKER_00Hey Michaela. How's it going, Michaela?
SPEAKER_02And congratulations, Robert, on winning your race to State House.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so we always ask the same question to newcomers. We can start wherever, but how did you become a socialist and why and how did you join DSA?
SPEAKER_00Okay, yeah, I come from an activist family. So I was an activist growing up. My grandmother is a locally known civil rights activist here. So it sort of grew up around people who were engaged in movement work, some of whom were socialists. And then I sort of uh found socialism on my own as a teenager through I think picking up a copy of the Covingist Manifesto at the bookstore, and then did a lot of work as the organizer through the anti-globalization movement, anti-fascist stuff, went to grad school, joined a grad school union, went on strike, became a Marxist, many years later joined DSA.
SPEAKER_02Wow, that was really hitting all the uh the highlights. I love that it was like I've found a copy of the Communist Manifesto by working at a bookstore, and that's what was the downhill role for me. Liz, why don't you go next?
SPEAKER_03You're you're next in my view. I think I have a pretty similar story. I'm from um not an activist family, but a very working class family. My mother's a nurse or was a nurse. My father worked at a factory, and particularly for my dad, you know, like working conditions just deteriorated through sort of all of his life. Uh he did not work in a union uh autoplant, he worked for Honda. And I don't know, we were kind of broke. And I was a really studious child, like I read a lot, it was really bookish.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, I read a lot of I I read Le Miz when I was in fourth grade. Uh, I read the Communist Manifesto around the same time. And then by the time I got to college, was sort of a college anarchist all the way through my 20s, and then sort of it kind of hit me, and and joining DSA is a is a much more um like I had this sort of semi-piphany of like, well, the things that would be necessary for like anarchist utopia to succeed are just don't seem to be coming together.
SPEAKER_03I think we need a different, more organized plan. So I joined DSA.
SPEAKER_02You've been organizing it ever since, right? Turns out it's not as organized as we need it to be, but at least we're together, right?
SPEAKER_03Significantly more organized than anarchy life. Yeah, right, JP.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so uh I've been on the left my entire life. Uh my mom uh was arrested at the uh DNC convention in Chicago in the 60s, uh, and you know, huge influence in my life, obviously. I was like a little rapple rouser student, like talking about like student rights and complaining when there was like a nativity scene set up at the school. And then, you know, I also came out of anarchy land uh like Liz, which is why we know each other. Uh I was organized, I became an organized socialist because of Robert Labertis Bell, who was recruiting me to DSA for a very long time.
SPEAKER_01And then uh when he was a delegate at the 2019 National Convention and telling me about all of the what was happening in that convention, the decisions that were made, I said, you know what, this is this is real, this is a real organized movement of people that want to change the world. And DSA has been my political home ever since I joined then.
SPEAKER_02Well, I've met you guys um, you know, also through DSA. I'm not a Louisville person, but I'm a huge fan of your chapter, especially because of how amazingly you've done um getting people elected, like you guys. I mean, this is a really crazy moment right now. We're, you know, looking at increasing our DSA footprint in national and local politics all over the country. But we're also in this moment of what people are calling a blue NAMI or this huge backlash against the Trump administration, which in our country manifests itself as a whole bunch of people voting for the only other party.
SPEAKER_02Um, so that is the Democrats. Um, so let's hear it. What are your initial takeaways? It's only been a couple of days. Obviously, Robert won. Um, and so did a whole bunch of other socialists in office. You guys aren't ready up for re-election yet, but obviously close observers and political sicklos on your own. So um how about it? What's what are your kind of uh big takeaways or what are you processing right now about what just happened?
SPEAKER_01Well, I I think just as a the top-line view, and you kind of alluded to it, it wasn't so much a vote for as a vote against. You know, the exit polls across the nation all agree that there's a negative view of both parties, but the uh Republican MAGA, you know, constitutional crisis overreach, uh uh combined with, you know, an absolutely, you know, cratered economy for working people, uh, and you know, the looming threat of forever war with Iran since he kept losing and then restarting a war with Iran every few weeks, uh, you know, that was a complete rejection by the entire country.
SPEAKER_01You know, this uh cratering of the Republican Party, like you said, the only place that voters know where to go is the Democrats. And so uh there's these you know huge wave of Democrats that are coming into Congress and in state legislatures across the country, but there's no there's no unified platform among them. You've got Abdul al-Sayed uh winning a very competitive uh Senate race in Michigan. Uh, you know, he's a capitalist, but he's clearly you know on the left end of things. Uh, and then you've got a bunch of blue dogs now elected throughout the South.
SPEAKER_02In Midwest, too, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think there's there's sort of two competing ideas, right, happening when I think about the national scene and what what's happened this week. One is, well, I I do have to be a little grateful, right, that you know Donald Trump cannot now proceed. Presumably, possibly, maybe he can be stopped, maybe things can be slowed down, maybe, maybe there are positive outcomes here. But then you just you're left with this, again, grab bag of people, and you just have to hope that all of these newly elected senators and this you know pretty significant turnover of the house, new, you know, a lot of new house reps, do they have a coherent through line?
SPEAKER_03Is there party leadership that can enforce any discipline? Probably not. Like, we're all excited right now, but by February, the rubber's gonna hit the road. Like, are we collaborating with ICE? Are we giving money to Israel? Like it will happen. It's binary, one thing will happen or it won't. And I'm not super optimistic that it's all gonna go our way just because one election.
SPEAKER_02Right. And you already have the presumptive speaker of the house saying that um he's not interested in retribution, that now's the time to come together. It's a lot of uh sort of milked toast, Obama-esque kind of we're gonna reach across the aisle stuff, which makes no sense because right now the count is that they have a hundred more people than than the Republicans. And what people want to see is accountability for what just transpired, what you just alluded to, JP, regarding the economy, but also all of these broken promises, right?
SPEAKER_02Trump said no more wars, no new wars, and cheaper stuff, right? Cheaper food, cheaper gas, all of this. Robert, any any big takeaways or thoughts? Um, maybe you could also speak a little bit about the DSA wins, too.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I think you guys really um covered anything that would say. Just I would like to hope that there's this indicates some sort of shift in the electorate as far as uh things that we can hold on to that might last more than a few months. Uh, but I don't I don't think that there's any indication that that's the case just yet. Um, these are still the people who voted two years ago in the way that they did. And um as JP said, if we don't present something that that is a positive affirmative vision uh for the world and actually have people gravitate towards that, then it's just gonna be this ping-pong of of voting against uh whatever the bad thing, uh whoever's in charge while the bad thing is happening.
SPEAKER_00And more bad things are gonna continue to happen regardless of who's in power. Uh so uh to speak to your question, uh yeah, the DSA had an excellent night the other night. We should be very proud of uh what we're doing. And I think a lot of our candidates, I mean, obviously, you know, every DSA member is is is perfect and we're all wonderful. Uh but in in general, um, you know, uh there's uh a a sort of uh a phylum, let's say, of of DSA candidates who are doing exactly what we're talking about, who are presenting democratic socialism as an affirmative vision for the world, um, who are rallying around uh the workers deserve more program, and uh are really sort of trying to set the ground for us to have these sort of stable coalitions that that can actually continue to fight uh regardless of who is actually in power for the capitalist parties.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, I agree. I think um the fact that we had such a good night, there's a couple of indications there. One is right before voting started, a poll came out from the economist in UGOV that said that 50% of Americans would be willing to pull the lever for our democratic socialist. And then before that, there was like this sort of yearly Gallup poll that's put out that has different comparisons of different statements about the economy. And 43% of people said they supported socialism, which undefined, of course, but nonetheless, um, it shows that this is really getting into people's thinking.
SPEAKER_02It's also getting into how they're voting, and it kind of implies that if people had had a DSA candidate to vote for, they might have voted for them, you know, and we're very careful about our electoral work in part because we have limited capacity, because we actually are a party or a proto-party that does a lot more than just elections. We do labor work, we do tennis rights, we do political education, we do all of these different things. And electoral work is just one slice of that, right? It's a big slice, but it's a tactic, right?
SPEAKER_02It's not the entire strategy of organizing for change. But it really, I think, does lift up and like kind of like raises the contradictions, but it also kind of resolves some stuff. At least now we know that people are not completely brainwashed by Trumpism. And I think for me that was a huge relief because I know a lot of people, all right, you know, in my family or, you know, just kind of like in my life who are either apolitical or they're just like very uh cynical, right?
SPEAKER_02About change, or they're conservatives, you know. Um, obviously this doesn't apply to DSA, but like I know a lot more people outside of DSA. So I don't know. I mean, to the extent that we can be optimistic, even though now we have to deal with a whole lot of Democrats who we know aren't gonna do what we need them to do, it's still, you know, buoyant. I mean, I feel great about Robert winning, obviously, and then all of these other people. I mean, how do you feel about our prospects in Congress?
SPEAKER_02Um, we have now a block of what, eight?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, better than zero, which is what we used to do.
SPEAKER_02Definitely better than zero. It's like zero with a little belt on or something. I don't know actually if eight's the correct number.
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, regardless of you know what the exact count ends up being, uh, I think it's very clear, you know, at this point, you know, the I haven't there's not a projection that's under 250 for the Democrats. Uh, you know, there's clearly not an issue with the socialist bloc deciding to, you know, form a caucus together and say these are going to be some things that we want, we want to move together.
SPEAKER_01That's that's entirely possible right now. And it wouldn't upset the Apple cart. You know, there's there's not a lot of big negatives to that, to them saying we're gonna move together and we're gonna have some expectations and some things we want to, you know, fight for. Uh, that's something that I personally would love to see from that group. You know, as a socialist elected, I want to see more coordination in any body that we're in. And in this case, it's one where we're kind of playing with house money. No one's gonna scream that, you know, all of this work and you're gonna cause, you know, the Republicans to be able to elect a speaker if you say we've got expectations for who the speaker is gonna be.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03Well, and and I would add, so I don't think it's coincidental that the number of people who say they would vote for democratic socialists has has gone up so significantly as we've had more wins, you know, more runs equal more people hearing from a socialist, right? More more doors knocked, more high profile races we've won. The the next thing we get to do with that, right? Because a lot of our messaging comes through campaigns. And for a lot of time, you know, a lot of times it through campaigns that lost, right, in the last 10 years.
SPEAKER_03And now we've started to win. We can continue messaging what socialism is, what democratic socialism is, what we want, what we think is right and wrong and unfair. Uh, but yeah, now that we kind of we have a pulpit, right? There are people in Congress who can stand up and like they're not, you can't tag them as a spoiler if the Democrats have such a majority. And you get to not only talk about socialism in a campaign, but you get to talk about it as an elected. Um, and you get to, I mean, I think some of some of what we saw this week with elections is just people are angry.
SPEAKER_03I think Americans feel uncomfortable with political anger, but I think we should become more comfortable with it. And and like expect those DSA representatives in Congress to really, you know, they can stand up there and have their time in the, you know, the Senate floor, the the House floor, and and speak those words. Because people are right to be mad about how the world is right now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think one thing I would add is that you know, we talk a lot in DSA about, you know, the contradictions uh for the Democratic Party, uh, for you know, a party that purports to uh serve the working class but actually is serving a donor class, uh, the people writing those checks now to entities that we can't see, even the absolute wave of dark money in all of these elections, which you know gratefully didn't work, didn't sway it to the Republicans, but you know, hundreds of millions of dollars spent by these tech moguls.
SPEAKER_01Uh, but some of that money does go to Democrats, uh, and you we can see it in policy votes and see how they're affected. Uh, but now we've we've seen some of the contradictions of the Republican Party, where they, you know, dabbled in populism uh through the Trump administrations, and we saw what happens when they failed to deliver to the working class for their populism. Those conditions are what created Trump.
SPEAKER_01Uh, you know, he's a symptom. Uh, and now they're reaping a little bit of what they sowed in terms of failing to deliver, despite you know, mouthing to the working class that they mattered and we care, we hear you, and we see your pain. The Democrats in Congress also serve those same masters in terms of you know, uh, the tech moguls and the ruling class and the people who write those giant checks. Our people in Congress, those democratic socialists need to keep the focus on the needs of the working class and saying if we don't deliver for the working class, then the fascists are right back in office in two years or four years.
SPEAKER_02Right. This gets to the question of like, why would socialists run anyway, especially when they're in the minority? Like you brought up the fact that because of the scale of the win, which is also in a way good because that does mean that more potential slowing can happen. But there's also this sense of, okay, but then there's less of an effect, um, potentially, which can also potentially cause people to, if they're not inclined to be in the minority, the strict minority, then they might start making deals we don't like.
SPEAKER_02And DSA currently is, you know, maybe in more news than we need to be, but nonetheless news, partly because we are making demands. For example, New York City DSA making demands on Ziran to uh curb uh the spread of near the NYPD's power. Um, you have the uh Nitya Rahman, now the mayor-elect of Los Angeles, um, also uh being, you know, demands to hold her accountable for her uh waffling on uh support for Palestine.
SPEAKER_02So, you know, this is the kind of thing that comes with power and being disempowered is that like there's this these demands to do compromise or to like in order to get things done, you have to start kind of bending. And I want to talk to you guys about that, especially you, JP, because we've talked about it before about like what you do when you're the only socialist. But Robert, you're about to become the only socialist in the state house, the first socialist elected to state government in Kentucky in a hundred over 160 years, right?
SPEAKER_00Um, just under.
SPEAKER_02Sorry, 156 years. Sorry, I was four years off. I did not win the prizes right. Um, so maybe you could talk a little bit about what your race was like. I got to knock doors for you for a couple of days uh back in May. Um, but the whole race entirely, like, you know, we knew you were gonna end up winning because you had no uh real opponents. So maybe speak a little bit about your race, who endorsed you, what kind of campaigning did you do, all of that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we won our race in May in the primary. The primary was a very competitive primary. It was a sort of interesting race that we're going to be running a lot more of as DSA nationwide, which was a DSA candidate like myself being pitted against someone who was a decent progressive. And having to differentiate myself from her ondoors to the electorate required some actual political education and required an elevated sort of discourse, honestly, in our in our campaign that it was the likes of which we haven't really seen much in political races here in Kentucky.
SPEAKER_00I mean, usually everything is, you know, your face, your name, your kids, your dog, whatever, and the team you play for. And then, you know, you're the red team or the blue team, and that's pretty much it. In my race, uh, it was a a real um, I think in some ways a sort of referendum on uh speaking on uh class issues. Um, my race, so uh to describe the the lecture a little bit, uh it included uh a good portion of JP's district, which is where I live, which is uh probably the most progressive areas in the city of Louisville, um, but also includes um very wealthy areas, also very, very poor areas, and um everybody in between.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, my district includes the majority black neighborhood that I grew up in, but but I don't live in. And uh in that district, it was uh just a matter of talking to working class black voters and saying, look, you know, actually sometimes your interests are not the same interests as even the the wealthy, the wealthier black voters who are in the same district. Um and and you know, that's those are political issues that have actually sort of been been on the back burner uh politically in this country, uh much less in this city for a very long time.
SPEAKER_00By intention, I would say. Um and so, you know, I think part of what we have to do as DSA and the electoral races that we're running is you know put class politics back on the menu, um, regardless of who the electorate is and and and you know what it looks like, and and not be afraid to um confront people with um you know difficult questions about um you know where they stand and uh who they align with and who they actually have have a commonality with. And I think that was what my race was about.
SPEAKER_00I had some really great endorsements from labor. Um, you know, I'm a I'm a public school teacher, uh Teachers Union supported me, um Team Series Local89 supported me, SEIU, the whole AFL CIO, the Kentucky AFL CIO uh endorsed in my campaign, and that was huge. Uh but yeah, um but it was a DSA campaign through and through and um class struggle through and through. And I think that was um one of the things that really carried the day, honestly.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think um this intent, I mean, behind suppressing class issues in order to elevate certain other important historical, but still um honestly, like when you're coming down to what people's material interests are. And it's interesting that you note that the poor and the rich districts are kind of like maybe bumping up against each other and and maybe there's some managed tension, you know, whenever that happens, you know, as far as like who you're gonna vote for. Maybe you can talk a little bit about your candidate.
SPEAKER_02I remember when I was there, you talked about how she like she's a progressive, so like some of the things on paper were probably pretty similar. Improved public schools, that kind of stuff. But how did that differentiation kind of take place? And were there any conflicts? Was it a pretty amicable competition, or were there times when it was like, you know, frustrating or difficult?
SPEAKER_00I mean, every campaign's gonna be frustrating at times, but I I think with this race, it was, I would say it's very amicable. I I I I say over and over again, and and I actually my team told me to stop saying it, but in in 90 out of 100 of the districts in the state of Kentucky, I would have actually supported the candidate I was running against. Um, you know, she's not one of us, but but she is actually a progressive. And uh, and that's when I draw the distinction between what one's policies are and what one's politics are. Um, because you know, on paper, you know, a lot of the times you know, we were saying some of the same things, or you know, I might have said a more um you know leftier, you know, rhetorically uh version of the same uh political policy stance.
SPEAKER_00Um you know, I there were some policy differences, of course. I don't want to um paper over that, but really the the distinction between us, and I think the electorate understood that was a politics um more broadly, like you know, what your theory of change is, who do you align with? Um, you know, I was aligned with labor, I was aligned with the DSA, and people know what DSA is now. And um, and I and I talked, you know, the the working class politics that um you know propel me.
SPEAKER_00And you know, my opponent was more aligned with the political establishment, um, took you know donations from the single billionaire in town who's involved in in local politics. Um, and I think people, if they were astute enough, were you know, in broad outline, saw that the political differences between me and her uh go beyond uh you know questions of of policy and and you know how much do you want to raise the taxes and so forth.
SPEAKER_01I I would say I I was Robert's campaign manager and pretty deep into that race with him. And you know, we frequently saw that the what was never contested or very rarely contested, the how and the why were always contested. And you know, that was that was great to be able to tell people about well, this is this is why we do things this way, and this is how we think real change can happen. Uh and it and it was amicable for the most part between uh Robert and his opponent.
SPEAKER_01Really, uh she and her team were only upset, not with us, but with a lot of media coverage, you know, that that said, you know, DSA versus a traditional Democrat. And they didn't like being painted with that brush, uh, and and were pretty vocal about you know objecting. There was nothing traditional about their candidate or their campaign, but that was the lens that a lot of people saw it through. And which, you know, we were happy to say, yes, this is a campaign where we were you are choosing between DSA and what has come before.
SPEAKER_02Um, that's a good place to actually ask about how this fits into the broader picture because it sounds like maybe the Democratic Party, while still likely to win or going to win in your district, Robert, it sounds like it was, I mean, you didn't have an opponent running against you on the Republican side during the general.
SPEAKER_00So we had a weirdo writing uh doing a writing campaign, uh the the Okay.
SPEAKER_02I mean, you didn't have a substantial challenge from the writing. But to the extent that we're talking about kind of like this mood, and your your opponent sound like she was running away from the label Democrat. Um, how does this successful election fit into the broader mood in Kentucky, Louisville, but Kentucky during this blue wave that we're seeing? I mean, you corrected me earlier, Robert, on there not, you know, I said there maybe was a failure or like not as big of one.
SPEAKER_02Um, don't want to, you know, step where I'm not an expert or anything like that. But to the extent that this fits in with broader discontent with how things are, broader discontent with Trump, broader discontent, maybe even with the Democratic Party, would you say um there was any of that that you've seen? I can say that when I was knocking doors for you, just the few that I was able to do over that weekend, um, people were extremely excited to vote for a socialist. It was almost like they were um excited for the first time to ever vote, you know, even though these were often like middle-aged people who always vote, right?
SPEAKER_02But it's just like change, like this idea of change was really like potent. Um, in the same way I'd say that probably, you know, was when Obama was elected or even when Trump was elected, right? So, this idea about what socialists can do in the arena of asking for change, this is actually a really important question for us. So maybe you can talk a little bit about what you think it indicates about your state's politics or local politics. Um, sorry if that's a little complicated question, but I feel it kind of brings some stuff together.
SPEAKER_03Well, I would I would lead off by saying that Kentucky DSA races um all four of them, because there are four in Kentucky that I'm aware of. Um, someone ran out in Owensboro and no one told me. Um Roberts is the only one that's sort of simple, right? He ran in a partisan primary, he had no opponent in the general, and he won. The other three are really complicated by the fact that the two big cities now in Kentucky have nonpartisan races.
SPEAKER_03And at least the two in Louisville, I actually don't know all of Herbert's opponents in Lexington, but the two in Louisville, it's it's a it's a Democrat versus us, right? In a Democrat majority district and in a Democrat majority city. So I, while neither Shamika Parish Wright nor Andrea Parr got elected this week, you know, 100,000 votes were cast for a socialist in the city, excluding Robert's votes. I have, you know, those also count. Um they're real, but like in a contested race.
SPEAKER_03And that is those are races where there's a real money disparity. Um, and we were still able to, you know, get you know, people to vote for really explicitly socialist messaging with very little money, and in a race where the Democrat, the establishment democrat is right there and you can vote for them and you can feel un unafraid, right? The maybe they don't like the establishment democrat. Plenty of people don't like our current mayor, but he's not you know Mitch McConnell reincarnated, he's not a Donald Trump acolyte, he's he's a democrat.
SPEAKER_03And still, yeah, like I said, 100,000 people voted for the socialist in their city. So I feel good about that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, was that Shemika's race?
SPEAKER_03So Shemika's Shemika's vote total was, I want to say they're not 100% done counting, but I think it's 96,000. And then Andrea Parr got 4,400 votes in her race. Um, I'm sure some of them overlap. It's not that 100,000 people, you know, individually voted, but you know, it's a nice round number that I'm keeping in my head.
SPEAKER_00Now let's see what voted for Herbert License is. So we definitely crossed the 100,000 uh threshold.
SPEAKER_03That's true. Yeah, 20,000 people, I think, voted for that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and he and that's a very new uh DSA chapter out there, Bluegrass DSA, um running running a race. That's I mean, that's one way to start off being a chapter is like actually run someone for office. It's pretty bold. And I I remember um hearing that it was because Louisville was running such a great operation that Lexington folks decided, hey, we should try to. But, you know, it sucks to lose, but we also know. I think this is your point, Liz. We know that there are lots of people who are willing to pull the lever, even when there's a Democrat who, you know, seems like the safe option or seems like somebody who is like, okay, so there's like a party here.
SPEAKER_02And the nonpartisan question is interesting because of course there's always people, oh ongoing question of whether or not we should break, right? Like whether or not we should run, you know, on the line our own ballot line as independents, whatever. Um, and I do think that these are going to be questions leading up, of course, to 2028 and beyond. To me, there's there's also this kind of broader scope of like, as we're in the minority, which we will be for the foreseeable future, nonetheless, you know, if even though 50% of people say they'll pull the lever for the democratic socialist, will they pull a lever for somebody who is a DSA patriot, right?
SPEAKER_02Like that's I think part of this. You guys run such explicitly DSA races, your DSA through and through. But there might be other places where there just isn't a powerful chapter, one that has less experience. People are always trying to tail the democratic socialist label because now it's kind of popular, but are they really? So these are all questions that are kind of floating around. But maybe we could um talk a little bit about how you how you cope with being in the minority or how you celebrate the fact that you're in the minority. JP, I know that you have something to say about this, about what your day-to-day as a city counselor looks like as a the only socialist.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, you know, in a lot of ways it's freeing uh that I am, you know, 100% comfortable, you know, knocking over the Apple cart when it's time to, you know, be honest about what the world looks like. We don't hide anything about being democratic socialists in our runs. And that was certainly true in my race. And so I came in with the attitude that, you know, people knew what they were voting for, and they knew that I was going to come in and I was gonna be oppositional.
SPEAKER_01I talked about that on the doors, that I was gonna come in and I was going to say what I thought and I wasn't gonna hold back. I was going to introduce things that were probably going to fail and that we were going to, you know, not gonna get everything all at once, that this was not, you know, some silver bullet that just because you voted for a socialist and a socialist was elected, that the world was gonna change. And this was going to be part of a process where we're going to be seeing, okay, who on city council is gonna vote for this? How are we gonna then talk to their constituents about whether or not they're voting for the things that they know that they need, you know, in their districts?
SPEAKER_01You know, how are we going to interact with that? Uh, and so that's been something that I was very comfortable with, and my colleagues have had to get comfortable with. I certainly don't have any regrets about how we've done this first couple of years in office in that way. You know, we had amendments to the city budget, uh, you know, on the floor uh on the night that the council is going to be passing the city budget,$1.2 billion budget. And that's just not something that's ever done in Louisville. People on both sides of the aisle were just screaming mad at me that I was introducing, you know, amendments to this very delicate House of Cards, in their opinion, of what was built in the budget.
SPEAKER_01But our, you know, our budget amendment was balanced and we said this is what we want to add, this is what we would cut. Uh and I think it was really important because people in the city finally got to see, okay, up or down, would these people vote for more money for transportation, more money for social services, more money for housing, and less money spent on, you know, what is 50% of Louisville's budget, which is policing and incarceration, excuse me. I think that that's the most important fight to pick is to get people on the record.
SPEAKER_01This is what I will actually vote for. Not what I'll pay lip service to, not what I'll say in my heart is super important. Ones and zeros, did you vote for this or didn't you? You know, did the same thing with uh an amendment to our mask ordinance here in Louisville about that there was not going to be an exception for law enforcement at any level. You know, we wanted to unmask ice. And there is a Democratic majority in the Louisville City Council, but that didn't pass. And people were really upset about that, and we're upset about that for months and months.
SPEAKER_01Uh, that not every Democratic representative voted to unmask ice in Louisville. You know, we had our trans safe haven uh resolution. And again, that was a that was a minority, a small minority of that Democratic Council that would vote for pretty basic civil rights legislation uh for city protections for trans people in Louisville. Uh, and you know, there are a lot of people throughout the city that were shocked that their representative didn't vote for it and that not every queer uh NGO came out swinging for it.
SPEAKER_01Uh, and so that's been a huge piece of political education where we're talking about why did that happen? And just like with everything we're doing, we're making more socialism, we're building working class power with what we're doing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, uh one thing that JP does really well, and and you know, we always talk about NDSA, it's just a point of cliche that we say, oh, we're heightening the contradictions or or whatever. But you know, often, you know, the we have to heighten the contradictions because uh that's not what other people do. They obscure the contradictions, uh, they they obscure their politics. Uh there's not an expectation that people are going to be forthright about what they believe and to try to fight for it uh in the face of institutional pressure.
SPEAKER_00And something that JP has done, and I think that all DSA elected should be doing is doing exactly that, setting an expectation that not just us, but our opposition are going to have to justify their actions. They have to tell their constituents why they think that ISIS agents should be able to wear masks or whatever. If JP weren't there, these these conversations would not be happening in the city of Louisville in the political in the political uh arena at the scale that they're happening.
SPEAKER_00And that's what we need to be focusing on is again when we talk about heightened the contradictions, that includes um, like I said, setting a standard for forthright, honest political discourse, an elevated political discourse, expecting that the electorate uh is intelligent enough to uh weigh in and understand what's going on. Just really, he's done a really amazing job.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and you know, and that and that's like the the exciting uh part of what I do. Uh and then the day-to-day, you know, is more make sure that people's trash gets picked up and uh talk to public works about potholes in the district, you know, regular politician stuff. Uh, but also the fact that we get to bring direct democracy to people in my district with our advisory council, all of the discretionary spending uh that we get for our budget, our district budget, you know, is voted on by people who live in the district.
SPEAKER_01And it's, you know, neighborhood by neighborhood. If your neighborhood is 30% of the district, 30% of that money is yours to decide what we're going to do. And we have meetings and people vote. Uh, people debate whether they think that's a good place to spend money. And we talk all the time about isn't this democracy great? Don't you wish we had more of it? Uh, and and people, people in my district and outside of my district view our project as one that's looking to expand democracy in their lives.
SPEAKER_01And that's, you know, I I think also pretty important to our project.
SPEAKER_02That's the aim, right? And Liz, um, as soil and water commissioner, is that your title? Close enough.
SPEAKER_03Soil and we're uh Soil and Water Conservation District Supervisor. So Commissioner. We'll call it the commissioner. It's more powerful. Which is a it's a silly, it's not silly. It's uh every county in Kentucky has a soil and water conservation uh district. We're sort of this odd county entity, we're only the only county entity really that exists in Louisville anymore. Our my function and DSA's function on the soil and water board, other than getting to be total nerds about soil and water stuff, like I'm a beekeeper, I get to like talk to people about how they can plant native plants and you know have rain barrels, and that's just you know, good and very positive work for the county.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's frankly nice. I do it even if I wasn't in DSA. I really like talking about button bushes. Um but his main function for DSA is the mayor tries to cut our budget literally every year, and we get to stand up as elected officials and be like, your mayor doesn't care if you know the soil erodes and your soil is full of lead and the streets flood, and you know, he doesn't seem to care that uh your backyard garden, you know, works or doesn't work, or you're you know, there's plenty of actually, honest to god, ag producers in Louisville because of a sort of I don't want to say quirk, a historical fact is that uh the county and the city merged, so plenty of things are Louisville, but are absolutely rural.
SPEAKER_03Um there are a lot of people covered by the conservation district that are ranching, that are growing corn or soy. Um, and the mayor doesn't care if your you know farmland is subsumed into a creek because we've built a development and eroded, you know, built housing develops on floodplains. We get to stand up every year and be like, the mayor doesn't care about any of these issues. He would rather spend money on cops.
SPEAKER_02Um it actually sounds like a great way to kind of start doing sort of a revival of Green New Deal stuff is like through some of these offices that seem they're gettable, right? Like the like these are the kinds of things that are gettable. And it actually, like you said, Liz, it gives you the opportunity to go out and talk to people. I think a lot of times people think these big sweeping, which are there are big, I mean, to to fix. Climate change, we're gonna need a lot more than soil and water conservation commissioners. Sorry, I'm really not trying to act like a like a ditz.
SPEAKER_02I just like can't remember the entire name. I will get it right when I have to say it again. Um, but I think that that is a really important thing. Like as socialists, we actually believe in universal good. We actually believe in like a big a big project to transform all of society. So we're not localists, right? We're not like, you know, kind of these parochial, like these these are the only things that matter. But the thing is, is that people matter, right? People matter and the way that we live matters.
SPEAKER_02The way that we want to live matters. And people deserve to live a lot better than they do. And having somebody who's going out fighting for the fact that we don't want to live in flooded streets. We don't want to live in barren, you know, ugly, you know, desolate places. We want to live with dignity and we want to live with pleasure and we want to live happily. So these are the kinds of things that we can actually bring to people and be like, this is what more democracy in our lives could bring us if we have the political will to do it.
SPEAKER_02And yeah, I I would actually love to have you on sometime, Liz, just to talk about this stuff because I think that a lot of our listeners would really like to hear more about kind of what it means to have like a Marxist eco-socialism or like a way to kind of like work towards these bigger picture things from the local basis. But we have to, we have to wrap up because you guys have to go off to a uh a speech or speaking engagement uh with Louisville, uh University of Louisville DSA. So I don't want to keep you too much longer, but I do want to leave you all with the question, and we'll start with Robert this time, especially because you're about to go into this brave new world of Frankfurt politics.
SPEAKER_02Um what do you think ought to be the task of DSA to support our SIOs going forward in these future battles? Because we just had this blue wave, but now we have all these establishment democrats, and we also have a rump right, right? So, what do you think we could do to support you? And also, what do you think the responsibility of socialists and office ought to be to further our movement and keep it from being kind of subsumed by Democrats or like kind of these like more um compromising progressives?
SPEAKER_00So, my answer to actually both of those questions, if I can do that, of course. It's it's infrastructure. Um, we we uh have done a good job of getting more socialists elected. Um, and and that's fantastic. But after we are elected, we have the task of governing or participating in government. And that's I think one of the places where we actually are at an extreme deficit relative to um our opposition in the in the capitalist parties, which is to say that they have a whole political um ecosystem, uh, infrastructural support um from policy shops uh to um yeah, not having to um craft an entire new electoral apparatus on the fly every single time there's an an election.
SPEAKER_00Um so yeah, thinking about, you know, uh some great legislation, for instance, has been written by DSA members uh nationwide um all over the place in New York City, especially. NJP is is is a testament to that too. But yeah, uh we need to be developing our own policy shops. Uh we need to be uh mobilizing our uh volunteers to our volunteer members of organization to um try to elevate various forms of of socialist-inspired legislation, uh craft it to uh this particular states and and municipalities, et cetera, uh, because it's gonna have to look different everywhere.
SPEAKER_00And and get eyes uh on these you know humongous pieces of legislation that are uh I are gonna be costing my desk. I don't have staff. So, you know, that sort of thing, um, just having people who are just willing to actually help with the governance process and actually develop uh infrastructural independence um, you know, from org tools and and campaign tools uh to policy shops, et cetera. That's where I think that's the next step for us.
SPEAKER_02Liz and JP, do you have any answers to those questions?
SPEAKER_01I would say, you know, when I ran, I said this so often that my daughter changed how I was saved in her phone because I would tell people I'm just some guy. And so now I'm just some guy in her phone. Uh, but I think that's really, really important in everything that we do when we run and also how we serve as socialists in office. Uh, you know, I don't want to be a political celebrity. I don't want this to be, wow, JP, you know, he's fighting for the working class on Metro Council. I want to be fighting with the working class on Metro Council.
SPEAKER_01I want to be building movement. And I think it's very important that, you know, we have chapters and socialists in office that are working together, building that working class power, building movement. Uh, you know, I'm never going to get anything accomplished on my own. And whether that's getting more people in office, but also, you know, throwing, throwing giant fits and uh making it clear what the will of working people, you know, is on any particular policy issue, crafting the legislation with our office, telling me what our campaign goals are, what we want to do this term, telling me what kind of legislation we want to introduce, what fights we want to pick.
SPEAKER_01You know, that's that's what I want to be doing with DSA. And I'm I'm very lucky to be in a chapter that that's what how it works. Uh and I think that's an important model because we want working class protagonists. You know, we want the working class fighting on its own behalf and our electeds, you know, being told, hey, get in. We're we're doing socialism. You know, I want to get in and do socialism, and I and I'm proud to be in chapter that's doing that.
SPEAKER_03I think the only thing I would add is as we have this urge to have more and more socialists elected, we gotta hold the line on sometimes you gotta run a bad race or race that's less likely to win, let's say. Not bad race, but and when every time you do that, you still must hold the line on being explicitly socialist. It would be really tempting to say, like, well, I want 10 more socialists in office with Robert. Let's run, you know, 10 more progressive, seeming hidden socialists, and and we'll get more done.
SPEAKER_03And that's not really the function of Robert in the State House or the function of JP at Metro Council. It is to heighten the contradictions. But also, people in America do not have are not born with the concept of what democratic socialism is. We we must be showing by example what it is, and that means campaigning um, you know, with the ideas in front.
SPEAKER_02Thanks as always to our guests and our production crew, Ewan, Jordan, Michael, and Tim, who put this all together. CLASS is a podcast of DSA's National Political Education Commission, or NPEC, which works to expand the knowledge of DSA members and non-members in the service of winning the struggle for socialism and democracy. You can find out more about NPEC by searching for us online or following us on social media, but the best way to find out what our committee's up to is by signing up for Red Letter, NPEC's monthly newsletter.
SPEAKER_02And if you aren't already, you can become a DSA member by following the link in the podcast description. Okay, until next time, solidarity.
SPEAKER_04Kommunismus heißt unsere Zeit an der Moska, an der Weichse, an der Moldau, an das Meer, stehe auf dem blöder Gnose, auf der Seele Volks auf mir.
This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...
In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...