Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar

Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar artwork

11/20/26: Schumer REJECTED By Allies, Slotkin DEFECTS, Trump ABANDONS Americans To West Bank Terror, Zohran SHOCKS: RIKERS TO CLOSE, MARKET FALLS, ANTHROPIC DOWN, AI BUBBLE POP?, Fox News FREAKS Over GTA VI

Nov 20, 20261 hr 46 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

The Friday gang digs into the growing support for Chris Van Hollen who is opposing Chuck Schumer in the Senate, Zohran Mamdani’s announcement to shut down Rikers Island, and are joined by guests, Jasper Nathaniel to talk about the treatment of Americans in the West Bank, Gary Marcus on the most recent AI developments, and Gene Park to discuss GTA 6. Jasper Nathaniel: https://x.com/infinite_jaz https://www.infinitejaz.com Gary Marcus: https://x.com/GaryMarcus https://garymarcus.substack.com Gene Park: https://x.com/GenePark https://linktr.ee/gene.meme To become a Breaking Points Premium Member and watch/listen to the show AD FREE, uncut and 1 hour early visit: www.breakingpoints.com Merch Store: https://shop.breakingpoints.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Had a busy day? Don't have time to listen to the show?

Speaker 2Catch up on Breaking Points with our free daily newsletter.

Speaker 3You'll get our breakdown of every daily story. And lots of links in your inbox every day.

Speaker 1So head over to BreakingPoints.com. You can sign up for the newsletter at the top for free today.

Speaker 4Hello.

Speaker 5Good morning, everyone. Is anyone watching YouTube right now or are they all playing Grand Theft Auto 6? That's going to be the question of the day. If anyone's still listening, we have an incredible show.

Speaker 1It's Friday.

Speaker 5We've got Crystal, Ryan, and Emily.

Speaker 1How's everybody doing?

Speaker 3Doing good.

Speaker 2They're all out like buying flowers for their fake girlfriend in GTA 6. That's the discourse I'm seeing.

Speaker 5Or raging out that they have to have a girlfriend or interact with women at all. We've got an incredible show today. We've got some updates on leadership battles. One friend of the show, Senator Alyssa Slotkin, coming out against Schumer as well as Adam Hamilton. Then we have another friend of the show, Jasper Nathaniel, with his incredible substack, Chronicling the West Bank. He's going to join us to give us some updates since his recent assault that we

Speaker 5covered a few weeks ago. Then we're checking back in with our AI Stocks Anthropic IPO. We've got Gary Marcus returning because there have been a lot of updates in the 24 hours since we last spoke to him.

Speaker 6And finally....

Speaker 5Gamers, we are going to be talking about Grand Theft Auto 6 with one video game journalist, Gene Park, from the Washington Post, who is an intrepid reporter on all things games. We're going to talk to him about the Fox News right-wing meltdowns, some vintage, old-school meltdowns about culture, women, girlfriends, strippers, and everything else that happens in Grand Theft Auto 6. But first, Crystal. What is Alyssa Slotkin up to?

Speaker 1Wait, wait, wait, hold on.

Speaker 5Oh, one matter of business, Ryan, please.

Speaker 1Very quickly, one more contest since we're wrapping up the last one.

Speaker 5No, no, no, no more contests.

Speaker 1Launching a new contest.

Speaker 6Just one.

Speaker 1So if by Sunday at midnight, you figure out a way that the U.S. Army does not have to blow up a giant pile of toxic lead in Iowa... and they use your solution to save the Midwest, you'll get two months free.

Speaker 6Just two months.

Speaker 7Two months.

Speaker 1Go to breakingpoints.com.

Speaker 3The one month is already free. We're just giving you one month for that, Ryan.

Speaker 1And we also don't want to manage this. So just tag Pete Hegseth with your solution. And he'll handle it. If he uses it, save that post so that you can prove that it was your solution. that prevented the Midwest from being poisoned by lead for eternity?

Speaker 7My parents thank you in advance.

Speaker 1You got it. So get to it. We can do this. We can do this together? The collective brainpower of this audience, we can do this.

Speaker 2And no one is saying, like, how did this lead all get degraded in the first place?

Speaker 1Apparently it just evaporated because nobody was checking it. Like the water, the water or whatever the solution was that needed to keep it stable evaporated.

Speaker 3And then they were just going to blow this up without really.

Speaker 1They knew about it in March or April. They knew about it in the spring and then just held it until after the election for no reason. They still lost all the races.

Speaker 3Including in Iowa.

Speaker 1Including Iowa.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 2But they didn't even they they didn't even give proper notice to like the Republican governor of Iowa.

Speaker 1They were going to blow it up today. They've they've postponed it to Monday. So we're extending the contest until Sunday night.

Speaker 3Absolutely insane.

Speaker 2The American government just loves like randomly poisoning its citizens for and not really caring or notifying them about what's going on.

Speaker 5So, yeah.

Speaker 8Thank you for your support of the Maha agenda.

Speaker 5That's very rude.

Speaker 6Wow.

Speaker 5How dare you? After Mulaney did it, his cruel impression on SNL, Emily kicking him while he's down. Well, that's the toxic lead challenge. Everyone can join that. And of course, guys, the fish contest officially over. We've picked our winners. They have been contacted. They are aware. Thank you, everyone else who is so excited, blowing up my inbox to join. But don't worry. There is a participation trophy. There will be a happy hour meetup. for drinks somewhere in the

Speaker 5city beforehand that we will send an email out to you as well. So everyone can get a little taste of that fish. But let's get to Senator Alyssa Slotkin, who recently came out to say she will not be endorsing one Chuck Schumer. Why don't we all take a listen?

Speaker 6Hi, everybody.

Speaker 9I have been vocal for many, many years about the importance in the Democratic Party of getting a new generation of leadership. particularly after the election we just had earlier this month. I think that message was sent loud and clear. The American public want a new generation and they want big and bold ideas. I've been clear as well that I don't think that Senator Schumer is best positioned to be our next leader. I'm encouraged that people like Chris Van Hollen got in the race. And because I've been

Speaker 9clear that I wasn't supporting Schumer, I will be supporting Chris Van Hollen. But I think no matter the outcome, It's going to be imperative for our leaders to demonstrate how they're going to incorporate that next generation and what big and bold ideas specifically they're going to put forward in the first 100 days.

Speaker 1All right.

Speaker 4So that's a taste of that right there.

Speaker 3Love to see that.

Speaker 5We'll start with Crystal.

Speaker 2I have some thoughts specifically about Slotkin. So it was very consequential that she came out and did that joint press conference with Bernie Sanders. And at that time, she wasn't willing to say, I'm going to vote for Chris Van Hollen.

Speaker 3Over Chuck Schumer.

Speaker 2But the fact that she joined together with Bernie, you know, left winger and the left winger of left wingers, Bernie Sanders. Here she is representative of the, you know, firmament establishment candidate within the Democratic Party coming out and saying we've got to do something different. I think that gave Chris Van Hollen a lot of momentum. And I also want to just give her credit. You know, I think we you know, she came on our show. She and her staff asked for her to come on our show. We had a challenging exchange. There was a lot of feedback that came her way. I think the fact that she

Speaker 2was willing to do some shows that were outside of her comfort zone and get that sort of input is perhaps part of what leads her to this place. She was already doing this rhetoric about like Democrats need folders, not fighters.

Speaker 3And it's not really about left, right.

Speaker 2I just thought that was like a bunch of bullshit to try to cover up for I'm going to pretend like I'm going to be different, but I'm really just going to use some more strident rhetoric and wrap the same policies in that strident rhetoric. This is her taking, you know, a real step towards we actually need to do something different within the Democratic Party. So kudos to her for stepping out and not just, you know, oh, I don't like Schumer. I'm not sure. I'll find out. But coming out and affirmatively saying, no, I am with Chris Van Hollen.

Speaker 1And do we have Adam Hamilton? So what's going to be critical is how these, and could be totally pivotal, how these freshmen, whether, you know, Andrews, Tallarico, El-Sayed already said he's going to be with Van Hollen and really helped to kind of instigate the challenge. He wasn't even running when he supported him. Peltola, Cologne, but then also Hamilton.

Speaker 10The first version of schism, which is just, again, the normal politics of party here, is that there's going to be a leadership election in the Senate. Chris Van Hollen is going to challenge Chuck Schumer, who has been the Senate majority leader, minority leader and majority leader for a while. You've said that you're not going to vote for Chuck Schumer. I think on sort of generational geographical grounds, as far as I understand it, are you going to vote for Chris Van Hollen?

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 11So I'm not going to tell you who I'm going to vote for yet. It's a secret ballot when it's taken. But I will say I will fulfill my promise that I made during the campaign. And it was no offense to Chuck Schumer.

Speaker 6He's done amazing things.

Speaker 11But In Kansas, there's a lot of folks who, Republicans and Democrats alike, who feel like it's time for change. It's time for somebody new. I appreciate Chuck and all the things that he's done, Senator Schumer, all the things he's done. And at the same time, I'm looking for somebody who's going to bring people together. And right now, in places like Kansas, there's a lot of people who don't feel that in Chuck Schumer. So I'm going to fulfill what I said. I will not be voting for Chuck Schumer for Senate Majority Leader.

Speaker 1And he could be holding out there for... something from van holland because you're like you're listening you're like wait a minute hold on what do you mean you're not like you kind of have to vote for somebody like if you don't you look like a guy who can't commit to something and nobody sent you there to vote present like you were sent there to vote one way or the other so why would he be saying that the only thing i can come up with is you know he's in talks with van holland about like what he wants like what committees he wants to be on you know, what kind of promises he wants for whatever

Speaker 1priorities he has. You know, Kansas is going to maybe need a lot of lead remediation beginning on Monday, depending on which way the wind blows from that toxic lead explosion, assuming that the breaking points audience doesn't figure out how to prevent that from happening. We also have Van Hollen here. I can play him. He was asked about how he's doing. Well, actually, so here's our updated whip count, by the way. 16 for Schumer, we count nine leaning. So by no means

Speaker 1is this, like Schumer was saying, you know, I've got these votes, I have all these commitments. You know, if it was really true that he had locked it up and he was he had firmly put Van Hollen away, you would expect that these Democrats would have at least, you know, would have would have come out and said, all right, yes, I told him privately. I might as well tell you I'm I'm with him. But that did that did not happen. So here's Van Hollen talking about his own situation.

Speaker 7On the leadership race, are you confident that you have enough votes at this point?

Speaker 6Where are you in the vote count?

Speaker 8And to those who have been calling for a fresh face in leadership, you have been in Congress for a while now.

Speaker 11How do you make that move?

Speaker 1So first of all, stay tuned.

Speaker 12I mean, the momentum is growing in support of this reform effort for a lot of reasons. One, I think people recognize that if we're going to deliver on the big things that the American voters stood up for and voted for. You can't just go back to business as usual and status quo. That's one piece of it. You also need to make sure the Senate works and can deliver. And some of these proposals that Senator Merkley has been talking about, he's been pushing them for a long time.

Speaker 12We should just get it done.

Speaker 1And Crystal, he was up there with Jeff Merkley, who is probably just as progressive, really, as Bernie Sanders is. but, you know, kind of a lower profile figure. Merkley has been pushing since he got to the Senate in 2009, I believe it was, or 2007, for significant reforms to make the place move faster. Not just filibuster reform, which he's been way ahead of, but also smaller things that would say like, hey, if we're going to do a judge,

Speaker 1why does it take a week? Like really like a week of floor time to get a judge through? Or we do cloture on a bill and then there's 30 hours plus an intervening day. Then you have to do cloture again. That's 30 hours. Then you do cloture again to get to final passage. And that's 30 hours and quote unquote intervening day. And so you've gone from Monday to Saturday. So clearly what Merkley got Van Hollen to agree to is that he's going to adopt most of the rules changes that Merkley has come up with. Plus,

Speaker 1Berkeley has a common sense stuff like, hey, if everybody agrees to something by two thirds vote, like in the House, let's just pass it. Like right now, right now you can't do that.

Speaker 3Well, and here's the thing.

Speaker 2Yeah, we had David Hogg on yesterday and he was really banging this drum and I think he makes a great point. The filibuster is really key here because the Democrats want to pursue this strategy of passing single issue bills through the House, through the Senate and putting pressure on Trump. to either sign or veto things that are incredibly popular. We're going to roll back the Medicaid cuts. We're going to expand the ACA subsidies, things like that, that will have massive approval ratings. And that will be hard for Trump to say no to, presumably, although he

Speaker 2doesn't seem to really give a shit about much of.

Speaker 3Anything these days. But in any case.

Speaker 2We'll put pressure on him. So you could do some of that through a cumbersome reconciliation process. But it's not going to be that same strategy of just here's a bill, very clear cut what it does. We're rolling these through the House and the Senate. We're sending them to the president's desk. So in terms of the entire strategy for how Democrats want to operate while they have the House and the Senate, but Trump in the White House, the filibuster piece is really, really key. You're going back to Adam Hamilton. We have to remember this guy was a

Speaker 2Republican very recently. Like, he's new to being on the Democratic side of things. And Van Hollen is, you know, quite progressive and has stuck his neck out on any number of issues. He's one of the more progressive members of the Senate by his voting record. And so it could be also that Hamilton doesn't necessarily want to say that he's voting for Chris Van Hollen because he's fearful of people going and looking through the voting record and saying, oh, you pretended to be, you know, this moderate and looking at bipartisanship. And here you are backing this guy who's extremely,

Speaker 2you know, on the radical left wing of the party. I think that could be part of what's going on here, too, of why he doesn't want to show his hand.

Speaker 7I think single issue bills would be fantastic.

Speaker 8That's and I guess people probably don't realize the extent to which special interests don't want single issue bills to happen because you can't quite lard them up and hide things in the same way that you can if you're governing by reconciliation and omnibus. And that was actually part of what Freedom Caucus people were pushing Kevin McCarthy to do. And it felt, I mean, it's a really remarkable thing because you actually get people on the record. You actually have to have, which sounds ridiculous, but you get members actually having to commit to supporting a single damn issue

Speaker 8that Sometimes they might have campaigned on it.

Speaker 7As opposed to a big bill that has all this other stuff.

Speaker 8And they can say, well, I didn't support the bill because I didn't support this or I didn't support that. I, of course, supported this. Don't get me wrong. I, of course, supported that part of the bill. But I voted against it because of this other part of the bill. And it's a great thing if you can have the House and the Senate on the same page. It takes a lot of effort now to do single issue bills, which, again, sounds ridiculous. And Ryan, you could probably speak to that. But it's just the way, you know, the muscle of the House and Senate have atrophied and actually like doing real legislation. So it's going to take somebody who's very energetic and very committed specifically to that goal. Mike Johnson

Speaker 8said he was going to do that. And look at where we are. Like everything was in one big, beautiful bill. They literally called it one big, beautiful bill. So I think it would be fantastic if we could reflex that muscle.

Speaker 5But Ryan, couldn't it be like a Couldn't it be a ballroom bill that we put Medicare for all and everything else under that would actually maybe get signed by Trump? Isn't there an omnibus strategy here?

Speaker 1Yeah, you could say we're lowering Medicare age to 60 and then 55 and covering children and rolling back the Medicaid cuts and funding the ballroom.

Speaker 7He doesn't need funding for the ballroom. He's got all of the billionaires.

Speaker 6Funding the ballroom.

Speaker 5There's always more funding needed. You know, you have to buy the nice napkins and chairs and stuff.

Speaker 1Yeah, cost overruns. Yeah, believe it or not. But maybe they'll put the threshold for cloture now is 60. Maybe they'll put it to 55. Like maybe that'll be their compromise because they'll have 56 seats. And that would require you to keep most of the caucus together. And then if you, you know, and then it's still present, you know, give some minority.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 2And would allow you to lose one John Fetterman, for example, if need be. Thank God that the margin is not close and we don't have to hear too much from Matt, dude.

Speaker 3It would be just absolutely insufferable.

Speaker 5He would have started a podcast if he had so much attention. What is the timeline now for people who are normies not tracking the ins and outs? How long do these insurgent Van Hollen supporters have to create a coalition?

Speaker 1December 1st. is my understanding, right?

Speaker 2Yeah, Schumer was trying to move the vote up, but looks like he's going to be unsuccessful in that, which was a real tell that he was feeling some pressure and all of this confidence they were putting onto the press of, we've got it in the bag and look at all these alleged commitments we have. I mean, I think we can see now that was like very clearly a psyop. And some of those people have already come out and said, I didn't actually commit to you. And I'm still still sorting things out here. So it looks like Schumer failed to move that vote up. that's good for Van Hollen, gives him more time to work with

Speaker 2the members who aren't sure and see what they want and do that horse trading behind the scenes and try to secure a majority here. But I don't know, Ryan, my sense is the momentum is on his side at this point.

Speaker 3What do you think?

Speaker 1I think so. He lost his fellow Maryland Senator Angela also Brooks recently, which people saw as a blow because, you know, he really stuck his neck out to support her over the, remember there were two billionaires was Delaney and that other, the total wine guy from Western Maryland.

Speaker 12Yeah.

Speaker 1But as she put it, she said, look, I promised Chuck and your word is everything here. I didn't know he was going to run. I regret it. I love Chris, but I promised Chuck. We've all been there. But yes, he has serious momentum. Like if, you know, Ossoff, Warnock, like if that kind of cluster, Bennett, Hickenlooper said he was Hickenlooper put out this thing saying we need to be serious about AI.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Addressing AI. And he's posted a letter basically that he sent to both Van Hollen and Schumer saying my vote is up for grabs here. And for Hickenlooper, Hickenlooper is a pretty center right kind of leadership friendly senator. So to have him waffling me and.

Speaker 3He also had a very.

Speaker 2Close scare in his primary with, you know, with a massive financial advantage. And if there had been, you know, more even funding and attention there, I don't think there's any doubt he would have gone down.

Speaker 1And Bennett lost the gubernatorial primary, right?

Speaker 3That's right.

Speaker 1And so he also has moved left because when he runs for reelection, there's probably going to be a challenge from his left. So what do they say? Nothing concentrates the mind like the prospect of a hangings like so these folks are seeing um they're they're seeing which way the political wind is is blowing and so van holland's benefiting from that.

Speaker 5Well schumer was walking tall here today projecting confidence let's take a quick look at here from pablo reports a clip that ryan wish he was able to grab.

Speaker 1Right next to pablo i was like.

Speaker 5This is the shot he missed it this is the national five million views on this pablo's killing me You.

Speaker 6Get any new votes today?

Speaker 13I'm feeling good.

Speaker 6I'm confident we got the votes. Okay. Still copying.

Speaker 1There's my shadow in that video. Which one's yours?

Speaker 5He's feeling good.

Speaker 1I'm like right behind him here. I was like, he's not making any news here. And then Pablo sent it to me yesterday. He's like, check it out. Five million views.

Speaker 5This was an embodiment of something, his strength, his power, his confidence. You know, we rarely get to do a mainstream media segment where we get a body language expert on. Crystal, as our in-house body language expert, what is this projecting?

Speaker 3Youth, vitality, vigor, will to win, fighting spirit.

Speaker 10All of that.

Speaker 1He's sneaking in.

Speaker 5He's sneaking in.

Speaker 8Can we mention actually also while we're looking at this, Virginia Fox, who has held that seat for years in North Carolina, loses her race by a couple points. The woman is 83 years old. Yesterday, she filed to run again to reclaim the seat two years from now. These are the people that we are dealing with.

Speaker 3You know what's sad? How sick do you have to be in the head to win it?

Speaker 2Because what's sad is that she has a decent chance.

Speaker 1To win it. She spent one week at home and she's like, no.

Speaker 3Can't do it.

Speaker 7She didn't because she announced. She didn't even do that. She announced.

Speaker 8After she fought tooth and nail to get every, you know, because it was said it was close. So she fought tooth and nail to make sure that every single vote had been counted before they called the race. And then immediately after they called the race for her opponent, she says she's filing to get run again.

Speaker 3What's the name of the guy that beat her? Is that Chuck Hubbard? Is that his name?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1He's the one that beat her, right? And then her chief of staff, Richard Hudson, was the... Right. Her former chief of staff was the congressman that Richard... That Ojeda beat. Yeah.

Speaker 10Yeah.

Speaker 2And Hubbard is just this, like, normal guy who is, you know, normal, very Southern dude. His daughter is a lesbian. That really energized him to want to make a change. Yeah, was sounding off on Nicki Minaj, and now he's in Congress.

Speaker 6Who is this guy?

Speaker 3If you haven't seen the videos, oh, he's great.

Speaker 7He's great.

Speaker 3We should get him on the show for sure.

Speaker 2He just really, you know, gives very ordinary person who saw no one else willing to run in this district. No one thought that anyone had a prayer to win against Virginia Fox, who's this longtime institution, this deep red district. And now, lo and behold, here he is, sauntering into Washington, D.C.

Speaker 3Amazing.

Speaker 7Take an L. You're 83 years old. Take an L. Surely there is another person in the district who is maybe 70, maybe 73, who could run in two years.

Speaker 1I think she has a Christmas tree farm. Can't she tend to that?

Speaker 8What a lovely life that would be. It would be a Hallmark movie. We could do a Hallmark movie about the senator who loses.

Speaker 1This is the busy season. She needs to focus on that.

Speaker 7The congresswoman who loses.

Speaker 8I mean, there's got to be better ways to spend time.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 5Folks, friends, family, fill your life with something other than your job. It's not all about the hustle grind, okay? Well, I think with that, that was the leadership battle. Let's get to Jasper Nathaniel over in the West Bay. And we're back with a friend of the show, Jasper Nathaniel, of course, from his hit sub stack, Infinite Jazz, which is hopefully shorter to read than Infinite Jazz. Jasper, welcome back to the show.

Speaker 6Thanks for having me.

Speaker 5Jasper, we've been tracking on the show your recent coverage in the West Bank. You are now on the West Coast of the United States back safely. But please tell us about your recent experiences. And we want to throw up this piece right here at the top from Harper's that you wrote, The State of Exception in Palestine, America Abandons Its Own. Why don't you give us a little bit of a snippet of what this piece is about? This piece focuses on a village called Al-Mezral, Sharqiyah. It's

Speaker 5east of Ramallah. And you probably remember a couple incidents that happened there. One of them was the 15-year-old Palestinian-American kid, Mahmoud Ibrahim. This is where he lived, where his family has a house. He was abducted by Israeli soldiers about two years ago, charged with throwing rocks, and spent almost a year in prison. And then last July, his first cousin, Seyfalla Mousselet, was beaten to death by settlers in the village.

Speaker 5And these are just two of a number of violent incidents and abductions that have happened there. But the basic story is that this is a village that is made up of 80 to 90 percent American citizens. So these are Palestinian Americans who go back and forth. For the most part, they have homes on both continents. A lot of these folks live in one community in Tampa Bay or in a couple of other diaspora communities across the country. And, you know, for a long time, this community was pretty

Speaker 5insulated from the violence of the occupation. And in part, that was because they had blue passports and they had some degree of protection and they would flash their passports at checkpoints and get right through. And they had more money and they had better security. It was mostly in areas A and B, which meant there were not settlers coming in. And really, just in the last two to three years, has that basically collapsed. And they have found themselves in the crosshairs of the occupation and the settler movement.

Speaker 5And they have turned to their government, the U.S. government, for protection and basically found that they've been abandoned. And so, you know, the piece is both about what's happening to this community, how the U.S. has, you know, ignored them and just left them out to dry. But also, it's about the way, you know, these Palestinian Americans are having, in the most literal sense, an identity crisis, trying to understand, you know, are we really Americans? Are we, you know,

Speaker 5no different from any Palestinian who could be, you know, murdered with no justice? What exactly, you know, where do we belong?

Speaker 2And Jasper, you say this has changed over the last two to three years. And certainly, you know, your American passport wasn't enough to save you from assault. We've seen American congressmen harassed and detained, not to mention, of course, the what's being done to Palestinian Americans. So what do you think has changed?

Speaker 4Well, on the Israeli side, I mean, the the settler movement is basically in control of the West Bank. You know, they have allies very high up in the Knesset and in the cabinet, of course, you know, Smotrich and Ben-Gavir and Netanyahu. They, you know, are basically given impunity to steal land, to, you know, beat and kill Palestinians, to assault journalists. And, you know, they're emboldened, of course. You know,

Speaker 4the other thing that's happened is that You have Mike Huckabee running the U.S. embassy in Jerusalem. He is the best ally the settlers have ever had. And what the piece goes into is that he does actually sort of put on the show of having sympathy and of caring about the American Palestinians who live there. But then he just disappears. And not only that, but he, you know,

Speaker 4obscures the facts of cases. He actually, like, he has somebody on his team, David Milstein, who is.

Speaker 8I was just going to ask about him, Jasper. Can you cue us in on how powerful David Milstein is over in Jerusalem?

Speaker 13Yeah.

Speaker 4Well, David Milstein is... He's... I don't know, like, his exact ranking, but he's one of Mike Huckabee's, you know, direct... direct lieutenants, so to speak. And he is, look, I don't think it's hyperbolic to say he's a traitor in the most technical sense. I mean, there was, for example, a last year, there was, or no, I guess it was earlier this year, there was a report about nine Palestinian Americans who have been killed in the West Bank

Speaker 4in the last couple of years. And the embassy staff, not Milstein, below him, the sort of like, you know, just bureaucrats there, put together a report that showed that the Israeli government had done basically nothing to investigate these killings. Milstein spikes that report and writes a new one that just says the complete opposite and sends it to Rubio. And so, you know, we're talking about American citizens, many of them minors who have been murdered in The U.S. has a responsibility to, at the very least, investigate these murders.

Speaker 4And you have somebody in the embassy who is, you know, fudging these reports. It should be said, though, that like, you know, before Huckabee, before Milstein, Palestinian Americans were not getting a lot of support, you know, from the American government. There's a story in there about a kid named Tawfiq, Tawfiq Abdel-Jabbar, who was murdered by Israeli soldiers in January 2024. You know, this is during Biden. This is during the Blinken administration. Certainly, you know, they never got any justice.

Speaker 4I mean, you know, obviously, Rachel Corey was killed 20 years ago and her family has fought for justice through, you know, Democratic and Republican administrations, and they've been able to get nothing. So, you know, there's a long pattern, of course, of American fealty to Israel, even in the face of you know, direct violence against American citizens. But like so many things, you know, the dials have all been turned up in the Trump administration.

Speaker 5Jasper, did you hear this goodbye note or goodbye call from Biden to Netanyahu that was released recently where he was like, I'm proud of you or something?

Speaker 1I don't remember what the exact quote was.

Speaker 8Yeah.

Speaker 13Yeah.

Speaker 1Yeah. I, yeah.

Speaker 4I mean, you know, was anybody here surprised by it?

Speaker 1Um, I wanted to ask how the kind of criticisms that are coming from the Israeli propagandists on regarding the settler movement are filtering down on the ground. I saw, let me put this up here on the screen. You might've seen this, this Hen Mazig post, you know, Hen is one of the most, uh, kind of influential and out there kind of propagandists. He posted this after a 72-year-old Palestinian woman was shot in the head outside of

Speaker 1her home in the West Bank. He wrote, I have spent years defending Israel's right to protect its people. I've done it on television, on campuses, and here on social media, and I stand by all of it. That is the reason I'm posting this. On Monday night, a Palestinian woman named Fada Fadat was shot dead at her home near Jericho. The facts are still disputed, and I lay out both the army's account and your neighbor's account in the video. Israel's case, the world rests on being a country that enforces its laws. Every time a violent minority in the West Bank acts without consequences, that case gets harder to make.

Speaker 1Israeli soldiers are put at greater risk, and Israel's enemies are handed exactly what they want. I served there, and I know how much the army has to carry already. Israel's friends should be the first to demand that the law be enforced. I will update this if the facts change. It seems like you're seeing more of that, yet at the same time, you're seeing more violence. What is the relationship between these comments in English for a global audience and violence on the ground? And how are these kind

Speaker 1of violent kids that are running around shooting people in the head and throwing rocks at them and ransacking and taking over homes, how are they. How are they reacting to this type of language?

Speaker 4You know, I don't know about Hedmazig, but, you know, in general, I think people know that the violent settlers, the most violent settlers in the West Bank, including the ones who have recently stolen homes in Jericho, which is a Palestinian city where settlers are not even legally allowed to be, they have the full support of the Israeli government. They are getting protection from the IDF. They're getting strategic support. They're getting political support. They're getting money. They're getting guns.

Speaker 4I mean, our tax dollars are going to arm these people. Henmaz Agnosis, you know, look, when things get really bad from a PR perspective, like there's an attack and the video goes viral or, you know, a 72-year-old woman is shot or something like that, as he lays out in that post, like, it is harmful to Israel's reputation. It causes diplomatic issues. It causes PR issues. And, you know, if you, if you read what these people say, like

Speaker 4typically the principal issue for them is not that a 17, a 72 year old woman was murdered. It's that this is bad for Israel. And they're talking about it.

Speaker 14Yeah.

Speaker 4So you're talking about it and they're right about that. It is bad for Israel just because then, you know, people like us talk about it. And so, you know, it, What he's doing, this is part of the, frankly, this is part of the ethnic cleansing machine. Like, you have to let out exhaust. When things get really hot, you know, you have to have people like Hen Mazik, and in some cases, as high up as Netanyahu, coming out and condemning the violence. But again, like, unless you are saying...

Speaker 4all of the settlers should leave the West Bank, the settlements should be dismantled, the land should all be given back to Palestinians, then you are supporting the violent settlers because everybody, including Hen Mazik, knows that there is no settlement movement without these violent settlers because they are the ones that are emptying the land of Palestinians that the Israeli Jews are then going and building settlements on. So I don't even know if I would call it disingenuous because I think to somebody like him, it genuinely is bad. But I think that, you know, there's another step you

Speaker 4have to take, which is that, like, what is the principal bad thing here? Is it that, you know, we are empowering young, violent Jews to, you know, to murder Palestinians and steal land? Or is it that it looks bad for Israel?

Speaker 1Yeah, I was struck in your piece about the super-rich Texas guy who just had his home taken, driving past, looking at these thugs, Kind of like washing the... Yeah. Like, if you talk a little bit about that, like, it's... Even as somebody who's covered this for so many years, it's just mind-blowing that, like... Yeah. You're a Texan, you own a home, and then it's taken from you, and you're... And you can, like, look at the thieves who are there, who didn't... Yeah. Like, it's so un-American, because we're like...

Speaker 1In America, we want people to work for everything. We're against handouts. And then there's some guy who just, like, took a house... enjoy it.

Speaker 4No, it's, it's, it never ceases to shock me. You know, look, like I would encourage people to read the story because the, you know, what, what makes it important to me, it's not that like Palestinian Americans should, you know, be treated as, you know, their lives more important or, you know, of more, you know, more deserving of protection than any other Palestinian. But what it shows is that if a Texas billionaire can get his home stolen by a couple of kids who then move in with their donkeys and there's nobody

Speaker 4that he can call. There's nowhere for him to turn to get his house back. And you can literally stand in the village and look out at the people living inside of his house. If there's nowhere for him to go to try to remedy that, then what does that say about every other Palestinian across the West Bank? And what does that say about America's relationship to Israel? I mean, there's another story in the piece about Mike Huckabee, the ambassador, you know, he goes out with the family of somebody

Speaker 4who was killed, of an American who was killed. And they want to show him where it happened. And he sees that there's settlers there. And he turns to somebody at the embassy and he says, quietly, you know, thinking nobody else can hear him, is that area, which area is that? Is it area A, B, or C? And the guy says to him, that's area A. And what area A means, again, is that This is Palestinian territory that there are not supposed to be settlers. And Huckabee seems genuinely confused by this. And he says to the guy, why are there settlers there if it's Area A? And

Speaker 4the guy says to him, well, sir, nobody has removed them. And then Huckabee bails on the rest of the trip.

Speaker 1He leaves.

Speaker 12Wow.

Speaker 4Um, and so like, you know, this is the reality. You have the ambassador actually burying his head in the sand to not have to see, you know, what's, what is happening there. And I guess just the last thing I'll say with what makes this piece to me, um, so fascinating to report was that like a lot of these guys, these Palestinian Americans are conservative. They, they really like, you know, believe in their property rights above, you know, any other sort of, um, ideology. Like so many Americans, frankly,

Speaker 4a lot of them are gun owners in the United States. I shot guns with them in Florida and they go to the West Bank and they lose all of those rights, obviously. And then, you know, they turn to their representatives for help and the door is slammed shut on them. And so it is also like it's scrambling their own politics and their worldview to see like how they're being treated when push comes to shove. So So, yeah, I mean, I think the story like it shows just how bad

Speaker 4things have gotten that people like this are now, you know, in the crosshairs.

Speaker 2Jasper, is there any hope that a change of government in Israel would change anything with regard to the situation in the West Bank?

Speaker 4Look, like I don't want to suggest that a change of government would do nothing because, you know, certainly it's the case that if, you know, Netanyahu's coalition is out, if Ben-Gavir and Smotrich are out like that, there will be a material change. benefit in that there will be less like overt support for the most violent settlers. But there's no version of an Israeli government that is going to actually, you know, stop the settler movement or roll it back. So what we're talking about here is how

Speaker 4fast are they going to be able to continue to steal land? If it's more of this government, it's going to be a lot faster. If it's an Eisenhower government, it's still going to happen, but it's not going to happen quite as fast. And so like I do have some Palestinian friends in the West Bank who live in really vulnerable communities who are very much hoping that Netanyahu is out because, you know, their their lives are on the line. Their homes are on the line. But when they take a step back, there's nobody that thinks like we will finally be able to, you know, live a good,

Speaker 4decent life here in the West Bank if the government of Israel changes, because. At the end of the day, the settlement movement is– it's completely ingrained and embedded in the state of Israel. Like, there's really very little daylight between the two at this point.

Speaker 5What about a change in our government?

Speaker 4Sorry, Em.

Speaker 1What about a change in our government?

Speaker 8Yeah, I was going to– and, Jasper, I'll tack on to that how potential change in our government and then potential change as that was playing out with the formation of the Israeli government in the election, like how political pressures were sort of shaping things.

Speaker 4Your guess is as good as mine on the our government question. I mean, look, like if we cut off Weapons support, if, you know, I haven't seen any major candidates suggest an arms embargo, but theoretically, if that were to happen, you know, the MOU is up in a couple of years.

Speaker 6If a U.S.

Speaker 4President supports pulling out of that, I think it can only, you know, help the Palestinians. But, you know, Israel is also preparing for this. Netanyahu gave this speech a couple of months ago where he said, you know, we need to become like super Sparta. where we are completely on our own. We rely on nobody. We do all our own manufacturing. And I don't think they can actually do that. But they are all preparing for that. And so I think it's impossible to know at this point just how

Speaker 4much of an impact it would have, though it would certainly have some. Your question, Emily, I mean, I'll start with Eisenkot, who was sort of framed as like a centrist, you know, reasonable savior. He got, he got glossy profiles and like all the, you know, respectable magazines here. And then he had to, and this is despite as, you know, many genocidal, uh, you know, behaviors from him over the years, but,

Speaker 4but over the course of the campaign, he had to keep moving right because of just the, the state of, you know, the Israeli electorate. And so he ends up having to say, uh, I would never work with the Arab parties. And in order to get votes, he had to swear off working with the Arab parties in Israel. And as a result, that's why he's not able to form a government right now, because he made that election promise, basically. The settler movement did play a role in the campaigns because,

Speaker 4like I said, pretty much across the board, they recognize that it's a diplomatic issue. But, you know, that has to be counterbalanced with the fact that these politicians need the settler votes. They need the right wing vote. And so but there is a sort of push and pull there between recognizing this has become a diplomatic issue. And that's often how they talk about it. Like when Eisenhower talks about the settler movement again, it's not like it's bad that we're stealing Palestinian land. It's like this is upsetting our allies. I mean, you know, these European diplomats

Speaker 4got literally attacked by settlers in the West Bank a month or so ago. That's bad for them. And so, like, it is a political issue in that sense. But that is up against the fact that, you know, the people want to steal the land. And so that's the campaign promises they have to make.

Speaker 8I do have one more question, Jasper, which is just, I mean, mentioning the European diplomats, also the Washington Post stringer. We talked to Brad Lander. Ryan called him right after he was detained recently. You've seen so much of this. And as an American diplomat, I know we've talked to you about this before, but I think it's always worth asking what it's like for you to witness these things.

Speaker 4Oh, um, it's early for that kind of a question. I mean, it's, it is still shocking. It's shocking to see an older, a 65 year old American woman get beaten 65. It's, it's shocking to see anybody get beaten, but you know, um, somebody who, uh, you know, like you, you just would think what kind of a person would attack an old woman and beat them with clubs. Um,

Speaker 4it's incredibly upsetting. And at the end of the day, like though it is, it's been clarifying for me who, who the Palestinians are up against. I mean, these are savages. These are savages. And like, you know, in this video that you're showing, this is Heidi Levine, of course, a Washington Post photojournalist. helping her get away from these violent settlers, there were soldiers there watching. There was, there were Israeli soldiers there watching, um, firing tear gas at us as I,

Speaker 4you know, we were trying to rescue this woman. And so it just, it's, it's like, it's clarifying that this is who you're up against. And, you know, I have this other piece that I wrote this week, um, in the Paris review about two weeks after the lesson, two weeks after this, I was myself beaten by settlers and arrested. And, and in my interrogation, you know, they were accusing me of provoking this specific incident. You know, they said, you know, we saw what happened. Like you're at, you're out there, like,

Speaker 4you know, they're, they're looking at these settlers and they're accusing me of provoking them or they're looking at these Palestinians who are, you know, throwing rocks to defend their village and they're accusing them of being terrorists. And so like, It's just, I'm sort of at a loss for words with this question. I mean, it's a good question, but it's really just, it brings the whole thing into such clarity that, you know, the Israeli government, to be clear, backs these guys. Like they give their full support to

Speaker 4those guys. And a Palestinian who so much as picks up a stone to defend his village or to rescue an American journalist, could be shot by a sniper or arrested and spent decades in prison or, you know, disappeared or, you know, at the very least, um, you know, the village will be raided right after this, literally minutes after this, the Israeli military who was right there watching rather than go after these guys, they went and shot a Palestinian

Speaker 4in the village and nobody's been arrested from this or nobody's been charged. So it just, it, it, it brings everything into such clarity. You know, also like the settlers here, we know where they live. I mean, they live in an outpost on the top of the hill that the Israeli security authorities, they all know this and they choose to let them live there. And so it just, it's clarifying, I guess. It really is clarifying. It's so straightforward what's

Speaker 4happening in the West Bank. I mean, I've run into reporters from, all the major newspapers in the field. And like, you know, some of them have to be more sort of measured in their language because of who they're writing for. But all, I mean, when we talk, they all, we're all on the same page. Like this is just insane. Like it is so clear that there's just a violent ethnic cleansing campaign going on with the full support of the Israeli government and they're doing nothing to stop it. They are supporting it. And it's just, you know, it's

Speaker 4one of the great, the grave, you know, moral catastrophes of our time.

Speaker 5Well, Jasper, we thank you so much for putting, you know, your body on the line out there to document all this stuff. We know that you're now a target of the government.

Speaker 1They're very aware of the.

Speaker 5Journalism that you bring back to America. So we're really grateful for that. And we hope that you remain safe as well as you continue this hard work. That's going to be Infinite Jazz on Substack and anywhere else they can follow you or check out your work right now.

Speaker 4Infinite jazz on all those platforms. But yeah, I really want to encourage people to read that, the Harper's piece. And also there's a piece in the Paris Review. But I think both of them really, you know, they show shocking incidents, but they also tell these stories of what's happening over there that I think are really important. And maybe the last thing I'll just say is like the Harper's one in particular, I mean it. You know, if you have friends who are, you know, perhaps conservative and, you know, maybe they're not the type that are thinking

Speaker 4about Palestinians all the time. Like, I think that this is a story that will shock their conscience just in the sense of like what America is letting happen to its own citizens. So definitely, you know, pass that along to people who may be moved by it.

Speaker 6Absolutely. We will.

Speaker 5We'll share that link in our description. And we thank you. And we'll check back in with you again very soon, Jasper.

Speaker 6Thanks. Have a good one.

Speaker 8Okay.

Speaker 4Thanks, everyone.

Speaker 5All right.

Speaker 1That was Jasper.

Speaker 5But let's look back over at New York City for a second. Checking in on Mamdani Stan. Mayor Zor Mamdani has a new announcement. Let's see what he's up to. He is closing Rikers. Once and for all, let's take a listen.

Speaker 15This is Rikers Island.

Speaker 6Rikers Island, the country's second largest jail.

Speaker 4New York's infamous city jail, Rikers Island.

Speaker 15One of the most violent jails in the country. The suicide of police router.

Speaker 13There's thousands more like myself who are incarcerated here over the years.

Speaker 1At Rikers, out of sight and out of mind is the norm.

Speaker 15That is why our administration is opposing Rikers Island once and for all. And building a city where we ask ourselves what a person needs, not just what they're accused of. And in its place, we will open four borough-based jails starting in 2029.

Speaker 13These jails will be closer to public transit from New Yorkers and reach family, legal counsel, and court faster. They will house thousands fewer New Yorkers, which will help correctional staff.

Speaker 6Better protect those in custody.

Speaker 15We're also adding hundreds of therapeutic beds across our city. These beds will move individuals with serious mental health and medical issues from jails to hospitals with around-the-clock care. We'll work across city agencies to speed up the exchange of evidence and address court backlogs. Our city is safest when our government refuses to accept failed approaches to public safety just because it's always been done this way.

Speaker 5All right, Rikers closing. Crystal, you wanted to bring this up. Your first thoughts.

Speaker 2And Ryan, I know, was focused on this as well. I mean, to be honest with you, I was kind of surprised how emotionally affected I was by learning that they were going to actually dive in and to what is a very politically fraught and I'm sure complicated challenge to close Rikers. Because this is, you know, I've been covering and watching these abuses and the violence there and the horror there and the dysfunction for so many years. It just felt like one of those horrific, intractable things. that everyone knows is there and is horrified by, but

Speaker 2it never ends and it never changes. And so to see him standing there, by the way, with, you know, the man that he put in charge of corrections, who himself was a Rikers detainee for two years. He was, he, you know, committed a theft robbery. And then he, you know, went through the system, reformed, rose up through the ranks of various organizations and finds himself in this position of power now.

Speaker 3It's just, It's incredibly moving.

Speaker 2And obviously, you know, there's years to go before this plan comes to fruition. And it's actually a done deal. But I think it's extraordinary that he plunged headfirst into this very, very difficult and very ugly situation. He, you know, just to name check, one of the things he mentions there, the suicide of Kalief Browder. And this is now over a decade ago that this occurred. So I want to make sure people know the details. This is a boy who was arrested when he was 16 for allegedly stealing a backpack. waited three years in Rikers for a trial

Speaker 2and eventually killed himself. So that's the type of horror that we're talking about coming out of this place.

Speaker 1Yeah, the place is just an absolute walking human, not walking, standing human rights nightmare. My cousin used to work there and I was talking to her about this last night as we were thinking about this segment. And she was saying that this is a kind of They also need to make sure that wherever they redevelop Rikers, if you're going to have the same guards, they're going to need some significant retraining. There's a real culture of abuse there,

Speaker 1abuse and neglect. But this is a generational opportunity to create something that is not just humane, but actually works. None of this is working. So many people who are in Rikers are in there for basically nothing. I remember being in a courtroom one time and I saw six guys come through who were accused of basically taking some oranges outside of a bodega. And the judge delayed their

Speaker 1trial and sent them back to Rikers for eight months. Next guy was a homeless person who had taken a bunch of New York Times out of a stack of things.

Speaker 6Crime.

Speaker 1Shouldn't do that. He sent him back. He's like, all right, your trial's postponed until whatever, it was like 10 months later, back to Rikers.

Speaker 5For like a $ 10 crime? Like how much money even is that?

Speaker 1The place is filled with those kinds of people that taxpayers are spending enormous amounts of money to keep in there and we're destroying their lives and making it much less likely that they're going to ever become kind of healthy, productive members of society. And so it doesn't work. It doesn't work for them. It doesn't work for us. It doesn't work for anybody.

Speaker 6And so.

Speaker 1as they redevelop this, hopefully they'll be able to find ways that it actually is beneficial to society.

Speaker 8It's amazing to watch Mayor Mamdani navigate the public safety politics. I actually think one year into your administration, less than one year into your administration, is remarkably fast. I know people were frustrated that it hadn't happened sooner, but I think it's actually a pretty in the perspective of how much time you have as mayor, you don't know if you're going to get another term.

Speaker 7I mean, he's very popular, so he probably could. But that actually seems to me very fast.

Speaker 8And I think it shows you give the guy time he's delivering on. I think, Ryan, you use the term generational change. But if you told somebody when Andrew Cuomo announced his run for mayor that not only would he lose to a genuine leftist socialist, but but that Rikers would actually be announced closing in November of 2026. I mean, it would have been hard for anybody to believe, even the most hopeful person on the left.

Speaker 7And so it's quite a political story.

Speaker 8If your left is looking for optimism in our political process, Look no further than this. Of course, it's still going to be a challenge for him to make sure that, you know, every time there's a public safety story, it doesn't come back to saying, well, look, he's taking these big steps. He closed Rikers. He disbanded the protest special response group and all that sort of like that is going to be a mounting challenge as he makes these. big decisions for him to deal with politically. But that's that is absolutely generational. And if you're if you're leftist

Speaker 8looking for optimism, if you're anybody looking for optimism in the system, this stuff can happen.

Speaker 5Emily mentioned disbanding of the SRG, which I don't know if we covered on the show as well this week. Lots of moves from Donnie. Ryan, can you explain that for our audience a little bit? Because that also was seen as a major leftist win against or subverting part of the NYPD.

Speaker 1Yeah, this was this kind of paramilitary unit that had authority over protests as well as also counterterrorism. And people argued, like, this is crazy. Like, you should not be having your kind of paramilitary counterterror force also dealing with, like, grandmas who are just sitting down in the street, you know, protesting whatever it is they're protesting and just doing civil disobedience because they're going to then. They're going to escalate like this paramilitary force is going

Speaker 1to escalate the situation and it's going to lead to violence. And so he's replacing it with for protests are going to have basically unarmed representatives of the state. Now, if there are people who are committing civil disobedience with the specific intent of getting arrested, like they're sitting down in the street, they want to get arrested. Like that's the goal of the protest. Then they're going to have officers with arrest authority who can come in and carry out those arrests sometimes it actually really frustrates protesters if you

Speaker 1just leave them there for days like wait we were planning on making our point getting arrested um you know get.

Speaker 5And then handcuffing yourself to a building like laura loomer did to twitter and then no one caring and people just moving.

Speaker 1Around that's that's cruel yes and so so they're replacing it with a unit who's it's who will just be doing that. And there, you know, it's, it's not abolishing the police. It's not completely getting rid of the entire function of the thing. So, you know, there've been some criticism, but I think that pretty marginal at this point.

Speaker 6Okay.

Speaker 5Well, that was our update.

Speaker 1You had, you had got the Alex Vitale, who's the radical, like, no, no, I really mean abolish the police. Like wrote the book on, we need to actually, I'm not, I don't mean this as like a slogan. Like, No police. Even he was like, this is a good step forward. But doesn't leave a lot of room for critics around him.

Speaker 5It seems like a large coalition brewing around this. Not a lot of tears for Rikers. And that'll do it for New York City. Why don't we look at A.I.

Speaker 17All right.

Speaker 2Yesterday, we spoke with Gary Marcus about the Anthropic IPO, and a lot has happened since then. So Gary Marcus is back with us. He is Professor Emeritus of Psychology and Neuroscience at New York University and author of the Marcus on AI Substack.

Speaker 3Great to have you back, Gary.

Speaker 6Pleasure.

Speaker 2So since we last spoke, what has transpired? How has it gone for Anthropic and how has it gone for the markets in general?

Speaker 18Well, so when we talked, Anthropic was planning on an IPO at 83. And when the market opened, it opened at 111. So people who were able to buy early in advance got it at 83. The rest of the people bought it at 111. I think hoping that it would rise like a rocket. Instead, it fell like a stone. So it fell over the day from 111 to 97. And I don't have my little stock chart in front of me, but it's falling more this morning.

Speaker 689 now. Now it's at 89. It's about 10, 15 a.m.

Speaker 18So, you know, anybody who bought it in those opening moments and all the exuberance after so much of the press kind of vaunted the thing, they all lost money. Some of them lost, I don't know, 25% already, at least on paper, in, you know, a day of trading. Some people lost, you know, 15% in an hour, basically, because it fell very quickly. So that's one thing that happened. Second thing to comment on is, I think a lot of, and we talked about this, I think, yesterday, a lot of people in the AI industry were hoping that this IPO would be super successful. because there was a lot

Speaker 18of headwinds on the industry already. So there was the credit crisis with CoreWeave was one thing that started making things go down. Then NVIDIA has what we'll call the Huang affair and so forth. And so that has driven things down. And so the industry was really talking up.

Speaker 6The anthropic IPO.

Speaker 18Even people that I think hate anthropic don't actually like Dario, et cetera, were talking it up because they wanted to save the industry. And instead, what we've seen is the opposite. The whole market is going down. And that's not just the U.S. market, but the Asian market as well. Now the European market, everything is down. The bump that people were hoping for, and we actually saw yesterday right after we talked in the opening bell, there was a little bump. And then it's been just straight downhill basically for everybody. So it's not looking like Anthropix is going to save anything.

Speaker 18And if anything, it might be the opposite, that people are like, well, you know, that was my chance. I better get out because that's not working.

Speaker 1So what is this? So let's say that with interest rates and with the ability to you know, invest heavily and continue to lose many, many billions of dollars a year. What does that do for kind of your take on the just compute first approach to AI? Just build, build, build, and just by brute force grow. Like what is it? How is it going to change the economics and kind of the ideology?

Speaker 18I was never fond of it, but I think it's going to die. So I was never fond of it for technical reasons, which is I thought, this idea of just building bigger data centers, collecting more data, was not actually going to bring us to the promised land of artificial general intelligence. And the whole industry kind of needs to have artificial general intelligence. The problem with what we have now is it's technically unreliable. And so people don't get return on their investments because the systems produce so-called AI slop and hallucinations and so forth. The output often looks great, but if you look carefully, it's not, and

Speaker 18you have to put in a lot of work. And at the end of the day, you maybe don't get that much ROI.

Speaker 6Right.

Speaker 18So the fantasy was if we had built big enough data centers, we'd solve all those problems. But first of all, I don't think that's happening. Second of all, we're making optimizations so people can use smaller models that aren't on the clouds, that don't need the data centers. That's the trend. We're not all the way there, but the trend is towards that, which already meant that we were probably going to build too much capacity. But now I think the enthusiasm for doing it is diminished, and that makes it more expensive. because the banks are rightly saying, I'm really

Speaker 18going to give you credit for this? Yesterday, there was an announcement that bankers were resisting Elon putting data centers in space because the chips would go up there and people wouldn't be able to recover them if loans weren't paid back. There's been a total shift in the mood from, hey, we will pour any money that we can possibly find into this very speculative, honestly, venture.

Speaker 2Well, and something else that you said yesterday, Gary, is I asked you basically like, OK, well, when is the shit going to hit the fan? And you were like, well, it low key kind of is hitting the fan. And here's some numbers I know you post reposted this tweet. This is from Bull Theory. They say these numbers are ridiculous. The top AI stocks are down 53% on average from their peak. In the dot-com crash, the top stocks fell 89% in 2008. They fell 87%, but it took two and a half years for the dot-com crash to play out. And about one and a half years in 2008, AI

Speaker 2stocks have just lost 53% in five months. And it goes on from there to show some details and also this very helpful graphic here about the AI bubble, is already halfway to a dot-com crash. So talk us through, you know, the extent of these losses and why, I guess, the mood, if this is such a significant crash, why the mood doesn't feel as apocalyptic as I recall it feeling back in 2008.

Speaker 18I mean, I think for some people it is starting to feel apocalyptic, and you might want to ask that question again on Monday. Like, you know, if it continues this way, to the end of the day, and Anthropic falls below its IPO price, I think people are going to be thinking about it as an apocalypse. And I mean, if you read the reaction on Twitter today, it's a lot of people are, you know, pretty concerned. For a long time, people would ask me, you know, you, Gary, you've been arguing for a while that generative AI is going to crash, but it hasn't really crashed. How do you think about this? And what I kept saying is, well,

Speaker 18there's two issues. One is about the fundamentals, and the fundamentals are These companies don't make profits. I said, you know, NVIDIA is making profits because people are buying their chips, but the end users, by which I meant both the LLM companies, the large language model companies, and the end users like the Fortune 500 companies are not really making money from this. So the Fortune 500 companies aren't getting ROI and the LLM companies are actually losing money because it costs so much to train their models and increasingly.

Speaker 6More and so forth. And so I said, the.

Speaker 18The numbers never made sense. And we always could tell, or I could tell since 2023, that there was going to be no moat, that everybody's building the same thing, and that was going to mean price wars. And that has increasingly happened. So I saw all of this all along, but I said that the missing part is the psychology of it. And I kept using the metaphor of Wile E. Coyote going off of a cliff. I said, you know, if you remember the cartoon, he doesn't fall until he notices. And there's kind of like, it's like, you can't look down. Once he looks down, it's all over. And the last

Speaker 18few weeks look like people are looking down and like that psychological moment has come.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 18You can have kind of a meme stock vibe for a long time. I think we did where people were just like so excited by all this stuff that they would pay any amount of money to get their hands on it. And now once they reconsider and they look at the math, they're like, what am I doing here? And so I think that reconsideration moment has come and people are looking down and it's falling.

Speaker 5So are the anthropic shares going down because of all the things you've laid out in the wider industry? Or what is this change from evaluation and then it going down for, like, normies who don't understand these kind of things?

Speaker 6Like, why is it sinking?

Speaker 18Nobody can know for sure, but I think it's probably a combination of things. One is some people just bought it to flip it. Like, a lot of people bought it to flip it. And those flippers maybe don't have... you know, nerves of steel and they're seeing it's not working and they're like, I better get out of here. So some of it is like short-term day trader kind of dynamics. Some of it, I think, is people were looking to it, as I said, to save the industry and they're like, well, that's not happening. And so, you know, some of it, it's like using it as a barometer

Speaker 18and the barometer doesn't look good. And, you know, now we're kind of like in a bank run or panic kind of cycle where, you know, it keeps falling. I mean, it did fall more overnight and come back a little bit, but it's, you know, it's down for the day. and significantly down for the day. And so I think that leads people to panic. And I think a lot of people in the industry, I've heard this, but indirectly, a lot of people in the industry never thought it made sense, but they're like, I can't be the guy in my company, the trader in my company that doesn't buy it if it goes up. And so I don't want to look stupid,

Speaker 18so I'm going to go in. Well, that kind of died. And so people aren't going to do it just because of fear of missing out or being embarrassed in front of their friends anymore.

Speaker 6And then they're like, okay, I better get the hell out.

Speaker 5FOMO is powerful.

Speaker 1Ryan, what were you going to ask? Um, I forget what I was, I forget what I was going to ask, but what I will ask is, is so you're, you're, you've always kind of argued that they have to add in kind of this neuro symbolic approach, um, is, is the collapse of the, the purely generative, like compute based approach going to, kind of incentivize them in some ways?

Speaker 18Like, is this a needed corrective? Yeah, there's two things or three things to say about that. First, what neurosymbolic AI is, is combining the scaling neural network approach that's popular with borrowing ideas from classical AI that these guys kept ridiculing for years. People like Jeff Hinton were like, that's like ether was scientific mistake. You shouldn't do that. The reality is neurosymbolic AI won. Most people don't realize that, but all the companies are actually doing some neurosymbolic AI now. They're They use words like harnesses and tools and stuff

Speaker 18like that. Nobody is actually trying to make pure scaling work anymore. Neurosymbolic did win. The fact that the public doesn't know that is because the companies don't want the public to know that because they wanted to sell the scaling story to investors. Maybe another time we could talk about why. So Neurosymbolic AI did win, but it's still not enough. We need other innovations. Things like world models, for example, that I've been writing about for years. There's still other things that we need to do. And to your question, I do think that short-term pain can lead

Speaker 18to long-term gain. It's like necessity is the mother of invention. People thought they could just do the scaling thing and it did not work, but people didn't want to accept that it didn't work because they were financially incented to sell scaling, get 2% management fees and all this kind of stuff. That's going to change. So there's going to be short-term pain for sure. I mean, that seems to be where we're at it. unless something radical shifts this, which I guess is always possible. But unless something radically shifts, stops the descent really radically, I think it will lead

Speaker 18people to look for other answers. The other reason to look for other answers is we have not gotten the ROI that we all know is possible. We know it's possible in principle to have AI that's as good as humans. There's nothing magical about being a carbon-based body as opposed to having a silicon digital brain. It should be possible to to build artificial general intelligence. It's just that this approach hasn't worked as well as people thought. And when the mania dies down, that's when people reflect and maybe do something better. So I do think there's a little

Speaker 18bit of Phoenix from the flames.

Speaker 1I do think.

Speaker 18That we will see better AI that we can actually trust emerge in part because this was a failure. I don't know the timescale of that because it requires fundamental innovations. But for a while, deep learning, large language models were sucking the oxygen from absolutely everything in the room. And now people have to kind of re-evaluate things. They will see that the neurosymbolic AI, which is one part of what we need to do, was actually helping them, that the scaling was not taking as far taking them as far as they want. And it will be, I think, a time for reflection.

Speaker 1Gary, let me ask.

Speaker 3Go ahead, Ryan.

Speaker 1Just real quick. Yeah, I remember what I was going to ask, which is you mentioned the failure to meet the kind of revenue that would be needed to justify what is going on. Yet at the same time, if you look around the world, clearly AI is having a huge dislocative effect on some employment somewhere. Like if India, for instance, seems to be India has this giant cockroach movement of all these students who are out in the streets, which seems to be somewhat connected to the pathway for

Speaker 1young Indian people who would move into IT and software and work for these global companies. That pathway just seems to be getting wrecked. I don't know if it's a coincidence, but it seems to be somewhat connected with these companies just not hiring, starting with young Indian engineers and software developers, but then We also seem to be seeing young people in the U.S. having a hard time, too. If that's AI-related, where's that money going? Why aren't the AI companies? And is it AI-related?

Speaker 2Yeah, I was going to ask something very similar, and here are some of the numbers on youth unemployment here and around the world and China as well, where it's spiked dramatically.

Speaker 18So I guess there's a couple of things to say. First is, my issue is not actually revenue. It's about profits. It just costs too much to build these models. And it increasingly costs more and more to eke out small gains. So I recently posted something that Rameznan plotted, which was like to get four more points on the benchmark, like used to take $ 100 million, then a billion, now it's like $ 10 billion. So the costs are rising exponentially. And meanwhile, you have a price war. So the result of that

Speaker 18is that everybody's losing money doing this. It doesn't mean that there isn't some value in using the technology for some people. And it is getting cheaper to use it, but it means that the vendors of this stuff don't really have a profit model. So that's the first part. It's an aside, but it's an important one. The second thing is it's still unclear how well AI is replacing entry-level jobs. What is clearer to me is that people want it to. The employers want it to. And so

Speaker 18they're not hiring entry-level people. Sometimes there's what I call Klarna effect.

Speaker 1Klarna was.

Speaker 18because it's a payday loan kind of company or something like that, they made a big announcement about getting rid of or not hiring any more human employees. They were going to use AI for everything. And then like 10 months later, they walked it back and were like, we've learned that humans are still valuable. And they started hiring humans again. And so a lot of companies have actually done that. And I keep calling it the Klarna effect because they were kind of the first to kind of walk that path. So one question is whether these things are long-term or not. Another question is, in some cases,

Speaker 18they probably really are going to happen. We really are going to lose entry-level jobs. In some cases, AI will be able to do those entry-level jobs, and often entry-level people aren't that good at the job. I mean, they just started. They don't really know how to do it. But we're going to wind up with a pipeline problem, what I like to call a pipeline problem, which is we're not going to train the people who do know what they're doing. So, like, in software, you can do a lot of low-level coding stuff that you might have outsourced to India before with these tools. But what you can't do is a kind of high-level software architecture. How

Speaker 18do you manage a project as a whole and so forth? And most people only learn that by doing the low-level stuff first and kind of going through the ranks, and they're not anymore. So we have a generation of youth that's not really getting hired. We have a pipeline problem that we may not really get the people that we need.

Speaker 6It's a bit of a mess.

Speaker 2And Gary, I wanted to get your thoughts on what's going on right now with all of these, you know, the airlines grounded and Microsoft Outlook and Teams down and major crypto heists and banks down and NSA has been down all week, which is crazy to me that they're still working from home because their communications network is still down. The cybersecurity director in this administration was just forced down. A lot of stuff happening. I think it's a lot of different things. I think some of it is from trying to patch. I think some of it is obviously

Speaker 2from hacking attacks. All of it does seem to stem from AI. And so I wanted to get your sense of what's going on there. And also, if this isn't a sort of make work project also for AI, because if you've unleashed this stuff. and you're a company that's now trying to defend against whatever, either nation state or individual or rogue or gang hackers are coming at you, then you are going to need the very latest model to try to protect yourself from what is going on out there in the world.

Speaker 18I think everything you just said is right. There are multiple factors, multiple things going on. The AI companies are there, kind of like protection rackets. Hey, it would be a shame if somebody broke your windows. Maybe we can help you out. So you have that going. I will say I told you so. I wrote a piece in Politico at the beginning of 2025 where they wanted what they called a black swan prediction, something that might happen soon, might not. But like you could see the writing on the wall. And I said, we're going to see soon. I didn't quite get the timing right. Our biggest cybersecurity

Speaker 18problems of all time. And I gave three reasons for that. One was that generative AI writes sloppy code that is vulnerable and it can be hacked itself. Another one of the reasons I said is Trump is coming in and he is going to cut agencies like CISA.

Speaker 6I didn't quite give those words.

Speaker 18But I said we're not going to have enough staff to deal with it. And I think that is part of the problem is we don't have enough staff to deal with it. I think the thing I didn't fully anticipate was how good these things would become at detecting vulnerabilities. And that is also a big part of the problem. I think when a guy like Rubio gets on TV and says it's not all cyber attacks– you know, at least a few days ago, that was true. I think now the cyber attacks are trickling in. So it's multiple things. Some of it's cyber attacks, some of it's discovery of vulnerabilities by malicious people. Some of it's just some of

Speaker 18the code written recently is not that good. And the sheer velocity of it means that nobody's really positioned to deal with it. And we have like, we don't have the mission command in Washington that we should have to try to deal with this. And so like people are just bumbling their way through and it is bad.

Speaker 5Is there a company that's trying to corner this now newly needed cyber defense market? They're like, oh, look, everything's on fire now. I guess you need us.

Speaker 18Well, OpenAI is trying to corner it, and a lot of small startups are. And it's going to be a big enough business to have room for multiple players. I think the interesting question is whether it's an enduring business. So some of the people who know this stuff better than I do— have the optimistic view that it won't last forever. So they all have the pessimistic view that in the short term, it can get worse before it gets better. But some people think what will happen over a couple of years is we'll get better at writing bug-free code, and we will kind of burn this out

Speaker 18because we'll find all the vulnerabilities. I'm not as optimistic. I think it's hard to write bug-free code, especially in existing languages. And if you want to rewrite everything in more stable languages, that's a problem project in itself. But there's some reason to think that we will eventually be able to deal with this. But I wouldn't, you know, expect it to be tomorrow. And honestly, I'm going out to get jugs of water as soon as I'm done my interviews for the day. Like, you know, the short term is not great.

Speaker 3Yeah.

Speaker 1I don't like to hear Gary Marcus say he's going out to get jugs of water. Yeah, I'm not into that either.

Speaker 6It is literally true. It is literally true.

Speaker 18I wanted to buy them yesterday. There were too many interviews and I couldn't go.

Speaker 2Well, we'll get you on to this one here in just a second. I just have one more for you. I will say, though, I was listening to cybersecurity experts talking to Derek Thompson, who was saying that these companies that do things like CrowdStrike that, you know, handle hacks and, you know, are already established, they're having to pull in like top level executives who haven't done this sort of, you know, active work in the field for years.

Speaker 18It's like COVID when they had to bring retired doctors in.

Speaker 2Yes, because they're so overwhelmed with the caseload. Just to give you a sense, because there is some narrative out there, too, like, oh, it's not different. We're just noticing more and it's getting covered more.

Speaker 3But no, there is something different going on here.

Speaker 18I was rare that I would plug another network, but I'll tell you something I'm excited to do. On CBC on Sunday, I don't know the time, Dmitry Alperovitch, if I've said his name right, who co-founded CrowdStrike and I, are going to do a panel together. I'm really looking forward to learning his take and interacting with him.

Speaker 2So, Gary, bottom line it for us with regard to if this is the bubble popping moment, what can people expect? How bad are things? Could things get?

Speaker 18The worst case is the banks go under.

Speaker 11Right.

Speaker 18The milder case is just a bunch of people who made bad bets and they lose some money. But the worst case is this stuff gets stuffed into the index fund. a lot of people lose money in their retirement funds. The banks lose a lot of money because they made a lot of bets, bad bets on things like the so-called neoclouds like CoreWeave. And we start hearing about needing bailouts. And, you know, I posted something on Twitter about a year and a half ago saying, you know, the countdown to their demands for bailouts begin. They're going to say, what about China? We need to catch up. And, you know,

Speaker 18we're going to hear that in the next couple of weeks that they need to bail out. And my attitude is, no, they don't. You know, Google will keep making generative AI models, even if OpenAI and Anthropic go out of business. We don't need to bail these companies out. Let capitalism take its course.

Speaker 12Amen.

Speaker 3Agree with that. Gary Marcus, thank you so much. Really appreciate your time. Go out and get your water. Do what you need to do. And we hope you'll come back and see us again soon.

Speaker 6My pleasure. I'd be happy to come back.

Speaker 1All right.

Speaker 5Now for a much requested segment in the comments. We are here to talk about the most important thing that happened in the world this week.

Speaker 1Not the IPO. None of the war.

Speaker 5We're talking Grand Theft Auto 6 with Washington Post digital critic Gene Park.

Speaker 16Gene, I'm a big fan. Been following your work for years. Welcome to the show. I appreciate that. Thanks so much for having me. I'm a big fan on this side over here, too. So this was huge.

Speaker 6Awesome.

Speaker 5Well, it is, like I said, your Super Bowl week. I'm sure you're flying from interview to interview. But we wanted to start, you know, we have a lot to get into with the cultural reaction to this show, some of the business and analytics behind it. But first, a really important question from Ryan. When Ryan asked me right before the game came out, can my 10-year-old son... play Grand Theft Auto 6. Your response, Gene?

Speaker 16I would highly recommend parents do not buy their small children. Teenage children, maybe, right? I think their minds are a little bit developed. It's not exactly like alcohol, right? But I would highly recommend parents do not buy their children Grand Theft Auto 6, even if they're well aware or even if they have to have a conversation with them, I think the better choice would be to not engage with the product yet.

Speaker 5And is that a content warning? What specifically about this game? Because, you know, there's games where you shoot people, shoot aliens or whatever.

Speaker 7Can I ask? I'll just tack on to that.

Speaker 1I think some people aren't... Okay. I show speed getting killed.

Speaker 6Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 5And I don't think some people.

Speaker 1I don't think some people are.

Speaker 8fully aware of the Grand Theft Auto tradition, and if they're really now hearing about Grand Theft Auto 6 and seeing some of these videos of people getting shot to pieces and slashed by polar bears or whatever else, they might think, oh, is this new? So is it worse in Grand Theft Auto 6 as well? I just want to tack that onto the question.

Speaker 6Well, that's an interesting question because is it worse?

Speaker 15No.

Speaker 16I think the actual content of the game is not worse. Grand Theft Auto is a series that has poured a controversy for the past two decades, right? It's been known as a series where you hire a prostitute, do your business with them, and then when they leave with your money, you can go back into your car or you stay in your car and then you run them over so you can get your money back, right? That was a famous, famous example back in 2001. But now, you can't do

Speaker 16that in Grand Theft Auto VI. There are no prostitutes for you to hire. There is no sex work that you can engage in. And you can't just kill somebody to get your money back, unless you were robbed by them. The other thing, though, is that the violence in this game has been... The depiction of the realism has been definitely ramped up to... to 9 or 10. I wouldn't say 11, but it's pretty extreme. As you said, when you shoot somebody with a shotgun, they will fly to pieces,

Speaker 16and it's pretty gross. There are spurts of blood everywhere. Griffin, you asked about content. There's straight-up nudity. I watched some streamers last night where they encountered an orgy with full frontal nudity, and then they had to cover their screen because it's violating a TOS in their various streaming sites. So again, if it's too raunchy for Twitch, and some of these adult streamers who don't like seeing rampant nudity

Speaker 16in their games, then yeah, I think there's a fair warning. I think the game handles its content fairly responsibly, but it also still allows the same kind of freedom that it had there before. But to your question, Emily, It's making people feel bad to be violent against other people because of how realistic it is.

Speaker 5Yes, I feel the same way. Every generation of Grand Theft Auto, it feels like the most real looking because you're kind of used to PlayStation 2 graphics or PlayStation 3 graphics. But you look at those back then, those seem very cartoony, low polygon. But if you go into a mall in Grand Theft Auto 6 and you start shooting it up, there is a darkness to that, that it really feels far more intense when you can see realistic limbs and realistic body parts flying off. There's something a little bit more bleak to that. And the way

Speaker 5everyone's screaming and everything, it's awful. It's genuinely an awful experience, unless you need to get your head checked. And so maybe it's encouraging people to be more law-abiding citizens than they would have in previous games. But you mentioned I mean, it's not a.

Speaker 8Crazy argument that when you're shooting a cartoon and there's like a little pixel, like big fat pixels of blood that come out of it, it's an entirely different experience than when you're shooting something that is increasingly so realistically humorous.

Speaker 5So I don't think it's a crazy argument. Stick figures versus life sim. But, you know, Gene, you did mention Fox News and Fox News has had a classic time as old as time tradition. of critiquing the GTA games and then being like, this is where our culture is. So I wanted to play two clips from recent Fox News worrying about this.

Speaker 6Let's take a listen.

Speaker 17But apparently you still can in this game visit strip clubs, take drugs, commit random acts of violence. Look, we have a First Amendment in this idea. You can do what you want in a game. But I do worry about the effect on a young generation. Paris, there's this Daily Mail headline.

Speaker 5So a lot of people have been upset that you can no longer engage in prostitution. A lot of right wing or conservative leaning gamers online, which there are far more many now than there were in previous GTAs. are saying the game is now woke. The Chuds are saying the game has gone woke. What is your opinion after playing probably 100 hours of this game?

Speaker 16I mean, you know, woke, quote-unquote woke allegations are always said in bad faith, you know, especially in gaming space. Those allegations have been from a small minority, you know, but... They are always lodged against pretty much every new game release. Every major new game release. Even indie game releases too. A good friend of mine who's trans was a voice actor in a very small indie game made by five

Speaker 16Eastern Europeans. And they tried to cancel that game because she's involved in there just because she's trans. She's quite apolitical. But she's merely trans and they couldn't leave that alone. Yet the game's still so... sold blockbuster numbers, over 100,000 copies, which is a lot of money for five people. So, you know, the impact of these complaints are quite minimal, as we've seen, but they're very loud. And they can shape discourse around the game. And there's so much misinformation

Speaker 16around Grand Theft Auto 6 that I'm noticing right now, where people are saying like, oh, like I saw one clip where he was trying to shoot up a club and he said, oh, you can't shoot up gay clubs in here. And the club that I saw, well, first of all, there are no gay clubs in Grand Theft Auto 6. There's no gay-only club. They're just regular clubs. And you can't go in and shoot in any of them. They made sure of that. And they're like, oh, well, why couldn't you do that? It's like, you couldn't do that in Grand Theft Auto 5 either. And Grand Theft Auto 5 is the one that all the quote-unquote chuds

Speaker 16are citing as the one that isn't woke.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 16And it's the same thing. So, you know, all of this is an extremely, extremely bad faith.

Speaker 8Yes.

Speaker 5There also seems to be drama centering around the fact that in this one, you are in a relationship with a female woman. And there seems to be a lot of rage around this. Now, I would say one of the biggest video game streamers, but also one of the biggest conservative commentators is this gentleman named Asmongold. Um, and Asmongold has been critiquing the game. Now he says the game is good, but he's been critiquing the game for having to, uh, buy flowers and clothes for his girlfriend,

Speaker 5calling it a cuck simulator.

Speaker 8Um, what is your, this is, can I just say, this is horseshoe gamer gate, like the complaints, right? Or now that you can't like bang prostitutes and you have to have a girlfriend.

Speaker 7This is what is woke now. I, whatever.

Speaker 16Yeah, yeah, that's problematic, right? To have a traditional heterosexual relationship within the bounds of the law, right?

Speaker 4Isn't that interesting?

Speaker 16Listen, I've been watching Asmongold for a long time.

Speaker 6Same.

Speaker 16He actually reads my work, too. Because Asmongold has been a streamer for a very long time, and he's developed his arc over time. A lot of what he says is very performative, sometimes made in jest, a lot of times made very seriously. But, you know, again, it goes to show it's very, because he likes the game, but then he'll he'll take little jabs at it to make sure that you know his audience is is feeling you know uh comfortable with with with with their with their insecurities basically you know uh i i have to imagine

Speaker 16that for someone who's never experienced a relationship before that the game would feel almost an attack on their own lives or a.

Speaker 6Critique on it. When it really isn't.

Speaker 16It's just about these two characters, Jason and Lucia, having their own thing. And then the thing is that there's a lot of complaints about, oh, you have to go buy flowers. Oh, you have to fix the house. First of all, that's only at the very beginning of the game. You don't do any of that stuff later on. Almost all the rest of the game is just robbing banks and fast cars and everything like that. But you can also choose not to do any of that stuff. You can choose to neglect your girlfriend the whole time. Which is what you did, right? Which is exactly what I

Speaker 16did because I played the game for 170 hours, which is enough time for me to try the game a second time where I was a terrible boyfriend to Lucia who was being released from prison and told me through the phone that she was being released from prison. And what I did was I didn't do any of the groceries. I didn't get any of the clothes. I didn't get her a haircut. I didn't wash the car. I didn't fix anything at the house. And I went back to bed and slept for 24 hours like a complete loser and didn't pick her up from prison.

Speaker 6What happened?

Speaker 16And that created new fights in the story. The story would respond to that. And she was less trustful of me. She was asking if she should go anywhere to stay. And then when I lied to her later in the game, shortly later in the game, she had a much harsher reaction to it than I did the last time where she simply just gave up talking to me. We were out and she says, you know what, can we just go home? And she just stays silent the whole time. And then now when she texts me and I say I'm busy, she puts notifications on snooze.

Speaker 5You're getting left on read?

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 5She's getting left on read in a video game. That is incredible.

Speaker 16Because before when we would text, she would like give little emoji reactions, you know, like assurances like, hey, you know, I still love you. Don't worry about this. But she doesn't do that at all anymore, which is terrifying. Okay, so Aspen Gold, if you hear this, you can be a bad boyfriend. You don't have to do these things and you are cucking yourself if you are because there are a million choices out there. I do think it's interesting because like you said earlier, Gene, so many games get this accusation of woke and I think it hits a lot harder as a critique when the game itself

Speaker 16is bad, maybe in structural ways or in other design ways and then people can blame it on wokeness. But with Grand Theft Auto, this is one of the largest entertainment selling products of all time.

Speaker 5It's clearly successful. It's clearly insane, unhinged, violent, and all these crazy things you can do. So this critique of wokeism really just falls apart. It just kind of falls flat as people continue to enjoy the game.

Speaker 16One of the things I always have trouble with the woke allegation is that, especially for Grand Theft Auto, is that Grand Theft Auto is meant to appeal to as broadly an audience as possible.

Speaker 6And it has done that.

Speaker 16By becoming the second best-selling video game of all time and charting on the charts almost every month since 2013 with Grand Theft Auto V. So they're making this game to appeal to as many perspectives as you can. So it is trying to, sure, it is trying to appeal to woke people, but it's also appealing to the judge. You can still go on mass shootings if you want to, no problem. There are so many clips of people just being completely racist and choosing people of color to only kill, you know? And the game allows for that completely.

Speaker 1And also, it's not woke to be respectful to your girlfriend. I thought like the traditional, isn't that like trad con, like traditional conservative values?

Speaker 6Yes.

Speaker 7But there's a Nietzschean, right?

Speaker 1The nuclear family and all that.

Speaker 5Emily, Emily, explain that to us.

Speaker 1It's anti-woke.

Speaker 8There's a sort of, there's the BAP, Nietzschean, pagan, right? And then there's the, you know, normie right. Which one's the incel side? In online spaces, the BAP right is ascendant and sort of dominates especially. And it comes out of Things like Gamergate, a lot of it actually did, as you guys know, grow out of Gamergate, which Steve Bannon very specifically cultivated because he thought these would be people who are no longer interested in the kind of post-Obama Democratic Party. And they're sick of political correctness and

Speaker 8they feel like it's suffocating their creative freedom. And they're lonely and isolated and alienated. And they're correct that the system is stacked against them. So you guys probably are fully aware of that. But it does create that kind of interesting tension on the one hand. They want the video game to be this kind of playground for immorality. On the other hand, they want to impose this moral structure on the video game, which is to say there should be no pressure to be a good boyfriend or

Speaker 8there should be no pressure to even be a boyfriend at all. So it's a very strange, to me it seems, and it's also, you know, the kind of thing where they don't want it to be taken as something that's construed as real. You know, the line that I'm sure we all are very familiar with, that like video games don't cause shootings.

Speaker 7There's research in that.

Speaker 8But at the same time, they want to say it is going to affect people's real lives, that like it is programming people to be chuds. So it's kind of, there's all kinds of like strange tension. I find this conversation really interesting. I'm so glad you're here, Jean.

Speaker 2Yeah, yeah.

Speaker 16Well, I mean, again, it speaks to the conflicts that video games often have, too. The one thing about video games is that so many of them aren't very political, or at least they claim to be. And these directors of video games almost universally will come out and say, no, we're not being political. And Rockstar Games has said that, too, where they say we're not responding to the politics of the times. And then you actually play the game and you listen to radio stations and And it's all about completely responding to the politics of the times.

Speaker 5It's Nick Fuentes. There's a Nick Fuentes, Alex Jones parody on the radio.

Speaker 6Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 16You know, I mean, I mean, Stabby is there for Pete's sake, you know, so it's like they are injecting political figures into the game completely.

Speaker 6Yeah.

Speaker 5Well, so outside of the political attacks, there has been another attack on this game and that it's removing productivity from America because too many people are playing it. Let's take a listen to this Fox News clip about affordability.

Speaker 14And if this generation wants to preach about affordability, but they're willing to cost billions of dollars in revenue loss on a day like today to go play a game, that probably tells you everything you need to know about what we need to be talking with this younger generation about.

Speaker 3And that, again, is be a good shepherd of what you have.

Speaker 5It may not be there tomorrow. Get yourself to work.

Speaker 1All right.

Speaker 5So get yourself to work. If you care about things being affordable, you shouldn't be playing an expensive video game like Grand Theft Auto, taking hard-earned dollars from the economy. Gene, can you break down some of this? How many people took off work, the sales of this? What is the impact of the game so far on American society?

Speaker 16Yeah, I'm not an economist, but I'm not sure how going to work affects the affordability crisis, which is interesting enough because I really do think Grand Theft Auto 6 is steeped in the affordability crisis. The game actually, more than any other Grand Theft Auto or Red Dead Redemption game, Red Dead Redemption is the Western series that Rockstar Games has made, and that was the last game they made in 2018, actually. Money is always an issue in the games, but they've never actually mattered all that much up until

Speaker 16this game, where, again, you are a couple. And, you know, I don't want to say the spoiler, even if the spoiler is well known right now, but there is a huge reason why these two people would want to be saving money. And the couple is constantly, constantly fighting for money. And you're always faced with the choice of, well, you know, I probably should rob a.

Speaker 6Bank or whatever.

Speaker 16So the game is certainly addressing the affordability crisis going on right now. But yeah, to your earlier question, yeah, certainly a lot of workers took off. You know, I've been doing a lot of the news hits and almost every news hit I've done, even the news stations are saying, yeah, we had.

Speaker 6A producer to actually take off work too.

Speaker 16ABC News, I was there yesterday, and he actually interviewed one of the APs who completely just took off for the game. And I think there are some reports from some firms that say like one in five workers were taking off for Grand Theft Auto 6. And, you know, like it's just a rare flash of monoculture. You know, we just haven't seen something like this in a long, long time where everybody is kind of interested in the same thing right now. And I think that's a little bit shocking, especially in 2026 after COVID and after the

Speaker 16fragmentation of entertainment, you know?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 1Absolutely.

Speaker 5Everyone, including our own White House, is very interested in this game. The House Republicans just put out this ad. Grand Theft Auto is a video game. Grand Theft Taxpayer is the Democrat playbook for January, and they want every last dollar in your pocket. We won't let that happen. Are they making them look cool? Yeah, so I don't know exactly what the attack was, but if you're just listening to the audio, it's AOC, Abdul, and Hakim, the trio here, looking like they're in Grand Theft Auto on

Speaker 5the poster for the game.

Speaker 1Yeah, I don't know.

Speaker 5About putting your opponent's in the coolest game of all time, if that's going to be effective.

Speaker 7They make Abdul look absolutely jacked.

Speaker 1They make their.

Speaker 8exactly like a portrait that they've commissioned.

Speaker 16This is a challenge impossible. Hakim is charismatic. His posture is great.

Speaker 1Facial symmetry.

Speaker 6And Abdul is looking swole as heck. It's great. And AOC looks just fine as usual. Yeah.

Speaker 16It's a very flattering picture of all three of them. It makes me want to, like, I'd like to see that story, actually.

Speaker 6It'd be interesting.

Speaker 5It does seem like, yeah, most of the cultural attacks against this game have fallen very flat this time, as most people just say, hey, we like this thing. Yeah, do you think that there's any last thoughts about, obviously, this game sold, I don't know, how many copies? Do you know how many copies it sold? And any thoughts on how this will affect the future of games? and if it is possible to have future monocultural moments like this.

Speaker 13Sure.

Speaker 16I think the Sensor Tower has been the tracking firm that we've been paying attention to. I was actually expecting that they might announce how many, Rockstar themselves might announce how many sales they've made. But, you know, estimates are around 20 million copies already, or maybe even 30 million copies, and it might have already made $ 2 billion, over $ 2 billion of revenue. which again would make it the biggest entertainment product launch in human history, at least in terms of finances. But yeah, in terms of like whether we

Speaker 16will see another monoculture moment like this again, I'm not sure. I mean, it's, you know, I think at least in the video game space, Minecraft.

Speaker 62 would be a huge deal.

Speaker 16You know, it'd be like announcing, you know, Tetris 2, which actually does exist or whatever. But yeah, Minecraft 2. Minecraft has never gotten a sequel. Fortnite 2 would be huge.

Speaker 1Are they building a Minecraft 2? Are they doing Minecraft 2?

Speaker 6No, no.

Speaker 16It's just Minecraft. They made the movie and that movie made a billion bucks too. So, I mean, again, that speaks to the cultural power of Minecraft and especially Roblox. But Roblox would never make a Roblox 2 either. But yeah, really, there's nothing else in the space. A Pokemon online game where you can live online and just catch Pokemon forever, that would probably do numbers. But Nintendo refuses to do that.

Speaker 6For some reason.

Speaker 5Yeah, they don't understand the internet.

Speaker 6Yeah, yeah. They kind of struggle a little bit there.

Speaker 16But if they ever open that genie, if they ever open that bottle, then it'll be all heck.

Speaker 8I do have one more question, Gene, actually kind of on that point, which is I feel like we're so used to in-shitification that every major corporate product that comes out is somehow worse than the last. And this seems to be totally bucking that trend. People seem to be really happy with it. It's a major commercial success. I was just wondering if you had any thoughts on how they pulled that off.

Speaker 16Yeah, they pulled it off by spending a lot, a lot of money. You know, the rumor budget, this has never been confirmed to be clear, but the rumor budget is that it is over a billion dollars, which would make it the same budget as building a rocket ship.

Speaker 5What did they say, Gene? They said it costs, they officially said it costs less than the Burj Khalifa, which I think was a $ 1. 5 billion construction.

Speaker 6So less than $ 1.

Speaker 85 billion.

Speaker 6Than the tallest structure in the world. Yes, exactly.

Speaker 16So that's why I've compared Rockstar Games to the wonders of the world. You ever look at the Great Pyramids and you wonder, why hasn't anyone else built something like this? And it's because it costs a lot of blood and there's a human cost to it. Fortunately, Rockstar Games had enough money because, again, Grand Theft Auto V was just simply printing money for the last 13 years for them. So they were able to spend that. Rockstar Games... a big part of the appeal of these games is the music. It has almost every genre and people love the music.

Speaker 16You see Doja Cat yesterday was tweeting angrily that she was not involved in this game whatsoever. So there is massive Grand Theft Auto FOMO at the highest level of culture there. But Rockstar Games created their own record label in 2021 so they could just host their own songs. So that's why the game itself has New original music from The Weeknd and SZA and Bad Bunny. Bad Bunny himself is a DJ for one of the stations. Pink Pantherous is a DJ for another station, completely. Weird Al

Speaker 16Yankovic is the DJ for the 80s station, too. And the game itself has a cast of tens of thousands of people, which is a massive, massive scale of production.

Speaker 6Wow.

Speaker 16You know, they were able to meet those expectations just by simply doing something that is impossible for any company to do other than Rockstar Games, including Nolan. I don't think Nolan would be able to engineer a product like this.

Speaker 5Yeah, I mean, the Odyssey costs only like a couple hundred million.

Speaker 6250 million, you know? Like, come on, you know?

Speaker 16It's just rating a few people, including Matt Damon in there. But, well, I mean, this game itself has so many... high budget and also low profile actors too. Grand Theft Auto likes to work with a lot of celebrities, but they also like to elevate a lot of not too well-known actors. They did start in 2002 or even in 2001 with Michael Madsen. Ray Liotta voiced the main character of Grand Theft Auto Vice City in 2002. Samuel Jackson was the

Speaker 16antagonist of Grand Theft Auto San Andreas. So they've obviously had headlining marquee talent before, too. And they're still doing that. But they're doing that at such a massive scale that there's just simply nobody can compete with them. So you ask me if anyone can do this. No, no one can. You know, Rockstar Games, Red Dead Redemption 2 came out in 2018. And that game is still more advanced than most games right now. So it's almost like Grand Theft Auto 6 is coming in here and it's like, try it.

Speaker 6You can't. This is impossible to pull off.

Speaker 5Well, I am itching to get back to playing Grand Theft Auto Genes. I can't believe I'm even on this episode right now. So I have to go and I have to go buy my girlfriend flowers. I have to massage her feet. I have to text her back and ask her.

Speaker 1How her day was.

Speaker 6What a cuck.

Speaker 5So I'm going to go back to my cuck simulator and... Gene, we really appreciate it. I've always loved following your work over the years. You have such an incredible insight into video games and culture and all sorts of stuff online. Where can people find you and more of your work?

Speaker 16You can just find me on WashingtonPost.com, Gene Park. If you just Google that, then you can find my author page. Today, I actually published a photo essay of Miami's nightlife and my attempt to recreate those photos with the game So, you know, there'd be a guy with a cowboy hat and khaki pants standing on a Jeep. And I'll be like, okay, well, now it's time for me to go shopping for khaki pants, a specific set of aviators, that cowboy hat. And now I have to go steal myself a Jeep to do this. And,

Speaker 16you know, I wrote about the economic impact that we talked about here. But also, like, I've done quite a bit of stories. Most recently, I interviewed Aisho Speed, who we featured earlier in the show. and his partnership with Obama to produce a documentary on The Eyes of Ghana, which is about anti-colonialist propaganda.

Speaker 6So, you know, fun times.

Speaker 5Yeah, we'll have to have you back sometime to talk about iShowSpeed and other streamers that are doing really interesting things in the space. But that'll do it for us on this Friday, everyone, gamers and non-gamers alike. We wish you the best and a happy weekend. And we'll see you on Monday.

Speaker 6Bye-bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 11/19/26: Saagar Debates Kalshi Investor, Elon Turns On MAGA, Anthropic IPO

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Saagar debates Kalshi investor, Elon turns on MAGA, Anthropic launches IPO. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111 Gary Marcus: https://x.com/GaryMarcus To...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 11/19/26: Jeffries Wins Speaker Vote, Trump Fumes At JD Over Iran, Shoppers Raid Costco For Doomsday Supplies

    Nov 19, 202651 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Jeffries wins the House speaker vote, Trump fumes at Vance over Iran, shoppers raid stores for doomsday supplies. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 11/18/26: Jeffries Caving On Iran War Funding, Navy Sec Unhinged Testimony, BAAJA Bill On The Verge In Congress

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Ryan and Emily discuss Jeffries already caving on Iran war funding, Navy Sec unhinged Senate testimony, BAAJA bill on verge of passing. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy: https://hamawyfornj.com/...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 11/18/26: Stocks Plunge Amid More Outages, Jensen Begs For Nvidia Job Back, Expert Says Epstein Was Murdered

    Nov 18, 202647 minAudio

    Ryan and Emily discuss stocks plunge amid more outages, Jensen begs for Nvidia job back, NYT flips on Epstein as expert says he was murdered. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy:...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 11/17/26: Nvidia Says Jensen Not Coming Back, AOC Ex Aide On Mistakes She Made, Emma Vigeland On Dem Leadership Fight

    Nov 17, 202655 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Nvidia says Jensen Huang is not coming back, AOC ex aide on how to avoid her mistakes, Emma Vigeland on Dem leadership fight. Emma Vigeland:...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode