Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

C B m E & U

C B m E & U artwork

Insurance Discrimination: Is it Fair? with Harisan Nasir

Sep 24, 202649 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live longer). But what if you had to pay more because you like suntanning? Or because you spend too much time sitting in an office chair everyday? Where should insurance providers draw the line when it comes to creating individual risk profiles? Together with Research Asst. Prof. Harisan Unais Nasir, we discuss the ethical principles underlying differentiation and discrimination in insurance. Remember people, be savvy!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00The Center presents a new podcast, C BMENU, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.

SPEAKER_02Welcome back to CB Me and You, a podcast about insurance risk and how you can take charge of your financial future. Yeah, just kidding, we don't know anything about money. This is a podcast about biomedical ethics, but we are talking about insurance discrimination in healthcare. Joining us today is our very own Harassan Nasir, research assistant professor at our Center for Biomedical Ethics here at NUS. Welcome, Harrisan.

SPEAKER_01Thanks, James. That's a brilliant introduction. Um, you know no, we don't know much about money, which is why we don't have much of a We went into philosophy for the money.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_05But no one ever. Welcome, Harrisan. We're super happy to have you on the pod today. Have a couple of quick questions to get to know you. Coffee or copy?

SPEAKER_01Um, I would have to say copy. So my go-to order is the Kopyoko Song Ice.

SPEAKER_05Um the one you have next to your elbow. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Um, but more for economic reasons, because this is like very cheap. Um, I do like the taste of espresso-based coffee more, but it's really expensive here in Singapore.

SPEAKER_05Expensive. So expensive.

SPEAKER_02See, this is a podcast about your finances. By saving by ordering coffee, you can save up to four dollars every single day. Up to four dollars.

SPEAKER_05Vice versa, um, just so you know.

SPEAKER_02I'm a coffee snob.

SPEAKER_05Sorry.

SPEAKER_02People aren't allowed to offer anything but a flo uh get anything but a floor.

SPEAKER_05So this whole question is designed just to me to be able to like, you know, come down hard on our guest straight away. Get that power balance correct from the get go.

SPEAKER_01I'm not embarrassed about my um economically incentivized um choices. Um, I think we we do we do act in relation to incentives. Um and it's good to to talk about why we purchase things like insurance um based on incentives. Yuck.

SPEAKER_05Next question. What country do you want to travel to next?

SPEAKER_01Um so I actually I really hate traveling.

SPEAKER_05Um that would have been a great moment to get a visual steal of my places.

SPEAKER_02Um judging you more and more.

SPEAKER_01But I I'm I'm I'm heading to Beijing and Shanghai in September um with family. Um so I'm looking forward to that very much.

SPEAKER_05I'm just gonna move straight on because I didn't want to talk about that anymore. Next question. What's your go-to karaoke song?

SPEAKER_01Uh so this will be as bland an answer as my first answer, which is Mr. Bright's eye. Yeah, so coming out of my cage.

SPEAKER_05Because I want it all. Sorry, that was you have uh what's the word? You've made a comeback. I'm willing to engage in this podcast further now.

SPEAKER_02Well, why did you say that's a boring choice? This is a classic.

SPEAKER_05So I it's a white person song, I get it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, it is it is a white person song. You don't think it's a claim song?

SPEAKER_05Excellent point. I'll stop colonizing now, shut up and leave.

SPEAKER_01But I think you do have like a rich data set of responses. And you know, I'm a I'm a big follower of the podcast, and I do think that Mr. Bright Side comes out a lot.

SPEAKER_05So it's always yeah, I think so. Really? We've had some, we've had like some like we had a Chinese love song, we had a lot of older songs, the Sherelles, a lot of other songs I don't know. I this is the first time I'm like Really?

SPEAKER_02Okay, I feel like we would have had that reaction if Mr. Brightside came up before. Yeah, okay.

SPEAKER_05Apolog apologies, apologies. We're we're clearly very excited to have you on the pod now. Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_02Hmm. You've you've really turned Saints into the sea with these answers. Anyway, so to the main questions. So, what we're here to talk about today and what you've worked on is what you've called information discrimination. Uh, can you take us through what this is in the first place and how it happens?

SPEAKER_01So perhaps this is best explained through an example. So um, so James and I, we're about the same age. We we're both male, um, you know, we both live in Singapore.

SPEAKER_05I love where this is going. Please continue.

SPEAKER_01So imagine if we went to an insurer. But this is this is the boring part. I guess. Imagine we went to an insurer and we asked the self-insurer, hey, um, we both want to buy insurance. Um, how much would it cost us? Um, and insurance typically, in Singapore at least, um, they'll price you based on your risk. Um, and imagine if James and I had about the same risk, or even exactly the same risk. Let's stipulate that's exactly the same risk. We're gonna die on the exact same day. It's fated for us. Adorable.

