Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Class

Class artwork

A Real Democracy with Aziz Rana

Sep 28, 20261 hr 36 minAudio

Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake outrage and centrists hand-wring over “the DSA takeover." Upcoming Class episodes will zoom in on different planks and demands raised in our program with expert guests and organizers from across DSA and the left, and talk about the why, how, when, and exactly what society must change, as well as the role of Workers Deserve More in that change. On this episode, we talk with Aziz Rana, a professor of law at Boston College and the author of the recent book, The Constitutional Bind, about various demands for democratic reform, the histories and complexities of these interlocking demands, and the importance of socialists pointing the way to a radically just and equal socialist future. Read Workers Deserve More here. You can find out more about Aziz and his work here. Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01The thing that I would say in in sort of engaging with that is that the current way, like if we're just talking about the institutions as they currently exist, the current way that these institutions are organized is uh effectively undermines any premise of checks and balances. Because the way that the institutions are currently arranged, they facilitate this combination of minority rule at the national level with like intensifying the power of specific um state legislatures and like states at the state level, and making making it so that we have a far more aggressive and coercive president that's backstoped by a Supreme Court that's wildly out of step with the rest of the public.

SPEAKER_01I mentioned that Trump got to nominate and confirm three justices to the Supreme Court despite losing the popular vote and using a Senate confirmation process in which senators that voted folks that voted for Republican senators, 40-something million as opposed to over 50 million people voted for Democratic senators. Nonetheless, the the Senate was controlled by the Republican Party. And Democrats have only been able to nominate and confirm five justices to the Supreme Court since 1968. I mean, so this is um this is a system that is that is creating you know far more sort of like intensified forms of centralized power at the top in ways that are producing extreme rights violations.

SPEAKER_00Hi comrades, and welcome to CLASS, the podcast of Democratic Socialists of America's National Political Education Commission, or NPEC. My name is Michaela, and I'm the current chair of NPEC and a member of North New Jersey DSA. Before we dive in, a reminder that CLAS is available on all major podcast platforms. Please consider becoming a DSA member by following the link in the podcast description. You can also send us a message about the episode and sign up for Red Letter, NPEC's monthly newsletter, using the provided links. Since DSA's political program, Workers Deserve More, was launched two months ago, it's been directly featured or referenced in one or more mainstream news stories, interviews, or opinion pieces almost every day.

SPEAKER_00To date, nearly 325,000 unique human visitors have come to the program site with over 600,000 page views. The vast majority of these visits are from search, individuals using key terms on Google or another search engine to find it. What does this indicate? The people hear or see something about our program and are looking for it to check it out for themselves. DSA now has 125,000 dues-paying members, with almost 24,000 joining in the last two and a half months since workers deserve more went viral after a right-wing leak of our preliminary draft language.

SPEAKER_00As our opponents and some of the more cautious or skeptical on the left have tried to either denigrate or have bemoaned certain parts of our program as being too radical, too woke, or too unrealistic, evidence on the ground so far has shown that the program is being received positively. There are many factors in DSA's growth. Often elections are a major driver, and that's the case here, but it would be difficult to say that the explosive, sustained growth over the past two and a half months, outpacing the previous period by a factor of three, is somehow harmed by this new item in the news cycle that's driving the right to distraction and causing serious consternation within the Democratic Party.

SPEAKER_00Many are finding out what Democratic socialists believe and what we want for the future by reading our own materials, and this can only be a good thing. Even with the sunniest outlook and the best efforts, any socialist program will have barriers to reception. This is a program designed to provide a wide range of positions and demands in a short form. There are no white papers detached to every sentence, and some demands may seem as if they're new or unworkable. Under capitalism, we're primed to believe that fundamental change isn't possible, and media is driven to embed that belief.

SPEAKER_00So it's going to take a lot of discussion, debate, and synthesis. And socialists love to talk about how things work and how the things we want can and should work. So over the next series of class episodes, and probably more, a lot of these are going to be focused on different parts of workers deserve more, with guests whose areas of work and scholarship can speak to them. We'll try to start with the ones that are the most focused on in the media, but the hope is that we'll get to all of them eventually. NPEC is also discussing some live events involving thinkers on the left focusing on our program, and if and when those start, we'll announce them.

SPEAKER_00So we begin with Aziz Rana to talk about our demands for a real democracy in this country. Aziz teaches constitutional law at Boston College and is the author of two books, The Two Faces of American Freedom and The Constitutional Bind, How Americans Came to Idolize a Document That Fails Them, which will be out in paperback this fall. Welcome back, Aziz.

SPEAKER_01Thanks so much for having me on the show. It's great to be in the show.

SPEAKER_00So thanks, come thanks for coming to talk about this specifically. A lot of what you've talked about on the show before has been, of course, around the Constitution. But now we actually have something that we've put out that we're going to talk about. But workers deserve more. It's our new program. I'm very happy with it, I have to say, partly because I was a big uh proponent of making it come to fruition and I was involved in writing it. But I assume that you have things to say about it.

SPEAKER_00You're really involved in kind of keeping up to date on things. And any thoughts that you have off the top about our program that you'd like to share before we get into more detail?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so maybe the first thing that I'd say from just like looking at it from the forest, the 30-foot, uh 30,000-foot heights, is that I think it's a very powerful program because of the ways in which it emphasizes at least three different kinds of principles. And to me, these are principles that really cut against how conventional politics typically operates in the U.S. So the first is that if you just like read the program as a totality, it refuses to separate between domestic politics and foreign affairs.

SPEAKER_01And one of the things that really defines how US politics works is that there's a set of reforms that folks are supposed to participate in that have to do with like internal life. Maybe these are bread and butter issues of like wages or basic security questions. And then there's foreign policy, and foreign policy is effectively left to the national security state. And this is a program that says that we can't think that way, that it's really important to recognize the extent to which one's capacity to enjoy something like equal and effective freedom here at home rests on the kind of approach to the world that the U.S.

SPEAKER_01engages in. And the forms of violence or injustice that the U.S. might promote overseas end up having profoundly rippling effects on what's actually possible domestically. And so this linkage between the domestic and the foreign, I think, is essential. And it's something that you see really throughout the program. The second thing that I'd say is it also refuses to distinguish between what you might think of as democracy in terms of like representative government, like a procedural agenda for changing how electoral institutions operate, and democracy as something that is a general way of life.

SPEAKER_01And you can see this specifically in the fact that the democracy agenda is both about representative institutions and about the workplace. So we live in a world in which typically the way that you talk about democracy is it's something that you access occasionally through the vote. But most of your life, really, you're not participating in democratic practice. And most people spend most of their time in workplaces that are incredibly hierarchical. Effectively, that means that most people experience on a day-to-day basis forms of external control that are really inconsistent with principles of solidarity, that don't allow you to develop the muscle of how to be a democratic participant engaged in shared practice with others.

SPEAKER_01And here's an overarching program that says, no, you have to actually think about the ways in which these two things are linked. That democracy is something that needs to be practiced and developed in one's everyday work workplace experience, everyday institutions, neighborhoods, schools, et cetera, in order to be able to effectively engage in democracy in other settings, and that they have to be understood as fundamentally connected. And then the third thing that I would say, and this maybe gets us into talking about some of the elements of the program that have become controversial, is that the program asks us to push back against how in the US we typically think about political pragmatism.

SPEAKER_01The basic way that we ordinarily think about political pragmatism is that there's a set of reforms out there that maybe they're good, maybe they're bad, but they're totally unfeasible. They're utopian in a negative sense. And so you actually have to kind of clip or limit your imagination about what's politically doable to what seems like it can make it through elite centers and institutions in the here and now. But in a way, like that's not the world we're living in.

SPEAKER_01You know, perhaps it's never been the world we're living in, but certainly today, 2026, is really different than like the 1990s, for instance. We're living in a world in which it increasingly seems that not just Americans, but folks across the globe are dealing with overlapping and rippling crises, from forever wars to financial and economic hardship and crisis and insecurity, precarity, to climate change and ecological catastrophe to pandemics, you name it.

SPEAKER_01And in this context, the institutions that have been the repositories of economic and political power really seem profoundly ill-equipped to address those problems or are actively abetting what feels like the intensification of these problems. And in that setting, it's a strange thing where what might one might think of as pragmatic, the kind of limited ameliorative response, feels so ill-equipped to address the moment that in a sense, it's the approach that feels like it's out of step with the times.

SPEAKER_01And by contrast, like thinking in more wide-ranging terms about what might be possible, what you might call utopian, that actually might be a more pragmatic way of, in fact, having an imagination that is responsive to the challenges of the present. And so conceiving of change as something that we can do, that doesn't have to be limited to what the talk of the past has been feels like, in a way, it's like the very sort of the very minimum of what might be required to get us from this moment to a future in which actually folks are able to experience meaningful improvements in their lives.

SPEAKER_01And so, in a sense, I think part of the reason why the program's gotten such extensive pushback, but also part of the reason why probably the program has gotten a lot of pip pickup and discussion is just in the way it's asking Americans to reconfigure, reimagine like what should be the scope of our demands. Like what should be the terms of our conversation? And even if, you know, I'll have my own disagreements with elements of what we'll discuss, even if one doesn't agree with all of the things that that you read, it's an invitation to have a conversation that is on the terms of the challenges that we face rather than presuming in advance we have to have a limited set of demands that are just simply not up to the challenges themselves.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I appreciate the fact that you noticed some of those things because they certainly were intentional by the group that wrote it when we were going through writing it. And I've said this on the program before. It was a week-by-week kind of writing group with democratic characteristics that we went through, um, decided how we were going to frame this and how we were going to structure it. I think that historically, socialist programs have had a very um limited structure. Um, even the ones that have um engaged in some kind of, you know, maximalist or or it's very separated.

SPEAKER_00Um what we decided to do besides structure it with a sort of three-part instead of just a two-part, um, like an introduction with a list of demands, or vice versa, we had this introductory beginning that does ask people to sort of take themselves out of the impossible, right? And think about what it would be like to actually have a good day without this other thing happening that is going to cause the rest of your days to be bad. Um, and I think that a lot of people have responded to that with surprise, but also with appreciation.

SPEAKER_00Like you said, there's also been a lot of pushback against elements of the program. And I think that some of these elements are also tried and true, you know, sort of media tactics to be like, we're gonna hammer on this one thing, and and this is gonna be the only thing that people remember. For example, police abolition or this sort of radical restructuring of our entire federal system, um, which we have you on to sort of talk about elements of. But I also think that a socialist can't really be a socialist unless they have a fundamental faith in human intelligence and the fact that people have been seeking out our program, actually going to it, not just imbibing what has been said.

SPEAKER_00Obviously, there's going to be people who do that, but it's unprecedented that this many people have looked up something DSA has has published. Um, and you know, there's a lot we don't know about it. It's only been a couple of months, but people have also said that the reception has been, if not interest, curiosity, and desire to discuss these things, right? To actually have it on the table as something that you can talk about, um, which of course completely baffles people who don't think about politics in these terms, as you pointed out, the Overton window, so-called, but really it's also about what's considered to be possible under the um the structure of ruling class kind of hegemony.

SPEAKER_00The other part that you said that I think is really important is that when we sort of mix together the pragmatic and the potential, I guess is how I put it, we're doing something different than what socialist programs or political programs generally do. Um, we're pushing, you know, we're pushing outward. And that was a decision partly because DSA is a multi-tenancy organization, and there are people who actually do think that certain things are possible under capitalism that others think we'll actually need to get to socialism for.

SPEAKER_00So that does bring into play like the fact that DSA itself has a wide range of socialisms kind of captured within it. But it also is a way for people to drill down into various kinds of reforms and think about what is actually needed for us to be able to have this work. Um, and so if you if you want, I know that, you know, historically um this may or may not be your area, but um, what do you think about it in comparison or or like kind of in the same context as other, either socialist programs or political programs, more so?

SPEAKER_00Because something that I always think about is the fact that a program is kind of like a founding document, even though we've put it out, even though we've existed for 40 years, like we've put this thing out. There is a kind of refoundational um gesture to it. And you're a constitutional scholar. Constitutions are often thought of as these founding documents or these sort of institutional documents. So maybe speak to what you think about it in that broader context of like programmatic or like political language.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I mean, so maybe the first thing just um to reflect on what you're saying about um what the the the like the multiple tendencies within the party and the various kinds of ambitions like the I think so reading it for me, I I approached it as a document that's very much a conversation starter. Like it's meant to be to be an invitation to discuss these various elements. So like the stuff that's about representative institutions, our legal system, um, the three different sort of democracy for all, a real democracy, a democratic Congress, they're notable for the fact that these are not extensive and they don't really sort of typify, like so they don't give you an account of how to get from here to there, or like what the actual fine-grained elements of the reforms might be.

SPEAKER_01And so it's feels to me like an invitation to then think through like you know, how to both realize this in practice, but also um what elements might require like fairly significant fine, fine-grained um adjustments. And then that does then raise a thing, which is you know, how different people might relate to it. So I will say, so as somebody that spends a fair amount of time like um thinking about the constitution, constitutional change, probably my primary focus is on thinking about change in terms of what a colleague of mine, Amna Akbar, has called non-reformist reforms, or sometimes I refer to as revolutionary reforms, which is like, what are if we if we take our institutions as they are right now, like what are the kinds of adjustments that would make it harder for the deleterious aspects of our status quo to reproduce themselves and make it easier to open up more far-reaching changes that are consistent with ends that provide equal and effective freedom for all?

SPEAKER_01And so, you know, I think that probably for like future conversations about these three elements, like I would be interested, and maybe we can get into that, in talking about how to transform or think about some of these principles in the context of um like non-reformist reforms that can be all that can alter our existing set of institutions. And here I think you know, just for that reason, um, you know, this program does it it feels to me like it's it's reminiscent of um some of the kind of classic programs of the past.

SPEAKER_01And the two in particular that I've spent some time with and thought about are like the 1912 Socialist Party of America platform and the Panthers sort of constitution, Revolutionary People's Constitutional Convention that they put together in 1970. And I think in many ways that what it shares with like both of those uh kind of platforms or agendas is the way in which it also essentially sets out a set of principles, pushes forward a clear conversation, and then articulates a kind of diagnosis of the present that grounds like the material injustice of the economy to a broader assessment about how the political system should be shifted, and that also combines like the international with the domestic.

SPEAKER_01And I would say by the same token, both of those documents, if you read them, you know, probably are navigating really similar tensions, which is how do you create a document that asserts principles and can be the basis for conversation, while at the same time recognizing that to transform any document like this into something that can be an articulable basis for change in the here and now, you probably need to you need to have a set of like more concrete specifications than what you can necessarily produce in that document.

SPEAKER_01The other thing that I would say that's interesting in thinking about this one by comparison with those earlier two is that the SPA 1912 document has a lot of very similar reforms to the democratic system. It does call for a broad protection of the right to vote, but it is notable for the extent to which it basically treats the question of race as subordinate to a broader question of class, even though Debs himself personally was strongly committed to equal rights for black people and the project of legal and civic equality.

SPEAKER_01And I would say that this is a document that's attempting quite seriously to sort of integrate questions of slavery. Colonialism, what some folks call racial capitalism, with the more classic accounts of capitalism, so that you can have a comprehensive articulation of like what democracy means to the plurality of people that live in the US. And then by comparison with the Panthers document from 1970, I think one of the things that's really strike striking about this one is that there's a lot of similarity in terms of maybe broad overarching principles, anti-imperialism, the connection between the foreign and the domestic, the link between economic democracy and political democracy.

SPEAKER_01But that was a document that was really uncertain about whether or not you could actually build a multiracial majority in the US in the 1970s on behalf of these demands. And for that reason, unlike the 1912 Socialist Party of America text, really ends up de-emphasizing the electoral question and electoral design. Where the document that you have here is at a moment where it's absolutely conceivable that you could have a multiracial majority that is committed, broadly speaking, to a set of principles.

SPEAKER_01And so is much more aware of attempting to connect maybe the question about black freedom and racial injustice to the possibility of entrenching it in a broad-ranging agenda that links economics, shifts in foreign policy to a mass popular base that's instituted through legislative and democratic means.

SPEAKER_01But at the same time, I think there is a significant need then to have a conversation about how the aspects, for instance, of the democracy agenda would be specified in practice and to and which elements of that might require significant clarification. And what does it mean to take the principle and turn it into something like a nonreformist reform that could concretely be implemented in the here and now and pushed toward more far-reaching change?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, the nonreformist reform concept or term of art also comes prior to. I actually have read the article and taught it, uh, the Amna Akbar piece in a Marxism and law class that I taught a couple years ago. Um, but it's borrowed also from Andre Gorse, which was, you know, the concept that there is like the democratic road to socialism requires a kind of middle-term and long-term view. The long-term view being socialism, the middle-term view being how do we build mass political hope through participation, through organizing?

SPEAKER_00It's an interesting question because we brought up elections and the fact that elections are both the focal point of all political activity in the United States. When people think of politics, they think of politicians, they think of elected officials. Um, part of DSA's effort is to try to expand the concept of what it means to be a democratic uh political agent, um, collectively and um individually in this under capitalism to get us further.

SPEAKER_00But the the issue around like what is possible and what is agitational, like what like what we can achieve, and then also what, even if we lose it, is building expectations, is building um, you know, militancy, is building a kind of um, like you said, muscle uh for participation and isn't just demoralizing people because so much of what elections focus on is the horse race. Horse races can only have one winner, right? And this is um, you know, part of why the um the timing of the program, which wasn't intentional, it was meant to come out earlier, um, but due to a delay on the part of those involved in uh seating the committee, we ended up putting it out in the middle of an election season.

SPEAKER_00And it turned out to be an election season where we were winning. And so this was also um part of why the fixation on our program and the what is possible is coming out at this moment when people are actually winning on the basis of a socialist platform, their own campaign platforms that are boosted by things like the win of Zuran Mamdani, these other kinds of um, you know, something that's more than just the left wing of the possible, but actually open socialist running for office, running for major offices and winning.

SPEAKER_00The job of the right wing, of course, is to say either it's a fluke that you can't do it in certain places in the United States, um, and or also saying um this is uh you know short-lived, this is a trend. Um, and I just wanted to also cite that there was a, I think a maybe two or three days ago, a poll put out by uh the New York Times. The the headline was uh socialism remains unpopular, poll finds.

SPEAKER_00What the poll said is that 51% of people in the US disapprove of socialism. 51%. And that's within the margin of error. But the way that they put it is socialism is unpopular. They also cited within that same uh article that um popularity has gone up 5% since they last measured it in May. Um, but then there's a whole swath of people who don't have an opinion. If you look at current polling for the Republican, the Democratic Party, 54% of Americans disapprove.

SPEAKER_00And that's a slight improvement from, you know, whatever the last has been. It's, I think they're they're tied now where it used to be, I don't know, 58% and 56% or something like that. So I think that, you know, as we go into talking about what it is people really respond to, these non-reformist reforms, I think that people also respond to um clear principles. They do actually respond to um a kind of, I may not agree with everything they say, but I appreciate the fact they're saying it.

SPEAKER_00This is kind of why Bernie was so attractive, even to people who might not have um voted for him, but he at least was liked and respected. And I think that's something we should think about as as we go forward, because what we're trying to do in DSA is make more and better socialists by attracting people to a set of principles. And also those principles are ones that we don't just believe, but we know are if people are given kind of the basis to have the discussion, really do actually turn people on, right?

SPEAKER_00They they really do want to talk about some of these details. Um, but one thing that we have actually found by talking to members who are organizing with them is that the Senate and like radical reform has actually been something that people have both wanted to talk about and have been um resistant to. Um I was surprised. We had a training last week where um it was a talking to non-socialists about the program.

SPEAKER_00And it was a great training. People, you know, lots uh over 100 people came. And um, one of the things that came up as kind of troubleshooting was how do you talk about the Senate? People really are like resistant to the idea that we're going to get rid of it or that we want to get rid of it. And I know you have opinions about how this may or may not work, but your own work talks about the um constitution, like the sort of romance of the constitution and the the constitution as this thing that even though it says right in there that we can change it if we want, and it has been changed, there's also this idea that it's permanent, that it's kind of a sort of if flawed, still more perfect than any other system, and that people have a strong attachment to it even when the institutions fail them, such as the Senate.

SPEAKER_00My own opinion of the Senate is that it essentially is a training ground for uh presidential failed campaigns. Um my own senator, Corey Booker, ran unopposed this year, even though he's not uh, you know, a shiny example of a successful senator or one with really any principles. And that's the case all over the country. The Senate itself is considered to be, I think, the most sort of technically undemocratic, um, besides the fact of the Electoral College.

SPEAKER_00But it also is something that people are very resistant to seeing change on because it's part of this idea that there is a co-equal branch of government system, these checks and balances, and that without a Senate, what would happen? And I'd love to get started talking about that. This is something that a lot of people have been curious about and have a lot of different things to say about it. There has to be more to it than just it's undemocratic. Tell us about your views on this and also maybe um talk a little bit about the argument of your book, The Constitutional Bind, um, and how it relates to sort of maybe what you think is happening when people resist this idea that we could change something so um kind of failed but still time honored as the Senate.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I mean there's a lot there. So maybe the first thing that I'd say is that you know when when I started talking about the undemocratic features of the Constitution, now this is like over a decade ago, I'd end up having to spend a lot of time just kind of working through the electoral college, the way that the Supreme Court works, the nature of the Senate. These days, these critiques are pretty widespread even in fairly mainstream liberal circles, and they're absolutely widespread within the legal academic academy.

SPEAKER_01And so that means that there's a general sense that our constitutional system just doesn't seem to be working the way it's supposed to for most Americans. I don't think that that's that controversial a position, that there's something that seems to be wrong with our big C constitution, the U.S. Federal Constitution. I think the issue is that because of the way in which a kind of culture of veneration has really emerged around the U.S.

SPEAKER_01Constitution, especially in the 20th century, and this connects to some of the stuff from the book, for a lot of Americans on the center left, and that you'd want to be sort of more forthrightly engaged in these discussions, the big C constitution of the U.S. Federal Constitution gets collapsed into a discussion about little C constitutionalism as such. The idea of a constitutional democracy in which there are constraints on the capacity of any political actor to exercise something like unchecked, unregulated authority.

SPEAKER_01And you know, I have to admit that I teach and study the law, and I'm committed personally to a vision of the rule of law. I think that whether you're a liberal democrat or a socialist, that a you know a compelling account of those visions require some version of the rule of law understood as a system that ensures that those in power can't exercise impunity and essentially enrich their friends while imposing violence and intimidation on their enemies.

