Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Class

Class artwork

What is Capitalism? Pt. 4 Keeanga-Yamahttah Taylor's #BlackLivesMatter to Black Liberation

Oct 27, 202218 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Featuring University of Massachusetts Amherst Sociologist Sanjiv Gupta and University of Massachusetts Amherst Economist David Kotz. This episode is a part of a 4-part series on “What is Capitalism?” This series is accompanying the DSA National Political Education Committee’s curriculum packet, which can find our curriculum at https://education.dsausa.org/resources/. This chapter, from a book published in 2016 at the time after the first Black Lives Matter protests, introduces the complex interactions between racism and capitalism in the U.S. Taylor reiterates CLR James’ assertion that Black struggles for democratic rights have been at the forefront of the socialist movement in the U.S. In turn, socialists been central to anti-racist struggles. Taylor argues that U.S. ruling classes have used racism and white supremacy, first to justify slavery, then to divide workers. The chapter highlights Marx’s statements on slavery, the Civil War, and capitalists’ use of ethnicity to divide workers. From #BlackLivesMatter to Black Liberation by Keeanga-Yamahttah Taylor https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Fj1NujY5Z3Qry_2HNCji1ktdW4N_Ajeo/view Credits: Producer: Elton LK Host: Daphna Thier Logo by Michaela Brangan Sound Engineer & Opening Music by Casey Stikker Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Elton LKWelcome to Class, an official podcast of the National Political Education Committee of the Democratic Socialists of America, discussing the organization's political education curriculum and more. My name is Elton LK. This episode is a part of a series called"What is Capitalism?" We're going to be discussing from#BlackLivesMatter to Black Liberation by Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor. Let's get right into it.

Daphna ThierWelcome to this episode of the DSA National Political Education podcast. My name is Daphna Thier, and I will be your host. This is the fourth and final episode of a series accompanying our curriculum packet on the question of"What is Capitalism?" You can find our curriculum on our website education.dsausa.org under the Resources tab. We're joined today again by sociologist Sanjiv Gupta and economics Professor David Kotz, who both teach at UMass Amherst.

Daphna ThierIn this episode, we'll focus on a small excerpt from Keeanga-Yamahtta Taylor's seminal book from#BlackLivesMatter to Black Liberation. The book was written at the height of the first Black Lives Matter rebellion in 2014, and was meant as both a historical record and an analysis that attempted to thread the needle between race and class. Today we'll try to talk about the intersection of those two things and ways in which capitalism has been shaped by racism and racism by capitalism.

Daphna ThierAnd we'll also talk about the ways that the black liberation movement and the socialist movement connect and fuel each other. Let's start with what does Taylor argue? Does capitalism rely on racism? Or how does capitalism fuel racism? And can you have capitalism without racism? Would there be racism without capitalism?

Sanjiv GuptaSo of all the questions we've dealt with so far, uh, you know, I'll say at the outset that, uh, these are the ones that I would say my understanding is really evolving, Uh, you know, in, in pretty much real time. I actually changed my mind while reading this piece. Uh, you know, just to prepare for this about a couple of things, and I think that's a question that DSA obviously is dealing with. Uh, and so I invite listeners to sort of really think of this as just a chance to think aloud.

Sanjiv GuptaUm, so what is Taylor's argument? So Taylor says two things. One is that capitalism in the US used racism as a mechanism to justify slavery, or more precisely, slavery in the US uh, relied on racism on racializing the skin color again, to to use the body as the focus here. And capitalism was happy to use the profits from the cotton trade to develop industry in the north.

Sanjiv GuptaSo, yes, Taylor says that capitalism used in that sense, in the origins in the US and then also subsequently to divide and conquer the working class to keep workers fighting among themselves on the basis of race. Now, where it gets complicated for me is that, as Taylor says, in the same excerpt, it is actually the industrial north that then turns on the slaveocracy to the point of basically fighting the most violent war in US history to that point.

Sanjiv GuptaAnd Taylor quotes Marxs, and I'll add another quote there that, uh, you know, Marxs says in a piece he wrote for the New York Tribune that the Civil War in the US is a war between two systems of labor, the system of slave labor, and of free wage labor. And he says, these two systems cannot coexist on the same continent, one of them has to go. So this is the, the paradox here that at some point the capitalists, if, if we call them that, uh, in the North, really decided that slavery as a system had to go.

Sanjiv GuptaAnd, you know, I think most of us will be glad that they did. Uh, it's hard to see slavery disappearing, uh, in the US uh, without that. So I think that is the sort of a little bit of a complication, which is worth thinking about. Now, the other piece of this that capitalists use to divide workers. Yes. So as late as in the auto plants in the sixties, if you've read the book, Detroit, I Mind Dying, for example, racism was used and exploited as a way to keep workers from uniting around their common interests.

Sanjiv GuptaUh, the most extreme case of this, you know, you could go to South Africa under a apartheid where white workers were explicitly given benefits, including allowed to unionize in, in some cases with the understanding that they would be much better off than the black majority in, uh, in South Africa. Now, again, let's complicate the the story. At some point, capitalists can actually decide that racism of that sort of, that crude sort is not in their interest, and both in the US and South Africa, apparently they did.

Sanjiv GuptaAnd, uh, in the us you know, the civil rights movement, of course the credit goes here to the mass movement, but a bunch of elites actually decided that, you know, this stuff was really backward and was actually impeding the development of capitalism. By the way, I think the same is true of the BLM support among, uh, big companies. Now, I actually don't think it was purely cosmetic or opportunistic. I think it's reflected something real that a section of the most advanced capitalist in tech and finance actually have grasped this, that the more egregious kinds of racial discrimination is actually now just an impediment.

Sanjiv GuptaI don't think they want to use it in the older way of dividing workers. I think it's served its purpose. So all that is to say is that we should give some credit to capitalists for being not so much racist or just using racism to further their interests, but being really exceptionally good at acting on their interests at the moment, you know, in a particular time and place. And that can involve actually turning against racism. So that is my, I don't think that's a disagreement with what Taylor is saying in this excerpt, but I think it's a little bit of a counterpoint to how she frames the role of capitalism in slavery.

Sanjiv GuptaAnd then, uh, subsequently, can you have racism without capitalism? I think this is also a time and place question. And, and here I think the work of actual historians matters. You know, we shouldn't just see this as a theoretical or analytical question or even one of pure strategy. I think we should take the actual history here seriously. And I think the, there, the record is a, is a little mixed. I'll just say one thing about, you know, so there's racism based on skin color. If you expand the definition a little bit to include caste, discrimination and say antisemitism, then of course there's not shortage of examples where these things existed.

Sanjiv GuptaAnd in sometimes really brutal form, well before capitalism in Europe and elsewhere, and I understand that's not the same as racism per se, but there are forms of oppression that are not strictly about class, uh, that precede capitalism and arguably took on much more rabid forms. They didn't need capitalism to be truly, truly destructive.

David KotzSanjiv raised a very good point about the evidence that some, uh, large capitalists, uh, enterprises have seemed to have taken a position, uh, critical of racism. After all, it was, uh, what caused former President Trump's business advisory councils to disband was when Trump praised the white supremacists in Charlottesville. And the CEOs who were on those councils, you know, one of them was African American, There were some women that played a leading role, they disbanded in response, but that's only part of the story.

David KotzThe biggest corporations that have some monopoly power, maybe they sell a lot to African American community. Perhaps they even have some, uh, African Americans and Latinos in, uh, management these days will take actions and adopt policies that are critical of old style racism. But if you look at capitalism as a whole, the divide and conquer is still there. Uh, it was interesting that in the, uh, buildup to the financial crisis of 2008, it turned out that the biggest banks were pushing subprime mortgages, which means morg- home mortgages at very high interest rates, specifically at black people.

David KotzThey even had a a name for them, which essentially meant and cleaned up language, you know, black people's mortgages, uh, because, uh, they could do it. And this is another side of it. The capitalism promotes racism, not just because, uh, it divides the working class, but because an oppressed minority can be super exploited in certain ways. They can be forced to take jobs at lower wages and they can be pressured into accepting mortgages at extra high interest rates because they don't have alternatives because of their race.

David KotzThere are other ways that sort of structurally racism serves capitalism. It is still the case that blacks and Latinos have a higher unemployment rate than whites. That means that those groups serve as a kind of a reserve labor force that can be drawn in when the economy is operating at a particularly high rate of economic growths. So I think there's still tied in with each other. It's not a question in my view of whether you could imagine a capitalism without racism.

David KotzWell, there are examples. You know, capitalism did develop in Japan in the 19th century in a very homogeneous population. It developed in Sweden with a very homogeneous population. But if there are distinguishable racial or ethnic groups and capitalism drive to divide, the working class takes over and strengthens racism. In my

Sanjiv GuptaView, there is basically an expanding market, the demographics of both people in the workforce, but also consumers, which I mean, there's an overlap there. And then transnationally, you know, as companies are, are basically, you know, wanting to establish themselves everywhere. Uh, there's actually a built in limit to how much you can think that or at least say, uh, that people who look a certain way in fear if you also want to, you know, work with them and uh, you know, sell them stuff.

Sanjiv GuptaUh, and I think that's a real thing. I also think we should take credit for some of this. That is, it's not happening by itself. It's happening because of the success of the mass movements and the sort of ways working class movements that are forced people including, and you know, I will also say, say, I mean I teach as probably David does, some of these young people who are going to end up, you know, they're white, uh, they're going to end up in companies and so on. And honestly, they're far more advanced on questions of race than most of us from a generation ago.

Sanjiv GuptaHowever, well educated we are. It just comes na the just much more woke in the best sense of the term. And so I think there is that as well that the people themselves have changed. I mean, yes, they're capitalists, but they're capitalists living now. And in fact the mentality can't change because, you know, the change has been forced and that's a good thing.

Daphna ThierSo in this excerpt Taylor quotes CLR James at length. What is CLR James arguing when he says that the anti-racist movement has a vitality of its own, but that it can intervene as a powerful force in the revolutionary movement? And what does that mean for how we organize?

David KotzOkay, that's a very good question. And earlier, uh, American history, some socialist organizations in the early 20th century thought that socialists should only organize based on class and should ignore other issues such as race or gender. But, uh, CLR James does make a very good point that that is a bad strategy In the US black people face a particularly harsh exploitation and depression in US capitalism.

David KotzBlack workers on the average are more, uh, favorable toward unionization and collective struggle. Uh, and they often play a leading role in class struggle the way to, there is not a conflict between class struggle and fighting against racial oppression. They go together and they can be worked on together. So I think it's right that the, the socialists socialists should aim to organize the entire working class while upholding the struggle for the rights of black people, explaining to white working people that it is in their interests to overcome racial oppression and arguing for unity of the multiracial, uh, working class, uh, while also fighting to end the particular oppression of various racial and ethnic minorities.

Sanjiv GuptaIn this quote, which I'll just, I'll read the first sentence. It says, we say number one, that the independent negro struggle has a vitality and a validity of its own. And that really struck me here, the claim that this is a valid struggle, whatever it's relationship or not, with the questions of, uh, you know, socialism and class and actually think this is something that we want to keep in mind. Now as we figure out as socialists and dsa, uh, that I think the time is passed for us to continuously revisit sort of, you know, is this as important?

Sanjiv GuptaHow should we be involved in it and so on. It doesn't matter really what we think about this. I think this is what CLR James is saying, this struggle for democratic rights, you know, whatever they are, however limited they are, but full democratic rights prevailing at the moment has validity of its own. And it's our job to support this. Now operationally there is, it raises this stuff question, Well, how do you, how do we do this as socialists? How do we distinguish ourselves from anti-racist, uh, activism in general?

Sanjiv GuptaThose are important questions, but I actually think the starting point should be, maybe doesn't matter so much that we figure this out before we go in, but that we simply do it wholeheartedly because it is something worth doing in and of itself. Um, and socialists historically, as Taylor points out have in fact done that. To our credit, take two summers ago with Black Lives Matter. I mean, who was prepared for this kind of upsurge, which still I would say is bigger than the, you know, we talk about the labor resurgence today, uh, which I think is actually a little mixed and maybe not as widespread as we think it is.

Sanjiv GuptaIn the last 10 years, that was the biggest outpouring of popular political energy in this country was Black Lives Matter or the gen-, not the organization, but the generally the, the movement against police brutality and, and all the other issues that raised. And I think this is a question for us as socialists, that has a life and a validity absolutely all its own. And our job is to figure out how we can contribute as socialists to it.

Sanjiv GuptaIt is able to exercise a powerful influence upon the revolutionary proletariat. Yeah, I think if we don't figure this out, we can't do socialism in the US.

Daphna ThierI hope this series has been helpful for people trying to learn about what capitalism is, how it works, or how it doesn't. The constant tension between the classes, the drive for profits over human need and the needs of our environment. This concludes the"What is Capitalism?" Series. Look out for our next mini-series, which will be on"What is Democratic Socialism?" This series was brought to you by the National Political Education Committee. I want to thank Sanjiv Gupta and David Kotz for speaking with us in this series.

Daphna ThierI'm Daphna Thier, and I was your host. It was a pleasure to be here with you all. Until next time.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Old Being Reborn @ Socialism Conference 2026

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Socialist Surge, feat. Louisville DSA

    Nov 10, 202652 minAudio

    We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Socialist Veteran

    Nov 3, 202658 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. "Joy Cometh In the Morning": The Words of Eugene Debs

    Oct 27, 202623 minAudio

    In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Carceral Minimalism, or Abolitionism?

    Oct 20, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...

    Credit the people on this episode