Krystal and Saagar discuss Iran bombs U.S. bases, tech bros panic begging for Nvidia to take back Jensen. Derek Thompson: https://www.youtube.com/@PlainEnglishwithDerekThompson Don Leonard: https://donforohio.com/ To become a Breaking Points Premium Member and watch/listen to the show AD FREE, uncut and 1 hour early visit: www.breakingpoints.com Merch Store: https://shop.breakingpoints.com/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Had a busy day? Don't have time to listen to the show?
Speaker 2Catch up on Breaking Points with our free daily newsletter.
Speaker 3You'll get our breakdown of every daily story.
Speaker 2And lots of links in your inbox every day.
Speaker 3So head over to BreakingPoints.com. You can sign up for the newsletter at the top for free today. Turning now to Iran, there are some very troubling signs, which nobody in the mainstream media or apparently even the oil markets are paying nearly enough.
Speaker 2Attention to.
Speaker 3Let's put this up here on the screen. First, this is always one of the most important signs to watch is that the USS Theodore Roosevelt will now join two other aircraft carriers in the Middle East within the next day. This is the first time since the Iraq war that the United States will have three carriers in the Middle East. So let's actually talk about why this is so important. For the entire Trump administration, leaks and rhetoric have basically mean nothing whenever it comes to military action. What has
Speaker 3been predictive every single time, Venezuela, Iran, Iran the second time, Iran the first time, was the amount of naval and U.S. military assets that are in the region. Now, why is this so significant? Number one, it's because all of our bases are destroyed, which means you need more of these aircraft carriers and these carrier strike groups to be around to provide the firepower if you do get into kinetic action. Second, This is the other thing which is the most important, is that the aircraft carriers themselves mean that you can
Speaker 3keep prolonged military operations going because the carriers that were already there clearly are being strained to the brink by having to run this convoy system and the blockade, which has now been going on for months. And so this is a sign that at the very least, the blockade will be going on for a very, very long time. And number two, that the options remain available for a renewed strike campaign, which Trump has promised is not happening. But signs are still very, very different behind the scenes because, again,
Speaker 3these are things which usually would have led the news and let our show in the past are now going completely unnoticed by oil markets and others. Let's cut D2, for example, up here on the screen. You would be forgiven if you had not heard. Iran targeted the U.S. military yesterday with a drone attack at the base in Bahrain. That is the second attempt to target the country in just three days. The IRGC said it targeted air defense radar facility at the Al-Rafa airfare base in Bahrain using
Speaker 3six separate drones. It comes after Iran fired similar drones on Bahrain on Friday, first attack against the Gulf countries since September 2020. And so what is this a retaliation for? It's for the blockade. You had sirens that were sounding across Bahrain. You had the condemnation and all of that. And then even more importantly, I think, is that you also saw the United States yesterday also bomb Iran. Again, very, very underreported by most people in the media. What you
Speaker 3are watching is the similar tit for tat problem that we saw before the midterms, except this time. The oil markets, I just checked, the Brent crude price is like around $ 95 per barrel. They seem to believe, perhaps correctly, although I'm not so sure, that the midterm results will provide a check against Trump to continue the war. But ultimately, this is a physical commodity that we are dealing with. The blockade is on. The amount of barrels coming out of the Strait of Hormuz obviously are not even close to where things were, even if they do eventually or
Speaker 3sometimes reach Hormuz. Those levels, there's a $ 30 or $ 40 per barrel premium coming on from the cost of the shuttle transfer and all of the other insanity that's going on in the region. This is a very dangerous situation, and Trump is not blinking. He is not accepting that he completely lost this war. If anything, this carrier strike group being deployed to the– or the third carrier now deployed to the region– and the fact that we were bombing bases, that they're bombing us right back in some sort of tit for tat. These are actually more hostilities
Speaker 3than we saw in the entire month of November. I just want to be very clear for where things stand as of right now and for the options that Trump now faces going into, I guess, the next two years of his presidency.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, I mean, we're in this sort of weird status quo that I think Trump is hoping is sustainable, and I'm not sure that it actually is. Because to your point, you know, we're very practiced now as a country at fighting wars that we push out of the public sight and put on the back burner because it's too painful to end the war, but it's also too painful to, you know, fully execute the war. And I'm glad that that's the case. And so they just try to, okay, well,
Speaker 2let's just put this on the, back burner and put it out of American consciousness so that they forget that we're doing all of this and we don't pay a political price. That has been the logic of endless war. That's how you end up in Afghanistan for 20 plus years, for example. This one may be a little different because first of all, as long as the blockade is on, Iran considers that an act of war because it is an act of war. And so they're not just going to stand quietly by and allow this status quo to unfold. You also have a lot that is unfolding in Israel
Speaker 2right now. We'll probably do a full block on this tomorrow, but Netanyahu is now being accused of election rigging. I don't know if you guys remember, right after their most recent elections, he came out and said that the Arab parties had rigged the results Now there's all sorts of information coming out that perhaps he actually, coming directly from his office, sent fake information to the police to arrest these Arab party-affiliated individuals. There's a whole thing going on there, and there's allegations. coming from before the election, that Netanyahu
Speaker 2was trying to precipitate some sort of crisis with Iran to justify retaliation and go back to a hot war with Iran. And we know how successful the Israelis have been in dragging us into war with Iran. Again, this is not to deny any agency from Trump, but they were clearly pushing the case and Trump eventually accepted it. So there's that piece going on as well. And then the other part is, You know, with Afghanistan, because of the nature of our military and that it's a tiny percentage of the population that actually serves, mostly working class
Speaker 2men and women, the pain of that was shouldered by a relatively small group of people. Well, the pain of increased gas prices and diesel prices and everything else prices is shouldered by the entire country. So if this is the new status quo, it is one that the American people absolutely loathe, hate and rejected in every way that they possibly could in November and are going to continue to hate, loathe and reject. So it is a very different situation than some of the other recent forever wars
Speaker 2that presidents were able to just sort of successfully place on the back burner.
Speaker 3Yeah, but man, this is so funny. While you were talking, Trump has now come out. With a response to 60 minutes of which will play here in a second. And but this is the level of delusion that we are now dealing with. Let's go ahead and put this up here on the screen, guys. We'll add it in posts. And by the way, this was reposted by Pete Hegseth. The new people running 60 minutes are worse than their predecessors since February 28th. Listen to this. This is like China numbers. or sorry, Syria election numbers. The start of
Speaker 3epic fury. Iran has fired 8,000 to 9,000 one-way attack drones. Only two of them got through, resulting in U.S. fatalities, both on the first day. Likewise, Iran has fired 2,000 ballistic missiles. Only one of those 2,000 got through and caused fatalities. Translation, 99.99%. of Iranian missiles and drones have been shot down or in any event not cause U.S.
Speaker 1Deaths.
Speaker 3So first of all, they're juking the numbers there. They're trying to define there about U.S. deaths. But second, even if you take it, you know, and try to interpret it, 99.99%, like, can you watch a video, man? Like literally of, or can you watch a video just of any of the random day during the war when you saw drones and missiles that were striking and making impact? Can we look at the billions of dollars of damage that have done to the bases?
Speaker 2This is the reality. Did we blow up our own bases? Like, how do you account for the fact that our entire presence in the region has been destroyed and decimated? And CBS revealed even more photos and videos and images of how extensive that devastation ultimately was.
Speaker 1Exactly.
Speaker 3And that's why this level of dilution. See, this is why, man, I'm sorry to be sick last week. I had so much to say about this Pete Hegseth thing. I mean, first of all, these people who were detained in traffic, like, really? But, you know, the other the other part of it is it shows you how the Trump and Hegseth now they have they are rats. Literally, they're literally like on this sinking ship. Right. And they have to drag each other down. And the thing is, is that the two are now linked intimately over the decision to go to war with Iran.
Speaker 3They will drag everybody else down with them because this is their legacy, their creation. This is everything. And so by both defending Hegseth against alleged impeachment or impeachment for going to war with Iran, but also in the constant defense of the war, they have to continue to articulate this straight up bullshit like 99.99% of our drones and our missiles were shot down. It's preposterous. And to show you how far they're willing to go, They're willing to torch negotiations and also J.D. Vance's political career. So over Friday,
Speaker 3let's take a listen. Or sorry, let's put this up here on the screen. Very noteworthy post here from Donald Trump. He says, I have asked Vice President Vance to focus his complete and total attention to the massive corruption. and crime taking place in Democrat cities, blah, blah, blah. Where he says at the end of the day, though, he says, we don't need a deal with Iran. Those days have long passed. We've got their money, hundreds of billions of dollars. We've got the strait. Thank you for your attention to this matter. You could read that in a different way, which is I have told J.D. to stop trying to
Speaker 3pursue a deal with the Iranians. And this was perhaps the one thing J.D. could have done to save his potential political future. And in fact, let's go to CNN. There's some very noteworthy quotes in this story. The headline that they say is once presumed Trump's air advances wrestling with this political future. I don't think that's true. I think he's going to run. But the question down at the bottom is about Trump's support and the vice that Trump kind of holds him in, where they specifically say that Trump, though publicly has not said anything truly negative
Speaker 3about J.D. 's post-midterm analysis about how the war cost him the election, privately has complained about it. And as he has showed us on camera, he's knifed him by saying the one thing he should have said is that it was a historic decision. So he's taking them off. any sort of negotiation or peace deal, or at least trying to publicly signal that he's publicly or privately annoyed that he admitted the most obvious truth on earth, that is the war. And yet by defending Pete Hegseth and by continuing to defend the war, this is the one
Speaker 3thing he knows not only will be remembered for, but which he must defend forever. And the legacy of that, I mean, not only just politically devastating, it's really bad for the country because again, I think the oil markets are in total denial they truly, I mean, remember, in the past, they would have reacted to this very, very differently. They also saw that you just are not, they also show us, like, you are not seeing any seriousness move on the diplomatic front, which means things only trend in one direction, more escalation in war. Yes, not necessarily tomorrow,
Speaker 3but you have Iran coming out and bombing U.S. bases and they've made it clear we're not just going to sit here. We're not going to take it. And now they've got a bunch of Democrats in the U.S. Senate who are going to respond if things can continue badly, which would put political pressure on Trump as additional to the economic pressure right now.
Speaker 2Yeah, no, it's an ugly situation. And for Trump with J.D. Vance, he doesn't care that potentially taking J.D. Vance off the negotiations is going to hinder the negotiations. He is just pissed off that his ego was bruised by this post that J.D. Vance put out. And for J.D. Vance, he feels like, oh, I took all this political risk to put this post out to signal that the Iran war is a problem. People should reward me for this, right? No,
Speaker 2they're not going to. You're the vice president. Like, you own this. There's no ability to run away from that or Trump's corruption or ICE murdering people on the streets or any of the many other things that have been done with your name right there, the Trump-Vance administration. There is going to be no ability to say I had nothing to do with any of this and I'll be completely different if I get ultimately elected. So, you know, I don't know if I buy all of this, like, oh, he may not run at all. That's hard for me to see because how— It would take something extraordinary for
Speaker 2him to mount a political comeback after all of this. You if you were vice president and you don't run for president, then what is the likelihood that then eight, 12, 16 years down the road, people come back around and say, you know, it was great that Trump Vance administration. Let's bring that guy in to be president of the United States. No, it's now or never. And I think he's smart enough to recognize that. So I'm very skeptical of some of these reports that, oh, like he may not even run because things are so dire for Republicans. They are pretty dire for Republicans. But, you know, if you end up
Speaker 2as one of the two major party nominees, you got a shot. That's just the way that American politics work. Another couple quick things here. Let's put D6 up on the screen. Just more information about that. how everything we've been fed from Trump and Hegseth and all the rest about how Iran is devastated, blah, blah, blah, continues to be false. The US's, our own estimates, say that Iran has still up to 2,500 missiles, Although it's hard to know exactly, but they certainly maintain significant capacity. And then
Speaker 2the last piece here, let's put D7 up on the screen. 60 Minutes did a devastating piece yesterday with some of the spouses of service members who were killed. And this comes on the heels of this reporting from The Atlantic, where they say that the Pentagon ignored a warning about the danger of Iran's drones. So, look, the U.S. had a bit of a warm-up for this with watching what unfolded in the Ukraine-Russia war and also being involved quite relatively directly in what's going on with the Russia-Ukraine war.
Speaker 2Ukraine has been dealing with these Shahid drones, and they have developed technology that actually does quite effectively deal with these Shahid drones and relatively inexpensively. So you don't have to use these multimillion-dollar interceptors and fire a bunch of them just to take down one drone. So we apparently knew this technology existed, was aware of how important it has been for Ukraine, but for whatever reason, chose not to adopt it, leaving our own service members and our
Speaker 2own facilities as well, which is part of the destruction throughout the region of our own bases and positions. We chose not to adopt this technology. Don't really know why, but that is where things stand. And just the level of incompetence arrogance, hubris, lack of planning, going back to the beginning, Trump's belief that this would be over in a few days. What do you need this technology for? We're going to blow them all off the face of the map and murder their leadership before they even have a chance to respond. And the whole thing is going to be all over. I mean, it really comes back
Speaker 2to that foolish level of arrogance and hubris that was displayed from the beginning.
Speaker 3I encourage people to read this story. You know, I got my lot of criticisms of Ukrainians, et cetera, you know, and all of that. But I mean, you can't deny that they've literally been sitting there taking tons of casualties on drones. Right. And so if there's going to be one thing that we get that we get out of it, everything they tell me, well, we got to fight the Russians over there so we don't fight them over here. That's what they keep telling me. And so that's why we need to put all these hundreds of billions of dollars. OK, let's take the technology that we literally paid for and then let's have some of it. And yet, you know, they report that to this day, there is still not
Speaker 3any of the Ukrainian anti-drone technology, which is in any of the U.S.
Speaker 1Bases.
Speaker 3How crazy is that? And do you remember how Dan Driscoll was forced out as army secretary? He was one of the chief proponents of this anti-drone warfare. And he was kicked out of the Pentagon for kind of questioning the Pete Hegseth regime. You also apparently you had 13000 of these interceptors to the Middle East, which were shipped in the immediate days after the war, even though they were denied in the lead up. But they only shot down one drone because the host countries and the military were not fast enough to approve them. So you could
Speaker 3just see the amount of hubris and the arrogance that went into all of this. And then the final thing, really, just to mention here about the Iranians, again, D6, let's put it up here. The U.S. intelligence community now, leaking through the Wall Street Journal, has currently got the number around 2,500 ballistic missiles. Quote, the reconstitution of Tehran's missile stockpile has now factored into Trump's discussion about whether even to resume strikes. Between 1,500 and 25 missiles are in the arsenal. Quote, officials said it was clear Iran maintained
Speaker 3a formidable stockpile. Remember- When the original war ceasefire was announced, they claimed that over 90% of the missiles had all been destroyed. So let's just remember that. Similarly, they say that they have rebuilt their arsenal, perhaps slower than where they were before, but all from stockpiled opponents, and they have many drones and short-range missiles all at their disposal. Quote, Israeli military officials concur with this assessment. And so you've got the two principal actors in the war, which have not destroyed the regime, where they still have missiles and
Speaker 3they still have significant ability to inflict major damage and pain on the global energy markets and really on the entire United States, on the Strait of Hormuz. And this can be going on for a long, long time. And this is one of those forever wars which you can't really forget, like with Afghanistan. Because this time the currency is literally yours that you have to keep putting at the pump. And, you know, it's the Iranians are smart. They know they've digested the midterm election results. They've seen
Speaker 3what a dramatic impact that their strategy had on the U.S. political system. Perhaps the one thing they didn't bargain for is that Trump doesn't care about that at all. And so, you know, that's actually more dangerous for all of us because it could mean even more sustained attacks, not just on our bases, perhaps cyber attacks and others. to inflict even more pain on the United States and its population.
Speaker 2Yep, that's exactly right. All right, well, there's another massive global story unfolding with regard to Jensen Huang and moves being made just this morning. Commerce Department creating new rules to try to close this export loophole. Let's go ahead and bring in Derek Thompson to talk about the latest. Joining us now to talk about the very latest with regards to NVIDIA and Jensen Huang and all of the various related things that are going on with this story is Derek Thompson. He is host of the Plain English podcast and also a contributing writer over at The Atlantic.
Speaker 2Welcome back, Derek.
Speaker 1Good to be back. Thank you very much.
Speaker 2Yeah, of course. So I don't even know where to start with this, but I think of the many places I could begin. I'll start with this effort underway to, among a lot of the other tech oligarchs, to support Jensen Huang's potential return to Nvidia. We had a story in the Financial Times also saying that Jensen was talking to his allies about the possibility of this. Trump was just asked about what he thought of whether Jensen should be brought back as CEO. Let's go ahead and take a listen to that.
Speaker 4I think having Jensen go back, a lot of people are asking Jensen, they think Jensen should go back. That certainly isn't a bad idea. I recommended Tim Cook, who, as you know, built Apple. I recommended Tim Cook to go and do a job.
Speaker 2So, Derek, what do you make of this? Do you think that this is a live possibility? Personally, you took note that Trump didn't, like, jump on this idea and say absolutely and give, like, a full-throated endorsement. But what do you think here?
Speaker 1Let me make two points. First, if Jensen Wong... resigns and then is brought back to become the chief executive at NVIDIA. That will mean that in the span of three years, the two most famous CEOs in all of AI, Sam Altman and Jensen Wong, will have both been de facto fired and then both been reinstated. And then the reinstatements will, of course, have to force the board to resolve. This never happens like in basically any other industry where like CEOs are fired and then brought back. So if
Speaker 1this does happen, I think it's going to raise major, major questions about corporate governance in AI. If you have all these boards that are trying to fire their CEOs, and the CEOs are like, no, I'm sorry, I'm actually a monarch. There's no corporate governance here. I do whatever I want to do. And then they remake the board. So if that does happen, we are in totally uncharted waters when it comes to the relationship between chief executives and the boards of directors who are supposed to stand over those chief executives and help to manage fiduciary duty and corporate governance. So that's the first point. The second point is, Democrats are about to have full control of
Speaker 1Congress and congressional investigations are coming. And if Jensen Wang is reinstated in NVIDIA, that will mean that the CEO of NVIDIA is going to have to answer some unbelievably embarrassing questions, such as why were you, a Taiwanese American, sleeping with a Chinese national. China, of course, wants to swallow up Taiwan entirely, who also was running an intermediary that was illegally smuggling chips to China that also might have been working with the state spy agency of China
Speaker 1at the same time. That is fantastically embarrassing, number one. Number two, as the New York Times reported, The general counsel of NVIDIA appears to have contacted the Commerce Department when they were investigating Megaspeed's relationship between the Chinese chips that were coming in, excuse me, the NVIDIA chips that were coming in and the Chinese chips, the chips that China was essentially taking out. which is itself unbelievably inappropriate. I mean, the chief counsel of companies are not supposed to contact FBI, DOJ, you know, commerce investigators and say, hey,
Speaker 1can you like slow down this investigation to my company, please? And thank you. So if Jensen's back, it's going to be absolute popcorn theater for these congressional investigations in the next few months.
Speaker 3You know, and that's one of the things that's really frustrated me, Derek. I'm glad that you hit on that here is everyone's like, oh, this is about affairs. And like, yeah, to a certain extent it is. You didn't even mention, by the way, that he is literally having an affair with a married subordinate of his and then using his private security as mafia goons going around asking people who are taking pictures of them canoodling at a company event and asking them to sign an NDA. As an NVIDIA shareholder, I guess I was literally paying for that. So that's a really good use of my dollars. You know, the
Speaker 3other thing I did want to get your reaction to, though, is this new revelation from the Wall Street Journal. Let's put E2 up here on the screen. The key line in this new Wall Street Journal investigation is that records seen show Megaspeed have arranged to send nearly $ 12 billion worth of the top of the line NVIDIA chips to companies in China between 2024 and June of 2025. NVIDIA previously had said it worked to prevent smuggling. That $ 12 billion figure is much larger than we previously knew. I
Speaker 3believe the number previously floated had been around $ 4 billion, so almost triple what we see. It does validate some of the short-seller claims from Culper Research, where he believed that some 20% of NVIDIA's business was illegally circumventing via these types of companies to China. So the affair scandal appears, again, just my view, curious for yours, I've kind of ripped the Band-Aid off of what is a pretty obvious, at the very least, financial fraud in violation of U.S. export law.
Speaker 3Curious for your view.
Speaker 1Well, of course, my view is that you're absolutely right. This is illegal. And I want to be clear, given what we've learned from The New York Times, from The Wall Street Journal, from The Financial Times, it does not seem outlandish to wonder if the largest AI company in the world, NVIDIA, was working hand in glove with the Trump administration to smuggle chips into China, oversee the smuggling of chips illegally into China, and turn a blind eye to the illegal smuggling of chips into China at the
Speaker 1same time that the laws on the books exist to keep the most advanced AI chips from Chinese companies precisely because we believe ourselves to be in a race against the Chinese to develop advanced AI faster than they are. Now, there's a huge debate. And if you want me, as I did recently in my podcast, to sort of play NVIDIA defense attorney and explain to you what I think that company thinks they're up to, I'm happy to do that. But the laws on the books exist, including the diffusion rule passed in 2022 under the Biden administration. exist to
Speaker 1stop this from happening. It is illegal according to the law to have chips either smuggled into China or to have China use remote access to use chips that exist in say Singaporean or Malaysian data centers. Both of these things seem to have been happening. The Trump administration seems to have understood that they were happening and was doing nothing about it. So this for now does seem to be, and I am the last person in the world who believes in conspiracy theories, but this seems to be very, very close to a corporate government conspiracy to violate the
Speaker 1letter of and spirit of the law in order to help NVIDIA get richer by expanding the market of global chip sales to include China rather than, as the law suggests, exclude China because we're racing against it.
Speaker 4Yeah.
Speaker 2And by the way, there's news this morning that Indonesian police went to the Jakarta headquarters of Megaspeed. They found empty server racks and no evidence of the NVIDIA chips that they were supposed to have. So again, you know, a lot of indications here that this was a massive smuggling ring to the tune of billions of dollars that at the very, very, very least NVIDIA was turning a blind eye to. And that gets me to, Derek, why I'm skeptical that they could bring Jensen back. I'm sure
Speaker 2they didn't want to really get rid of Jensen. I'm sure that their hand was completely forced because this board's very friendly. to him, but they felt they had no choice. And I'm wondering if part of that is because when you get rid of Jensen, you can say, oh, well, he was a singular figure. It's all on him. Now we're doing something different. However, we also have reporting about how they changed their accounting practices to cover up the amount of their revenue that was coming from entities in Singapore. So there's a lot of questions here about who knew
Speaker 2what within NVIDIA. And I have my doubts. It's just Jensen. So it sort of solves a problem for them if they can just be like, oh, it's just this guy we're moving forward. If you bring him back, then you have to scrutinize the entire company and say what the hell is going on here.
Speaker 1There's something you said that I think is really, really important to put some numbers to. That something happened in Singapore that NVIDIA seems to have identified in their corporate accounting and then stopped identifying. So here's the numbers that we know from NVIDIA 10Ks, their corporate accounting statement at the end of the year. Between the fiscal year of 2023 and the fiscal year of 2025, which essentially overlaps with what we understand to be the beginning of Jensen's relationship with Alice Wong, the managing director of Megaspeed. NVIDIA
Speaker 1revenue booked through Singapore increased from $ 2. 3 billion to $ 23 billion. It increased by a factor of 10%. in three years and then Nvidia stopped breaking out its Singapore specific accounting. Now that's just one data point. And there could of course be many legal explanations for that data point. But we're looking at a situation where, and I think the next two things that come out of my mouth are objective facts. Singapore Nvidia revenue increased by a factor of
Speaker 110 in the exact same years when Jensen Wong began a romantic affair with the managing director of Megaspeed, a Singaporean data center company that buys Nvidia chips and does not seem to be very careful about making sure that those Nvidia chips stay out of Chinese hands. We now have initial information that they were overseeing both direct smuggling of chips, the hardware being moved into China, and illegal or extra-legal remote access where, for example, Chinese companies that
Speaker 1weren't supposed to use NVIDIA chips owned by Megaspeed that were situated in, say, Malaysia data centers being used essentially to power these Chinese companies that we didn't want them to power so that they could develop really advanced AI that could rival entropic and open AI. This is unbelievably sketchy. We haven't even gotten into some of the most interesting data or interesting Details come out of the New York Times, Wall Street Journal, Financial Times reporting that suggests that at some point, at one point, Megaspeed didn't seem to have more than a couple dozen employees on LinkedIn. That if
Speaker 1you visit their offices in Singapore, there seems to be no one there. Like, you don't want this company to look like a shell through which Nvidia chips pass into China. But when you talk about an empty corporate headquarters, that's literally a shell. So there is a lot there. There are a lot of very, very obvious questions that congressional investigators are going to ask this company. And I agree with you, Crystal and Sagar, that I think that one major reason why Jensen can't come back is that the level of either illegality or blind eye paid to the
Speaker 1illegality happening between NVIDIA and Megaspeed is going to be too obvious for them to keep Jensen Wong at the head of this company.
Speaker 3The other thing we haven't even mentioned here is the government angle. So you went through the finances, which Scott Besson had touched on. But another remarkable moment is where he basically direct, it goes after the Secretary Lutnick, the Secretary of Commerce here, where, you know, Larry Kudlow asked him about these export restrictions, which were supposed to have been approved, or the export restrictions, the investigation, how it got kicked away. The whole of government was ready to go, except for the Commerce Department. They apparently quashed it. And here was Scott Besson's response, E4, let's take a listen.
Speaker 5It doesn't matter to me whether she's a spy or not. Jensen's foibles are his foibles. Obviously, it's a problem if, in fact, he was having relationships with subordinates. And I know and every director knows that's a corporate no-no. But again, I want to keep coming back to what was the culture at NVIDIA and were they pressing these subordinates seemingly
Speaker 5illicit sales to goose their revenues and their earnings. And I think we need answers in the next 10 days from the board and from the outside counsel.
Speaker 3Yeah. So I'll leave it to them, but I do agree with you.
Speaker 1Uh, I think that's got best in saying, uh, Howard Lutnick has been hoisted by his own petard and I'm going to leave him to clean up the mess that he started. I mean, the layers here are unbelievable. We have the commerce department, which is overseen by, uh, Howard Lutnick, uh, whose sons, um, operate Canada Fitzgerald, which itself operates.
Speaker 3We could put E5 up here while you're talking.
Speaker 1Sure, yeah, operate status centers in Southeast Asia that now we believe to be smuggling chips or allowing remote access for Chinese companies illegally or extra legally. There's that angle. So Howard Lutnick and the Lutnick family might be directly benefiting from a scheme that runs counter to American law. But we also have the fact that investigators at the Commerce Department spent months investigating Megaspeed for suspected smuggling of immediate chips into China. They were contacted by an Nvidia lawyer, the top lawyer at Nvidia, and then that investigation was
Speaker 1transferred to the Justice Department. Now, why is that story itself so sketchy? I talked to Ben Buchanan, who worked on AI for the Biden administration. He told me that despite all of the security access that he had in the Biden administration overseeing AI policy, He could not either directly contact these Commerce Department investigators if they were investigating something AI, didn't even know what they were working on, that the firewall was so high and so thick between the AI experts at the Biden administration and the investigators
Speaker 1at the Commerce Department that the idea that they're contacting each other in order to influence investigations was completely verboten to him. Here, we're not talking about the Biden administration contacting investigators at the Commerce Department. We're talking about NVIDIA contacting the investigators, the Commerce Department, about an investigation into NVIDIA. This is unbelievable levels of cosmic sketchiness that, again, I think a congressional investigation is going to lead to explosive headline after explosive headline in a way that is just
Speaker 1going to make it very difficult for maybe Howard Lutton to keep his job, but certainly, I think, for Jensen Wong to come back and lead NVIDIA.
Speaker 2Yeah. And, you know, in a sense, like I think you're identifying the most crucial issues here, which are about corruption. What was the government doing? Who had an interest in all of this? And then the criminality, the potential criminality of a mass smuggling ring and whether or not our government was effectively sort of greasing skids for that smuggling ring against our own laws. In a sense, I feel like the spy narrative is kind of a distraction from the most crucial points. Not that it's not important, but that's been called into question. OK, maybe our intelligence agencies
Speaker 2aren't certain what her affiliation with China is. But you have this potential criminality, which to me is really where a lot of the focus should be. Markets are sliding this morning. I want to talk to you, Derek, a little bit about what the broader impact is likely to be. You know, we've all seen the chart of NVIDIA at the center of all of the AI financing, some of it circular, you know, but they're connected to every significant entity in the space. And a lot of not that significant entities in the space, they've effectively acted like the
Speaker 2bank of AI. So and a lot of this has come directly from Jensen. There's reporting now. that the CFO, who is now the interim CEO, has been uncomfortable with some of the loans, some of the circular financing schemes, some of what he has been ultimately up to here. So what does this mean more broadly for AI investments in the entire ecosystem?
Speaker 1So let me begin by answering that in a way that I think might surprise you, some listeners. I don't think this has much to do with the question of whether AI is a bubble. The question of whether AI is a bubble is about whether or not the investments to make AI available to consumers are met by sufficient demand among consumers to spend for AI. The most important question for whether or not AI is a bubble is not who is the chief executive in NVIDIA. The most
Speaker 1important question is how big is the demand for artificial intelligence? And that's a question for the tech companies in America and throughout the world that are buying AI. It's a question for the banks that are buying AI and using APIs for tokens. It's a question about demand. And this is an incredibly interesting story that touches on so many things, but it's not fundamentally about the fundamental question of the AI bubble, which is, is the demand rising fast enough? So I want to separate the question of why does the story matter so much with the question of, is it a bubble? Why it matters so much goes to,
Speaker 1you set this up well, Crystal, like, NVIDIA was doing something really interesting with this circular financing. And just to get a little bit technical, it wasn't as silly or as stupid as me giving children $ 10 that they give me $ 10 to buy lemonade for my lemonade stand, right? That would not increase economic activity at all. I'm basically out $ 0 because I've given the $ 10 that I've been given back. what Jensen Wong was trying to do was a little bit more akin to a loan guarantee. So
Speaker 1for example, if you're trying to get a mortgage for, let's say a million dollar mortgage, just to make it a nice round number, And the bank looks at your finances and says, God, your finances don't look so good. We're going to charge you like 9%, 10% for this loan. And then you find a rich friend. And that rich friend says, I promise that I'll pay back the first $ 800, 000 of that loan. And the bank looks at that guarantee and says, oh, rather than a 10% mortgage, we'll give you a 6% mortgage. And now you can buy
Speaker 1a house. The same thing can work with companies. If a company, like a neo-cloud company, which is building data centers, wants to get a loan or is looking to create some business partners, and those business partners see this new company as being quite risky, then they might not do business. But if they know that NVIDIA is backstopping them with certain guarantees, and they might say, oh, okay, we'll do business with you. We know that you're backed by NVIDIA, which is worth $ 4 or $ 5 trillion. So the circular financing scheme was a little bit more similar to those kind of loan guarantees than it was a simple, here's $ 10,
Speaker 1you know, Betty, give me $ 10 and buy my cookies. So it looks like I've sold $ 10 worth of cookies. It wasn't that simplistic. But to this point, what happens now that the circular financing scheme is no longer in place? It's essentially that all of these startups that relied on the backing of NVIDIA can no longer rely on the backing of NVIDIA now that the CFO is in charge and the company is going to look to protect its earnings at a time that its market cap has declined by more than $ 1 trillion. So the analysts that I've read and spoken to say that the thing that's going
Speaker 1to most likely change is that while the big guys in AI might not suffer so much, your alphabets and maybe anthropics, a lot of these smaller companies, the neoclouds, some of the AI startups that are being invested in by the Andreessen Horowitz of the world, they might struggle in the short term because they lose the central banker of AI, which has been NVIDIA. And so that's where I'm looking at in terms of how is the ecosystem going to change now that NVIDIA is wobbling.
Speaker 3Great point, Derek. You know, I saw some similar analysis as well out there today, just about Jensen. And just a reminder of Elon Musk. in his bid to get Jensen back. He's like, a lot of these were handshake deals. They weren't even on paper.
Speaker 1It was just Jensen.
Speaker 3We're like, yeah, that seems kind of a problem there, don't you think? For the company and for going forward. Very thoughtful as always, man. We appreciate it. Plain English Podcast, your sub stack as well. Links down in the description. Thank you for joining us.
Speaker 1Good to see you both. Thank you guys so much for watching.
Speaker 3We appreciate it. We'll have a great show for everybody tomorrow.
The Friday gang digs into the growing support for Chris Van Hollen who is opposing Chuck Schumer in the Senate, Zohran Mamdani’s announcement to shut down Rikers Island, and are joined by guests, Jasper Nathaniel to...
Krystal and Saagar discuss Saagar debates Kalshi investor, Elon turns on MAGA, Anthropic launches IPO. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111 Gary Marcus: https://x.com/GaryMarcus To...
Krystal and Saagar discuss Jeffries wins the House speaker vote, Trump fumes at Vance over Iran, shoppers raid stores for doomsday supplies. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111...
Ryan and Emily discuss Jeffries already caving on Iran war funding, Navy Sec unhinged Senate testimony, BAAJA bill on verge of passing. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy: https://hamawyfornj.com/...
Ryan and Emily discuss stocks plunge amid more outages, Jensen begs for Nvidia job back, NYT flips on Epstein as expert says he was murdered. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy:...