Send us Fan Mail In the first episode of 2025, Julian and Sinead interview Professor Peter Singer on his life's work and controversial ideas in bioethics and ethics more broadly. Peter discusses his favourite karaoke song, his legacy as a philosopher, utilitarianism, what morality requires of us, and how is views have changed over time. Peter discusses various topics including euthanasia, animal ethics, altruistic organ donation, and human enhancement. Peter has his own podcast, Lives Well Lived, which can be found here: https://www.petersinger.info/podcast Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01The centre presents a new podcast, C BME and U, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_03Welcome to the final episode of CBME and U for 2024. To conclude our premiere season, we have Professor Peter Singer, visiting professor here at the National University of Singapore to the Centre for Biomedical Ethics, to answer some questions about philosophy, his life and legacy, and thoughts on cancel culture, which Julian is most excited about. Welcome, Peter.
SPEAKER_00Hi, good to be with you.
SPEAKER_03Thank you. So to begin the pod, we have some questions for you, which we ask all of our guests first. Coffee or coffee?
SPEAKER_00Well, I don't drink either of them because uh unfortunately coffee gives me migraines. So I'm so sorry to hear that. Yeah, well, you know, I can cope, but uh that's one thing I had to give up when I realized there was that connection.
SPEAKER_03I think for myself and other people it's the other way around. Coffee helps with migraines. So it's very interesting. That that's what it's like.
SPEAKER_00There's quite a few people that it actually is a trigger for.
SPEAKER_03Next question. Which country would you like to travel to the most?
SPEAKER_00Um I've been to Nepal twice. I I love mountains, and of course the mountains there are incredibly impressive. Uh I was there in '69 the first time, and then I was there in the mid-80s hiking both times. Uh I'd love to go back.
SPEAKER_03I'm sure that's why you were drawn to Singapore. We have all the mountains here. Absolutely, yes.
SPEAKER_00That's right. And that fresh, cool air that we get from the mountains.
SPEAKER_03Carisp really matches those beach mornings back home. And then final question, my favourite. Uh, what song would you sing at karaoke?
SPEAKER_00Well, I should warn you first that I sing very badly, so you probably don't want to be there. But um, how about uh Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow?
SPEAKER_03Who's that by?
SPEAKER_00Uh the Sherelles is the version that I know. And it's um I don't remember. Can you have a go now? I will not have a go. Actually, um Carol King composed it, I think.
SPEAKER_03Okay, okay. I do not know this one. I'll have a listen to it after.
SPEAKER_00You should definitely listen to it. Go for the Sherelles version, though. There are others, but all right.
SPEAKER_03Before I pick up practical ethics again, I'll listen to this stuff. Absolutely. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02Okay, Peter, um, so thanks very much for coming on the podcast. Um, you've been described as the world's um greatest living philosopher. Um so can you tell us, you know, what does a philosopher do?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, first a small correction. I think most influential is the phrase, which is a bit different from greatest. Oh, okay. Um and maybe there's some basis, at least most influential living philosopher, anyway. Um, there's some basis for that, because uh very few philosophers are influential at all. Um but greatest I'm certainly not going to uh claim. What do philosophers do? Um they think about uh issues that can't really be resolved by running experiments, uh basically.
SPEAKER_00So we we think hard about questions like how ought I to live? Uh what what what are the criteria for an action being the right action or the action that you ought to do? That's within the field of ethics. And uh then you can take that down to more applied and practical levels, like is it okay for me to eat meat? Um uh what should I be doing with my spare money given that I live in a world in which there are lots of people who are in extreme poverty?
SPEAKER_00Uh and of course, specific questions in bioethics, like is it okay for my physician to help me to die if I'm terminally ill and ask for them to do that? Uh so you can see that those questions can't really be resolved just by gathering more information. Uh, you have to think them through. And that's what we philosophers spend our time doing.
SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell But I guess a lot of people will say it's really up to the individual, you know, or the society. Um so isn't this just your opinion of what they should do rather than theirs? I mean, how do you how do you get to think about those things in a way that uh is different from how we think about them?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think most philosophers would agree that reason can play some role, that it's not just your opinion in the sense that anyone's opinion is as good as anyone else's. Um It might be that when you get down to the most fundamental questions, it's very difficult to decide between fundamentally different ethical views. But especially at the applied level, there are many people who hold views that turn out to be ones that have implications that they can't accept. So there's clearly a problem going on there.
SPEAKER_00You know, they they say one thing like, I think um all human life is of equal value, but then they don't act in accord with that if a baby is born with um enencephaly, which is a condition where there's really no cortex, so the baby will never be conscious or smile at their parents or do anything. And uh it's difficult to see that that that life is of equal value to that of other humans who can do all those things and can have rich and fulfilling lives.
SPEAKER_00So uh one of the things that we do is we try to look at the implications of different views and see which of them are most defensible in those terms. But we can also try and reason about the foundations and we we do that uh even if we don't always get uh uh complete agreement in in the views that we hold.
SPEAKER_02Okay, great. We'll come back to some of your your thoughts about different ethical issues, but but just you know, you corrected me. You're the the great the most influential living philosopher, um but perhaps not the greatest philosopher ever. Um who who is your favorite philosopher?
SPEAKER_00Well, my favorite philosopher uh of the you know period that I've been involved in philosophy is sadly is is no longer alive, but was until a few years ago, and that's Derek Parfitt, um, who was a philosopher in Oxford when I went there as a graduate student in uh 1969, and uh the seminars that he and Jonathan Glover and Jim Griffin gave uh about ethics just starting to do interesting issues in applied ethics, which wasn't really very much done before, uh, was really exciting.
SPEAKER_00Uh and he wrote a fascinating book called Reasons and Persons, published in 1984, and then uh he started working on this question of the objectivity of ethics um and uh uh wrote uh uh wrote a what was originally a two-volume, large two large volumes called On What Matters, um, and then there was a third volume published uh just around the time he died. Uh but you know, uh in conversations with him, I always felt the feel the I always had the feeling that here was somebody who was thinking ahead of me.
SPEAKER_00Um it was a bit like um me and a very amateur chess player um playing against the grandmaster, you know, and you know that whatever move you come up with, they've already thought of it and they've already thought of how to reply, and they've thought of how you might reply to their reply and so on. Uh so talking to Derek was a little bit like that.
SPEAKER_02Yes, he was a very impressive man. Um I wonder while we're still on the sort of philosophy and and the sort of the kind of contributions to philosophy, what do you hope that your legacy will be in the future? What what do you hope you'll be remembered for?
SPEAKER_00Uh I hope I'll be remembered for having put some challenging views out there that uh have had a practical impact, that have changed the way people have lived, maybe they've changed what people have eaten, maybe they've changed what people have done with their spare cash. Um and they've done that in ways that were positive, not only for um, let's say, for reducing the suffering of animals or or assisting people in extreme poverty, but also for the person themselves who changed their views.
SPEAKER_00That is, that they that their lives became more rewarding, uh, more fulfilling because they now had an an ethical purpose that maybe they didn't have before. What do you think your most controversial idea has been? Uh probably well, there's a couple of candidates for that, really. One of them is uh my views about um the permissibility of euthanasia for severely disabled newborn infants.
SPEAKER_00Um that is that parents should have the option of euthanasia, not that anybody else should perform it without the parents expressing the request for it, but that if parents did think that that was best after discussing that with those who know about the disability and uh with the the the doctors uh uh that they should be able to have that. So that's been controversial and has caused uh some protests against some of the things that uh against has caused some protests uh when I've been speaking in some countries.
SPEAKER_02So in these cases, uh you believe that well-being would be maximized by, in one case, performing infanticide for a severely uh suffering baby experiencing pain for is that is that the idea?
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's the idea. Um in the case of the the suffering infant, particularly a suffering infant where there is no prospect that this condition can be cured and that eventually we will get um a child and and later an adult who can have an enjoyable life which will make up for the fact that they had to suffer for some time after birth. You know, that's not an unusual situation. But if there is suffering and if there is no prospect of um the life becoming one that is positive quality.
SPEAKER_00Plus, of course, it may be very distressing for the parents to have to look after this child, and and in some cases it's inevitable that the child will die within months or at the most a couple of years. Um but the child has to be cared for during that period, and maybe that detracts from the care they can give to their uh existing children. So um I think it may be better all around, both for the child and for the parents, uh, that the child that the child not live.
SPEAKER_00And in fact, decisions are being taken and can be taken in neonatal intensive care units all over the world to ensure that the child doesn't live, but they're taken by non-treatment rather than by active assistance in dying. And non-treatment might mean such things as withdrawing the respirator if the child needs a respirator to breathe, in which case the child will struggle for breath for some hours before eventually dying. Um, and you know, what's the point of that struggling and gasping for breath for a few hours?
SPEAKER_00Um and in other cases, this is actually the circumstance that first brought this issue to my attention when I was directing the Center for Human Bioethics at Monash University. We were visited by the director of the neonatal intensive care uh unit at the Royal Children's Hospital in Melbourne, Neil Campbell. Um, and he told us of cases where babies born with severe spinobifida, where the parents and doctors thought it was better that the child not live. But the child didn't need a respirator, so so what they did was not close the wound on the back.
SPEAKER_00Babies with spinobifida have an open wound at the back with damage to the spinal cord. Um they would not close the wound, so the baby would get an infection, because you know, lying there with an open wound, they get an infection, and then you don't treat the infection either. So the baby goes through um certainly days and sometimes uh weeks of struggling with that infection before dying. Um and again, you know, you you've made a decision that it's better that the baby should die, and that's why you didn't uh surgically close the wound or treat the infection.
SPEAKER_00But what's the point of letting the baby go through that suffering before dying when you could give uh an injection that the baby would fall asleep and and die without any further suffering?
SPEAKER_02Well um those are very sad cases, and um it's important to remember that I think Peter is discussing very severe cases like this, or another one you had in your book, Should the Baby Live, was epidermalisis bullosa, or severe cases where the baby's skin peels off and they're in constant pain and suffer serious infections and there's no treatment. Um Utilitarianism was a radical theory when uh Jeremy Bentham first introduced it. For the first time everyone's well-being or happiness is counted equally.
SPEAKER_02The pauper's happiness counted as equally as much as the princes. And he said each is to count for one and none for more than one. So many people don't realise, but utilitarianism is a is it has a very strong focus on the equality of everyone's happiness and well-being, and and that's what matters, how happy or well-being people are, how happy or well off they are.
SPEAKER_03In practical ethics, you differentiate between hedonistic utilitarianism and preference utilitarianism. For our audience, would you mind distinguishing which one you prefer and why?
SPEAKER_00Right. Um So I've already said, you know, hedonistic utilitarianism is concerned with maximizing the surplus of pleasure over pain or happiness over misery. Preference utilitarianism is concerned with maximizing the satisfaction of preferences over the thwarting or frustrating of preferences. And in some versions, you know, when you say satisfaction and frustration or thwarting, that sounds like a mental state, you know. Oh, I'm I'm feeling great, I'm really really satisfied my preferences, or I'm so frustrated I can't satisfy my preferences.
SPEAKER_00But the the pure preference utilitarian um is not just talking about those mental states. They're talking about the fact that the preference is satisfied, whether or not um it gives me a feeling of satisfaction, and maybe even in some cases I never know it, right? So there's some discussions, for example, about you know, you're a huge supporter of I I I know you're an Australian background. So let's say uh as I am, I'm a supporter of Hawthorne in the Australian Football League. Um so uh suppose that um I'm really hoping that Hawthorne will win the premiership this season, but um I'm away where there's no contact with the rest of the world.
SPEAKER_00I'm on a hike somewhere in a remote area, and uh Hawthorne do win the premiership, but sadly I die before I ever get back to civilization and I never find out. Still, my preference was satisfied. Um, and and that's a sort of peculiarity of preference utilitarianism that uh it sort of floats between this idea that, well, it's almost like hedonistic utilitarianism because it's talking about satisfaction being a good thing and frustration and thwarting being a bad thing. Um, or you say, no, that's not what I'm talking about.
SPEAKER_00I'm just talking about that what you preferred did actually happen. You know, so the state of affairs occurred that you preferred, and that's a good thing. Um so uh one of them one of them risks becoming just another sort of form of preference of sorry, just another form of hedonistic utilitarianism, and the other becomes somewhat implausible. You know, how how did how did my life go better? Because my football team won the premiership, but I never knew about it. Um that seems odd. So in practical ethics, as you say, I distinguish between these two, and there's a story in that because when I wrote Practical Ethics originally in 1979 was the first edition, um, I was a preference utilitarian.
SPEAKER_00Uh I'd been influenced by the by teacher and and professor at Oxford, R. M. Hare, who defended a form of preference utilitarianism. Uh and um I guess I was also influenced by the fact that it seemed like it was sort of value neutral in a way. You know, it was just saying, well, whatever your preferences are, that's what that's what's good for you. Um, and I'm not imposing on you this idea that somehow what's good for you is your happiness um and the absence of suffering.
SPEAKER_00Uh but then by the time it came to the third edition, which was 2011, I was starting to think that that was mistaken. But I hadn't fully made up my mind. So the the third, still the current edition, is a little bit ambivalent on that question and uh you know does talk a bit more about hedonistic utilitarianism, which um by the time I published uh The Point of View of the Universe, a book co-authored with Charajina de Lazari Radek, um I had actually abandoned preference utilitarianism uh and um accepted hedonistic utilitarianism, which is still the position that I hold now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you I think one of the very admirable things about you is your views have evolved over the years, and we'll talk a little bit about some of the other changes in your views. But you mentioned R. M. Hare Um who was a famous utilitarian. Um I I remember this funny story about Hare, and I I wonder what your response to this is, because I was mentioning the radical implications of utilitarianism. And one of the radical implications of utilitarianism is we we should give as much consideration to strangers if we don't know, to their well-being, as we should to our own children.
SPEAKER_02And apparently Hare was once in a debate with uh another English philosopher who was an anti-utilitarian, Bernard Williams, who you'd also know. And um they were having a television debate and and Williams turned to Hare and said, imagine a plane is crashing. You know, and or you know, it's crashed and the that's going down. And you have only time to rescue your child um or two strangers' children. You know, w which one are you going to choose? And and Hare was apparently flabbergasted by this this question.
SPEAKER_02Um but so I wonder what what you think about the Williams' challenge. You know, w would you rescue the the two strangers or your own child?
SPEAKER_00Well, if you're asking, would I rescue my own child to be able to do that? What do you think the right thing to do? They're different things, right? I probably would rescue my own child, but I would not really think that I'd done the right thing. Um I think looking at it um as you say, impartially, um if if there's nothing else I know about the other children, um, and I have no reason to think that uh they're gonna have less good, worthwhile lives than my own child, and or that they're loved any less by their parents than my own children are loved, um I would think that I would have done more good if I'd saved two children.
SPEAKER_00At the same time, I wouldn't really think that I was blameworthy for saving my own child, because after all, it's good that children are brought up in in loving families. I think there's no better way being shown to bring up children who are gonna have um happy and healthy lives uh than to bring them up in loving families. And if you do let parents follow their natural instincts and and love their children, then uh of course in those situations they're gonna save their child.
SPEAKER_00Uh so that's um gets gets back to Parfit. I think he he had the the term blameless wrongdoing for this kind of situation. Uh and I think we need to keep those things separate. What would really be the right thing to do, or what was the wrong thing, um, and what would you blame somebody uh for doing?
SPEAKER_02Trevor Burrus, Jr. Yeah, I guess this sometimes called the over-demandingness objection to utilitarianism, it makes life extremely demanding. That you know every day we're doing so many wrong things, especially if we accept the utilitarian idea that our omissions are are you know just as um we're just as just as we're equally responsible for the consequences of our omissions as we are for our actions. And y you've uh been famous for arguing that we have much greater obligations to people throughout the world, particularly those in the developing world to uh give money and and and and other goods to increase their um their well-being.
SPEAKER_02Uh and and if you think about how much we spend each day that could go to be saving very large numbers of lives, you know, there is a huge gap between uh what we do and what we should be doing. Would you like to tell us you know your ideas around uh how much we should be doing then for others?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's it's uh difficult to say exactly where that line is to be drawn. In the first piece I wrote on this, uh Famine, Affluence and Morality, published in 1972, um I suggested that ultimately the only place to draw a line would be the point at which if you gave away more, you would be reducing your own well being by as much as you were raising the. Being of somebody else.
SPEAKER_00And in one sense, you know, I think that that's right. But there's uh also this question that I just mentioned about what you ought to be blamed for. And I think if you're giving at a significantly higher level than most people in your community, the higher level than most of your peers, then even if you're giving much less than that level that I just mentioned, you shouldn't be blamed because what you're trying to do is, or what you are in fact doing, is raising the standard in your community.
SPEAKER_00And if you're encouraging others to raise their standard, that may be the best thing that you can do. It it may be that if you go around telling everybody, hey, you should impoverish yourself to the point at which, if you impoverished yourself any further, you'd be worse off than the poorest person that you can find to help. Um people would, you know, just throw up their hands and say, well, if that's what morality demands, uh I'm just going to give up on morality. It's too demanding. So what I've done in my more recent writing, in particular in the book Um The Life You Can Save, is to set out a scale, it's a progressive scale like income tax, so that the more you earn, the more you give, and the the larger the percentage that you give as well as the larger absolute sum, uh, and uh suggested that people might like to follow that scale.
SPEAKER_00And it's a scale which starts off quite low for people who are not well off, maybe at 1% of their income, and it increases then gradually until for people who are really well off, it's suggesting they give away a third of their income. But these are people who can live very good lives on two-thirds of their income. They're living, you know, in fact, on far more than most people in the community. So um I think th, you know, w what we need to try to do is to develop social standards that are realistic, that people uh can follow and that can raise the amount that is being given while still um making a big difference to to people in need.
SPEAKER_00Uh and when you look at the amount that could be given without any real hardship, uh, I think perhaps we would come close to eliminating extreme poverty without really affluent people themselves um being all that seriously negatively affected by by what they're giving. And arguably, um, as some of the people who've read The Life You Can Save have told me, uh they are actually better off. They might be uh poorer financially, you know, have somewhat less uh wealth, but they have a a purpose and and uh they find their lives more rewarding because uh they know about the good that they're doing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, one of the features of utilitarianism is it's it's very dependent on what the facts are, and particularly facts about people's psychology and behavior. So you you've you've made this claim, which it seems quite plausible. I know you give a lot of your own personal wealth to charities, um but you've made this claim that if we you know set the bar too high close to this ideal standard of uh giving away as much until it's your you know you start to affect your your own well-being to a greater degree, um it's likely to put off people.
SPEAKER_02But you and I both know um young people, A. B. Rohig, Josh Morrison, people in One Day Sooner who have given a kidney to a stranger. Um this is something that you know you might say, well, if we go around telling people that they should be giving a kidney to the stran uh to strangers, it's just going to put them off and they are not gonna do anything. But in fact, A. B. Rohrig's personal story um was that initially his mother was uh shocked and very angry and tried to do everything she could to to stop him from donating a kidney to a stranger.
SPEAKER_02And then after he explained it and had donated the kidney and she knew the family, she then decided to donate a kidney. And now she's actually campaigning for the pa payment of live donors for organs for other people. So, you know, empirically it didn't turn well, it doesn't seem to me that people going around donating kidneys and and arguing that we should is uh putting people off. So I know you haven't donated a kidney, but maybe uh you know that would be something that level of sacrifice might not be something that puts people off, rather it encourages them.
SPEAKER_02So how how do you make this decision about what level of sacrifice is going to be off-putting or encouraging?
SPEAKER_00Um as you say, utilitarianism is a view that is very sensitive to the facts of the situation. And and I see that as a plus. I mean, there are some people who think, you know, no, you must have a moral principle that says uh do not tell a lie, never ever, no matter what the circumstances. Um and I just think that that's wrong. And you know, clearly that gets you into various situations that you should not be getting yourself into, uh, and and you know, with negative effects for sometimes many other people.
SPEAKER_00Uh so it's a good thing, but um, sometimes the facts are pretty difficult to work at, I agree. Um I'm not trying to produce uh a justification for myself in in not donating a kidney. Um I I don't have any such moral defense. I think I probably should have. Maybe I should have done it many years ago when it would have been a younger and healthier kidney, perhaps. Nothing, not there's anything really wrong with my kidneys, as far as I know, but um uh you know certainly would have been a younger kidney than it is now. Uh so I I greatly admire people like uh Abby Rohrig and uh Josh Morrison um and uh a few others I know.
SPEAKER_00Um some there's a guy called Chris Croy who who wrote to me after he donated it, and and his decision actually started in an ethics class, which is quite interesting about you know the effect that ethics classes have on people. They were they the class was reading Famine, Affluence, and Morality, and uh somebody objected to the argument that if that argument is true, then surely, you know, you have two kidneys, you can save somebody's life with one, surely you ought to give one. And and Chris sort of bit the bullet on the objection. Uh it took him a while, some months to think it through.
SPEAKER_00Uh, but eventually he said, yes, that's right, I should. Uh so I admire people who do that. Um, but it's true. I um, you know, maybe I'm just a coward about going into hospital and getting my body cut open to donate kidney. Um I think it's quite possible that it would be good to encourage more people to do that. I I've noticed that the number of altruistic kidney donors, I mean don donors to strangers, has been rising a little bit. Um so maybe that's becoming more widely accepted now.
SPEAKER_03Do you think that there's a difference between what morality expects of us and what makes us a hero? And morality doesn't expect us to be heroes, but even if it might be good to do so.
SPEAKER_00Yes, except that the phrase, you know, what morality expects is a phrase that's a little difficult to work out because morality isn't a thing with expectations. So you could say what morality requires, and then you would be introducing a distinction between, if you like, what is obligatory and what is super erogatory. That is, um, so some things are obligatory and then other things they're good to do, but then not obligatory. It's not wrong not to do. But as a utilitarian, I can't really accept that distinction.
SPEAKER_00Um and I think it it's it is more a matter of you know what c what should you be blamed for not doing. That comes close to what the uh obligation, supererogation distinction is, but it's not exactly that. Um and especially where there's something like donating to charity where you can do uh a great deal of good at quite a small cost to yourself, or as I said, maybe even zero cost, um I think you ought to do it. So that's why I don't think that that line is really one that can be drawn.
SPEAKER_03So you don't accept an asymmetry between like harms and benefits?
SPEAKER_00No, not really. Again, there's questions about um how much harm are you doing, how much benefiting uh are you doing. Um but it's a it's on it's a it's a continuum.
SPEAKER_02Um so I don't exactly So Philip A Foote had this famous example um that there is a difference between failing to send money to save a child's life in a developing country to sending a a poisoned food parcel to a starving child and killing them. Um so I'm not supporting this, but it it is the sort of there is the view that many people hold that you know harming is worse than failing to benefit.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because you if you think about that case, you're obviously influenced by the motivation, right? The failing to benefit is well, uh this person you know wanted to spend the money on something that themselves, I don't know, they wanted to get the latest iPhone, so they didn't send them, even though they had a perfectly good working phone, um, so they didn't send the money to somebody else, and so a child died. Um that's one thing. Um, and we sort of kind of to some extent empathize with that motivation because we feel it ourselves, and you know, as I say, none of us are saints, so we all do that to some extent.
SPEAKER_00Uh and on the other hand, there's a person who went to the trouble of getting a poison, putting it into this food package in a way that presumably would be disguised so nobody would notice, and then sending it over to these people who would eat it. And and that's completely different motivation. Yeah, but motivation is irrelevant to utilitarians. The outcome is the same in both cases. The outcome is the same. So um, you know, you could say both acts do equal harm. Let's say there's one child dead because I didn't send the money to the effective aid organization, and there's one child dead because I did send the poisoned food package.
SPEAKER_00But um when Foote or somebody uh describes that case, what we think of is what kind of a person would do that. Um we don't we don't just sort of push all that aside and say, okay, think about the objective outcome. The objective outcomes are equally bad. Uh we tend to think, oh, here's a this is a terrible person, this is a somebody I want to condemn, this is somebody who ought to be punished in the one case, and then the other case, oh, this person's a bit like me, really.
SPEAKER_00You know, lots of lots of people are like that. Um so I don't have that kind of negative view. Um so really I'm I'm I'm I am sort of biting the bullet. I'm saying they are both equally bad in terms of objective outcome. I'm just saying that there are all of these other factors about motivation, about condemning the agent.
SPEAKER_02I just want to sort of push that one another very famous pr counterintuitive implication for some is that utilitarianism justifies the killing of one individual to save a greater number of famous trolley style cases where you push an individual in front of a train to stop it to save five other lives. But perhaps the most famous example of this is the uh bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, um, which killed um more than a hundred thousand people in order to supposedly save greater numbers of lives.
SPEAKER_02Um in these kinds of cases where uh the intention is to kill uh in innocent individuals, as in the case of the U.S. bombings, um are you saying that uh you know those sorts of motivations and character don't count? Uh is is it are those acts justified by the uh does the end justify the means?
SPEAKER_00Well, as you said, utilitarians want to know all of the relevant facts. Um and in this case, they want to know things like was there any other way to persuade the Japanese to surrender? Uh once the United States had this weapon and had tested it, was there a way to convince the Japanese that um they had to surrender, otherwise it would be used? And there was discussions about performing a demonstration that the Japanese could actually witness to see the devastating power of this weapon.
SPEAKER_00Um that was one question. Uh another question was uh was it necessary to drop the bomb on Nagasaki? Um Japan might have surrendered. There's some historians, I think, debate whether how far that process had gone in terms of what Japan was ready to do or what the Japanese government was ready to do after um the destruction of of uh Hiroshima had had sunk in. Uh so maybe that one was justified and Nagasaki was not, that's possible.
SPEAKER_00The other question is, you know, was there any other way to induce the Japanese to surrender, or would it have been necessary to invade the Japanese home islands and fight all the way up, which no doubt would have led to uh widespread killing? Um and of course there was enormous deaths from the conventional bombing of of Tokyo and other Japanese cities uh before the Americans had the nuclear bomb. So I think all of those questions need to be asked, and it seems from my reading of of the history that they weren't really asked in a way that placed uh value on Japanese lives, on the lives of particularly of civilian Japanese.
SPEAKER_00Um they were asked in terms of how many American lives would be lost uh if we had to fight this, much more than how many total lives would be would be lost. Uh and so uh I'm not saying that the decision was justified, but uh but there is a possible justification if various steps had been taken and if the facts had come out in a way that said this is uh the only way to minimize uh overall loss of life.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean if you if you ask me what your most controversial idea is, I mean I'm biased, but I I think your view that uh human lives differ in value um is extremely controversial to you know people who want to hold that all human life you know has dignity and is of equal moral worth. And the perhaps the most extreme example of that is uh I think you've argued that um human beings born with aninkephily could be experimented on.
SPEAKER_02We could take their organs for transplantation because in your view that human life has no worth because it's unconscious. So killing that individual would not be wrong, and and benefiting from the the death of that individual would not be wrong. Um is that correct?
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's correct. Um again, just so that our audience are clear, we're talking about a child who is undoubtedly a living human being, um, but who is missing all of the cortex and who will not be a conscious being, um, will not be able to enjoy anything, uh, and conversely will will not be able to suffer. So I don't think there's any need to keep that baby alive, and in fact, uh except for a very small number of cases of people with very strong religious convictions, um uh and in Capelic uh babies, well, usually they they don't come to term because it's detected during pregnancy and the um the the pregnant woman elects to to terminate the pregnancy.
SPEAKER_00Um but if they do, then nothing is done to resuscitate them and they um and they do die reasonably reasonably soon. But um yeah, there was one case that I talk about where a a woman uh or a couple actually in Florida wanted something good to emerge from the tragedy of their baby being born with with Annan Kerle. And um they asked uh the court to make the baby's heart available to be taken while the still beating out of the baby and donated to another uh child who needed a heart, and that would have saved a life because uh it's quite difficult to you know where there's a baby born with a heart defect who needs a heart transplant, it's very rare to have uh an infant-sized heart available.
SPEAKER_00Uh but the court said no, and I I can't really see um a moral justification for saying no. I can see a legal justification, perhaps in the way the law stands at present. Um but I I you know I I don't actually think that is such a controversial implication. Uh uh it is maybe for people who are just committed to this idea that all life is of equal value. But Julian, I wouldn't have thought you would hold that view.
SPEAKER_02Um, no, I don't. But um I think many people would. And you can extend this argument because of course it's not just an Caphalics who become unconscious. For example, the end point of dementia um is unconsciousness. So as people become severely demented, uh if we extended your argument, and one of the things that's always impressed me is the sort of razor-sharp white light of your logic, is that uh individuals who have become unconscious with dementia or through trauma could be experimented on or have their organs taken.
SPEAKER_00Yes, that's true. Um there is one difference, and that is that they, having been normal conscious individuals, could express a view about that uh while they were conscious and in possession of their faculties. Whereas um an infant born with without consciousness, of course, can never do that. Um but I would certainly think it would be uh a reasonable thing to uh get people to or to make available to people uh a document that they could sign if they wished, saying that um if they ever irreversibly lost consciousness, they would not mind being experimented on or having their organs removed.
SPEAKER_00Um I'd be quite happy to sign such a document.
SPEAKER_02Uh but as a hedonistic utilitarian, why would we need such a document? At that point, they have no experiences.
SPEAKER_03So preferences once that they're dads.
SPEAKER_02But so is it because you're worried that people will become anxious at the thought that this might happen to them?
SPEAKER_00Trevor Burrus, Jr. Some people might not like living with the thought that, uh oh, um I'm gonna be cut up. And some people, of course, may worry that uh the tests will not be properly performed or um that they somehow will be.
SPEAKER_02But again, you have to weigh that against all of the lives that you can save. Maybe they will be distressed. But um, for example, if we introduced organ conscription rather than just opt-out organ schemes, there may well be people that are distressed, but then there may well be many more people whose lives are saved. So from a utilitarian perspective, isn't it just a matter of weighing up those?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's a matter of seeing how that would play out. But if you had a culture that accepted organ conscription, you know, this is like John Harris's idea of the organ lottery, right? That you you you all go into this lottery and uh when organs are needed and there aren't enough from deceased donors or voluntary donors, uh you draw a ticket in the lottery and um and somebody is chosen as the donor and they get carved up and their organs help five people live. Um so given that you could be one of the five people, that would also maximize your chances of survival.
SPEAKER_00Um but nobody has wanted to take that up because people think that uh I don't know, people wouldn't wouldn't trust the lottery or uh or they just don't like the idea. So I think that's a good idea.
SPEAKER_02But do you see nothing net intrinsically wrong?
SPEAKER_00No, I see nothing intrinsically wrong with it. Um I just see the likelihood of strong resistance if you try to do it in societies at the moment. But you know, maybe one day people will become more rational about this and they'll accept that this is going to improve their own chances of survival. Um it's like choosing behind the veil of ignorance in uh Rawls' stuff.
SPEAKER_02So in terms of programming driverless cars, you would be in favour of them pro being programmed to just save the greatest number of people. So even if they have to swerve off the road to save five lives in the car and kill a pedestrian or a cyclist. Your view is that the the policy of programming should be just to save the greatest number of individuals, regardless of whether they're road users, innocents.
SPEAKER_00Uh I mean you'd have to mandate that because um if if people are still choosing to buy their cars as they do today, they would choose to buy the cars that are going to save those in the car.
SPEAKER_02Would you do you think it would be right to mandate that?
SPEAKER_00If you could reliably um increase the number of lives saved, yes.
SPEAKER_03My view or my understanding, and please correct me if I'm wrong, that your views about animals and the values of lives and whether or not we can eat them has changed over time. I understand that there are certain contexts in which you might think this is okay. I was wondering what it was that changed your mind or slowly changed your mind about whether or not it's okay to eat certain animals.
SPEAKER_00Well, the the the main change that I've made from the first edition of Animal Liberation is in response to this argument that if animals have good lives, so they're not in factory farms, they're out in the fields, they're doing whatever is natural for their species, they're in the kind of social group that they can enjoy being part of. Um and if they're then killed without pain or suffering, preferably on the farm rather than being transported, they're Slaughter. And if they would not have existed at all if it were not for some people purchasing their the meat of pri animals who were previously reared and killed, um in reared in that way and killed, um, then it's hard to say how the animal is harmed, because by eating meat produced in that way, you provide the farmer with a reason for bringing more animals into existence, and those animals have good lives uh and are then killed prematurely, of course, because nobody likes to eat old animals.
SPEAKER_00But um but still they have they have good lives, which are better than no life at all. So um I did shift my position after the first edition where I'd I'd I'd I'd argued that even so it was wrong to do that, and I became unconvinced with the the arguments that I gave for saying that that was wrong. Uh so that's the major change that I've made.
SPEAKER_03Does this mean that if we have reason to create these animals that will have good lives so that we can eat them? Does this mean that you think it is better to you know reproduce as humans if we can guarantee that these children will have good lives than it is to not reproduce at all?
SPEAKER_00Um Yes, actually, I I think you can say that. And I said it just um two days ago when I was speaking in Korea, which, as you may know, has one of the lowest fertility rates in the world. Um fertility is now something like 0.7 children per woman. Um, and Koreans are very seriously concerned about uh their nation dwindling, basically, um, and and uh not really being able to maintain its its uh place in the world.
SPEAKER_00Um and so I was asked um whether I thought that there was some sort of moral reason for having children, if or I was asked more broadly than that if there's anything I should say to to couples who are thinking about having children or were not having children. And I said something along those lines that, you know, obviously it's a decision for couples or or women to whether they want to have children or not. And I was not saying that they should be coerced into having children at all, but um I think in their thinking about whether it is or is not good to have children, um, they should give some weight to the fact that Korea's a prosperous, well-ordered society.
SPEAKER_00Um uh there's no reason to think that children born into Korea today, um South Korea, of course, I'm talking about, um, would not lead good lives. Um, and that the fact that they can give rise to the existence of children who can lead good lives should be a factor in their decision. Um I didn't want to say more than that, but uh not an obligation, but a good reason.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02So, you know, not only are you the world's most influential living philosopher, you're probably the world's most controversial philosopher, and and you've been cancelled on many occasions. Uh dating back to the nineties. I remember when I was doing my PhD with you at Monash. Uh you were cancelled from a a German conference, which seemed to me particularly ironic since I believe that your grandparents were in uh in involved in the Holocaust as um as uh Jewish victims.
SPEAKER_02Um so I uh uh you've also just recently established this journal of controversial ideas. I mean, I wonder if you can share your views on freedom of speech, uh cancellation, and and and why you've decided to establish this journal.
SPEAKER_00Uh yes, so uh you're right. Um I uh the term canceled wasn't actually in use in it was 1989, the first uh conference that my invitation was uh to speak at was withdrawn from uh in Germany. And eventually I think the whole conference was cancelled, actually, because there was just so much controversy about it. Uh and there were some other occasions when that occurred. And you're right, um it was ironic because three of my or grandparents were murdered by the Nazis.
SPEAKER_00Um but somehow the Germans had this idea that the Nazis had a so-called euthanasia program, which was not really a euthanasia program in the sense of being for the good of the individuals at all. It was a program to rid the Aryan people of uh you know, those who were considered a blot on their uh racial or genetic composition. Um so that was certainly uh you know something in the back of my mind um when the cancel culture uh became more prominent in not just in in Germany but in uh Western nations as a whole.
SPEAKER_00Um and uh the the spark for the Journal of Controversial Ideas wasn't mine, it came from Francesca Minerva, who was uh who published an article on abortion and and infanticide defending uh both of those in some circumstances and uh received uh appalling hate mail, um, including death threats of the kind, you know, you better watch your back when you go home because we know where you live. Uh and also thought that she may have permanently, you know, blotted her uh sorry, permanently wiped out her prospects of having an academic career because there was so much hostility to this.
SPEAKER_00Uh fortunately she does uh have an academic career still. But um but she floated the idea of a journal that would publish things that were controversial and that might not get published elsewhere, and where authors, if they wished, could publish under a pseudonym, so that the kind of attacks that she had been subject to would not uh be possible. Um and then if they you know, if things calmed down and they were applying for a job and they wanted to take credit for an article in the journal that they were the author of, um, they would be able to do so.
SPEAKER_00So um so it was her idea. She talked to me, she talked to Jeff McMahon, uh, and uh the three of us agreed then to found the journal and to co-edit it. And I think the articles we published have shown that there is a need for a journal like that. There are many articles that did not get published, um, despite, in some cases, despite having gone through the peer review process and getting uh strongly positive uh reviews, but then the editors decided clearly on political grounds not to publish them.
SPEAKER_00So uh we've published many of those articles on which do you think was the most interesting? The most interesting articles we published. Yeah, which which is which is your favorite? Um actually I there's an article in the first issue that I really liked, um uh called Creation Science. Oh, is that the exact word? Um I'm that that may not be the exact title, but it's it's essentially arguing that um the denial of the idea that there are genetic differences in intelligence um is equivalent to uh denial of the idea that um uh uh that life has developed through evolution rather than through divine creation.
SPEAKER_00Um and uh and I thought that was a that got us off to a to a good start. It made a very strong scientific case that um the denial that differences between individuals um have some genetic component is um just so much flying in the face of facts.
SPEAKER_02Well, again, maybe you could just allow a lot of people will be shocked by that today. Um and you know, you've been a staunch egalitarian, um, and so many people will see this as being eugenic or discriminatory. Um could could you tell us you know how you can hold this scientific belief yet still be an egalitarian?
SPEAKER_00I think that you there's a sharp distinction between looking at the facts, um trying to get the best evidence, which essentially is what science is doing, and uh assess that evidence and um as objectively as you can try to say what the evidence points to um and what that implies in terms of how people ought to be treated, which is uh an ethical question, not a scientific one. So um, yes, certainly you can be an egalitarian and and say, look, there are differences, there are genetic differences between between human beings, and they um don't just relate to things like the kind of hair you have or your skin color um or your height, but um they relate to various cognitive abilities.
SPEAKER_00Uh that doesn't mean that you say we ought to give less consideration to those who um have less aptitude for cognitive tasks um than others. Uh on the contrary, I think you should clearly give equal consideration to uh to the interests of people, irrespective of their cognitive abilities. Um But it may be relevant to questions uh um about what what kind of what kind of uh roles they have in terms of what what jobs they're capable of doing.
SPEAKER_00Uh uh those questions may clearly depend on cognitive abilities.
SPEAKER_02So uh w we now have the potential to change the genetic makeup of future generations. We can already genetically select embryos for traits, not just uh disease traits, but also for for IQ to some degree. And of course, in the future we'll be able to gene edit. And you you've have this paper called The Genetic Supermarket, where I think you're a great paper. Shopping at the genetic supermarket, I wouldn't shopping. You're against shopping in general. You have another book against shopping, but uh too much.
SPEAKER_02You're in favour of shopping. Well But so tell us what what's your view around around uh then changing the genes uh if there are these genetic differences and you think that they they're associated with disadvantages. Do you what would do you think we should be allowing people, encouraging people, compelling people to change the genes of the next generation?
SPEAKER_00Well, the first claim that I make in that is that this is an issue that we ought to be discussing. Um in fact, it's taken somewhat longer to come. That's a very weak more discussion. I wasn't I wasn't cut off.
SPEAKER_03What do you think instead?
SPEAKER_00I wasn't going to stop at that point. Maybe you're just thinking while you're but that that is that is the first thing. But um But we haven't had enough discussion of this. Um and as you say, it's coming. I mean you you said we can already select at the embryonic stage for IQ. Um I'm not sure to what extent that's right. I mean it's a polygenic tray, right? It's not like finding just one gene. Yeah, you can get polygenic scores now.
SPEAKER_02Um it's not gonna precisely, but you can within a range you can affect it. Now, how much you can affect it, people disagree, but there's no doubt. I mean, you y w genomic prediction originally marketed their polygenic score to select out um embryos in the low normal range, and they got pushback, so they moved the cutoff to just disease. Um but you know, that is already here, it will increase in power, and then of course you've got polygenic editing in the future.
SPEAKER_00So they so genomic prediction pulled back from doing that, but is there anything to stop another company saying, hey, there's a bargain?
SPEAKER_02In fact, in fact, another one just recently came saying that they were going to offer it. So it is here, in other words, what you're saying. But it's not gonna have a massive effect, but it's the tip of the iceberg.
SPEAKER_00Increasingly, as we get better at the predictions, it will have a more more effect, right? Because I mean, I think parents will definitely want this. Uh one of the I I also think I wrote a piece that I noticed when I got to Princeton that in the student newspaper, the Daily Princetonian, at that time, there were ads appearing for uh female students to donate their eggs uh to for essentially, you know, to to people who I guess perhaps were not fertile, but they wanted eggs from people who had had scholastic aptitude scores above, I can't remember it was 1,300 or 1400, anyway, some high end.
SPEAKER_00And sometimes they refer to other characteristics, must be over this height, you know. So um there was clearly genetic selection that people were willing to pay, and and the offers were I think$25,000, and this was in you know 20 years ago, so that's uh more than that now. So people are clearly willing to pay for having a child with a better chance of getting into Princeton or Harvard or Yale or one of those elite American universities. And um, so once you get companies offering this, I think people will be taking it up, and it will depend on how reliable the prediction is.
SPEAKER_00But if it turns out to be reliable, um then I think we'll get that. And then the question is, you know, the ethical question is, is that a bad thing? Is this eugenics? And is this eugenics in a bad sense of the term? Because I think the term eugenics is used loosely and widely, and uh in fact, if you really are opposed to eugenics entirely or to prohibit women having abortions based on prenatal testing, because if that isn't eugenics, I don't know why it isn't eugenics, but it so happens that the people who shout eugenics as a bad word also support uh abortion rights, as I do.
SPEAKER_00So um they haven't quite grappled with that fact that those two views are in contradiction with each other. Uh so um yeah, I th I don't think it would be a bad thing, I have to say. You know, we it may take us some time to get used to it. There may be some things that we need to sort out. But if um parents uh choose to have children with higher cognitive abilities, um we have a lot of problems that um are going to be assisted if we do have um a lot of people with with high cognitive abilities.
SPEAKER_00So I would not oppose that.
SPEAKER_03So I'm particularly interested in the um the human enhancement question, um which is the idea that you know if we could improve these abilities, we should. And I was wondering if you think there's a a presumption there that more is better, that higher is better, that increasing every capacity or function will guarantee an increase in well-being. But I do remember reading in your book Practical Ethics that it is not necessarily true that the more intelligence you have, the more well-being you have. So if your measurement is only happiness, then on what grounds should we enhance intelligence or other factors?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think it's not necessarily true that the more intelligence you have, the happier you will be. But it and of course it isn't necessarily true that people with high levels of intelligence or other cognitive abilities are going to do good with them. Some of them may do terrible things with them. That's certainly possible. But I think that on balance, people with higher cognitive abilities are able to do more good. And so I'm optimistic enough to hope that they will do more good.
SPEAKER_00So I think that's the utilitarian reason for um trying to um encourage people to develop their own cognitive abilities and and those of their children.
SPEAKER_03Do you think then it's equally valuable to enhance some children who might go on to have higher cognitive abilities as well as to uh provide the socioeconomic resources to those who already have the higher cognitive abilities but haven't had the opportunity to access them? Do you think there is no difference?
SPEAKER_00Uh if the enhancing is has the same effect, there's no real difference, right? So I don't think we've done enough in enhancing to know whether that's the case and and how it works. But if it could be done uh safely and it had the same effect as, let's say, giving the children um an absolutely first-class educational uh an absolutely first-class education. Um and I think you know everybody would say, yeah, it would be fantastic if the government could give everybody in society the best kind of education that there is uh available.
SPEAKER_00So um if if uh other forms of enhancement had the same effect, then I don't see why we shouldn't do it.
SPEAKER_02So you you won this Begruen Prize, which comes with a million dollars, which I believe you donated to charity. So it's most important.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_02Oh, it's a prestigious prize. And I actually met Nicholas Begruen once and we had lunch, and then right at the end of lunch, he said to me, uh yeah, he paid for lunch. Uh he said, Um, I've got this book I'm going to give to my daughter when she's older, and I ask everyone I meet, um, you know, I w I want one I want one line that that will be passed on to my daughter, and and and I went into this state of panic. But then I remembered this sort of one line that it's um it's it's better to fail doing what you want to do than succeed doing what you don't want to do.
SPEAKER_02Um but I'm wondering what the line was that that you gave Nicholas Begruen for his uh for his little quote.
SPEAKER_03That's an inside joke here.
SPEAKER_02Or you can make up another line that you want to be remembered for.
SPEAKER_00Um I I did get presented with a book. I did write something in it. I no longer uh remember with any reliability what I wrote in it. Um but I hope it was probably something along the lines of um do the most good you can. I would have thought it's if you can be happy, be happy.
SPEAKER_02It's the model of the utilitarian. I mean, that's that's that's make everyone else happy podcast.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. If you if you had the and make everybody else happy, you're happy and reduce suffering.
SPEAKER_03Um there's opportunity there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I give the floor to you, Peter. Um, is there anything you want to say to the billions of people that will be listening to this podcast?
SPEAKER_00Well, um well, one thing I do want to say is um I I have my own podcast and I would like you to listen to it. Uh it's called Lives Well Live. I do it with uh Akasha Delazari Radek, and I mentioned, a co-author of uh a couple of books that I've written. Um, and uh we discuss how to live well, which I think is along the lines and how to help others live well, which is along the lines of what we've been talking about, uh, with a different, exciting, stimulating guest each week. And you can find it wherever you get your podcast.
SPEAKER_03To our listeners, um, I've checked the list. It includes Jane Goodall, Neil deGrasse Tyson, and no Yuval Harari.
SPEAKER_00Uval Harari, that's right. Yes, it does. So excellent.
SPEAKER_03This podcast does support the other podcasts. But thank you for listening, um, and we'll see you next year.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and U and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...