Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Class

Class artwork

Non-Reformist Reforms

Mar 22, 202323 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Socialism 2022 Conference, Chicago Recording was taken from the “How Do We Get a New Constitution” session, of which “part 1” was released in the previous episode of Class Panelists: Amna Akbar, Aziz Rana The Left’s path to power is blocked by one of the oldest and least democratic founding documents in the world. Will it take a revolution to rewrite our Constitution? The recent Constituent Assembly in Chile may show a way forward. Amna Akbar is a professor of law at The Ohio State University Moritz College of Law. Her popular essays and op-eds have appeared in the venues like the New York Times, New York Review of Books, the Boston Review, The Nation, and Jacobin. She serves on the editorial board of the Law and Political Economy Blog. Aziz Rana is a professor of law at Cornell University. He is the author of The Two Faces of American Freedom and the forthcoming book, The Constitutional Bind: Why a Broken Document Rules America. Aziz Rana, “Who Owns the Constitution”, Jacobin https://jacobin.com/2020/10/us-constitution-law-supreme-court-socialism Aziz Rana, “Why Americans Worship the Constitution”, Public Seminar of The New School https://publicseminar.org/essays/why-americans-worship-the-constitution/ Andre Gorz’s “Reform and Revolution” https://socialistregister.com/index.php/srv/article/view/5272/2173 Paris, May of ’68 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_68 Join DSA. Become a Member. https://act.dsausa.org/donate/membership/ Credits: Producer: Elton LK Logo by Michaela Brangan Sound Engineer & Opening Music by Casey Sticker Additional Assistance, including content by Palmer Conrad Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Elton LKThis is Class, an official podcast to the Democratic Socialists of America National Political Education Committee. My name is Elton LK. I've named this episode Non-Reformist Reforms because it focuses on that topic, and it is a live topic in DSA right now. But technically this is part two of DSA's session called"How Do We Get a New Constitution?" from the Socialism 2022 Conference in September. There were three panelists on the"How do we Get a New Constitution?" panel.

Elton LKThe entire session was excellent. For the sake of clarity, this episode of Class focuses on non-reformist reforms and includes a presentation by Amna Akbar, primarily as well as answers during the q and a portion of the session from both Amna and Aziz Rana. Amna Akbar is an associate professor of law at Ohio State University. Aziz Rana is a professor of law at Cornell University. I introduced him in greater detail in the previous episode of Class.

Elton LKNot included in either episode is an interesting talk by long-term DSA member David Alde about Chile and their attempt to replace their constitution. Perhaps we can address this topic in another episode soon. Non-reformist reforms are about getting out of the historic socialist deadlock between reform and revolution. DSA is far from resolved on this topic. Some members proudly identify as revolutionaries rejecting anything that hints at reformism.

Elton LKOthers have never taken Socialist Revolution seriously dismissing it as a failed 20th century strategy. Austrian and French Marxist, and sometimes called post-Marxist, André Gorz tried to rethink this deadlock in his 1967 book, A Strategy for Labor, and his March 17th, 1968 essay Reform and Revolution. Gorz lived at a time when Marxist believed the socialist revolution was just around the corner.

Elton LKRemember that he didn't know it at the time, but Paris was just about to experience a revolutionary moment in the May of 1968, just a few months later. If you're not familiar with May of 68, I've included a link to the Wikipedia article in the show notes. Gorz was tired of being told the revolution was just around the corner. Revolutionary Marxists were refraining from reforming capitalism because they feared it would weaken the socialist movement.

Elton LKRevolutionary Marxists were afraid that political compromises with a hegemonic capitalist class would cause workers to resign themselves to a more gentle capitalism and give off the appearance that the socialists were collaborating with the capitalists. But Gorz believed in action. Waiting for capitalism to destroy itself was more demoralizing to the legitimacy of the socialist movement. Gorz argued that socialists needed to proactively join workers in struggle by fighting for non-reformist reforms.

Elton LKSo let me give you some tangible examples, especially in our own context. Medicare for All would give workers healthcare so that their unions would have more space to negotiate, not for insurance, cuz they've already got that taken care of. But for political power. Free college would give workers more courage in their labor actions in the workplace because they would have more disposable income and less debt. The Pro Act would give greater protection to workers against retribution from their bosses, and thus, a better position from which to fight the bosses.

Elton LKAnd then of course, a new more democratic constitution, like Aziz discussed in the last episode, could go a long way towards strengthening working class power. Gords believed as workers won victories that reformed capitalism, the victories would build hope and excitement that the battle for socialism was winnable and workers would join their comrades in struggle. Building working class power means not merely waiting until we have the numbers and the power to implement socialism, but having the power at all levels of society to limit what the ruling class can get away with.

Elton LKThis gives you a little context about non reformist reforms, though keep in mind that Amna in her lecture is more concerned with coming up with a conception of non-reformist reforms that's relevant for our current material conditions, not those of Paris in the sixties.

Amna AkbarI teach at a law school and I'm trained as a lawyer. A lot of what I've been doing for the last several years is, um, in some sense, um, studying what people in this room are doing and what the broader left has been doing and engaging in all these sorts of campaigns and protest activity, um, since Occupy onward. Um, and so typically I'm in rooms, um, and I'm talking to people who are lawyers and law professors and more liberals. So this is, um, humbling and a little intimidating for me to be speaking to, um, a room at the Socialism conference.

Amna AkbarUm, and so please, um, I'd be eager to hear any feedback and talk back both in the q and a and afterwards. Um, okay, so Mia asked about this concept of non-reformist reforms, um, and whether that's a way to think about, um, the way forward, um, as many of you know and are engaged with, um, the concept of the non-reformist reform is kind of a concept that is, um, rooted in the socialist and broader left, um, to develop a kind of alternative to liberal reformism as Aziz was talking about.

Amna AkbarUm, it's about the demand itself, so what it is that you're demanding, but more importantly about how you fight, um, and to what ends, right? So if liberal reformers are often focused on tinkering and, um, liberal reformism often entails buying into the precepts, the discourses and the processes that, um, formal legal and political process involves. So for example, testifying at a hearing, filing a lawsuit, um, lobbying in Congress, but refusing and de-legitimizing the importance of protest and rebell rebellious kind of activity from below the building of autonomous organizations and so on and so forth.

Amna AkbarUm, the non-reformist performed then is a concept that's designed not just to, um, demand and envision an alternate horizon, a different world, socialism, abolition, democracy, so on and so forth. Um, but also to entail a broader, more disruptive and more kind of mul, um, uh, uh, diverse and multiplicitous kind of set of strategies and tactics for transforming, um, the world. Um, and so André Gorz is often credited with, or is credited with coming up with this term, but I think right now it's in such broad circulation across the broader left from the DSA and Jacobin, um, to prison abolitionist organizing, um, indigenous organizing, and so on and so forth, that I kind of think we're in a moment where we should all be kind of thinking about what is the concept of the non reformist reform that we need for today.

Amna AkbarBecause when Gorz was writing, he was talking about, um, Europe and France, and there were in different ways mature socialist, communist and workers movements and parties in a way that we don't have here. And so the question of how we engage in struggles, um, whether for non reformist reforms are something else in order to advance the power of the working class, to advance the power of democratic and self-governance and rule and so on and so forth, requires assessing the conditions in which we are in the balance of power in society. And to try to figure out from where we are at now, an assessment of this conjuncture, what are the strategic battles, um, that we should be engaging in.

Amna AkbarUm, so it's worth saying. Um, oh, right. The other thing worth saying is that often, um, and we're seeing this actually right now in a really interesting way, the demands that liberals make and the demands that leftists or socialists are making are not necessarily different. As I was saying, the different is the horizon, how we fight for the fight. And so right now, partly because of the success of, um, and the kind of rebellious nature of all the protests of the last decade, a lot of the demands the left is making, whether it's the socialist agree, socialist green new deal that the DSA is making, whether it's campaigns for no new jails, whether it's, um, uh, demands for single payer healthcare, all of the or cancel student debt.

Amna AkbarThese are demands now that have become so central in the discourse and are being waged at the local state and federal level all over the country that you have liberals also echoing them and kind of chiming in in different ways, whether it's people who are like, okay, yeah, let's shut down this one jail or defund the police by 1%, but we're not really for fully defunding or yes, you know, um, when we call for the green New Deal, we want a little bit of a transformation of the economy, but we're not really looking for worker, um, power and control, that sort of thing. And so it's kind of important to kind of think about that. All right.

Amna AkbarOne of the things that's I think basic and important to say about the non reformist reform, in addition to what I already said, this is kind of how it's typically talked about, is that the basic concept in terms of the nature of the demand, it's something that's under undermining the prevailing system. So capitalism, um, or, um, in some people's account, uh, prison, industrial, um, complex and building another one. So socialism, communism, um, uh, abolition democracy, and then engaging in concrete material and ideological struggle that offers concrete things to people that makes a difference in their lives.

Amna AkbarBut it's also like I was gesturing at before strategic in the particular moment, um, and contributing to the building of autonomous power, um, and organization. Um, okay, one of the reasons why it's really important, as you all know, is precisely this idea of how do we link our longer term desire for revolutionary and transformative change, um, under understanding that it's not simply about changing the terms, um, in which we live are the laws or legal relations, but relations, uh, more broadly and who's in charge of society.

Amna AkbarUm, so one of the things, so this, this panel is focused on the question of the constitution, or that was the frame anyways, but I think one of the problems with thinking that way is if we concede that the terms of the debate, and I know people in this room probably wouldn't, but if we concede that the terms of the debate are the constitution or even law and legalism more broadly, we've lost already, right? Because the law pretends to set the rules by which society lives. Um, but as we all know, it's at best a partial contradictory conflicting set of rules that often kind of puts out a certain kind of face of how it's acting projects, one story of what's going on, um, but is often doing very different things.

Amna AkbarOkay? So if you look back at, um, Gorz, or even if you look at Ruth Wilson Gilmore's writing and speaking, one of the things that's important to understand, um, is that non-reformist performs in a lot of these people's thinking and writing. Um, and even in some of the campaigns we see today is not simply about, um, state power, but it's about, uh, the power of workers over the economy more broadly and other contesting other modes of, um, relationship and power. So Gilmore, for example, talks about, um, this idea that seems to be the name of the conference about changing everything.

Amna AkbarShe talks about building abolition geographies as part of her concept of non-reformist reform. In Gorz's writing, he talks about not just demands on the state, but demands on the economy and on capital. Um, and then this contemporary organization, the Red Nation, um, they, uh, talk about not simply that their concept of non-reformist reform is focused on how to return social wealth to those who produce it. But they also say, and I'm gonna actually read this from their Red Deal, they say they're a concept of non-reformist reforms. They'll take quote many forms, and then the examples they create, and I think this is really important, is interesting, is grassroots indigenous seed bank networks where thousands of sustainable farmers share trade and feed their communities successful runs for city council elections, where left candidates implement a people's platform for climate social justice at city and municipal levels, and land back campaigns or tribal council resolutions that reject colonial water settle settlements by banding with oth other indigenous nations to blockade all government and corporate efforts to commodify water.

Amna AkbarSo here, just like with Gorz and Gilmore, they're making clear that their concept of the non-reformist reform is a broader array of, um, different sorts of action than just kind of making demands on the state or seeking changes in the law. Okay, so the last thing I just want just to pick up, um, on where Mia was kind of setting us up to some extent about, um, the Constitution in crisis and the way that liberals are kind of waking up to, um, the problem with the Supreme Court in a particular way.

Amna AkbarUm, I think there is a kind of opening and an opportunity with that, um, crisis of legitimacy. Um, but if you think about the Supreme Court and the question of the Constitution as kind of this concern about what you might think of as like high law, kind of the face of law, um, in liberal society and in the New York Times and so on and so forth, I think it's an opportunity to link it to where we're actually seeing militancy and struggle happen all over the country, which is not in relation to the Supreme Court, but it's in relation to all the other forms of court and legalism that do violence and extract from poor working class black and brown communities all over the country.

Amna AkbarSo whether you're talking about housing court where, uh, where evictions happen, you're talking about criminal courts where people are being policed, fined and feed incarcerated immigration court where people are being deported. All the courts have actually become a very central place where a lot of, um, the mechanics of the contemporary state, um, are, are extracting from, um, and doing violence to working people and poor people all over the country. And that's where you see a lot of con contestation of, um, of the political economic order, whether it's in the criminal courts, in terms of bail funds and Dianes and the different kinds of protests we saw, um, through the movement for Black Lives Ferguson, um, uh, Minneapolis and so on.

Amna AkbarWhether it's the kind of work that Casey Tenents is doing, um, in Kansas City to disrupt eviction courts and make sure that, um, the judges there can't continue to evict, um, people, whether it's, um, the way that immigration, um, uh, immigrant justice activists have disrupted, um, the ability of deportations to be affected. And so in an interesting way, and I haven't quite worked this out, but it feels to me a little bit like, um, if one of the major wins of the civil rights movement was, was this kind of, um, uh, legal equality win that we're now coming back, our movements now are kind of confronting the fact that the legal equality, um, is not enough liberal legal equality is not enough, and that what we're looking for is a fundamentally transformed society.

Amna AkbarAnd so to do that, you have to engage more than, um, you can't just engage with the court's legislators and so on, on their own terms, but you have to kind of engage in this broader kind of realm of contestation from below and to feed, um, in some sense where the militancy is already happening. So I think the courts are important place, but not necessarily the Supreme Court or, um, the Constitution.

Aziz RanaThanks. One of the real problems with the liberal imagination around constitutions is the way in which it separates what we can think of as process and substance, so that they're rules, they're the rules of representative government, and those are supposed to be held constant. And instead then there's like politics that takes place within those rules around policies like, you know, the Obama's aca when it comes to, to healthcare. And that separation then transforms this issue of the rules of the game, essentially into a matter of kind of like technical expertise.

Aziz RanaSo they're lawyers or political scientists or social scientists that have different models, and they conceive of different potential fixes to the rules to make sure that those rules function adequately and then people operate within, within those terms. And I think one of the real kind of contributions of socialist thinking, especially in the early part of the 20th century, was to say, you cannot separate process and substance that we actually live. We don't live in a world that distinguishes these two. We operate in worlds in which there's just a landscape of institutions, institutions of state of economy, at all levels of, of government and society that impose a kind of pervasive status quo.

Aziz RanaAnd that in a way, the function of thinking about revolutionary or non reformist performs is like, well, what are the levers that we have at our disposal that can disrupt as many of these existing hierarchies, uh, at once? And like, what kinds of levers would make it harder for the existing status quo to reproduce itself? And some of those might operate at the level of the actual written constitution. So for example, having a much simplified amendment process would, would, would create a mechanism where our basic rules would be ones that we can continuously change and alter based on mass popular commitment.

Aziz RanaSome of them though might have nothing to do with, with the structure of the constitution, but actually might operate at the local level, for instance, around broadly expanding access to public housing that would have a transformative effect on the type of communities that people find themselves embedded in. And that all of these things should be thought of along the same continuum of struggle. And one of the worries that I have with let's say a, a kind of particular direction in left politics, totally understandably, is that precisely because of the dominance of a liberal imagination about what constitutions are, what constitutionalism consistent is, you sort of think of that, well, that's the stuff that liberals care about, that's about fixes.

Aziz RanaIt's not really where like the working class lives. And I think a long tradition of a radical activist was to say, well, that's precisely part of the actual project of socialist change, which is how do you create an organized majority that understands that there isn't a difference between an eight hour day, for instance, or like, you know, really strong and genuine unionization. And the fact that we have a system that basically disenfranchises large percentages of the population that you need to actually have fundamental voting reform, that these things are, are in fact connected as part of transforming the framework.

Aziz RanaSo I would call, you know, um, non reformist reforms, things that span the gamut from changing our voting system. Um, so, uh, everything from what we think of as like multi-member districts and and houses to eliminating felony disenfranchisement to ensuring that voting is based on residency rather than citizenship. So immigrants actually have voting power in this country. Two things, uh, that we don't oftentimes think of as quote unquote constitutional, like the infrastructure of prison and police abolition, and that they're all part of the same, let's say broad spectrum.

Aziz RanaOn the specific thing about conventions, I personally, you know, I, I would love for us to inhabit a world like Chile in which one could actually significantly think about can we replace this constitution with another, not because it would be a panacea, but because the idea of the convention, this is why, you know, the bogs is, for example, we're in, we're interested in having a constitutional convention or a constitution, an alternative constitution as part of their agenda setting is that the idea of a wholly different constitution is a way to galvanize people around imagining a fundamentally different legal political system.

Aziz RanaThe problem in the United States is we're not remotely there, and it's really telling that the biggest push for a convention right now is actually from the far right, and it's from the far right to basically entrench elements of the 18th century text that would undermine democracy. And that means that if, let's say you just closed your eyes, open them, and tomorrow there was a convention because of the, the nature of our existing economic system, the array of forces, the amount of money groups like the Federalist Society have, chances are the constitutional order that would be replicated would be one per, you know, far worse than even the one that we have right now.

Aziz RanaSo that means, as a tactical matter, I think that the best way to think about a socialist constitutional politics is precisely by focusing on these specific reforms. And oftentimes these are reforms that there's liberal agreement with and then pressing for those in a sustained way, not because they're fixes, but because they open up the potential for even more far-reaching reforms. And I should also say that the liberal uncertainty about what to do, like the idea that like, so liberals want judicial reform, but they also think the constitution is perfect, actually undermines the possibility of even these piecemeal reforms in the first place.

Aziz RanaAnd so a left politics that says this system has to be transcended, but in this moment we can focus on particular levers, whether it's judicial reform, whether it's changes to the electoral system, whether it's the addition of DC as a, a state, um, that have capacity to move us in a direction that power builds and then allows for even more far-reaching changes, uh, down the line. I think that's unfortunately where we're currently placed.

Elton LKThis is class, an official podcast of the Democratic Socialists of America National Political Education Committee. My name is Elton LK. If you're inspired by anything we've been talking about, if you think the system is rigged and democracy is a solution, join DSA. Become a member. I've put a link in the show notes to DSA's website. If you're already a member of DSA, please share this episode with your local chapter. Class is intended to be a resource for chapters and members to articulate, apply and share socialist theory with DSA and the wider working class.

Elton LKAlso, remember to rate and review us on iTunes or your favorite podcatcher. This is an important way to get out the word about class. I'd like to thank Sean Larson from Haymarket Books for sharing the recordings from the socialism conference, Casey Stikker for sound engineering theme, music and editing. And thanks to Palmer Conrad for administrative assistance.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Old Being Reborn @ Socialism Conference 2026

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Socialist Surge, feat. Louisville DSA

    Nov 10, 202652 minAudio

    We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Socialist Veteran

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Joy Cometh In the Morning": The Words of Eugene Debs

    Oct 27, 202623 minAudio

    In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Carceral Minimalism, or Abolitionism?

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode