Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

C B m E & U

C B m E & U artwork

Happiness and Meaning: Can you have both? with Matthew Hammerton

Jul 14, 202546 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Dr. Matthew Hammerton (Singapore Management University) presents the ideas of happiness, well-being, and the meaningful life, to answer what it really means to live a good life. He discusses the difference between meaning in life, meaningful lives, and the meaning of life (we promise they are different!), and whether there is a point in our lives where time doesn't give us more meaning. More importantly, we discuss spiderman, Matthew turns the questions back on Sinead and James, and philosophers who don't wear pants. Remember people, be savvy!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02The center presents a new podcast at C BME You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.

SPEAKER_03Welcome back to CB Me and You, a podcast about biomedical ethics. Today we're gonna ask the deep questions, perhaps the deepest and biggest question of all. What makes a life meaningful? What does meaning have to do with end-of-life decisions? And how will philosophy help me get over my own existential angst and ennui? Joining us today is Matthew Hamerton, Associate Professor of Philosophy at the Singapore Management University. Welcome, Matthew. Great to be here.

SPEAKER_01We have a couple of icebreaker questions to get to know you a little bit better. We ask all of our guests these questions. So very first up, coffee or coffee?

SPEAKER_05Um, well, espresso coffee made well, but depending on the mood, coffee as well can be nice. Sugar hit.

SPEAKER_01So espresso, just one shot?

SPEAKER_05Uh piccolo.

SPEAKER_01Oh, interesting. Have you tried a ristretto? I learnt about this recently.

SPEAKER_05No.

SPEAKER_01So a ristretto is like two espresso shots stopped a little bit short to get rid of the bitterness. Okay. A tiny little bit of milk.

SPEAKER_05I have to try this.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, me me too. I I learned about it last week. So yeah, maybe we should go after this.

SPEAKER_03What's the name of this thing again?

SPEAKER_01A ristretto.

SPEAKER_03Okay.

SPEAKER_01You wouldn't know, you're not really into coffee.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. You can listeners can tell I'm the coffee snob here.

SPEAKER_01He drinks a cappuccino. My goodness.

SPEAKER_03I still don't see why that's a bad thing.

SPEAKER_01Anyway, next one. Moving on. What country do you want to travel to next?

SPEAKER_05Well, I'm going to Malaysia for a short holiday next week, so I hope that goes ahead. So that's where I want to be next. Otherwise, my life, something bad has happened.

SPEAKER_01Wow.

SPEAKER_05But taking your question more seriously, I think a country I've been wanting to visit but haven't had a chance is Peru. I've been to Cuba, Dominican Republic, Mexico, but not Peru. It's the next on my list for Latin America.

SPEAKER_01Excellent, excellent. Anything about specifically about Peru that intrigues you?

SPEAKER_05Well, you have the history and culture there, the Incas, but you also a lot of Latin Americans will say that Peruvian food is like the French cuisine of Latin America. Really? They really have great chefs and they love their food.

SPEAKER_03I didn't know this.

SPEAKER_05And the markets, you know, you can go to a market there, you can get like 20 varieties of corn. They have an amazing agriculture. So much of our modern food comes from the Incas and from Latin America. Tomatoes and corn and all these things.

SPEAKER_03Potatoes, right?

SPEAKER_05Yeah, potatoes as well. Sweet potatoes, you can get like 30 varieties in a market there. It's amazing.

SPEAKER_03I didn't know there was more than one.

SPEAKER_01My life has so much more meaning. I'm just gonna spend the next 40 years trying all the different types of potatoes.

SPEAKER_03What's gonna give me meaning in life? Trying 40 types of potatoes.

SPEAKER_01Potatoes.

SPEAKER_03Anyway.

SPEAKER_01Moving on to our last question. Uh, what's your go-to karaoke song?

SPEAKER_05This is a very embarrassing question. Oh, this is the best question. No, I hate karaoke.

SPEAKER_01Oh no.

SPEAKER_05In fact, I think karaoke is evil, right? So evil. Imagine that I said, here's a new thing that's taking off. Like you get you go to a room, you get really drunk, and there's all instruments there that you don't know how to play, and you just start playing them randomly. It's like, why would you do that? That's stupid.

SPEAKER_01There are so many disanalogies there though. Like, A, you don't have to be drunk. Like I would say I've done karaoke sober more times than I've done it drunk. And two, it's not like you're learning an instrument, it's just like singing, it's your own voice.

SPEAKER_05I mean, if you can sing well, then sing and perform for your friends, but but karaoke is just not the kind of context for that. But look, if you force me to do karaoke, I would choose calypso music. It's the one music that I think kind of makes sense in karaoke.

SPEAKER_01What's calypso music?

SPEAKER_05It's a music from Trinidad and Tobago that was popular in the 50s, it's still around today. Um very cool upbeat music with uh sing song playful lyrics that often are comedic.

SPEAKER_01Oh so wait, wait, you know when uh on Valentine's Day you get like four singers that come in in pinstripe suits and little hats and they sing an ar cappello song about how much the boy loves the girl or whatever. Is that it? Is that a no that's not it? No, that's the only music I know from the 50s.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Well, if you ever do karaoke with us, we'll show you that karaoke is not about singing well. Um that's the problem.

SPEAKER_00I see, I see. Anyway.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Moving on from that, uh, you might you might top the list in terms of people who hate karaoke who've come on to our podcast because there are quite a few. Um, but anyway, we've had very uh entertaining discussions about this. To the meaning of life. So I need you to solve some problems for me, you know. Uh sometimes I wake up in the morning and sometimes I just don't want to get out of bed because firstly, my bed is comfortable. And secondly, sometimes I wake up thinking, oh, I don't I don't want to do or achieve anything today. Um what is life even like?

SPEAKER_03No, I'm no way that articulate in the morning. But uh help me out here. Why does my life sometimes feel like it could do with a bit of extra sprinkling of meaning?

SPEAKER_01Where's the sauce?

SPEAKER_03Where's the sauce? Uh show me the sauce in my life.

SPEAKER_05Right. Well, let's let's start by talking about the experience of meaning in life, right? Because there's first of all a subjective thing that we experience our lives as more or less meaningful, and then we can talk about uh, but are our lives really meaningful regardless of what we experience? But let's start with the experience. So this is the kind of thing that I think psychology is well placed to investigate in. Psychologists have, and there seems to be three different components going on when we experience our lives as having or lacking meaning. So the first component is purpose. So purpose is about life being centered around an aim that we can endorse.

SPEAKER_05And if you feel purpose in your life, what you feel is you feel enthusiastic about your life, you feel motivated, you have future-oriented goals that you feel motivated towards. And if you're lacking purpose in your life, then you feel demotivated, you feel bored, or you feel depressed. So that's one aspect. But beyond purpose, we also have mattering. So it's not just enough that we have a purpose, we want our purpose to matter. And mattering is feeling like you're contributing to something that goes beyond yourself, adding value to the world in some way.

SPEAKER_05And when you feel that your life matters, what you feel is fulfillment, pride, and uh self-esteem. You feel high self-esteem. And if you feel like your life doesn't matter, you have feelings of failure or angst in your life. And then the third component that the psychologists talk about is intelligibility. So this is about life having a narrative unity, a desirable pattern, fitting well in a way that makes sense to you, fitting together in a way that makes sense to you. Um so if you have this, you have a sense of comprehension about your life.

SPEAKER_05And if it's lacking, you feel disorientation, you feel kind of lost and disorientated from your life.

SPEAKER_01I can see like that when we talk about meaning that there are going to be different ways we conceptualize it, but isn't it true that if you lack purpose, you're also gonna feel disoriented and you don't know which way you're going? So how can they so clearly distinguish between these three different these three different concepts?

SPEAKER_05Right. If you lack purpose, I mean you could be a happy-go lucky person, right? Who's just living in the moment and doesn't really have a a purpose that drives you. This is the kind of person that would not even consider the question of is my life meaningful? Ah, right. So you could be that kind of person. You may not feel disorientated, you just feel engaged by whatever's happening in the moment. Um, so to feel disorientation, you really have to look to make sense of your life, look to kind of see it in a way that fits all the different parts together that makes it comprehensible to you.

SPEAKER_05So if you're not even doing that, um, you're not going to feel the disorientation.

SPEAKER_01So if, you know, like that that phase that people go through in their early 20s, late teens, where they go on gap year and they're backpacking and they're just happy go lucky, whatever comes next. But that also brings them meaning, or that that's what they feel like their their purpose is. That's not what you mean by purpose.

SPEAKER_05Well, their purpose there might be self-development, right? So maybe they're like, this is a period where I need to explore, develop myself, uh, work out what talents I have, like work out how to be a good friend and how to have long, like, you know, friendships that kind of feel like they're less superficial and matter more in an adult way. Perhaps that's the purpose that people have in mind during that type time of their life. Now, look, they may stop at some point and think, but does it matter, right? I see I have a purpose, but wait a minute, it's all focused on myself. You know, is it really matter that I like, you know, and and that that could be a kind of mini crisis of meaning where they then move on to something else that they think is more of a social contribution because they want to find the mattering?

SPEAKER_05I think at different stages in your life, actually, different components here may be more or less salient or important.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I was gonna ask, how how do these component components come together? Do you if you have a lot of one, for example, you have a lot of purpose, but you know, uh the other two are well, you still don't know what you're doing, or you still don't really have an experience of the other two. Um is that sufficient for having a meaningful life, or do you need some kind of balance between the three?

SPEAKER_05Right. We want to be careful here because there's is it enough to make you feel your life is meaningful? Yeah, and then there's the question of, but wait a minute, is your life really meaningful? So so far we're just talking about people experiencing their life as meaningful, which is a psychological question. So as I understand the psychology, but look, I'm not an expert on this literature. All of them matter. So if you're really low in one of them, then that can lead to feelings of my life is lacking in meaning.

SPEAKER_03Uh speaking of which, you you did you just make a distinction between the experience of meaning uh versus the kind of uh objective meaning in a life. So can a person feel like their life is really meaningful, but from an objective on an objective perspective, they don't have a very meaningful life, or vice versa. Somebody feeling like their life is meaningless, but if you step back and you look at their lives from kind of some kind of third person perspective, they have a really meaningful life. Can these come apart?

SPEAKER_05Yeah, they definitely come apart. So this is where we move from psychology to philosophy, right? Because uh we have to ask, uh, well, what is it really to live a meaningful life? And um, I think it's clear in the way people just think about their lives, these things come apart. Because people will wonder, they'll say, Well, my life feels meaningful, but like, is life really meaningful? Am I missing something? Maybe there's no meaning to life. They'll have these kinds of thoughts. So by having those thoughts, they already open themselves up to the idea that you know their experience of meaning might not actually track the meaning that's there.

SPEAKER_05Uh, and people also have epiphanies, so they have situations where they experienced a period of their life as not very meaningful, but then a decade later they look back and they realize they missed something and there was some aspect of that part of their life where they felt like it, they feel now like it actually was meaningful, and their experience at the time didn't represent what was really going on in their life, or vice versa, experience their life as meaningful. Then later on, they think I had the wrong values then. That was actually not a very meaningful time of my life. Um, so certainly there's something that goes on, and this this is not about objective or subjective.

SPEAKER_05So a philosopher might be a subjectivist about meaning in life. They may think that to have a meaningful life, you merely have to have a certain subjective state in relation to your life, but that will still come apart from the experience of meaning in life, right? Um, because I could experience my life wrongly as meaningful because I don't realize I wrongly think I have the subjective state and I don't have it, for example.

SPEAKER_01Um so I do have a question, and to be fair, it's because I read some of your work before you came. And I wanted to ask you, is there a difference between what the ordinary person might think of as well-being, like having well-being in life versus having a meaningful or meaning in life?

SPEAKER_05Yes. So the the literature, the philosophical literature on meaning in life, a key starting point of it is that this is a different kind of value we can have in our lives separate from well-being, our life going well for us. And so a common way this thought might be motivated is to just imagine a life that is a very meaningful life where a person, you know, does a lot of important things, makes a big contribution, but maybe not the best life for the person living it. Maybe it's a life that has suffering and betrayal and tragedy. There's sacrifice there that's very painful and difficult.

SPEAKER_05And so from a well-being perspective, you'd say that's not a great life. Maybe it's an average life or even a good life, but it's not an outstanding life. But from a meaning perspective, it may be a very highly meaningful life for a human to live where they sacrifice a lot to, you know, bring about great goods for others. Um, so that's the kind of case that helps to separate the concept of meaning from the concept of well-being.

SPEAKER_01Can I push on that for a second? So, what we're saying is if we look at a superhero, for example, you know, someone who sacrifices a lot for the good of others and doesn't really get a lot back for themselves, they have a very meaningful life. They've done a lot of good for the planet or the earth or their community, but they aren't, they don't have well-being. What do you mean by they don't have well-being? Are they unhappy?

SPEAKER_05Well, their well-being might be low or average, it might not be particularly high. So why? Well, it could be various things, right? It may just be that, you know, there's a lot of pain they have to deal with and and not that much pleasure, not enough pleasures to make up for the pain. But it may be that by making these sacrifices, they miss out on a lot of objective goods, right? Like if you're an objectivist about well-being, then you might think, well, they're missing out on a lot of important objective goods. Like they had to sacrifice their chance to develop their understanding of things or pursue certain relationships by Spider-Man, you know, who lost Mary Jane.

SPEAKER_01So I just really wanted to get that in there.

SPEAKER_03Was it Gwen Stacy?

SPEAKER_01Are we talking about DC or are we talking about Marvel?

SPEAKER_03Gwen Stacy and and Mary Jane are both in Marvel.

SPEAKER_01Oh, I th I was just thinking about MJ because I'm Gen Z.

SPEAKER_00I was like, who's Gwen Stacy?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, this was the bit before in the uh the the one with uh Andrew, what's his face? Anyway, moving.

SPEAKER_01Andrew Garfield.

SPEAKER_03Andrew Garfield.

SPEAKER_01Oh, I thought I thought it was just all MJ. Uh I'm so sorry. But do you think though that like if what you want from life is to be a hero and to sacrifice a lot for others, then you would also have well-being because you're achieving exactly what you wanted from life.

SPEAKER_05Right. So on some theories of well-being, they would count that life as high in well-being. And so this led me in one of my papers to ask what really is the difference? If you grant any kind of theory of well-being that might kind of seem to overlap with stuff people say about meaning in life, can we really make a difference? And that led me to a particular view about what pulls them apart. I said, we can imagine someone with a theory of well-being that focuses on all the same goods that you might put on your list of what adds meaning to life.

SPEAKER_05And I said, even if you had that identity there, I think there's a way in which they're still going to come apart. And that has to do with contrasting the well-rounded life with the specialized, lopsided, highly focused life. You know, imagine two lives, and these lives have the same total amount of good, these goods in them. Like you've got this long list of goods, right? And now one of those lives has this amount of good by focusing mainly on one good, achieving so much. Maybe the person's focusing on being a moral leader in their community.

SPEAKER_05And to do that and produce all that moral good that way, they have to give up on like pursuing relationships as much as they could, or getting understanding and knowledge of like the world they live in, or um looking after their you know selves physically and whatever, all the all the other goods you might pursue in life. And now compare that with a life, a well-randed life of moderate achievement in all the goods. So you have a moderate level of every single good. Uh, and ask which would be the better life to live. Um, and many people would say the well-rounded life, right? I'd rather live that life with a moderate amount of each good.

SPEAKER_05Uh, and some people take this further. They would say, you know what, like the well-randed life, it's an important value. I'd be happy to sacrifice some total quantity of good to be more well-rounded. So maybe I'd prefer the well-rounded life over the narrowly focused life that has slightly more good than the well-rounded life. Um, so many people would say that about uh well-being. And it makes a lot of sense about well-being that there's something attractive about living a well-rounded life. To ignore some of the prudential goods and only focus on others of them, maybe you're missing something Kasar's well-being has to offer.

SPEAKER_05So that makes sense in well-being, but I think that doesn't make sense in meaning. So when it comes to living a meaningful life, it seems like it's just about producing as much good in the world as possible. And if you can produce more good by living a very narrowly focused life, then that could be a more meaningful life. And one way to see this is to think about paradigm cases of highly meaningful lives. So if you ask people to name what they think are some of the most meaningful human lives that have been lived, they will name uh, you know, moral leaders like Gandhi, or great humanitarians like Mother Teresa, or great scientists like Einstein, great artists like Frida Kahlo, uh, maybe philosophers like Confucius.

SPEAKER_05They'll name these kinds of people. Now, if you think about these people, they're not noted for living well-rounded lives. In fact, they did the opposite. They lived narrowly focused lives. In fact, what they did was they saw a contribution they could make, and they purposely narrowly focused and sacrificed other goods they could have pursued to narrowly focus on this kind of mission or excellence or good they could pursue, because they knew they could achieve so much or do so much through that. Um, so yeah, arguably, or at least in my theory, that's the key difference maker that marks out meaning from well-being. It's about the aggregation and uh how the goods in our life should be counted when it comes to deciding what has value.

SPEAKER_03This really is a superhero issue, right? Like, like, you know, uh where we love reading stories about superheroes and we we they aesthetically they're amazing. That they're the stories we like to see, um, where they dedicate their lives to saving uh lots of people and doing good. But you ask somebody, do you really want to be a superhero who has like to sacrifice their family and and friends and to have no hobbies and have to spend all day saving lives? I think most people would say, no, actually, I'd rather be a you know be like an average hero. You know, I want to do some good things, but I want to have a happily happy family life, I want to have hobbies.

SPEAKER_05Right. And so you can think of that decision as do I want to live a more meaningful life that goes less well for me, that is less good for the person living it, that would be the superhero life, or do I want to live a life that goes uh better for me, but maybe and has good meaning, but doesn't have as much meaning as the superhero life.

SPEAKER_01Do you think though that the gap between well-being and meaning can be met by the principle of autonomy? And so if, you know, for most people I would say would probably prefer a well-rounded life. Most of us aren't cut out to be heroes. And for those that are forced into positions of being a hero, whether that be they're forced into being an advocate for change, maybe they you're right, maybe they don't have a lot of well-being. Like they've had to sacrifice so much and they didn't choose to be there. But some people do choose, like Derek Parfitt chose to be a philosopher. And you know, he I love your description of him in your paper towards the end where he just like, what is it?

SPEAKER_01He stops wearing pants. He just gets so focused on maximizing his time into philosophy that he just goes down there. But he chose that. And do you think that if when you when you realize that some people are choosing to maximize their meaning, that that also means that that bridges that gap. Their life is exactly how they want it to be, and therefore they would also, it would be a well-lived life for them.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, I I think so. So so the way I think of this are there's two sources of value here, right, that tug us in different directions. And I don't think there's some answer where it says, like, well, you should always favor the meaning over the well-being, otherwise you're selfish or favor the well-being over the meaning, otherwise you're being irrational. I think it's kind of a decision we have to make of what kind of life do you want to live? Which of these competing values do we want to prioritize in choosing the life? By the way, I just push back against, well, not push back, but I'd I'd caution against one thing.

SPEAKER_05Like, so when we talk about superheroes and Derek Puffett, sometimes people think, sometimes people think like this is only a choice for people of great talent who can do great things. But I think this is a choice that, you know, an average ordinary person also faces, right? Because, you know, you can decide, well, I'm half good at this. I'm could be average level good at this thing, or I could not be. Do I want to put the effort in and focus on that thing I could be average good at? Or do I want to try to like be a little bit good at a bunch of different things or put effort into a bunch of different things? So that's that's on a more like average person's level choice between do I want to do the more meaningful thing or or more focus on the well-roundedness that will give me greater well-being?

SPEAKER_03Well, we had Peter Singer here we uh a few months ago on our podcast, and he has famously advocated for people to uh put as much as they can into finding a very high-earning job so that they can uh donate lots of money to charity and doing as much good as they can, maybe at the expense of their other life projects. Right, exactly.

SPEAKER_01Are you worried that what you're talking about when you say meaning and by maximizing one particular good to its absolute best, are you worried that what maybe people might interpret is just being successful, achieving one thing which is really just one good if you accept value pluralism? Because it it it kind of sounds like, yeah, like Derek Parfitt was amazing at philosophy, but also that's just one achievement. Um, and it's just you are you worried that you're you're you're putting out the idea that mean a meaningful life is just the most successful one.

SPEAKER_05Uh well, let's let's be careful here, right? So there's status, right? And we want to we wanna clear away status from this. So we shouldn't be pursuing status. Uh if you're if you're it's about status and you want to earn status, you want to be seen as important and prestigious, that's a bad motive. And that may not go along at all with actually making a difference. So it's about wanting to Make the difference, biggest impact, like produce as much good as you can. Whether that's recognized or not is kind of a separate thing. So I guess on a personal level, you might think, well, I want to be as successful as I can personally by doing as much as I can.

SPEAKER_05Um, so I don't think that's problematic, right? That's a good thing. Like if there's goods that you can have in your life and you can work hard and produce those goods and have them there, isn't that a good thing to do? As long as we clear that that doesn't mean chasing status.

SPEAKER_01Because I think there's a worry where if, you know, let's just say that um James is really good at philosophy, so he puts everything else, you know, um his Lego, his jazz, all of that on hold.

SPEAKER_03I feel like I know where the jazz one comes from, but what is the Lego?

SPEAKER_01Oh, I just wanted to make it out like you're a big Lego fiend.

SPEAKER_03Oh, okay.

SPEAKER_01Um anyway.

SPEAKER_03For legal reasons this may or may not be true.

SPEAKER_01Anyway, he puts his improv and his jazz on hold to pursue his the philosophy, and he becomes an ex Eric Parfit. And he's just he's just accomplished a lot. But what about and then because of that we say he had a really meaningful life. But then what about, you know, like those incredible stories of single parents who raise their kid and they see their kid become, you know, that their kid gets a stable job and has a family, and that single parent is like, my life was so meaningful because I got to do this. And do you think it might be unfair to then compare those lives and say one life is more meaningful than it than the other?

SPEAKER_05No, I mean, I think we make these comparisons all the time, uh, right? I think what's a mistake here we need to be wary of is getting caught up in ranking ourselves, right? So there are ranks, but we don't want to get carried away with the ranks. So if you ask people, did Einstein live a more meaningful life than an average scientist that did average scientific work in the early 20th century, the answer is clearly yes. Like, you just can't get past that. Clearly, by what he did, by what how he contributed to human knowledge, his life was more meaningful than the person living an average life.

SPEAKER_05Um so we shouldn't deny that. But what we should be wary of here is this trap where we might be like, well, then only the great important lives matter, and all the other lives are insignificant. Uh actually, what we should aspire to is having the most meaningful life we can, and we should accept who we are and what our limitations are and just want to do the best that we can for ourselves in our own position. And this can come from a uh diversity of sources. So I guess on the list of great meaningful lives, there was no one whose life was simply great in meaning because of their amazing relationships.

SPEAKER_05And I guess that's because relationships have a kind of natural limit of how much good they produce, they can't go beyond that. So that's why that doesn't feature there. But I don't want anyone to wrongly think that means relationships don't matter, right? Relationships are a huge source of meaning for people. Uh, it's just that they have a natural limit of how far they can go in terms of the good they produce. So if you have a life where you have really solid, important relationships and you really love and care for people, uh, and you also help people to be the best they can, and that helps them make a better contribution. That's a great contribution that you have made to the world, and you should find your life very meaningful for doing those things.

SPEAKER_05And you shouldn't fall into the trap of comparing yourselves to people that had more natural talent than you, and therefore were able and use that talent well and were able to live more meaningful lives and think that somehow diminishes what you did with your life.

SPEAKER_03So uh at this point, I think I want to uh ask a question that I know you're gonna find a little bit frustrating, but I think a lot of listeners might be thinking about this, and it's just tell me, okay. Like we've been dancing around the issue, we've been talking about the goods. Okay, tell me what these goods are. Uh what what is it something I need to achieve? Is it some kind of story or narrative uh that I need to create with my life? Um, so give me something that I can work on. Oh, I I have to start by apologizing for disappointing.

SPEAKER_05There's there's uh lots of disagreement, right? Um, so so I'm not gonna say this is the official proper list of what are the final goods that everyone should pursue in their life. Uh, but what we can do is say the kinds of goods that occur again and again uh when philosophers think about and try to work out what are the basic values of life. So you're gonna have, I mean, the things we've already mentioned, relationships, very important. Uh, achievement, right? Having goals that you pursue and then achieve something that's of value. Um, knowledge, understanding the world, uh, being in touch with the beautiful, right?

SPEAKER_05Aesthetic appreciation or being creative and producing beautiful things yourself, moral virtue, right? Being a good person, making a contribution to the world. So these are the kinds of things that uh philosophers list. The point is, whatever you think is on that list, whatever you think are the things that have value that we ought to pursue in our lives, there's these interesting questions about how those things might add to meaning in life or well-being.

SPEAKER_03And do these things have to have a certain pattern in terms of like how they how how we achieve these throughout our lives?

SPEAKER_05Right, yeah. So I I think you're alluding at narrativism, which is an interesting idea. Some people are narrativists about well-being, but it's more commonly proposed in meaning in life. So let's talk about it in that context. So some philosophers say, look, when it comes to your life, and this sorry, this ties in with the intelligibility thing we mentioned earlier about experiencing life as intelligible. So when that plays out in philosophical theories of meaning in life, it often plays out in terms of the life narrative. So some philosophers say the meaning of your life is not just about the values that you instantiate throughout your life in each moment, like I had knowledge here, I had moral virtue here, I had a good relationship here.

SPEAKER_05It's not just adding those things up, it's also about the pattern, about how those things fit together through your whole life. So they say there's certain life narratives or patterns that make sensor attractive, hang together well, and there's others that don't. So let me give you a simple example. It's being used in the well-being literature, but it it really applies well in the meaning in life literature. So imagine a case where a person has a relationship, that relationship fails, and then they go on to have a successful relationship afterwards and find happiness and contentment.

SPEAKER_05And now compared two versions of this, in the first one, the failure has nothing to do with the success that later comes, right? It's like I failed, and then for totally unrelated reasons, I just found a person I better click with, and then we succeeded and had a meaningful like relationship. And in the second one, the failed relationship is instrumental, is fundamentally important for then having a successful relationship. The person is able to learn lessons from the failed relationship, use those lessons, find some kind of redemption through this, and then build an actual relationship that works.

SPEAKER_03A very satisfying character arc.

SPEAKER_05Right. And the idea is that uh that's more meaningful, right? Even though the badness of the not so good relationship and the goodness of the good relationship might be held constant in those two cases, where you actually learn from your mistakes and fit them together nicely, that adds extra meaning to your life to take the bad bits of your life and use them to then contribute to or build the good bits. That's a nice, coherent, intelligible life story. And that adds meaning. That's the idea.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I've also seen that pop up in uh life satisfaction theories of well-being. So um Wayne Sumner has a really interesting theory of well-being as authentic happiness. Um, and in my own work, I've slightly modified it to account for objective goods because I just don't think you can have a theory of well-being that's purely based on how you think about your own life. So basically, he talks about how uh your well-being is not merely just like when you look at it one day and and and and make a decision, oh, do I like my my life or not? He says it's an evaluative concept.

SPEAKER_01Um, and so you have to look at your life as a whole. It's not just one moment, it's not an aggregate of moments. It's does my life like, is it satisfactory as a whole? And so I do, I'm sympathetic to the view that in order to have what you would call meaning, a meaningful life or meaning in life and what I would call well-being, isn't it? There is an evaluative component. You really do have to look at your life as a whole and ask how it all fits together. And that doesn't mean that it all has to fit together. I mean, I bad things happen to good people, and that and I'm sure they would look back on that and go, I wish that didn't happen.

SPEAKER_01No matter how good my life is right now, that should never have happened. But I do agree with you, it's an evaluative concept or you know, a narrative, looking for that narrative in your life.

SPEAKER_05Yeah. You made the point well. I don't have anything to add.

SPEAKER_01We might call it different things, but I I think, yeah, we might be at the core of it. We're talking about some of the same things.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Okay. Uh I want to get to the biomedical ethics question about uh how this relates to the kinds of decisions we might make at the end of our lives. But before we do do that, I just want to ask a quick question about a very closely associated phrase that I think many people think of first before thinking about meaning of life, and that's the meaning of life. Now I know you make a distinction between the two things, so could you tell us a little just a little bit about how you see those terms and how they're related to the same thing?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, what's the point of human existence?

SPEAKER_05So often in the literature they say, look, there's the cosmic question asked at the species level. What if anything could make a human life meaningful? And then they say there's the individual question we can ask. We can just look at your life, my life, any individual life, and say, well, what can add meaning to this life? And they often distinguish those things and say that they're different. But this is an ongoing level of uh an ongoing issue of dispute. Uh and I don't think it's settled as to how the cosmic question fits in with the kind of individual personal question.

SPEAKER_05So let me just quickly give you one take you might have on this that I'm I'm somewhat attracted to. Uh so if you're willing to be an objectivist about value, if you think that there really are these objective values, like metaphysically in the world, this like stuff that's just to be done, like this is just calling out to kind of follow this thing. It's got this strong sense of objectivity. I think that can answer a lot of our cosmic concerns, right? So people sometimes say, well, how can our lives be meaningful if we're just the random product of blind natural selection and you know we weren't created by some God, for example, uh with a purpose and mission in mind, then aren't our lives just purposeless?

SPEAKER_05There's no, there's nothing there about, there's no point to them. Um, and I think if you think there's these subjective values in the world, then even if we came about in this random way, humans, there's value there that metaphysically is calling out for us to pursue it and instantiate in our lives. And if we do that, then that's a purpose. It's a kind of purpose built into the universe.

SPEAKER_01You mean things like knowledge and love?

SPEAKER_05Right. If those are the the objective values. So if you're a subjectivist and you just say, well, it's just all we decide for ourselves, and I think this is a much harder question to say what's the point of our existence if we weren't designed for anything. But I think that can answer that question. And the other the other cosmic concern that people have is they say, look, we'll all die. And then your legacy may live on, but your legacy will eventually die. Um, the memory of you will die. Uh, most of us will be insignificant to humans in a thousand years, but even if you were the greatest ever, eventually humans will die, the universe will dissipate.

SPEAKER_05And what's the point of it all on that level, right? And and maybe some people are nihilists, they say life is meaningless because it's just headed to oblivion. Um, but I I think the objective value stuff can also respond to that to some degree. So the objective value in the universe is kind of timeless. Like if you instantiate this value in your life, that's there, that objectively happened, that mattered. It doesn't depend on human beings thinking it's important, it's valuable. If it's objectively valuable and that's kind of built into the very fabric of the universe, then it's kind of a timeless good that's achieved, that's there even after you die and and no one remembers you.

SPEAKER_05So I think that objectivist views are able to answer to some extent the cosmic concerns about life being meaningless.

SPEAKER_01See, I went the other way. I went the way, well, if nothing matters, then that gives me a little bit of freedom to not take myself so seriously. And if it doesn't matter, then that mistake that I made or that job that I didn't get, it doesn't matter. My life will continue. So that's I went the complete opposite way.

SPEAKER_05Right. And this is of course a whole absurdist tradition.

SPEAKER_01But I also I I the other lesson I got, which I once again went the complete opposite direction, which is if no one will remember me and I'm such a small speck of the universe, that's like a good reminder to be a bit more humble that the universe is not in fact about me, that my life is it might not be meaningful in the broad spectrum of the universe. But that's that just I think that's a good grounding thing that I like to remind myself. Just be a bit more humble. Life is not all about you. I might have one, but it's not all about me.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, I think we need both, right?

SPEAKER_01I think I lost us. How often can I bring that up in a podcast?

SPEAKER_03That's the first time we've done it.

SPEAKER_01I think we'll have to do a TikTok snippet of every cut every time I've said it.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, it won't be the last, I'm sure. I I think it's both. So I think that, you know, humans realizing, hey, we're not the center of the universe, it's not all about us, was a good humility check for us. But on the other hand, I think we don't want to let that go too far so that we we then become uh, you know, nihilists who think like nothing matters and it's all pointless. So we want to both be humble about our small, insignificant role in the universe, and yet realize that there really is objective value there that we can instantiate and produce in our lives, and that matters, and that's important.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, just because like humans might not matter in the broad scheme of the universe doesn't mean we don't matter to each other.

SPEAKER_03I feel like I'm jumping straight from my early 30s into my midlife crisis right now.

SPEAKER_01Oh, honey, go by.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's only gonna get that portion that I cannot afford. Okay. Now let's talk about the bioethics question. And I want to uh start this by giving by laying down an example. So in March last year, we had this famous case of a Nobel-winning economist, Daniel Kahneman, who chose to undergo assisted suicide in Switzerland. Now he had to go to Switzerland because he wasn't suffering from any diagnosable mental illness and did not have any terminal illness either.

SPEAKER_03Uh and reports say that uh, you know, well, he was 90 years old, you know, so so his his he was obviously not in peak condition, but he was still a relatively healthy man for his age. Um but he chose to end his life anyway, uh, seemingly because he just decided that his life was no longer worth living. And uh a quote from a friend, um Philip Tetlock, is is the following, right? Uh he said, I suspect he worked out on a hedonic calculus of when the burdens of life would begin to outweigh the benefits, and he just probably foresaw a very steep decline in his early 90s.

SPEAKER_03So how does I guess your work on the meaning of life um as well as well-being, uh, kind of help us make sense of uh of cases like Daniel's and how people might make their decisions uh uh at this point and whether decisions like this are rational or good to make?

SPEAKER_05Yeah, uh this is really interesting. So I think that end-of-life discussions for understandable reasons often focus narrowly on suffering and pleasure and pain and quality of life in that sense, right? Uh and that's obviously important, but I think that meaning can bring a new perspective to these debates. Uh so on that narrow perspective, you just say, well, what's the quality of life? Like, does the suffering and pain, is it so great that it outweighs the goods in this life, the pleasure, the satisfaction, the relationships the person can engage with?

SPEAKER_05And if the pain outweighs that, then it's like, well, it's it's a reasonable, acceptable decision for a person to end their life in those circumstances if they choose to. But if it doesn't, then uh, you know, they should go on with their life. That's the common way to think of this. And I think what meaning can add here is to bring us a broader perspective beyond this narrow perspective of suffering. And it can go either way, right? So, first of all, you can imagine someone who uh what they have ahead of them, they're quite old, what they have ahead of them is going to be a lot of suffering. And it's not gonna be outweighed by the pleasures that are left in their life.

SPEAKER_05But they may think, you know, I think it would be a cop-out of my life to end it. Now I think it would be more meaningful. Maybe they feel like life's a great gift, and the more meaningful thing to do is to persevere and see out their life to their natural end. So people might be motivated by considerations of meaning to look beyond the suffering and find greater meaning. And it can go the other way as well. So, and this might be what's going on in the Kahneman case, at least cases like his case could be like this. So the other way is you might have people who say, Look, I've reached the end of my life.

SPEAKER_05I've had a life where I've made a positive contribution, I've been very actively engaged in the world, but I've reached a stage where my physical and mental capacities have deteriorated and I can no longer be so active and make such a contribution. Now, my health is not so bad that I'm gonna be in pain and suffering all the time. I could live on for another, say, 10 years and on balance have more pleasure than pain, slightly more pleasure than pain. Uh but I feel like that's kind of a bad end to my life. Like, what's the point of that?

SPEAKER_05I feel like I'd rather my life ended now. Um I feel like it'd be more meaningful for me to say my my time here, my my mission, what I've been doing is over, and now I'm ready to, you know, say goodbye and and and and be done with my life. Um and so that could be motivated by meaning. So it need not be about you need not use the suffering uh ahead of you to justify the decision to end your life. You could simply be concerned with meaning. And this this goes into the narrativism view as well, right? So a narrativist might say, well, you know, 70 years of kind of active engagement in the world, followed by 10 years of kind of passive minimal pleasure, is not such a great end to a life.

SPEAKER_05It's not a very good life narrative. It kind of diminishes what you achieved in your life a little bit to have that 10 years of not much. And and maybe someone will feel like their life would better make sense, better cohere if they chose to end it at that point where uh their faculties deteriorated in that way.

SPEAKER_03And maybe even more than 10 years, because I think a lot of people for a lot of people work is a huge source of meaning in their lives. And I think uh in Singapore the retirement age is somewhere in the low 60s, I believe, where whereas the uh the uh the the expected life, the the life expectancy of a Singaporean is into the well into the 80s, into the the late 80s, I believe. So you have a period of 20, almost 30 years where somebody uh might be uh sitting around and not knowing where their meaning in life is coming from.

SPEAKER_05Yeah, it's interesting. So if you read accounts of how to retire well, right? Like they'll say, like, you know, don't focus on all this material consumption and this kind of stuff. So they'll say, like, you know, do some volunteer work. It's a great thing to do. If you're if you're in able and healthy, do some volunteer work when you require uh retire. Or if you have grandchildren, great, spend time bonding and connecting with your grandchildren. And these can be very meaningful things to do. So I think there's lots of ways for people who retire to continue to find meaning in their life. You can also, you know, take up a creative habit or uh try to appreciate culture and and and art more and stuff like that.

SPEAKER_05Um, but I guess people might reach a point where things deteriorate further and they feel like, you know, they're too frail and struggle to kind of play with their grandchildren, or they're not able to do volunteer work anymore, all those kinds of things. And they might wonder what's the point of living. And I guess what meaning brings is there's more to that question, that calculus, than simply how much pleasure versus pain or subjective goods do I have in my future. There's this further question about, well, how meaningful would it be for my life to say end now versus continue on for another 10 years?

SPEAKER_05Well, let me put to you what I think is is the most difficult case I can see in this respect, right? So imagine someone who uh maybe they're in their early 40s, right? And they feel like they've already passed the peak of their life. Maybe like they were a very successful influencer in their 20s or something, and they feel like it's all gone downhill and there's nowhere left for them. So they decide they want to end their life because they think like I've already passed the peak. I'm not gonna do much more. So better that my life ends now, and at least there was that nice peak of like being a great influencer and and and now I'm done.

SPEAKER_05Uh so are we happy for that person to then make use of very liberal euthanasia laws to end their life because they think like there's not meaning left for them. Um, so it seems to me like they're making a mistake, right? It seems to me like that's a bad decision. Um, and it's a harder case. It's easier when people are at the end of their life anyway, and then maybe they could live on for five years. Maybe they shouldn't, they're gonna make that call themselves. It's harder with someone in this position to say, but we should fully let them do that and just end their life at that point. But what do you guys think?

SPEAKER_01I think it's an empirical question.

SPEAKER_03You're throwing it back to us.

SPEAKER_01No, it's not allowed. I think it's an empirical question to the extent that if you allowed permissive legislation that allowed this to happen and it reduces the instances of unfortunate suicides, which have really drastic impacts on emergency workers, family, friends, and it does reduce that, then I think that is a better form of legislation. If, however, we keep our laws the way they are, and that also reduces uh unfortunate instances of suicide by say allowing um interventions like counseling and psychology to maybe well, I agree, like, you know, a person in the early 40s has much to do and much to live for, and that reduces the unfortunate instances of suicide.

SPEAKER_01Well, then I think that's the better choice. So for me, I come at it from a pragmatic perspective, which is how do we end those horrible cases of unfortunate suicide? And so that that's how I would answer it.

SPEAKER_03But yeah, so I guess there are two questions here, right? Like one is the the question of how do we deal with these kinds of cases. And I think there is a presumption that I think ethicists uh mostly should have against interfering and and being paternalistic. At the same time, uh like it does seem to me that this this is clearly irrational. Like uh a life at least lived healthily can go on for much longer than 40 years, and you can definitely achieve get meaning um after the age of 40.

SPEAKER_03So it it's so there's a question here of like how do we balance the like not wanting to help a person not make a mistake versus the presumption against paternalism.

SPEAKER_01I think that's why it all comes down to how do we reduce unfortunate and early deaths because I agree with you, it's an objective thing. Many people learn to run marathons, do Iron Man's, get PhDs well into their 60s. Uh, some people in their 60s are fitter than I am.

SPEAKER_05And so there is, yeah, I I don't think that's or develop relationships and become a really important person in other people's lives.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, like lots of people might go through a divorce in their early 40s and then find the absolute love of their life in their late 40s, 50s, or 60s, you know, that you have so much to look forward to. So I think the the foot, like just by virtue of someone being 40, it's a bit arbitrary. But that's why I think it comes down to how you regulate it, which can reduce people making uh life-ending mistakes. I don't like being asked questions. Not you get one.

SPEAKER_03I want to be like asking some questions, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Bridges across the table and we're a little fascinating. And yeah, just to avoid you asking any more questions, I think we're done.

SPEAKER_03Okay, thank you very much, Matthew. He's good.

SPEAKER_00We caught him within really chinky water.

SPEAKER_03Well, this is really interesting. Um, hopefully, uh I can I can go to sleep and sleep well tonight.

SPEAKER_01We'll check in tomorrow. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Live updates. Just kidding, I just have insomnia half the time.

SPEAKER_00We'll take you to the top down. Anyway, thanks for listening.

SPEAKER_02Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and you and be savvy.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can Nihilism Improve Your Mental Wellbeing?

    Nov 2, 202645 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Insurance Discrimination: Is it Fair? with Harisan Nasir

    Sep 24, 202649 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Genomic Newborn Screening: Where less really is sometimes more with Ainsley Newson

    Aug 25, 202655 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Hidden Side of Birth: Injury, Trauma, and PTSD with Angela Ballantyne

    Jul 2, 202648 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Brains in Jars with Insoo Hyun

    Jun 1, 202656 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...

    Credit the people on this episode