Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

WTF Bach

WTF Bach artwork

149: The Battle Between Life and Death

Sep 24, 20261 hr 17 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

“The consummate expressiveness of {BWV 4] has always been marvelled at. Each verse is as if chiselled in music.” -Albert Schweitzer, Vol. 2 Bach’s early Easter cantata remains one of the most beloved in the entire canon. Barely 22 years old, he is already in full command of his tone-painting. Here are three measures particularly packed with symbolism: Filling the music with rests at the word nothing, ‘one death eating another’ through the closest possible canon, crosses both in shape and every note ‘sharped’ (gekreuzt,) dripping blood on the Passover doors with short 8th notes, leaping a diminished 12th (!) in the bass aria at the word death, this cantata is a dictionary of text painting. …und singen Halleluja! The chorale cantata was probably composed for Bach’s Easter Sunday audition in 1707 for the organist post at St. Blaise’s Church in Mühlhausen, left vacant by the death of Johann Georg Ahle. Bach’s older cousin, Johann Gottfried Walther, had an audition for the same post, but withdrew - possibly because Bach himself was interested! Later, Bach revived this cantata his first two Easters in Leipzig, 1724 and 1725. Only the Leipzig parts survive, hence the original 1707 version is lost. Any differences between the revised and earliest versions - which may have been substantial - are lost. In any case, the remaining style certainly reflects his early vocal writing par excellence. The cantata is one of only a handful of per omnes versus cantatas, going through all seven verses of Martin Luther’s 1524 hymn text. Theologically, the text goes deeply into Lutheran ideas linking Jewish Passover - the blood-marked doorposts and unleavened bread - to Christian Easter, reading the Passover lamb as a prefiguration of Christ’s crucifixion and the Eucharist. Such deep theological reflection was something Bach understood and made apparent in tone. Spotify listeners! Some new AI is taking down episodes on Spotify without warning. Check the episode numbers to see if an episode has been removed! Be sure to check on wtfbach.com to make sure you’re caught up with all the episodes. Thanks! PS! Shelly conveniently does in fact quote the biblical, ‘O Death, where is thy sting?’ but the poem I was thinking of was Pope’s, The Dying Christian to his Soul: VITAL spark of heav’nly flame!Quit, O quit this mortal frame:Trembling, hoping, ling’ring, flying,O the pain, the bliss of dying!Cease, fond Nature, cease thy strife,And let me languish into life. Hark! they whisper; angels say,Sister Spirit, come away!What is this absorbs me quite?Steals my senses, shuts my sight,Drowns my spirits, draws my breath?Tell me, my soul, can this be death? The world recedes; it disappears!Heav’n opens on my eyes! my earsWith sounds seraphic ring!Lend, lend your wings! I mount! I fly!O Grave! where is thy victory?O Death! where is thy sting? Write That Fugue! We Rely Exclusively on Paid Subscriptions! Help WTF Bach endure:Join at WTFBach.comThis is the only place Evan checks comments regularly.You can also make a one-time donation here:https://www.paypal.me/wtfbachhttps://venmo.com/wtfbachThank you for your help! Get full access to W.T.F. Bach? at wtfbach.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_02It's Evan Shinners. How are you doing? Today we are concluding our tour of the earliest cantatas by J.S. Bach with one that is beloved. Krieslag in Todespanden, BWV4. That is the melody playing in the background. That was the introductory music. Where do we start with this piece, however, this very famous early Bach cantata? Well, maybe with the death of one Johann Georg Ahle, A-H-L-E, an interesting man, this J.G.

SPEAKER_02Ahle, born in 1651, Bach himself born in 1685. Anna, born in 1651, succeeded his own father as organist at St. Blaise's Church in Mühlhausen. So we've got father and son organists. The son was named Poet Laureate by Emperor Leopold I. And the son is also a writer. So he's a writer and a composer. And it seems like he was more famous for his writings, being named Poet Laureate.

SPEAKER_02Most of his works, both words and music, are lost. Apparently some of his word works were novels, which included musical interludes and songs. Isn't that interesting to think about? Can you aspiring novelists out there think about that? Maybe putting musical interludes between your next murder mystery. So, Ahle dies. In December of 1706, the organist of Mühlhausen dies, and the news of this death reaches young J.S. Bach in Arnstadt, just a few kilometers away.

SPEAKER_02How does news travel in those days, however? How does Bach find out that the organist... In yonder town has just, has just died. Well, this now coming from friend of the show, Christoph Wolf, the Ruhlhausen townscribe was Johann Hermann Bellstedt, whose brother was not only the townscribe in Arnstadt, but was also related by marriage to the Bach family. It's not convenient. So we've got these two brothers and they're both town scribes. One in the town Bach lives in and the other in the town Bach wants to go.

SPEAKER_02Why does Bach want to leave Arnstadt? Well, Bach isn't responsible for the vocal music in Arnstadt. And we know from one of the very few statements from Bach himself about his artistic vision... I mean, if you can even use such a modern-sounding term for Bach artistic vision, he wanted to write, quote, well-regulated church music to the glory of God. And in Arnstadt, he's organist and he's a recitalist performing some sacred, some secular or profane music, as it was called.

SPEAKER_02But in Mühlhausen, the duties are mostly composing occasional church pieces, as we've seen by looking at these other cantatas. So Bach wants to go there. Bach hears that the Milhausen organist has died, and who applies for the job other than Bach's cousin? Yes, Bach's cousin, J.G. Walter, applies for the job. He prepares, as the requirement is for the position, two cantatas, and he has an audition scheduled for February 27, 1707. But...

SPEAKER_02He withdraws his candidacy for the position. Why? Why does Wouter withdraw his application? Well, in his own words, as he himself wrote 30 years later, quote, some acquaintances viewed such a plan as unsuitable. Some acquaintances eh Walter? Who were these acquaintances? Were these perhaps acquaintances interested in the jobs themselves? Were these acquaintances your younger cousin J.S. Bach? Very interesting the relationship between Johann Gottfried Walter Walter and J.S.

SPEAKER_02Bach. Walter taught the famous Prince Johann Ernst of Saxe Weimar, the very talented composer who died at 18 years old. Bach knew him too. This is a very brilliant career, cut very short in music, 18 years old. But this was the prince that had all the Italian music sent back to Weimar. This is basically Bach's biggest introduction to Italian music. Through this prince, Walter taught the prince. And both Bach and Walter sort of divvied up the duties of this Of the Italian music saying,

SPEAKER_02you transcribe these concertos, I'll transcribe these concertos. So Walter makes some 14 concerto transcriptions, Bach a few more than 14. But interestingly enough, Walter is two years older than J.S. Bach. So if in fact he withdrew from this Mühlhausen organist position because his younger cousin wanted to audition himself, I think this speaks... Of the immense respect that Walter must have had for J.S. Bach, already as young men, this is 1706, so Bach is 21 and Walter's 23.

SPEAKER_02Walter withdraws the application and Bach applies for the job and he gets an addition on Easter Sunday, 1707. We have reason to believe that Christlagen Todespanden, being an Easter hymn, that this cantata is one of the two cantatas Bach presented at this audition. So, as we close this study of Bach's early cantatas, we're answering the all-important cantata questions. When and why was it written, and what are they singing? It was written in 1707 for an Easter Sunday audition in Mühlhausen.

SPEAKER_02What are they singing? Why, they're singing entirely through the hymn, By Mr. Martin Luther himself written in 1524, they're actually singing through every single verse of the hymn. This is a rare example of what they call per omnis verses, through every verse, through all the verses. Martin Luther wrote seven stanzas of text and Bach will set all seven stanzas to music. But more about that and the stylistic influences later when we look at the music. It's obvious this cantata was important to Bach.

SPEAKER_02Maybe he remembers it as the piece that won him the audition in Mühlhausen because he reprises it in 1724, his first Easter in Leipzig. 1724, we did a few episodes. Bach began this chorale cantata cycle in 1724, and Martin Luther published these hymns in 1524, so 24, the year in the century.

SPEAKER_02Bach's first Easter in Leipzig happened to be 1724. He performs this hymn that uses all seven verses of the 1524 hymn. Do you see the symmetry? And again, in 1725, Easter, Bach performs this cantata again. So twice we have two documented performances of this cantata. But interestingly enough, we don't have the parts, the surviving music from 1707. We only have the Leipzig parts, right? So we only have the music 20 years or so after it was written.

SPEAKER_02And we believe that there were probably substantial revisions made to this cantata when he reprised it in Leipzig. One major revision is the inclusion of the four-part chorale at the end of the cantata. I might use this as, you know, clickbait on the episode title and say, ah, it's Bach's first four-part chorale. But actually in all of the other cantatas we've studied, we haven't seen these four-part chorales, these slow-moving, very vertical textures.

SPEAKER_02We haven't seen this and we won't see this until Weimar and even more frequently in Leipzig. Some speculation believes that instead of the four-part chorale at the end, they would have reprised the first big chorale movement, which you'll hear some recordings do. But what other revisions might there have been? It's hard to say. It's actually impossible to say. We can't know. How extensive were they? I've recently been playing a Prelude and Fugue with origins around 1704, 1707,

SPEAKER_02most definitely an Arnstadt piece, but it was revised in his Weimar years, so, you know, some eight, ten years later, but the revisions are so extensive, it's really something to see both versions of the piece. You think, how did he go from A to B? Wow, that's just amazing. To think maybe what the original version was in 1707 versus almost 20 years later. Wow, I really wanted to know what that very first version sounded like. Do you again start? What did that early version sound like?

SPEAKER_02Were there some movements that had very poetic flourishes or dramatic endings that Bach, now a much more mature man in Leipzig, said, ah, the public isn't ready for that, so he smooths this out or inserts this transition a bit more chromatically, or maybe he took out some more chromatic jagged edges that now Bach, the master carpenter, has sanded down in Leipzig. We will never know what those Where, oh well, what we have is enough to sustain our minds and our souls. So let's dig in to Kreislagen Todesbanden BWV4.

SPEAKER_00Tune in and listen. Listen to this. This is W.T.F. Bach.

SPEAKER_01For Easter, Bach wrote the chorale cantata Kreislagen Todesbanden, the consummate expressiveness of which has always been marveled at. Each verse is as if chiseled in music, says Albert Schweitzer. Chiseled in music. Wonderful image that. There are seven verses, so we will get to look at seven sculptures made from sound. There's also a small instrumental introduction at the beginning of it. If you look at the structure, it's beautifully symmetrical.

SPEAKER_01The verses go chorus, duet, solo, chorus, solo, duet, chorus. So I'll do that again. From big to small, chorus, four parts, duet, two parts, solo, one part. Going small into the middle, then in the middle, back to full chorus, then out the other way, solo, duet, chorus. So you could see it sort of going toward the middle, getting smaller and butterflying out again. Now the first music I'd like to feature is a bit, well, boastful maybe on my part.

SPEAKER_01It was during the pandemic I was featured on a playlist with a bunch of Thuringian Bach Festival artists where we each played one Goldberg variation a night for a month. And who opened the playlist but my idol, Rudolf Lutz. And who played the aria but friend of the show, Ton Koopman? Talk about feeling imposter syndrome being on the same playlist as those cats. But Lutz played to introduce the Goldberg Variations on a big grand piano in the middle of a church during COVID.

SPEAKER_01The instrumental introduction to this cantata, Kreislaug. In G minor, it's normally in E minor, but he played it in G minor so that it would flow into the Goldbergs. I'd never heard Lutz play the piano, and it was just so lovely. So this should be a special treat for those of you who know the JS Bach Foundation and Rudolf Lutz and this cantata. Have a listen.

SPEAKER_01And then Tom Koopman played on a fortepiano. Just kidding, he played it on a harpsichord. Yes, that is the music. That is the music played by Lutz in G minor. I will give it to you now in the string version.

SPEAKER_01The American Bach soulist there, Jeffrey Thomas, musical director, I will be featuring their recording on this show. They make a lot of beautiful recordings, and I don't think I've ever featured them on this podcast. Now, this melody, the Kreislaug in Todespanden, has been featured on the show before in episode 96, dealing with the word hallelujah, because indeed every movement will end with the word hallelujah. And in every single movement, we will hear the chorale melody. Well, what is this chorale melody? Bach is hinting at it here.

SPEAKER_01He's saying, not yet, but not yet either, but now. Christslagen Todesbanden. Now, if you recall the episode, this Christslagen Todesbanden melody is a bit complicated. It is from the original Latin Easter chant, Victime Pascale Laudes. Victime Pascale Laudes.

SPEAKER_01Also shares many melodic similarities to Christisterstanden. So these are Easter hymns. Christ lay in the bonds of death, and Christ ist erstanden, and Christ is risen. So here first is Christ ist erstanden, because this is, for some reason, this particular recording with the Chamber Choir of Europe and Nicole Matt conducting, this is like one of my favorite 70 seconds of music, this old hymn, just the way that Bach has harmonized it.

SPEAKER_01Listen to this, gorgeous.

SPEAKER_03. . . . . .

SPEAKER_03. . . . .

SPEAKER_03Christus, the mother of God, Christus, the mother of God.

SPEAKER_01I just love that recording. There's something about the soprano voice, the quality of that voice. I'm not very picky about my singers, but there is something that that particular soprano, the way that the voice just sometimes breaks into vibrato. Anyways, I love that recording. Here is the same ensemble now doing Krieslag and Todespanden, and note these similarities in melodic shape.

SPEAKER_03Krieslag and Todespanden . . . . .

SPEAKER_03. . . . .

SPEAKER_01So in Christ is risen, every verse ends with Kyrie Elais, Lord have mercy, and in Christ lay in the bonds of death, every verse will end in Hallelujah. So the easiest way, or maybe even the requirement, Bach, as he inherits every form, he knows the history of this chorale cantata.

SPEAKER_01In fact, there is a history of elaborating instrumentally and vocally, sort of weaving these magnificent sonic tapestries around these older melodies in one of Bach's Leipzig predecessors. Now, I know this is 1707. He's not in Leipzig. He probably has no idea he's going to be the successor to Johann Hermann Schein, but he certainly knows Schein's work. Schein is the originator, I think it's safe to say, of this form. He published volumes in the early 60s.

SPEAKER_01Now I don't think we know if Bach met Pachelbel, but we certainly know about his visit to Bachabell and Buxtehude wrote cantatas per omnis verses, through all the stanzas. These are like theme and variation works. You go through the melody once with a certain style. Bach has great examples of this work for keyboard instruments.

SPEAKER_01So, yes, the only variations that Bach wrote are not the Goldberg variations or the aria variata. He's got these chorale partidas that are wonderful examples of Variations, theme and variations on a chorale melody. That's what's happening here, only we've got a full orchestra now and singers to realize this same idea. Or I should say strings and singers, no other instruments, just strings.

SPEAKER_01Well, okay, fine. In 1725, When Bach did it again, he had some trombones doubling the singers, but that was in 1725. We're trying to imagine this music in 1707. Fine, fine. Okay, let's hear what I think is one of the more simple examples of this idea. This is Variation 3, or Verse 3. The text of which is, Jesus Christ, God's Son, has come in our stead. And I think it's important that we say stead because he came an unsere Stadt.

SPEAKER_01It doesn't mean that he came to our city or that he came to our place, but that he came into our stead. This is now from Melamed and Merison. Quote, the line of the hymn assumes that Jesus came out of eternity into the world as a human being to die on the cross in an atoning sacrifice to God for the sin of humanity. That is, Jesus was punished in our stead as a sort of scapegoat. So he didn't come into our city, he came into our stead as And did away with our sin,

SPEAKER_01thereby taking from death all its privilege and its power. There remains nothing but death's shape. Death has lost its sting. Hallelujah. O death, where is thy sting? That is the verse there. I think Shelley also quotes that. Could be mistaken. Okay, here is the music now. Violins, two violins weaving this image over a tenor solo.

SPEAKER_00Jesus Christus, Gottes Sohn, an unsere Stadt ist kommend. Und hat die Finger weggebrannt,

SPEAKER_00Da bleibt nichts.

SPEAKER_00. . . . .

SPEAKER_02Do you love this cantata already? Amazing.

SPEAKER_01Word painting, word painting. Taking from death its privilege and its power. And on the word power, the violin line stops. It stops this stuff.

SPEAKER_02And we have this image here.

SPEAKER_01And this would be on the violin. All four strings at the same time. So literally requires more power to play. Nyang, nyang, nyang. And you can see the image of Christ stomping on death in the continuo. The look of this on the page looks like a pedal line in the organ music. You're going right, left, right, left.

SPEAKER_01And there you have Christ just stomping on death. Then the singer says, nothing, nothing. There remains nothing but death's shape. But let's hear just this. The power... The stomping on death, and then let's hear nothing, and we will hear arrest. We will actually hear nothing. Wow, there actually remains nothing.

SPEAKER_01Nothing but death's shape. And we'll hear in the continuo the forbidden interval of the tritone. That's the devil's Interval, we will hear this in the violin, this in the tenor. So we have some pretty sneaky intervals. The tempo is marked adagio. So that sort of the outline of death's shape is pretty eerie before it snaps back into this.

SPEAKER_01And we will also look at how Bach sets the word Hallelujah as we did in episode 96. Hallelujah is different in every single verse here. Very virtuosic singing on the word Hallelujah in this variation.

SPEAKER_01Yes, still the American Bach soloists there. Beautiful recording. Now let's go backwards. So this is verse two, second verse through this seven stanza hymn. The text, nobody could restrain death among all the children of humankind. Our sin made that so. No innocence was to be found. And as a result, death overcame us immediately and seized power over us and held us imprisoned in its realm. Hallelujah.

SPEAKER_01So this image of being captive, being a prisoner in death's realm, can we hear that? A duet between alto and tenor. I don't know if this recording will feature the trombones and the cornetto. Maybe I should do a side-by-side recording. Anyhow, hear more from the American Bach syllabists.

SPEAKER_03. . .

. . .

SPEAKER_03. .

SPEAKER_03. . . . . . .

SPEAKER_03. . .

SPEAKER_01Brass, certainly there in that record. It sounded lovely, don't you think? Am I imagining this, or am I hearing the struggle to break free, the melody struggling to start? Okay, so, you know, trying to break into the melody, the suspensions, the trading of dissonance from one singer onto the other, man handing on misery to man, pain begetting pain. Now, I could be imagining that, but this is probably something I wouldn't have noticed had I not tried

SPEAKER_01to play this movement myself. There is a tricky crossing here where the tenor goes higher than the alto. The alto line. So dropping this octave. And down here, gefangen, gefangen. The tenor, meanwhile, above the alto. And so what you have here is this is my right hand playing this lower note and the left hand playing the upper note.

SPEAKER_01So you're sort of crossed over yourself. You are held captive. It's almost like my hands are in handcuffs on this word gefangen. What is this word gefangen? Well, that's captive. That's held. That's the prisoner. So it's almost all too literal of an image to see these two voices sort of held up in this dissonance.

SPEAKER_01Hallelujah there. Now, I might be digging too much, but I think it's the same idea, trading dissonance between singers, mankind struggling to break free of the sin, but then hallelujah, there's actually real relief in it for the first time in this movement. And could this be Bach painting? Yes, dissonance. Yes, death. But then consonants. After all, it is pretty strange to say no one could restrain death. After all, our sin caused this. We were prisoners by death. Hallelujah.

SPEAKER_01But, you know, for a Christian like Bach, it is the fact that Christ endured the real human death. He was also in death's bonds, totus banden. So can we hear the bondage of dissonance leading into consonants? Hallelujah. Maybe, maybe, I could just be off my rocker. Anyhow, let's hear the Hallelujah. It is somehow musically different.

SPEAKER_01In the chorus, Es war ein wunderbar Krieg der Tod und Leben rungen. It was a marvelous struggle between life and death. We seem to see a knot of bodies in conflict as in a picture of Michelangelo. Thus spake Albert Schweitzer in Movement 5 in verse 4. This is the middle movement. Perhaps the central idea for Luther, the theology here goes deep. I hope you're prepared to go deep as well.

SPEAKER_01Bach certainly knows this Lutheran theology. Let's read the text first. It was a wondrous battle on the cross where death, Satan, and life, Jesus, wrestled. Life got the victory. And it has swallowed up death. Scripture has proclaimed this, how one death, Christ's death, devoured the other death, as in Satan's death. And a mockery was made of death. Hallelujah. So again, from Matthew.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And the same verb, Ringen, to wrestle, was used by Luther in his rendering of Genesis.

SPEAKER_01The enigmatic foundational story of Jacob, the father of the twelve tribes of Israel, wrestling through an entire night with a certain man at the Jabbok River. In the Luther Bibles of Bach's day, Genesis 32 reads, Darang anman. There at the riverbank on the Jabbok, a possibly divine figure in the form of a man wrestled with him. According to Luther's radically Christocentric reading of the Hebrew scriptures, the figure with whom Jacob wrestled was actually Christ himself.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I don't know what to say about that other than you have layers upon layers upon layers of learning. There is so much to this music. You could start at Bach's models for this type of composition. You could look at just the notes themselves, just study the countenances. Or like this, you could dig deeply into the text and take a left turn into Lutheranism, and wherever you turn, the study will be endless. One lifetime is not enough. It's no wonder these Bach scholars write a giant book, like here's a thousand pages on So,

SPEAKER_01anyhow, this idea, wrestling, death vs. Christ, the final battle. We hear the notes of the four vocal lines in four different sounds in four different areas of your speaker. Just the MIDI, the chorale line here, the slow-moving melody, is in the altos, the second highest part, and it travels slower than the other parts, about twice as slow. So fix your ears on the slowest moving part in this battle between life and death.

SPEAKER_02Two voices. Three voices, warring on the field. Now here comes the slow melody.

SPEAKER_01Now pay attention to this music here. And this music here.

SPEAKER_02Here's Hallelujah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so it's beautiful music, even without the words, but when you put the words to it, all of a sudden these abstract shapes make even more sense. Where I first said, pay attention to this shape, the melody has this. In the auto, slow-moving, and the text is wie ein Tod denn an den Frass, how one death ate another or devoured another. Frass, fressen, they tell you in German class that the verb to use when animals eat something is fressen.

SPEAKER_01We humans, we essen, but animals fressen, so how they sort of like And before that long phrase comes, the chorale melody comes in the alto, the other three parts sort of commenting on everything, the warring parts, if you will. And they come in such close succession that you get this image, actually, of the other voices sort of eating each other.

SPEAKER_01So what you have here is the closest possible canonic imitation. You have the image of one voice eating the other one because I'm not even going to let you get out more than two voices before I'm just going to frass you. Okay, so that's the one thing. The second thing I pointed your attention to was when the altos sing. The text here, ein Spott aus den Tod ist worden.

SPEAKER_01Ein Spott. What's ein Spott? Ein Spott is a mockery. I wonder if it is etymologically related to a spot, as in just a dot or something, because there the texture becomes almost laughable. Ein Spott. Ein Spott. This is the counterpoint there. Like some silly children's piece. Imagine Bach sitting there saying a mockery. Hmm, what will I do? Well, I guess I'll write this really ridiculous sounding counterpoint.

SPEAKER_01See if we can hear that. We'll hear one voice eating another and then we'll hear the spot.

SPEAKER_01Okay, I think we're ready to listen to a recording. Now it will be René Jacobs and the Netherlands Bach Ensemble. Keeping in mind those two things, one death eating another in close canonic succession and a spot, the mockery of death. And of course, always listening for Hallelujah. And I'll remind us one more time of what Schweitzer says of this movement. We seem to see a knot of bodies in conflict as in a picture of Michelangelo.

SPEAKER_00CHOIR SINGS

SPEAKER_03CHOIR SINGS CHOIR SINGS

SPEAKER_03CHOIR SINGS

SPEAKER_01Wow, okay, just once more. One voice eating another. The mockery of death and hallelujah. Wow, hallelujah in this movement.

SPEAKER_00Wow.

SPEAKER_03. . .

SPEAKER_01Here is the true Easter lamb that God has offered, which high on the trunk of a cross is roasted in burning love, whose blood marks our doors, which faith holds in front of death. The strangler can harm us no more. Hallelujah. Wow. Roasted lamb, blood on the doors. We're obviously referencing Passover. And this is, again, from Melamed and Merison on Bach Cantata texts.org. Oster lamb literally would just be Easter lamb.

SPEAKER_01But Luther and Lutheranism equivocated to an extent, though, on whether the word Oster referred to the Christian festival of Easter or to the Jewish festival of Passover, with the latter also understood as prefiguring the former. Okay, so... The Jewish Passover pre-figures Christian Easter. And it goes on to say that in traditional Christianity, the Passover narrative in Exodus, including the marking of the doors with blood, is believed to foreshadow the crucifixion of Jesus.

SPEAKER_01The Paschal Lamb, Jesus, sheds blood as he is metaphorically roasted on the cross and his literal physical body and blood, according to the Lutheran belief, is then consumed in, with, among, under the consecrated elements in the sacrament of communion. Those who follow the Lamb, Jesus, are no longer enslaved to Egypt, sin, because the life-saving blood of the Lamb, Jesus, occasions God to pass over their door,

SPEAKER_01and such that in the cases the destroyer, death, Satan, does not carry out its destruction. Wow, I hope you don't mind me going so deeply into these notes on the text, but this is obviously something that Bach thought about. This deeply Bach, the great theologian, clearly understood this level of detail. I have never considered this level of detail when thinking about this music, but it's there. It's in there. Okay, but on to the music now. A bass aria with the strings above, and we will stop to discuss some word painting.

SPEAKER_01Well, I could stop it right there, actually, in the continuo. This is the passion motif. We will see this in the crucifixus. We see this in the lament aria, in the B-flat major capricio. This is passion music. So Bach, saying, here is the Easter lamb, begins this movement with steps down, steps down from Golgotha.

SPEAKER_00. . . .

SPEAKER_01On the Kreuzesstamm, on the crosses trunk, and when he says crosses, the bass. Makes this cross motif. This note here is crossed over by the C sharp and the A sharp. What are the other notes in all of the strings? E-sharp, G-sharp, C-sharp. What is sharp in German but a kreuz? So Bach quite seriously saying, I'm going to put kreuzes in all the parts and I'm going to have the bass make a little cross melody.

SPEAKER_01The music changes there. Bach painting the word, painting the word cross, kreuzes stump, the cross's trunk. Listen to that again.

SPEAKER_00Okay, I don't know if you can hear any roasting sounds.

SPEAKER_01Gebraten in the end of that phrase, but now you will certainly be able to hear the blood marking the doors. This is Le Banquet Celeste. This is Damien Gullion's recording. It's a live recording, and he really brings this out here, that the blood marks our door.

SPEAKER_00Das Blut zeichnet. Das Blut zeichnet. Das Blut zeichnet. . . . .

SPEAKER_01Are you getting an idea of how literal this word painting is? In the next beat, if I didn't stop to talk about it, we would hear this immediately. The faith that we have holding back death. So this blood that we have put on our doors, we have the faith that it will push back against death. Death will come onto our doors, but we will push back against it with this blood. And you will hear the drops of blood going immediately into the holding back, holding back. .

SPEAKER_00. .

SPEAKER_01That's not the ending yet. We still have to paint the strangler, and of course we still have to say hallelujah, but that was the word there, death. Death. How can we paint death? How about this? What is this interval? From this B here, I wasn't making that up. This B here, top of the range, down to this E sharp. What was this, a diminished twelfth?

SPEAKER_01This is a diminished twelfth. Ask your theory teacher if it's okay to write diminished twelfths in your vocal parts. From this painting of death to the strangler, der Wögler, and we will hear some very excited strangling in the violin parts, and then the end of the aria, hallelujah.

SPEAKER_00Hear it.

Yes, we heard the strangler there.

SPEAKER_01We heard him in the violin. He's trying to strangle us, but then the bass saying, nicht, nicht, he can't. No, he can't. And where did he go? Where did the violin go after that? This virgler, this strangler? He can't touch us. Hallelujah. Der

SPEAKER_00vierger kann uns nicht, nicht, nicht, nicht mehr schein.

SPEAKER_01So I'm looking at the time. I've been wondering if I should break this cantata into two episodes, but I think this one will just go long. I still have to cover the first movement that's the most exciting movement after all. And I'm going to just mention some legal housekeeping here because this is happening as I write and record this episode. So if you don't have time to listen for more than the hour, I want you to hear this announcement. My Spotify listeners, there's over 2,000 of you. Thank you. You might have to stop listening on Spotify or at least check at wtfbach.com to see

SPEAKER_01if you're caught up with all the episodes because Spotify has got this new bot. They're just, they violate the Spotify terms, so I combed through the terms. Well, this

SPEAKER_01show uses recordings that are not my recordings, as does every YouTube channel talking about music, as does every single account of social media talking about Beethoven or the Beatles or what have you. But since I'm a music commentary show, and since I comment on the music, I'm talking about the music, I'm mentioning specific things about the recordings, In other words, I'm not using Tom Koopman's cantatas as background music. I'm allowed to do this. And so is everyone with a music commentary show, obviously. Otherwise, how would you have any shows talking about music? So I filed appeals, and the appeals are rejected now, basically.

SPEAKER_01So yeah, three episodes have just been removed from Spotify, just like that, and maybe more to come. This is extremely frustrating. So you, if you're listening on Spotify, do me a favor, check to see which episodes there are. All the episodes should now be numbered. So if you see episode 145, 146, 148, then you know that episode 147 has been removed. Sorry to mention this in the midst of our battle between life and death,

SPEAKER_01but there's another battle going on between W.T.F. and A.I. So thanks for thinking about that. That's just another. So, back to the bonds of death. So,

SPEAKER_00. .

SPEAKER_03. . .

SPEAKER_03. . . . .

SPEAKER_01Thus we celebrate the high feast with joy in our hearts and delight that the Lord lets shine for us. He himself is the sun who through the brilliance of his grace enlightens our hearts completely. The might of sin has Disappeared, hallelujah. This rhythm here, this is what Schweitzer calls the rhythm of solemnity. So we go from this passion music to a solemn feast.

SPEAKER_01And in the following movement, we will actually eat and live well the Easter cakes. Let's translate this as Melamed and Merison. Do we eat and live well in Christ the proper Easter flatbread? So this proper Easter flatbread, the The expression Old Sourdough comes from 1st

SPEAKER_01All leaven is commanded in Exodus to be removed from home in the preparation for Passover, and sweet dough, as in unleavened dough, is commanded in Exodus to be employed to make the Paschal bread. So again, this idea of Passover and the Exodus leading to the Easter Feast, a dimension

SPEAKER_01Of which I was entirely unaware until I started looking into this cantata. Very fascinating. It is thought that maybe in the pre-Leipzig versions we went back to the first movement, but here in the Leipzig versions of 1724 and 25 we have our first four-part chorale, and I would like to sing it for you now.

SPEAKER_00With joyful heart we now surround the hallowed Easter table. The word of grace doth now confound the leaven old unstable. Christ alone will be our food for hungry souls the livelihood in faith none else is tenable.

SPEAKER_01I love doing that. I used to do that every day, in fact. We had a WhatsApp group with a bunch of musicians doing that every day, overdubbing yourself, singing a chorale. We went nearly for an entire year, and then it sort of fizzled out. But if you think that's a good idea, because singing through all Four parts of a four-part chorale is a great exercise for musicians. Sight singing and trying to tune with yourself from 15 seconds ago, that's amazing. So if I get a bunch of responses to this episode saying, hey, I want that chorale group to come back, maybe we could start another one. This time I think on Telegram because WhatsApp shares phone numbers.

SPEAKER_01So we want to protect some of our very famous members a bit. Anyhow, here's how it sounds when professional singers do the chorale. CHOIR SINGS

SPEAKER_01Masakai Suzuki there, from one legend to another, hears Philip Hervega. Notice how he pauses between every phrase on every fermata. The rest of the world is born.

. . . . .

SPEAKER_01Okay, shall we go on to the first movement? Easter news. Easter news. The melody in the soprano up high. It's the truth up high. Christ is risen. This is Easter Sunday. We hear the women scattering the news among the disciples beneath them. Did you hear? We went to the tune. We went to the tune. Here it starts.

. .

SPEAKER_03.

. . .

SPEAKER_03.

. . .

SPEAKER_03. . . .

SPEAKER_01I don't know what to say about this music. It's unbelievably overwhelming. I get so emotional while listening to it. I'm sorry if you feel like your captain on the airplane is... Crying because the sky is so beautiful. He's liable to crash the plane. Maybe let's just break it down a bit. There is so much going on, especially in the other parts, the string parts, very different from the vocal parts. So I'd like to play some of that for you. Why don't we start with the lower parts? There are two violas.

SPEAKER_01And the basso continuo. And as they go along, I will add the violins. You'll hear everyone talking to each other. The violas. Oh, did you hear about this? Did you hear about that? Yes, I did. Yes, I did. And then we add the violins. So it begins like this. There are the violas.

SPEAKER_01And if I add the chorale melody. That's the first part, now I'm gonna add the violins.

SPEAKER_01Now here, an instrumental interlude, right before the words that we should be happy. Listen to the change of mood. All the motors of joy, leaping in all the string parts, and then the soprano melody.

SPEAKER_02Listen to this happiness in the violins. . . .

SPEAKER_01Here's where they start singing hallelujah. Trading back and forth. More of it. We should be singing hallelujah, shouldn't we? Yes, we should. Some more. And then double time, hallelujah, hallelujah, and it goes faster in the recording and faster and faster, hallelujah, hallelujah, until you're out of your mind with ecstasy ululating toward the divine,

SPEAKER_01mouth open, sunshine. Very interesting to hear how different interpreters interpret that a la breve. Do you actually go twice as fast?

SPEAKER_01If you start this piece anything other than slowly, it's very difficult to go twice as fast. That recording there American Bach soloists, they don't go quite as fast as the other recording I first played, Rene Jacobson, the Netherlands Bach Ensemble. Anyhow, now I would like to play the string parts, those string parts that we dissected in various parts of your speaker, all in one area of your speaker against the vocal parts in the other area around that time when they start singing hallelujah. You hear the hallelujah, oh, there's a hallelujah, he's risen, he's risen, he's risen.

SPEAKER_01You hear the rumors starting in the strings, then passing it over to the vocals.

SPEAKER_00Twice as fast.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, something like that. Did you hear this in the violins? They start out the same toward the end, but then they have this beautiful... That reminds us of a few different orchestral effects we've seen in Cantata 106. So what else is there to say about this cantata? Let me see if I can think of anything else to say. Otherwise, we're just going to give this a wrap. Which do you like better, this one or Gottszeiteste Allabestezeit? That's number 106.

SPEAKER_01Is this a wrap? Is this a decent survey to Bach's first forays into the cantata genre? Yeah, had to listen up to this point, and I will indeed stop the episode here. Next week, before moving on, however, I will do a conclusionary episode on all these early cantatas, a big overview of what we've just been through in the past few months. So if you've thought of something I missed, or if you really want to hear, say, alto and bassoon in MIDI, From cantata number whatever,

SPEAKER_01let me know in the Substack comments, and I will make that wish come true. Does the four-part chorale telegram group tickle your fancy? And yes, unfortunate news about the Spotify AI. Really surprising, really annoying, that just some poof, poof, just some episode's gone. So please check the episode numbers, see if there's something missing. Listen on wtfbach.com if you can help it, and many thanks for listening in general. Thanks.

SPEAKER_00All relevant links are found in this episode's description. Give us a shout at bach at wtfbach.com. So thank you for listening.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 154: The Trinity Seen In A Prelude

    Nov 10, 20261 hrAudio

    The opening piece in Clavier-Übung III! A massive prelude with three parts. The three ideas are a representation of the trinity. Here is God the Father at the opening, full organ, dotted rhythms, pedals, lots of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 153: Clavier-Übung III! A New Series.

    Nov 3, 202645 minAudio

    Welcome to a new series on Bach’s first and most comprehensive published collection of organ music, the so-called, ‘Organ Mass,’ more accurately known as, Clavier-Übung III. Got Bach? The title page reads: Third Part of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. 152: Bach’s Obituary (1754)

    Oct 27, 202638 minAudio

    One of the most important documents we posses about J.S. Bach - indeed the first biographical writing - is his obituary, written by his son, C.P.E., and his student, Agricola. Also referred to as the ‘Nekrolog,’ the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. (Rant) ‘More Than Food.’

    Oct 19, 20267 minAudio

    The music at the end is BWV 600, from a forthcoming ‘electrified’ arrangement of Bach’s Orgelbüchlein. The beautiful passage toward the end of my rant - with the koto accompaniment and bird song - comes from one of my...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 151: New Album! (& New Sonic Experience?)

    Oct 13, 202644 minAudio

    Volume 6 in ‘J.S. Bach: Complete Keyboard Works’ is on presale today! Here are the relevant links: * J.S. Bach: Complete Keyboard Works, Vol. 6 - Arrangements of Albinoni and...

    Credit the people on this episode