Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Class

Class artwork

What is Socialism? Pt. 2 Ben Tarnoff's Building Socialism from Below: Popular Power and the State

May 19, 202326 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Responding to the swelling socialist movement, Tarnoff builds on the work of Nicos Poulantzas and “Eurocommunism” to illustrate how growing a socialist movement requires both competing within the institutions of the state (for example through elections) and developing an autonomous layer of “people power” to act on the state. His essay blends an analysis of tactics and strategy for the socialist movement with a vision of the ultimate goal of a democratic socialism that will have both a transformed state and transformed civil society. In this episode members of DSA’s National Political Committee (NPC) discuss Ben Tarnoff’s essay. José La Luz is a lifelong labor organizer and campaigner with roots in the New Left in the late 60’s and early 70’s. He was a founding member of DSA after joining DSOC prior to the merger with NAM in the mid 80’s. He is the most senior member of the NPC (in age) adding a multigenerational presence to the national leadership. Sofia Cutler is a member of North New Jersey DSA, and has been a member of the DSA National Political Committee since 2021 as part of the Bread and Roses Slate. She is a rank-and-file member of Unite Here Local 33. Justin Charles is a member of North Brooklyn DSA, and has been a member of the DSA National Political Committee since July 2020. DSA NPEC Curriculum https://dsa-education.pubpub.org/modules DSA’s Leadership and Structure https://www.dsausa.org/about-us/structure/ Ben Tarnoff’s “Building Socialism from Below: Popular Power and the State” https://drive.google.com/file/d/1731oHoNsQJLzoXU6yO_ZXjAT9MT4BQnr/view Credits: Producer: Elton LK Logo by Michaela Brangan Sound Engineer & Opening Music by Casey Stikker Additional Assistance, including content by Palmer Conrad Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Elton LKThis is Class, an official podcast of the Democratic Socialists of America National Political Education Committee. My name is Elton LK. This episode is part two of a series called What is Socialism. There is no simple answer to this question. So we're asking several members of DSA's elected leadership, members of the National Political Committee, known as the NPC, and not to be confused with the National Political Education Committee( NPEC).

Elton LKOn the last episode, you met José Alejandra La Luz, Justin Charles, and Sofia Cutler. We'll hear our guests discuss the curriculum from their different socialist perspectives, how they view socialism and the socialist movement. And in this episode, they'll talk about where the focus of the socialist movement should be and how we win some of those reforms like Medicare for All. Today's episode will cover an article by Ben Tarnoff entitled, building Socialism from Below: Popular Power in the State, which is available in the curriculum on our website@education.dsausa.org.

Elton LKPlease note that this interview was recorded back in the summer of 2022, so they won't be commenting about events that have occurred in the meantime. Okay, here's our episode.

Daphne ThierWelcome to this episode of the DSA National Political Education Podcast. My name is Daphne Thier. Welcome Justin, Sofia, José. First, let's explain some terms that Tarnoff is using. What does he mean when he talks about the autonomous layer? Justin, can you walk us through that?

Justin CharlesSure. So the autonomous layer, um, and that autonomy, you know, I think being mostly about autonomy from the state, that being self-organized and self-managed groups of working class people fighting around specific, uh, demands or goals. The, the, the, the key, the key distinction being outside of the state and not within it.

Daphne ThierRight. That's gonna bring us to the approach that Tarnoff is talking about in his piece. But before we get there, maybe a little bit more about this autonomous layer. Sofia, Tarnoff also uses the term"socialism from below". That's a big one. What does that mean?

Sofia CutlerWhen he talks about socialism from below, he means socialism that's fought for through working class self-activity in the streets and our workplaces and protests and strikes. It's an inside outside approach to the state. So one that still engages in elections and, and parliamentary politics, but that always has its foot in the workplace, in the community, in the streets, and is distinct from a socialism from above that sees socialism being fought for by, he calls them"self-appointed saviors" who we elect in the state.

Sofia CutlerThis approach of socialism from below sees the engagement outside the state that Justin was talking about as really important and not one that we can lose.

Daphne ThierJosé, did you wanna add anything about socialism from below? What it means to you?

José La LuzFrankly speaking, I, uh, do not know of any successful socialist revolution that hasn't been organized by the working class building power from below. Uh, eh, anything else is just a coup d'état, eh, or, uh, you know, what some of us will call, uh,? Or, uh, you know, the use of, uh, you know, terror or other, uh, means, eh, to impose, uh, a certain, uh, eh change, uh, in this case of the social order from the top.

José La LuzAnd that's not what we, uh, democratic socialists, eh, are about. We are about, uh, building, you know, power from below by organizing, in our case here in America, the multiracial, uh, working class, uh, and organizing it, uh, first and foremost at the point of production in the workplaces and in the communities, eh, and organizing also, you know, the, uh, different, uh, you know, racial, uh, expressions of this, uh, working class.

José La LuzI mean, uh, we witness, uh, an uprising, uh, in this country, uh, against, uh, racial oppression. The Black Lives, uh, Matter, uh, and a different intervals in the history of this country because of the way, you know, capitalism has been constructed, uh, in America where race is central for the construction of us capitalism at different intervals in the history of America. You know, certain struggles against racial and national operation, uh, have risen, uh, you know, to, uh, to the forefront.

José La LuzUh, and, uh, you know, this is one of the most important elements for us, uh, in DSA to understand, and I suspect is the source of some of our political and ideological differences, eh, that, uh, will be playing out, eh, in the course of our, uh, you know, tenure in the next, uh, you know, year or so, eh, but, uh, I have never known of any successful, eh, you know, socialist, uh, eh, uh, country, eh, that where socialism has not been built by the working class from below.

Daphne ThierThis article was written back in 2018 before a majority of DSA's members today were even members. But at a time when movements and socialism were already on the rise, AOC had already won the primary in New York, the terrain was clearly shifting. But like Tarnoff says, the main beneficiaries of the breakdown and legitimacy and stability of the establishment, you know, the ruling class, the traditional sort of actors in government is actually the far right and not the left.

Daphne ThierAnd as part of that, today, we're seeing an alarming rollback of some major gains of previous movements. Most recent was Roe v Wade, but it's also LGBTQ rights, voting rights like rampant gerrymandering, really a rollback of the Civil Rights Movement and all under a Biden administration, a Democratic administration. Justin, can you talk to us, why is this happening? Why isn't Biden better? What is it gonna take to make him better? Tarnoff argues for a two-pronged approach inside, outside the state.

Daphne ThierCan you explain that approach? Do you agree with it? Why or why not?

Justin CharlesUh, we don't really have time to talk about, um, all the reasons why this is happening and all the reasons why Biden is so terrible. Um, but I'll try and I'll try and be brief and summarize. I mean, I think the, what you said about the far right, uh, being the beneficiaries of, of the breakdown and legitimacy and stability of our, of our, of our, you know, systems of governance. I think usually in my experience in my lifetime, I've observed that the right or the GOP in power means, you know, regression.

Justin CharlesUm, i t means, you know, peeling away some of the rights that have been established and moving towards, uh, a much, much worse, you know, uh, s tate of affairs Democrats in power on t he other hand, usually I think means trying to kind of reach some kind of equilibrium or stabilize. The problem with that is that we've been drug to the right by, um, t he right in p ower. So the way that works out is like, you know, sliding to the right no matter what. Even if we're just kind of stabilizing, it's something that's like a little bit more in aligned with whatever norms, uh, the Democrats are observing.

Justin CharlesUltimately, that only leads rightward. I don't think you can make Biden better. I think maybe you can extract some concessions from him, but it might be too late for that. Cuz, you know, he's about to lose Congress and, you know, probably he is gonna get whacked in 2024. Um, if he decides to run again, we'll see what happens. But I think, you know, as to the, the inside outside approach, one, we can't afford to, to just forfeit engaging with the state. For us, that means, you know, running an elections for office as well as fighting for legislation, fighting for reforms, right?

Justin CharlesWe need to replace the elements in the state legislators who don't re really represent us as a class and our interests. But that's not sufficient. If we did all that. Capital is very flexible and adaptive and would find a way to keep us from getting what we want. There has to be more to our, to our approach than that. And that's, that's where I think the autonomous layer, the outside comes in. You know, f you know, in our, in, in, in, in the episode about what democratic socialism is, I think, you know, we talk a lot about democracy, and I think part of what the autonomous layer, the outside approach is, is developing that future, uh, idea of what democracy looks like.

Justin CharlesAnd that's gonna look like independent class struggle organizations, working class institutions, fighting and winning things. And in the process of doing so, building solidarity, showing each other what solidarity looks like. Cause I don't think we as a society really have a good idea about what that is. But I think once you've experienced it in the form of whatever fight you've, you, you, you get in to, to win something, to improve your station, to improve your life, in my experience, when you, when you, when you win one of those fights, you wanna win more and you wanna bring more people into that fight with you.

Justin CharlesAnd I think that one scares the state, um, and makes it do things it wouldn't do otherwise. But it also, it, it, it builds the capacity for our class, uh, to go on and to win bigger victories for ourselves. And I think ultimately winning the victory of running society. I agree with the approach. I think it's very important.

Daphne ThierJosé, Tarnoff argues against the left's impulse to sometimes just quote, do something. So what should we be doing? Should we be defending democracy right now, like voting rights and abolishing the filibuster, abolishing the Supreme Court? Or is our focus on social movements? Or do we put more effort into organizing workers?

José La LuzFrankly speaking, I don't know what, uh, comrade Tarnoff means about the left's impulse to just, uh, do nothing or something because, uh, we, you know, uh, in DSA and we're only one expression of the left, you know, there is a much, uh, broader and bigger left, uh, in our country. We might very well be the, the largest organization, but we are not the sum of the left, uh, in the United States. Uh, and so, you know, on the question of, uh, what are our most important tasks, uh, one is, uh, building the capacity of the working class of the, once again, the multiracial working class to fight, you know, for fundamental material gains, the working class most achieve fundamental material gains, if it is to move from an economic, you know, struggle, you know, the fight to raise, uh, the wages and, uh, increase benefits and worker protections to a political fight, you know, which would signal a higher a level of, uh, social and political consciousness.

José La LuzYou know, let me give you a, a an important example of, uh, one critical democratic, fundamental democratic, right, that the American multiracial working class should fight for. In Canada and in Mexico, the right to organize is a constitutional right. And in the so-called most democratic country on the face of the earth, we have got to fight this, you know, in Congress, uh, in a Congress that, uh, has been dominated by corporate interests, whether they happen to be in the Republican party, which is totally captured by extreme right neofascist, right-wing populist elements that include, uh, paramilitary wing as we saw, uh, on June, uh, on, uh, January 6th.

José La LuzUh, which, uh, you know, it's, uh, a, a very frightening and threatening, uh, for people like ourselves, uh, who are, uh, socialists because we will be the primary targets. And I mean, physically, you know, the primary targets, uh, if these people capture, uh, power in America. Uh, but on the question of, uh, fighting for material gains, eh, comrade, uh, Sanders, eh, put together, he crafted a package of social democratic reforms, uh, which was described as the build back better, uh, you know, package.

José La LuzI'm trying to, to figure out what the hell is the meaning of the build back better. But I know that the person who crafted the package is comrade Sanders, who is a Democratic socialist. Uh, and this package failed because, uh, you know, the Democrats could not master enough votes to get a pass. Why? Because they have, you know, uh, voices for the capitalist class, uh, inside, uh, their midst, you know, this fellow Manchin and this other, uh, person, uh, Sinema are just mouthpieces of the capitalist class.

José La LuzUh, you know, uh, glaring, uh, you know, uh, shameless, uh, you know, voices for the capitalist class. So comrade Sanders package failed, and, uh, it erases, it, it that generates, you know, the kind of, uh, political backlash that gives and empower, uh, you know, the right wing and neo fascism in this country, which has become such an imminent, you know, threat to our existence. Uh, and, uh, as, as workers and as, uh, you know, workers that are racially diverse, uh, because, uh, you know, for me, you know, the rise of this right wing, uh, paramilitary elements, he puts a target on my back as a, as a worker, you know, as a Puerto Rican worker.

José La LuzUh, and so, uh, you know, that is one thing. I don't know the meaning of the inside and outside strategy, frankly speaking, I don't know what the hell that means. I know that socialism has to be built by accumulating power by the working class, and that means by organizing the class, uh, economically in trade unions in this country, we have one of the lowest unionization rates, uh, in the capitalist, uh, world. And it's, once again, a travesty.

José La LuzUh, we have got to organize corporate giants like, uh, Amazon, uh, we have to organize the baristas, uh, in the Starbucks, but that's not going to give us, uh, substantial, you know, power, uh, of the kind that we need to acc accumulate to be able to be in a position, uh, to rest power from the capitalist, uh, class. Because if this is a, a question of achieving power, uh, is it gonna be done by, uh, a general strike? Is it gonna be, uh, achieved by a combination of, uh, mass struggle in the streets?

José La LuzA general strike, perhaps other forms of struggle that we couldn't discuss here, uh, in this podcast mean all of those things, uh, are going to be on the table. But at this point, you know, the American working class is desperately in need of a mass socialist organization that is multi-racial, and that is rooted in the class because we are far from being, uh, an organization rooted in the working class and mostly rooted in the multiracial working class.

Daphne ThierActually, I have a follow up on that because you're talking about the multiracial working class a lot, and I'm wondering what specifically you think the socialist movement has to offer the anti-racist movement, and conversely, why the anti-racist movement is so important to the socialist movement

José La LuzHere in the United States. Uh, and it's also true, uh, across the Atlantic and, and in other countries, by the way, uh, in Latin America, Asia, and even in Africa, race, uh, has been central to the construction of capitalism here in the United States. Uh, you know, there was a great accumulation of wealth, uh, as a result of the enslavement of African, uh, labor, eh, performing, uh, uh, uh, work and labor in implantations, uh, in the south.

José La LuzThat kind of accumulation made it possible, uh, for the, uh, rapid development of the productive forces in the north and the industrialization of not only the north in this country, but actually the industrialization of, uh, of Great Britain. Uh, so, uh, we can argue that on the backs of the, uh, enslavement of, uh, African workers plantations in the south, capitalism was highly developed. Not only did it happen on the back, uh, of, uh, you know, enslaved African workers, but it happened as a result of the brutal expropriation and genocide of, uh, first nations in this country, uh, in what we call, you know, settle, uh, colonial, uh, capitalism in this country, capitalism is always racial, but in this countries fundamentally constructed racially.

José La LuzAnd so we are going to have to address the contradictions that exist in the class because white supremacy has been made a premium and a privilege in this country. And that is one of the reasons why the class has not been able to build unity. And why, you know, uh, uh, neo fascism, what some people call, you know, Trumpism, which is an expression of, uh, you know, right wing populism. Cause, uh, you know, fascism is very different, uh, in every country, uh, uh, in the world.

José La LuzUh, one of the, one of the fundamental challenges that we face is white supremacists, uh, ideology, which doesn't allow for black and Latino and Asian workers and white workers to understand that they have a common enemy in the capitalist class. Uh, and this is something that we are gonna have to address, uh, in DSA, but I suspect, and I dare suggest that is going to be the result of intense a political and ideological debate, beginning with the national leadership of the organization, and also throughout and across the entire organization.

Justin CharlesYou know, if I could, you know, just kind of, you know, respond a bit to, to some of what José was saying, particularly in the US context, I think, you know, I think it's really important for, for, for American socialists to understand the history of the United States as it relates to race. I, you know, I personally think, you know, if, if we had, if something we ought to look into, add into our curriculum is, is, is is Black Reconstruction by W.E.B. Du Bois, because I think telling the story of, you know, as, as he calls it, the general strike, but also of, of, of enslaved people, you know, laying down their tools and, and, and walking off plantations, but also talking about the intense, like just the, the potential and the, that period of reconstruction, you know, which was, you know, attacked, you know, brutally by the capitalist class in the north and the south, and not protected at all in any way by the state meaningfully.

Justin CharlesThere was so much potential that I think, you know, much of what we talk about in DSA in terms of kind of the social democratic reforms that were after, like that stuff was instituted in reconstruction and, and, and taken away white supremacy being a tool by which it was, it was taken away, you know, not just from black folks, but from, from poor white folks in the south too. So I think it's essential for American, for us socialists to, to, to have an understanding of, of, of that history. Um, but, but I'll say that, you know, I think the, the classes in motion in a lot of different ways and a lot of different places, and I think, you know, some of, of that struggle, you know, I think we, we do talk a lot about universal demands in, in DSA, and we should, but I think there's also an argument to be made for a bit of analysis of the particular ways in which, uh, the class, and its different permutations, black, brown, indigenous, uh, Asian, various people of color experienced their oppression and exploitation, and in what way are we as socialists engaged in those struggles directly?

Justin CharlesBecause I mean, and I think, you know, we could talk a little bit about this, but I think there's, there, there are so many struggles that we need to be in and tie together in order for us to, to get that kind of really robust autonomous layer that's going to lead to us building socialism in this country and in the world.

Daphne ThierThat is fascinating history, and I'm really glad you mentioned the slave strike, which to my knowledge is the largest labor strike in US history and ultimately won the war. And we don't even talk about it like that. Sofia, this is the kind of secret power that we always talk about, which we'll have a series dedicated to why the working class organized labor is such a force. Can you talk to us about how organized labor can help us be more effective in reforming the state?

Daphne ThierWhat are some of the examples of how an organized labor movement might be able to counter the rise of the right or win reforms?

Sofia CutlerYeah, so labor and organized labor is central to socialism, not out of, primarily out of a, a, a moral commitment, although I, I think that's part of it. The people who do the work should get the profits, but it's also a strategic question. Labor is the goose that lays the golden egg. It's the source of profit under capitalism. And why withholding labor and striking is arguably the most powerful tool we have in terms of reforming the state.

Sofia CutlerWe need a really strong labor movement to do so. We saw that in the history of this country with the New deal, which arose out of one of the most militant periods in American labor history. And I think as an organization, we have done a good job electing people, but it's harder to govern, and it's harder to legislate, partly because we don't have an organized labor movement in this country, although that's, it's reawakening in many ways, but it's still not where we need it to be.

Sofia CutlerHistorically, labor and, and militant unions are important for fighting the right, because they offer workers, uh, class consciousness instead of racism, xenophobia, patriarchy, um, for understanding their society. And, uh, that's why they're so important for, for democracy. In some ways, though, I think you asked how can it counter the right Historically strong labor movements also fuel fascism and, and response too.

Sofia CutlerSo it's a, a tricky dialectic. I think our, our central task is, is to build a, a, a militant labor movement if we wanna fight for anything.

Daphne ThierMy main takeaway from this discussion is that it's not gonna be easy, it's complicated. I am hoping though, that this conversation helps people who are new to our organization, maybe new to socialist politics, to understand more what this organization is about and what our politics are. There are lots of political debates in dsa. Mostly there's strategic debates. I think a lot of our end goals are in line, but how we get there to our end goal, to socialism, that's really the million dollar question.

Daphne ThierAnd figuring that out is going to start with conversations like these about what our politics are and where our focus should be, what our strategy is.

Elton LKThis is Class, an official podcast of the Democratic Socialists of America National Political Education Committee. My name is Elton LK. If you're interested in anything we've been talking about, if you think the system is rigged and democracy is the solution, join DSA, become a member. I've put a link in the show notes to DSA's website. If you're already a member of DSA, please share this podcast with your local chapter. Class is intended to be a resource for chapters and members to articulate, apply and share socialist theory with DSA and the wider working class.

Elton LKAlso, remember to rate and review us on iTunes or your favorite pod catcher. And last, I'd like to thank Casey sticker for sound engineering theme, music and editing. Thanks to Palmer Conrad for administrative assistance and helping with the content. Alright, we'll be back in two weeks.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Old Being Reborn @ Socialism Conference 2026

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Socialist Surge, feat. Louisville DSA

    Nov 10, 202652 minAudio

    We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Socialist Veteran

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Joy Cometh In the Morning": The Words of Eugene Debs

    Oct 27, 202623 minAudio

    In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Carceral Minimalism, or Abolitionism?

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode