The Crisis of American Politics: Socialists and Liberal Democracy Pt. 2
15 minAudio
The Republican Party is the biggest threat to our liberal democracy, and we cannot depend on the liberals to defend our liberal democracy. How then should we as democratic socialists spearhead the fight for democracy and worker power? Socialism 2022 Conference, Chicago “The Crisis of American Politics: Socialists and Liberal Democracy”, part 2. Moderator: Griffin Mahon Panelists: Sanjiv Gupta, Paul Heideman Sanjiv Gupta is a member of the River Valley DSA chapter in Western Massachusetts, and is a sociologist at UMass-Amherst. I personally discovered Sanjiv first from his excellent podcast Socialism in the Time of Corona. You’ll find the link in the show notes. NOTE: In the episode Sanjiv was introduced as a sociologist at Amherst College, but Sanjiv is at UMass-Amherst. Paul Heideman is a writer and high school teacher in NYC. He is the editor of Class Struggle and the Color Line and his work has appeared in Jacobin, Dissent, and In These Times. He is currently working on a history of the modern Republican Party. There is a link to his article “Behind the Republican Party Crack-up” in Catalyst. Links: Haymarket Books Socialism 2022 podcast https://socialismconference.org/ Sanjiv Gupta’s podcast Socialism in the Time of Corona https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/socialism-in-the-time-of-corona/id1511330379 Paul Heideman “Behind the Republican Party Crack-up”, Catalyst https://catalyst-journal.com/2021/09/behind-the-republican-party-crack-up ***At a point in the recording something was repeatedly hitting the microphone, making it difficult to hear Griffin the moderator. Griffin asked Paul and Sanjiv why they didn’t use the F word “fascism.” Griffin assumed it was intentional to avoid this term, but asked them to expound on their opinion on the use of the word fascism. And he asked a follow up question, if they prefer not to use the term, how would they describe the Republican Party? Paul said he wasn’t opposed to the use of the term for rhetorical reasons, but argues it isn’t particularly accurate. Historically fascism has been the complete crushing of liberal democracy and a complete break with the constitutional order. When fascists come to power the old constitution is no longer in effect, and all opposing political parties would be removed. This is not actually what the Republican Party is doing, though we could consider calling them “Authoritarian,” like India and Turkey where they still have limited civil liberties and opposition parties. You’ll continue to hear some noise as Sanjiv answered Griffin’s question, but we were able to make the sound quality good enough to include it into the episode. Thanks for bearing with us.*** Credits: Producer: Elton LK Logo by Michaela Brangan Sound Engineer & Opening Music by Casey Stikker Send us Fan Mail Become a member of Democratic Socialists of America. Sign up to receive NPEC's newsletter, Red Letter.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Elton LKThis is Class, an official podcast of the Democratic Socialists of America National Political Education Committee. My name is Elton LK. This is the second and final part of DSA session called The Crisis of American Politics, Socialists and Liberal Democracy from the Socialism 2022 Conference in September. Thanks to Haymarket Books for sharing the recording. The panel included Sanjiv Gupta, sociologist from Amherst College in Massachusetts, and Paul Heideman is a writer and high school teacher in New York City, editor of Class Struggle and the Color Line, and his work has appeared in Jacobin, Dissent, and In These Times.
Elton LKThe session was moderated by Griffin Mahome. If you haven't heard the first part of this session that was in our previous episode of Class, I recommend that you go back to it. In the last episode, Sanjiv Gupta made the case that without bourgeois democracy, also known as liberal democracy, socialists cannot win power.
Elton LKWe need freedom of speech and freedom of assembly in order to organize. Socialists often make the mistake of assuming that liberals are the reason why we have a liberal democracy. In truth, it is the working class and the masses in struggle. I should mention that this was recorded before the midterm election, but I think that you'll find that while they did not predict the future, much of Paul Heideman's analysis was spot on.
Paul HeidemanNow, Trumpism was itself clearly a product of disorganization within the Republican party. And so, so I wrote a long article in the journal Catalyst, um, that goes into what, what I think are the deep roots of disorganization in American politics. So to understand why Trump won in 2016 and the Republican primaries, I think there's a kind of simple explanation of it. Um, in addition to obviously his name recognition and that kind of thing, and that's that there was a real battle in the Republican party between the party establishment who had coalesced, of course, around Jeb Bush, right?
Paul HeidemanAnd the insurgents who were allied with the Tea Party, um, who favored either Ted Cruz or, or, or Scott Walker kind of initially before just what a dud he was. So essentially the kind of signals from the party's elite, either the establishment elite or kind of the insurgent Tea Party elite, basically canceled each other out. There was no clear signal from the, the party leadership over who was the preferred candidate in the Republican primary. Uh, in, in physics, in the physics of acoustics, there's a phenomenon called destructive interference where two sound waves have opposing wavelengths and the result is silence.
Paul HeidemanAnd that's essentially what happened in the Republican party. The messages from the establishment and from the insurgents canceled one another out to Donald Trump's benefit, and he was able to leverage his tremendous name recognition, celebrity, and particular brand of a cruel charisma in order to take the primaries by storm. So, so the, the party was already factionalized and to a degree divided, and that's what allowed Trump to win. And I think that is rooted in some very deep facts in American social life and political life, um, including the, the fact that American parties are kind of unique in much of the world in that parties don't control who gets nominated.
Paul HeidemanSo in American politics, right, you have, like in the Chicago area, a couple years ago, there was that Holocaust denier who got on the Republican congressional ticket because it was like, you know, a 90% blue district or something, and the Republicans weren't gonna waste any money running someone. And this guy was like, I'm gonna run. And the party had totally denounced him, but they couldn't remove him from the ticket, which is again, kind of just unheard of in most political parties around the world, that like a party itself can't decide who runs on its ticket. There's a kind of set of external rules, and if people win the primary, then they're, they're on the party ticket, whether the party itself likes that or not.
Paul HeidemanUm, and that clearly happened with Trump, and it's happened again and again with, uh, various kinds of Republican primary victories in particular. And, and the other part of this is the disorganization of the American corporate elite. So American corporations are very strong, right? And, and, and have a, an iron grip on American politics in a lot of ways, and that's been true kind of historically. We don't have a social democratic party. The union movement in the United States is considerably weaker than the union movement in other countries. And so American corporations, in order to maintain their hold on politics and, and on on kind of the, the economy more generally have not had to be as organized as, uh, corporations and, and employers in many other countries.
Paul HeidemanThere's been a kind of persistent disorganization and a kind of fractiousness, uh, divisions within the American corporate elite. And we see those in the Republican party today in that, you know, you have plenty of big capitalists who are backing the Tea party, that kind of thing, right? And then you have like the Chamber of Commerce and the, and the Business Roundtable, uh, the kind of representatives of kind of more traditional capital who, uh, are much more firmly allied with like Mitch McConnell and those kind of people. So the fact that the American corporate elite is itself divided and disorganized, uh, particularly with comparison to like other rich democracies, also contributes to the kind of wars that we see inside the Republican party in its directionlessness.
Paul HeidemanSo to wrap up, both parties in the United States are structurally weak, and both parties are subject to what I was describing with primary candidates being unable to choose their own candidates, that kind of thing. Now, the structural weakness of the Democratic Party has been a real boon to the left, I would argue, right? Like, you don't get Bernie Sanders running for president and being on the news every night without that weakness, right? Without him being able to be like, Hey, I'm, I'm, there's gonna be a six month primary campaign, right, in which I'm gonna be putting forward the case for democratic socialism, et cetera, et cetera.
Paul HeidemanSo the weakness of of the Democrats has been something that the Left has been able to really take advantage of in that respect. At the same time, I, I think it's also important to note that the divisions within the Democratic Party, which certainly exist, are not nearly so severe as the divisions within the Republican party, right? Like, there's no analog in the Democrats to Liz Cheney being stripped of leadership and, and basically run out of the party. Um, so, so the divisions in the Democratic party are, are, are much less sharp than in the Republican party. The Republican party is considerably more divided. At the same time, even as the weakness of the Democrats has been something the left has taken advantage of.
Paul HeidemanIt's not something that we can kind of bank on long term in that we need a strong party, right? We need a party that's democratically accountable, a party that is controlled by its membership and that decides who runs on our belt line, is who we want to not like who can win a primary by throwing the most money at the wall, et cetera, that kind of thing, right? So there, I think there's something of a paradox in the, the kind of disorganization of the parties and that the weakness of the Democrats in particular has been a boon to the left. But ultimately it's something that we have to overcome if we wanna have a strong socialist party in the United States, there cannot be a socialist party in the United States that's organized in the way that the Democratic party is, uh, is organized.
Paul HeidemanThe Republican party then is I think, deeply divided and disorganized much more so than the Democrats, which doesn't mean they're not dangerous. I just wanna emphasize that again, they, the Republican should definitely win in 2024, which I think would probably have grave consequences for liberal democracy and then precisely the way that Sanjiv laid out. So I'm not saying they can't win, I'm saying that the probability of them winning would be significantly higher if they were not so disorganized right now. And that disorganization and weakness has, uh, I think a number of opportunities for the left.
Paul HeidemanSo, uh, Griffin alluded to the description of the event that says the Democrats can't govern, which like, again, in the last month, uh, whatever you wanna say about the Democrats, they're clearly doing some governing and some of it's pretty good, you know, uh, a lot of people got their student loans forgiven. Um, so I think these kinds of things, which are clearly a product of pressure from the left in various ways and of the strength of the left within the Democratic party, are things that the left really needs to claim as victories and say, these are things that we won. Your life is better because socialists pushed for these things, right?
Paul HeidemanAnd that I think is how we build a bigger base for the left in the United States and how we build a sense that workers have the right to expect something from their government. The government's gonna give them things, right? Like if you're a worker, that's how you should think about the government. Their job is to give you things, right? That's not a sense American workers have it all, all it's something we need to build. Um, and I think doing that is gonna be one of the key ways of deepening the marginalization of the Republican party and pushing them even further to the margins of American politics and keeping them there in a place where they are much further from the levers of power and where, um, they are can hopefully be restrained and ultimately crushed completely.
Sanjiv GuptaSo other than not trying to avoid using the F word generally, uh, in public, I'd say in this particular case, politically, what I found is, um, especially when you're talking to people who aren't kinda keeping up with the politics at the level, I'm assuming most of us here are using the term is confusing and sometimes just gets in the way. I, I, I like to think of this like, you know, if I were a meteorologist, you know, and there's a big storm, you know, there's ways, you can't just call it a hurricane.
Sanjiv GuptaYou really have like the criteria it has to satisfy before you say it's a hurricane and then you have to say category, this or that, and there are consequences to being wrong. You know, when, when you do that, there are also consequences of not doing it when you should. But in the meanwhile, I think it's, you know, just like if you are looking at a storm, whether or not it's a hurricane, you can talk about how you know, what the wind speed is or, uh, how heavy the rain is going to be and so on. And you can do all of that without calling it a hurricane unless you think it really is, is a hurricane.
Sanjiv GuptaSo yeah, I will say I think in an equally sort of semi flippant way that Paul said, if we do get to fascism in the US of course there is, um, Canada, but that also in some ways, you know, the, the other reason I don't use the word yet, in some ways it's actually makes the job much easier. It's clarifying. The thing is, if there really was anything resembling that kind of thing in the US, you know, we know what to do or at least, uh, we, uh, you know, and it's, it goes beyond the scope of a conversation like this, but then we would do something very different.
Sanjiv GuptaSo, you know, that, that we are not big enough. Well, I think that's right. I mean, we are much bigger than we were a few years ago. And so one thing I think we can all agree with is that we just need to keep getting bigger. So then it's about like, well, how do you do that? And this is where I think, you know, my, my gut sense is that unless we are clearly in the lead of making it clear that basic liberal democracy is absolutely critical for us, that we are right there.
Sanjiv GuptaUm, you know, and that synthesizes the abortion rights, you know, black Lives Matter, all of it. Um, and that, that really is our fight. Uh, and so, you know, we've put a lot of work into the, uh, Medicare for all union organizing and so on, and we need to keep doing that. But I think this is the piece that's missing the great political sort of that this whatever its limits, you know, liberal democracy is, was an achievement by the people, for the people, and we are the ones who are going to be put ourselves out to make it stick.
Sanjiv GuptaSo I think that is one way to, uh, to get bigger that I think we are probably not doing enough of. But that's as far as I've gotten.
Elton LKThis is Class, an official podcast of the Democratic Socialists of America National Political Education Committee. My name is Elton LK. I'd like to thank Sean Larson from Haymarket Books, Griffin Maho for hosting this session, Sanjiv Gupta for contributing to sound engineering and other technical support, Casey Stikker as a key member of our tiny team for sound engineering theme, music and editing. If you're a member of DSA, please share this podcast with your local chapter.
Elton LKClass is intended to be a resource for chapters and members to articulate, apply and share socialist theory with DSA and the wider working class. Also, remember to rate and review us on iTunes or your favorite podcatcher.
This summer, Class’s host and NPEC cochair Michaela moderated a panel with David Duhalde (NYC-DSA) and Joe Todd (Green Party UK) at Socialism Conference in Chicago, discussing their reports on DSA and its past and...
We saw a bluenami on Election Day, and with it, scores of DSA victories. Hundreds of socialists will be in office by January - now what? SIOs, current and elected, from Louisville DSA join us to talk about the election,...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...
In this episode, we celebrate Eugene Debs’s powerful insights and brilliant writing on the occasion of his passing 100 years ago. If you like what you hear and want to read more Debs, let us know by sending us a...
Workers Deserve More, DSA’s new national program, has become a widely discussed phenomenon across national media and elections, making headlines and chyrons over the last few months as the right lashes out with fake...