This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and present comparisons, published by the Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung’s NYC office. Thanks to RLS for supplying us with the panel recording! Enjoy the discussion, and apologies in advance for Joe's sound quality during the introduction. Read “The Long Reroute” here Read “Between Autonomy and Control” here Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hi comrades and welcome to CLAS, the podcast of Democratic Socialists of America's National Political Education Commission, or NPEC. My name's Michaela, and I'm NPEC's co-chair and a member of North New Jersey DSA. Before we dive in, a reminder that CLAS is available on all major podcast platforms. Please consider becoming a DSA member by following the link in the podcast description. You can also send us a message about the episode and sign up for Red Letter, NPEC's Monthly Newsletter, using the provided links. This year at Socialism Conference in Chicago, I was invited to moderate a panel discussion between David Duhalde, a longtime member of New York City DSA, and Joe Todd, a UK Green Party member and political researcher, hosted by the Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung's New York office.
SPEAKER_00The RLS is a foundation attached to Delinka, Germany's left party, that engages in broad education activities to explore the different reaches of socialist research, theory, and practice, and unsurprisingly, its office in the U.S. often puts on events that relate the current U.S. left to other formations and histories. This panel was largely about comparing the current DSA to what David argued in the long reroute is the closest historical analog, Eugene Debs's Socialist Party. Joe compares DSA to the current Belgian Workers' Party, which is a comparison others in the UK have made spontaneously.
SPEAKER_00In between Autonomy and Control, Joe tries to suss out the real differences and similarities, largely by talking with DSA and PTB, Belgian Workers' Party's members. I won't go too deep here since you're about to hear a whole panel introduction after I talk with David and Joe a bit more, but I do want to note that the interest in DSA and our place in history and the international ecosystem of socialist and left parties and movements is something we can see as a cosmic demand to, as the man says, make our own history.
SPEAKER_00DSA is catching attention because of our successes, and we have nowhere to go but up and keep on creating reasons why people want to understand us, learn for us, and compare themselves and others, especially other successful movements, to us. So let's get started. Welcome, David and Joe.
SPEAKER_01Hey, guys.
SPEAKER_00Nice to see you guys again. It's been uh a couple months since we talked, and um, you know, just want to give our listeners a little context about um what they're about to hear. But first of all, I just wanted to ask you both what you've been up to the last couple of months. It's definitely feels over here, like you know, weeks where decades happen a little bit. So I don't know if that's the same for each of you individually, but yeah, why don't we start with David and you can um speak a little about what you've been up to.
SPEAKER_01Sure. Thanks, Michaela. It's great to see you both again uh since our panel at Socialism 2026. Um for me, uh minorly, I mean the paper I wrote, The Long Reroute, still seems to be getting some attention. Um for better or for worse, uh the right-wing commentator Glenn Beck in his profile of the Rosa-Luxeberg stiftung included a snapshot of the paper with my name on his show. And but on a more productive note, I did actually finally see a left-wing critique of it uh from an author named Tony Tesso, who wrote a very comradely article kind of pushing back on he thinks some of my biases against forming a party.
SPEAKER_01Um, and so I do think that's worth checking out, and shows people are still engaging with the material. Um I've been, you know, in addition to doing get out the vote efforts um in Maine this weekend with some DSA folks, um, including seeing uh Todd Todd, who's uh contract candidate running in Portland, who's a friend of Michaela and I's um it was really great to see him. Um, you know, I'm still doing some writing. I'm focused on some book reviews, uh, one on David Dinkins, the first DSA mayor of New York City, um, and about his time as mayor, trying to write some stuff on uh that and what it's what it means for you know the current political situation, what we can learn.
SPEAKER_01And also Sean Good uh has written a wonderful biography about Eugene Debs, which was a very very important figure in my uh research, um, and that I really encourage DSAers and anyone to read uh called American Socialist. And we're writing a review for that for dissent.
SPEAKER_00Cool. We're actually gonna probably have Sean on here, and we might even have like a mass reading group of his book. Um Sounds like There's some interest for YDSA, so little YDSA and uh NPEC collab in the future, which could be cool. Um, and yeah, thanks for that, David. I'm really uh looking forward to reading that stuff. And as somebody who also has been uh splashed across uh right-wing blogs in the last uh couple of weeks, I definitely sympathize. It has its own fun, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_01It does. It's a solidarity, but also it's a badge of honor.
SPEAKER_00Yes, exactly. Um all right, Joe, why don't you tell us what you've been up to as well?
SPEAKER_02Well, I haven't been spending my time being attacked by the right, which is which is good for me. You haven't been trying
SPEAKER_00hard enough.
SPEAKER_02I clearly haven't been trying hard enough. I need to do more effective organizing work to get attacked by the right, but it's true. No, I straight after Chicago uh when we were there for socialism conference, I went to Belgium to go to Manifiesta, which is the big festival that the Belgian Workers Party run. Um, and I was just pretty stunned by the level of professionalism um and the scale of it. It was interesting actually that they led they led a lot more with the cultural elements of the program.
SPEAKER_02Um they had a big artist, I can't remember what it was called. I'm not into popular music, so I never know who any of these people are, but everyone was very excited that they're complaining. And lots of people, and lots of people, and lots of people were there to see the artists rather than to come to the talks, but then obviously people are not going to the talks and and yellow yada. So yeah, it was just very, very impressive and a kind of model for the kind of big broad 10 event that some of our parties and specialist organizations could be doing. And then, you know, it's back to the UK, back to London, and back into an autumn of candidate selection.
SPEAKER_02Um I'm I'm part of the Green Party in the UK, and we're selecting our candidates to run in parliamentary elections, and we're trying to get lots of socialist candidates selected. So that is that is what I'm focusing on at the moment.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and you had a by-election and um also like a controversial vote in the Green Party recently. Um, do you feel comfortable maybe talking a little bit about that and like how you think that's potentially affecting your work right now?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, for sure. I mean, we so we had we had a by-election, which in the UK is where you have uh an election for one singular MP when a member of parliament resigns midterm. And our leader, Zach Polansky, contested it. Unfortunately, we lost it. We got a we got a good vote share, but unfortunately we lost it in part because the new Labour government has a new leader, and the burnt is very popular. And you know, after we lost that, obviously all of the right-wing papers said, Oh, Zach Polansky must resign. It's the end of Zach Polansky, and lo and behold, Zach Polansky is still here and still
SPEAKER_00alive.
SPEAKER_02Still alive, still going, we just signaled it. And then we had a motion go to our conference um entitled Zionism is Racism, which I think actually originally was based on a DSA motion. So Yeah, I
SPEAKER_00probably um resolution well, we've had a few anti-Zionist uh resolutions passed over the last few conventions, but I'm imagining this is uh based on resolution 22, which we actually recently have seen um debated and argued over in regards to uh the Los Angeles mayor's race. I won't get into all of that, especially because
SPEAKER_02it's
SPEAKER_00extremely fresh and
SPEAKER_02that's
SPEAKER_00not what this topic is,
SPEAKER_01but
SPEAKER_00it is about kind of holding um, well, essentially holding candidates accountable for um supporting BDS. So yeah, if you if you don't mind talking just a little about that before we get into everything else, I think our listeners would be curious.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, for sure. I mean, look, there were definitely there were definitely lots of different views on the motion, and the left in the party was quite split on it as well. Um, some of the left that had a more like a stronger anti-imperialist band and for whom Palestine was a bigger issue, really backed the motion. Other people were more cautious about it. I think I think it's definitely the case that it's picked off a massive conversation, and you know, like there are people in the UK now talking about Zionism that that were definitely not talking about it before, and that kind of what Zionism is and its ideology has kind of like come into the light.
SPEAKER_02There are still some concerns that it pushes the party away from focusing on quote unquote more material or majoritarian issues, like there's a huge cost of living crisis here, and that that is the thing that's really biting. But yeah, I'm I'm although it was pretty controversial at the time, I think the party has come through it really well. And it hasn't, you know, we haven't descended into factionalism in a way that maybe we could have.
SPEAKER_00That's great, that's really good to hear. And um also once the vote happened, I just saw a few headlines and then was kind of like, oh, and so I'm really glad that you're here to talk to us about that. Um, one thing that I think is interesting is that it seems like socialist debates are uh finding resonances all over. Um, just the same kind of like, do we focus on these more sometimes called cultural issues or social justice issues at the expense of materialist issues or the issues that are more considered to be more popular?
SPEAKER_00We're definitely having those kinds of things right now. But DSA is also doing gangbusters right now. Today we're recording on American Election Day, the first Tuesday in November. And it's a huge one because this is considered to be an election, midterm election that is a referendum on Trump, a referendum on um his water carriers in both parties, I think, um, as well as just kind of like more broadly a test of DSA's popularity. What we're we've also seen in um recent weeks are several polls coming out showing that socialism broadly has gained more popularity than ever, 43% according to the last Gallup poll.
SPEAKER_00That um a recent poll by The Economist in Ugov has shown that we are, you know, we're we could potentially have one in two voters. Um, it said 50% of Americans would pull the lever for a democratic socialist. So this is historic, right? Like we already know because of the primary wins we've already had, and that we kind of touch on and discuss a little bit um in the panel, from what I can recall. We already know that DSA is like becoming a household name.
SPEAKER_00Um, obviously, we've been splashed all over the right. Um Trump now has a website, whitehouse.gov slash socialism, where he takes our program and dissects it. Um obviously it's bullshit, but like um it also just shows how um broadly we are both appealing and also scaring, I think, you know, establishment um politicians. So we're gonna we're gonna watch those midterms roll in. Joe probably will be asleep by the time there's anything interesting going on, but you'll wake up in the morning and find out what's what's happening.
SPEAKER_00And progressives, people who aren't uh DSA or DSA endorsed are also um probably gonna win major uh positions in the government, such as Abdul Al-Sayed in Michigan. It looks um not to be like predictive or anything, but it does currently look like he has great prospects, predictive in the past because people will be listening to this in two weeks. And so whatever is happening, happening. But kind of more broadly, in the context of that, on the occasion of this historic uh test of socialism, what do you think that our victories, um, because we will have them, um, and also, you know, kind of more broadly, this uh potential sweep of the GOP means for DSA and socialist politics going forward.
SPEAKER_00I mean, Joe, part of the reason why you wrote, or a big impetus, I guess, for why you wrote your paper was because DSA is kind of inspiring uh people across Europe, maybe even in you know, in other countries for sure. You know, you talk to comrades from South America and stuff, they're like, we love DSA and everything. So maybe just a little about what you think about this today. Um, Joe, if you want to go first, I'd be interested to hear about like what what people are talking about over there or kind of what you think about today and
SPEAKER_02what
SPEAKER_00we're doing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, for sure. Yeah, yeah, for sure. I mean, I think so. I haven't been following the mid term super closely, but I think it is for me, it just reinforces this idea that leaders are incredibly important in in modern politics. That we, you know, we we exist in this heavily mediatized politics where people are watching clips all the time and spending loads of time on their phone, and social media, as much as we may hate it, hasn't become just so so so important. And I think it means that having these charismatic figureheads, whether they be Mamdani or AOC, or I I know it's not necessarily a DSA endorse, but Abdel al-Saif becomes incredibly important.
SPEAKER_02And then we I look to our own institutions and socialist organizations in the UK, and actually the organizations we have are very, very bad at producing these leaders, is why I'm doing what I'm doing now, is because we have this institutional problem where these leaders don't come through organically, we don't have the trade union movement producing working class autodidacts anymore, like that that just doesn't exist. The Labour Party awarded people who were loyal to the right cliques rather than the people who are actually very competent and could be good members of parliament. So, yeah, like we're just we're really we're really looking at what's going on and thinking, wow, these these inspiring socialist leaders are really important and we need to we need to find our own.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, David, actually, um speaking of the production of leaders in the trade union movement, you mentioned before we started recording that you were just in Maine knocking doors for Troy Jackson, without saying anything about whether or not he has prevailed. Um maybe you can talk a little bit about that, given that, you know, you wrote about Eugene Debs and like it's kind of like one of your major interests is like talking about somebody from the union or somebody from the the union movement um who can actually wear those two hats, and maybe something about what you're thinking in regards to what these um, you know, this kind of blue wave, but then also a little red wave within the blue wave is doing uh for us today.
SPEAKER_00A
SPEAKER_01pink tide, if you will, or at least a new one.
SPEAKER_00A pink,
SPEAKER_01a purple
SPEAKER_00tide, actually.
SPEAKER_01Yes, purple tide. Um so I got a chance to go up with some DSA from New York just as volunteers. Um, not anything official with the chapter to canvas for Troy Jackson, who's the labor tr uh candidate, also the Democratic nominee for U.S. Senate after um a very ill to say eventful primary. Um and uh he it was it was just but it was really great as usual to be not only with comrades but also just with other unionists because it was an AFL CIO canvas.
SPEAKER_01Um and it was, and I just remember one door, it's a guy who doesn't want to vote. I don't know if I really moved him, but when he saw he's like, oh, he's a labor guy, I was
unknownlike,
SPEAKER_01yeah, he was like, he's for workers' rights, and that's why I'm here because he's actually like someone who comes from the union movement. He's not just someone who says he's pro-union. And you could see that how the guy was moving, and he really did believe that you know labor movement would be better for him. It's just really that people, understandably in Maine are obviously one, totally inundated with that. Was this a thing I heard from all the voters that they were just exhausted and kind of it reminded me of actually an anti-union campaign um where like you just overwhelm the voter, so they end up just voting for the status quo because they just want the thing to end.
SPEAKER_01But he but you can just still tell there's like a noise that you can cut through with labor candidates. Um, and that made me at least hopeful um as we start running more people like Claire Valdez, who is the DSA member for we have her on
SPEAKER_00her, and she has one.
SPEAKER_01Yes, yes, yes, uh, who will like be winning tonight um as we we could safely predict that who
SPEAKER_00safely predict, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, UAW staffer and member coming for first a member, um, and really someone who was a cadre candidate really was part of the DSA rankophile as well. And those kind of and I remember that's what moved my union to endorse her earlier when before other unions hadn't was that that she had been a trade unionist herself, that she was being backed by Sean Fain. Like that does matter to workers um in kind of helping us bridge the divide. Um, I'm also just excited in general about seeing how we do the we as DSA in these elections.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I think we can be there's only like a hand, there's maybe one, for example, we're talking about just the federal midterms with uh the LA race, where we don't truly know, but we can basically assume there'll be like six or seven at least uh Congress people in DSA. And I what I've been saying to people, to folks, is like this is like much better than the old DSA ever did, um, in terms of like maybe topping off at two. Um, and what's been interesting for me just to see too is like how people are talking about it, both internally and externally in DSA, about how it relates to politics in general.
SPEAKER_01Like I was listening to NPR and NPR, they were talking about Republicans, we're talking about DSA, like you were mentioning earlier. It's like because Trump is talking about DSA so much, and so I'm excited. Um, and I will say like one thing we didn't mention in the beginning, what we're working on is like that you know, there will be uh a program over the next two years called like the left wing of the possible, which is like using Michael Harrington, the one of the DSA founders, as like a retrospective tool. And I think one of the things we want to examine that I've been seeing, because this can't just be because it should be about debates and reflections and uh analysis, is like what is why are we now seeing the most socialists in Congress?
SPEAKER_01Like, what has changed? What has like led people, voters particular in the Democratic primary to make this happen? And I think when this is election is over and we kind of have a better sense of like how that's ripple effects that are happening, like it's gonna be really, really important for us to have these structured debates that with the and with MPAC and other people uh to really analyze where we're going because it's really unprecedented in a very exciting way, but also a way where I can't even I'm not gonna be I'll be mild enough to say, like, I don't know where this is headed.
SPEAKER_01So uh we'll see, we'll we'll have a lot more to discuss, I think, in the coming weeks for sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I also think it's worth noting, which you know, many of our listeners will already know this, but DSA is also on a historic upswing and like consistently gaining members, um, you know, kind of hand over fist. I mean, we have these usual election bumps, but then while it waned, it didn't like drop, you know, like people are really
SPEAKER_01finding
SPEAKER_00out about us and joining. And we just hit over 400,000 uh unique visitors to our program site, which is like for a DSA website, pretty historic. But all of this so-called negative press, I mean, John Hannity also had DSA's program like on his blog the other day and stuff. It only drives people to towards us. Either they become curious about us um and want to find out more, um, or you know, people are like, this is what I've been looking for, and they want to join. And then all the people who are willing to vote.
SPEAKER_00I mean, it was just striking, you know, like reading all these polls at first, you know, a couple weeks a couple months ago when we were talking. I think that uh New York Times had put out something with the headline of like only 25% of people support democratic socialists showing its unpopularity or something like that. And like one in four people
SPEAKER_01one
SPEAKER_00in four people prefer, like DSA. And I think that like over time, like just to kind of go off what Todd was saying, we have all of these different like kind of tactics to for the ultimate strategy of like mass action and getting people moving towards socialism. Are elected are some of those people. Um, and then we're building this bench. You know, tonight we're also gonna see city council races, we're gonna see um state representatives, we're gonna have uh Robert Bell, who has is the presumptive nominee for Kentucky State House on class in a couple of days to talk about the elections, um, which I'm excited about because he's great and I'm friends with him too, but also because he also has a very astute and Louisville DSA is one of these chapters that isn't New York City, that isn't Los Angeles, that has like an electoral program, you know, sort of par excellence, right?
SPEAKER_00Like they actually have like these committed cadre candidates, they have an incredible um, you know, kind of uh attack stance against like, you know, normal Democrats, but as well as the right in a red state, you know. I mean, Louisville is a blue island in a red state, but it also like goes to show that socialism is for everyone and it can be for everyone. And the more that we kind of put that out into the world, that's what people are going to remember, and they're going to continue to kind of be like, wow, I'm really curious about them and what they really stand for.
SPEAKER_00I want to find out more, which to me is kind of better than relying solely on elections. But we're still excited for the elections. So, you know, I'm I'm really uh looking forward to it. I'm getting uh my vaccine today, too. So I'll be lying on the couch in luxury, drinking tea or something while I'm Watching those rolling. Um, finally, I just wanted to ask you guys in general, um, anything that has shifted for you opinion-wise, or if like any like questions arose? Because when we finished our discussion back in September, kind of like left it on a all right, this is an opening.
SPEAKER_00We like started like sort of talking about this, but um, yeah, maybe just leave us with a couple of takeaways or anything that you've been thinking about recently um before we get into it.
SPEAKER_02I think a I think a shift for me and maybe for other party oriented socialists in the UK is I think after seeing popularity organizers program, and also seeing the the importance of uh the Francis Amusers program, which was really much hell and is a kind of acting uh movement. I think we're really looking seriously in the Green Party Green Party uh what it would mean for us to put together a program.
SPEAKER_02I think this was especially not just a manifesto, but like a broader, you know, transitional program. And I think this was especially important in light of us having a new Labour government here where you know we have anti-band as prime minister, the press applauded him as having uh a vision, as it were. His vision is incredibly mean, obviously. But you know, lauded him as doing this kind of visionary politician, and I think he's able to seem like a visionary politician because he's operating in a void where no other party or politicians are looking forward to.
SPEAKER_02So I think I think yeah, I think he's really on that how we can how we can do that.
SPEAKER_01I think what I mean about more and more since we last mad is that we in DSA and I think the social left in general should also still be considering that some of our excess is also the collapse of civic society. And I think we talked about it a bit in our talk in a little bit, and we've and I've addressed it in like a response I did to Harold Myrrison in the American Prospect when he was like, Why aren't all these people joining DSA? And I was
unknownlike,
SPEAKER_01Why aren't these people joining anything? Um and then you know we have to remember that I think you see this in New York a little bit, but like it was it was reflecting also going to Maine and like there were trade unions there, but um, I was deeply impressed, for example, like uh how DSA runs elections, and not just like New York, I'm talking about Mikhail and I have gone to she knows like going to Jersey City, and it's the same very methodical, like people volunteers know what to do, and there were points where we had to be like So what do you people are asking the question?
SPEAKER_01So, what do you do if no one's home? And it's like and like we have really maintained this part of civic society that is kind of being atrophied and forgotten. Um, and that is like so we have to keep that a little humble in that like it's great that we've done it, but it's not there's some people have also abandoned it, and we need to also be still scaling up, and I think that's teaching, and that's not just as we were saying, it's not just elections, it's also like trade unionism, housing organizing, just like still continuing to build the left flank there, and I think that's like really still more and more uh appreciate the critical role socials are playing in just like teaching long-term skills to activists.
SPEAKER_01Whether they end up staying in DSA or not, like it's really critical um for us to put that into context about like why we're succeeding. It's partly some people have abandoned this, but also that then we even have a greater moral responsibility in maintaining um these abilities across different movements.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and also, you know, keeping that institutional knowledge alive, which
SPEAKER_01is
SPEAKER_00part of why we have like empack actually. It's like try to like you know distribute that stuff more widely. Um, well, thank you so much for coming on to give context to what's what our listeners are about to hear, which is the old being reborn. Welcome everyone. My name is Michaela. I am the current chair of DSA's National Inclusible Education Commission. Um DSA since 2017, as many people have been uh first for me
SPEAKER_03bloom. Um welcome everyone. We're here for the old being reboard, and I can't remember the rest of the subtitle. But um basically, this is a discussion around uh DSA should and the reverse. Um DSA is a 44-year-old institution. Oh, by the way, the announcements that normally come before are not taped to the podium. Hopefully, all of you have been to a few of these already and already have them memorized, but I can't read them out because they're not here.
SPEAKER_03Um basically it's uh be mindful of your masking unless you're speaking, um, and then also don't record. This is being recorded, but don't record yourself. Thank you. Um so DSA is a 44-year-old institution. It came into existence through a merger of the Democratic Socialist Organizing Committee and the New American Movement in 1982. Um so, yay, us, 44 is good age. Um, but it's really over the last 10 years that has experienced first a massive resurgence through the first uh Bernie Sanders presidential campaign in 2015 and 2016, and then these uh periodic sort of surges of growth that, while not altogether consistent, have built a visible and increasingly viable political home and political alternative for the left and for those seeking uh solace and uh sort of like desperate refuge from the oppressive two-party system in Latin America.
SPEAKER_03So this is a really exciting moment for us. I was just notified that the we just released a new program. Um, some of them are available in the back, but uh since it was released in July, we have just hit over 300,000 human visitors to our website, um, meeting human visitors, not blocks, and not free visits, um, which shows that people are, even though we're being you know, sort of non-stop pilloried in the right wing and the centrist media, people are incredibly curious about what we have to offer here in the US.
SPEAKER_03We have well over 120,000 dues paying members, um, which is huge. This is the biggest that any socialist party has ever been in the United States, obviously proportional to population, but it's still incredible, right? And then, you know, we have the DSA difference. We have all of these people who are being elected to office. We have doubled or over doubled our likely presence in Congress. Um, just this year, we're going to have four people going to Congress who are open socialists running on the DSA under the DSA banner.
SPEAKER_03Um, and there's with all of that growth, of course, there's so much excitement, so much hope, but also a lot of DSA should, right? DSA should do this, DSA should do that, DSA should be more like these people, that people, the Labour Party of the UK, the Greens in the UK, um, more like uh, you know, in Suisse in France. However, it also goes in the reverse. A lot of parties in the you know wider world are saying we should be more like DSA and this, that, and the other way. A lot of those are filtered through, of course, really exciting news like Zahan Mamdani winning the mayoralship of New York City, massive news, of course, and so everyone's like, what did they do?
SPEAKER_03How did they do it? What's the DSA difference? So, this is a conversation that we're gonna have about sort of two ways of thinking about this comparisons to our American past, um, as well as a current, you know, group, um, a mass party cadre organization in Belgium called the Workers' Party of Belgium. And I'm just gonna turn it over to these guys to introduce themselves, but we have David Du Halde and Joe Tot. David is a comrade from way back, he's a DSA oldie, I guess, you know, relatively speaking.
SPEAKER_03Been in the organization for 20 years, and then Joe is here visiting us from the Green Party in the UK and has been um uh what did we call you a party operative? Is that okay?
SPEAKER_02That's a black conversation. A
SPEAKER_03Padre member of um sort of the Corbin uh Momentum um movement, and then through your party, and now he's um working in the socialist faction in the Green Party. So um I don't want to take up more of your time with that. What what's gonna what we're gonna do today is have these folks give their presentations about 10 to 12 minutes each flexibly. Then I'm gonna ask some questions and kind of get the conversation moving, and we're gonna move it out to y'all.
SPEAKER_03So it's we're a small group. Um I think that because we don't have a microphone and this is a small room, what I'm just gonna do is um whenever anyone wants to speak, I'm just going to try to remember the order unless I get confused, unless everyone's raising their hands at once, and then I'll ask you to come up and sort of stand, um, or however you want to do it. But yeah, we can handle this, right? All right, so let's get started. Um, we're gonna have uh David, I think, here first, right? And so please take it away, and then right after that, Joe, you'll just speak.
SPEAKER_03Okay?
SPEAKER_04Great, thank you. Thank you, Michaela. So, first of all, big thank you to all of you for being here. Good morning. I want to thank the Rosa Luxemburg Stiftel New York office with Julian, another wonderful representative, uh, for making our reports possible. Um, these uh research was funded by them, uh both myself and Joe. Um I also want to thank Michaela for all of her wonderful work in getting us together. Uh so just to quit myself quickly, uh I've been a member and also a DSA staff person. I've been on the national leadership, like some of our folks over there currently are, um, and also in the chair of the C3, the DSA Funds organization.
SPEAKER_04Uh, but I'm also a student of history, and I find um a lot of this really interesting. I'm happy to share it with you. So, my outline on my this talk briefly will be I'll go over my thesis, um, why I think also, second the second part, why I think consensus and organizational culture are important to understand and think about while we're doing this work, uh, why I did the report, kind of what I was reacting to, not just because of my interest in the subject, but things I wanted to push against. Um, what was some of my analysis? How did I reach these conclusions?
SPEAKER_04What kind of qualitative kind of state the steps that I did, and ultimately then concluding again why I think it's important to look at this stuff, why are we even discussing it? Uh, because I think it does have current relevance and for uh looking at the past. So my thesis uh in the long reroute comes to two things. But first, it's like why do I call it the long reroute? So it's one, it's a play on a book called The Long Detour by James Weinstein, a socialist scholar, but it's really because I feel that DS, the new DSA, as I'm defining as past 2016, is very much similar to the way US social organizations, primarily the Socialist Party, historically have existed and formed.
SPEAKER_04And that so it's a reroute, it's kind of going back to, and that DSA itself, the DSA Addicts part, was kind of the detour of that. And so what that means specifically is that DSA today has lots of organized factions, so the Socialist Party, some of those factions have viewpoints that are totally in opposition to each other, but they still exist under one room. Whereas the DSA I joined was very much out of a single strain of the democratic social tradition, had some different differences of opinion, but were not as great as the DSA you see today.
SPEAKER_04Um, and so there was a lot more consensus in that organization, which is uh unusual in the when I'm talking simply about like democratic socialist groups, not like cadre groups that we'll talk about with the PTB. And my other thesis is that there's usually one central question in the US socialist movement at a time, that's really the dividing question. So that can be, and that changes over time. So what I don't go into the paper, but I mentioned is it could be the Vietnam War, which ultimately split the Socialist Party of America into three different factions, one that one that became DSA, but that's a so as long as the question does not get resolved.
SPEAKER_04Um, what I would say is a hundred years ago that question was the labor movement or labor strategy, while there was consensus around doing independent politics, specifically outside of the Democratic Party. Um I signed is this Warner Sombark, who maybe some of you have read him or heard of him when we when you're undergraduate, who says, like, there's no socialists in America because people love, you know, he has a scary line about roast beef and apple pies, and there's no socialist utopian speech built on that. But he actually says also, too, even though he's not bullish on the socialist chances, he says that there is no difference between the parties at the time.
SPEAKER_04Like he really felt like the Democratic-Republican parties were very regional, very not coherent. Whereas now I don't think that's the case, we can get into that. Whereas I feel the debates then were much more about do you build the industrial workers of the world, do you build industrial unions, kind of represented by the IWW and Debs for Eugene Debs for a time, or are you born within the American Federation of Labor, because there's no CIO then, uh, represented by the sewer socialists? Whereas now I feel there's much more consensus, even though there are differences, and I'm trading this myself, so we can get it.
SPEAKER_04But really, the rank and file strategy, which we'll get into, is like the defining overarching strategy that DSA takes. So, why do I think it's important to look at consensus and organizational culture? Um, I think so. When I'm talking about consensus, I think it's easy to forget that when we have unity on something, and it's usually it's an organizational-cultural thing, and we kind of forget about it. It gets in the background, it's not in our minds. So, like, going back to the uh union example is like people know not to cross a picket line. They know, like, oh, we're supposed to buy union-made goods when we do things.
SPEAKER_04These aren't things that we debate, they're just things that we do or don't do, because organizational cultures watch what you don't do. So those kind of great points of unity can kind of get lost, and people can kind of fixate on what is the differences between us. Um, and those, even if those are small, they become, they can seem very large because you can kind of lose the bigger picture. So, one example that I give that made me start thinking about this was when I was writing a few years ago in our quarterly online journal, the Socialist Forum, I said, like, you know, I started noticing, I was like, you know, we're not actually advocating forming new unions.
SPEAKER_04By that I mean not like new organizing, I'm talking about like things that are totally different outside the existing trade unions that exist in this country. Because we do actually get involved in unions, maybe start new unions, but it's usually with uh existing organized labor. And I was like, but we're asking people to maybe long-term build a new party. I was like, why is that? Why are and we started that's what started kind of getting me to think about this. And so I think that you, and so it's important also for people who aren't in DSA to know what some of these debates are, so I'll do my best to summarize them, specifically around the electoral questions that are that are most dividing the organization.
SPEAKER_04And I say that in more as like in people having time radically differences, but they can get intense. Is that officially we have this dirty break strategy, which is the idea that DSA will kind of use the Democratic Party line, not necessarily infrastructure, to elect people, as Michaela was mentioning, to Congress, but also hundreds of people to state offices. Um eventually that can be built up to, you know, whether we're forced out or whether we do it on our own, form a new party. So that's called the dirty break. There are some people who advocate for like a clean break, just like we'll do it right now. But those are really in the minority.
SPEAKER_04Um, it's very much the dirty break, is kind of this position, but um, but you would say that like, but then there's real differences of like, do you do it when do you do it? How do you do it? Like, that's when you start getting the debates. So, and I looked at this also by uh preparing my paper for the 2025 DSA convention. So I looked at like the different resolutions and amendments to resolutions that were coming up to kind of do an analysis to show, kind of support, like, am I right that like I'm seeing these differences?
SPEAKER_04And what I noticed was that like of the 90 resolutions, 10 were about labor. Whereas electoral politics, a quarter about electoral politics and difference within electoral politics. And of the amendments, it went up to 30%. So that was that alone I could see like a quantitative difference between like what the conventional delegates were discussing there. And but I think it's important, so that's okay, so I made my point. Great, thanks. Why does this matter?
SPEAKER_04And I think that this matters because for me, I was kind of seeing that people, especially some of the people from the old guard, like me, who were in DSA in 2016 before, were trying to understand DSA and they were misunderstanding it. And they were especially looking at, going back to my point about the factions, they were looking at the factions, the caucuses, the internal formal groupings, and saying that this is a entryism. So, what is entryism? So, entryism is the idea that you have groups on the outside that are going in to either change an organization from to be in its own image or to like create a split in the organization, something, it's usually a negative connotation.
SPEAKER_04And what and I just didn't feel that was that they were actually getting what was happening correctly. And I felt that it was much more like the Socialist Party where you would have factions that could be borrowing from outside traditions or could be associated broadly with other currents abroad, but really were people who were organic to the organization, like DSA is DSA, the Socialist Party was their first and only home. They were doing politics through that. And that and that these the old guards especially were making these comparisons to the Students for Democratic Society, this campus group, which is not just a campus group, but it's a large mass organization from a half a century ago that was destroyed by introdism.
SPEAKER_04And I said that that analogy was flawed for a few reasons. One is that SDS in its existence, whole existence, not counting at the time it was most factuous, is shorter than the new DSA is existence. So already the new DSA has shown to be more sustainable than SDS. Two, SDS is not, was just a student organization, whereas DSA is a multi-generational organization, still heavily younger, sometimes exkewed older when I joined, with a canvas wing. So it's already the demographics are apples to apples.
SPEAKER_04And I would say lastly, I just want to reiterate the point I made again, too, was that it is ultimately it's a community-based group that does multiple issues. Whereas SDS could do multiple issues, but ultimately could not resolve questions, it could not resolve how we want to approach the Vietnam War and split. So that's where I felt like those, and the DSA has structures in which, through the conventions, through local chapter autonomy, that democratic decisions can be resolved. They're not always done in making hands, but they're like, they are, there is a resolution that SDS wasn't able to attain for whatever reasons that we don't have to spend too much time in today.
SPEAKER_04And so I think this is important, and I'll end here, because I want to make sure Joe gets to talk with you. I want to hear from you guys too. Like, why does this matter? I think it matters because I think misunderstanding history and misunderstanding the organization makes us make bad decisions and bad analysis going forward. And I think in that to why I felt like I think the comrades who I'm closer to probably in day-to-day politics, I push against, they're the ones I'm actually pushing back against a lot of this paper because I feel they're misunderstanding DSA, misunderstanding how you can intervene to make a difference. And I think it's important for us, whether you're socialists in or outside of DSA, because my paper was written also for people outside of DSA, why the Germans Foundation supported it, because you understand where DSA fits in US history, and that there can be kind of this what I'll say is presentism, or like you know, just looking so immediately back, only looking back so far and trying to find analogs, comparisons, that you can kind of miss the whole picture.
SPEAKER_04So I will stop there and I'll hand it over to Joe. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_02Okay, if the slides work, it will be a very
SPEAKER_05good thing.
SPEAKER_03We've already tried it once. I
SPEAKER_02know, but I'm just sure. I'm just sure something has gone wrong in the internet, but we'll see.
SPEAKER_05Uh yeah, turn on the T turn on the root button?
SPEAKER_03Um I didn't really look where you told me to. Okay.
SPEAKER_02Okay, that's my whole talk. You don't have to. Okay, I'm Joe Todd. Thank you so much for having me. It's great to be in the US. I very rarely get to be here. Um if I start mumbling, just tell me, because I'm British and we have a tendency to mumble. So genuinely just like, shut up. Um it is, yeah, it's reasonable to describe me as kind of like a Corbyn, your party, Green
SPEAKER_06Party cader in the UK. I've been part of all these party projects. Mainly I keep switching because they keep failing. And because they keep failing, we look abroad for inspiration, uh, we look abroad for inspiration. A lot of us have been looking to the US and to the Democratic Socialists of America. Lots of people, um, very intenly interest in what you guys are doing. But we also looked at the continent, we looked to Belgium, we looked to France, we looked to Spain. And I basically ended up writing this report because when we were in the position of trying to found your party, which I don't know, have people heard of your party, like Zara Sultana Jackson, RP?
SPEAKER_06Yeah, RRP. This didn't last very long, we can talk about that if it's interesting. But when we were forming your party, lots of people referencing the DSA and the Belgian Workers' Party as the two organizations we want to be like. It's like we want to be like the DSA because we're doing all this great stuff, and we want to be like the Belgian Workers' Party because they have this Marxist cater that drives the organization. But there was very little understanding that these organizations are actually. Different, like they're just not very similar organizations at all. And even on their own terms, people didn't really understand, you know, like what each organization was about, how its structure works, how its structures work, and also what was not so good about each organization as well.
SPEAKER_06Like the positives often get communicated quite strongly and they make it across borders, the negatives less so. So this is why I wrote this report, mostly for British comrades. It's really cool that other people are interested in it. I apologize that the pictures are not very generous towards the DSA. But like the picture of the PCD makes it look incredible. They're like, oh, it was so well organized, etc. etc. The picture at the top makes the DSA look a bit droopy. I don't think that, I don't think the DSA is droopy, I think the DSA is great.
SPEAKER_06But the RLS are very into copyright, and you know you can't use it in copyrighted images. Anyway, why are we talking about Belgium? Belgium's a tiny country in Europe, a long way away. It basically has no geopolitical significance. They make great waffles, they have beautiful architecture, but like why are we talking about Belgium? The reason we're talking about Belgium is because of these guys, the Belgian Markets Party. Founded in there's actually different dates, but I think like 69, 71. Um, they've been a party for 49 years now, and they are actually incredibly successful.
SPEAKER_06Um they now have 25,000 members, which if you were to translate that into US terms, it would be 725,000 members adjusting population difference. Yeah, I thought I'd get a good reaction from that. Um they top the polls in Brussels, so they're like 25% in Brussels, so they're topping the polls in Brussels, and they're quite close in other regions. They have 50 parliamentary seats, and I think the most interesting thing for us is that they do all of this
SPEAKER_02whilst being an explicitly Marxist party.
SPEAKER_06So
SPEAKER_02they do not hide the fact that they're Marxists. Here in the Brussels Times, um, you know, they're talking about we're Marxists in a Belgian source,
SPEAKER_06which
SPEAKER_02sounds kind of disgusting, but
SPEAKER_06I kind
SPEAKER_02of get I kind of get what they're getting at.
SPEAKER_06And I think, yeah,
SPEAKER_02and I think
SPEAKER_06it's just I find this
SPEAKER_02really
SPEAKER_06interesting because they basically haven't followed the trajectory of either the old European Communist parties or the new populist movements from the 2010s. So you have like lots of old European Communist parties who, over the years, and after successive failures, liquidated their politics. They became kind of indistinguishable from social democratic parties, they'd often enter coalitions and governments with social democratic parties. Some of them turned quite far to the right on migration and social issues. They didn't want to do that. They didn't want to do that. And then you have the populist parties of the 2010s, so Sarriza in Greece or Podemos in Spain, Jeremy Corbyn's Labour in the UK.
SPEAKER_06And those parties, although they had a kind of socialist core to them, they often tried to hide it. They often had this orientation around the people rather than the class. They would often not use red, you see colours like purple, purple, they love purple, like purple's always the light populist party colour. Um, and they tried to build these kind of like big, spectacular movement-style parties which didn't have much of a kind of core membership and kind of I would say lacked in political ideology sometimes. Um, a lot of those parties have failed in various ways, and now the PTB, along with the Forest Institute Museum in France, which we can talk about if you want, but along with the BTB are the kind of the two left projects in Europe that are at the forefront and are really interesting.
SPEAKER_06So, yeah, that's why we're talking about them. And I'm basically going to emphasize three different things that I think was just really, really important for this modern iteration of the Belgian Markets Party, which maybe we and DSA Comrades and other
SPEAKER_02people can learn from. Number one, the Refounding Congress in 2008. So they had a big Congress in 2008. For decades and decades and decades, they were, in the words of one staff member, a little party with a big head, is how they described it. So there were not many people in the party at all, it was really quite sectarian, they were very ideologically
SPEAKER_06coherent, and they would go to picket lines and they would go out to the worker class and they'd tell them all about Mao and they would tell them all about China or whatever, and people wouldn't really listen. They didn't have like a mass space at all, and this was this was a problem they wanted to change it. So they had this big congressional process that I think ran for four years, so from 2004 to 2008, onto all the party's cater, and they basically decided to re-found as a mass party. I don't know why they decided to put pictures of three Belgian children on the front of the Congress document, but nevertheless that's what they decided to do.
SPEAKER_06They're very flexible. Yeah, apparently they're very flexible, and they basically came up, they came up with this concept of like we want to be a principled, flexible party of the working class. So I think I think the last bit is kind of obvious, they want to be a mass working class-oriented party, but the principled flexible bit is interesting, right? Because those two words are often in contradiction. It's like, are we going to be pragmatic and flexible, or are we going to be principled and ideological? They're trying to do both. And I think the way they primarily achieve this is through introducing this basically structured levels of engagement and membership.
SPEAKER_06They don't have one flat layer of membership. In the DSA, if you're a member of the DSA, you're a member of the DSA. Obviously, you can have positions in committees or you can be part of a caucus or whatever, but nevertheless, you know, a member is a member, right? And this is also the case for most left parties in Europe. The PTB said, no, we don't want to do this. What we want to do is that we want to try and maintain our kind of very ideological, very trained up, caterized core, and that's around two, two and a half thousand people that sit in this militant layer right in the middle.
SPEAKER_06Um, but then we want to have these kind of more relaxed, easier ways to engage with the party, so you don't have to be a cater. You know what I mean? Like you don't have to have that really high level of commitment to the party to engage with it, to identify with it. And they came up with these three letters. So they have a they have a broader support to that on the outer, which is roughly 15 to 20,000. These people don't have any obligations or responsibilities in the party. They just pay 20 euros a year, they get the magazine, they can come to protests, they can come to actions, but they're it's a very casual relationship, right?
SPEAKER_06If you're a member, you have to turn up to your base group meeting once a month. They have a fantastic mechanism where you pay your dues in person at the meeting. So if you don't go to the meeting, you're not a member anymore because you haven't paid your dues. It's really cool. Like I really like it. So it's like you have to come to the meeting, you pay your dues to the meeting, you're expected to go to the meeting once a month, turn up to actions, help organize stuff, but it's still a maybe you know five to ten hour week commitment. It's not a, you know, it's not a really like high-level commitment.
SPEAKER_06Then there's the militant there. So the militant now are the lad that really drive the party, and they submit themselves to a volunteer wage cap. So they only take 2,040, 2,400 euros a month from their wage, and that's you know, 28,000, 30,000 euros a year, and they give everything above that to the party. So they give everything above that to the party as a sign of their commitment to the party, understanding that the party needs to raise its own funds to be able to do stuff. And these people will be the people that run the committees, these people will be people who are like at the top of the party, they're really dedicating their lives to it, and they're giving probably 20 hours a week plus to the party.
SPEAKER_06This is how I think they've managed to, in the words of one political theorist, and this is their big festival that they run every year, Manifiesta, 15,000 people come, this is one of their kind of like broad front organizations to get people involved. This is how they managed to have this kind of like core cater who are very ideologically aligned and very highly trained, whilst having this broad, in his words, united colours of Benetton approach, where like everyone can get involved, even if you don't really think yourself a socialist, just because you think it's cool or interesting, or you went to the festival and you know met a new friend or whatever.
SPEAKER_06There's this kind of like casual lair around it. Kind of like the mass award to part. Kind of like a mass or
unknownkind
SPEAKER_06of situation? I can't remember. Can
SPEAKER_03we save the questions until after?
SPEAKER_06Sorry, sorry. Um yeah, so I think this like this membership, it's not the only way they do it, but this membership structure is just really, really, really important to how they have what I would describe as this like Marxist core, but like populist outer, which I just haven't really seen any other party achieve, you know. Number two, they provide direct support, direct support, direct services to the people. So this is like a big, big debate in the UK, is how much we should be doing this at the moment. But they've run medical centres since the 70s.
SPEAKER_06Um they now have, I'm really bad at remembering figures, put the down here. They have 11 medical centres employing 220 staff members, which again is a tiny country, 220 staff members, treating 250,000 patients every year. So it's like a serious operation that they run. Um they do it because of a specific way in which the Belgian healthcare system is set up, which I won't go into because it's long, but basically they can get money from the state to run these medical centres. And there's two reasons they do it.
SPEAKER_06Number one, they think it's a really good opportunity to organize working class people. People come in with health issues that are because of their work, there might be repetitive strain injuries from cleaning, similar things, and they can then collectively organize the people that have those negative health outcomes. But the other reason is because they just don't think people trust political parties and politicians unless you actually do something for them that materially makes a difference to their day-to-day life. And they put down a lot of their success and then kind of a lot of their support amongst working class people in Belgium to the fact that they don't just ask them to vote for them, but they actually support them when they feel most vulnerable, really, which is like with their healthcare and with their medical stuff.
SPEAKER_06I think the thing to emphasize after having conversations with Commodore the last few days is that this should not be considered mutual aid. Like, this is not mutual aid insofar as it's some kind of horizontalist thing where people are helping people in a kind of anarchistic way. No, it's it's very directed by the party. It's a separate organization, but it's like focused and it's directed and it's planned. And yeah, so I think those two things should be thought for as separate. And then the third, oh, and I wrote an article on this for Jack Been,
unknownso
SPEAKER_06if you want to read more about it, you can. I'm just here to plug my work. And then the third thing, and we kind of talked about this, but I'll elaborate. The third thing is that they just have an incredible focus on building a dedicated and disciplined cater. They have this theory, which is basically like if we can't have, if we don't have thousands and thousands of people in the country who are at high levels of commitment and ideological alignment, we're never going to be able to take on capital, we're never gonna be able to take a state and you know, like actually be resilient enough to face all of the attacks that we'll face when we do that.
SPEAKER_06So they, you know, they focus on the base groups, and I think another thing to say about the base groups is they're all super small. They're only nine to eleven members, and when they get bigger than nine to eleven members, they split into other base groups. And the reason they do that is because they want to maintain relationships among small groups of people over time. So you go to your base group and you you know the people in your base group because it's the same nine to eleven people over and over again. They're often hyper like neighborhood level. So I'll be going to a base group with people in the two or three streets around where I live, or in my workplace.
SPEAKER_06They also have base groups in workplaces. Um, they put a ton of focus on building cater through political education and training. They have separate political education schools for blue-collar workers, as they do for what they call intellectuals or white-collar workers, because they see that these kind of groups need different support and they need to be in their own spaces. Um, and I think the final thing that I'll say is that they, I mean, you can talk about this more, but they are a democratic centralist organization, at least in a soft way. And what I mean by that is that they they have some form of internal democracy.
SPEAKER_06Like the militants are very, very strong, but they have some form of internal democracy. But once they come to a line and they've agreed that line, they will stick to it. And they will often say the same thing. Like it was quite hard researching them because you talk to different catering, different members who all talked anonymously because they weren't allowed to talk to me. And they would still say the same thing. It's still the same thing. I mean, it was totally the different opposite for the DSA. You guys say a load of different
SPEAKER_05things.
SPEAKER_06They said the same thing over and over again. And you know, we can talk about the benefits and downsides of that. There are obvious downsides to a democratic centrist organization for sure, but I think it means they do manage to maintain the sense of kind of like unity and focus, which they which they see is very powerful and very important.
SPEAKER_03Um, you're almost
SPEAKER_06I'm I'm done, this is my
SPEAKER_03answer. This is it.
SPEAKER_02Great. Just the final thing to the final thing to emphasize is that I understand that the PTB and the DSA are really different organizations. I'm not here to say you guys in the DSA should just be like the PTB. It's it's way more complicated than that. But I just think that some of these things are interesting and can be learned from, at least in a function sense. Thank you. Thank you.
SPEAKER_03Um people are urging with questions want to get started. I just want to pull together a few threads first. Um Something that I think many people in here in DSA are at least familiar with it, and you mentioned it, Joe. Like once you pay, you're in. And the internal democracy of DSA also means that anyone can be eligible to join in. As many people might know, chapters have very different entry points into this.
SPEAKER_03And um there have been efforts recently through the Democracy Commission reforms that were introduced at the convention last year that were researched over actually over two years, introduced in 2023, the committee formed and then issued the recommendations in 2025 where they studied other parties to figure out how they did things. Um, I can't recall at the moment whether or not the Workers Party was one of them, but I wouldn't be surprised if they didn't come up. Um, so that question of what like mass democracy looks like and how that then uh speaks out or like ideologically inflects like what people are trying to do whenever they're building, trying to build a democratic society, I think is a really interesting question.
SPEAKER_03Um, particularly given what David said is that there's often this students for a democratic society being like the sort of touchstone or like the the most like the thing that people go for instantly, probably in part because it's so like close in time. There's lots of people, maybe even even in this room, or at least at this conference, who are involved in organizing the SDS. So I guess I would like to maybe open it up into like your thoughts about the how the actual structures, the organizational structures of any party, we can you know touch on DSA just so everyone knows Joe writes a lot about DSA in his report.
SPEAKER_03He's not just writing like kind of the intro and then. I'm just a little too shy
SPEAKER_06to
SPEAKER_03be a report. I don't don't mean to like you know inflect on you guys. But you should be feel free to ask him anything opinion-wise, and I'm about to. What do you guys think is kind of the um the purpose of the party in reflecting a kind of mass democratic uh ethos outwardly? And how good a job do you think that either any party is doing on that? Because as we know, what you're saying, Joe, is that there's also this kind of like easy entry point into like the outer layer, and we do have the labor notes bullside that we often use to talk about like organizational structure where it's like people kind of come in through the outside and we try to bring them closer in.
SPEAKER_03But part of what we do in BSA is also try
unknownto
SPEAKER_03make sure that core doesn't stay stagnant, that people don't aren't compelled to stay in that core, but we are really building leadership, allowing people to step back and that kind of thing. So maybe just in general, your thoughts about this sort of mass democratic, like how closely should the party reflect something that we're also trying to bring out into the like agitate and bring out into um sort of the public to build like a more socialist view of what people should have, agency over their lives, that kind of thing. David, maybe you go first.
SPEAKER_03I'll go
SPEAKER_04first. Perfect. Um
SPEAKER_03that's a clear enough question. It's kind of
SPEAKER_04over Riff and then you can call me in about that. Um so one so there's lots to chew on there. And I think that going back to being a little repetitive to what I said, uh, just to reissue the frame to answer the question, is like there's lots of similarities I felt between the old Social Party in America, especially with its first 20 years. It's founded in 1901, um, and DSA Today in terms of the organized factions, the local economy, the differences. Um, I think what's really important to remember, too, and then I'll get to the question, but I think it's helpful, it's like the Socialist Party doesn't become irrelevant because it has like this giant fractional blow up per se.
SPEAKER_04It's like because of massive government repression. Um Socialist Party has lots of internal fights. I remember Austin and I teaching reactions, Austin, and I didn't even know. You know, it's like the right wing of the party at one point, who I call moderates the use euphemisms, you know, don't even recognize the election of the more radical people. The DSA doesn't have that problem right now. But um because like there's no because we can't predict the future. But it was interesting where DSA, at least right now, has like, you know, people recognize elections, people recognize election results internally. They can be very factious, but like when things are so that's an important part of also going back to us like consensus that people we take, we shouldn't take for granted that people actually can like be committed to like recognizing election results.
SPEAKER_04Um we don't have that in this country right now, we don't take that for granted. Um so but so the government requests is important to know because the Social Party was being very successful in the limited capacity it could to organize the class through trade unions, through um especially through elections, that there were limitations like that we are familiar with about the how the systems are run or how str how much how conservative unions can be. And I do think that DSA very much represents that kind of good tradition and that teaching people that it is a place where you can be democratically involved.
SPEAKER_04I think that gets to what Joe was talking about, where it's very weird. We were talking about in our prep session how like the media is often looking for like, is Zaron Mr. DSA? Like who's Mr. Miss or what gender neutral socialism term? Whereas like historically that was the case in the United States. So you
unknownhave
SPEAKER_04like Eugene Debs, he was followed by Norman Thomas, then Michael Harrington, who is the the head of one of the DSA chairs. You can have these kind of figures, whereas DSA, I would say it's like leaderful. Um, and I think that's a good thing. I think it's good that DSA is a democratic organization where people could step up. Um and I think that it's really wonderful that people are like, how can I get involved? But I do think it um but I want to hand with Joe there. I just wanted to emphasize too that a lot of sometimes it's important to remember that a lot of the problems that can kind of undermine social movements aren't actually the democracy in itself.
SPEAKER_04It's like you know, state repression, it's like people, other actors too. Um doesn't absolve us from not um doing a good job, but I think it these this is why I'd say it's important to look to these history lessons because right now we do have the burgeon
unknownof
SPEAKER_04a red scare, but it still is not anything like um what happened during the first world war. Like we're right now, so far, no one has been elected to DS office who's a DSA member who hasn't been able to sit sit in the office. That was like thing. I grew up knowing about New York, but then I learned in my research. Cleveland didn't, there were three city councillors, they were not allowed to sit. I mean, that's like next level that we should prepare for, but it um but there's something about. Sorry, Joe, go
SPEAKER_03ahead. Yeah.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, I mean I think I think it is how much of it is the purpose of the party to reflect mass democratic ethos? Yeah, I think it very much is. I think the PTB do it in a very different way to the DSA. I mean, you're talking about how the DSA, one of the amazing things about it is that a bunch of people that basically joined after Bonnie then suddenly just ran the organization really quickly, and you have this like incredible recomposition where it's like 80 or 90%, or maybe even more, of like the membership joined after bone.
SPEAKER_04Sounds like
SPEAKER_06that. I get 90%.
SPEAKER_04So it's like you
SPEAKER_06have this like wild recomposition, whereas you haven't had that in the PTB because to move up the ranks of the PTB, it's not just about how much work you do, although you do have to do work, um, and it's not about really winning democratic positions, it's more about agreeing with the existing direction of the PTB and having a conversation because you have to you basically get interviewed by someone who is a layer higher than you to move from membership to militant, and the militant kind of when they interview you kind of works out if you're a right fit for the PTB, and they kind of manufacture a bit of a consensus through that, you know?
SPEAKER_06And it's just very, very different in that regard. And that means they do struggle with a slightly ossified, they won't really talk about it, but they do struggle with a like an ossified layer in the middle, but they find it hard to get more people to move up to the militant layer. They find it hard to recruit millennials, actually, into that into that layer. Like that layer is a lot older. Whereas like in the DSA, millennials just seem, as far as I can tell, incredibly
SPEAKER_02dominant.
SPEAKER_03It's like the big chunk.
SPEAKER_06Yeah,
SPEAKER_03they're
SPEAKER_02incredibly dominant. And that and that is because of your guys' openness. Like that's that that's kind of how that happened. And the PCB would love that, but they also want to retain a certain control and a certain focus, and they're stuck in that tension, I think.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, great. Um, just another question. I mean, there's I'm I'm kind of curious about this labor versus electoral question. Or, you know, in the US, we kind of are always talking about the weakness of I would say weakened state, maybe, of the labor movement, right? I mean, and this also happened through state repression, but it also happened through like various other, you know, kind of um media propaganda. I remember my own father. Never joined a union even though he was in uh uh construction and was you know all around him because he just like unions are corrupt,
SPEAKER_04right?
SPEAKER_03So I do think that like in the US we do have we just don't have the social democratic history um that they have um in Europe, widespread in Europe, in Belgium, especially a parliamentary system, but also like a strong tradition of social democracy. Um, so I guess I just want to hear about that, the relationship between uh labor and the PTB. You talked about like the way blue-collar workers and white white-collar, but white-collar workers are also unionized in Belgium, probably, you know, pretty widely spread.
SPEAKER_03Um, but then also David's thoughts about like this relationship because a lot of times, and I do think that this is mostly um propagandized, but a lot of times people criticize DSA for being um you know not working class culturally or what have you. I do think that that's um largely false because a lot of people we don't have people with a lot of independent wealth or ability to um you know sort of rely on uh supervisory roles or what have you, but what we do have are a lot of people who are college educated, um, which is culturally considered not working class, even though that's rapidly changing.
SPEAKER_03So maybe just a conversation quickly about that, and then when folks want to start joining in the conversation, just raise your hand once these guys uh through talking. So clear enough?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, go ahead.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, so it's yeah, it's worth saying that as you said, like strong tradition of social democracy in Belgium, like the unions always seen as like a pillar of that social democracy to the extent that they a lot of the unions distribute uh their members' pensions after they leave their jobs, so they kind of have this like structural embeddedness into the state and into social democracy, which is really different to Britain, never mind, really different to here, but it's it's quite a unique thing, and it means that the PTB's approach to the unions is though again, I won't probably say this, but it is it is kind of one of trying to capture the top of those unions and kind of move them from part of the social democratic settlement into a new socialist settlement.
SPEAKER_06Like that's kind of their theory with that. Um, I'd say with the competition of their membership, though, and how much of their membership is white-collar rather than blue-collar, or college educators rather than um in a trade, or working in a in a manual trade, they suffer exactly the same problems that everybody else suffers in this regard. Like they struggle to recruit
SPEAKER_02non-college
SPEAKER_06educated
SPEAKER_02blue-collar
SPEAKER_06workers in the same
SPEAKER_02way as basically every
SPEAKER_06left-free project across Europe does.
SPEAKER_02As
SPEAKER_06far as I can tell, in the same way as you guys do. Like, this is not, as far as I can tell, like a failure of organization or organizational structure. It's a it's a more meta trend on the left. And that's not to say that we shouldn't try and overcome it, but I don't I don't think like structuring your organization in a different way is necessarily gonna completely kick that problem.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I was thinking about where to begin. Um such a great question. So one of the so kind of in the rosier kind of retellings of the Socialist Party, there's always these ideas, which are true that like the Socialist Party had a lot of like workers, um, especially garment workers. It's maybe like say if you grew up in New York and you're all the garment workers' unions, uh, but in general, it was really a working class party. Um but I think that, and then you look at DSA today and you're like, oh, and I just go saying like, oh, where are the workers?
SPEAKER_04And I think one is that it kind of ignores the fact that like shockingly work has changed in this country in the past 20 years. Like
SPEAKER_03that.
SPEAKER_04Um, that there we just don't, we have lots of industrial workers, but the percentage that people are actually in manufacturing, it's as part of like the whole workforce, has like gone down. And it's something you always notice when people are like, well, why aren't workers voting for like Democrats? Actually, new workers are. Um is there's so there's fewer and fewer of them in key industries. Um and also that some of these dynamics, when I was talking about the history rhyming, you would see in the Socialist Party. And Sean Good, who wrote a really good book on the Eugene Debs, um, he spoke yesterday. Um try on, I just read it to do a book review.
SPEAKER_04And one of the things that I really laughed, because it sounded exactly like today, where he was talking about like he was like, people would attack these socialists for being professionals of being like bourgeois, and the people attacking them were also professionals and bourgeois. And it was like, and it was a professional managerial discourse. I mean, it was just like 120 years ago, it's like who is attacking who is often this projection of like who has got a remote. So it's like
SPEAKER_03international socialism, isn't a Spider-Man.
SPEAKER_04Yeah,
SPEAKER_06yeah.
SPEAKER_04It sometimes can get lost in the sauce where like the Belgian sauce is the Belgian sauce, the American sauce, the Russian sauce. How much of these attacks are actually just loaded and they're not made? And that's why I think my history was like looking at like, well, what's actually happening? It's like, and by that, it's what's called like uh a posit uh a positive analysis. Like I'm not looking, I'm not actually trying to say like one is a good thing, one thing is a bad thing. I'm just saying like what is? And DSA has workers. I mean, the thing is that there are workers who are like, because of call because life has changed.
SPEAKER_04There's more white-collar workers. The percentage of the I'm a public sector worker in my J job. We represent the majority of the union movement now because of the way attacks, because for historic reasons. Like, why wouldn't DSA want to have a presence with public sector workers even if it's a white-collar uh job? And so I think that it's like who and and it being and what's interesting too about my position and how D and where it comes in is like I'm in a middle managers union because New York City still has very favorable labor laws when you compare it to the rest of the country, it's more like Belgium, where like the unions still have a lot of power, not only in like politically, but in how they double out benefits.
SPEAKER_04So there's still lots of leftists, but there's also lots of right-wing people in the union. And how do you have those struggles or very similar um and try to get people to think around class?
SPEAKER_00Thanks as always to our guests and our production crew, Ewan, Jordan, Michael, and Tim who put this all together. Class is a podcast of DSA's National Political Education Commission for NPEC, which works to expand the knowledge of DSA members and non-members in the service of winning the struggle for socialism and democracy. You can find out more about NPAC by searching for us online or following us on social media. But the best way to find out what our committee is up to is by signing up for Red Letter, NPEC's monthly newsletter. And if you aren't already, you can become a DSA member by following the link in the podcast description.
We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election,...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...
In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...