Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

C B m E & U

C B m E & U artwork

Dementia and Desires: Which you is the real you? with Rand Hirmiz

Oct 2, 202537 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail In this episode, Dr. Rand Hirmiz (Singapore Management University) discusses how people with dementia can sometimes drastically change their preferences, including their long held values such as religious views or ethical standpoints. If a person then tries to go against their former views, such as by eating meat despite being a lifelong vegetarian, which views should we respect? What if their new views are less harmful or restricting than their previous views? Rand talks about the ways in which we form values, and the similarities and differences between the person pre-dementia and post-dementia. We also debate coffee (once again), and the wild concept of half-and-half milk, and that is not so half-and-half as they say. Remember people, be savvy!

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, C BME and You, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.

SPEAKER_06Welcome back to CB Me and You, a podcast about biomedical ethics. Today, what happens if you have dementia and your personality changes? Should everyone respect the preferences of your old self or the new self? What does it mean to be a self anyway? Do I have a self? Somebody help me!

SPEAKER_03Calm down.

SPEAKER_06Breathe. Joining us to solve my existential crisis is Ren Hermes, assistant professor of philosophy at Singapore Management University. Welcome, Ren.

SPEAKER_03Hi. That was a really nice intro. So dramatic. In case you can't tell, it's Friday. We're so excited to have you on the pod. I'm gonna do some easy fun questions before we get into James's existential crisis. They're there. They're there. First question: coffee or coffee?

SPEAKER_01So you guys took me for my first coffee today. I think you wanted me. You were so excited about it. You wanted me so badly. I do like it. I do like it. Um I just I think it tastes like coffee. But here's what it is. It tastes like coffee with milk. Like coffee with milk and sugar is what coffee tastes like to me.

SPEAKER_03Okay, okay. So I just have a quick question about this. Um, do you just drink like instant coffee?

SPEAKER_01No. Um so I normally, and by the way, this is it's been one of the hardest parts about moving to Singapore has been first off, you don't sell like half and half here. What you don't know what half and half is that's exactly yeah. So it's it's 10% cream and you keep it in the fridge and then but why is it half and half if it's only 10% cream? Oh, because like full cream is like a lot higher.

SPEAKER_03So it's full cream is actually 50-50.

SPEAKER_01So half and half. No, no, 10% so milk is like 2%. Like whole milk is like 2%. There's like whole milk is 3%. But there's so cream, okay. So actually like full, full cream. Okay, like whipping like whipped cream, like the kind that you would make whipped cream out of. I think that's like 40-ish percent, like closer to like 40%. So closer to half and half.

SPEAKER_02So half and half is like 10, 10%. It's literally called half and half. Okay, this makes it makes no sense. I know.

SPEAKER_01Okay, okay. But so that's how I would and like if you go to like the US, like if you go to a Starbucks or a Tim Hortons or anything like that, you would order a coffee. So like a double double at Tim Hortons, not here.

SPEAKER_02Oh, we don't know what a double double is. No, but we do have Tim Hortons.

SPEAKER_01You do have Tim Hortons.

SPEAKER_06They don't have they don't have creamer, they don't have half and half and they don't have I'm really enjoying this because the first time you have shenanigans not knowing about the coffee thing.

SPEAKER_02This isn't coffee, this is milk.

SPEAKER_01No, no, it's not milk, it's creamer. What's creamer? It's a very that's it's so crazy because like in the US or Canada, like you would not, this would not be a conversation that will happen.

SPEAKER_03You will never Okay, so it's the half and half the cream in the milk?

SPEAKER_02No, it's not in the instead of milk, instead of milk. Wait a minute.

SPEAKER_01Milk is too milky, milk is too milky.

SPEAKER_03Then why have milk? Why not have milk cream?

SPEAKER_01It tastes so different. It tastes so different. It's like, okay, so here's I'll I'll tell you what it's closest to, and then it's gonna make sense to you. Because I'm used to drinking my coffee with cream, with cream and sweetener. When I came here, I there you don't they don't exist in Singapore. Uh-huh. But I've been finding evaporated creamer.

SPEAKER_05Evaporated milk.

SPEAKER_01No, cream. Evaporated cream. But there's evaporated milk, but there's also evaporated creamer, and they actually exist. So you can buy them from like grocery stores here. Um and they I keep them in the fridge. You don't need to keep them in the fridge because they're canned, but I keep them in the fridge and then I use them in my coffee, and it it tastes so close-ish to the cream. Okay.

SPEAKER_06Wai Kyung has almost never uh chimed in during a podcast before. And then so I guess what did it for him? The Rubicon, the line that he would not accept is the idea of evaporated cream.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Okay. You know what? Let's move on. What country do you want to travel to next?

SPEAKER_01Um, I mean, I have I have a long bucket list, but for now, during the break, I'm planning to go to KL, Malaysia. Um, yeah, just uh it's it's really good for like a short trip. Um I have like let's say four days. I can just go. It's very affordable from here. The flights are really cheap. Uh hotels are very affordable. So it's gonna be a really nice trip. I'm gonna go see some like temples and some uh go to the food markets and just enjoy.

SPEAKER_03Excellent, excellent. Um, haven't been to KL yet, but I've just booked a holiday to Tiaman Island, which is off like the northeast coast of Malaysia.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, somewhere there. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03It's like a three-hour drive and then a ferry and then a four-wheel drive. Uh, the long weekend that's coming up. I'm so excited. I'm gonna swim. I'm just never gonna get out of the water. That sounds amazing. Sorry, this was meant to be about you. No, that sounds amazing.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, so like the similar thing, but completely different. One's a city, one's a beach.

SPEAKER_03Okay, okay, okay, okay. What's your go-to karaoke song?

SPEAKER_01Oh, so I I like duet karaokes. Um, so I like uh you're the one that I want from Greece.

unknownYeah!

SPEAKER_03Okay, she's coming with us. You are we we gotta karaoke all the time. You are invited. We have a voucher we need to use.

SPEAKER_06We do, we do. Not valid on Fridays and Saturdays. We learned that. You're the lawyer. I don't know why you just don't do this yourself.

SPEAKER_03It's your voucher! Anyway, anyway, this is about her. I'm excited. I'm down. Excellent.

SPEAKER_06The karaoke group expands. Okay. Time to get down to business to the feather hunts. Um, so uh in a paper that you've written recently, uh, you describe a really interesting case. So it goes something like this: an elder an elderly man with Alzheimer's residing in a Swedish care home has consistently been served vegetarian meals. And he long he's a long-standing uh vegetarian, so he's committed to ethical vegetarianism. Uh one day he was mistakenly given an another residence meal which contained meat.

SPEAKER_06And after eating it and jo and enjoyed it, he's like, Oh my god, meat! Um and he refused to return to his to his usual vegetarian diet. Right. Um, we seem to have a a situation here where there seems to be a conflict between what he used to believe, his his long-standing commitments, and his his now self who has dementia, but you know, it this is a person who says, No, look, I wanna I wanna have this this steak. It's tasty. Um so what what do we make of this kind of case? What do we do and why?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that touches on like a really, really tough issue where there's this person who throughout his life has made this commitment. Uh like has has thought about this, and this is something that's been really important to him, and and every day of his life he's made the the decision, the active decision, that I'm gonna refrain from having meat because these are my values. And then uh, you know, he he has dementia, and then he becomes now this person who will say can't I mean it's I guess it's a complicated issue, but either uh can't recall his his reasons for his values or just doesn't care about them or just doesn't acknowledge them or just literally is not even in the place to be questioning what the what what the implications of eating this and not eating it are.

SPEAKER_01They're just in a place where this is taste better than what I've been eating so far. So why can't I keep having it? I'm so confused. Why do my my friends in my in my home get to have this and I'm not allowed to? Um so I think it touches on this really, really tough situation where there's this conflict between the person's own selves, uh the sort of pre-dimensional self and the post-dimential self, where now they have conflicting interests. And if we can kind of imagine them being in the same room together, we can see how like this conflict would come about.

SPEAKER_01It's like trying to convince yourself. I don't know if you've ever like tried to convince your future. Like it, like if you've ever been in a place where you think, oh, I'm I'm worried about what my future self, when they're emotional or when they're in this situation, I'm I'm worried about what they're gonna do. So you like record a voice note for your future. I don't know if you guys do that.

SPEAKER_03Um this is how we should get out of bed in the morning. I'm just gonna tell this exactly. This is this happen, this happens to me on a like a daily basis. I'm like, I'm gonna get up in the morning, I'm gonna go for a swim, I'm gonna, I'm gonna be productive. And then the morning comes and I'm groggy, I'm tired, and I don't want to be anywhere about bed. And I'm like, no. And then I've asked Joshua, my my partner, to like come wake me up. And he was like, Come on, you've got to go sober me. And I'm like, no.

SPEAKER_01It really feels like a different version of Joshua. Yeah. Um, and so if we have that kind of conflict, um, you can imagine how something where like, and it's more than just sleeping or getting out of bed, it's like something that really matters to you. And so there's this conflict where now, let's say now you you've just been diagnosed with dementia, and now you you are you have this worry that, oh my God, what's gonna happen to the values that I hold so dear right now? What's gonna happen to all the commitments that I hold right now? Am I gonna forget about them? Am I gonna be the kind of person who gives them up?

SPEAKER_01So from the one side to the person who was committed to not eating meat, there's this worry of like, wait, is my narrative gonna change? Is who I am, is it gonna be broken by what happens when I'm no longer in control of this, when I'm no longer capable of like revisiting the reasons for for my values. On the other hand, the current version who literally just wants to eat meat because it tastes so good. Uh you can also imagine how that that would be confusing and how that can be like hurtful of like just not understanding why.

SPEAKER_01Why can't I have it? I want it, why are you refusing it and not understanding why? So there's this conflict, and then the the question we get to is when we're faced with I mean, these kinds of situations, but also of course much bigger, much more important situations um about someone's life and their values and the things that matter to them and their commitments. How do we settle the question of how to how to weigh the values and and the and the um the things that are important and the I I don't know the word is like slimming from me, just the preferences, the preferences of the the current self who has the dementia and their previous self who uh was more capable of making their decisions and thinking through their values.

SPEAKER_01How do we weigh those against each other? And so um yeah, that's kind of the the issue.

SPEAKER_03So based on the vegetarianism example, because my brain was going, look, I was vegetarian being vegan, now I live in Singapore and chassu and pork ri uh roast pork rice is one of my favorite dishes. You know, we understand that people's like diet preferences can be really important to them, but also like the content of that preference is simply like it's just eating steak. You know, like the the harm that you might do to that person by forcing them against what their current desires are might outweigh uh helping them to protect that value.

SPEAKER_03So does like the content of that value matter? Is it like, okay, look, you used to hate wearing purple, but now you really want to wear purple? Just just just let them wear the purple. But if it's something more important, like maybe like a religious view or a really deep-rooted, like ethical position like vegetarianism, does that matter a bit more?

SPEAKER_01Of course, yeah. Um yeah, I think if if if someone always wore a certain color and then now they're trying to wear a different color, it would seem a little bit unreasonable to say, well, no, your whole life you haven't, so you can't anymore. Um But I I think there are there are decisions that I think we do give more weight to. Things that are less about preferences and more about this is the kind of person I am. This is my narrative, this is who I want to be, and this is who I want to be remembered as after I'm gone.

SPEAKER_01Um and I think decisions like that, and of course they're there are decisions that are gonna be bigger than just not eating meat, and there are decisions that are gonna be less than that. But um, yeah, something like religion. Yeah, someone someone just deciding to to um do something or yeah, do something that would conflict with their religious beliefs afterwards.

SPEAKER_03Like not eating halal food.

SPEAKER_01Yes, yes.

SPEAKER_06Well, just to ramp up the stakes even more, you can imagine cases like I think it's the Jehovah's Witnesses who don't want blood transfusions. So what if you have like somebody who's like who has been a Jehovah's Witness their whole life and now they have dementia and and now maybe they need a blood transfusion and they're like, give it to me. It's like okay, well, this is the literally a life or death situation. If we don't give this person who wants to have a blood a blood transfusion fusion the blood, they might die.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_06Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And so I think these these become tougher cases because again, it's not it's no longer just about preference. It's no longer about just like this tastes good to me now and it didn't taste good to me before, uh, or I like this now or I didn't like it before. It's uh it's really like a core, like it's a big part of who you are as a person and who you want to be as a person and how you want to represent yourself throughout your life. And then it seems like um I mean, for the same reason I would imagine uh like someone there's this there's this discussion of uh of whether like posthumous harms are even a thing. Like if uh if after you die someone makes up a rumor about you having done all these things that you didn't do, uh, are you really harmed?

SPEAKER_01And for the same reason I think that I I'm tempted to say that you will be, I also want to say that the actions of your post-dementia self not not being in line with the kind of person that you've worked your whole life to be would also hurt you.

SPEAKER_03Okay, so based on what you've said just just then, and and also I've read your paper, so I'm I do know yes to this. You've done the whole board. So so you do think that some uh priority should be afforded to the the then version of yourself over the now version of yourself. And so how like how did you figure that out? Like what's your measure for for making that claim?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, so to some extent, I you're you're right to some extent. So I think for the most part, if if we are able to repudiate our previous values, so if we're able to um, if we're able to understand the reasons for why we we decided on having a certain value to begin with, and then also understand that that reason no longer applies. Like if we're able to have that, then I think you should be able to break your prior commitments or change them. Because we don't ever we don't what I don't want to want to say is um that anytime you make a commitment, you should never be allowed to break it.

SPEAKER_01Like anytime you have a value, if you decide to be vegetarian, you are literally never allowed to break that. No, I think if you, and a lot of people do, like a lot of people will try veganism or vegetarianism, and then we'll we'll change their minds later. But it's usually after like reflection, like, okay, I understood the reasons that I I made that commitment. I also understand now this new information, or I understand that my previous uh reasons don't no longer apply, so I'm allowed to break it, or something like that. That seems like a more rational um way to justify it, as opposed to someone just saying, I just want this now, and like not even thinking about their previous reasons.

SPEAKER_01So, what I want to say is in order to really be able to break a commitment, you have to have this kind of this capacity to have uh this is this is what Ari Frankfurt calls uh second order volitions. So we have our first order desires. This is like I want this.

SPEAKER_03I want to sleep in.

SPEAKER_01I want to sleep in. That's a first order desire. I just want to do that. And then we have our second order desires, and second order desires are desires about our desires. So you want to sleep in, but you also have this second order desire about your first order desire of our sleeping in.

SPEAKER_03I don't want to want to sleep in. Is that what we No? That's literally it. Yeah, yeah. I I want to sleep in, but I don't want to want to sleep in. That's right. That's right. Unfortunately for me, my second order desires never seem to come through.

SPEAKER_06Like, I'm thinking about that. I'm like, I think I still want to want to sleep in.

SPEAKER_01Our lives would be a lot easier if we just wanted to, honestly. Um, but though, so there we have first order desires, second order desires, and then we have second order volitions, which are really these desires that are second-order desires, certain second order desires are the ones that guide us to action. So, for example, um, I could have a desire for meat. I could also have this second order desire that has to do with my desires about meat, that I don't want to be the kind of person who eats meat. I don't want to be the kind of person who uh goes with their desire to eat meat. Um and then the second order of volition would be, well, I want my desire to refrain from eating meat to be the one that guides me to action.

SPEAKER_01And if you get to a point where you're no longer capable of having these, this capacity to form second order desires, this this ability to think about your desires about your desires, then it it's a little bit it's tough to say that you're able to now break or like cancel out or like repudiate your prior commitments. Um it would be you can, I mean, there are there are instances where we do this, but it's I want to say it's a mistake to just break a prior commitment without that kind of reflection.

SPEAKER_03I've heard this um termed reflective endorsement. Uh this idea that like uh you have your your first order preferences or like impulses, emotions, uh things that you don't generate reasons for, they just sort of pop into your head. Like, I want to do this. And then you reflectively endorse on that and go, is this in line with my values? So I think like in my head, I categorize it as like first order preferences and then second order values. And then that's the way that my brain seems to like understand that. So I get your point that if a person then doesn't have capacity to reflect on their values and check themselves and their emotions and their impulses in accordance with their values, it would seem like uh it would seem kind of like a mistake to then allow them to go back on their own values that they've formed over a lifetime and that they've spent uh moving towards in like a particular narrative.

SPEAKER_03Does that make sense?

unknownYeah.

SPEAKER_06Yeah. Although I think there might be a bit of a lot of people. Although no our job is to be critical. Um so yeah, you might think that there is a bit of a difference between um some ways, the typical ways in which we fail to live up our c to our commitments and cases of dementia. And that's that we come back, right? Like uh if I think to myself, well, I I'm I'm gonna do it. Today's the day I um I stop procrastinating and um start getting my life together.

SPEAKER_03I will give you a hundred bucks on the day you finally followed.

SPEAKER_06I will give me a hundred bucks. Well, it's not gonna happen. We both know that. But you know, I go through the day, I procrastinate, uh, I s uh I I spend half the day in bed, uh, etc. And then I I I end up the next day going like, oh man, I shouldn't have done that. I really screwed up. Now, there so there's a sense of you know, bouncing back and forth between the two. So there's a sense in which those second order desires do matter because I'll go back to them. In the case in some cases or cases of dementia, you you we can but there might be some people who will just never go back.

SPEAKER_06Like those commitments that they once made are just gone. They it'll never matter for them or maybe anybody else ever. Ever again. So does that matter? Does that change things? Like why why should we care about those commitments when they're never gonna matter again?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I mean you're thinking of it. Here's the thing. I think the what you're saying makes sense if we were just thinking about preferences. Um and again, if it was just about the color, like with the way that I dress, uh or the kind of food, if let's say I like bananas right now and I've never liked apples, I don't really care if I end up only eating apples and never eating bananas again. Like there are some things like that where I think it's no longer, it's not gonna be not tasty to me anymore. Whatever, let whatever happens, happens. But I think there are with with things like values, with things that are like again, the way that we the way that we think of ourselves, like the the sort of uh bigger way that we want to represent ourselves and the way that we want to think of our life narrative, I think it does matter because it's not just about us in terms of like how things feel to us, but it's it's more about like you caring about certain issues, uh, you caring about your future self doing those things, not just because it feels good to you or not good to you right now, but just because that's that's that's what you want in general.

SPEAKER_01Um and it's the same thing. I mean, if you if you are vegetarian, you probably want other people to have that kind of like um I respect for you? R respect for your your um what you're doing. Um like not what you're doing but like but for for like what you're trying to endorse, like the things that matter to you, like their causes. There are certain causes that matter to us, not just because it feels good for us, but you actually care about them in the bigger scheme of things. Uh you care about what it says about the bigger, the bigger thing.

unknownI don't know.

SPEAKER_03I don't know if this is making sense. I don't know. I think that makes sense. Like if, you know, I was vegetarian for like my whole life. Like let's imagine I'm Peter Singer, you know, lifelong vegan. Gets to a point, loses capacity. I think that he's made it such a big part of his life that he would want his friends to keep him accountable even if he changed his mind because they would dishonor him. Like respect for his agency and his decision making.

SPEAKER_01The thing is, I mean, yeah, absolutely. That's that's a big part of it, but also just it's like representing that thing that matters to him. He doesn't ever want to be the the kind of person who is seen eating meat as though like eating meat is something that is okay. Uh it's that like what you're endorsing and what you want the whole world. Usually when we when we ha have certain Values we want other people, like they're kind of values that we want other people to also have. And it's that kind of thing that that I'm worried about. So think of um like Malala, for example, her whole life, and for the rest of her life, I imagine, um has this cause that she's that she's very committed to.

SPEAKER_01And if after she gets dementia, she says, uh, I I've never understood why women should ever be educated.

SPEAKER_03It seems like it seems heartbreaking. Seems like someone should honor her by taking down her Twitter account. And literally We're just not gonna let you say these things.

SPEAKER_01Literally, literally, literally, yes, exactly. Um, or just or just like at the very least, just like with the vegetarian example, say, no, that's not actually what the few that we should attribute to her. That's that's like a mistake.

unknownMistake.

SPEAKER_03I'm so sorry.

SPEAKER_02I just got it. I'm so sorry.

SPEAKER_06It came out of nowhere.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I want to be remembered for being funny, so well then you're gonna have to try a little harder.

SPEAKER_06No, we're good friends here.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, we'll talk about that later. This is so okay. Um, one of the things when I was reading your paper, I was really intrigued by is how like the ro the role of relationality in the sense of like uh developing your identity and understanding your sense of self. So like there are many like feminist theories about like relational autonomy and the idea that the self is not, you know, a vacuum. We don't exist in a vacuum. Who we are is made up of our relationships around us. And so I was wondering if you'd considered how like a way for those relationships to protect that person's autonomy is to continue to like uphold the values that they spent so long endorsing.

SPEAKER_03Because you might we could then justify and identify who is responsible then for helping that person who has lost capacity to continue to like practice their values. So it's like, for example, if I you know there's a stranger on the street and I I know them because they're famous, that you know, let's just say I don't know Peter. I see him on the street, I see him eating a steak. Uh I've never met him in my life, I go up and I go, You shouldn't be eating that. It's like that's really not my position to be doing that. Whereas maybe his close family and friends would have much more moral power or responsibility, even.

SPEAKER_03Um so yeah, I I was just sort of wondering if you'd thought about that.

SPEAKER_01Uh yeah, I mean that could be part of the like giving like part of the advanced directive to say this is the kind of this is who I want to be making decisions on my behalf when I'm in that, when I'm no longer have the capacity to make decisions for myself. I think that I think that's a big part of it. The thing is though, we're kind of back to the same to the same question if your post-dementia self says, no, I don't want this person making decisions on my behalf anymore. Who do you what do you do at the point twist?

SPEAKER_03Particularly when like uh people with dementia will often forget. Right, right, right, right. Um and you know, uh forcing a person or you know, forcing that relationship or friendship or forcing someone that they d no longer recognize into the room could be quite harmful to them.

SPEAKER_01But then also they could end up in a position where they would say, like, this other person no longer understands this new version of me is how I think the other side might argue too. They might say, like, okay, maybe the whoever gave the advanced directive for this person in their life for their mom or their spouse to make decisions on their behalf, that person only understands their previous version of them. They no longer understand this. So it kind of complicates this. So you still kind of have to. Yeah, we're kind of back to the same same same sort of problem. But I think I I mean what you're saying is right in line with what I want to say, which is like again, part of respecting that person's wishes and their values at that time is also respecting who they trust to make sure that those values are kept.

SPEAKER_03Just that line, you don't understand me anymore, just sounds like like a goth teenager. Nobody understands you. So on this on this grounds, maybe teenagers shouldn't be making their own decisions.

SPEAKER_06We know this.

SPEAKER_03We might have to cut that joke.

SPEAKER_06So I just want to like shift gears a little bit and now not to be that guy, I'm gonna bring in metaphysics. Um I guess so far we've kind of been um going between two kinds of modes. You know, one says we've been talking about this self and then that self, almost as if there are two separate uh people uh kind of in conflict with each other. And then at certain points we've also been talking about it as if it's the same person. And this brings up an uh a pretty old debate in philosophy about what the self means, right?

SPEAKER_06And there are some views in philosophy that um the that say the self is constituted by some of our mental states, like our memories, our personality, and our commitments. Um so there are some people who would say, uh look, if you've really changed that much as a person, if you really don't remember anything, if you really have different beliefs or values or whatever, then you might legitimately be a different person. And in a sense, it'd be weird to say the past self should have power over what the new current updated self um should be able to do.

SPEAKER_06It's a kind of like weird paternalism or uh uh unjustified authority. Um so how I guess uh what do we want to make of um this kind of argument?

SPEAKER_01I think I mean yeah, you're absolutely right. That is one view that what makes me the same me that I was yesterday is is like memories and consciousness that that I remember the things that yesterday me did. And um there are stronger accounts of this. There are accounts that'll say like if you if you don't have the same memories, you're really no longer the same person. Um that's a little bit strong because then you'd have to say that like your five-year-old self isn't really this yourself anymore.

SPEAKER_03My 7 a.m. self is not myself. I've been completely honest.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, it seems plausible.

SPEAKER_03Actually, yeah.

SPEAKER_06I think I'm literally a different person.

SPEAKER_03100%. I bec I think I become like three or four different peoples between the like times of 6 a.m. and 10 a.m.

SPEAKER_05That's impressive. It's like you have a superpower.

SPEAKER_03One way to look at it.

unknownSorry.

SPEAKER_03It is impressive. I'm doing philosophical theories here in the podcast.

SPEAKER_06Um It's like you go to Parfit or what a fancy philosopher is like, you're failing to take into account how dysfunctional I am.

SPEAKER_03Sorry, um, where were we?

SPEAKER_01Um yeah, yeah, yeah. So so yeah, there are the it's a little bit strong because I don't know if we want to make that commitment that like my my five-year-old self is not this me. Even though there's really very, very little that is very similar between you and your five-year-old self. The thing is though, I think we can keep even if we keep the same sort of account of consciousness, but we make it more about like the the I don't know how how to how to say this. There is an actual way of saying it that's just slipping me right now. Continuation. Continuation.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, the example, it's like, okay, I don't remember who I was a year, like maybe five years ago, but I remember who I was yesterday. And yesterday me remembers who I was the day before.

unknownPerfect.

SPEAKER_03That was so clear in your paper. Thank you.

SPEAKER_02Thank you. It's not clear to my friends. It's because you're a different self.

SPEAKER_06I mean we we all have the experience of like writing a paper and then like going back to it a few months later and like, what?

SPEAKER_03How yeah. It goes one or two ways. It goes, what the hell was I thinking?

SPEAKER_04Or like, damn.

SPEAKER_03I am cut out for this.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Thank you so much for helping me out. They're welcome.

SPEAKER_01Uh yes, connection. Yeah, so that that's right. So I think like a much more we can still stick to the view and say, like, you know, we don't have to say that the self is only the self because of like numerical identity, that like it's the one is one. Uh, we can say like it's still about consciousness, it's still about memory, but um, it's more about the connection. Like I'm connected, yeah, I'm strongly connected to my yesterday self, straw, and my yesterday self is strongly connected to my two days ago self, and so on, until back when I was five years old. And so, if that's how we think of it, I think there is a good reason to still think that patients with dementia um are still have still have the same identity.

SPEAKER_01Um, there are have been some studies that have been done that kind of show some reasons that that tell us that they are the same person. Um, so you know, things like them saying, like them just even acknowledging that there was a time where they were different, them saying, like, I used to, I used to remember more. I don't, I'm my memory's not as good as it used to be, or I used to read more, or like little things like that where there is some some connection that hasn't been 100% severed. There is still some link to some previous version of themselves.

SPEAKER_01Uh, and I think that even if it comes out every once in a while, even if it comes out on some days, I think that's enough of a reason to think that they're not actually two separate people in the way that a stranger would be. Um we don't have to say it's the same relationship that you have to your yesterday self, um, but we can say it's it's stronger than a relationship you would have to a stranger where you have no business telling them what their values should be or what they should hold on to and what commitments they're not allowed to break.

SPEAKER_03I like the idea of um leaving room for just like changing one's mind. Like it's completely acceptable to be vegetarian or not. Not according to Peter Singer, but um and so it's it's you can you know look at someone with dementia and be like, okay, like yeah, you're right. Like you you remember that that you used to be this, but you uh you decided or you that you're not now. Um but it that would be very different to someone going, what do you mean I never ate meat?

SPEAKER_03I think the way you worded it was just so interesting. It's just that if you don't have that capacity for like reflecting on your values and checking your preferences in line with your values, then you know, you're you're just you are a completely different person. You sort of lack those capacities to make agential decisions that you know we should be respecting.

SPEAKER_06So this leaves me wondering about something because I like I think I'm persuaded by the idea that there's some sense in which I've made a mistake if I uh have a commitment and I just you know go like eh, don't feel like it uh the next day. But usually in many cases, that's not people might say, hey, you want to think about that a little bit more? But it's usually not a call for people to stop me. So um I guess would people be morally justified or would people have the right to stop dementia patients from just eating meat if they just felt like it?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I love that question. Yeah, because you might say, why? Why do we have this um this benefit? Yeah, if I if I committed to stop drinking or stop smoking, whatever it is, and then tomorrow I just went and I wanted to. Yeah, you could say it's a mistake, I committed and then I broke my commitment, but who has the right to to like actually stop me?

SPEAKER_06I shouldn't step in.

SPEAKER_01You shouldn't step in. I I'm Oh, I'll step in. See, we need that. We need a friend like that.

SPEAKER_03Not for his benefit, but because I can just tell him what to do.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, she likes doing that. It's like a sport for a.

SPEAKER_01Oh yeah. Um, but yeah, I the thing is though, we have we have that benefit because we are still capable of second order volitions, and we may not always employ it, we may not always use it, but it is there. Um and so the fact that we have access to it, I think is something that differentiates us from that. And again, when we're when the question isn't about like what you should do given that you have the capacity to do whatever you want, but the question becomes what is in the best interest of your overall self, taking into account the the the then self and the now self, the the predimential and post-dimensional self, which which one, given that there are conflicting values, conflicting preferences, what should we do that's gonna benefit the overall well-being of the patient?

SPEAKER_01What is really in their most overall interest? And if we would ask that about you, if you committed to not smoking, and then let's say, let's say you you wanted to buy a pack of cigarettes and we wanted to figure out for your overall self what really is the best decision, the best decision would be the one that you arrived at using your second order volitions when you had the capacity. And so I think it's a different case. We're allowed to because we have the option to employ our second-order volitions at any point. We just sometimes choose not to, uh, versus literally just not having access to it.

SPEAKER_01And I think when you don't have access to it, you really do need to rely now on being um what's the word, like bonded. There's a yeah, like binding future, binding yourself. Yes, yeah, like binding yourself. Um I think we do need that when we literally just don't have the capacity for it anymore. Um, but again, just thinking overall of the decision. Again, it is a mistake. We if you were to always be making decisions that were in your overall best interest, you wouldn't break a commitment that you thought about very well.

SPEAKER_01And so when we think about what we should do, what should we let patients have when they when their new preferences conflict with their prior ones, which one is less likely to be an error? Um, and it's really, I want to say it's the one that they've arrived at the decision they've arrived at, the values and the preferences they arrived at after that kind of reflection that comes from having access to the capacity to form segno revelations.

SPEAKER_03Do you have any final questions?

SPEAKER_06Uh no, I there's so many questions.

SPEAKER_04It's a touch thing to end on so little time. Yes.

SPEAKER_06But so little time. So I think we'll just end it there. And maybe we'll have you back for part two when we talk about dying.

SPEAKER_03Uh it has been an absolute pleasure. We've had so much fun on this podcast. It's been like, I think, more laughing than talking.

SPEAKER_06It's a good sign.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_06For the listeners, I don't know what the experience will be for.

SPEAKER_03Let us know in the comments.

SPEAKER_06Let us know in the comments. Remember to like and subscribe.

SPEAKER_03I told you his accents would come out.

SPEAKER_02What was that? Was that an accent?

SPEAKER_06What when did you say his accents would come out?

SPEAKER_02No, we weren't here. Anyway, thank you so much. Thank you so much. Thank you guys.

SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and U and be savvy.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Can Nihilism Improve Your Mental Wellbeing?

    Nov 2, 202645 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Insurance Discrimination: Is it Fair? with Harisan Nasir

    Sep 24, 202649 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Genomic Newborn Screening: Where less really is sometimes more with Ainsley Newson

    Aug 25, 202655 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Hidden Side of Birth: Injury, Trauma, and PTSD with Angela Ballantyne

    Jul 2, 202648 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Brains in Jars with Insoo Hyun

    Jun 1, 202656 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...

    Credit the people on this episode