SPEAKER_01And there are many different ways of organizing a system that combines the principles of democracy and constitutionalism. And I would say the story of democratic socialism in the U.S., certainly going back to the SPA, is one in which many of the folks arguing for things like free speech rights, rights for dissidents, a system that actually constrains the power of the state to impose forms of excess that link business and military security elites together, has come from folks that would identify as socialists, from Debs or Crystal Eastman, et cetera.

SPEAKER_01So that there are many ways that you can have constitutionalism and you can defend it while at the same time calling for fairly significant reforms to the U.S. Federal Constitution. The thing that's happened in the States, and this is what you know largely has to do with the way in which the story of the U.S. Federal Constitution and its particular institutional details, which are highly insulated from ordinary political participation, that have an incredibly powerful both president and court, became bound up with justifications for growing American global power over the course of the 20th century and for how the US constructed its confrontation with the Soviet Union during the Cold War.

SPEAKER_01And as a result, like one of the effects was that the variety of different constitutionalisms that one could imagine in the states became almost reduced to just the US model. It's hard for Americans to conceive of constitutional orders that are not organized around this federal constitution, even though today, if you actually look at constitutions around the globe, that in representative governments, they look a lot more like the kinds of demands that the SPA was making in the early part of the 20th century.

SPEAKER_01They look more like mass parliamentary democracies with various kinds, you know, with systems that are much less insulated than the version that we have in the States. And so that the U.S. Federal Constitution is actually a kind of global outlier. Nonetheless, it's hard for many Americans to hear constitutional change and not think that it's an assault on constitutionalism as such. And all of that, I think, is intensified by the fact of Trump, where it's perhaps easier to have these conversations about constitutional change when it doesn't seem like you're confronting a political figure that is taking apart the principle of constitutionalism itself.

SPEAKER_01And that ends up further muddying the divide between the two, because it raises all these questions about in this moment, can you have a discussion about making pretty significant reforms to the constitutional system if you have a figure that's accumulating more and more power in ways that undermine the very principles of like limitations on state power?

SPEAKER_00Right. And accumulating more power that's then also being tested in the Supreme Court and in general supported because of unitary executive theory and the way in which it's embedded itself or kind of, I would maybe even say actualized, like under Trump, um, even though it's existed since, I mean, people have said prior to, but at least since 9-11. And that kind of embedding of executive power as an almost independent and impunity um favored uh office, then protected by the law.

SPEAKER_00And then, I mean, we were started off talking about the Senate. I want to hear about that, but yeah, this kind of system where people are saying it's not working, but what would happen if it went away? I think is a lot another part of it. Because the imagin the imagination is also one, I think, of um of fear. You know, it's it's it's about fear and the way in which people do believe that the constitution protects our freedoms, like that the constitution itself is a protecting document that constrains power, yes, but also allows people to live um kind of a minimally liberated life.

SPEAKER_00And I think socialists, our idea of liberation is human emancipation, that is about being able to flourish and participate fully in the life that you're meant to live, not a kind of um protectorate, I guess I would say. But maybe you can speak a little bit to the president question, um, just because you brought it up under Trump, and then we can also talk more about like how that fits in with the rest of the system.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So it and I I definitely want us to get back to the conversation about the Senate. So, you know, part of the way that I would think about it is that, and this is one of the reasons why the my most recent book was called Constitutional Bind. And it's that it's very difficult, I think, for Americans to keep in keep in tension or in mind almost two things at the same time, which is the reason why, one of the significant reasons why we have the kind of political formation in power today is because of the constitutional system.

SPEAKER_01It's actual decision-making apparatus. And it's because there is a constitutive flaw in the constitutional system, namely the fact that it is not organized on the principle of one person, one vote. It's instead organized on the principle of geographic representation. You know, the where you live ends up shaping who enjoys political power rather than the idea that everybody should just have the same amount of political power and influence.

SPEAKER_01And the way you see this focus on geographic representation is that it's the unit of the state that determines who ends up enjoying political authority. So it's the unit of the state that shapes the Senate, that shapes who's president through the Electoral College, through the combination of the two, ends up shaping who's on the Supreme Court, ends up shaping even the House of Representatives, because it's at the state level that you have all of this kind of control through gerrymandering over the very nature of the districts themselves.

SPEAKER_01And then all of this is even further insulated by the fact that it's virtually impossible, the U.S. has the hardest constitution in the world to actually formally amend. And so constitutional decision-making gets essentially funneled into either the unilateral choices of the president. The president decides to illegally declare war on Iran, even though that's you know that's a power that's supposed to be held by Congress and the Constitution. But the limitations and constraints of the system makes it very difficult to hold the president accountable, especially in a context with a court that almost unilaterally ends up enjoying the decision over how to interpret the text because you don't have a functioning amendment process.

SPEAKER_01Anyway, I say all of this to say that these are the conditions that lead to a person being elected as president even though they didn't win the popular vote, to then being able to reconstruct the Supreme Court with three new appointees because it's through the president and the Senate, even though actually more people voted for the Democratic Party in 2016, significantly more people in the Senate than for the Republican Party. So you have the rise of a system of minority rule that has intensified the power of the far right.

SPEAKER_01And then once that far right has sort of like taken over the institutions of government, then pursued an agenda that really combines what we can think of as a kind of imperial president with an imperial court. So that's reinforcing each other. So that you have a court that, through a theory like the unitary executive theory, which says that within the executive branch, there that it's an infringement on the power of the executive for Congress to place various kinds of rules about like the hiring and firing and appointment structure of who's within the executive, so that the executive has a kind of more totalizing authority within that, but also through various kinds of deference to executive decision making in the context of national security settings, has sort of intensified both the international and domestic power of the president.

SPEAKER_01Then the president's operating in ways that are highly coercive against the backdrop of an incredibly limited Congress, and all of that is being further reinforced by the court so that we have a contemporary moment in which our current version of the executive and the judicial branches are working together in ways that intensify existing forms not just of minority rule, but of policy outcomes that are highly coercive towards various constituents. And so this is building what you can think of as a new form of increasingly authoritarian practice in the US.

SPEAKER_01Now, I think this is a critique that folks understand, but then there's this issue about well, what will we replace it with? Yeah, what you know, how could we imagine change? We have to like so there's Sense that the Constitution is the problem, but then for many people, it's like, oh my gosh, only the Constitution can save us. And so we have to reinvest in the institutions of the Constitution, especially, for instance, in the Supreme Court, because there's this memory of the Supreme Court under the war in court in the 50s and 60s, which was a really kind of an exceptional moment in the court's life.

SPEAKER_00It was also a Cold War, it was also a Cold War relic, you know, like to try to create moral authority.

SPEAKER_01The Cold War conditions created depolarization that shaped the terms of who ended up on the court, that produced a set of policy decisions basically at the Supreme Court that are very different from the version of the Supreme Court that we've seen before that time or since. But rat but regardless, I think I think the hesitance speaks to a very understandable sense that there's a recognition that the institutions are in crisis, that they're not organized on principles that we would collectively choose.

SPEAKER_01But there's a worry, especially in the face of authoritarian entrenchment, about like how to how to engage in change without experiencing various kinds of political collapse. And I think that's so that that then requires us to have a conversation on political strategy, but I think it also then entails thinking really seriously about well, what are the principles? Like what should be the kind of principles that organize our legal and political institutions? And then how does that connect to thinking about reforms in the here and now that can push us toward those principles?

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I also think that the, you know, the socialist view is we want to create something that's never happened yet. And I think that transitional question, how do we get from here to there, really requires socialists to think about persuasion, but not think about persuasion at the sacrifice of our principles and especially not like saying something we don't mean, right? And I think that a lot of people who have been maybe worried that the program goes too far or that it's saying too much or that it wants too much have been worried about that political strategy question first and foremost, which is how does this communicate what we believe in a way that will be receptive or received by the most people?

SPEAKER_00But this also gets to this question of how well is does is what most people measured in the chaotic conditions that we're under, especially right now. I mean, it's kind of a people say this all the time, which is that the average American's political views are mixed at best. They they there's not a lot of you know strict party lines and the the kinds of things that are considered to be um, you know, immovable red lines are often more based in sort of social value questions than they are based on sort of complex political questions.

SPEAKER_00But just to get back to the Senate question, whenever it's brought up, this question of, well, what would you replace it with or what would you do with it? What the program says is that we would expand the House of Representatives, have a multi-party democracy, and also make the president and the Supreme Court um appointed by and subject to the House. This is a radical reform. It's creating a unicameral Congress and also more of a prime ministerial um uh system for the executive, as well as kind of more of a civil service uh model for the Supreme Court rather than an independent judiciary.

SPEAKER_00And we only have a few minutes left. Um, we've talked a lot about various kind of like broader questions, but I'd love to hear what you think about this structure. I mean, which is not actually too far off from existing um constitutional structures um in, you know, comparably um economically well-off places that are not, you know, socialists, um, they're social democracies or they're just capitalist countries. Um, but it does require, you know, this kind of break with um with just not just tradition, but the idea that the Senate is um somehow representing something meaningful.

SPEAKER_00Um, you just brought into into play the the sort of regional or the geographical representation question. And a lot of people feel that the Senate does validly represent the state's interests in the federal government. So what what about it? Like what about the this like sort of Senate reform? Um, I know that you had said um earlier that you're not uh thinking of an abolitionist horizon for the Senate necessarily, but um, you do probably agree that it needs to be reduced in its power and its ability to essentially block popular legislation.

SPEAKER_00Um famously, the Senate has been um key to you know, sort of ending a lot of um radical sort of popular uh movements, um at least um on the legislative level, even if these things end up winning maybe in a court setting or movement uh, you know, more movement politics. But the Senate has been not great, I would say, for our democracy. So why should we keep it or should we keep it?

SPEAKER_01So uh so first, you know, I think I I have a little bit more time, and it'd be great for us to be able to just like continue so that we can finish our conversation. But yeah, I mean, so uh my own view is that the the this is the point about like you were making about the importance of being clear about principles and then thinking about reforms in the context of how, you know, what kinds of reforms um are both consistent with principles and make the kind of imagined future more likely rather than less likely.

SPEAKER_01That's the way that I sort of approach this. And when I look at the question of representative government, my initial like bedrock principle is the idea that everybody is entitled to equal and effective freedom, and that means that you want systems that are premised on the basic principle of um one person, one vote. And if I were thinking completely abstractly from any kind of a like a social order, an existing political system, I would probably say that I would be a strong proponent of like little D democracy that's premised on kind of unicameral arrangements.

SPEAKER_01So at the just like at the most kind of idealized theory level. But then that I think requires, for me, thinking about two uh kind of related but distinct issues. One is removing that that sort of purely idealized frame, like what is the nature of the particular society in which I'm embedded? Like what is what's the nature of the United States? And that means a question of size, 350 million plus people. It means a question of its own specific histories, histories connected to Native expropriation and the enslavement of black people and segregation, and on and on and on.

SPEAKER_01They're like very specific kinds of dynamics that shape within a particular society what would be the kinds of institutional arrangements that make something like equal and effective freedom more likely rather than less. And then related to that, there's the issue of, okay, we have a set of institutions that just do not work. What kinds of concrete alterations to these institutions would actually move them significantly in a kind of transformative direction, that are not just kind of patchworks, but are the minimum requirements to actually address the problems of the day?

SPEAKER_01And it's with this in mind that I probably think about the question of the Senate. So I totally cosign that the existing Senate, and you can go back all the way to slavery in the 19th century, has had a pretty profoundly deleterious effect on the capacity of most Americans to have their interests met. And it's because of like how wildly out of step the kind of extremity of geographic representation is with the principle of one person, one vote, and also the way in which the Senate is almost like a symbol for this basic issue, which is that we have representation not arranged around one person, one vote, but instead arranged around geography.

SPEAKER_01So it has all, and then there's you add on top of that subconstitutional principles like the filibuster, which means in a moment like today, where a minority is able to control the Senate because of geography, this means effectively for a center-left or a left coalition to have the Senate, you'd need to already have a supermajority of support. And then to get over the filibuster to get 60 votes, it's like a supermajority on top of a supermajority.

SPEAKER_01So pretty profound reform is necessary. And I think one of the reasons probably why there's been a lot of you know uh excitement around the idea of, if not Senate abolition, Senate reform, is precisely the way in which it can be a shorthand for articulating like this broader principle, which is there is something wrong with a democracy that is organized to represent territory rather than to represent people.

SPEAKER_01Like that is not a functioning democracy, and it's wildly out of step with how you know most representative governments forget about democratic socialist ones, would be organized and are organized elsewhere. But then there's, I think, this second issue, which is like the particularities of the society. And here, probably the person that's most influential to me is Du Bois. So Du Bois actually had a back and forth and a kind of friendly kind of critique, I would say, with the SPA's approach to democracy reform in the early 20th century, where the focus of the SPA platform in 1912, and I think the focus of many socialist platforms since, has been like the problem in the US is minority rule, and what you need to do is just move toward pure kind of majoritarianism in various ways.

SPEAKER_01And what Du Bois said is that precisely because the history of racial discrimination in the US, it's a little bit more complicated, where the difficulty in the US is a combination of minority rule at the federal level with the way in which that then generates majority tyranny. So minority tyranny at the federal level and the way that generates a kind of minority, uh, excuse me, majority tyranny at the state level.

SPEAKER_01What do I mean by this? This is an overarching system because of the focus on the state as the primary unit of representation that produces these really destructive minority coalitions that are able to impose their political will even in the face of cultural, political, social, economic opposition at the national level. But then, precisely because of that and the way that that intersects with the state, how that often is played out historically is it gives a huge amount of power to specific state elites.

SPEAKER_01And this is the story of like slavery in the South as well as segregation in the South, where you have these state elites within a particular party that are essentially like empowered to use these levers to kind of reconstruct the nature of House of Representatives like districts, but also to shape the terms of state politics and in those state contexts to wield an actual numerical majority to impose on racial and other minority groups various forms of political and economic oppression.

SPEAKER_00And also make sure that you break up.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So you what you do is you effectively break up through a system, the federal system, what it does is it breaks up the possibility of a multiracial majority at the national level while at the state level empowering specific state officials to use a kind of racial numerical majority to impose various kinds of controls on specific minority groups at the state level.

SPEAKER_01So there is something like a kind of racial majority tyranny at the state level, and then a kind of minority, uh majority tyranny at the state level, minority tyranny at the national level. And these two things interact. For him, it was part of the story of the defeat of Reconstruction. It's part of the story of the failures across the first two-thirds of the 20th century to actually address in a systematic way questions of race. And so what does that mean? That means that for me, like even though the central principle has to be a principle of one person, one vote, thinking about the US in the here and now probably also requires recognizing it's a country of 350 million plus people with lots of pluralism and difference, and that there has to be an institutional framework that's able to address both majority tyranny and minority tyranny at the same time.

SPEAKER_01And so it might suggest, my view is like, you know, even if in principle, like in the most abstracted principle, I would only have like a kind of unicam, I might have a unicameral legislature. In practice, I think there might be reasons why you want to have bicameral arrangements so as to ensure that different kinds of pockets of collective life are expressed, and so that you can have certain types of deviations from the principle of one person, one vote as a way of addressing the particular dynamics of the U.S.

SPEAKER_01as a society.

SPEAKER_00So maybe something like a Senate council or something. Or so yeah.

SPEAKER_01So like there's lots of ways to think about this. And I want to note like these are not, these are still dramatic changes to our constitutional system. So we're not, we're still in the a world of a profound alteration in the terms of government. But like, for instance, if you want to still hold on to the state as a as a political unit, um, and you're thinking about these issues of geography, then maybe each state has a certain number of senators, but there's additional senators for each state based on like the population in the state.

SPEAKER_01So that's that's one thing. Or you can add cities as potential senators that would be part of a Senate. And then even more important, or just alongside this, equally important, would be like, well, what is it that the Senate does? A large part of the problem right now is so much of the legislative authority is directed into the Senate. And this is because the framers of the original constitution were deeply suspicious of little D democracy. And so the reason why they wanted a Senate in 1788 was a constraint on popular political authority.

SPEAKER_01That would not be the reason why you might say there's still value to bicameralism in a kind of multiracial, incredibly diverse, massive country of 2026. Instead, it would be how to ensure a proper representative patchwork. And so you might still say what we need is a very strong House of Representatives. It's the House of Representatives that should be the site for the vast majority of legislative decision making. So the House proposes, passes, you know, what it sort of like votes on bills, then it can go to the Senate.

SPEAKER_01But you can also have frameworks that say if the Senate votes it down or refuses, then it goes back to the House and the House can repass the bill.

SPEAKER_00So you can I just ask really quick, um, would you picture it instead of a filibuster to pass, instead it requires a filibuster to veto or something like that? Like so that it would be a way to, and then after that, that would have to go back down instead of just dying.

SPEAKER_01Totally. So you you think about it as like the main site of legislative decision making is the House because of this principle of one person, one vote. But you have a society that's remarkably diverse, and you might want it's important to have like rural interests represented. Um and so, but then you can do what you can do is you can provide certain kinds of veto powers to the Senate while at the same time making it in many cases far more ceremonial than it currently is. So like the Senate has an opportunity to vote it up.

SPEAKER_01If they choose not to, then the House has to repass it. Um, many of the forms of power that are currently residing in the Senate don't have to be in the Senate. Like the confirmation process for justices, federal judges, all of this kind of stuff. Like you can play around with some of the authority that currently applies to the Senate. And then, you know, another thing that I think is really key here is, and that isn't currently in the program, is how all of this fits with another element of democracy that's highly limited in the states, which is the ability outside of the court system to engage in constitutional interpretation and change.

SPEAKER_01And so having a much more flexible and fluid amendment process. And so maybe the amendment process is a place where you actually want the Senate to play a more active role because of the ways in which it's like represents interests instead of simply like constituents. So that so that you wouldn't want a kind of notwithstanding approach that I just described for the Senate when it comes to constitutional amendments. Maybe there you'd want both houses have to actually pass the amendment and then it has to go to a national vote.

SPEAKER_01And then based on the national vote, maybe there's there could even potentially be a like a supermajority requirement for the national vote or not, then, or even uh some kind of geographical distribution if you want, then that would end up being implemented as an amendment. Anyway, so I I go into all of this to say that there are ways to think about pretty profound constitutional change that's still responsive to the kind of dynamics that of the US.

SPEAKER_01Now, the thing that I think is really key is that that all of this highlights that there is no, in my view, defensible ground if you're committed to the principle of democracy for the way that our representative institutions are currently organized and the kind of overwhelming power that the Senate has. Even if you think geographic representation is really important, or that we need to have a system of checks and balances like I do, there's no reason to say that the version that we have, which so dramatically overrepresents particular constituencies in parts of the country, makes any kind of sense.

SPEAKER_01Like it can't possibly be the case that such a small number of states and small number of people effectively should have a kind of absolute veto power over the effectiveness of government or have its relevant political coalition so dramatically overrepresented. That not only has basically transformed our legislative branch into a completely broken branch and in the process intensified the accumulation of not just lawmaking but coercive power in the president.

SPEAKER_01What it's also done is it's fed the kind of authoritarian turn of one of the two political parties because it's made the actual electoral incentives of Republican politicians incentives that treat something like a multiracial democracy as an almost existential threat. There was a time in this country where the Republican Party was legitimately the majority party. Whether or not you like whatever you might think of Reagan, Nixon, they were politicians that were elected from the most populous state in the country, California, that won landslide re-elections.

SPEAKER_01And that was a party that mobilized a majority. What's happened over the last half century is that party's popularity has declined significantly. But the kinds of institutions of government of which the Senate as it's currently constituted typifies, what it's done is it's created an alternative mechanism to still hold on to power, which is through national minority rule that then is effectuated at the state level through. Control of these states.

SPEAKER_01And what that's produced is an intensification of the defection by the right, effectively, from a compact that assumes that multiracial democracy should be the basic principle of the of the country. One last sort of point to make on this is that all of this highlights to me the value of having this conversation, which is you cannot get to a place where you can talk seriously about American institutions if we're going to begin by saying, well, we can't change them.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we're not going to be able to change them in any kind of like systematic way. And we can't have the discussion about some of the other uh other um things that are that are raised. And I would add something that's in the document that I I support, and maybe we can talk a little bit about why, that is that permanent residents should also have voting rights. Yeah. And that's something that I believe has to be part of the conversation that that we're having about like the future of American democracy, especially at a time like now where we're seeing you know such a crackdown on immigrants within our community.

SPEAKER_01So happy to talk a little bit about that if you think that would be productive.

SPEAKER_00Definitely. Um, obviously, we could also have you on in the future. I definitely want to make sure that we confirm that you are in favor of abolishing the Capital S Senate, but replacing it with a potential Senate-like structure that does represent something other than um geographic uh, because that's also what the House represents is you know, one vote per sector, essentially. Something like a Soviet, maybe.

SPEAKER_00I don't want to like put words in your mouth, but something that actually represents constituencies formed around interest, um, formed around particular kinds of um, you know, kind of either historical needs um or um, you know, there's all kinds of ways, as you said, to organize this, but maybe even saying that an amendment could be abolishing the minoritarian Senate, you know, or or something along those lines. My sense is that the the tendency of the word abolish to show up in various places in the program, it shows up like at least three times to my to my recollection, um, has also a lot to do with the fact that socialists um want to, well, need to distinguish themselves from uh liberals or even progressives, right?

SPEAKER_00Progressives are how to continue to make things the like um more tolerant for more people, but never actually get to a stage, a new stage of um democratic society that is distinctive and and leaves behind uh capitalist uh social relations, right? This is the theory of change of socialists, is that we do want to transform society, but democratic socialism is about doing that through the democratic road, which has so many different um, you know, tactics to get to it.

SPEAKER_00And I think what you just said really brings to mind like having these conversations about what we could be doing, what we could be advocating for, not just that are you know immediately possible, because a lot of things about um trying to crack the Senate, I mean, is so daunting from a from a perspective of we don't have any money, you know, we don't, you know, we don't have the same kind of power, but persuading people that maybe this thing that they have been um inured to, maybe, um, or or sort of trained to believe that nothing could ever change, having those conversations are important and talking about what is it that the Senate as such is doing for you right now, um besides kind of like taking up space in like what otherwise is a kind of you know fixed constellation of what makes up the federal government.

unknownGo ahead.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, so so just a lot of thoughts. Like, so the first is I think the the concerns when folks hear about like you know, abolish the the Senate is is this worry about are we are we doing away with a system of checks and balances entirely that's gonna protect and preserve rights? And the the the thing that I would say in in sort of engaging with that is that the current way, like if we're just talking about the institutions as they currently exist, the current way that these institutions are organized is uh effectively undermines any premise of checks and balances.

SPEAKER_01Because the way that the institutions are currently arranged, they facilitate this combination of minority rule at the national level with like intensifying the power of specific um state um legislatures and like states at the state level, and making making it so that we have a far more aggressive and coercive president that's backstoped by a Supreme Court that's wildly out of step with the rest of the public. I mentioned that Trump got to nominate and confirm three justices to the Supreme Court despite losing the popular vote and using a Senate confirmation process in which senators that voted folks that voted for Republican senators, 40-something million as opposed to over 50 million people voted for Democratic senators.

SPEAKER_01Nonetheless, the the Senate was controlled by the Republican Party. And Democrats have only been able to nominate and confirm five justices to the Supreme Court since 1968. I mean, so this is um this is a system that is that is creating you know far more sort of like intensified forms of centralized power at the top in ways that are producing extreme rights violations. So what we currently have is not compatible with the principles of checks and balances.

SPEAKER_01And effectively, the argument is that the way to get to a place where rights are more likely to be respected is actually, perhaps surprisingly, if you have a more democratic system because you have more people that are involved in the decision-making process. And those rights are more likely to be entrenched over the long term if they're responsive to the demands and interests of a majority. The reason why the civil rights movement was as effective and successful as it was was not just because of Supreme Court decisions, but was because of the way in which it was the embodiment of a multiracial majority in the U.S.

SPEAKER_01And nonetheless, you can have arrangements that still ensure that there's some constraints so that you don't just have pure majoritarianism through some version of a reconstructed bicameralism, through an independent judiciary, and perhaps most importantly, through vibrant civil society, intermediate institutions that serve as a kind of safeguard against an overweening state, even in this moment. Like what pushed back against Trump's and ICE's actions in places like Minnesota?

SPEAKER_01It's like organization on the ground. And as a way of thinking about this, you know, I'd say that if we think about an institution like the Senate, that the defense of bicameralism at 200 plus years ago was really grounded in two things that, in my view, should not be the basis for how we think about our representative institutions.

SPEAKER_01Argument number one was, I think, a deep wariness of ordinary political power, especially as exercised by people that were not property. And what Senates had long been, you know, going back to ancient times and Florence, was a way for property and interests to be able to ensure that their interests were insulated from ordinary political passions. And so that was a key reason why folks defended a Senate. That's one argument. The other argument was the United States at that time was a relatively weak set of newly independent colonies organized around the unit of the state.

SPEAKER_01And in that setting, when you had these states that were really independent colonies with fairly distinct in various ways identities, even if they were part of a shared project, having representative arrangements that recognized the unit made a lot of sense. We're now at a place, 250 years later, where there's much more of a general agreement about the importance of uh of equal citizenship for all, that cuts against the kind of classic aristocratic defense of upper houses, and much more of a sense that, well, wait a second, why should the artifact of this particular unit be the basis for our entire representative system?

SPEAKER_01If the claim is that what we care about in a system of diversity is local democracy and local voice, local democracy and local voice is not the same thing as the state. Like the state of California, the state of Texas is a massive entity in and of itself that isn't necessarily indicative of local political power. Like, why shouldn't cities have various kinds of representation within our political system? And so then that suggests that when we're thinking about representation now, that in order to be able to represent like the plurality and diversity, it might still be really valuable to have versions of bicameralism, but it should be organized around well, what are the principles we care about?

SPEAKER_01Checks and balances that actually protect the rights of those that are most marginalized, a system of pluralism that ensures that interests are broadly reflected across all of the different spaces within society. And so you might want to have an upper house that is reconstructed perhaps in some of the ways that I described, but there's lots of other possibilities that's able to provide some degree of balance, but within a system that's organized around, again, not just a um a house of representatives, but a house of representatives that's framed through some of the other demands, like multi-member districts that are proportional, that an elimination of gerrymandering where elected officials don't get to pick who their voters are, an end to a framework that's premised on the flooding of private money to shape elections, um, you know, a reconstruction effectively of our electoral system so that the House is a more like you know, authentic interpreter of where the public is and the diversity of perspectives across the public.

SPEAKER_01And it's then in conversation with these different institutions, maybe with a reimagined bicameralism, and then with a pre like an independent executive and judiciary that is able to effectuate policy, but isn't unilaterally shaping the direction of lawmaking and then essentially placing its own actions through the combination of executive and judicial power above the terms of the law. And then all of that still with place for ordinary people to shape constitutional change through an amendment process that can be accessed by folks.

SPEAKER_01And alongside this, I'd say that there's lots of things that we can do to change the judiciary. There are court reform measures that I would suggest, including having a much larger Supreme Court, having term limits for the court, reforming the docket.

SPEAKER_00I was gonna say I think they should just have to um they should uh they shouldn't be allowed to pick.

SPEAKER_01Well, this this is this is a significant the the USS Supreme Court is among, if not the most powerful constitutional courts in the world. And it's because of a series of factors that we just take for granted.

SPEAKER_00Norms, basically. Yeah. Self-imposed rules.

SPEAKER_01It's incredibly small, the number of justices, nine, that which has emerged as a norm, where Germany, for instance, 16, um, India 34 in its Supreme Court. You serve for life where typically you have term limits somewhere between nine and fifteen years elsewhere around the world. You don't have an effective amendment process. So all constitutional decision making gets funneled into the court, and they're not clear ways to overrule, reject what the court says. There's no supermajority requirement for decisions when the decisions of the Supreme Court specifically overturn congressional legislation.

SPEAKER_015-4. Like you could, you might want to have a supermajority rule, which is something that socialists and progressives have been calling for for you know decades. And then on top of all of that, starting in the 1920s, there was essentially reforms to Supreme Court practice that gave the power to select the case to the justices. And if four justices on the court want to hear a case, that's those are the cases that come. And if you might wonder, like, you know, there was six years ago, folks were in the streets talking about racial justice in the context of the murder of um George Floyd.

SPEAKER_01And that was entirely about questions of race within our constitutional system. Yet no cases really end up getting litigated at the Supreme Court about the the intersection of our carceral state and race because you have control of the court by an ideological minority that's entrenched through representation that's geographic rather than popular. And then four of those judges get to select what cases.

SPEAKER_01And so, over and over and over again, the only thing that comes up as a question, not the only thing, but like the thing that comes up repeatedly as a question about race is affirmative action. So that essentially a small number of judges are determining for the rest of the country what the reform conversation should be. And it's not even that the cases that they select is indicative of the broad range of cases that most Americans care about. It's that effectively now the country has become like a prisoner to an internal debate within the right wing's coalition about what it alone cares about.

SPEAKER_01And it's a good thing.

SPEAKER_00So you could imagine massive amounts of money and they have endless time to make sure that these cases make their way up to the Supreme Court.

SPEAKER_01Aaron Powell And because there's essentially no ethics code that's been placed on the court, you have direct conflicts of interest and personal ties between the folks that are making decisions about which cases to select and the people that are doing business before the court or are part of political coalitions that are mobilizing legislation. You could imagine reforms that reshape the docket, like that say, that give to a separate body across the federal judiciary the authority to decide what cases go to the Supreme Court, or you could pass congressional law that where Congress ends up stipulating certain topics, the court cases the court has to hear or shapes the terms of the docket.

