Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar

Breaking Points with Krystal and Saagar artwork

11/10/26: Jensen Huang Scandal Explodes, Culture War Dead As Kansas Flips Blue, Tech Oligarchs Lies Exposed

Nov 10, 202644 minAudio
  • Apple Podcasts
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Krystal and Saagar discuss Trump promises to save Jensen Huang, culture war dead as Kansas goes blue, tech oligarchs lies exposed. Chuck Rocha: https://x.com/ChuckRocha?lang=en Thomas Frank: https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/743572/the-creativity-con-by-thomas-frank/ To become a Breaking Points Premium Member and watch/listen to the show AD FREE, uncut and 1 hour early visit: www.breakingpoints.com Merch Store: https://shop.breakingpoints.com/

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Speaker 1Had a busy day? Don't have time to listen to the show?

Speaker 2Catch up on Breaking Points with our free daily newsletter.

Speaker 1You'll get our breakdown of every daily story.

Speaker 2And lots of links in your inbox every day.

Speaker 1So head over to BreakingPoints.com. You can sign up for the newsletter at the top for free today. All right, turning now to Jensen Wong. Many of you might have heard of this as a sex scandal, but we have the details. And this is not just a sex scandal. This is actually a massive corporate scandal. and corruption scandal. So ironically, thanks to Jensen's own chips, I was able to use Claude to put all of the details together for you guys. Let's put it up here on the screen. So here we have by the numbers, basically, and even

Speaker 1this number is currently in dispute. There have been $ 4. 8 billion worth of NVIDIA chips that have been bought by this company called Megaspeed. Megaseed is a Singaporean Chinese state-backed company cutout, which was run by Alice Wong, who is the alleged affair partner. of Jensen Wang. She used her proximity with Jensen, and Jensen used her to purchase billions of dollars worth of chips for this data center and for this company, which specifically was circumventing U.S. sanctions. That's

Speaker 1the core scandal here. There have been over $ 2. 5 billion in server purchases that have been cited by the Department of Justice and involving a company called Supermicro, which is genuinely about diversion to China, explicit illegal violation of the law, which is linked to Megaspeed. Literally over a year ago, October of 2025, the New York Times reports U.S. intelligence has been monitoring this woman, Alice Wong, who was pictured in 2024 with Jensen Wong basically kissing and hugging in

Speaker 1July of 2024. in Taipei. And then finally, only recently in November, have three Republican House chairs requested for a closed door briefing with Jensen. So we put together this timeline. Let's go to the next one. Again, just to summarize the real scandal here is that in April of 2025, the US restricted NVIDIA's H20 chips to China. NVIDIA later says that its China business went to zero. This was a lie. Jensen and Alice Wong in May of 2025 died again in Taipei. That month, he says there is

Speaker 1no evidence of any chip diversion. Then the Times reports that the U.S. intelligence monitored Alice Wong, found contact with Jensen, briefed Trump again over a year ago. And then this is the real kicker. What happened is that in October 2025, around when this article comes out, is that the Commerce Department, which is investigating Nvidia, diverting trip-chip-chips to China, specifically to this company called Megaspeed, which is run by Jensen's now-admitted girlfriend, Basically,

Speaker 1they say that they have found no Chinese ownership or chip diversion. But the critical part is that they email Crystal, the Commerce Department investigators, the nonpartisan investigators who are looking into this company, and they name drop their boss, who is a Trump appointee who works for Howard Lutnick. And obviously, what hovers over all of this is that Trump has been Jensen's biggest cheerleader sending a message to the DOJ

Speaker 1and to the Commerce Department, keep your hands off my man, even though he appears to have been flouting. And NVIDIA, specifically the company, has been openly flouting a lot of these export control restrictions. And so that's why this affair matters. Yes, Alice Wong, we believe that she might have been a Chinese spy. That's according to U.S. intelligence assessment as of October 2025. But the real big picture here is their relationship is secondary, right, to all of this. Is Jensen is basically, she's running this Chinese state-backed company. He's selling

Speaker 1her chips, which he's not supposed to be doing. She is involved in all kinds of sketchy stuff behind the scenes, as licked to the DOJ. The Commerce Department starts looking into this about how Jensen is inflating this company and sending up to $ 8 billion almost of chips over there, potentially in violation here, of U.S.

Speaker 2Law.

Speaker 1And then the Trump corruption angle here of Nvidia name dropping the boss of the investigators being like, Hey, he told us, you know, to basically, uh, to get into contact with you guys. Lo and behold, they dropped the investigation. It gets kicked over to DOJ. Nothing's going on as of right now. That's the scandal that we see right now.

Speaker 3So if I can back up for a second and kind of TLDR this for everybody. I mean, first of all, let's contemplate how important Nvidia is to the entire AI build on. They're the only company that manufacture these highest end chips that are essential to especially the frontier models. The Biden administration was quite restrictive in terms of what could be sold to China. The Trump administration has rolled back some of those restrictions. And one of the people who has been a foremost, most influential advocate of an

Speaker 3open trading relationship and rolling back all of these restrictions is Jensen Huang. We all got a taste of this recently in the wake of the hugging face hack. Jensen was one of the people who was arguing that, okay, we need to continue to be off to the races with AI development. We need to expand. We need to be interacting with China. We should allow them to buy our chips so that they're using our tech. stack in their development, and this is important. Now look, he has every business incentive to say these things. He is the

Speaker 3guy selling the chips, so of course he would be also arguing we should sell the chips everywhere.

Speaker 2As much as we possibly can. However, The fact that he now has this.

Speaker 3Relationship with an alleged Chinese spy does call into question the advice that he is giving, the direction that he is going in. And again, this is someone who is very trusted by Trump and a top advisor. Then you layer into this investigation into this company where NVIDIA intervenes and suddenly the investigation is very much changed in the way that it's handling. The allegations that, you know, obviously he has been selling massive amounts of chips to this woman that he's having an affair with. And it appears

Speaker 3she may have been taking some of those high-end chips, which are not supposed to be sold to China, and shipping them to China. That layers a whole lot onto this thing. And NVIDIA is really so central to the AI buildup, not only because they developed the chips, but they also have all of these business dealings, all of these sort of like circular financing deals. at the center of all of this. Here's the other piece. Jensen Huang is not just an ordinary CEO. There's a lot of ways you can run a company. Some CEOs are relatively hands-off.

Speaker 3They just sort of delegate and they handle the high-level decisions. That is not him. He famously runs this very flat organization where he is deeply involved in all of the day-to-day decisions. He has something like 60 people report directly to him. He is very deeply enmeshed and involved in what's going on. Furthermore, there is no succession plan. There is no one who's being groomed to potentially take over in the event that there's some problem with Jensen Huang. He is really all they've got. There is no backup

Speaker 3plan in this company. So now the board of NVIDIA is investigating all of this to find out what the hell is going on and the way this affair interacted with the business decisions that were being made and if anything improper was going on, etc., But part of the reason why everyone from Trump to, you know, all these Silicon Valley guys are basically running cover for him is because he and this was the headline of an Atlantic article about this. They're like, Jensen Huang is too big to fail. He is too important to this company. This company is too important to the entire global economy, but

Speaker 3specifically the American AI build-on, which our entire economy is basically bet on right now. So, okay, he was with a Chinese spy. I guess we're just going to have to pretend all that didn't happen and keep pushing forward. One more thing before I toss it back to you, that it just should be absolutely insane to people, regardless of how you feel, by the way, about the export controls with China, which I kind of have complicated feelings about. Trump has known about this for a year. He was briefed on this a year ago. OK, that was before

Speaker 3he brought Jensen Huang with him on his trip to China. That was before he called him on stage with, you know, all in and the besties to talk to him about how we got to continue the A.I. build up that he has maintained Jensen Huang as this very close friend.

Speaker 1Advisor.

Speaker 2Put the shoe on the other foot.

Speaker 3Imagine that you had the Biden administration being closely advised by someone who was having an.

Speaker 2Affair with some foreign spy. People would lose their minds.

Speaker 3Trump, again, has known about this for a year and did not change one iota how he was operating or engaging with this man.

Speaker 2It is really bonkers.

Speaker 1I totally agree. Look, There's a great, fair conversation to be had here about export controls, about openness and all of that. Jensen Wong doesn't care about any of that. He cares about getting rich. That's what this whole thing is about. That's why this is a corruption scandal. What he did is he allied with this woman to divert things directly in circumvention of U.S. law to enrich her and to enrich him and then use his connections with the Trump administration to quash any investigation into that. If you disagree with the law, let's change the law. That's fine.

Speaker 1and then we can set level playing grounds. But it shouldn't be that because you're one of the richest men in the world, I believe the eighth richest man in the world, something like that, $ 200 billion net worth, that you're trying to protect your own company and basically cozying up to the Trump administration. And remember, I mean, you know, he's taking calls from Trump at the all-in summit. He's just slobbering all over him on the Joe Rogan podcast. I mean, it's just so ridiculous. Also, I have the number here in front of me. NVIDIA is 8.5% of the entire S & P 500. So nearly 10% of

Speaker 1the entire S & P 500, which is where the vast majority of people by index fund are holding all their wealth. Whether you have NVIDIA stock directly or not, you bet on this company. The whole US economy bets on this company. And for these tech people, my God. To your point here about Jensen, Jensen not only runs with 60 direct reports, Jensen has near total control, is a very weak board, and he has the ability to go out there and take multi-billion dollar flyers because of his inflated stock to go out there and say, let's throw $ 50 billion at this deal here. Let's throw $ 100

Speaker 1billion at this deal here. Let's do this co-financing deal here. So remember all the circular financing deals that we've been talking about for years? NVIDIA is at the heart of that. He is the beating heart. Jensen Wong is. I saw an analyst, a stock analyst say this morning, Jensen and video without Jensen, the stock is worth 25 to 30 percent less just because if they'd run themselves like a normal company, that's how much of a hit that the stock would take, which means we would all take a massive haircut on our 401ks. And this is why Trump,

Speaker 1I mean, is coming out here and basically saying and absolving him. of all guilt in his press conference yesterday, he even acknowledges that there's an FBI investigation, but is saying, eh, he's going to be fine. Well, since he runs the government, that kind of tells you where things are going. D1, let's take a listen.

Speaker 4I would say that when I heard about it, first of all, I was amazed because I view him as a very high quality person. I've known him a long time. It's actually the largest, I think by value, it's probably the largest or one of the largest companies in the world. He did that with a chip. You know, when you think about it, he's got a chip that's 10 years advanced. Can't be cut because of the complexity. Can't even the Blackwell can't even be copied. He's an amazing guy. I just hope it's I hope there's no problem. If there

Speaker 4is a problem, we'll let you know about it. But I hope there's no problem. I believe he's suffering greatly. I read his statement and I believe he's suffering greatly, more so because of his family, his wife, who he loves and his family. But he is definitely suffering.

Speaker 3Just to follow up on the when were you first told of these potential issues with Mr.

Speaker 1Blank? You didn't answer that question.

Speaker 4Well, I've been hearing about it and I've been reading a little bit about it over a period of time. But not too long ago. We'll look into it. I know the FBI is looking into it in terms of something else. And I think that he'll be in good shape. I asked him today because I did speak to him today just to see if he's feeling all right. How you doing? And I asked him about that. And he said he had absolutely no idea that the person in question was a spy. I asked him that question. Did

Speaker 4you have any idea that she was a spy? He said, I had no idea that she was a spy.

Speaker 1Well, we can always count on Jensen to tell the truth, especially to Trump, can't we? But look, most noteworthy comment there was him saying again that, oh, the FBI will look into it, but it's going to be fine. I mean, I think, and we've already seen this, Senator Warren... Van Hollen, others are all over this. Chris Coons as well. This may end up being one of the most consequential investigations that they run. And, you know, look, I get the tawdry details are everywhere. And we'll get to some of

Speaker 1the ironically that Jensen's greatest legacy is chips have created some of the best AI memes I've personally ever seen about this situation. But I will say the details of this have been out there for a long time. I want to give special credit to Culper Research. Let's put my tweet up there, D5. I was doing a lot of research on this yesterday. So Culper Research are short sellers, actually, very similar to the ones who put out bets against Enron. And in May of 2026, they put out a report

Speaker 1which details the affair with Alice Wong about the flouting of U.S.

Speaker 2Law.

Speaker 1About the diversion of chips. And they said, this is ultimately why we are short this company. They said they have major problems in China and it's only a matter of time until regulators come out. And so because they did so much of the work, they have their own sources, which kind of tells them some of the tawdry details about Alice Wong and more. I just wanted to make sure I give them a shout out. I've really relied on them for the research. And obviously they've been totally vindicated after all of this has come out. So it's so crazy. And I think- You know, look, not in

Speaker 1the immediate term. I think Jensen's going down as a result of this. His fingerprints are all over this. The way that he has run this company and more. He cannot come unscathed.

Speaker 2I don't know. I mean, in terms of the short sellers, like.

Speaker 3NVIDIA is down, but I don't know if they counted on the fact that, yeah, he's too big to fail. The company can't take the hit, like, and there is no replacement. So now you've got the president of the United States like, yeah, the FBI is looking into it, but nothing to see here. And he's going through a tough time, by the way. We should all feel really bad for him. To me, it also just underscores how fragile this whole thing is. Like, Jensen has, I don't know if people follow this, but he's got like a cult mentality.

Speaker 2Of fans.

Speaker 3There are tons of Jensen fanboys out there who love his whole attitude and.

Speaker 2The leather jacket.

Speaker 4And girls.

Speaker 2Yeah, and fan girls too, clearly.

Speaker 1He signs their boobs, literally, on camera. You can see the video.

Speaker 3He's really tried to style himself as this kind of cool, edgy, tech dude. And that image has really worked for him, made him obviously extremely influential, extremely powerful. and then come to realize, oh my God, this is a fallible human being.

Speaker 2Who could have known?

Speaker 3And the entire global economy is like resting on the tent pole of Jensen Huang.

Speaker 2And turns out.

Speaker 3That there can be, as with any human being, there can be some misjudgments. Oh my God, lo and behold, I thought she just loved me. It turns out she's a Chinese spy. Who could have known, right?

Speaker 2And so, you know, this is the situation. This is the economy that we have built.

Speaker 3Where if it's not Jensen, it's Dario or it's Sam Altman or it's Elon Musk, like there's just a handful that you can name by first name of people who this entire AI build out depend upon, who are being handed this immense wealth and power and our future is being sold out to them. You know, they're deciding right now, we might get some Democratic push, small D Democratic pushback on that. But as of now, they are deciding how far and how fast AI is going to go and

Speaker 3the way that it is going to change all of our lives and our children's lives and penetrate society.

Speaker 2And threaten humanity.

Speaker 3Like that is resting in the hands of these type of people.

Speaker 2And guess what?

Speaker 3Whether you like them, whether you think they're cool, whether you dig the leather jacket or not, these are fallible human beings. And so everyone needs to take a beat with this and say, what the hell are we doing?

Speaker 1What are we doing? You know, to your point, too, we can even skip the meme thing. It's stupid. Just to make a substantive point. Just think about this. This company, which is 8.5% of the S & P 500, we now found out has no succession plan, is a cult of personality with an idiot personality. 63-year-old man who wears a leather jacket, which, okay, I think we all know what's going on there in terms of Mr. Midlife Crisis. And we also find out, I read this today, they had no plan for if China takes over Taiwan. Jensen

Speaker 1personally banned a Taiwan contingency plan for NVIDIA, I guess with the assumption of we're dead if that ever happens. So, I mean, our, my child's 529 plan is in the hands of this fucking moron who apparently thinks that she loves him or whatever at this bar in Taipei and who refused to have any succession. Apparently the board of directors completely out to lunch. This company is worth more

Speaker 1than the entire European stock market. It is one of the most valuable companies in the history of mankind. And these are the people who are running it. That is what terrifies me actually more than anything. is that all brittleness comes apart like this. And now the government has to save him. Basically, if there's a normal president in charge, he would be going to jail. Or at the very least, he would be removed. And so, yeah, I don't know. I think it's so insane.

Speaker 5I really do.

Speaker 1And again, no matter what you think about export controls or not, things should not be working like this. They should not be working via your affair partner and more. And to the board, the board, by the way, is pathetic. They're like, oh, we have no indication that anything was done wrong. I mean, it's people, I mean, what, you know, they're in the same hotel room. Uh, Trump calls him every day, all the time to talk about what, I mean, who knows what they're talking about on the phone, private things that they're sharing details behind the scenes. What's Trump's mood. What's he's thinking. I mean, these are massively valuable to

Speaker 1any intelligence service. It's just stunning. It really is.

Speaker 3You know, for me, the, uh, the mass really came off of, of Jen said, I mean, there were a number of moments, the, the, Trump's speakerphone at the All In Summit was one of them for sure. But I watched his interview with Ezra Klein in the wake of the hugging face hack. And he went on to make the case that we can control AI and it's nothing to worry about and we shouldn't regulate and we just need to be off to the races. And I, you know, I assumed that I would hear some like compelling arguments that made my position of like, no, we need to pause.

Speaker 3We need to get this thing under control, that would challenge me. And it was some of the worst argumentation I've ever seen. You know, I mean, he literally was like, oh, the free market will figure it out if there's a problem. And Ezra Wright Lee was like, well, that's not how we operate with like airplanes, for example. We don't go, well, you know, a whole plane drops out of the sky and a bunch of people die. The free market will fix it. That's not how we operate. And currently, you know, the AI labs, who is it that says like it takes more licensing and regulation to run the cafeteria at

Speaker 3the AI lab than actually develop technology? this very dangerous and potentially world-changing technology.

Speaker 2That is an insane state of affairs.

Speaker 3So when I watched that, that was already really disturbing to me because I was like, oh, this guy is not the incredible mastermind genius that he is being portrayed as. And now we see the, again, incredibly human failures of judgment that have massive consequences, potentially criminally so, although I don't think that will come to that under this administration. So this is what we're, these are the types of people that we have put all of our future in the hands of.

Speaker 2Congratulations, everyone.

Speaker 1Yeah, that's right. Maybe I should sell my stock. Now I'm thinking about it.

Speaker 4All right.

Speaker 1Appreciate everybody watching. We're going to skip all in just for timing purposes. We went long with several guests, which we think is more important than dunking on the bros. We'll do it, I guess, on our Thursday show. We'll get to it. It is still important. It's still important. All right. So let's kick it to ourselves with Thomas Rank.

Speaker 3All right, guys, it is quite an honor to be joined live in person here in the studio by Thomas Frank, an extraordinary author of many books, including The People Know, Listen Liberal, What's the Matter with Kansas, and his new book, The Creativity Con, which we're going to speak with him about. But first, we wanted to get into a little bit of Kansas convo for you since you are the resident expert.

Speaker 2Great to see you.

Speaker 5It's great to see you as well, Crystal.

Speaker 6But I have to warn you, I don't live there anymore. I moved out of Kansas some years ago.

Speaker 2They chased you out?

Speaker 5No, no, no, no. It's a long story.

Speaker 6But, you know, life takes you down some strange pathways. And I actually live in Bethesda, Maryland now.

Speaker 2Beautiful place.

Speaker 7Very nice place.

Speaker 5The opposite of Kansas.

Speaker 3But, Woody, I mean, you must have some thoughts, though. First, tell people who, because we have an audience that's relatively young who may not.

Speaker 2Have read the book, actually.

Speaker 3Tell us what the thesis of What's the Matter with Kansas was really all about.

Speaker 6Well, it was about how ordinary people were voting for right-wing candidates. So Kansas has always been, or used to always be, a Republican state. I mean, when I was a kid, the neighborhood I grew up in was, I thought, the most Republican place in America.

Speaker 5It was up there like with Orange County. It was that kind of thing.

Speaker 6And so the question is, how do conservatives appeal to ordinary people whose interests they don't share? It's sort of the question of our times. I was looking for a way to examine or talk about the great turn to the right that this country has made beginning in the 70s and 80s. And we've never really looked back. We've never really turned away from it. And this is the

Speaker 6question of our time. How did this happen? Why did people sign up for it? And so that's what I did. I studied ordinary people and why they... you know, signed up for this sort of awful movement that was ruining their life chances.

Speaker 5And the answer was the culture wars. The culture wars were.

Speaker 6Extremely powerful for the people that I studied and the people that I talked about. By the way, I chose Kansas not only because I come from there, but because it's often used as a symbol.

Speaker 5Of middle America. You know, it's right in the middle of the country.

Speaker 6It's statistically very, very average, you know. And so it was it was very useful for that. But, yeah, the culture wars.

Speaker 1Yeah, Thomas, I am actually the person who put their request in for you in anticipation of this potential Democratic victory, because I said, well, now we can do a 22 year later follow up about what is the matter with Kansas. We pulled actually this video of Adam Hamilton, the senator elect from the state. I'm curious what you make of it. Let's take a listen.

Speaker 8So I went to the Wizard of Oz Museum, and while I was there, I get to watch a certain clip from the Wizard of Oz. You've got Dorothy with Toto, she's on the yellow brick road, they're going to see the wizard, and her three trusty sidekicks, you remember them.

Speaker 7The Scarecrow, the Tin Man, and who? Cowardly Lion.

Speaker 8And I'm standing there, it's been 20 years since I watched it, I said, okay, what did the Scarecrow need?

Speaker 7Do you remember? He needed a brain. He needed a brain. What did the Tin Man need? They needed a heart. What did the Cowardly Lion need? They needed courage.

Speaker 8And I had to laugh, and I thought, this is what's wrong in Washington, D.C.

Speaker 7Right now.

Speaker 8We got a lot of people up there. We got a lot of people up there who have lost their minds. They're no longer using critical thinking skills to solve problems. They're not thinking for themselves. They're doing whatever their president or their party tells them to do. That's not good for Kansas. We have a lot of people who lost their hearts in Washington, D.C., and that's easy to have happen. You go to Washington, you live there for 180 days, you go to Florida for a while, you come back to Kansas and all of your stops are photo ops in front of Cabela's or somewhere else. You got five minutes. You don't actually stop and listen. You have a listening session in Oakley and you get upset, you walk out.

Speaker 8And instead of listening to people. Then you say, you know what? We don't do listening sessions because those people are too dangerous in Kansas. I'm looking at you, even the Marshall fans, you don't look dangerous to me. You got to listen. You listen to your people. And when you do, you find a heart because you see people suffering. You hear their pain.

Speaker 7And you say, I got to do something about that.

Speaker 8And I can't keep voting for things that take away 51,000 people's health insurance in the state of Kansas.

Speaker 718,000 kids who don't get SNAP benefits anymore. Finally, you got to have courage.

Speaker 8And courage is when you stand up to your president and your party and you say, This is hurting people back home. And you say it, even if your president's going to bully you, pick on you, primary you, and call you names, you still say, this is not okay.

Speaker 1A little hokey for my taste, Thomas, but clearly it worked.

Speaker 5Come on, that was awesome. What are you talking about? It's the allegory that never ends.

Speaker 6You know, so that book was written as an allegory of the populist uprising in Kansas, where the tin man symbolizes the proletariat, you know, the industrial working class.

Speaker 5Obviously, the scarecrow is a.

Speaker 6Farmer and the cowardly lion was William Jennings Bryan, you know.

Speaker 5Oh, wow. And yeah, the lion that never could really, you know, never get it done. But it's funny how that that allegory works.

Speaker 6And it just keeps on it just keeps on going. That was I think that was really wonderful. That's I thought that was touching.

Speaker 2So what do you think of this?

Speaker 3Evolution, you know, to go from Kansas being this really hard right bastion to now, you know, how does and how does it reflect some of the shifts that are happening in the country more broadly?

Speaker 6So Adam Hamilton, good guy, decent man, but it was a Republican himself up until earlier this year.

Speaker 1And right.

Speaker 6The what you have to remember. So in what's the matter with Kansas? The main tension was not between Republicans and Democrats. It was between these two factions of the Republican Party. the so-called moderates and the conservatives. I grew up in moderate land. All my neighbors were Republican moderates. They loved Bob Dole, Nancy Kassebaum, George Bush Sr., these kind of people. And that group has, by and large, become Democrats here in the last few years. So the

Speaker 6county I grew up in, which I was saying when I was a kid, most Republican place in America, Johnson County, Kansas. This is the most It's the richest county in Kansas and also has the most people. When I was a kid, very, very, very Republican. When I was there in 2020, it flipped for Biden, and it's continuing to go deeper and deeper into the blue. But this is the case that you'll find everywhere where people are affluent and highly educated and white-collar together.

Speaker 5They're they're doing this.

Speaker 6So that's I mean, it's so it reflects it reflects that divide, that dichotomy in Kansas.

Speaker 3I wondered if there's another we're talking to a strategist, Chuck Rocha, earlier, who was involved in the Texas Senate race. He was involved in Adam Hamilton's victory, also was involved in the Michigan Senate victory. And one of the things he said is that, you know, culture war really sells when people are.

Speaker 2Doing okay economically. Exactly. And, yeah, I wonder if that is a part of the story.

Speaker 5Here, too.

Speaker 1Yes.

Speaker 6And when the pain gets too, you know, too deep, obviously people aren't going to be, you know, palliated by it.

Speaker 5I don't know, what's the culture war this year? I was sort of out of touch.

Speaker 2Trans.

Speaker 5Okay, yeah.

Speaker 6Or I was going to say the war on Christmas was one of the big ones when I was writing.

Speaker 5That's a throwback.

Speaker 1Thomas, that's a long time ago. I know, I know.

Speaker 6There's this endless, endless stream of them, and they come up with new ones every year. But there was this hilarious... exchange with Roger Marshall. This is the Republican who just went down. And, you know, you just can't ask for a more out of touch. And so in Kansas, like in a lot of states out west, they have this problem where they're they elect guys to the U.S.

Speaker 5Senate. And then they never come home. They don't even own houses.

Speaker 6Not him specifically, but this is a problem. Do you remember Pat Roberts? So he rarely came back to the state. Bob Dole rarely came back to Kansas. None of these guys ever intend to retire in Kansas.

Speaker 5But he ran this.

Speaker 6It was either an ad or an interview that I was watching with Roger Marshall where he was saying, you know, sometimes you have to overlook your economic interests and you have to vote on your values and, you know, your culture. And it was like— it was right out of What's the Matter with Kansas.

Speaker 5It was so perfect.

Speaker 6But the strategy failed this time, as it does in situations where the pain is bad. The other thing is it fails when there's no daylight between Democrats and Republicans on economic issues. So when you got a guy like Bill Clinton who's deregulating Wall Street banks and the Democrats are signing off on these trade agreements and that sort of thing, And they're effectively that everybody is agreeing on the economic issues.

Speaker 5Yeah, the culture wars are going to work.

Speaker 6It's a way of doing this kind of anti-elite politics and getting back at the people in charge in your society. But you take that stuff off the table and it's a very different, you know, very different ballgame.

Speaker 1Yeah, Thomas, I think that's what's really fascinating is kind of to watch this. I was looking at the results, 1932. That's the last time that Kansas elected a Democrat. Actually, even then, it was barely by a point. I didn't realize it was that close. Kind of shocking in retrospect. And McGill actually gets crushed in the 1938 election, I guess, after things get a little bit better. So now that we know what's the matter with Kansas and how to solve that matter, how does an Adam Hamilton not pull a McGill here? And actually, Hold on. I mean, what

Speaker 1does he need to do?

Speaker 6So that I can't really answer because I don't, like I say, I don't live there anymore.

Speaker 5I'm not in touch with what the issues are.

Speaker 6But it's so easy to see how, I mean, how this unfolded this time around. Donald Trump has sort of you know, gone to his voters and given them the biggest betrayal, I think, that we have ever seen in our lifetimes. You think about what his big issues were in 2016. He was going to drain the swamp. I mean, this is the most, this guy, the corruption now is in your face. It's so extreme, so incredible. He was gonna end the forever wars. Instead, he got us into

Speaker 6a new one that just, who knows, is it going on today?

Speaker 5Are we bombing today? Are we not bombing today?

Speaker 6And then he was going to be on the side of ordinary people. Do you remember the forgotten man? A line, by the way, that he swiped from Franklin Roosevelt. And now who's his best friends? Well, it's all these Silicon Valley guys who are building this new invention. They're innovating this new device that might just end your way of life.

Speaker 5It's, you know, it's horrifying. It's frightening. It's terrifying.

Speaker 6So it's easy in circumstances like that to, you know, to knock off.

Speaker 5I don't know. Nothing is easy.

Speaker 6I've never done politics. I'm sure it's very, very hard. But you've got these out-of-touch Republican senators who just do whatever the lobbyists tell them to do.

Speaker 5Yeah, it's like, you know, good riddance, you know?

Speaker 2That's actually good.

Speaker 3Talking to someone about the tech oligarchs, that's actually a good transition to talk about your book. The book is The Creativity Con, How Innovation Became America's Biggest Racket. And, you know, prior to reading this book, I would have said, you're a very creative person, but I don't know, maybe.

Speaker 2It's an insult.

Speaker 3Because you effectively argue that the whole fixation on creativity in America was a kind of psyop to usher in a neoliberal era to a public that was instinctually opposed to these arguments about IQ and how some people are just inherently superior.

Speaker 2So lay out your argument here a little bit.

Speaker 5Yeah.

Speaker 6So creativity sounds like this wonderful thing. It's what we want for all our children.

Speaker 5And by the way, I started a literary magazine when I was an undergraduate. It's still going. Did you know this?

Speaker 1Wow. I didn't.

Speaker 7That's awesome.

Speaker 5Yes.

Speaker 6And yeah, I'm very much like all my friends are writers or musicians or artists.

Speaker 5I mean, that's who I am.

Speaker 6But the creativity doctrine, creativity theory has never been about us. It's never been about people like that. It takes the sort of nobility of those very honored callings and swipes it and moves it to Silicon Valley guys, Wall Street guys. the CEO of your company. Why are they in charge? Because they're an innovator, because they know how to innovate.

Speaker 5It's basically become, over the years, I wouldn't say.

Speaker 6It was done deliberately as in a psyop, but it has nevertheless become a way of excusing or rationalizing the sort of insane, extreme inequality that we live with today. Why are these companies, why are we dominated by this handful of industries? Why does the wealth in this country get more concentrated every single year? because they know how to innovate. They deserve it. Why do we offshore blue collar work? Why do we send manufacturing overseas? Because those

Speaker 6people aren't creative, which is all false.

Speaker 5It's all wrong.

Speaker 6But that's what we tell ourselves. That's what we've been told. And by the way, by Democrats as well as by Republicans.

Speaker 5This is a very....

Speaker 6Creativity is a very attractive doctrine for all sorts of different reasons. But one of them is that it's extremely conservative while sounding radical.

Speaker 1Right.

Speaker 6You know, it's all about like this kind of countercultural, nonconformist, you know, zany individualism.

Speaker 5But what does it wind up, you know, it winds up being used to.

Speaker 6Like Let's cut taxes. We got to put more money in the hands of innovators, you know? So, and you go back down the, this is one of the things I do in the book. You go through the history of the neoliberal turn. As I said, my obsessive subject, how did this country move to the right in the way that it did? And you go back through the history of the neoliberal turn and at every event, every stop in this terrible story, Creativity and innovation are the reasons that we did what we did. It's why we cut taxes in the 70s and 80s. It's why we

Speaker 6deregulated Wall Street in the 1990s. It's why we signed, why we negotiated all of those awful trade agreements. And it's also when you get up to a guy like Barack Obama, who at first at least seemed like his heart was in the right place, why he decided he couldn't do anything about it.

Speaker 5It was all up to, there's nothing he can.

Speaker 6Do to help out people in sort of ruined heartland towns in Kansas and Missouri. The only hope for them is that innovators will innovate something that will rescue them, which is not an answer at all.

Speaker 5But that's what I'm saying. The only answer is we can all go.

Speaker 6Out and get STEM degrees and learn how to innovate. And I'm sorry, I chuckle at inappropriate moments.

Speaker 5But it's I mean, it's I.

Speaker 1Don't think that's inappropriate. It's a joke. It is.

Speaker 5It's so preposterous.

Speaker 6And yet that is our country, you know, and until the day that we start seeing through this stuff and and get over this stuff, we're going to be stuck in this in this broken record where we keep looking to these tech titans and pharma bros to rescue us, and they're never going to do it.

Speaker 5And by the way, Trump is just.

Speaker 6As big an offender in this regard as Ronald Reagan or Barack Obama or Bill Clinton. Trump declared last year that we were entering a golden age of innovation to be powered by AI and has gone to great lengths to associate himself with the various Silicon Valley leaders. He gives them innovation prizes and stuff like this.

Speaker 1Really smart, Thomas. My last question for you is why didn't you call it the meritocracy con? That was the last book.

Speaker 5Come on, Sager.

Speaker 1That was the last book. Yeah, but it's like the kind of– because it strikes me everything that you're talking about is basically the same critique I would give of the so-called meritocracy.

Speaker 4Yes. Right?

Speaker 1Is that it gives you– like the elites of today are just like the wasps of the 1950s. but at least those people had like a familial noblesse oblige, whereas everybody today is like, I earned it. I got into Harvard, right? Whereas last time, everybody knew they only got into Harvard because of their last name. It was almost better that way, honestly.

Speaker 5Yeah, I mean, that's a really good point.

Speaker 6And so obviously meritocracy is a huge part of the same story that we're telling. But how do they sell it? They don't use the word meritocracy, of course, but they do talk about themselves as creatives and as innovators. You go to something like South by Southwest, which is I think the part of the book that I'm proudest of. I went to South by Southwest a couple of years ago, stayed for the entire run of the whole thing, and really got a belly full of creativity and innovation. Basically,

Speaker 6this is how our ruling class understands themselves. This is how they present themselves to the world. You know, I was thinking about Jensen Huang on my way over here.

Speaker 5Because he's in the news. Oh, yeah, we're covering him.

Speaker 6He's a very interesting guy, but he also, you know, he always wears that black leather jacket, right?

Speaker 5Because he's like the tech Fonz, you know?

Speaker 4Yeah.

Speaker 6But they're all like this. And this is how they rationalize their authority. And this is how they rationalize this incredible concentration of wealth in this country. And it's how they explain to us our elites. It's not those wasps in the 1950s, who, by the way, the 1950s, we had incredible, by the standards of today, we had great shared wealth in the 1950s. The affluent society, that's all over now. But why do these guys get to live

Speaker 6the way they do? Why do they get to consume so many resources? Why do they get to own everything? Because they're these kind of zany, countercultural.

Speaker 5Rule breakers.

Speaker 6They are the incarnation of this doctrine that we all love, this idea of creativity that we're all in love with. Once you start putting these things together, once you understand how critical these words are, it's everywhere.

Speaker 5Once you start seeing it, it's like your eyes open.

Speaker 6By the way, I say this because this is what happened to me doing the research for the book. When I started out, I meant something completely different by it. I was going to write mainly about the Richard Florida thing, the idea of the creative class. But once you plug that idea, the creative class, into your brain and open your eyes, you see it everywhere and it all starts to make sense.

Speaker 5And it's very disturbing.

Speaker 2Have you seen You Can See Everything yet?

Speaker 5Not yet.

Speaker 1You need to see it.

Speaker 2You're gonna find it very interesting.

Speaker 1You really need to see it, Thomas.

Speaker 2You're gonna find it very interesting.

Speaker 3But my last question for you here, and people should really read the book because it definitely shifts your perspective on things. I hadn't thought about it quite the way that you lay it out at all.

Speaker 2Have we actually gotten more creative.

Speaker 3As this is all foisted upon us and pushed in national creativity efforts and, you know, lionizing the innovators, et cetera? Have we as a population been creative because of this project?

Speaker 5It's exactly the opposite.

Speaker 6And this is the real tragedy of what I'm talking about here. For the last 60 years, we have worshipped at the Shrine of Creativity. Our government has done endless things to promote innovation.

Speaker 5You know, endless.

Speaker 6I mean, it goes on and on and on, you know, Carter administration, Clinton, Reagan, Obama, and now Trump, all of these things to say that they say they're promoting innovation. You look at the actual creative occupations in this country, writing, music, liberal arts scholarship, all of them, career dead ends today. Everybody knows it. I mean, I remember what F. Scott Fitzgerald used to call a writer's are poets, the unacknowledged legislators of the world. When I was a kid, that's what you wanted to be. You wanted to be a great novelist. You wanted to be a great writer. You

Speaker 6wanted to be a great musician. All gone today. You can't earn a living doing any of those things. And the economists have all these different ways to shift slightly. Economists have ways of measuring how innovative a society is. It mainly has to do with GDP growth and productivity growth. By those standards, we are getting worse, not better.

Speaker 5I mean, think about it.

Speaker 6So I was born in 1965. The U.S. gross domestic product grew by 6% that year. OK, that's an innovative society. That's a society that's growing by leaps and bounds. And by the way, blue collar people work work along.

Speaker 5For the ride.

Speaker 6Part of the great society. This was President Johnson's idea. Bring everybody in. Everybody was going to be middle class. Taxes were high. Unions were strong. And America was growing by leaps and bounds. Today, it's like, what, two and a half percent, 2.1 percent what our annual growth is. I mean, if we get to 3 percent, nowadays. I mean, they pop champagne corks. It's like the greatest thing in the world. No, we're on an incredible downhill slope. And it feels, if you're in a place like Washington, D.C.,

Speaker 6You look around and you say, wow, this country is really rich. This country is really great. Because we've concentrated all the wealth, all the development into these little areas and these small little handfuls of people. And so to them, it looks like everything's great. But statistically, no. And in terms of actual creative production, no. This country is totally stagnant. Think about Hollywood movies. Think about classic rock. I mean, can I give you one last example?

Speaker 1Yeah, go ahead. Yeah.

Speaker 5We're flying B-52 bombers over Iran. These are planes made before I was born.

Speaker 6I mean, what kind of innovative society does that?

Speaker 2And it's not going that well either, by the way.

Speaker 1Yeah, and they're not even working.

Speaker 5Yeah, exactly.

Speaker 3The book is The Creativity Con. Thomas Frank, great to see you. Thank you so much for coming in.

Speaker 1Thank you, sir.

Speaker 5Absolutely my pleasure.

Speaker 1Anytime, you guys. You should tell some of your neighbors in Bethesda to listen. All right?

Speaker 5I'll do that.

Speaker 1Just saying. Just saying. Thank you guys so much for watching. We appreciate it. We will see you all later. Great Friday show, or great Emily and Ryan show for everybody tomorrow.

Speaker 2Wednesday, that's it.

Speaker 1Yeah, Wednesday.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 11/20/26: Schumer REJECTED By Allies, Slotkin DEFECTS, Trump ABANDONS Americans To West Bank Terror, Zohran SHOCKS: RIKERS TO CLOSE, MARKET FALLS, ANTHROPIC DOWN, AI BUBBLE POP?, Fox News FREAKS Over GTA VI

    Nov 20, 20261 hr 46 minAudio

    The Friday gang digs into the growing support for Chris Van Hollen who is opposing Chuck Schumer in the Senate, Zohran Mamdani’s announcement to shut down Rikers Island, and are joined by guests, Jasper Nathaniel to...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 11/19/26: Saagar Debates Kalshi Investor, Elon Turns On MAGA, Anthropic IPO

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 9 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Saagar debates Kalshi investor, Elon turns on MAGA, Anthropic launches IPO. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111 Gary Marcus: https://x.com/GaryMarcus To...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 11/19/26: Jeffries Wins Speaker Vote, Trump Fumes At JD Over Iran, Shoppers Raid Costco For Doomsday Supplies

    Nov 19, 202651 minAudio

    Krystal and Saagar discuss Jeffries wins the House speaker vote, Trump fumes at Vance over Iran, shoppers raid stores for doomsday supplies. Ali Partovi: https://x.com/apartovi David Hogg: https://x.com/davidhogg111...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 11/18/26: Jeffries Caving On Iran War Funding, Navy Sec Unhinged Testimony, BAAJA Bill On The Verge In Congress

    Nov 18, 20261 hr 7 minAudio

    Ryan and Emily discuss Jeffries already caving on Iran war funding, Navy Sec unhinged Senate testimony, BAAJA bill on verge of passing. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy: https://hamawyfornj.com/...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 11/18/26: Stocks Plunge Amid More Outages, Jensen Begs For Nvidia Job Back, Expert Says Epstein Was Murdered

    Nov 18, 202647 minAudio

    Ryan and Emily discuss stocks plunge amid more outages, Jensen begs for Nvidia job back, NYT flips on Epstein as expert says he was murdered. Warren Davidson: https://davidson.house.gov/ Adam Hamawy:...

    • Apple Podcasts

    Credit the people on this episode