Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

WTF Bach

WTF Bach artwork

152: Bach’s Obituary (1754)

Oct 27, 202638 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

One of the most important documents we posses about J.S. Bach - indeed the first biographical writing - is his obituary, written by his son, C.P.E., and his student, Agricola. Also referred to as the ‘Nekrolog,’ the obituary appeared in Mizler’s (yes, the Society of Musical Sciences gentleman) publication, Musikalische Bibliothek, in its very last installment. In this brief portrait of the greatest composer, we are struck by the renown of his family tree, the unanimous admiration of all those who heard Bach, but ultimately by the humility of his spirit despite his towering achievements. Write That Fugue! The obituary is also important because it contains Bach’s ‘first list of works.’ The five cantata cycles and five passions mentioned in the list are addressed in this article on Bach’s missing works: We Rely Exclusively on Paid Subscriptions! Help WTF Bach endure:Join at WTFBach.comYou can also make a one-time donation here:https://www.paypal.me/wtfbachhttps://venmo.com/wtfbach A new Telegram group is slowly forming! Singing through chorales and doing other cool Bachian things. Join here: https://t.me/+86a_lET5XKdmYTk0 Spotify Listeners: New AI software has unjustly removed episodes. They are deaf to appeals. Stick it to the robot by listening on the Substack app.Thank you for your support! Get full access to W.T.F. Bach? at wtfbach.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_02This is W.T.F. Bach. Work those fingers. Write that fugue. Wow, that's fabulous.

SPEAKER_01This is the podcast about all things Johann Sebastian Bach.

SPEAKER_02Why don't you let W.T.F. Bach guide your mind?

SPEAKER_01Join W.T.F.

SPEAKER_02Bach as he guides your mind through a contrapuntal journey. And now, let's hear from W.T.F.

SPEAKER_00Bach. W.T.F. Bach here. It's Evan. Thanks for listening. Glad you're here. I'm stalling. Stalling in bringing you our series on Clavier Übung 3, the organ mass. Well, I guess I'm not stalling, but I'm currently doing some research and planning and finding out the best way to present this very deep material to you over the upcoming weeks. So today I thought I would present something that needs no planning on my part, but it is a completely essential part of understanding Bach.

SPEAKER_00Indeed, sort of the beginning, the ur-text of Bach scholarship, really, which is Bach's obituary. I'm going to read you Bach's obituary. If scholarship is... Looking at documents, lining them up, comparing what people have said, and trying to paint this picture from writings that have been scattered throughout history, you inevitably always end up going back to the first layer of that, the earliest stuff, and Bach's This obituary is the first time in history

SPEAKER_00that anyone is writing extensively about Bach's life. Before the obituary, we have only a few statements here and there, comments and remarks from people who heard him live. But this obituary is an extended piece of biography compiled not only by people who knew him, but by one of his sons, C.P.E., Carl Philipp Emanuel, and one of his last students and important copyists, Johann Friedrich Agricola. These two gentlemen wrote the obituary immediately after Bach's death,

SPEAKER_00but it wasn't published until four years later. I imagine many of you have read Bach's obituary, or at least were supposed to have read it. That's the type of thing you are definitely assigned to read in music history class. It is a very important historical document. Just a wonderful biopic, you know? It really paints the picture of the personality of Bach. It's a really beautiful piece of writing. But if you're anything like me, hearing something read has a different way of sticking in your head

SPEAKER_00than reading something. And I myself have never read the obituary aloud, so this will be fun for me too. Hope you enjoy this Bach's obituary. Here we go. The world-famous organist, Mr. Johann Sebastian Bach, Royal Polish and Electoral Saxon court composer and music director in Leipzig. Obituary by C.P.E. Bach and Agricola, published in 1754.

SPEAKER_00Johann Sebastian Bach belongs to a family that seems to have received a love and aptitude for music as a gift of nature to all its members in common. So much is certain That fight Bach, the founder of the family, and all his descendants, even to the present seventh generation, have been devoted to music, and all save perhaps a very few have made it their profession. This fight had been expelled from Hungary in the 16th century for religious reasons,

SPEAKER_00and had later settled in Turingia. Many of his descendants have also made their homes in that province. Among the many members of the Bach family who have excelled in practical music, as well as the building of new musical instruments, the following, in addition to our Johann Sebastian, are particularly noteworthy for their composition. Heinrich Bach, an organist in Arnstadt who died in 1692. And his two sons, Johann Christoph,

SPEAKER_00organist of the court and town of Eisenach, who died in 1703, and Johann Michael, organist and clerk in the district of Geren, Johann Sebastian's first father-in-law. Johann Ludwig Bach, capelmeister to the Duke of Menningen. Johann Bernhard Bach, chamber musician and organist in Eisenach, who entered into eternity in 1749. Of all these men, we still have works at hand, bearing witness to their strength in vocal as well as instrumental composition.

SPEAKER_00The aforesaid Johann Christoph particularly was strong in the invention of beautiful ideas as well as in the expression of the meaning of the words. His writing was, so far as the taste of his day permitted, gallant and singing as well as remarkably polyphonous. To the first point, a motet written nearly 70-odd years ago, in which, apart from other fine ideas, he had the courage to use the augmented sixth may bear witness, and the second point is borne out just as remarkably by a church piece composed

SPEAKER_00by him for 22 obligato voices without the slightest violence to the purest harmony, and by the fact that both on the organ and on the clavier he never played in fewer than five real parts. Johann Bernard wrote many fine overtures in the manner of Telemann. It would be a matter for astonishment that such excellent men should be so little known outside their native land if one did not remember that these honest Tyringians were so well satisfied with their native land and

SPEAKER_00with their situation in life that they did not even dare to wander far to seek their fortune. They gladly preferred the approval of the rulers in whose domains they were born, and the approval of a throng of their faithful countrymen who were close at hand to the uncertain manifestations of praise that they might gather, at great pains and expense, from a few perhaps even envious foreigners. Meanwhile, the obligation we have of establishing and keeping fresh the memory of worthy men will sufficiently excuse us to those

SPEAKER_00who may have found this little excursion into the musical history of the Bach family too lengthy. We return to our Johann Sebastian. He was born in the year 1685 on March 21st in Eisenach. His parents were Johann Ambrosius Bach, court and town musicians there, and Elisabeth, née Lemehert, the daughter of a town official in Erfurt. His father had a twin brother named Johann Christoph, who was court and town musician in Arnstadt.

SPEAKER_00The two brothers were so much alike in every respect, even as concerns their health, their knowledge of music, that when they were together they could be distinguished only by their clothing. Johann Sebastian was not yet ten years old when he found himself bereft of his parents by death. He betook himself to Ordruf, where his eldest brother Johann Christoph was an organist, and under this brother's guidance he laid the foundation The love of our little Johann Sebastian for music was uncommonly great even

SPEAKER_00at this tender age. In a short time he had fully mastered all the pieces his brother had voluntarily given him to learn. This book was kept in a cabinet whose doors consisted only of grillwork.

SPEAKER_00Now, with his little hands, he could reach through the grillwork and roll the book up, for it had only a paper cover. Accordingly, he would fetch the book out at night, and when everyone had gone to bed, and since he was not even possessed of a light, copy it by moonlight. In six months' time he had these musical spoils in his own hands. Secretly and with extraordinary eagerness he was trying to put it to use when his brother, to his great dismay, found out about it and without mercy took away from him the copy he had made

SPEAKER_00with such pains. We may gain a good idea of our little Johann Sebastian's sorrow over this loss by imagining a miser whose ship sailing for Peru has foundered with its cargo of $100,000. He did not recover the book until after the death of his brother in 1721, but did not this very passion to improve himself in music and the very industry applied to the aforesaid book perhaps by coincidence provide the first basis for the cause of his own death, as we shall later hear.

SPEAKER_00After the death of his brother, Johann Sebastian took himself in company with one of his school fellows named Ertmann, who not many years since departed this life as Baron and Imperial Russian resident minister in Danzig to the St. Michael Gymnasium in Lüneburg. In Lüneburg, our Bach, because of his uncommonly fine soprano voice, was well received. Sometime thereafter, as he was singing in the choir, and without his knowledge or will, there was once heard, with the soprano tones that he had to execute, the lower octave of the same.

SPEAKER_00He kept this quite new species of voice for eight days, during which he could neither speak nor sing except in octaves. Thereupon he lost his fine soprano tones, and with them his fine voice. From Lüneburg he journeyed now and again to Hamburg to hear then the famous organist of St. Catherine's Johann Adam Reincken, and here too he had the opportunity to go and listen to then a famous band kept by the Duke of Zelle, consisting for the most part of Frenchmen.

SPEAKER_00Thus he acquired a thorough grounding in the French taste, which in those regions was at the time something quite new. In the year 1703 he came to Weimar and there became a musician of the court. The next year he received the post of organist in the new church in Arnstadt. Here he really showed the first fruits of his application to the art of organ playing and to composition, which he had chiefly learned by the observation of the works of the most famous and proficient composers of his day,

SPEAKER_00and by the fruits of his own reflection upon them. In the art of the organ, he took the works of Bruns, Reinken, Buxtehude, and several good French organists as models. While he was in Arnstadt, he was once moved by a particularly strong desire to hear as many good organists as he could, so he undertook a journey on foot to Lübeck in order to listen to the famous organist of St. Mary's Church there, Dietrich Buxtehude. He tarried there, not without profit, for almost a quarter of a year and then returned to Arnstadt.

SPEAKER_00In the year 1707 he was called as organist to the church of St. Blasius in Mühlhausen, but this town was not to have the pleasure of holding him long, for in the following year, 1708, he undertook a journey to Weimar, had the opportunity to be heard by the reigning duke, and was offered the post of chamber and court organist in Weimar, of which post he immediately took possession. The pleasure his grace took in his playing fired him with the desire to try every possible artistry in his treatment of the organ.

SPEAKER_00Here, too, he wrote most of his organ works. In the year 1714, he was named Concert Master at the same court. Now the functions connected with this post then consisted mainly in composing church pieces and performing them. In Weimar, he also trained various competent organists, among whom Johann Kasper Vogler, his second successor there, deserves to be especially noticed. After the death of Zachau, music director and organist at the Market Church in Halle,

SPEAKER_00Bach received a call to take his post. He indeed did journey to Halle and produced his trial work there, but he found reasons to reject this post, which thereupon was filled by Gottfried Kirchhoff. The year 1717 gave our already so famous Bach a new opportunity to achieve still further honor. Marchand, the clavier player and organist famous in France, had come to Dresden, had let himself be heard by the king with exceptional success,

SPEAKER_00and was so fortunate as to be offered a highly paid post in the royal service. The concertmaster in Dresden at the time, Jean-Baptiste Volumier, wrote to Bach, whose merits were not unknown to him, at Weimar, and invited him to come forthwith to Dresden in order to engage in a musical contest for superiority. Bach, thereupon, invited,

SPEAKER_00Marchand to a contest, in a courteous letter in which he declared himself ready to execute extemporary whatever musical tasks Marchand should set him, and in turn expressed his expectation that Marchand would show the same willingness, certainly a proof of great daring. Marchand showed himself quite ready to accept the invitation. The time and place were set, not without the foreknowledge of the king. Bach appeared at the appointed time at the scene of the contest, in the home of a leading minister of state, where a large company of persons of high rank and of both sexes was assembled.

SPEAKER_00There was a long wait for Marchand. Finally, the host sent to Marchand's quarters to remind him, in case he should have forgotten, that it was now time for him to show himself a man. But it was learned, to the great astonishment of everyone, that M. Marchand had, very early in the morning of the same day, left Dresden by a special coach. Bach, who thus remained sole master of the scene of the contest, accordingly had plentiful opportunity to exhibit the talents with which he was armed

SPEAKER_00against his opponent, and this he did to the astonishment of all present men. The king had intended to present him on this occasion with five hundred toller, but through the dishonesty of a certain servant who believed that he could use this gift to better advantage, he was deprived of it, and had to take back with him, as sole reward of his efforts, the honor he had won. Strange fate. A Frenchman voluntarily abandons a permanent salary offered to him amounting to more than a thousand dollar, and the German, to whom the former by his flight certainly seem to have conceded the preference,

SPEAKER_00cannot even obtain possession of the one special gift intended for him by the favor of the king. For the rest, our Bach willingly credited Marchand with a reputation of fine and very proper playing. Whether, however, Marchand's Musettes for Christmas Eve, the composition and playing of which is said to have contributed most to his fame in Paris, would have been able to hold the field before connoisseurs against Bach's multiple fugues, that may be decided by those who heard both men in their prime.

SPEAKER_00In this same year, after our Bach had returned to Weimar, the reigning Prince Leopold of Anhalt-Kürten, a great connoisseur and amateur of music, called him to be his capelmeister. He entered forthwith upon the duties of this post, which he filled for almost six months. St. Catharines. . . .

SPEAKER_00. I thought that this art was dead, but I see that in you it still lives.

SPEAKER_00This verdict of Reinken's was the more unexpected since he himself had set the same corral many years before in the manner described above, and this fact, as also that otherwise he had always been somewhat inclined to be envious, was not unknown to Arbach. Reinken thereupon pressed him to visit and showed him much courtesy. The town of Leipzig chose Arbach in the year 1723 as its music director and cantor at the St. Thomas School. He heeded this call, although he was loath to leave his gracious prince.

SPEAKER_00Providence seemed to wish to remove him from Curtin before the death. But he had the sad satisfaction of preparing in Leipzig the funeral music for the prince, whom he had loved so dearly, and of performing it in person in Curtin. Not long thereafter, the Duke of Weissenfels appointed him to be his kapelmeister, and in the year 1736 he was named Royal Polish and Electoral Saxon Court Composer,

SPEAKER_00that is, after he had let himself be heard variously at Dresden, playing the organ publicly and with great success before the court and the connoisseurs of music of that city. In the year 1747 he made a journey to Berlin, and on this occasion had the opportunity of being heard at Potsdam by His Majesty the King in Prussia. His Majesty himself played for him a theme for a fugue which he at once developed to the particular pleasure of the monarch on the pianoforte.

SPEAKER_00Hereupon His Majesty demanded to hear a fugue with six obligato voices which command he also fulfilled to the astonishment of the king and the musicians there present using a theme of his own. After his return to Leipzig, he set down on paper a three-voiced and a six-voiced so-called Richard Carr, together with several other intricate little pieces, all on the very theme that had been given to him by his majesty, and this he dedicated engraved on copper to the king. His naturally somewhat weak eyesight further weakened by his unheard of zeal

SPEAKER_00in studying, which made him particularly in his youth sit at work the whole night through, led in his last years to an eye disease. He wished to rid himself. And partly on the advice of some of his friends who placed great confidence in an oculist who had recently arrived in Leipzig. But the operation, although it had to be repeated, turned out very badly.

SPEAKER_00Not only could he no longer use his eyes, but his whole system, which was otherwise thoroughly healthy, was completely overthrown by the operation and by the addition of harmful medicaments and other things, so that thereafter he was almost continuously ill for a half a year. Ten days before his death his eyes suddenly seemed better so that one morning he could see quite well again and could also endure the light. But a few hours later he suffered a stroke and this was followed by a raging fever. As a victim of which,

SPEAKER_00despite every possible care given to him by two of the most skillful physicians of Leipzig, on the 28th of July, 1750, a little after a quarter past eight in the evening, in the 66th year of his life, he quietly and peacefully, by the merit of his Redeemer, departed this life. The works we owe to this great composer are, in the first place, the following which have been made generally available by means of copper engraving.

SPEAKER_001. The first part of the clavier-übung consisting of six suites. 2. The second part of the clavier-übung consisting of a concerto and an overture for the harpsichord with two manuals. 3. The third part of the clavier-übung consisting of various preludes on some church hymns for the organ. 4. An aria with 30 variations for two manuals. 5. Six three-voiced preludes on as many hymns for the organ.

SPEAKER_006. Some canonic variations on the hymn Von Himmelhoch da Kommich Her. 7. Two fugues, a trio, and several canons on the above-mentioned theme given by His Majesty the King of Prussia under the title Musical Offering. The Art of the Fugue. This is the last work of the author, which contains all sorts of counterpoints and canons on a single principal subject. His last illness prevented him from completing his project of bringing

SPEAKER_00the next-to-last fugue to completion, and working out the last one, which was to contain four themes and to have been afterward inverted note for note in all four voices. This work saw the light of day only after the death of the late author. 3. Five Passions.

SPEAKER_00Of which one is for double chorus. Four, some double chorus motets. Five, a lot of free preludes, fugues, and similar pieces for organ with obligato pedal. Six, six trios for the organ with obligato pedal. Seven, many preludes on corrals for the organ. Eight, a book of short preludes on mostly church hymns for the organ. Nine, twice 24 preludes and fugues in all keys for the clavier. Ten, six staccatas for the clavier.

SPEAKER_00Eleven, six suites for the same. Twelve, six more of the same, somewhat shorter. Thirteen, six sonatas for the violin, without bass. Fourteen, six of the same for the violoncello. Fifteen, various concertos for one, two, three, and four harpsichords. Sixteen, finally a mass of other instrumental pieces of all sorts and for all kinds of instruments. Our Bach was twice married, the first time with Mistress Maria Barbara, youngest daughter of the above-mentioned Johann Michael Bach, a worthy composer.

SPEAKER_00By this wife, he begot seven children, namely five sons and two daughters, among whom were a pair of twins. Three of these children are still living, namely the eldest unmarried daughter, Katharina Dortea, born in 1708, Wilhelm Friedemann, born in 1710, now music director and organist at the Market Church in Halle, and Carl Philip Emanuel, born in 1714, royal Prussian chamber musician. After 13 years of blissful married life with his first wife, The misfortune overtook him in the year 1720 upon his return to Curtin from

SPEAKER_00a journey with his prince to Carlsbad of finding her dead and buried. Although he had left her hale and hardy on his departure, the news that she had been ill and died reached him only when he entered his own house. He took for his second wife in Curtin in the year 1721, Mistress Anna Magdalena, youngest daughter of Mr. Johann Caspar Wilken, court trumpeter to the Duke of Weissenfalls. Of thirteen children, namely six sons and seven daughters, The following six are still alive.

SPEAKER_00Gottfried Heinrich, born in 1724, Elisabeth Julian Friedrich, born in 1726, and married to the organist of St. Wenzel's in Namburg, Mr. Altnikal, a skilled composer. Johann Christoph Friedrich, born in 1732, now chamber musician to the Imperial Court in Schaumburg-Lippe. Johann Christian, born in 1735. Johanna Caroline, born in 1737. And Regina Susanna, born in 1742. The widow is also still living.

SPEAKER_00This is the brief description of the life of a man who contributed quite exceptionally to the honor of music, of his fatherland, and of his family. If ever a composer showed polyphony in its greatest strength, it was certainly our late, lamented Bach. If ever a musician employed the most hidden secrets of harmony with the most skilled artistry, it was certainly our Bach. He never showed so many ingenious and unusual ideas as he in elaborate pieces such as ordinarily seemed dry exercises in craftsmanship.

SPEAKER_00He needed only to have heard any theme to be aware it seemed in the same instant of almost every intricate . . . . .

SPEAKER_00His constant practice in the working out of polyphonic pieces had given his eye such faculty that even in the largest scores he could take in all the simultaneously sounding parts at a glance. His hearing was so fine that he was able to detect the slightest error even in the largest ensembles. It is but a pity that it was only seldom he had the good fortune of finding a body of such performers as could have spared him his unpleasant discoveries of this nature. In conducting he was very accurate,

SPEAKER_00and of the tempo which he generally took very lively he was uncommonly sure. So long as we can be offered in contradiction no more than the mere suggestion of the possible existence of better organists and clavier players, so long we cannot be blamed if we are bold enough to declare that our Bach was the greatest organist and clavier player that we have ever had. It may be that many a famous man has accomplished much in polyphony upon this instrument. Is he therefore just as skillful in both hands and feet, just as skillful as Bach was?

SPEAKER_00This doubt will not be considered unfounded by anyone who ever had the pleasure of hearing both him and others and is not carried away by prejudice. And anyone who looks at Bach's organ and clavier pieces, which, as is generally known, he himself performed with the greatest perfection, will also not find much to object to in the sentence above. How strange, how new, how expressive, how beautiful were his ideas in improvising, how perfectly he realized them. All his fingers were equally skillful and were equally capable of

SPEAKER_00the most perfect accuracy in performance. He had devised himself so convenient a system of fingering that it was not hard for him to conquer the greatest difficulties with the most flowing facility. Before him, the most famous clavier players in Germany and other lands had used the thumb but little. All the better did he know how to use it. With his two feet, he could play things on the pedals that many not unskillful clavier players would find it bitter enough to have to play with five fingers.

SPEAKER_00He not only understood the art of playing the organ in combining the various stops of that instrument in the most skillful manner and of displaying each stop according to its character in the greatest perfection, but he also knew the construction of organs from one end to the other. This latter knowledge he demonstrated particularly on one occasion, among others, at the trial of a new organ in the church not far from which his earthly remains now lie. The builder of this instrument was a man who was in the last years of his long life.

SPEAKER_00The trial was perhaps one of the most exacting ever made. Accordingly, a complete approval that Arbach expressed about the instrument did no slight honor both to the organ builder and, because of certain circumstances, to Bach himself. No one could draw up or judge dispositions for new organs better than he, but despite all this knowledge of the organ, he never enjoyed the good fortune, as he used to point out frequently with regret, of having a really large and beautiful organ at his constant disposal.

SPEAKER_00. . . . . Of his moral character, those may speak who enjoyed association and friendship with him and were witnesses

SPEAKER_00to his uprightness toward God and his neighbor. He joined the Society of Musical Sciences in the year 1747 in the month of June at the Our lately departed Bach did not, it is true, occupy himself with deep theoretical He also presented to the Society the canon reproduced in Table 4, page 16, and he would undoubtedly had done much more had not the shortness of time.

SPEAKER_00He was a member for only three years prevented him from doing so. So many little gems in there, more mentions than I remember of his abilities to improvise.

SPEAKER_00But how wonderful is that, that he could perfectly execute these ideas. And of course, the story of the contest between Marchand is hilarious. And how strange his melodies and how they sounded like no one else's. There's even that moment when the writers wax poetic. They go, how strange, how odd. The tuning of the harpsichord, that he found a way to tune it so that every tonality was beautiful, so that he could play in every key, and his conducting, that he took brisk tempos. You can mention that to the band you're in as they drag and make dirges out

SPEAKER_00of Bach pieces, that Bach himself took lively tempos. It's right there in the obituary. It says it. And of course his ability to hear the slightest flub in a huge ensemble, that is quite a skill. That is not an exaggerated skill, I've seen it once in my life. Pierre Boulez conducted the Juilliard Orchestra in this open rehearsal of Bartók, and in the middle of this giant chord, like the whole room is shaking with sound, he says, stop, oboe and second clarinet play, they play. A very out of tune unison. And he says, you see, you're playing the same note.

SPEAKER_00You should tune to each other. Now everyone again, the big chord, but then it sounded better. Everyone in the audience looked at each other like, what is that? I've seen that in real life. I've seen someone be able to hear a wall of sound. Realize what was wrong with it, open it up, dissect it, perform a surgery, put it back together. If Boulez could do it, Bach could do that. It makes you realize that these stories are not like epics or fairy tales. They are not exaggerated. He really could do that.

SPEAKER_00He really did improvise a six-part fugue on the spot to the astonishment of all present. And how... How come I don't remember this? How come I've never mentioned this on the podcast? The part where Bach could speak and sing in parallel octaves for eight days? What is that? That is a pretty wild story. It's when you... I guess I shouldn't try and do it into this microphone where you're trying to move from your head voice into your chest voice and just get that thing going just on the breaking point so that you can,

SPEAKER_00you know, after about 45 minutes of annoying everyone around you, you can have that polyphonic singing thing happening. That is pretty cool. Well, Bach did that for eight days. And I suppose I found this reading, this narrative device, maybe this genuine artistic choice on CPE and Agricola's part of framing the whole obituary with the Copying music by moonlight with the fact that he was 10 he used these eyes by moonlight very bad for your eyes

SPEAKER_00and even this devotion wore him down to his eventual death it paints a portrait of a worker of a real studious A person, a student. Of course, the most famous part of the obituary is the first list of works. Those are all the pieces that they mention in the middle. This is called the first list of works because this is the first time where we have people near him saying, this is everything he wrote. And the first section, all the published works, the four parts, the Klavierübung, the Schubler chorales, von Himmelhoch variations, musical offering, Artifugue, not complicated.

SPEAKER_00We have all those. We know them because they were published. But this second section, the unpublished works, this has been a source of pain and confusion for many years. Mostly because it's written five cantata cycles, five passions. Five passions. Matthew, John, Luke, Mark, and Steve. What is this? We, of course, know many works went missing between 1754 and now. We also have to take into account that something...

SPEAKER_00Written 300 years ago, even if it's a number, even like the number five, might not mean really five completely unique works. I wrote about this extensively in a post called Bach's Lost Works, How Much Is Missing? And I examine this number, five passions, five cantata cycles. I will include that link in the episode description. Finally, it seemed... So very important for the obituary to point out the accomplishments of the family,

SPEAKER_00and they even excuse themselves for saying, pardon us for going so deeply or even touching on the Bach family, but we felt like we should do it. To point out that the honest Thuringians, these people were not hell-bent on fame or going abroad, but they were just fine and content in Thuringia where they were. As I learn more about Bach, as I try and realize more of his spirit, I think that that idea is reflected here, this idea of being grounded and not being dazzled by fame and fortune,

SPEAKER_00but just being focused on the competency and going as deep as you can in your craft. That really reminds me of Bach, as I'm understanding him these days. It's like... 17th, 18th century Japan when they just closed the borders. It said, no one's leaving and no one's getting in. And yet you saw this remarkable flourishing of creativity. Well, that was Bach. Maybe it's a bit of a stretch. I know he went to Lübeck when he needed to.

SPEAKER_00He went and he got a few of these things when he needed to. But most of it, you know, he just stayed there, focused. Maybe it's a bit of a stretch to connect 17th century Thuringian polyphonic organ playing with Thanks for listening. Be sure to sign up at WTFBach. Sign up at WTFBach.com. And be sure to check the episode description for helpful images and links.

[music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. 154: The Trinity Seen In A Prelude

    Nov 10, 20261 hrAudio

    The opening piece in Clavier-Übung III! A massive prelude with three parts. The three ideas are a representation of the trinity. Here is God the Father at the opening, full organ, dotted rhythms, pedals, lots of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. 153: Clavier-Übung III! A New Series.

    Nov 3, 202645 minAudio

    Welcome to a new series on Bach’s first and most comprehensive published collection of organ music, the so-called, ‘Organ Mass,’ more accurately known as, Clavier-Übung III. Got Bach? The title page reads: Third Part of...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. (Rant) ‘More Than Food.’

    Oct 19, 20267 minAudio

    The music at the end is BWV 600, from a forthcoming ‘electrified’ arrangement of Bach’s Orgelbüchlein. The beautiful passage toward the end of my rant - with the koto accompaniment and bird song - comes from one of my...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. 151: New Album! (& New Sonic Experience?)

    Oct 13, 202644 minAudio

    Volume 6 in ‘J.S. Bach: Complete Keyboard Works’ is on presale today! Here are the relevant links: * J.S. Bach: Complete Keyboard Works, Vol. 6 - Arrangements of Albinoni and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. 150: The Early Cantatas, All Summed Up.

    Oct 6, 202641 minAudio

    We’ve now covered the seven surviving earliest vocal works by Johann Sebastian Bach! This episode is a brief tour through the episodes we dedicated to these pieces, refreshing our memories and attempting to identify...

    Credit the people on this episode