Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and organoid research, joins Sinead and James to discuss what organoids are, why scientists are so excited about them, and why bioethicists are watching very closely. Insoo explains who has rights over donated cells that end up being brain models, whether organoids can have moral status, and what happens when an organoid has no donor at all - or many donors at once. Would you want a copy of your brain in a jar? Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, C BME and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_03And welcome back to CB Me and You, a podcast about biomedical ethics. Today, we dive into the strange, wonderful world of organoids. What are they? Why would we want to make them? And do we get to talk about an all-time philosophical hit brains and vats? I'm excited. Joining us for today's part is Professor Insu Hyan, senior researcher at the Hastings Center for Bioethics and affiliate of the Center for Bioethics at the Harvard Medical School. Bam, first try.
SPEAKER_03You did it. It's a mouthful.
SPEAKER_01Welcome, welcome, welcome. Thank you. We have a couple of questions to get to know you a little bit better. First question: I see your hand just covering the cup of coffee. Coffee or copy?
SPEAKER_02That's a really good question. So I would say, thank you for first of all for letting me be here. This is really fun. But second thing I want to say, yeah, it's a very important question. So health-wise, I would prefer coffee. But if you actually put down in front of me a cup of coffee and a cup of coffee, I would grab the copy. So I think if your preferences are revealed by behavior, that reveals what I prefer.
SPEAKER_01I'm so intrigued because you've this is the first time you've had coffee. And so you're saying your preferences have changed that quickly. Are you trying to like suck up to us?
SPEAKER_02Well, so no, no, no. I think coffee is pretty similar to other things I like, like Vietnamese coffee. And there are like many coffees that I've had that have that sweet condensed milk added to it. I I don't think I could eat drink it daily. So like I said, for health reasons, I think coffee is a better choice. But again, if you put two cups in front of me, the hand will grab the copy.
SPEAKER_01The hand. Not you, the hand. The hand, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Inexplicably grab the county.
SPEAKER_03He's like a behaviorist about himself.
SPEAKER_02Exact exactly, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02You can talk big about what your your values are, but really it's what you do that I think reveals your your true preferences.
SPEAKER_01I agree, I agree. I think copy is delicious. When I first moved here, I had one every day until A, I realized how much sugar is actually in it. And B, how much caffeine is truly in it. Um and now I sort of treat it like a sweet treat. When I need just a little bit of caffeine, but I want something sweet, copy is where I go. But you definitely have to have it before midday, otherwise I will be up all night.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think I passed the midday point. So thank you for this. Um I'll be lying in bed tonight just cursing the two of you.
SPEAKER_01You wouldn't be the first.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, your curses will be well well received. Okay, okay.
SPEAKER_01Uh next question. Uh, what country do you want to travel to next?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's actually the country I'm going to next. Next week I'm going to uh Kenya. Wow. And it'll be my first time, and I'm really looking forward to it. I'll spend some extra time on safari, not shooting anything, but you know, obviously just watching, looking for animals.
SPEAKER_01I'm sorry, not in the gun context. I thought you meant shooting a movie.
SPEAKER_02No, no, no. No, no, that'll be kind of fun too, but no, no, no. Um just iPhone capture of uh of animals. Um I'm really looking forward to that. I've always wanted to go and have an opportunity to go for work reasons, but again, you you add on days to make it fun. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, I hope the iPhone shooting goes really well. We look forward to seeing a post online.
SPEAKER_02I hope all these blurry shots of these like little specks.
SPEAKER_01How wonderful.
SPEAKER_02How wonderful is this picture? It's like, what is that, a rat? If you squint, you might be able to see the line that was like too much. Move the picture in front of your face really fast because that's what it was like in real life.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, there's a uh effect now on Instagram that's really popular that actually blurs it to the kind of quality of photos that were taken in the 2000s. So we're so nostalgic for better times that we are actively making up. Downgrade the photos of worse quality.
SPEAKER_02There was a time where you actually had to take photos and hope that it turned out and you have to wait for the developer to develop them. It was you sold it, it's it's um it does kind of make each shot sort of precious, right? You have to be really thoughtful. It's not just volume, and then you pick the one that looks good out of a hundred, but um you could end up getting 12 back of the all. They're all terrible. That's the risk.
SPEAKER_01That is worth that. Um, last question for the whole entire pod, and then you can go home. What's your go-to karaoke song?
SPEAKER_02So I I'm a terrible singer. It's one of the things like I wish I could sing. Probably, you know, uh, but anyway, but so I'm a terrible singer, but if I had to do karaoke with a gun to my head, I'd probably pick a song that's I I I think it'd be pretty easy for me. It's um Billy Idol's Um Eyes Without a Face, because it's kind of monotone. It's not there's not a lot of range to that song. It's kind of mid-level. Because you don't have a gun to my head. I there's no there's no incentive for me to embarrass myself.
SPEAKER_02I'll be real blurry. Yeah. Um but that would that'll be it. My wife is a fantastic singer, and her go-to is either I actually recently it's been that that song by four non-blondes, What's Up?
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah, that one.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, she and her her female friends just get all into it. Um that's fun. Uh so I I watch that, but I don't I don't embarrass myself. Try not to.
SPEAKER_01Just just so you know, um, out of the two of us, James is the better karaoke person at all types of uh singing, including higher pitches, which is very disappointing for me because it's like, what do I contribute to karaoke if he can do all the high hits?
SPEAKER_03Well, here at the center we believe that karaoke is not about singing ability, it's about interesting.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Now I can't say I'll put a gun to your head one day, but I do hope that when you come back to Singapore we can entice you to do karaoke.
SPEAKER_02I did the Billy Idol song. Go back to 1984 or 83, I think, is when it came out.
SPEAKER_03Okay, so in the words of one of my favorite karaoke songs, Let's Get Down to Business.
SPEAKER_02I like what you did there.
SPEAKER_03Uh I like it too. Leave it in! Um Okay, so let's start with the basic question. Uh many people are wondering right now, what are these organoids that we're about to talk about?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know, so there are various ways to explain it. So organoids are many, many different types. Um basically, there are three-dimensional models of human organ systems. So there are brain organoids, there are liver organoids, airway, eye, gut, you name it. Um, and they're small. So, I mean, the idea of calling something an organoid kind of it may make people envision kind of like a like a really sizable clump of tissue.
SPEAKER_02But for example, human brain organoids are really no bigger than boba, and they kind of look like white boba. I wouldn't recommend putting that in your tea. In your tea, but that's what they look like. Uh but but but when you imagine, maybe you know, you hear the term brain organoid, you kind of think, oh, it might be pink and has like folds and it looks like a little mini tiny brain. Doesn't look like that at all. Now, um, how are they made? You can uh make them from what are called pluripotent stem cells, which are stem cells that could become any kind of tissue type, any cell type.
SPEAKER_02And traditionally, we've only been we've started by using embryonic stem cells, which come from fertility clinic embryos, pre-implantation. Now we can make those types of cells from any kind of cell from an adult body. So you can use blood cells, skin cells, you reprogram them in the lab to become pluripotent. And then once you get a pluripotent cell life from a sample, um, you can coax it, you can, you can, you can nudge it to make these different organoids. And uh it's really quite amazing. I mean, you know, you you can make these models in a dish, um, and they are pretty consistent in terms of how they uh to use the fancy term, recapitulate developmental biology or replay the developmental playbook of like when your brain forms or when other organ systems form.
SPEAKER_02So it's really a cool tool to see how someone with a genetic disorder uh might be different in terms of their early development by looking at these different organ systems compared to a control cell line, a quote unquote healthy cell line, and what it does. So it's a really beautiful model, three-dimensional of um organ systems to study function, growth, and also compare diseased and non-diseased organoids. Uh, and then the the application for this, besides expanding your knowledge of what cells do and what development can do, is to actually have a three-dimensional test bed for uh drugs and other other interventions.
SPEAKER_02You know, so if you make a disease-specific, let's say um brain organoid that comes from an autism patient, you can try to see like what's not only different about the neuronal growth, but are there any factors you could apply to the brain organoid to slow down or reverse the the abnormalities there? Um so as a research tool, very, very interesting. Uh they don't look like anything impressive. Like I said, you know, the brain organoids kind of look like boba floating around. A little disappointed, yeah. But but when you put it under a microscope after you've tagged all the cell types to different colors, it's really beautiful.
SPEAKER_02So anybody at home, Google brain organoid, and what you'll see in the images are just beautiful rainbow-colored things that under a black light will sort of you know shine shine and show all the different cell types. But uh but normally when you look at them in a dish or a vial, they just look like little white blobs.
SPEAKER_03And so so these are literally living things like that. Oh yeah, that's a good point.
SPEAKER_02Yes, it's living cells, and they they actually go through the initial stages of embryo and fetal development. So brain organoids could be grown or kept in a dish, growing, fed for a year or longer. Now, it might take nine months to a year to start seeing mature brain cell types because the actual developmental program in humans is uh is is uh shown yet again in the dish. Um, but now why are they so small? Why are they white? It's because they don't have vasculature.
SPEAKER_02And because there's no way to bring in nutrients and remove waste products, that really limits how big they can get. Because once they start growing beyond a certain size, the middle, the very middle core of the brain organoid starts to die. It forms what's called a necrotic core. And so um it really is kind of limited if uh in terms of how large, large they can get. There are people who are trying to like find ways to vascularize them, or uh this is really fascinating, uh, combine them with other organoid types. They could be the same brain organoid regions, or it can be other organ types.
SPEAKER_02So that combination is what we call assembloids. You take brain organoids and maybe other brain organoids and you put them together and it forms a little bit more of a complex, fused model. The thing I should point out is brain organoids only uh recapitulate a particular region of the brain. So you never have a single brain organoid that represents everything. It's going to be like, you know, cerebellum or frontal cortex or some other part. Um and so the assembloid idea is kind of cool because you can imagine it's almost like taking like little play-doh balls and you put them together and kind of assemble this like a little better of an approximation of the real brain.
SPEAKER_02Uh so if they get a little bit bigger, um, the really fascinating work is where you combine organoids of different types. So one uh research team that I've worked with a lot at Stanford, Sergio Paschka's team, he um put a brain organoid, fused it with a spinal cord organoid, and they put on the end of that a muscle organoid and got the muscle organoid to twitch by stimulating the brain organoid. Now, why is that important? Well, you know, there could be a again, a really interesting model system for movement disorders or other things, and you know, you can get these cells from people who have various conditions you want to study, and then you just basically build a little model of their physiology.
SPEAKER_02It's so interesting because it's genetically specific to that person. Um, so you can make it really disease specific, individual specific. Um, so that's the kind of work. You know, I mean, there are other we can talk later about the other, like what are the issues coming up on that, because that's might have been a big area of my research. Um, what are the other issues, ethical issues, whether it's about you know worries about consciousness or other applications of them. So happy to get into that later. But a very long response or answer to your question, what are organoids? There are these things that are created in the lab, three-dimensional, use for uh all these different types of purposes.
SPEAKER_01I can just imagine a um my brain is going, a lab scientist has two organoids, and it's like now kith and just push them once they're together.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know, sometimes I ask people, um, and they don't give me a straight answer. I say, Do you have your entire lab? Like this, did everybody in your lab contribute materials and you have organoids and you have like a culture dish with your whole lab represented and organoids? I think probably somewhere people have done that because you know, lab folks are kind of fun and quirky. And and I'm sure people will be, because it's easy to do. You can just take a blood draw, you can take a little skin sample, you reprogram that into what are called induced pluripotent stem cells, IPS cells. You can do it yourself.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I wouldn't really call it self-experimentation, but it's just sort of you're at the lab, you're doing this all the way with other samples, why not just throw in your own sample and do it? I wouldn't tell, you know, I wouldn't like tell on them if that's what they did, but I wouldn't be surprised. So the next step is then what do you do with that cell line? Maybe you enter it into the protocol that you're working on and you just see what do my brain organisms look like. Wouldn't you be curious?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02You know, and look at it under the microscope and see this is replaying, replaying what happened in the womb when I was uh when I was coming into being.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I'd be very scared though. Like, what if my brain organized turns out to be like well, you know what's interesting?
SPEAKER_02It's like they have found like some strange, some and you don't know why, but some cell lines like don't do a good job making organisms. It's like so was what's why? Is it because there's something intrinsic about the cell line that really, you know, it it it it hints at a potential problem that you may be facing? One of the interesting ethical issues in this area of work, so I've worked with these labs. We had a grant from the NIH to look at ethical issues and scientific issues early, uh early on in brain organoid research. And one of the things we've realized was there could be what we might call developmental incidental findings.
SPEAKER_02You guys know what incidental findings is in terms of genetics research and like imaging. You you during the course of your research might have something like you know, CT scans, you could have genetic samples, and you're you know, probing around, getting your data, and then nearby you realize there's some abnormality. And you wonder, hmm, in this scan, it looks like they might have like a tumor. Or in this you know, genetic uh panel that we're doing, they they actually have a mutation for a pretty serious disease. I don't know who this person is, I don't know anything about this person, but I'm working with their biospecimen or their their image.
SPEAKER_02Should I, do I have a responsibility to return this information back to them and give them a heads up? Hey, you may want to go to the doctor and get a checkup. So that's a whole issue of incidental findings in genetics and imaging. What's interesting about the brain organoid stuff or other brain organoid research is there might be some issues that you're seeing in the developmental trajectory that might hint at something unusual about the person's brain or about the person's gut or anything like that. And do you have a responsibility to go back to the to the original donor and and not you yourself, but maybe contact the clinician in charge who really is supposed to be the person who talks to the original donor?
SPEAKER_02And the answers for all these issues normally is well, you have better make sure that you validate what you found clinically. You can't just kind of take a research grade, scan and scare everybody, you know, and and and and waste time and money. Following up if it's not really like re uh it's not clinical level. And so the problem is, well, how how do we know that the brain organoid is truly, truly representative of development? We're still figuring that out. So it's too early to do anything about that. But it is really interesting, you know. You you say, yeah, what if what if there you find something strange?
SPEAKER_02And people have found uh unusual um differences between the organoid types. And again, you don't know exactly what that signifies. But maybe in the future, once we know that these models are really great models, um, you may be in a position where, yeah, that does become a serious consideration. You need to you need to get somebody needs to get in touch with this person, especially if it's actionable, like they can do something about it. There's a another area where people might argue if you can't do anything about it, why would you want to tell them? And there are actually some donors who say, I wouldn't want to know if it was something you found that I couldn't do anything about.
SPEAKER_01James, would you want to know when they find something?
SPEAKER_03I think I would. Unless it's something really weird, then you know, don't tell me. You know, not like a health issue, but like, you know, turns out like, oh yeah, you should uh you know you have scales or something, you would be growing scales.
SPEAKER_02Here's the problem with that. So you tell the researcher, well, don't tell me anything if it's really bad or weird, and the person says, Oh, okay, I won't tell you anything then.
SPEAKER_03It's like, well, guess what? You're all weird. Everything is. This is really interesting because I'm now wondering what the the limits are to this, right? Like, so you've already mentioned, well, it's gonna be really hard to advance in terms of size at least, uh, if we don't find a way to vascularize these organoids. But now I'm wondering uh both in terms of practical limits and theoretical limits, looking into the future, as there was some sci-fi projection here. Well, what what are the limits here? Could we actually just like grow full brains or parts of brains and like have them hovering around in vats?
SPEAKER_02Um, I think there are lots of technical limitations happening here. Um so yeah, we still haven't solved the vascularization problem, which is a which is just a big hindrance on how big and complex these things can get. Um the other one is people worry, so so let's let's just stick with brain organized, because of all the organoid types, that seems to be the one that's the most controversial. I think people are more concerned about brain organized because brains represent personhood and seats of consciousness. So if you're modeling that, then it seems like the concerns and all the value we place on human brains gets transferred over into these models.
SPEAKER_02Whereas the gut, sort of, you know, who cares about the gut or the kidney morally? I mean, except for like maybe transplant reasons. Um I let me qualify that. There are two other areas. So I think it's brain organoids and what are called gonadal organoids, or organoids of testicular testes and the ovaries. Seems to be like brains and guts or sorry, brains and gonads are all what people care about or worry about. So there are people who are trying to develop testicular organoids and ovarian ones, and I can say like why and why would they do that in a minute? But let's just stick with the brain organoids.
SPEAKER_02So um, a couple of worries about the future. One is right now, what we found in our brain organoid project for the NIH was we don't have to worry right now about there being consciousness or sentience in these little boba balls in a VAT. These are like basically brain models in a VAT, right? They're floating around solutions. Why? Well, we we can we can give a number of answers to say why right now we're not worried about anything like consciousness. Um, there are just a million or two million cells in a brain organ, right? The human brain has, you can look it up, I don't remember the exact number, but it's billions of cells.
SPEAKER_02Not only in volume, it's you know, uh uh you don't have anything close to the real human brain, but it doesn't have the regions you need, all the different regions. It doesn't have long-range projection. Uh everything that we know about consciousness today has to do with kind of the architecture of the brain, not just that there are neurons, but it's the architecture, it's the arrangement, it's the long-term signaling. The brain starts to develop in combination with um interaction with the environment, right? So you can imagine this is a terrible thing to imagine, but you can imagine like a newborn baby being born and just like kept in the vat.
SPEAKER_02I don't think that baby could develop what we would consider to be typical or normal human awareness and consciousness. Yeah, so so I mean, even I mean, so that's what's happening during pregnancy. You got a little, you know, brain in the vat with everything else, right? Um yeah, but but see, but it still has um limbs, it has, you know, other nerves, and and there's some interaction with the maternal environment, obviously, right? And and babies can or fetuses and uterine can hear. There are lots of things, right?
SPEAKER_02Um so so there are no sensory organs, there's no input like that. So it's just floating around. Um, but but getting back to the newborn idea, even with all the other sensory inputs and stuff, just without having social interaction, with you know, without having any kind of communication, you miss a window of opportunity in developmental brain biology to actually develop the capacity for language and for uh recognition and empathy and all the things that make us human. Um, so just you know, you can't recreate those circumstances in the brain organoid in the dish.
SPEAKER_02Now, I say that you know, for right now, we don't really worry about consciousness, but there are people, and I'm I'm on one of these projects where they want to do brain organoid-based computing. So you use a brain organoid instead of a microchip to do some basic computation uh for let's say AI applications. And you know, yeah, so just some interaction with the outside world, uh, this little neural network kind of you know, getting some stimulation and having output. So you think, well, that's still kind of like brain in the back kind of work. Um so what the team has been thinking of doing is maybe pairing the brain organoid with a human humanoid robot and it communicates through Bluetooth.
SPEAKER_02And so then you kind of get Of it, it's not physically inside the robot, but it's it's interacting with a body, you know, it's got embodied. And that's kind of a couple of things, you know, just to kind of see can you develop neurons more accurately through this kind of interaction with an environment? And then, you know, can the brain organoid kind of like a desk and more like quote unquote desktop computing, like control something like that? And they're finding that it can.
SPEAKER_01So how does a brain organoid like a boba connect by Bluetooth to a robot?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. So it sits on top of it's called wetware instead of hardware. And uh so you can look up papers. Uh so if you Google, uh telling people to Google lots of stuff, if you Google organoid wetware or uh organoid-based computing, the images will show from the scientific papers. There was a proof of principle paper published in Nature Electronics, and that team is the team I'm working with. So in their figures, uh they should be available online, you'll see what these things look like. They're they're drawings, schematics, but um, but I actually honestly don't quite understand how it works, but it seems to work.
SPEAKER_01I'm so you could finally have a friend.
SPEAKER_03It could even be you're a little organoid. The funny thing is like it could just be you. I was just thinking of like a video game, which I think uses the term wetware. I think it's like cyberpunk or something. I was like, well, so guess what? Video games are already my friend.
SPEAKER_01Really happy for you. Yeah. People obviously donate cells to create lots of these research lines uh and sell lines ethically, hopefully now. Um it's not necessarily just lab scientists using their own cells for all of this. So is there do you are you finding that people are more concerned about donating cells when it could be growing into something alive?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. So there there are two ways to answer that. So one is unfortunately a lot of the work that's being done in this area is with um pretty long established cell lines for which there was no explicit consent for this kind of work. Um, you know, I mean they've used that there's so many different ones. Um so yeah, I wouldn't be surprised if that's one of them. But um so what that means is there is no explicit consent for anything like this kind of work. And the reason why people can sort of get away with this is you've anonymized the cell line, meaning you scrubbed all the personal identifying information off that.
SPEAKER_02My view is I mean, genetics is the ultimate personal identifier. So actually, if you take any of these cell lines, if you really wanted to, you could probably figure out who that is, right? So I think that idea of that little quote-unquote loophole of not having to get explicit consent or even any consent from um people who provided tissues during hospital stays and other things like that, uh, is probably on the way out. It's gonna be harder and harder to defend this idea of, well, you scrubbed away their personal information, there's no risk of privacy invasion, I think, because all these cell lines, all the organizers have also genetic data attached to them and it travels with the cell line.
SPEAKER_02It just takes someone, just you know, the yeah, just just the interest in the motivation, just to just the triage, you know, from the sequencing all the different like publicly available or or commercially available ancestry databases and you just figure it out. And people have been able to do that. Um, so so one way to answer your question is you know, so far there actually hasn't been a very robust history of getting consent for these for this kind of work. Um, I mentioned hospitals. This is something that I should probably point out to your listeners, and they might be interested in this.
SPEAKER_02Anytime you go get medical care at a teaching hospital, so it's a hospital like NUS or Hospital Harvard Medical School, whatever, you know, that's affiliated with a research institution or a medical school. What you'll notice is that there's a consent form for when you get admitted to the hospital. And so you're consenting to you know being treated at the hospital, et cetera. There's usually a paragraph in there that says, anything I leave behind, meaning like any biomaterials you leave behind in a hospital, whether it's a urine in a urine bag, and yes, you can get IPS cells from urine, because there are cells in your urine, or you know, a blood draw, uh, any clinical discards of tissue during your procedure, anything you leave behind can be used for education and research.
SPEAKER_02That's what it says in the consent form. It can be used for education and research at that institution.
SPEAKER_01Does that include if you describe the toilet?
SPEAKER_02Um, so fecal matter is not great because it's it's it's hard to isolate DNA because of so much micro micro microbial things in it, so yuck, right? But the urine is sterile and there's a lot, there are a lot of cells floating around in the urine from your bladder. So that's actually probably the least invasive way to get cells uh for your research. Yeah, so hold your pee when you're at the doctor. Medicate to the M notate.
SPEAKER_02You insist that you're gonna flush it down to toilet, you're not gonna leave it in the bag behind because they're gonna take that little bag and make IPS cells and brain organoids from it.
SPEAKER_03So not to like raise any panic, but for all we know, there could be like mini jimmies that somebody is like growing somewhere. So that's that's interesting. Yeah, that's interesting.
SPEAKER_02And uh, well, yeah, the P. Um uh yes. I mean it could in principle be the case. And you know, you would think, oh, if I found that out, would I be satisfied with the rationale that, well, don't worry, we scrubbed your identifying information off that. You might think, well, no, but I because you the way you said it, could there be something that I'm kind of like tied to biologically, right? Um you said many, you know, many use, but um yeah, so I think that's that's of great interest to me. Um I've asked the lawyer, so what is someone supposed to do to opt out of this?
SPEAKER_02And I've been in the medical field, I've been doing research ethics for a long time. The answer really surprised me. She said, You would have to find that paragraph, circle it, cross it out, write no and initial it. Who the heck would know how to do that? I didn't know. Yeah. Right? So I I had argued like you need to actually have uh institutional policy that you will not use those specimens for this type of work because it's so far beyond what people imagine could happen. Can you imagine telling somebody, some some patient who's at the hospital getting their routine care or getting their surgery, and you say, Oh, you know, you point out, you know, anything you leave behind here could be useful education and research.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, that's fine, you know, health helps people that that's cool. Uh why would I care, you know, what you do with my cubicancer, please. Yeah. And then he said, Do you know that one of the things you could do for education and research, and this might be a very active area in this particular institution, is to convert somebody's cells into an immortal cell line. What's that? Well, this is a perpetual stem cell line, it could be shared around the world, has all your genetic data, and the people can do other things. Well, then of course it's all reviewed by a committee, but but the the future is pretty wide open for that. Oh, well, what are some of the crazy things that could happen?
SPEAKER_02Ever heard of brain organoids? You know, so can you imagine somebody like sitting there contemplating that that's one possibility? Now, I I want to tell the audience, it's not like it's super common, but there are some places for which there's a lot of this research happening, so chances are not zero that this could happen. Um, so anyway, so I think that that's a big problem. When you get back to like, well, then okay, of course you would have to get or want to get consent explicitly explicitly for this kind of work. When you talk to those people, like the prospective donors, they do say, I would want to know if what you're gonna do, one of the things you're gonna do is brain organoids.
SPEAKER_02And you say, well, why? Because I feel this sort of connection maybe to this. And it's important that I am at least aware of what you're doing, why you're doing it, what's gonna happen to the brain organoids. It's a little interesting to me because it's sort of like you can't have your cake and eat it too as a researcher. You can't say, on the one hand, this is such an incredible model because it tells me what happened when you were developing. Because that's what they tell like autism, you know, patients, they tell like parents who are donating samples, they'll say, one of the goals of this research is to better understand something about your child.
SPEAKER_02So you want to, that's true. You want, but you can't at the same time then say to the other donors, oh then don't worry, it's just it's just a lump of tissue. It's meaningless. How could you have it both ways? Either it's super significant and biologically really uh it is tied to their history in some way, their their developmental history, or it's just a mere lump of worthless tissue. You can't you can't say both. Um so that I see the attitude kind of changing. Like on the one hand, if you're talking to some donors, you really want to like convey the truth, which is like this is pretty significant in terms of what it will tell us about development.
SPEAKER_02And then if you want to kind of say, oh, no, no, there's nothing to worry about, then you end up downplaying what's exactly so scientifically compelling about this work. So uh so anyway, so I think that the the folks who do say I would want to know, um, they do have grounds for kind of you know having an interest in what happens to them, that their cell lines. And we've done research that we've published papers on like donors' attitudes toward organoid research, and especially for brain organoids, they want to know. So it kind of backs up what I said earlier about, you know, sometimes people don't care so much about other things that don't have this like moral or sentimental connection, whether it's the gut or liver.
SPEAKER_02I mean, it's it's interesting. Some people have some connection to uh eye, uh eye cup, or uh heart. It's really kind of interesting culturally, right? You kind of say go through the organ system, which ones kind of matter to you.
SPEAKER_01My colon.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I'm just kidding. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, there's some people for whom that's uh I believed you. That's uh that's uh that's a big deal.
SPEAKER_01You guys were like, mmm. Can I can I ask for both of you? Um, do you feel strange about having a brain organoid of based on your own DNA?
SPEAKER_02Uh would I I don't think I have one, uh have any in the world, but would I I wouldn't feel strange. I would be really fascinated. Like I really want to look at it.
SPEAKER_01Just look at it.
SPEAKER_02And yeah, I mean just you know I'd be interested. Yeah, I would.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I'd be fascinating. I'd also be a bit flattered, you know, if a scientist told me that they wanted to take my cells and like made it make it into the immortal gene. What if I put it in the robot? Yeah, and then like send it all over the world and be like, Me? Well, okay.
SPEAKER_01So is there research asking people how they feel about this, or is it just a presupposition that because it's the brain?
SPEAKER_02I don't understand the question. So it was a study where you we we asked people how they feel about it.
SPEAKER_01Yes. And the majority of people feel like there's a special something about it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. You know, uh people may have heard of the Gila cell line, the Henrietta Lacks cell line. And it's fascinating because her family still talks about that cell line as if it had some meaningful connection to their loved one. They'll say, you know, our grandmother has been to space. Our grandmother has been in labs all over the world. She has helped, you know, um develop a vaccine for polio, which is all true. But they're saying, she, she was part of that. And um, and that's even like that's not even a uh a neural cell, it's it's a lump of um uh cervical, cervical cancerous tumor cells that are just growing like crazy.
SPEAKER_02So normally people don't like identify with your tumor cells, right? Uh probably more so with like heart cells and you know, uh, yeah, like I said, the brain. Um that way of thinking outside of the scientific community is is prevalent. People do think that there's this connection to it. Yeah, when you talk to um donor families for like, let's say the autism studies, um, a lot of them want to know like, so you just told us that this is really valuable, it's kind of unlocking a lot of information about our child, who in a lot of cases these are for like undiagnosable neurological disorders, or just trying to figure out what is going on here.
SPEAKER_02So you just told us about all the relevant biological connections to them. What are you gonna do with them after that you're done? Like, how are you gonna dispose of them? It's really kind of an interesting question, right? Like, are you gonna treat it respectfully? Um, it's not it, it it shows me that there's again like great importance that maybe scientists like overlook because they're just so familiar with this stuff, it's kind of routine. For the person just hearing about this for their first time and kind of framing it in their own ways of understanding the world and their loved ones, it's um it's quite remarkable that um other people may not think that that's something that you have to talk about.
SPEAKER_02Um, but clearly from the donors that they have these questions that the IRB or other you know groups wouldn't have necessarily thought should be a talking point. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It kind of sounds like um, is is there a TV series called like Black Friday or like the the Netflix horror series? Black Mirror? Black Mirror, thank you, thank you. Friday, the scariest thing I can think of. Big content consumer, this one. Massive. I feel like it could be an episode of Black Mirror where um I I think there was an episode where you could order a replication of a loved one who'd passed away um to try to help you deal with the grieving process. I wonder if we would get to a point where you could get like a little a little organoid of a loved one and you just like feed it or take we're gonna teach people how to because you feed your cells.
SPEAKER_02Well, well. I'll do one one better than that. Because what one of the things I didn't talk about, because we because you asked me what are organoids, and I told you about organoids, I told you about assembly, which are pretty crude. There's actually uh embryo models you can make with stem cells. So so what you do is it's not just doesn't just make a brain organoid or a heart or it does the whole model, the whole embryo. Both pre-implantation stage and we think post-implantation stage.
SPEAKER_01But we haven't tested it in a worm.
SPEAKER_02No, and so the guidelines that I helped draft internationally say you can't transfer any human embryo models into a human or non-human uterus. But I think we have to revisit that language because now there are teams that will make these embryo models. So, again, you know, the idea of like taking cells from you, reprogram, programming them into IPS cells, you put them together and they self-organize. All these things are just incredible. They self-organize, they know what to do into what look like pre-implantation stage fertility clinic embryos. Those are what are called blastocysts, these are what they call blastoids, they look a lot like that.
SPEAKER_02Are they able to make a baby? Well, you make mouse blastoids from mouse cells, transplant them uh in a uterus, and it kind of starts triggering a pregnancy response, but they don't go very far. And there's some scientific reasons I'm not gonna get into like technical reasons for why they think developmentally they don't go so far as about erasing parental imprinting. But anyway, um uh it it's it's incredible work. So you were saying, what if you know someone were to kind of like someone passed away and you've um in principle, not I'm not saying that this is what anybody should do, but in principle, the technology is there where your loved one has passed away, you take a little bit of skin, any biospecimen of the living cells, send it to the lab, they make IPS cells, and then they can make not one, but countless, as many as you want, embryo models that are genetically identical to that person.
SPEAKER_02Now, this to me brings up the idea of human cloning, where originally the idea of cloning was you take an unfertilized egg, you take out the nucleus and you put it in the nucleus of a somatic cell. That's how they cloned all eat a sheep, it's how they clone cats and other animals today. But the thing about that is you have different mitochondria because you have the mitochondria from the donor egg. So it's not a true clone of the original. And in fact, having different mitochondria um might affect development in uh in interesting ways. This case is everything's the same. It's all the same mitochondria, it's everything it's the same.
SPEAKER_01I think a Schneid 2.0.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. So you can create embryo models and then you can have a friend, and you can store them.
SPEAKER_01Oh, wait, you know what it was?
SPEAKER_02And you can you can store them, yeah. Yeah. Here's another wild one. So other things that you can do in stem cell biology, this is the the thing I I find fascinating about stem cell biology is that it kind of makes human cells and human biomaterial, quote unquote, plastic, which means you can mold it into other things, you can do things with it, you can build things with it. Okay, because you transfer the cells back to an original cell type, a blank sleigh called a pluriplet stem cell, and then you drive it down and make it do other things. So you can build a lot of things with that same DNA.
SPEAKER_01You can replace your own heart.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, you know, one of the dreams of uh this research is to have personalized regenerative medicine. Right. Um but but one of the things that's really interesting is not only uh can you make stem cells make organoids and brain cells and all that, but you can also, in principle, create uh functional gametes, sperm or eggs. So they've done this with mice. You take skin off the tail of a mouse, you can reprogram into IPS cells. They're able to make functional sperm and eggs, but to do that last step, you have to make what are called primordial germ cells, germ cells that are almost finished.
SPEAKER_02But you put them into the testes of a mouse to do the final stages of development, ovaries of a mouse to do the final stages of egg development. You can't really do that with human because you you can't get FDA approval to put something that experimental in someone's testes or ovaries to do the last step. That's why people want to make the testicular or ovarian organoids. If you make organoids, maybe you can seed them with the primordial germ cells that you can create. So, so anyway, if if if you can make lab-grown sperm or eggs, okay, here's the crazy experiment. Here's a crazy, okay.
SPEAKER_02So we know in mouse studies you can like cross-breed, you can do all kinds of really interesting cross strains for research. This would be all done in a dish. Again, I'm not telling anybody you should do this. I'm just pointing out this is possible. You can make um sperm or you can make an embryo model, and then um from that, you know, get pluripotent stem cells because embryo models also start, it's interesting. They kind of make stem cells. And it's a little weird. Like, what do you call these? Are they embryonic stem cells? But then this isn't really an embryo.
SPEAKER_02What are it? There's some of the classification issues that come up. But okay, so here's here, let me walk you through. You get uh embryo model that's completely genetically identical to a particular person. You get a male one, you get a female one, you make gametes from the stem cells from that embryo model, and then you put them together, you make another. This wouldn't be an embryo model, this would be an actual embryo. And then you keep doing that, and and you can combine the sperm and eggs from all these without ever having it grow up into a person, and you do the your cross um strains that way, a human.
SPEAKER_02So you can't do the experiment where you actually raise babies, wait until like like mice breed them together, but you can do it all in a dish. You can have multiple generations. Now that would be really interesting scientifically because you can kind of do the human studies the way you would do. Well, you could already do that right now with with cloning, you know, you you can it wouldn't be your your child, it would be your twin. So you would give birth if you're an identical twin.
SPEAKER_01Finally. James a friend.
SPEAKER_03Do you really want your Chine 2.0 to be James's friend?
SPEAKER_01No, I think. Yeah, excellent.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. That's that's fascinating. So you could ha you could like simulate, you know, thousands of years of or millions of years of like human evolution in like just one petri dish.
SPEAKER_02You're you're only going from you know making the germ, and by the way, the promordial germ cells they appear very early in the embryo models. It's real and they just pump them out. So it's a fascinating thing of not only you know creating an embryo model to study development, but it's an unlimited source for promordial germ cells, which then you can hopefully mature in vitro, and then you just start combining them. Um I need to point out because a lot of people, I as a responsible bioethicist, I should actually be saying, like, well, what's the point of making embryo models? I don't want to just scare everybody and just sensationalize it because certainly that's possible, but you really have to ground in like what's the point of it.
SPEAKER_02So let me just give you an example of how significant this work could be. So you can make an embryo model that represents a pre-implantation embryo. This is the stage right before you put it in, you know, into the womb for fertility treatment. The vast majority of drugs that women take while they're pregnant have no data on safety for the embryo. So you make embryo models, you can make them all identical from the same cell line. So you have total control over your your your your population of embryo models, and you can put the drugs that people take and examine what's going on.
SPEAKER_02But that's incredible. That alone is pretty amazing to be able to do that kind of research for for just healthier babies in pregnancy, and you're not creating a real embryo. The other thing I I should also qualify is all the embryo models I'm talking about don't seem to have full developmental potential. There's always something missing. So I don't mean to say that like they are equal to a fertility clinic embryo. The biologists are very clear there are certain cell types we're not aware that we're not familiar with, like it has these other weird cells in it. The spatial organization is not quite right. So none of them will be able to create a baby if you transplant them.
SPEAKER_02That could change in the future with more animal work, and that's an interesting way to think about this. But right now, there's no potential.
SPEAKER_01So you could significantly reduce the amount of research burden on uh like fertility clinic embryo and egg donation. Um because because I'm thinking if you just took one embryo and then you compared it to seven and just tested it to be like, okay, is it having the same outcome for this drug? Then you could continue to use those seven uh lab-bane ones for a bunch of tests. Yeah. That's amazing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and you can generate as many as you want. Now, I worked with a team in Michigan, the state of Michigan in the United States, uh and I told them that when you make because they can make hundreds of these things, okay? I said, when you make any of them, make sure you always leave out some important component for development. Like don't make them, don't ever try to make it a complete model. You don't need to for your research question anyway. You know, if you want to study the engine of a car, why would you make a model that also has wheels? Like, you know, just don't complete it. And the reason for that is the state of Michigan has said ever since Dolly, the shapeless clone, that's a crime, criminal offense to do human cloning.
SPEAKER_02And we have to then worry about this count as human cloning. And it would if it was developmentally competent. Because it doesn't matter how you create the clone, whether it's nuclear transfer or this other method. If it could create a baby that's a genetic identical genetically identical to the original donor, that is technically a clone. And the fact that I was just mentioned earlier, the embryo models are truer clone than the nuclear transfer was because of the mitochondria. In fact, the word clone is a Greek word that means twig, and it comes from horticulture.
SPEAKER_02When you take like a geranium little twig and you can propagate it, that's where uh the term clone comes from. So technically a clone is kind of like this embryo model. It would be something that you take from your skin and you can then create another being from it.
SPEAKER_01Do you think that a lot of the resistance to the concept of cloning is coming from the genuine safety concerns? Like we don't know what the quality of life of this person will be, or do you think it's the ick factor?
SPEAKER_02Oh, okay, okay. So I can answer that. Um so yeah, so a lot of my early work was oddly enough in this area of cloning, and it came up through sort of like the technique of um research cloning for stem cell research. But in any case, let me answer that question in a in a couple of ways. Um, it's highly dangerous to try to do reproductive cloning for any animal. So you've heard that, oh you know, they've cloned uh horses, they've cloned pigs, they've cloned all the time. Oh yeah, yeah. They've cloned lots of like they actually, this is a big business in Texas.
SPEAKER_02You take your prize bowls or your prize animals and you clone them. People have tried to do this with racehorses too, like really, really big prize prize things. Yeah, and then there's also dog cloning for people who lose a beloved dog. Tom Brady has cloned his dog and Barbara Streisand has cloned her dog. Now, the thing I want to say about animal cloning, pet cloning or anything like that, it's what we know from developmental biology, what we know from the people that I work with, is there's no such thing as a healthy clone. The one that's born is the least abnormal.
SPEAKER_02It's the least abnormal, but there's always something wrong. Why? Because the repro the reprogramming process of the egg for the DNA is not perfect. The cell that you put in could have and most likely will have mutations. The cell is just especially older animals, older humans, you're gonna have lots of mutation burning. We don't know what what you're transferring in there, how the quality of that, and you won't really know till you know, further on. So it's very dangerous. It's like Russian relay, it's very dangerous for those reasons of the imperfect brew programming, and then the so biologically it's it's dangerous.
SPEAKER_02Um lots of miscarriage, lots of you know, uh, things wrong with the with the animals that that are born. So the ones that make it to adulthood are the least abnormal. Now it's interesting if you if you breed a male and female clone, if you breed them together, their sexually produced offspring are fine. That's really interesting. Yeah. Yeah. So I would say, like, you know, gen one is not great, but number two could be could be okay. Yeah, or gen zero, I'm not sure how how you account that, but yeah.
SPEAKER_03It's something about the sexual reproduction that can be. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02So what happens is it resets all the all the uh methylation, all the stuff that's that doesn't get um completely reset in the first in the first attempt.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_02So it's so for humans, humans would be very unsafe in terms of you're probably not gonna have a have a healthy baby. The other, you were mentioning the psychological issues. Ick factor. Oh sorry, yeah. Well, the ick factor, I I think people might get over that if if it actually did work and you had healthy children, because there was a lot of ick factor around IVF. A lot of people were like, oh, that's so unnatural. They used to call them test you babies. And then as soon as real babies that were healthy were being born, everyone kind of dropped that and they just gravitated toward I want, you know, I want one.
SPEAKER_01There should be t-shirts now, like test you.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Capitalism should get in there.
SPEAKER_02Well, wouldn't it be surprised if there are this big thing? It has in the US. Yeah, IVF is very unregulated.
SPEAKER_01It's like, all right, here's your family t-shirts.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. So so the ick factor, um, yeah, I mean, you that's a that's also present in human reproductive cloning, but I think a lot of people also worry about identity issues, psychological well-being of the you know, of the clone. It's interesting because back in the day when people were debating this, someone said, Oh, you know, clones were all identical. It wouldn't be an individual. And I said, Are you kidding me? Whoever if there were ever a baby that was born through clone, it would be the most unusual human in all human history. It would be like the most special human being if you knew about that person.
SPEAKER_02So don't tell me that what's wrong about it is you lose individuality. That would be like amazing in all of human history of all the people who've ever lived. Like you are the asexually reproduced human.
SPEAKER_03Counterpoint. Child actors often turn out to be like, you know, uh mentally Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02I I I'm so I'm not tying this to the to the mental well-being. I I'm tying it to the objection that it's bad for the child because the child doesn't have a unique identity. Yeah. Um now that unique identity, as I was thinking of it, uh it could also lead to psychological damage and everything. So I I you know, it's it's it's complicated. But I think that the the psychological damage is actually coming from misunderstanding of what the technology can actually achieve. Like people maybe expecting you to reproduce not only the genetics of the original donor, but just like their personality and their the the the the talents and what made them unique.
SPEAKER_02They were hoping to Xerox the individual, right? But we know that that won't work.
SPEAKER_01Not even twins are that a lot.
SPEAKER_02Oh, that's a really good point. Yeah, yeah. So identical twins. Yeah. I mean, they were even in this the same mitochondria in the same uterine environment, often treated in similar ways environmentally, and they're still uh different. It was it was interesting. Um there was this whole committee in bioethics looking at the cloning issue during President Clinton's uh administration. And the person at the head of the whole thing, his name is Harold Shapiro, he used to be the president of Princeton. He was the head of this whole thing about task force about human cloning, and he's an identical twin. He has an identical twin. I said, How did you feel sitting there hearing all these arguments about genetic identity and you know how important that is when in your own experience you know the truth?
SPEAKER_02And he said, It was kind of amusing to hear people's misconceptions about genetic determinism.
SPEAKER_01It sort of seems like a lot of the issues with brain organoids, cloning, um, stem cell replication, etc., comes down to some form of genetic essentialism, which is this uh either presumption, not necessarily an argument, that uh genetics are exceptional or special just but simply because they have DNA. But I think for when you sit there and think about it and you actually ask yourself why? Why is the DNA the most important thing?
SPEAKER_01Why is that why does that thing make it more special than everything else? I'm not so sure that the answers are are are so clear.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I I there's a version of that that's called genetic determinism. So like everything about your genes determines everything that you'll be and it'll totally accomplish, right? Yeah, so I I mean, you know, and and I think here's a very simple thought experiment for the everyday person to do. Okay, so imagine someone have in mind someone that you really love, that you're in uh a relationship with, and that person unfortunately passes away. Imagine a doctor coming up to you and saying, I don't know why you're so sad, I don't know why you're grieving. We can clone that person and bring that person back. Would you think that you are actually going to be able to bring that person back?
SPEAKER_02There's no way, right? Because what made that person special to you were the things you went through together, you know, all their experiences they went through. It's that wasn't just like their genetics. So that's why it's just so, I think, off-target to talk about, you know, the risk, the moral objections to human cloning is something about, you know, reproducing identity. Because like just do that simple flax for it. You know you're not getting that person back. There was a really beautiful essay written by the former president of the Hastings Center for Bioethics, Tom Murray. And very unfortunately, during the whole cloning debate, his daughter in college was murdered.
SPEAKER_02And he wrote this like really moving essay. It was called Um, Even If Cloning Worked, It Wouldn't Bring Her Back. So, yeah, so that's that's where I kind of got decided. Like, yes, yes, look, realistically, this is like think it through. Don't be worried about that issue. Think be more worried about safety, be more worried about more attractable issues that are probably realistic and not this fantasy about you know reproducing people and everything about them.
SPEAKER_01So for now, we don't need to worry about cloning people and cloning babies and making an army of giant clones and brains and vats. But what is exciting, I think, one area that we haven't quite touched on, but I do think is super exciting, is the way that these um brain organoids can really contribute to the gap in pediatric research uh research for child uh developmental disorders because they're such a small pool of children with rare genetic conditions, and it's so difficult to subject them to so much research that you know we have a massive gap.
SPEAKER_01And um, but now you can get people who have had those genetic conditions as as adults and they can consent and provide full and valid consent to have basically their whole childhood just regrown in a jar. Um, and I I'm really excited about that, like the therapeutic potential of this, not necessarily the reproductive potential.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, that's that's a really good point. I wish that more often people thought about the opportunities to actually not have to use pediatric samples and kind of you the example you gave is why can't you just wait till they're old enough to give consent? Um so a couple of things. One is like people just um maybe it's a condition for which uh all throughout their lifespan they lack decision-making capacity. Because that's true for a lot of neurological conditions. So it's unfortunately you kind of never get to the point where the person can give consent.
SPEAKER_01Or if the child possibly majority.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly. Yeah, so so often um for neurological disorders for children, you genetic base, usually for the majority of them, they're fatal. Yeah, that's quite unfortunate. So that's where there's some desperation about finding out what's going on. Like use all the tools in your toolkit. There's X factor, yes, but as I said earlier, you have to balance it against like what is the benefit? You can't just look at the bad. Everything has a good and a bad. You can't just look at the bad. Even if you're making weekend plans, you got pros and cons. Who would only look at the cons? You gotta also look at the pros.
SPEAKER_02Um, so everything's got pros and cons.
SPEAKER_03So don't worry about brains and bats, but worry about doctors stealing your p.
SPEAKER_01And maybe James will finally have a friend.
SPEAKER_03Oh well. Let's not get too optimistic about that. So that comes from the person who has admitted to going for karaoke with me. I'm gonna put that many times.
SPEAKER_01But I'm I'm look, mate, I'm there for the vocals, not necessarily the the brain.
SPEAKER_02Maybe we can clone clone the vocal cords, you can get a vocal uh chord organoid.
SPEAKER_01I'm just imagining like a little brain that's like singing in the bat, and it's like doing a little dance moves. My brain's living is like a bowl of boba and it's just like driving to the music, like all the vibrations.
SPEAKER_02You can take it around. Uh you can actually preserve it in like a little keychain so you can carry around your your friend. A little tomato cheese.
SPEAKER_01You can literally wear your friends.
SPEAKER_03Jewelry.
SPEAKER_01Okay, I think that is all the time we have for today. This has been such a fascinating pod. I feel like I've learned a lot. Um, a little bit grossed out, also pretty excited.
SPEAKER_03It's been so interesting.
SPEAKER_01Let us know where we can get James a friend, and we'll uh see you round.
SPEAKER_02Well, welcome to my world. Thanks. It was fun.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and U and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail In this episode, guest-host Kat Muyskens and Sinead chat with Dr. Johannes Kniess from Newcastle University (UK) about what governments are legitimately allowed to make us do, whether we like it or not....