Send us Fan Mail In the second episode of CBmE & U, Sinead and James interview Dr. Barry Solaiman (Associate Professor from Hamad Bin Khalifa University in Qatar). Barry answers questions such as how is AI being used in healthcare? What are the main ethical concerns with using AI in healthcare? And, can the law ensure the ethical implementation of AI in healthcare? For those interested in Barry's work, see his newly published book titled AI, Health and the Law (Edward Elgar, 2024). Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, C BME and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_01Hello, welcome to CB Me and You. My name's James, Research Fellow at the Center for Biomedical Ethics.
SPEAKER_03And my name is Snaid, also a research fellow here at CB Me.
SPEAKER_01Today we welcome Dr. Barry Solomon, Assistant Professor of Law at Hamat bin Khalifa University and co-editor of the forthcoming book AI Health and the Law. Welcome, Dr. Barry.
SPEAKER_04Hello. How are you? I'm good, thank you. How are you? Not bad. Getting used to the humidity of Singapore. It's not too bad. It's not too bad, actually. I I couldn't feel it myself. It's not too bad.
SPEAKER_03Thank you for coming in. We're really excited to have you on the pod today. We have a couple of quick questions to get to know you a little bit better. First question is what country would you like to travel to the most?
SPEAKER_04Japan.
SPEAKER_03Interesting.
SPEAKER_04Well, I'd say I'd like to. I've been like five times. But I would keep going back there if the choice was there.
SPEAKER_03That is a valid choice. Um I also concur with that choice.
SPEAKER_01Are you doing when you go back, are you doing the same things or the new things that you wanted to say?
SPEAKER_04I've been to Tokyo twice in Kyoto three times. But what what you find is that there is like so many layers to this these cities. So you spend time in different parts of them for a long time, and you find all of the subcultures and things going on. It's really fun.
SPEAKER_03Agreed. Next question is coffee or copy?
SPEAKER_04Coffee.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's fair.
SPEAKER_04Although I like both.
SPEAKER_03So uh for our listeners, just a reference, we've given Barry um his first copy. I'm assuming this is your first one.
SPEAKER_04Copy.
SPEAKER_03Copy?
SPEAKER_04Um actually, I don't think it is my I've had something very similar.
SPEAKER_03Ah, I think.
SPEAKER_04But it's nice. I like it. But the reason I say coffee is because it's um it's healthier. Just a plain Americano.
SPEAKER_03Okay, so we have some consistent guests on the podcast preferring coffee for health reasons. And I just want to say I think we need to get a different selection of guests.
SPEAKER_01I'll just leave now. Almost representatives for the Center of Biomedical Ethics.
SPEAKER_03Promoting Health. So last question is what is your go-to karaoke song?
SPEAKER_04Don't look back in anger by Oasis.
SPEAKER_03I don't know this question. Could you give us a come on?
SPEAKER_04Like whenever that plays in um in a bar or something, everyone sings along. It's great. Anyway.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I'm very disappointed by the reactions to that. They haven't got a clue I'm talking about.
SPEAKER_01I know when I think Oasis, I only think of the of anyway. Here's Wonder Wall.
SPEAKER_04Wonder Wall, yeah. Wonder Wall is too obvious though. Don't look back in Anger is the one that people really enjoy. Well, both. Anyway.
SPEAKER_03Okay. I wish I could um say that's a great song, but I've never heard this song before. So um good job.
SPEAKER_01All right. Now for some substantive questions, the reason why we're here. So the first question is this um you have written previously on AI and done a lot of research on AI ethics and AI and the regulation of AI issues. Um so, firstly, what drives your interest in uh AI and what are the things that you find really interesting or promising about it, and how does that influence your research?
SPEAKER_04Uh what drives it? I think um so I just like um I like technology. I find technology interesting, and I always have. So I for me as an academic, the question was when I came to do healthcare law, because before I went, so before I did my current job as assistant professor, I did my PhD and it didn't have anything to do with healthcare law. It was constitutional law and it was lobbying of government and parliament. But then when I started this job, they needed someone to teach healthcare law.
SPEAKER_04So I said, okay, I can do it, I'll adapt, I'll learn as as uh as you know, as the opportunity was there. And um once I started doing healthcare law, then I had to ask where I can add value to the field, because if I'm writing in traditional areas that established professors are already writing in, then um I'm not gonna really be able to add much to what they've been doing for decades. And at that time, about five years ago, there was a handful of professors, mainly in America, who were writing about AI and healthcare, and I like tech.
SPEAKER_04And I was a little bit interested in AI just from my general interest uh in technology. So that's what got me into it. I thought maybe I can add value here, maybe this is something I can rapidly learn. There aren't many people doing it, and I can work with the people who were doing it quite early on. So that's what led me to it. It was more of that process rather than like a specific issue in health that grabbed me, that made me feel so terrible, that drew me to it. No, it was like this like deductive process leading to that choice.
SPEAKER_01And now five years later, everybody's doing it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, exactly. Especially this year since ChatGPT came out. That's it. Everyone is now the expert, everyone is writing about it, talking about it. Um, so yeah, I it feels good that we were doing it many years ago, and the people doing it even before me in health and law, AI generally we know has been going on for decades. It's actually been going since the 1940s, was when AI started in very rudimentary ways. In healthcare, it was used in very simplistic ways from the late 60s and 70s, so it's not new, but healthcare lawyers and bioethicists that have come to the table has only really st started five years ago.
SPEAKER_04I think the earliest writings I could see at least were 2014, but there were only like one or two pieces, and that was my co-editor um for the book Glenn Cohen. He he wrote something I think 2014. So, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So that's um You get to say you were on it before it became cool, or just when it was starting to become cool.
SPEAKER_04Maybe, maybe. I haven't really thought about that, perhaps. Yeah, before before at least uh everybody was talking about it. Yeah, but that means now I do have to sift through what is actually good scholarship and what isn't, um, because everybody's writing about it. And I'm I'm curious what people actually when I started. I also went and actually learned about AI. I did two courses on AI. I sat down with computer scientists in my university and said, Teach me about AI. I I don't know anything. And um, my brothers are computer scientists too. So I sat down with people who actually and also AI developers in my university who develop algorithms.
SPEAKER_04I'm part of research projects. So I like to sit down with people and just learn the technology itself before actually then discussing the law.
SPEAKER_03Well, that's perfect because I was hoping you could tell us some examples of actual AI devices in use in healthcare at the moment. Maybe if you have some leading successful examples, or maybe some examples of someone that we tried and then we quickly realized it wasn't working.
SPEAKER_04Um, so it's not so transparent from all the hospitals around the world what they're using. Um if we just take a like a big picture look at things, there are some leading hospitals in the US which have used AI for uh some time and they've experimented with different systems. Some have been successful, some haven't. Nowadays we see more hospitals using them. Oh, NHS in the UK also trialed some wearable uh AI devices quite broadly a few years ago. I would say now my my feeling is that China's really taking a lead. It seems they're they're doing a lot in healthcare, and I don't know enough about what they're doing.
SPEAKER_04Um that's like something I want to look at in the future, a bit more research. But in terms of specific things, it's been used in all sorts of ways. So um scans is one like big area scanning images like for tumours. So might scan an X-ray or look at multiple X-rays or MRI scans, CT scans. You feed the image data into an AI system and it can determine with greater accuracy than a doctor if the person actually has a cancerous tumor or not. And these are being used in practice to support doctors.
SPEAKER_04Um there are also like wearables. So in the in the past, let's say you've been discharged from an intensive care unit. One of the issues with that is if you've had some major surgery or an intensive care unit, you then leave. You have to come back at points in time in the future to be tested to see how you're progressing. But the problem is, say, if you come back three months later and then six months later and nine months later, you get a snapshot in time of that person's health. It doesn't actually give you the full picture of what's going on day to day.
SPEAKER_04So there have been uses of wearable uh devices that are constantly tracking people's vitals, integrated with AI with AI. AI is assessing those vital signs of that person on a day-to-day basis and can pick up problems before they actually happen. And they can alert the doctor and say this person's vitals are showing concerns in this way. Um and then there are lots of other ones. So um I've written about the use of AI in psychiatric wards. It hasn't happened yet, but there are developers who are developing this.
SPEAKER_04So you might have a camera pointed towards a bed and it can detect uh if somebody's fallen from the bed and alert the staff. Or there is AI used in um uh suicide prediction, able to predict the likelihood of suicide, contraband detection, seeing if somebody is may have some contraband they're not allowed in a psychiatric unit, or this is used in prisons at the moment, but I think it could be used in psychiatric units one day. Um, so it might detect if somebody's you got something they might harm themselves with, or even facial expressions, or even they can be used to uh listen in on phone calls.
SPEAKER_04Like these are more futuristic ones that are coming, but I mean there's all sorts of applications. There are books on this dedicated just to the applications, loads of them now.
SPEAKER_03You started off there, and I got really excited about some of those. I was like, yay, like we can process so many more patients in a day. We can save radiologists so much more time. And then as you continued going down that list, I progressively got a bit more anxious. As some of you know, you talked about some of the applications, and you know, my mind is just bazifying things like right to privacy, um, you know, overuse, particularly if um, you know, someone else has access to that data through a slip in regulation, which means they can use it for other means and you know, data is bias. So I was wondering if we could just talk a little bit more about maybe what how you see some of those and whether or not that's the same way that you know I might see it, with a bit of fear, a bit of anxiety.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, of course. Uh and actually so do the developers themselves and and and those in health. So I published an article in a journal called Jamda, a journal of the Association of Medical Directors, um, which was about people in post-acute and long-term care. In in those circumstances, the problem is that AI systems they don't have enough data to be trained on. And so the accuracy in that context, say if you've got a camera in a unit where a resident is living, they might not actually be very accurate at making predictions.
SPEAKER_04Um, and there are really big privacy concerns. Like the residents just don't like having a camera watching them. And so some developers have just decided, you know what, we're we're not gonna use it, we're not gonna develop these anymore. The the privacy concerns are too high. People not not many people want them. So we'll focus on other AI applications we might use. So, in many cases, I would actually say because of the risks of privacy and health, there is a big limitation on developing uh AI systems for a lot of health applications.
SPEAKER_04Uh-huh. There's quite the limitation. Like I gave the example of psychiatric wards. I don't actually think it's going to be easy at all to develop robust AI systems to use in that context, because I don't think they can get the data. I think the pushback's going to be quite hard unless they develop them in countries where data rights aren't so strong. So But those are just a couple there's loads of concerns. So the the key concerns, if we think about what are the key concerns about AI in health, there are about six or seven.
SPEAKER_04So the first three are all about data, which are uh data discrimination and bias. The second one's data privacy, third one's data security. Then you've got concerns about medical liability, informed consent, and intellectual property. These are the the the broad, those are, I think there's six like this there, those are the six core concerns you find no matter what the AI application is in health, those arise. And they arise to different degrees depending on the context.
SPEAKER_04So in some contexts, medical liability might be more of a worry, in other contexts, it might be data privacy, and others it might be biased and others it might be IP. So these play out in different ways, and the balance needs to be found between these six for something to come to market and be safe and robust to use in practice. That's what we've identified in our book too. And actually, there's very little development in the law in any of these areas, very little.
SPEAKER_01So when you talked, when you started talking about mental health, there was another question that uh popped into my head, or another issue that popped into my head, and that's that sometimes predictions can actually affect the outcome. For example, if you tell me, oh, you're gonna fall sick tomorrow, you know, that's it. I might fall sick tomorrow, and your prediction in that case will come true. But if you tell me, oh, you're gonna behave like this tomorrow, I might think, you know what, screw you. I guess I won't do it now. You know? Uh do you think are there any distinct ethical issues that arise in that kind of case?
SPEAKER_01I call it the that's so raven problem for all the people who know that.
SPEAKER_03Have you seen that?
SPEAKER_01No, I haven't.
SPEAKER_04No, I don't get your cultural reference over here.
SPEAKER_01It it it's this it's this Disney Channel show uh in the late 90s, I think.
SPEAKER_03Maybe 2000s. Anyway, just the character, she just gets visions um of you know the future, so then she can act around it and make sure it doesn't happen.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Okay. But but what's the concern though there?
SPEAKER_01So I'm trying to understand what you're so the concern is what people might act a certain way if AI Yeah, if we have a program that uh predicts if somebody is gonna uh self-harm or even commit suicide, will that actually affect the rates at which people actually uh end up harming themselves?
SPEAKER_04Um I think it's more like a diagnostic. We do it anyway, this stuff. So, like if so in suicide prediction, they'll do a survey, they'll meet with someone and say, you know, what are how you they'll do the survey to determine suicide risk. I don't know if that affects their behavior, it might do, but I don't think AI changes that. It's just a more advanced tool for doing that. I think the way AI might affect behaviors is if you I gave the example of elder care. So one of the tools in elder care are social robots, care bots that um residents um may interact with and they may form a bond with.
SPEAKER_04And so that raises questions of how that affects their behavior day-to-day. Some of them form such a strong bond they don't want to let them go. And so, what does that say about their autonomy? Another one is um again in the this residence context and post-acute and long-term care, if somebody is going to um um it's interesting. It a person's being detected by AI all the time so that if they spend too long in the toilet, it will alert their family that something might have gone wrong.
SPEAKER_04But that means it's affected their behavior in terms of now they're nervous and they're rushing every time they go to the bathroom because they don't want the alarm to go off. So it can affect behaviors in this way, I would say, less so than you know, the more diagnostic bits that you just mentioned, from what I can tell anyway.
SPEAKER_01No more scrolling on your phone on the toilet.
SPEAKER_04No, I mean that's that was a worry. That's why they'd go in and rush back in. I mean, that's nowhere to live. You can't live like that.
SPEAKER_03Basic rights is your toilet phone time.
SPEAKER_01I need to enjoy my time on the throne. On the throne.
SPEAKER_03Look, I'm loving the direction of this chat, but I'm just gonna wheel it straight back. Um so my next question is the very first problem that you actually raised, the first of those six. Um, so I'm particularly interested in the nature of violence in big data. Um, particularly, I read this really, really great book. I don't know if you've heard of it called Invisible Women. Um I think it's by Carolyn uh something Perez. I'll um have to put the link in the podcast notes when we upload it. But basically, she goes through every facet of uh a woman's life, public and private, to show that there is just fundamentally data lacking on pretty much everything.
SPEAKER_03And she has one particular chapter on medicine and health. And this, I just there was she she she said so many things I didn't even know, like um paracetamol wasn't even um clinically trialed on women until 2015 or 2016. There is just so much data lacking on the way the female body works and the way the female body responds to drug treatment, to medical treatment. You know, women have a 50% higher chance of um dying from a heart attack than men because they are all funded like at the core of it and misdiagnosed most of the time because we present differently.
SPEAKER_03And I was just wondering um if you were aware of any way that we can both implement AI which has amazing um, particularly medical imaging things like breast cancer, they have amazing uses for women. Um, but also are we gonna just continue to reperpetrate bias and continue to cause harm?
SPEAKER_04So I think we could add a few more lays to that. I she's right that there's definitely data lacking for women, but I would actually say there's data lacking for men too. So that I'd say there's data lacking across the board everywhere. The the core amount of data that's used to train AI comes out of a few elite research centers in the US. And in perhaps I perhaps there are some in in Europe that I'm not aware of, but it's basically a very, very small number of elite research centers, and what they're able to do in their studies because they have they've managed to get funding, that's not a criticism of them.
SPEAKER_04You know, they can only do what they can within the confines of what they've got, and there's only so much you can do in a research project, and they're so hard to run. Um, but they are the ones who who've managed to get the funding for this very expensive research, and so the pool of data that they produce is tiny. So actually, there's a huge gap across the board on almost every factor. We could talk about cultural reasons, we could talk about um matters of culture that might feed into decisions of health, matters of religion, um, demographics across the like you talk about like women, that might be true.
SPEAKER_04It might be true in in America that men, there's more data about regarding men's health in the US, for example. But what I would say is in the Middle East, there's no data about anyone. Uh, there's no big research centers really pulling in lots of data to train AI systems in a big systematic way, or in the African continent, or in South America, and so on. So, what's needed really to have as much data as possible to sort of train AI systems in a way that, like biases, we just need a lot more data across the board from around the world.
SPEAKER_04And I can't see I can't see how it's going to be done easily, honestly. Like is it is the we I was discussing this with somebody recently. Do we just need lots of big res research centers dotted around the world in different demographics, all creating data that then we pull to train AI systems? Maybe. How possible is that? I don't know. It doesn't sound very likely to me. So what we do in the meantime, um, I don't know. Honestly, I it it's if those are still the ones running the show, these elite centers, then at least they have to try and balance the type of data they're getting if we're relying on them for now.
SPEAKER_04But that's just a very short-term stopgap solution. We need actually data coming from all around the world. You know, one analogy I could draw is um I saw a talk about it was a bioethics talk, and it was about um I think it was it was it was something about somebody presented about the use of um because I think there's an analogy in here actually. Yeah, somebody somebody presented, I believe, about the the there was the colonization of bioethics, right?
SPEAKER_04Like bioethics they so they put forward has been colonized by Western academia, which caused me to reflect and go in in my opinion, not really, you know, bioethics arose out of uh Western academia, created it, it didn't colonize a field, it created a field. But the point they were making was there wasn't a balance of different views. But my solution in my mind was well, then it's up to other demographics and groups around the world to contribute to the conversation and develop capacity.
SPEAKER_04And I've seen that, for example, in the Middle East. So we could argue that Islamic bioethics hasn't been considered enough in the discourse. So, what have they done in HBKU? We have an Islamic bioethics center, they produce loads of research, they hold the World Congress on Bioethics in Doha. And so I see that in a way in like there's I think there's an analogy there for AI, which is we need people from around the world to start creating their own centers, creating their own data, contributing to it, and changing the complex.
SPEAKER_04Conversation. Like it's it's almost like you we just can't rely on just the same groups of people to fix problems, they won't. Like you need others to come and come on board and and contribute to that. I think that's a very long-winded answer.
SPEAKER_03Well, I see. I did to be honest, I didn't know about the big data missing problem. Um, so that's been a real eye-opener for me. And um, I'm intrigued by the fact that you said you don't know how it's gonna go. Like we just need more data, but you we're not sure how to actually get it.
SPEAKER_04Can I jump in on the data thing too? Uh there's because there was one uh interesting example. You know, the the data point, it like the accuracy of AI systems can easily be affected. So there've been AI systems that have been trained on demographics in one state in the US, then used on patient populations in other states, and they weren't very accurate. And that's even within the same country. So it just shows you like even within one country, because your demographics can be quite diverse, um, you can have quite inaccurate systems.
SPEAKER_03So we can start to undo that fear that there's gonna be this one big mega AI bot that's gonna take over the world and it's gonna apply in all situations, we really need contextual uh AI driven by the communities in those places.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but might not happen though.
SPEAKER_01You mean contextual AI overlords? On this note, one of the questions we really wanted to ask was that given that you've written a lot on why we currently don't have enough law, laws, and regulations about the use of AI in healthcare, we were just wondering why we can't just repurpose existing laws or just apply existing laws to whatever the issues are.
SPEAKER_01For example, we already have privacy laws and we already have torts, we already have laws about informed consent. Why can't we just take those, apply them to the use of AI in healthcare, uh, and bada bing, bada boom, all our issues disappear.
SPEAKER_04That was the first step. So, in um there's been a four-stage process on the development from uh from you what you're I think referencing is something I've written about uh in a in an article from AI to law. So there's been a four-stage process on this path that we have to law. First stage was you have AI posing challenges that didn't exist before. For example, we don't have in before you might have locked algorithms, they produce the same result every time. AI produces is has adaptive algorithms, so you might have a different result over time.
SPEAKER_04What you approve now might not be what exists six months down the line that you initially approved because the algorithms would have changed. And so um, and there are other issues which make um AI unique. So that's been so that's been the first thing. So the first thing is you've got this new challenge posed by technology. So the second stage of what happened was that lawyers then look to see how do we adapt existing laws to deal with those problems, and they found that um you can adapt existing laws only up to a certain point they help.
SPEAKER_04They answer some questions, but not every question. And actually, there are new questions that AI poses that we can't answer with existing laws. It hasn't even gone to court in many cases, these cases haven't been tried, tested. Um so so that what you've mentioned has kind of happened already. There's been a big process of that, mainly in tort law and or or injury laws, it's called in some places, but it's it's only taken us so far. So then what's happened in the third step is that you've had all of these guidelines developing around the world as a stopgap to plug the gap while we're still figuring out what the answer is.
SPEAKER_04Like, and a lot of these guidelines will have lots of principles. Like you've got them from the World Health Organization, OECD. There is there are hundreds of them now. Um, most of them are not very good. But there are some good ones. We developed someone, I I've developed last three years some guidelines in Qatar for the use of AI and healthcare research, very granular detailed guidelines. Um, anyway, so then the fourth stage is now actually we need to create new law. And they're kind of informed by the first three stages. What was the problem that we had? Why didn't the law that we tried to adapt not adapt very well?
SPEAKER_04What gaps did the guidelines plug? And can we take all of that and create a new law which kind of starts to remedy some of those problems? And you can't, I think, just make one law that remedies all of those problems. You either have to amend existing laws or create laws in lots of bespoke areas to deal with that issue. Um, and that process is, like I mentioned, only just beginning. It's a very, very new process with the AI Act and some medical device regulations.
SPEAKER_03We have one final question, James, or do you do the honors?
SPEAKER_01I will do the honors. So if you could snap your fingers and change one specific thing instantly, what would it be? Oh my god. What's your Thanos moment? What's my what? Thanos moment. Thanos moment, yeah. You have all six.
SPEAKER_03The Thanos question.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the Thanos question. You have all six stones. What are you gonna change? But it's really, really underpowered stones.
SPEAKER_04Okay. And this is kind of a cheat. If I was Thanos, I could sap my fingers and change one thing. I would I would change okay. This is gonna sound ridiculous. I would change the nature of who I am so that I can have superpowers to have unlimited wishes. Oh, new world. So then I can change many things.
SPEAKER_03You know what? Legal scholar, we did not actually put any qualifiers on it.
SPEAKER_01We we we'll get our lawyers on this too.
SPEAKER_04If you want me, if I have to, if that's prohibited, which I don't think it should be, because as you say, it didn't stipulate. If I had to choose one thing, oh that's really difficult.
SPEAKER_03Um maybe just something about AI, if you want.
SPEAKER_04Uh no, I like the bigger one. I like grappling with these existential Yeah, that's fair. Um There's so many aspects. It's actually really common. Like, what do I want to solve? Do I want to solve uh it's actually me to reflect deeply. Would I do I want to solve all the health problems in the world and make it go away? Or do I want to solve I suppose I mean You know what? I think if there's one thing, if I could click my fingers, that I would do is have the instant solution to the organization of society across the globe.
SPEAKER_04And by that I mean that we have different ways of organizing society around the world, whether it's democracy, autocracy, uh communism, there are loads of different ways of organizing society, and each way you could argue has its positives and negatives. Uh but then there are always negatives in every aspect, which I think leads to problems in society for like the future. How do we, you know, how do we solve problems as a society? What do we look like as a human race for the future? So if I could click my fingers, it would be the solution to that.
SPEAKER_04We have that one system that just works for the world, where there's that it finds that perfect balance where we organize society in a way that we can solve our problems, people can live in you know, in good lives, but in harmony in a way that takes care of um the issues that we have, and we have this sort of a collective vision for where we're going as an entire race for the planet. So that's a quite a big one, but I think that's that's probably what I would try and find the solution to if I could click my fingers.
SPEAKER_01If you click your fingers and created an organization, would it then not make you the organizing principal?
SPEAKER_04You are well, maybe this is revealing about me. Uh no, uh, I would uh see the perfect system I I don't think revolves around a single person. But it it's who it revolves around. I don't I don't know what that answer is. I don't know what it is. I don't know what the perfect system is, honestly. Well flawed.
SPEAKER_03We wish you the best in that endeavour. Well, I'm gonna go to the back. If you walk out of here, just pick your fingers. Um, we are so grateful that you took some time out of your day to come on the pod. Um you're welcome back anytime. Um and I do want to know if you finished the rest of that copy.
SPEAKER_04I drank about 65% of the coffee.
SPEAKER_03Well, congrats.
SPEAKER_04It was good.
SPEAKER_03Good effort. Good effort.
SPEAKER_04But now I'm hydrating with water.
SPEAKER_03Well, thank you so much, and we look forward to seeing you again.
SPEAKER_04Thank you so much for having me. It's been fun.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and U and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...