Send us Fan Mail What is Daoism? What is to be in harmony with Dao? Is it just to roll with the punches or go with the flow? How can doctors use Daoism to better help their patients live with chronic illnesses? Is Daoism just jazz or does James just love scatting? Dr. Alexa Nord-Bronzyk from the Centre for Biomedical Ethics at NUS talks about her research on ancient Chinese philosophy and its relationship with bioethics. Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, C B and Me and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_03Welcome back to C B Me and You, a podcast about biomedical ethics. What? I'm sorry.
unknownWhat?
SPEAKER_01Do you want me to do that again? No, no, no. Please continue, my bad.
SPEAKER_03Today we discuss the philosophy of Taoism and its implications for medicine and the doctor-patient relationship. What key lessons can we learn from Taoism? How is his ancient philosophy relevant to us today? And what's all this stuff about butterflies anyway?
SPEAKER_01And what accent is James really doing? Joining us.
SPEAKER_03It's like old timey, timey radio guy. Joining us is for this is our very own Dr. Alexa Nordbronzik, research fellow at the NUS Center for Biomedical Ethics. Welcome, Alexa.
SPEAKER_05Hi, thank you for having me.
SPEAKER_01Honestly, James, you've set it up so high. Unless the rest of us.
SPEAKER_05Are we supposed to match that?
SPEAKER_03If you can, match it however you like. No, you don't think that's a good one.
SPEAKER_01That's your special skill.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, all-timey radio man.
SPEAKER_01Okay, I like that each time we do an episode, uh, you have a new voice. But please, Alexa, welcome. Thank you. This is about you, not James's, you know, improved skills. Uh so our first three questions for you are coffee or copy.
SPEAKER_05Coffee.
SPEAKER_01Really?
SPEAKER_05Like in a serious way.
SPEAKER_01I love how every time someone answers that question, I'm surprised.
SPEAKER_05Tell me. Yeah, I was like, is that so crazy?
SPEAKER_01I don't know. You've just been here for such a long time. I was wondering if you'd adapted your preferences.
SPEAKER_05Um, in many ways, I have with coffee, it's non-negotiable for me. I'm a diehard coffee fan. Never got into Kopi. I'm not a sweet and condensed milk person, for one. And I know you can have the Kopi. Oh, that's the black coffee, right? But even then, there's something about the brewed coffee that I make in my French press that I'm just wedded to.
SPEAKER_01You walking past my desk in the morning with your big thing of French press is like part of my day.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Oh, that's a ritual. Well, and I think also I've heard, I think it was your previous guest, Lucy, who mentioned that Kopi's like a punch in the face. And I was listening to this and I thought, well, she just hasn't had my coffee because it is it is aggressively a punch in the face, and I love that.
SPEAKER_03Very competitive all of a sudden. Oh, yeah, I can punch you in the face harder.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Next question. Which country do you want to travel to next the most?
SPEAKER_05I thought about this and I thought it would just be so much easier if you asked me which country I don't want to travel to next.
SPEAKER_01Oh.
SPEAKER_05But if I have to answer the question, I have to tweak it a little bit to say which part of a country do I want to travel to next. Alright, alright. Because um I have been to China in several places, but one place that I'm dying to go to is Chengdu and in the Sichuan province. One because it's my favorite cuisine. I love spicy mala hot pot. Um, I love the pickled fish. And also for the nature, I hear there's beautiful hiking there. So it's on my bucket list.
SPEAKER_01For those of you who don't know, um, currently Alexa is our adventure queen in the office. You've been in Singapore for how many years? Um over eleven. Over eleven years. And so Alexa is slowly guiding me through gaining XP or adventure points. Yes. So the more things I try in Singapore, the more XP I get, and the cooler I objectively become. Right. Alexa being my guide. Yes.
SPEAKER_03I don't usually I know you don't usually play games, but do you think XP stands for adventure points?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_03What is moving on.
SPEAKER_01What does XP stand for?
SPEAKER_03Experience points. Oh.
SPEAKER_01Okay, well, come on, it's not so different. Uh it's close. Adventure experience.
SPEAKER_03I just couldn't help myself but get a bit, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Get a bit about that.
SPEAKER_01We'll be beeping that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03We know who the gamers are here.
SPEAKER_01Excuse me.
SPEAKER_03Okay, that was a toxic gamer bro in me coming up. Let's move on.
SPEAKER_01Self-reflection, self-awareness. We're proud of you, James. Last question, our favorite question. And we know that you're a karaoke queen. So, what song would you sing at karaoke?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so it's just anything Mariah Carey. Um, big fan, it just depends on my mood. So maybe like if I'm feeling like a love ballad, it's without you. And then if I want to be inspirational, it's hero. And then if I want to be like fun and flirty, it's fantasy.
SPEAKER_01Wow, I love this.
SPEAKER_03What a range. And do you actually hit the notes? Nope. And neither are you expected to.
SPEAKER_05Eight octaves, man. That's uh that's serious talent. Unbelievable. Are you serious? I barely have one. Yeah, I have like one and a half.
SPEAKER_03Okay. Serious stuff. Alright. Um in exactly 50 words or less. Can you give us a summary of the entire philosophy of Taoism?
SPEAKER_05Um, I'd like to challenge your 50-word request with a three-word reply, which is harmony with Tao.
SPEAKER_03Damn it.
SPEAKER_05Essentially, that is what Taoism is as a philosophy, but then there's a lot to unpack with that, right? So um there's a difference between philosophical Taoism and religious Taoism. And philosophical Taoism is usually thought of I'm going way beyond your 50 now, but I just those three words harm me with that.
SPEAKER_01Honestly, I felt chills.
SPEAKER_05Oh, I felt boom deep in my soul.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I felt like gave you a challenge, and you just like went on challenge accepted. I was like, oh shit.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Damn. Chills.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Please keep going.
SPEAKER_05Okay, yes. Um, so philosophical Taoism is usually thought of as the expression of two texts, the Lao Tzu and the Zhuangzi. Lao Tzu came before Zhuangzi. Lao Tzu was around 5th, 6th century BCE, and Zhuangzi was around 4th century BCE. Um, and they're thought to mostly comprise of Taoist thought as a philosophical tradition, but there have been other texts that contribute later on, like the Li Tze, but mostly when people talk about philosophical Taoism, it's these two texts.
SPEAKER_05However, they are quite different. The Lao Tse is thought to have been written more for the ruler and touches more on things like governance, and it's also more prescriptive. The Dwangzi, on the other hand, is more literary and playful and focuses a lot on challenging norms. And this idea of living in harmony with Tao is usually emphasized with different concepts like freedom and spontaneity and effortlessness and non-action. Um, and all of these have sort of different interpretations depending on the scholar who's interpreting it.
SPEAKER_05Um, but in general, uh, this idea of spontaneity is uh through a term called zuran, and um it basically means the spontaneous emergence that happens both metaphysically within the world and within the individual. And then the second most prominent one that people talk about is usually uwe, which literally means non-action, um, but it has connotations of um purpose, not necessarily purposeless action, but indirectly achieving actions.
SPEAKER_05And there are lots and lots of other concepts, and it just depends on who's talking about it. Certain people decide to focus on different things, but some other prominent concepts include freedom and self-realization and self-actualization, limitlessness in thought, open-mindedness, how to break down preconceived notions and distinctions, things that we think about to categorize the world, um, including hierarchies. A lot of people also talk about forgetting and sitting and waiting.
SPEAKER_01So this is gonna be a terrible recap of what you've just said. What you're saying is, and I know this is very wrong for so many reasons, but I'm going ahead anyway.
SPEAKER_03I want to be here for this.
SPEAKER_01So so is Taoism the philosophy that just like roll with the punches?
SPEAKER_05Well, I think a lot of people read it that way, um, but I think most Taoist scholars would probably disagree with you and say that there's a lot of nuances to what that means. Um Be the punch.
SPEAKER_01Um punch yourself. Didn't see that one coming.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean there are there are definitely aspects to Taoism that that motivate that kind of behavior, but it doesn't mean that the Taoist sage sits there and does nothing or sits there and waits for things to happen necessarily. There is a level of action that um the sage is as they would call it um takes in life, but it's only actions that are in harmony with Tao. And so sometimes that translates as things that are um emerging without intention or without purpose.
SPEAKER_03Is there like a like a definition of Tao that we can roll with?
SPEAKER_01How do I know if I'm rolling with the punches? Yeah. How do I know if I'm in harmony with the Tao? With Tao?
SPEAKER_05Okay, well the complicated part about that is that Tao isn't definable, it is the ineffable. And so um there are different ways of thinking about it, but one way I like to think about it, which might sound really funny, um, is to think about the kind of metaphysical foundation of Tao in the texts. So that starts with woo, which means nothingness. And the way I think about that in my head is actually um like just a big scribbly scribble on a piece of paper where you can't really tell where something begins or ends, and it's just kind of all interconnected uh nothingness.
SPEAKER_05Okay? And then what happens is it turns into the one E. And so it turns from indistinctness to distinct entities. Things start to form into entities, basically, and then from there it becomes the many things, and all of these things are a mirroring of Tao. And it is this harmony with like the emergence, the emergence of things that comes from nothing that is Tao.
SPEAKER_05And I know that probably didn't help at all.
SPEAKER_01No, no, no, no, no. My my little brain is like imagining my um like biomedical drawings of mitosis, and then when you have the chromosomes that are like an absolute the the um the material that's just a massive mess and it's just like a big scribble, and then it slowly becomes the X's, and then they replicate and become many more. So that's they got the scribble thing. Excellent.
SPEAKER_05That's another good one. Yeah, it can be it can apply.
SPEAKER_03I was thinking about a game from Art Attack.
SPEAKER_05But kind of to answer your question about how do I know when I'm in harmony with Tao, I think sort of the idea is the second you know it, you're probably not in harmony with Tao anymore.
SPEAKER_02Whoa.
SPEAKER_05What?
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Um because this is this goes back to that concept of wu wei, the non-action um concept. So it it's a way of acting without intention or purpose, such that things are achieved of themselves. Um and so that means that in order to be in harmony with Dao, once you know it, you're out of it.
SPEAKER_01Okay, okay, I've got this. I've got this, I've figured it out. So have you seen the movie Inside Out? No, no, no, Soul. Soul, Disney's soul.
SPEAKER_03It was a yes and then a no.
SPEAKER_01Okay, okay, so in that movie, um, it's all about this little soul that's not in the pre-soul place, and that the the this little soul doesn't want to go to earth because they think it sucks. I mean, like, fair point, right? Anyway that anyway, one of the there's this thing in there called the flow state, and it's how people on earth can access like that great before by entering the flow state by doing something. So whether that's playing piano or playing soccer, um, and they're just so in the zone of what they're doing that they're in that this their own universe.
SPEAKER_01They're just but as soon as you realize you're in the universe, you you fall out of it. You're no longer in the flow.
SPEAKER_05Is that that's very similar, and there's been a lot of literature on flow state and Taoism comparatively, and a lot of people do think that that was sort of what these texts were getting at um with Wuei and Zuran. But um there's also uh an important distinction, so these uh skills are usually things that you have to practice for a while in order to get that flow state. Whereas for the type of harmony with Tao, where um we're talking about, you know, not skills that you build to be so that they become natural, but that are already natural within you.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So Tao is jazz, is what I'm hearing.
SPEAKER_01Maybe, yeah, spontaneous, you go with the flow, you bow with the punches, you ball with the phone. That's so good. I like it. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03You need to scatter a little bit in this presentation.
SPEAKER_01This would not be the first time you've scattered in a in a podcast.
SPEAKER_03Skibadi da ba-pa-de-beep. Skibbity. Daoism, daoism, skib. I'm glad you came on the pod. So it does sound like I kind of get what you're saying, but it does sound a little bit indeterminate as far as ethics goes. Because in ethics we're interested in figuring out what's good and what's bad and what's right and what's wrong. But I guess firstly, uh it doesn't sound like there are any like really clear principles about what's good and what's bad.
SPEAKER_03And on top of that, you said you the moment you know, you're not in it. So it's like, okay, if we can't know what it's like, and we can't um and there are no principles.
SPEAKER_01And there's no definition of how to get there.
SPEAKER_03And there's no definition of how to get there, uh, is it selling us much at all?
SPEAKER_05Um well, I think I I'm gonna focus on the Dwangzi a little bit because the way that the Zhuangzi is able to convey these messages is often through the use of like parables and allegories, and without you can kind of call it wordless teaching. So without telling or saying or deeming right and wrong, you're able to kind of get the motivations from the story. Um, and I guess in that way, it's able to give you uh a sense of what maybe behind behind it all there are because okay, to be fair, I think even though in general the text does not promote uh any sort of morality, any sort of right or wrong, good or bad, you get the gist that he probably prizes certain things like spontaneity and freedom and limit limitlessness in thought, uh flexibility, adaptability, things like that.
SPEAKER_05So um I guess to answer your question, Zhuangzi in particular is not really going to give you prescriptive things that we can use in ethics and you know any sort of set of principles, but you can ascertain from reading the text maybe what you could do. But he's just not gonna tell you to do it or exactly how.
SPEAKER_01It I get the vibe that it's more descriptive than actively prescriptive. Yeah. And in being descriptive, you can learn things.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Um it's it's uh it's very literary and playful, and there are a lot of uses of like metaphors and things, so that it it challenges you to think about what they're saying when they're not actually saying it in the text. Um I mean some things are much more clear than others. Um and you know, there are stories where you're like, oh, I get what that means, and then there are stories that you have a very difficult time figuring out the meaning. Um But I mean themes of there are themes, themes that come out that just stand out in the literature.
SPEAKER_05Um so those are usually what you'd say, if you wanted to like parallel with principles, you'd say those are maybe like the principles of Taoism. But it's just that Taoism wouldn't want you to have principles as such.
SPEAKER_01So how then is Taoism relevant to medicine?
SPEAKER_05So I guess just like very macro and broadly, I think any discipline and medicine is one, can value can have a valuable addition of perspectives that aren't always there. So um I think Taoist perspectives uh well in traditional Chinese medicine, that's the foundation, but in Western medicine, which is what I think um we're talking about, Taoism is not present, right?
SPEAKER_05Um, and so these perspectives sort of offer a new way to orient different issues um that might come up um in medicine. So maybe one is the doctor-patient relationship. Um right now we're working on um um not another model to the doctor-patient relationship, but a way for the doctor-patient relationship to orient itself in the clinic where you could use any of the models that already exist.
SPEAKER_05So let's just take like paternalistic, for example. Some um people might really like to be uh kind of told what to do and have the doctor be the authority and they just do what the doctor says. Um, and with our model, there's more of a holistic approach. So a doctor could still have that sort of uh modus operandi, if you will, but be able to be more um in tune with that particular person. So taking into account um the maybe the lifestyle of the person, their social life, their work, things that are maybe stressing them, their relationships, and incorporate that into care plans.
SPEAKER_05Um because part of part of the way that could augment the entire situation is that a person is uh is sort of their whole bit, their whole ecosystem of of life and experiences. So incorporating that into a care plan um really personalizes uh what that care plan looks like and it just offers a new perspective for um doctors and patients to to relate. So yeah, I guess that's sort of the macro reason that I think Taoism is helpful.
SPEAKER_05But then um there are particular areas of medicine that I think Taoism can be especially helpful. Um one of them is in uh disability narratives. Um there's a term called structural structural ableism, uh, which is you know the the norms and policies and processes that we have in place in the institutions that um privilege able-bodied people, um, and maybe on you know another level, just the societal belief that able-bodied people are uh maybe better and that disability is a bad thing that should be cured or treated.
SPEAKER_05Um, and I guess because Taoism sort of breaks down these distinctions and doesn't think about things in terms of good or bad, uh, it offers a new way to think about the disability narrative where maybe people with disabilities don't need to be treated or cured, but rather we can think about treatments or plans that help them to live a higher quality of life. And this also has implications for precision medicine and genetics and genomics, and thinking about how and what sort of gene testing should be promoted and available to people and how they should interpret these tests.
SPEAKER_05Um, because maybe for a certain uh prenatal genetic test, some a parent might find out that there's a there's a positive result for some sort of disability, and then maybe change the way that they decide to move forward with the birth. Um and there's no necessarily right or wrong uh way to do that. Um but if you know we think about the Taoist perspective, um, especially in the Asian context where um these beliefs are kind of embedded in the culture, it gives um it gives a new way to think about these areas of medicine.
SPEAKER_03So that's that's very interesting. And um what what I'm gonna try to get at is is the the idea of is there anything really, really distinctive about Taoism? Not like there has to be, but um yeah, so so um many of people who are who are like invested in these kinds of conversations uh might point out that there are a lot of movements within medicine to change things in a direction that you're already talking about, right? Like uh pe there are people who um say say who are saying that disability not necessarily A bad thing.
SPEAKER_03It's just a different kind of life. And there are people who say who are saying that, yeah, doctors and patients, doc should doctors should be more uh uh consultative towards the patients and uh be more interested in what their patients see as a life worth living, etc. etc. So I'm wondering if Taoism says like you know, adds something, a distinctive kind of flavor that uh would be surprising even to these people.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I love that question. Um there there are a few things to that. First is in today's frameworks of medicine and and the way people appreciate um maybe academic literature and medicine, uh they might see the word Taoism or hear the word Taoism and and instantly kind of be like, oh, it that doesn't apply to me, or that's not relevant for medicine. And the interesting thing is partially, you're right in saying we don't need Taoism to have these ideas.
SPEAKER_05Taoism, which just give credit where credit's due. I mean, they thought of it first, right? So, no, I mean I could take my paper on the Taoist perspective on the doctor-patient relationship, and I could remove all the Taoist concept as such and just talk about them descriptively and not reference Taoism. But I I know that you know a lot of these ideas sprouted from Taoism for me, so I'm I'm talking about it in that context. But you're completely right that a lot of the ideas are already present in in literature um on medicine today, but in bioethics, but um there are certain nuances also to Taoism that I think are um important, and I think a lot of it um comes down to under like it comes down to when you actually read the texts and the way that they sort of transform you while reading them.
SPEAKER_05Um I'm not saying that you have to read the text in order to understand a Taoist perspective to bioethics, but I think that um there's a transformative effect. I would also just say that these concepts do have acute definitions that are distinct from the way similar concepts might be described today. Just by virtue of being their own concept that was originally created by a certain thinker from 4th, 5th century BCE, the entire context and metaphysical foundation for that thinker imagining that concept is different, which means it's inherently unique in itself.
SPEAKER_05And while there are some discussions on medical nihilism, I'm not actually sure many people, if anyone in modern medicine is actually talking about spontaneity or allowing actions to emerge of themselves and achieving things indirectly.
SPEAKER_03It just occurred to me that that these people named their texts after themselves. Uh well because it's a retrospective kind of thing.
SPEAKER_05They didn't really name their own text, they were kind of named later.
SPEAKER_03Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Um there's a bottom.
SPEAKER_05But but no, the Zhuangzi is the Zhuangzi, but the Lao Tzu is also called the Dao Dijing. So Lao Tzu is the guy, Dao Dijing is the book, but a lot of people just call it the Lao Tzu.
SPEAKER_01So I I I'm running this, I'm running this through my brain, and I think what a lot of what you're saying sounds really beautiful. Um, and as an abled-bodied person, I think this has been really enlightening for me. Um and so one of the things you're saying is like that the Taoist perspective can come along and say, okay, let's learn to live with this. Let's in my brain, let's roll with the punches, let's go with the flow. There is nothing to fix, that is just how can we continue to keep moving forward in a in a flow state? Or I've really latched onto that word, haven't I?
SPEAKER_03Um It's jazz, man.
SPEAKER_01No, I'm not sure. Um but then what about what about like you know, treatments for disability? What does this have to say about should we then not be looking for cures or do people not want cures if they are available? Or is it like a in in a medium or like a momentary state of mind until research develops?
SPEAKER_05Um I think uh the Taoist perspective definitely would not reject treatment um or even a cure necessarily. It's just it it comes down to the perspective of the patient and how the patient I'm gonna go back to the spontaneous self, the Zuran. Um how they view themselves as a spontaneous self within the context of Tao. So harmony with Tao. Um I guess maybe a patient with disability wouldn't want to be cured, maybe they would.
SPEAKER_05Maybe there are certain interventions that they would be uh open to because they improve their quality of life, but maybe there will be other interventions that would be imposed upon them because of maybe some uh belief of the doctor that they need to not have that disability, or maybe um impositions from the doctor's belief about what uh disabilities should be changed. Uh so it really is about listening to the patient and what they feel is important about their quality of life.
SPEAKER_05Many people with disability live very happy lives, um, which is well documented. Um, so it's about listening to the individual. And and I think many people with disability will want certain treatments to improve their quality of life. And a Taoism wouldn't have a problem with that. It's more if the interventions are put on because of um imposed societal norms or hierarchies, um, things that aren't spontaneously natural to them.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so what we're looking at with Taoism is not putting the patient onto the societal flow state, but identifying their own and keeping them on that path. That's quite lovely. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And uh here again we see that nice little convergence with like the way I think that the kind of thing that the doctors a lot are moving to for the most part, where they'll say, Hey, here's a treatment. Um, I recommend it, but like go home, talk to your family about it or something.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Uh talk to your friends.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. No, it's great to see that that we've moved have we? Towards doctor has never said that to me. Go home and talk about it with your family and friends. You know, I have to say the same because I keep hearing that this is happening, um, but I I don't I don't experience it and I don't meet many people that experience it.
SPEAKER_01Hmm. I've been to the doctor twice in the last month, and I don't think either of them actually asked, like, how how are you? It's just like, why are you here? Yeah. Yeah. What can I do for you? Yeah. Okay.
SPEAKER_03Okay, yeah. Fix my problem. That's what doctors supp uh say they're doing.
SPEAKER_01Um, so I'm really enjoying this idea and I think it's quite beautiful. Um, but how can you implement like guidance for health practitioners who don't have time to read these texts and learn these things so that they can then provide care in accordance with these perspectives?
SPEAKER_05Um well, I mean, we have lots of ethical codes for various uh physicians. I think it's very easy to plop a few things in there from a Taoist perspective.
SPEAKER_01Be spontaneous. Ask for consent, don't ask for consent. Decide on the day.
SPEAKER_05Well, I mean, those the those things have to be more practical. And I think what I'm getting at more is like a perspective or an orientation. So it's a perspective and an orientation from which actions will follow, but it's not pr I mean, as we talked about, these actions have to emerge out of themselves. So if we were to put things within guidelines, you know, um more prescriptive prescriptive guidelines, it would be sort of uh it would be about how the doctor can think about a situation rather than telling the doctor what to do.
SPEAKER_05And so I think that could include things like well, I mean, my my my first instinct is to be prescriptive actually when thinking about it, because um that's the way I think most of the codes are written. Uh so I'm not I'm not you know, I haven't really put much thought into the wording because you know, I'm just thinking, would it be uh ask about their personal life or would it be more like um how might your treatment plan interact with the person's uh personal life?
SPEAKER_05I think one good example is um there's some literature on the um Muslim Malay women with diabetes in Singapore who um maybe they they might get a treatment plan to have better diet and exercise habits. And this might conflict with their personal life um due to cultural norms and um just general lifestyle norms that they experience that would uh prohibit them from having um substantial changes in their diet and exercise plans.
SPEAKER_05Um so I guess the perspective of the doctor kind of has to shift with the patient's lifestyle and think about how does this care plan fit in with that person's everyday life? Is it something that is achievable? Um and so I think yeah, this shift has to go from rather than doctors thinking about the standard of care, the standard procedure and process that they're they're used to, or the the care plan that they would normally just give without thinking they can incorporate the person's um daily life.
SPEAKER_01So do you think though that this might meet make healthcare kind of relative and in a way that's not No, I think it makes it incredibly appropriate to the person. Sorry. Um yes, and that that's what I mean. So, for example, currently we like patient comes in to the doctor, um, doctor goes, Okay, well, this is like the standard of health of which we expect a human to be. This is how you can achieve that standard of health. Instead, what we're saying is, well, let's look at the person, and according to their social life, their person, their being, who they are, this is this maybe what they're capable of based on their other priorities, is not the the classic human standard of health, but something maybe a little bit s shorter than that.
SPEAKER_01And in in doing that though, and I and whilst I think that I haven't thought this through, so help is what I'm saying. Would that mean though, that we're making healthcare relativistic in a prob like would there be negative consequences of just being like, oh, okay, well, according to your values, which is you really like this really poor lifestyle? And I'm not talking about disability here, let's talk about people who just make poor life choices that result in really really bad health. Okay, well, this is only what you're capable of. Or are you limiting this model more to like disability?
SPEAKER_05I think it applies really well in disability and chronic illness. Um, but I th I think yeah, because those are areas where the imperative curative model isn't um always applicable. But I I think there may be situations where um this is especially true when you take into consideration psychological well-being and and mental health, because um maybe someone doesn't want to take care of themselves. How does a doctor deal with that? Um I know.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_04You'll be all saving. Goodbye.
SPEAKER_05Um yeah, so yeah, I think this perspective is definitely more applicable um in certain areas than others. Um, but I don't think um it's I don't think it's not worth exploring in almost every area of medicine because it is quite broad and because it isn't prescriptive, it's kind of easy to apply in various areas of medicine. Um and and yet to your question again, I think so um there are different views about relativism in the Zhuangzi.
SPEAKER_05Um but one view is that he's well it's funny because this pi this paper is not about bioethics, but he used the uses the term patient relativism. Um but the idea is there's the golden rule, which is do unto others as you would like done unto yourself, and then there's the Confucian negative version version, which is do not do unto others as you would not want done unto yourself. And then this um author um coins Zhangzi as the bronze rule, which is uh do unto others as they would want done unto themselves.
SPEAKER_05And so this is his idea of patient relativism, where um I guess in the doctor-patient relationship context, this would mean that the doctor um shouldn't necessarily impose his standard of care uh despite um it being in the best interest of the patient potentially, or you know, what he believes is, but rather that what the patient believes is best for him or herself is what is best.
SPEAKER_03So I have a potential objection. So uh imagine I'm a doctor of the physician variety.
SPEAKER_01Um of what other varieties are that, man?
SPEAKER_03Of the academic variety, like you are my bad.
SPEAKER_01Sorry, it didn't land yeah.
SPEAKER_03So so so so you're telling you telling me all uh imagine I'm a doctor, you're telling me all this, and I just say, look, man, I I've got a very I've got a very specific set of skills. You know, and and it's uh look at uh something going on with the body and try to fix it. Uh and you know you're telling me to do all these other things. It sounds like this is just stuff for the patient to figure out with their family or their guidance counselor or their life coach or whatever. Um, you know, I'm specialized, I just want to uh focus on my thing, and by asking me to do all these other things, you're making my my job so much harder.
SPEAKER_03Why don't I just do my part? And if the patient wants a wants more than that, they they can look for other people who will do their part.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Well, I think you can do both, and I don't think the doctor you're talking about has to do that job necessarily. I think there could be a complementary kind of system where this uh specialized doctor works with maybe that person's um life coach. Life coach or whatever or whatever. Or or or maybe, you know, like there are definitely gonna be certain doctors who are more suited to this kind of model and other doctors who aren't really maybe good at talking about certain things like that.
SPEAKER_05But um again, it's not uh it's not necessarily necessarily that a doctor has to get to know a patient on a personal, because you know, also many patients may not want this. Um the whole the whole idea is that the relationship should be um this emerging sort of understanding from one another that is reciprocal. So if that means that the doctor doesn't want to do that and the patient doesn't want it done to them, then that's how it should be.
SPEAKER_05So it I think when we're talking about this relationship, that's what we mean is uh the perspective and the orientation, but we're also saying that sometimes that will manifest that um a more holistic incorporation of the person's values and personal life will emerge.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, thanks. Because I was just thinking, if I went to a doctor and they're like, what do you want out of life? I'd be like, whoa, whoa, man.
SPEAKER_04Single to you.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, no, I and I don't really think that's what we're trying to say either. Um I think it's like I, you know, I have been to a doctor who who's sort of um been a little bit more friendly in terms of trying to understand me as an individual. Um, and it's definitely hasn't been the norm in my experience, but when that's happened, I think they've gotten the right information to be able to understand me and my situation better.
SPEAKER_05And I think it might also be sort of um um, it doesn't have to be an in-depth conversation like what is your truth in life, but it could just be like maybe understanding what does that person usually eat? Or um, you know, how how often is that person getting up out of out of their desk? I don't know, some sort of less invasive bits of information that could contribute to the person's care plan.
SPEAKER_01I'm I've got an example of this. Um and it it may be TMI, so we we can cut it if required. But I I think a really good example of this um is when I went to um go on contraception and um they were the first point of call is the pill. If the doctor had literally taken the time to ask me, are you good at doing things at the same time every day? Like, are you an organized person? I would have been like, absolutely not. And they would have said, Okay, well, you're not going on the pill because you need to take it within the same hour every day.
SPEAKER_01I was on it for many years. I did not take it like once the same hour. I just forget. And the thing is, is each time, each time you forget to take it within an hour, that your week of um like being fertile starts again, so you can fall pregnant. And so if the doctor had just wanted to know a little bit more about my personality and my habits, I could have been recommended an IUD much earlier, which is like you get it in once, forget about it, which was much more suited to my lifestyle. And so you're you're so right.
SPEAKER_01If they had just not just asked a little bit more to draw more information out of me, they could have helped me make a much better healthcare choice way earlier on.
SPEAKER_05Thank you. I'm gonna use that in my next paper.
SPEAKER_01Yes, you earned it. Thank you. But like the way the way I'm thinking about this is, and correct me if I'm phrasing this wrong in my head, it's not so much like Taoism is not so much telling doctors what to say, but it's uh like a behavioral guidance. Yeah. So, you know, go through your methods, but be open. And so if this happens, then be open. And then if something else happens, then be then be open. It's more of like a how to get to the final product rather than what is the final product.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, absolutely.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_05Beautiful. How rather than what. Great! Yes. Yeah, it's I I think that's what what we're trying to go for is an orientation and a perspective, and like you said, a um a a behavioral sort of guidance. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Excellent. No further questions.
SPEAKER_05Great. My palms are sweaty.
SPEAKER_03This has been a high stress interview.
SPEAKER_05No man, I'm Zen out.
SPEAKER_01That is the best use of that ever.
SPEAKER_03Podcasts, they're just like performing jazz.
SPEAKER_01Podcast title Is Taoism just jazz? Or is Jazz Taoism?
SPEAKER_03Ooh.
SPEAKER_01Ooh.
SPEAKER_03If you're saying something is something, then the opposite will be I'm out, man.
SPEAKER_01It's like five o'clock. Anyway, um, I want to say thank you so much for coming on the pod. I've learned a lot. I feel enlightened. I feel not quite then. I feel a little confused.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, me too. But okay. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Oh, I nailed it. Actually, I I would go as far as to say as if you're confused, you're doing it right. Ooh.
SPEAKER_01Acceptance of confusion. Yes, yeah. Not Confucius. Confusion.
SPEAKER_05Thank you so much for having me. It has been awesome. You're welcome anytime.
SPEAKER_03Uh and to all listeners, if you're a doctor and you have a jazz band, let us know. Just because that'll be all I got really fixated on this analogy, didn't I?
SPEAKER_01Skibbity baby out.
SPEAKER_03Can you do that again, but with a bit more?
SPEAKER_01No, next.
SPEAKER_03Ah, one day.
SPEAKER_01That was Alexa's famous chipmunk noise, everybody.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_01All right. Goodbye. Goodbye.
SPEAKER_00Goodbye. Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and U and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...