SPEAKER_01Anyway, this is to say there's no there's no single silver bullet, but there's an institutional landscape that the that Americans experience that they've taken for granted that's entrenched through a language of veneration and kind of constitution worship that is wildly out of step, forget with you know democratic socialism, but with like practices in most places around the world. And that thinking about well, what would be the types of changes to each of these elements that working together can make it more possible for a program like the program we've discussed discussed to be like a feasible future that we can imagine seems to be key.

SPEAKER_01And it can't be the response that, well, we just shouldn't have the conversation. Because if we don't have the conversation, we're gonna be stuck where we are, which is in a setting in which we're all being collectively driven off a cliff. We all recognize the vast majority of Americans recognize that this is a problem, and yet we have institutions and leaders that are either willfully participating in this or seem like uh utterly incapable of addressing the challenges of the time.

SPEAKER_01Like we're at a moment, again, just to like maybe sort of finish up here where we started, where we do have to think in utopian terms in the best sense. Like that, in a sense, to be utopian and to confront our moment with a much broader imagination is almost like the bare minimum that's required to actually pragmatically address the problems we have.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, just two things. One, um the expansion of the House of Representatives and some kind of we'll say radical transformation of a Senate-like structure, which is not, you know, we could we could say that the program itself doesn't forbid something like that. Um, it doesn't say no bicameralism, it just says get rid of the capitalist senate, which I think we could say if the capitalist Senate is the one that we have structured the way that we have the Senate as it is. Yes, the Senate as it is.

SPEAKER_00But the way that people can become empowered, and I'm not crazy about that word, it often is used to mean kind of something more abstract. But to think about themselves as power people with power over the constitution instead of the constitution having power over them in the abstract, I think is something that is does require a feat of imagination because of everything that you've done scholarship on and that you know we can kind of understand the constitution, capital C Constitution, has a hold on imagination.

SPEAKER_00It kind of is synonymous or or contiguous with the idea of America as um a society, even if a lot of the people who maybe are the most um offended or upset are the types who might believe that America is actually decentralized, and that's fine. We don't have, you know, uh um America as uh a unified structure, but America as this kind of um lodestar of uh idealism, exceptionalism, um, freedom is so captured within the constitution.

SPEAKER_00But talking to people about their material interests, what they actually need and want, and the way in which the constitution as it's structured, the ways in which these parts interact, the ways in which the interests of individual politicians who are embedded and who are kind of um uh incentivized to uh take up these structures and capitalize on them are standing in the way of real freedom, real, real freedom to be able to make decisions together, um, you know, as a democratic constituency.

SPEAKER_00I think that's super important to think about through like the lens of having these maybe um, you know, uh minimal demands in the sense that they are not fully fleshed out. They cause people to say, hey, do I agree with this or not? And that way, just to connect to the last thing you said, the conversation ends up happening not just in theoretical um pages of law journals um or you know, kind of within uh the business of those who are maybe uh paid to uh research these things, teach about these things, but having it out in the open, ask individual, ordinary people, what do you think about this?

SPEAKER_00What it like what what do you think about when you think about the idea that um we should have more voting rights instead of less? That we should have you know uh more accountability um for the people who we elect than less, right? Because then you can kind of, I think, to get to your point, identify what is it about the idea of the Senate that people like. And it's the idea that you could have a government. That's responsive and not corrupt, right?

SPEAKER_00That's that it's not just about a bunch of people sort of running rampant over the interests of people, but that people could actually make these decisions together and hold people accountable, which the Senate doesn't is not held accountable by its constituencies in any meaningful way, right? It's a it's essentially a career position as long as people want it, unless and until uh something bad happens, basically. But they're often very uncompetitive and they're very unresponsive to the needs of their constituents. Um, and I don't want to keep you here much longer.

SPEAKER_00And I know that there are other things you wanted to touch on, but um, maybe just one last thought before we finish up.

SPEAKER_01You know, I think I think it's it might be helpful to just think about like, so why is it that folks, including people at DSA, but not just DSA, lots of different um reform groups that are broadly speaking part of, let's say, the left part of the Democratic Party, are talking about constitutional reform, democracy reform right now? Like there are many reasons for it, but I think it's just like worth noting that this was not a conversation 50 years ago. But a hundred years ago, at the time of like the um the SPA and the 1912 platform, it was a conversation.

SPEAKER_01So that there's like an ebb and flow. One of the reasons why there's there's like an ebb and flow is that if you just looked at politics again a half century ago, there wasn't something really like a potential majority in this country that was committed to a whole range of fairly like transformative changes because of the sense that these changes are just like common, you know, common sense things that like that Americans need.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um if you went back a hundred years ago and you read the SPA's platform, or even if you went a little further and you read some of the stuff that was circulating around the New Deal, like again, there's a real majority behind a fairly comprehensive set of changes. And what does that do? That like forces people to say, well, if there's a majority of people that seem to think, for instance, like Medicare for all is a good idea, or that there should be a guaranteed job, or that we have to.

SPEAKER_01Well, it should be free. Yeah, like so if there there is there are large numbers of people behind these policies, and yet the policies cannot be implemented through the existing institutions. That raises the question about like, well, what's going on? And it forces you to think about the relationship between what you might describe as your material demands, like the things that will actually help your day-to-day life, like how do I ensure that like my, you know, like gas prices are lower, whatever it is, and the procedural arrangements of government, which are the rules of the game.

SPEAKER_01And we're living in a moment where I think more and more people recognize that the rules of the game actually have massive effects on the capacity of most people to actually have like their basic basic ends met. And if that's the case, then you can't just proceed by treating those rules as fixed. Like you have to have an approach that combines a conversation about how can we change the rules with a conversation about how your everyday uh goals and needs can be connected.

SPEAKER_01It's why, like, you know, it might be surprising to think like, why is it that the SPA like had to spend so much time on political demands? Because they recognize that these things were connected precisely because of the kinds of roadblocks that were placed. And so then the question, I think, for the present is really to kind of emphasize how those two things are linked, but then to again, along with expanding the imaginative horizon, start really thinking about well, what what are the the steps and processes that get us from like here to there, how to think of things like significant institutional reform while still holding on to a real ethics of political responsibility that ensures that changes to the big C constitution, changes to the big S Senate go hand in hand with, in my view, a respect for the little C principles of constitutionalism that are grounded in anti-impunity, um uh like um a suspicion and opposition to the use of like coercive violence as a mechanism for pursuing various kinds of change, like a refusal to fall prey to the kinds of authoritarian, you know, assertions that that precisely define the actions of the right while still thinking about how we can engage in change.

SPEAKER_01And that's like a a conversation that asks us, and I think we're all capable of doing this, of basically like um, you know, as they say, like um walking and chewing gum at the same time.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Being able to hold in common a vision of a world that we want, of a set of reforms that we need, and a recognition of the kinds of practices that we have to engage in, and really the kind of democratic ethic we have to hold firm to as the mechanism by which we pursue those changes.

SPEAKER_00Well, thanks so much for joining us and thanks to our production crew, Michael and Tim, who put this all together. CLASS is a podcast of DSA's National Political Education Commission, or NPEC, which works to expand the knowledge of DSA members and non-members in the service of winning the struggle for socialism and democracy. You can find out more about NPEC by searching for us online or following us on social media. But the best way to find out what our committee's up to is by signing up for Red Letter, NPEC's monthly newsletter. And if you aren't already, you can become a DSA member by following the link in the podcast description.

SPEAKER_00Okay, until next time, solidarity.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Old Being Reborn @ Socialism Conference 2026

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Socialist Surge, feat. Louisville DSA

    Nov 10, 202652 minAudio

    We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Socialist Veteran

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Joy Cometh In the Morning": The Words of Eugene Debs

    Oct 27, 202623 minAudio

    In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Carceral Minimalism, or Abolitionism?

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode