Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

C B m E & U

C B m E & U artwork

Discrimination Against Men?? with David Benatar

Jun 2, 202558 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Kat and James interview world famous David Benatar on his controversial work, 'The Second Sexism', a book that argues that we need to understand how men are also, and uniquely, discriminated against, including conscription and men's mental health. Some people have said David is just anti-feminist, but we get to the bottom of it, and Kat and David bond over their shared hatred of karaoke. Remember people, be savvy!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast at C BMENU, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.

SPEAKER_01Welcome back to CBMENU, a podcast about biomedical ethics. Today, we discussed the health issues faced by men and a slightly spicier question: Are these issues the result of discrimination against men and boys? Joining us today is David Benatar, emiritus professor of philosophy and former director of the Bioethics Center at the University of Cape Town and author of The Second Sexism: Discrimination Against Men and Boys. Welcome, David. Thanks very much. Good to be with you. Now, uh, some of you may be familiar with the other host of this podcast, Sinead, who is unfortunately not here because she's traveling.

SPEAKER_01So my co-host for today is our very own Kat Meiskins from our Center for Biomedical Ethics. Kat, would you like to do the honors?

SPEAKER_03Yes, it will be my pleasure. For any uh earlier listeners to the podcast, they'll know how I feel about one of these questions. Um, David, coffee or copy?

SPEAKER_02Well, I didn't know what copi was until you sent me this question in advance, and now I've got some rudimentary idea. I can't exper I've never experienced the one, I can't make a comparison.

SPEAKER_03Okay. All right, fair. It's a pity that you can't try copy as well, because I think it's very good. It's my favorite.

SPEAKER_01A priori, do you think you'll like it? I don't make those kind of a priori judgment.

SPEAKER_03All right, on to the next question. Uh what country do you most want to travel to next?

SPEAKER_02I don't have one. Uh I'd I I'd be interested in visiting any number of countries.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Okay. And uh my favorite question. What is your go-to karaoke song?

SPEAKER_02I don't touch the stuff.

SPEAKER_03A man after my own heart.

SPEAKER_01I guess I'll leave. It's not like I like the sound of my own voice or anything. I don't run a podcast or whatever. Anyway, moving on. Uh okay, we want to start today's podcast by talking about the men's issues in healthcare. Uh welcome to the men's health podcast, everybody. Um, so uh as many people have already pointed out, um, men face a number of poorer health outcomes uh compared to women. Uh this includes being more likely to die prematurely before 75. It includes and obviously that's related to um lower life expectancy, more deaths from certain diseases like COVID, uh lower rates of getting preventative health care, and higher rates of harm resulting from at least certain mental health issues.

SPEAKER_01So I guess uh my first set of questions uh is well, firstly, would you like to add to that list? And secondly, uh, what do you think are like the most important explanations for uh some of these observations?

SPEAKER_02Right. I think you've pointed out some of the important ones. Although when I wrote the second sexism, I mentioned a range of other disadvantages that men have, and some of them also constitute forms of discrimination, and many of those can have health impacts as well. So uh if you think about uh sexual assault, for example, uh it's very common with women, we know that, but uh for all the taboos that they are and the the impediments to women reporting it, there is good evidence that there's even more of an impediment towards men reporting being sexually assaulted.

SPEAKER_02And that kind of thing can obviously have psychological and uh health impacts as well. So there are the medical issues in the narrower sense, and then there are medical issues in a broader sense as well. Uh I uh you ask whether this is discrimination, whether there's something else. I am quite careful to distinguish between disadvantage on the one hand, discrimination, and then if there were a third hand, a wrongful discrimination. These are all distinct concepts. So sometimes a particular sex is going to suffer a disadvantage, and there's no reason to think that that disadvantage per se is a form of discrimination.

SPEAKER_02So if you think, for example, about women being more likely to suffer from anemia as a result of regular blood loss, um, that's a disadvantage that women have in terms of the biology, but it's less likely to be it's not likely to be a matter of discrimination per se. If you do nothing about it, then there may be an issue of discrimination. If you think about a condition known as hemochromatosis, in which there is iron accumulation in uh in the body, uh well, men are more likely to suffer, men with the condition are more likely to suffer the effects of it because they do not have the menstrual cycle that results in more regular blood loss.

SPEAKER_02And that's going to be a disadvantage for males, but it's not itself the product of discrimination. When you do have discrimination, sometimes discrimination is not unjustified. So if you think about, let's say, an insurance company covering routine mammograms for women over a certain age, but not for men over that same age, there is a form of discrimination going on, discrimination in the sense of differentiating between cases, but because there are important biological differences between women, it's not, I think, wrongfully discriminatory.

SPEAKER_02Now, if there were a particular man in whom a mammogram were indicated and he would deprive that on the grounds of being a male, then I think that would now be wrongful discrimination. And I take sexism to be wrongful discrimination on the grounds of sex.

SPEAKER_03Okay, that's a very detailed answer. You've given some examples biologically where the sexes differ and those have consequences to the different outcomes. But do you have um some cases in mind where you think sex discrimination in particular causes men to have worse health outcomes?

SPEAKER_02Well, I think it depends on whether you're speaking about immediate discrimination or upstream discrimination. And I think in the case of sexism against women, we quite well attuned to upstream factors that can result in discrimination. So if you think about girls being reared within a certain sex role, and then they come to make certain choices in part as a result of that rearing, then it's not that at the point they make, let's say, a career decision, they're being discriminated against in making that career decision rather than another one, but it might be the product of the earlier rearing in a particular way.

SPEAKER_02I think we're much less inclined to recognize the same phenomenon in boys. So very often when boys or men make choices which are harmful to themselves, they are judged just to be decisions that they made rather than to be seen as a product of upstream considerations like the gender role within which they were raised.

SPEAKER_03So, in some sense, men can be harmed by the uh like standards of masculinity that they're held to.

SPEAKER_01Correct. Correct. So like a guy says, Well, I don't want to see a doctor for this silly little disease that I have because I'm tough, you would argue that that is a product of discrimination that that men has to be.

SPEAKER_02Well, it's maybe one of the complexities here, which is often not recognized when we're speaking about anti-female sexism, uh, but we think we need to attend to both in the male and the female case, is the extent to which a disadvantage is the product of a gender role, and to what extent it is just the result of natural differences between men and women. And I suspect that it's not all attributable to nature and it's not all attributable to nurture. I suspect that there's actually a dynamic there and an interplay.

SPEAKER_02So if you think about the strong likelihood that they're going to be at least some kinds of average differences between men and women. Now, an average difference doesn't mean that every last man has a particular attribute and every last female has a different attribute. What it means is that the distribution of attributes skews differently for the uh for the different sexes. It's very likely that some of those are at least attributable to biology, to nature. And what I suspect often happens is that humans perceive these differences and then they amplify them through the social roles, through the sex roles that uh that are then imposed.

SPEAKER_02And so what we often have, I think, is a combination really of nature and nurture. And it's often hard to completely disentangle that, but I think both are operative.

SPEAKER_01Another kind of discrimination, so you mentioned upstream discrimination. Something else that I was thinking about is some kind of downstream discrimination. So you have stuff that happened a long time ago that might result in people having certain attitudes towards themselves or other people of the same gender. Uh then you might have like the right squarely in the middle what is most obviously to people, uh, what is obviously discrimination to many people. And then there's maybe downstream discrimination and the kinds of attitudes that we form in reaction to um to the discrimination that happens or the disadvantage that happens rather.

SPEAKER_01Um the attitudes and uh reactions and uh responses that we have. For example, um, I guess one in in in I guess I guess anti-female uh sexism that people talk about quite a lot is when when women report uh certain cases of sexual assault that happened to them. A lot of people document that, oh yeah, in many cases they're not taken seriously by the courts and the and the law. And I think that there might be a kind of like downstream discrimination there.

SPEAKER_02I'm not sure that you and I are using the terms upstream and downstream in exactly the same way. Uh my my geography is it's been a while. What when I speak about upstream, what I mean is that there's no explicit discrimination at the moment at which, let's say, the choice is made, but it's a result of earlier mechanisms, let's say, of rearing or the establishment of gender roles. Now, if at a particular point, let's say a woman reports uh sexual assault and she's not taken seriously, that is in the moment, there and then she's not taken seriously.

SPEAKER_02Now, is that on account of her being a woman? If it is, uh then I would say that is an instance of sex discrimination. But we do find this curious phenomenon that men are very often even less likely to be taken seriously. And so it's not clear to me that this is an issue that affects only men or only women. Uh, as in many other cases, I think there are different dynamics that uh are operative in in each of the two cases.

SPEAKER_03Aaron Ross Powell So I would like to ask about some specific examples of like different outcomes that I've encountered before. I think it's at least said, I don't know what the numbers are on this, but it's reported that women's pain when they go into the ER might be discounted compared to a man's. So coming in for chest pains, I think that's one of the examples that women are treated less urgently in that case than men are. And the reasoning is supposedly that men are actually more likely to have a heart attack. So they're um that's taken with more concern. But women are perceived to be more likely to be overplaying their suffering, or they're so they're not believed that the pain or the symptoms are as bad as they are.

SPEAKER_03So then they're they're uh deprioritized in an emergency room situation. So what is your opinion on that? And how does sex discrimination come in? How would you try to illuminate that?

SPEAKER_02I can't speak to the specific facts in these cases. I've got some awareness of them, but I can't speak with authority on them. But I can speak to the more general point that you're raising. I think one of the difficulties is that when you do have average differences between different groups of people, whether it's males and females or or anybody else, any other categories, it's not unreasonable to assume uh that it's m something is more likely or less likely with the person who presents in front of you. And that in itself is fine, uh, but when it becomes an unreasonable assessment of the risks, uh then I think we're veering into dangerous territory.

SPEAKER_02So you you shouldn't expect, for example, that 40-year-old women have the same risk of being in a car accident as 18-year-old men. The risk profiles there are likely to be different. But that doesn't mean to say that you should assume all 18-year-old men are driving badly and all 40-year-old women are driving well. So that's the problem, is you can recognize that there are differences. That's perfectly reasonable, but once you move from the generalization to a stereotype, then you're going to get a problem.

SPEAKER_03Um one of the other health outcome differences that I know, we mentioned it a little bit earlier, uh, is the idea that men are more likely to have shorter life expectancy. Um, but there's an additional data point there, which is that uh unmarried men are even more likely to die prematurely. And do you have an opinion on why that is? Is that related to sex discrimination?

SPEAKER_02Again, this is one of those very complicated cases. Let me just first go back. It's not just that men are dying earlier than women from, let's say, adolescence onwards. It's actually even true of male embryos. So the the conception ratio is much higher when it comes to males than than females, and there are many more spontaneous abortions uh earlier on. So then you get still more males than females born, and then uh more males die off at all ages, and so you get more females uh overall.

SPEAKER_02So there does seem to be something more vulnerable biologically about the about the male. And I assume that this is part of what's going on, and there may be limits to what we can do to rectify that. In the case of embryos, it may be that there's nothing that we need to do to uh to rectify that. But uh it's also likely that there are other social factors that are playing a role in shorter male life expectancy. And there I think we should we can and we should be doing something about it in the exactly the same way that we would deal, let's say, with maternal mortality during childbirth.

SPEAKER_02It's not enough just to say, look, it's women who give birth to children rather than men. And so we should fully expect that women are going to die in greater numbers at the around the age at which they would be giving birth. That's a biological given. The risk is a biological given, but we need to respond to it in social ways. And I'd say similar things about at least some of the ways in which uh males are going to have shorter life expectancy.

SPEAKER_01Do you have an example of uh one or two of these issues where you think, yeah, there might be uh an underlying biological um cause, but uh we can and should be taking it more seriously because there's clearly something we can do about it.

SPEAKER_02Well, look, perhaps it's the case that on average males are more aggressive than females. Perhaps that's the case. And if it is, then it may be the males are more likely naturally to get into fights with one another, and some of those will land up with injuries to the person or even death in some cases. Now, if that is just a biological matter, it doesn't mean that we should be indifferent to it. So there are violence protection mechanisms, things that we can do to try to minimize it. But I suspect that it's not just attributable to biology.

SPEAKER_02I think that this may well be a case where there is some average difference between males and females, and that then a social or gender role gets generated, and now boys and men are expected to comply with that in some way. And so there are actual social forces there that we could be doing something about.

SPEAKER_01So one um response that I'm I've heard a few times, and I'm sure that you've heard as well, is that it's something like this. Well, whose fault is that? You know, uh if if men are getting into fights themselves or choosing to get into fights, um well, whose fault is that? Well, why should we why should the rest of society be expected to, I guess, care about it or uh invest resources into trying to deal with this problem uh when there are groups in society that are getting harmed by through through no fault of their own.

SPEAKER_02Well, I don't think to be that cavalier in other cases. So if you think about people who have uh alcoholism, they make choices to start drinking even if they didn't have complete control over decisions to continue drinking. Or if you think about people who started to smoke, they chose to smoke, and then they became addicted, we don't think, well, you're on your own now. We're not going to do anything for you. We try to mitigate those kinds of problems, which we often see correctly as as social problems. And I think there are also cases in which uh females might be uh on on the receiving end in of your kind of uh argument if if we were to extend it logically.

SPEAKER_02So let's imagine you have a society in which women are not prohibited from entering certain professions, but they choose in smaller numbers to enter particular professions. So let's imagine it's something like engineering. I don't know whether that's true in Singapore, but in many places engineering is still largely male.

SPEAKER_01I find it so hard to imagine this world.

SPEAKER_02And uh women are maybe choosing not to go into engineering. Now a lot of people don't think we should just leave it at that. Sometimes they're concerned about upstream factors that have resulted in girls making those decisions. Now, I'm not saying that it's entirely attributable to that, but we should at least be attentive to whether that is a causal factor. Because if girls are getting the message that engineering's not for you, that would be unfortunate. If on the other hand we just find that the sexes naturally distribute, despite sort of impartial rearing, uh, without gender roles, they're going to migrate to different professions to different extents, then I think we should just let the chips fall where they where they do.

SPEAKER_02Those are choices that people make.

SPEAKER_01And obviously and not obviously bad ones. So maybe uh having started out with some of these health issues, I guess I want to broaden this uh discussion out a little bit, right? Um, to other ways in which discrimination might have happen might happen against men and boys and to see if we can draw some general conclusions from that. So I know that you've written a lot about uh discrimination in a whole bunch of areas, and there's one that's very close to the Singaporean public consciousness, and that's conscription, because uh, as many of our listeners probably already know, there is conscription in Singapore, it's conscription only for boys, uh, and it's two years.

SPEAKER_01This is your chance to say what you want about conscription, but also um what I'm interested in is whether we can identify certain unifying factors or explanations behind the kinds of differential treatment with conscription and you know maybe other areas of life that we've talked about, like healthcare.

SPEAKER_02Well, I do think that conscripting only males is a form of wrongful discrimination. Uh, I know that there are people who have the alternative view and they do want to point to biological differences between males and females. So, for example, the greater average upper body strength of males versus females. But my worry is that uh those are averages, and when you turn the average into a stereotype, you're now overlooking differences because there's certainly going to be some women who have greater upper body strength than some men.

SPEAKER_02And if the relevant criterion for serving in the military is the upper body strength, or to the extent that it is, then you should surely be deciding whom to conscript on the basis of upper body strength rather than the basis of whether they are male or female. And now notice that we wouldn't be that indulgent of your kind of argument, your proposed kind of argument in in other scenarios. So let's imagine you say, well, women are biologically the ones who are going to be gestating children and giving birth to children and then breastfeeding children, and this is going to result in more time out of the job market, and so we're not going to admit women to universities or into careers, and certainly not into careers where there's a high social value to reaping the benefits of training somebody.

SPEAKER_02So if you think if you find, for example, that female doctors w work on average fewer hours over the course of their careers than than males do, according to your argument, we'd have to say, well, now we don't admit women because on average we get less benefit for our buck. And I think in that context, we just see how abhorrent the argument is. But if that kind of argument doesn't work in the female case, I think it ought not to work in the male case either.

SPEAKER_03Okay. This is changing the topic a little bit, but um when I was reading one of the uh chapters that we circulated among ourselves before um coming here, you gave the example of um abuse in the homes, like um, or domestic abuse, that boys, male children are more likely to receive physical abuse from um abusive parents than female children. And you explained that in terms of sexism, right? Or sex discrimination towards boys. And I think my pushback on that is that the problem here maybe is not about sexism.

SPEAKER_03You don't need to educate the abusive uh parents in this case so much about uh not picking on boys, but that you just need to teach them not to hit. Um yeah, how would you respond?

SPEAKER_02So, of course, the category of domestic abuse is quite wide. Part of it is directed towards children and part of it is directed towards spouses. So let's put the spouses aside for now, we can we can return to that. Yeah, if parents are, let's say, physically chastising boys but not girls, daughters but sons but not daughters, or they're doing it disproportionately to the to the behavior, then I think that this is an interest a a case of of uh sexism. Now, if your view is that corporal punishment is wrong, physical punishment is wrong, yes, then the solution is to abandon it, to abandon it entirely.

SPEAKER_02Uh but that doesn't mean to say that while it's going on, it's not a form of sex discrimination, given that it's

unknownOkay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I do remember stories growing up in school about like boys getting caned. Don't remember any stories about girls getting caned.

SPEAKER_02There's some jurisdictions where it's prohibited to inflict a physical physical punishment, let's say in schools on girls, but it is permissible to inflict it on boys. There are other jurisdictions where it's prohibited for both, and there are other jurisdictions in which it's permitted for both. But even in those where it's permitted for both, there tends to be more of a reticence to inflict it on females than on males. And this is just one manifestation of a broad attitude that I think society has, which is that it is more socially acceptable to inflict violence on males than it is on females.

SPEAKER_02And there are many, many manifestations of that. Physical violence in the home or schools is one example, but there are many others. If you think, for example, about a serious assault in crime statistics and murder, by far the majority of victims are males, and that's true pretty much all over the world.

SPEAKER_01So I remember watching a TV show, a comedy TV show, where two characters bring up the uh um the issue of like a woman slapping a man, right? And then they both agree. So there's a male and female character talking to each other, and they're like, Yeah, this is a double standard. Uh but then they also come to the conclusion, um, well, but we're probably better off with this double standard. So I guess uh I guess the thought is um we don't want an alternative where people see that oh, we should get rid of this double standard, therefore it's fine for men to be hitting women.

SPEAKER_01Uh now, of course, there's the uh you you might say, well, then the obvious conclusion is to say that nobody should be hitting each other. I would say, yeah, exactly, right? Um but so but one I guess one uh argument that somebody might make is like is a kind of second best argument. Like, look, uh we get that the best outcome is when we're hitting each other, but what this double standard kind of does is that it kind of ensures a second best outcome because the first best outcome for some reason maybe humans are so broken and so uh naturally crappy towards each other that we're never gonna achieve that.

SPEAKER_01So let's just settle for this double standard where uh, you know, at least men unhit aren't hitting women.

SPEAKER_02Look, that argument rests on empirical claims, which are mere speculation. And we would worry about that kind of argument in other contexts where women were on the receiving end of unfortunate treatment. And so I think we should be very skeptical of that kind of argument. But as it happens, when you look at the evidence around domestic abuse now between partners, what you find is that it's not just women slapping men, it's actually engaging in much more serious forms of violence. And the sociologists who were doing this research were so astounded by their findings that the levels of violence were comparable between males and females that they kept re-looking at the data.

SPEAKER_02These were people sort of on the left of the political spectrum. They were surprised by the data, they kept recalculating it to try and find out if there's something that they've missed, and they they hadn't missed anything. They're eventually forced to come to the conclusion that violence between partners, domestic partners, is as commonly initiated by women as it is by men. It can become as serious when inflicted by men as uh by women as by men. And so I think we're dealing with a fairly important problem here.

SPEAKER_02And of course, there's the further difficulty that men are going to be even less likely to report this than females. We already know that there are females who are unlikely to report it. But if a man's got to go to a police station and say, my wife is beating me, he's facing a further obstacle to reporting because he's he's gonna be even less likely to be believed. And so I think we just need to have a broader view. We need to recognize here as elsewhere that the discriminatory profiles of men and women do differ. So it's the it is the case that women are more likely to suffer sexual assault than males are, at least outside of prisons.

SPEAKER_02But uh males are more likely to be the victims of non-sexual violent crime. Now, those are both very big problems, and I think that we should confront both of those problems. I don't see why we need to focus on one rather than on the other. It's possible to keep two thoughts in your head at the same time.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I do like that. Like uh the world has many problems. Uh we can't just focus on the biggest problem in the same uh we can't all just focus on the one biggest problem in any given um amount of time. Even if we did agree that discrimination against women is bigger or more widespread or more serious, uh it's still important that we focus on two things at once. More than two, in fact. Correct. So maybe a thousand.

SPEAKER_02Well, they're obviously going to be attention problems. So not everybody's gonna be able to say focus on the same problem and devote the same energies to it. But one of the points that I've made is that when it comes to sex discrimination, there's actually an intertwinement between anti-male and anti-female sexism. It's not that they are so related that you have to reduce the one in order to reduce the other. Because we have found that anti-female sexism has declined much more than anti-male uh sexism has declined.

SPEAKER_02So it is possible for one to be reduced without concomitant reductions in the other. But at the end of the day, if you're wanting to address this problem, you need to address its root cause. And the root cause, I think, is these sex roles. And they are having different effects in in different contexts and for the different sexes. So there's a sense in which both of these tasks are one task, one task with different faces, with different manifestations.

SPEAKER_01So this does uh bring me to a question that I kind of wanted to ask at the end, but I'm just gonna ask it now. So listening to all that you've said so far and get getting um from from what I've read about your work, there's a kind of vibe for no better uh for uh for the lack of a better word, that you're kind of draw drawing kind of symmetry between the kind of uh discrimination that men face and the kind of uh discrimination that women face. You know, it's two sides of the same coin, roughly uh in a sense, or at least they they come from certain the same root causes.

SPEAKER_01Some some some feminists might disagree, and uh, and I think many feminists do try to point out that uh anti-uh female anti-woman uh discrimination often also comes with other things like um like power imbalances, or maybe power imbalances at least on average. Uh they come with uh they come with certain structural uh forces that um end up combining with discrimination to produce something new and produce something even more difficult to overcome. I'm wondering if you want to push back against that and say, no, it actually these problems are more similar than uh we think, or if you want to say that that, yeah, there are certain important differences between the kinds of discrimination that men face versus the kinds of discrimination that women face.

SPEAKER_02Well, there obviously are differences, but I think they're also uh common causes. And I think the very things that you've pointed to about, let's say, power dynamics are not operative only in the anti-female case. So it is true that in many societies, most societies, men disproportionately occupy the most powerful positions, but it's also the case that men disproportionately occupy the most powerless uh positions. So if you think about homelessness, that is disproportionately a male problem. Uh, these are the most unempowered people.

SPEAKER_02So if you're pointing to that homeless man and you think, well, there's patriarchy for you, you've you've misdiagnosed what the problem is. Again, you're going to get a different uh distribution. Part of that might again be biological, but part of it I'm sure is uh socially reinforced. And so I think each of those kinds of phenomena that you mentioned that are meant to differentiate the first sexism from the second sexism, do not do a complete differentiation. But that is at the same time not to deny that they're not different manifestations of the problem for males and for females.

SPEAKER_03Um can I just push back a little bit on what you said there? Because you gave the example that, uh, or you you think there's something wrong with pointing to the homeless man and saying, well, there's patriarchy for you. Uh at least in my interpretation or my understanding of how feminists use that word, that would be a compatible statement that men can suffer under patriarchy too. It doesn't mean that in all cases men are doing better or men are winning. Um can you say a little bit more about what you mean by that?

SPEAKER_02But I'm glad you asked that question because it is true that many feminists do want to attribute the problems to patriarchy, and then they want to say that some of the disadvantages, or perhaps even they want to say all of the disadvantages that males suffer are really just a product of patriarchy. And I worry about that schema for explaining what's going on. I don't think it's as explanatory as my one, and I'll I'll give you an example for why that's the case. So it's clearly true that many societies have become much less patriarchal than they once were.

SPEAKER_02So women are now gaining entry into professions from which they were previously prohibited. And in fact, the the female gender role has become much less constraining than it used to be, and has become much less constraining than the male one is. The male one has remained much stronger than the female one. And yet we find that there's some forms of discrimination against males that have actually increased while patriarchy has been declining. So if you think about during the height of patriarchy, you would have men routinely getting custody of their children following divorce.

SPEAKER_02And now, at least in many societies, it's uh the opposite. It's that women will routinely get custody. And this is even when you control for things like who was the primary caregiver beforehand, whether custody was contested, you control for all of those things, you still find that women are much more likely to gain custody of their children. Now, this is a disadvantage that men have now. If you want to pin this on patriarchy, that's really hard to do because it's clearly a less patriarchal society now. In a really patriarchal society, men got custody of their children.

SPEAKER_02I think the better explanatory medium is to say that there are these sex roles, and that very often sex roles produce a patriarchal society, but it is the sex roles that are fundamentally what explain the problem, whether it be patriarchy or any of these other forms of discrimination.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and there there are there are some ambiguities in what people mean by the patriarchy. Yeah, they are. Sometimes it just seems to refer to a set of attitudes about what um what the gender roles are. And if that's the case, then it does look like you know everything is the patriarchy. But then that that's a really loose way of defining it. And once we try to narrow it down uh to um to a slightly more uh specific definition, and I guess that's where the differences uh appear, but that's where you might say, look, then it really isn't all just the patriarchy, there are other things at play here.

SPEAKER_01I I thought maybe I I just push back against your previous point about how there are men at the bottom, uh including there there are men at the top, there are also men at the bottom. I'm wondering if what happened what you might say if some uh uh somebody came back at you and said, uh, look, but as far as you know diagnosing the problems faced by uh by a lot of women, and maybe a bunch of men too, what matters is who's at the top because they're the ones who get to uh control uh what happens. And if you look at just who's who's at the top, well, you see mostly men.

SPEAKER_01Um what might you uh say to that kind of response?

SPEAKER_02I don't think that's true because I think it can be the case that people can work against their own interests or at least work against the interests of people who share a superficial trait with them. So it can be that men, let's say, are disproportionately in power and yet they're quite happy to conscript other men into the military and to send them off to war where they'll die in disproportionate numbers. So I don't think the mere fact that somebody shares that superficial attribute of being male means that they're not going to participate in some way.

SPEAKER_02There are analogies. If you think about female genital cutting, this is performed invariably by females. But we don't think that because it's performed by females, that it's not a form of discrimination against the girls on whom it is performed. Now, of course, some people will want to argue that they are really just doing the bidding of the male leaders of society, but that I think is to oversimplify the picture because many of the uh fem uh female performers of female genital cutting are devoted to the uh to the practice and they have a vested interest in the practice and they're defenders of the practice.

SPEAKER_02Uh, now you can argue that that's a result of their having been reared in a certain way, but then you can say precisely the same thing about male rulers having been reared in a particular way, that they're more inclined to send males to war than they are to send females.

SPEAKER_01What about certain issues related to oversight? For example, you can imagine a board of directors or male, somebody comes up to them and says, Hey, why is it that uh there are so few women in this department and they have no idea? And it turns out it's because of work hours and because of the kinds of parenting duties that women tend to take on more than men. Maybe it's not necessarily the case that uh this board of directors wanted to bring about this outcome and were uh had intentions to disadvantage certain groups, but they just didn't think about it. And as it turns out, if you just put a bunch of women in this board, somebody would have pointed it out earlier.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, what about so maybe problems can arise by concentrating a bunch of men at the top just because of oversight?

SPEAKER_02Well, I think you're pointed to two problems there, if I if I'm not mistaken. So the one is, let's say, the complete absence of women in decision-making bodies, and you're saying, well, if there'd been a woman there, then it would have been recognized earlier. And I don't think we're in that sort of situation in many societies. There's some, perhaps in Afghanistan that's the case, but now, but it's it's not the case in many other countries where you do have women in some of the senior positions, and so you do have that kind of input. But I also think we need to worry about assuming what somebody's view is going to be on the basis of, let's say, their sex or their race or their religion.

SPEAKER_02Uh, we can't make those assumptions. And very often people are not interested in getting in actual alternate views. They're interested in getting in somebody who has an attribute that they think is associated with with an alternative view. So I I don't think I don't think that's um that's a actually the problem that we have at the moment. And then there's the question about not not intending something. And I do think that forms of sexism can be unintended.

SPEAKER_02I don't think that they are less wrongful for being unintended uh uh unintended. They're unintended, we may blame people less. May, it depends on the circumstance. Uh, but it it's it's still wrongful. And just as we try to seek out those kinds of implicit biases against women, I think we ought to be looking and paying more attention to the implicit biases against men.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Um for lack of a great transition, I'll just ask this question. Um we wanted to give you a chance, because uh some some people might uh characterize your view as anti-feminist. And I I personally don't think it is, but I think it's um important that we give you a chance to respond to that possible accusation.

SPEAKER_02Aaron Powell Thanks for giving me that opportunity because uh I've been misrepresented and mischaracterized so often. In fact, when the book came out, there was somebody writing in one of the newspapers in the UK who told her readers that I deny that women are the victims of sexism and that the problems are entirely uh for the males. And this, of course, is the exact opposite of what I say, and I say it pretty early in the book. I acknowledge that there are many, many ways in which girls and women are the victims of sexism. I think that the arguments I advance are ones that should be very amenable to and attractive to feminists who are concerned about equality of the sexes.

SPEAKER_02So if you're interested in equality of the sexes, then you need to be interested in it both ways. And I think genuine egalitarian feminists would adopt that exact view. I think there is a group of feminists who do perceive this as hostile, and I suspect that what's very often going on there is that they're not actually committed to equality of the sexes. What they're interested in is the advancement of the position of women. Sometimes that coincides with equality of the sexes, because what they're doing is they're removing those impediments to treating women equally.

SPEAKER_02So they're giving them the advantage, and that's fine. Uh but if you're only interested in advancing the position of women, then you're going to advance the patient of women even when they're not worse off, even in the circumstances in which they're not worse off. And then you just become an ideologue. You're just a partial, a partialist. You're just committed only to uh one particular group, even if it's to the unfair detriment of others. And uh I imagine the feminists of that kind would be opposed to what I'm saying, but I don't think they're on firm grounds with their view.

SPEAKER_02I think this partialist kind of view is not a defensible one. They're very quick to point to the so-called men's rights people, and I think some of their critiques are correct because I think there's some men's rights activists who are really only interested in the well-being of men at all costs. But just if we have that phenomenon, I think we've got a parallel phenomenon among some feminists who are really only interested in advancing women.

SPEAKER_01So do we have you on record saying that you are an egalitarian feminist?

SPEAKER_02I am, exactly. I think I've said that in print as well. I hope uh uh I hope it won't be ignored.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I'd I'd like to ask another follow-up question to that. So um I don't want to accuse um people in the academic world of being um these stereotypes, but like you said, there are some men's rights activists out there who have very, I think, simplistic views that like it is really just the the war of the sexes. And maybe there are some like sort of straw feminists that you could point to that are the same on the other side, that it's a war of the sexes and uh it's either women or men who are going to be on top.

SPEAKER_02I don't think they're straw feminists. Just as I think there are real men's rights activists who have that agenda, I think there are real feminists and quite a few of them who are really only interested in advancing the position of women. So I don't think it's a straw position. I think it's a real one, and it's now up to respectively each of those groups to demonstrate to us just how committed they actually are to equality. And the way to demonstrate that is, even if you're not devoting all your energies, at least to acknowledge where the other side is at a disadvantage and not to want to impede progress in that area.

SPEAKER_03I guess my question to you really is though, um, do you think uh that true egalitarian societies are possible? Do you think that we can live in a gender-egalitarian world?

SPEAKER_02Depends what you mean by gender-egalitarian world, because if by that you mean that men and women will occupy all positions equally, as it were, there'll be an equal number, let's say, of female as male murder victims, and there'll be an equal number of female and male doctors, and an equal number of female and male engineers, and an equal number of female and male members of parliament, I don't think that we're going to attain that. And I think in part that is because of uh underlying uh biological factors and just in choices that people make independent of uh sex role socialization.

SPEAKER_02But if by uh an egalitarian society, a gender egalitarian society, we mean one in which people are not subjected to sex role expectations and not coerced or for or forced into those things, then I think we can certainly make progress. I don't have the kind of faith in humanity that would lead me to think that we could have perfect egalitarianism in that sense, but I think we could make substantial strides towards that. And we have in many societies. I I just think there's a lot more to be done.

SPEAKER_01It requires a lot of faith in humanity indeed. Um I I want to press on the point about you know straw feminism versus uh partisan feminism. Um like I I think it's probably true that there are there are probably some feminists in the world who are more interested in pursuing uh more opportunities for women at all costs, as as you might put it. But I wonder if we might be a bit uncharitable in interpreting what they're doing, because um I think well, one charitable way of interpreting what I guess most feminists are doing is that they're just focusing their efforts, right?

SPEAKER_01It's uh they might say, look, I want to advance the opportunities of women. Uh you can go ahead and and focus on men's issues if you want, it's just not my issue. And I wonder how many uh feminists would really fall into that category of partisan feminists as you describe it.

SPEAKER_02I don't know. They have to demonstrate that. But I have implicitly answered your question because I did say that I'm not requiring everybody to devote themselves equally in their energies to each of the sexes. But one of the tests is whether you're willing to recognize the forms of unfair discrimination that the other sex is subject to. And if you're not willing to do that, even when the arguments and the evidence suggests that there is a form of unfair discrimination there, then this has got beyond the question of whether you where you're devoting your energies.

SPEAKER_02It's now become a kind of ideological point. And and then I worry. And and that I think can be true of men and it can be true of women.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Um I imagine that there are many people who would recognize the kinds of uh disadvantages and discrimination that men face, but also just say, Well, I I just don't see how that's a priority in comparison to the kinds of uh in comparison to like uh the the sheer number of women across the world who uh for example get uh girls who get killed as baby uh before they're they're before they have a chance to grow up or something like that because of their gender or something like that.

SPEAKER_02I really worry about that global focus because if you w take that global focus you're gonna immediately evaporate a whole lot of feminist concerns. Because if you worried let's say about whether you refer to women, a married woman as Ms or Mrs, and you compare that with a female genital cutting in the in certain parts of the of the developing world, you just have to take the title issue off the table and say why why are we worrying about that when there there's much there's much bigger problem going on or global poverty or any number of other issues or climate change.

SPEAKER_02And the point is the world contains many different problems and the fact that there's some worse problem doesn't mean to say you can't deal where you can with a with a lesser problem.

SPEAKER_01That makes sense uh you gotta solve more than one thing at a time.

SPEAKER_02Well the point is that uh people do put energies into different places and different people can do different things and it's not that one problem has to be solved before another one is solved. And so I think it's entirely reasonable to be addressing different things in uh in different in different places. So we much less likely to have an effect on what's going on halfway around the world than we are in our immediate circle. If you can sensitize some people in your immediate circle to let's say linguistic conventions that might be problematic, you may just be much more successful at doing that than solving global poverty.

SPEAKER_01So I I know that you think that uh we can certainly deal with both the kinds of disadvantages that men face and the kind of disadvantages and discrimination that women face at the same time if not you know different people working on both issues at the same time and often these issues are related and solving one set of issues will go some way to solving the other set of issues. Are there also ways of going about pursuing these objectives that do get in the way of the other set of issues do you do you think?

SPEAKER_03Yeah I think if I can help you out. So you you explained in your own words earlier how sometimes advocating for um feminist causes might also benefit men, right? So sometimes the moving towards a more egalitarian world where you kill two birds with one stone, but other times you can see the boat rise for women but not for men or maybe even get worse. So the question is if you focus on certain men's issues, do you think that that runs into conflict with women's issues? Are there any that you can think of that fit that pattern?

SPEAKER_02I'd prefer if you told me something that you're thinking of I I I think it is true sometimes that when women advance men with a certain mentality feel worse off and they feel unjustly aggrieved. That is uh that is certainly a phenomenon but I think there are ways to address that not that we're always going to be successful in it but part of the way to address it is to undermine the the male gender role. So this expectation let's say that the male is going to be the breadwinner such that when he's not and his spouse is bringing in his female spouse is bringing in the salary he now feels that he's less of a male that's an unfortunate situation and we can try and do something about that.

SPEAKER_02It'll be to his advantage and to her advantage.

SPEAKER_03Yeah um so I was thinking about you asking me to give an example of uh what would it look like if there's a men's role that we can advocate for more that would seem to come at the cost of women. I'm thinking about like the cultural narratives that we give the genders. So you just mentioned uh like it's good if we can edit the gender norms and say like well women can be the breadwinners too. Then that takes away some shame for men. But it also might take away some sense of pride for them for being the breadwinner in a family or maybe think about it in terms of um professions.

SPEAKER_03So nursing is an overwhelmingly female profession. Doctors at least used to be overwhelmingly male but I think sometimes you notice that men are drawn to professions that are coded as male. So if you suddenly take away that coding of the profession of doctor if it becomes maybe female coded then you have men who don't want to be doctors anymore because they don't want to be considered girly. Is that an instance of like a it being a zero-sum scenario?

SPEAKER_02Aaron Ross Powell But again I'm worried about our viewing some professions as male or some professions as female if what you mean is what gender, what sex ought to occupy those kind of professional roles. If if all you're doing is a description and you say well nursing is female in the sense that most nurses are female. Well that's just a true description in some places and may not always be but it it is now and here. But if you mean a profession that ought to be male or female that's exactly one of the ideas that we ought to be undermining. And you should have people going into it if they want to go into it.

SPEAKER_02And what w what what one of the criteria for whether they want to go into it shouldn't be whether it's male or female.

SPEAKER_03So I mean to me that sounds like an advocacy for gender neutral things, right? So that there is no such thing as a male coded job or a female coded job.

SPEAKER_02And yes if by coded you mean one where it's desirable or undesirable for one or other of the sexes to to inhabit.

SPEAKER_01So this is uh a slight tangent but there is also a brand of feminism called radical feminism I'm sure you're aware of that that has the goal of just breaking down the the gender roles altogether. I was wondering what you thought about that that kind of view that says well s since we're going part of the way to try to uh get rid of um the kinds of uh stereotypes that we have of of m what what it is to be man a man and what it is to be a woman we might as well just get rid of gender altogether do you have any thoughts on that?

SPEAKER_02Well I'd want again to have you define your terms before before I answer that but in in general I am opposed to sex roles. I I think again that there are average differences between people of different sexes but I also recognize there's a lot of individual variation. And I think we need to move more towards a world in which an individual is treated as that individual with their unique set of attributes rather than as somebody who occupies a particular sex or no sex. That's problematic was you're trying to now shoehorn an individual into some pre-formulated category.

SPEAKER_02And I don't think that's good for anybody. Again sorry just to complete it's it's not that I think that if you do that you will end up with perfect proportionality of representation in all areas. I I don't think that's the case. And so it's hard to know when we've reached the ideal state. But we can know for sure that we're far from that at the moment and there's lots that we can do to improve.

SPEAKER_01So so I guess the position is well as long as we're in a state of the world where sure there might be differences but we cannot reasonably trace these differences to some kind of unjust uh discrimination or unjust differential treatment uh that that that's what you're that's the kind of world that you'd say would be a fairer be a fairer world yes again we need to be alert to possible blind spots as yeah as to what might explain differences that might not be biological, might not be natural.

SPEAKER_02But yeah I think I think that's exactly right otherwise.

SPEAKER_03Yeah okay I'd like to clarify my own view a little bit because I uh I don't want to give the impression that I am against a um that kind of picture of a world either. I just wanted to be pushing back on some of these ideas because I know that if you look at the history of societies, they've all had gender roles that they seem to prescribe to people. And I think there's a sort of need that people often feel to live up to those roles. So it just occurred to me that there's one way of trying to expand um the roles open to men by giving them a different narrative about what it means to be masculine or manly.

SPEAKER_03So you could say that oh it's actually a very manly thing to be um the primary caregiver in the home. And that would be one way of perhaps increasing a feeling of gender egalitarian roles in the home by giving them a positive narrative about that being masculine. And the other is more of what it sounds like you were suggesting where you just there is no such thing as living up to the masculine ideal. Like we just give that up and say you're just an individual.

SPEAKER_02That's my preference I I don't see why we need to be boxing people into masculine or feminine or non-binary categories.

SPEAKER_01I think that's part of the problem I guess maybe one thought is that it's just got something to do with I guess building your own self-identity in the world you know uh sometimes people just like to and maybe this is a product of socialization but maybe some some people just like to think of themselves as a as a better man. Yeah you know I wanna I wanna be the man that uh that my father taught me to be or something like that. And maybe this is just the product of the socialization that you want to get rid of in the first place. But maybe there is like innately human need to to to fit certain categories and to feel a sense of belonging to certain categories.

SPEAKER_02So if we look at contemporary society in many parts of the world what we find is your ordinary male and your ordinary female look radically different from what they did 300 or 400 or 500 years prior to that. And if you had to ask people in that earlier time whether they could imagine a world like we inhabit now, they would be convinced that this was a kind of biological impossibility. So given the move that we've made it's really difficult to have confidence in thinking that similar degrees of change are not possible in the future.

SPEAKER_02We can't assume that they are but we also can't assume that they're not and so we need to work along the spectrum as it were we need to do what we can to minimize those kinds of expectations and that's why I would advocate not trying to p push people into the category of masculine or feminine even if you try to rejig what it means to be masculine or feminine. Rather focus more on treating an individual as the individual that that person is and then see where you get led with that.

SPEAKER_02And then we'll find out how far you can go. It may reach a certain limit and if that's the limit that's fine. But we may also recognize and we can go a lot farther than we think we than we now think we can.

SPEAKER_03My work is on um bringing Asian perspectives into bioethics. So something that is occurring to me as I listen to you is that that position might actually sound compatible with a Taoist perspective that what the Taoists tell us is to let go of the kinds of cultural impositions, the things that we are instructed to believe and the roles that we're taught to live up to and just return to some sort of natural spontaneous state of being so that you just let yourself be whatever you are without trying to live up to societal expectations or forms.

SPEAKER_03But that's the opposite of or is often portrayed as the opposite of the Confucian view, which is very roles based. So I completely understand your point about like 300 years ago, thousand years ago gender roles are totally different. They totally changed. But I don't think that the idea of dividing roles up socially changed. People do swap things around. So like what was considered feminine once is now considered masculine in some cases and vice versa. But we still kind of have this idea of a division of labor or a division of social roles.

SPEAKER_03I'm more skeptical that that will change personally and that fits with the Confucian view that like society or like what it means to be a person is to fulfill your roles in society. And maybe those specific roles or duties change but uh that that is sort of what it means to be a person is to to live up to those roles.

SPEAKER_02I think you've made two points the first one is about the what you said is the Taoist view of just expressing yourself and living as the kind of person you want to be. And I I can't comment on the correctness or otherwise of that but would want to caution against the misinterpretation of a view like that and or misinterpretation of something that I said. That is that I don't think we should just give free expression to whoever we are because if you're a a violent person, I think you just give free expression to that. I don't think you ought to express just whatever comes out of you.

SPEAKER_02It it needs to pass a kind of moral filter is this something that's acceptable to do or not do. So I'm really only speaking against the idea that who you ought to be and what you ought to be is is what you ought to do is def is determined by your your sex. The second point you made was about social roles and I think there do need to be social roles I just don't think they need to be determined by your sex. They need to be social roles in the sense that a complex society requires a degree of specialization. Not everybody can be a doctor and an IT expert and an accountant and a lawyer and so we need to have differentiation between a different different roles.

SPEAKER_02So that that is I think inevitable but it doesn't have to be dished out on the basis of person sex. And also we'd hope that people are not cramped in their opportunities by other factors such as economic ones. So if there are opportunities for people to move from one social class to another through education and other mechanisms then that that's also good. Now we've moved of course beyond the realm of sexism into into class issues but again there's often an intersection between those.

SPEAKER_02So if you find for example in the US that African American males are m more underrepresented in tertiary education than African American females.

SPEAKER_00So there's there's a a race and a sex issue that is uh that is operative we need to be attentive to those kinds of things too alrighty uh we've been at this for a while and what a discussion we've had I've really enjoyed it um so thank you david thank you with you thanks for listening to our new podcast subscribe online and tune in every first of the month in the meantime listen to C BME and you and be savvy

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can Nihilism Improve Your Mental Wellbeing?

    Nov 2, 202645 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Insurance Discrimination: Is it Fair? with Harisan Nasir

    Sep 24, 202649 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Genomic Newborn Screening: Where less really is sometimes more with Ainsley Newson

    Aug 25, 202655 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Hidden Side of Birth: Injury, Trauma, and PTSD with Angela Ballantyne

    Jul 2, 202648 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Brains in Jars with Insoo Hyun

    Jun 1, 202656 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...

    Credit the people on this episode