Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake outrage and centrists hand-wring over “the DSA takeover." Upcoming Class episodes will zoom in on different planks and demands raised in our program with expert guests and organizers from across DSA and the left, and talk about the why, how, when, and exactly what society must change, as well as the role of Workers Deserve More in that change. On this episode, we talk with Paul Heideman (Jacobin, Catalyst) about the theory and practices of penal or carceral minimalism, which has recently been suggested as an alternative to abolitionism by some social theorists and political strategists and which has been influencing debate within DSA and elsewhere (as listeners to the last two episodes may realize). This is the third in a series discussing socialism and abolition, related to the “End Mass Incarceration and Police Immunity” plank in Workers Deserve More. To read Workers Deserve More, DSA’s program, go here. To read Paul’s article, "The Case for Carceral Minimalism," go here. Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hi comrades and welcome to CLASS, the podcast of Democratic Socialists of America's National Political Education Commission, or NPEC. My name is Michaela, and I'm co-chair of NPEC and a member of North New Jersey DSA. Today I'll be speaking with Paul Heidemann about his article, The Case for Carceral Minimalism, published in August in Jacobin, as the latest installment of our series of episodes discussing abolition and DSA's program, Workers Deserve More. Before we dive in, a reminder that class is available on all major podcast platforms.
SPEAKER_01Please consider becoming a DSA member by following the link in the podcast description. You can also send us a message about the episode and sign up for Red Letter, NPEC's monthly newsletter, using the provided links. In other NPEC news, I'm delighted to let you know that we're once again starting up our annual mass reading group of Capital Volume 1 on October 27th. This time we're going to try bi-weekly, that's one meeting every two weeks, and hope to get a lot of brave souls out to take another wild trip around Carl's spooky universe full of blobs of congealed labor, vampires and werewolves hungrily chasing profit, commodity fetishism, mute compulsions, and of course, the most terrifying of all, the labor theory of value.
SPEAKER_01It's a hard book, but we promise that we will make it fun with lots of support and camaraderie. So join us, the RSVP for the kickoff, which has no required reading, is in the show notes, as well as in this month's NPC newsletter and in this month's installation of Red Letter. Over the last few weeks, I've talked with two scholars and practitioners of decarceration and community safety, Alec Karakatsanis and Alex Vitale, one a lawyer and one a sociologist, or at least he's categorized as one.
SPEAKER_01Both of them had strong disagreements with the recent spate of articles and analyses from other scholars of the socialist left who inclined towards rejecting abolition, either the word, the movement, the framework, or all three, and instead embracing police and prisons as a necessary evil under capitalism, or as a reformable social good that people both want and need, and may even need more of, under capitalism and however long into the transitional future. DSA's program out in July endorses an abolitionist horizon and reducing the power and size of the current police and prison systems, and unsurprisingly has been attacked by mainstream media for it.
SPEAKER_01Some have claimed that the demand for a future without police or prisons is both unrealistic and harmful to our current prospects for winning and governing as socialists. One of these is Paul Heidemann, who claims that the social imperative to protect those without power from those with more power demands at least a minimum level of policing, what he is calling carceral minimalism. Paul writes regularly for Jacobit and Catalyst and is recently the author of Rogue Elephant, How Republicans Went From the Party of Business to the Party of Chaos.
SPEAKER_01He's also a member of New York City DSA. Hey Paul, welcome to class.
SPEAKER_00Hey, thanks for having me on.
SPEAKER_01Of course. Great to see you. And um, we always ask the first question to the people on for the first time that's the same. Um hopefully you don't mind answering it. Um, how and why did you become a socialist and how and why did you join DSA? I feel like I already know this, and if people like have read your stuff, they might they might already know like part of the story, but if you wouldn't mind doing your elevator speech for us.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, you know, I've I've suppose I've reached the age where, you know, the story becomes kind of longer and longer the older you get in some ways. Um I I I became a socialist back in 2003 when I went to college. Um, you know, I had uh I'd read like Howard Zinn and Noam Chomsky in high school and that kind of thing, and had a kind of incohate uh radicalism. Um, but it was when I went to college at um UW Madison and met um a socialist group there, the now now defunct, the International Socialist Organization, and and joined that.
SPEAKER_00Um and was was a member of that for uh about a decade and a half um before before it fell apart in uh I guess late 2018, uh early 2019. Um and so I was I was part of the the socialist movement, albeit in a different form and a different wing of it from DSA for for quite some time. And after that project failed, um was when I joined DSA. I think I joined DSA officially in like late 2019, I want to say, um, when it had become clear that uh DSA had done a number of things right, and my other group, which had ceased to exist, had clearly done a number of things wrong.
SPEAKER_00Um, so uh I joined DSA after having been uh an active and an organized socialist for uh quite some time.
SPEAKER_01Out of curiosity, what made you decide you wanted to join ISO? Was it because they were just there on campus organizing? And it was like, I'm interested in this and I'm learning about it, and I'm going to get organized. Or was it kind of like there are these specific things about ISO that I feel drawn to as a student or a worker or whatever?
SPEAKER_00It was partially that uh, you know, when you put your name down, they called you back and some other groups didn't. Um that that definitely helped. Um, but I was definitely also impressed with the kind of discipline and seriousness that um I saw people bringing to the project of radical politics. And I think, you know, as a as a college freshman, it taught me quite a bit. And I think, you know, it's I certainly cast a jaundiced eye these days towards much of uh the ISO's politics and and organizing.
SPEAKER_00But I would say that like I absolutely credit that experience with teaching me that, you know, politics, radical politics is not a do what you want when you want kind of endeavor. It's the kind of thing that takes serious discipline. And uh, you know, being forced to get up at 8 a.m. Saturday mornings to go sell socialist newspapers uh may not have accomplished a great deal for socialism in the long run, but uh it did teach me that um politics is a collective endeavor of collective responsibility to one another, not um do what you want today.
SPEAKER_01That's a great segue into what we're about to talk about because you do have a couple of articles out. You write a lot for Jacobin, um, and Jacobin Catalyst, obviously related. Catalyst uh is the quarterly um peer-reviewed, kind of like more thick journal. I'm a subscriber to both, actually. Um, and in Catalyst, you recently published uh Where is DSA going? Um we're not gonna focus wholly on that. We're not gonna like talk about that, but it really I think relates to another article you wrote earlier in the year, a couple weeks after Workers Deserve More, DSA's program came out, the case for carceral minimalism.
SPEAKER_01Um, which whether coincidentally or not, it kind of responds to things that are happening right now within DSA and outside of it, because of the media coverage of Workers Deserve More and Mass Incarceration and Police Immunity Plank, which now is just being nicknamed the abolition plank. Um, primarily because within it there's the call for a future abolishing of the police in prison system that protects the rich and jails the poor, which electeds and um like socialists in office as well as socialist uh candidates have been kind of grilled on nonstop by the media.
SPEAKER_01And when you wrote that article, which was the beginning of August, that was when it really was starting to light up. I know this personally because I myself was being uh clipped and splashed across Fox News daily pretty much for weeks. Um, but this is particularly kind of controversial currently within DSA because there's a few different strands um attached to it. And one of them, you sort of premise your article on carceral minimalism, which is a term I'm assuming you made up to kind of replace penal minimalism, which is this other similar thing.
SPEAKER_01We can talk about the distinction that you want to make there. But the argument you're making or the premise that you kind of introduce at the beginning of carceral minimalism or the case for carceral minimalism, is that it's indefensible for electeds because they understand that it's an unpopular demand. Abolition specifically. Now, the demand for abolition in the program is a sort of future horizon. And Eugene Debs, who died almost exactly a hundred years ago, he his death date is October 20th, 1926, in his only um existing book that he put together himself.
SPEAKER_01Um, he calls for the abolition of prison. And he says it cannot be reformed. In fact, the quote itself is the prison ought not merely to be reformed, but abolished as an institution for the punishment and degradation of unfortunate human beings. And he talks about this in the context of capitalism, poverty, and the sort of like social pressures to do crimes, those kinds of things, which I know that you're interested in because you're a Marxist and a disciplined one, um, as your training uh you know implies. But I mean, I just want to ask you like, do you think that that is a system that ought to be abolished?
SPEAKER_01A police in prison system that protects the rich and jails the poor? I mean, just like on its face. I'm not asking you to like over like just a yes or no. I know that's not a gotcha, but it sounds like something that needs to be abolished, I would say.
SPEAKER_00Certainly with that qualifier, a system that uh protects the rich and uh and what was the word punishes the poor?
SPEAKER_01Jails the poor, punish, yeah, jails the poor.
SPEAKER_00Jails the poor. Uh certain certainly with that qualifier, it's um by definition um an unjust system. But the more interesting question is uh is it possible for a system of um public safety, uh, you know, coercive a coercive apparatus of the state that includes incarceration? The the question is, I think that's more interesting, is is it possible for it to be something else than a system that uh protects the rich and punishes, jails the poor?
SPEAKER_00Um and there, I think there are good reasons for thinking that it certainly can be moved in that direction under capitalism. Um, whether, you know, I think uh there's a reasonable argument to be made that um some kind of bias will always remain in any system that's administered in a capitalist society. But um I do think that there are very good reasons to think that the system could be significantly less unjust uh even in a capitalist society than it is in the United States today.
SPEAKER_00And I think that that kind of reform is a worthy goal. So uh, you know, for me, the key question uh hinges on, you know, can it be reformed and ought it be reformed if it can? Um and I would answer both of those in the affirmative, and I think that is uh uh one of the big areas of disagreement between carceral minimalism and um other kind of radical left approaches.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'd love to talk to you more about that because I do think, and and as people who've been listening for maybe the last couple of weeks would know, Alec Karakazzanis as well as Alex Vitali, both of whom are would describe and do describe themselves as abolitionists, would agree with you. And they work daily in order to try to bring about those kinds of, we can even call them within that state, like non-reformist reforms. So in our program, we also call for demilitarizing police departments, disempowering police unions, and redirecting funding to public services as steps towards abolition.
SPEAKER_01So it's kind of a clunky sentence in some ways. It's grammatically correct, believe me, I know. Um, but nonetheless, it may be confusing for people who are like, but I want abolition now. And in fact, some of the calls for or some of the slogans will say have said, defund the police, abolition now, right? The program itself doesn't necessarily call for that. And many of the people who work for these, um, you know, who are their lawyers or who are otherwise like involved in um organizing, they'll say, we know we can't abolish it overnight.
SPEAKER_01But the idea that like there's a horizon is something that I'm kind of wondering, like when we're talking about what socialists ought to do, yeah, working towards reforms that are non-reformist reforms, to borrow the phrase from Andre Gors, um, and as well as have been kind of like cycled through DSA nonstop. Um, and people also have different opinions about what a non-reformist reform is, let's be honest. But like there is a strain of abolition that would say trying to reform the system is just capitulation.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_01But then there are others who still call themselves abolitionists who say harm reduction is important, trying to achieve justice for prisoners as well as for um people who are oppressed by police is important. And they wouldn't call it carceral minimalism or penal minimalism, because there's also the strait in there that says actually incarceration as punishment itself as like a sort of retributive factor in social, um, like as a social good is itself unjust.
SPEAKER_01So they would not call it that. What do you what's your view on that as far as like the actual, like just to go back to the debs, as an institution for the punishment and degradation of unfortunate human beings, which prisons do. I think in your article you talk about that a bit, about funding and things like that. But yeah.
SPEAKER_00I think, well, I I think you want to distinguish between retribution as a goal of punishment and deterrence as a goal of punishment. Um, retribution says it is just that this thing happens to this person who has committed some sort of wrong uh in punishment for their wrong, regardless of its effects on the rest of society, right? The retribution itself is a good. Um the and and I don't think that's particularly defensible as a as a kind of moral theory of punishment.
SPEAKER_00I do think that deterrence is defensible as a theory of punishment, which says we must take away this person's liberty to some degree in order that people who might think about doing something similar uh don't do it. Right. And there, the uh purpose of punishment is not, you know, to punish someone in a sense to show that what they did is wrong or anything like that. The purpose is to have enough of a punishment to disincentivize others from engaging in that behavior, because that behavior is socially destructive.
SPEAKER_00Um, and I think that is not only defensible, but I think that it's absolutely necessary uh in order to protect um, particularly the most oppressed and poorest people in our society, who are the people who suffer um by far the most from um crime, violence, uh, etc. So um so that I think would be a um a difference between um carceral minimalism and abolition is that most abolitionists would deny that police and prisons have any real effect in preventing crime.
SPEAKER_00Um and therefore they conclude that they're not really legitimate as institutions, and we want these reforms that will chip away at their power until we get rid of them altogether, right? Um and I think if you think that uh police and prisons don't have a deterrent effect on crime, and that that policing and prisons don't have any role in stopping crime, I think that's a very logical conclusion to reach. Um the harms of policing and prisons in American society are so overwhelming that if they don't have some kind of role that makes somebody's life uh better in some kind of justifiable way, they should absolutely be abolished, you know?
SPEAKER_00Um uh but that's a premise that I don't agree with. I don't think it's true that policing and prisons have no deterrent effect. And that's why I um think that uh there are institutions that in many ways, unfortunately, we need. I mean, I I used to uh consider myself an abolitionist and uh and adopt the position that we should abolish these institutions, but um, as I read more, I I found there were arguments against it that I felt I couldn't answer until I I felt I had to abandon that position and adopt the one that that seemed to me much stronger.
SPEAKER_01Um and on the question of the horizon, I'm can I can I actually just interject real quick because like there was a lot there, and I do want to ask a follow-up, which is that I mean, you do talk about this in your article, which is that the data supports that there is this deterrent effect where when there are police around, when there are patrolling, when they are walking about, when there's uh cruisers, whatever, people don't do crime. Now, that is logical, that is obvious. People don't do crimes right in front of the cops.
SPEAKER_01However, what a what a person would say is like that may be true. However, this is also assuming that there's no other solution, right? That there's no other viable solution besides the police have to be there in order for people not to commit crimes. And actually, this um, you know, discussion kind of is like, well, what are the ranges of kinds of things? Because you also have within abolition a big tent those who think that we should actually be abolishing state power altogether, and those who believe that no, actually, police in prisons are a historic, like the way that they look and act and uh are arranged and funded and everything right now is a historical technology, right?
SPEAKER_01Like that it was it was made this way in order to both um create reforms that would um consolidate police forces under state power instead of having kind of some mercenaries over here and some private security forces here and some military guys over here. So having the standing police force is historical circumstance and you know arrived at under the conditions of industrial capitalism. And the way that prisons are also set up now are not like the local jail, right?
SPEAKER_01And they're not even like military prisons. They are more like, you know, entire systems, ecosystems, even um that have public and private aspects to them. Prisons are primarily public institutions, they're regulated by the state, but they have all of these um private, you know, kinds of like tendrils, we'll say, that are about the way in which it it belongs to. I know this is an old-fashioned term, but an industrial complex of punishment, what Alec would call the punishment bureaucracy.
SPEAKER_01Now, I want to get to the horizon part because I do think this gets really into the role of DSA, but just to kind of keep it within the sense that you're talking about with deterrence, abolition advocates, ones who don't think we should just get rid of all state power, maybe they do, but they also kind of overlap, believe that there are better solutions to deterring people from crimes than putting them under the foot of the state, like the monop monopolistic power of violence that the state is able to hold over them.
SPEAKER_01And I'm wondering whether you disagree on the merits of those arguments, that you actually don't think that those solutions are viable, or whether you're kind of like, well, under capitalism, this kind of like premises the horizon conversation. Under capitalism, this is what the state has to wield. This is the kind of thing the state has to wield. And therefore we should be using that intended to deter, but improve kind of like all of the ways in which it's violent.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01Do you understand what I'm saying?
SPEAKER_00And maybe I totally agree that um things can reduce there are ways to reduce crime that don't include policing. Um that or that there are things specifically, yeah. Well, I wouldn't say I wouldn't call so are you thinking of something like um Medicaid expansion, Medicare for all, providing some of the things.
SPEAKER_01There's kind of the macro and the micro. Because a lot of I would say that that the sort of Debian argument is get rid of the causes of crime and then you get rid of it. That's not deterrence, then deterrence is whether someone's going to do something, they have an incentive, right, to do something and they don't, right?
SPEAKER_00They're they're just violence responders, community interventions, those kind of programs.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Or, you know, to the extent that we're talking about recidivism, you know, what are the ways in which you deter people from returning? Because sometimes there are incentives to do that too.
SPEAKER_00Totally, totally. So um, yeah, uh let's um try let's try and have like kind of a typology here of uh of different forces. So I think that there is some good evidence that kinds of community programs that intervene with um, in particular young men in in very poor areas, um, or uh that are interventions done upon uh uh prisoners uh who are returning uh from incarceration, things like that, can have a real effect in. lowering crime.
SPEAKER_00And those, you know, I think the evidence suggests that those kind of programs deserve much more money than they they currently get. So so that that we could kind of include in the in the deterrent camp in a kind of we can call that nonviolent deterrence, right? And yeah, I think I I think the evidence suggests those deserve a lot more. Then there's the camp of violent deterrence, which is the use of of police power, both both preventative uh police power, where it's like you see something and you see a cop and you're like, well, you know, I'm not not going to do the thing I was going to do.
SPEAKER_00Or, you know, you know someone who is arrested and incarcerated and you're like, I don't want that to happen. That's violent, you'd call that violent deterrence. And then there are the kind of structural solutions that Deb's talked about that reduce the incentive for crime, which is, you know, on the biggest level socialism, but on a smaller level, social programs, things that that uh give people who have very few options more options.
SPEAKER_01Well reducing inequality too, because it also reduces the need or desire to go and take or whatever, because here we're talking about property crimes. Yes. Which are the pain drivers. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I I I would put it a little bit differently from the incentive to take. I I think a good way to think about it is that the better your life outside prison, the worse a punishment prison is, right? And so for like the poorest Americans, their lives outside prison are horrible. Are horrible. So imprisonment is not that much of a uh you know imprisonment uh is less of a deterrent than if we raised the quality of the lives of the poorest Americans.
SPEAKER_00So I think I think that's the main way uh that these kind of structural solutions work is that when you when you increase the quality of life of the poorest people, they have uh uh much much less incentive to engage in crime. Um so so I I'm in favor of those things. My kind of big picture uh perspective is that these kind of three different things all work best together and that you can't put all of the weight on any one of them in a capitalist society and expect it to work.
SPEAKER_00And that particularly in a you know grotesquely high violence society like the United States, um I I think it's unrealistic that we could simply expand one of those margins and expect that to produce a a more civilized livable society again particularly for the poorest and most oppressed people in the country.
SPEAKER_01Yeah so I would say that probably if you're gonna do it I love a typology of three gives you got lots of options and and ways to mix things together. But I would say that you know when I'm saying I would say I'm literally saying I would say because I also am I'm thinking through these things because I also just want to say that when I use the term police power I'm not solely talking about the violent coercive aspects of the cops right talking about the entire plenary power of the state to regulate public health welfare morals and security what is talked about kind of in the early 20th century and like with the advent actually of more social safety nets and more kind of ways in which the state is trying to do things like vaccinate um its population.
SPEAKER_01That was referred to as police power and some tried to claim that that was violent but obviously the Supreme Court at the time was just like no it's not go away. But nonetheless like we'll see a bit yeah exactly now it's considered a medical assault right to like tell somebody they have to get a vaccination. But just to kind of go back to this this um picking one or the other and that's not going to work I would say probably and this gets back to the reform question most abolitionists work towards decarceration right as like a tactic within um the larger strategy of abolitionism or the larger movement within abolitionism as well as sort of alternative community safety some believe in things like restorative justice that kind of stuff I don't think it's a it's an absolute requirement of any person who subscribes to abolition especially maybe those who kind of more side on yeah I actually think the state has a role and I think that the police power the broad police power has a role but the large scale macro making people's lives better, I don't see that as deterrence because what I see that as taking away any incentives to do crime at all.
SPEAKER_01You're not even thinking about it. The deterrent part is when you can tell somebody who's about to do something stop and that's the argument you're making in your article about why we need the police I don't want to like you know keep repeating the same ground but like I'm gonna I guess to the extent that we if we could take two of those three I would say that a socialist view would be the things that are going to reduce inequality and also improve people's like capacities right like to actually like create the the the grounds for human beings to become better people which prisons and police do not you know because then we're also talking about like we've got the different ways in which police and prison power is um kind of advocated for the justification for it we've got deterrence we've got re uh retribution we also have rehabilitation which has been completely you know dispelled as as far as like what what that's for so maybe this gets to this question of like what should socialists advocate for because when we're in in your article like obviously Jacobin and catalyst too you subscribe to them but people can read them online and they don't have to be a socialist to do so but most people listening to this this uh podcast are people who are curious about DSA interested in what we are saying about what we should be doing and what socialists should be doing as well as DSA members themselves so tell me like I mean should we be saying as socialists we've got these three things these this typology of three and we have to do all of them or should we be saying if we do these two things then the other thing is kind of what you say actually I really like the way you phrase this in your article shrunken and softened like that like that that part actually becomes shrunken and softened.
SPEAKER_01That's such a gross thing to say oh my God it should be it should it should kind of minimal minimize itself I guess one could say um with the other two things. So what do you think of that theory?
SPEAKER_00Maybe it's a little bit in no in the abstract in the abstract I think it's true. Like if we were in a position to win um an expansion of the welfare state in the United States that would you know put us on northern European levels of social spending um you know if we're in a position to do that I I think that would drastically reduce the need for policing in the United States. But I think the trickier part comes when we have some power but not enough power to win something like that.
SPEAKER_00You know so in uh the the most violent cities in the United States cities like Memphis um Jackson St. Louis um the ratio of police to murders is there's about 10 police for every murder committed in the city. That's a situation in which it is simply impossible to provide public safety. And now those cities would all be made much, much safer if we had a massive investment of uh uh in employment uh social services all of that right um and and we should fight for that but I think there's a real question where we have like in situations where we have some power and but not enough power to win that do we say no no no it is a principle that we never expand the police that we never expand the power of of policing in society um we we fight for this other thing uh uh this expansion of of social services reduction in inequality and until we win that there's simply nothing we can do on public safety and I I I think that is um gonna be unsuccessful for and I I also think it's unjustifiable.
SPEAKER_00I think it's unjustifiable to condemn the uh poorest and most oppressed sectors of our society to the kind of levels of violence that they suffer from I mean in in 2021 uh the highest crime neighborhoods in the United States a young black man had a higher probability of being murdered than an American soldier in Iraq in 2005 at the very height of the Iraq war right like that's that's the level of violence that we're dealing with. Like when people call it a war zone, they're not exaggerating. Fortunately that level of violence has declined somewhat since that peak, that post-pandemic peak in 2021, but that that wasn't for that that long ago.
SPEAKER_00And so I think it's true to say that the best way to solve that is with uh socialist policies that decommodify uh the provisioning of needed goods and services that reduce inequality. But I think it's also the case that we have to have something to say uh about this when at a point when we are not able to win that. And in uh in some places at least I I think socialists should be for hiring more police such that there is some capacity to address violence and to produce public safety for the people who are suffering most from its absence.
SPEAKER_01Yeah I think that there um I definitely know that Alec and Alex and I also disagree that that is a something that needs to be called for for a couple reasons. And I know where this you know kind of has sparked a lot of debate is uh Adner Usmani's article that advocated for I think the hiring of about half a million police the distinctions between what kinds of I mean this this is something Alec talks about in his um in his interview but like this also can just sort of be brought about like the the the the violent power of the police in this country the like the actual like capacity to arm and to discharge weaponry and like to kill people with some with with most mostly with impunity we'll say is much high it's astronomical in this country but also it doesn't count you know the all the different types of police going to another country in Europe uh Italy Spain there's all these different types of police they're all just kind of called police in the United States we have the police which people kind of think of as the city police um but we also have all these other types um and some of which are you know actually beat cops um carrying weapons some of which are doing other kinds of um work uh doing various kinds of agency work and those kinds of things and how to count police I think that's the way that Alec put it is like a really difficult one when we're talking about this.
SPEAKER_01But just the absolute ability to discharge violence in this country compared to other peer countries. We're talking here about developed quote unquote developed nations or nations that have similar types of police forces that we do is much, much higher. And so this question of whether we need more police um or advocate like the advocate for more police or we even say a stable police population in relation to the general population and have some kind of like this many police per historical murders or this many police per citizen.
SPEAKER_01Because the nature of the police, the way in which the police are able to function in our society is with near impunity and very, very difficult to control. I mean we're kind of seeing what's happening in New York City right now where the police have an agency within it that aids um you know it's called the strategic it's called SRG and I or Response group strategic response group strategic response group which is deployed to like sites of like sort of mass gathering and that kind of thing that seems I mean that's that's a seems like a relic of like the riot police or something like that.
SPEAKER_01But it exists and people are calling for it to be dismantled but then there's also the fact that a lot of police within uh cities and um you know other you know state agencies they have to be actively stopped by like pass a law has to be passed or some kind of like command has to be sort of passed down for them not to cooperate with for example ICE or these other agencies. So a very difficult nut to crack I think when you're saying that socialists should be doing this because of safety when the police themselves represent this massive bureaucracy that is like already difficult for the state to control um and has all of these sort of like tendrils I'm using that word again for some reason must be the word of the day but these these sort of like attachments let's say to like all of these other sort of powerful violent forces in society.
SPEAKER_01And maybe that's a little bit of like a a comment rather than a question. But but to me I do think that there's a lot to be said for well if you go back to the fact that we can reduce crimes themselves like at bottom by just not having them even under capitalism, you know, improving social services but then also um replacing the violent gun carrying police with people who can actually respond to certain kinds of violence more constructively.
SPEAKER_01And I know that for some that sounds naive right it sounds naive to say that you would send a social worker instead of a cop to like a violent interaction but others would say no that actually does have like an amiliatory effect on the overall occurrence of violence and the the ability to de-escalate.
SPEAKER_00So maybe you could just respond yeah yeah there there's a lot of things there to to prize apart I think one of them is that this question of counting police which is really an artifact of the decentralization of policing in the United States policing in the United States is extraordinarily decentralized compared to um other countries where the you know the federal police are the generally the primarily the primary police force in most other rich democracies. In the United States it's overwhelmingly local police.
SPEAKER_00And that is related very closely to the governance problem you raise, which is that decentralized police forces have a much easier time governing themselves and resisting governance than uh centralized ones do. So I think I I think one thing that socialists should be talking about in the United States is centralizing the police forces that exist in the way that we see in other countries where their accountability processes are far, far more effective than ours.
SPEAKER_00It is very easy for a small local police force to beat a small local civilian review board or something like that. On a federal level if if there's one federal body that isn't responsible for investigating police misconduct in the entire country it is much easier to get that the kind of power it needs to to be able to do the kind of investigations that will actually deter police misconduct to talk about deterrence on the other side of the equation. And I think the evidence for that is quite strong if you look at other rich democracies that more centralized police forces are easier to bring under democratic control than decentralized police forces.
SPEAKER_00So I I I do think that's a reform socialists should should take it would also fit in with disempowering police unions because there simply wouldn't be any anymore. Yeah yeah you could it would it would be much easier uh to to um to deal with them I mean yeah again police forces on the local level have a much easier time being uh uh strong than if than if it was one uh uh national than that than if the majority of the force was were national um I do think the counting question though is is really a red herring um I I don't think it's very relevant. And the reason is that no matter how you count police in the United States versus police in Europe, the number of police per murder in the United States is far, far smaller.
SPEAKER_00So if you think about that in terms of a uh uh the need for policing just like in terms of the number of doctors in a population if the population is old and sick you need more doctors per capita in order to produce a certain level of health than in a younger and healthier population. In a society with a much higher crime rate and a much higher rate of violent crime you need more police to produce a certain level of public safety unless we're going to change that other margin uh by uh expanding social services, which again I'm for but I do think we need to have something to say about the interim before we're able to do that.
SPEAKER_00I mean we're we're looking at sending what seven or eight socialists to Congress in the next Congress, right? We are we're a long ways from being able to win the kind of massive expansion of the American welfare state that would allow us to shrink the policing force. And and you know I I want to win that but I I think we have to have something to say in the meantime that's not just we have a principle that we don't expand the police force, we want to expand these other things instead. Well we can't expand those right now we are not able to win that. And part of the reason that uh it is more realistic to expand policing particularly again in the most dangerous uh uh neighborhoods in the United States where where people face um you know risks to their lives that are are just totally unacceptable in a in a rich democracy um is that preventing crime through policing is much cheaper than preventing it through the welfare state.
SPEAKER_00And the reason is very simple right when we expand the welfare state you expand the welfare state for everybody who's eligible right we we Medicare for all goes to everybody right policing is concentrated uh in the areas in which there is a lot of crime and so you can hire you know in in a city like Jackson let's say or or or Memphis you can hire 200 police officers and that will have a real effect on the number of murders that are committed in that city um you you can do that for just a fraction of the cost of what it would take to give the poorest people in that area livable lives right that's why capitalists prefer policing to the welfare state as a tool of crime management right capital capitalists and more specifically that the the capitalist state right they they have to do some kind of crime management and provision of public safety in a democratic society otherwise they get voted out of office right so like clear enough it's a democratic society actually regardless of whether it's a democratic society but I don't think I don't think we would question that people have been voted out of office or or voted into office because of the issue of crime right like that's uh that's the kind of thing that people uh that that leads to voter rebellions I mean I don't think Ed Koch or Rudy Giuliani would have won in New York if the crime rate weren't as high as it were when they were running for office.
SPEAKER_00They ran campaigns around public safety and around crime that of course involved a tremendous amount of fear mongering and scapegoating but nonetheless it was a real issue. I mean New York City in 1990 had like 2000 murders a year. It's kind of unthinkable now, right? Crime's fallen by 85 90% since then. Right so you know regardless of the people okay but I I want to finish this point on democracy because regardless of the limitations of democracy in American society it is clear that a politician uh a government that completely fails at the task of uh public safety will face a backlash from voters and so they do have an incentive to manage crime to some degree they want to do it the cheapest way possible that doesn't require huge levels of taxation that doesn't require giving workers options outside the market and that's police right that's that that explains the focus on policing in American society rather than the welfare state is the fact that that it's so much cheaper.
SPEAKER_00But that very fact also means that it is realistic to do something about crime in the absence of the expansion of the welfare state and in a position where socialists are cannot win a large expansion of the welfare state in the near future, I think we we still have to have something to say about the provision of public safety.
SPEAKER_01Yeah I I I'm glad you mentioned first of all the electoral prospects which is related directly to whether or not we can win certain demands now, later, way later or never um but the other part that I wanted to Mention is the fall in crime in New York City since Zaron Mamdani has been elected. Now, the New York City DSA Racial Justice Working Group advertises on its internal, well not even the internal website, but like the outward-facing website, that they are organizing for police abolitionism.
SPEAKER_01And earlier this year, they successfully were able to organize to pressure Zaron not to hire uh police when he was going to. I can't remember the exact number, but it was in the hundreds of new police officers. Crime continued to go down. And I admit I don't know every single detail of why it did, especially given that we had a lot of crazy weather and things like that that often tend to exacerbate certain kinds of criminal activity.
SPEAKER_01Um, but the count of murders, especially, but also other crimes, has fallen dramatically, the lowest in history. And while Zaron, um, when questioned, actually when asked, Do you support DSA's call to abolish the police? They also said to defund the police, which we don't actually say in our program, even though we do say direct public or direct resources to uh social services. Um, he said, No, I don't support defunding the police.
SPEAKER_01And what you're kind of pointing out is that putting electeds in a position to where they could lose their office, our socialists, uh elected, to where they could lose their office if they were to stand on principle, um, this principle of abolitionism. It was just, it's just a foolhardy errand, like in your in your view, where it's just like, why would we do that when we could be doing something else that would both satisfy voters, the the whoever voter, the the people who are not principled in the way that socialists are around this, but desire public safety and also desire a better life?
SPEAKER_01We can like kind of steer our both our policy and our rhetoric that direction. And why would we like like we need those kinds of things to kind of build up in order to be able to get the things that we really want? So I feel like that there's this kind of two levels. It's like what we really want, what we're really after, are these major reforms, reducing inequality, giving power back to the working class to advocate for themselves politically on the things that are material desires, right?
SPEAKER_01Desires, wants, needs, um, and being able to make you know big changes, more uh Congress people in office, maybe a president one day, but like more people. And then we in the meantime, I think that this is kind of going to like we can't actually say we want the end of policing, because to do that would just be political suicide. Now, what abolitionists would say is well, we're not saying like even Alec and Alex say, I don't say we don't say abolition.
SPEAKER_01What we say are these other things instead, but they're not going to, when talking about it with like-minded organizers or anything, try to hide the ball. And the thing with the Workers Deserve More program is that it's a kind of like a statement of what DSA stands for. It's not primarily campaign material for electeds. Nonetheless, it I do think that saying, I do want to abolish the police and prison system that protects the rich and jails the poor, I think everyone should, is not a difficult thing for an elected person to say.
SPEAKER_01And it doesn't like diverge really from these other kinds of efforts that Zaron's doing with community safety and those kinds of things. I'm kind of wondering where you sit on the DSA's responsibility to get the things we really want is to make it easier on our socialists in office and our candidates to be able to defend us as well as to get in office and be able to govern and therefore be able to build up the credibility that we need in order to get the things we really want.
SPEAKER_00I to be honest, I think it's best just to start with substantively what do we think would be good policy? You know, like what actually should we try and pass in the here and now uh that will put us in a better position to win more in the future and will also help accomplish our goals in the here and now, our goals of uh reducing inequality, of uh expanding the life chances of the poorest and most oppressed people in the country. Um and and there, you know, when it comes to Zoran specifically, um, so you know, if you look at the ratio of like police to murders in New York City, it's actually a lot closer to the European average than it is to uh the American average.
SPEAKER_00Um so yeah, you know, I'm not I'm not necessarily opposed to uh uh freezing the hiring of police in the United States, um, particularly if if crime continues dropping the the way it is. It's not clear to me that New York City uh needs more police. I don't think that can be said of a number of other cities in the United States. There's certainly cities where I would say that that can't be said. So I'm not necessarily opposed to that in the in the context of New York. Um, you know, thinking about the crime decline generally, I mean, crime has been declining from its kind of post-COVID highs and returning more or less to the trajectory it was on in the mid-2010s.
SPEAKER_00Um, I think that's basically what what we're seeing here. Um so yeah, like I I have a hard time thinking about like kind of what the program should be for socialist electeds and that kind of thing, apart from what kind of policies we should concretely be advocating. And so, like in New York City, I would definitely be opposed to like an effort to cut policing, you know, to cut like the NYPD by 20%, let's say.
SPEAKER_00You know, I I I think I think that would probably make the lives of the poorest people in New York City a lot worse if we did that. Um, regardless, you know, even if we plowed all of that money into uh uh schools or or you know, pick pick whatever social service you want, right? So I think I think we should be opposed to that. I think we should be for um expanding social services. I think we should be for trying to achieve more democratic control over the police, which is a really, really hard task, but also deeply necessary in in many different ways.
SPEAKER_00I mean, it's a major I I think it's a you know the the political power of police in American cities is a threat to American democracy. I think, you know, I don't think that's like an exaggeration. And and figuring out how to counter that threat and neutralize it is one of the urgent tasks for socialist municipal governance right now, and something that I think deserves a lot more thinking. And I think in some ways, I think, you know, defunding the police, abolishing the police has been allowed to overshadow that kind of work on thinking of like how can the police be made accountable?
SPEAKER_00Because a lot of people want to say, well, look, in a capitalist society that's built on slavery, um police will never be accountable. And so there you you you can't. So that's that's the kind of stuff I think we should focus on. And, you know, I don't know if you if you saw, but just today the Mamdani administration announced um some new accountability measures for the NYPD, um, including kind of the um uh uh making sure that cops aren't simply able to kind of retire when they're under investigation for misconduct and like just kind of retire at their full pension then, that kind of thing, um, as well as a number of other uh uh new new policies.
SPEAKER_00So I I think we need a lot more thinking about how to control the police that that isn't premised on the idea that they simply can't be controlled. I I think that's giving up um what is actually one of the most important questions for socialist politics today.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think that the question of the impunity of the police is also a legal issue because of qualified immunity and the ways in which um the unions are able to essentially um do a lot of internal and self-discipline um and and also defend themselves against a lot of um even ways that you can get within the cracks of the where a qualified immunity doesn't count, uh, police unions serve as a way to essentially create a barrier between public accountability and um individual police officers.
SPEAKER_01This is, I mean, I think that in a lot of ways some people would say you would disagree, obviously, vociferously, because you're making a distinction, but they would say, well, carceral minimalism, if what you're talking about is like what we can do right now under capitalism, definitely the idea of hiring more police in order to achieve more safety would be the most controversial aspect of this, and the the thing that most people would would disagree with because of all the reasons that you may think are not relevant, but also the ways in which there are these negative externalities that also come from having more police around, including the people for the reasons that we just talked about, which is the relative impunity um that police have to wield violence.
SPEAKER_01Um it's a little bit of a chicken and egg there. It's like what comes first, the actual accountability measures or the hiring of a bunch of people, right? Like this is, I mean, I think that maybe that would be maybe for another topic or another another article or another another debate. But this idea of an abolitionist horizon, this is kind of the Debsian way of using abolition. Because what he says in his book is that one day we will not need this, we will, we will be a more humane, a more civilized society.
SPEAKER_01We will not need to treat people this way, right? Which I think is a pretty bog standard socialist position. When we get to socialism, our lives, we will, we will be transformed and the conditions under which we live as we live will also and at the same time be transformed. It will be a new society. But some have argued that there will be a need for the police, and we should just admit it, because there will still be antisocial behavior under socialism, because it's not as if everybody is going to suddenly become like perfectly enlightened.
SPEAKER_01We're still going to have human difference, we're going to have conflict, we're going to have, you know, various other forms of um out-of-control behavior. I would say that truly antisocial behavior will be so minimal and so occasional that having like a standing police force for it will also just be unnecessary. Um, because first of all, a lot of crimes will no longer exist. But then also there will be a sense in which the people who are actually acting in an antisocial way require other forms of um discipline that do not require punishment or a way to like kind of satisfy society that these people have been dealt with, more like ref, you know, the in like individual reform or something like that.
SPEAKER_01But I guess I would just to wrap up, like, wonder what you think about the abolitionist horizon and whether or not you still believe in it, or whether you think, like, no, actually, I think that we'll probably always need police. This is a technology, the way that this works is a technology that we will keep um in some form even after we have moved to the next stage.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, to be honest, I just don't think that there's a lot that can be said with confidence one way or the other, on what the public safety infrastructure of late communism would look like. Uh, you know, um, in terms of like a you know, a fully realized classless society, um, I like we we know so little about that in institutional setup and and things that like I just you know, to me it's kind of a coin flip on whether that will be necessary just because we have there's so little that that we can say about that.
SPEAKER_00Um so so in the in the far off future where where the circumstances of social justice have largely been realized, whether that'll be necessary, uh my only answer is I don't know. Um I don't know.
SPEAKER_01That's funny because Alex also said, I'm not going to speculate about what's going to happen later, which I think this kind of actually gets to like what it means to be an American socialist in the 21st century, because to be a like socialists in the past were always thinking about what things were gonna be like.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_01Always. And I I guess it's kind of like I am not a prefigurative politics person. I don't think like we need to be living exactly the way that we think we want to live once we're in. But I do think that questioning whether we can talk about what we're doing now as a way to get to a future, we have to do that. In fact, you were just saying, in order for us to be able to get to what we need to do to win the demands, to be able to agitate our class, to be able to do all of the things that we know are necessary, we have to do these other things first.
SPEAKER_01And some of them are not going to be as pleasant or as principled as we'd like, maybe. Um those for those of you who for those who are not as persuaded as you are that we need to hire more police, I think that this would probably be like, okay, the only way I would go along with this is if there was some short-term gain that we could like immediately like get rid of later. But my question maybe, and like maybe this is less of a question and more just kind of like a conclusion. Um, but I'd like to hear what you have to say, is that like something like imagining a world without police is in a in a a lot of for a lot of communities, including the ones you're talking about, the ones that are actually being, and the argument is sometimes they're under police, but a lot of these experience police actually as like a daily force and an invasive force um in their lives.
SPEAKER_01Imagining a world where that's not the way it is is synonymous with imagining a world that doesn't have capitalism in it, right? And that's the sort of Mark Fisher Fred Jameson idea. It's like it's harder to imagine the end of the world, or it's easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of capitalism. For some people, it's easier to imagine the end of the world than the end of police. And maybe that's part of this, is that our culture is so infused with the police, um, as Alec calls it copaganda, but also others have kind of talked about it as like this is what's considered to be normal order.
SPEAKER_01This like the policing is normal order. So do you think that that has something to do with it? Maybe your propensity is not to imagine the future because you don't know, but maybe there's also something about imagining a future where there is no police is just like, what? That would not be you like, can't do it. Just can't do it.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, I certainly think most of them most Americans today would would think that's a very unlikely future. Um, but that in itself is not a very good argument against it. Um uh and I don't have any particular objection to to trying to think about what such a future would look like, uh, but I do have a problem with then trying to elevate that kind of speculation to a principle for the movement in the here and now, um, because precisely because I think it is um, you know, undisciplined by um kind of any kind of empirical uh uh uh uh confirmation, one way or the other.
SPEAKER_00So uh, you know, more broadly on the question of socialist transformation. I mean, personally, I think the most likely version of a road to socialism is a transformation that stretches across decades, um, so and that, as Jean Jeraz, uh the great French socialist once said, is like a ship crossing a line in the ocean uh such that you can't say when you're on one side or the other. I mean, to me, that's the most likely version of uh of a road to socialism. And so uh in that sense, I think we'll be contending with uh institutions of capitalism and aspects of capitalist society.
SPEAKER_00Hopefully we will be steadily reducing their influence, reach, and power in our society uh over the long run until, as Grover Norquist said, of the welfare state, it is uh capitalism is small enough to drown in the bathtub. Um, but uh, you know, that's so that's that's at what I think is probably the most likely version of socialist transformation. Other people uh hew to a more kind of killiastic vision of uh rupture, uh uh and there's kind of a moment of socialist transformation. I I I've come to think that that's very unlikely.
SPEAKER_00Um But I think that um so so I think we'll be dealing with aspects of uh of capitalism for a very long time to come. And I think in that context, uh that um uh you know uh an official public safety bureaucracy that includes powers of coercion will probably uh be part of what is necessary to secure the the rights of the poorest people in society in particular, as well as to uh impose any kind of accountability on those at the top.
SPEAKER_00I mean, you know, like an OSHA fine ultimately has power because the government has the power to arrest the guy if he doesn't pay it, right? Like a factory owner if he doesn't pay it.
SPEAKER_01Which they're not doing right now, but that's beside the point.
SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah, exactly. The factory inspection police have unfortunately been defunded along with the tax police um under Donald Trump. We should we we should want to fund uh in particular those aspects of the police that enforce coercion against capital. Um so so yeah, all that is to say that for for both um imposing our will on the predators at the top of society and securing the rights of of those at the bottom, um, I I think a police power in some sense will be necessary for a very long time to come, though we need to do a tremendous amount to make it uh much more uh democratically accountable, less brutal, less capricious, all of those kind of things.
SPEAKER_00And and whether or not it is uh limitable in the in the far future, um, I'm I'm I'm happy to listen to people who think that uh it can be so, and I'm totally willing to be persuaded on it.
SPEAKER_01All right. Well, you couldn't ask for more than that. I mean, one of the one of the things before we we go is just this is going to be a debate within DSA for a while, especially because the question, and I think you brought it up well, like what I mentioned, police power is a way to describe the ability of the state to coerce people in ways that are kind of limitless, right? Like we have fines, we have incarceration, we have actual violence, um, there's other forms of like coercion.
SPEAKER_01But what does it mean? What could it mean if we had a truly democratic society and those forms of coercion, everyone agreed, well, they shouldn't, you know, they should stop short of violence, right? Unless there's like an emergency, right? Um some kind of way to be able to have people who are in charge of those kinds of things that are accountable and are able to respond correctly to the actual situations at hand. I mean, one of the things that Alex has written about, and a lot of DSA members have read his book, The End of Policing, is talking about the ways that the police actually respond in an ill-fitting way to a whole host of social disorder, um, things from mental illness, um, homeless encampment encampments, as well as just people standing around on the street, right?
SPEAKER_01Um, and right now I know that New York City DSA, there's a convention resolution that Alex is responsible for, but also has been signed by lots of people to try to end broken windows policing, which for those who may have been paying attention in I think the 80s maybe or early 90s, broken windows policing is this like famous essay um where it talks about like in order to be able to have order and safety, people have to feel safe and therefore they have to be able to see that there's order around them.
SPEAKER_01Under a socialist society, we could have that by dint of actually having funding in the right places. And it sounds to me like you agree with that. And I really like the, I mean, I love using that Grover Norquist uh thing for lots of different things. But the idea may be that by the time we actually are in really existing socialism, we will have to have looked back and been like, oh, we actually got out of really existing capitalism. That that transition itself won't be something that happens like, yes, we are crashing over the threshold, but it will actually happen as a process of movement and class, you know, sort of class struggle moving towards more successes.
SPEAKER_01And it sounds like you want that. That's the that's the idea, too. Thanks as always to our guests and to our production crew, Michael and Tim, who put this all together. CLASS is a podcast of DSA's National Political Education Commission, or NPEC, which works to expand the knowledge of DSA members and non-members in the service of winning the struggle for socialism and democracy. You can find out more about NPEC by searching for us online or following us on social media. But the best way to find out what our committee's up to is by signing up for Red Letter, NPEC's monthly newsletter.
SPEAKER_01And if you aren't already, you can become a DSA member by following the link in the podcast description. Okay, until next time. Solidarity.
This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and...
We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election,...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...
In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...