Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar

Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar artwork

11/18/26: Jeffries Caving On Iran War Funding, Navy Sec Unhinged Testimony, BAAJA Bill On The Verge In Congress

Nov 18, 20261 hr 7 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Ryan and Emily discuss Jeffries already caving on Iran war funding, Navy Sec unhinged Senate testimony, BAAJA bill on verge of passing. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy: https://hamawyfornj.com/ Julian Brave: https://www.julianbravenoisecat.com/ To become a Breaking Points Premium Member and watch/listen to the show AD FREE, uncut and 1 hour early visit: www.breakingpoints.com Merch Store: https://shop.breakingpoints.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Had a busy day? Don't have time to listen to the show? Catch up on Breaking Points with our free daily newsletter. You'll get our breakdown of every daily story. And lots of links in your inbox every day. So head over to BreakingPoints.com. You can sign up for the newsletter at the top for free today.

Speaker 2We're joined now by Congressman Warren Davidson from Ohio's 8th Congressional District. Congressman, thank you so much for being here.

Speaker 3It's an honor to join you all.

Speaker 2You know, we've been tracking your position as a Republican on the Iran war since the very beginning. And it's interesting and it's nuanced. I actually just wanted to start there because you were one of the Republicans that broke with the party on war powers. And now Secretary Hexeth obviously squeaked out of that impeachment effort on the House side recently, which we covered here a lot. But I just wanted to ask, you know, what you think of the administration's handling of the war from that vantage point of executive branch power?

Speaker 4Well, if you start with executive branch power, the Constitution isn't silent on it. It lays out Article 1, the power to declare war is Congress's power. Article 2, of course, the president has a duty to respond to an immediate threat to the United States. And the founding fathers laid out the debate in Federalist 69. So they made it clear why they crafted it this way in Federalist 69. And it's like, yes, Congress is meant to have this power of war When you see that the United States

Speaker 4has used the power that way where the country goes to war not just the military We tend to prevail we tend to win decisively the public's behind the effort the funding flows and when you see that it's you know done differently The results are pretty mixed right and so I think it was very thoughtful how they laid it out The War Powers Act came into being because really, you know, we declared war in World War two, but then in Korea, uh, they never declared war. So an

Speaker 4Ohio senator, Senator Taft, always protested that it was unconstitutional, but they always sort of passively funded it. And the chief power of Congress is the power of the purse. So nevertheless, Vietnam comes in and they're sort of passively funding another war that was pseudo-authorized with the Tonkin Resolution. It didn't say you could wage a long war, sort of tortured. And so that debate came to a head in 73, and they said, let's lay out the ways that the president can go to war and can take action.

Speaker 4And of course, if there's a war declared, well, then the president can wage a war if Congress authorizes it. And, you know, that's a distinction that is meaningful, but essentially the same thing. So post 9-11, it took three days for Congress to vote and say, yeah, we want to take action against the people that did this to the United States of America. Um, and then the third way is to repel an imminent threat. And frankly, uh, you get 60 days in that window. So it's a very generous thing. Some people think it's unconstitutional because it confers

Speaker 4a power on the presidency that it doesn't.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 4Um, and then some people say it's unconstitutional because it limits the president and they believe the president can basically do whatever he wants. Um, so they've never really taken this to the Supreme court and partially because it hasn't ripened. So it's passed the house. But we haven't gotten it through the Senate. And of course, the president probably wouldn't sign it. But the question is, well, then what happens in the court? But nevertheless, as the as the War Powers Act lays out, when the president isn't seeking any of this authorization, then it's unconstitutional. Now, that's not unprecedented,

Speaker 4but in my view, it is unconstitutional.

Speaker 2So the Trump administration not seeking permission from Congress has amounted to a violation of the Constitution.

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean, that's my view. And frankly, it was President Trump's view when Barack Obama was president. It was Republicans' view when Barack Obama was president. And frankly, Democrats disagreed then. So I think a lot of people are pretty duplicitous in these votes. And in a lot of ways, our country is really governed as if we have a parliament instead of Congress. And if we're not going to be governed by our Constitution, I mean, the reality is we are effectively governed by brute force.

Speaker 3It is a matter of.

Speaker 4To me, that is one of the core principles we have. I mean, that's the oath. The oath is to support and defend the Constitution. The oath isn't to a person or a party. And so I think it's vital that we do that. But when you look at it, you say, well, is it unprecedented? No, it's become kind of the de facto way that our country has gone to war. So I think it's really one of the most essential things for us to work through is say, hey, are we going to agree to be governed by this constitution or not? Because if we're not, then, well, then we should have another constitutional convention and change it. But we're in this never,

Speaker 4never land. And I really think it's important that we finally pass something on war powers and get an adjudication in the courts.

Speaker 6The War Powers Act also includes a provision, I don't know exactly how it says it, but something about American troops entered into hostilities, which is understood, I believe, to mean put at risk. In other words, oftentimes the administration, this one or a Democratic one, will say, well, we're not at war, we're not shooting. But if you've put three carrier groups within shooting range of somebody that you say is an adversary, I imagine the people on those

Speaker 6carrier groups feel like they're not at Disney World. They've been entered into hostilities and at any moment they could be fired upon So in your view, does the War Powers Act, does the clock start ticking then? In other words, even though they're not, well, we were shooting yesterday, actually, but let's say we weren't shooting.

Speaker 1Are we still entered into hostilities? And what does that mean for?

Speaker 4I mean, personally, I don't think it trips until there's an act of war. Um, but you know, when you think about the whole positioning, I mean, this for me is when I wanted a briefing. So, um, I think February 17th, I asked for a briefing at the White House. I noticed that we have, according to public reports, two aircraft carrier groups and about 40 to 50 percent of the Air Force, you know, in in the theater there. And so you look at positioning. I mean, if it's public,

Speaker 4you can you can know some things about this. And I was like, well, we've never put that much firepower somewhere and not started shooting.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 2So.

Speaker 3I would like a briefing.

Speaker 4So I went to the White House, met with some folks there on February 22nd, and basically made my case for why we should take a different course of action. I mean, the reality is, is Iran, maximum pressure wasn't working anymore. Maximum pressure President Trump used very effectively in his first term to cut down on the cash that the Iranian regime had and to cut down as predictable as gravity. I mean, if Iran gets money, they're going to try to kill people in Israel. they fund proxy groups and terror throughout the region. So sure enough, if

Speaker 4they've got cash, that's what they're doing. And honestly, a lot of our, uh, friends and allies, uh, were trading on black market oil. They were getting Russian oil, Iranian oil, and Venezuelan oil. They were getting it in Europe and India and Japan and Korea and very significantly in China. And so this was, uh, causing no real consequence for Iran. So we had no more pressure on the administration. So I think the blockade could have been and is having

Speaker 4a tremendous effect because we can control the flow of oil by controlling really the Arabian Sea. Now, why do we care more about the Strait? Yeah, it's not free, but you can do it. And it's certainly different than waging a regime change war. So different strategies, but a similar goal. is to change the behavior of the country of Iran. And the downside is Iran has leveraged all of their neighbor's oil since theirs is at risk by

Speaker 4trying to control the Strait of Hormuz. And we certainly need to keep the support of UAE, Bahrain, Saudi Arabia, for example. So we really want the Strait to be open. And the world markets want the Strait to be open so that the price is better. But in terms of leverage on Iran, I mean, you can control everything flowing in and out of the Arabian Sea with the United States Navy. So a lot of that is underway. And frankly, it's working. But nevertheless, we've entered into a state of war. We had this weird period where Republicans were pretending not

Speaker 4to know what a war was.

Speaker 7It's embarrassing.

Speaker 1It's embarrassing.

Speaker 4One of the speeches I made on the floor of the House on the first war powers vote is, you know, but. You know, here we are, at least now they're acknowledging it as a war. But it's not a war that we've really structured properly. And I think, you know, the challenge we're coming to a head here as we go into December 11th, you've got a war that is clearly, you know, the young people who would be expected to wage this war strongly oppose the war. And it seems like nearly everyone else does, too. Except that if you're

Speaker 4an elected official, it seems that your odds of supporting the war seem to be very high. And frankly, generationally, people tend to be on a generational break. So the country is divided on it, and it's not clear that we could even fund a war. So part of the reason why the president should work with Congress to declare a war is very pragmatic, is how are you going to effectively wage a war that you can't even fund? And if you can't persuade the public, your odds of getting the support of Congress to fund it are much lower.

Speaker 4So nevertheless, my prediction is that the Democrats will fund the war post-December 11th.

Speaker 2So we actually want to ask you about this because Hakeem Jeffries was talking to Punchbowl yesterday. I think we can put this up on the screen. So Max Cohen of Punchbowl asks Hakim Jeffries if we're going to head for a government shutdown next month if Republicans don't agree to cut Iran war funding. You mentioned December 11th. Hakim Jeffries says, I think the four corners are an active conversation right now as it relates to trying to arrive at either a government funding agreement in advance of December 11th that meets the needs of the American people in terms of their health, their safety, their national security, and their economic well-being, or we have to move toward a continuing resolution of funding that would put us into some point next year with Democrats holding the gavels in both

Speaker 2the House and the Senate. So we'll see what happens. I don't want to get out ahead of that process. What is clear is that the reckless and costly war of choice in Iran needs to end.

Speaker 3It should end today.

Speaker 2But Congressman, to your point, a lot of people on the left looked at that and read into it. Hakeem Jeffrey is basically capitulating. to the administration. And that's your prediction of what will happen in mid-December as well.

Speaker 1And tell us who the four corners are for people who aren't. Yeah.

Speaker 4So for people that don't know, that's effectively how Congress governs. They don't really pass real appropriations bills. Four corners would say like, you know, I'm on the financial services committee. And so the chairman and ranking member in the house, French Hill and Maxine Waters are the two corners that are in the house side. And then Tim Scott, who's the chairman of Senate Banking, and Elizabeth Warren, who's the ranking member of Senate Banking, they basically work together to cut a deal. And that's how you wind up with an omnibus that's got certain things in it or a

Speaker 4continuing resolution or.

Speaker 3These big packages.

Speaker 4And part of that is because the Senate, to move a bill on a single subject, takes nine days unless there's unanimous consent. So they tend to not vote on standalone legislation in the Senate. It all gets packaged. And whether it makes it in or not really kind of depends on whether the House can demonstrate the level of bipartisan support for it. And you get the buy in on a four corners tradeoff. If it's super partisan, then it's a trade of, well, I can live with your super partisan thing if you live with my super partisan thing. And that's kind of the deal making that goes on. And it's that way across committee after committee and it

Speaker 4stacks up. So that's the four corners deal. And, you know, some people say, well, you won't be able to get support for Iran war. from Democrats broadly. But if they put it on the floor and half the Republicans and half the Democrats vote for it, it still passes. And generally, to get something through the Senate, if you don't have enough votes, you just add more spending. So that's why I say, if they can't get the votes to fund the Iran war, they'll probably fund a war in Ukraine and the war in Iran.

Speaker 6And as you had mentioned earlier, it's certainly true that Iran and Israel have had long, long-simmering hostility with each other. But why is that an issue that the U.S. has to concern itself with?

Speaker 4Well, I think the relationship with Israel is important to the United States. I mean, the American people have a strong affinity for the people of Israel. I mean, by faith and culture, we're bonded in a lot of ways. And so I think it's popular across the country to be supportive of Israel. But pragmatically for us, I mean, Israel is stability in the region. And when you look at terror, an awful lot of the terror is directed against them. So, you know, as I say, as predictable as gravity, if Iran has money, they're going to fund proxies.

Speaker 4And so who funded the 10-7 massacre in Israel? Iran, because Hamas got the money from Iran.

Speaker 6Well, and also from Israel. They were routing it through Qatar to Hamas, which is... complicates the question a little bit.

Speaker 3As a counter to Hezbollah.

Speaker 4So they wanted the Palestinian folks divided. They were, in fact, divided. The one thing that unites them is they like to kill Jewish people in Israel. So they're very, very fond of that, and they tend to do it every chance they get.

Speaker 1On the question of stability and security, though, the U.S.

Speaker 6Relationship with Israel doesn't seem to, like, if you look at the last 50 years of in the Middle East, we wouldn't call that stable, right?

Speaker 4Yeah, I mean, I think if you look at the history of Israel, the country hasn't been secure ever. I mean, they've been at war kind of nearly continually since 48, right? But to your point, I mean, you go back as old as recorded history, people in Persia have had conflicts with people in Israel.

Speaker 3I mean, it's as old as time.

Speaker 2Can I ask where you stand on funding the war? So like with this broad war powers concern, you know, there is something so real about looking at impeachment concerns with Hegseth. And by the way, we should put up Secretary Hegseth. We should put up on the screen this Newsweek report. It found when people were asked by YouGov in a survey recently about a list of cabinet members, Americans want President Donald Trump to fire. They report Hegseth split was worse on balance than Robert F. Kennedy split. 43% wanted Hegseth fired and 26% wanted him kept, leaving him

Speaker 2with a net score of minus 17. That was the lowest of the six cabinet members that YouGov asked Americans about. But just the big picture question, if we have delegated an inappropriate level of war powers to the executive that is contradictory to what the founders envisioned for the role of Congress and the executive, then does it even follow logically that we can impeach the executive for abusing the war powers that we have unfortunately delegated to the executive via congress so i know that's that's one of the ways that you think about it so help us flesh

Speaker 2that out and how it comes down or how you think about funding a war uh that you feel like has that sort of central.

Speaker 4Problem well that is the clear power that congress has is whether to fund something or not fund it and if you're truly opposed to it you cut off the funding for it and or you change it you put conditions on it and um You know, the House and Senate make their own rules. They make it very hard to put strings attached to the money. You can do it if you're on appropriations, but no amendment that does that is made in order in the House. It's sort of irrelevant anyway, because the standalone appropriations bills are never actually what become law. It's a four corners deal. And

Speaker 4that's been the way since the 90s. So our governance model is broken and either our Constitution authorizes or it's been powerless to prevent it.

Speaker 2Which is part of what you all tried to fix with Kevin McCarthy. Those are the conditions that you all tried to put with Kevin.

Speaker 4We tried hard and we lost support, frankly, because to get it across the finish line, it spent more than some of us would have liked. And look, I'm a fiscal conservative. You know, I ran on don't bankrupt America. And then when I realized this place is very committed to bankrupting America, at least saying it is the most bipartisan thing in town is spending far more money than we have. And it's not compassionate to bankrupt America. I mean, you can see the consequences of these giant fiscal deficits. I mean, that's inflation, right? I mean, we are fueling

Speaker 4the inflation that people are out there campaigning against. And they're very dishonestly saying, oh, well, it's caused by corporate greed. Well, no, we know what causes inflation. And when you have fiscal dominance like we have today, and you have a Federal Reserve that chooses to accommodate the massive deficits... I mean, you're going to have inflation and it's going to wreck.

Speaker 2You're also always going to have corporate greed.

Speaker 4Well, yeah, that's a constant, right? Every corporation would prefer to make more money.

Speaker 6So how do we fix the poor powers situation? Like if you could sit down with Democrats in the next Congress and say, OK, we passed this in the 1970s because we.

Speaker 1Identified these problems with the structure.

Speaker 6We now passed a war powers resolution through both the Senate and the House and it didn't stop the war.

Speaker 1So how would you rewrite it?

Speaker 6What are the key provisions you think if you were going to write a new War Powers Act that applied to the way that Congress functions today?

Speaker 4Well, one of the changes that I think is important is that if something's privileged, it deserves a vote. So I don't like the idea that you can just table something and avoid answering the question and say, oh, well, we tabled it. Well, then don't make it privileged. I think they rightly made the War Powers Act privileged. And so we get votes most of the time on the War Powers Resolutions. Occasionally, they shirk the responsibility and they just table it. And I think the sort of adjacent thing is we need to be clear. I think rather

Speaker 4than fighting over the 2001 AUMF, we should just create a proper way to say, when can the president act with discretion? And I think it really is meaningfully different to take action against a transnational organization like a cartel or a terrorist group than it is to go to war with a nation state. And so I've worked for a long time on an authorization for use of military force. I would think the best thing we could do before Christmas is pass an AUMF.

Speaker 3If it could be bipartisan, that would be great.

Speaker 2Specific to Iran.

Speaker 4Specific to broadly. Iran is a nation state. Now, Hezbollah and Hamas, they're not nation states.

Speaker 3They're different.

Speaker 4You know, the Sinaloa cartel, not a nation state. Enemy of our country, in my view. And I think, finally, this administration is properly treating them as enemies of our country. But, you know, when you look at non-state actors that are really killing Americans through their actions, I think we should rightly be able to treat them as enemies of our country. The way that Congress and the president works on that, I think, is important to define the And I think if we get that resolved with an AUMF, it will set better conditions for, well, okay, let's agree that when

Speaker 4you want to go to war with a nation state, this is a different thing, in part because of the scale. And okay, Venezuela is a nation state and Iran is a nation state. They're clearly very different. I mean, it's a small family business in Venezuela versus, I mean, you've got one of the more substantial militaries. They have a strong industrial and technological capability in Iran. It's a country four times as big as California. with some very rigorous terrain. So, you know, you can't necessarily say, oh, well, you treat them the same. You can't wage a war against them

Speaker 4in the same manner. But the protocols for Congress, I think, are important when you want to go to war with a nation.

Speaker 1On the cartel front.

Speaker 6What do we do about the complicating factor that The cartels are often allied with governments that we're allied with, like whether it's Neboa in Ecuador, the Honduran government.

Speaker 1And so on.

Speaker 6They're basically one and the same, like this political economy and the kind of coalition that makes up.

Speaker 1The.

Speaker 6Current Colombian president is the lawyer for the cartels, right?

Speaker 1And he's our ally. We helped.

Speaker 6you know, we supported his election. So what do we do about, like, how do you go to war with?

Speaker 2Venezuela is a good example of there are still people from the prior regime that are part of the indictment in the Southern District of New York of Cartel de los Soles that we covered at the time.

Speaker 1Which was created by the U.S.

Speaker 2But also, I guess I would add on to that. I think what people are maybe most nervous about in the administration, this is my sense, is the drug boat strikes because there wasn't something like an AUMF. And the executive power, I mean, we saw the opinion that came out of OLC on that. I think people feel very uncomfortable with that use of executive power.

Speaker 3I'm grateful.

Speaker 4I mean, I had a bill called the Stop the Cartels Act. I've been pleading for them to do that. But I think we'd be in better standing if you did pass an annual act. And what I don't want, like I'm a former Army Ranger, you know, I mean, I'm not an isolationist, but I also don't think we need to get in all the wars we're invited to. We certainly don't need to seek out extra ones. But the cartels have clearly brought, you know, terror to our streets, not in the same way that terror groups do. But, you know, you're seeing, you know, hundreds of thousands of Americans killed with poison drugs.

Speaker 3I mean, drugs are bad. People know that.

Speaker 4But, you know, taking a Xanax at a party isn't supposed to kill you. These things have been laced with fentanyl. They're killing Americans and they know it.

Speaker 8Right.

Speaker 4And so they're still pumping that poison into our streets every day. Unfortunately, sanctuary cities are saying not only is there a lot of demand here, we'll keep you safe. Just base your operations here. That's another layer to the problem. So that's where I think like.

Speaker 2You get out of prison and ICE doesn't have a detainer operating in.

Speaker 3The everything about it.

Speaker 4And, you know, the way that cartels are making their money isn't just drugs. A lot of it is human smuggling, some of it for labor, some of it just to basically look, America is so awesome that the cartels charge a toll.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 4If you don't pay the cartels, you're not crossing the border. They have their own border security operation in their own little regions, right? So you're not coming over without paying.

Speaker 2I was told directly that in northern Mexico by Red Cross people who were involved. They looked at it and said every single person has paid the cartel.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 4And usually a number that means there's ongoing payments and network and leverage against anybody that you would care about. So these are evil people, and I think it's right that we should treat them that way. And if you have a government that is somehow captured and accommodates them, I think maybe living in Colombia, you have a pragmatic accommodation. And in El Salvador, they were pragmatically accommodating MS-13 and some others for.

Speaker 3A long time.

Speaker 4And then you got Bukele, who decided to kind of go about it in a different way. It's been very effective at keeping the peace, but it doesn't exactly comply with the U.S.

Speaker 3Bill of Rights, right?

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 4But I think they reached a point where they said, well, we don't have to live this way, and so we're not going to. I think that's a better way of life than the way they were living before Bukele, and maybe someday they'll get to other civil liberties, but they've got to fix the base culture to even be.

Speaker 3Able to be governed that way.

Speaker 4Let them govern their own countries, but if they're going to be a base of operations, it's the same with the cartels, right? We had this with bin Laden in Pakistan. If the government wasn't officially harboring them, okay, fine, we didn't go to war with the country of Pakistan, but we're coming in and we're smoking bin Laden. I mean, I think it was right and just that we did that. And I feel the same about some of these cartels. It would be right and just for us to take action against them. In a lot of ways, I think kinetic activity, sinking drug boats, is a very effective means

Speaker 4of doing that. But in other ways, look, we don't even adequately follow the money. When you look at the money that's being laundered today, I mean, it's massive in scale. And we have all these banks that have know your customer laws. And they can't even tell you whether someone's lawfully present in the United States.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 6And also in South and Central America, I'm telling you, like these cartels are deeply embedded with the coalitions that are running the countries.

Speaker 1Yeah, no question. They're our allies.

Speaker 3Yeah. I mean, even in Mexico, I mean, it's a very.

Speaker 4If they don't get along with the cartels, you saw like maybe a decade or so ago, 30 plus thousand killed in Mexico because of the feuding, because they did try to crack down on the cartels. And the challenge down there is big, but I think the bad news doesn't get better with time, right? So we're happy to help you. And frankly, call an exterminator. If you've got a terrorist problem in your country, if you don't deal with it yourself, call us. Maybe we'll help you with your terrorist problem. But if you don't, well, then we're

Speaker 4going to have a problem with you and your government, right?

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 6What seems like in Ecuador, for instance, oftentimes it seems like the U.S. is being dispatched to deal with Neboa's cartel rivals. Neboa, his own cartel gets protected and then we go in and eliminate the competition and we just kind of end up strengthening one.

Speaker 3Of the cartels.

Speaker 4Yeah, this is the common denominator, frankly, that I will lump the the neocons, or as I call them, the not conservatives. Neo is new conservatives. They're clearly not conservatives. And by the way, they're not defined by their race or religion or ethnicity. They're defined by their ideas and beliefs.

Speaker 2Right. Because that's been referred to as a smear against Jewish conservatives.

Speaker 4Well, that's how you know they're losing the argument, frankly. So you're clearly losing the argument. The globalists, you pick any number of these folks. Uncle Sucker is the common thing. They're totally... baiting the United States to do things that are against our own interests. And I think that's really one of the clear messages from this election is the American people have noticed.

Speaker 3They're like, hey, we.

Speaker 4Said stay out of all these wars. Let's just fix America. I mean, you've got an air traffic control system that won't even work correctly. And you can't shovel enough cash out of our country to fund other governments. How about you fund our government? Can't our government work right? And I think people are rightly frustrated by that. And they basically went to the ballot box and said, hey, we feel pretty unheard. And I don't think that was an embrace of Democrats. I think it was, we hate all of you, but we hate the party that's in the majority a little more because they're in the majority.

Speaker 2Is your party getting that message?

Speaker 1Well, some of them are.

Speaker 4And I think in the House, we took a step in the right direction because, you know, Jim Jordan's, to me, been sort of an outside agitator, pushing leadership to go towards more of the, you know, forgotten men and women of America as kind of the sort of charter for, you know, the organizations that he's helped found and build. And I think the title of his book, you know, lays out the message, you know, do what you said you would do.

Speaker 2Will he whip votes to not fund the war?

Speaker 3I don't know. I mean, I can't speak for Jim Jordan on that.

Speaker 4But, you know, when you say do what you said you would do, if we had delivered on the message of the 2024 election, I think we'd be talking about a very different post-election analysis. And so clearly, you know, we did do some of the things that we said we would do. But we also, you know, broke some trust on some of the things that we clearly promised to deliver on. And I think some of those results will show up a little later. There's lags, but it hasn't been seen or felt by a lot of people, and they're rightly frustrated about it.

Speaker 2Well, Congressman Warren Davidson, thank you so much for your time today. We appreciate you coming in the studio.

Speaker 3Yeah, thanks for talking with me.

Speaker 6House Democrats are choosing their new leadership today, joining us to discuss that. Incoming Congressman Adam Hamoy. Congressman, I guess I can't call you Congressman yet, but soon to be Congressman, thanks so much for being here. Thank you for inviting me. You guys, you won a very competitive primary in New Jersey. And one of the kind of rare members of Congress who I think was on breaking points several years ago in a different life after you had returned from from

Speaker 6Gaza where you were volunteering in a hospital.

Speaker 1What hospital were you in, remind me?

Speaker 9So I've been to Gaza twice. In 2024, I was in the European Hospital of Gaza.

Speaker 6Okay, because Nasser Hospital was just struck by the Israelis killing some medical professionals.

Speaker 1Did you follow that?

Speaker 6Are you keeping up with colleagues who are going in and out or who are still Palestinian doctors who are still there?

Speaker 9Yes, and I had actually gone back then to Gaza. It had been occupied and struck, and they were reconstructing it at the time. And then on my second visit to Gaza, I actually worked there. And again, some of my colleagues at Nasser Hospital. And since then, it's been struck multiple times. I have had colleagues, both doctors as well as journalists, that have been killed every time they strike.

Speaker 6So as you go into this vote, which you'll be leaving the studio to go to the vote, they'll be choosing WIP, then also choosing the speaker nominee. How do you think about the experiences that you had over there that you're bringing here to Washington as you go into that I guess, as a ballot box, or we'll find out if you're writing it down, whether it's a publicly recorded vote or if it's a secret ballot. I think it's going to be a secret ballot. They say that politics is the art of compromise. At the same time,

Speaker 6you treated the victims of a genocide that the U.S.

Speaker 1Was complicit in.

Speaker 6So how do you balance being a voice for that with just the demands that Washington puts on top of you?

Speaker 7These decisions have real consequence.

Speaker 9It's not a yes or no vote just because it's politics as usual or I'm gaining favor. These are life and death decisions often for Americans and really impact the whole world. When I was in Gaza, I saw the consequence of our decision to be able to provide arms and bombs and support because those bombs that are falling and killing doctors and patients, these are our bombs.

Speaker 7The bullets that are.

Speaker 9Being used to shoot everyone, these are our bullets. So these are decisions made right here in Washington. And running to come here, I understood that.

Speaker 7And now it's heavy.

Speaker 9So again, the pressure is to kind of like, okay, these are easy decisions.

Speaker 7You have to make this roll.

Speaker 9But I think back to the patients that I've treated and the families that are looking up for a change.

Speaker 7And if we're not.

Speaker 9Going to follow through on the promises that we talked about in trying to push for that change and fight, then what did I really fight for and why am I here?

Speaker 6So there's no one else officially running for Speaker today. What are you going to do when you're given your ballot?

Speaker 7I'm still undecided.

Speaker 9I mean, the whole point is, you know, the American people spoke up. And, um, they're looking for a bold future, uh, not happy with, you know, how we've conducted ourselves as Democrats in the past. And, um, they're looking for indications that something has to be different come January, uh, January 3rd.

Speaker 7Yeah.

Speaker 6And there, and there may be speeches that people give. There may be somebody nominated down there. Um, would you nominate anybody? How did like, I mean, this is your first time going through this kind of a process.

Speaker 9It's the first time going through the process, but you know, someone has to step up. I mean, I could nominate someone and they say no. So what's the whole point of the nomination? I mean, it's not about theatrics. We really want substantive change. And how do you do that? There's two ways to go about it. You could go and you could try to change leadership.

Speaker 10Okay.

Speaker 9And that's one way to do it. The other thing you could do is you could try to have leadership change. The point is that we want to move. It's not about personalities. It's not about you know, again, just, uh, making a whole show about it is like, how are we going to deliver to the American people? And what's the best way to go about it?

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 6One thing I try to remind myself is that, uh, in these bleak moments, Richard Nixon signed the EPA into law, LBJ and avowed racist.

Speaker 1Signed into law, the civil rights act and the voting rights act.

Speaker 6Sometimes it's more of the moment than the person who's in the office and the pressure that, is put on them by people and by the political moment that they're in.

Speaker 1Have you spoken with Jeffries if he gets through?

Speaker 6What indications have people gotten that he could be the person for this moment or not?

Speaker 9I have spoken with him this week. The conversations, again, were positive. Again, it's pretty clear, and it's me just having this conversation, is that we can't have business as usual.

Speaker 7And it's pretty clear that if he doesn't listen... Was it a one-on-one?

Speaker 1Or were you in with a group of people?

Speaker 7It was a one-on-one.

Speaker 9I had a one-on-one conversation with him. So, I mean, you know, these conversations are still ongoing. And we just want to see indications, you know, that something is going to happen. And again, that's why I'm undecided. And like until, you know, the decision actually comes, you know, anything could happen. Again, someone could step up and get nominated. You know, he could deliver and say, I am committed to doing X, Y, Z. Um, these are all possibilities and, you know, uh, I don't want to close that window.

Speaker 1Did he ask you at all about your experience in Gaza?

Speaker 6What is like one thing that people were excited about when, when you won was that you'd be able to bring that kind of firsthand witness.

Speaker 9Um, I don't wait for people to ask. Um, I tell them, listen, I was on the ground there and this is what I witnessed.

Speaker 2Right.

Speaker 9And, um, this is, uh, something that we are enabling and, um, allowing to happen. And these are American tax dollars and, and we don't want to continue doing that. We have bigger problems here at home that we could solve with that, you know, with that money.

Speaker 1Um, did he respond at all? Like how, or how did he respond to that?

Speaker 9Uh, you know, he indicated that he heard what I'm saying and, um, you know, this is why, you know, we're still in, in, in talks.

Speaker 3Right.

Speaker 6The other, another major issue of course is the war. And if we could actually put up on the screen E4. So last night, so the U.S. bombed Kesham Island in the Strait of Hormuz. Iran has responded by what appears to be a pretty significant attack on U.S. facilities inside Kuwait.

Speaker 3U.S.

Speaker 1May continue to respond. This may. Bring us back to major combat operations. It's unclear.

Speaker 6This may peter out and go back to the kind of status quo of ships constantly burning and getting struck. A lot of Democrats have been pushing for using this speaker vote as well as the upcoming December 11th expiry of government funding to force a legal end to the war. Did you talk to Jeffries about that?

Speaker 9Well, I think Democrats in general, and this isn't just on him, are committed towards ending this war. This is really an issue that I think we're all united on, that it's not productive, it's hurting the American people, and it's illegal, it's immoral. And so I don't think this is going to be a hard issue come January for us to kind of try to put an end to it. Congress has really the power to declare war, and that's been ignored.

Speaker 7And we want to take that power back.

Speaker 6Did he give any indication of where he was on that question come January? Because I know that he and Schumer have kind of wanted to punt into January. But once January comes, are they?

Speaker 7I'm not going to discuss the details of our conversation.

Speaker 6So I also wanted to ask you, so Hung Kao is the acting Secretary of the Navy. He was in the Senate yesterday getting grilled about a variety of different things. Wanted to play some of his testimony and get your. get your reaction to. And let's start with E1 here.

Speaker 10I care greatly for our sailors. They know.

Speaker 8Your solution seems to be to continue just asking these sailors and their families for more without giving them or us the truth about what the nature and length of their deployments going to be?

Speaker 10Well, Senator, I don't control the deployment lengths, but I did answer those inquiries right away, especially with the mental health issues. You see as eight suicide attempts, I see as eight suicides mitigations because of the chaplains we have on board, the deployment resiliency counselors, as well as mental health specialists.

Speaker 6So this is the flip side of U.S. aggression over there. I want to roll E2 also before we get you to respond. This is on the infamous dietary restrictions that were kind of forced on the sailors by the severing of the supply lines.

Speaker 1Apparently, the U.S.

Speaker 6Did not anticipate that Iran would be so able to diminish our capacity to basically supply the ships in the region.

Speaker 1Let's roll E2.

Speaker 5So are you saying then that these reports of somebody losing 45 pounds are not true?

Speaker 10Well, Senator, it's just not what they want. It's like my kids opening up the refrigerator door and saying, there's nothing to eat in here.

Speaker 11No, I don't think that's, Mr.

Speaker 5Secretary, I don't, somebody doesn't, somebody doesn't lose 45 pounds just because they don't like the options. I don't think that's a fair assessment.

Speaker 6And Secretary Cal went back to this, this analogy when it came to the munitions that the U.S.

Speaker 1Fired off during this war. Let's roll E3.

Speaker 10A lot of the munitions we use in Epic Fury were actually, we were able to recode those. They were code echo, code Foxtrot, which means they're expired. But, you know, I came from a poor family, right? You know, bread, things like bread doesn't expire. You just rub some water on the microwave for 15 seconds and it's good to go. And so for some of these munitions, we recoded them. And so we're able to shoot off the expired munitions, Senator.

Speaker 8All right.

Speaker 6So the suicide attempts are OK because they were averted. The 45 pounds was shed because they didn't like what was.

Speaker 1In the pantry.

Speaker 6And yes, we shot off all our munitions, but those were expired munitions anyway. As you kind of survey the landscape of this entire war, where are you and your kind of this new generation of politicians thinking about what the how how how do you how does this make you think about what the U.S.

Speaker 1Role should be over there?

Speaker 9I mean, this kind of highlights the incompetence, the failure of leadership, first of all, to take care of the troops, to lead, and also to take responsibility. I mean, when you're a leader at all levels, you take responsibility for the good as well as the bad. And this spinning and failure to take responsibility just as an indication from the top down, from the beginning to now, how this war is conducted and why we need proper oversight, why we need proper leadership in place. So again, going back

Speaker 9to Hegseth and all the way up to their president, what was their motivation, their thinking, their planning going into this war?

Speaker 7It seems to have been a haphazard.

Speaker 9So these are all more indications that we need to step in, stop this war because it's not helping the American people. Our troops are not betting. It's actually diminishing American power around the world. We appear incompetent. We have failed to achieve objectives.

Speaker 7We have not even set out clear objectives.

Speaker 9And it's going to take a lot of time, you know, decades really, to be able to restore that image again.

Speaker 7And this isn't making Americans safer.

Speaker 1Last question.

Speaker 6Since you have this expertise in the medical profession, I found it interesting that Hakeem Jeffries came out this week and basically embraced what Bernie Sanders has been pushing for. in this upcoming year, which is to say, so the first year of his Medicare for all bill would, would add dental and vision coverage to Medicare. It would lower the age from 65 down to 55. Uh, it would cover children, uh, and it would otherwise kind of, uh, expand the, expand the quality of the care as he

Speaker 6then envisions it, you know, continuing to close as you go forward. Jeffrey's said he said he's going to push forward with lowering it to 55 cover.

Speaker 1Like.

Speaker 6Is healthcare going to be, because of your background, is that going to be something that you are making a priority of yours? And what was your reaction to seeing Jeffries come out and adopt what is the kind of populist left position now on healthcare?

Speaker 7I mean, that's very positive. I mean, it is a priority.

Speaker 9I ran on healthcare, not bombs, which covers everything that we've been talking about right now. This is what we need to be focusing on. And we're always told that we can't afford to do that, but we can. And that's a great first step. This is what the American people want. It's an affordability issue. We shouldn't have to be worried about paying our rent and paying our medical bills and the debt that's associated. And these are really basic things that other countries are providing, and they're a lot less wealthy than we are. So it's a good

Speaker 9first step.

Speaker 11Yeah.

Speaker 6And the vote today for people watching is not final. They'll be choosing the Democratic nominee for Speaker.

Speaker 5Right.

Speaker 6And then on January 3rd, I think it is, there'll be the actual vote for Speaker. He has to get 218 at that point. Do you sense any pressure at this point at all to try to round up 40-plus Democrats to stop him short of 218, like the Republicans tried with Kevin McCarthy? They only needed five or so. Or do you think that whoever wins a nomination here is kind of on a glide path.

Speaker 7No, I think there's pressure.

Speaker 9The American people spoke loud and clear during the elections. They're making their dissatisfaction also clear during this whole process. So there's real pressure for substantive bold changes. And that's going to be, you know, there's still a lot of time to work between now and January 3rd to get there. But I'm not sure if we're there yet.

Speaker 6I talked to somebody, and I know I said last question, this is really last one, I talked to somebody in Bonnie Watson Coleman's office, who is the outgoing representative whose seat you're taking. They were saying that even though she doesn't even have a vote, they were getting hundreds of calls a day begging her not to vote for Hakeem Jeffries. And she would tell, well, look, good news for you. I'm not going to vote for Jeffries because I'm leaving Congress. Have you also been getting calls? Do you or do you even have the kind of. capacity yet to receive calls? Is that why she's getting them all? Because your office

Speaker 6isn't in place yet. How are you feeling the kind of grassroots pressure?

Speaker 9So I don't have a phone number yet. So our office is not open, but we are getting emails.

Speaker 1They're finding you?

Speaker 9Yeah, they're letting their wishes known in other ways.

Speaker 6Do you get any groundswell of you must support Hakeem Jeffries from voters in your district?

Speaker 7He has supporters.

Speaker 9I mean, he does have supporters, but, uh, I think that's the whole thing about a democracy. It's, um, you know, there's a lot of other voices as well, and we need to listen to everyone and understand that it is real pressure that's out there. And, uh, there is a, there is a pathway where everyone can have a win-win. I mean, if we are able to have change, um, and we are able to, um, strive for that vision of, you know, a better America, um, then, you know, we.

Speaker 7Could get there. But there's still a lot of work to do between now and January 3rd.

Speaker 3Great. Well, Dr.

Speaker 1Hamway, always a pleasure. Let us know how it goes down there.

Speaker 2All right.

Speaker 7Thank you very much.

Speaker 3See ya.

Speaker 6This week, a Senate energy bill, also described as permitting reform, also known as BAJA, which is called the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, cleared a major hurdle with a, I think it was like a 70 to 27 vote or something like that, like, you know, just kind of an unusually bipartisan effort that still had, I think, 21 Democrats voting against it. It is, in Washington, one of the few things that's actually happening that's actually going to

Speaker 6have an impact on your life. And there was recent polling, I think, that showed that something like 3% of the public kind of even knew that it was happening. It's moving towards final passage in the Senate this week, and it is still likely then to get a Yeah, there's the polling.

Speaker 1Nobody has any idea what's going on.

Speaker 6And it's partly the fault of the media and partly our fault. We barely covered this thing. So we're going to rectify that. Because it is expected to pass in the House before the lame duck ends and then be signed into law by President Trump. Somebody who has been following this is author and filmmaker Julian Brave Noisecat, who joins us here.

Speaker 1Julian.

Speaker 6Most importantly, a former colleague of mine back at the Huffington Post many years ago. But I've been following your career with great.

Speaker 1Pride since then.

Speaker 6You became pretty active in the climate movement along with your writing and filmmaking.

Speaker 1So thank you for taking some time to join us here today.

Speaker 12Thanks so much for having me, Ryan. It's good to be on your show. And yeah, it's been a treat to follow your career over the years as well.

Speaker 6So I wanted to start by getting the kind of opposition perspective out there, because this has divided the climate and environmental community. On the environmental side, the organizations that are more of a kind of, they prefer kind of to litigate against fossil fuel companies. They want regulation to kind of keep fossil fuels in the ground. They are largely for the most part, against this. There are some climate and environmental groups who are supportive of this and

Speaker 6argue that it's because the clean energy industry is so strongly behind it and because the only way to kind of address the climate catastrophe is to massively expand clean energy that you have to accept some trade-offs. But I wanted to get the kind of opposition argument out there. So Aaron Regenberg is a former candidate for Congress, climate activist. And he posted this on Instagram.

Speaker 13So this month, Democrats won this massive mandate running against Donald Trump and Republicans and corporate corruption and big tech and AI data centers. And what is the first action that Democratic leaders in the Senate took after winning this massive victory? They are supporting a Republican Trump big tech campaign. big oil-backed bill to eviscerate our bedrock environmental laws and give a massive giveaway to big oil and big tech.

Speaker 13So the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BHA, it's been framed as like a compromise to make it easier to build both clean energy and fossil fuel infrastructure. But it's not a compromise. It's more like a little nugget of something good in a massive shit sandwich, a generationally significant shit sandwich of MAGA, right-wing, pro-corporate bullshit. The nugget of good is around transmission, which we do need in order to build out more clean energy. But the

Speaker 13modeling such that it exists shows that this will have almost no impact on lowering climate emissions. The range is from it'll have a negative impact, like we will have more climate pollution, to the best case models, the best case scenarios are that it'll have almost no impact.

Speaker 6So Julian, stepping back, what is Baja or Baja? What does this bill do broadly?

Speaker 11The bill makes it easier to build in America.

Speaker 12I think that many are familiar with the challenges that our country faces in building out all forms of energy infrastructure, regardless of which type you prefer. Maybe you're a Texas Republican and you want more fossil fuel pipelines. Maybe you're a California Democrat and you wish that that damn train from San Francisco to LA had been built.

Speaker 11It's hard to build in this country.

Speaker 12The thing is, is that if you want to build more, you're going to have to roll back some of the bedrock environmental and historic preservation laws to make it a little bit easier for developers to build regardless of what they're building.

Speaker 6And so as somebody who's been as active as you in the climate movement, where would you say you stand on this on this legislation and why?

Speaker 12I think that I've been trying to be a little bit more of a describer than a stance taker. I mean, you know, there's this kind of funny thing that everybody does on social media where they all pretend like they're little mini politicians.

Speaker 11And that I don't think is really what.

Speaker 3I want to do.

Speaker 11I think that the world is a very complicated place.

Speaker 12And I think describing it is often a pretty good place to start.

Speaker 11I myself feel a bit cross-pressured on this.

Speaker 12I am convinced that we do, in fact, need to make it easier.

Speaker 11To build clean energy.

Speaker 12I'm also convinced that that is only going to happen in a compromise with Republicans in this Congress, who, of course, are not going to vote for something that is sort of a clean energy only bill. But among the environmental and historic preservation laws that are impacted by this bill are is unfortunately the nation-to-nation relationship with the 575 federally recognized tribes across this country, which of course is something that I, perhaps for obvious reasons for those watching on

Speaker 12a screen, care about.

Speaker 2Yeah, and I was actually just going to ask you about this because I think a lot of people, myself included, look at legislation and that has significant bipartisan support with some skepticism and say, wow, if you can get both parties to support something in Washington, what's the benefit for their donors and for the special interests? And so I was hoping you could talk to us a little bit about how they were able to make a piece of legislation that might genuinely be important and decent bipartisan over the course of this process.

Speaker 12Yeah, I mean I think that the process– I'm not exactly the most like sort of insidery guy on all this sort of stuff. So like if you want like the nitty-gritty of it, you should follow Josh Stegall at Punchbowl News. But basically, essentially, you got both sides of the aisle in on this. by doing things that both sides want. So on the one hand, clean energy advocates will point out that Donald Trump has had a really punitive relationship to building out any sort of wind energy infrastructure, like his administration is just stopping it left and right.

Speaker 12And the bill includes provisions that would make it impossible for a future administration to do that. Interestingly, the opponents of the bill will point at that exact same provision and tell you that that'll make it possible for fossil fuel corporations to seek you know, sort of damages for the infrastructure that they were unable to build, maybe because, you know, some of my friends in like tents are camped out in front of their project. So, you know, I think that part of what it's trying to achieve

Speaker 12here is just to make it easier to build everything. And of course, you know, all of us would prefer certain things to be built and other things perhaps not to be built.

Speaker 6Yeah, there was an article in Sludge that you and I were talking about last night, the headline, you could be on the hook for big oil's next pipeline. And yeah, can you like unpack that a little bit more? So the idea here is the original effort was to say, like, if you, you know, if the government is hostile to clean energy, because ideologically that the company can then, you know, sue and basically get paid back. But the opponents are arguing that this could also be weaponized by fossil fuel industry.

Speaker 1Is that right? What are we talking about here?

Speaker 6Is there actually a world in which if you get protesters who persuade a state or the feds to block a pipeline, that then the courts can say, okay, now the state and the feds have to actually just completely pay for the pipeline?

Speaker 12Yeah, I mean, I think that it is certainly possible that that could happen. I think, though, that the real energy nerds will point out that the glut of projects that are about to be– that need to be built are overwhelmingly clean energy projects and the projects that have faced– far more scrutiny, ironically, through our environmental review process, tend to be clean energy projects. Part of that is actually because of the way that clean energy infrastructure, if you

Speaker 12just think about it for one second, like a pipeline is often below the ground, so there's no sightline concerns in the way that these permitting review processes are done. A big wind farm, on the other hand, quite visible, a transmission line, similarly. And so there are, in fact, and this is one of the great ironies of these laws, in a certain way, greater barriers to building clean energy than there are to building fossil fuel infrastructure, which, you know, even the opponents of the.

Speaker 11Bill would agree that that is part of my language here, but asked backwards.

Speaker 2Yeah.

Speaker 6And so I wanted to give the kind of the best counter argument, as I see it, to what Aaron was saying at the top and get your get your.

Speaker 1Take on it.

Speaker 2So.

Speaker 6The keep it in the ground argument from climate activists, I think, is the most obviously kind of scientifically sound. We are in a climate crisis and burning more carbon is going to push us deeper into that crisis.

Speaker 1And so logically, you've got to stop at this point.

Speaker 6However, what I think the politics of the world have shown us, whether it was France with the yellow vest protests, whether it's authoritarian countries ousted, whose dictators are ousted when energy prices skyrocket or when they remove subsidies from energy prices, or here in the United States. Not just this recent election, which was significantly over energy prices fueled by the Iran war, but we had it in the 2000s as well. When gas prices spike, the party in power pays a price.

Speaker 6That is basically kind of axiomatic and inherent at this point to the democratic process here in the United States.

Speaker 1So if your climate.

Speaker 6Policy involves, so this would be the counter argument, if your climate policy involves driving up the price of energy, your climate policy will fail. Like at best it will be implemented and then you'll be ousted and it will be reversed. More likely it won't actually even ever be implemented. Therefore you need a climate policy that does not do that, which requires then a massive build out of clean energy, which is going to be very difficult to accomplish without

Speaker 6also building, allowing for the build out of dirty energy, given our political structure at the moment where we have a Republican president and we're going to, and we still have a filibuster in place, you know, Republican president for the next two years. So that's the, that to me is the counter argument to Aaron. What, How do you see that argument, and what is it missing.

Speaker 1And what are the holes in it?

Speaker 12Yeah, I mean, I think that the argument in favor of the bill is, as you described, an affordability argument and a climate argument. I think that the affordability argument, I think you made.

Speaker 11It pretty well, but I drive a truck.

Speaker 12It has gotten quite expensive to drive that truck, and so— I drive around my little, uh, hybrid in town instead, uh, even though I would really prefer to be driving around my truck because it looks cool and it's fun. And, you know, I could take it down a dirt road when I want to, uh, and, you know, just, uh, it's not diesel, thank God.

Speaker 11Um, but you.

Speaker 12Know, I, uh, I got family in, in very rural parts of this continent, um, like living down dirt roads and that kind of thing.

Speaker 11And so I kind of need a truck. Um, I don't really get to drive these days.

Speaker 12And, um, you know, I think it's also worth pointing out that we are now living in a period of time where energy demand is going up significantly because of the AI boom, um, you know, which we all seem to just be kind of along for the ride on at this point.

Speaker 11I mean, like, um, there's really no accountability.

Speaker 12It seems like for those guys, um, There are some strong provisions around the data centers in this bill.

Speaker 11To make them actually kind of pay in certain kind of ways.

Speaker 12And so that demand is going to be met in some way, shape, or form. And I think that this bill does make it easier to build clean and makes it more likely that the energy demand that we're meeting in the future increases. not just for affordability and cost reasons, but also because of geopolitical concerns now around fossil fuel energy, which I think we're all aware of with what's gone on in the Middle East, is looking more and more enticing. And so I think that the argument is that this will supercharge the transition moving forward and will set up

Speaker 12a next democratic.

Speaker 11Administration to really juice our efforts on climate.

Speaker 2I guess it's sort of an answer to the question of whether abundance, at least from a leftist perspective, is possible, or maybe it's a test of the theory that abundance and leftism can kind of work hand in hand in a way that is politically viable too.

Speaker 12Yeah, I mean, I think that a lot of people have said that this is sort of one of the crowning achievements, I guess, of the sort of sort of abundance bros.

Speaker 11I don't think that that's necessarily wrong.

Speaker 12I would also say, though, that like, you know, if you happen to have a politics that might be interested in things like more planning, the system that we currently have, wherein it is impossible really to build, you know, uh, I mean, like I lived in New York for a few years, how many years did it take us to get that, uh, first Avenue, you know, subway, um, you know, politics where it's difficult to, to build things is, is not actually good for, um, you know, uh, a social democratic, democratic socialist, whatever your persuasion is, view of the world either.

Speaker 12So this is a difficult piece of legislation for, I think, in a weird way, everybody kind of to swallow, because that's actually also the.

Speaker 11Nature of bipartisan compromise.

Speaker 12But there are things in here that I think people on both sides of the issue can like.

Speaker 6Yeah, I think it also implicates taxation, too. There were some There was some collection of people in California who were uninterested in approving a billionaire tax because they're like, what are you going to do with the money? Like, we've given you money. You said you were going to build a high speed rail. You said you were going to do this, said you're going to do that. You haven't built it. So build some stuff first before coming back and asking for more money. And so it even then complicates the attempt to do some wealth inequality reduction.

Speaker 1But Julian, thank you so much for joining us. We really, really appreciate it.

Speaker 11Yeah, thanks so much for having me.

Speaker 12And the last thing I just want to say is that one of the most interesting parts of this whole saga has been that the tribal concerns in the bill ended up being a real.

Speaker 11Point in negotiation in the last week on this thing.

Speaker 6Can you explain to us how that unfolded? I forgot that was one of the things I wanted to ask you about.

Speaker 1What does it do?

Speaker 6In the way that it kind of rearranges the relationship between the federal government and the tribes?

Speaker 12Yeah, you know, I think that, so there's this thing called tribal consultation. Tribes are sovereign entities. Many of them went to war with the United States and signed treaties with the United States. It doesn't get much more sovereign than that. And the federal government also has, through over, almost 200 years now of federal Indian law, a federal trust responsibility to tribes, which basically means a responsibility to avoid harming the tribes as much as possible, which of course the federal government has not been great at throughout

Speaker 12its history. This bill impacts one little piece of that relationship. It's called the National Historic Preservation Act. Section 106 of that act involves how the federal government is supposed to consult with tribes on projects that are going to impact their cultural sites. Like with the rest of the review processes, the bill expedites that process, but there's been a lot of negotiations around it. In fact, more favorable negotiations than on other environmental titles in the bill, in part because

Speaker 12tribes have pushed back pretty hard because, of course, they believe that cutting down on those review processes uh, infringes upon their sovereignty and their right to have some say about development that impacts, um, you know, sacred sites, burial grounds.

Speaker 11Uh, you know, things of that nature.

Speaker 6And I saw you, you were also part of exposing, um, a bit of a scandal where a lot of environmental groups were caught, um, paying, uh, kind of, uh, American Indian influencers to, to put, put out social videos, opposing like what, what happened there?

Speaker 12And, um, Yeah, I, uh, you know, um, people, uh, can get a little funny on, on the Twitter machine and, and simply so describing the bill apparently makes nobody happy on either side. And so I was pointing it out, like, listen, like if you're going to call somebody a sellout, you're calling the wrong dude to sell out. Like I, I did not take the money to become a a paid influencer on this thing. One of the things that has happened here is, in point of fact, the green groups

Speaker 12have been a bit rolled by this. If there's any big loser coming out of this legislation, it's probably the environmental groups. There has been a history going back at least 10 years, probably longer, of tribes being treated as sort of a junior partner in the environmental coalition. And I don't think that that has served their interests particularly well. Clearly on this bill, they've been able to get more independent of the green groups than they did with them. And I think that there might be a new alignment

Speaker 12of all these different sort of NGOs and tribes and things the coalition on climate environmental concerns might look a bit different moving forward Yeah, it.

Speaker 6Was interesting because after the green groups kind of paid some of these influencers American Indian influence to oppose it The tribes ended up getting the concessions rather than the green groups was actually I guess would be appropriate because if you're going to use them as your front It would be appropriate that then the negotiators like okay.

Speaker 1Well, you've got objections. Let's let's talk.

Speaker 6About those and And then you've got the green groups in the background being like, well, actually, it was about hours.

Speaker 12Yeah, you know, I think people are always surprised to learn this, especially if they're from the East. But tribes are actually pretty significant players in American politics, particularly in the West. The interesting divide to me on Baja has not necessarily been the right-left divide, but the regional divide. I think Western politicians in particular have been quite cross-pressured on this piece of legislation. There's more tribes in their states. There's also, no offense to those East Coast folks, but there's also a little bit more environment out in the West. And,

Speaker 12you know, I think that, listen, Indian casinos are a $ 45 billion a year industry that's bigger than U.S.

Speaker 3Steel.

Speaker 12We had three historic firsts for Native women this election cycle, the first Native American woman governor, two of the first Native women senators. Tribes, despite what everybody has heard in their history classes, are actually quite savvy actors in politics and remain so to this day. And so, you know, I don't know if any of you guys have seen Eddington, but the plot of Eddington, the Ari Aster film ends with the tribe owning the data center. I, you know, that's not my particular political persuasion, but I don't know if.

Speaker 11That's actually that far off of the truth.

Speaker 3That we're headed towards for the future.

Speaker 2That's a good point. Right.

Speaker 1Well, Julian, thank you. Really appreciate it.

Speaker 11Thanks for having me.

Speaker 2Well, a little bit of TV magic here. Ryan just had a handful of trail mix before we recorded the outro. And we taped the Hamawee interview first. We taped it out of order. And I missed that we had a time change. So I literally walked into the studio as Adam Hamawee was walking into the studio. And I was like, oh, I think I missed the time.

Speaker 5I know.

Speaker 6I keep arguing that we need to do these programs live. But then we're just kind of.

Speaker 1I think people would be fine with that. Just to be a lot of out of order stuff.

Speaker 2Crystal and Sagar are very type A people, and we are very much type B people, if that is such a type, if it exists.

Speaker 1I think people would be fine with that, right?

Speaker 2Ryan and I are a little more relaxed.

Speaker 7Yeah, we'll show up.

Speaker 2Crystal and Sagar are here on the dot, ready to go. Ryan and I are like, we're taking our time. We like to ease into it.

Speaker 1We might see you Friday, we might not.

Speaker 2Yes, just a reminder also that if you want to be entered into the fish raffle, you've got to respond to the e-mail message. by 5 p.m.

Speaker 3Today.

Speaker 2Please check out the new merch. It's all over at BreakingPoints.com. You can get a premium subscription there as well, and we hope you do. We'll see you back here on Friday.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 11/20/26: Schumer REJECTED By Allies, Slotkin DEFECTS, Trump ABANDONS Americans To West Bank Terror, Zohran SHOCKS: RIKERS TO CLOSE, MARKET FALLS, ANTHROPIC DOWN, AI BUBBLE POP?, Fox News FREAKS Over GTA VI

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 46 minAudio

    The Friday gang digs into the growing support for Chris Van Hollen who is opposing Chuck Schumer in the Senate, Zohran Mamdani’s announcement to shut down Rikers Island, and are joined by guests, Jasper Nathaniel to...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 11/19/26: Saagar Debates Kalshi Investor, Elon Turns On MAGA, Anthropic IPO

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Saagar debates Kalshi investor, Elon turns on MAGA, Anthropic launches IPO. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111 Gary Marcus: https://x.com/GaryMarcus To...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 11/19/26: Jeffries Wins Speaker Vote, Trump Fumes At JD Over Iran, Shoppers Raid Costco For Doomsday Supplies

    Nov 19, 202651 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Jeffries wins the House speaker vote, Trump fumes at Vance over Iran, shoppers raid stores for doomsday supplies. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 11/18/26: Stocks Plunge Amid More Outages, Jensen Begs For Nvidia Job Back, Expert Says Epstein Was Murdered

    Nov 18, 202647 minAudio

    Ryan and Emily discuss stocks plunge amid more outages, Jensen begs for Nvidia job back, NYT flips on Epstein as expert says he was murdered. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy:...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 11/17/26: Nvidia Says Jensen Not Coming Back, AOC Ex Aide On Mistakes She Made, Emma Vigeland On Dem Leadership Fight

    Nov 17, 202655 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Nvidia says Jensen Huang is not coming back, AOC ex aide on how to avoid her mistakes, Emma Vigeland on Dem leadership fight. Emma Vigeland:...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode