Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

C B m E & U

C B m E & U artwork

Can Nihilism Improve Your Mental Wellbeing?

Nov 2, 202645 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named Jonas judges you for using non-natural deodorant. Dr. Christine Tan has a different suggestion. Drawing on her research in Daoist and Buddhist philosophies, she makes arguments in favour of Nihilism: the view that life need not have an overarching purpose or narrative. Remember people, be savvy!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01The center presents a new podcast, C BME and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.

SPEAKER_02Welcome back to CB Me and You, a podcast about biomedical ethics. Today we talk about the question that people ask me when they find out I'm a philosopher.

SPEAKER_04Why?

SPEAKER_02Because it's about the meaning of life. Wow. You joining into the intro now. I'm shocked.

SPEAKER_04Gotta shake things up somehow.

SPEAKER_02Well, now I've lost my okay. But also, what is the meaning of life in connection with Taoism? Well-being and mental health? And whether I should go to Bali for a wellness retreat with a bunch of white people with jet loss.

SPEAKER_04Absolutely. No further questions. The podcast is done.

SPEAKER_02You know, I've heard they'll like play whale sounds and all that while you just, I don't know, relax and meditate. Yeah. Sounds nice.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, actually.

SPEAKER_02Anyway, I'm just waiting for a life crisis to happen and I'll get there.

SPEAKER_04You mean you're waiting?

SPEAKER_02I am turning a little bit older very soon. Anyway, joining us for today's pod is Dr. Christine Tan, lecturer at the NUS College here at the National University of Singapore. Welcome, Christine.

SPEAKER_00Thank you. Thank you for having me.

SPEAKER_04Our absolute pleasure. Thank you for being patient with us as we take double time to get through that intro. We have a couple of questions to get to know you a little bit better. Our first question, my absolute favorite, tread lightly. Coffee or copy?

SPEAKER_00Well, actually, it depends on the time of day and the weather. But because I do love both. My husband makes the best coffee, like you know, uh with the French press and everything. But, you know, sometimes you need that copy hit. There are times when you do need that copy hit, I think. So I like both.

SPEAKER_02So I'm hearing I like coffee, but I need coffee.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I can need and like both, yes.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's true.

SPEAKER_04Okay, all right. I'll let it I'll let it pass. Next question. Uh, what country do you want to travel to next?

SPEAKER_00Are we talking about realistic or like pipe dreams?

SPEAKER_04What are we lost?

SPEAKER_00Like we could do a little bit of um well, realistic. I would like to go to Sucho and Hangzhou, maybe next. Um, there's a saying in Chinese like shang yo, tien, uh, uh Sucho and Hangzhou. And it means like above there's heaven, and below we have Suchou and Hangzhou because like the landscapes are really pretty. So I would like to go there sometime soon. Pipe Dream is somewhere in Latin America because I haven't been.

SPEAKER_00And as a Filipino, we are the uh we are often referred to as the Latinos of Asia. So I would like to reconvene with some of my brethren in Latin America in the in you know, sometime.

SPEAKER_02It's like, oh, we're called the same thing.

SPEAKER_00So we're we're we're we are um uh maybe talk about you know how the Spanish colonized us, share a lot of common ground.

SPEAKER_04Next question. What's your go-to karaoke song?

SPEAKER_00Ooh, uh do I have a go my way.

SPEAKER_02Oh, very classic. I think that's my dad's favorite song, too.

SPEAKER_00It's a very classic Filipino karaoke go-to. How does it go?

SPEAKER_02I did it my way. Oh yeah.

SPEAKER_04Okay, excellent. That is actually a really good song. I've been thinking we should start adding some more classics to our karaoke.

SPEAKER_02We should, we should. Uh yeah. Although I have heard this story, there's this, I don't know if you've heard this one. This is urban legend that goes around that, you know, people sing my way and then get killed.

SPEAKER_00I heard of it!

SPEAKER_03Have you heard of it?

SPEAKER_00I think that is a coincidence because my like everybody sings my way. So, you know, whenever somebody gets killed, like, you know, correlation doesn't mean causation.

SPEAKER_02It's a numbers game.

SPEAKER_04Do you remember when there was that um question going around, like, if you're ever in a car accident and does your music just sort of keep playing? Um, and then there was this uh video that went round of this guy and he's like he's like distressed, he looks a little bit red. You realize he's upside down in the car, and he goes, Have you ever wondered if the if the car keeps playing music when you get into an accident? He goes, I can't confirm it does. And then he like films it's like actually. It's just like some rock and roll song.

SPEAKER_02Okay, so uh Christine, what does meaning of life or in life refer to and how have you connected it to well-being and mental health more generally?

SPEAKER_00Well, uh, when we talk about meaning of an in-life, we we talk about it in three senses. So there's coherence, purpose, and significance. So we want our lives to matter, significance, we want our lives to have some kind of direction, purpose, and we want things in our lives to hang together and cohere in some sense. So it's really in these three senses that I mean when I say, well, most people mean when they say meaning of or in life.

SPEAKER_00And I relate it to, well, it's uh it's related to well-being most of the time by psychologists, because they think that if we think that our lives are meaningful, then it's it actually increases our well-being. And more specifically, if we can narrate our lives and have ownership of that narration as a story, you know, the story of my life, then actually that can increase well-being.

SPEAKER_00So that's the relationship between uh mental health discourse and meaning in life.

SPEAKER_02So when you say it has these three uh components of significance and purpose and coherence, does something need all three at the same time to count as something that gives us gives us meaning? For example, can I have something that gives me meaning that uh gives my life a sense of significance but is utterly incoherent? Uh would would that be uh be be meaningful in at least some sense, or it just doesn't count at all?

SPEAKER_00I think it could be meaningful in at least some sense. But when we talk about narrative therapy, for example, and specifically in uh psychology and therapy, it needs to have all three. So maybe the highest thing for you is significance, but that significance, if it's to be like actually meaning in your life, then it should also have coherence and purpose. Uh, it could be that the main thing for you is coherence, but that coherence should have some kind or several purposes and significance as well.

SPEAKER_00So they do all three need to be present if we're talking about narrative uh meaning in life.

SPEAKER_04So in Avatar the Last Airbender, yes, good reference when Zuko lets APA uh or releases APA, and for listeners, if you don't know what Avatar the Last Airbender is, please pause. Go watch three seasons. I think it's on Netflix at the moment, and then come back. Yeah, it's only life-changing, that's all. Uh basically, you know, he he's been chasing Aang and APA for ages, trying to hunt them down, and then he finally has this crisis moment with his uncle where he's like, No, I'm gonna do the right thing.

SPEAKER_04He releases ARPA instead of capturing him. Um, and then he falls sick. He gets like a fever for like what, a week, two weeks in Avatar time? I'm not sure. And so what you're saying, therefore, is he had significance and purpose, but no narrative. It was so spontaneous for him to do the right thing that it caused him to be mentally unwell.

SPEAKER_02Shockingly relevant example.

SPEAKER_04Thank you.

SPEAKER_00Because I haven't, I'm sorry to admit that I haven't seen it and I don't know the context. I'm not entirely sure. James would want to weigh in that that's what led him to being mentally unwell.

SPEAKER_04This is no longer a podcast about bioethics, it's about diagnosing mental health conditions in habitat and uh I mean I think if you look at the narrative, that makes sense.

SPEAKER_02That's what happens. Uh so um I just want to dig into the idea of coherence a little bit more, right? Um Does it require a sense of an overarching life story, or can things be coherent in a more localized, more simple way? You know, like can something be coherent just because it it ties together like an activity that I really like with an activity that I find at least fulfilling in some sense, and it, you know, as long as it ties a few elements elements of my life together, or minimally as long as it's coherent with a bunch of things, could that uh count towards being coherent, or does it really have to be a kind of like a big arc, character arc into my entire life?

SPEAKER_00That's a good question because when we usually when we talk about meaning in life, we usually conflate meaning with a lot of other different senses of meaning. And that's one sense, right? Like meaning in my the meaning of my suffering, for example, or the meaning of my grief, I can make sense of my grief, and that's something that is coherent, my makes my grief coherent, but that doesn't necessarily have something to do with the meaning and a meaning in my life or meaning of my life.

SPEAKER_00So it could there is, I'm not really talking about when I talk against coherence, I don't necessarily mean localized coherence. We can definitely make sense of our grief, and that's a good thing, but making that a part of your life story or making things as parts of your life stories, then that's the part where it becomes a little bit problematic, where that is the overarching coherence or coherent narrative of your life.

unknownAll right.

SPEAKER_02So I guess you've kind of like given us the uh the the teaser onto why uh we brought you here. Because you don't like, at least to my knowledge, you don't like some of this narrative about meaning of life and in life. Could you say a little bit more about why you think that's really problematic?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that that's problematic because uh it's what I call when we talk about meaning, even in life, because like when we when people talk about meaning of life, they mean this one thing that are the meanings of all our lives, right? But meaning in life is just what meaning means for you. But I think that's still problematic because that has this presumption of what I will call or what I would like to call the bounded life assumption. It assumes that our life is something that's bounded, meaning it has a beginning and end temporarily and spatially.

SPEAKER_00But life is not like that.

SPEAKER_02So are you about to tell us I can live forever?

SPEAKER_00Well, temporally, yes, but not spatially. Where your life ends doesn't necessarily mean that um it's where someone else's life begins. Like we are all co-rel correlated, right? We're all relational and we are all bounded together. So it's problematic when we assume that our lives are bounded. Because when you want to have meaning in life, it rests on that assumption. Because when you want meaning in life, it needs for your life to be coherent, purposive, and significant in a sense, you need to be able to tell what motive, what motivates your actions, what values guide your actions, what shapes your identity.

SPEAKER_00And these are things that, according to a lot of empirical studies, we don't do well. And we actually have we actually justify our actions in the same sense that a stranger would. So, or like someone looking from outside in would. So it comes a posteriore or after the fact that we actually say, Oh, I did that because of this. We rationalize it like that, but we it's not something that we think about before doing things.

SPEAKER_00We don't necessarily know why we do things and we confabulate a lot. So it's dishonest to be able to say, that's my life story, that's why I did these things, that these are my values and these are the reasons for why I do the things that I do.

SPEAKER_02Some people might say that's a good thing, though. Like it, you know, I think a lot of people would there's this thing called the paradox of hedonism. If you try to seek out happiness, you're not gonna get it. Uh and there might some people might reply, look, there's something similar going on here. If people try to to figure out what is the gonna be the most meaningful life and then pursue that, that they're definitely gonna miss it. But then, you know, that that's why there's a certain beauty in being able to look backwards and and confabulate and be tell a story. And sure, maybe the story is not quite accurate, but you know, if you can look back at your life and be like, oh yeah, that that's why it all comes together.

SPEAKER_02Some people might say that's a good thing rather than a problem.

SPEAKER_00Well, personally, yes, actually, uh, there are a lot of studies that do say that it helps our well-being, that it leads to more maturity about how we think about ourselves and actually gives us a sense of agency because you get owner, you take ownership and responsibility for your actions. But collectively, it also personalizes and individualizes a lot of systemic issues where the sources of our sufferings or problems are not actually seldom individual, but we trace it towards the individual when we confabulate, and that's when it becomes problematic.

SPEAKER_04So, what you're saying is we don't necessarily have meaning in our lives from the get-go. And potentially one of the problems in trying to find it in ourselves is the same s leads to the same sorts of problems where we start to see like suffering because we trace it back to ourselves rather than seeing it as part of a bigger picture. Yes. So what you're saying is there's a bigger picture. Yes.

SPEAKER_03Is there meaning?

SPEAKER_04Sorry. I digress. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So there is a bigger picture. Yes. Sorry. And it's these problems in mental health discourse are not it's not new that, you know, I'm not pointing it out from absolute nothing. There's a lot of research on these problems. Uh, probably one of the most famous and more accessible arguments is Ron Purser's McMindfulness, where he says that, you know, mindfulness practices individualize issues that are systemic and actually are a violence to the practice because you use it to then push people back or send people back to become even more productive and back to the conditions that actually made them unwell.

SPEAKER_00And there's also a lot of research on decolonial psychiatry. So there's this term black rage, for example, where uh, and it this was way back in the 1960s, where these researchers said that actually rage is something that is a rational reaction to the systemic issues and brutality that black people were facing, but it becomes pathologized and individualized and treated as something that they need to be medicated on instead of something that needs to be addressed systemically.

SPEAKER_00So, I mean, Franz Fanon also, like this huge guy in decolonial theory, was a psychiatrist in colonial Algeria, and in The Retro of the Earth, he talks about how colonial psychiatry um treats the rage and the grief that we feel as something that comes from the individual or is a source, the source is individual rather than systemic.

SPEAKER_00And this is something that needs to be addressed systemically as well, not just on the individual um level.

SPEAKER_04So going back then, so I think that makes a lot of sense that uh a lot of the problems that people experience or are told to individualize are something that they should not be told to individualize. They are outside problems, not inside problems. But then does that are we saying then that that goes back to the meaning in life? That meaning in life is also not an inside thing, it's an outside thing.

SPEAKER_00Um, I think that when we talk about meaning in life, even if you say that it can come from relationships or community, it's still ultimately something that needs control or agency within you. So it pushes back the control or agency or authorship towards the individual. And that's just not doable for most people, for many people. And again, it goes back to that purpose.

SPEAKER_00You know, you have to have this purpose that's coherent and significant where that's just not how life works.

SPEAKER_04Sounds a little bit like capitalism. Your life can only mean something if you've done really well and it makes sense to me.

SPEAKER_00Exactly.

SPEAKER_04Am I good at philosophy?

SPEAKER_02Nobody has ever drawn the connection between capitalism and colonialism before. Oh it's pretty brilliant. You should write a book about it. Okay, so imagine this case, right? Somebody gets swept up in some kind of movement, some kind of community movement that maybe uh opposes some of these kind of systemic issues that you've talked about. Uh they they don't it's not like they try to individually create a sense of agency which uh drove them towards these aims. But then at some point later in their life, they're reflecting and went and then and then they go.

SPEAKER_02Maybe they confabulate a little bit and like, oh yeah, this is like a really cool life arc trajectory that I had. It gives me a lot of meaning that I got swept up in this movement, uh, I contributed to this movement, I feel like I'm a part of something bigger, uh, and and I'm happier now going to my later years because of that. Yeah, or something like that. Um that that that sounds like a plausible thing that could happen, a plausible life story.

SPEAKER_04Enjoy it from experience. Your birthday is tomorrow, you are getting very old.

SPEAKER_02I'm getting very old, but it's not like I've contributed to the world in that way. Um so you know, so what's wrong with anything wrong with that?

SPEAKER_04James really wants to know. Asking for a friend.

SPEAKER_00Well, I don't think it's my position to judge. So, I mean, good for you, individual. Good for you, and I'm happy for for that hypothetical person that hypothetical person. Uh, I don't think that there's anything wrong with that. It's just that as a society, that's not something that we should be content with. Like that's not the end, that shouldn't be the end goal of what we want as a society for these individual people.

SPEAKER_04What do we want? Oh sorry. I am asking the big questions one more time, and you may have already answered this, but what do we want again?

SPEAKER_00When do we want to address yeah, we want to address systemic issues.

SPEAKER_04Okay, okay. But let's just in an ideal world where there are no systemic issues and everyone gets the you know, equal privilege or all the resources, one when would we then know that they had meaning in life?

SPEAKER_00I think that the question of meaning in life is something that culturally we have inflated. Or like it's not you don't need meaning in life to have a fulfilled life. And that's something that we often conflate. Yes, it individually it leads to higher well-being, but there might be more harms in our conversations and rhetoric on meaning in life than there are individual benefits.

SPEAKER_04Okay, so we swing the other way and we let go. There is no meaning in life. Do we descend into nihilism and group depression? Or is there something better waiting for us on the other side of letting go of that rhetoric?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that it is a valid concern, but I also think that culturally we have this this nihilism word is has functioned as kind of a bogeyman. For if you don't necessarily believe in kind of an overarching theme for your life or some overarching themes, then you're necessarily automatically a nihilist and nothing matters, right? And I don't think that that is necessarily that that's like an automatic effect or consequence.

SPEAKER_00There are many steps towards that. And in fact, being a nihilist is a commitment, is a theme itself. So it's not necessary that we become nihilists. We can find fulfillment in many things in our lives without necessarily believing in overarching themes or overarching meanings in our lives.

SPEAKER_04So it's like you can go from being religious to doesn't necessarily mean you're atheist. You could be agnostic. I guess hang out in the middle for a little bit. See how you lack it.

SPEAKER_02Trying out different meanings. So you made a distinction between stuff that you find fulfilling and stuff that is the meaning in life. Um can you say a little bit more about what you take to be this the distinction between fulfilling and meaning? Because I I think when I hear meaning, I'm I I I think, oh yeah, that's quite synonymous with fulfillment in some ways.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, so there is meaning in the sense of like those coherent significance and purpose, but there's also fulfillment in the sense of just uh, I guess, enjoyment or contentment, which is more really a very practical and psychological thing rather than something that is normative. So I think that's one distinction. And to give you an example, we see this a lot in Taoist and Buddhist practices where they don't believe in this singular, not singular will, this essential self.

SPEAKER_00And because for meaning in life, you have to have a self that actually strives for that meaning. But for Buddhists and Taoists, there's no self. So there's just responding to each situation, and that situation itself can cohere, can have its own purpose, can have its own relevance even, but it doesn't need to be part of the meaning of your life story or the meaning of you know your own narrative. And we can have that kind of fulfillment, or as we say, more like appropriateness, and it can be it can feel fitting, ra but even if it doesn't go into your life story.

SPEAKER_04So what I'm hearing is all the embarrassing things I've done in my life, I can just go, that's just not part of my bigger you can let them go.

SPEAKER_02She just gave you a life hack.

SPEAKER_04Damn, yeah.

SPEAKER_02And to bring back Avatar, the last Avender, you can be like Guru Lahima and let go of your earthly attachments.

SPEAKER_04And that worked out famously well.

SPEAKER_00There's a famous uh mirror the Buddhist metaphor of the mirror. This the Signal you see now is not the same one as the next second. So that embarrassing stuff is not the same you anymore.

SPEAKER_04Someone needs to be with me as I go to sleep tonight, and then as my brain feeds all the embarrassing moments, I can go, that's not you. Wow. It's a life-changing episode for me.

SPEAKER_02You have a lot to think about.

SPEAKER_04Or I could just not.

SPEAKER_02Or maybe or maybe you shouldn't think about it. Yeah. I'm interested in this idea of you know finding a kind of not just happiness or like basic contentment, but something that we would describe as fulfillment or uh a higher level of satisfaction, um, just based on realizing in in the kind of Buddhist or Taoist sense of I'm not sure how quite to describe it. Uh is it a combination of detachment from like your ego or no self?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, for the self in the sense of the self. Um what's the psychological evidence behind that? You know, is there uh like good psychological evidence that you know this can be lead to just as good a life, at least psychologically, as finding meaning?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, uh there are uh a good amount of psychological evidences, both in psychology as well as in the self-knowledge literature, that do show that, you know, it's not necessarily we don't necessarily need that meaning in life or narrative meaning in life. And other there are many other this is just one alternative, and there are many other alternatives to having a fulfilling life.

SPEAKER_00I mean, probably one of the most famous ones in philosophy is Galen Strawson's Against Narrativity, where he talks about people having or assuming that you have to be able to tell your life as if it's a story in order for it to be p fulfilling, but you can see it as some kind of episodes, but and that can be just as fulfilling.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I think that there's a nice way uh in which that combines with at least the kind of stories we see in pop culture, which I was originally gonna raise as a counterexample, but now I see it might be uh might support your point is that when we see stories in pop culture, they contain episodes in life. You know, we don't see a story of a whole life in a movie. We see, oh, the time this guy saved the universe or something, and then you know, maybe the superhero goes on to do something else, and then you know, it's like in a comic book series, there are all these little episodes, and each one could be quite meaningful in and of itself.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_04One of the things we you sort of mentioned at the start, we've got meaning in life, and we've got that's dis distinct from fulfillment or satisfaction, and that's also distinct um from the meaning of life. And so I assume uh bold of me, because you know, we did do our readings, that those are different things and that they are you are sort of arguing that there is maybe no such thing as meaning of life. Wow. So all it is is for up to each of us to just go about our day and see if we like it.

SPEAKER_00If you want, but I I wouldn't I wouldn't say so, but uh I guess if that's what you want, uh I'm also not going to judge you if you go about your day.

SPEAKER_04You do Uber.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, but I do think that it doesn't necessarily mean that, you know, whatever, each do our own, do whatever you want. At least if we look at the Taoist and Buddhist alternatives, it actually raises rather than diminishes responsibility because for the suffering that you see now, you can't defer that to the future or your later life story or whatever. This isn't about you, it's about the world, it's about responding to situations, it's about responding to the suffering that you see now.

SPEAKER_00And to me, that actually raises a lot of responsibility rather than diminish it.

SPEAKER_04So do you sort of sort of see like fulfillment and satisfaction as inherently uh mixed up, not mixed up, but uh inherently entwined with uh morality and ethics?

SPEAKER_00It could be. I think that there is and the the interesting thing is that in mental health or scores, usually there's something wrong with you if you're very, very disturbed by the suffering that's going on around the world. But we don't see it as something wrong with you if you you go about your day okay, knowing that there are suffering that's happening around you. And I think that there's something to that as well. It's outside my scope, but I think that there's something about something disturbing about about that kind of you know, focus that we have.

SPEAKER_02So this is an example in I think in the philosophy of the meaning of no of of well-being rather. Uh this pair of examples, you know, somebody who has a hard time going up, um, and then for whatever reason has a better time in there when when when they're older, you know, maybe because they worked hard or something. And the idea is that there's some narrative, right? Of like, you know, suffering at first and then everything becoming better. And you contrast this to the idea of like somebody who started off well and then and some bad things happened and then ended up uh a pauper or something like that.

SPEAKER_02Uh I think a lot of people have the intuition that you know the first one is better, uh, precisely because of the narrative stuff. But you're pushing back on that. So I'm just wondering uh what you think you know Taoism or Buddhism might say about these pair of cases. Would they agree that uh the first life looks better than the second life? Uh if so, how would they explain that? Or would they disagree with that intuition?

SPEAKER_00I think they would definitely disagree. And even with the question of which is better, like there's no way of telling which is better or not, by what measurement even do we value one life over another. And our intuition to narrativize these kinds of even if you find some way to make the second life better, maybe you can narrative it as, oh, in the end he learned the lesson of what it's like to be like other people, right?

SPEAKER_00Or what it's what it's like to live the life of a pauper, and that's a lesson that they learned. And I think that that's again going back to individualizing these problems when we narrativize our lives, because it's really more a systemic issue. Nobody should have that kind of traumatic childhood, I guess. And changing it so that, or narrativizing it so that it becomes a necessary part of your growth is a problem.

SPEAKER_00And there's a lot of conversation about this when it comes to trauma studies as well, right? When it comes to trauma, we have this tendency to narrativize our trauma and say, oh, it's because of that that I now grow as a or I've now grown as a person and I've become a better person. But is was that suffering really necessary for you to be able to learn those lessons? I'm not sure.

SPEAKER_04I I see this um happening in the way we've sort of changed discourse around like childhood bullying.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_04Like, you know, probably a lot of kids got bullied. And one of the things that you we sort of get told is, oh, you know, like you're more resilient now, like you learnt how to deal with bullies so that when you're an adult and a bully comes, you know, you you know how to deal with it. No, I didn't. You ride a lot. I hated going to school for a while, and it you know, it took me a little while to get over that sort of stuff. It didn't, it it didn't make me like more resilient. And you're right, there were probably easier ways to learn some of those lessons. And it's kind of I wonder if we sort of get this false idea from a very young age from being taught like those fables.

SPEAKER_04You know what the the hare and the and the the fox is it that race or the hare and the turtle? And it's like, you know, oh you learn that going slow is best, and you just gotta do your best to get to the end, and all makes sense in the end. It's like, well, who let's maybe if we step back and look out, why are a hare and a turtle racing each other and why do we care about the result? We should have just been like, wow, a hare, wow, a turtle, and then leave. But it's kind of like this idea that everything has to make sense. You know, you're you're so right. I I do sort of see how it's been sort of like pushed into my brain a lot.

SPEAKER_04Um I'm having quite a moment.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and those stories are, like I said, bounded. You know, they have a beginning and end. These characters are bounded and they have games and novels and stories. They are bounded, they have limits, but we actually don't as human beings.

SPEAKER_02I'm still having a bit of trouble stepping outside of this. You know, I'm gonna be honest, like, yeah, like I I see some of the arguments that, yeah, there's there's clearly a sense in which, you know, we do have a bias. Uh, and this does seem to be a fairly uh deep bias that yeah, I I need to make something of my life, uh, if not for the system, which we all know sucks. Uh we can uh moving beyond that, I need to make some uh something of my life maybe for the people I care about or something like that.

SPEAKER_02Uh and it's it's I'm finding it really difficult to to go from there and be like, all right, then what? But then but then I imagine you might say, well, the fact that you're asking then what in the first place is what goes against the.

SPEAKER_04If you rewind 20 minutes, the same thing happened to me.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, but I'm rejecting it still. Uh so I guess my the question at the uh here is something like this. Uh apart from, you know, maybe there's a select few who have uh uh achieved enlightenment or something, uh who don't need this, but is it is there evidence or are there reasons to believe that it's even psychologically possible for a large number of people to just uh give up on the search for some kind of narrative?

SPEAKER_00That's a good question. And I'm not personally I'm not sure either. It's just that I think it's still important to show that it is a function of, like you said, liberal society or neoliberal capitalist society to constantly ask us to narrativize our experiences. And, you know, individuals are really not to blame because one of the most self-interested things that an oppressed person can do is to buy into the system.

SPEAKER_00One of the most self-interested things, for example, that a woman can do is to play into misogynist tropes and you know, kind of game the system that way. Uh but you know, even if that is self-interested and benefits me personally, it doesn't mean that it's going to bring about social change. So it is harmful collectively, even if it is personally beneficial to each of us to continue to think of our lives as having meaning in certain senses.

SPEAKER_00But it is a function of neoliberal capitalist society to want us to think that way because you then you know individualize the systemic issues and say it's part of my growth, it's part of my narrative, it's part of my resilience story, etc. So I think that even though I might not necessarily have the solution for individuals, it still might be an important task to show that it is one of the functions of our society to do that, and it is a harmful function.

SPEAKER_04This kind of reminds me of this um really cool quote I read. I was over in uh JewChat the other day, and there was this really cool backup boutique store with a local artist who had done a bunch of um sort of, I guess, visual visual work on postcards, and then there was some like quotes or poems on the back that were really interesting. Um, and or or maybe it was like this frog and dog uh visual display, also at Do Tat Road. Excellent, you should go check it out. Basically, there was this one quote and it was like, uh, you know, like the frog talking to the dog, like, do you have time for this?

SPEAKER_04And then um the other one going, uh, I will always have time for this. You are what time is for. And I I had one of those moments where I was like, oh, like better philosophy than I'll ever do in my life. I should quit now. And it's sort of it was just such a nice, like refreshing, like pivotal change in how you sort of see time. Like you always think of things as, oh, I need to fit this in, I need to do this, this is uh, I've only got so much time. And then it's like, well, you are what time is for. It was such a cute little postcard, and I obviously bought it.

SPEAKER_04And now I'm wondering, did I just buy into more capitalism and buy more stuff telling me to find meaning in something when I should have just figured out for myself?

SPEAKER_02Just to go back to the uh the link between capitalism and the idea of meaning, um, I'm just guessing about history because I wasn't there, although Sinead will say that I was there. Uh it does seem like you know, questions about meaning do uh in some sense predate like capitalism. Um so I guess, you know, like we were telling stories about heroes and we've been telling stories about heroes and what the overarching narrative to their lives are for hundreds, if not thousands of years.

SPEAKER_02Uh so I'm wondering does this critique, the same kind of critique, apply to the ancient Babylon? Yeah, to like, you know, Homer and all that, since Odyssey, uh the Odyssey is gonna come out. Uh, you know, Homer was telling stories about this hero, these heroes and their lives. Uh, how does the critique that is that your critique seems to be railing to capitalism? Would the same kind of critique apply to to them?

SPEAKER_00Yes, and I think I'm I do history of philosophy, so you've just unlocked something in me. At the 40-minute mark, we're getting to it. Yes, this is the question.

SPEAKER_02And we can cut earlier things out.

SPEAKER_00So, way back then used to be the work of meaning in life, used to be done by the idea of a god or fates. So, meaning in your life was decided by a god or the fates, and you just get that. So, you you know, your meaning in life or the meaning of your life, the purpose of your life is something that you get from God. And then I'm gonna skip towards the that's a long way, but I'm gonna skip towards the enlightenment.

SPEAKER_00But after you know, many religions and then towards the enlightenment, that's when we started trying to be more secular, right? So during that time with Kant and Hegel, it went to reason. So you have Hegel saying the real is the rational, the rational is the real. So reason dictates what ought to be, what your where our purposes are, our essences are. So that's where meaning in life comes from. And you're right, that definitely predates capitalism, but it becomes co-opted with capitalism after maybe about existentialism or during about that time where meaning becomes your responsibility.

SPEAKER_00And that is just very good coincidence for neoliberal capitalism, where they take up this idea of democracy and capitalism being the perfect combination, and democracy needs individual agency in order for it to function. So this idea of individual agency and individual responsibility and individualizing meaning as your responsibility actually blends perfectly well with neoliberal capitalism.

SPEAKER_00So, yes, it predates it, but it also co-opts it into something that has become possibly even more sinister than it used to be.

SPEAKER_02So is that just coincidence that capitalism happened to come around at the same time when people were uh, I guess, leaving some of the metaphysical ideas behind, like fates giving just handing us our meaning in a little envelope or something like that? Uh or do you think there's a deeper connection between uh the idea that yeah, we're finding our own meaning in the universe uh and capitalism?

SPEAKER_00I think like with a lot of structural problems, there's no deliberate intention to do it. But because it works perfectly well and because it serves the interests of well, what we call, you know, the elite, right? Uh, because it serves that that interest, then it pro it propagates itself or they find ways. There are ways to propagate it for for that purpose.

SPEAKER_04So it's kind of like humans have always looked for meaning sort of in something else. Um whether it be one religion or another religion, or whether it be during the Enlightenment, they looked to reason itself, and then I I disagree. I think capitalism's been a long time coming. Uh it didn't just like pop out of the ground during the Enlightenment period. And I think we should definitely have a dance battle about who is correct, but back to that later. I will win.

SPEAKER_02Well, how do we commercialize this dance battle? How do we make money from it?

SPEAKER_04That's my question. So what you're sort of arguing for is probably something that is very antithetical to almost the entirety of human history, which is stop looking for things outside yourself for meaning by stop looking for meaning at all. Damn girl, get it.

SPEAKER_02So the question was, damn girl.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, like that's just like I don't know. That's fascinating. That is a massive amount of work to be done.

SPEAKER_00It is antithetical to and Taoist, there's a lot of uh Taoist ideas about this, where actually our nature is to find meaning, find value, makes make make things make sense, but it's uh to coat Chuangzi, it's the rut in which we are stuck in, and we just have to, which is why actually it grates me when people think that Taoist is so optimistic and it's you know like about fulfillment and being happy.

SPEAKER_00Actually, Zhuangzi was very much a pessimist, and he did think that, you know, we do have these tendencies, and it's a shame, but we have to fight against it.

SPEAKER_02I think it's a good place to wrap. Thank you very much. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_04That was so interesting. Thank you, and you know, good job. Oh, thank you. Get it, girl.

SPEAKER_01Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and you and be savvy.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Insurance Discrimination: Is it Fair? with Harisan Nasir

    Sep 24, 202649 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Genomic Newborn Screening: Where less really is sometimes more with Ainsley Newson

    Aug 25, 202655 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Hidden Side of Birth: Injury, Trauma, and PTSD with Angela Ballantyne

    Jul 2, 202648 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Brains in Jars with Insoo Hyun

    Jun 1, 202656 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. To smoke or to vape? With Johannes Kniess

    May 14, 202654 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In this episode, guest-host Kat Muyskens and Sinead chat with Dr. Johannes Kniess from Newcastle University (UK) about what governments are legitimately allowed to make us do, whether we like it or not....

    Credit the people on this episode