Send us Fan Mail Should children be able to sue their birth parent? Is not being genetically related to your parents really that bad? And is every child always a blessing? In this episode, Sreenivasan Narayanan and Sathya Narayanan from Sreenivasan Chambers LLC talk about what should happen when children are conceived because someone was negligent, and how this has played out in Singapore’s courts. Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02The Center presents a new podcast, C BME You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_00Welcome back to episode 7, Season 2 of CB Me and You. In today's episode, should children be able to sue their birth parent? Is not being genetically related to your parents really a problem? And is every child always a blessing? In today's episode, we have Srinivasan Narayanan and Satya Narayanan from Srinivasan Chambers LLC. Yes, lawyers. And a double feature at that to talk us through an unresolved bioethical dilemma of wrongful conception and how this has played out in Singapore's courts.
SPEAKER_00Welcome.
SPEAKER_03Hi, good afternoon. I'm Sweeney.
SPEAKER_04Hi, I'm Satya.
SPEAKER_01Well having us. So excited to have you. So we are first question: coffee or coffee?
SPEAKER_03Coffee, but not what you pay$5.50 for in Starbucks. Uh South Indian filter coffee or brew coffee.
SPEAKER_01Excellent.
SPEAKER_00We've been asking these two choices this whole time, and we didn't even think about South Indian coffee.
SPEAKER_03You can go to Mustafa's. Their best brand is Brew B R U. And once you taste it, that's it. You won't get back to anything else.
SPEAKER_01Alright, I will hold you to it.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_04Big Brew coffee fan as well. And I think the difference in taste is it's a bit more shakory. What is shakory? It's uh it's like an earthen root. Yem, a cousin of the yem.
SPEAKER_03It's a root that is cheap and used to as a filler when you're too poor to pay for pure coffee.
SPEAKER_04It's got a very nice earthy taste to it. And because it is an Indian coffee, can I say it's very a lot of sugar and milk?
SPEAKER_00I love how they're like, oh yeah, there's this amazing thing that they add in. And he's just like, yeah, it's sawdust. I think sawdust is though.
SPEAKER_01Um, which country would would you like to travel to next? That's me.
SPEAKER_04Uh what country would you like to travel to next? I've never been to South America. If I can get time away from my all-encompassing job, uh, I'd love to go uh Machu Picchu is what I've been thinking about. I don't know which country that's in Peru. Peru. Peru. Peru. Yeah. So quite keen to make a trip there at some point.
SPEAKER_03I've been wanting to go to Central Asia, uh, Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan. Uh, my wife has refused. So um, excellent.
SPEAKER_01And finally, our favorite question: what song do you sing at karaoke?
SPEAKER_03I'm a litigation senior counsel, and ego is important. Sense of uh self-belief is important. So it has to be Frank Sinatra my way.
SPEAKER_00What else? I think that's my dad's favorite. I think one of his favorites, too.
SPEAKER_03A tinge of NPD would want to sing that.
SPEAKER_04For me, I mean I'm born in 1995. So it's Mr. Brightside's only Mr. Brightside.
SPEAKER_06Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Number one. Uh anywhere hit, shower hit, club hit, okay hit, Mr. Brightside. Yeah. That's true.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know, I've heard a rumor that if you just someone starts playing that song, all the millennials come running.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I've heard it's actually been on the charts like for the longest. I think non-stop on the Billboard Top 100, uh, consistently since release.
SPEAKER_01And I say millennials have no personalities. It's all the same.
SPEAKER_00I don't know what to tell you. I'll start it out with a kiss.
SPEAKER_01Nice. Are you happy with that one?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. All right. Now we're gonna get down to business, but please let the banter banter continue. Um, but we're gonna start asking you about the substantive stuff. Okay, so we're here to discuss uh the issue of wrongful conception, and we're gonna do it through the lens of a case which uh you guys have been involved in, uh, which is the 2017 case ACB versus Thompson Medical. Um, could you walk us through it?
SPEAKER_03I think uh when we do a case like this, and it it was quite a long-drawn-out case, the human element is very important. So if one wants to have perspective in an issue like this, it's great to look at it through legal argument and principles, and it's great to look at it through an academic bioethics point of view. But at the middle of it, a few people the father, the mother, the child, the siblings. So if you look at it from a very human angle is a starting point.
SPEAKER_03And that's what I would like to do. You have the father and the mother, they have a previous child, they wanted one more, they went for IVF. The facts of the case gives the nationality, so it's nothing secret. The father was j uh is German, the mother is Singaporean Chinese. The mix-up occurred, and the sperm that was inadvertently used was of South Asian origin. So you look at the mix, you're already looking at a mix that's going to be quite not just at the point of birth, but it's gonna go on.
SPEAKER_03I mean, daddy's white, mummy's yellow, why am I brown? And so if one looks at it, and because there's an earlier child who is half white, half Chinese, then why am I different from my elder brother? These are the questions that will crop up. So that is the human angle to it. And that's why if you read ACB, the Court of Appeal looked at pushing the boundaries where the punitive damages come in. Because what exactly are you going to compensate?
SPEAKER_03So now we come in, you call it wrongful conception. It's not a wrongful conception. Because the conception was intended. So it's not like a failed sterilizing case case. So it's a conception, the conception was intended, but not this conception. And that's why the Court of Appeal Justice Pang said it doesn't fall into the three categories that everybody was looking at wrongful love birth, wrongful life, wrongful conception, or something different.
SPEAKER_03So what we had to do as lawyers is we had to take care of the clients, we had to explain to them what the procedure what was going on in court, what the arguments were, we had to make arguments that the parties could be sensitively made. And I can tell you, and I know I'm moving away from the topic, I'll get back to it. But I can tell you, can you imagine the little child who is not so little now, then grows up and then reads ACB versus Thomson Medical and then says this case is about me, and then sees what were the arguments that were made for and against what the judges said, what was the mother and father's position, etc.
SPEAKER_03So quite apart from the substantive biomedical issue, it's the issue that we as lawyers face. I don't want to hijack this from the medical school, but it's the issue that we lawyers face. Whenever we deal with human cases, there's a dimension to it, it goes beyond what we have. So now we come here. There was a series of cases, very clear series, that says the birth of a child is a blessing, and then the law made distinction that if the child is with a has a disability, you can claim the incremental difference in upkeep.
SPEAKER_03So it's like a basic child 101 is what you need and what you get. And then you only pay for the damage, so to speak. I think that was the problem the courts had in ACB. Uh not to compensate would be not right. To compensate uh would go against a series of well-established cases, and more important, what has been stated, I don't agree, but what has been stated to be core values and morals of society.
SPEAKER_03And that's why we ended up with a genetic affinity. When you ask me another question, then I will talk about one angle that was not considered in the written judgment, and that's the issue of contractual breach. But I'll come to that later. So that's the background of this case.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so just to clarify, um, in terms of who was suing who, was it the parents claiming a wrong done to them, or was it the parents claiming that a wrong was done to the child?
SPEAKER_03Okay. So it was the parents claiming a wrong a wrong done to them and not to the child. And it was not the parents, it was just the mother. Uh and the reason why we had to do it that way, and this actually segues into the next point, we had a claim in thought and a claim in contract. And the claim in contract itself uh was not really covered in the judgment. And I think the claim in contract caused a lot of discomfort because from the lawyer's point of view, we could deal with the claim in contract in a very cold-blooded way.
SPEAKER_03Don't give us issues of morality, right and wrong. Is the birth rightful, is the birth wrongful, is the child wanted? No, no, no, no. You'd rather argue it uh on the basis that I went there, I paid you, this was the IVF I was supposed to have. And you didn't give me what I contracted for.
SPEAKER_04So maybe if I can just jump in just to provide a quick explanation on how a concurrent claim in tort and contract works. Essentially, uh where you have a contractual claim, the contract itself creates obligations between two parties. So if I contract to give you A and in return I get B from you, uh the obligations are according to the contract. Tort is a different species, it's a different kind of a head of claim where it's also obligations, but it's obligations that you owe. I mean, the classic formulation would be who is your neighbor, where you owe a duty of care to someone.
SPEAKER_04So a contract itself can be the source of contractual obligations, but where you have a relationship like that of a doctor and a patient, there may also be uh a there will be a duty of care imposed. So both duties exist simultaneously, and in in Singapore at least, you are allowed to have a concurrent claim in both. However, in the end of the day, and uh jump in if I'm wrong, or maybe we can just edit this out. But essentially, where there is um the same harm, you can only claim for the same harm once.
SPEAKER_04So even though your claim can be phrased in contract or in terms in tort, uh you can you have to elect at some point to choose uh which path we are taking, and you can only claim for the same damage in one way.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, but uh if you take a contractual route, then the damages flow uh in terms of what is the breach of contract, and the breach would be what is the performance I expect from you and your failure to perform what I contracted for. And then the damages would be how do you put me back uh into a situation where had you performed, this is what I would have got. Or monetary compensation for that.
SPEAKER_03And how do you compensate me for having suffered the wrong? So we look at the context of this case, and I can understand why the Court of Appeal didn't like the argument because we said we contracted for A. You did not give us A. Now this is not buying a car where I can return it to the showroom and I want my money back. So uh I have no choice. And not because I don't love this child, I don't want this child, but because I have no choice, I have to raise the child, that was not the outcome I contracted for.
SPEAKER_03I don't blame the Court of Appeal for not liking this argument. From the legal point of view, it was clean, it was efficient, but it was cold and it didn't really go into the values of society. On the other hand, if the Court of Appeal had uh applied the existing law, you would have got nothing. So I think that is where the Court of Appeal came out with the concept of the loss of genetic affinity.
SPEAKER_03I mean, I reread the case for the purpose of today's podcast and sort of scratch my head because in a more frivolous moment I would ask myself is the loss of genetic affinity? Some sort of breach of warranty that I was I contracted to have a child with my genetic features and you didn't give it to me. So is that a breach of warranty of some sort? But if we call it a breach of warranty, what are you saying? The child is defective, you can't.
SPEAKER_03So I think that's where we ended up with this. Uh, it's an elegant solution, and I think it's a solution that would be picked up. Satya actually ended up writing his final year dissertation on this because he was in final year at this time. Six years ago, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Six years ago.
SPEAKER_03And so when he read the judgment, he said, That this sounds interesting.
SPEAKER_04I think uh you know we try not to date ourselves on this podcast. Okay.
SPEAKER_01You try not to date yourself.
SPEAKER_04But I I think the the issue here is for me at the time, and maybe it's a generational gap thing, where uh it seemed very odd that there was a very clear loss to me, at least, which was the loss of parental autonomy. And I believe in Thompson Medical itself, there was a counsel, Amicus Cure was Goyhan. Goyhan from SMU. Who was from SMU, he is now uh deputy AG. Yep. He was previously briefly at the bench as a judicial commissioner, and high court judge. And high court judge, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, he was an high court judge, but uh essentially uh he was of the view, I think he advocated for parental autonomy uh uh as the loss being characterized as a loss of parental autonomy. So read having read that, uh, it made conceptually a lot more sense. Um, and then because I went to law school in the UK, there's obviously a long line of cases there. And uh I it just made a lot of sense to sidestep the whole no upkeep for a healthy child principle, which was the Mac it was a McFarland principle, and to just focus on the parents instead.
SPEAKER_01I wanted to ask about that because um I've done some research and comparison across the United States, Australia, the United Kingdom, um, and to some extent Singapore with the Thomson Medical. And courts around the world have struggled or just outright refuse to award upkeep because they say that a child is always a blessing. But that that's a factually incorrect statement, children. It can sometimes be unwanted. Um I've also read in cases that they they talk about it, how unnatural it is for a woman to reject motherhood and to then sue for wrongful conception.
SPEAKER_01And when I mean when I'm talking about wrongful conception, I mean in the in the broader sense of the term, all the different ways in which failed sterilization cases and um wrongful insemination, those sorts of things. And so what I was so astounded about was which I th I somewhat agree with you, it isn't an elegant solution to a very practical problem. Courts just simply refuse to recognise a child as anything other than a blessing. So, in order for some damages to be awarded, we just have to deal with the facts. But I wanted to ask you about well, that that's the way it is. Is that the way it should be?
SPEAKER_01And I found your your arguments about um, instead of trying to center it around, well, what is the value of the child? Is the child a blessing? Do you actually regret having the child? If we refocus it on parental loss of autonomy, that could actually widen the number of legal cases that would be available. So I was wondering if you could talk us through what you mean by loss of parental autonomy.
SPEAKER_04Uh yeah, sure. So I think in terms of characterizing the loss. So before we go into the actual quantification, because quantification is a whole nother issue as well.
SPEAKER_01It's a really fun game. People don't tell you in law school that there's math.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Wait, what? But but uh essentially, um yeah, quantification is a whole issue as well because they've only ever used the upkeep of a child and there really is no other metric. But in terms of uh identifying the loss, I think it's very odd and it's a bit Victorian as well. So the first gut instinct is that, oh, you're gonna say that having a child is a bad thing, or are we gonna, as as I think, as you've mentioned, say that women are rejecting motherhood if they have a kid that they don't want.
SPEAKER_04But uh I like to look at it from a legal point of view. So as I covered earlier, it's obligations, right? You and we do legally only recognize a child as being a person once they are born. Uh that's just the state of the law as it is now. No political undertones or I don't lean anyway.
SPEAKER_01I'm not making any other claims.
SPEAKER_04So it's a bit strange if there's no real debate as to when these breaches occur. It'll happen in the in the case of you have a wrongful conception where you have a failed sterilization. I think it's quite clear that the breach happens at the point where the sterilization fails. Maybe in the initial procedure it's not done properly, or there's re-canalization that happens later on or over time. I think it's quite clear the breach happens at that point. Uh for wrongful birth, it happens at the type at the point of the health screening, but there's a decision to be made to terminate or not.
SPEAKER_01But just to clarify, wrongful birth is when um there's negligence in carrier screening, which prevents the uh birthing parent the choice to terminate on the basis that they now have more information about the genetic nature of the child.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Cool. So uh just on those two areas, it's quite clear where the breach occurs. And it happens before the child is born. And if it happens before the child is born, then the duty can't be owed to the child. And if the duty isn't owed to the child, why are we so obsessed about uh the loss in relation to the child's life? So I think parental autonomy is a much easier way of not really, I wouldn't say it's I mean, it's lucky, it's it's good in the sense that it does get us around that nasty area about are we quantifying in the life of a child?
SPEAKER_04But it also is practical. There's no relationship with the child at a point. The child can is not a legal person. So why don't we deal with the people who the obligation is actually owed to?
SPEAKER_03Okay, just let me just say that in UK they've got the 1976 uh thing it's called the Congenital Defects Act that allows a child to sue for what happened before conception. That's a statutory provision. We don't have it in Singapore. Uh it wouldn't apply to the case like ACB, but it would apply to the wrongful birth cases, where the child can also sue subsequently. But what I was checking on my phone, I wasn't being rude, was the audience wouldn't have seen it.
SPEAKER_00You kind of just outed yourself.
SPEAKER_03Because the compensation, the the damages basis that the Court of Appeal in ACB decided on was what they called a conventional sum. Which means uh it's a very complicated legal term to mean you pluck a figure from the air that you think is about right. And the Court of Appeal also looked at the possibility of dealing with punitive damages, where if somebody created a real mess, and just because I can't quantify the mess doesn't mean the person who created a mess for profit uh gets away with it and add that on.
SPEAKER_03So it's a bit of uh hit and miss. And interestingly, the conventional sum was tied up to the upkeep cost. So it has to be.
SPEAKER_04There's nothing else to tie to it.
SPEAKER_03There was nothing else to tie to the math ain't mathing. But in the end, so on one hand, you say we don't like upkeep because it's demeaning, and then you tie the conventional cost to the up conventional damages to the upkeep cost. And I do remember very clearly that when the uh judgment came out, both my learned friend and I were told you guys go and sort out the damages because then the arguments would come on what would be upkeep, what etc.
SPEAKER_03and what amount. And uh fortunately both my learned friend and I we went for mediation and we managed to settle the damages amount. Because otherwise you would have another interesting judgment on how do you actually compute damages or loss of autonomy. Parental autonomy or loss of genetic affinity.
SPEAKER_04You know, I just want to jump in here and say that I actually think it's a bit strange that and the status quo, maybe it's a generational thing, that we all kind of assume oh, damages being awarded to the parent is offensive. It's for the life of a child. Because I think practically, uh, in the end of the day, most, if not all, parents, I think I can say, uh, would apply those damages to taking care of their children. In the end of the day, even if the parents are awarded for your uh the the the doctor that uh that mixed up the procedure uh did compensate the parents, the parents would probably use that money for the child.
SPEAKER_04So why is it so offensive if it allows for a more comfortable upbringing for the child?
SPEAKER_01I've thought about this because if I found out that my parents could sue to recuperate all the costs they spent on me growing up, I would be like, good for you. Do it.
SPEAKER_03No, but hang on, hang on, hang on, hang on. But if you found out that their parents did it because you were not really the ass, or you were only half the ass, would you still think that?
SPEAKER_01I think so. I'd be like, I'm like fair. You just you deserve that money back. I don't I don't think it would change how much they love me or how much I love them. Like people find out that their parents aren't their parents all the time. Um, it doesn't change the fact that like the way that you grew up together and it doesn't affect those memories. So for me, if I found out that you know my parents sued for the upkeep costs because they found out something went wrong before I was born, I'd be like, so you should.
SPEAKER_04But and also uh what eight-year-old is reading court judgment. And then yeah, when you grow up and you'd probably be of a different, like you'd be more mature, you'd be able to handle with the repercussions of your parents having sued.
SPEAKER_01If you can find out semicles ain't real.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, a 15-year-old might read uh a court judgment, and 15-year-olds famously not that mature. At least I remember what I was like when I was 15 years old. I could have, I didn't, but also wasn't mature.
SPEAKER_03I can tell you 30-year-old legally qualified sons can also be more mature sometimes.
SPEAKER_04Should be more mature.
SPEAKER_01Just for our listeners, I hope you're aware that our yes are in fact father and son.
SPEAKER_04Can't see yes, but there's no visual resemblance. Lucky for me.
SPEAKER_01So I I do have one question though, because if the court had looked at this case and awarded it on the base of loss of parental autonomy, I understand why only the parents could sue. But if there is now a damage for loss of genetic affinity, why could the child not similarly sue for that loss?
SPEAKER_03Because we don't have a congenital defects act. So a child can't sue for anything pre birth.
SPEAKER_01But the loss of genetic affinity damages is in tort, not in statute.
SPEAKER_03No, but the the statute doesn't allow it because there was no cause of action at that point in time. The child didn't exist. So the UK by statute they allowed the cause of action to arise. In UK by statute, they allowed it. So if the statute wasn't there, you can't do it. Secondly, what was the child's expectation? The child had no expectation. We don't choose our parents.
SPEAKER_03When we are born, we are born. That's it. So uh in the absence of any genetic effect in terms of upkeep disability, then uh I don't think you can the child can sue. And what's the child gonna say? I didn't want to be born to these parents, I wanted to be born to somebody else.
SPEAKER_01I definitely said that to my parents growing up. Why do you have to be my mom?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03But fortunately, you couldn't sue your mom for that.
SPEAKER_01So just maybe. So let's let's continue on about whether or not children can sue. Because um, as we've alluded to, there the UK has a very different system. Their parliament long ago addressed this, whereas in Singapore and many other countries it's been left to the courts, and we should talk about that later as well. But in the UK, the the the particular act allows children to sue. And so there was a a case a few years ago, um, Evie Toomes and Mitchell.
SPEAKER_06Yep.
SPEAKER_01So Evie Toomes um sued her mother's doctor for negligence because when her mother went to go get uh advice about whether or not she sh should start to try to fall pregnant with her husband, she specifically asked the doctor, should I take folic acid? And the doctor said, nah, you're good. Um, and that was that's scientifically proven to be negligent advice. And then Evie was subsequently born with spina bifida, which was causally related to the lack of folic acid. And the Evie was successful in this claim.
SPEAKER_01And so everyone was like, wah. And that's my visual, my audio representation of what happened around the globe at the time. But basically, the courts ignored the question of is this claim asking about the value of Evie's life? Are we we are not comparing Evie's life to non-existence? She's not saying that she shouldn't have existed, all things considered. She was just saying that because of the negligence, she now suffers a disability. And so there has been a strong binary focus, I think, in the courts around the world that uh the birth of healthy children are very different to the birth of children with disabilities that have been brought about because of negligence.
SPEAKER_01So I was wondering what you think about like A, the statutory regime in the UK, whether it it should be implemented in Singapore through a similar system. Um, and B, how do you think uh what what the courts did was good? Do you think it was reasonable?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think uh we shouldn't read too much into this case because the particular act uh simply says this that if there's an occurrence before your conception and that occurrence has resulted in damage to you, then you can sue for it. So in a normal circumstance, the parents would be able to sue for the upkeep of a child. In if we take a tomb's case, would have been able to sue for the upkeep.
SPEAKER_03The mother could have sued a doctor for negligence. Now all these case allowed also Eevee to do it. And no more than that. So it basically says that the when we look for thought negligence, you need to have a breach, a duty, a breach, and damage flowing from it. So in this case there was a duty, but the duty was to the mother. Because Eevee wasn't conceived yet. There was a breach of that duty and the damage resulted in Eevee suffered the damage.
SPEAKER_03So all that acts says if there's a breach, a duty and a breach, and you suffered the damage, the fact that it occurred before you were conceived shouldn't stop you from suing. So if you look at that the major problem at that time, why there was a lot of pushback, there's a very interesting article written by one of the barristers on 39 SX uh is that it would then create a floodgate of cases in the National Health Service.
SPEAKER_03And similarly, we have something like this in Singapore. There will be an argument uh by the insurers that you're gonna have a floodgate of cases and there's gonna be unnecessary litigation because uh the Toombs case, I criticize it for an entirely different reason. And on the grounds of causation, it doesn't mean that if you're given enough folic acid, you won't have spiny uh befida and the cause and effect was not clear.
SPEAKER_03And if I remember correctly, all the judge said was the case can move forward. I don't think the case actually went to trial. Oh, it did. Okay. That's right, there were two different judges, Koji and then There were two separate judgments.
SPEAKER_04Yep, that's right. Okay. Okay, actually, can I ask was the action how old was Evie at the time the action was taken on? 19. 19 years old. So she really did take it on herself.
SPEAKER_01Yes, the the judge was very clear that the mother was not suing.
SPEAKER_04Why didn't the mother sue? Do we have to?
SPEAKER_01I think the mother just didn't want to send that message to her daughter.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I think uh I don't know, I I feel a bit critical of the act as well because I do think that this is a kind of it that well, there there's so many issues involved when you talk about uh birth of a child, right? There's a religious dimension to it where and obviously the state, the various states of the world wouldn't want to outright say, Oh, the there's no soul in the baby, there's no there's no legal rights accruing is one thing, but acknowledging when a person to be's life starts is a bit of a hairy issue, can be a bit of a hairy issue.
SPEAKER_03That's why we don't look at that question. Yeah, because if you didn't have the act, you would have to answer that question. But now with the act, all it says it's a legal fiction, or if you then you can sue for something that occurred before you were conceived.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but the thing is that you don't have to look at any act at all, if you just phrase it in terms of parental autonomy. Because the parent is there throughout, the duty is owed to the parent, and if it is not too bad to say the harm is suffered by the parent.
SPEAKER_03The parent doesn't sue, and the child is 19, the child is still disabled, the child of 50 years of disability are here.
SPEAKER_04Well, the parents will be less likely to sue if you insist that the damage is to a child who I didn't really want. But if you phrase it in terms of parental autonomy, I don't see what's the issue with that.
SPEAKER_01Why why can't we have both? Why is that two sides of the same coin? Two sides of the same coin, but if you have two separate claimants, surely you stemming from even though it's a single action, it is it seems logically impossible. But at the same time, you there are many other acts of negligence where the flow and effects happen to many different people, so you can have multiple claimants for the same action.
SPEAKER_04Well, it's the same dollars being spent. No, no, no.
SPEAKER_03It's not the same because let's take an example of an accident.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_03There's a motor accident. Uh I get injured, uh, I've got young children. My children may have a dependency claim because I can't take care of them anymore. And I suffer, I don't have my arm or my leg or whatever. So they're two separate victims from the same act. And here, the parents have got to take care of them.
SPEAKER_04Well, hang on, but there's an element of double recovery there. Because the dollars that would have gone to you would have been spent on your children.
SPEAKER_03No, the court, the courts would have uh balanced that out. Yeah. They won't pay out twice.
SPEAKER_00I've got uh a question that's not exactly on this, but I think related to what you've we've been talking about. So I'm gonna move a little bit from like law to morality because that's what I like more. Um not biased at all. Yeah, so like, you know, in common sense, my morality, uh morality, a lot of people would say that uh yeah, you can be wrong by actions with uh before your birth or before your conception, you know. Like most people agree that you know a mother has duties to their child if they know they're gonna have a child by you know not drinking, or even before conception, parents have duties, have at least some duties to make sure that they don't have any like uh serious congenital uh issues that might be passed on to their children.
SPEAKER_00So, what's stopping uh the law from recognizing that people can be wronged by actions taken or actions that I think failed to happen before uh they were conceived a warrant?
SPEAKER_03Let's look at it this way. The English Act uh expressly excludes the mother. You can't sue the mother under the act. It actually says that so mothers who drink or shoot themselves up uh while they're pregnant, the child who is born can't sue. So now just take a look at the father. Let's assume they didn't go for genetic counseling and then the child is born with a G6PD deficiency or something. Can you sue your father for not going for genetic counseling?
SPEAKER_03Well, the act doesn't say you can go and sue everybody and anybody for anything, it merely states if the wrong has been committed, it must be a wrong in the first place. Now, if there's no widespread duty for genetic counselling and you fail to do it, then there's no duty or no breach of that duty. So we are not opening the flat gates. Similarly, if there is a widespread duty, then why not? So I think we must be very careful.
SPEAKER_03That's why we use the word morality and then you ask a lawyer a question.
SPEAKER_00I know that was dangerous.
SPEAKER_03I know. Uh but fortunately for us, we don't practice morality. Because if we did, we'll all be skizo if we didn't start living mad by now. So the amount of things we see that meet does not meet moral standards but happens every day is you've got to sort of broke it off your head. But I don't see a problem with that. Uh I don't see a problem with the English act because it just provides an avenue for a child who, upon reaching adulthood, to make a claim with his or her parents should have but did not.
SPEAKER_03To me, I see it that way. Now you can have other arguments. If the claim comes out and when the child is 18 years old, like in the tomb scales, the doctor couldn't remember what happened, he had no records, he had no notes. So those are other issues.
SPEAKER_01I mean, the I think the judge found that the the doctor had conflicting stories over time. So the the doctor tried saying they did remember, and then later on they said they didn't remember, and there were no notes when there should have been notes, so the doctor was negligent in in that regard. Um, but I did want to ask you, because in Singapore, with the the loss of genetic affinity, that doesn't differentiate between um children who are healthy and children who have disabilities. But around the world, courts have been really consistent, I think, at holding that that line steadfast.
SPEAKER_01They say you can't award upkeep costs, and I realize as we say this, we probably haven't defined it upkeep cost things for like what food, uh, education, medical bills, all the costs associated of raising a child. And but they will award the difference for um the extra costs that come when a child has a disability. And at that sometimes makes sense, but then it also sometimes seems a bit discriminatory. And so I know that Singapore circumvented that by allocating it only to um uh a parental claim.
SPEAKER_01But I was wondering if you had any thoughts about that.
SPEAKER_04Well, I think uh the point at which it starts to get wonky. Uh so for an unhealthy child, if the principal is no upkeep for a healthy child, then an unhealthy child seems to be a logical exception. But I think there have been cases, I think it's Ime in the UK, where essentially the parent went for sterilization, there was recanalisation, and she ended up pregnant with a healthy child. But in that case, damages were awarded for the additional difficulties she would face as a blind woman taking care of a child.
SPEAKER_04So at that point, you are essentially, and those additional damages, uh amounting for the additional need that she had because she was blind, was also based on the the basic cost was upkeep of a child as well. So at that point, you are actually awarding damages. Well, I mean, they've reasoned it differently, but I mean on the face of it, it is an award for damages for a healthy child because of the circumstances of the mother. So I think for me that's where it gets a bit wonky. And I think that's why the principle, uh, if it gets wonky at certain parts, then maybe it's not a principle that we should take with us uh into the 21st century.
SPEAKER_01Well, because uh in with Australia in um catnac, catanak. Catanak and Melanquir, I don't know that I forget the the second name of that. Um the court held that uh you could award damages for the upkeep of a child, healthy or not. That was just a claim. And then Queensland very quickly was like, no, you can't. And so several acts were passed around Australia saying, no, no, you can you can only do it if the child has a disability. But for the rest of the Australian states, that that law is still good law. Yeah. Um and I think it's I think it's I I still kind of can't make sense of it.
SPEAKER_01I do see the the the idea that, well, if you went through so many measures to try not to fall pregnant, to not have a kid, and then by someone's negligence you fell pregnant, well, you should be awarded the losses that you're going to have to pay for their negligence. Um, but at the same time, I do see that difference, that that principle of that's a lot. That could open like so many pregnancies are unwanted. Um, and so I do see some difference at drawing that line, but then you know that that can be said to be a bit discriminatory.
SPEAKER_03Well, I think this is where James's uh issue of morality comes in.
SPEAKER_00It's only my issue, no one else has an issue with that.
SPEAKER_03Because that's why I prefer the somewhat cold-breded approach of breach of contract. Uh breaches of contract has got more no moral no moral issues on it. It's commercial. Uh you put me back into the position I would have been had you performed a contract. So it's always restorative. And if the child gets a better education with more money for upkeep, I share your view.
SPEAKER_03Uh good. And it's some I mean, if you look at it in the Thomson medical case, it was a for-profit IVF setup. And a mistake was made because they would do more cases than they could handle. And then shouldn't there be a price to pay? And I think that's where, and it's interesting, both myself, V Ming, my opposing counsel, and Go Yi Han was the amicus, all said that punitive damages were not payable.
SPEAKER_03Uh but the CA in the judgment eventually said, hey, it's not out of the question. But now, with the benefit of hindsight, I think going forward that might be a solution sometimes. So where you can measure out the justice depending on the facts of the case.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't think it should be a bar to create a law on the grounds that people might disobey this law. Murder shouldn't be a law because you know, uh otherwise people might commit murder and that will open the floodgates to litigation. I know litigation doesn't apply in that specific context, but still, um, yeah. So I I think that I I still struggle to make sense of this space. I think there is a lot going on, particularly with the morality issue, like should we be able to sue for, you know, these sorts of relationships. But I do think that having a child is one of the most life-changing, life-altering decisions.
SPEAKER_01It it's with you for the rest of your life. It's not merely a breach of contract where you don't get your steel on time. And so I think the consequences of negligence in this this area should be proportional to that particular outcome.
SPEAKER_03So now let me give it a counter-argument.
SPEAKER_01Oh no.
SPEAKER_03Okay, and the counter-argument is you're absolutely right. And therefore, why should you be compensated for a child? Because it's uh it's a combined bundle, right?
SPEAKER_04Huge blessing.
SPEAKER_03The you get the good and the bad. And do you really want the courts? It happened. I mean, you don't get compensated if you get an illness that makes you blind. You don't get compensated if you get cancer. Now, here, if you have a child, which is a mixed bag, why should you be compensated for? Maybe there's some areas that the law shouldn't get involved in. Maybe there's some things that happen. Should be between you and your maker, or you and morality, or if you have a humanistic bent, whatever your value systems are.
SPEAKER_03Maybe. But it's not a view I I share. Because when people do things for profit, then I think there's a bit of a difference.
SPEAKER_00Uh isn't one possible answer to that, just at least in law and even in morality, too, for the record.
SPEAKER_01Uh they can be they can be the same thing sometimes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, is that the idea of acknowledging a wrong is separate from making a judgment over whether something is good or bad. So I can have something good happen to me. Like maybe somebody uh like hurts me in some way, and but then I grow from it, and then you know, many years looking back, I'll say, Yeah, it's a good thing that this person hurt me. Uh, but that's compatible with saying this person did a wrong to me. Um, so isn't that one answer?
SPEAKER_03Exactly. But then uh is inflicting a child upon you doing you a wrong.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Uh at this point in my life, absolutely.
SPEAKER_03I've got four children, uh two grandchildren. The jury is still out.
SPEAKER_01I love that one of the children is sitting here as you said that.
SPEAKER_04I I think I think for me the danger is that uh we're gonna run the risk of being behind the times. So one of the big shifts is quite interesting. Uh Baroness Hale, who was a House of Lords judge, had uh came out and spoke both curally and extracurricular about how uh crazy it is for a woman who didn't wish to be pregnant to become pregnant. Uh it's a huge invasion of her of her bodily privacy, it's a huge infringement on her rights.
SPEAKER_04I think that kind of, and we've seen this when society frees up and we are more uh well, we are more recognizing of women's rights than we traditionally have been. And that comes to the forefront. I think that sparks kind of opening up the the gates to awarding damages. And I fear that if we tie this to genetic affinity, as we enter into a frame where we have more. Uh mixed race families, adoption, same-sex couples, these issues are just coming to the forefront. And I think by labeling it genetic affinity, we run the risk of the fact of saying, uh, are there connotations of race there?
SPEAKER_04Are there connotations of saying that a child that is not biologically yours is bad? I think those come up when where the label is genetic affinity.
SPEAKER_03That's why I agree with you. And that's why I think the contractual argument, the it must be seized. That we take away morality from it, we take away right from wrong from it, we take away societal judgment from it, and we see this is a bargain, this is the outcome, and this is the what should be done to restore me to the outcome. Had you fulfilled your bargain. Uh but I can tell you, when we argued ACB and Thomson, uh the partner was with arguing it with me.
SPEAKER_03Maybe I should have brought him here as well. We pitched it at that level and we had such an uphill task because it's almost blasphemous to say, let's deal with the birth of a child, like a mercantile transaction. But if you don't, you end up with a mess that we are in. Court trying to create categorization. Child disabled can claim.
SPEAKER_03Mother disabled, you can claim. But child and mother both able, you can't. I mean, there's no logical difference there.
SPEAKER_04And can you foresee a situation where this happens where there is no contract uh between the tort visa and person suffering from the breach?
SPEAKER_03We may well, if there's a non-contractual situation, maybe the situation can be different. Because then you look at it, what is the law of thoughts all about? So now I'm moving away from today's topic, but the law of thought is about allocation of risk. Right? So you drive a car, you take the risk, then society protects the risk by insurance. You go to New Zealand, you've got no fault thought. You don't have to prove that the driver is at blame to get compensation.
SPEAKER_03Knock down on the road, you get compensated. Doesn't matter whose fault it is. So the allocation of the risk has been moved on to the society. The tomb scales created a lot of uproar because it was NHS. And the question is if you open a front gate of cases, is the NHS going to be overwhelmed? So thought takes care of that. Contract, the allocation of risk is you decide it by contract, and you cover your losses by insurance.
SPEAKER_03And in ACB and Thomson, Thomson was insured. So I think in a contractual situation, the concept of allocation of race assumption of responsibility would be different. And I don't think we should mix the two regimes up, even though you're right, there is a concurrent duty and the same damage may result. But then again, uh, this is a topic for another day, another forum.
SPEAKER_01I think I think that's a perfect way to end. We'll have to get you back. Topic for another time. Um, did you have any further questions?
SPEAKER_00Many, but sure. We'll leave that for another time.
SPEAKER_01Um, so I I don't know if we have any solid answers. I think we have a lot to think about. Um, and honestly, I think I'll be thinking about this for a very long time. But I really enjoyed this conversation, and we want to thank you so much for coming all the way down here to speak with us about it. Thank you for inviting us. My pleasure.
SPEAKER_03You're welcome.
SPEAKER_02Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and U and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...