Send us Fan Mail Is feminist science more than just having more women in STEM? Is science itself capable of being a form of feminism? Have you ever wondered whether there's more to science than Nobel Prizes and almost magical discoveries? In this episode, Professor Deboleena Roy (Emory University), a neuroscientist and behavioural biologist, discusses what it means to do feminist science and be a feminist scientist. In so doing, Deboleena helps Sinead find meaning in the five laborous, monotonous weeks she spent in a lab in 2018, doing what amounted to what she thought was nothing. Remember people, be savvy!
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The center presents a new podcast, CBMENU, a podcast devoted to promoting awareness and debate around controversial ethical issues in biomedicine.
SPEAKER_02Welcome back to CBMENU. On our second episode of the season, we have Professor Devolina Roy from Emory College of Arts and Sciences, an expert in neuroscience and behavioral biology, and in capital letters, feminist theory.
SPEAKER_01Welcome, welcome. We are so happy to have you here. Thank you for having me. Now we're gonna um ask you a question that uh we ask everyone, and I'm so excited to know your answer because I've heard a little bit of it. Do you prefer coffee or coffee?
SPEAKER_04Okay, so um when I was doing research coming here, I understood that I had to try coffee, and I made that part of my research plan for this morning and actually had it, and it was life-changing. So definitely going forward, as soon as I can get it, again, coffee is gonna be the way to go. Oh wow.
SPEAKER_01Really is do you just get traditional straight coffee?
SPEAKER_04Yes. Um, if traditional straight means with some milk. Yeah, okay. Yeah, that's one. That's sweet. That's so good. So good, yes. Um, very chocolatey. Yes, uh, love the undertones.
SPEAKER_01Be careful. So when I first moved here, um I am also a massive avid coffee drinker, and I was so excited to find these copies that are$1,$1.40, and you get so much in it. And so for about three months I was having these. And then Josh and I uh finally Googled how much caffeine is in them, and it's like three times your normal amount in a flat wife. No wonder I didn't sleep for like three months.
SPEAKER_04You know, I uh I felt this feels like three times the level, and uh I was offered more coffee. I thought, not not before the talk. And then I thought good too.
SPEAKER_02Something's gotta get you through the Singaporean work day. Did anybody try to uh teach you about the different ways of ordering copy? Uh copy o copy sutai and all that. Oh no. There there's about 50 different permutations you can Okay, so I hope I didn't do it wrong.
SPEAKER_04Um, but whatever I asked for, they gave me something very delicious.
SPEAKER_02So it must have been okay. Yeah. All right. Yeah. I think the default way of making it is just put all of this stuff.
unknownOkay, yeah.
SPEAKER_02A bit less of this, I want less sugar, less uh less milk. Yeah, okay, yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_04More research for tonight. So much more research.
SPEAKER_01Maybe tomorrow. Tomorrow morning. Yes, 6 a.m. So the caffeine burns off. Yes. Um, our next question is where do you want to travel to next?
SPEAKER_04Where do I want to travel? Well, actually, I'm uh headed there in a few days. So Australia. I've never been. I'm headed to Sydney. Um, so I'm looking forward to connecting with some colleagues and friends there. Um, but then after that, um I think it might be time to go to Egypt. I've been thinking about Egypt a lot lately, and uh yeah, so I think the pyram uh the pyramids are on my horizon.
SPEAKER_01Oh, what a good line that pyramids are on my horizon.
SPEAKER_02I can just see the tops of a mistake. The tops that used to be coated in gold.
SPEAKER_01I can really recommend Sydney. Uh I haven't been to Egypt. Uh my mother has, okay, which I'm really proud of her for because she doesn't travel a lot, but yeah.
SPEAKER_04All the best with that. Yeah, it's it's time to start making that list. You know, I I I've got, I hope, several more years and you know, years of travel, but I think, you know, making those big trips, you've got to start planning it early. So yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's one of the things I like about living in Singapore though, is that because it's just so what from Australia, it's like eight hours and you're still in Australia. Whereas in Singapore, two hours and you're like three countries away. It's amazing.
SPEAKER_02Half an hour you're out of Singapore.
SPEAKER_0120 minutes. Literally a 20-minute ferry. Yep. Uh, and our final and favorite question. Okay. What song is your favorite song to sing at karaoke?
SPEAKER_02I noticed you took in a deep breath. It's like, okay, I can do this.
SPEAKER_04No, it's because it's a it's a very meaningful question to me. So I um I am a singer and I'm trained in North Indian classical vocal. And in fact, um, our family has a family band. We're called the Lollipops. So I'm serious. I like I sing and uh I also play the bass, and so um singing is part of our lives every day. I will say that people have told me uh that I sound like Karen Carpenter. I don't know if you all know who Karen Carpenter is. I'm sorry, sorry to go.
SPEAKER_04On top of the world. Is that map? Yeah, yeah. So um any uh the the go-to song is usually a Karen Carpenter.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Wow. If you were sticking around on Friday, James and I are going out for karaoke.
SPEAKER_04Okay.
SPEAKER_01So if you want, you can uh give give us some songs to do homework on.
SPEAKER_04I would have loved that, but I think I will be in Sydney on Friday.
SPEAKER_01Are you sure you don't want to stick around? Um we are so I'm particularly excited to uh have you um come on the podcast to talk about your book, which what is the exact title of it again?
SPEAKER_04That's a good question. I should know this one. Um, Molecular Feminisms, Biology Becomings, and Life in the Lab.
SPEAKER_01An incredible and like extraordinary amount of work um and theory going into that book. So uh as someone who has struggled a bit to reconcile my feminist approaches to ethics and then my also uh background in biomedical science, I am so excited for you to teach me so much work. I tried, I read uh one of your chapters, um, but it just opened up so many more questions, and I'm so glad that we have you. So, my very first question for me and also uh all of our listeners is what is feminist theory when it comes to science?
SPEAKER_01Like, can can we even categorize it that broadly for this context?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, let's start there. How about? Um, and I think your point about um when you go into something, more questions arrive. That's been one of the best parts of this intellectual journey for me as an interdisciplinary scholar, as a feminist, as a scientist, and someone try to actually bring those two words together as a feminist scientist. It's all about questions and new questions every encounter. Um, so if you're asking what is um kind of feminist theory broadly and how does it apply to science, um there are many different approaches, as many as there are to how people would define feminism.
SPEAKER_04So, for uh most of us, um, we know feminism as kind of a um a strategy or a structure, a way of thinking um to bring equality between um women and men. Equality in society, equality in legal status, inquality in labor and work. And of course, that is an important project of feminism. Um for myself, what uh and where I'm coming from, um kind of from multiple lenses, not only through gender, but also through perhaps race, uh sexuality, um, ability, and all kinds of other kinds of measures, feminism serves as a tool for me, as a kind of a toolkit to think about difference, to think about um how have we established a norm and who gets to reside in that norm or belong to that group, and then who becomes an other when once you've established a norm.
SPEAKER_04And so feminism gives me the tools to think about um to think from the margins or places that have become the margins, and to um think about structural ways to change um our way of thinking. Uh, and that could be for something as philosophical as the question of subjectivity, or it could be uh how do I approach a uh a lab experiment and think about this this differently? Um, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Do you have some examples of specific problems and how maybe a feminist scientist would approach that problem or approach that uh a set of uh scientific questions differently from how a uh a normie scientist might do it? A normie. Yeah, normie. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Well, okay, so once again, it could be in different ways. I'll I'll start with what might be um something that people usually, when they see that I'm in um neuroscience and women's studies, they would assume, for example, that I study women's brains, which I don't. Um and in fact, the idea that one could create this binary between, you know, that this would be a male brain and this would be a female brain, and just to use gender as the one key distinguishing factor for an organ is a very strange thing to do, right?
SPEAKER_04Uh, because our physiology is made of all kinds of other things, not just by the hormones or the genes that um make one an XX or an XY, you know, holding individual. So that might be a feminist way to think about science and doing scientific research is okay, well, you know, not enough work has been done on women's brains or on women's bodies, for example. And those are valid questions in some regard. You know, there have been studies to show that um certain drugs that have, you know, been put out there, they only used 35-year-old white men as the model.
SPEAKER_04And because women's uh typically might have a smaller stature or their weight might be less, they were overdosing in all of these kind of drugs scenarios. So studying women in as, you know, for clinical work is important and different groups, but once again, it's not the type of research that I'm interested in. Once again, bringing kind of that feminist lens, and for me, it's a philosophical lens of how do we think differently around um scientific questions.
SPEAKER_04Um, in my own research, I um I worked on GNRH neurons, which are gonodotropin-releasing hormone neurons. They're found in the hypothalamus of the brain, and um, they are part of what is known as the HPG axis or the hypothalamus uh hypothalamic pituitary gonadal axis. This axis, for example, um, and other axes in the body are often thinking thought of in these hierarchical terms, and particularly when you're talking about neuroscience and the brain, the brain is supposed to be kind of the master of it all, sending down signals and orders to the rest of the body.
SPEAKER_04The idea that actually the rest of the body, in fact, you know, has a feedback mechanism and is influencing the brain is a different way to build a paradigm. Instead of this like hierarchical HPG axis, you can think about it in terms of a feedback loop where the brain is also being acted upon and it's not just sending out the control signals, right? Um, so to me, that's a feminist approach to thinking about biology. It's reorienting a dominant paradigm of hierarchy.
SPEAKER_01I remember one time I saw a video, and I'm not entirely sure if it's true, about the ways in which we use language to convey certain meanings and science. And I remember learning that, and this was not in my biomedical science degree whatsoever. This was just on Facebook one day. So please let's question this if it's true.
SPEAKER_02This idea Most of our citations on this podcast come from YouTube videos or Instagram redes.
SPEAKER_01Just a disclaimer. Yes, yes. So it's this idea that uh we always talk about how the sperm will find the egg, but actually we are discovering that it's the other way around. The sperm is so useless that the egg actually has to go find the sperm and be like, hey, bud, I'm here. And just that terminology, that idea that like it's the sperm finding the egg, it's doing all the work, it's such a strong swimmer, but it's actually the other way around. I felt that quite interesting. So is this what kind of what you're talking about?
SPEAKER_01How if we finally start to look at these problems differently, question the the like the language as well that we're using these sorts of things?
SPEAKER_04Yes. So let me just clarify, I think the sperm is not useless altogether. Um, but um I beg to differ. But you're right. It's it's about the language that's been used to describe a biological part or entity. It's the paradigm that then influences how we actually do the research, right? So um I remember when I had just started my doctoral work, I was in a lab that was beside a lab that was doing reproductive technologies research. And the uh experiments that they were working on was literally to use a kind of uh a drill, a laser to drill a hole into an oocyte so that a sperm could be, you know, forcibly uh, you know, put into this egg.
SPEAKER_04So that paradigm, you know, that would have been used would have followed that, you know, the sperm does all the work and the egg is just this passive entity, right? Um, as kind of like the female of all, right? It's thought as the passive, the vessel. Um, and so, but literally a technology was being designed to drill a hole into an oocyte to get a sperm inside, when all the research around what signals could an oocyte be sending out there as well to uh invite a sperm in or to you know make that that happen, that kind of research only started after.
SPEAKER_04So, but we develop actual science and technologies and see the world in a certain way that is based on our language, our paradigms, and quite frankly, our politics as well.
SPEAKER_02So um it sounds like what what happen what's happening is that there's a whole bunch of like disparate kinds of ideas or criticisms that are coming together here. There's the idea that oh, there's certain features of our human biobiology that are turned turns out more active than we thought it would be, or we haven't thought that it's active because, well, it's called an egg, you know, obviously it's not gonna be active. Or and there's criticisms of hierarchy, and I think you mentioned subjectivity earlier. So it seems like there's a lot of different threads that we're pulling together and we're calling like feminist theory.
SPEAKER_02Is there a a way of like pulling them together and saying, oh yeah, this is how they're all feminist, or like a way of almost unifying it? Or do you want to resist that?
SPEAKER_04So there we go. So that tendency to unify, right? And to have this like kind of overarching understanding and to go forward. Um, I think I would resist that. And that maybe is also coming from a different like form of critique of um, you know, maybe a post-colonial critique. That, you know, we don't want to just colonize our ideas, we don't want one unified uh kind of way to just see all of being.
SPEAKER_04Um, that there are other stories. So yeah, I do resist the kind of like feminist series, it's one thing. Like I say, if I am to say it's one thing, it's a toolkit. And whether you want to use that to think about um equality in pay, that's a way to go about making that happen. It's a type of, it's an exercise, it's a type of politics to organize, to advocate, to do research, to do change and make that kind of happen. Um but if it's also a way to question the identity of like what counts as a woman, um, you know, or are there only two genders?
SPEAKER_04Um, we could use a feminist toolkit to kind of queer those ideas as well.
SPEAKER_01So one of the things that I picked up, and um let me know if this is a wrong interpretation, is that you're quite careful to delineate feminism from merely being like the addition of women insides, um, in in the inclusive term of what that means. Um and so what I interpret that to mean is that we're not necessarily going to address the inequities and inequalities that we find in health and all of research essentially, by simply having more women. Um so you know, like this idea of you know, um, women being in male-dominated or men-dominated fields.
SPEAKER_01Have you seen the jokes about King uh Kim Jong-un's daughter becoming the first woman dictator and how exc exciting we are excited we are to see women arriving in these traditionally male-dominated industries? Yes.
SPEAKER_02I mean dictatorial tyrants. I feel like women can do that too.
SPEAKER_04Women can be dictators too. Yes. Yeah, it is kind of like that. You know, if we are to have more women enter into the sciences, but nothing about the sciences change, I don't think that that's necessarily the project. You know, in in the US and uh the National Science Foundation uh for decades has used this metaphor called the pipeline, you know, the you know, the pipeline theory, and that there's all these leaks in the pipeline. Where is it that, you know, there are the leaks that women are not staying in the sciences? Uh so for example, you know, you might have a certain number of in in biology, the field of biology, more than 50% of undergrads are women in biology.
SPEAKER_04And then when you get to the postdocs, it's still over 50%. But then it drops off. And all of a sudden, if you're looking at, you know, researchers in labs or in in universities, in tenure-track jobs, that number goes down to like 30%. And then you look at full professors, it's something like 12, right? So where are the leaks in that pipeline? And the idea would be you somehow like, you know, clog up those leaks so it's not happening anymore. But with what? You know, um, if the idea of that pipeline is just and duct tape, as we know, it's what a man.
SPEAKER_01Thank you for that contribution, James. That was really helpful.
SPEAKER_04WD40.
SPEAKER_01But after a while it doesn't, Professor Debolina was never gonna figure that out on her own. Thank you.
SPEAKER_04Um, but we found that, you know, um duct tape isn't always the best thing.
SPEAKER_01But James, have you considered no?
SPEAKER_04I mean, it's useful, but the pipe itself is the problem. And the idea that you're gonna put everybody in and fit them in in one place and they're all gonna come out in the same way, that is the issue. So then if you could reformulate that's not a pipeline that we need, and what we need is like an expansive kind of you know, stellar like kind of um cosmos of different ideas that people can contribute within that, um, then you don't need duct tape. And uh you you can knowledge can grow in different ways.
SPEAKER_04So uh so my whole thing about having more women enter into science, it doesn't necessarily solve the problem or get us to ask the type of scientific questions that I think we need to. Um and at the same time, if there are men who are thinking differently, who um they don't have to call themselves feminist, but are coming with the kind of different uh orientation and approach to knowing the world, then that's great. That's what we also need. And in fact, in my experiences of you know, training and becoming a scientist, I have had many colleagues who are men who are pushing those questions.
SPEAKER_01So I like that in your book um you call them the nitty-gritty practices in the lab. This idea that we can develop practice-oriented approaches that scientists, regardless of their gender or their identification with feminist politics, can make these very specific changes to do the kind of science that it is that you're talking about. Could you give could you give like a couple of examples or one example of like the nitty-gritty as well?
SPEAKER_04Yes, okay.
SPEAKER_01What would you recommend?
SPEAKER_04So, what I mean by the nitty-gritty is is the like kind of the everyday things that you don't really aren't glamorous and you don't really giving give an accounting of it. Maybe in a methods section you might talk about it, but I'm I'm talking about, for example, you know, um pipetting uh and the hours that one spends pipetting. I'm talking about the hours in a dark room trying to look at, you know, images.
SPEAKER_04I'm talking about that scientist who um I remember this, this was at a Keck Foundation conference that I had gone to, where there was a man, he must have been in his 70s, maybe even early 80s, who was standing beside his poster and his entire career he had studied one protein, right? And he was there to talk about that one protein and its relationships to other molecules, but he was all about that one protein for 50 years.
SPEAKER_04He'd been thinking about this. I can't even think about the same thing for like 15 minutes. And to me, that is, you know, uh an example of um like getting absorbed into the daily, into those kind of very small practices that actually bring movement and have uh movement. And I think maybe I'm talking as a molecular biologist too, that the nitty-gritty is that which often we don't see and it's obscure. But once you start seeing it, it brings a lot of meaning.
SPEAKER_02So, in case it wasn't clear, I'm the apple in this duel.
SPEAKER_01So for this podcast. For this podcast.
SPEAKER_02So so I I guess I've got a uh slightly like push it push pushy back question. Okay. And it does sound like w we have cost of Really, really expansive net here. Like, like uh, as long as it's al it almost sounds to me like as long as you're coming in with a different kind of perspective, you're a feminist uh in in in science. And to quote one of my favorite movies, if everybody is super, nobody is super, no one will be.
SPEAKER_01Is that Mr. Incredible?
SPEAKER_02Uh yeah, it's from The Incredibles. You know, so so what if somebody says, well, if everybody's a feminist, then nobody's a feminist. Yeah, the do is there a risk here of trying of trying to cast the net a bit too wide?
SPEAKER_04Sure. So then maybe I should uh roll about maybe there's some assumptions here that um if you are interested in questions of um difference and you are aware that you know certain individuals um have privilege, that you've had to live a life where, you know, um you've been marked as another, where you can see that there are inequalities and that you are dedicated to um addressing those inequalities.
SPEAKER_04I think that's kind of the groundwork you need to do to call yourself a feminist to begin with. Um yeah, and that doesn't just happen overnight. That has to happen through one, you know, um living uh life experience and being part of a community and knowing that, you know, um it's our role uh to actually advocate and make changes and to have that kind of a um advocacy and activist orientation.
SPEAKER_04So I think that is probably uh like a starting place.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um, but once again, like you know, if somebody claims that they they see an inequality, and once again, it doesn't have to be based on gender for me, but it's some other reason, whether it's a um a learning style, if if it is through, you know, a neurodivergence, like are we, is it through design, is it through like body abilities? Like if there's a lived experience that then says, you know what, we need to be actually thinking about something differently here. Are we serving everyone that we can be? Do we need to revisit the design of uh you know a building, a ramp, or you know, those are the kinds of um things I think I would count as being a feminist motivation to then produce knowledge in a new way.
SPEAKER_04Does that's actually really helpful.
SPEAKER_01Is that kind of like a Venn diagram where on the left you might have people who identify as feminists, and then on the right, like this kind of different sort of science that you're talking about, like outside the conventions, and they can overlap. A person can be both feminist and pursuing these sorts of sciences, but you don't necessarily have to be a feminist in order to think differently. Exactly.
SPEAKER_04And you don't need to call yourself that. So I do because I come from a certain kind of um training and history and um interest in social justice movements. But once again, you know, that one uh that scientist who's been studying that protein that other people thought, you know, why are you doing this for so long? They're convinced this has a role, this we need to understand it, um, and stick to that. To me, there's something about that way of coming to the world um that um actually um it dislodges kind of this hierarchical uh mode of being or chain of being, right?
SPEAKER_04So, okay, let me let me backtrack a bit. In in knowing this person who studied a protein for so long, I think that they came to see the natural world in a way that they could really learn from that world. And that became their life pursuit, right? Not the scientist going in to um discover the world, get what they needed, extract what they needed, and move on. But rather just be with this molecule and be with this and learn from it for so long. To me, something about that kind of reorientation to getting to know the world or getting to be with nature, that to me is a big paradigm shift.
SPEAKER_04And for and then I translate that as a practice within feminist science. Like you got a paradigm shift, and you, you know, you have to rewrite those those models and metaphors and how we think about things. Um, but once again, this person would never have called himself a feminist, but I find that to be a feminist project.
SPEAKER_02I wonder if you could call Thomas Kuhn a feminist project. Sure.
SPEAKER_04I mean paradigm shifts. Yeah, uh, you know, if you're talking about paradigm shifts, that these things happen in science, that you, you know, this is how science happens. I think that's that is an important element, and feminist scientists have learned from that a great deal.
SPEAKER_01So I kind of um this kind of got me thinking about this one time. I spent five weeks in a lab trying to combine two pieces of DNA so that we could genetically modify bacteria to test a particular protein. It didn't work um because turns out recombining DNA is really hard. You know, but for a long time I thought about how um, you know, when my uh supervisor told me that it didn't work, we thought it had worked, but it didn't. And I was like, oh, that really sucks. Like I wasted five weeks. And she was like, no, like you did so much work in five weeks that I wouldn't have been able to get to in my own schedule.
SPEAKER_01Like you accelerated a lot of research for me, and we now know it doesn't work that way. And so this sort of uh what you were talking about brought back that memory, and it it it reminds reminds me of something else you wrote in your book, which is that uh in feminist approaches, a purposeful effort is made to avoid the tide and predictable tendencies found throughout most scholarly traditions that would have us believe that theoretical progress can only occur by dismissing or discrediting previous forms of scholarship. It's this idea that you haven't made it unless you've discovered something brand new, you know, like the light bulb or electricity or an atom.
SPEAKER_01You're not really big unless you've, you know, got 10,000 citations in nature. But what you're talking about with your colleague is that he just did his thing in quiet time. Sorry, um, they did their thing in quiet time and just did what worked for them. And that was the practice-oriented approach that brought about something really interesting, regardless of how the world sees it.
SPEAKER_04So my question after all of that, I I love this reflection, actually.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. If we all aren't like so focused on discovering the next best thing and competition, but appreciating and advancing sort of as a collective, you do that thing, you work on that protein, we'll we'll all do something different. And it's not about who gets to the top first, it's how we get there together. How would this impact our current like scientific or scholarship model?
SPEAKER_04That's such a great question. And it takes me back to when I was an undergrad and I had the great privilege of meeting with um the scientist Ursula Franklin. I've written about her some in some other project of mine, but Ursula Franklin was a professor of um geology, I think, in um the University of Toronto. And um she used to talk about if she could have all the money and you know um uh research funding support to give out, she would create an institute of unfundable research.
SPEAKER_04And that to me was uh her saying that I mean your project of five weeks and it didn't work. Sorry much pipetting. But you see exactly right. Uh but you see that that itself, we didn't know that it wasn't gonna work. But then also, but it did work because you found out something that this doesn't do what we thought it was gonna do. That's research we need to know. Otherwise, again and again, other people will try to do it and then it won't work or work in that way.
SPEAKER_04But maybe your research did work and it did a type of work that then is contributing to science making, right, and knowledge making. Right. So um, and though that drive for always getting that positive result, right? Where in fact, if we don't learn from the negative results, right, we won't know what a positive result is. So just reframing what counts as knowledge and what counts as a scientific contribution, I think is important for all of us to and when you've been in the sciences long enough, you know that you know, more than half the times the experiments fail.
SPEAKER_04But if we didn't do that work, how would we Yeah, it didn't work for a reason. Yes, yes. And then now we need then you get to explore, well, why didn't it work? Right. So um anyway, that un that idea, now that's not how you know big federal funding agencies are usually structured that you know go ahead and keep failing at something and then you know, but in a way, uh this is why I science as a kind of a whole community of knowers, we're all relying on each other because we will find out from someone else, hey, this this did not make it happen.
SPEAKER_04Um, where we're trying to head, we need to try something different, right? And so you get to join a community of knowers and share that um experience.
SPEAKER_02I really like that. Uh I I can't wait for somebody to pick up my grants about dinosaurs and trolley problem.
unknownOh what?
SPEAKER_01I'm sorry, I haven't had about this one.
SPEAKER_02Oh, the one that I haven't written.
SPEAKER_04Oh, okay, okay, okay.
SPEAKER_02But you know, if somebody would pick it up, I think I'd write. Somebody unfund fund my unfundable.
SPEAKER_04Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_02So there's one uh one one of the threats that I picked up on in some of your work, and then I think in a lot of other things, uh feminist um research literature as well, is the idea of the subjective. Um so it's a criticism of the standard scientific model that uh there's some certain objective facts out there uh that we need to go out there and we're just gonna find using certain methods and we're gonna figure it out. And I think one criticism that I've seen is the the introduction of the uh the subjective or the point of view or the intersubjective uh or something like that.
SPEAKER_02Uh could you say a little bit more about that? Because I think that's quite interesting.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and this comes back to I think what you were saying before, um, Shaineed, about uh how to think about objectivity. If you're um you're a feminist and you're trying to do feminist science, this idea of um, you know, objectivity and the critique of objectivity that is important, I think, through a feminist science lens and a feminist STS lens is really um how do we define that objectivity and is that objectivity even possible?
SPEAKER_04So it's been important for me as a scientist and also training other scientists to not start off the conversation and say no such thing as objectivity. And because that's such a grounded idea of how it is that we do science, at least Western modern science. Um, and what was helpful to me and what I try to share with others is actually turning to the work of a lot of historians of science. Um, in fact, uh, work by um Lorraine Dastin and Peter Gallison.
SPEAKER_04They wrote this, like I think it's 700 pages, uh, this book called Objectivity. And it's a history of the concept of objectivity. And apparently there's something been something like you know, 18 different understandings of what objectivity is over in the last few hundred years.
SPEAKER_0218 is low.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Um, but the one that's really stuck is the version it's called aperspectival objectivity. So it's the idea that you can actually try to know something from a position of nowhere, of having no perspective.
SPEAKER_02The view from nowhere.
SPEAKER_04The view from nowhere, right? Or what Donna Harrowy would talk about as the God trick, kind of, right? That you somehow, as a scientist, are in this kind of very um neutral space, you're not coming with your own ideas or histories or language or perspectives, and you're able to know an object of inquiry, right? Um, and so you know, going back to this example around the sperm and the egg, right?
SPEAKER_04So if the stories have been that the egg or the oocyte is inactive, it's passive, it's aligned with the female, it's the vessel, it's the receptor, it's not supposed to be active. And you're a scientist now and you're studying reproduction and you're studying how eggs and sperm interact, the idea that you could be aperspectival, like we're not a perspectival uh beings.
SPEAKER_04We all come from cultures, we have our certain traditions, rituals, language. So you don't get like just putting on a white lab coat doesn't erase all that. You actually bring that with you into the science that you do. So so the idea that one could can still have or does build up an experiment, I'm not disputing that. But I don't think objectivity in this aperspectival sense actually can exist. And so there have been other philosophers and you know, uh philosophers of science and feminist science studies scholars who have tried to develop, well, how do we still do experiments?
SPEAKER_04How do we still believe in science, but not cling to this idea of this view from nowhere? And um actually admit that, well, we come with certain biases, but let's put those biases on the table. And then, in fact, we we do that, we might actually get a more objective science once we know what our biases are. Um, so all of these have been framed in different ways. Um, for example, Donna Haraway's idea of situated knowledges is that we can produce knowledge, it's just gonna come from somewhere, right?
SPEAKER_04Uh, and in fact, there might be, you know, for feminist scholars who talk about standpoint theory, they might argue, for example, that in fact, if you're doing, for example, research on a group of people and you don't speak their language or you don't, you don't know where they're coming, you know, where they're coming from, it's hard for you to actually produce knowledge that's gonna be of use to them. And the fact that that person belongs to a group who knows the most about themselves, right?
SPEAKER_04And they have some kind of epistemic privilege in what they're gonna be able to tell you is important for for the research you're gonna do. So um that distance, and I call that a distance between the knower and the known. Um, in my work and in feminist work, I think we try to break break that distance down in order to do the research and not try to keep that distance um between that relationship.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, when I was in undergrad, I and I first came across some of this literature, I had a worry. Uh, and it's that there's the kind of uh trope that it that we have in pop culture that the masculine or men is supposed to be objective and the feminine is associated with the subjective. And I I had this worry when I first encountered this literature. Uh, can you tell me now if I should continue to be worried about this?
SPEAKER_04Um sorry, your worry was about this plays into the trope a bit too much. Yes. So I mean, relying on those kinds of dualisms is that that Cartesian kind of split between mind and body, right? They have been aligned with the masculine and then the feminine. So the fem the feminine gets tied, or the female gets tied to the body and to a certain type of materiality. Whereas the male gets uh identified with the mind or intellectual or something else. Or, or if you want to talk about the um body and soul split as well.
SPEAKER_04Like, and then those binaries get attached to ways of framing the world. And so I think, yeah, you one should continue to question and probe that. Um, and I would I would argue that that reliance on that kind of distinction um is what um, you know, what I call a molecular feminism is trying to break apart those kinds of dualisms and break apart that kind of idea that you have a unified entity that is only a mind or that is only a body, right?
SPEAKER_04That it they can be such divided.
SPEAKER_01I completely understand um what you were saying about how if you're trying to understand a group of people and what um is most important to them, they're going to have the best knowledge and the best understanding of what that is. And I I see how feminism so beautifully sits within things like sociology or the social sciences, where you're studying people's behaviors. And forgive me if I haven't been able to quickly enough adapt this onto molecular biology. But how how does that apply when what you're studying is things like DNA or molecules, or you're trying to see how a certain chemical interacts with another chemical?
SPEAKER_01How might this apply in those contexts? Your understandings of objectivity?
SPEAKER_04Yes, that's a great question. Um because it doesn't translate so quickly. Um, because you know, um it takes a while to um kind of and a kind of a lifetime of work to appreciate a type of togetherness that you might have with a non-human entity, right? And so uh part of this project of molecular feminisms is to really think about the non-human and how do you develop a relationship uh relationality, or how does that relation already exist, but we've been taught not to know it.
SPEAKER_04Um, and so here I would turn to the work of, for example, Barbara McClintock, who I also talk about a great deal in my work. Um have you ever heard of Barbara McClintock? Okay, Barbara McClintock, um she won a Nobel Prize in um biology for her work on transposons. And so she was a professor at Cornell University and uh probably for you know 40 years of her adult life studied um um maize, corn, and looking at the the um chromosomes of maize.
SPEAKER_04And she describes um, or it is described in a book that's written about her. The book is called A Feeling for the Organism. Um, it's written by Evelyn Fox Keller. Uh Evelyn Fox Keller describes Barbara McClintock's work for that, you know, for decades basically that uh Barbara McClintock used to look through a microscope at the DNA, at the chromosomes of these corn of corn. And it was from that careful, careful work, that nitty-gritty, that she literally saw jumping genes, genes moving from a piece of it, like from a one chromosome to another.
SPEAKER_04And because she was in and with that uh DNA in that close relationship for so long, developed a relationship with with that moment, with that kind of uh experience, that she was able to make this discovery. To me, that is developing a different kind of relation to the non-human that I think um that's what I'm drawing on in like learning from. So it's not a community of knowers that speak a language that you can understand, but it's a different type of community of no knowers that you form when you're working with these non-human actants.
SPEAKER_01I think the way my brain is picturing that or describing that to me is kind of like instead of saying these are my cells, like we used to talk about in the lab, like, oh, I've got to like, you know, feed my cells or my cells, they're so annoying, like they're so, they're so picky with me, they'll just like die out of nowhere. And you you call it like this, this is my research, this is you know what I know. It's like I'm coming into the room just waiting to see what's before me rather than trying to own it or step into that space as like I am the knower and you will be known.
SPEAKER_01That's right, right?
SPEAKER_04Because you get thwarted all the time, right? If it was this like one-way relation and this is the dominant, I'm the scientist who would get to, I get to come in, do what I need to do, and extract what I need, and then you're out of here, right? That's not how it kind of works. And in fact, uh, one of the examples that I also talk about and is working with the in vitro cell line, you know, I was studying uh estrogen receptors expression in in these cell lines in this GNRH um model of neurons, and uh then I went on to study circadian rhythmicity in these neurons and looking at the impact of melatonin on GNRH and on reproduction.
SPEAKER_04And for years, for years, I had to do, whenever I'd set up an experiment, I had to do time points to measure GNRH secretion every six hours. And so what did that mean? That meant I had a time point at you know, eight, eight p.m., two a.m. eight a.m. for years. So my own circadian rhythmicity was impacted by me studying the circadian rhythmicity of these cells, and they were doing this on me, you know.
SPEAKER_04I I became part of the feedback loop in this, and so to see myself as um not this knower who could who had control over, but that I too was controlled by the system that I was participating in, that was a reconfiguration that I think was a very important lesson for me in how do we do science and what is our role as a scientist.
SPEAKER_02I'm not wondering how I can take this back to my boss. I can be like, look, I don't control my research. My research controls me. If I produce one paper this entire year, so be it.
SPEAKER_01I'm not gonna dominate word anymore. I'm gonna let word come to me.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, just it I mean, it's more of a go of the floor, wait for the vibe kind of the thing.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, try it. Let's see how it works.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah, let's go. I think it'll work. I'll be the control where I'll continue to do what I do normally, and we'll see what works for you.
SPEAKER_02Uh I'll say I'm doing this experiment with Sinead where I do nothing.
SPEAKER_04But you see, we've we've just talked about how important it is to have the null result. So I think you're onto something.
SPEAKER_01Thank you. Thank you very much. Um, I've got one more question for you. Um, it's in the title of your book, and then it popped up a little bit in a chapter, which is this idea of becoming with. I think I'm I might be starting to get it, but I was wondering if you could like fully explain it to me in the in the sense that you you mean it.
SPEAKER_04I will try.
SPEAKER_01Thank you.
SPEAKER_04Okay, and this has been a project, uh, you know, because of my training in the sciences, and but as an interdisciplinary scholar over the last few years, I've uh benefited from the patience and uh knowledge of colleagues. So, you know, I have ventured into more kind of philosophical realms over the years. So for me, the idea of becoming is um kind of going back to what you were um asking as a question, it's it's it's an ontological orientation to the world.
SPEAKER_01So you will continue to go on doing your marvelous work for many years to come.
SPEAKER_04I hope so. But Egypt first, maybe Egypt first.
SPEAKER_01Pyramids on the horizon.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So all right. So it's becoming time to wrap this up. So thank you so much, Professor Devolina Royal.
SPEAKER_04Oh, thank you both. Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for listening to our new podcast. Subscribe online and tune in every first of the month. In the meantime, listen to CBME and U and be savvy.
Send us Fan Mail We spend much of our lives searching for meaning. Some of us look for it at work. Some in our families and friends. Some look for it at an overpriced spiritual retreat in Bali where some dude named...
Send us Fan Mail In some insurance scheme, you might be required to pay more because you are more prone to disability. In another, you may have to pay more because you're a woman (and are statistically likely to live...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that genomic sequencing can now screen newborns for hundreds of rare conditions right at birth? That looking too closely at our DNA might actually cause more anxiety than answers? And is...
Send us Fan Mail Did you know that over 80% of people who give birth experience an injury? That anywhere between 30 and 50% of people who give birth find it traumatic? And that up to 15% of people experience PTSD from...
Send us Fan Mail Could a blob of cells in a petri dish one day think? Feel? Have rights? In this episode, Professor Insoo Hyun (Harvard Medical School, one of the world's leading experts on the ethics of stem cell and...