Send us Fan Mail Why do people judge getting Traditional Chinese Medicine as pointless, or even as bad? Is your grief related to your lungs? In this episode, Dr. Michael Stanley-Baker from Nanyang Technological University discusses the history and ethics of Asian medical practices with Kathryn and James. Michael talks about the value of meaning for patients in understanding the role of medicine, whether medical care is really just a relative practice, and if the only benefit is merely placebo, is it really ethical to sell it to someone? Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast called C BME and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_05And welcome back to CB Me and You. Today we dive once more into the realm of traditional Chinese medicine and its history. And once again, I will ask about how I can run on top of trees. Just like in the I look, I watched Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon. It left an impression. Joining us today is Michael Stanley Baker, associate professor at the Nanyang Technological University School of Humanities. Welcome, Michael.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Great to be here.
SPEAKER_05And again, today we have uh Cat Meiskins, who's, as you know, or if you've been following the podcast, as you might know, uh knows a thing or two about China traditional Chinese medicine.
SPEAKER_03Hi, thank you. Glad to be here. Okay, uh, shall I do the icebreaker question? Do you want to do the fun questions? Yes, I'll do the fun questions. Okay, so uh we ask these three questions to every guest. Um, first of all, coffee or copy?
SPEAKER_01Oh, copy for sure. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Do you have a specific order?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's um copysi kosong. Yeah. And if it's before 12 o'clock, it'll just be copy all. Time dependent.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, time-dependent copy order.
SPEAKER_01Very much so. Well, sometimes, or I'll just do a phenomenological judge of how the body's feeling.
SPEAKER_03Is there a TCM reason for this?
SPEAKER_01Actually, it's uh it's a it's a keto reason. Uh the 18-6 um fasting.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I do need to do a bit of phenomenology when people ask me what I want for lunch. People think I'm indecisive. I'm just trying to imagine what it's like to eat every single food.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_01The body is this fount of much wisdom.
SPEAKER_03Okay, next question. What country do you most want to travel to next?
SPEAKER_01That's a really good question. Um because we're situated in so many. So many people want to go to Bali for their holiday, right? But actually, my dad lives in Bali, so I'm going there all the time for family reasons. So what we haven't done is seen more of the rest of Southeast Asia. And I our next we wanted to go to um uh Cambodia to go to Angkor Wat. We were gonna go for Vesak Day, but we had so much admin for our uh doing getting our grades in that we couldn't do it. So that's our next target.
SPEAKER_03Okay, that'll be exciting.
SPEAKER_05That should be very cool.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Okay. Next question. What is your go-to karaoke song?
SPEAKER_05Kat is a big fan of this question.
SPEAKER_03No.
SPEAKER_01Well, silence, my silence is my first response. I'm really not a karaoke person. The sound of silence. Got it. The sound of silence. I did have one once I I sang in a karaoke, which was um the answer to my the answer I give to every taxi driver's question in Taiwan. You know, they was like, oh, where are you from? Where you from? And there's this um Chinese song called Shu, uh, which is uh the olive tree. But the opening line is Puyo wen wu tong na li lilai.
SPEAKER_01So I thought this is the appropriate answer.
SPEAKER_05I feel like I've been flex on so hard. You are the the second uh non-Chinese person, or third maybe, to come on the podcast and and just say a list of Chinese song, and I'm like, okay.
SPEAKER_01Well, I don't have many in my repertoire, but that's what I got.
SPEAKER_05All right. Uh now we talk about some uh what we're here to talk about, uh, which is the your work and the topic of traditional Chinese medicine. Um so you're a historian, um, and we are hoping that you could uh we could we could begin by with you telling us a little bit more about the history of traditional Chinese medicine, about its roots, and some of the, I guess maybe the philosophical background behind um some of the practices.
SPEAKER_01So what's interesting, a good thing to distinguish is Chinese medicine from traditional Chinese medicine. So TCM or traditional Chinese medicine becomes T and C in the 1950s when Mao Zedong kind of wants to scientize it and and make it uh the kind of national treasure that can be integrate with modern healthcare. Um but before that it was just medicine. Um and so but Chinese medicine has like many various roots. It sort of emerges. We have excavated texts from tombs from about uh roughly 200 BC, give or take, um, which indicate early predecessors of the classic, which is composed around 50 BC, 50 to 0 BC.
SPEAKER_01Um, the Yellow Emperor is in a classic, where a lot of the theoretical uh framework is there, the description of the channels, um, acupuncture is described in in its kind of richest form. Um it's the first rich description. And a couple hundred years later, you have the Bansao tradition, that this sort of pharmacological tradition emerging. We don't know where from in China, although I just published a paper recently that showed it doesn't come from uh the mountains or the plains as had been thought, but actually it originates, at least in the texts, from rivers and lakes.
SPEAKER_01And one of the things that that paper argues is that because they're citing all these places on rivers and lakes, those sites are not biotopes, but they're sites of socio-technical practice that migrates wild objects into the purview of writers and and for sort of pharmacological documenters. So there's a whole rich culture of many silenced actors who are producing this kind of knowledge. But you can still meet people like that today, you know, like at the um at the various herb gardens that are here in Singapore, who are working in vernacular ways that don't match up to.
SPEAKER_01But uh uh so so that kind of trans translation from vernacular into systematized medicine is an old historical process, but it's one that's ongoing. Um when you get into the sixth, the between the third and the eighth, ninth century, a lot of migration of uh Buddhist medicine uh migrates South Asian medicine into China, um, both through Buddhist monastics and Persian traders, and in the Song dynasty, 11th, 12th century, you see an increase of trade with Southeast Asia. A lot of drugs are coming north uh from Southeast Asia.
SPEAKER_01So it's really comes from all over the place. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So that that's a lot. That's a lot of different complex in uh influences throughout its history. Um I want to try to come at this from um like a modern person's uh point of view as well. Uh so I think a lot of people wonder or they're skeptical about TCM because they think it's unscientific. So you use the word scientized in the 50s uh for the creation of TCM. Uh would you like to say a little bit more about like how scientific TCM is or how scientific Chinese medicine is or what uh how should we characterize the kind of knowledge practices um throughout its history?
SPEAKER_01That is uh the rich question. Um, that would we could pick that out and say, well, what's science first? Is science a method? Is it is it an institution? Is this is it a set of standards? Um and uh Stephen Shapin had has written many times, you know, that although all governments agree that science is important and science scientists agree that there is uh that this is important, there's no single scientific method. Um so it's a it's an assemblage of multiple different kinds of practices and ways of asserting.
SPEAKER_01I use the term robust knowledge. Um and some forms of knowledge are more robust than others because of the community practices that have gone in to establish and solidify and regularize it. Um so in terms of you know, there's uh so there were attempts in the, you know, in the 60s and 70s to create direct equations between the kidney, you know, in in Chinese medicine and the shin, right? In in in sorry, the kidney and western medicine and the shin and Chinese medicine. And then they're sort of arguing that some of the activities like, you know, adrenaline and other and you know insulin management in the biomedical kidney were parallel to functions in the shin, etc.
SPEAKER_01But they realized these mappings just don't map up, match up at all. So the shin became conceptualized as kind of well the the Zhang Fu, uh, sorry, which is the names for the two different categories of inner organs, are more like, yes, they have a physical locus, but they also are processual dynamics that manage physiology. Um, in terms of so the scientization is about the standardization and regularization of it. I I don't have a simple answer for that because I think it's going through a lot of different kinds of study.
SPEAKER_01There's a nice article in EASTS, the journal, um, East Asian Science and Technology Studies that looks at Chinese herbs as a boundary object. They say, well, Chinese medicine isn't scientific, but that they pick out like seven to nine different types of scientists in Australia that are studying Chinese herbs for different regions, whether it's, you know, the the botany, biodiversity, bioactivity, right, toxicity, et cetera, et cetera. There's just all these kind of different ways of approaching them. Um so it's it's complicated.
SPEAKER_01It's a simple answer.
SPEAKER_03Um that's uh that's the heart of some of the work that I've been trying to do on um sort of a bioethical approach to TCM, um, is trying to address these questions that a lot of people have, like ordinary people who might be interested in consuming TCM um or biomedicine and maybe sometimes combining them. Um and then just I can speak a little bit from a patient's perspective, because I've gone to TCM doctors, I've gone to Western doctors, um, and I've encountered situations where you go to the TCM doctor and they will sometimes try to translate what they're doing into biomedical terms for you.
SPEAKER_03So they say, like, okay, you have spleen qi deficiency, but uh like that's something about your digestion. So they might try to do some translation work there. But what you said earlier about um kidney qi and or kidney in the Western medical tradition, like the literal organ versus shen, um, you said they don't totally map up or yeah, align with each other. So I guess that's one thing that I continue to question or wrestle with is how um commensurable are these practices?
SPEAKER_03Are they talking past each other? Uh you also you mentioned the um different research into traditional Chinese herbal remedies. Uh and I think that we know that some scientific work can be done on that and shown uh has shown them to be effective for this or that, like malaria, for instance. Um but other things might not be so easy to quote unquote prove scientifically. And then what would what would Chinese medicine's response be to that?
SPEAKER_01Right, right, right. Um so spleen and kidney and malaria. It's a lot there on the table. Umly related things. Yeah. Well, I'm sure they're all impacted. If you if you got malaria, you'd have different impacts on them. Um so the the address the malaria part first. So the the so Tuyoyo got the Nobel Prize in 2016 for for discovering Artemisin or Artemisinin. Um and uh out of interestingly, reading a Taoist text or a text by a Taoist author uh Go Hong and where he describes cold washing uh Artemisia or Qinghao.
SPEAKER_01And then so she used a cold extraction method and then preserved that um that component. So that comes out of a uh uh a single a sort of you know silver bullet model for for for efficacy combating disease, which is totally not a TCM um approach to medicine. Um it's much more about the it's not pharmacodynamics, it's not pharmaco, it's like synergistics, right? How drugs interact with one another and how these they can complement, they can support, they can do guiding, right, to different parts of the body.
SPEAKER_01Um so it's always a complex set of formulas. And unlike um unlike single drug approaches, um each each each treatment is going to be different. So that your patient may keep coming back with the same biomedical condition, but because their body will be in a different state, the TCM practitioner will adjust will adjust and adopt it according to their um according to their current situation. So the single drug model and the standardized body, that those whole those whole methods of research, which are the foundations for randomized controlled trials and evidence-based medicine, kind of fall out the window already.
SPEAKER_01And so one of the things I think is a is a problem in the kind of current state of governance and uh kind of the the logistics of of deploying these traditional practices within uh modern medical frameworks, is that those epistemes, those kind of ways of thinking about uh drug function, body function, which don't lend themselves to the kinds of legitimating research practices that we use as kind of the gold standard, fall out the window and they can't be adapted and used.
SPEAKER_01In the case of artimecea, for example, people have noticed researchers have since noticed that mosquitoes, or rather the malaria, is developing much more resistance to artemines than they are to Qinghao, the herb, because there's many more things, complex things in Qinghao. So Qinghao is a longer-term, more effective remedy. However, because of that, you have policies. There's a really good, interesting film has been looking at how Big Pharma, Gates Foundation, and others have been promoting the distribution of artemisin in third world countries and trying to downplay the local use of traditional herbs, um, which actually may be showing to be more effective, but it's hard to do that scientifically because of the limitations of trial design and the way that trial design has be become anchored into this whole architecture of legitimacy.
SPEAKER_01Um so I think I I believe we're at this point where we can begin to think a little more flexibly about how we can adopt practices, judge that they're safe, they're non-toxic, right? Some the last in fact there was the the the panel we were in in in October, a bunch of docs at a medical humanity conference. And they're saying it's great that you look at the you can talk about conceptual incommensurability, but what about these drugs which have large molecules that are blocking out my patients' you know livers? And that's an interesting, it's it's it's obviously it's a problem, but it's not like Western drugs don't also have their problems, right, with toxicity limits that need to be controlled.
SPEAKER_01Um, but because Chinese medicine isn't so easily regulalizable in the same ways, it there's the epistemic bias against it generally. And I think it's really it's really exciting place to be in uh a space like you know, thinking in a in a group community of bioethicists, or in the humanistic frame, you know, looking at philosophy or or or thinking about policy, because we don't have um the drivers of patient health uh or or or trying to make a bottom line if you're a pharmaceutical company or trying to get votes if you're a government.
SPEAKER_01And we can have the ability to be more epistemically reflexive and think about better possibilities for making room while maintaining uh safety and also drawing on the potential for efficacy. Um scholars uh have tried to black box the causal, you know, the causal driver of a particular therapy and just say, look, you go to a TCM doctor, they give you some formula, we don't know how it works, but do they get a better result than placebo?
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_01And just not worrying about the cause. And that might be a better, that might be an option to look at further.
SPEAKER_03I mean that's that's an interesting one, um, because we do a lot of work on AI in this center, and the AI has uh famously a black box problem that may or may not be a problem, depending on what you think matters. Like if if you think the outcome matters uh r uh more than the exact knowledge of how it got from A to B, then yeah, maybe it's not so a problem.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Um I guess that could leave us in a bit of a weird position, right? It's it's almost like okay, we we so somebody says, okay, we have this TCM practice, and it it it it we've shown that it works. Uh no, and and they have a whole theory about how it works, about qi and all that. But I guess from from my point of view, it's like, okay, we we don't have a way to test that. So what do I make of the explanation if I don't know how to test that? If I if I'm I might be skeptical about the kind of metaphysics going on behind it.
