Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Class

Class artwork

What is Capitalism? Pt. 3 Marx & Engels' "Bourgeois and Proletarians” from the Communist Manifesto

Oct 13, 202223 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Featuring University of Massachusetts Amherst Sociologist Sanjiv Gupta and University of Massachusetts Amherst Economist David Kotz. This is episode 3 of a 4-part series on “What is Capitalism?” This series is accompanying the DSA National Political Education Committee’s curriculum packet, which can find our curriculum at https://education.dsausa.org/resources/. This episode goes into classes and class struggle under capitalism. The discussion is in response to a chapter from the Communist Manifesto about us, the working class, and the capitalists class. The Communist Manifesto was written just as the French Revolution of 1848 was getting started. “Bourgeois and Proletarians” by Karl Marx & Frederick Engels https://drive.google.com/file/d/1WfYU9Aa8SIPZom3yzC-c7PpD_wLe0W7E/view Credits: Producer: Elton LK Host: Daphna Thier Logo by Michaela Brangan Sound Engineer & Opening Music by Casey Stikker Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Elton LKWelcome to Class, an official podcast of the National Political Education Committee of the Democratic Socialists of America, discussing the organization's political education curriculum and more. My name is Elton LK. We're gonna be discussing the section"Bourgeois and Proletarians" from the Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. Let's get right into it.

Daphna ThierWelcome to this episode of the DSA National Political Education Podcast. My name is Daphna Thier, and I'll be your host. This series is accompanying our curriculum packet on the question of"What is Capitalism?" You can find our curriculum on our website, education.dsausa.org under the Resources tab. We're joined today by sociologist Sanjiv Gupta and economics professor David Kotz, who both teach at UMass Amherst. In this episode, we'll focus on classes and class struggle under capitalism.

Daphna ThierIf you're following along with the readings of the curriculum. This episode is based on an excerpt from the Communist Manifesto by Karl Marks and Frederick Engels, a chapter called"Bourgeois and Proletarians", which just means the boss class and us the working class. They wrote the manifesto in 1848 at a time when revolution was in the air that year. There were several revolutions in Europe that challenged and even top old monarchies, and they're making the case that workers can overthrow capitalism.

Daphna ThierDavid, Marx and Engels write that history is the history of class struggle. What does that mean? Is class struggle going on all the time? Is it going on right now? And maybe you can give us also some examples of class struggle today.

David KotzI preferred in the first episode to very early human history are usually called pre-history. Before there were classes in society when we lived in, uh, hunter gatherer bands, relatively equal cooperative sharing relations. But society has since moved through a series of class-based economic formations, starting with a slave system, then a futile system. And today, capitalism. And in each of these class based systems, there has been class struggle built into the structure between those who produce and those who own the producers or the enterprises or the land, and take part of what the producers produce.

David KotzThere were slave rebellions in ancient slave systems and modern slave systems. There were peasant uprisings in feudalism, Uh, capitalism from the beginning has seen struggles between workers and capitalists. It's rooted in the origin of profit. Capitalist profit comes from being able to keep the biggest cost of production, that of labor low enough so that they can get a margin, a profit margin.

David KotzAnd that means a constant drive to push down wages on the part of capitalists and make workers work harder. Whereas workers want a decent wage and they want working conditions that won't exhaust them, uh, leave them exhausted and, uh, cause their powers to decline over time and threaten their health. So this is the root of the class struggle that takes place in capitalism. Uh, Marx and Engels refer to the bourgeoisie and the proletariat.

David KotzWell, those are French words for capitalists and workers. French terms have a lot of prestige among intellectuals and academics, but the more commonplace words serve just as well, today especially. And class struggle or class conflict occurs on many levels. It's not just over economic issues. Also in the realm of politics and even in the realm of ideas you usually think of when you think of class strike, you think of workers going on strike.

David KotzAnd that has always happened, at least once capitalism had developed to a certain point, and in recent times in the US there have been factory workers strikes. Kellogg workers went on a long strike, other groups of factory workers, but class struggle is not limited to factory workers. Fast food workers have been going on strike, have been trying to organize unions. High tech workers have been withholding their labor, trying to organize unions.

David KotzTeachers have engaged in well publicized strikes. Many different groups of workers have engaged in economic action. And it includes not just strikes, but union organizing campaigns. Boycots slowdowns, other methods, but class struggle is not just in the economic side of society. It takes place in the political realm. Many of the political struggles in our country today are really class struggles, fights over labor rights, uh, that are embodied in law battles in which the representatives of big business want to cut social programs which provide unemployment, compensation and other benefits for workers.

David KotzWhile labor unions and other workers organizations try to expand and make them more generous housing programs, public housing programs benefit working people. And the interests of capitalists are always there trying to limit housing programs, tax policy, who will pay taxes to support the public sector, those who can most afford it, or those who can least afford it. Even antitrust policy intended to regulate or reduce monopoly power affects workers, not just consumers who are harmed by concentrations of economic power in an industry, but workers who find fewer perspective employers for their specialty also are at a disadvantage.

David KotzFinally, there is a hidden class struggle in the realm of ideas. You often hear the term neoliberalism that refers to a set of ideas and policies and practices that are aimed at justifying and providing maximum freedom for property owners claiming that that will benefit everyone. That limited government regulation of business will get the government off our backs and, and be good for everyone.

David KotzThis is class struggle in the realm of ideas. And unfortunately, in recent decades, the capitalism have been pretty successsful in, uh, imposing ideas that are unfavorable for working people. A belief that government intervention in the economy is simply bad, and that if you just leave it to the genius of private business, all will be well. So it it's important that for working people's to advance their conditions, to be ready to fight on all three fronts.

Daphna ThierDid you have any thoughts on that Sanjiv?

Sanjiv GuptaWhat I love about this first sentence is that it's a theory of history in one sentence. So not only are they describing history as, you know, one class struggle after another, they're actually saying that this is in fact how history moves forward is through class struggle. And you know, then they go on to say that you can have struggles between, you know, surfs and lords and slaves and slave owners and so on.

Sanjiv GuptaAnd that is a historical constant, the struggle between groups of people who are trying to do their thing and, you know, live their lives and other people who are monopolizing power and resources in, in some way. And what's unique about capitalism is, I mean, this is their claim, is that it's, uh, it's, it's an advance because it's a great simplification of this class struggle into the two camps that David described, you know, the bosses and workers essentially.

Sanjiv GuptaSo yeah, it's a fabulous first sentence. Um, it's just something to think about that this is actually a very compact statement of how to understand history as more than a succession of events.

David KotzAnd I might add that successful class struggle by workers has at times led to making capitalism a little bit better for working people. But in the long run, it is hoped that it is class struggle that will enable us to move beyond capitalism and to bring about a future socialist society, which while it will not be perfect, no society ever is, there will be no exploitation and there will be no class. It will be possible to have a cooperative society instead of one based on trying to rise by driving others down.

Daphna ThierRight? And now it's actually necessary because what you were saying earlier is that this tension between capitalists and workers is constant. It's a constant feature in capitalism. So, so long as that tension exists, we're always gonna have to be fighting for the most basic of our rights. But the other weird part about this chapter in the manifesto is that marks and angles are arguing that capitalism is progress. And it's like, well, why do they say that? I mean, capitalism, everything we've been describing in the last couple of episodes is horrible, and they're writing at a time when child labor is rampant.

Daphna ThierAnd we're talking at a time when children are victims of incredible violence. That doesn't seem so great. . So what, what do they mean Sanjiv? In what way is this progress? And would you say that that's still true today? If they were writing the manifesto today, would they still think of this as progress?

Sanjiv GuptaI'll say about this, that it's simultaneously, I think one of the most interesting and important things for socialists to, you know, kind of struggle through is this, uh, tension between this view of progress and everything else we say about capitalism. So that's one thing. And the other is that this is one of those things about which my own understanding is in flux. Uh, and so I'll try to say something about that. So, you know, why is capitalism an advance? So in addition to the communist manifesto, let me just quote from the, this is the very end of the piece, wage, labor and capital, which they wrote four workers.

Sanjiv GuptaAnd here's how that these ends. It says, capital is Barbaras, it drags with it workers into its grave, uh, the corpse of its slaves, uh, who perish and capitalist crises and so on. And we thus see that if capital grows rapidly, competition among the workers grows even more rapidly and the subsistence levels decrease even more rapidly. But, and here's the last sentence of this piece.

Sanjiv GuptaThis not withstanding the rapid growth of capital is the most favorable condition for wage label, right? So I'll see this again, this is the thing they leave us with at the end of a piece directed at workers that despite everything about capitalism, the rapid growth of capital is the most favorable condition for wage label. And, you know, it's like this is kind of a surprise ending until we remember that yes, this is a time when wage label is actually in England, especially you know, people are fleeing the countryside, assembling in factories, unionizing, figuring out their common interests.

Sanjiv GuptaAnd so it is the favorable condition in the sense that large numbers of people are being put into conditions and being given the resources to actually develop their collective interests. And accompanying that is the claim that capitalism is simplifying these very complicated divisions among people, into these two great camps. I mean, they actually use that term. It's these two great camps facing each other. And so in that sense, uh, it is and in advance, here's something else to to think about.

Sanjiv GuptaYou know, uh, in previous episodes I was drawing on this theme of like, just thinking about our bodies. Up until 1800, life expectancy across the world taken as a whole was under 30 years, three zero. Today it's over 70, also around 800, there was 600 million people on the planet. And today there's more than 6 billion, 10 times more. So I'm being very simplistic here, but this is capitalism. So if you think having lots of people around is a good thing, and I do, I mean, you know, we are not sort of malians here.

Sanjiv GuptaLet's be frank about this. The reason the planet can now support so many people is that a tiny fraction of the US population engaged in agriculture generates enough food to supply 2000 calories in principle to every person on the planet. This is absolutely phenomenal. It is unprecedented, and basically it should be put on the balance sheet of capital as a massive advance in human history. So to this extent, I think that are absolutely right.

Sanjiv GuptaI also, I will say, coming from India, you know, I grew up, uh, watching sort of, uh, uh, large numbers of people being condemned to live as uh, or to work as maids for other people who had money. And today a common complaint is you can't find people to do that work anymore. Uh, you know, maids come and go. They leave without, uh, giving you warning. They want to educate their kids and so on. Well, that is the development of capitalism in India. So I, I have actually watched it happen. It's freed in that sense, large numbers of people also from the shackles of cast in the countryside.

Sanjiv GuptaIt's brought them into the, the countryside. So I think yes, again, it's a question of time and place. Uh, you could argue that for large sections of the US geographically in the south, for example, possibly, and I'm saying this a little maybe deliberately to be a little iCal about this, that one issue with sections of the US might be insufficient capitalism. So the problem may not be too much, but rather than not enough, the parts of the country may not have escaped sufficiently from, you know, Jim Crow and share cropping and so on.

Sanjiv GuptaWe might actually need a greater sort of development of capitalism in some parts of, uh, of the us. So time and place, uh, is, is important here. Now, I was very happy to sort of say this without qualification a few years ago. So now I'll add why, in addition to all the other things we've said about capitalism, you know, being bad for us, you know, climate change now is a species level threat that I think mark and angles actually anticipate. There are other you know, in the German neology you find some references and so on.

Sanjiv GuptaBut, you know, why should we expect people in the 18 hundreds to sort of figure this all out? I don't know that people foresaw that the entire species could be simultaneously, first of all, so successful, 6 billion, 7 billion people and create the conditions for quote unquote its own destruction. Not the species as a whole, but as David was pointing out, this is capitalist competition and so on, but it is the same system that is freeing us from the starvation and, you know, hurting us towards, uh, this cliff.

Sanjiv GuptaAnd then here's another qualification to this. It's 7 billion human beings. And now as we are becoming increasingly conscious of the consequences to other species on the planet, and again, this is not a malian thing that just the numbers of people are a problem, it's not bad. But having this enormous success for the human species in terms of numbers and longevity, the habitat for other species has, you know, imploded dramatically. And so quite apart from the issue of climate change, the question is what do we owe the other inhabitants, uh, both plants and animals?

Sanjiv GuptaAgain, time and place.

Daphna ThierYou threw out the term Malthusian a couple of times. You know, Malthus the idea that people think that the issue is too much consumption or too many people overcrowding.

David KotzWell, when capitalism becomes advanced, the population growth does slow down. So it seems to have its own and in fact, heads toward, uh, toward no more population growth. So it's not clear that in the long run, capitalism will keep, uh, increasing the population. But I, I think it's important to qualify the deserved praise that Mex and angles keeped upon capitalism for bringing human progress. And there are two important qualifications. First, while capitalism has produced technological advances with potential benefit for humanity, at the same time, it always tends to limit the actual benefit that results because the profit motive leads to patents and control of technologies so that life saving drugs become extremely expensive, become unaffordable for many people.

David KotzThere are many areas in which capitalism restricts the benefit from new technologies. Perhaps more important is that while capitalist enterprises are good at making minor changes in production methods that, uh, make them more efficient, they're not good at major innovations because the pursuit of a major new thing is too risky to make sense in the profit and risk calculations of capitalists and all studies of the origin of the major life changing, uh, innovations, you know, the internet, uh, cell phones, et cetera, all of those things, none of them came from profit oriented enterprises.

David KotzThey come instead from government, from universities, from non-profit institutions, and from odd independent inventors who are driven left by the pursuit of wealth than by the obsession with solving a problem and coming up with something new. And there's every reason to believe that a future democratic socialism will be much more effective than capitalism's record at advancing human productive power in ways that will genuinely benefit human beings

Daphna ThierAt one point in the text Marx and Engels, right? But not only has the bourgeoisie forged the weapons that bring death to itself, it has also called into existence the men who are to wield those weapons. The modern working class, the proletarians. Where within this capitalist reality do we see the hope for a different future?

David KotzI think Marx and Engels were right, that it is the central victims of capitalism, those who are exploited to produce the growing flow of wealth, that have the power and the potential to overcome this system. But capitalism oppresses other groups in society as well. It, it oppresses people of color. It oppresses women. The danger to the environment has activated many young people who are greatly concerned about, uh, the future.

David KotzSo there are, I think, a, an alliance of the working class, a working class movement with the other groups, uh, in the population that are harmed by the way capitalism works, particularly in this era that has the potential to build an alternative to capitalism in the future. They have the power, the motivation, and I think that is the hope for the future.

Sanjiv GuptaSo I, I think they're right that the bourgeoisie is calling into existence. It's mortal enemy. At the same time that module enemy has to act self-consciously in its own interest. That is, there's nothing automatic about this. Uh, we need the conscious agent and, you know, this is where organizers and, you know, socialists come in is, uh, it doesn't happen automatically. We also know this from the site of the bourgeoisie. They don't win sort of just because they're more productive.

Sanjiv GuptaThey won historically through wars and great political struggles. And because they had people who laid out the aims and organized other members of their class effectively.

Daphna ThierAlright, well that was a fascinating conversation. We're gonna end here. We do actually have also curriculum materials for a session on why the working class, which will cover some of those things more. The final episode of this series, which is gonna cover racism and capitalism. And we'll be looking at a small excerpt from Keeyanga Yamatta-Taylor's book, From Black Lives Matter to Black Liberation. I want to thank Sanjiv Gupta and David Kotz for speaking with us in this series, as well as our producer, Elton LK, and our co-producer Jeff Barrois and Casey Stikker, our sound engineer.

Daphna ThierReally appreciate you all. I'm Daphna Thier, and I was your host. I was a pleasure to be here. Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Old Being Reborn @ Socialism Conference 2026

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Socialist Surge, feat. Louisville DSA

    Nov 10, 202652 minAudio

    We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Socialist Veteran

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Joy Cometh In the Morning": The Words of Eugene Debs

    Oct 27, 202623 minAudio

    In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Carceral Minimalism, or Abolitionism?

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode