Send us Fan Mail Episode #6 explores with Dr. Kathryn Muysken (Research Fellow, Centre for Biomedical Ethics) the ethics of Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM). Kathryn shares her expertise on what counts as TCM, the importance and humanity of TCM as distinct from Western medicine, whether the inexplicability of TCM is ethically problematic for patient autonomy and consent, and the vulnerability of humans whilst eating mala hotpot. Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, C BMENU, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_02Welcome back to CB Me and You, a podcast about biomedical ethics. Today we discuss traditional Asian medicine. What is it? Is it science or pseudoscience? Should you use it? When my auntie tells me you eat more yogurt, should I do it? Joining us today is CBME's very own Dr. Katherine Lynn Meiskins, who will answer all of our questions. Welcome, Kat.
SPEAKER_05Hi.
SPEAKER_04Just some long expectations that we have today.
SPEAKER_02I have 50 questions about the universe.
SPEAKER_04Okay. Where do we begin? Well, there was a big bang. Some sciencey things happened.
SPEAKER_02I feel like we're glossing over some details.
SPEAKER_05My brain is running through the Big Bang Theory song right now. That's honestly how I think about the start of the universe. So we have some icebreakers for you. Some questions. So coffee or copy? Copy. Oh, excellent. Um, uh just plain copy or like copy seiko song pang. Get girl. So for our listeners.
SPEAKER_04I've been here a while.
SPEAKER_05For our listeners, copy seco song peng is ice, copy with evaporated milk, less sugar. No sugar. No sugar. And yes. So close. Okay. Next question. What country do you want to travel to the most?
SPEAKER_04Um, okay. So Portugal is on my list. Uh, haven't been there. Uh no current plans to go. No occasion for it. But one day. One day.
SPEAKER_02It's an expression of desire, not so much an expression of plan. Yeah, we're not pressing you on any details you have.
SPEAKER_05And last question, my favorite, what's your go-to karaoke song?
SPEAKER_04Yes. And so this is the one that I knew is coming, because I know you. And so I prepared an answer, but I couldn't pick just one. So the first one is pass. Second, no. Third, how dare you? And also, why?
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_02One of those must be a song.
SPEAKER_05I think probably all songs will hold you to it. Okay, okay.
SPEAKER_04When you find a song called Pass, let me know.
SPEAKER_02It is like one of those, you know, uh Spotify playlists where people make it up.
SPEAKER_05And like it's just different songs, but when you read it from the list, absolutely not, no way.
SPEAKER_04Over my dead body.
SPEAKER_05I love that one. Sort of adds a ring to it.
SPEAKER_02I feel like you're writing a whole album here.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04The CBME album.
SPEAKER_05Track seven. Go away. Go away. Yes. My favorite. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02All right. Now for some real questions. Okay. So the first thing we want to start with is definitions. So what is the definition of traditional medicine? Um, you know, is it just this hodgepodge of random ideas that are associated with tradition? For example, if if some auntie comes up to me and says, oh, blah, blah, blah, it's heaty and blah, blah, blah, it's cooling. Does that count as medicine?
SPEAKER_04Okay, those are actually two excellent questions in there. Um, the first was what counts as tradition? And the other one is actually what counts as medicine. So I think those are both valid questions to ask. Um but talking about labels first, just with the notion of traditional medicine, um, I think ordinarily people think of that as any sort of tradition of medicine that's connected with um an ethnicity or culture that has a long history. So we think of things like traditional Chinese medicine, you might think of Ayurveda for Indian medicine, um, and there's others as well.
SPEAKER_04But uh I think it's a great question because this is a really controversial category as well. So, how old does something have to be to be called traditional? What's the boundary between something that's a folk remedy, like the fact that you drink cranberry juice if you have uh a bladder infection, versus going to an acupuncturist for traditional medicine, if you want to call it that? Um yeah, so that's that's some of the difficulty with the traditional label. People have tried some other labels in the past and still trying um some now.
SPEAKER_04Like people have called it vernacular medicine to try to uh link in the kind of folk tradition. Um then there's uh another popular category called complementary and alternative medicine. So all of these things I think they have their problems and limitations because they set this up as a category that is um not real medicine. Like by adding that adjective, uh it separates it from whatever you think of as mainstream medicine or real medicine, maybe.
SPEAKER_04So there's always a little bit of uh othering happening with that label.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so so like what if you know where when we think about medicines like uh stories about how to cure hiccups, for example, or hangovers, um, where would those fall in the in the spectrum of uh conventional medicine to uh tr quote unquote traditional medicine? Um because even you know, even even Western culture comes with uh a lot of like folk remedy ideas, right? Like drink drink a bloody Mary after I had to cure cure a hangover.
SPEAKER_04Okay, I wouldn't call that Western medicine.
SPEAKER_02It's the best of modern science. But you know, like there's a lot of folk ideas about what counts as medicine.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um and I guess that really blurs the line between what we conventionally see as traditional medicine and what we call like Western um medicine or science.
SPEAKER_04Um yeah. So I would say the labels are always imperfect. Um I'm trying to separate out this notion of what counts as a medical practice to begin with, with um the notion of what counts as a traditional medicine. Um what you mentioned earlier there, like um, drinking a bloody Mary for a hangover or cures for hiccups, I would say that that's generally just not medical. That's like folk practices that might be relate to your health, but they're not addressing a particular medical problem, right?
SPEAKER_02I don't think it fixes me.
SPEAKER_04Okay. Yeah, you know what? You convinced me.
SPEAKER_05Using that, I could just say that's not what bars.
SPEAKER_04James is a doctor, you know.
unknownNo, yeah.
SPEAKER_05I have a question. Um, I think that, you know, all of this discussion about labels um got me thinking, are they important to have these sorts of labels? Do they have any meaning? Like, are is traditional medicine regulated differently? Do you get more subsidies for one than the other? Like, what is important about giving it a very specific label?
SPEAKER_04So this we can continue talking about the the category of tradition, right? So a claim to tradition is a claim to often like uh an ancient ancestry or um cultural importance sometimes. And um there's something interesting within the study of these tr practices, is uh to question how traditional they are, in fact. So what people now think of as traditional Chinese medicine, if you go to a uh acupuncture clinic, uh, you go to someone who has a degree in traditional Chinese medicine, um, the stuff that they learn and practice was uh codified by Mao.
SPEAKER_04Um and it comes from earlier practices that were folk traditions in China, but he uh sort of sifted it through and standardized it for um the Chinese state. So and then he used it as a way to um export that across the world as a kind of soft power uh outreach for for China. Um so that's what people think of are or that's the kind of TCM that you will encounter. It's it has uh roots at least that far back.
SPEAKER_04Um how similar it is to earlier versions is kind of up for debate. I think you can see that um it some of the practices have long histories, others don't. And it's a living practice as well, so it keeps developing and changing.
SPEAKER_05Thank you. Um I was wondering uh there's mixed evidence about the effectiveness of um different traditional Chinese medicine treatments. So how do we go about moving through this space? If some work, some don't, how are we supposed to know which ones work? Um and why should we take traditional Chinese medicine seriously given the uncertainty of the evidence?
SPEAKER_04Okay. So in the work that I've been doing with this, um I think it's important to try to understand tr traditional Chinese medicine and other traditional medicines on their own terms. So um to see what counts as effective, you have to know what the goals of the practice are. And TCM many of the treatments that it would prescribe don't map onto any um analogous Western medical condition. So um, I mean, a lot of TCM remedies or things like that are not even addressing a illness in particular.
SPEAKER_04They might be aimed at longevity or clarifying your qi or making you overall um more healthy, something like a holistic sense of health. Um so there there isn't a necessarily a concrete problem that they're trying to fix or overcome. Um but of course, this depends on which thing you're talking about. That's why I think you asked the question well to say which treatments have uh evidence for efficacy and which don't. Because um there have been some remedies from TCM uh that have been shown to be effective for diseases that Western medicine also recognizes, like malaria.
SPEAKER_04Um I can't remember her name right now, but someone won a Nobel Prize a while ago for um proving the efficacy of this herb called artemizanin uh against malaria. And that uh knowledge came from TCM originally, from the old texts and old remedies.
SPEAKER_05That's fascinating. Um I actually didn't know that about malaria. That's so exciting.
SPEAKER_02You said that it's important to take um certain traditions and certain practices or set of practices um on their own terms, right? Uh I'm just worried that this might be a bit too permissive because it it could kind of like create uh justification for almost anything. Uh for example, maybe slightly controversially, uh take something like astrology. Sorry to all the astrology fans out there. Um, if if we assess it uh quote unquote on its own terms, we might find that it's really successful at uh doing whatever it seems to try to be setting out to achieve.
SPEAKER_02So um I'm wondering if there's anything we can say to to, I guess, up the rigor a little bit.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so other another good question. Um so I think this comes down to what do we mean by taking traditional medicines seriously? And um that doesn't have to mean that we treat them as though they are facts. Um I think one of the things that's important to me is to look for respectful engagement with the people who take these things seriously. So um medicine is a I mean, there's various ways of defining it. You can define it as an applied science, that's a popular um way of thinking about it.
SPEAKER_04It's also a profession, a social institution, and I like to think of it as a relationship. So there's people involved, right? There's patients and doctors, and you want to look after their health if that's the goal of medicine, and that must involve respect for them. So in taking traditional medicine seriously, I don't think it means that we have to treat it as though it's all factual. Uh, I think that you want to um try to meet people where they're at. Um, at least so one of the reasons that got me into this is realizing that traditional medicines are very commonly engaged with in places like Singapore.
SPEAKER_04So something like 45% of people might um have engaged in TCM within the past year. But they often don't disclose this to their Western medical doctors when they see them. And part of that is that they're afraid of being shamed or scolded because those practices are kind of seen as maybe backward or traditional, whereas Western medicine is seen as modern and um progressive or uh, you know, has a kind of prestige and authority that they feel like uh doesn't gel with their traditional values.
SPEAKER_04So um I think that's a a barrier that needs to be overcome. And with more respectful engagement, you can um have a more real meeting of minds between patients and practitioners and Western medical professionals as well.
SPEAKER_05I like what you said about uh respecting TCM on its own terms and recognizing that perhaps the goals of TCM don't always match up with the goals of Western medicine, and that's okay. People can have their own values and see their bodies in the ways that they wish to. However, I think that that's you know fairly justifiable when it doesn't cause harm to the person's body. Um I don't I'm not familiar with teas and herbs, so maybe like consuming them really doesn't actually affect any or track any physiological changes to the body, but the person derives value from it nonetheless.
SPEAKER_05What happens though when you know certain t practices are actually harmful to the person? Should we be regulating that, even though we're saying we should match it on its own terms?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I mean that's a good line to draw, I think, is the harm to people. Um, and I think again, engaging seriously with traditional medicines can facilitate that. Um, you have to look at what they're actually prescribing before you can tell if any of that might actually be harmful or dangerous to people. Um so I do think that's important. I think harm is an important uh line to draw in the sand. Um so if things are non-harmful and important to people, but not necessarily proven to be effective, I think people should be allowed to choose them.
SPEAKER_04Um I think there's a little bit more to say about that line of harm, though, because really hardline uh skeptics about traditional medicines or anti-traditional alternative practices um people would say that it's all harmful because it's all opportunity cost. If you uh are spending money, then you're being harmed, essentially. If you're going to give your money to the acupuncturist and it's not really doing anything for you, then that's still a harm. Um I wouldn't draw the line there because I think people can derive value beyond uh just like a clinically measurable um outcome.
SPEAKER_04So sometimes uh I think actually a lot of medicine, even Western medicine, uh can be somewhat placebo. And so like if you're gonna say that you can't do that in traditional medicine and that's a harm, then you're gonna have to find a lot more practices in Western medicine and weed them out too. And actually, in my opinion, placebo's not that bad. Like, sometimes maybe I do need a placebo. If I feel better, that's what matters to me.
SPEAKER_04So if all I needed was you to um put some needles in me and hold my hand for an hour, you know, like maybe that's that's good.
SPEAKER_02So we have you on the record as saying it's good to just deceive yourself sometimes.
SPEAKER_01Sometimes.
SPEAKER_02As long as it makes you feel good. What about trickier cases? For example, if if there's a risk that if we know that some treatment is is not harmful, but there's a risk that some people will take that treatment and and in the place of uh effective treatment. For example, somebody saying, Oh, I don't need a vaccine because I'm already like um sniffing crystals or something. Okay.
SPEAKER_04Deciding.
SPEAKER_02Um by crystals I mean um quartz.
SPEAKER_04Quartz specifically. James knows his crystals. Yes. Um okay, so on that note, you s you chose the vaccine example. So the the obvious response would be like if you're putting other people at risk, then that shouldn't necessarily be indulged. It depends on what the risk is that you're exposing people to. Um, if you say I'd rather uh ward off the flu with my quartz, you know, and not get the flu shot this year, I think that's something you're allowed to decide. Um if it's, you know, a pandemic and you would rather treat it with crystals, maybe the calculus is different.
SPEAKER_05I mean, we often let patients prioritize other values outside their the traditional scope of what we see as health or in the Western view of what health means. You know, we allow patients to choose religion over health and to decline blood transfusions over reasons of faith. So I think that it's fair. Like if a patient wants to pursue traditional Chinese medicine because that has greater value to them than what Western medicine says.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05And I think you have a good point.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So the I mean, that's why the vaccine case was a little bit more um complicated, because if you're putting other people at risk, then you might not be um permitted to do that in the same way as like putting yourself at risk. People do that all the time. And if as long as we think that you're a competent adult, um we have to respect that. You know, to respect autonomy means you respect people's choices to sometimes make or decisions to make sometimes ill-informed choices or choices that you disagree with.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So it seems like there's definitely a bit of a a spectrum in which we can put different uh specific kinds of treatment. On one hand, we have things that uh we can prove have at least some positive effect. Um on the other hand, there are things that might be uh downright harmful. And in the middle, you have things with that that may be doing something and maybe a placebo or something like that. So if I'm interested in uh uh in traditional medicine or TCM, how do I navigate how how can how how can I navigate this this sort of um landscape uh given that um the standards of just looking at scientific journals and all that don't seem to uh quite apply as easily.
SPEAKER_04Um so you're you're wondering how to navigate the realm of traditional medicines when you can't rely on scientific journal articles, is it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Uh okay. So I mean that's presuming that you're already someone who's interested in using and consume consuming uh a traditional medicine.
SPEAKER_02If I'm not interested, then it's not an issue.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Um so I mean, I I have used TCM. Um I have found it to be helpful, and I would admit to myself that some of that might be placebo. Um it could be. I don't know. I don't know what the causal uh relationship is between the herbs that I might take uh or that they might recommend and whatever's happening. But sometimes it does help to just go and and talk to somebody. And um, so one of the things that I like about TCM is the uh sort of difference in the epistemic landscape between doctor and patient.
SPEAKER_04Um so for anyone out there who has like a chronic condition that they might have to go in to uh see a medical professional often, um, you might have experienced um a feeling of disempowerment when you go to see a Western-style doctor. There's a lot about the style of delivery of Western medicine that is um set up in the in what we'd call an epistemically opaque way. Uh it's not clear to you as a patient uh what all these machines do, uh, what all the chemical interactions might be with the drugs.
SPEAKER_04Um someone could explain that to you, but will you understand? I don't. I have a PhD in philosophy, I still don't understand these things. Um there's a lot of feeling of vulnerability, and I mean we call patients patients. It's sort of a passive role to be placed in. What I as a patient have liked about TCM is the feeling of a lot more epistemic empowerment. And this is um very different from saying that like I know that these treatments are factually correct or map onto a concrete real condition.
