Send us Fan Mail In this episode, guest-host Kat Muyskens and Sinead chat with Dr. Johannes Kniess from Newcastle University (UK) about what governments are legitimately allowed to make us do, whether we like it or not. Using case studies of tobacco restrictions and vaping bans, Johannes discusses how governments must grapple with their duties to let us live our lives the way we see fit, but also their duties to protect us from harms such as poor health. When can governments override our life plans, and can Gen Z fight back? Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, C BME and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_03Welcome, welcome, welcome to episode four of our season three, CBM Me and New, a podcast about bioethics. And today we have guest host, Kat Myskins. Welcome back to Kat. Here to chat with Dr. Johann's niece. Is that how we say it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's fine.
SPEAKER_03I'm amazing. James, step aside. Uh, senior lecturer from Newcastle University, the UK, not Australia, as we've chatted to before. We're gonna talk to him about what our governments are legitimately allowed to make us do, particularly in the context of health, whether we like it or not, and whether or not Singapore can fairly deny people access to vaping. And maybe that that is just a little catchphrase to sneak you into the pod. Welcome, Johans.
SPEAKER_01Thanks very much. Great to be here.
SPEAKER_03So we have a couple of introductory questions to get to know you. Our first one, coffee or coffee or none at all. And why, if not, does that make you a bad person?
SPEAKER_01So uh I don't really drink coffee and I haven't tried coffee, so weak. So based on absolutely nothing other than I guess a willingness to play to the home crowd, uh I'd say coffee.
SPEAKER_03If worse to pick, we will pick coffee. Okay, okay, so just a follow-up question about that. Have you just never had coffee?
SPEAKER_01I think I've tried it maybe once or twice, and I I feel it's too late, too late to get into the coffee game now.
SPEAKER_03Look, it's not too late. We will have you if you would like to start drinking. Is it like you just don't like the flavour?
SPEAKER_01I don't really remember the flavour, if if I'm honest. So I'm missing out. I guess I guess I haven't needed it.
SPEAKER_04Or maybe maybe I have and think of all the papers you could have written if you were more caffeinated.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Wow.
SPEAKER_01It's a terrifying thought. I prefer not to um not to think about it yet.
SPEAKER_03When was the last time you tried it?
SPEAKER_01I don't know. It must have been 12 or so.
SPEAKER_04Well, 12 is really too young, right? Like you're you're not gonna like it at that age.
SPEAKER_03Like kids don't even like pumpkin when they're 12. Maybe you're just well known. Maybe you're wrong. Straight up facts. So so one more question about that. If we took you out for coffee while you're here, would you try it? Or are you just like no? You're just gone down the ideological dogmatic route.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I guess I'm gonna be dogmatic about this now. I think I have to.
SPEAKER_03Have we been back to this movie?
SPEAKER_04We haven't been very good PR people for coffee.
SPEAKER_03No, my approaches tend to like bully them, which is not really actually working out well for me. Yeah, okay. It's okay. I'll be just as dogmatic too. Next question: where do you want to travel to next?
SPEAKER_01Uh so I'm going to Indonesia in a couple of weeks to travel a bit in Java. And yeah, really excited, really looking forward to.
SPEAKER_04Java is like the home of coffee.
SPEAKER_01It is, yeah, you're right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04You should really try it. You can try the poop coffee.
SPEAKER_01Oh, what's that?
SPEAKER_04Luak coffee.
SPEAKER_01Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_04It's coffee that has been fed to a civet cat and uh then pooped out. Okay. And then fermented, I think. Sounds delicious.
SPEAKER_03It is. I've had it. It's wonderful. It's the most expensive type of coffee. It is. Is it?
SPEAKER_01Oh wow, okay.
SPEAKER_03I have not tried it. Um, I'm still a bit weirded out by the the word poop. Alright, we'll get there. Why? I have no idea. Awesome. So, what are you doing in Java?
SPEAKER_01Uh, traveling a bit and hiking up some volcanoes and seeing some temples, and yeah, just just a holiday, I guess.
SPEAKER_03Oh, how lovely. Very nice for you. But our f my favorite and final question, and then we're done for the podcast. This is a good one. You all for what you're here for. Uh, what song would you sing at karaoke?
SPEAKER_01Well, I'm not a I mean, I'm not a big karaoke guy, but I guess I guess I would do a dread, something like Islands in the Stream. So from you know, Dolly Parton and Kenny Rogers.
SPEAKER_03I do know Dolly Parton and Kenny Rogers. What's the song?
SPEAKER_01Islands in the Stream.
SPEAKER_03How's it go? We'll have to look it up.
SPEAKER_01Islands in the Stream. Ah, I shouldn't sing on this. That was a terrible idea.
SPEAKER_03Terrible idea. Oh, you know, when I had that, you say it like that. I clearly actually got it.
SPEAKER_04I remember it. I did. Really? I do know that song.
SPEAKER_03Yes. Okay. We will have to see that. Yes, I'll pick that one. Okay, and you'll obviously do the jelly pot and pot.
SPEAKER_01Of course.
SPEAKER_04All right. All right. So uh let's get down to the more meaty questions. I'll start us off with uh something kind of big picture. What is healthism and why is it bad? Isn't it true that people generally want to be healthy?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so healthism is, I guess, a pejorative term, a type of accusation that somebody might um make against health promotion strategies, uh, if they want to say that they go too far. So I I first encountered this term in a book by a Czech writer called Peter Scrabenek, who um had fled the uh when the Soviet Union invaded Czechoslovakia, he had gone to the West. And he saw in the West a tendency to overvalue health and to sort of push health on people. That reminded him of the totalitarianism in the Eastern Bloc.
SPEAKER_01And he thought this goes too far. And if people want to have unhealthy lifestyles, then let them. And uh it's not really the role of the government to change people, to sort of impose preferences on them. And so the idea of healthism, I guess, essentially is that we're overvaluing health. So there's many different goods, many different values, and um, there might be a tendency uh by governments or by the medical establishment to think that health is always the highest good. And maybe it's not. And so I guess the problem with that is that we have certain, I guess, liberal commitments to freedom and autonomy, and a certain type of neutrality on the side of the state about the different ways in which people might choose to live their lives.
SPEAKER_01Now, I should say uh personally, uh uh I don't agree with the healthism objection in many cases. So I uh I'm actually sympathetic to many of the public health policies that are accused of being healthist. But I do think that it's an important worry that we have to take seriously, that we have to address.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, okay. So I I'll I'll say a little bit more about that, because uh I've I'm a little bit familiar with uh like Eastern European history as well. I did my undergraduate degree in Russian of all things, never used it again. Um but yeah, I can see how fascist governments have promoted like this idea of the ideal citizen as something, uh as a healthy body for the for the nation. And maybe there's a sense that you owe it to the nation somehow to be healthy. So um could you maybe say a little bit more about that?
SPEAKER_04Like uh why is what differentiates that kind of negative or oppressive uh influence of healthism from what you would think of as acceptable?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I suppose the difference, if if you're sympathetic to this worry, is that health should be a personal desire or something that that you want, as opposed to something that you owe to others or that's imposed to you uh from above by by the government or by the state. Now, um, you said in your first question, uh, doesn't everybody want to be healthy? And I think that's a good question. I I think that's probably on some level that's true. Uh I think we're we'd be hard-pressed to find someone who doesn't want to be healthy. But people want different things and they want them to different degrees.
SPEAKER_01And so being healthy might um there might be trade-offs with other goods or values that you might have. So somebody who, let's say, likes to go binge drinking or likes to eat delicious but really unhealthy food, um, they might put these other goods, comfort or or pleasure or whatever it is, above being healthy. And so um uh if the government tried to uh change their ways, then it looks like they would be trying to overturn their preferences, the way they have decided they want to live their lives.
SPEAKER_01And I guess that's the that's the uh the core of the problem.
SPEAKER_03So can you give us a couple of examples? You're talking about trying to change people's ways, um, and that might come from campaigns like advertisements on the side of bus shelters or just advertisements around the city in general. Or is are you talking something more about like incentives or penalties when people do not conform to certain uh health messages like vaccines or something?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it could be any of these. So I guess I'm talking very generally about health promotion campaigns. Uh, and that could be, for example, anti-smoking uh policies or policies designed to change people change people's diets or uh promote more active lifestyles. And I guess you have, I mean, I guess the goal is to get people to live more healthy lifestyles, but there's a lot of different means. So you can have information campaigns that are not coercive but simply inform people about or warn people about the risks of unhealthy lifestyles.
SPEAKER_01You can have incentives, you can have regulatory measures like taxation and so on, and you can have more coercive measures like bans. You can simply say this type of behavior is is is banned, or this uh product, for example, cigarettes, uh, we're we're just not gonna um allow the sale of this anymore. And so there's a range of interventions from um sort of more persuasion to more coercion, I guess. And um, but all of them, I suppose, are uh efforts to get people to adopt more healthy lifestyles.
SPEAKER_01And so in theory, all of them could give rise to this health is a worry.
SPEAKER_04Um I'd like to ask a little bit more about this. Because you said that you give this example of someone who might engage in binge drinking because they there's some other good that they might validly want to pursue there. Like say that's hangover is my favorite part. One of the best things. Um yeah, so there you're describing that in a way that makes it sound like it's a rational or reasonable choice. Um, but I think a lot of people make these decisions more out of ignorance or out of there isn't a better option available to them. So um can't health policies sometimes uh be a way to give someone a better option instead of um or to give them maybe um more information, like you said?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah. So I guess your question is, aren't people making a mistake when they're when they're um prioritizing other things other than their health? And I think the answer to that is sometimes, yes. So uh somebody might choose the the sort of binge drinking lifestyle because they're not adequately informed about the the health risks of alcohol, for example, or they might be um they might have certain cognitive biases or irrationalities, they might be discounting future risks in an irrational way, or or maybe they're just um they suffer from weakness of the will or something like that.
SPEAKER_01And their actual preferences, so what they actually would prefer is to be healthy, but they're choosing the wrong means to attain that end. And so in this case, it looks easier to justify um a campaign to sort of uh hey help that person um lead a more healthy lifestyle. However, I think it's also going to be true that at least some people make no mistake when they decide that for them other goals are more important. So um we can't imagine someone who's adequately informed and has all the sort of um cognitive capabilities to make an informed choice and says, well, this is the way I want to lead my life.
SPEAKER_01And if that means I'm shaving off a few years of my life expectancy, um, or that my risk for certain diseases, illnesses is is greater, then I accept that. And that's a trade-off I make. And I think here it's hard to say that this person is making a mistake. Um so I think there's a a reasonable range of different ways to lead your life and um different trade-offs that you can make between goods like health and and other things. Uh and so I guess we need a good answer of what uh as to why uh in this case we should nevertheless attempt to um um pursue a policy that that encourages uh a healthier lifestyle.
SPEAKER_03But we might uh the government and I think quite a few philosophers or or scholars point out that health, your health doesn't just affect you. And yes, it is true that uh there are many goods in life that you are free to pursue, like health or accomplishments or relationships or clothing and and good skin. Um but at the same time, many of these decisions do not just affect you. Some affect others um in unequal levels. And health is one of those things. And we see that time and time again when it comes to pandemics, when it comes to the limited resources we have available in the healthcare systems and in public healthcare systems where the government is paying for these things.
SPEAKER_03Do you think that there is a response to be made here that sure, you are free to value things other than health, but insofar as you are using state resources to pursue those lives or to pursue those different goods, we are able to try to influence uh you in a way that makes you cheaper to pay for, essentially. I don't know how else to phrase that.
SPEAKER_01No, that was perfectly phrased. Uh so I think uh this is a very popular argument by defenders of public health uh policies, um, a sort of third-party cost argument. And it has also, I guess, a sort of liberal um justification. So John Stuart Mill in On Liberty says that um uh I guess the only reason to interfere with someone's liberty or freedom is if they're if they're causing harms to others. And so you might make the argument that somebody's unhealthy lifestyle imposes costs on others uh through, for example, higher public health care costs.
SPEAKER_01So this is a very popular argument. I'm not entirely convinced that it works all of the time. So take smoking, for example. Uh it's actually, I think, quite a uh contested empirical question what the costs of smoking are. So of course, smokers generate healthcare costs, public healthcare costs. Um, but there's at least some uh studies that suggest that because they die earlier, they it all evens out.
SPEAKER_01They prevent certain, yeah, certain certain other public health care costs that they would uh that they would generate later on in their lives.
SPEAKER_04You know, those last few years of life tend to be very expensive. You know, because die younger, cheaper.
SPEAKER_01There's also public public pension payments and so on. So it's a complicated empirical question, uh, is what I'm trying to say. Now you might make the case, well, but of course, uh, whatever public health care costs are, um, you know, if we even if we put that to one side, by dying earlier, um this really affects the productivity in the economy. So if smokers have shorter lifespans or suffer from illnesses, disabilities, uh, that kind of saps the economic strength of a country. But I think this type of argument is, at least from a million perspective, uh, is too indirect to make because if we started to uh limit people's personal liberty when they are not optimally contributing to the economy or something like that, then I think we would be overreaching in in in you know, at least in on one interpretation of the harm principle.
SPEAKER_01So I'm not saying that this argument, the cost to others argument, is always wrong. But I think that it has limits. And so sometimes we need a better justification or or a or a better reason for why these public health campaigns are justified.
SPEAKER_03So do you think then that we can or governments can legitimately try to influence people to protect their health for the sake of their health?
SPEAKER_01Well, okay, so that that sounds um I mean if you if you express it at at that level of generality, then yes. But if if if what you're saying is um is this a paternalistic rationale? So are we making uh sure that people um are healthy because health is a objectively important good and it's better for you regardless of what you think, then I think that's probably the wrong way of putting it. So I guess my own view is that governments have an important responsibility or a duty of justice to uh protect and promote population health.
SPEAKER_01Um but that's primarily because they have an obligation to create social environments that um eliminate major health risks. And so um, of course, some people might have preferences that put other things above health. But when it comes to very important health risks, I think that um it's important to create social environments that don't encourage preferences that that uh heavily undermine people's lifetime expectations of health. So I think that's uh uh for me at least a more reasonable, a more a more plausible foundation for for these public health efforts.
SPEAKER_03So what you're saying then is okay, maybe we can't try to encourage people to value health for the sake of health, regardless of whether or not they feel about it. What you're saying is we shouldn't encourage the other way, which is to not value their health. So are you saying then the state should just be neutral? Like they shouldn't be commenting on people's health.
SPEAKER_01So I do think that the state should be neutral in the sense that it should not promote any one specific version of the good life. So I I I guess I am committed to neutrality in that sense. But I think that there are certain goods that are generically valuable. So whatever your life plan is, some things you will need.
SPEAKER_03Like being able to breathe.
SPEAKER_01Being able to breathe is one of them. And more generally, your health, um, you know, but also things like certain opportunities, rights, um, well uh wealth, income, and so on. So these are, I think, generically important. And so we I think we have to take care that people have at least a good level of these goods. And if we frame it that way, then I think we're avoiding this more perfectionist view that says health is the most important thing in your life. Um rather, it's simply about creating a social environment that makes sure that people have access to these generically important goods.
SPEAKER_01That's my view.
SPEAKER_04Okay. Okay. So like I see that what you're saying is you want policies to um like s enable people to pursue health, um, however they define it, however, they value it within like a set of other goods that they may value. Is that correct?
SPEAKER_01Yes, I think so, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um so I want to just do a shameless little plug here of my own work.
SPEAKER_03Hey, a man wouldn't be shameless.
SPEAKER_04Okay. That's as maybe. But um, so I wrote a paper with uh a colleague of ours, um Angus Dawson, recently about Confucian approaches to public health. And uh so I would just want to play like the Confucian devil's advocate to you here and ask you um, a Confucian might say, your framework that you're proposing still looks like it's trying to avoid saying something that's actually true, um, which is that some ways of living are better than others. And uh liberalism might just be too reluctant to make that judgment.
SPEAKER_04So what would you say in response to that?
SPEAKER_01Uh yeah, great. I read your paper and it's really, really helpful, and I learned a lot from it. So I guess I guess I would answer to that question yes. Uh I guess at least one view of liberalism, the one I suppose I subscribe to, is reluctant to make these judgments about the Git Life. Now, I don't doubt there's there's a lot to learn from Confucianism, as there is from any other sort of um uh world view, Christianity, Islam, whatever. But I think there's something valuable about uh having governments or the state justify at least coercive policies with reasons that anyone could accept.
SPEAKER_01And so um if you were to um ground a public health uh campaign or policy on confusion values, because you think that's that's the best way to live, or that's the that's the one path to flourishing, I think that wouldn't give a very convincing justification for people who don't subscribe to this view of the good life. And so I think we're on a safer, um, safer ground if we attempt to justify policies with reasons that uh any citizen, regardless of their comprehensive view of the of the good life, um can at least in principle accept.
SPEAKER_01So there is a type of restraint here about saying, yes, uh you know, this is good for you, uh, but I think it's justified in terms of the political legit legitimacy of the laws that we impose on one another.
SPEAKER_03So it it seems like if we take what the government is promoting in isolation and we look across the board and say, is it just fairly promoting multiple values or multiple versions of the possible good life, then that might be okay to also promote health. Like if they're also promoting education and I'm not I'm not sure, uh, holidays, for example, or or other ways of of um living a good life, then it that it's okay to to encourage people to value their health. But we can't take what the government's doing in isolation.
SPEAKER_03They are not the only regulators and operators and people who are sending messages in society. We have mass corporations, we have industries, we have everyone out there in capitalist societies trying to make as much money as they can to convince people to change their behavior in ways that increase spending. So if then we have all these other operators or uh people in the arena trying to encourage people to behave in certain Certain ways, then maybe we what we can do is think of that the government is therefore justified in pushing health even harder, particularly when we have so many other operators pushing people really hard the other way.
SPEAKER_03What uh do you think this might make a better sense?
SPEAKER_01Yes, no, I actually agree. It makes a lot of sense. No, I agree with that. So I think that um there is an obligation on on the part of the government to create a social environment that at least eliminates some of some of the biggest health risks. And if we had a society where, let's say, smoking was normalized because um big tobacco companies spend a lot of advertising uh advertising and uh encourage the formation of these preferences for for cigarettes, which I guess historically has been the case, then I do think that um there is a sort of um obligation uh to uh to uh intervene in this social environment uh so that you create at least uh a more level playing field, but uh more importantly that you sort of eliminate uh risks or health risks that would um lead to the um development of these preferences in the first place.
SPEAKER_01So it's uh it's actually a quite it's a complicated line that I'm pushing here. So I think that we do have to, on some level, respect people's preferences. And somebody might develop a um a preference for smoking and think that for me, smoking is more important than uh than being healthy and living a long life. So I do think that. But on the other hand, I also think that we can't just take that preference in isolation, and preferences are not formed in a vacuum. And so there is an obligation to intervene in social environments that encourage the formation of those preferences, especially when you have um maybe unjust influences.
SPEAKER_01And and that could be, for example, um big corporations exploiting people's vulnerabilities or something like that.
SPEAKER_03I love that idea of relational autonomy that comes from feminist literature, which talks exact exactly to what you're saying, which is that we do not form our values in vacuums, we form them from the get-go, uh, under the influence of our parents, of our friends, of our peers, of our religious and cultural norms, of the institutions that are trying to get us to do what they want us to do. And so just because someone thinks that smoking is what they want to do, when we actually look at the content of their preference, and we have to look at the content of their preference to go, why would you possibly want to do that?
SPEAKER_03Like, what are your reasons for wanting to do that? It's only when you judge their preferences that you can determine whether or not they're probably coming from unjust or exploitative circumstances, or if someone could have reasonably come up with that preference in their in their own right. And I think this speaks to what you're saying and about how we can sort of draw the line as to when it is okay. So things like binge drinking or smoking or really obvious, oppressively unhealthy behaviors that we wouldn't come up with on our own. The only reason we have them is because someone's trying to make money off us.
SPEAKER_03Whereas when there are other things that we could legitimately value that aren't great for us, which is like having the occasional wine. It's not, you know, there's not a lot of empirical evidence that having the occasional wine makes your life, your health bat worse off. Actually, there are some studies that say red wine's good for you. Chocolate. So um yeah, maybe Yes, absolutely.
SPEAKER_01No, I I fully agree with that. And um, I mean the glass of wine, that's that's a good point, because um, I guess what I'm not advocating is to um eliminate all health risks uh and to make people, you know, health health freaks. And I think that would go too far. Uh, but intervening so so as to eliminate major risks, um, and I mean I think I think you mentioned some of them, um, that I think is uh not just permissible, but in a way uh required by by by justice.
SPEAKER_03Aaron Powell But that also introduces a new empirical condition on what governments are justified in doing, because it has to be statistically or empirically beyond doubt proven that that health behavior is actually contributing to that health outcome.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a good point. And that's a criticism that a lot of um public health behavior change campaigns often get is that uh sometimes we don't understand the empirics of uh whether a behavior is actually unhealthy. Often it goes back and forth. I mean, you were saying these studies about uh whether a glass of wine is good for you or not. Yeah. It feels like every year that changes.
SPEAKER_04Health information is so maddening. That's actually another, this is a good segue to another question I have for you. Um because if you look at the health information landscape that we're in, you do get these really conflicting messages sometimes. Um, that red wine is good for you, any alcohol is bad for you, um, eggs are good for you, eggs are gonna kill you.
SPEAKER_03Oh, the egg debate is 24.
SPEAKER_04Um and so, like as a lay person, I also often feel like, how do I navigate this information landscape? Uh and sometimes I feel like maybe I would like a benevolent government to come and make it simpler for me.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So yeah, it's it's a tricky, it's a tricky question. So uh not only is the sort of epistemic basis of some of these behavior change interventions sometimes unclear, um, it's also sometimes unclear whether the measures used to change that behavior work or not. So whether, let's say, a sugar tax is gonna work or not, I mean, that will depend as well on the sort of empirical circumstances of the case. So there's a lot of open questions here. And of course, overall, the justifiability of any policy will depend on whether it's gonna work or not.
SPEAKER_01So um so some people take this as a reason to reject public health behavior change campaigns, but I think that goes too far because uh essentially any policy will um give rise to these questions. Uh, no policy is gonna be justified if we don't know if it's gonna work or not. Um, so um there are at least some behaviors that we know almost beyond doubt they are bad for you, like smoking, let's say. There are some probably where the the science is still a bit more uh unclear. Uh but nevertheless, um if you have a robust enough evidence basis, then I think um uh you you might be justified in in encouraging behavior change.
SPEAKER_03The sugar tax works on me in this country. It's it's just never on sale, it's always so expensive. I'm like, what's the point?
SPEAKER_04Well, here they also have the Nutrigrade thing, right? Um it judges you. And I can't bring myself to buy a D anymore. I feel too bad about it.
SPEAKER_01I yeah, I encountered this on my first day here in Singapore. I hadn't seen that before, and it completely changed my choice. You know, I I I never I never knew that this tea was going to be, you know, would have more sugar than the coke. And so it changed the the thing that I would have chosen. It was quite amazing how quickly that works.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, in Australia, we don't have the we have a star system, one, two, three, four, five stars. And I was actually looking at my Wheedy Bix this morning, which is a classic Australian breakfast. You wouldn't know because Newcastle University is we we have we we call it Wheatabix.
SPEAKER_01Weedy tabix.
SPEAKER_03Classic British, take something good and make it worse. And it had five stars on it, and I actually felt good about myself. I was like, I am an adult making healthy choices.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but this is another um thing that we could explore here. Uh, you mentioned information campaigns. So I want to just explore that a little bit because I've read some things that say um, I mean, that's not always empowering. So just giving people the calorie labels on their McDonald's order doesn't make them make better choices. It just sometimes makes them feel worse about their choices that were available to them. Whilst they still make the same choice. Well, they still make the same choice because it doesn't change the reasons for being there, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um so yeah, what what could you say about that?
SPEAKER_01Yes, you're right. I mean, again, uh there's I guess it's an empirical question whether the information, uh the information first approach works. And there's also some evidence that suggests that uh often it doesn't work to simply inform people. And when it works, it might uh work differently for different social groups. And so there's some evidence as well that suggests that um it tends to widen social inequalities in in health because often the more educated, the more middle class uh people um listen to the health advice or take in the information, and others don't.
SPEAKER_01And so that leads up increasing the gap uh in health outcomes, uh, which is something that we don't want. So um I'm not saying that the information approach always works, but I guess in some cases it might. Um and of course, I'm not saying that uh information is the only means to promote health. So uh I think that in some cases when uh information isn't enough, then uh we might be justified in pursuing uh more forceful means or um at least uh stronger incentives.
SPEAKER_03Well, on that, um, we know that New Zealand, to in my perspective, and I'm going out here saying this, did a wonderful job in banning tobacco for if you were, I think what was it, born after 1998 or 2000?
SPEAKER_01Do you know the I don't know the year exactly in New Zealand?
SPEAKER_03It was yeah, it was one of the younger generations.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Um and essentially the plan was you wouldn't be able to buy it if that was your birth year, and they would just continue like every new generation would just increasingly not be able to buy it to the point where no one could buy tobacco anymore. Um, I thought that was a fantastic idea. I I will go down on the books that smoking is very bad for you. Um I'm fine with that judgment. Other things, um, I'm gonna let you know, be weird about. But with this, then the new conservative government came in um and they undid, in my perspective, all the good work. They just pulled back the legislation and now anyone can buy tobacco again.
SPEAKER_03Obviously, you have to be over what the age is 18 or 21, the standard across most countries. Why should one generation be allowed to continue like access uh uh tobacco just simply by virtue of their age? Yeah. Whereas the younger gener generation was being essentially punished for the crimes of something they never did.
SPEAKER_01Good. Yeah, great.
SPEAKER_03They fought back.
SPEAKER_01So uh yeah, so tobacco control, I think, is a great example of this worry about healthism. And um, as you say, New Zealand tried to get this policy through um and the new government reversed it. So, yeah, as you say, the tobacco-free generation idea is something that the tobacco control community has been pushing for for a while. And the idea is that you um create a cutoff year, and everybody born after that year um will never be able to buy cigarettes legally. And so it didn't work in New Zealand, but in the UK where where I live, uh it they uh they have passed.
SPEAKER_01Not Australia. Which is not which is not in Australia, that's right. Um the previous government, the conservative government, introduced legislation, and the new government, the Labour government, has uh reintroduced it and it's ha it has gone through the House of Commons. I think it has now gone through the Lords as well. So it's it's probably gonna be implemented this year. And everybody born after 2009 will never be able to buy cigarettes in the UK. Now, um of course there are a lot of questions people might have about this policy.
SPEAKER_01Some of them are about the implementation and the enforcement of it. So is it gonna work? Is it gonna create a black market in cigarettes, for example? And I think these are all sort of practical questions that we have to address. And obviously, if it's the case that it's not gonna work, then maybe that's a reason not to do it. But on the normative level, so on the sort of ethical defensibility of the proposal, do I think it's justified? Um I think I think it might be. I think it is. And the reason is that um what's nice about the policy, I think, is that it um it allows people who have grown up uh in an environment where it was possible to smoke and have created their life plan um with the option to smoke, uh it doesn't affect their freedom directly to keep smoking.
SPEAKER_01So if you're a smoker, the policy doesn't affect you directly because you're gonna be able to keep buying cigarettes. But if you have never smoked before, so if you're a child who hasn't started to smoke, then that option uh is simply with uh withheld from you as opposed to withdrawn. And that seems more justifiable because you haven't already um created your life plan in a way that assumed that cigarettes were gonna be available. And so that's an important difference. And I think for the people who haven't started smoking, for the age cohort, for the birth cohorts who who haven't uh begun smoking, the question that we have to ask is this if cigarettes were invented today, if if it was a new product that we invented, uh should we allow it onto the market?
SPEAKER_01And then we have to weigh the health risks of this product against its benefits. So I don't want to say that smoking has no benefits. People derive pleasure from it. It might be nice it might have a social function and so on. But the health risks are so significant that I think in my view, they very clearly outweigh whatever benefits smoking has. So I mean, cigarettes are quite a unique product. They're they're the only legal consumer product, well, currently legal consumer product that kill uh half of its users when used as intended.
SPEAKER_01So if you think about it that way, uh it'd be it'd be crazy to allow a product like this onto the market. And so the question for me is um uh should uh or to people in birth cohorts uh that haven't begun smoking and people in the future, could they have a reasonable complaint against growing up in a social environment or smoking and this considerable health risk was normalized? And I think probably the answer is yes, they could have a reasonable complaint. And for that reason, I think something like the tobacco-free generation policy can be justified.
SPEAKER_03So if the government is justified in taking certain life plans off the table, how far can that go? Can they just be like, yoink, you can't go snowboarding? And if you pose that same question about alcohol, like if alcohol was invented today, should it go on the market?
SPEAKER_01No, it's a really good question. And I mean, I don't have an answer to the to the alcohol question. It's it's a lot more complicated, I think. For one thing, because um, well, this is contested, but at lost at least some people think that there there are levels of consumption that are uh at least don't pose a huge health risk. Uh some people say there is no safe level, and that again kind of goes back and forth. But um in any case, I think alcohol has other functions in society that are probably more important than whatever functions smoking has.
SPEAKER_03So it is Friday evening.
SPEAKER_01It is a social lubricant. It is uh something that's quite ingrained in into our culture, at least in in the West. And and so I think you do have to weigh the health risks of the product or behavior against whatever values you would undermine by taking it away. And so um it's a hard question, actually. I I don't know about alcohol. And I think also that the justifiability of um discouraging alcohol consumption, I mean, discouraging it, I think that's probably uh justified, but banning it, the justifiability of that would also depend on whether there are alternatives that fulfill similar functions.
SPEAKER_01So if we invented a sort of similar drink to alcohol that served a similar purpose, and I think people are working on this as well. Yes, exactly. Then probably the the idea of banning alcohol is gonna become more uh it's gonna be on the table if that happens. So um that's not a very clear answer to your question. But uh I I guess I guess you have to weigh in a way the the values that you would undermine by eliminating a health risk.
SPEAKER_01And by the way, uh I don't think that um, you know, it just you know uh I don't I don't think the point of government is to maximize people's health. So when you said, you know, are we gonna ban snowboarding or something like that? I th I think really it's about eliminating significant health risks, uh especially health risks that are not uh outweighed by other considerations that might be more important.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I had another question for you. Um since we've talked about um certain things being uh you're okay with certain coercive measures or certain kinds of uh public health campaigns that might put pressure on people to adopt certain healthy behaviors or or resist certain unhealthy behaviors. Um and we've talked about healthism, but I want to talk about like the moralization of health. So um I think we can agree that a society that prioritizes health to the exclusion of other goods is a little warped. But what about the moralization of health behaviors?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Uh because some public health campaigns do seem to come with that, where there's like a lot of judgment attached to people who smoke or drink too much, right? Or or people who eat too much, um, things like that. So uh what could you say about that?
SPEAKER_01That's a really good question. And I think this is about the means of the of behavior change. Uh so is it justified to use, for example, stigma or moralization as a public health tool? And then there's there is a debate about this in the literature, um, especially around smoking, uh, where I think probably some governments have have gone that way and attempted to stigmatize uh uh smokers so as to get them to change their ways. I think it's a it's a very difficult line actually to tread because um on the one hand, we do want to change probably social norms.
SPEAKER_01Um I guess the term is denormalization of smoking, for example. Um and part of that is, for example, um having counter advertising campaigns or um you know plain packaging, that kind of thing, um, or elimin eliminating um smoking in in uh in the movies or or TV or whatever. But you could go further and you could say uh, you know, smokers are uh smokers are disgusting, they stink, and that and that kind of messaging, which sometimes happens.
SPEAKER_01Uh I mean obviously the risks here are that um that you're not just alienating people, but you're marginalizing a group of people. And especially when certain behaviors are clustered in certain socioeconomic groups, that also raises questions of social justice. So it's a very difficult line to take. Uh I mean, I think you'd have to be very careful to um to sort of uh use stigma as a tool. And I I guess you want to eliminate or you want to avoid a sort of moralizing discourse that makes this about personal failure when people uh don't change their behavior.
SPEAKER_01And rather I think you want to put the emphasis on the responsibilities of government to create environments that that don't expose people to significant health risks. So I would say it's um it's preferable to focus on um, I don't know, the regulation of of corporate actors such as tobacco companies, as opposed to um focusing on the individual and how they choose to live lead their lives.
SPEAKER_03So to be true to the introduction, uh, which is to discuss a wee bit of vaping, in case you've been living under a rock since you got to Singapore, you've probably seen the signs around uh my my personal favorite that pops up in my HDB at the elevator is final destination. I keep thinking it's an advertisement for a movie. Yeah, I keep thinking it's another but it's actually talking about um vaping, final destination. Is it hospital or death?
SPEAKER_04It doesn't matter. It's a real one or the other.
SPEAKER_03It's a um interesting combination of cinematic wording and uh health messaging. But then there are there are other ones that get sent around, which is the one of their father who lost his 18-year-old to vaping, allegedly. Um, and then there's all the other penalties that we face. So as a um as a uh person on a visa in this country, if I get caught with a vape three times, I get kicked out and have to return. Then there's also like fines, prison, etc.
SPEAKER_03So this is what you were talking about, which is when we take health messaging and we attribute it to the individual rather than regulating the industries around it. And the reason that Singapore can't do that is because they've already banned it. So they've already they've already banned the selling of these goods. You you can only get them via illegal means, but people still do it. There is still a problem. And so now the government is coming for the individuals who do it in a surprisingly cinematic way. Yes. So how does this sort of fit the policies that you have in mind where they've already banned it and now it's still a problem?
SPEAKER_03And you know, uh there's also questions about the empirical evidence of vaping or e-cigarettes, etc.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Yeah, great. That's a great question. And when you told me you were gonna ask me about the vaping ban in Singapore, I went and looked at the government's justification for it. So let me first say about whether the ban itself might be justified and then about the means to to pursue it. So um I think Singapore is one of 30 or so countries in the world that has banned vaping, but it's probably one of the countries with the better enforcement capabilities and sort of more robust measures to uh to enforce that ban. And uh the justification, I thought this was really interesting, was the following.
SPEAKER_01Smoking already exists in Singapore, and uh it's sort of entrenched in people's habits and their and their ways of living. Um but vaping is new and it's a new product. Uh and so we can eliminate this option before it has even sort of had a chance to establish itself in in the society. Uh and of course, if you uh if you frame me, this this is exactly the same justification that I gave for the tobacco free generation.
SPEAKER_01Proposal, so it's more justifiable to withhold an option that hasn't existed before, so in the case of cigarettes, for future people who haven't begun, you know, haven't formed their preferences for cigarettes, than it is to withdraw it from existing smokers. And so the logic of the argument is exactly the same. And so I do think there's this sort of sound general justification for for the for the ban, assuming, of course, that vapes are uh very important or very grave health risks.
SPEAKER_01Um but I think it gets more complicated, and that's because um because of the relationship between um smoking and vaping. So uh there's a there's a life debate in the public health community about whether vapes are a good uh smoking cessation device. So uh some people believe, not everyone, but a lot of people believe that um for existing smokers, uh, vapes are a great way to stop smoking because you know it's it's a different and presumably more uh healthy way to consume nicotine.
SPEAKER_01And and for a lot of smokers it has worked. So they can they can sort of uh wean themselves of the of the smoking habit through through vaping. Uh now I say presumably because we don't fully know the health risks of vaping. And so this again is an empirical question that uh you know I can't assess myself personally, but uh from what I understand, the health risks of vaping are uh not as great as the risks of smoking. It's not great for you, obviously, and we don't have the long-term studies that really show what's going to happen to vape, you know, vapors in 50 years.
SPEAKER_01But it's safe to assume, probably, that that vaping is better for you than smoking. But there is a risk, of course, that people who haven't been smoking start a vaping habit. And we can see that with kids everywhere in the world, in the UK for sure, maybe here as well, that uh children who haven't started to smoke are vaping. And so they're exposing themselves to a health risk that uh, you know, maybe they they they shouldn't be exposed to. Uh, and so there's a bit of a trade-off here between the vapes as a smoking cessation tool and the risk of creating a new sort of generation of uh of people addicted to nicotine who might then possibly uh go into cigarettes as well after after they develop a vaping habit.
SPEAKER_01So that's that's a complication. And then there's another complication, another twist to this, and that is that uh if you're interested in something like the tobacco-free generation proposal, the smoke-free generation idea, uh, and as I said, I think it's a it's a it's a good idea, then uh the availability of uh vapes is gonna probably make um this smoke-free generation proposal more justifiable. And that's because if you're gonna take away cigarettes uh from people, um it's easy to justify that if there's a very close analog to smoking, another way that's very similar of consuming nicotine, and that's vaping.
SPEAKER_01And so if you're gonna pursue the smoke-free generation, it's easy to justify to people if you allow vaping. And in fact, the the the UK legislation, the tobacco and vapes bill, it's gonna um phase out smoking for future birth cohorts, but vaping is still gonna be allowed. I mean, we're gonna crack down on flavors and and sort of uh you know things that encourage children to start vaping. But nevertheless, uh it's it's gonna be legal to buy vapes. So you have these kind of trade-offs here, which make it very complicated.
SPEAKER_01Um, so I guess my answer to is vape, you know, is a vaping ban justified is maybe, yeah. I mean, it depends on on these circumstances, some of which are just empirical questions. And then you have the further question. Sorry, this is a very long-winded answer, but uh you have the further question of what means are permissible. If you think that the vaping ban is a is permissible from a from a sort of ethical standpoint, then what means can you use to enforce it? And and you said that um in Singapore, it's not just the uh the sellers of e-cigarettes that face these penalties, it's also the users.
SPEAKER_01Now, personally, I think that with all addictive substances, it's better to attach the penalties to to the sellers as opposed to the users. Um, I guess from a sort of harm reduction perspective. So um what if that's not enough? What if that doesn't get people to stop smok uh to stop vaping? Well, I don't know. That's a difficult question to answer, but I th I think it's probably preferable uh not to um not to attach penalties directly to to consumers.
SPEAKER_03I think it's well established that if you want to reduce undesirable health addictive health behaviors like drug use, alcohol use, it's better to use a uh supportive rehabilitative approach than a uh punitive approach. Um that's why, like in uh we used to have drug court in Queensland, uh back home in Australia, where instead of trying to just punish drug users and send them to prison where it might essentially just get worse, uh, they would be sent to rehabilitative services and it was treated as a health issue rather than a uh a criminal issue.
SPEAKER_03Um unfortunately that got defunded, obviously, under the next government, et cetera. Um, but yeah, I I completely agree with you. Punishments should sit with those who exploit these addictive behaviors rather than those who fall prey to these addictive behaviors.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, another thing I wanted to respond to about what you said is the um the point about like efficacy of the policy, right? Like, so what if it still doesn't work? Um because you've you've highlighted that in a couple of your answers earlier as well, about uh like it depends on if the policy works. If we find out that the policy works, then we should keep doing it or um something like that. But obviously that's not the only consideration, right? Because you could have a I mean, Singapore also has really strong penalties for drug behavior or uh drug selling, things like that. And uh so even that, even as severe as it is here, it's not um 100% effective.
SPEAKER_04There still does happen to be um some drug use. Um but you could imagine a society that just says instant death penalty every time you vape. You know, you will we will find you and we'll kill you. Maybe that would be really effective, but would it be ethical? Would it be justified?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_04Um so it's always a trade-off between those values, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes, absolutely. Yeah. And I think, I mean, yeah, when we think about the means of behavior change, as I was saying before, probably there's a spectrum between resuation and coercion. And I mean, there's some complications here, but probably the the more you move to the cursive side, the the stronger the justification has to be. And if uh you have to move to very cursive means, death penalty for everyone who takes uh then probably it's not worth it.
SPEAKER_01Um and then probably you just have to say, well, in principle, we would be justified in attempting to change this behavior uh to encourage a more healthy lifestyle. But um the the the practical costs are so great, or the sort of um the other moral consideration, people's dignity and so on, uh outweighs whatever gain we would have here in terms of in terms of the promotion of health. And so, yeah, we can't be health absolutists in this regard. Um and um yeah, so I think I think I think obviously the the means matter.
SPEAKER_01And also a lot of this will depend on the again, on the empirical circumstances of the country in question. And I think even like a policy like uh to go back to the tobacco, the tobacco-free generation, the the um smoke, smoking and in uh tobacco and vape spill in the UK, I mean, one reason that is probably more justified to try in the UK is that smoking rates are, at least on a sort of uh in a European comparison, relatively low. Um so if you had a much more a society where smoking was a lot more established, then doing this would be probably harder to justify.
SPEAKER_01Um and the the costs, the other moral costs in pursuing this type of policy, would be greater. And again, in Singapore, circumstances are very different from uh the UK, let's say, or other countries in the West. And so uh the permissibility of certain public health campaigns here will also depend on um local norms, expectations, and so on. And and so what what can be pursued here, maybe a anti-vaping law, wouldn't wouldn't be permissible in in the UK.
SPEAKER_01So it will all depend on a lot of a lot of moral considerations.
SPEAKER_03So what you're saying is governments need to pick their battles.
SPEAKER_01I guess so.
SPEAKER_03You cannot fight uh poor health on all fronts.
SPEAKER_01But I guess so, yes.
SPEAKER_03That is all the time uh we have today. This has been both fun and interesting. Um, and pew pew. Yeah, if you have one takeaway. Thank you so much for having me.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, thank you very much. Yeah, this is great.
SPEAKER_04Great, thanks.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and you and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...