SPEAKER_01Um but the interesting thing here that could happen is that my risk could be concentrated into in things that are expensive to identify. That is something like perhaps in today's um reality is something like perhaps a genetic sequencing panel. And for James, his risks are easier or cheaper to identify.

SPEAKER_05But he's very tall, so he's gonna die five years younger than everyone else.

SPEAKER_02You know, it could be anything. Um but if we're gonna go with that, sure. There are multiple things we could go with.

SPEAKER_05Please continue.

SPEAKER_01No, no. Um so yeah, it could be anything. Could be it could be that James has a particular family history, or maybe um there's something really obvious, um, something like that.

SPEAKER_02My daredevil lifestyle.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, maybe maybe he's a base jumper, he's maybe a well-known base jumper. And um, and the insurance is insurance are gonna look at this and go like, well, you know, we're gonna price James a little bit more. But for me, I get I get really lucky in the sense that even though I have the exact same risk factors, or like I have the exact same risk as James does in terms of drawing down on the insurance pool down the line, uh, my risks are hidden in things that are expensive to identify. So the insurer doesn't really bother in terms of gathering information from me.

SPEAKER_01Um so at the end, the result is that James will have a higher premium and I would have a lower premium, uh, despite the fact that we have the same risk. Um and that's the kind of discrimination that I'm trying to flesh out here in my paper. Um, and I call it information discrimination, uh, because it simply is about two people with the exact same risks, um, but one person happens to be lucky in that his risks are concentrated in factors that are harder to identify than the average person.

SPEAKER_05So we're not you're not talking about how if you and I went to the same uh insurance provider and because we have different risks, we would be treated differently, which is technically a form of discrimination because it's a or take it could be a form of discrimination. What you're talking about is when people have sort of like an objective same risk, even though like we don't actually know how we get there, and because it's too difficult to get one risk profile, they're getting treated better. And that's what you mean by discrimination.

SPEAKER_01Right. Um, that's exactly it. Um so the typical story that ethicists might have when they are speaking out against risk pricing and insurance is that we don't like risk pricing itself because um it discriminates against people with risks um that tracks perhaps some social injustices. Right. In my view, perhaps that's correct, but in my paper specifically, I'm actually quite um indifferent to that.

SPEAKER_01Um I show that information discrimination can arise um even if we have systems that um take into consideration whether people should be responsible for that risk. So what I call responsibility-sensitive systems. Um the point is that I think when it comes to discrimination, information discrimination, um, it is that pursuit of information is not equal across individuals. Now, there are good reasons perhaps to limit information gathering all sometimes.

SPEAKER_01Um, but I think we just need to be upfront about it and say when we are limiting information gathering. Um, as it is right now, uh, we don't. Um and the insurers are saying, look, risk is risk, and that's why we're gonna price you at this amount. But what they don't tell you is that, well, actually, not all risk is equal because we're not gonna spend so much money to find out certain kinds of risk. Uh, we're just gonna go with the ones that are cheap. And I think that's the problem.

SPEAKER_01All right.

SPEAKER_02So you said, well, there might be good reasons, right? Like we can't expect uh institutions or insurance companies to spend uh exorbitant amounts of money to figure out which ones, which kinds of risk factors or which profiles exist for a person. And I think it it's almost it's possibly impossible, it might defeat the purpose entirely of insurance if we decided we needed to figure out every person's individualized risk to the most fine-grained thing possible. So I guess when we use the word discrimination, are we signal necessarily signaling that something wrong is going on here?

SPEAKER_02Or what what are we doing when we use the word discrimination?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so treating people differently isn't automatically wrong. And I think we'd be in trouble if it were. Um, even in the case of insurance, right? It seems intuitively permissible to charge a base jumper more for life insurance than it is an academic or an accountant.

SPEAKER_05Some bias going on there, maybe.

SPEAKER_01But I would think that you know we we lead less risky lives. Um and and I think that's that's right. So treating people differently isn't automatically wrong. Um, but more to the case, I think what you're trying to say is that, well, sometimes discrimination can be permissible. Yeah, I have that view where there are good reasons to discriminate. Um, one really good example, I think, is this office right here, right? Like this university is funded by taxpayers, but we still discriminate in terms of who can enter the office and who is not allowed to enter the office.

SPEAKER_01That's why we have a staff pass to tap in, right? Um, and that's discrimination, right? But then there's a good reason to do that because we don't want our workplace to be disruptive and there's some utility gain uh from doing all this ethics, of course, for society. Um so we we deem that allegedly. Sorry?

SPEAKER_02That's what we tell people. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01We don't want them, we don't want anyone to be stealing all our ethics, right? Um we keep it uh locked in secure here. Uh but you know, it's it's there there are good reasons too, right? The safety of our workers or safety of the employees of NUS. Um and those reasons are, I think, good reasons to discriminate workers from non-workers from entering this building. Um so discrimination, for me, at least, um, just because something is discrimination doesn't make it all things considered impermissible.

SPEAKER_01I think that's the point. Um in this case, I in information discrimination, I do think that there are good reasons to um commit information discrimination, uh, but I do think that that sometimes it's it's it's uh it's not permissible. We can talk about that later, so I'm rambling.

SPEAKER_02Is is that all there is to discrimination? Like just pure differential differential differentiantial treatment.

SPEAKER_05One more time.

SPEAKER_02If a treatment. Uh you're saying anything, I mean, anytime we treat people differently, that's a form of discrimination. Is that a bit of an expansion of the concept? It does seem like you know, we wouldn't want to say that yeah, anytime somebody treats anybody differently, that's a form of discrimination. Like if if I if, for example, if I go out, you know, on a dating app and I just swipe right on some people and swipe left on some people, am I discriminating?

SPEAKER_05Yes. You are the worst. On behalf of all women, please get off the apps.

SPEAKER_02So there might be multiple reasons to want me off the apps.

SPEAKER_01So maybe there are good reasons why you just make it discrimination. Um but okay, so I so two things here first, right? Like, we don't want to inflate the term discrimination. Some people think that we don't want to inflate discrimination, but there are people who think like, well, whether it's discrimination or not, or discrimination or differentiation or not, um what matters really is that is this being done um permissibly? Like, is there a good reason to do this, right? Um I do think that discrimination has a group level valence to it.

SPEAKER_01So the way I see discrimination is that there is some group-level valence rather than a moral valence, I think. I think the the common interpretation is that discrimination has a moral valence and differentiation does not. I think that might be mistaken. I think discrimination has a group-level valence to it, or differentiation can be on the individual level. So that's just my thoughts. I don't know if I'm going too far with this. Um But you're right, there are some philosophical traditions that say that discrimination should the term discrimination should be reserved for only things that are morally wrong.

SPEAKER_01Clearly morally wrong. I think that's a very difficult task. Because then it narrows discrimination to situations where it's really, really clear that all things considered, it would be impermissible. I don't know if anybody has done such a rigorous analysis to say that um we do find things like racial discrimination in society. We think that that is impermissible, all things considered. But then there are a lot of other situations where it looks like racial discrimination or some form of discrimination, but there are really good reasons to do so.

SPEAKER_01Some things like affirmative action, for one example. In affirmative action, it's clear that it's some form of um discrimination that is group-based. But there are good reasons at the end of the day to do so. Um, and I want to point out to this book uh by Jonathan Kuipers. I think I'm I don't know if I'm pronouncing his last name right. Um, but he writes about how affirmative action in some cases um can be very helpful in nation building. Okay. Because you want people to feel as though your institutions are represented.

SPEAKER_01So you have affirmative action to get all perhaps ethnic groups or racial groups into the institutions, into the public institutions, so that you feel represented. Is that racial discrimination? Yeah, it is, but I would say that in some cases it's very permissible, in fact, required to prevent the kind of inter-ethnic, interracial conflicts that might appear.

SPEAKER_05I love the I love that example to show that um discrimination isn't inherently all things considered impermissible. What we're talking about with discrimination is is this differential treatment fair or not fair? Um then you can take into account many other ethical or like salient issues. So I understand that that discrimination doesn't inherently have to be bad. It doesn't have to be all things considered permissible. But what kinds of information are relevant to assessing um like people's health risk in insurance?

SPEAKER_05Is it what sort of information is it fair to include or fair to exclude?

SPEAKER_01Right. So I think there are at least three different views on this specific question of what sorts of information should be included or excluded when we think about distributing the burdens of healthcare, which is what we're thinking about when we're talking about insurance. Um the three important views. The first one is that no information is relevant. The first thing the first position that some people take is that some sort of universal coverage is the only ethically permissible uh option here. So no information at all um is relevant.

SPEAKER_01The second is the what I would call the responsibilist's view or the responsibilism view, um, which is that the only information that we should ever take into consideration is the kind of information um of which you could be held responsible for. And the last is what uh many people would call the actually fair view or actual fairness, and that's the view that most insurers hold. And that view says all information about risk is fair game, um, and any risk is fair game.

SPEAKER_01Um, and and that's just their view. Yeah, so this these are the three main views I would say. Um, and my paper finds that the second and third views are problematic, um, but I'm less interested in which specific information is fair game, uh, and more uh on whether they are actually applied consistently under whatever theories they are working under. Um so the ideal that risk is priced is supposed to live up to this idea that oh, risk is risk. Um if you're gonna price it, then price it all the way.

SPEAKER_01Um the unfairness of information discrimination is that you know certain types of risk is not priced in. Um and this, of course, goes similarly with the responsiblist view, um, which we might talk about later down the road, which is that if we come up with a system that says you should um be held responsible for um the risks of certain risks, um then the the worry is that there's this selectivity bias. Um we tend to pick on risks um that somehow attract social injustice a lot.

SPEAKER_01Um some people might point that to how people in power tend to be um really advantaged, um, and and that's why it's the kinds of risk that they point to is um attracts people with less power, perhaps.

SPEAKER_02Okay, so you so you mentioned these three views. It gives us a really nice format to explore the issues further. So I guess what I want to do is maybe we start with the first one, the idea that let's just give everybody the same amount of uh the same insurance premium, right? Uh could you just give us a couple of a very short spiel about why people might believe that? Because that clearly goes against uh current practices for the most part.

SPEAKER_01A, it goes against current practices here in Singapore and in the region. Um, but in in in other places it's completely consistent with their policies. So like in America, for instance, where you know, when it comes to healthcare in America, people always shun um their policies. But they're actually very progressive on this point, which is that insurance premiums over there don't fluctuate based on the kinds of risk that you have, um only for smoking. And that's only to a limit. Whereas in Singapore, for instance, we don't have such limits.

SPEAKER_01You insurers can price whatever they want, basically. Um, sure, there are regulations here and there, but all kinds of factors are fair game. One of the reasons why we believe in that view or why we want that view is that a lot of the risk that we have is is really hard to control and attract social injustices. Uh, I think one of the very good examples is um by Deborah Hellman from University of Virginia, um, and she writes about um women who are victims of domestic abuse, right? And of course, domestic abuse uh would increase your health risk.

SPEAKER_01It's it's it's an obvious reason why. It feels very off like it it feels very much beyond the pale to be using a person's status as a victim of domestic abuse and then increasing their premiums for it. Uh so that's why we think that okay, perhaps maybe none of this risk information should be used at all. Now, of course, the insurers will will push back and they will say, Well, you know, uh nobody will buy insurance then if if that were the case, right?

SPEAKER_01So to give an ex to give another example, right? Like um, we're very sensitive to price. I'm very sensitive to price. Uh that's why I buy my copy of co-song, right? Which is why I don't buy coffee. Um but you know, but if everybody were to be priced the same insurance premium, that means for a lot of healthy people, their insurance premiums are gonna go up. Like inevitably, it's gonna go up. Um and one way you could solve it is by forcing everyone through the state to have uh force everyone to we some some systems have that.

SPEAKER_01Um but generally why we don't like it is because um insurance is supposed to be this autonomous autonomy preserving system, right? You can choose to buy insurance or you can choose not to. Um and it's up to you whether however you want to deal with your risk, right? Um, so there's this thought that if we don't use any information, then the prices are gonna go up. And if the prices go up, then people are not gonna buy insurance anymore. And if people don't buy insurance, then there's this other host of problems of people being underinsured.

SPEAKER_01Now you can solve that by forcing everyone to buy insurance. Singapore does that too, to some degree. Um but then you obviously have this loss of autonomy. So everything is a trade-off in some sense. Um you either have risk pricing together with uh voluntary insurance, or get rid of risk pricing, but you might lose out on people being insured, and therefore you might need to force everyone to be insured.

SPEAKER_01So I think these are very complex questions in the policy domain.

SPEAKER_05Can I push back on one of those, which is the idea that for many people who are at sort of the need or have the highest need for insurance because their health needs are higher, we also know that the majority of health inequities come from the social determinants of health, you know, factors outside their control. And as you were right, it would be unjust to double perpetrate that injustice against them by forcing them to pay more. And so what that sort of means is that for those of us who are already healthy, it's not because we chose to be healthy, it's the social determinants of health again.

SPEAKER_05We have been privileged to uh have, you know, secure housing, food storage, access to medical care. We aren't unaffected by them. And so it would be unfair of those of us already privileged to be healthy to then push back and say, no, no, my insurance should be lower and yours should be higher because neither of our risks are within our but neither of our risks are in our control anyway.

SPEAKER_01That's right. But I've never heard anyone buy insurance for a moral reason, right? So take coffee. Again, another coffee example. Sometimes we buy coffee because it's environmentally friendly, right? We buy the coffee versions that's like direct from the farmer. It's certified that this is green and it doesn't cause as much environmental damage. And for moral reasons, we choose that kind of coffee. Um I don't know if I've ever seen someone buy insurance because, oh, my premiums are going to be higher, but that's okay because I'm doing a moral good by subsidizing someone else.

SPEAKER_05But it's not the same because with coffee, you know exactly what you're getting. Whereas with buying insurance, it's I I might be healthy now, but I actually have no idea what's coming tomorrow.

SPEAKER_01Yes. That's that's that's I mean next one.

SPEAKER_05No, kidding, kidding. We continue.

SPEAKER_01That's exactly so okay. We buy insurance for many reasons. Okay. Um, we like to think in the purest version, we like to think of insurance as this de-risking measure. We buy insurance to remove risk, but in reality, we buy insurance for very, very different reasons across very different people. One of the reasons why you buy insurance is for access. Here at NUS, and in this office particular in particular, we're just one road away from the hospital.

SPEAKER_01But if I were to ask you, how much does a night in that hospital cost? I don't think anyone in this office can tell me.

SPEAKER_05Actually, I think for me it's like, I don't know, 10 to 20 grand. I had to Google it because as a foreigner, I had to know exactly how much to spend.

SPEAKER_02But that's a big range, right? Yeah. So uh a night how, you know, uh I could hide in a corridor somewhere.

SPEAKER_05But it also depends. I guess it also depends if you're getting surgery or Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And one of the reasons why we buy insurance is not really for risk, but it's to gain access at all as a foreign, like you've mentioned, as a foreigner.

SPEAKER_05Actually, and just to disclose, I actually have no idea how much is customing I realize when I say that uh withdraw.

SPEAKER_02Just make it up.

SPEAKER_05It's like I'm being called out in real time. I have no idea what I'm talking about. You're calling yourself out. Yeah, I am.

SPEAKER_01No, but but you wouldn't some people wouldn't step into the hospital if they're not insured because they are so worried about the cost of medical care that they wouldn't even step in. So they would only step in if they buy insurance. So what that means is that they're not really buying insurance because of some future risk in the abstract. They're buying insurance because they want to go into the hospital, and without that insurance, they don't feel confident enough to go into the hospital. That's one of the reasons why people buy insurance. Yes, another reason is to de-risk. Um, another reason is consumption smoothing.

SPEAKER_01You can't really for when when a hospital bill comes, it comes like in a full thing, like just here's the bill, 40 grand immediately. But if you buy insurance, you can spread that out over, say, a couple of years or across a lifetime, right? So that's another reason why people buy insurance. So I think there's a lot of different motivations to buying insurance. Um, and you're right to say that when if it's for access, definitely our moral analysis has to be very different.

SPEAKER_01So um in the US, for instance, pre-Obamacare, pre-ACA, the entire conversation was about underinsurance. People who are underinsured, uh American society didn't peep people in America um were were not insured, basically. So the the the goal was to get as many people insured as possible, because insurance meant access. It didn't really mean de-risking, right? So but that's very different from say things like life insurance, which also is covered here, right?

SPEAKER_01Life insurance is not really about access anymore. Like you'd be dead by the time you're getting inside. I was waiting for that. Um, yeah. So although risk pricing is used in life insurance, we buy life insurance not for access. Sometimes we buy it for inheritance, we think about our children, we think about our spouses. Um, so in some sense, it's about the welfare of other people around us rather than for ourselves. Um so definitely, I think um what a good analysis of insurance requires um a very specific idea of what exactly is this insurance for, right?

SPEAKER_01So there are luxury life insurance. I think very recently this year, the highest um life insurance payout amount was here in Singapore, it's something like a half a billion dollars.

SPEAKER_05Who is worth that much money?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so it was some rich person. Uh so he he didn't die yet, but basically his his his insurance contract says that if he dies, he would get his his family members would get this half billion dollars.

SPEAKER_05Um I think you make a really good point that uh insurance, there are many reasons why people pursue insurance. One is for access. And but in countries like Australia, where we have like a dual health system, half public, half private, it's not necessarily about access, it's about priority. Or what sometimes people think is better quality medical treatment. Although, you know, that's that's a empirical claim that I'm not sure can or has been proven. So completely agree.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, um, Singapore has the same dual system as well. Um the common misconception is that Singapore doesn't have universal healthcare. We actually do have universal healthcare. Um, but people still buy private insurance above that because they either want faster care, um perhaps better quality of care, what they perceive is better quality of care, um, and also just just for what they call peace of mind, right? Um yeah, so this is just the risk aversion leads them to buy insurance. Um, and very interestingly, right now, the Ministry of Health is going on this advertising campaign to get people to buy less insurance by trying to reassure them that look, you know, you can come into the hospital and and and get a lot of things without medical insurance, or without so much medical insurance, at least.

SPEAKER_02Um, so there's only in Singapore when does the government have to go around saying, hey, chill out.

SPEAKER_05We've got you. You don't need that much insurance.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, you don't need half a billion dollar payout.

SPEAKER_05I do. I wouldn't mind to say that.

SPEAKER_02Are you willing to pay the premium?

SPEAKER_05No. Not over my dead body. That can be a remaining. So moving on to the second area of insurance that you were talking about, which is the responsibility idea, which is that we don't discriminate on physiological factors like um uh like how well your heart pumps blood or how well your kidneys filter the blood based, you know, in comparison to other people. It's looking at what have you done to put your own health at risk. And can can we talk a little bit there again about like the social determinants of health?

SPEAKER_05Because it is so it is often so difficult to prove that someone is the overall reason for their own health status, unless, of course, they went bike riding and didn't wear a helmet. I have I have bones to pick in that space.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so you're right in that um the problem with this sort of risk pricing is that one of the problems we'd see um is that we could use the social determinants um to determine a person's health risks and then price them accordingly, right? Um and I actually don't know if that's how insurance actually is practiced. But the fact of the matter is that it's still actually quite expensive to determine your health risks from your social determinants alone, right?

SPEAKER_01Um it is the the variance is very huge in terms of um health that is determined by your income, for instance. Yes, on average, people who are uh well paid um are healthier, um, but it just is not specific enough in terms of the results um to apply to individuals, right? Um and you might think that, oh, that's a good thing. It means that insurance insurers can't use things like income and household and whatever have you to actually um price you, but that's actually a result of not the insurers being nice, that's a result of the insurers being trying to be profitable, right?

SPEAKER_01They actually don't want to go through all that trouble because that's actually very costly for them. So, like James mentioned, to some degree, it becomes a self-defeating thing. They don't want to see all of your risk because it's gonna be really expensive for them to actually look through everything. Um so I think when we are if we are we shouldn't be too worried about that. Um, but then at the same time, you could still say that this is the kind of information discrimination that we should be worried about, right?

SPEAKER_01Because other information that is much clearer um or at the forefront um could be used. Um, and the things that could perhaps redeem you um can't be used because they don't care about it, right? So um smoking, I think, is the best example. They'll just come up to you and ask you, how much do you smoke? Um, and then they'll price you accordingly. But then we do a lot of healthy behaviors too, right? There are things that are like, well, I go to the gym, um, I run this much in a week.

SPEAKER_01Um, and all those things do affect your health, but somehow it's sort of invisible to the insurer, right? Because they don't want to go through that effort.

SPEAKER_05It sort of seems unfair though, because like um I I I I I think I'm starting to sympathize with your point about information discrimination, which is it seems really unfair that I could you could just look at someone's aunt and be like, oh, they had breast cancer, therefore your risk is higher. But you might have the exact same risk as someone else. It's just that you'd have to screen their genome. And it seems really unfair that two people can be penalized uh despite having the same risk. It's just because the companies were too cheap to actually figure it out.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I mean, part of this is that we are insurers are being very inconsistent in how they um price risk. Um and I think if we were being really, really honest about how risk is priced, um the the the actual answer is that we only price risk to the point where it's actually cheap to do so. Um then that's of course a problem there, right? Because um, if we really want a system that's fair, then how cheap it is to determine um your risk um shouldn't be a factor.

SPEAKER_01Um and you know, to listeners who might think like, no, I think it's a very good reason for insurance to be profitable, or say for even if you're not talking about insurance, if you're talking about the government, for instance, or the state, um, and they're determining how to allocate burdens, you might think, well, the state should be efficient, right? We shouldn't be wasting money in terms of discovering exactly how much James's risk is compared to Harrisan's or whatever. Um, but we actually do invest a lot in terms of asking whether people are responsible for the things that they do.

SPEAKER_01We do that in the court system, for instance, right? There's no limit. Boom!

SPEAKER_05That was such a good point.

SPEAKER_01You know, we don't think like, oh, you know, we should stop collecting evidence because it's gonna be really expensive to do so.

SPEAKER_02No, like that's just stick them in tick, just in case. Just in case they were responsible.

SPEAKER_05Just say where you just say whether or not you did it. Like, come on, come on.

SPEAKER_01I mean, it would be good to say. Did you mean it though? No, all right. Yeah, so it seems that um if we want to be consistent, the cost to identify risk or the cost for information shouldn't be a factor. Now, this can lead you to down two paths. You can either go all the way in, and yes, you can bite the bullet and go, like, yes, we should be spending way more money to make sure that we're pricing people accurately.

SPEAKER_01But I think that's a self-defeating view, right? Like you'll be paying more for the cost of information than on the cost of healthcare itself. Um, and then the other position is just, well, just don't use any information then, don't use any risk, um, which is the universal position. Now, of course, I don't have an argument for universal healthcare. Um, but I think my argument is revealing about the inconsistency of the practice of actual fairness.

SPEAKER_02So I imagine many people at this point might push back. They say, well, they might say, well, surely we can discover some things because I don't want to be paying the same premium as somebody who goes base jumping every single day. Uh just you know, that that would feel unfair to a lot of people, I think. So um, you know, couldn't some people at this point point uh uh a couple of different factors, such as responsibility for one, and even within the space of things that we might be responsible for. I think you listed a couple of really good examples.

SPEAKER_02We don't go around asking people uh how much they exercise a week or something like that. Maybe something to do with how verifiable um what somebody says on their insurance form might be. Uh how yeah, you need a couple of different factors and use a few of them to come up with a criteria for uh you know, some set of factors that might result in a higher or lower insurance.

SPEAKER_01I'm of two minds with this. On the one hand, I'm um I'm attracted to this idea that we can possibly think about this list, right? Of like, okay, given that um we don't have all the money in the world and we can't really get to everybody's risk, um we can perhaps come up with a list. Um, but I think we need to be honest about the list, right? I think that's the first step. And right now it just feels as though um people are being told that risk is risk, but really it's something else.

SPEAKER_01I think it would be a good step to tell people honestly, like, hey, actually risk, not all risk is equal. Some risk is cheap, some risk is expensive, and we're gonna do the thing where we're gonna price you based on the risk that's cheap. I think just that transparency would be an improvement. Um, so I'm sympathetic to that view. The reason why I'm not completely sympathetic to that view has to do with who actually gets to determine that list. Now, when it comes to a private insurer um who has you know that autonomy to do that, perhaps you know they can come up with the list however they want.

SPEAKER_01Um, but when it comes to the state with certain sets of powers, um, you know, that becomes less um I I would want to see what the democratic processes are to determine that list. I think that would be important in that determination. Um but even so, I think it would be an improvement if we are just transparent about the fact that the risk that we are using here or the list that we've come up um is because um of the costs, you know.

SPEAKER_01We can only uh identify these few things within uh our budget, and that's why we um are using that list. And it says nothing about you personally, right? So when we come up with this list, uh it often is the case that it gets moralized, right? Um when we say that people aren't you know, we can't get rid of this residue of you know health and and and moral purity, unfortunately. So whenever we say that you know we're gonna charge you higher because of these risks, people can hear that and translate that into um I'm doing something bad, right?

SPEAKER_01Um and if it's a factor that you can't change, then even worse, right? Um one of the examples that I used in the paper was uh Singapore's national disability scheme. So Singapore has this um national disability insurance scheme um that everyone is forced to pay for and um could draw on, uh, but it charges women higher because women live like I think eight years on average more than the average man in Singapore, so therefore they live longer years in disability.

SPEAKER_01So they're more likely to draw down on that. Um the problem with that is that when it comes from a state's perspective, um, and if it is related to health risk, a lot of people tend to look at that as moralizing. Like I've I'm I'm marked for something that is not as morally good as something else. Um and I think that's something that we want to stay clear of, or something we should at least be worried about. Um and within that scheme, when when it was first launched about 10 years ago, there was this very interesting quote that I actually used for my paper, which was something like she went, um, why stop at gender?

SPEAKER_01You can find risks wherever, in your race, in your activities, in your daily habits, in what you eat, in what you drink, in anything that you do. So why stop at gender? And I think that's the question that I go back to a lot, which is when we choose these variables to determine per people's risks. I don't think it's obvious that these aren't very neutral variables, because you really could be using any other uh factors as well, right?

SPEAKER_01Um but the fact that they chose only gender felt like information discrimination because they weren't using any other information at all to determine risk.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, you bring up the point about moralization is interesting because uh I find that especially concerning when we combine that bit of the discussion with the bit on responsibility, right? You know, because responsibility intersects with the moral discussion even more, and me even more obviously. You know, and I don't want to really live in a society where uh if I go out to the beach and suntan a little bit, uh, you know, increase my risk of skin cancer by a tiny amount, some insurance agent is gonna come running up and like, hey, we're gonna increase your premium now.

SPEAKER_02Or if like I have an extra ice cream, they're gonna again some insurance agent is gonna come run running up. So uh that seems like a situation that we don't want to aim towards. Uh but and and I guess people who have who do have the intuition, who do believe that insurance should take into account moral responsibility, I guess have to contend with this kind of tension.

SPEAKER_01Oh yes, yes. Uh I think that tension that you speak of um between perhaps um living in a society where you're not surveilled at every turn, um, and also Well, are you talking about the surveillance bit, or are you talking about just the moralization of the moralization?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so like even if nobody is watching me, I don't want to feel bad.

SPEAKER_01Like I have to, oh, I should be paying more insurance because I'm you know, I think it it it does depend partially on the kind of background culture that we have, right? So Singapore is very unique in the sense that we don't actually feel too we we don't find it too problematic to to in a way have a responsibilist view. This is a state where we've been told again and again that you need to be responsible for your own lives, right? So when it comes to insurance, that's actually not the thing that they were against.

SPEAKER_01They were actually fine with the fact that you are to be responsible for your own behaviors. What they were against was particularly that the assessment itself didn't um align with their view of what should be held responsible or not, right? So it's a very weird thing where for for the Singapore's case at least, um people were fine with the the responsibilists' moralization bit, but what they were not fine with was the fact that the information gathering just didn't go far enough, right?

SPEAKER_01Um so so so yeah, very strange case. Um but my my inclination is to say um the worry, another worry that we would have is that the given the sense that we are okay with the moralization, um any factor that you choose uh ends up being um taken to be that moralizing factor. Right. So even if you know it's bad to not say even if even if it makes your health worse to sunbathe, the choice to include sunbathing activities um uh can send a signal to everyone else that this is a bad behavior to have and that you should avoid it.

SPEAKER_01It's difficult for me to say that there are any behaviors that we could point to. I think, you know, skydiving, maybe base jumping, I think, yeah, sure.

SPEAKER_05Free self.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, re-swallowing. But a lot of things, like Shanine mentioned, um, does track social injustice and social determinants of health. Smoking is one, right?

SPEAKER_02Doing a PhD.

SPEAKER_01Doing a PhD, exactly. The amount of stress and the amount of you know, uh, but we but we don't typically um we do we do punish PhDs. But we don't typically go there, but but we punish, we don't punish them in the health system, but we punish smokers. But despite the fact that doing a PhD increases your rates of depression by like, I don't know, by a lot, right? Uh I know that the literature says that you know doing a PhD is is very depressing for a lot of people, right? But yet we don't uh ask the health system to charge uh people who do PhDs more, right?

SPEAKER_01Right. But we do ask the health system to charge smokers more. And that inconsistency.

SPEAKER_05It's not a value neutral decision.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's not it's not a value neutral decision.

SPEAKER_05And it's also kind of worrying how much um things that we think are uh risks that are outside of our control are actually just proxies for social determinants of health, um, particularly if you trace them back far enough. And so I my I I like what you said before about how um, you know, they ask me if I smoke, but they don't ask me how many times I exercise during the week. And it sort of seems like my view, I think, is that I don't think there should be any risks. I think we should all just pay the same price. I'm willing to defend that on a random battlefield one day out there.

SPEAKER_05Meet me at 3 pm, James, we'll have a dance off. Now moving on to the code.

SPEAKER_02I really agree with you on this one. And let's find about something else.

SPEAKER_05But I do see your point that insurance companies are going to discriminate and that you know, this ideal picture, it might not necessarily work in all contexts. And so maybe what we need is a second list, like an offset list. So you tick all the bad things or whatever things that they seem to be blaming you for, or that that that risks like smoking or suntanning or eating too many mandarins. And then on the good list, you have things that can offset that, where we do we have so much research that shows that there are protective factors of your health. And so maybe, maybe poca no los dos, maybe we do both.

SPEAKER_02Not your nice list.

SPEAKER_01Um also I I wouldn't I wouldn't say no right away. Um, I just have I I don't know much about this. But I do know that some I really know very little. I know that some jurisdictions have such um lists in the genetic space. So uh for instance, there's there's some kinds of genetic testing that you can submit to your insurer to actually improve your premiums, not increase them, but actually to decrease them. Um so say you have a family history um that uh shows that you have that that shows that you potentially might have a genetic condition based on your family history.

SPEAKER_01Now you can actually submit your genetic information to to show that you actually did not inherit uh that genetic condition and therefore can get a better premium. Um I'm not actually sure which jurisdictions have this right now. I think the UK has that in their moratorium. Um I know Australia actually just recently had had a few legal changes, but I have to look at that.

SPEAKER_05Guilty until proven is innocent.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Um yeah, it it does sound like it's guilty, but at the very least, it provides an avenue for people to actually submit their information and show that you know I don't actually have this risk that you say I have. Um and other countries have just, you know, perhaps sometimes just banned the use of genetic information altogether. I can't comment as to which is a cleaner approach um for any jurisdiction, but um there are merits to both, I think.

SPEAKER_05Well, I think then we'll save the genetic testing for another podcast.

unknownThank you.

SPEAKER_05Um but this has been actually fascinating. Um I am definitely gonna advocate for the universal no-risk, no information approach, uh, but I will do it from the silent armchair of my desk.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. Thanks. I will not tell my insurer how much ice cream.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, you should not tell anyone that. That's not that you should keep that to yourself.

SPEAKER_02Some people have said it's a plus.

SPEAKER_05Oh.

SPEAKER_02Yep. Yeah. I think it's a green flag, liking ice cream.

SPEAKER_05You know what?

SPEAKER_01Personality-wise. You sound like you're sponsored by the cafe downstairs.

SPEAKER_02I didn't say their name, you said it. So you're the one being sponsored.

SPEAKER_05Anyway, anyway.

SPEAKER_02Anyway, that would be a Messina.

SPEAKER_05Thanks, Harazat.

SPEAKER_01All right, thank you. Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to C BME and U and be savvy.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can Nihilism Improve Your Mental Wellbeing?

    Nov 2, 202645 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Genomic Newborn Screening: Where less really is sometimes more with Ainsley Newson

    Aug 25, 202655 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. The Hidden Side of Birth: Injury, Trauma, and PTSD with Angela Ballantyne

    Jul 2, 202648 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Brains in Jars with Insoo Hyun

    Jun 1, 202656 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. To smoke or to vape? With Johannes Kniess

    May 14, 202654 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In this episode, guest-host Kat Muyskens and Sinead chat with Dr. Johannes Kniess from Newcastle University (UK) about what governments are legitimately allowed to make us do, whether we like it or not....

    Credit the people on this episode