SPEAKER_04But if my TCM doctor says, oh, you have spleen qi deficiency, and you know what? Spleen qi is orange and you should eat orange things, that's very accessible to me. Like I know what to do. And that feeling of empowerment is helpful itself.
SPEAKER_02It could be empowering but worrying, right? Like I feel like if I understand it, yeah, it's so simple that I can understand it, it must be something wrong.
SPEAKER_04So that's an interesting thing though, because I I've also heard I've talked to some people who are um anthropologists of medicine. And so they study TCM and other traditional medicines, and sometimes outside of the mainstream, like in the villages in China, and um they would report something very different than my experience. So my experience is that I like this feeling of empowerment. So yeah, uh I like learning about the way that TCM approaches health because it feels very intuitive to me. Like, okay, I I feel this today, so I'm gonna eat something green, um, something like that.
SPEAKER_04Or I feel heaty, so I need to eat something cooling. Um, but that's not always what people want. Sometimes people do want to be sort of Bowled over with the magic and the mystery of it. And the less they understand, the better. Because then that means it's really powerful.
SPEAKER_05I would like to offer an alternate interpretation. And I've seen I've I've seen studies which show that patients you're right, patients are vulnerable. They are sick and they do not lack, they do not have the knowledge to treat themselves or to know what's going on with them or to navigate the different medicines out there themselves. And there are there's like the feminist interpretation which says that just because someone is vulnerable doesn't mean they lack autonomy. Um it's okay to be dependent on someone else for their help. And I do I do respect though that that there is that feeling of empowerment and that it can come in different ways.
SPEAKER_05So you lack the empowerment of the the simple explanation that you can do it every day, you you have that knowledge. Um and I think that maybe what we need to move forward to is a better compromise in potentially Western medicine. So both withholding, you know, overbearing information that the patient does not need to know, but giving them just the little bits that they actually could use in their daily life. But yeah, I'm just asking for a system overhaul, nothing, you know, nothing big. But with that, I was wondering if patients uh consent to this treatment for which there is, you know, no evidential explanation.
SPEAKER_05It's more of just a what what you said, spleen she. You are lacking orange and therefore you need to take orange. Do you think that patients can actually consent to this sort of treatment if there is no evidence that it works?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Um, in my opinion, yes. Simple answer. So um I think that I guess one of the differences or um nuances there is there's knowing that and um knowing how, or there's there's maybe that's not the best uh way of putting that, but um, I might not understand why, but I can understand that. You know, I don't understand why aspirin makes me feel better. I don't need to. When I have a headache, I take aspirin, I feel better.
SPEAKER_05Excellent. Perfect. Moving on.
SPEAKER_02We're very critical here. We we subject ideas to rigorous interrogation. Yes. Like, thank you. Okay. Well, I guess um there this is tradition uh in standard medicine that uh consent has to be informed to a certain extent, right? Um and and yeah, it's true to some extent that um we don't need to know everything about something uh in order to provide informed consent. I don't need to know how aspirin works to um uh to to to be able to consent to it.
SPEAKER_02But we might say, well, at least there's this idea that it's been tested. Uh at least in Western uh medicine, something's been tested. Uh a lot of scientists would readily back this up, and that might be something that can can affect my informed consent, maybe. And that I I can I can think about that and be like, oh, you know what, even though I don't know how this works, I know that a bunch of people would be willing to put their careers on the line to say that this works. Um can we apply that to traditional medicine?
SPEAKER_04I think you can. Um so I think trying to say that it's all about informed consent or patient autonomy, those are very um liberal bioethics words. Um but if you think about it maybe more abstractly or more like in fundamental concepts, what you need is trust and sorry, I bumped the mic. Uh yeah, you you want uh to give consent or or you give consent to things that you trust and believe, right?
SPEAKER_04So um I think the fact that TCM practitioners are um, you know, they earn degrees to do what they do. Um there is some sort of professional vetting that happens. There's a community of people. There are legal regulations. If they give you something that, you know, hurts you, they can be held accountable. Um so you might not understand the the theoretical mechanism or um causality behind why a certain root or tea should fix your stomach ulcer or something, but you can understand that they would be held responsible if if it didn't or if it harmed you.
SPEAKER_04And I think so those things affect that relationship. Um yeah, I think that that can be sufficient for um trusting situation.
SPEAKER_05That was a really great answer. We have one final question for you. So, could Western medicine learn anything from the practice of TCM? Yes. No further question.
SPEAKER_04Yes. Well, I mean, in many ways. So, I mean, like I said before, there was already that um discovery about artemisinin, right? So there are some um some traditional Chinese remedies that would stand up to scientific rigor. So sometimes that happens. Other times it might be vague, maybe the f the effect is really just placebo. But I think even there, going back to the epistemic relationship or dynamics between uh doctors and patients, I think one of the reasons that people tend to go to traditional medical practitioners is because of the intimacy that they experience and the feeling of care.
SPEAKER_04Um, so there's a lot of strains on Western medicine that I I don't want to like say that doctors are at fault for this because sometimes it's the system that just the way it's structured, they don't have a lot of time to spend with patients. So it's kind of like a factory-lined system. If you're a doctor, you um have a really long day of meeting with patients and you get to spend maybe five, 10 minutes uh with them, and then you have to move them along. And um, if you take an hour to talk to them about their lives, uh, you're just not gonna get to see that many people and there's limited resources.
SPEAKER_04But that's why people go to the TCM doctor instead, because they do have that time. And um, I mean, we uh had a colleague come out for one of these papers that we're working on related to this, and he interviewed um a bunch of TCM doctors and a bunch of Western medical doctors about their their habits and how they try to establish trust with um patients. And one of the things that stuck in my mind is that um with Western medicine, patients feel this very transactional relationship.
SPEAKER_04Um they go to the TCM clinic, they go out for hot pot afterward. So like it's really different. And that kind of human, the human side of things uh is something that Western medicine has uh fallen a little bit behind with, I think.
SPEAKER_05Is that hot pot after every patient?
SPEAKER_03That would be a lot of hot pot.
SPEAKER_05Should I become a TCM doctor?
SPEAKER_02I also don't know if I want to go out and for a hot pot with somebody who's like seen my x-ray. Who's seeing your insides? Yeah, who's seeing my insides. I think I feel a little vulnerable.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Would you feel less vulnerable after a hot pot, though?
SPEAKER_05Based on how I cry when I eat a hot pot, yes.
SPEAKER_01Less vulnerable.
SPEAKER_05No, no, no. Incredibly vulnerable while eating while a hot pot. I could not stand up to anyone. I'm weak.
SPEAKER_02Final, final question. So, as somebody who uh is an expert on philosophy and TCM, you clearly know a lot about qi. So, how do I get to the point where I can run on top of the trees like wind?
SPEAKER_04Well, you have to cultivate it for like a thousand years at least.
unknownOh.
SPEAKER_02We don't have that long.
SPEAKER_04But if you start now, preserve your tea. Well, you know, some of the there actually are um, there actually are people who can run at the top of shit.
SPEAKER_03There actually are people who say that they can help you get there. Um there's like, I don't know.
SPEAKER_04I've met too many uh TCM practitioners, I guess.
SPEAKER_02And should I trust them?
SPEAKER_04Well, you know, this is one of those untestable hypnosis.
SPEAKER_03Like maybe they are out there.
SPEAKER_02But like like you don't believe hard enough.
SPEAKER_03Like, I'm not gonna be around in a thousand years to like test this. So our reputation is not on the line.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Thank you so much. I really enjoyed this chat. I feel like I've learnt a lot. Um, you had some great answers. Thank you so much for coming on the pod. Thank you.
SPEAKER_04Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and U and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...