Religion & Bioethics with Anantharaman Muralidharan
43 minAudio
Send us Fan Mail Should religious views be a part of bioethics debates? Should doctors be able to conscientiously object on religious grounds to abortion or assisted dying? And would excluding religious views be discriminatory or sometimes okay? In Episode #5, Dr. Anantharaman Muralidharan from the Centre for Biomedical Ethics discusses his research on religious bioethics, how we can distinguish religious from moral views, and the gods of philosophy. Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast at C B and Me and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_02Welcome to season two, episode five of CB Me and You. In today's episode, we discuss the role, if any, of religious bioethics. Should practitioners be able to religiously reject providing health treatment? Should religious res uh researchers be able to publish religious views on controversial bioethics topics? Should we even be talking about this on a bioethics podcast? Joining us today is our very own Dr. Anantharaman Murali Daran from CBME. Murali, welcome to the pod.
SPEAKER_02Hey, great to be here.
SPEAKER_01Welcome, O'Reilly. We are very excited to have you on the pod. Our very first question for you copy or copy?
SPEAKER_05Copy.
SPEAKER_01What's your order?
SPEAKER_05Uh copy C. Oh no, actually, just copy.
SPEAKER_01Just copy.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, because I ask for copy C. I'm not going to add sugar to it anyway. Might as well just get copy.
SPEAKER_01Is do you have a particular place that you get it from that's your favorite?
SPEAKER_05No, I just get it from the science case.
SPEAKER_01Oh that's not even copy, that's copy C.
SPEAKER_05That's copy C. That's true. That's true. So I'm not generally a coffee drinker as such, but I drink coffee for or copy for necessity. And sometimes it's whatever's available, but um the one that science canteen is it's nice, but we add enough sugar.
SPEAKER_01And how do you feel about the current um price increase from 90 cents to a dollar?
SPEAKER_02It was a controversial.
SPEAKER_01It was. There were there were protests.
SPEAKER_02Um rides in the streets almost.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Were you among the writers? No. I mean, I was like inflation, yeah, man, move on.
SPEAKER_01He signed an NDA.
SPEAKER_02Not in this economy.
SPEAKER_01Our next question for you. Which country would you like to travel to next?
SPEAKER_05Okay, so I've got a clarificatory part about that. Are you asking? Are you asking, okay, which country um does this include countries I'm already planning to go to and whether I'm looking forward to them? Then the or are you talking about apart from the countries that I'm already planning to go to, um, what do I want to visit next?
SPEAKER_01So we're gonna skip this question. You lost question privileges. It just means that if you could take a pick as to which country you would go to next, that's the country you would go to.
SPEAKER_05Oh, um, actually I miss England a lot. Uh I mean not England as such, UK. Um, I like to go to Wales.
SPEAKER_01Ah, interesting. A particular part of Wales?
SPEAKER_05Um, usually the north country in Wales. Um, because it's the flowers are nicer and um there's more nice castle ruins, and it's a very wonderful drive. Um if you're and going driving from England to Wales, you can tell when you entered Wales. Um reason, not because everything starts with has the multiple L's and Ys, um, those there's that.
SPEAKER_01The increased signage of it against England just in general.
SPEAKER_05Um, but it's just a sheer, it's like the foliage is entirely different. So it's like when okay, say it's March now, right? Um mid-March already. So um leaves are out, right? Um you're dri you're driving and it's green, green, green. And then the first burst of colour, you say you're in wheels.
SPEAKER_01You know, that was surprisingly sweet.
SPEAKER_02Surprisingly detailed, very poetic. Yeah. Well, nobody has justified their their answer to this question as much as you have. Well done.
SPEAKER_01Uh, you know, given his research is in the public justification.
SPEAKER_02Um, on brand. We should have seen this coming.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we should have. Okay.
SPEAKER_02I I hope you're all buckled in, ladies and gentlemen, and all listeners. We're gonna take you for a long drive.
SPEAKER_01Next question. I know it's your favorite. What is your favorite karaoke song?
SPEAKER_05Maybe I I'm a maybe I'm amazed by Paul McCartney.
SPEAKER_01Can you just give us like a little snippet?
SPEAKER_04Maybe I'm amazed at the way you love me all the time. Maybe I'm amazed at the way I love you.
SPEAKER_01I think I know two Paul McCartney songs. One is the Kanye West Rihanna song. And one is the drum solo from is it the gorilla movie?
SPEAKER_02You said you know two Paul McCartney songs. I still haven't heard two Paul McCartney songs.
SPEAKER_01I'm feeling attacked. Excellent. We look forward to doing that with you at your birthday, karaoke.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Alrighty. Are you ready for some serious questions now? Yeah, sure, sure, sure, sure. Alright, so in this episode, we want to deal with the topic of uh religious bioethics. And I think it's not exactly clear just from the sound of it what what the scope of this discussion is. I think roughly what we want to get at is the idea of people uh using religious arguments or using real using religious concepts uh in their bioethical practice and uh how, why, or whether they should be uh doing that.
SPEAKER_02Is is that roughly correct, Murali?
SPEAKER_05Um there is that, um, and that's part certainly part of it, but it also involves a lot of personal decisions as well. Okay, um, I mean, cards on the table, um, I myself am religious as well. I'm a Hindu, um, I'm practicing Hindu, but um there so and often sometimes, for example, some of the decisions I make in my day-to-day life are driven by my religion. Sometimes it's like what I eat, um, that's driven by my religious beliefs, right? Um and I'm not saying that people can't do that when it comes to their medical decisions, right?
SPEAKER_05So um sometimes um like if you're if a Jehovah's Witness once um feels that due to their religion, um, they cannot accept blood transfusions, um, that's perfectly fine, right? I think that's a deeply I might, because of my different religious beliefs, I think that's a deeply um regrettable decision, right? Um, but my principle that we shouldn't for um impose our religious beliefs on others or our moral or moral beliefs on people who reasonably disagree, um that principle means that, well, we cannot force a Jehovah's Witness to accept the blood transfusion.
SPEAKER_02But how do we define religious bio with bioethics? Are we just talking about, for example, any doctor who happens to have a religion? Um, or are you referring to something a bit more specific than that?
SPEAKER_05Um It's so, I mean, how I define it is um any bioethical bioethical claim which is grounded in uh religious doctrine. So, for example, and this and so sometimes it's not like any specific position, but sometimes it's also involves the particular way in which you reach the position, right? So, for example, if you're um uh against um euthanasia, for instance, or it's a dying for religious reasons, because um your religion says that you know um all life is precious, no matter how much suffering it is, and therefore it's a sin to um forcibly take a life or deliberately take a life, uh that's a religious bioeth position that um euthanasia is wrong and you've got it for a particular religious reason.
SPEAKER_02Right. What about um cases where you have religious beliefs that just converge with a lot of um non-religious views? For example, a lot of religions believe you should help people in need. Do those count as do do those kinds of positions count as religious bioethical positions?
SPEAKER_05So as I was saying, right? It's not just it's not the position itself, right? Because um lots of just as there are people who um and you know are against euthanasia for religious reasons, there are people who are against euthanasia for non-religious reasons, right? Um and this holds true for not just euthanasia for almost just about every other um bioethical position. I'm not sure there's any one bioethical position that only um that's only endorsed by people of a particular religion, right?
SPEAKER_05Usually there's some other um non-religious um moral viewpoint that is at least notionally can support that view. Or there are for the matter, like even um explicitly religious religious organizations try to offer some kind of non-religious rationale for the particular view. So it's a matter, it's a combination of both a position and the particular way in which it's reached, right? So for example, someone who had endorses a particular religious bioethical viewpoint and is in just insofar as they arrived at that position and they maintained that position for religious reasons.
SPEAKER_02So do you need both for for it to count as uh for our purposes? Yeah. Do you need both? You need to have both uh a religious starting point, a religious reasoning, I guess. Yeah. And you need to have a conclusion that that you know, without that religion, you wouldn't pro you probably wouldn't get to that same conclusion.
SPEAKER_05Um it doesn't have to be the case that uh without the religion you wouldn't get to the same conclusion because of the convergence between views. So I'm willing to count someone who um says, well, we should help the poor in this case because, well, it's my rel my it's part of my religious tendency to help the poor, then and you might think that that's throwing a very wide net, right? And part of this is, granted, it is throwing a wide net, but um there is a phenomenon that is not just a matter of substantive positions and the particular ways in which it reached there, that is unique to at least really people who explicitly espouse religious points of views in bioethics.
SPEAKER_05And that's where certain interesting things come in, right? And it's basically um it goes into the kind of dialectic that uh religious bioethicists use the kind of dialectic that goes on when religious bioethics um try to um say stuff, um, that's very different from how, say, a utilitarian or someone else will try to uh make that point. Um and we can see this difference um in the kinds of arguments um they make and in the kinds of arguments they at least signal that they're prepared to offer or the kind of moves that they're prepared to offer.
SPEAKER_05Okay, so for example, a utilitarian, right? Um he will say, okay, utilitarianism requires this, and then he says, well, suppose you're not a utilitarian, he will try to come, okay, here are good reasons why you should be a utilitarian. Well, either those arguments work, or if they don't, he'll try to offer different ones, and maybe you can go back and forth. And in principle, maybe he's he's committed to um either offering different justifications if he wants to maintain his utilitarianism or revising his utilitarianism in some way.
SPEAKER_05Now I'm not saying that religious bioethicists um do something slightly different. They don't say, um, this is my religion. Here are the reasons why, for example, you should follow my religion instead of others. Um this is what it requires. They say, here's my religion, it's a reasonable view, include our voice in it. And therefore you should include our voice um in you know various public policy making or various social policies or decision-making bodies and stuff like that. And that we want our voice heard because ours is a reasonable voice, not my view is in fact right.
SPEAKER_02It sounds to me that this distinction ends up a little fuzzy because it sounds to me like the distinction is basically a matter of of how people communicate their views. Because a religious person could communicate their view in terms of, hey, look, this is my religious view. This is why I think you should agree with my religious view, um, uh adopt my religious view, uh, and here's what uh it would say if you were committed to my religious position. Like they could say that.
SPEAKER_05They could say that, um, but they don't, and for good reason, right? Because when we when things get down to it, there is a difference between, say, very generic philosoph the god of the philosophers, the particular details of any given religious doctrine. For example, right? The god of the philosophers.
SPEAKER_01Who's that?
SPEAKER_05Hypatia.
SPEAKER_01Nice.
SPEAKER_05So for example, that's that's it's one thing to claim that perhaps some kind of omnibenevolent, omnipresent, omnipotent being exists, and maybe is the source, you know, created the world and stuff. And it's another to say so and so was his prophet, or so-and-so was his incarnation, who came down to earth at this particular point in time um and performed such and such miracles, right? So that means that there are particular historical claims that are maybe more or less fantastic, and there are um particular abstract um theological claims, right?
SPEAKER_05And the kind of particular religious doctrines which can actually get you to particular moral uh claims require the kind of historical claims, the kind of historical claims that um particular religious doctrines have. Why? Because you can't just get from abstract claims about God, whether he exists or not, to any kind of moral, any substantive moral position. What you do need is um claims about revelation, claims about God has given people a message, and this is the message, and that is why this is the right thing to do, right?
SPEAKER_05And in order to do that, you need to have these kinds of um specific historical claims. Now, just because a claim is historical doesn't mean it's implausible, but the sheer fact is that we live in a world where there are many religions stretching back thousands of years. So everybody has, or almost every major world religion has so-called all these kinds of testimonial claims, historical claims, testimonial claims about the particular historical events um and particular revelations that conflict with each other.
SPEAKER_05It's just not possible for someone to um say that, well, my to do special plead for their own uh religious doctrine, right? They just can't.
SPEAKER_02But aren't things often a little bit more complicated in terms of the content of religious beliefs? For example, a few weeks ago we had uh Alexa down talking about uh Taoism and how um at least the philosophical side of Taoism has implications for bioethics. Um But of course, there's some overlap between the philosophical Taoism and Taoism as a religion. I guess what I'm saying is that it's not always clear uh when a claim is more religious in character, as you might say, and comes from revelation, and when it's uh a kind of like philosophical claim.
SPEAKER_02Or at least a claim that's based on um the kinds of methods that we're familiar with in philosophy, which is using reason to figure out uh what kinds of claims are uh reasonable and accurate, and using uh you know certain standards of logic.
SPEAKER_05Right. I mean that's fair, right? So that means that it might turn out and uh for example, lots of religions have um bodies of religious disputation, theological argument, and a lot of this theological argument, sometimes just philosophical arguments, right? Um and so that's fair, right? But that's a question I think, and so I'm not saying that's a sharp boundary between religious and non-religious bioethics, but I don't think we need there needs to be a sharp boundary between religious and non-religious bioethics. There are clear-cut cases of religious bioethics, there are clear-cut cases of non-religious bioethics, and there are kind of fuzzy, fuzzy areas in between which are we're not sure which, you can decide, and because they play by different rules, um, you can the maybe in the fuzzy regions you can decide which kind of which set of rules you want to play with.
SPEAKER_05Deciding which, if you want to play by the religious rules, you don't get to have your voice in the public square. And if you uh want to play by the philosophical standards, then by the philosophical rules, then you get to be threatened by the very real chance that people will find very strong arguments against your position and just you know completely rubbish your position. So the that's that's the threat that you have.
SPEAKER_01Can I ask a question? Yeah, which is the whole point of this podcast. Nice. Uh not you. So one of the things you've said is that people can hold religious views and get to an endpoint where they say, for example, God has a no-kill policy, killing is wrong, therefore we shouldn't allow assisted dying.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then you've also said that people could theoretically just drop that first sentence and go, killing is wrong, therefore assisted dying is wrong. So if the outcome is the same, then why does it matter whether or not we identify these as religious or non-religious? Because it would be reasonable for someone to say killing is wrong. We just don't need to ask them about the metaphysical physical nature of where they got that argument from.
SPEAKER_05It does matter, um, at least sometimes, right? There are some arguments. Let me give a case example, right? So Sandel, when he's talking against human um enhancement, um says that we're talking about Michael Sandel. Yes. Yeah, just for the Yes, uh yeah, Michael Sandel. When he's talking about human enhancement, one of the one of his arguments against human enhancement is that, you know, all this talk about dignity and everything else kind of um forgets is that we're and the whole modern outlook that forgets is the gifted, is the so-called giftedness of our faculties, right?
SPEAKER_05And these are gifts to us. The way he puts it, right, um, you know, it sounds deep and wise, but it's very religious. Why? Why? Because if they are gifts, right? The only way you can get from um our abilities being gifts to it being impermissible to tamper with whatever natural the natural lottery of our gifts is if there's something like these are gifts from God, and um it's wrong to play God.
SPEAKER_05Right? You need those two claims. If it's not wrong to play God, right, then the mere fact that they're gifts from God doesn't uh I would like to raise an objection here based on the movie Kung Fu Panda.
SPEAKER_01So I recently re-watched this movie, and there is an excellent quote in there from Master Ugwe Minutes, minutes before Ugwe Ascends by Zit is it John Powell or Han Zimmer?
SPEAKER_02John Powell.
SPEAKER_01John Powell. Um, you know, and he turns into cherry blossom leaves and then disappears into the spirit world. He says something along the lines of what is it? Um do you know the quote I'm talking about, JS?
SPEAKER_02I do not.
SPEAKER_01Oh come on, man. It's like, you know, um, the past is history, the future is mystery, today's uh a gift. That is why it's called the present. No one's making a religious claim there. You can have a gift without a giver.
SPEAKER_06It's a silly bit of wordplay, though.
SPEAKER_01It's beautiful.
SPEAKER_06It's okay. It's a beautiful bit of silly wordplay.
SPEAKER_01Hurt my feelings.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but I think that that speaks uh uh an important point that uh sometimes uh a word can have religion religious connotations or origin. For example, I believe even the word human dignity um uh at least came from um at least Christian theology at first and then became a philosophical term.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um but that doesn't mean they they have to be, right?
SPEAKER_05No, so it doesn't mean they have to be, but um sorry for interrupting. Um so rude.
SPEAKER_01Off podcast ended. Banned. Herma ban.
SPEAKER_05Okay. So it now you're right, it doesn't have to be, but um, sometimes certain arguments hold water when they have those kinds of when you explicitly inv invoke the particular religious meaning, and sometimes the arguments just don't hold water if they don't. Right? If we're talking about gift in its non without a gift giver sense, what's the logical connection between um something being a gift in this um non-gift giver sense and exchanging that and the wrongness of, for example, um exchanging that gift for something else.
SPEAKER_05Okay, imagine you get a birthday present. It's rude and insulting to your gift giver to exchange a birthday present for something else that you'd like to do.
SPEAKER_01I don't think this argument is gonna hold up um if we'd played white elephant at Christmas time. The whole point of the game is that you don't know who your gift is.
SPEAKER_05Okay, that's true. That's true, but that's g but those are the internal rules of that game.
SPEAKER_01Well, see, now we're putting some constraints on it, which means the water is no longer holding in the cup.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01We you know you know what, we've we've delayed by Michael Sandals, and I think I think a a good argument would be the God has no kill policy, and therefore you can't, you know, use you you can't implement euthanasia. But as soon as you start implementing claims like this, they there are also secular ways to get there.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And so what you're saying is that when the only particular outcome of a religious claim is a particular religious outcome, or there is no secular way to get there, then it's not permissible in the public sphere.
SPEAKER_05So I'm not saying there's no secular way to get there because I think that's too weak uh a requirement. I think I'm saying something much stronger. As long as there Is some uh reasonable way in which you couldn't get there, as long as some reasonable moral doctrine. Okay, so whether you're religious or not, right? Whether a particular viewpoint is religious or not, as long as a the conclusion um places some kind of requirement on somebody that um some other reasonable view couldn't get you to, you're not allowed to use that point of view to push that doctrine onto people.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think I see what you're saying now.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it sounds to me like the objection isn't against just against religion then. It's really a really wide objection that applies to a lot of philosophical views, in fact. Yeah. Like for example, uh, you know, a common thing in bioethics is this idea that you know the doing and allowing distinction. Yeah, the causing harm is is not the same as allowing harm.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But uh, but there's some reasonable views that disagree with that, yeah. Therefore, we can't. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05So I mean, whichever view of so I guess you have two reasonable views. One has the doing allowing distinction, one has the one doesn't have the whichever of these views is the more demanding one, we can't use that distinction to So we can't distinguish between murder and manslaughter because some people don't accept the doing allowing distinction. I'm not sure that that that follows.
SPEAKER_01Well, murder is causing the death of another. Manslaughter is allowing the death of another.
SPEAKER_05Not quite, right?
SPEAKER_01Manslaughter accounts for things like criminal negligence. Like if you fail to do something that you were supposed to do and then someone dies, it's manslaughter. You didn't intend to kill them, but based on an action that you did, you allowed someone to die when you shouldn't have.
SPEAKER_02There are active forms of manslaughter too, aren't there? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Are there?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, like you know, like getting really angry and punching somebody really hard and then they fall down and hit their head.
SPEAKER_05But does that mean that there is no we shouldn't allow the So I'm not sure that uh doing allowing distinction is what underlies manslaughter anyway.
SPEAKER_01But still.
SPEAKER_02But intent would also fall under uh the kind of uh net that you're casting here. Because many philosophers do reasonably it seems, disagree that intent makes a difference to the morality of an act.
SPEAKER_01Same same, got that different way.
SPEAKER_05So, but now we have to ask who is in fact imposing something on what. So what's being imposed on who in this case, right?
SPEAKER_01So government is imposing different mandatory sentencing sentencing laws on people who commit those crimes. So perhaps based on a distinction that people cannot reasonably disagree with, or do reasonably disagree with.
SPEAKER_05So based on the decision, on a on the on a on cra on on principles that people reasonably disagree with, the government is um treating people differently, and that seems wrong.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_05I'm gonna bite the bullet.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01Nice. It's so rare that you meet someone that's yep, you know what? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02That is the logical consequence of an argument. I'm okay with that.
SPEAKER_01Okay. So next question then, now that we've established this, uh I'm I'm not, you know what? I think we can just agree to disagree on that point. So, what then is the problem with religious bioethics? So, if a pluralist society, so one such as Singapore or Australia or pretty much most places, accept the rights of people to express their opinions and accepts that we shouldn't force our views on each other, yeah, is then rejecting the role of religious bioethics simply us forcing our view on them?
SPEAKER_05Um, no, it's not, and for two reasons, right? First of all, um it's the question of what table is religious bioethics being excluded from. So it's being excluded from a much more public-facing role, right? So that means that uh religious bioethics shouldn't be in the business of telling people what to do, um, especially when um this is um people who reasonably disagree with that religion, um, especially when the telling is not just, oh, this is a nice suggestion. No. Um, this is going to, for example, the law uh where you have the state, which will coercive make people abide by certain requirements that people with certain religious or uh philosophical views could reasonably disagree with.
SPEAKER_05Like, for example, it allows people for religious reasons um to um say, no, look, uh, my religion allows this, don't force me to do something that my religion is saying is perfectly okay. There's an asymmetry here, right? It's another kind of claim that we're making, right? So are people making a demand on others? That means is someone saying you should do this or you shouldn't do this, or is someone saying, Hey, I'm allowed to do this? And there's an asymmetry between people who say, Hey, I'm allowed to do this.
SPEAKER_05Those people, right, in whatever context can invoke their religious beliefs, right? So long as it's a reasonable religious belief. While those who are um saying, Hey, you should do this, you shouldn't do this, those people well um are not allowed to invoke views that people could reasonably disagree with to get there.
SPEAKER_02It sounds to me that your view is that there's a kind of default stance that we should take uh with respect to all people, and it's kind of the stance of non-interference, right? Uh you don't tell people what to do unless you there's a a reason that everybody, every reasonable person can agree with, uh, and then we'll tell somebody what to do.
SPEAKER_05Is that I mean, pretty much, right? Because we're all moral equals here, right? We're all persons, we all have the at least a very minimal capacity to think about what's right and wrong. Uh we all have the capacity to at least, you know, um, with maybe sufficient help, and we work it out maybe on a piece of paper or something, figure it figure out uh what we ought to do. And if that's the case, I don't get um, unless you know I've got superior evidence to you, or you've clearly made a mistake in your reasoning to tell you what to do, right?
SPEAKER_05Because if you've made a mistake in your reasoning, then all that means is that I'm just um helping you see see here, you made a mistake in your reasoning. If you had didn't make that mistake in your reasoning, you would agree with me and you would decide and you would see that you you have to do what you ought to do what I'm telling you to do anyway, right? In those kinds of cases, I'm just helping you do what by your own lights, by your own reasons, right? You ought to do anyway, right? Um, and this basic moral equality between people, right? That no one is a person's default um natural master, no one is someone else's natural slave, right?
SPEAKER_05No one get like as long as we're talking about um, you know, competent adults here, we're all moral equals.
SPEAKER_01So should doctors then be allowed to reject providing legal and justified services such as abortion and assisted dying on religious grounds?
SPEAKER_05Um so, yes, my view does um allow for a wider range of conscientious objection. That said, things get a bit complicated here. It's partly because there's a kind of uh there's a kind of public trust that's involved in being a doctor, right? In virtue in virtue of setting up your practice or of being a practicing physician, yeah, right. Um there are certain things that at least implicitly you're claiming to uh um you're certain kind of services you're claiming to offer.
SPEAKER_05Right? Now, we can't take this too far to completely um say that, well, that means doctors have no ability to um conscientiously object. But we have to be very careful and look at the particular social circumstances to any particular service is part of the contract, right? For example, if you're an OBGYN, right, it's gonna be a lot harder for you to say, well, no, I can't pre I shouldn't, I can't perform abortions, at least um where especially those which are which appear more medically necessary, um, and especially when you're part of uh you're not explicitly part of a very religious um practice.
SPEAKER_05I think things matter if you're, for example, part of like an explicitly religious um hospital. I doubt anybody expects a Catholic hospital, for example, to to provide abortions. People don't expect a Catholic hospital to provide abortions.
SPEAKER_01Well it depends if it's publicly funded, then yeah.
SPEAKER_05Well, so okay, so that's a different, right? So that means if it's publicly funded, then um again things change, right?
SPEAKER_01Because and if it's the only one in the area, if it's gonna make the person extremely difficult to access an abortion at all. A these things as well that you consider.
SPEAKER_05Does that does it matter whether so some of these things are again, things get hard because these questions get hard because um if you're the only hospital in the area, are you allowed to then say you're not providing certain services? Sometimes that occurs for certain private hospitals and emergency services, right? You know, like for example, um some some private hospitals, their emergency services are just in name only.
SPEAKER_01I wouldn't go to them for emergency for you wouldn't go to them, or there's actually no emergency room, it just says emergency. And if you go in there, there's just like a wall. That's what I'm imagining.
SPEAKER_02There is one doctor who may or may not distribute your organs to five other needy people.
SPEAKER_01I'm so happy that you got to bring that up into this podcast, Dave.
SPEAKER_05No, but I mean it's like, look, you may not you may not get the full you may not have the full sit the full suite of services that um, for example, a full-fledged emergency department in, for example, SGH or NUH would have. Even though they as they have emergency on their thing, no public ambulance would actually take their take any patients to those hospitals. And they shouldn't, because they are not prepared to take on emergency cases.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and I I don't I didn't know that the these hospitals existed, but they do. Um thank you for lighting.
SPEAKER_01So what you're saying is if a hospital is already going to deny services for some reasons, yeah, then religious reasons are acceptable as well.
SPEAKER_05Yes.
SPEAKER_01And there's no distinction there on the on the grounds that it's reasonable to disagree with those, so they shouldn't be using those reasons.
SPEAKER_05Um so it's not a m matter of whether they should be using we shouldn't be using those reasons because people reasonably disagree about that, we shouldn't be uh using the our reasons, because again, our reasons are also reasons that people can reasonably disagree with, right? To make demands on them. So it goes both ways, right? It's not that, oh, religion is unique in this particular way, right? Um I'm saying that look, um my particular permissive view is also a view that people can reasonably disagree with.
SPEAKER_05The only thing that we can require of each other is something that we all reasonably agree is required.
SPEAKER_02Okay. This is interesting because uh in certain circumstances, for example, in the case where uh you have a hospital in an area and they're the only ones who are capable of providing us a certain kind of treatment, uh, to not provide those that treatment for certain reasons would uh in a way be an imposition on people. Right? If I go up to a hospital asking for uh specific kind of treatment. For shingles. For shingles, you know, and maybe the the the the doctor is religious and believes that or yeah, sure, the hospital is religious and believes that you know shingles is is is something that that God intends for you to deal with it on your own experience.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, to deal with on your own. Um by refusing to treat me, they're they're putting an imposition on me.
SPEAKER_05So again, this is balanced by the kind of the reasonableness of what the reasonableness of the view. Not everything, you don't get to call a view reasonable just because someone um claims it under the name under under the name of religion. There are certain kind of epistemic standards that um it must abide by.
SPEAKER_01So not all religious reasons are equal.
unknownNo.
SPEAKER_01How do you get to pick which ones are?
SPEAKER_05I mean, that's something that we have to kind of work through and see. For instance, right? Um, not in the moral realm, but think about something like young earth creationism. Um it's the view that the world is roughly about 4,000 or 6,000 years old and scientific evidence to the contrary. That's a I think that's just an unreasonable view because the best scientific evidence. Um it's more probable that the scientific evidence is um, as the scientific evidence reliably tells us, the world is the earth is um billions of years old, then it's likely that you know the whole thing is a hoax or that we're all being deceived by some kind of evil demon.
SPEAKER_02And there's some people out there who will challenge this and say, well, all religions are unreasonable, you know. So there's some people who believe that uh religion is unreasonable because they think that, well, there's no evidence for God, therefore all religion is unreasonable. So um how would you I guess say that religion is there, there's religion in itself that's reasonable, and then there's some specific views within religion that just fails this reasonable test.
SPEAKER_05Um I mean this this is this is a hard question.
SPEAKER_02Um in part because we're not here to take it easy on you, really.
SPEAKER_05Uh you know, in part because um this depends on uh these questions about what the right epistemic standards are, um what um what arguments or evidence there is for certain religious views, and um it also depends partly on what evidence someone has been exposed to, right? If someone has been exposed to a lot of testimonial evidence that in favor of their own religious view, knows off other testimonial evidence for contrary views but hasn't really been exposed to them, even though they're in a very different evidential situation than from someone who's um exposed to maybe know very little testimonial evidence about religion or testimonial evidence about a different religious uh belief.
SPEAKER_05These things matter. And the same applies for things like um arguments for the existence of God, um, and depending on how you define God, depending on how um uh on the particular details of the argument, um, some of these arguments are more plausible, some of these are not. For example, right, I you might say, well, you might think like for example, if you're a kind of Spinozist kind of pantheist, you might think that yes, um every God exists um because maybe, and you might say trivially because everything is God. And some people might say, why call that God?
SPEAKER_05Sure, there are many religious traditions where that kind of view, God just doesn't count as that kind of view, right? But there are also plenty of religious traditions where that's exactly explicitly part of the religious doctrine that um when people are talking about God, they all they really are talking about um just everything that exists.
SPEAKER_02It seems to me that um there's a bit of cultural relativity in built into this epistemic standard then, because uh to me I was raised Catholic, so to me believing that there is a God seems like a religious view. Uh seems like a No, it's a religious view. Uh seems like a reasonable view for somebody to have. But if somebody said uh but if something like believing in in Thor or Zeus, well that's a you know that's a bit silly. But I have to admit that, you know, if we grew up in a culture where belief in Thor or Zeus was was more common, um, and more people sincerely had religious revelations where they they believe that they talk to Thor, uh I'd have to admit that maybe it's re reasonable to admit that.
SPEAKER_05Um it's not so much cultural, it's not so much cultural relativist as it's just a basic evidentialist view, right? Um in a in a society where people claim to have religious revelations about Thor, that's just a matter of you're now receiving a lot more testimonial evidence in that society um about Thor than you are about Jesus and Mary, right? While in a society where people more people are raised, um Roman Catholic and um claim to have uh religious revelations about um Jesus and Mary. Well, um Jesus and Mary, well, you have people that you have different evidence about Jesus and Mary than you would have in a society where you have Thor.
SPEAKER_05So insofar as you must proportion your belief to your evidence, um, when you have different evidence, you have different different beliefs become reasonable.
SPEAKER_01We have time for one last question. And I think it has all been leading to this moment. And I'm so excited for your answer. When, if any, is religious bioethics allowed a seat at the policy table?
SPEAKER_05So my view here is going to be um twofold. When religious bioethics is making claims that are, let's call them biorestrictionist, and that means they want to restrict what people can or cannot do, right? It's not allowed on the table. And in this way, religious bioethics is not no different from non-religious bioethics. Okay?
SPEAKER_01It's like restricting people's access to healthcare.
SPEAKER_05Yes. Or like restricting what people can do, what people are not allowed to are allowed or not allowed to do, right? When religious bioethics um doesn't do that, it's not at the policy-seeking table either. Because imagine a case, right? Imagine a case where um you have a very liberal or permissive religious view, there are people discussing, is this right or wrong? And I think one thing that comes up often, right? So it's not that it's not allowed at the table. There's no motivation for people with religious permissive religious views to bring their views to the table.
SPEAKER_05Why? Because when something is allowed by common morality, right? That's the same morality that, you know, or at least the kind of principles that everybody does accept, I there's no particular need to bring a particular religious view to the table.
SPEAKER_01So it's a religion a religion says you should drink water, and because everyone believes that, then there is no need for it to be at the policy table because there is no policy about it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. What about uh the kind of model that I know that policy making in Singapore sometimes uh uses or sometimes claims to use this? I don't know how it what happens in the room where it happens. It's kind of like a consensus-building kind of project. You get a bunch of people, religious people, at the table to discuss an issue with the with the aim of trying to uh get a bit of a cons consensus uh going out of that. So there's there's religion, but also you try to use that opportunity to iron out this agreement.
SPEAKER_05I mean you might think that that works, but you might think that that would abide by my public justification requirement, but it doesn't. It actually gets the opposite thing. What happens is that um each individual religion has its own specific restriction and own specific um issue with the more permissive position. And so they each decide to imp like add in their requirements. So instead of having like at least the least restrictive requirement that everybody can agree on, or at least not all the time, but at least what you often get is what is uh what everybody can cram in their particular uh restriction on what people can do.
SPEAKER_05In a society where the least restrictive position is say A, like for example, again, assistance, medical assistance in dying. The consent, you know, consensual, do it only when it's consensual is the least restrictive, reasonable position. Then let's say four of the five major religions in society in the society um think that that's wrong, that it should be forbidden. Maybe one or or maybe the secular guys who think that it's perfectly okay, right, are are left without a voice or are left having to compromise with the religious people, meet them halfway.
SPEAKER_05But even meeting them halfway is some kind of imposition. So either you're required to compromise, and that is still some imposition on people who reasonably disagree, because if the least restrictive reasonable position is a reason, in fact, a reasonable position, compromising from that means being more restricted than the least restrictive position. So when governments try to say, okay, um, we'll bring you to the table, and you kind of like hammer it out and compromise between yourselves, you're still imposing something on people who reasonably disagree.
SPEAKER_02It sounds like that's all the time we have. So thank you for joining us.
SPEAKER_05Thank you. Nice to be here.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to C BME and you and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...