Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Professor Larry Temkin (Rutgers University) proposes the initially controversial idea that expecting all countries to provide universal healthcare is more problematic than we realise. In what Larry has retrospectively described as a podcast that 'may have been my most FUN interview ever', Larry talks about his impact on Chinese healthcare systems, the social determinants of health, and our moral responsibilities to help other countries. Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01The center presents a new podcast at C BME and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_02And welcome back to CB Me and You, a podcast about biomedical ethics. Today we talk about universal health coverage. What is it? Should all nations aspire to achieve it, or is universal health coverage a pie in the sky fantasy? Joining us today is Larry Temkin, distinguished professor emeritus of philosophy at Rutgers University. Welcome, Larry. Great. Great to be here. Thanks a lot.
SPEAKER_00To get to know you a little bit better, we have three questions. Um and I know some of the your answers to some of these already, but for for the sake of the pod, please endure with us. First question: coffee or copy?
SPEAKER_03Okay, so until I met you 10 minutes ago, I'd never heard of copy. I still don't really know what it is, but you may need to drink some of this.
SPEAKER_00Well, this isn't so we've given you Milo. Oh, Milo.
SPEAKER_03Okay, okay. So I still don't know what copy is. So is Milo different than copy? Yes. Oh, so then I have no view about coffee or copy. What I can say is I don't like coffee at all. I don't like the taste. I like the smell of it. I have no idea whether I like copy, uh, smell, or taste.
SPEAKER_00No, I just realized that I was said I was gonna let you have a sip of my coffee, and then I went ahead and drank it all and proceeded to ask you the question. So this is technically my fault.
SPEAKER_04Okay. It's on you.
SPEAKER_00It is on me. So copy is Singaporean coffee, um, and it's uh beans, generally robuster beans, that have been roasted with uh caramel or sugar, caramelized sugar, and butter, and then they serve it generally with sweetened condensed milk.
SPEAKER_03Well, I'm gonna guess I prefer coffee because anything with butter type stuff is usually better than anything without it. So uh so and also I'm a guest in the country, and I don't want to be a rude guest, so I will go with copy with no basis for that judgment at all, other than your description of it.
SPEAKER_02The butter stuff is great because in some of the more traditional uh like coffee shops, they'll give you the copy and they'll just put like a little stick of butter straight in.
SPEAKER_03So there's a famous hamburger place in the city where I grew up, and I think it was once rated as one of the ten best hamburger places in America, and they make what's called a butter burger. And the butter burger is you grill a hamburger and you have a bun, and they put about a quarter of a pound of melted butter on it, and just slop it on with grilled onions, and it's incredibly good. So I assume that's a lot like coffee.
SPEAKER_04Yes, an onion drink, notoriously.
SPEAKER_03A butter onion drink, that's the thing.
SPEAKER_02Okay, off you go a drink version of the burger.
SPEAKER_00Excellent. Uh, next question What country do you most want to travel to next?
SPEAKER_03Okay, so I don't have a very good answer to that because my wife and I have traveled really a lot already. We've gone to all seven continents, and um and we've been to most of the places we really want to travel to. We've been to Africa multiple times, we've been to Egypt, part of Africa, of course, been to Jordan, part of the Middle East, been to Turkey, been to Greece. I won't try to name all the places. Went to Russia in 1977, went to China in 1997, been back five times. First time to Singapore, though.
SPEAKER_03Really? Um so what country do I want to go to next? I think it might be Iceland. I think it might be Iceland. We are scheduled to go to Iceland. Uh uh, we are on uh the Faroe Islands, actually, uh, with a friend of mine. Um most people have never heard of the Faroe Islands, but it's a very cool place.
SPEAKER_00Haven't been to Kangaroo Island.
SPEAKER_03Uh yeah, well they're both great. And we were supposed to go to Iceland next, and sadly my mom passed away, so all plans had to be canceled, and we haven't yet made it back because we have COVID intervened, traveling came to a halt. Um, but probably Iceland, possibly Iceland, um, we had a trip to Machu Picchu planned, and I came down with double pneumonia and had to go to the hospital, so I had to cancel the trip to Machu Picchu. So maybe Peru, but I have been to Peru, so it's not like if it next means I might still go back in order to go to Machu Picchu, but it wouldn't be like the first time.
SPEAKER_02Now you say you've been to seven continents. Does that include Antarctica?
SPEAKER_03Since there are only seven continents, one of which is Antarctica, you can infer correctly that it does. Sorry. That was an drawback of it completely. We are losing that. Yes, it does. It does include Antarctica.
SPEAKER_00Next time he asks a question, please feel free to do just that again.
SPEAKER_03Am I allowed to say that's the stupidest question I've ever heard? No.
SPEAKER_02You have some records. Larry is a bit sassy sometimes.
SPEAKER_03It does include Antarctica. We had a fabulous trip. It's my wife's favorite trip ever. The trip to Antarctica.
SPEAKER_00Now for our final question.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00What is your go-to karaoke song?
SPEAKER_03Okay, so as you know, my go-to karaoke song is There Is None. Is there a song? Is there a song called There Is None? Because that's it. I have never karaoked in my life, and I don't, it's not actually on my bucket list. It's not not it's not just not at the top of my bucket list, it's not second on my bucket list, it's not even last on my bucket list. It's just not there.
SPEAKER_00I am really sorry to hear that. Yeah. It seems like you've for the most part lived a really rich and fulfilling life. But I think that, you know, this is a bit of a this is a bit of a red flag.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, probably. Probably it is. There's got to be something that you save for the afterlife.
SPEAKER_00A thousand years of karaoke.
SPEAKER_03I hope not. I hope not. We do actually.
SPEAKER_04He's like, that does not sound like a good half-to-like.
SPEAKER_03Our department has a karaoke uh holiday party every year. Um, and I do attend the party. I declined to participate in the karaoke.
SPEAKER_00So you've never sung in like the shower or in the car by yourself, just you know, a little boogie.
SPEAKER_03I have sung by myself in the shower in the car. I don't know. Do I? Let me think about that. I'm sure the answer to that question must be no, because you said have you never. So I think I have sung to myself at some point in my life, uh, maybe more than once. But no, I don't usually sing to myself. Uh partly though, I said I have no visual imagery, but I also have no auditory imagery, so I can't really hear a song in my head.
SPEAKER_00What what's going on in there?
SPEAKER_03Uh I do analytic philosophy. I'm pretty good at that. We can talk about that maybe a little too, you know.
SPEAKER_00All the other unnecessary bits and pieces, and that's that that's just that's it.
SPEAKER_03No, I do, I mean, I do lots of stuff, as you can tell. I travel a lot, and I have kids, and I have grandkids, and I do lots of fun things. But um, and my wife and I have had an incredibly rich life together, and I don't regret it for a second. And uh I have lots of really, really interesting, smart friends and fun people and things to do, and I do a lot of sports.
SPEAKER_00Just not karaoke.
SPEAKER_03But karaoke isn't one of them. No, no, not one of them.
SPEAKER_00So, our first question for you is what exactly do people mean when they talk about universal health coverage?
SPEAKER_03So it turns out that a lot of people mean different things by it, and that's uh a complication in its own right. But um, but there are standard ideas of what universal health care ideally is supposed to represent. And ideally, it's supposed to represent um health coverage for anybody who needs it. Um and ideally, at an affordable price that will not cause anyone to go into significant debt. So if the question is who should be covered, the answer for universal health coverage is everyone.
SPEAKER_03Uh if the question is what condition should be covered, then again, ideally, the answer is every condition. And if the question is who's to pay for it, it's people pay according to their ability to pay. But if you don't have the ability to pay, then it should be provided for you. That's the idea. And uh in any event, nobody should have to pay um and be reduced to poverty or have a catastrophic economic impact on their lives as a result of having to have uh needed health care.
SPEAKER_03That's the ideal. And that's what uh in theory um the United Nations said, you know, it's a universal declaration of rights. Everybody has a right to health coverage, and as that's been expounded over the years, uh, this is the way most people understand it. Now, in fact, when I mean I know a lot of the people who are working in this field and who are really, really good, people like Ole Norheim or Nir Ayell, and um they'll say, well, you know, we say universal health care, but of course, you know, that's that's the ideal, that's what we want, but we're really just trying to get people to inch closer to it.
SPEAKER_03Um but um there's dangers in telling people you have a right to universal health care in the world's poorest countries, or so I believe and argue, and we can talk more about that uh for reasons that we might talk about.
SPEAKER_02So you you just mentioned uh that this is ideal that at least ideally we want to cover every single thing. Yeah. Does that include um what many people would call really elective um medical interventions, for example, braces? Is there are there people out there advocating that everybody should get free braces if they want braces?
SPEAKER_03Okay, so that I I I I think I'd I'll decline to answer that question in the following way. If you say something like, are there people out there who the answer to that's almost always going to be yes, because there's always somebody who's gonna take the most extreme position on any view you might want to put forward. And I don't know whether braces is an example of the most extreme condition. And then there'll be debates in the United States about whether you should pay for uh trans surgeries and so on. You know, it's a more substantive debate. How important is that for human well-being?
SPEAKER_03And, you know, is this a controversial one for other reasons? Blah, blah, blah. Um, but but certainly any sort of so elective surgery, you might you might say, you know, should we be paying for you know collagen implants or whatever it is, you know, injections, collagen in uh injections or whatever. Um, I don't hear any serious bioethicists arguing for that, uh, or plastic surgery in general. Um, but they do mean, you know, if you you know are suffering, you know, some serious disease, a kidney disease or something like that, and you would need uh, you know, uh to be hooked up to a dialysis machine, then on the theory of universal health care, and if you have a universal, if there's a universal right to health care, then uh that should be provided to you and without significant damaging your financial uh situation.
SPEAKER_03Um so anything of that sort certainly would be covered um uh on this view if we could.
SPEAKER_02So in terms of the serious views like proposed by serious ethicists, yeah. We're talking about a very wide range of um medical procedures, but that maybe excludes some cosmetic, the more obviously cosmetics. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03I I mean uh certainly uh the the ones that have a significant impact and this is where it gets controversial, I must say. But the the thought is the ones that have a significant impact on the quality of one's physical and psychological well-being should be covered. And then one might say, you know, I'm a teenager unless I get this tattoo, you know, I want to end my life. And, you know, for a teenager, something like that might be true. Uh and then the question is, does that mean you have to give them a tattoo? So, you know, it's it's uh there could be murky interpretations of this, but but there's kind of standard views about what is normally necessary from a health standpoint for physical and psychological wholeness or well-being.
SPEAKER_03Anything that threatens that will in principle be covered. Um, but um there's you know these whole categories of different diseases, you know, uh uh condition one, condition two, condition three type diseases, and uh um and they cover you know the wide range of things from you know measles and diphtheria and uh dengue fever and so on and so forth to cancers, heart disease, um, all sorts of stuff of that kind, to accidents, near drownings, being hit by a lightning strike, all those kinds of things, type one, type two, and type three different conditions are in theory um part of what universal healthcare wants to address.
SPEAKER_00One of the things you said that I hadn't quite realized about universal health coverage was that it's according to ability to pay, not a blanket coverage for all. And so I'm quite intrigued by that because that seems quite reasonable. It should be based on how much you can afford. So if you really can't afford it without going quite bankrupt or not being able to afford it, the other necessities for life, and you know, it should be free for you. But millionaires, billionaires should be paying, you know, full costs all the time because it won't bankrupt them. Is this consistent with what you're saying?
SPEAKER_03It is. It is. I mean, as it's typically understood. I mean, there's lots of people who will advocate for a variety of social and political reasons. Uh no, everybody just gets it. You know, we're gonna have a system where everybody gets a healthcare, and if they want to, and and then we have these variations, but you know, again, if we talk about the ideal, so far, all we're doing is talking about the ideal rather than what will actually happen and what would happen in different kinds of countries. Uh but often universal health care is a level of coverage for certain kinds of diseases, and it might be provided to everybody in the country for social and political reasons, regardless of how much money they have.
SPEAKER_03And then uh, if someone wants to buy private insurance or they're wealthy enough to afford their own doctors, or you know, I lived in Houston, Texas for many years. We had one of the world's greatest medical centers, the Texas Medical Center at one point had the two greatest living heart surgeons. And all the time, you know, Sheikhs and others from uh from uh the Middle East would fly into Houston, Texas to have, you know, their hearts addressed by the two world's leading uh heart surgeons. Um so if you can afford that on your own, then that's another matter, you know.
SPEAKER_03Um but but in the ideal situation, everyone needs to be able to have access to coverage that will not significantly impact their financial well-being. And um, if you can afford to pay it, then there's no reason why uh you can't be required to pay it, on this kind of view.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so that all sounds very appealing, right? It sounds like a very attractive ideal, right? Everybody being able to get the health care they need without being made bankrupt uh by uh by it, or in worst case scenarios, just not being able to get it, period.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um but I know that you've expressed a little bit of skepticism, or you've expressed some concerns about this. So uh could could we rehearse some of these con uh these main concerns that you have?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, sure. So so this is a classic example where a lot of people with the best of intentions latch onto an ideal. And the idea of universal health care is one that people said a dozen years ago or so, you know. This is the next great revolution in healthcare, universal healthcare for everyone. And all of the developed countries save one, my own backward country in the United States, has univers some form of universal health care, social science medicine of some form or another.
SPEAKER_03Uh only the United States does not, among the most 25 most advanced countries, economically advanced countries in the world. And um and then a few middle income countries and a few even lower level countries began to get some form of uh universal health care. And then people thought, well, gosh, if some of these countries can do it, really everyone should do it. We really need to have this everywhere. And so there became a big push, roughly around, I'm gonna say 2010, uh plus or minus a couple of years. Uh, the World Health Organization, the UN, uh others, in 2012, there was a major uh series of articles, whole series of articles, an entire issue of the Lancet, which was one of the great biomedical ethical journals, that was um urging that we needed to, we needed to, and I'm gonna use that word on purpose, uh, we typically in the West needed to, you know, urge pressure, maybe coerce, certainly strongly encourage uh that there be universal health care, even in the world's poorest countries, uh, with the noblest of ideals because people are sick, we want to help them.
SPEAKER_03That's the thought. Um, and so uh there was the this big uproar, and I participated in a conference at Harvard in the Harvard School of Public Health. Maybe it was in 2012, I mean we'd have to look it up, somewhere around there, might have been 2014. Um, and it was really it was held at the School of Public Health, but it was really uh deeply connected with the United Nations. And I heard lecture after lecture about why we need universal health care in the developing world, why that's important.
SPEAKER_03Its time has come, we have to find a way to make that happen, etc. Um, and I'm actually very concerned about that. And I'm concerned about that for a variety of reasons, actually. Um, but um I'll just mention a few of them. The main reason, probably I'm concerned about it, is as most people in this area have recognized, um, if there's going to be universal health care, it will overwhelmingly have to be funded by the poor nations themselves. Uh the reality is uh external aid doesn't come close to funding what would be necessary to cover something like universal health care, just doesn't do it.
SPEAKER_03Um and in um most of the developing world, the amount of aid that comes in or pours in um at least a few years ago, last time I looked at these numbers, was you know, countries were paying 16 times as much as outside aid was paying for. Um and in the world's poorest African countries, that was more like uh ten times as much or nine times as much. So the amount of coverage that would actually come from external aid at this point, uh realistically speaking, is you know, less than one-tenth.
SPEAKER_03Um and then the question is, well, um, should we be still pushing them if we're not willing to pay for it, if we're not actually going to be paying for it, should we be pushing them to bring this about? And the problem is that um in the world's poorest countries, they just don't have very much income. They don't have very much money. And it turns out that if they took all of their money that they have as a government that would normally go to spend on, you know, fire, police, defense, social services, infrastructure, energy development, education, and so on, all of that money and they uh spent it on health care.
SPEAKER_03They would barely have enough to cover most of what are called the type one diseases, you know, addressing the malarias and the infectious diseases and perinatal care and uh maternal health care and so on and so forth. Um, and that wouldn't cover any of the type two or any three, even if they're devoting all of their resources to it. And these are the ones that we often think of, you know, someone has a stroke and has kidney disease, someone has an accident, you want them to have health care. Um now, so what's the problem with that? Well, the obvious problem is if they devote all of their money to this, there's no money left over for education, for infrastructure, for fire and police and all the other things, social services, uh taking care of the elderly in non-healthcare related ways, uh, all of which are hugely important.
SPEAKER_03And um, there's a very famous guy, of course, from Michael Marmot in this domain, in the area of healthcare, who pointed out rightly what are called the social determinants of disease. And we all know that there's a large number of determinants of disease that are related to, like, you know, education levels, social status, whether your mother went to school or not, there's a whole bunch of where you live in a city that have a massive impact on the quality of a person's health. And um, and very, very often, um, expenditures on the social determinants of disease would be more effective in addressing a poor country's overall health than addressing it on health care itself.
SPEAKER_03But the sad part is that when you say you want a universal health care and you have a right to universal health care, you appeal to the United Nations and so on, then people think, well, if I'm sick, that means I have a right to be taken care of. And that means that the univer the government somehow provide to take care of me. And um and they'll only be able to do that if they're not spending money elsewhere. And the two things to notice about that is many times the money that would be spent on treating a disease, this is like the old issue of treating versus prevention.
SPEAKER_03We have I'm I'm rambling for a while here because these are you asked me, and there's just so many things to say about that. The reality is interviewee. Yeah, yeah, yeah. The reality is the reality is they have like uh three more strands I want to get to. I may never get off this strand. But the reality is that even if all you cared about with hell was healthcare, which I'm not gonna talk about, you have this issue of um uh treatment, you know, versus prevention. And and many people have recognized that, you know, ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.
SPEAKER_03It's so much cheaper often to prevent certain things from happening than to try to treat them after they've already happened or after they've started. You know, you prevent the cancer rather than treat the cancer, et cetera, et cetera. Um, but we have we everyone has always talked about the military industrial complex. Only recently have people begun to talk about the medical industrial complex. And the medical industrial complex, you know, represents a whole slew of interests, which are the interests of patients who are ill, doctors and nurses that service them, hospitals that take care of the ill, um, you know, the pharmaceutical companies, the insurance companies, there's this massive number of people who have a special interest in making sure that we can cure people who are sick.
SPEAKER_03But sadly, that's a special interest in curing people who are sick. It's not an interest in stopping people from getting sick. If people no longer got sick, the pharmaceutical companies would be out of a job, the doctors would be out of a job, the nurses would be out of a job, the insurance companies that make boatloads of money would be out of a job. So they don't have a particular interest, actually, to be honest, in preventing illnesses. They have a big interest in treating illnesses. There's money to be made, and money talks. Money exerts a tremendous power here.
SPEAKER_03So unfortunately, that combined with the humanitarian instinct to help someone in need, right? Someone's actually sick. They need your help. They have heart disease, they had a stroke, they had, you know, all these various problems. And you want to help them. They've been hit by lightning. Whatever it is, they showed up at the hospital door, and no one wants to shut the door on them. I don't want to shut the door on them either, don't get me wrong. Nobody wants to shut the door on them. But but the net result is we try to help everybody who's actually ill, and that crowds out, predictably, having resources to do things like prevent people from getting ill.
SPEAKER_03But that's just one small part of the problem. As I was saying, it also crowds out resources to improving housing, improving education, improving safety, uh, all these kinds of things in the article that uh that I sent you guys to read in advance of this interview. I mean, there's all sorts of psychological studies that show things like um when elderly people have pets, they live happier, contented lives, they live longer. Well, and when people laugh, that helps their psychology. They fare better.
SPEAKER_03Well, no health minister is gonna say we should be spending money on comedy clubs. I I think uh I would have been this.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Like we we have a right to pets and and comedy clubs. Right. Right. It's a fundamental human right.
SPEAKER_03Well, see, this is what people are gonna say. No one's gonna we have a right to health care, we think, if we're sick and somebody should treat us. No one thinks we should have a right to pet pet food. We should have a right to comedy clubs. But if we're actually interested in the health states of the citizens of our societies, it's very important psychologically that people have a good laugh. It's very important that elderly people, not everyone, has a pet. These are ways of actually improving health that can often be much more cost-effective than trying to treat people who are suffering from depression because they don't laugh enough and they don't have a pet, and so on and so forth.
SPEAKER_03So, so the reality is that there's so many ways in which the emphasis on health care turns into the emphasis on treatment of diseases, and this takes away resources from so many other factors that could be better for health. And then I'll just say one more thing now, and then I'll pause, let you guys back in. I really have four more points to make, but I'll just say one more here. And the other thing to bear in mind is health is only one of the many things that matter for a flourishing human life.
SPEAKER_03Health is important, but friendships are important, love is important, expanding your mind is important. There's so many things, freedom is important, autonomy is important, human rights are important. There are just so many things that are important for a flourishing human life. And the emphasis on health care can force the world's poorest countries to spending way, way, way more resources than they can afford to at the cost of other things that are very often as valuable, if not more, for the overall well-being of their citizens.
SPEAKER_02Can can we not draw a distinction between the kind of philosophical claim, which is there's an ideal about uh universal healthcare, and that there's a right to universal healthcare, and how we communicate this ideal to you know in public spaces, right? For example, we might instead say, look, this is this is there's an ideal, there's a right, there's this way we want to get to, but what this means is that we should spend as much as we reasonably can uh on healthcare, keeping in mind all the other important things in in a human life.
SPEAKER_02Aren't those two positions compatible?
SPEAKER_03Well, I I do think this is something we should do, but there's a real danger. There's a country, and sadly I'm forgetting the name of it right now. I'm not good with names as you guys know. Um I'm trying to think of which uh what country it was. It might have been Indonesia, um, where they had inscribed the universal right to health care in the Constitution. And um this was some years back, the country was not particularly wealthy, and um someone came down with uh had kidney failure.
SPEAKER_03And you know, they went to their doctors, they went to the hospitals, and they were basically told, um I'm sorry, but we just can't afford it. I mean, we don't have enough resources, you know. We're spending money on vaccinations and other kinds of things that affect large numbers of people. And they put it quite this way, but we can't afford to spend the amount of money to hook you up to a dialysis machine uh uh that would take away funds that we could use elsewhere that might save thousands of lives instead of just prolong your life, you know, for a few more years.
SPEAKER_03Um and they sued. And it went all the way up to the Supreme Court. And uh the Supreme Court of that country ruled that because the Constitution said they had a universal right to health care, they had the right to the kidney machine. And um so so words have a precise meaning, as I like to as I like to always say. And um and words have an impact. And when you say uh you have a universal right to X, that's much, much more, that's much stronger than saying, you know, it'd be really nice if everyone could have their health needs met.
SPEAKER_03Uh we do want everyone to have their health needs meet. I want that as much as anyone. I mean, I want to be very clear about this. I think I would like every country in the world to have universal health care, the sooner the better. Absolutely. And um, if external, if if the rich and powerful countries of the world, um uh it's a whole nother uh book of mine that we could talk about, uh a couple of books of mine actually, uh, were willing to do more and could more do more effectively to uh to help the world's poorest countries so that they could provide for themselves, uh, then far more people would be able to have access to the kind of health care that we would like them to have than they currently have.
SPEAKER_03But for us, another thing that I object to, for us, say in the West, or the richest countries, uh, you know, to be telling these poor countries uh there's a universal right to health care. You need to have that. You need to make that happen for your country, for us to be telling them what they should do for their citizens. I mean, that's smacks to me of those old attitudes of colonialism, imperialism, uh, we know what's best for you, paternalism. Um, I think countries have to decide for themselves what their priorities are.
SPEAKER_03And if their priorities are spending money on health care to a certain degree, then that's what they should decide on the basis of what's in the best interest of their citizens as they decide. It's not for us to decide for them whether it's more important to spend money on education or drilling wells or energy production or um or health care. So I think.
SPEAKER_00I wanted to butt in here because I'm I'm really intrigued by the way you talk about how you know there's like love and laughing and all of these things are wonderful for human flourishing, and I completely agree with you. The problem is that I have in the past, and anyone who's been critically ill will understand this, is that when you are critically ill or just ill, down with the common cold with the flu, you're bedridden, you you do not have the agency or the you have autonomy, but you cannot exercise it to go out and enjoy all those other values that contribute to human flourishing. And so I do think that, you know, in a pluralistic lens of what matters in life, health is but one of things, but health is also critical often to engage and properly exercise the other contribute, like the other values that contribute to our human flourishing.
SPEAKER_00So I s I slightly disagree with you there about how you say, you know, we can just equally or we can look at health the way we look at other things like education, because if you're sick, you can't go to school. If you're sick, you can't even sometimes, you know, with COVID, you get brain fog, you can't even think properly. And so I do disagree with you about how uh health can be preconditional to exercising other goods that society or governments might want to fund.
SPEAKER_03It's really a shame you missed my last lecture. I was on a political.
SPEAKER_02It might have been mentioned.
SPEAKER_03Where I gave an example of precisely this sort. You're not actually disagreeing with me. I mean, I do think that um health is in many ways, uh in many ways a necessary precondition for human flourishing. So we need good health. Um but to say it's a necessary precondition for human flourishing, there are many things that are necessary preconditions for human flourishing. I think I will push back on you a little bit on that. Uh clean air is a necessary health.
SPEAKER_03I mean, you might say clean air is more important than health.
SPEAKER_02I hear that for a second too.
SPEAKER_03You don't have clean air, you don't have clean water, and then you don't have health. So you better address your climate before you address your health, because without that, you won't have good health. Um, you need a good food supply. So maybe we need to be spending money on growing more crops rather than building more hospitals, because if we don't have more crops, then you won't have the food that you need for the health. So when you say the health is a necessary precondition, there are a lot of things that are necessary preconditions that the government has to spend on, without which there's no chance of having good health.
SPEAKER_03Um, so you know, as I say, agriculture, climate, uh, pollution, there's a whole bunch of things that would make a claim on us. Um, energy. I mean, if you don't have good energy, then your hospitals don't function, then you can't treat the people who are in poor health. So it doesn't matter. So so I think I'll stand by my claim. I mean, in in the article in the lecture I gave that you missed, um, I did say You can point this out how many more times. As many as it takes to get it to you, let's go.
SPEAKER_03But I agree, I agree, I agree absolutely entirely that. I mean, I actually gave uh an example which was uh trivial and laughable in a way, but I had had food poisoning. I was extremely ill for three hours. It was just three hours, but during that time, you know, all the other things that seemed to matter so much in our life.
SPEAKER_00Did they just slip away?
SPEAKER_03Didn't matter at all. Doesn't matter at all. I was just so sick. I was so ill, I couldn't imagine going on that way for a week or two weeks or a month, and and so on. So I'm entirely on board that you know health is hugely important. It's not all that matters, it's a big part. And none of these other things matter to you, your life, your love, your autonomy, your freedom if you're if you're really deeply sick. But it turns out many of these other things matter and also matter. And what happens when you're focusing on health is if you say you have a right to universal health care, you start by doing the life-threatening conditions, but then someone just comes in with a broken leg, and and now you're trading off between the broken leg or various other kinds of uh you know, conditions that are you want them met, but at this point spending more resources on those rather than these other resources, which are hugely important for human flourishing, um, becomes problematic.
SPEAKER_03And the push for universal health care, it's a right. We all should have it. You need to have it, every human being should have it. It just distorts the way these decisions should be made because it starts with it's like a bargaining chip. You've started with the bargaining over here, and then everyone else has to fight to get claw some of it back for these other domains that are extremely important. Um, and I think this turns out, in fact, to be very problematic.
SPEAKER_03I and partly it's problematic precisely because the ideal of, I mean, the title of the article on which this interview is being based was something like a universal healthcare solution or siren, you know, some preliminary thoughts. I do want to stress, these are, as it were, preliminary thoughts. This this is not supposed to settle any issues, anything I'm saying here. It's but it's to get us to think more about them. Because if you go to like the conference I was at in 2012 at Harvard, and everybody is, you know, yeah, you gotta have universal health care, gotta have a universal health care, yeah.
SPEAKER_03And and I'm gonna say one more thing about this. And then so there was a woman there from the World Health Organization, no, no, sorry, from the United Nations. I've conveniently forgotten her name, I'm bad with names, and it's just as well that I have. And she was very, very smart, and she was very, very powerful. And she was the head of the relevant committee that was trying to generate and uh the push for universal health care in the developing world. So she had a very, very important position in the United Nations, and everyone was giving their talks, and um, and she was sitting there in the audience listening intently.
SPEAKER_03And then I gave my talk. Well, I was giving my talk, which was raising some of the worries we're talking about today. The entire time I was raising, I was giving my talk. The philosophers in the audience were all nodding their heads, your audience won't be able to see this, but they were nodding their heads up and down. And this woman, who is the head, the chair of this very powerful and important committee at the United Nations, was shaking her head with a scowl on her face, shaking her head no, from side to side to side. She was very upset, increasingly upset the longer my talk went on.
SPEAKER_03And she was just, and then at the end, sh she got up and she gave some final summarizing remarks. And one of the things she said without naming me or my paper is that in the world in which she has she inhabits, she doesn't have time to get bogged down in complexities. She can't think about, well, this argument on this side, and this argument on this side, and this argument on this side, and this argument on this side.
SPEAKER_03You gotta find something, you gotta have a path, you gotta have a plan, you gotta put it forward, you gotta be 100% behind it because you need to galve political action. And then she said a bit more about this, and what she basically said is at the end of all this, I have to come up with a report, and that report can be no longer than two or three pages that I'm gonna hope an assistant to the Minister of Health in some important country might read those two or three pages.
SPEAKER_03They're very busy people, and they're not gonna read a whole long, complex paper uh report, a 200-page report. They're gonna read two or three pages by the time it gets to the assistance of the minister. And then that assistant to the minister has to come away and condense it down to one or two sentences. This is what she said at this Harvard meeting, and put it before the health minister. And that one or two sentences doesn't have room for, but we have to make sure that we're not taking money away from education, and we have to pay attention to the importance of love and laughter and well-being, and that we we can't do that, because that will just destroy it effectively, it will die in the vine.
SPEAKER_03It has to be a message that's basically reducible to one sentence for the Prime Minister's eyes, and it says something like universal health care, good, sickness, bad. And I I'm sympathetic to the position she finds herself in. I understand that. She's living in the world of action, and I'm living in the ivory tower. But it turns out that again and again and again in the world of action, these simplifications for practicality's sake are made that have real world consequences for the bad.
SPEAKER_03And I'm interested in the truth. I'm interested in the moral factors, I'm interested in what happens when countries feel compelled or pressured by their peers or by the West or by the United Nations or by the World Health Organization or by the World Bank, that they better be seen as delivering on this unfunded mandate that they can't possibly meet. And that might actually be doing more harm than good for their citizens. That's my worry.
SPEAKER_03And so I get that she's got to somehow have something that reduces to one sentence. And if she says something like, well, on the one hand, healthcare is really important, but on the other hand, other things are also important, so you know. But then that's just to sweep away all the concerns, like, you know, maybe spending money on education would actually be better for the health of the citizens of the country than spending it on hospitals.
SPEAKER_00Do you think that, though, that the problem that some countries find themselves in is almost it's it's cyclical. It's like you're walking down the street, there's a child drowning, you know, Peter Singer's famous case, do you give easy rescue? And let's just say, let's just modify it a little. You have there's a child drowning here that I could save, or I could stop the next child from falling in in the first place. Alternatively, I could save this one, that one will fall in, and then I can just keep going down the street and I keep saving the kids as they fall in. And you're always one step behind, but no one dies.
SPEAKER_00It's the most, it's not the most cost-effective, but in this situation, it is the most effective to making sure that no one, in fact, gets sick. And do you think that maybe that's just the the problem of these sort of the the problem that these countries find themselves in is that ideally we could withdraw some funding, invest for the future generation so that less people get sick in the long run. But no one wants to be the person to pull the trigger to say, okay, but we're not treating these this generation now.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so so the it's a great question, and it's an important question. But the problem is in the real world, the assumption underlying that question is mistaken. Because it's not a no one dies. It's uh you can save this person now, but if you do save that person, five more are gonna fall in the water, and we can only save one of them. And if that's the choice, then it's much harder. Now I do think I'm a big believer, I am a pluralist, I'm a big believer in the urgency of now, as Dr.
SPEAKER_03Martin Luther King Jr. put it in another context. And when people are suffering right now, there's a very powerful humanitarian, not just humanitarian um uh requirement, as it were, to do what you can for them. But that's the whole point about politics. That's the whole point about not just taking that personal in the moment here I am now, what do I do from here perspective? The whole point about politics and governments and world organizations like the UN and others, it's uh supposed to be able to step back, take the more objective perspective, and ask what's best.
SPEAKER_03And now when I say what's best, I don't mean just what's best to maximize the numbers saving of lives. I don't mean that at all. Because I do care about making choices that are, as it were, morally um uh laudable, which includes paying attention to concerns about deontic concerns, about certain duties we have, as well as caring concerns, virtue ethics concerns. It's a very complex list. It's not just do whatever maximizes good. If it was do what maximizes good, we'd start killing people and using their organs to save other people.
SPEAKER_03Nobody's arguing for that. So we should just take off the table that the idea here is that we're just gonna do whatever maximizes good. Nobody believes that. We have to do what maximizes the good in legitimate, morally permissible, acceptable ways as decent human beings. What does that require of us? But part of what it requires from us is making sure that we have governments and international organizations that are looking at the big picture and are bearing in mind that if you make this move here, it has consequences elsewhere in the system, now and down the line.
SPEAKER_03And we require that of our leaders and of our international organizations. And if they're not willing to do that, because as it were, my job at the UN or as the Minister of Health is to get as many funds as I can for health. And this is what happens you get these little fiefdoms, you get these little domains, you know, everybody's fighting. You know, the energy minister wants what he needs, the infrastructure minister wants what they want, the education minister wants what they want, the health minister wants what they want, and nobody really is looking at what's best for the citizens of the country.
SPEAKER_03I hate to Put it that way, but I believe that's largely true. Each is looking at what I can do to maximize the resources in my domain so as to promote the goals of this domain. And those narrow goals are often in conflict with other narrow goals, which collectively leaves citizens of the world worse off than they would otherwise be. And when we're talking about the citizens of the world and the world's poorest countries, that's the last thing we want.
SPEAKER_02Okay, so there's a rumor going around that I've heard that you uh may or may not be responsible for saving the claim, is I believe 800 million lives. Uh would you be able to speak to this rumor?
SPEAKER_03I can speak to that rumor. So that's not quite right. Um RP right now, I mean maybe it is many more by now, but it wasn't 800 million lives. So uh so here's the here's this is a wonderful story. So we could lengthen this interview by twice as long. I'll end but um but let me let me tell you a little bit of story, you can cut it out if you want. Um so the story is this. Um it comes in, uh I'm gonna tell a moderately long version of it, but not the longest version of it.
SPEAKER_03Um the moderately long version of this is um many years ago. So there was a guy named Chris Murray. So you may or may not have heard of Chris, but Chris is um currently the head of the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluations in Seattle, Washington, which is funded by the Gates Foundation. Chris Murray is the genius, really, who when he was a young kid invented dollies. So it was Chris Murray and his team, he was part of a team, but he was the head of it, then invented the concept of dollies that I believe in 1996 was accepted by the World Health Organization and other universal and other major global organizations as the best way of trying to decide, you know, where they should spend their health funding funding so as to do the most good in terms of promoting health.
SPEAKER_00Just for the listener, uh if they get caught up with what I thought was USA dollies.
SPEAKER_03Dollies, D-A-L-Y.
SPEAKER_00Not D-O-L-L-I-E-S.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it stands for D came up with Barbie.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03D-A-L-Y-S, disability adjusted life years. And I wasn't going to go into details. You can look it up on Wikipedia or somewhere about what that is, but it's a hugely important move in global health. And he and his team came up with it. And the World Health Organization decided to adopt his approach for thinking about how they should address World Health, and they brought him to the World Health Organization. Then somewhere around the late 1990s, someone came to the view that the notion of equality was extremely important for health care.
SPEAKER_03And that in fact, if you had states with more equality in them, people did better in terms of health than states with less equality in them. And there seemed to be a bunch of evidence in support of that claim. So he was very interested. So up until that point, most of global health had been dominated by the economist way of thinking, and that was basically a maximized expected utility. So, you know, you kind of did a cost-benefit analysis. You could spend money on this disease or this disease. You did cost-benefit analysis, whichever one would, you know, in this case reduce, you know, dollies by the greatest amount, you know, do the most good in terms of curing illnesses, that's what you did.
SPEAKER_03And that, by the way, that approach is open to the worry you raised earlier about lots and lots of small diseases versus one major disease. They would go with lots and lots of small diseases according to standard cost-benefit analysis. I think that was a mistake. But he had someone working for him at the time, a staff philosopher for the World Health Organization named Dan Wickler. And Dan Wickler was someone that I knew from the Harvard School. Uh from we had spent a year together at Harvard at something that was then called the Programming Ethics and the Professions.
SPEAKER_03All right. So he asked Dan, was there anybody out there who was working on equality who could give the World Health Organization advice on how to promote equality in the distribution of health states and health care? And Dan Wickler said, Well, there's only one person you should contact on this. It's Larry Tempkin. He's the guy who wrote the book on equality, actually, and the book is called Inequality. And so I did write such a book. So uh Chris Murray invited me out to the World Health Organization, and I gave a talk there. And then Chris brought me into his office, and he said something like, Larry, I have roughly$200 million to spend on promoting healthcare globally, and I want you to tell me now how I can do that in a way that will promote equality in the distribution of health states and not just efficiency.
SPEAKER_03And I said to him, I can't really do that, Chris. And he said, Well, you're the world's expert on equality. If not you, who? And I said, I don't know, but it's way more complicated. I'm sitting here in your office. You want me to give you an answer to that question? And this is an extraordinarily complex topic about which I wrote in my book, but you know, I spent 15 years on that book. I'm not going to be able to, you know, in two minutes tell you what to do. And he said, Well, Larry, if you don't do it, someone else will. And I said, Well, someone else is going to have to.
SPEAKER_03And I left. Okay, that was the end of the story as far as I knew it. Okay. Advanced forward about 10 years. Maybe I should just give the punchline. But advanced for, it's a fun story. I advanced forward about 10 years. I'm at a school at a lecture. For all I know, it's the one I'm talking about, it was probably a different one at this Harvard School for Public Health. Dan Wickler has gone back to the Harvard School of Public Health at that point. He's no longer at the World Health Organization. And he says, Hey, Larry, did I ever tell you what happened after you came to the World Health Organization lecture?
SPEAKER_03That was in 1999 that I lectured. I said, No, I don't know what happened. And he said, Oh, it was the coolest thing. He said, the entire staff, I mean, everybody who was at your lecture, they were so excited by your lecture, they got really caught up in it. And they they just, you know, they couldn't stop talking about it for the next week. And Chris decided to take, you know, Chris and his wife had read my book carefully and they had an idea of what was on it, and they just decided that they would uh figure out. Um, they would use your book and they would use a bunch of diagrams in your book, and they would figure out what a good measure of inequality would be for health and health states.
SPEAKER_03And so one of the things Chris did is he basically required, I mean, the way it was originally told me by Dan Wickler is uh Chris hijacked the World Health Systems, I don't know if this is true, organizations, but this is how I first heard it. He hijacked their email system so that nobody could do any emails until they answered a poll. And the poll was a bunch of diagrams that had come from my book that if depending on the answer to those diagrams, I had indicated that the answers went certain ways, it showed how much people cared about different aspects of inequality.
SPEAKER_03So basically, Chris managed to acquire information from World Health Organization people all over, and then he amassed that to create his own equality measure. In 2002, the World Health Organization released an absolutely monumental pioneering work, which you guys may know of, some of your audience may know of. It's called The Global Burden of Diseases. This came out in 2002, and it revolutionized the way people thought about health and health care.
SPEAKER_03At the end of that, he had an appendix. That appendix listed every country in the world according to not efficiency, how efficient were they in delivering health to their health care to their citizens and promoting good health states, but how equal were they in terms of health and health states in their country? And it was a whole list of every country in the world. Okay. So Dan said, Your work had a real impact. I mean, they were really excited, they took this stuff, he ran all these, you know, empirical stuff, he got all these results, and then literally had an appendix in the 2002 book ranking every country in the world.
SPEAKER_03I thought, well, that's pretty cool. That was the end of the story so far as I knew. Fast forward another four years. I'm sitting in my office at home. Dan Wickler calls me, he's so excited, and he says, Larry, I've got to talk to you. You need to sit down. I'm gonna say something that's gonna blow your mind. And I said, Really? He said, Yeah, this is gonna give you such a swelled head. I said, Is that a good idea? Because I kind of already have a big head. He says, No, no, you need to hear this. So it turns out that it was also roughly about 2002 when SARS broke out in China, and Harvard was involved in helping to figure out how to respond to the SARS epidemic.
SPEAKER_03So post-2002, Harvard and the Chinese Ministry of Health had run sort of regular conferences back and forth, going between Beijing, I think it was Beijing and Harvard, and Beijing and Harvard. This happened to be a year when they were having one of these conferences, and it was at Harvard. And Dan Wickler had been very, very curious, because as you and some of your readers may know, over the previous 20-some odd years, there had been massive leaps forward in the world in global health. The state of the world's global health between 2002 and you know 2016 had massively leapt forward, primarily as a result of two main changes: progress in India and mostly progress in China.
SPEAKER_03Massive improvements in China affected the entire global health. So Dan Whittler had been curious like, why did the Chinese government make the changes that they did in how they delivered health care in their system that had this massive impact on health within um within China, but also then global health totally. And he talked to one of the assistant ministers of health, and he says, So, so you know, I've always been wondering why did you make these changes that you did? And the changes and the Minister of Health looked at him and said, Well, it was actually very complex, and there were a whole lot of reasons.
SPEAKER_03But one of the main reasons is the Chinese committee, the major committee, I think it's called the Polyburo, had read the 2002 global report on the global burden of disease, and they'd seen the appendix. And in the appendix, every country was listed according to how good they were in terms of um health, equality of health and health care and health state. And China was rated very low on this list. And they were laid uh rated way lower than places like the United States and Great Britain.
SPEAKER_03And the Polyburo decided this was a disgrace, this wasn't acceptable. It would be okay to be behind the United States and say in steel production, it would be okay to be behind the United States in certain kind of scientific things. But they're a communist country. And the other is a like, you know, a capitalist country. And for a capitalist country to be better than a communist country in terms of the equality of health and health states, that was unacceptable.
SPEAKER_03So they decided that they may had to make a difference. And up to that point, they had been mainly focused on maximizing the total amount of health care, how good health results that they got from the expenditures of money. And that meant primarily focusing for a variety of reasons on the health of people in China's largest cities. And it was more or less a capitalistic system at the time. In the large cities, you could build hospitals, have better infrastructure, doctors, et cetera, et cetera. You got more bang for the buck.
SPEAKER_03This is so-called problem of last mile. But it also led to massive inequality in the health states and health care between people living in the big cities and people in the rural committees, communities. So a decision was made. We need to bring much better health care, at least basic primary health care, to the rural poor. And as a result, they brought health care, they created a health system that brought basic primary health care to 800 million rural Chinese.
SPEAKER_03That's where you get the number 800 million, on a more or less yearly basis starting roughly 2003-2004. Dan Wickler claims that was in part due to my work on inequality, which produced indirectly the ranking of the index, which produced indirectly this impact on the Chinese Ministry of Health when they saw how low they were by that criteria. And then Dan very sweetly said, we have a guy named Richard Cash, who's very famous at the Harvard School of Public Health, because it's re he's the guy who came up with the idea of oral rehydration tablets.
SPEAKER_03And he it's been claimed that he saved roughly 50 million lives. He sleeps very well at night. I think you should too, Larry. And that's the story.
SPEAKER_00Of how you've been sleeping good ever since. Save 800 million people, and you too could have a good night's sleep.
SPEAKER_02It's easy.
SPEAKER_00Wow, that that is truly an incredible story. I I don't know what to say to that.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's the truncated version, apparently. So one day we'll get the full story.
SPEAKER_00Part two, tune in next time. Um, thank you so much for that. That's incredible. Um, I think that's a really great place to leave this podcast uh and that there is some truth in the in the words that you're saying that things can be better, and there are it's not just forcing everyone to do it the way the West wants it done. So I think that's really incredible. Thank you so much for coming on the pod.
SPEAKER_03Thank you very much. Thank you. It's a great pleasure to be here, and thanks for doing this.
SPEAKER_00My pleasure.
SPEAKER_01Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and U and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...