Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

C B m E & U

C B m E & U artwork

Who are your parents? with Hilary Bowman-Smart

Nov 14, 202547 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail The New York Times recently published an article on a woman who is fighting for custody and legal parenthood of twin children that she is not genetically related to, whom she did not gestate and birth herself, and who have not been living with her: her only connection with the twins is that she wanted them and so (under very interesting conditions) paid for the IVF and surrogate to birth them. In this episode, Dr. Hilary Bowman-Smart (University of South Australia) discusses the impact of assisted reproductive technologies on what we think it means to be a parent. Hilary discusses this case and answers questions such as what if the embryo that made you, was made from 4 different people's gametes? What if you could have children with your friends, instead of your romantic partner? Should James start a cult? Remember to review, subscribe, and like the podcast! Remember people, be savvy!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, CBMENU, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.

SPEAKER_01Welcome back to CBMe and You, a podcast about biomedical ethics. Today we have Hilary Bowman Smart, postdoctoral research fellow from the University of South Australia. Today we want to know, are your parents just those that contributed to your DNA? Or is there something more to being a parent, you know, other than being a supportive, caring, nurturing force for a growing human being for the rest of their life? Oh my gosh. So welcome, Hilary.

SPEAKER_04Hi, thanks. Thanks for having me on. It's fantastic. I'm so glad that we finally got to do this. It's been weeks, but months, weeks, weeks.

SPEAKER_02At least weeks, yes.

SPEAKER_04Okay, I've gone to like North America, come back, hit a different time zone, and I'm not sure what day. I actually woke up this morning not knowing where I was. Had to like lie there, squeeze my eyes shut for a minute, and be like, hold on, you got this.

SPEAKER_01I wake up like that every morning.

SPEAKER_04Hillary, so we have some little questions to get to know you. Our first question is coffee or coffee?

SPEAKER_02So uh yeah, so my answer would be coffee or sugar-free Red Bull, uh, because I'm actually drinking a sugar-free Red Bull right now. Um, this is not an ad or anything. It's just I yeah, I live sort of permanently on a on a supplement of Red Bull um or cold brew, um, which is handy because you can use really cheap coffee grounds to make cold brew.

SPEAKER_04You can, you can. Uh that's one of the things I miss about Australia is I could go to Aldi, get a one kilogram bag of like cheap beans, make cold brew, and it just tastes takes all the bitterness out, and you go like, I've got these like floral notes. Oh yeah, but you know, that's that's it.

SPEAKER_02Otherwise, I use the the little like stovetop mocha pot thing. Uh, but you actually have to have high quality uh coffee grounds for that, otherwise it tastes like absolute garbage.

SPEAKER_04Um so so so so your daily is your daily is cold brew or caffeine and uh Red Bull.

SPEAKER_02Yes, yes. But I'm off I'm often out of the house quite early, so it's like and quickly, so it's often easier just to grab a Red Bull from the fridge, basically. Um at work, I'll have like, you know, a latte or something.

SPEAKER_04Okay. When you were here, we should have got you to try an iced coffee because Josh and I, when we first moved here, we're like, these sweet drinks, they are so delicious, they're kind of like Vietnamese iced coffee. We were just downing them because they're like a dollar, dollar seventy. And then we realized how much more caffeine is in coffee than it than is a normal cup of coffee. It's like what triple, triple the amount of caffeine. And I was like, no wonder I'm just pinging, thinking that Singapore is just the best. I was borderline up there with the fairies for a while.

SPEAKER_04Okay, okay, okay, okay. Next question, next question. What country do you want to travel to next?

SPEAKER_02Um, so I I'm actually really keen to travel to Central Asia. Um I guess like Mongolia. Um uh I just think it would be really interesting to go. Uh a friend of mine and I had like these grand plans to do the Trans-Siberian Railway, it's like Beijing to Moscow kind of thing a few years ago, but then obviously, like, you know, war in Ukraine and stuff made that um seem ill-advised, perhaps.

SPEAKER_02But yeah, I'd be I I'm I'm very keen to kind of just like check out that area of the world because uh yeah, basically, I've just never been anywhere kind of like that, so that's probably what I would say. Cool. Excellent choice.

SPEAKER_04Final question. What's your go-to karaoke song?

SPEAKER_02So uh I'm gonna say something by the Spice Girls. Um, I don't actually recall the the names of any of the songs, they're just like, you know, like, give me what you want, what you really mean. Uh not yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Not not because like I love the Spice Girls or anything, but just because like having grown up in the 90s, those lyrics are like permanently etched in my brain. So they're a very easy go-to karaoke song. An alternatively uh an alternatively uh kind of alternative option would be um an ABBA song because we did uh an ABBA sort of matinee thing in primary school, so also inscribed in my brain.

SPEAKER_04Okay, okay, okay. Question about the matinee. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Which member of ABBA were you?

SPEAKER_02Well, um, I actually can't remember. It was either I don't remember their names. It's either Frida or Anna. Yeah, I think I think so. I I don't know. I do not remember, but we did do Mamma Mia and Dancing Queen. Um, so it's just it just feels like you learn the lyrics at a very young age and you can never forget them in the same way that you never forget your like best friend's landline number from primary school.

SPEAKER_01Can I just pick up on something you said earlier? You're allowed to say you like the the Spice Girls. You're allowed to admit it here on this podcast.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, this is a safe space. Yeah. I don't I don't hate the Spice Girls. It's just not like I don't like go out of my way to listen to the Spice Girls, as it were. It's just like if you're at a karaoke bar, so I actually had some friends who got married at a karaoke bar on New Year's Eve this year. Well, like the most recent New Year's Eve, um, uh, which was very fun. It was a very fun wedding. Um, their wedding song was Baseline Junkie by Dizzy Rascal. Um, my contribution was the wedding cake.

SPEAKER_04So I'm sorry, sorry, sorry. Did you make the cake? Did you bring the cake, or were you guarding the cake?

SPEAKER_02I bought the cake.

SPEAKER_04Okay.

SPEAKER_01That was a big contribution.

SPEAKER_04No, it was a massive contribution. Wow, was it? Yeah, well, what's the case?

SPEAKER_02No, I uh I think it was vanilla or something. I didn't, I couldn't actually eat any because I have celiac disease, and I wasn't gonna I wasn't I wasn't gonna inflict a gluten-free cake on my friends.

SPEAKER_04That's so brutal that wait, did they ask you to buy the cake and then you were like yes, but I can't have any of it?

SPEAKER_02No, I offered they were like, because it was kind of like um uh they basically were like, oh well, we haven't organized a cake, and I was like, I will do this for you, um, and kind of uh organized it kind of uh last minute, but it was like tall. I didn't realize how tall it was gonna be. And we got it there and none of us knew how to cut a tall cake. Um so there's these very funny photos of them trying to cut this very tall cake and without it like completely falling apart. So it was overall very fun karaoke wedding.

SPEAKER_02Um it was great.

SPEAKER_04Okay, all right, James, you can put that on your Pinterest board for your wedding one day.

SPEAKER_01A tall cake?

SPEAKER_04No, a karaoke book. Oh, but yeah, also, you know, spice girls for the whole thing.

SPEAKER_01A tall cake, you know. Do I need to write that down?

SPEAKER_04Honestly, for you, probably, yeah.

SPEAKER_02They're very hard to cut because it's like where do you start? It's a very tall, thin cake, like a top hat kind of size cake.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'll write that one down. Like, uh learn how to cut tall cake.

SPEAKER_04Takeaways from today's podcast. Learn how to cut a tall cake.

SPEAKER_01Oh, especially if it's an ice cream cake. Anyway, let's start with some conceptual con uh clarifications. Uh, what is genetic parenthood and how does this differ from other types of parenthood, such as gestational, legal, social, and moral parenthood?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So let's transition there. Yeah, it was so smooth. Yes. Um, so I think this is a really interesting topic that I sort of stumbled into a bit. Uh, a lot of my work sort of is on in reproduction, uh, prenatal testing, uh, pregnancy, uh, and that sort of thing. Uh and Sinead and I recently uh co-authored a sort of commentary on the recent sort of IVF embryo mix-ups um that have happened in Australia.

SPEAKER_02Um and it's quite an interesting question, I suppose, for two reasons. Uh, well, for many reasons. Uh, firstly, we have all of these technologies, these reproductive technologies that are changing what we kind of understand as genetic parenthood, uh, and they're making us sort of look, how do we actually define this? Uh, but we also have a lot of social changes uh over the past sort of 50 years, you know, 100 years, uh, that are really highlighting, you know, the I suppose pulling apart of this idea of genetic parenthood with the other ways that we might think about parenthood, like so, as you mentioned, like um gestational parenthood, which uh can be defended as another form of biological parenthood.

SPEAKER_02Because we often, when we we often say biological parenthood, and what we mean by that is genetic parenthood. Um, whereas I think there's a reasonable case to be made that gestational parenthood can be considered at least a form of biological parenthood. Uh, and so that in the case, for example, where you have a surrogate um, you know, who is uh gestating an embryo that has genetic material from two other people, that there are three sort of biological parents involved of different types, uh basically.

SPEAKER_02Um that's separate from the question of what's the normative significance of those things, to be clear, um, although related, as I will discuss, I guess. Um so, and then there's obviously like, you know, legal parenthood, like who do we sort of legally assign custody to, uh sort of authority over who gets to decide where you know a child goes to school, um, you know, pays for sort of the child's sort of needs and that sort of thing. Social parenthood, again, that's often separate from legal parenthood.

SPEAKER_02We have many people like grandparents, uh, other family members, sort of members in the community. Step parents are a really sort of common example. Step parents don't necessarily have sort of legal rights over uh the child that might have been very involved with raising them as a parental figure. Um, and then sort of this question of moral parenthood, like who sort of owes uh, you know, who has duties uh and and obligations towards this child and who sort of has the, I suppose, responsibility for helping them grow and uh become, you know, a healthy, flourishing adult.

SPEAKER_01So in my mind, you we have genetic, no, we have legal and moral parenthood, and that seems to be the thing, those two things seem to be the things that really matter. And the other things, like gestational or genetic parenthood, uh are means of finding out who is who who has legal or moral parenthood. Is that the right way of thinking about things to see uh to see these things as instrumental to figuring out what the moral duties are or what the legal duties are?

SPEAKER_02Yes.

SPEAKER_01All right then.

SPEAKER_04So no further questions? Great, all right, moving on, Kenny.

SPEAKER_02Essentially that, um, okay, so this is kind of, I suppose, going back to this question of like, what is the concept of genetic parenthood, and then why does it matter? Um and so I would say I've spent a lot of time sort of being like, oh, this is a puzzle. What is genetic parenthood? When we think about all of these technologies like in vitro gametogenesis, uh, where you can essentially create a gamete from, let's say, a skin cell or something like that.

SPEAKER_02We have um, you know, ectogenesis, uh, so external wombs, artificial womb. We have uh things like mitochondrial replacement therapy, which is already sort of being you know put into practice, uh, where sort of you've got nuclear DNA from two people, but then mitochondrial DNA from a third person, uh you know, uh heritable human genome editing, uh, a range of kind of technologies basically that are reshaping kind of this uh idea of genetic relation away from this very straightforward like egg, sperm, embryo, done.

SPEAKER_02Right. So uh I kind of started out by thinking, okay, well, you know, there's it's almost like, oh, this is an interesting puzzle. Like, what is it conceptually? Like, how can we define it in a way that maps onto our intuitions about kind of uh parenthood um and what it should be? But the reality is that uh the reason that it's such an interesting concept to define is precisely because of the value that we assign to it. Um and I think in part use of the term parenthood when we think about genetic parenthood, uh really brings in a lot of these sort of moral and social and legal kind of values and and and norms and intuitions that are not going to be helpful as we move towards a very, very different kind of uh landscape of reproductive biotechnologies.

SPEAKER_02So I think sort of biological parenthood or the genetic relation, essentially, I might just say genetic relation, um, is it's often seen as valuable because it essentially is presumed to have some normative value in assigning moral parenthood. So, like uh, you know, sort of moral sort of duties and and and responsibilities. Um but I think there is, I would say both a generally kind of accepted social view as well as sort of some fairly extensive philosophical arguments in the literature, basically saying like this is not um a super strong kind of connection, right?

SPEAKER_02It's it seems very apparent that like we see this in kind of pop culture and that sort of thing, where we say it's not necessarily the biological connection that's the be-all and end all. It's about who you know puts you to bed at the end of, puts the kid to bed at the end of the day, who um you know comforts you when you're upset, who you know makes you dinner, who you know teaches you lessons, etc. etc. That that actual kind of day-to-day practice of parenting, actually parenting. So um uh but it's still there might still be some reasons why we might want to know about it as a concept, um, just that they might be slightly different uh to assigning sort of either parental kind of rights or responsibilities um or uh you know legal kind of decisions and so on.

SPEAKER_04I think we should apply this to the New York Times article that broke, what was it yesterday or the day before, or it or it came out this week? So, so I don't know if you've read it, but a I think she's like a 60, now she might be 66 or 65-year-old woman called Mary Beth, and she is fighting for legal guardianship and uh to be the legal parents of her twins, which were born via surrogate, and they are uh, I believe, uh made from donut, egg, and sperm.

SPEAKER_04So she is neither genetically related nor gestationally related, so she didn't she didn't birth these these twins. And then twins are now two years old and have been living with foster parents for the past two years. Now there's a whole lot of controversy because these are her 14th and 15th child. She uh they are genetically related to her pre- Oh no, they're not. So her previous three children before that, so children's 11, 12, and 13. She birthed via IVF by fraudulently signing her husband's name so that she could have the children.

SPEAKER_04And then with these last two, he didn't even know until about a month out from this the the twins being born. So she was for she fraudulently uh presented him in like magistrates' court by like signing him on a Zoom. She like forged his name. So he was a pilot and she said she got very good at forging his name over the last 20, 30 years. And so there are lots of things that have gone or have been quite unfortunate in the lead up to the the birth and the subsequent birth of these children, particularly like how much fraud she committed in going through the IVF process to get these children born.

SPEAKER_04And there were some, you know, there are the some other people have spurred out worries about her age, but I think we can just put that to the side. Uh concerns about her uh her having like an empty nesters issue. So she just she confessed to just whenever the child had grown up a bit, she just felt lonely and empty again. And we'll just put those issues to aside as well. I don't think we need to make comments on the reasons why people have children. Um, but I think one of the most interesting things is this might be one of the first cases, well not maybe one of the first cases, but a very interesting case where gestational, genetic, and social parenthood are not there.

SPEAKER_04So she has not, she has not seen these children, she actually doesn't know their names. And they're two years old, and she's fighting, her and her husband are now fighting for guardianship and legal parenthood over them. And so we have a very interesting case where someone is not related to a child in any way at all. In genes, you know, surrogacy, they don't even know the kid. And we're uh uh the courts haven't made a decision yet. Uh, and so it's is intent to have a kid simply enough to lay claim to lack legal or moral parenthood.

SPEAKER_01It's like intentional parenthood.

SPEAKER_04Intentional parenthood, because that's what the American courts have so long upheld, which is you know who intended to bring about the child. They're the they're the parents. But Hillary, based on the very small facts and potentially some of them are wrong, what do you think? So the job of the courts. Judge Hillary, welcome, welcome.

SPEAKER_02You're not uh I'm not a legal scholar, I don't have a legal background, and I I feel like we can put legal questions aside. Okay, yeah, especially, you know, in the particular case of the US, the the laws differ so significantly from state to state. Yeah. Uh, but just from sort of an again, if we go back to these two kind of elements, this kind of conceptual question, um, and then the sort of normative or or moral question.

SPEAKER_02Um I guess in terms of intent uh or causality, uh, I think when we look at kind of these definitions of biological parenthood that have come up sort of in the literature, causation and causality seems quite sort of important in some way. Um the challenge is that uh defining, you know, the appropriate kind of level of causation is actually really hard.

SPEAKER_02Because again, if we're trying to take intuitions that we've got from what I might call as kind of like standard sexual reproduction, um where you have sort of you know two people having sexual intercourse and bringing about you know a child, uh you know, um causation seems fairly sort of sort of straightforward there. Intent generally, um, you know, we can obviously sort of uh look at how that might the actual kind of intent or motivation might come apart there.

SPEAKER_02But uh it's in these cases where it becomes clear that it's it's sort of challenging to pick out the exact level of causation that might be kind of like conceptually relevant. Because if we make causation too broad, you end up saying, oh, there's this IVF lab technician out there who has 500,000 children. Um, because they are causally involved in bringing about the child, right? Um you know, they they are there. Um, but if you uh sort of, you know, basically, so if if you make uh causation too broad as a criteria, you basically create a too many parents problem.

SPEAKER_02Like you have too many parents uh who can reasonably say they've they've caused this child to come about. Um uh in terms of this specific case, uh, I think we might sort of reasonably say, well, it just played some role in bringing causing this child to come into existence, sure. Um I'm not you know super sort of again, then there's this question of like, well, does she sort of you know, count as a parent in?

SPEAKER_02Some way, well setting aside that kind of abstract conceptual question. It's like, well, does it matter? Like how much does it mat how much does her role matter? Um, how much kind of uh you know, weight should we give her role in this process? And I would think it's reasonable to say, again, setting aside the legal questions, um not because they're irrelevant, but just because I don't know enough sort of to comment on the specific legal matters, but her sort of she doesn't know these children.

SPEAKER_02Um, she hasn't sort of like uh contributed uh you know a lot of labor in bringing them about. Um you might say that she has spent some money, perhaps, in that sense, but yeah, it doesn't seem like she has a super strong sort of moral claim to actually having, you know, the ability to raise and have custody of these children. Um you've also of course got to think about what you know, what is the best thing for these children.

SPEAKER_02Um, obviously, like then, you know, you're going back to think like sort of, you know, like the best interest test or whatever. Um what is the best thing for them? And I'm gonna take a wild stab in the dark without knowing any of the facts about the case, but it's probably not for her to raise these children. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I feel like that case raises an another issue, another kind of parenthood, which is like something like maybe continuous parenthood or something. Because if you gave me that case and and said, Oh, yeah, maybe she has some kind of claim. And then if you also tell me that she has been raising the kids this whole time, and this has come up now, you know, there might be an argument here. It's like, yeah, she had a claim in the beginning, plus the fact that she has been raising the kids, it would be good in terms of like the continued support and contact for her to uh to continue to be a parent.

SPEAKER_01But in this case, she she hasn't even been there in the last two years. So uh so whatever claim she might have had at first maybe just doesn't exist anymore. And the is that another possibility?

SPEAKER_02This is where I would think we would sort of go away from, I guess, this question of oh, what is you know biological sort of parenthood? What is this biological relation, which is almost in a sense basically a distraction, um, and look at all of these sort of other accounts in the philosophical literature about what is moral parenthood and what what counts. So, you know, we have uh philosophers like uh Joseph, Joseph Millam or Luara Ferrocioli who are talking about we might have things like an investment or kind of labor-based account, like how much work are you actually doing in the day-to-day?

SPEAKER_02Like, what are you actually doing? You waking them up, you're making them breakfast, are you helping them, you know, with their homework, that sort of thing? What is the actual labor that you are doing? Um and you know, or or how much are you committed to their well-being and and to their flourishing? Um, how much are you sort of committed to helping them become, you know, a functioning adult living a happy life? Uh and on the first sort of, you know, if we if we think about, well, how much work has she actually done it like she has not kind of built a uh we might say that she has done some sort of investment in a sense, but she doesn't have any actual direct relational kind of uh like she does not actually have a social connection with these children.

SPEAKER_02She does not know them, she does not you know even know their names uh from what you've told me. Yeah, there's not that sort of direct relational element. So you can kind of sort of think about it from that perspective, but also if we think about sort of is she committed to their well-being um and their flourishing? I don't know enough to say, but my immediate instinct would be that it sounds like from just again from your description, it sounds like she sort of views these children in a kind of quite instrumental way um in terms of what they do for her well-being.

SPEAKER_02Um, that might be very off base. Um, again, they might they might be better off with her. I do not know, but um, we might also think about it from that perspective. So I think in this case, um there's already existing a huge amount of philosophical work on how we can think about moral parenthood that is sort of the I suppose the thing that we should look at rather than being almost like distracted by this question of like genetic or biological relation.

SPEAKER_01There's also the possibility coming up on the horizon of more than two parents, right?

SPEAKER_04It's already here.

SPEAKER_01Okay, it's oh it's come up over the horizon. The sun is shining brightly upon us, uh, and in this case, more than two suns shining brightly upon us. A sun and a moon, and even okay, you know what? This analogy is going too far. But the point is um there's the idea of um more than two parents, and even in the case of and and I think many of us, you've as you've already pointed out, if you we expand the scope and concept of parenthood to beyond the biological parent, I think many of us have already uh already recognized and probably have already recognized for a long time that in a sense several people can be a person's parent, right?

SPEAKER_01Uh in many many families and in many cultures, uh siblings or other relatives are involved in bringing up a child and are and might be parents in a sense. But now there's a very you know, this problem this this idea is is almost even more apparent when we have the idea of multiple genetic parents with uh uh IVG and MRT. Uh those correct, did I say those right?

SPEAKER_04Um, where you have an ABC, FGD, FGD, uh yeah.

SPEAKER_01So uh yeah. Uh is there are there new moral uh implications here?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I think um uh there's already, as you say, so when there was the debate around sort of um legislation for mitochondrial replacement therapy in the UK and Australia, again, where you have mitochondrial like genetic material from a third person, um the question was, and it was often the term was often used in the media, three parent babies. Um and so, you know, one of the sort of questions that the Australian Senate reviewed was like, well, is the person who provides the mitochondria essentially, are they a donor?

SPEAKER_02Or could they qualify as a third parent? And so there's essentially these two conceptual frameworks for how we might think about that person who provides that those that sort of uh mitochondrial genetic material. We might think of them as like a donor akin to like a kidney donor, like we've got, you know, uh some mitochondria that don't work, we're gonna swap them out for, you know, some mitochondria that do, in the same way that we might swap out a kidney that doesn't work for a kidney that does. Uh, but we might also think about them as a third parent who has provided some genetic material.

SPEAKER_02And there's like obviously a lot of debate around that. You might say, well, like uh mitochondrial DNA is a very, very small amount, you know, relative to nuclear DNA. Um, it might not be sort of as identity determining. Um, but also that on the other, like it's pretty critical to actually having that child exist at all. Um, so you know, there's that as well. Um but basically the debate was should this person count as a third parent?

SPEAKER_02And you know, the reality is that our legal and social systems, you know, our social, I think socially we uh are very actually accustomed to dealing with the idea of more than two parents socially. Like we have step parents and you know, guardians and family members and all kinds of we're we're we're you know socially used to sort of saying, like, oh, you know, um that's Greg, you know, he's not the legal parent of this child, but he's been around since, you know, since she was, you know, six months old.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, of course he's gonna be was like a father to me.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. Oh my god, that that too. Um, but uh yeah, so but but legally, like if we think about these kind of nitty-gritty, very practical questions, like who has to pay sort of money for them to eat, who has to pay for their food, who has to choose, who gets to choose where they go to school, like these very sort of uh tricky questions are legal sort of systems that are set up to account for two parents.

SPEAKER_02And that's increasingly being tested, you know. For example, with sperm donors, we're moving away from donor anonymity. Like previously we had this approach of like, well, uh sperm donor is essentially invisible. Um uh, you know, they're they're sort of we're gonna try and essentially keep them out of the picture as much as possible. Like we, you know, because we have this system that's that's mapped around a very specific model of the family. Um and it's kind of uh inconvenient to to sort of have this third person count as as a biological parent.

SPEAKER_02And to be clear, many sperm donors did do not want to count as as as sort of parents, uh, in a sense. But um, you know, so the way we actually think about these concepts is shaped by you know what we want it to, you know, what what our sort of I suppose uh social values are and what our moral beliefs are actually. So it's not like we have this neutral conceptual question of like, oh, who is a parent? It's actually very much, you know, um a you know, a very sort of normatively loaded question.

SPEAKER_02Um and it gets that's why it gets so confusing. So even though I sort of have said like there's these two elements, our desire to to define that on a conceptual level is driven by the social values and the and the sort of uh beliefs that we hold. So yeah, if so we have a legal framework that's like you know, uh biological parenthood is really useful in helping us essentially pick out two people who are parents, um, and it's quite useful in that respect.

SPEAKER_02Um it's not gonna work. It's not, you know, in the future we're gonna have increasing sort of situations uh where we have reproductive biotechnologies uh creating complex complex situations, like for example, the IVF embryo mix-ups, um, or even just as we have seen like um you know, uh changes in kinship structures and and and family dynamics, you know, um in terms of like say um queer families, um you know, uh blended families, just like all of these sort of different ways that we build families um that are challenging that kind of you know two and no more approach.

SPEAKER_04So if I G enables us to reproduce without like the usual means, like sexual intercourse, and IVF has allowed us to do this for a while, but how is this going to uh transform not just like family structures? You know, we might have more than two parents, quotation marks, but also more things like cultural narratives around like love, reproduction, and and things like human lineage.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I think um, and this is something that we often see with technology generally, is that so I often think of an example being like the Jetsons, you know, that cartoon from some time ago. Yes, I do remember this. Um, and so the Jetsons, you know, it's basically I've never actually watched it, honestly, but like, you know, the the whole kind of thing is like, oh, it's in space, it's like uh hundred years in the future. And and the housewife has a robot maid uh who helps her with her housewife duties.

SPEAKER_02And uh, you know I did not remember this. The husband, you know, who is the breadwinner of the family, you know, gets in his self-driving car to go to work and so on and so forth. So essentially the Jetsons was like this image of a future where everything is the same in terms of social structure, but just plus robots, which we and flying cars and flying cars or whatever, which is not how we like technology shapes, you know, our social structures, right?

SPEAKER_02Um, I think this is one of the things with in vitro gametogenesis that I sort of think is uh it almost kind of like uh undermines the reason for its existence because we spend so much money developing these technologies, like in vitro gametogenesis, because it's positioned as a way to help people have biologically related children. Um, you know, it might be sort of in terms of whether that's uh because of uh infertility, whether sort of sort of from a biological perspective or social infertility or or whatever.

SPEAKER_02Um it helps it will help people have biologically related children, which is important to them and that they want to have, but it disrupts the idea of biological parenthood. It disrupts that concept. And so you have this sort of like collect conceptual collapse where uh you know the drive to develop this technology uh is because we place all of this moral sort of weight on this concept of genetic parenthood, but it kind of in a circular fashion makes the concept of genetic parenthood incoherent almost or very difficult to define.

SPEAKER_02So uh, you know, then it it yeah, kind of is is then disrupting this kind of driver for for developing it and and actually bringing it um into existence. So I think, you know, one of the interesting things about in vitro gaminogenesis is like, so there's a bunch of sort of different scenarios that have been raised in the literature, um uh, you know, like multiplex parenting. Um, you know, that's not my idea. Uh so you know, essentially like having four people have a child that is related to them as in the sense of a grandparent, but the sort of inter sort of intermediate generation is is in vitro.

SPEAKER_02Um sorry, it's a bit complex without drawing a diagram, but basically, like the child comes about with parents being in vitro embryos, and there are four people who are parents, so you have have like uh that kind of setup. And I think in particular, like the way we think about biological reproduction is is very kind of um uh you know, maps onto essentially like sexual and romantic relationships. So even with things like IVF, where you do not actually have to have sexual intercourse to have a child, um there's still this element of like uh, I suppose, um sexual roles that are mapped onto the gametes, like sperm, man, egg, you know, woman, that that kind of thing.

SPEAKER_02And they they they so these uh biotechnologies also sort of disrupt these uh sexed and gendered, I suppose, ideas around uh reproduction and gestation and and so on. And so with IVG, because you're sort of uh removing your you're sort of divorcing uh sexual kind of uh and romantic, I suppose, relationships from that process of reproduction, even more so, I think you know, it's possible that it would become much more normalized to just have children with your friends.

SPEAKER_02Because, you know, and lots of people have done this throughout history, you know, historically, like many sort of like gay men and lesbian women have had children together um through these kind of like informally negotiated kind of relationships. Even in pop culture, though, it's it's often represented as like like there's this movie um friends with kids. Uh it's got like that guy from Parks and Wreck in it. And it's like it opens with, you know, these two heterosexual friends, they're like, oh, we're gonna have a kid together, um, you know, just as friends, and then obviously by the end of the film, they're together in a romantic film.

SPEAKER_02Because crazy. Yeah. So uh, you know, this, so there's this like implicit framing of gametes like fusing to create an embryo as sort of a almost like some sort of sexual relationship, um, you know, which kind of inherently kind of positions this idea of reproduction as sitting within you know romantic and sexual relationships. Um, and the idea of doing it outside that is sort of well, it's unusual. Um you know, that's yeah, that's just a sort of a an example um of you know, it might yeah, reshape sort of the sort of political and social dynamics of reproduction such that it's more normalized to have kids with friends or just like people who you might like to sort of raise a child with or whatever, because you're you're abstracting it even more away from the the the a sort of sexual uh relationship.

SPEAKER_02That's just an example.

SPEAKER_04Um I'd love that. I did not even think that you could have friends with your kids because I'm I'm clearly just like locked into that, whatever that that thing that you were talking about. But in this economy, I think that IVG is the way to go. Like I can't afford to have a kid with with just my husband, like you know, double income, no kids can't, it's just not gonna be feasible for quite some time, maybe ever. But if there were just a couple other, you know, income supporters in that, you know, and then I don't have to do child pickup like you know, half of the week, or I could just, you know, be a parent once a month or like one week out of a month.

SPEAKER_04Um Killery, you've opened my mind.

SPEAKER_01You want to give a kid timeshare?

SPEAKER_04Kid timeshare.

SPEAKER_02I think like like with your point about in this, like I think a lot of us kind of dream about raising kids in a kind of commune setup.

SPEAKER_04Like because like the childhood that we had in like, I don't know, early 2000s or 90s, you know, where it's just like all of us like just sort of babysit each other in the in the cul-de-sac, you know, and it's just you just go to everyone's houses all afternoon, and that that's just sort of how you're raised. But in a in the commune, yes, Hillary, everyone's kid.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, but I mean, maybe that's just maybe this is just sort of displaying how atomized we have, you know, sort of become. And you know, I'm not gonna delve into the whole kind of sociological kind of thing there, but we're all sort of aware of that that issue, like, you know, not being anywhere near your parents or your friends and makes it really difficult, like just two parents working to raise, you know, a child or whatever. But yeah, I I think just sort of the interesting thing that we're gonna see with these reproductive biotechnologies is it's not really like, oh, we're gonna have to like really nail down this concept of genetic parenthood.

SPEAKER_02We're gonna have to, it's it's gonna be really tricky. We're gonna have to nail it down. I think what it shows is like, oh, actually, like we're not gonna be able to nail it down in some sort of precise, exact way. We're actually gonna have to reflect more on its uh sort of normative uh significance, um, and also sort of just its conceptual coherence kind of generally. Uh, and that, you know, could be could be good, could I guess could be bad in in some ways.

SPEAKER_02Like uh obviously I don't have time to sort of go into all of that.

SPEAKER_04It's like we're trying to cookie-cut a cloud into shape. It's just maybe maybe we just let it drift away.

SPEAKER_01Just like your kids.

SPEAKER_02Again, like I I think there might be some reasons why we might want to know about these relations, right? Like, um, I don't want to say it's like unimportant because there might be some reasons why it is important, but I think we can move away from this idea of like, oh, we're gonna be able to very clearly pick out who are the biological parents, who are the genetic parents, and move towards a more kind of like, I suppose like almost like fuzzy concept, um, where there are lots of different kinds of parents with different kinds of duties and rights and responsibilities.

SPEAKER_02Um, and there's gonna be some difficult practical questions, there's gonna be some different difficult kind of ethical questions, there's gonna be some difficult legal questions, uh, but essentially what we are moving towards, I think, is an understanding of parenthood that is a bit fuzzy.

SPEAKER_04Like a cloud. See, we need the cloud. The cloud brings rain and that helps us grow, but we can't force it into a particular shape. You know, they come in all different shapes. We have the nebulous cloud, you have the nimbus cloud. Actually, don't know if nebulous is just from guys of the galaxy.

SPEAKER_02Do not know um, I do not know enough about meteorology to comment on the appropriateness of that metaphor because I actually doubt on the cloud thing. I I I actually originally wanted to do a uh climate science uh minor in my undergrad. Um and then I got to the end of first year and I was like, mm-mm. No, no thanks. That's actually really hard.

SPEAKER_04No, no, no, thanks.

SPEAKER_02This is not for my I will stick with molecular biology. Thank you.

SPEAKER_04Okay, okay. It really was, James. I don't know why you didn't do it.

SPEAKER_01Oh, because philosophy is even easier.

SPEAKER_04Uh well, I also did a philosophy degree. I also did a phone.

SPEAKER_02Um no, that's why it took forever to finish my undergrad.

SPEAKER_04So a lot of confessions coming out today. Okay, so we're gonna leave our listeners there. That parenthood is like a cloud. Uh useful, but a bit fuzzy. Uh and thank you so much, Hilary, for coming on and letting us just waffle on about this. We really appreciated it.

SPEAKER_01I feel like we should end with an epilogue. Like, Hillary went on to become a leading researcher in uh uh bioethics and parenting. James went on to be a hobul. Sinead started a commune.

SPEAKER_02Yes, that's it. Just leave it. Actually, I actually have have thought about my dream commune setup, but I won't go into this. Okay, we're gonna end the podcast here.

SPEAKER_01All right, thank you.

SPEAKER_02Thanks so much, guys.

SPEAKER_00Okay Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to C BME and you and be stabby.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can Nihilism Improve Your Mental Wellbeing?

    Nov 2, 202645 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Insurance Discrimination: Is it Fair? with Harisan Nasir

    Sep 24, 202649 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Genomic Newborn Screening: Where less really is sometimes more with Ainsley Newson

    Aug 25, 202655 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Hidden Side of Birth: Injury, Trauma, and PTSD with Angela Ballantyne

    Jul 2, 202648 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Brains in Jars with Insoo Hyun

    Jun 1, 202656 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...

    Credit the people on this episode