Send us Fan Mail In episode 2, and series first, James and Sinead banter their way through the ethics of human genetic enhancement. Many people think of this as designer babies, but whether we should genetically modify people requires us to ask deeper questions: what is it to live a good life? Is wanting a better life for your child always a good reason to change your child? Where is the line between wanting a better life for someone, and trying to control too much? Is it fair to others to become a superhuman? What karaoke song is best? Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, C BME and U, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_05Hello and welcome to episode two of season two, our 2025 podcast series. Today's episode is the one you've been waiting for. The episode where your two favourite people?
SPEAKER_04Peeper. Peeper. Because people isn't already a plural. We're doing well with that.
SPEAKER_05You know what I was about to say? Just banter about bioethics and karaoke. Um, case in point. So the episode on human genetic enhancement. So we will first consider what it means to enhance a person and whether ultimately this is a good idea. But first, the questions you've come to expect. James, coffee or copy?
SPEAKER_04Uh it depends on my mood and how much money I want to save. But but but if we're leaving money out of the equation, then coffee. Yeah, you know I like my my milky cappuccino.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah. And so what's the difference, James, between a cappuccino and a latte?
SPEAKER_04I could not tell you.
SPEAKER_05That's what I thought.
SPEAKER_04Okay, you tell me then, coffee snob. Coffee or coffee?
SPEAKER_05Uh coffee. Um, flat white, if I'm at an untrusted cafe, if I'm at a trustworthy cafe where they, you know, can identify the actual beans they use. I'm a bit of a batch fruit kind of galey.
SPEAKER_04I want them to identify the kind of beans they use. I only take the fanciest beans from the fanciest places. Next question. Which country?
SPEAKER_05So aggressive. Hey, I just like my coffee. I'm allowed to be s if you're gonna be snobbish about something, let it be something pointless like coffee. Oh, I hate the way that rolled off my tongue.
SPEAKER_04Next question.
SPEAKER_05Which country would you like to travel to next?
SPEAKER_04Uh I think I've told you this one before. I I think um one of the places that I really want to travel to the most is uh the Baltics.
SPEAKER_05So my brain just doing some job geography.
SPEAKER_04Lithuania, Estonia, and Latvia.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. That has nothing to do with Brooklyn 99.
SPEAKER_04It's got nothing to do with Nikolaj.
SPEAKER_05Nicolaj.
SPEAKER_04Nicolaj. Nicolaj. Nicolaj.
SPEAKER_05I feel like I'm saying it right. Nicolaj.
SPEAKER_04We're gonna cut so much from this episode.
SPEAKER_05Absolutely not that. Um, so for me, I want to go to Vietnam next. I would like to go to Hanoi. I would like to have some fur. Um, I would like to swim in the ocean. Fur. One more time. Nicolas. Nicolas. We have issues. Okay, final question. Um, and I feel like I could answer this for James Fanley because we've both done karaoke before and I've answered this exact question. But what song would you sing in karaoke?
SPEAKER_04Uh it's it's it's hard to choose hard to choose. Um, but I think one of the top ones is anything by the lonely island.
SPEAKER_05Uh which is not a song, he literally means any song.
SPEAKER_04Any song by the by the comedy musical band The Lonely Island.
SPEAKER_05And I I reckon there's a 95% success rate that you would know every single lyric through every single song.
SPEAKER_04I think there's a decent chance. Especially with the lyrics in front of me.
SPEAKER_05But you've got two other songs. You've got Thrishop.
SPEAKER_04Thrift Shop. It's one that uh that I almost always do at karaoke.
SPEAKER_05And my personal favorite holding up for a hero.
unknownHolding up for a hero.
SPEAKER_04It's just Barney Tyler just makes you feel things. Okay.
SPEAKER_05I'd love to see you like in the um like the Shrek Law outfit though. Fairy Godmother.
SPEAKER_04Fairy Godmother. The red dresses. Only if there's a grand piano that I can sprawl on top of. You can find me at Grand Piano, I'll wear a fairy godmother dress.
SPEAKER_05Absolutely, yes. Um, we've got that on live, no, on streamed recording. We will be doing this. Um, so my personal favourite song to do at karaoke, my go-to is Always Dancing Queen by Abba.
SPEAKER_01Classic.
SPEAKER_05As we were talking about before, I think this is because it both is a song everyone knows and everyone can get behind. Um, but my second go-to song is actually um Skaterboy by Avril Levine because I'm just a 2010 girly trying to live out her dreams.
SPEAKER_04I feel like it's pre-2010s, Avril Levine.
SPEAKER_05Oh, that hurts a little. Am I older than I think I am?
SPEAKER_04I don't know. How old do you think you are? We can censor this part for the fall.
SPEAKER_05I am.
SPEAKER_04Jesus, not in front of the kids. Okay, moving on. So today we're gonna be talking about genetic uh selection and modification, basically the forms of genetic enhancement that we can do to a person. And fortunately, we have here Shine Prince, who did her PhD on human enhancement, as well as James, who did his master's thesis on this.
SPEAKER_05Don't leave me out here alone.
SPEAKER_04I was hoping to make you fully responsible for everything we said. I'm not going down. Damn it. Alright. So genetic selection refers to the process of choosing specific genetic traits for offspring, either through natural means or assisted reproductive technologies such as in vitro fertilization, and the pre-implantation genetic testing. This practice allows parents to screen embryos for certain genetic conditions and in some cases select for traits like gender or even potential physical and cognitive attributes.
SPEAKER_04One particular type of pre implant pre-implantation genetic testing screening is polygenic embryonic screening, a lot of big words here, where parents can select between different embryos during IVF procedures based on polygenic risk scores. Then there's also genetic modification, as in the modifying of G of a gene to produce a particular trait. So right here we have already have a little bit of a uh bifurcation, I guess you can say, uh, between different kinds of genetic modification.
SPEAKER_04Uh Shine, you did more biology than I did in uni. Could you say a little bit more about the differences between just selecting and modifying?
SPEAKER_05Okay. So selecting is basically where we go through IVF, and in the natural course of IVF, you're going to produce, you know, between five or ten embryos. I'm not exactly sure the certain number, but a certain number of embryos for the purpose of screening them for particular traits. Now, this is usually done to avoid heterogenic conditions that the parents may have.
SPEAKER_04Um what do you mean by heterogenic conditions?
SPEAKER_05Is that even a word? Did I just make up a word?
SPEAKER_04You said I believe you said heterogenic.
SPEAKER_05I don't think that's heritable.
SPEAKER_04Heritable.
SPEAKER_05We're doing really well. So we're screening for heroes.
SPEAKER_04So like I have like three arms or something.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I can make sure that if I do IVF, my kid doesn't have three arms.
SPEAKER_05Correct. Um, unless, of course, you want them to be just like you. Anyway, we get it, we're we're going down a different path there. But basically, we're going to screen these embryos to see what sort of genetic conditions they have, whether or not they're there's a high risk that they're going to put uh have a particular kind of genetic condition. And now this is generally only done for therapeutic purposes. So one exception to that is for sex selection. And this is not done for family balancing per se, although there might be some changes around that happening.
SPEAKER_05This is generally done to avoid sex-based traits, such as sex-based conditions. So these are conditions that are like linked to the X or the Y chromosome. And so one of the things that people are considering now is well, if we can already do it for therapeutic reasons, should we also do it for enhancement reasons? Should we now be selecting for particular traits like height and height and intelligence and um certain hair colour or eye colour or these sorts of things? But then on the other hand, we now have enhancement technologies through genetic modification. And so this is the way in which we can go into a person's genes.
SPEAKER_05So for example, let's take James here. We could take a little sample from his stem cells or his wherever they are in his body, I forget where they are now, potentially bone marrow. It's been a while since I did Biomed. Um, and basically we can take those stem cells and then we can send certain feedback signals to them, and we can modify them into the kinds of genes we want, and then we can insert them back into the body. The other way you can do that is you can take a particular virus, basically, you can modify the virus so that it has a memory for a certain gene, and then you can insert this into the body and hope for the best, basically hope that this virus will go through and then modify the gene in that person.
SPEAKER_05And so we're hoping that we can take these genetic therapies for adults, these very specific single gene therapies, and we can start to do them on embryos. And then not only can we just do one gene at a time, we're hoping we can do multiple genes. And then the same question arises. Well, if we're doing it for therapeutic purposes, why should we stop there? Why can't we use it for non-therapeutic purposes? And then there that raises a question of whether or not there is a difference at all. So if the whole purpose is because you're trying to help the child live a better life, why just limit it to health conditions?
SPEAKER_05Why not give them all the best traits so that they can live the best life? Now there's a question between, another question between selection and modification, which is, well, if you're already selecting this one, they already exist. You're not actually like, you know, doing anything in particular. Um, it is a person that could exist. Whereas if you're enhancing them, you're going into their genes, you're modifying them around. You might do what some pro proponents or critics would call playing God. Um and I know that adds a lot of normative language to it, and it's not my favorite use of the term. And so the question is, is there a difference between causing a person a specific person to exist or simply allowing a specific person to exist?
SPEAKER_05So these are some questions, James. What do you think?
SPEAKER_04Well, firstly, I want to point out that what you you said really surprised me because uh I thought it was kind of the other way around in terms of like our knowledge about and our skill at modifying like people who don't exist yet versus modifying adult human beings or people who already exist. So you're saying that potentially somebody could put a virus in me that m that makes genetic modifications to my body right now that could turn me into Spider-Man.
SPEAKER_05I refuse to answer that question. I have the right to remain silent. No, so we it depends how far these technologies go. Um if we're currently on that trajectory, so we can modify one gene at a time. Technically, if we continue to do that over and over again, we could really change you. However, this relies on two things. One, the technology to be able to continue to modify genes, and so therefore, questions of safety and efficacy and risk arise. We don't know what the knock-on effects might be of modifying one gene, let alone 700, as is the case with intelligence.
SPEAKER_04And the second, um uh I don't need to be more intelligent, I just want to be spider.
SPEAKER_05So that's all hard. So hold on, hold on. Do you do you want to um have the the little webs coming out of your palms, or do you want the one where he has to make the webs out of little little little suits? We're asking wetsuits.
SPEAKER_04The the the little web shooters.
SPEAKER_05You want web shooters. That's so disgusting though.
SPEAKER_04Uh no, I don't yeah, I don't want them coming out out of my wrists. Yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_05So what do you really want? You just want the suit. Well, uh um, you want to be one of the Batman, so super rich to be able to afford the the outerwear.
SPEAKER_04Well, but then the the super agility and climbing on walls seems really cool.
SPEAKER_05I thought that was part of the suit. No, it's no it's yeah, we are really getting into the MCU lore here.
SPEAKER_04Welcome to the lore podcast.
SPEAKER_05But essentially, um there are many difficulties with this. Um, but yes, one of the main ways in which we treat certain cancers now is through gene therapy of adults um and even children. So technically, if we continue down this path, we might get to a point where we can make a lot of changes to an adult, but it's always going to be much easier modifying an embryo.
SPEAKER_04What I do find interesting is the distinction between um therapeutic uses of uh medicine or or whatever scientific technology that we have versus enhancement. Because intuitively that like I think a lot of people would say, yeah, there's a difference between curing somebody of a disease and then going in and poking around in in their DNA or whatever to make them live a lot longer than they would otherwise. But if you think about it, what really causes people to die is uh certain kinds of disease.
SPEAKER_04So by trying to cure disease, we're effectively, in a sense, enhancing people to live longer or healthier lives than than nature has made possible. Right? So are there any good arguments um or ways of drawing the distinction between uh therapy and enhancement?
SPEAKER_05So I think there are two. One is specific about the therapy enhancement debate, and one is about the is treating aging a therapy or an enhancement? So I'll start with the first one. And so the way I respond to the first one is to adopt an objective definition of what it of what health and disease actually mean. So there is this really big debate in philosophy as to whether or not the concept of health and disease are objective or uh normative concepts. And so for me, I think that there is a robust definition of what health and disease means, and it's an empirically driven science field.
SPEAKER_05I think we can discover what it is the heart does, and we can discover when it is the heart has a disease. And so when I say the word disease, I mean all pathology. And so for those who aren't the biggest fan of the use of the word disease to refer to non-infectious diseases, just know that what I really mean here is pathology. And so I think therefore that if you're intervening in a state of disease or pathology, that would be called therapy. So it's not because maybe we want that particular outcome or we have particular values about it, it's simply a mechanical question.
SPEAKER_05Which state of body are you intervening in will determine whether or not it's therapy or enhancement. So if I'm intervening in a pathology, that would be called a therapy. If I'm intervening in a state of health, that would be called an enhancement. And so that's how I distinguish between the two. And now I acknowledge that there are many people who reject that definition and would say that health and disease are normative concepts. And so, according to them, they would need to define the difference based on various or different values about what health means or or what enhancement means. And so for them, I leave it up to them.
SPEAKER_05So that's that's their job. They put themselves in that in that bucket. That's by all means, um, I would love to help get them out, but I'm in a very different bucket in that situation. And so, what this means for me about aging is that aging is a completely natural and healthy thing that all biological organisms must go through. So, in the same way that in order to get to be an adult, you have to go through development, you have to go through being a baby, you have to go through being an infant, through a toddler, through all of these sorts of different stages. And at all these various different stages, you have different capabilities and functions.
SPEAKER_05So a baby, for example, cannot reproduce. It cannot run, it can barely walk, it can barely eat on its own. And these are all completely healthy. So arguably at the end of life, just because we don't want to be this way doesn't mean that that's a disease. It's a perfectly natural end of life for all biological organisms. So I would argue that taking an enhancement and trying to extend human life is, well, is an enhancement and not a therapy or a treatment of a particular disease.
SPEAKER_04Making bold claims saying babies not being able to walk is a normal thing. Walk child.
SPEAKER_05I don't have kids. I don't know what age they start walking.
SPEAKER_04Somewhere between zero and five. So just uh put a bit of pressure on uh on what you've been saying, um, it sounds like it does paint a bit of uh kind of idea, I guess, idealistic or unchanging picture of what it means to be human. Because it sounds like you're saying, okay, this is what the human body is like, this is what each organ is supposed to be doing at any given point in time, and any deviations from that picture uh might be counted as disease. But but you know, uh like biology changes over time, uh evolution happens, for example, and things change.
SPEAKER_04So how does this how can you square that picture of of of function and disease with the fact that things change all the time?
SPEAKER_05Things do change all the time. Um and if you're talking about time as in the past, how how old is the earth?
SPEAKER_04Uh 4.
SPEAKER_05So, in the concept of 4.7 billion years, yes, things change all the time. But in the history of the Homo sapien, things have rarely changed, if at all. Um, and so for example, there are some things that never change, like um humans only and must have 12 cranial nerves. We have the the liver that's meant to filter blood, we have the heart that's meant to pump blood. Um, and these things have not changed. And so, arguably, within our understanding of science and in understanding of biology, scientists do not try to put rules together based on future hypotheticals that may or may not happen.
SPEAKER_05We can only do so based on what we know now. Um, and so, arguably, particularly given the nature of medicine, um, food security in many parts of the world, um, and our hygiene practices, evolution for humans is not particularly going anywhere. We're treating all these diseases before we have the chance to reproduce. And so I think it's uh it's a bold claim to say that enhancements are good for us because humans will continue to evolve anyway, particularly because now we have a choice over which way we go with enhancement, how we enhance ourselves.
SPEAKER_05We now finally have a say as to what's good and what's not. And so the claim that it's inevitable, I think is a is a very bold um and poor claim to make.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so there's one claim that um uh proponents of genetic enhancement can make that, and it's it's inevitable. We're just we're like history marches towards a certain direction and we're just aiding it along. Which I agree sounds a bit uh a bit too bold, right? And it's like nobody can predict the future. Uh philosophers probably worst of all at predicting the future, right? Uh Marx, I'm looking at you.
SPEAKER_05I'm a law background, man. I don't know what you're saying.
SPEAKER_04Well well, it's Marx who was like, well, eventually everybody will become a communist utopia.
SPEAKER_05Oh, nice.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Bold claim.
SPEAKER_04Bold claim.
SPEAKER_05Capitalism was that not today, sucker.
SPEAKER_04It hasn't panned out. Um anyway, um, but the other argument that I think is probably more popular among ethicists uh is that it's a normative argument. Like, who cares? Okay, we're not making any pred so ethicists might say, we're not making any predictions about what's gonna happen, but we do know things about what makes people's lives better or worse. You know? Um being healthier, all th other things being equal makes a person's life go better. Um having more money to a certain extent, or else being equal tends to make people's lives go better, etc.
SPEAKER_04etc. And and people also make these claims about things like intelligence or height or whatever. So uh I think a lot of ethicists, including uh someone we know, uh Julian Sevolescu, have claimed that yeah, it's it's not only good to try to make people's lives go better, but it's almost an obligation, especially if you're about to have children, to make your kids have uh to try to make your your kids have as good as possible lives. Um so what do we think about that kind of argument?
SPEAKER_05So James, just just for our listeners, has asked me what makes the life good? What makes a good life?
SPEAKER_04What makes a good life? We're solving it today, everyone.
SPEAKER_05So I love this question. Um this and this is a question I was really interested in in my PhD. Um, and so I came to, after much research, after much um consideration of the various theories of well-being and what makes a life good, I came to the conclusion that well-being is mostly made up of both objective and subjective conditions. And so what I mean by this are there are things that I can tell you you need to have these in order for your life to go really well. And so I agree with you, things like health. You need to actually survive in order to have a good life.
SPEAKER_05I think you need to be able to communicate and have relationships. I think that someone living by themselves, all alone, um, potentially not particularly not out of choice, is probably not having a really good life. And I would not wish that life for anyone. And so this is what I mean by objective conditions. So, regardless of how you feel about these certain things, I think that you need them. Um, and so for me, the most obvious two are health and relationships. But then I think that there is a subjective nuance to this claim. Um, and as much as I want to come around and say, oh, look, you have health and you have relationships, therefore you should feel good about your life, you might not still feel that way.
SPEAKER_05You might actually hate your life. You might have other things that are not going well for you. You might have a really poor judgment about what relationships and health are, and you might think you need more than that. James, is there something you want to share?
SPEAKER_03Nope.
SPEAKER_05And so I think that um any theory of well-being needs to be able to incorporate these two things together, which is very difficult because they are all they are often seen to be mutually exclusive. And so what I realized is that one of the best ways to combine these two different um conditions is the principle of autonomy. And so, as much as I might want to come along and say, you have health, you have relationships, therefore you have a good life. If you have not been free to assess your own life and if you don't have the final say over what whether your life is going good for you, I really don't think that you can truly have well-being.
SPEAKER_05And so the question that I want to ask about human enhancement is why are we valuing certain enhancements over others? Why do we think these are going to make our lives better off? So the question of intelligence, for example, many people will show, well, the more intelligent you are, the better off your life is. And that's not true. There are many studies that show there is not an association between superior intelligence and happiness. In fact, it can go the other way. And also it's relative. So just because you're a smart woman doesn't mean your life is going to be better off. Just because you're a smart person of colour doesn't mean that life is going to go better off for you.
SPEAKER_05It's very relative to the society that you're in. Same with height. If you're a really tall woman, life may not go well for you because you might be discriminated against for not being, you know, feminine enough. And for men, um, you know, the question of, well, if you're a short man, it's not that being short is intrinsically bad. It's that society masculine, like puts, you know, masculine priority on being tall. And so the question is, well, should we fix individuals to meet these particular norms that aren't necessarily good for us? They're just the result of particular oppressive societies, or should we fix society first?
SPEAKER_05And so my focus and argument is that, well, we have responsibility to not fit people and code their DNA with oppressive norms. We should fix society first. Whereas I've had chats with Julian about this, and he says, well, their lives are gonna like their lives might suck now. They should be given the means to make their lives as as happy, as full and prosperous as possible. And I think that I, to some extent, I do agree, but that also just reperpetrates and um you know further exacerbates those oppressive norms.
SPEAKER_05So who's who which generation is it that's gonna be responsible for standing up to this and finally changing it?
SPEAKER_04But will you support then uh enhancements that focus on what you do call the objective uh elements of well-being? For example, let's say we discovered a bunch of genes that can make that them that affect somebody's weirdness or social. You know, like you know, if you have these genes, then you you you might be a bit weird and it makes it harder for you to make friends, and then if you have another set of genes, you would just become the coolest person in the in the room.
SPEAKER_05You know, like I yes, because coolness is a gene thing, not just some arbitrary social background. Solid point, my friend.
SPEAKER_04Oh well, yeah, sure. But you know, there there's some things that might make somebody uh more, you know, naturally sociable. So let's say we were to discover these genes, would you then like say, oh yeah, because that that's an objective uh element of well-being, maybe we should look into uh trying to select for those kinds of genes.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I 100% see what you're you're saying, and I've definitely struggled with this because in accepting that there are objective conditions like health and good relationships, there are obviously certain things that I value more than others. However, let's just stick to the category of relationships here. I think that putting this idea out there that there are weird people who might might struggle to have make friends is not inconsistent with the idea that they can still have really good ones. And I don't want to go creating a like heterogeneous society in which we all look exactly the same and we all have the exact same traits and we all have the exact same combination of genes that make us all behave in the exact same way.
SPEAKER_05There are, I have friends who are weird and wonderful, and they are some of my favorite people. I'm not saying that they had it easy. Um maybe uh, you know, I feel like most people have experienced some bullying throughout childhood. But I think it would be really um over-clinical and over-medicalized to say that we should fix their genes rather than trying to make society a a nicer place that's less judgmental about different traits.
SPEAKER_04There could be like two different perspectives that we take towards issues like this. One is a kind of uh worldwide or society-wide perspective where we can all agree we can say, look, it'd be better if instead of trying to enhance people to be uh more sociable or good looking, we as a society develop better norms. Right, and say, and say, look, we should change the way we look at uh things like beauty and uh and so that you know we become more accepting of people of different kinds of looks or different kinds of ways of interacting with people.
SPEAKER_04But you can also take the the perspective of a parent, you know, and say of a or a prospective parent. Uh and that parent might might think, uh, look, I can't change my uh my society's norms. The only thing I can change is my kid. And given that I can only change uh the the kid that I have, I'm gonna try to make sure that they're as like they're as good looking or as cool as possible, uh, because I know that given society's norms, a will live a better or worse life. Um so what do we say to that the those kinds of parents might be in that kind of situation?
SPEAKER_05Um that parents will be facing with this. And I think it's totally fair to think about it. Yeah. Um the problem with that sort of thinking though is that if you fix the person, not the oppressive norms, that could lead you to a really dark place where we are only selecting or modifying white males um with whatever genes that we can find for any other like um, you know, standard norms. And so the parents of those who select just white males could say, Well, you know, I want my child to have the best life, and you know, white men have it easiest. You know, well, that's a big generalization.
SPEAKER_05And I know David Bannatar will have something to say about this later on. Um, but I think they would be under that theory, they would be completely justified, and that would be really problematic. And so I I think that it's fair for parents to have certain struggles and to want their child to have it easiest, but also they are responsible for partaking in those oppressive norms by conforming their own child to it. And so I think in the same way that um you can't hide or shield your kid from all the bad things in the world, you can only really prepare them as best you can for it and give them the values and skills and traits in order to deal with it fairly and as morally as possible.
SPEAKER_05That's just gonna have to continue. You can't just rule it out and be like, oh, you know what, they'll have it easy from now on. Well, they won't. You won't be able to shield them from everything. And there are arguably some things we should not shield them from. Um, and I I do not think that uh producing children in accordance with oppressive norms is the way forward in parenting norms.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but I guess there's an interesting question of where we draw the line when it comes to these things, right? Like in Singapore, uh, there's a big kind of like rat race mentality among parents and and the children of those parents, right? And children in general, you know, you have parents who send their kids to uh tuition like three times a week or enrichment classes and all that. And I think most of these parents will probably agree, yeah. Look, if everybody would just chill and didn't send their kids to enrichment, I would prefer it. I'd save a bunch of money, my kid can go out and play and all that, and they wouldn't be stressed out all the time.
SPEAKER_04But because all the parents are doing it, I just have to do it. Um so, and I think uh at least my intuition is that look, I don't blame these kind of parents. I I don't think they're doing anything wrong because they're still trying to uh do the best for their kids, even though yeah, it would be better off from the society perspective if everybody just chilled out.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So I guess, yeah. So I guess the question is look, if that if we fix that as a point and say, look, that's fair enough, uh, then where do we draw in the line and say, oh, that's some point of like enhancement or or meddling with your child, that goes that we've gone too far, it's not fair enough.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. I think you have an excellent point, and I'd be very interested in you sharing your perspective of being raised here in Singapore and how whether or not you would like to take what you went through and put that onto the next generation. But before we come back to that, I just want to say that I think that we can draw lines. So just because things are always on a scale doesn't mean that they are all equally okay. Um, and so one of the things I think we can do is look at parents who do these sorts of things and go, I hear you, I see you, I really understand that you had no choice and you did what was available to you.
SPEAKER_05And so the last part of that is recognizing that these are legal, lawful, and um uh cultural norms here in Singapore and and elsewhere. But genetic enhancement is not legal yet. It's not even like an actually discovered yet. We can barely modify one gene at a time to prevent people with cancer from having to go through that. And so there is big space to say we don't have to put the judgment or the responsibility onto parents to make these decisions. We could actually make enforceable legal bans up until we've had a really good chance to have a public consensus, you know, big uh education on what it means to genetic enhance and these sorts of things.
SPEAKER_05And we could just say we're just gonna have a massive halt. Um, because in instances of a Red Queen uh Red Queen event, which is what you're describing, which is where everyone has to continue to expend resources to stay in the same place. No one's further off. Everyone's actually worse off because they've spent all these resources just trying to keep up. In in instances like this, um uh you just have to rely on regulatory bans because it's not up to the individual in that situation to change society because they'll just get absolutely screwed over. And so I think one of the differences between what parents already do and genetic enhancement is that genetic enhancement is not here yet, which means we can hold it.
SPEAKER_05We can not put this on their shoulders, we can we can keep this with government and um you know empirically backed research.
SPEAKER_04For all the Paul Sai majors out there, we're talking about regulation to solve the prisoners' dilemmas.
SPEAKER_05It's called a ban.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, but in the literature they don't quite uh talk about it that way. But that that yeah, so I actually read an article recently which uh our very own Julian sent me about about how they actually did a study in Singapore uh surveying parents on what they might think about using IVF and uh pre-implantation genetic screening to test for things like uh for traits for various traits. And I think uh for therapeutic reasons, I think vast majority say yeah, fine, that's it's good to do it.
SPEAKER_04But I still think that at least in Singapore, I think a a majority of parents, or at least a plurality, seem or Singaporeans seem to think that if yeah, there's nothing wrong with using uh genetic screening to make sure your kid gets more intelligent or something. Uh so it seems that I I think at least in Singapore, uh yeah, if you didn't put in any regulations, you'd have a slow creep towards uh genetic screening or traits like intelligence becoming a norm.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I think that's why um it's really important that governments are proactive and regulatory bodies are really proactive with this. Because we are in a really unique situation where we've identified a technology before it exists and it hasn't just burst open on us with all options and opportunities available. Um and so I think we really need to have a hard look at history at every time we've invented a new enhancement, a new technology that was allegedly for human benefit, and retrospectively asked, well, was this was the sum total of benefits that this produced did that really outweigh the harms? And I think with the questions of human enhancement, I I really don't think that the sum total of alleged benefits are gonna outweigh the harms, particularly when you account for things like justice and equality and discrimination issues that will inevitably arise.
SPEAKER_04That's interesting. I I feel like a lot of uh pro-enhancement people use that exact same argument. They say, well, there was so much pearl clutching when we invented books and more pearl clutching when we we invented like standardized education or something like that. But look where we are now. Everybody agrees that we're better off. So the same thing will happen when when we enhance everybody, you know. Uh people will people will complain and have ethical worries, but a hundred years from now, everybody will be doing it and we'll be looking back and saying, well, it's insane that we ever thought that this was a bad idea.
SPEAKER_05There's a really um, there's a prominent author, and I forget whether or not it's um Alan Buchanan or Nicholas Bostrom who makes the claim um that only uh enhanced civilizations are the ones that are most well off. And I think if you stick to that idea that every time we've had a technology or a tool that it's improved us for the better, you run into a very difficult position of trying to explain why um maybe First Nations groups or uh groups of people that don't rely on technology and mass education systems cannot have a similarly good life to us.
SPEAKER_05And I don't think that's a defensible position whatsoever. I I'm with um, I think it's is it Yval Noah Harari or yeah, Nova Is it the humankind person?
SPEAKER_04The the human the sapiens.
SPEAKER_05On brief history of humankind. Uh, where he goes through the um uh cognitive, agricultural, industrial, and scientific revolutions and shows that there is no evidence that humans are better off for all the technology we've discovered. Whether or not we are actually happier, whether or not we have more meaningful relationships, whether or not we are better at any of the things that objectively make our lives go well, there is no evidence apart from the fact that we live longer, so we have longer time to achieve these goods, that we're actually happier. And I'm with that. I I I don't think that it's true that the smarter you are, the better your life goes, or or um the taller you are.
SPEAKER_05I don't know, you might want to comment on this. For our listeners, James has recently discovered he's six three, not six foot two and a half. Do you have any comment, James?
SPEAKER_04Well, somebody who uh nearly identifies as a six-three man. I can confidently say that my life has not gone any better since the starting of 6'3 instead of 6'2.
SPEAKER_05There we go, problem solved. Human enhancement, not required. Um, and so yeah, I just don't think it's true that the more technology, the more enhanced we are as a people, as individuals, along the evolutionary scale, the happier or more meaningful our lives become. So that's my answer.
SPEAKER_04What I don't I don't know about that because I feel like I would have not made it to adulthood if not for technology.
SPEAKER_05And so remember, remember, knowing your background, um, remember my distinction between therapy and enhancement. I I think that um when we're discussing enhancement, we are discussing very different things from therapy and the treatment of human diseases and pathology. Um and so I'm very happy to put a normative difference upon those two different categories.
SPEAKER_04So I want to go back to some of the concerns about uh enhancement that are that have to something to do with equality, right? Uh equality and justice and the idea that uh if people are just enhancing, uh firstly, what one one one worries that uh the rich are going to have get more enhancements than the poor, uh a lot more, and widen the gap between the rich and the poor and the poor. And the other concern being it's some kinds of discrimination, right? You have everybody tending towards certain kinds of of enhancements and and with uh with a result being firstly that society becomes a bit more uh uh h homogenous.
SPEAKER_04And secondly, it kind of well, I I think if everybody's like you know trying to create kids of a certain race or something, you can see the obvious problems with that. It's like it's discriminatory, it's kind of like disrespectful to the people who are who are, you know. Imagine if if you're in a situation everybody's trying to enhance their kids to not look like you, you'd be like, hey, what up with that? Um I guess one potential answer to that is that okay, enhancement is fine as long as we make sure that everybody has access to enhancement, you know. Uh so instead of just saying we should let it happen, we should say, oh, maybe we should uh we should tax people more and then use those taxes to to provide enhancement to everybody and and maybe even regulate it so that uh people have to choose between a wide variety of enhancements.
SPEAKER_04So we could go the other direction and try to ramp up the process even more so that everybody can have it. And that seems more equal. Um so why not that instead of saying no enhancements at all?
SPEAKER_05Okay, so uh you raise a really good point. Um many scholars have recognized that if we just allow free um market access, unregulated by government restriction to genetic enhancements, there will be inequality or the exacerbation of inequality. And so this is because um there is the belief that the better your genes are, um the better your life will go, um, which I've already argued is not necessarily true in like the philosophical sense of the concept of the good life. However, we ought to recognize that there are certain genetic traits that um produce certain phenotypes.
SPEAKER_05So there are what I mean by that is you have a specific genetic code for blue eyes. Blue eyes is the phenotype, so they're they're two separate things. And so um there is there are certain phenotypes that are associated with higher socioeconomic reward. For example, um being a white person, um, being a man, being tall if you're a man, being petite if you're a woman, these sorts of things. The more attractive you are, um, the more you earn over your lifetime. So I ought to recognize these things, and I would like to acknowledge that.
SPEAKER_05However, there is two problems with the argument saying, well, therefore, we should just make sure everyone has access to it. So one is this idea of genetic determinism and this idea that whatever gene you have is the phenotype you'll have. So this is a false or a misconception of how genes work. So you have your gene and then you have what's known as a gene environment interaction. And so this is where your environment, whether that be your body and your body chemistry or the physical environment you're in, can actually intervene in your genes to produce different phenotypes.
SPEAKER_05So you might have a gene, for example, for a normal amount of like serotonin uptake. However, because you go through childhood trauma or because you're in the womb, the um your maternal parent or the per person giving birth to you goes through trauma or because there was a famine and there was a nutrient deficit. Any sorts of these sorts of issues can actually interfere with your genes and produce worse outcomes. So, more often than not, this manifests in poor health.
SPEAKER_05Um, and so one argument is well, even if everyone got access to these genes, let's just play by the rules here and just pretend that for some reason the government is interested in modifying every single person. And that that's how governments are very likely to spend their money. Just give them the stick.
SPEAKER_04There have never been any problems with governments getting involved with people's genetics.
SPEAKER_05Ever. That's A, not an issue. And B, um, you know, exactly how they would like to spend their million dollars per person, which you know, they are famous for investing in each individual.
SPEAKER_04I mean, they're not investing in just stopping poverty, so no.
SPEAKER_05They've just been waiting for human enhancement. They've just been waiting.
SPEAKER_04It's a gigantic stash of cash somewhere.
SPEAKER_05We're just waiting. And so one of the problems with this is even if everyone was enhanced, we would not all then have the same phenotype. And this is because um there are massive socioeconomic inequalities in society that will continue to interfere and drag down your genes per se. And what I mean by that is even if you got enhanced, you have equivalent intelligence to your wealthier um uh high or higher socioeconomic peers. Um, the kind of uh uh gene environment interaction between a socioeconomic status and your genes is really prevalent and well researched.
SPEAKER_05It's probably the most commonly researched apart from maternal impact. And so, what I mean by this is even if you had the same genes, you would then not have the same IQ. You would still be behind. In fact, you would need to be even more enhanced than your higher socioeconomic peers. And so, is that something we're willing to do? Are they gonna allow that? Would the higher socioeconomic class be okay with everyone else actually being genetically smarter than them? And so this raises questions of genetic determinism, so this false belief that your genes will just produce those traits and this ignorance of the gene environment interaction and how if you are of a certain race, if you are of a certain socioeconomic class, if you experience any form of child maltreatment, these are all gonna negatively interfere with your genes and interfere with any genetic enhancement the government is promising to give you.
SPEAKER_05So I just would like to be really clear about that. And so my concern about equality is not, well, if it happens, you know, if we can give it to everyone, it's gonna be okay, then I agree with it. I I don't, I really don't think it's ever gonna be able to have that equal impact that proponents are allegedly saying it will.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I feel like we should have figured that one out the first time we had a pair of identical twins who were raised by different families and turned out different. And shockingly, shockingly, the way you're raised affects who you are. I don't know how how could you say something so controversial on this point?
SPEAKER_05I don't know. Am I gonna get cancelled after this?
SPEAKER_04Probably. Oh, here we go.
SPEAKER_05You know what? I'll pack up my desk on the way out.
SPEAKER_04So what was I gonna say? Um Yeah, so but but then I feel like a proponent of genetic enhancement could take that argument you just made and turn it back against uh one of the other concerns about um genetic enhancement is the concern about uh homogeneity.
SPEAKER_05Homogeneity?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, whatever you say.
SPEAKER_05Triagan men.
SPEAKER_04No. Uh yeah, like like look, it's you could say, look, uh so we've already based on your precise argument, we we know that people are gonna turn out different and there's gonna be a lot of beautiful diversity and all that. Uh even if we uh enhance everybody because of the way people are raised. So we should stop being so worried about that.
SPEAKER_05Ah, yes, socio economic inequality, also known as beautiful diversity. Racism, another classic example.
SPEAKER_04Well uh yeah, well, but you know, we're talking about uh differences that aren't so much to do with equality, but just uh, you know, differences in how people act, behave, uh the way, you know, uh somebody might enjoy, might want to be a singer, and while somebody might want to be a uh a data broker or something like that.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, the the the problem with that is um or that view that ah yes, we'll still have an equal representation of like singers to academics, to janitors, to hospitality workers is will we? If we're all genetically encoding the same intelligence with the exact same combination of you know personality genes, will we actually have people who are you know equally equipped for all the various roles that we need in society? Um and I also think that it takes a rather what's the word naive perspective of the way jobs in our society are distributed and this idea that we should be planning the job for the child rather than planning the child for life.
SPEAKER_05Um and I I I think it's unfair because what if a child has been genetically programmed per se to be ballerina, but they actually just want to be a pro-wrestling person? What's the what's the title there? A wrestler. I'm I'm clearly down on my UFC. Look at that. I knew UFC, that's the one where they act by getting slammed on the ground, right?
SPEAKER_04Uh I feel like slamming is a thing shared by fighting sports.
SPEAKER_05There's this concept of incompatible excellence. So the um the kind of body that is best suited to being a ballerina is not the same kind of body that's best suited to being a power lifter or wrestler. And so you can't know which one the child is going to be best suited for, or which is the more important question, is going to be most interested in. And so why? Why do it in the first place? If there is no way to know whether or not you're actually improving their chances of having a meaningful life by pursuing something that's interesting to them, then there is no reason to say that you should pursue it because it will benefit them, because you can't you can't know.
SPEAKER_05It's a big fat question mark. And so you can't rely on that to then make a moral claim that you should be pursuing it for the benefit of the child.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I I feel that. Like, like I go anywhere and people are like, especially since it's just Chinese, it's just been Chinese New Year. The number of times people have asked me if I've played basketball, man.
SPEAKER_05Oh, that's that reminds me, do you?
SPEAKER_04No. Get out.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, just because your body is suited to a suited in crestation marks to a particular field or industry doesn't mean that's the one that you're actually interested in.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah. Um, although I guess what if there are certain traits that are kind of all purpose, you know, things that make you better at a whole bunch of things. You know, isn't better just give people the option uh and let them choose for themselves?
SPEAKER_05Could you name some of these traits?
SPEAKER_04Uh being having having good motor skills. Very wide range, you know. Uh having good motor skills could make you a great ballerina or a great basketball player.
SPEAKER_05I'm just not sure about whether or not enhancing will achieve it any more than just, you know, practice and dedication over childhood and you know, in well into adulthood.
SPEAKER_04In the words of a wise woman, porque no los dos.
SPEAKER_05That is just so for everyone listening. That is my catchphrase around here. Should we have ice cream or myelodinosaurs? Porque no los?
SPEAKER_04The wise woman I had in mind was the girl in the ad.
SPEAKER_05Damn it. Called out.
SPEAKER_04In the taco.
SPEAKER_05I just want a catchphrase, man. Let me have it. I think that's a really great question. And it's something that I'm not too settled on myself as to whether or not I have a full answer. Um, the question is though, is you know, there are some people who are super well suited to being surgeons because they have the most excellent, you know, hand-eye coordination there is. But for the rest of us who aren't interested in that career or who don't pursue it, that kind of skill is pretty much useless. No other area of my life would I need the kind of hand-eye coordination to suture an artery than, I don't know, trying to drive.
SPEAKER_05And so the question is, is it really adding that much value? Or, you know, if there's already going to be a genetic lottery of of traits out there that are mismatched to our personalities and our interests, who's to say that the parents or researchers in question are going to do that any better than nature itself? And so I'm just I'm not entirely sure it's a strong claim. I'm sure it is a it is a claim that needs to be addressed. I'm just not sure it's really that strong.
SPEAKER_04Might make you a bit better at cooking.
SPEAKER_05Anyway, so we're done.
SPEAKER_04Well, you said you're done, so I can't ask you any more questions.
SPEAKER_05No. Um any is there anything you'd like to add? I know that this is an area of interest to you.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, uh, I think my main interests are uh to do with the equality aspect of it, uh, which we've talked about extensively. Um I one thing that I've thought about a bit is uh the issue of whether parents have uh responsibilities to make their kids have to uh try try to ensure that their kids have the best possible lives or just good lives. You know, uh I think uh somebody I've worked with, uh Matthew Liao um at NYU has argued that we don't really have responsibilities to make sure our kids have the best possible lives.
SPEAKER_04So he has this example which I really like. So imagine if there's this gene that you could insert into your kid that would help them appreciate extremely fine wine. Right? Uh and let's say like if they could really appreciate really strong uh fine wine, their lives would definitely go better. So let's hold fix all these claims and let's assume that you're right. That there's you could do an enhancement, a simple announcement, wouldn't be too costly, and suddenly there'd be the best wine connoisseur and their lives would be better for it.
SPEAKER_05I think there's a specific title for it. Can you say it?
SPEAKER_04Snob.
SPEAKER_05Isn't it like somelia?
SPEAKER_04Uh snob. I'm I'm I'm that's what I'm going with.
SPEAKER_05So according to according to James, anyone who appreciates any food or beverage to any sort of detail is a snob.
SPEAKER_04You can appreciate it, but uh if you're going around saying uh you you don't really know what a cappuccino is.
SPEAKER_05I didn't say that. I asked you to define a cappuccino. I don't know. Anyway, please keep going.
SPEAKER_04Anyone who's smarter than me is a snob. Um there it is. Uh yeah, so so so so the thought is like that do you really have a duty to make sure that your your kid has the ability, uh uh has has the skills of extreme wine snobbery? And my intuition is that no, you don't you you don't have to. And I think uh that that is kind of um evidence of the idea that um a parent's responsibility is not to make sure that the kids have the best life possible, but just uh a good life.
SPEAKER_04Uh and I wish we could bring Marcus back in to uh talk about that a bit. But yeah.
SPEAKER_05I agree with you. So there are a lot of proponents in the enhancement literature that say that enhancement is necessary for our future because it contributes to excellence, and excellence is where you know the good life is. And I just strongly disagree, there is beauty in mediocrity. Um when I was in high school that to my parents. When I was in high school, my mum used to check my grades and then also my effort grades. And so if I didn't if I didn't have an excellence grade in my effort, I would get in trouble. I would be asked why didn't I put in effort? And it was like, can I just not put effort into this one thing?
SPEAKER_05Can I just be okay at math? Like I don't care for it, I don't want to be good at it. I can I just be okay at it. I am okay with just being mediocre at this particular thing. And so I think we really need a question that I think which is a largely patriarchal and capitalist value, that the only thing that's good is is if it's excellent. And I just don't think that's true for life in general. You can live a very mediocre life and be very happy. You can um, you know, there are many great religions that teach acceptance and um what's what's the word?
SPEAKER_05Um, graciousness, is that it? Gratefulness for what you have, not looking for something new. Um, and I think there is some wisdom in that because when has the satisfaction of all our desires ever made us, you know, better off? Sure, it might be some of them, but I really don't think every time I've desired a snack and I've eaten it that I was really better off after. Probably could have held off a couple of the snacks. So I can I I agree with you. I think we really need to question that that strive for excellence and perfection. Like, where is that coming from? Because it's not a universal truth that it's better.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And it's not just an enhancement thing, it it it's it's it it goes into like a lot of things that parents do. You have cultures around sending your kids for a love and enrichment. I think there are lots of what is enrichment? Like just going for classes, extra classes outside of normal school. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05That's so unfortunate.
SPEAKER_04There were points in my life where I had to go for that three times a week.
SPEAKER_05Oh man.
SPEAKER_04Instead of playing video games.
SPEAKER_05I make no comment.
SPEAKER_04You know, uh or like um, you know, there are forums of uh where you know a lot of mums will come together and and argue with each and like say, oh, if you use like a little bit of like formula milk or something, you're a terrible parent or something like that. Uh you know, and and I my intuition is my here's my my my considered philosophical intuition. Just chill.
SPEAKER_05Solved it. So at the start of this podcast, we set out to answer the question of what is the meaning of the good life. James's answer is just just chill out.
SPEAKER_04Just chill out, just chill out. Um that's I'll write a paper about it. I'll write a paper. Excellent.
SPEAKER_05I look forward to reading it. Excellent. I hope I'm the reviewer.
SPEAKER_04I hope so too, and I expect a very charitable review.
SPEAKER_05I was just mainly gonna respond. Have you ever heard of enrichment classes?
SPEAKER_04Triggered.
SPEAKER_05Um anyway, I don't have any more questions for you, James. Do you have anything else for me?
SPEAKER_04Uh I think that's the time we have for today.
SPEAKER_05Excellent. Um, I appreciated this. I was a little nervous coming into this. Everyone loves being questioned on their PhD topic, after all. Um Joy. Thanks for listening.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to C BME and U and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...