SPEAKER_05Uh even if I know that the ri it gets results. Uh should I just sideline that and just say, okay, I'm just gonna ignore all that stuff and just focus on the practice itself and just uh as long as it works, I'm fine with it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I mean, so the other way to look at it is it it the the to look at the metaphysics takes a lot of time and you know cognitive effort to lean into the the ways in which those systems came to know in in in those ways. There was a I don't know, this conversation came up uh on Facebook a couple uh a month ago or so, and people were saying, ah, you know, this now the WHO is is putting um uh uh TCM disease conditions in the ISD, right? ISD 12.
SPEAKER_01Um as sorry, that's the international standard for disease classification. And you know, this is this is you know, there's there's ridiculous theories in there, like, you know, how are you can remember the concept he had? Oh, something about the lungs being related to grief and depression, right? Which is um a sort of um that this comes out of five agents thinking or or five phase five phase or five elements of wishing thinking, where the lungs correspond to the metal, which is a descending thing, and and but any uh observer will notice if you're crying, you you your breathing changes.
SPEAKER_01Um and there are and there's also other elements about the the metal being about descending qi within the within the body and um things like that. So the idea that grief and lungs have a have a have a relationship is is there in Chinese medicine, and so this person was challenging that. Like, how can you prove that? That's ridiculous. Um and so we got online and a few people were discussing it. One is a very famous um sort of Chinese medical physician, anthropologist, and historian. He's like does all the three.
SPEAKER_01Um he's really good, very skilled. And he was saying, Oh, well, you just read Zhu Xi, was his offhand remark. And if you know about kind of Song dynasty, kind of you know, Confucianism and their go, which is a kind of movement of kind of observing the world to explain how it works, and how that fed into um Chinese pharmacognosy over the over the next three centuries. Um, and the kind of self-cultivation and training and all of this, and the ways in which physicians achieve a kind of virtuosity in their ability to diagnose, to read the signs.
SPEAKER_01Um this is this is one of the evidence bases within Chinese medicine. It's a it's a very cultivated individual, it's not an externalized objectify, objectifiable form of evidence. Which was a which is one way of of of approaching the kind of epistemic commensurability. And then so then what did we do? We sort of looked around and some people found, well, actually, you can look at some of the ingredients that are listed in some of the remedies for for lungs, and actually they were also listed as effective for and there are randomized CAMAL trials that show that they're effective for um, you know, sort of mental uh mental health issues as well.
SPEAKER_01So there's a you can trace a long link across them without you know making a direct um without making a direct you know single bullet kind of claim. But it requires a sustained um this is a term you published on, Catherine, epistemic humility. Right? This kind of ability to suspend your own assumptions and and listen deeply to how someone else thinks. And and so I I was complimenting you by adding another term, a sort of uh sort of tampening down the epistemic um epistemic ragadoccio.
SPEAKER_01Bigotry, epistemic bigotry. We're like, oh, yeah, that's just quackery, let's just forget it. So we need a little more nuance in the conversations, I think. So so without that thick engagement, which to be honest, only those of us in the humanities have time to do. The simple answer is yes.
SPEAKER_05Don't don't don't tell them, don't let them know that. That we just sit around and think all day.
SPEAKER_01That's our job. We can do that. Let's let's own it.
SPEAKER_05I feel like once they know how the sausage is made, they might not give us money anymore.
SPEAKER_01No, but many people don't want to do it. There was a during COVID, there was a it was a survey in Singapore about what jobs do you want? You know, and people were like, Yeah, lawyer and all this other stuff. Professor, 25% or less people were like, Yeah, wanted a professor job. It's not a highly prized occupation.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, um I want to go a little bit of a different direction um based on what you said there. Uh I noticed that like we've been talking about the different epistemic practices, knowledge uh practices that um TCM versus Western scientific medicine might have. But uh we also know that TCM has a very long history, or Chinese medicine has a very, very long history. Um and it might be more fair to call it something like pre-scientific, um, or like it comes from an era where these things were not separated or separable all the time.
SPEAKER_03So I think you've done some work on uh uh the religious influences on TCM or on Chinese medicine. So how much of modern TCM is religiously related or is explainable in sort of religious terms? Is is that still um part of the practice?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a that's a great question too. Thank you. You have to mix these amazing uh simple questions like oh this we have So I want to step back about kind of the origins that got me into that question was that TCM is framed today as a compliment complementary and alternative medicine. And it's lumped in with many other things, right? Yoga, meditation, relaxation, and all these other things. Um Tai Chi. And so when I got into when I was training in uh so I also have a TCM clinical degree, and when I was training, my my teacher, who is like a family trained practitioner from Southern Taiwan from Gaoshion, um, but we were training in Colorado, just by circumstances brought me there.
SPEAKER_01And and he was quite interesting because he would say, well, you know, you can if you know you use the he would say, first you use yin yang to diagnose. If that doesn't work, then use sanse, right? Um sense Tian D Rem, which is heaven, earth, and man, and think about the three uh different levels of the body. Um if not, then use five elements. If that doesn't work, use the Bagong, the sort of eight, the modernization of TCM in China, develop these kind of, you know, is it hot, cold, internal, external, these kind of these four binaries.
SPEAKER_01Uh is it hard, soft, you know, this sort of thing. Um and then if if that doesn't work, then go to 64, use the Yijing and cast, do divination. I'm like, oh, that's an interesting response. I wasn't expecting that. And as I kept listening to him, he would say, back in Taiwan, my ref his referral um network of other practitioners were um diviners, were feng shui people, um temple, uh temple ritualists, kung fu masters, tai chi, right? Then sort of a very different kind of network than you think of, you know, your cardiologist, your kinesiologist, and this, you know, your PT physical therapist.
SPEAKER_05Sounds like the start of a movie.
SPEAKER_01Huh. That's a good idea. I know a guy who does movies at NTU. That could be fun. Um, so so that started my question, and and then I realized that because my parents are both like historians, art historians, that most of my questions in clinic, my clinical training were cultural, historical. I also was wondering why is why is using a needle a political act in the middle of Midwestern America? It felt political. Like, why should it be like that? And my TCM training didn't tell me that.
SPEAKER_01I had to go to grad school to read Foucault and realize, oh, okay, it's biopolitics. It's uh, you know, you're in a in a in a fabric of polit political, medical uh action. Um so that framework got me thinking, well, we we call it complimentary alternative medicine, we lump it with all these other practices. Is that a feature of it just being the rest, the non-biomedical uh stuff? Or was it a feature of uh traditional, you know, in history? So I also had to go to grad school to learn how to read classical and literary Chinese to read those texts and find out.
SPEAKER_01And I I'd say there's different levels of you guys had a podcast on Taoism a couple a month or so ago. There's actually at least three different types of Taoism that you could talk about in relationship to TCM. Early Lao Zhang Taoism, which that podcast was about, comes out of these two texts and this kind of attitude of surrender and going with the flow and you know kind of cohering with broader nature, um, and situating yourself in ideal relationship to to the universe.
SPEAKER_01By the time the Han Empire forms, um qi becomes to the forefront and starts to have a whole new valence. Um and it it's already embodied by the time Lao Zhang were writing, but by the which was in let's say the fifth to fourth century. Those were not individual authors, by the way, both those texts are compilation of many different hands. But in the Han Dynasty, uh the the in the politics in Lao Zhang is very apolitical.
SPEAKER_01It's like, you know, go live in a small village where you hear your neighbors in the village far away and you can hear the sound of their chickens and their dogs, but you actually have never met them. Like really small community is the political ideal. By the time you get to the Han Dynasty, it's how can we understand the forces of nature and govern the Tien Xia, everything under heaven? And so it's about governance. So this form of Taoism is called Huangla Taoism, which is refers to the Yellow Emperor and Lao Tzu. And there they're thinking about how do we interact with the Wuxing, the five agents, understand the what the stars are telling us about the ideal rule of the emperor, and these kind of large and and also the the flow of the seasons and the macrocosm and its relationship to the microcosm and create ideal individuals and an ideal state.
SPEAKER_01Um and it's within that genre of writing about which is not just religion, it's science, religion science aren't divided. They are we we've imposed we impose those categories as moderns. Um but these are kind of thinking about how does the universe work. And it's of course it's got gods and it's got uh q qi and it's got people and it's got weather and all these things. Bugs and pollutants and accidents and warfare, tigers. They're all part of the model that you have to deal with.
SPEAKER_01So so that and that's kind of some of the fabric that TCM, I say TCM, uh classical Chinese medicine and the the Yellow Emperor's classic is written in. Um Towards the end of the Han Dynasty, it's collapsing, and there's pandemic, the epidemics all over the place, military upheaval, and the state has lost its mandate and it become very clear and it's contested in all these domains. Disease is rampant, and that's one of the signs of the loss of the state's mandate. In comes religious, what we now call religious Taoism, um, which is also a modern construct, um, where they introduce all these ritual practices, right?
SPEAKER_01Let's uh find the sin that your ancestors committed unknowingly to anybody else and resolve that by petitioning the gods with documents and ritual. Um, or they're you know, the Xianren become uh these transcendence come into the forefront of the cultural imagination during that dynasty. And these are the ones who eat mount eat eat herbs and minerals and live on the mountains and do exercises and live forever and walk on bamboo and fly to heaven.
SPEAKER_05So it's real?
SPEAKER_01In those stories, yes.
SPEAKER_03Oh, you're in the wrong century.
SPEAKER_01I mean, it's really interesting because those a lot of those stories become part of state history in the Qin dynasty. And there are these these Chigua tales and Xian, uh Tales of the Strange and transcendent hagiographies are are drawn on by the by the state as evidence, right? So in that state, it it it it is evidentiary practice. So, you know, it gets really complicated at that point, you know, and there's no regulatory bodies, there's no state regulatory body at that time.
SPEAKER_01There are individual pai or um what do you call this, uh lineages of doctors, or lineages of Taoists, or or there's the Taoist religion that hins to the celestial master Taoism, um, which has a regulated body, and you can get your registration with the community in different places through that system. So all different ways to become a profession, uh, not a professional, but you a functioning authority in in the community. And many of the biographies show us that doctors and Taoists were they learn one and they and then they go to the other, or vice versa.
SPEAKER_01You start out learning herbs and then you become a transcendent, or you you know, you start out studying transcendence and you learn how to heal along the way. Um so they've become culturally blended at that time. In the Tang dynasty, in my forthcoming book, is kind of shows this, you start the state comes in and starts to separate that out slowly. So they separate separate out the catalogs, they separate out the lineages, they create, they they secularize some of the Taoist exercises and things, and and so it it shifts in different governments over time.
SPEAKER_01Today, um, you know, how Taoist do you have to be to do TCM? That is a is a really open question. Um you can see this admixture in uh there's a really lovely film in uh Taiwan called um Shu Guan Shenjin, the test tube transcender, the test tube god. And it starts out, this guy's getting his himself pulsed, and then he's getting acupunctures, going, oh, wow, ooh, ow, ooh, ow. And then the the the the the doctor gives him a jar full of herbal medicines with a snake that's glaring out of it. It's a comedy.
SPEAKER_01And then he says, Ah, but if you want this to really work, you need the help of Tai Shang Dao Jun. And he pulls across a curtain and he's got a temple right next door. And then Tang Dili Kangkyang, he starts doing, you know, ritual to augment this. And in the film, he goes through this whole gamut of different kinds of folk practices, right? And then there's the there's a the Hua Po, the, the, the, the, this woman who transmit um trances gods and speaks to him. And his parents in the countryside are trying to get him to do this, and he's like, ah, forget this.
SPEAKER_01And then he's going to a fertility clinic, high-end biomedicine. And there's a whole range of practices that are that are going on and available in Taiwan. Um, and in the end, spoiler alert, it's okay. The the baby is born, right? And and so so it works. And at that point, he's they're so anxious about the there's there's a there's a risk at the at the point of birth. Um he starts he finally buckles in and starts praying to the to the god, that the the tran the donkey transmet trances.
SPEAKER_01And in the end, you know, the baby's born and everybody's happy. And the epistemic incommensurability is not a problem. This is the issue disappears because the result that's wanted is the baby's there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So I think that's a it's a really excellent um depiction of of uh kind of the patient perspective uh on that. In there's a nice ethnography by Zhang Zhen uh called Worlding Chinese Medicine, or something to that uh account, where she asks practitioners in the Shanghai TCM hospital, and it's definitely a TCM hospital because that's the hospital where it was teed and seed. Um and it was the kind of the forefront of the scientific research into it.
SPEAKER_01And they're like, no, Chinese medicine is not a religion at all. This is really it's it is science, baby. And that you know, there's lots of you know hardcore evidence research that's going in, a lot of industry. Um regularization and repeatability is really uh uh at the forefront there. Um and then she interviews students in a uh uh Chinese medicine school in California, and like, yeah, if you don't understand the Tao, and you don't understand qi and wu Xing and all these other elements, these religious elements, which they define as religious, you can't understand Chinese medicine and its roots and its history, and so you're alienated from the tradition.
SPEAKER_01You don't have to be religious to get acupuncture or to take herbs. The last uh the last dimension of answer to that, a really nice book by Judith Farquahar, where she's giving these uh these Terry lectures at Yale, which specifically ask about to describe scientific practices uh that speak to a religious mentality that's good for the the the world of you have to look we'll have to look up the intro to the Terry lectures, but it it combines this this kind of religion as an ecumenical worldview of you know how to be in the world with scientific practice and how to think about that.
SPEAKER_01And she writes about Chinese medicine as um as a contrast from the analysis of Western medicine, which differentiates into fine detail the synthesis and instead of diagnosis, it's a cognosis of putting together and synthesizing all of these different um dimensions that cohere in a particular patient's moment in their trajectory and response to that very specifically. And so she argues there that this um uh kind of coherent of all of these different dimensions of life is uh is is part of uh the that kind of you could call it religion without having to have a god or an orthodoxy.
SPEAKER_01Um but it it produces a meaningful world in which to live. And I think that's one of the attractions of Chinese medicine in the West, um, because of the kind of separation and dissection of of people and individuals and their bodies and their functions, that there's and and the what does Foucault talk about? The the power of the physician's gaze onto latent forces in the body over which the patient has no control or cognizance, giving the physician more authority over the patient than they have over themselves.
SPEAKER_01That is a resistance to that that that epistemic gaze and the politics and power that's associated with it. We saw all that resistance happen in COVID with that, all the anti-mask movement in the US. Um that that anti-science is and interestingly, during COVID, the TCM used to be a leftist thing in in the U.S. It was all these communist hippie sympathizers in the 60s and in the 70s, you know, who were attracted to um TCM, uh uh, you know, have now kind of merged with the far left, far right um conspiracy theorists in their common anti-science sympathies.
SPEAKER_01Um so I think there's a there's there's also these kind of political dimensions that are there in the what's laden into the yeah, in in in part of the attractions to to Chinese medicine. So there's a very varied multicolored um sets of ways in which people come to to Chinese medicine and religion can be part of it.
SPEAKER_03Okay, that's a huge answer. Um Yeah, there's a lot of things I could respond to. I have uh I have a few things I want to respond to. Um so let's let's set aside the the political thing and the like overlap with conspiracy theorists um for for now.
SPEAKER_05In the next episode.
SPEAKER_03Q and on. Um okay. I wanted to respond to this uh idea about like the um the physician's gaze and things like that, and how this how the um sort of story that comes along with TCM might uh influence the patient's feeling or the or the healing process. Because I think that's something I I did bring up when uh you were when James and Sinead were interviewing me uh last time, is that like I I completely believe what what you said earlier that you can imagine that patients can benefit from TCM regardless of understanding what the theory is behind it.
SPEAKER_03So you can kind of just compartmentalize that that narrative off, and you can still benefit from TCM if you want to. But for me as someone who um has had a chronic illness and has dealt with chronic pain, um, I've had those kind of clinical experiences, going to a Western medical doctor versus going to different kinds of TCM doctors. And um I have felt what you're talking about. Like uh when you go to a Western medical doctor, you feel you know, it's not really their fault. It's not that they're trying to be mean, but you don't have this feeling um of being empowered all the time.
SPEAKER_03Like there's a there's a force of the sort of structure and ritual of Western medicine that is very like factory line. You go in, you meet them, five minutes, they stare at a computer screen, type on their keyboard, um, and then uh, you know, ask you a few questions and then sh shh shuffle you out the door. And you know, maybe you get a pharmaceutical, or maybe you don't. Um but TCM is very different. And um, what I enjoyed about it was actually ax asking the acupuncturist to tell me that story about like, well, why is this point?
SPEAKER_03Why are you needling that point? Why what what does that do? Personally, I don't know whether this is placebo or not, but the idea that this is like connected or that there's some sort of meaning um behind all these things felt more empowering and felt more therapeutic. Um so I think that there is some real action to that, to just the story that you're being told. And I I think there's uh there's a whole category of like narrative medicine too that explores this. Like how how do patients understand their condition, how do they find meaning in it?
SPEAKER_03Um, and that can have a therapeutic effect itself. So it's it's not all about the, like you call it, the silver bullets or the um pharmaceuticals that might be tested uh with randomized control trials. Some of it is the ritual aspects of medicine. Um yeah. So I mean that's that's my personal anecdote there.
SPEAKER_01Um Yeah, I I I think I I completely agree with you. I think there's a lot that goes on in the in the just being with the with the person, the kind of presence that you have, the depths of question you ask a a patient. And even just the it's funny, the the act of pulsing itself. Um when you're touching someone on the wrist and you're listening to in TCM, you it's not the it's not just the the systole and the diastole you're listening for, it's the textures, the quality, and the the rhythms, not just the number per beat, but how regular they are.
SPEAKER_01Um and and you know that and there's three different dimensions, so you're listening to three different um areas of the body, the upper chest, the middle, and then the lower abdomen. Um and there's just just something, there's a quality that's in there. And I I didn't I I didn't recognize this it e in the act of pulsing until a Tibetan practitioner mentioned to me, she said, yes, actually treatment begins with pulsing. That's not just a diagnosis, there's an exchange of qi. Um whether whether we have to assent epistemically to the concept of qi as a thing, that that kind of I think that sense of intimacy is is yeah, is palpable.
SPEAKER_01Um so actually there's this scholar Mormon, I can't remember his first name, who's written about the way that we can think about placebo more productively uh is as a meaning response. Um so because placebo tends to evoke these notions of what is it, malingerers? Malingering, right? People trying to get off work or whatever, get excuses, and and and uh this kind of false consciousness. Um whereas actually you can also lean into that. I think there's what there's now a Harvard group of identified like 12 or more different kinds of placebo and nocebo.
SPEAKER_01There's a whole variety of things. And I think the the efficacy of that in itself is is definitely part of the treatment. That may raise, of course, the skeptics, you know, saying, well, then it's then then it's meaningless, right? It's not because it's not, you know, biologic, it's not a biological mechanic that's producing that. Is that true? I don't know. I think there's this whole realms of dimension to to to to tease out there. Interesting, there's there was a study in Taiwan took looking at the responses of medical humanities training to biomedical students and TCM students.
SPEAKER_01And for the biomedical students who got this training, they were like, Wow, this is so cool. I never thought I could interact with my patients this way. It's really eye-opening. And the TCM students were like, What? We do this all the time. This is not innovative.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05So I I'm interested in this discussion about the placebos, right? Um, and I I just want to try to push the skeptics line a little bit more because I guess I'm just a disagreeable person. Um so so I guess one takeaway you can make with the whole placebo stuff is look, it's meaningless because uh turns out we can tell people anything. And and as long as we say it uh well enough, or if we we ground it in some kind of like really uh fanciful story, somebody will believe it, somebody will find it meaningful, and it'll make somebody feel better.
SPEAKER_05Uh and and I guess uh the the the the the charge of of this of this uh kind of objection is that well, if you can say anything to make a person feel better, then it it it uh it's all up in the air, it's all pointless, it's all anything goes, basically. It it how how how would you respond to that kind of criticism?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so there's a I think there's a there's a it's an interesting phenomenon that comes out of maybe essentializing, but I guess this is where I think about that that kind of anxiety is sort of like the anxiety that um is there about relativism generally, right? Sort of you have to have objectivity if you don't have objective knowledge that is separated from Individual responses, then you know it's meaningless. You can say anything you want. But if you look at the responses from the actor network theory, people like you know Brunille Tour and stuff who's been very explicit and articulate about that.
SPEAKER_01It's not anything goes at all. In fact, it's those meanings are deeply embedded in thick networks of value. Are not as mutable as one might think. Because people don't just think anything. And we have a good sense, even with TCM doctors when they're kind of faking it, right? There's a there's there's a whether it's definable or quantifiable, there's a there's a clear sense, and that's been true, you know, even before the the invention of objectivity in the in the late 19th century.
SPEAKER_01But in terms of the so so can can can a TCM doctor say anything? I think no they can't. And it you know, but some people do do have, and maybe more thinking about those layers and nuances might help us separate out the kind of more fanciful, innovative new age theories, you know, uh about things which people just make up and say, well, I believe this, it's my religion, but I'm a religion of one, right? But I claim the rights as a religion, you know, to do these actions. And so one of the ways I think about this is robust knowledge systems.
SPEAKER_01Um so T Chinese medicine has become robust over time through a layering of professionals who have, you know, been adjudicating the value of their claims um over centuries through all kinds of different means, you know, whether it's through publishing case histories, whether it's through experimenting with recipes, um, going through uh uh experience of epidemics and treating thousands of patients. Um that's kind of the call sign of a a number of famous uh um pharmace pharmacists in Chinese history.
SPEAKER_01On the one hand, so I think thinking about how knowledge becomes robust and who robusts it and how is really useful. So I one of my call catchphrases that I love and I notice I keep producing this in graduate classes and in undergrad classes is situating knowledge, like in a particular moment, what what what what are the foundations of it in its in in making a claim? And it's usually Chinese medicine is has got a is is quite a robust uh uh understructure to it.
SPEAKER_01On the other side, I think you can still black box the placebo to a degree by doing trials and just saying, okay, we just we we do these we do acupuncture um in as much as it's possible versus no acupuncture. Um right, and and we see is it more effective or not, you know, or however, you know, I would like to learn a little more or work together with a trial design theorist and and think about how we can create more sophisticated designs that can allay the anxieties about about placebo.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, okay. It's really interesting.
SPEAKER_05I think that's all the time we have for today. The next time we have you on, I will ask you how to harness the power of my avatar state.
SPEAKER_03Okay. Yeah, thank you. Thank you so much for joining us.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much for having me. I think with your your the podcast that you're doing is great, and it's a really important and useful intervention, and it's a real honor to have been included. Thanks.
SPEAKER_04Thank you very much. Yeah, it's an honor to have you.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and you and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...