Sticky & Icky: Trusting Your Moral Gut with Brandon Yip
45 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail In this episode, James and Sinead ask Dr. Brandon Yip (Singapore Management University) whether the instinctive 'yuck' that we respond to some things is a reliable tool for evaluating moral judgements. Brendan considers the sticky and icky situations, like relationship age gaps, and asks whether we can really trust our emotions and instincts to guide our responses. As always, James and Sinead fight over which karaoke is best (at what point is the podcast just a conduit for curating a top tier karaoke list), but most importantly, we learn when and how to control our moral gut. Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, C BME and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_03Welcome back to CBMENU, a podcast about biomedical ethics. Today we talk about disgust. Does it play a role in bioethics? Can it tell us anything about controversial practices like cloning? And why is deep dish pizza so gross? Joining us today is Brandon Yip, assistant professor of philosophy at the Singapore Management University School of Social Sciences. Welcome, Brandon. Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_04I always love it when we like throw it to them straight away and they're like, thanks.
SPEAKER_03It's like, wait a minute. Saying thanks is not a part of the script. You didn't send me this. Next time we'll put it in. We'll be like, uh, Brandon or guest, thanks.
SPEAKER_04Welcome, Brandon. Um, first question for you coffee or coffee?
SPEAKER_01Um, yeah, so that's a that's a great. I'm not sure if it's a great question, actually, but uh it's irrelevant.
SPEAKER_03Um actually not much.
SPEAKER_01I'm not really I like I enjoy the taste of coffee, but it's not that it's not, I know many people like they need coffee every day. I'm not that sort of person. Um and I think my tastes are pretty basic. I usually I'm okay with anything, like as long as there's lots of milk in it. So a kopi see or a latte would be fine. I mean there are some standards, right? I think I wouldn't take anything worse than like Yakun for Kopi. Um yeah, like I wouldn't get kopi from the food court. What do you think of the cappuccino? I don't usually drink a cappuccino. I think it's a perfect answer.
SPEAKER_04Again, you're wrong. So would you classify yourself as a latte girly then?
SPEAKER_01Maybe.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I don't know.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Episode out of disgust with latte girly.
SPEAKER_03I don't think he has a negative opinion towards cappuccinos.
SPEAKER_04Well, he just said he doesn't drink them.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I usually drink lattes.
SPEAKER_04You know the difference between a cappuccino and a latte.
SPEAKER_01Well, not precisely. I know I only noted a latte has more milk than a cappuccino.
SPEAKER_04Well, that's more than what you knew, so that's okay. We're good.
SPEAKER_01I knew that.
SPEAKER_04Uh James, James thinks I'm a bit of a coffee snob. I just think he just he told me the story once, which is that when he went out to have coffee for the very first time, the person in front of him ordered a cappuccino, and so he went with that and he's stuck with it ever since. And I think that's irrational.
SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah. Well, I mean, I've met real coffee snobs. They would not drink coffee of any kind of milk in it at all. It's usually like the oh, you know why.
SPEAKER_03Okay, fine, you're snob-bish.
SPEAKER_04Alright, alright. Uh, what country would you like to travel to next?
SPEAKER_01Right. Uh, great question again. I have uh very basic tastes. So actually, like my wife, Yushu and I have been talking about going to Japan actually for the last five years.
SPEAKER_03Knew it. And um, first guess.
SPEAKER_01Well, there was COVID, and then we had a kid, so that like traveling has been made a bit difficult, but we're actually finally going there at the end of the year, so I'm really looking forward to that.
SPEAKER_04Oh, how exciting!
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's uh it's uh it's just a nice place with great food. I enjoy the food there, it's clean and I think it's they're great things to see as well.
SPEAKER_04Oh yeah, yeah, yeah. And finally, what's your go-to karaoke song?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so actually I've been to karaoke with James, so yeah. Yeah, we have done karaoke together. So you might know my tastes, but it's kind of strange. I actually enjoy like singing old Disney songs. Yes, all right, let's go. I'm more of a of a of a ballad guy, so if I had to pick, I'd say like um part of your world from the little moment. Excellent. Yeah, very good.
SPEAKER_04How do we feel about I'll make a man out of you? Is that up there in top three?
SPEAKER_01What's not a ballad?
SPEAKER_04How do we define a ballad? You know what? That's a different podcast.
SPEAKER_03I think it's like like slow-ish and also very emotional.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's right. Um I mean it's a fun song for sure.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. What other ballads in Disney are there?
SPEAKER_01Um, I can show you the world.
SPEAKER_04Oh love ballads.
SPEAKER_03Uh yeah, reflections. Oh, yeah, reflection. No, I like that.
SPEAKER_04Reflections is a banger.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. I've also heard you sing colors of the wind. That also comes as a bag, yeah, although it's not about romance. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Let's do that. Let's go out for karaoke and start with colors of the wind. It's been too long for me.
SPEAKER_03Right. It has not for me.
SPEAKER_04Oh, we know.
SPEAKER_03It's almost like a bi-weekly activity. Anyway. Okay, let's talk about disgust. Now, um, so we both know that uh we all know that you're very interested in uh disgust and what it has to do what disgust has to do with morality, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Um now this is interesting because the most obvious feeling of disgust is that kind of physical sensation that we get when confronted with something disgusting, something gross, like you know, seeing somebody vomit or seeing like uh poop in the wrong place. Yeah. Uh so what does this have to do with morality? Isn't disgustingness just disgustingness?
SPEAKER_01I should say being a father, and I guess I think there are some empirical studies, but when you do get a kid, your disgust sensitivity actually goes down because you have to deal with poop so much. But anyway, I think that's a great question. So I should say that in my in my in my work, I do draw a distinction between two forms of revulsion, um, what's often called core disgust and moral disgust, mainly focus on moral disgust. But I think before turning to moral disgust, I think it's worth noticing that even core disgust is actually more entangled in the social world than we might first assume. So I think here's a here's a fun little experiment that the listeners can try.
SPEAKER_01So spit into a glass. He brought experiments, and then try to swallow the spit back. I think most people find that disgusting.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, cannot.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. But with a straw. Oh, it's even better if it's straw. So it might lead you to think that you know, disgust tracks these simple physical boundaries, like inside versus outside. But now, again, you can imagine, or again, if you could try if you if you're in the right position at home, you can try kissing your romantic partner, having some of the saliva enter your mouth. Most people find that feels entirely different. Most wouldn't find it disgusting, many find it pleasurable. I think it suggests that the boundaries that core disgust responds to are not simple physical boundaries, but social ones, right?
SPEAKER_01Social categories of what's inside and outside. In fact, there's a recent paper in the journal Science, um, which is a famous journal just to boost my condition. I'm not just like, yes, I know the journal science.
SPEAKER_03So it's it about is it science. Wow.
SPEAKER_01Right. So in this paper, it shows that actually young children infer social relationships between people based on whether they share saliva or not, um, true food or utensils. Um I mean, just think about your own attitudes to people sharing food, right? Like um among family or friends, no one really bats an eyelid. But if a stranger comes to eat your leftovers, I think most people find that repulsive, disgusting. Um, even core disgust, I think, polices social boundaries, not merely physical ones. Uh but as I said, my main focus is on moral disgust. Um, I studies phenomenology, what it feels like, and I try to examine paradigm cases of moral disgust to make sense of the emotion and try to give their argument that moral disgust really alerts us to actions that undermine the normative structures that we value.
SPEAKER_01Um so I'll just give a bit of example, right? So I guess to make that clear, think about playing a game of football, there's some players, you know, they suddenly start picking up the ball of their hands and fooling around. Some sense in which the practice breaks down. Even if I follow the rules, my actions no longer count as playing football in any meaningful sense. So there's a shared structure that gives our actions meaning that sorry, this this shared structure is under mind. I think in the same way, our social lives really rely rely on shared norms, ideals of mutual respect, certain forms of hierarchies, civic or religious values. And these structures are fragile.
SPEAKER_01They can come apart. They exist because we continue to uphold them and they can be corroded by certain actions. And I think when someone is attuned to a particular social order and sees it threatened, uh more disgust can arise in response. I think that's what more disgust in particular has to do with morality.
SPEAKER_04I like your um distinction between what I I would have thought to just be physical disgust, which is just vomit is gross generally. Yeah. But yeah, I think I think it also applies to like your home toilet versus a public toilet. Yeah. Like I will hold it so that I can go home and use my own toilet. Yeah. And I share the toilet with my husband. And it's not like we share the same germs.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um, but I'm so much more likely to share my toilet with him because I just know him, even though it's not, you know, biologically true that his germs are safer than some other strangers' germs.
SPEAKER_03That's right.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. That actually makes a lot of sense. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So just to, I guess, get our intuitions up and running. Yeah. Right. Could could you give examples of uh certain kinds of moral transgressions which would create this kind of disgust, feelings of disgust, versus just, I guess, run-of-the-mill other transgressions which wouldn't create disgust?
SPEAKER_01Right. So, I mean, one way to answer that question is um by giving sort of pure cases of moral disgust where it's a bit tricky because these two often run together. I mean, like, think about the creep or you know, the person who goes around like the molester or something, or someone goes around taking up skirts. Um, I don't know why there are apparently lots of these in Singapore. I think these people, you could see that they are both like physically repulsive in some ways. I guess they do something that is associated with what's usually like physical contaminants.
SPEAKER_01Um, they I think they are morally repulsive as well. I think they are there could be pure cases. So um there's a study um on so sorry, betrayal, I think, is one of those things that could you could think of as a pure moral case in the way in the sense that there's not that there doesn't seem to be any of the usual physical revulsion type elicitors. And there's a study also in science, the journalists. He's hand dropping everybody. Yes, um where basically they they had like subjects play what's called an ultimatum game.
SPEAKER_01It's a sort of cooperative game where you can get betrayed, and when they receive unfair offers, they hook them up on the MRI and everything. Maybe it wasn't MRI, but somehow they looked at their neurosignatures, and it does actually track what's what's like what usually goes on when in core disgust. So there's a kind of disgust that is directed at like moral um type phenomena. I can give a couple examples of what I think are more discussed as well, like more the contemporary ones. And so here's here's a recent example that I found. So, I mean, most of you have seen that um that scene in the White House where Truman Vance ambushed Zelensky.
SPEAKER_01Um actually David Brooks made this comment. I actually um noted it down so I could use it here. And he actually said, I was nauseated, just nauseated. All my life had a certain idea of America that we're a flawed country, but we're fundamentally a force for good in the world. Again, I you could question that, but that's what he thinks. And then he says he believes that might might make right. Trump and Putin together are trying to create a world that's safe for gangsters where ruthless people can thrive. Now, whatever you think about that vision of America, I think the quote is quite clear about what Brooks is worried about, right? Not that Trump is doing something wrong or disrespectful, but that he's nauseated because he believes that Trump is corroding and staining a certain normative order centered around particular ideals of American civility and global beneficence.
SPEAKER_01And of course, since we're in a bioethics podcast, there's this very famous article by Leon Kass titled The Wisdom of Repugnance, where he appeals to this moral disgust towards cloning as a source of insight into its wrongness. Kass seems to cast disgust as a sort of mysterious source of revelation. I wouldn't go that far, but I do think that moral disgust carries a certain wisdom. I think if you look at his arguments, again, his worry is that human cloning serves to undermine a particular way of structuring society built around certain practices of child rearing. So yeah, I think that those are some cases of moral disgust.
SPEAKER_04I have a question. And so I'm gonna start off with an example, which is that you know, sometimes you have a friend and you know, they might be like 20 or 21 of legal age.
SPEAKER_03For the for the for the listeners, she's pointing to me at for some reason. I am not 20 or 21.
SPEAKER_04And how old are you?
SPEAKER_03400. Anyway. 400.
SPEAKER_04It's his 401st birthday on Friday. So we're actually very clear. Yeah, yeah. Going off a prawns.
SPEAKER_03Well, 400 was a big one. 401, no big one. Yeah, that's just karaoke. Right. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04No celebration at MBS. Anyway, so so you know, you know, when you hear those stories of like a 20-year-old that starts dating like a 50-year-old. Yeah. Um, and you know, like it's their legal age, they're consenting. And it just it feels icky. But then, but then, you know, um, you know, there's this like sort of phenomena, I think, in in the sisterhood, which is that you want to support your sisters or your or your girls, yeah, sort of doing uh, you know, what it is they do. Again, she's still pointing James, my notorious sisterhood.
SPEAKER_04And so sometimes I also find myself, you know, like my a friend might make a quest questionable sexual choice. Yeah. And you're like, you know what, girl? It's called you do you. And I've termed this you do you ethics, which is where sometimes you'll just sort of excuse your friends from doing things that you would judge other people for. You find it gross and icky. But when they do it, you're like, yeah, no, you you go, girl. Like you get that, you do what you want. And so it's what I'm trying to pull out there, though, is that it seems a bit relative. Like my disgust at some random stranger or some random 20-year-old dating like a 50 or a 60-year-old, is which doesn't arise when my friend does it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Like it seems a bit relative and subjective. So then how can we draw moral principles or like universal principles about how reliable disgust is in in guiding our intuitions?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I guess one question to ask is um, I guess there are a couple of lots of questions asked.
SPEAKER_02Obviously, me too.
SPEAKER_01Um, I guess one is so do you actually feel the disgust towards what your friend's doing, or is it like you don't feel disgust towards what your friend's doing, but you feel it when someone else is doing it?
SPEAKER_04I honestly don't think I feel disgust. I think it's more like empowering. Like you go girl. Yeah, you know what? Like society says you can't do this, but you're gonna do what you want because you know, society has held women back for so long, and you can make your choice, and I'm not gonna judge you because I'm a feminist. And then when a stranger does it, I'm like, ugh.
SPEAKER_01Right. I mean, I guess all sorts of things can be going on as to it to what explains. I mean, so the second I guess the second question is whether you're you're actually feeling moral disgust or some other kind of disgust, like core disgust. I guess I I don't know, I think like someone once told me that uh they found age-gap relationships disgusting in in any case. Um and I think it's interesting. I think age cap relationships are again, I think there are certainly benign cases of that. I think it can get problematic because it's age usually implicated with like power and hierarchy and so on.
SPEAKER_04So maybe we change the example to like a 30, a 35-year-old and like a 70-year-old.
SPEAKER_01A 35-year-old and a 70-year-old.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Um you know where there's less concerns about consent, because they're still quite young.
SPEAKER_01Which is the guy?
SPEAKER_04Uh or yeah, at some point. Yeah, I feel like we're getting really specific.
SPEAKER_01Um, but I think that matters because I I I have the sense that our discussion might be tracking something moral and it's tracking these like problematic power dynamics that could be going on in the world.
SPEAKER_04Let's invert it and let's make the woman the older one.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Would you find that disgusting? No, I'm putting you on the spot, but probably not. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, no, you're right. I I wouldn't. Once again, I'd say that you go gal. Women in male-dominated fields.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so being old. I do think that look, I do think that, I mean, just it's a bit weird as a guy saying, but obviously, women could abuse their positions of power as well. Yes. I mean, I think that would like persisted Vita Ronell case, I think, in philosophy a while back. So, but not normally that's not the case. Um so I do think that we are so I mean I think that's interesting, right? It does suggest that our sense of disgust is sensitive to more complex factors than just icky age gap, something simplistic. There are all these sorts of factors that we are taking into account. And I think I think I share the same intuitions as you.
SPEAKER_01I wouldn't find it as disgusting if it's a 70-year-old woman and a 35-year-old man. Actually, that's like uh Emmanuel Macron, right? Isn't it? I don't think that's I don't think the Okay, okay. I know I know it's like 70 and 35, but it's the French president. It's the French president.
SPEAKER_04His wife is 70?
SPEAKER_01Okay, his wife is not 70.
SPEAKER_03How old is he? Is it really uh well I I don't know how no, not older than 70. She's just older than him, quite by quite a bit. Okay. And I think they started dating.
SPEAKER_01Well, okay, there are more complications there because he she was his teacher. She was his she was his high school teacher. Yeah, so there could be a power imbalance there as well. But obviously he's a he's the president of the French Republic right now. Like there's no there's no sense in which there's any more power imbalance. So like I don't think that's yeah, I wouldn't find that.
SPEAKER_04So do you think then that our emotions, like like discuss, do track reliable intuitions?
SPEAKER_01Um, so I do think so I guess here's what they I I say, which is that the way I think about moral discuss is that it tracks um infractions on like the novelty structures we care about. But which novelty structures we care about can vary depending on what sort of our brain, what sort of convictions you have. Um and that explains the variety. So I think it's an important like piece of information as to when certain sorts of actions uh might compromise the knowledge structure you care about. But you still have to ask the question, I guess, like is this something I should care about?
SPEAKER_01It opens up the space for reflection. Uh, but um yeah, you might not always want to take it a face value, I guess.
SPEAKER_03You you are throwing about a fancy term here, and it's normative structure. Sorry. Uh can you break that down for us? Because we we uh we kind of know what normative claims are. This is just like claims about what we should and shouldn't do. So is that what you mean by normative structure, or are you talking about something else?
SPEAKER_01Right. So I mean something more like social norms. Norm. So I mean the simplest way to think about is that like norms of etiquette. That's what normative structure. We take certain things for granted. Um, I used a game example earlier. Um, that when we play, what was the example of sport? I used soccer, I think. Maybe it was basketball.
SPEAKER_03So sports ball.
SPEAKER_01Actually, I think I said football.
SPEAKER_04Um by which I mean soccer because we're in Oh no, I I thought footy.
SPEAKER_01Right, yeah, no, I mean soccer. That's what I had in mind.
SPEAKER_04We've cleared up a lot of things. Like we don't know sports.
SPEAKER_01I'm a sports guy. Um yeah, so there's some sense in which like because of the motivational sets of the players and everything, and because of like certain sorts of public rules, like that's these norms are in force. So I say when I talk about norm destruction, I mean some like something like operative norms, the way things are done around here, uh, the way we actually structure our societies. And that can of course come apart from um maybe aspirational norms. So for example, I guess vegetarians um they hope that there'd be less meat meat eating.
SPEAKER_01So in some sense, they take that as a norm. But it's obviously not the operative normative structure. Certainly not in in most in Singapore, where almost everyone is omnivorous. Um so I'd say the normative structure of like vegetarianism doesn't hold here. It's like more omnivorous here. And yeah, so I think that's what I mean by normative structure. I don't mean uh uh what we should do or what we shouldn't do, but what's taken to be the way the way things are done um in a certain group or society.
SPEAKER_03Okay, so this does sound pretty broad. So are you saying that any act which kind of violates uh any of the norms held by society at large is something that can be considered disgusting?
SPEAKER_01Um so I think that's a great question. Um I guess there are two things I want to say to that. Uh first, obviously not we might not accept all the norms that are operative in society. As I said, it's the ones that we care about. You might think there are certain ways that society structures ourselves that you find regrettable, in which case you actually rejoice uh when people do things that transgress those norms. I have this point in the paper that even if you think that moral discuss tracks like only the worst sorts of normative structures, it's so important to pay attention because that gives you a clue on how to destroy the normative structures you don't like.
SPEAKER_01I mean, you can be you think about why so so many like liberation movements they seem to do a lot of transgressive stuff. Or it's maybe it's because they're onto something. I guess the other thing to say, and and this is a point that it's a bit more subtle, but I don't think every norm-violation, even if the norm is something that you care about, is morally disgusting. Um I think it has to be a sort of non-violation that somehow like undermines the structure in a deeper, more contaminating way. I mean, just to give you a couple of uh like give you one example, like so strategic fouls in basketball, for example.
SPEAKER_04I mean that's hold on, hold on. Do you know what these are, James?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, a strategic foul is is a foul that's strategic.
SPEAKER_04Anyway, back to you, Brendan.
SPEAKER_01Right, so should I sleep with strategic fouls?
SPEAKER_04He has no idea.
SPEAKER_01I'm sure he has some idea.
SPEAKER_03He's just look, I you can kind of put it together by what it is. Right, by the term, right? Yeah. Like you know what a foul is, and then a strategic foul is a foul that you do to uh get something else done.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so you violate the norms because you want to obtain some kind of strategic advantage, just off the time, for example, in basketball. Um so those are norm violations. I think we do want those norms there, but most people don't really ban eyelid. There's a penalty that's stitched out. Um that's about it.
SPEAKER_04No, it's how you consider unsportsman-like.
SPEAKER_01So I think that's the interesting part, right? I think in certain games, they are considered unsportsman-like, but whereas in others, so this is what I talk again. I I should say I'm not really that much of a sports person myself, but I think this is an easy way to look at the example. So I'm told that in basketball, strategic files are completely fine. Almost it's it's quite broadly accepted. Uh, but my sense is that in in soccer, um, people are really unhappy whenever someone tries to do a strategic foul.
SPEAKER_04Um like we used to get told in basketball, particularly at like champ schools and stuff, that like towards the end to run out the clock, you would intentionally foul them because they're less likely to make the free throw than get a layup.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. It's unlikely you get a free throw if you punch them in the face.
SPEAKER_04It's not you don't even that that oh my goodness is you you know very little. You could just literally push them very lightly and that's a foul. Oh because you can't touch them. You could literally just poke them in the ear and that would be a foul.
SPEAKER_03Oh you know, just since you're there.
SPEAKER_04Maybe maybe there's a maybe you just got excluded from all sport.
SPEAKER_01Uh yeah. Yep. Anyway, I I think that's that's that's exactly right. And I think the way that I explained that difference is that it really has to do with like I guess the other thing we I want to say about these normative structures is that they're not just like a random bunch of rules, they're usually structured around certain sorts of ideals. Um and you think I think what what seems to be the case about soccer, which might explain why strategic files are less tolerated, is that part of the game of soccer, beauty of soccer is like the flow of the ball from one to another. If you keep committing files, that kind of like speeds the whole purpose of the game, which is to display some sort of like beautiful vertrosic goal scoring or something like that.
SPEAKER_01Or at least that seems to be what um people who care about soccer, seem to care about. Again, I don't I'm not really that much of a sports person, but it's a great analogy.
SPEAKER_04But I think it raises a worry, which is that uh it shows that disgust, the concept of disgusting and like morals can be relative. And so if we take it out of the arbitrary nature of sports, which is where the rules are just sort of made up and you just have to follow them anyway, and we put it into real life. Do you get worried though that like what might be disgusting in one culture might not be disgusting in another, even though it's actually wrong and it should be disgusting or like the other way around?
SPEAKER_01Right. So that's definitely the case. I mean, there's at least one sense in which like all emotions are subjective or or relative in the sense that like what emotions I feel might not be the same as the emotions you feel. Um of course that's not unique to emotions, like any of my mental states, what I believe in is not the same as what you believe in. But that doesn't mean that one of us couldn't be right or wrong, or that it's important to pay attention to our beliefs or emotions when we try to figure out these sorts of things. I think the main uh target of my analysis is is really just it's primarily descriptive.
SPEAKER_01So I'm trying to figure out what what are what are we feeling, like what's the what are we doing, or what are we feeling when we feel moral disgust? What are we trying to respond to? Um and that can come apart as to whether or not um we are right in many cases. Obviously, from the first person's point of view, when we feel uh moral disgust, and here I do think that I don't think if we feel core disgust, we always necessarily think something is wrong. So I'm usually disgusted by the person who maybe eats my leftovers after I've left the restaurant. But I wouldn't think that I wouldn't always think that something is wrong.
SPEAKER_01But I do think when it comes to moral disgust, that particular emotion usually comes with at least a thought that something wrong is going on. That not just I should find that wrong, but really anyone in my position would find that wrong. Um and so that's how it feels from the first person point of view. Um I do think as well that just as many normative structures, most of them could be reprehensible. Presumably there are some that are worth preserving, in which case there's only there's gonna be at least some cases of moral disgust that we should pay attention to and could be an important tool in those sorts of cases as well.
SPEAKER_04I'm so glad you said that because um I would like to raise a hypothetical case that has been brought to my attention, and I'm just gonna give him a shout out here, Blair. Blair, thank you for this one for starting many dinner parties with this one. So Blair has brought up, my friend Blair has brought up this problem, which is is consensual cannibalism wrong apart from the fact that it's just disgusting? And so it's this, you know, for those of you who are who are trying to picture this, get this. So essentially, two people could consent, or one person could consent to another person taking a little chunk and having a little munch.
SPEAKER_04I'm trying to make it sound as less disgusting as I can because it's pretty to me it's pretty feral. And so he he raised the point that if as long as they're consenting to it, what's actually dislike apart from the fact that it's just got an ick factor, and is that ick factor enough to translate into like a moral or a legal prohibition, which there currently is.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So how how can you can you try to explain to me how the the ick factor is working in in this case? Because I I I don't want to admit it to him, but here I am. I think he has a point.
SPEAKER_01Right. So I guess I mean one thing to say is that if you if you have the sort of moral view that um sort of libertarian where anything that's consensual is completely fine, you might not think there's an issue there. Um that being said, I think I do I would experience more discuss towards that thought. Um but I guess once you move away from this sort of like pure consensual type view that anything goes as long as every everyone consents to it, uh then you might think that perhaps morality or maybe legal structures, it's permitted for them not just to like regulate voluntary contracts we we hold between one another, but certain sorts of ideals or certain sorts of values that we want to uphold as a community.
SPEAKER_01Obviously, if a libertarian one can't care about any of that. Um anything thicker than that, I think anyone who's a political theorist would think that there's there are certain values that you want to preserve as a society that's permissible for the state to impose. Um and then I guess then the question is what what are the values at stake? And I and I guess here is here's the part where I think it's interesting, it's a really interesting question. I think one needs to think about what the relationship is between the body and food, how are we treating the body when we just treat another piece another person's body as if it was a piece of food, what are the attitudes involved, what what sorts of attitudes are are we expressing?
SPEAKER_01And my hunch, again, I need to think carefully about this case, is that there's some sort of disrespect that's going on, or some sort of disvaluing of the body. And I guess I want to say that the important part is that this way we value the body as a community, precisely because of the way you brought the case, isn't reduced to our respect for someone's autonomy. Um if you think that's the case, and I do have the intuition that someone's body matters, it's about someone's dignity or something like that, it's like inalienable, even in they can't even self-alienate, they can't even alienate themselves from that self-digity, is something we should all care about.
SPEAKER_01Um I suspect that that's perhaps what we're responding to, or maybe what you're responding to when we experience discuss there. Now you could think all this is an illusion. Obviously, many people, perhaps I don't know if many people do. I think they're I'm certainly in the group of the illusion. If it is an illusion. Um but I think here's one thing, important thing to say, which is uh even if you think it's an illusion, it's worth articulating. So just saying that you're just responding it, responding to it because it's icky, uh that's sort of stops debate. Actually, I think discuss response to we are tuned to certain sorts of ideals, we care about certain sorts of the ways the body is valued.
SPEAKER_01You could dispute that, that our body should be valued that way. Uh, but I think like just saying it's icky, therefore, I can dismiss what you say. I think that's uh that's cutting short our ethical reflection, the much needed ethical reflection in that case.
SPEAKER_04I'd you love to use a oh, that's just icky as a way to shut down debates that I don't want to be part of anymore.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah, so like what happens then when you talk about it and you think about it a while. Uh and you start out with an intuition that something is disgusting, and but then you know you get to a point where you if you think about it a bunch and you just cannot think of a good reason to uh uh like a and by good I mean just like something that's supported by moral theory or whatever, to think that it's uh immoral. You know, like uh another example that I think I encountered, and I think many philosophy undergrad students will encounter this one, is uh the issue of incest, right?
SPEAKER_03Uh-huh. Uh yeah, you know uh you know the classic example of a philosophy professor challenging the students. What's wrong with incest? Well, there are a bunch of obvious answers, right? Like the first thing people say is that, oh, there's a chance of deformities. Okay. They use contraception. All right, what what what next what's next? All right, uh and the students will come up with a whole bunch of reasons, but in the end, it like the philosophy professor usually fairly easily just like knocks all of those reasons down and shows why they uh they don't really work. So what do we do then when we when do when we end up at a point where we still feel disgusted by something, but we just cannot think of a good moral reason to think it's wrong.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so that's a that's a really interesting case. They well, the incest one. So this is, I mean, I'm sure I presume you're referring to It's another fun party conversation.
SPEAKER_03Brian at the next one.
SPEAKER_04Consensual cannibalism and incest.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Um so I mean, many people may know this, but there's a series of experiments run by Jonathan Haid. Um phenomenon he calls this moral dumbfounding. A lot of it revolves around disgust. I think he showed like students a bunch of cases. Um the incest is one. I think there's another one where you when one uh shits on the American flag. Oh no, you they use the American flag to clean the toilet. Um I don't make I don't make any comments about the case because I'm traveling to the US in September.
SPEAKER_02So Yeah, I didn't say anything about that.
SPEAKER_01Um I'm just pointing out that that's something that's that's one of the cases that he talks about. Um I think there's also like having sex with a dead chicken and then eating it. Anyway, so it's quite interesting. So let's just go with the incest case. I mean, the way Height sets it up is supposed to be that it's completely risk-free. Uh, like what are the names? I think Mark and Julie, they yeah, they decide to have sex.
SPEAKER_04Those freaks.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, decide it would be just a fun experience. Completely consensual, they do it once, and hey, they use contraceptives and everything. Uh, and it was completely fine. So I think what's interesting is that I think in the experiment in the study, what what happens is that students will give a bunch of reasons, they're thinking, articulate, but isn't it risky and so on? And then the experimenter is apparently so I think there's actually a problem for the experimental setup for those sorts of experiments. I actually suspect now that what's going on is that Haid and his colleagues were sort of gaslighting subjects because they were they had a certain sort of conception about what counts as a reason, and I think in their minds only it has to be harm.
SPEAKER_01But in their minds, they set up the case such that there are no harm-based reasons, therefore there cannot possibly be any reasons in which any of the subjects could come up with. It's like the subject would say something and then hide in the colleagues to say, Yeah, but you know, they use contraceptives, right? So they sort of grasp, they do have certain reasons that they're made to feel as though, and then in the end they just say, Alright, I just feel disgusted. I actually think that more is going on here. I think there's two things to say here. I think there was another study that's done to that that made this point. I can't remember how they did this study, but the point that was made is that look, the act was risky.
SPEAKER_01Would you really approve of a bunch of they say they've done used the contraceptive, they say that they've done they they did everything they could, and they say that there are no more psychological harms. But surely the act is still gonna be risky. I think that's something that we should be morally responsive to. Obviously, I don't think just because an act is risky means it's disgusting, so there's still a question about what explains the moral disgust. I think in my view, I think part of the reason why you know we find incest morally disgusting has something to do with we of again, I think this needs to be unpacked carefully, maybe some sort of anthropological work.
SPEAKER_01Something to do with the role that we think families play in our society. I do think a certain sort of ideal we have of families where it's some sort of shelter from like the world, and somehow sex in some ways is one of those things that kind of undermines the sanctity of the family in a certain way. Now, of course, once I say it that way, now this is a reason I could give you an explanation for what I'm responsive to, but you might ask that you might still ask the question is this really the ideal that we want to uphold in a society? Something is it something we care about? Um I think it's something we should, but again, you could dispute that.
SPEAKER_01You'd think that, no, there are some the lots of people who think that families shouldn't be destructive. Like families are a source of oppression and so on, so we shouldn't think about families such and such a way. I don't think that's right we think about families, I think they're important. Um obviously there's also a question as whether you need to tie this to certain sorts of ways of thinking about sex. Uh, but I do think that actually it is possible to articulate um what what once more discuss is responding to in these cases, um, such that there's some sort of intelligible, coherent structure. I said that's just a starting point. Um, and then we still need to ask ourselves, is this really the structure that we want?
SPEAKER_01Now, you gave me a case, you started with asking me the question about what about this, what about the sorts of cases where I just can't articulate what my discuss is responding to? Um and obviously, according to height, a bunch of his subjects could not articulate. And I think that's actually quite common. Does that mean therefore we shouldn't trust our discuss? What should we do then? I think it's very hard to give answers in general. It really depends on the case, I guess. And what and I think, I guess one thing to say, I think this sort of ethical reflection is best done by talking to people, especially if you feel icky about something. I think that's a good step.
SPEAKER_01Talk to your friends. Your family. Uh yeah, maybe not your family, but that might make things. Right, yeah. So I wouldn't, yeah.
SPEAKER_02My sister doesn't be this hypothetical question.
SPEAKER_01Um, yeah. Sorry. Right. So sorry. The other point I wanted to make was uh I think we need to be careful because I think sometimes the reason there can be like more nefarious reasons why we people struggle to articulate the reasons why they feel disgust. So I think I think gaslighting is one source some one possibility. I mean, I think in the paper, I do discuss this sort of example where I think many this is the sort of thing that Miranda Fricker brings up. She coined this term called hermeneutical injustice.
SPEAKER_01Um, where I mean a central case is I think a couple of decades. Can't remember what the time period she was thinking of again, but there was a time when this concept of sexual harassment uh hadn't really been clearly formulated. Um presumably many women had a sense that certain sorts of sexual harassment, those were disgusting, they did feel disgusted, but they found it hard to articulate what exactly was wrong. Usually the structures back then were such that the men could just pass it off as, well, I'm just being friendly, while you're overreacting. And so they could, you know, be gaslighted in such a way that they found it hard to articulate what exactly they were responding to, what exactly their emotions were responding to.
SPEAKER_01But clearly there was a form of disrespect. There's something creepy about their behavior. And I think in those cases, I guess we need to be alert to the fact that certain sorts of hermeneutical injustices can cloud our ability to articulate the reasons behind disgust as well. So I think that's that's another thing to say. So I guess in general, I still wouldn't say you should dismiss your feeling of disgust if you cannot articulate it, but you should be very careful because it can lead you astray as well.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and it can also be tied up with other emotions. Like I think it's a fairly common experience as a woman growing up, is that you get sexualized from a very young age. Right. And so I do remember though, um, like growing up being like 10, 11, 12, and you'd get like wolf whistled from like a car driving past, or someone would just say like something particularly nice to you. Yeah. And it would feel both gross and nice at the same time. You would feel good about yourself because you've been socialized to see yourself that way. So you feel like you're fulfilling a particular role. Yeah. But then also depending on who it was that said it to you, could make you more or less disgusted about it.
SPEAKER_04Right. And it's it it's so complicated. And it's something I think women still battle with, you know, to this day is like I I both like want it, but also when it happens, I feel repulsed. And it's so it just it it's difficult to reconcile.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_04So I I agree with you that like moral moral disgust is something that you need to explore and you need to ask yourself why. You can't just sit, you can't just feel disgusted and be like, yeah, it's just icky.
SPEAKER_01Right. No, I think that's I think that's a great point. So I think actually what you bring out is that in some ways, our kind of effective attunement to the social world is really kind of morally ambivalent because the social world itself is morally ambivalent. I mean, there are all sorts of we attend to norms that we care about, we want to preserve, like norms of mutual respect and so on. But it can be there can be other persistent effects of the social world that we kind of implicitly accept, maybe certain forms of like harmful patriarchy and so on. Maybe there's not so much moral disgust, but I think like core disgust is very much tied to like our sense of like how we appear, how we look.
SPEAKER_01I think it's quite common growing up that I've found myself looking disgusting. I'm sure I I mean I I don't speak for women, I assume that I mean all teenagers feel that. And some of that sort of like our aesthetic sensibilities that can be driven by injustice as well. Um, some of it is unfair, unhelpful, um objectifying, sexualizing in helpful ways. So that's something, that's another reason why we shouldn't take all emotions at face value. But sometimes they can be um tuned to the right sorts of norms, and so we shouldn't dismiss them as well.
SPEAKER_04And sometimes they're really weird. Like, you know, pimple popping and is like an ASMR thing on the internet?
SPEAKER_03Like I don't know about that, but okay, but is it supposed to be a isn't ASMR supposed to be a sound thing?
SPEAKER_04Okay, so I'm likening it to ASMR and that people love to like watch it. Yeah, and and so um there are whole channels dedicated to just watching people pop pimples. Right. And it's disgusting and satisfying at the same time. And there's a new trend at the moment, actually, of watching people clean like cow hoofs. I'm so sorry. I was speaking to men about pimple cow hoofs, men.
SPEAKER_03Why can't you see them into them?
SPEAKER_04But you've seen them. Like slowly shave more and more of it. It's like the pus comes out, and you're like, ew, I'll just keep watching for a few a bit longer. It's so interesting how like things that you know are moral disgusting can track things that are objectively morally wrong. But then like the what what was the other one, the other disgust? Core disgust. Yeah, it can be it's fine. Like if you like watching someone vomit, is there anything intrinsically wrong with that?
SPEAKER_03Yes.
SPEAKER_04Why? Okay, we've learned nothing.
SPEAKER_03Desiring to watch people vomit?
SPEAKER_04Um, I've got that question, but I uh it's actually James's question. Um, but I think it's a really interesting question.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04And it's people have expressed disgust of things like, and we've talked about it, um, like incest, um, but also things like interracial marriage, uh, same-sex relationships, premarital sex, masturbation. Is disgust inherently like morally conservative?
SPEAKER_01Right. So I think that's a great question. I guess I guess I should say that there's there's at least one sentence which discusses conservative. Um, if you use the classical understanding of conservatism, where conservatism, I guess of the Burkean sort, is interested in kind of preserving social structures. You don't want them to change. I mean, in some ways, I think that's exactly what more discussed is marshall to preserve. Uh, but need not be conservative in the sense that it's preserving only conservative structures because I think lots of liberals, there are structures they want to preserve as well. They would think that freedom, democracy, uh certain ideals of certain ways, particular ways of doing democracy.
SPEAKER_01Um, so I mean think about something called cancel culture. I think that's I think a lot of what's powering uh what's powering that is discussed. Um I I think I know some people use cancel culture as a prerogative as like a bad term, but really I think when the right complains about cancel culture, they're just being hypocritical because obviously the right does their own share of deplatforming as well. But the point is that I think they both recognize that there are important structures that we need to preserve, and excluding certain people, that's one way of preserving them. There's also this large uh literature, there's some empirical work that suggests conservatives have higher disgust sensitivity than liberals.
SPEAKER_01Uh, but I actually think that a lot of that is also a result of bias measurement tools. Uh so I think usually on these studies, the items on disgust sensitivity scales uh usually are tied to stuff that only conservatives are mainly disgusted by, like sexual items. Um obviously liberals are disgusted by a different set of things. That's a nice paper by uh Juliet Elet Strenger that develops a more rigorous scale, and she finds that once you use a more rigorous scale, this disgust sensitivity is actually not really affected by political orientation. So I wouldn't peg it as a particularly conservative emotion.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03There you go. And that's all the time we have for today. So thank you, Brennan, for coming here all the way here and talking about disgust. Yeah, no, it was fun.
SPEAKER_04That was really fun. Thanks for putting up with um our banter about and asking lots of answering lots of questions about incest. This has been fun for everyone.
SPEAKER_03For the record, what is the most disgusting food?
SPEAKER_04Ooh. And why is it deep dish pizza?
SPEAKER_01Um, oh gosh. Let me think about that.
SPEAKER_04James, what do you think it is?
SPEAKER_03Uh man, look, I wrote the deep dish pizza thing, so I'm just gonna commit to it.
SPEAKER_04Okay.
SPEAKER_03But you know, if I thought about it, I'm sure I'd think of something else. But also there are cultural things here, so I'm not gonna say it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's uh I find really it's interesting. I like so maybe here's here's that's another example of like of cultural stuff. But I find like really gamey foods disgusting. So actually, here's one. I mean, I've been I did my PhD in Australia, so I thought I should try kangaroo meat. Okay, try kangaroo sausages. I just couldn't stomach them. Uh but they're gamey. Yeah, they are gamey, but they'll it's it's interesting. I think it's I need to get used to that particular sort of gaminess because there are lots of other foods here in Singapore, which I think I mean, you can tell me what you you feel, Shanai, but I think there are lots of stuff that you might find gamey as well, but I find completely fine.
SPEAKER_04Well, I I love that you directed kangaroo question towards me because I did not grow up eating kangaroo, I grew up vegetarian, right? But for me, it's foods that don't chew well. Okay. So things like I really want to get into it, but I can't, which is bok choy. Because I struggle, I just struggle to chew it, and then I end up half swallowing it, and then because it's halfway down my throat and still half out, I'm just yeah, it's just not a fun time.
SPEAKER_01Okay, yeah.
SPEAKER_04I also struggle with mochi because it you just mochi, you just can't chew it. It doesn't, you just end up having to swallow it whole.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. It's like more of a texture thing.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, texture thing. I'm fine, I'm fine with that. Yeah, great. Yeah. Anyway, uh, great way to summarize that podcast. Already. See you around.
SPEAKER_01Thanks. See you.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and you and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...