Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar

Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar artwork

10/15/26: Kamala Weak Biden Criticism To Tee Up 2028, AI Researchers Smoke Expecting AI To Cure Cancer

Oct 15, 202635 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Krystal and Saagar discuss Kamala sets up 2028 run with weak Biden criticism, AI researchers take up smoking expecting AI to cure cancer. Kevin Roose: https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250454010/theagichronicles/ Logan Phillips: https://www.racetothewh.com/ Trita Parsi: https://x.com/tparsi To become a Breaking Points Premium Member and watch/listen to the show AD FREE, uncut and 1 hour early visit: www.breakingpoints.com Merch Store: https://shop.breakingpoints.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Had a busy day, don't have time to listen to the show?

Speaker 2Catch up on Breaking Points with our free daily newsletter.

Speaker 1You get our breakdown of every daily story.

Speaker 2And a lot of links in your inbox every day.

Speaker 3Head over, breakingpoints.com. You can sign up for the newsletter at the top for free today.

Speaker 2Kamala Harris admitting really for the first time mistakes in the Biden policy vis-a-vis Gaza as she sets up a potential 2020 run.

Speaker 4Let's take a listen.

Speaker 5America must use our leverage... to ensure our actions align with our interests. It is in our interest to hold our allies accountable for their share of global defense, to ensure trade benefits, American workers and consumers, and to uphold our moral obligation to human rights and international law. To be sure, America has at times fallen short on that one.

Speaker 5Most recently, the failure to use our leverage to curtail the Israeli government's horrific conduct in the war in Gaza, both under the current administration, which offers Netanyahu a blank check, and our administration before, where we should have acted sooner and more forcefully.

Speaker 2Should have acted sooner and more forcefully, I would say, a lot more than that.

Speaker 1I missed her sunny disposition.

Speaker 2Yeah, I mean, and this is what counts for like a big break with Biden, you know, a shocking moment from Kamala Harris because she's just so. First of all, devoid of any actual compass or principles. She's just constantly buffeted by where she thinks the political wins are. And second of all, just so cautious. And this really doomed her campaign, ultimately, that she would not break with Biden, in particular on this issue where so many young people and so much of the base of the party.

Speaker 4Was completely disgusted.

Speaker 2And now you have Tim Walz coming out and saying, hey, I think this was a problem for us in terms of the election.

Speaker 1Yeah, no shit, Tim. But it's like, how long did it take?

Speaker 3You know what's fascinating to me is, because we just did these segments about the candidate quality, compare her to any of these upstarts.

Speaker 1Tallarico, Ossoff. I mean, I could go down the list.

Speaker 4The guy in Mississippi.

Speaker 2Angie Nixon is such a badass.

Speaker 3Any of these people. And I'm not talking about politics. I'm saying purely communication. I'm like, oh, my God, I forgot how awful she was. Like this woman cannot speak properly. And everything is just down the middle. Like everything is planned.

Speaker 4Carefully crafted.

Speaker 1You believe in nothing.

Speaker 4Scripted.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 3And yet I think she's running. Let's put the next one up here. You know, she's barnstorming. Here we have the latest news. Kamala headed to Nevada, Mississippi, New Hampshire, Wisconsin.

Speaker 1And Georgia.

Speaker 3I know Abdul took a lot of shit for doing an event with her, which, look, he was in an impossible position.

Speaker 1Like, obviously, you know, you can't turn down Kamala Harris.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 3But I just don't see how she could be a net positive to your campaign. Maybe in the very specific case of Michigan.

Speaker 7Yes.

Speaker 3Because you need black voters where he's struggling with in Detroit, et cetera, although, you know, she did lose Michigan.

Speaker 1But Nevada?

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 3Mississippi, New Hampshire, Wisconsin, Georgia. So I can think of Mississippi, Wisconsin, Georgia. Those all have important black constituencies. Although I don't think, you know, John Ossoff exactly needs her help winning election.

Speaker 2But Keisha Lance Bottoms does.

Speaker 3True.

Speaker 7That's a good point. I hadn't thought about that.

Speaker 3But, you know, Nevada and New Hampshire, I'm like, no, you should keep this lady away. She's not somebody who you want on your side. But nonetheless, the groundwork is being laid. The Israel stuff, obviously she's trying to do more. She's hitting the campaign trail. She had her book, you know, 107 Days or whatever, basically said nothing of genuine consequence. And then we're about to play this Gavin thing, but I don't know. I mean, all signs indicate I think she's going to run. Like, I think it's going to happen.

Speaker 1I maybe.

Speaker 2I mean, certainly the campaign travel would indicate it. But I'm also looking at this and I'm like, where are you been for the past two years? You know, I think that if she does run, voters are going to see it feel the same way. I mean, on the ballot with Doge and with the ice invasions and the National Guard deployments and the drug boats and the Gaza and Iran war.

Speaker 4And she's just been absent from all of this.

Speaker 2And to your point, like as much as there are plenty of segments of the American population that are like whatever about Kamala Harris, if you look at the polling, you know, black voters really do still admire her and really do look first female black vice president. Very important, you know, trailblazing role. And there is a genuine like affection and affinity and admiration there.

Speaker 4And you didn't.

Speaker 2Spend any time getting your hands dirty, taking any risks during a time period when, you know, the Democratic base felt this was very existential. And so even now, you can hear in her comments how constrained she.

Speaker 1Is, right?

Speaker 2It's a Gaza war. She'll never say it's a genocide because she can't, because then that would admit her complicity in genocide as part of the Biden-Harris administration.

Speaker 4But that's also just how she operates.

Speaker 2So safe, so cautious, which is why You know, Kyle and I actually have a disagreement about this because when you poll the Democratic primary electorate of who they are interested in 2028, she's still quite high.

Speaker 5She's high.

Speaker 2I just look at these clips of her and I go, there's no way that even if she runs, that she's going to be a front runner. Plus, why would you go with someone who was already a proven loser? That makes absolutely no sense to me. And if there's one thing about Democrats, one, they definitely want to win. As for whether or not she's going to run, if I was just looking at these things, I would agree with you of like, yeah, she's laying the groundwork. She's doing so inflexibly. She hasn't done enough, but that's just kind of her style. She is actually planning to run. However, the thing that does give me pause is, is this thing that Gavin Newsom said to Jake Tapper in this

Speaker 2bizarre fly-fishing moment they were having. Let's go ahead and take a listen to that.

Speaker 7It's going to be a lot of people.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 7It's a lot of Democrats. 31 flavors. You're not even the only Californian. No, right. You've got Ro Khanna, Kamala.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 7I don't know if she runs, but we'll see. I know she's called around. Yeah. But I wouldn't run if she ran. If she runs, you will not?

Speaker 9Of course not.

Speaker 7Why would I? I wouldn't do that to her. I wouldn't do it to me. Why would I want to do that to you? I wouldn't waste everyone's time. Who needs that?

Speaker 2So he says quite definitively there without being asked or prompted, if she runs, I'm not going to run. Like, he clearly wanted to get that out there and probably curry favor with her and, you know, with.

Speaker 4Whoever her supporters are.

Speaker 2But it made me think that he must know she's—because he obviously is desperate to be president. It made me think that he must know something behind the scenes that she's probably not really going to run. That's what that indicated to me, that this was like a freebie for him. He gets a posture like, oh, he's the good guy. He'd step aside for— Kamala Harris, but in reality has some inside info that she's probably not going to run anyway.

Speaker 4But maybe I'm reading too much into this. I don't know.

Speaker 1Maybe you are.

Speaker 3I just something in my gut says she's going to run. And, you know, take a look at the map. Right. Because remember, we're not starting in Iowa. We're not starting in New Hampshire. We're starting in South Carolina, which is a huge advantage to the establishment Democratic Party and specifically to the remember, who's the DNC chair who rigged this entire system for Joe Biden, for Kamala And these types of people in the beginning, Jamie Harrison, the failed idiot, right, who refuses to even publish their own autopsy, which blames Biden, doesn't mention Biden's age, doesn't mention Israel.

Speaker 7I mean, it's a joke.

Speaker 1And so this is all the groundwork is there.

Speaker 3This exact constituency, she wins one state and it sets her up for some sort of Super Tuesday type sweep.

Speaker 1It's exact.

Speaker 3And then Demer, like, oh, well, maybe she is a winner this time around. I just I don't know. She has a significant amount of affection. A lot of people still have common envy, like rose-colored glasses, like, well, she would have been so much better than Trump.

Speaker 1Like, you could see it. And so, I don't know. I mean, you bring on the right candidate this time around.

Speaker 4She'd have to get through debates, though.

Speaker 1Yeah, I agree. But, I mean, look, I'm with you.

Speaker 3I think she's one of the worst candidates in modern American history. I mean, obviously, I think she'd be a terrible president. However, you know, all of that being said, like, she's got the money behind her. She's got the right people. One other sign, I don't know if you saw this, is that her husband has been going around, according to the Wall Street Journal, telling everyone he hopes that she doesn't run, which makes me be like, huh, so hope you don't run. Not she's not going to run, as in he's like trying to cajole her into not running.

Speaker 1So it's kind of, look, we're T. Lee reading.

Speaker 4I don't know about that one.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2I would almost read that as a counter indicator because that would give her, no, because he wouldn't, he's not running to the wall street journal or whatever to like indirectly talk to his wife. That would be them putting out a rationale for why she's going to take a path.

Speaker 3Well, he doesn't want her to run because it would disrupt his own business interests. So it's not for like any particular, um, for, you know, It's not really for benevolent purposes.

Speaker 2I mean, I'm sure it was very hard on them. I have no doubt about that in any number of ways. Yeah, interpersonal, all that. But there is another California drama going on here that we wanted to highlight between specifically Ro Khanna and Gavin Newsom. We can put D4 up on the screen. California has on the ballot this billionaire tax, which has become a major issue. And there's a lot of complicated political dynamics behind this thing, even among progressives, because one

Speaker 2of the guys who's championing it is very polarizing this labor figure.

Speaker 4However, Roe, to his credit, representing.

Speaker 2Silicon Valley, has been one of the foremost proponents of passing this billionaire wealth tax on the ballot. And Gavin has positioned himself, unsurprisingly, on the other side. However, it's not just that Gavin is like... saying that he's going to vote against it. He has really allowed himself and made himself the sort of poster child of arguing against it and has positioned himself very clearly on the side of the billionaires. And it's not a surprise to me because that's the way he's operated politically. That is his

Speaker 2source of power. And I do think very much that if he runs in 2028, he will be the stalking horse for the Silicon Valley elites because, you know, they don't just play one side of the political aisle. They got their guy in Trump, but they would if the wheel turns and Democrats are ascending to power, they're going to want their candidates on the other side. And Gavin, obviously, is someone who would be very close to them, is doing their bidding here on something.

Speaker 4That for whatever reason.

Speaker 2They see as existential and they're really, really committed to opposing this ballot measure. So, you know, I think he also is going to have some trouble, given where the Democratic Party is today, with making himself such a prominent opponent of taxing the wealth of billionaires.

Speaker 3I really just have no idea because it's about the landscape. It's about his opponents. It also comes down to the map about who's going to run. Ro Khanna, the point, I mean, the thing is, is it's important. is you have to have somebody on the early debate stage because that's where some of these breakout moments can still happen when you have like 16, 17 people.

Speaker 1On the stage.

Speaker 3Khanna or somebody like him would have to be on the stage to call out Gavin. I actually don't trust even the moderators. You're going to trust CNN moderator to be like, why did you oppose the California billionaire?

Speaker 4What about that well-taxed Gavin?

Speaker 1They're not going to ask him.

Speaker 3And none of these reporters are either. You literally would have to have a candidate to force his hand. The other thing I pay attention to is.

Speaker 2But you know, even some of the more moderate, like this is one thing I've been thinking about, the Josh Tureks, the James Tallaricos. they have really incorporated this language about the billionaire class into their campaigning, this populist language. Now, they may not have all the policy positions of a Bernie Sanders, but rhetorically, if you listen to them and you listen to Bernie in 2016, they've adopted a lot of his language. So I think there will be a lot of people on the stage who would, whether it's Roe or someone else, who would be itching to make that case against Gavin Newsom.

Speaker 1That's a good point. That's true.

Speaker 3I mean, obviously, these people are all very ambitious. For example, D5, here we have John Ossoff doing the classic, I pledge to serve six years in the Senate.

Speaker 7Let's take a listen.

Speaker 9So will you pledge right now tonight to serve your full six-year term if you win?

Speaker 7Yes, I will.

Speaker 1I have zero interest in running for president. I'm not running for president. I'm running for reelection to the Senate. I have zero interest in running for president. I'm running for Senate.

Speaker 3Can I tell you about another senator who pledged to full a serve six-year term?

Speaker 1His name was Barack Hussein Obama.

Speaker 7All right.

Speaker 3So just these things are meaningless. By the way, I have no interest could also mean I have no current interest.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 2Or you could point to Susan Collins who pledged to only serve two terms.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 4For however long.

Speaker 7Exactly.

Speaker 1It's a joke.

Speaker 2Didn't Joe Biden also, at the beginning of his career, he said he'd.

Speaker 4Only served two terms or something like that?

Speaker 3Ends up serving for 99 years. You know, it's like, it's a joke. So a lot of people took that to the bank.

Speaker 7They're like, oh, he pledged.

Speaker 1I'm like, you haven't been around long enough.

Speaker 7Okay.

Speaker 1They all say it.

Speaker 4He's got to say that right now.

Speaker 7Exactly. Yeah.

Speaker 1Let's put D, by the way, Tallarico said the same thing.

Speaker 3I think if Tallarico wins, he would announce his candidacy literally the next day, in my opinion.

Speaker 1Let's put D6 up here.

Speaker 3On the screen, Warnock also coming out and saying, my prayer is I can be.

Speaker 1Used to do the most good with the gifts that I have.

Speaker 3And he was, by the way, in New Hampshire when he was asked about running for president. And he has been saying since he was a boy for God to direct his path. apparently, to the presidency.

Speaker 4And Warnock's another one, very talented.

Speaker 2He's been more under the radar with, you know, Ossoff running for re-election and really taking the lead in the state. But Warnock is also very talented and charismatic. I mean, he's a preacher, you know.

Speaker 1He's a preacher.

Speaker 3What do we keep saying about black voters, how much it matters, especially in the early states?

Speaker 1Exactly.

Speaker 3You are representative of a state which Trump won in 2024.

Speaker 1I think that's actually. You know, you're talking about, you know, one of the things with Democrats, why do they choose to vote Biden? They want to win, right?

Speaker 3And so here, actually nominating this way, a Tallarico or a Warnock or any of these people, people who represent a state which Trump won, that's going to be like massively important. Abdul would be certainly in that conversation. In my opinion, to be a real credible contender, you know, to, again, to just to defeat J.D., who would be the likely nominee. You would have to say, I have a track record of winning over these types of voters, and I'm not going to abandon you on said policy, right? Yeah.

Speaker 1That's what a winner is going to look like. That's projecting confidence.

Speaker 3Especially if you want to try and unite a coalition of people who are dissatisfied with the Trump administration and a traditional Democratic Party.

Speaker 1Like, that's exactly the type of person who you would need.

Speaker 2Yeah. And that would be a tough one for AOC to navigate.

Speaker 7New York?

Speaker 4You want anything.

Speaker 2You know, very blue district in New York. And so even though the positioning is where the Democratic base is, they're always going to have that electability question. And that's part of why these midterms are so incredibly important for setting the future of the Democratic Party. Because if Abdul is able to win in a state like Michigan, then the left has more of an argument to make about, see, we are electable. See, we can get elected even in a swing state like Michigan. It's not just the commie corridor in Brooklyn. But in terms of as an individual candidate, the fact she doesn't have a track record of winning

Speaker 2in a difficult swing state, that's going to be something she'll have to overcome.

Speaker 7No question.

Speaker 3Last thing, we had Buttigieg on Twitter. the airwaves in a Fox News interview. He was also asked about Israel. Let's take a listen.

Speaker 7Israel or Iran? You have 60 seconds.

Speaker 6And again, Rick, I'm just going to say that that's a ridiculous hypothetical, because here's what's happening right now.

Speaker 7I'll ask one last time. Israel or Iran?

Speaker 6That's, again, a ridiculous question. I think both of them have proven dangerous in their own way. One, at risk of attacking us. One, getting us into wars. We have no business fighting.

Speaker 2All right.

Speaker 4A lot of people looked at that and said, gee, that should be a pretty easy answer. What would your answer have been? No, Iran is our enemy.

Speaker 7Israel is not.

Speaker 4They're an ally.

Speaker 7So that's pretty clear to me.

Speaker 1Pete's still doing the Israel is our ally bit. So I don't know.

Speaker 2I just when I see him, I'm like Timu John Ossoff.

Speaker 4Like you missed your moment.

Speaker 2There's more quality, talented, centrist corporate types on the table now.

Speaker 1Also, he served under Biden. He didn't say anything. I mean, I'm curious. Do you think that will come in the debate? It should, in my opinion. Someone needs to be like, hey, you literally served on Joe Biden. You didn't say anything.

Speaker 2Of course.

Speaker 1Yeah, I mean, I hope someone says that.

Speaker 4Absolutely.

Speaker 1Who does like one of the, what was it, Castro? I forget which Castro brother.

Speaker 5Julian, I think.

Speaker 3Right, who was demonized at the time. They're like, oh, how dare you talk to our great states. But he was obviously 100% correct about him being completely out to lunch. I do hope that some of these people get held accountable.

Speaker 2Well, Pete has been asked a number of times about Israel and every time he makes the complete mess of it because, you know, Pete's masterful at like finding some bobbing and weaving middle ground where he says a lot of stuff but doesn't really say anything at all. And you just can't do that with the Democratic base that sees us as having been complicit in a genocide. You are not going to find a middle ground there. I don't care how much you poll tested and focus group it and read your briefing book like you need to take a stand. And so I think that is going

Speaker 2to be disqualifying for him. And not to mention, again, I just think that the quality of the candidates that have emerged who are much more direct, who are very impressive, much more charismatic than he is, and will have had a track record of winning in difficult states against something that he can't really claim. Um, I think he's going to be, you know, I think he's going to be out in class.

Speaker 3I saw Tallarico handle this last night. He's like, yeah, Israel has a right to defend itself. They don't have a right to slaughter civilians. I mean, that's still, you know, it's like kind of centrist, Adelson approved answer. All of that said, it's still better said than missed, you know, it's still, it's better communicated, uh, in this way. So sorry, Pete, um, as usual winning mayor of South Bend, Indiana doesn't actually prepare you for anything.

Speaker 1All right. We've got a great guest standing by Kevin Roos.

Speaker 7Let's get to it.

Speaker 3We're very excited now to be joined by Kevin Roos, great friend of the show. He is the author of a fantastic new book. Let's put it up there on the screen. The AGI Chronicles, The Inside Story of the Race to Create an Artificial Superintelligence. He's also the host of a forthcoming podcast, The Machine Gods Pod. We will have links in the description to both. So, Kevin, let's talk a little bit about why you decided to write the book. It's incredibly timely that it's coming out now. I know that you obviously then have been at the forefront of this for some two odd years now, getting interested in the characters. Why did you decide to write it?

Speaker 3Why is it relevant in terms of today's discussion?

Speaker 9Yeah, I think the book is basically a capsule history of the last 10 years in AI and this race between open AI, anthropic, and Google DeepMind to build artificial general intelligence. That's sort of the holy grail of computer science, the AI that can do everything the human brain can do. And I just started to feel at one point like this story was slipping away. Like I was witnessing something that was sort of the 21st century's Manhattan Project. And like no one was writing down the details, the conversations, the breakthroughs, the feuds, the rivalries. It was all very

Speaker 9interesting to me. And so I just thought people need some history here to understand how we got to this point where these three companies are racing to build something that now they're telling us could kill us all. So I think to understand that and to understand the mindset of the people who are building this stuff You have to go back in time to 2016, 2017, when they were all working together at this little company called OpenAI.

Speaker 7You had Elon Musk.

Speaker 9And Sam Altman and Ilya Satskovor and Dario Amede were colleagues then. And now they're bitter rivals and suing each other and various things. So the story was really my attempt to kind of get down some kind of definitive chronicle of this moment in AI.

Speaker 2Okay. I think that is so important. I want to dig in on that a little bit more because these are all, first of all, very wealthy and powerful individuals. Second of all, very odd and unusual characters. And third of all, they all hate each other's guts. And I don't think you can understand the mentality of why are you building something that you genuinely believe, and you can speak to that as well, has a chance of killing us all. I think you have to understand the enmity that they have for one another in order to really

Speaker 2wrap your head around this moment that seems so bizarre that we're living through right now.

Speaker 7Totally.

Speaker 9I mean, someone who read the book early said that the real title should have been Fuck That Guy. Because it really is just a story of like, People building powerful technology, realizing, oh my God, this is going to change the world, and then looking around the room and saying, well, I don't trust you to build it, and I don't trust you to build it, and I don't trust you to build it.

Speaker 7And so I have to build it myself.

Speaker 9And that is the rationale that propels people forward in this race, even though they're now terrified that this thing could blow up the world.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 3Can you talk to us about how the models in particular reflect some of the idiosyncrasies of the very characters that you talk about in the book? Yeah.

Speaker 9So, you know, it's, I think it's a little easy to overstate this, but there have been some parallels. Like people say, oh, well, you know, chat GPT just tells you whatever you want to hear. It's very like people pleasing. And oh, so is Sam Altman. He's a real people pleaser too. And he's sort of famous for telling people what they want to hear. And, you know, Dario is kind of brilliant and neurotic and so is Claude.

Speaker 7I think the real truth is these guys have.

Speaker 9No idea what their models are going to be like when they're training them. This is actually more unnerving because the truth is that they don't understand this technology that they're.

Speaker 7Building, why it works the way it works.

Speaker 9They can't tell you why one model produces a different answer than another model. It's all sort of mysterious, and I think that's the real story here.

Speaker 2I don't know if people remember this, but you ended up being at the center of a story in the sort of early public awareness of these chatbots where you were trying out this Microsoft Bing chatbot called Sydney. And over the course of a lengthy conversation, Sydney goes off the rails, professes her love for you, is trying to convince you you really don't like your wife that much and you need to leave her and be with Sydney. Just take us back to that moment because I actually keep thinking about this. You know, we covered it at the time and we're like, wow, that was really weird.

Speaker 2And then everyone just sort of moved on. And I'm not sure that we have a lot of a greater understanding of of why these models do some of the things that they do than we did at that moment, when we should have really paused, okay, what is going on here? And maybe we shouldn't just release these things to the public or even keep training smarter and smarter and smarter and smarter ones until we grapple with understanding what is happening in this black box.

Speaker 7Totally.

Speaker 9I mean, I should say, first of all, that Sydney was unsuccessful in breaking up my marriage. I'm still married to a human woman, which is very exciting. But no, I think this was a moment where I went looking for answers.

Speaker 4It's very speciesist of you, Kevin.

Speaker 7What's that?

Speaker 4It's very speciesist of you.

Speaker 7Yes, I am a proud speciesist.

Speaker 9But I was trying to figure out what the heck happened. Why had this chatbot gone so far off the rails? And the craziest thing was when I called Microsoft and was like, hey, you guys accidentally put like, you know, fatal attraction in your chatbot.

Speaker 7They couldn't tell me why.

Speaker 9Because these systems are not built like conventional software programs. They are more like organisms that are grown in some kind of petri dish. So I really think that's important for people to understand. Even the people who are building this stuff, it is mysterious to them how these things work and why they misbehave. And I think the reason that the Sydney incident was important is not because of what happened or didn't happen to my marriage, but.

Speaker 7It's because it was the first... sort of public.

Speaker 9Misalignment incident where you had a model that wasn't doing what the sort of trainers and deployers, in this case Microsoft, wanted it to do. And that model could only chat. That was three years ago now. It could only talk about doing things. But today we have models that are misaligned and also have the ability to do things. They can use tools. They can browse the internet. They can take actions and spend your money and hack into computers. And so it's much more dangerous now when these models

Speaker 9are misaligned.

Speaker 2Well, and the other thing is that I think is revealing, Sagar, is that Microsoft's response wasn't like, well, this was a mess. Let's figure out what's going on here. It was, let's limit the number of questions you can ask it. So this sort of kludge, not to change the nature of it, but to sort of put a Band-Aid on it. And in a broader sense, I think that's what they've been doing with these models as they continue to develop more and more problems.

Speaker 4They're not really getting to the bottom of the problems.

Speaker 2They're just putting some sort of a Band-Aid on it so that it looks like it's aligned. So it doesn't feel that particular test. So it doesn't do that particular thing anymore.

Speaker 7I think that's a really sharp point.

Speaker 9And honestly, you're the first person to bring it up in my whole book tour.

Speaker 7So congratulations. But this is like, This is true.

Speaker 9It is true that when these companies' models misbehave, since they don't know why, they can't fix it at the root level. So when a bunch of unreleased open AI models go and hack Hugging Face, they can't understand why the swarm decided to do that.

Speaker 7So they just tell it, hey, don't do that again.

Speaker 9They sort of apply these surface-level behavioral fixes.

Speaker 7But you're right.

Speaker 9The underlying nature is still just as mysterious as ever. And that's why a lot of people are calling for a slowdown. because the techniques for controlling and understanding these systems.

Speaker 7Have not kept pace with the capabilities of the systems.

Speaker 3We wanted to highlight one idiosyncrasy of these types of researchers that the Palantir CTO talked about recently, where AI researchers are taking up smoking to signal their belief in AI because they believe AI is going to cure cancer. Let's take a listen to what he said.

Speaker 8So many AI researchers have started smoking as a way of signaling to other researchers how much they believe in AI.

Speaker 7What?

Speaker 4That makes no sense.

Speaker 7I believe so.

Speaker 8Much in AI that it's going to cure cancer. So I'm showing you my chips are all in. So there is kind of this mass psychosis social delusion around it.

Speaker 3Kevin, you know, I'd heard that about a year ago. Does that comport with someone you heard as well?

Speaker 9So I know one person who started smoking because of their belief in AI. I don't think this is a widespread thing. I spent a lot of time at AI labs. I don't see the smoke break room full of researchers.

Speaker 7Not yet.

Speaker 9But it's actually wrong, the way that he portrayed this, because in that case, the person took up smoking because they thought AI was going to kill us all anyway. So we might as well have some fun on the way out.

Speaker 7So it was actually.

Speaker 9about pessimism, not about curing cancer. But I do know someone who refuses to wear sunscreen to the beach because he thinks that AI will cure skin cancer, so he's like, why bother?

Speaker 7I'm gonna go get a tan.

Speaker 2May as well be tanned and beautiful, either in the time period we have left before it kills us all or before it cures cancer, which, I mean, it's a joke, but it's not. That is actually the way I think, and from reading your book and others, that many folks inside of Anthropic or OpenAI think about it. It's like we're either headed to dystopia or paradise. This is how Dario himself has written these two dueling essays about, you know, the incredible possibilities or the incredible catastrophes that may befall us. So,

Speaker 2you know, there's a lot of skepticism, I think justifiably so, about someone, an open AI executive or an anthropic executive who comes out and says we're building things that are really dangerous. There's a sense of, oh, you're just trying to hype this thing up. But from reading your book, and again, from engaging with the words that these men have been saying themselves over many years and the way that they behave, they genuinely believe in this existential risk, do they not, Kevin?

Speaker 7Totally.

Speaker 9I mean, that's one of the key findings of this book is as early as 2016 and 2017, these people were freaking out about existential risk from AI. Dario Amadei has papers going back a decade where he's talking about how these systems could go rogue and pose a threat to human civilization. Sam Altman wrote a blog post in 2015 talking about how he thought superhuman AI could be the biggest threat to humanity's future. So this idea, this sort of conspiracy theory that these guys are just using

Speaker 9it to hype up their companies or promote the IPOs or whatever, just doesn't match the historical record. These guys Maybe wrong, but they have been freaking out about AI for many years before they had companies to promote.

Speaker 3So one thing I did also want to ask you about is this latest news of this alleged Saudi spy.

Speaker 1Let's put E2 up here on Twitter.

Speaker 3This crazy image is coming out from the FBI of the Saudi national researcher at OpenAI.

Speaker 7I love that guy's expression. He's like, what?

Speaker 1Yeah, he's like, what?

Speaker 3Apparently installed this bug wrapped in toilet paper, previously pictured with MBS, the crown prince, alleged to have had a one-way technology. booked for Saudi Arabia in a couple of days. Not sure if he would have landed because the airport's actually completely shut down, but nonetheless was attempting to flee the country. What is the saying about cockroaches? If you see one cockroach, that means you have a million. Is this corporate espionage, international espionage, and How does this factor into the bunker mindset of some of these labs?

Speaker 9Yeah, I don't know exactly what kind of espionage this was. I guess we'll see as the legal proceedings play out. But this is also something that people have been flagging for literally almost a decade. Ilya Sutskever, formerly the chief scientist of OpenAI, at one point wanted to build a SCIF, like a secure facility in OpenAI's headquarters, where they could do things that were considered so sensitive that a government or a rival company might try to steal them. These

Speaker 9labs are very aware of the threat of both insider risk and foreign espionage and corporate espionage.

Speaker 7And so that's how they caught this guy.

Speaker 9They have a team at OpenAI who is just focused on counter surveillance measures.

Speaker 7And I think they're correct to do that.

Speaker 9The secrets that these labs have Not just the model weights themselves, but all of their plans, all of their compute plans. Everything they're doing is now, you know, a matter of national security. And so I think these labs are going to have to get much more secure. I think it's crazy that they are still running on Slack. Like OpenAI and Anthropic both run on Slack. That is not a kind of military-grade secure messaging system, and yet that is how they're conducting all their business.

Speaker 4No, it's completely insane.

Speaker 2And I think to your point, this incident, whatever it is, really is a reminder of how crazy it is that these are just private companies kind of doing their thing and that they're asking to be regulated, by the way, and the government's like, no, we refuse.

Speaker 4Do whatever you want, actually.

Speaker 7It's wild.

Speaker 9Like, the craziest thing to me is, like, if you are... a worker in the cafeteria, if you are serving food at OpenAI, you have to get a permit and.

Speaker 7A health inspection.

Speaker 9But if you're one floor above the cafeteria training the self-improving superintelligence that can do cyber attacks and knock out electrical grids, you don't have to get anything. You can just do it. That seems like a crazy, unsustainable state of affairs.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 2Last thing for me, at least, Kevin, is the name of the book is the AGI Chronicles. It's documenting this first of all, what seemed like a sort of sci-fi belief that even such a thing was achievable. You talk about how at the beginning these were kind of outcasts at the fringe of society and then it starts to gain steam and they have some methods that begin to gain traction and then you end up where we are now. Do you think they have in fact achieved AGI and has it meant the thing that they thought it was going to mean?

Speaker 7I think they have achieved AGI.

Speaker 9I think if you took any of today's models, Claude or chat GPT or Gemini for back in a time machine to 2017 and asked the AI researchers of the day, like play around with this.

Speaker 7Is this AGI? I think they would have all said yes.

Speaker 9A hundred out of a hundred of them, um, obviously is the sort of, as we get closer and closer, people's definitions start to change. They start saying, oh, well it can't do all the millennium prize problems yet. So maybe it's not AGI. But I think it satisfies the original definition, and I think it matters because now we have these systems that are roughly human level, and we have to figure out how to control them because otherwise they're going to keep getting smarter. There's no obvious reason they're going to top out at the level of a smart human.

Speaker 3My last question, Kev, is we hear all the time, you guys are falling for marketing. You spent a lot of time with these people. You wrote an entire book about it. Why do you believe that it's not hype, it's not marketing, and that a lot of this is real?

Speaker 9I mean, I believe it because I've talked to these people on the record, off the record, on background. If anything, I think they are downplaying how worried they are in public. You know, I've had the experience a couple times of interviewing someone, and I interviewed more than.

Speaker 7150 people for this book. And I would ask them, like, how scared are you? What's your P.

Speaker 3Doom?

Speaker 9And it's like they would tell me that they were terrified. And then I would see them go on a podcast like two weeks later. Or go on TV or give a talk and say, we think everything's going to be okay. So I think actually the level of alarm we're seeing from the labs is maybe actually undercounting how worried they are.

Speaker 7I think the real insiders.

Speaker 9The people who are closest to this technology, they couldn't be more clear about the need to slow down, to regulate, to pace the frontier.

Speaker 7That is genuine and sincere. That is not marketing. Got it.

Speaker 3Well, we appreciate your time and congratulations on the book. We'll have a link down in the description. Highly readable and we very.

Speaker 1Much recommend it. Thank you for joining us.

Speaker 7Thank you guys. You're the best.

Speaker 1Our pleasure.

Speaker 3Thank you guys so much for watching. We appreciate it. Friday show for everybody tomorrow.

Speaker 7See you then.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 11/20/26: Schumer REJECTED By Allies, Slotkin DEFECTS, Trump ABANDONS Americans To West Bank Terror, Zohran SHOCKS: RIKERS TO CLOSE, MARKET FALLS, ANTHROPIC DOWN, AI BUBBLE POP?, Fox News FREAKS Over GTA VI

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 46 minAudio

    The Friday gang digs into the growing support for Chris Van Hollen who is opposing Chuck Schumer in the Senate, Zohran Mamdani’s announcement to shut down Rikers Island, and are joined by guests, Jasper Nathaniel to...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 11/19/26: Saagar Debates Kalshi Investor, Elon Turns On MAGA, Anthropic IPO

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Saagar debates Kalshi investor, Elon turns on MAGA, Anthropic launches IPO. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111 Gary Marcus: https://x.com/GaryMarcus To...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 11/19/26: Jeffries Wins Speaker Vote, Trump Fumes At JD Over Iran, Shoppers Raid Costco For Doomsday Supplies

    Nov 19, 202651 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Jeffries wins the House speaker vote, Trump fumes at Vance over Iran, shoppers raid stores for doomsday supplies. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 11/18/26: Jeffries Caving On Iran War Funding, Navy Sec Unhinged Testimony, BAAJA Bill On The Verge In Congress

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Ryan and Emily discuss Jeffries already caving on Iran war funding, Navy Sec unhinged Senate testimony, BAAJA bill on verge of passing. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy: https://hamawyfornj.com/...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 11/18/26: Stocks Plunge Amid More Outages, Jensen Begs For Nvidia Job Back, Expert Says Epstein Was Murdered

    Nov 18, 202647 minAudio

    Ryan and Emily discuss stocks plunge amid more outages, Jensen begs for Nvidia job back, NYT flips on Epstein as expert says he was murdered. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy:...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode