Ryan and Emily discuss stocks plunge amid more outages, Jensen begs for Nvidia job back, NYT flips on Epstein as expert says he was murdered. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy: https://hamawyfornj.com/ Julian Brave: https://www.julianbravenoisecat.com/ To become a Breaking Points Premium Member and watch/listen to the show AD FREE, uncut and 1 hour early visit: www.breakingpoints.com Merch Store: https://shop.breakingpoints.com/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Had a busy day? Don't have time to listen to the show?
Speaker 2Catch up on Breaking Points with our free daily newsletter.
Speaker 3You'll get our breakdown of every daily story. And lots of links in your inbox every day. So head over to BreakingPoints.com.
Speaker 1You can sign up for the newsletter at the top for free today.
Speaker 3All right, good morning and welcome to Breaking Points. We're all here just white knuckling it through this internet apocalypse.
Speaker 1Yeah, fingers crossed that we can record the show in full.
Speaker 3Just trying to make it to Madison Square Garden.
Speaker 1That's right. Well, that's the big news that we have at the top of the show today.
Speaker 3So we'll talk about that in a second. We're also going to try to sell you some merch before the end of the world. But we'll begin the show by talking about... Oh, well, they just put the merch up. Merch is up. Let's talk about the merch. So we have new, exclusive, exciting holiday merch. We got hats. We got ugly sweaters.
Speaker 1We got mugs.
Speaker 3We got baby onesies. We got baby onesies.
Speaker 1Which I'm convinced is because Sagar wants... That's right.
Speaker 3Yes, exactly.
Speaker 1So we made them for everyone so Sager can have them.
Speaker 3Classic conservative.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's right.
Speaker 3Life experience, and all of a sudden, it's like, let's put some onesies up there.
Speaker 1He loves it. He loves it.
Speaker 3So anyway, there's not a whole lot of it, so you better, if you want your ugly sweaters, I think there's only like 300 of them or something.
Speaker 1Yeah, that's what we've been told. It's like a limited edition rollout here. So act quickly. For anybody in your life who needs a Christmas gift, a Breaking Points-themed Christmas gift, now's your opportunity.
Speaker 3Also, act quickly because commerce is still working as of today on the internet. That's a great point. Like, basically.
Speaker 1You're an consummate salesman. You have to instill fear.
Speaker 3Sort of working.
Speaker 1It's like Don Draper shit.
Speaker 3From some apps to other apps. We'll see. And we'll see how long that lasts. And that'll be the topic of our top block. Also, later in the show, we'll talk about the renewed hostilities between Iran and the United States. We'll talk about that with incoming Congressman Adam Hamaway, who's later in the program. The latest on NVIDIA, where Jensen Wong said that he is willing to come back, which spiked shares of the company. The company said, no, not interested. Trump said he'd be OK with him coming back. The
Speaker 3New York Times and the BBC are taking very seriously a forensic scientist who says that all indications are that Epstein was killed in jail. I know what you're going to say. You already knew that. This is not news. What's news is. is that places like the New York Times are finding it worth reporting. And I think that itself is the most interesting element of this. We'll also be joined by Republican Congressman Warren Davidson, one of the most interesting members of the House, I think.
Speaker 1Definitely.
Speaker 3And towards the end, a lot of people have been saying, hey, what about the permitting reform energy bill? The only thing that's actually happening in Washington that will impact people's lives.
Speaker 1Don't forget your Halloween.
Speaker 3Are you going to cover that? Yes, we'll talk to Hamway about the Akeem Jeffries leadership contest, which will unfold today. But then we'll talk about the permitting reform bill. We'll have Julian Brave, Noisecat, actually my fellow from HuffPost like 10 years ago. Amazing. He's going to break down what this bill does. It's become extremely contentious across, kind of across the spectrum because it has both, it has the support of both the clean energy industry and the fossil
Speaker 3fuel industry. industry plus big tech plus some data center folks opposition support from some environmental groups of opposition from some environmental groups uh we'll talk about what the bill does and why it's uh why it's splitting people um but first uh everything is falling apart.
Speaker 1Well we also have the fish announcement oh yes before everything falls apart we're going to sell you merch we are going to help you get to fish.
Speaker 3We've been getting a lot of questions about the fish lottery the fish lottery ph It's P-H-I-S-H. It's a jam band. They are playing a four-night run at Madison Square Garden in New York City over New Year's. If you subscribe by the end of today, you'll be entered into a contest to win a ticket or win two tickets, actually, for the New Year's Eve show. My wife and I will be going with you. It's going to be a
Speaker 3lot of fun. And then there will be another email saying like, hey, are you actually trying to enter into the fish lottery or are you just subscribing to the show? Because I think most people are like, I'm really sorry. I have no interest in going to this show.
Speaker 1Yeah, they're like.
Speaker 4No.
Speaker 3Thanks, but no thanks.
Speaker 1I'm here for the actual political news.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 1But some people are here for both.
Speaker 3If you're in the thanks but no thanks camp, you don't know what you're missing, but I'm not here to proselytize.
Speaker 1Yeah, so just make sure that by 5 p.m., You reply to that email so that you are inserted into, it's a lottery.
Speaker 3Yeah, and I think Thursday the winners are going to, winners will be chosen.
Speaker 1Whether or not it qualifies, meets that definition of what is a winner.
Speaker 3Yeah, and we're going to try to plan a meetup for everybody who's going to the show and who watches this show before Thursday. the New Year's Eve show.
Speaker 1Ryan Graham is a generous man, but yeah, let's make sure.
Speaker 3I'm so generous, I'm willing to go to this New Year's Eve show.
Speaker 1And drink beforehand at a bar. It's too much.
Speaker 3It might just be water for that show, but we'll see.
Speaker 1Oh, it won't just be water, but... It'll be fun. So thanks, everyone. If you have subscribed, if you haven't, you can head over to BreakingPoints.com. But make sure if you did subscribe in that window, if you're interested in the fish raffle, you respond to the email that you've gotten. Get in on it so that by 5 p.m. today, we'll have everything set and can make that announcement. Tomorrow, all right, let's get to today's show.
Speaker 3Their 100th show at Madison Square Garden is January 2nd. Well, you didn't say it was the 100th. This will be their 98th.
Speaker 1I mean, this is history. Be a part of history.
Speaker 3100 shows. That's like Billy Joel level.
Speaker 1Speaking of history in the making, history appears to be– I think actually we.
Speaker 3Are living through history right now. History beyond making, yeah.
Speaker 1Yeah, right. We are living through history right now. Let's start with today's top of the show news, which is a block here. We have news– Let's go to A1. This is a New York Times headline yesterday. AI helps find major security bug in Java, a software platform vital to the Internet. Yeah, no kidding. But outages continued yesterday. We're going to get into all of this news. Let's start also with the NSA. The NSA experienced an outage yesterday.
Speaker 1This was a report with a Natasha Bertrand byline in CNN.
Speaker 5A2.
Speaker 1Always worth recognizing. The highly classified network that the National Security Agency uses for its internal communications is down, according to six people familiar with the matter. At this point, there's no evidence of a cyber attack, sources said. CNN has asked the NSA for comment. So that comes out around the middle of the day yesterday. I think it was about 11 a.m. that comes out. And everyone is thinking, OK, we've had this cascade of of significant outages from Microsoft to the FAA, and now you are telling me that the NSA has an outage as well. Well, then the
Speaker 1NSA comes, probably an hour later. They say, this is the next element, it was actually just a software update. Quote, a person familiar with the incident said the NSA was simply updating its software to patch the system, noting that NSA Net would be offline only temporarily and that there was no evidence of a cyber attack. So you have six people familiar going to CNN and saying, our internal system is down. And then within an hour, the journal gets an update of somebody saying, no, no, we're just
Speaker 1patching the system. That is a tension that feels unresolvable, Ryan.
Speaker 3Yeah, and so this comes after Microsoft was down across the board the other day. We put up A5. Apple announced that it was... experiencing periodic collapse of some of its platforms, including just some minor ones like iCloud, Apple Pay, and the App Store. No big deal. That's fine. That contributed to a stock market route, put up A6, stock
Speaker 3market shedding, the Dow shedding nearly 1,000 points. And so the conventional wisdom that is going around, and I actually spoke with a source at Microsoft who I trust. I spoke with somebody at Chase as well who had gotten some insight because Chase and some other banks went down. And this is what they're saying. And the Microsoft source is involved in this and has been reliable over many years. I don't think it was spinning. Making the case that
Speaker 3basically what, so this is the case. I know a lot of people are skeptical. They think this is a you know, probing or a cyber attack or these are rogue AI agents. What also could make sense is the claim that the NSA made. And so basically what they're saying is this, AI has unleashed extraordinary offensive capabilities for hackers. And when we say hackers, we're not talking about like kids who are like trying to like hack away their
Speaker 3student debt. That kind of anonymous collective of hackers They've basically been crushed. They put a bunch of them in prison and the rest of them have mostly disbanded. When you're talking about hacking, you're talking about state actors for the most part and maybe some criminal enterprises that are state-sponsored. We can talk later about how we should think about that when it comes to building the infrastructure of the
Speaker 3internet going forward.
Speaker 1You just reminded me to turn my phone off and on again, by the way.
Speaker 3That's right, it kicks out the hackers. So because there are is now this almost infinite offensive capability on the part of people who are going after websites, they're able to find these exploits very quickly. So all of these companies have unleashed their cybersecurity defense teams to say, Go find the zero-day exploits before the hackers find them and
Speaker 3patch them. And what one source was telling me is that in the past, you used to have a significant amount of time once you found an exploit to be able to design your patch to then go in and clean it up because there was no expectation that it was going to be coincidentally found by a hacker like 24 hours later.
Speaker 5Mm-hmm.
Speaker 3Now they're saying like max seven days, like from identification of it to patching. And so they develop the patch and then they have to upload it like immediately almost without testing what it does to the rest of the consumer facing interface. And what it did at Microsoft, what it did at the NSA apparently, what it did over at Chase is, oh, the site stopped working. So the point would be, if that's true, the point would be that These are not AI hacks, but it is AI
Speaker 3hacking that is driving it.
Speaker 1Yeah, and we can actually go to the first element again here in this New York Times report on the Java vulnerability, which was found by the startup called Calif that has been working, according to the New York Times, with the five I's. So U.S., Canada, Australia, New Zealand and Britain. The Times reached out to the NSA for comment about whether or not this was related to the Java bug. So was the NSA panicking to patch the Java bug? Not everybody internally was aware that they were patching the Java bug. Some people go to the media
Speaker 1and say this is internally down. Other people then go to another media outlet and say, no, it was just a routine patch. So this stuff is moving. I mean, it's a good example of how quickly this stuff is moving. And The quote from this fellow who's a senior researcher at Calif in the New York Times drives it home. He says, Java is the beating heart of the modern economy. Practically speaking, all major companies will be affected by the bug, according to the New York Times. And so just to bring your point home, Ryan, everybody is now racing. And
Speaker 1what we could be in the midst of is some companies panicking to patch or some companies actually being taken down by hackers. We're, on the outside, in the public, not always going to know which is true, and then you end up having to rely on government officials like Vice President J.D. Vance to tell you what's happening, or big business to tell you what's happening, and people are left wondering about the beating heart of the modern economy, whether or not it's appropriately, or how vulnerable it is, and whether or not their daily lives can be disrupted
Speaker 1in really significant ways when we're talking about banking or your iCloud on any given day.
Speaker 3And OpenAI has basically reinvented the mafia. We can put up A7 here. OpenAI announces cybersecurity partnership with NATO, revealing that NATO was already using 300 billion tokens per month as part of cybersecurity initiatives, per the Wall Street Journal. So in other words, they created the risk. Nice internet you've got here. Sure would be a shame if our products destroyed it. But if you use our products, we can protect it. But J.D. Vance is not too concerned.
Speaker 3He says you probably don't necessarily need a bunker. Let's roll. Laura Ingram sat down with J.D. Vance and asked him how concerned people should be. Let's play A4 here.
Speaker 6In addition to that ground stop, we saw massive separate tech outages last week.
Speaker 1So Microsoft Outlook, Workday.
Speaker 6Meanwhile, the Pentagon has bases prepping for 90 days off the grid. And then countries like the UK and France are urging citizens to have days worth of food and water stockpiled. So should Americans be prepping for something here, given what's just happened over the past two weeks, Mr.
Speaker 3Vice President?
Speaker 7Yeah, I've had a lot of my friends reach out and say, should we be preparing to build a bunker to stock up on food and water? And my answer to that is no, we do not see some crisis coming down, but you have to be prepared for everything. And what we want to do is make sure that we prevent the worst outcomes, but we're also prepared for the worst outcomes. So I think a lot of what's being reported on is just basic good government, making sure that our military would be prepared, God forbid, if there was a crisis, but we don't see a crisis coming down the pike. And in part, What the president has been so successful at is ensuring that we're reinvesting in
Speaker 7the United States of America and we're better prepared for crisis. That doesn't mean crisis is around the corner. That just means you've got a government who's actually preparing for it.
Speaker 3Rubio, meanwhile, has said all of these things that are happening all at the same time are completely unrelated. Let's roll Rubio here.
Speaker 8We are not under systemic attack. These events, one has nothing to do with the other. They're not interrelated. They're all separate and they're distinct. And we have no evidence. On the contrary, every indicator we have is that every single one of these events has an explanation or a cause that has nothing to do with a cyber criminal, has nothing to do with a hostile actor or another country. That doesn't mean that there aren't hostile actors and cyber criminals in other countries that aren't trying to harm us. It just means these events have nothing to do with that. And the American people should have confidence in that. And I think the best way to address it with people
Speaker 8is just to be straight out and say, you know, this is the information we have right now. We have a duty to report that to the American people.
Speaker 3What do you think, Emily?
Speaker 1Worth contrasting that with Senator Josh Hawley, who was asked in the halls of the Senate yesterday about all of this. And he said, if it's all a coincidence, quote, it's like the greatest coincidence in the history of the world. So not buying what Rubio is telling Rubio is, of course, also the national security advisor, in addition to being secretary of state. And Hawley is just flat out saying that makes no sense to me.
Speaker 3And the explanation that I laid out could still be true, which is, and what Rubio was saying could also be true if you said, if you said, okay, they're not related in the sense they're done by the same actor, but they're all happening at the same time for the same reason. Because we built this over the past 30, 40 years, we built a pretty open and vulnerable internet. We then, took us a little while, but we got everybody to put all of their data and all of their money onto it. And then shortly after we accomplished that,
Speaker 3we developed new technology that made all of what we had done before completely insecure. And so now we're spending our time trying to patch it up.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And now we're in the we hope this works phase.
Speaker 1Well, I also wanted to ask you about this. Tomorrow will potentially be the largest IPO in the history of the world. That timing seems conspicuous as well.
Speaker 4Yes.
Speaker 3You're like, wait a minute, you guys are planning on getting rich from this? It's so strange. It's like, wait a minute, okay. Usually you get rich it's because you brought something good or the idea is you're supposed to bring something into the world that people want and make the world better and then you profit from that. Y'all have brought nothing but chaos. Well, not nothing. Obviously there's some utility to the technology, good and bad, but they're
Speaker 3wrecking the planet, wrecking our entire connected society. And they're going to get fantastically rich from it.
Speaker 1Well, yeah, this crisis cascade, sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt, but the crisis cascade starts a week before their IPO, roughly, right? So you have the FAA. Well, actually, Microsoft Outlook was last Thursday, I believe. FAA is last Friday, and then everything else since. The IPO is tomorrow. So like literally a week before the IPO, all of this starts happening. I mean, again, to quote Josh Hawley, if it's a coincidence, it's a pretty great coincidence.
Speaker 3And the NVIDIA crisis probably also connected.
Speaker 7Great point.
Speaker 3Like the Jensen Huang affairs.
Speaker 1Have been going on for months.
Speaker 3Months to years and have been an open secret apparently in Silicon Valley and Wall Street. They were written about publicly by short sellers. who were arguing, hey, there's a lot of risk to this company because this guy's got this relationship with Alice Wong. When this is fully exposed, it's going to cause problems for them. You should short their company. It all comes out right after the midterms and right before this looming IPO, while Jensen Wong was
Speaker 3kind of a commercial partner with Anthropic and OpenAI, but opponent in the sense that their vision of a kind of closed, monopolized AI world was contrary to his own interests, which is in an open one where he's selling chips to everybody and one or two companies monopolizes the entire thing. And now he's been smashed for now.
Speaker 1And people can cash out on the fear of If the fear hypes the IPO up to a certain level, they will have made more money with the greater hype just in the last week. If that works, their shares explode and they can cash.
Speaker 4Out on it.
Speaker 1Yes.
Speaker 3Well, let's talk about the NVIDIA comeback that Jensen Wong is trying to pull off.
Speaker 1Let's do it. Well, outgoing NVIDIA CEO Jensen Wong put out an interesting statement yesterday on X. And when I say interesting, it was almost Ackman length, maybe half an Ackman. He wrote, over the past week, I've been overwhelmed by the love and support of friends, industry colleagues, and people I've never met. Thank you to everyone who has shown kindness to my family and me. It means the world to me. He says, since my departure, I've seen an outpouring of calls from NVIDIA's employees, investors, business partners, and
Speaker 1customers for me to return as CEO. Many continue to reach out to me directly as the company navigates complex technology market competitive and geopolitical dynamics. NVIDIA is a once in a generation If the board of directors decides that my return is in the best interest of our shareholders, our employees, the company, and America, I would be honored to answer these calls and return as CEO. Meanwhile, though, the Wall Street Journal reported yesterday that the SEC is probing NVIDIA after Wang's departure. actually on the basis of
Speaker 1investor disclosure. So the journal writes, just weeks ago, NVIDIA was a stock market darling at the center of the booming artificial intelligence trade and the most valuable company in the world. But now it has faced questions from investors about its disclosures related to Wong's affairs and its sales of its chips in Asia. So Ryan, to say the very least, it seems unlikely. that the board re-accepts Jensen Wong as CEO of NVIDIA, given that, A, the board was very frustrated by what it felt, apparently, according to reporting,
Speaker 1was a lack of disclosure from Wong, that he was the source of the problems with disclosure that the company is now being probed by the SEC over.
Speaker 3I'm not sure, though, that this means the board is closing the door to him coming back, because if they said, sure, we'll think about it, Like, it's over. If you open that door, a crack, he walks, like, right through it. And so it's one of those things that they will not say is going to happen until the second it happens, if it does end up happening. I mean, what's so
Speaker 3interesting about this is, I mean, obviously it seems like he's not denying the underlying allegations here that he was having, like, affairs all over the place with at least two underlings. And then somebody who was said to be a spy by the New York Times because they were sourcing it to somebody in the Trump administration. And we'll get to that in one second. But it turns out there's apparently no evidence that they were a spy, but they were involved.
Speaker 1In some decision-making.
Speaker 3I mean, there's evidence that you could assume. We'll get into it in a second. So let's think about how this unfolded. The CIA writes a report about this, right? And in the report, they say that they don't have evidence that she's a spy, but that it's of concern to them because of her role with these other companies. And they had been trying to crack down on some of the distribution of these chips in some of these commercial networks. which she was playing a role in.
Speaker 1Rare I say that, but that seems to be an eminently reasonable source of a report or subject of a report from the CIA.
Speaker 3That's fine. Yeah, yeah, sure. This is what the CIA is there for.
Speaker 1A huge company, very important to the economy, to national security, that.
Speaker 3Sort of thing. So then Marco Rubio, who wears a hat as national security advisor, takes the CIA report, writes a memo about the report, and adds to it, embellishes it to say, oh, she's a spy.
Speaker 1Extreme China hawk, Marco Rubio.
Speaker 3Right. Then it winds up in the New York Times.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3So we're not children here. Let's just be clear. Rubio or Mike Eden.
Speaker 1It's a laundering operation.
Speaker 2Leaked.
Speaker 3Yeah. They embellished a report and then they used the report and they got it into the New York Times.
Speaker 1Framed as accurate. Basically. Framed as credible and serious.
Speaker 3And now at the same time, was it Anthropic who had just hired Continental? So there's a lobbying firm out there. So there's two key lobbying firms. There's Ballard Partners, which is Susie Wiles' world, right? It's Florida world, Susie Wiles' world. And then there's Continental, which is basically Rubio's kind of lobbying operation.
Speaker 1Ballard is very friendly to Rubio, too.
Speaker 3So they're both, I'd say, Continental probably a little tighter and more concentrated because Ballard has a more sprawling operation. But yeah, it's all the Susie Wiles, Marco Rubio, Florida mafia, right? So Continental's getting a bunch of money from, was it OpenAI or Anthropic, right around the time that this is happening, directly to Rubio's former chief of staff. And this entire operation unfolds. And where is Trump in this? Trump is
Speaker 3close to Jensen Wong. Rubio is frustrated that Trump is close to Jensen Wong. And so, and apparently Jensen Wong was trying to meet with Rubio, you know, for the last two years to build a relationship with him. Rubio refused. He then refused. creates this memo that embellishes the woman's espionage connections, gets it into the New York Times, and then uses that to end him. While Jensen's rivals are paying...
Speaker 3To potentially end Lutnick. His allies and Lutnick, right. He's trying to nuke Lutnick, too.
Speaker 1Could even have wanted to nuke Lutnick more than Wong, to be honest. Because clearly there were deep simmering tensions. First of all, I don't think many people, not, I shouldn't say many, but there are a lot of people who don't personally like Howard Lutnick.
Speaker 3This is not a rush to the defense of Howard Lutnick's show, right?
Speaker 1No, they are not personally favorable to Howard Lutnick. They don't like him. They don't feel like he has a good influence on the president. And they, I think, have been deeply suspicious of the way his sons take over Cantor Fitzgerald. And it just rubs people the wrong way.
Speaker 3It bought up all the tariff money.
Speaker 1And I was going to say, the president himself obviously has that problem, too. But when it's like the hangers on, sometimes the Trump allies really don't like it. And that has always been a problem with Letnick. And Rubio is in. arch China hawk. And so when he sees evidence, which I think Crystal was making this point, it is perfectly fair for any American to look at what Jensen Wang was doing and then also to look at Howard Lutnick's reluctance to take particular regulatory steps and say, huh, is
Speaker 1this actually about you making money or is this about the national interest? A perfectly fair, reasonable response to that. Perfectly fair, reasonable response to Wang's relationship with Alice Wang who is at the very least moving chips through shell companies, it would be perfectly reasonable to assume or suspect that she had been a target for recruitment, even if she hadn't been recruited for espionage. It would be reasonable to look into that, which is what we were getting at earlier, whether it's CIA or whomever's probing that. Totally fair and reasonable. What do we actually know right now is that, well, logically,
Speaker 1it would make sense. It would be weird if she hadn't been a target for espionage. But to your point, We don't know. And so Rubio seizes the opportunity, not just to oust Wang, who he probably thinks is boosting China at our expense, but then also Lutnik, two birds with one stone. What a smooth move.
Speaker 3Yeah. And so for the specifics on the money flow here, anthropic, paid $ 740, 000 to Continental Strategy.
Speaker 1And Ballard.
Speaker 3And also Ballard.
Speaker 1They were paying both of them.
Speaker 3And so Continental Strategy, the D.C. office is run by Alberto Martinez, who is the former chief of staff to Marco Rubio. When you file, you're supposed to reveal who it is in particular you intend to lobby. They They continental lists the NSC, National Security Council, which is that's Rubio's domain here. And so, yeah. And so they're also
Speaker 3Ballard Partners, which is the Susie Wiles and Rubio linked. So this is a kind of Florida operation. It's widely known in Washington. And this goes for Venezuela, probably even more so than this, that if you want some type of business in Venezuela, some type of oil business in Venezuela, you better pay continental strategy, better pay Rubio's, uh, lobby shop. That's not owned by Rubio, but it is this it's Rubio world. And it's just understood that this is that they,
Speaker 3and Ballard are the ones that you, that you pay. I think Ballard has the most, uh, the highest publicly declared revenue of any lobbying firm in Washington over the past two years.
Speaker 1And it is exploded.
Speaker 3And it's a fraction of what they, um, have made, but what they've had to declare.
Speaker 1Oh my gosh. It's like Politico influence has done a ton of really good reporting on this. It's just completely exploded in revenue since Susie Wiles was tapped as chief of staff. Uh, and so, you know, probably continue to be really strong, maybe not quite as strong as it was when Susie was chief of staff, but Susie still has influence in Trump world. She went, I think she went to, uh, MAGA Inc. They haven't I don't know if they've officially confirmed that. But I think that's the suspicion is that she's just going back to the PAC side to work on. I mean, they still have a lot of money.
Speaker 3So anyway, she's going to get richer.
Speaker 1And they're going to get richer. They're going to continue to get richer off of those connections. No question about it.
Speaker 3Very happy for everybody involved.
Speaker 1Yes, congratulations. Speaking of everyone involved being on the up and up, let's turn to news on the Jeffrey Epstein front.
Speaker 3Probably most people that are watching this already assume that Jeffrey Epstein was murdered in prison. The New York Times now considers that opinion fit to print, which by itself is quite fascinating. Michael Freeman is is a forensic scientist who was given access to autopsy photos and data by Mark Epstein, the surviving brother of Jeffrey Epstein. And we put up C2. According to this New York Times report, challenging consensus, scientist says photos show Epstein was killed. Interesting
Speaker 3kind of headline, challenging consensus. I think the consensus among the public is kind of the opposite. But the consensus in the New York Times world is that that is a crazy view. to hold. And so just the fact that the New York Times is willing to report this, I think, is itself newsworthy and suggests that we've, perhaps in the wake of the blue tsunami, we've kind of taken a turn on this story. But let's roll a little bit of his interview that was aired by the BBC. This is C1.
Speaker 4So you are saying that Epstein was killed by another person and he did not die by suicide.
Speaker 2I cannot think of a scenario in which he could have caused the spectrum of injuries that he has to him that are outside of the injuries that would be associated with the suicidal hanging that could have been self-inflicted other than if Epstein himself wanted to stage his suicide as a homicide. That is the one in, what, 1,000, 1 in 10,000 possibility. It's not something I've ever seen described in the world literature on hanging or strangulation. and it's not something that is very consistent with what's likely.
Speaker 4Can you describe what you think happened in that cell, what you believe happened in that cell?
Speaker 2I believe that the evidence is most consistent with an assault, a ligature strangulation from behind, and then most probably using that same ligature to suspend the body from the bunk bed.
Speaker 4That's quite an extraordinary claim to make. You're saying that someone else killed.
Speaker 2Him Well, what I'm saying as a certainty is he didn't get all of those injuries from self-inflicted hanging, that just the hanging alone cannot explain the injuries. And by a process of elimination, he didn't die from a natural cause. He didn't die from old age in his cell, and he didn't die from an accident. So the only option that we have is that he died as a result of a homicide.
Speaker 3So the Times and others published some photos. We're going to put up C3 just to give an indication of the types of evidence that he's looking at. I'm not a forensic scientist, so I'm not going to pretend that I am. But, you know, you look at that, you're like, it's kind of hard to see.
Speaker 1Yeah. These were released to him by Mark Epstein, the brother of Jeffrey Epstein. So he then just uploaded the pictures as well.
Speaker 3That's a thyroid bone that the forensic scientist was saying he's never seen a thyroid bone broken into three pieces in a suicide hanging.
Speaker 1He said the ligature marks on the neck, they're not consistent with where you would see in a hanging them going up at the back based on the motion of the body. Ryan, you can refresh our memories on this, but you've interviewed people who've been in that shoe, the special housing unit that Epstein was in when this happened and when conveniently the guards were not paying attention, those sorts of things. Uh, there are all kinds of inconsistencies with what should have happened versus what did happen that night.
Speaker 3Right there.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 3There's, um, and you know, the guards testimony was that, um, she was either kind of on her phone and like, and pretended to check the cell, but didn't actually, uh, check the cell may have, may or may not have been sleeping. Um, There's a little bit of missing footage. There's, you know, there's like, and how much footage is missing? You know, are there blind spots where people could have kind of moved in and out? So, yeah, this certainly
Speaker 3brings a kind of mainstream legitimacy to what a lot of people have kind of assumed. is the case now. There's certainly an argument that he was a billionaire who was a sex addict and a narcissist who was addicted to flattery and that the first people who were close to him told me that the first conviction was severely
Speaker 3damaging to him socially and he's a social creature and he After his conviction and spent time in prison for, you know, he whittled it down to like one child prostitution case.
Speaker 1Right.
Speaker 3After that, he was able to, with some effort, you know, build back his social and professional life. And so people were close to say, well, he understood that particularly at the height of this Me Too movement, that was done. Like there was no coming back from a second round of this, even if he got out of prison and that, that, that could have been enough to get him to end his life. His brother doesn't believe that, you know, his brother, uh, believes that he was the kind of person who his
Speaker 3entire life was in, was backed into various corners and always in a jam and always survived and always got out and always came out on top and always fought to get, always fought to get out and, and was going to fight again. until until according to his brother he was killed.
Speaker 1And you know obviously this is not a cornerstone of the broader theories about Jeffrey Epstein some of which are not actually even conspiracy theories anymore. I mean I recently went back and read the grand jury testimony where you have the FBI explaining how many girls they have talked to who have told them what was happening. I mean dozens of underage girls who have told them that. And then the comparison between what the grand jury heard and then what happens in the deal, it goes back to that time period, but it goes back even further per
Speaker 1your reporting on this, potentially to a Ron Contra era. So the suicide theory isn't a cornerstone of any of the broader things about Epstein, but what it does show is that it looks like the story, I mean, it doesn't look like, the story is completely suspicious. It's riddled with all kinds of coincidences at the time where you have somebody who's wrapped up in all of this, who's been reported to potentially be intelligence, dying under suspicious circumstances.
Speaker 1It's just another oddity in the life of Jeffrey Epstein that is enormously difficult for the public to believe is all part of a giant coincidence.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 3And most, like a lot of the public has moved on to, he's not even dead. He's in Brazil or he's in a basement in Ohio or Something, which has been an interesting evolution in kind of news reporting is that there's nothing we can report to people that matches what they already think is happening in the world. And so now if the New York Times is like, oh, he was killed, a bunch of people will be like, hmm,
Speaker 3This will only. This will confuse a lot of people and push them to think, wait a minute, if the New York Times is now willing to accept.
Speaker 1This, Well, say that Jeffrey Epstein had died under circumstances that were believable. Like, say the camera actually had been on the cell and recorded literally nobody coming in or out, and we could know with 95% confidence, you know, all of the autopsy lined up, independent autopsies lined up. You didn't have medical experts questioning it like we've seen here. Say that was all the case. You would still have an enormous trove of just awful.
Speaker 3awful.
Speaker 1Things in the life of Jeffrey Epstein and his associates.
Speaker 2Right.
Speaker 3Because driving someone to suicide is similar in some ways.
Speaker 1Exactly.
Speaker 3And has the same outcome as committing homicide.
Speaker 4Right.
Speaker 5Yeah.
Speaker 1So we'll obviously continue to follow the story because if you do, I mean, that's the thing with the prison quote suicide is that if you do accumulate enough evidence and that it was somebody else and the government is insisting the opposite, well, then that's just another giant smoking gun. So we'll obviously continue to follow the story.
Speaker 3And Thomas Massey continuing with his effort to force a vote on what's called the Epstein Files Transparency Act 2. And so Massey, and I talked to him last week about this, he basically wrote, he and Ro Khanna wrote the first one in a day. And they have some regrets about how it was drafted because there's no enforcement mechanism. They did not anticipate the attorney general simply disregarding the law.
Speaker 3And so now they've come forward with EFTA II, which would create a private right of action for victims who are in the files to sue for access and also for attorneys general around the country, like the state attorneys general. So they will then have access, particularly New Mexico, where his ranch is was a real center of the crime spree. And so that is getting close to, actually they have,
Speaker 3I think, 218. He told me last week they're at 218, so now they should be able to force a floor vote unless Speaker Johnson uses parliamentary maneuvers to keep it from happening and then adjourns until Democrats come back into Congress.
Speaker 1Mm-hmm. Yes. What's Hakeem Jeffries going to do about that?
Speaker 3I think Jeffries is going to go forward with it.
Speaker 1I mean, during the Trump administration, it's politically quite a tool for Democrats.
Speaker 3He's going to be under pressure not to, but he's going to be under pressure to do it. And so we'll see which pressure, you know. he feels.
Speaker 1It's an easy sort of pressure relief valve of all the tensions on you if you're Hakeem Jeffries and you can make this about the Trump administration. So that's good news for people who are looking to see that get momentum.
Speaker 3Yeah. Let's put up C5, quick update. The head of, the dean of the Harvard Kennedy School has put a working group together to try to, quote, contextualize the Wexner-Epstein ties because Leslie Wexner's name is still on a building there. They did a legal analysis. They said we can't take it off because of the sheer amount of money that Wexner gave. It looks like, according to this article, $ 142
Speaker 3million over four decades. It's a non-trivial amount of money. And the bad news for them is maybe nobody is more closely associated with Epstein and the rise of Epstein. than Wexner, who handed him power of attorney.
Speaker 1So bizarre.
Speaker 3Allowed him to basically kind of manage in significant ways the Wexner Foundation.
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3And allowed him also to use his connection to Victoria's Secret, Wexner, which Wexner owned, to aid his trafficking network because he would be able then to dangle... in front of trafficking victims, like, hey, I'm connected with Victoria's Secret, I'm connected with these pageants, I know all these different agents, so I can make your career, and that lures them into the network. So
Speaker 3we're contextualizing that for Harvard.
Speaker 5Seriously.
Speaker 1Seriously. And we should play this clip of Johnny McEntee, who is very, very close to Trump world, served in the first Trump administration, was ousted over gambling debts, and is now a lobbyist for all kinds of, I mean, he was a lobbyist for Tencent. I just was looking at a Politico influence report on that. He's an interesting character. He goes on Jack Neill's podcast and says this about Epstein.
Speaker 3Do you regret helping Kash Patel, in a way, get into his position?
Speaker 8No.
Speaker 5In fact, the first week of the administration, Kash Patel and Dan Bongino and others went to the White House and they said, we need to release the Epstein files right now. fully unredacted. And the person running the White House was a grandma who didn't understand that this was a big deal. So she said, no, we're not going to do that right now. We're going to redact it. We're going to take our time.
Speaker 1That's what happened.
Speaker 5We had a grandma running the White House.
Speaker 1And who's this?
Speaker 5This is the person that just got fired, Susie Wiles. She should be at home baking cookies with her grandkids, not running the White House. But for whatever reason, they thought that was a good idea. So these guys, they're hyper online.
Speaker 1They know the base.
Speaker 5They go and they say, well, we have to do this. She doesn't know that it's a big deal. She doesn't know anything about this.
Speaker 1She doesn't know anything about much. So that's where it's botched. People think, oh my God, they're hiding it for this.
Speaker 4Nope.
Speaker 1Grandma. Blame grandma.
Speaker 7Really?
Speaker 1Yeah.
Speaker 3You think it's as simple as that?
Speaker 1Yeah. Ryan, I don't think it's as simple as that because the president of the United States obviously put his thumb on the scale on this as well. And then Pam Bondi and the binders.
Speaker 3And Wiles is not some grandma either.
Speaker 1Oh my goodness. And he's probably so he would be in a position to know if Susie Wiles played a really big role in trying to obstruct transparency. And I actually don't doubt at all that Wiles is somebody who didn't understand how important the Epstein issue was, not actually just to the Trump base, but in general to the American public, which does care about this. So I don't totally discount that possibility that he's telling the truth, that Susie Wiles is. absolutely injected herself into this in a
Speaker 1way that downplayed the importance and missed the moment politically, didn't understand and influenced the president to not have a good grip on how important this was. I think that is entirely possible, but he's just said it's as simple as that. Well, no, it's not as simple as that because the president of the United States has Even since that interview with Rachel Campos Duffy when he was campaigning, the one thing that she asked him about that he was a little bit more reluctant to say he would release the files on was Jeffrey Epstein. Do you remember that?
Speaker 4Oh, yes.
Speaker 1When Rachel's going down the line, 9-11, JFK.
Speaker 3He's like, yep, yep, yep, yep.
Speaker 1Epstein, well, yeah.
Speaker 3I understand people want that.
Speaker 1Yeah, it was like, yeah, probably, something like that. And so it's the game of like the Cali means thing. With Callie Means, what he's trying to do is persuade the president that he was being misled by Susie Wiles. I don't know if that's what Johnny McEntee is doing, but of course, the effect of that is to offload blame from Trump, which, of course, Trump bears the blame because it was sincere. It appeared to be entirely sincere from Donald Trump that he thought, he said it himself.
Speaker 1He's like, are we still talking about the Epstein files? You heard it from his mouth.
Speaker 3Yeah, what are we doing? Still talking about Epstein.
The Friday gang digs into the growing support for Chris Van Hollen who is opposing Chuck Schumer in the Senate, Zohran Mamdani’s announcement to shut down Rikers Island, and are joined by guests, Jasper Nathaniel to...
Krystal and Saagar discuss Saagar debates Kalshi investor, Elon turns on MAGA, Anthropic launches IPO. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111 Gary Marcus: https://x.com/GaryMarcus To...
Krystal and Saagar discuss Jeffries wins the House speaker vote, Trump fumes at Vance over Iran, shoppers raid stores for doomsday supplies. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111...
Ryan and Emily discuss Jeffries already caving on Iran war funding, Navy Sec unhinged Senate testimony, BAAJA bill on verge of passing. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy: https://hamawyfornj.com/...
Krystal and Saagar discuss Nvidia says Jensen Huang is not coming back, AOC ex aide on how to avoid her mistakes, Emma Vigeland on Dem leadership fight. Emma Vigeland:...