In this episode of Varn Vlog, you and Brandon Lightly analyze the failures of the "New Democracy" and "National Front" strategies as globalized Marxist frameworks. Key points include: Indonesia: D.N. Aidit’s PKI collapsed because they mistakenly empowered a mass movement while failing to neutralize the military's hostile command structure. The Philippines: The NDFP’s program prioritized state-regulated capitalism and tariff protection for domestic bourgeoisie over systemic socialist transformation. Nepal: The Maoist party utilized the "New Democracy" label to justify transitioning into a standard, market-dependent capitalist state after 2006. Right-Wing Inversion: The organizational structures of popular fronts and Leninist centralization have been repurposed by right-wing movements to advance integral nationalism and corporate-welfare states. Works Cited: Foundations of the United, Popular, and National Fronts Fourth Congress of the Communist International. (1922, December). Theses on Comintern tactics. In J. Degras (Ed.), The Communist International, 1919-1943: Documents (Vol. 1). Oxford University Press. Dimitrov, G. (1935). The fascist offensive and the tasks of the Communist International in the struggle of the working class against fascism. Foreign Languages Publishing House. Executive Committee of the Communist International. (1921, December). Theses on the unity of the proletarian front. International Press Correspondence, 2(2), 11-14. Mao, Z. (1965). On new democracy. In Selected works of Mao Tse-tung (Vol. 2, pp. 339-384). Foreign Languages Press. (Original work published 1940). Pre-Marxist, Right-Wing, and Nationalist Lineage Barrès, M. (1902). Scènes et doctrines du nationalisme [Scenes and doctrines of nationalism]. Émile-Paul Frères. Maurras, C. (1900). Enquête sur la monarchie [Enquiry into the monarchy]. Nouvelle Librairie Nationale. Maurras, C. (1937). Mes idées politiques [My political ideas]. Fayard. Moeller van den Bruck, A. (1971). Germany's Third Empire (E. O. Lorimer, Trans.). Howard Fertig. (Original work published 1923). Niekisch, E. (Ed.). (1926-1934). Widerstand: Zeitschrift für nationalrevolutionäre Politik [Resistance: Journal for National-Revolutionary Politics]. Widerstand-Verlag. Nepal Dahal, P. K. [Prachanda]. (2004). Problems of the development of revolution in Nepal. In Selected Works of Prachanda (Vol. 1). Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist). Ogura, K. (2008). Seeking state power through communism: The strategic evolution of the CPN (Maoist) (Asiatic 14). Political Transitions in Asia. Thapa, D., & Sijapati, B. (2004). A kingdom under siege: Nepal's Maoist insurgency, 1996-2004. Zed Books. Cambodia Chandler, D. P. (1992). Brother Number One: A political biography of Pol Pot. Westview Press. Kiernan, B. (2004). The Pol Pot regime: Race, power, and genocide in Cambodia under the Khmer Rouge, 1975-79 (2nd ed.). Yale University Press. Pol Pot. (1977). Long live the 17th anniversary of the Communist Party of Kampuchea. Democratic Kampuchea Ministry of Foreign Affairs. 3. The Philippines Guerrero, A. [Sison, J. M.]. (1970). Philippine society and revolution. Ta Kung Pao. National Democratic Front of the Philippines. (1985). Program of the National Democratic Front of the Philippines. NDFP Secretariat. Weekley, K. (2001). The Communist Party of the Philippines, 1968-1993: A story of its theory and practice. University of the Philippines Press. India Banerjee, S. (1980). In the wake of Naxalbari: A history of the Naxalite movement in India. Subarnarekha. Communist Party of India (Maoist). (2004). Party programme. CPI (Maoist) Central Committee. Kennedy, J. (2018). The liberalized state and the path of rebellion: A comparative assessment of the Maoist insurgency in India. Routledge. IV. Broad Scholarly Histories & Historiography Carr, E. H. (1982). The twilight of Comintern, 1930-1935. Macmillan. Denning, M. (1996). The cultural front: The laboring of American culture in the twentieth century. Verso. Priestland, D. (2009). The red flag: A history of communism. Grove Press. Sternhell, Z. (1986). Neither right nor left: Fascist ideology in France (D. Maisel, Trans.). Princeton University Press. Send us Fan Mail Musis by Bitterlake, Used with Permission, all rights to Bitterlake Support the show Crew: Host: C. Derick Varn Intro and Outro Music by Bitter Lake. Intro Video Design: Jason Myles Art Design: Corn and C. Derick Varn Links and Social Media: twitter: @varnvlog blue sky: @varnvlog.bsky.social You can find the additional streams on Youtube Current Patreon at the Sponsor Tier: Jordan Sheldon, Mark J. Matthews, Lindsay Kimbrough, RedWolf, DRV, Kenneth McKee, JY Chan, Matthew Monahan, Parzival, Adriel Mixon, Buddy Roark, Daniel Petrovic,Julian, Drea, Free Beer, SNT-BRCH, Joshua Parsons
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
C. Derick VarnAll right, so we are back. Brennan Lightly and I are going to be talking about new democracy outside of China because we kind of covered it within China and then the National Fronts, which is going to be complicated because the National Front, to me, has a dual track history that come that collapses into itself in a weird way in the late 80s. But the reason why I wanted to talk about the new democracy outside of China first was that I think it sets up the Marxian form of the National Front.
C. Derick VarnBut we're gonna have to talk about the other forms of national fronts that formed on the right before the Marxist form. Then you have the Marxist form predominating, then you have a new like synthesis of the two, unfortunately, in Europe and the 1980s and 90s. It is kind of a nightmare. But I wanted to talk about new democracy outside of China, and I'm not gonna go very deep into it, but I wanted to talk about the Philippines, Indonesia, and Nepal.
C. Derick VarnAnd let's start with Indonesia. So new democracy, as we admit it, is a highly specific thing. China had it very delimited in time, yet it showed back up a lot because the the idea of like a coalition of X number of classes became super popular as a national liberation issue, particularly in Southeast Asia.
C. Derick VarnUnfortunately, for those of us talking about Southeast Asia, unlike East Asia, this almost never went well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah.
C. Derick VarnSo, like we can talk about like this kind of national front and Vietnam and whatnot, but when we look at like Indonesia, the Philippines, and India, Nepal. I guess we could talk about India too. Uh it's also unclear to me whether I should include include Peru in this. What do you think?
SPEAKER_03So I've I feel like I've thought about South America a lot when it comes to and I almost there's a part of me that feels very conflicted because on one hand, I I do think in a lot of ways Peru does actually like it is a national front. But then my thing is I think if we start to include Peru, then all of a sudden we have to like move into other forms that aren't technically a national front but are kind of close enough. I'm thinking of thinking of the PLO, I'm thinking of even like Mossadek and like the new national front movement out there in Iran.
SPEAKER_03I'm thinking of India in a little bit, but yeah, I I think honestly, let's do it. Let's talk Peru. I like it.
C. Derick VarnAll right. Uh let's start though with these things that are actually, I think, applications of new democracy that kind of almost become national fronts. We can talk about the most disastrous first, which everyone knows because of the Jakarta method. Thank you, Benson Bebbins, I guess. Although I think that Bevan's books underplays how much new democracy actually made this easy to do. But so communist leader and theorist DN Aidit, I think.
C. Derick VarnI've never actually heard his name pronounced, I've just read it for years. That's A I D I T attempted a massive, peaceful cross-cast coalition on a new dec on a new democratic model in Indonesia. He said that because Indonesia was semi-colonial and actually still semi-feudal, so you have both those conditions similar to pre-revolution China, that a socialist revolution was impossible without passing through a new democratic stage.
C. Derick VarnAnd it's not actually in China.
SPEAKER_03I actually think as the National Front gets taken up in Europe as like a explicitly right-wing project, that's when we actually see Maoism. Like we see Maoism, Third Worldism, and New Democracy merge into just Maoism going forward.
C. Derick VarnRight. So, well, I mean, and then it splits back off and Mao Zedong thought, Maoism, third worldism, Maoism, Leninism, Marxism, or Marxism, Leninism, Maoism, which is like the most common form until recently. The most recent, most common form outside of China now is is dungism or dung zhi hybrid thought or whatever, Chinese characteristics, whatever the fuck that means.
SPEAKER_03I've always been confused because I thought that like my understanding of Mao Zedong thought was that it was like a living, breathing like philosophy of specifically Chinese ideological conditions, and that it so then it would then include dung, and then it would also include Ji. But I don't know how other people talk about it, I guess. I think Maoism the same way that popular fronts mean like 20 different things, I think Maoism means yeah, just like Trotskyism.
C. Derick VarnThe thing is with Trotskyism, the labels are clearer, like we have all the theorist names for all the labels, even though most people don't know them all. Like, yes, go back and see my trot spotting episodes. But with Maoism, you have like three distinct tendencies with maybe a fourth, which is Maoism, Maoism, Third Worldism, or Marxism, internationalist Maoism, depending on who you who you're talking to. And the thing is, third worldism has about five different forms itself, which is confusing.
SPEAKER_03With with like independent thought, like different independent thinkers starting their own thing that kind of became third worldism, then then later get lumped together.
C. Derick VarnWell, the because the other thing is like the non-aligned movement could actually be seen in origins of third world moves. Dung's speech on Lin Bao could be an origin of third worldism and world systems theory, which was like crypto maoist in a lot of ways, but it developed in its own way, and most of them didn't end up dying Marxist anyway. And Wallerstein was always cagey about whether or not he considered himself a Marxist in the first place. That's a form of third worldism, but they theoretically don't agree with each other, like in how, like, for example, world systems theory, the call, the whole the whole expansion of labor aristocracy to an almost ontological category didn't happen, like it's not part of their analysis.
C. Derick VarnSo, yeah, so you have that problem. We're gonna set that aside. We're not talking about third warbus really. The other problem that you have is that the national liberation movements and most of the planet, particular, but particularly Africa, and early on, Latin America and in the Caribbean were actually just plain old revisionist Marxist Leninism as sponsored by the Soviet Union.
SPEAKER_03Yes, and I think that's where a lot of initial confusion comes in.
C. Derick VarnRight. So everyone thinks all those things were like Maoist revolutions, like no, and sometimes the Maoists oppose them. Um so, but anyway, back to Indonesia. So we got DNAT, I'm just gonna say ate it, it's probably not right, talks about this peaceful communist movement where we adopt new democracy as a transition for what second international and early Leninist and Social Democrats and Orthodox Marxists and quotation marks would have all called bourgeois revolution.
C. Derick VarnI find this interesting because new democracy to me just sounds like you're just talking about bourgeois revolution, but controlled by the communist party first.
SPEAKER_03That's the only like I think I think some people would even like even people who are proponents of new democracy would admit that too, though.
C. Derick VarnRight. Well, I mean, I think that Aid would have. That's my that's my like he thought it was necessary, so he helped Sukarno's nationalist government and a coalition, and they also tied in the cooperation with the national bourgeoisie versus the compar bourgeoisie, just like is in China and Chinese theories to help the progressive aspect of the state develop so that the communists could eventually take over.
C. Derick VarnThe the PKI, the Communist Party of Indonesia, entered into a united front, and they actually did it in a way that's kind of unique. And I think this is not discussed enough in the Vincent Bevin's book, which was and this is a very Soviet-esque way to say this, I think funny, but Nasak Nasakcom N-A-S-A-K-U-O-M in English.
C. Derick VarnI but anyway, it's a it's a compound, it's one of those things like adjutprop where you use the first syllable in each part of it. It's natural, it's it's nationalism religion and and communism because they they didn't think they could appeal the Indonesian Islamists without making concessions to religion, so that became part of their their vision.
SPEAKER_03The Lunacharsky head strike again, yeah.
C. Derick VarnSo Audit talked about the two legs of the state. This is an interesting theory. So instead of like state autonomy, our class state, the great its old debates in Marxism, he actually thought that the state was of dual nature, and you had the pro-people side, which is Socarno, the uh the the PKI, the the national bourgeoisie's progressive liberalism, and the anti-people side, which was comprador capital and the military elite uh reliant on foreign military power and and whatnot.
C. Derick VarnSo the PKI thought that what they should do is strengthen the state by strengthening the progressive elements of capitalists against the regressive elements of capitalists and have an explicitly communist collaborated and partially led new democratic revolution. The problem is Suharto. Um so the quote unquote reactionary leg of a state, which was backed by European and American powers, gave Suharto the ability to stage a coup, and one million PK PKI members died.
C. Derick VarnWell, maybe it's between 500,000 and 1 million, and we don't know, but it's a large part of the population, yeah, and sympathizers. So this this is a case where the movement wasn't just broken, it was almost literally annihilated, not quite to a man, but pretty close. And so as far as United Fronts and New Democracy are this one's probably the most disastrous outside of Chile.
SPEAKER_03Um just from like your reading on it, because I feel like Bevins does Bevins like talks about it, but doesn't, and I think this goes into what you were saying, how Bevins doesn't actually talk about the why. It just is kind of like the US did this, the US or US backed forces did this, Western or capitalist backed forces did this.
C. Derick VarnBut like would you say enough, but yeah.
SPEAKER_03There is there was probably there's a more underpinning nature of like like the alliances that were being formed or what was happening internally, was there?
C. Derick VarnThere's an alliance with with from what I can understand, there was an alliance with clerics and the military that desperately needed munitions and they weren't getting enough of it from the Soviets or the Chinese because they weren't clear enough in their orbit. So, and since they didn't try to unseat the army or even replace the generals, they just thought that they could build up a counterforce within the state itself, they got couped. And so, yeah, Bevins is right that the US totally supported it, but this is that's a US centric view that uh ironically that does not look at the dynamics within the Indonesian military itself that would have led to them seeking an alliance to do this because there had to be a significant portion of the of the military for them to be able to pull that off.
C. Derick VarnAnd I I think Bevins is you know doing like what Trotsky does, which is like look at America's influence here, and he's absolutely correct about that. But what he misses is like, no, but the only reason that was possible was that there were divisions in the Yeah, there are internal organizing forms that are almost allowing coming and break through the cracks. And theoretically, the PKI was thinking that you could do this without suppressing the military or replacing them.
C. Derick VarnI mean, I I that's been my critique of Evans on a lot of things. He's like, we need a Leninist party. I'm like, dude, we've had Leninist party. Like the PKI was a Leninist party. I don't know what you're talking about. Like, you know, but whatever, journalism, man.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_03I feel like Bevins is specific. Oh, no.
C. Derick VarnGo ahead. No, no, talk about Bevinson.
SPEAKER_03I think Bevins is specifically like intervening on like this uh post-Occupy movement where we've just completely decided to not have any belief systems or we're just vibing our way through it all. So I think Bevins is 100% right about that. It's like, no, we actually probably need a more organized path forward. But then I do think the fail, like the falling point is you're right, is that you you fall into a you fall into a trap of looking at all of these different groups, saying these are all Marxist-Leninist groups, even though they're organized fundamentally differently, and then from there saying, Well, we just needed to like pick and choose the best parts of all of these and build our own zombie party out of it.
SPEAKER_03But then it's internally incoherent.
C. Derick VarnIt can be that is what even says in Marxist, either. So, like, you know, I just you know, it's like the gray zone problem. I'm just like, you guys aren't even saying that you're actually in support of Marx and Lenin. You have people who come on who do, but what you're actually in support of is probably never mind, I'm not gonna have to finish that sentence, but this will be behind the double paywall now. Um, but it it is interesting to think about because I mean I don't think Bevins is entirely wrong, but you can't you the US and Europe being able to have access to this is related to there being enough friction in Indonesian society and the strategic orientation of the PKI being flawed enough that they could not really deal with the situation, otherwise, US would have had to invade it directly.
C. Derick VarnAnd that's what you're missing in that Bevan's book. He's right about the Jakarta method, he's right about the imperialist intervention, but he does not deal with in any significant way the frictions in Indonesian elite society, the division between different kinds of Islamist, etc. etc. etc. And anyone who studied this significantly can point out that, like, this is this is an okay book, but it's flawed. Similarly, when it comes to the problems of Occupy and whatnot, that is a response uh two generations down to the collapse of the highly Leninist new communist movement, which failed along the same lines that Occupy did, even though it was party-oriented, because it wasn't mass-based, and so that's why a lot of these anarchist techniques that in 1992 together are why a lot of these anarchist techniques really became so predominant because it was just like look at the world, you have the Chinese being the bread the production basket for the Imperial Corps, you have Russia's gone, the new communist movement failed so bad we almost joke about it.
C. Derick VarnWhat do we have left? Well, we have these NCOA various forms of first what uh what we might call identity and issue anarchism that kind of develops out of liberalism that's getting more more radicalized, and then like a new form of what I have actually thought I'd think of as a neo-anarchism because it was invented mostly by people who actually dissented from new left Marxist groups like Murray Bookchin or Wayne Price, who I've even had on the show, who are people who were either Trotskyist or situationist or whatever, who were trying to reinvent an anarchism out of first principles because the original anarchists were dead.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's what I feel like Zoe Zoe Baker, yeah.
C. Derick VarnZoe Baker is really good about making this very clear.
SPEAKER_03Yes, yeah.
C. Derick VarnAnd me like her book, right? Well, I read that book, it's actually quite good. Yeah, I really had her on the show, too. And I think that's something we have to contend with because when like people like anarchists, I'm like, the anarchists you're talking about, like anarchists and Marxists historically haven't gotten along since the Bolshevik Revolution, but the anarchists we're talking about now, and the anarchists you're talking about in the 19th and early 20th century are fundamentally a different group of people. Um was it David Graber who is even just like I don't know any, I don't know any anarchists, like yeah, David Graber, and I got mad, people got mad at me for saying that, and I like quoted him saying it three different times.
C. Derick VarnI'm like, he says it, I didn't say it, he says it, he did not know much about anarchism. Literally, the only anarch, the anarchist with liberal ties who has any historical continuity with the historical anarchist movement at all was Chomsky, and I don't think that's viable by the 1970s, so you know, because to me, Chomsky's always just been a populist with some anarchist quotations when he's fighting with Leninists. That's it, like, but anyway, that's that's not related to our topic, but I do want to like talk about this.
C. Derick VarnLet's jump ahead to the Philippines. So, and the you know, the National Democratic Platform, which may not be new democracy, but kind of smells like it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I feel like we we we start to get this pretty quickly, actually. When I mean, because again, Maoism is understood as a thing that's just happening in in China. It's like just a it's a very specific context, but then there is a general success to it that I feel like then other revolutionary movements try to take and build from in their own ways, even though you don't have all of the documents out. I don't think you have you don't have the red book until the Cultural Revolution.
C. Derick VarnYeah, the red book. I think you get red book at the beginning of the Cultural Revolution in the 60s, and that's like exporting Maoism.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So before that, people just have to like look and see kind of from the outside, looking in what were what was happening with China. So, anyway, so you can continue.
C. Derick VarnAnd they were kind of like if you read stuff from the 70s, even from Maoist, you can tell they don't know that much. Yeah, like Maoist in a Maoist in Europe and America, anyway. So, anyway, Jose Maria Cezone, I think, Saison, was leader of the CPP, the Communist Party of the Philippines, and it had a diplomatic arm called the National Democratic Front. And a lot of people will tell you that the the in uh the National Democratic Fronts are the NDFP's 12-point program was a literal translation put into points of Mal's New Democracy pamphlet that was kind of glazed over with the Philippine context.
C. Derick VarnAnd it explicitly aims to protect the national bourgeoisie against foreign monopoly powers and foreign corporations. Now, what makes this different than the PKI's version is this is also in a mechanism of protracted people's war, which is weird because the protracted people's war part had to be done for mal before new democracy was possible. So, like like this is a little like, even though it's like technically more new democracy, I mean and you could say in some ways, you know, part of the problem with uh with new democracy and the P in the P in the PKI context in Indonesia is that it's trying to apply it before there's been a revolution, and they tried to skip the protracted people's war part of Maoism.
C. Derick VarnAnd I'm not even really completely sure if they were taking all of their orders from China or are the Soviet Union or both, because this is also like in that period where the Sino Soviet split is happening, but it hasn't completely happened yet. So, like so the the CCP sets up when they have guerrilla zones where They try to operate a dual power parallel government through protracted people's war. They they they do not demand any abolition of any national private enterprise.
C. Derick VarnThey demand sovereign industrialization by domestic private capital, not even nationalized, not even nationalized industrialization. So sovereign industrialization of by domestic private capital, protectionist tariffs to shield local Filipino business businessmen from not just the I find this funny because a lot of people are like, oh, why don't all the Maoists get along? Well, one of the things is like the Maoist party in the Philippines actually sees China as an enemy because they want to shield Filipino businessmen from European, US, and Chinese multinational interests.
C. Derick VarnAnd then they only want confiscation of land from comprador or feudal landlords. So landlords left over from the pre-capitalist system are from corporate-backed landlords. All local petit bourgeois landlords are okay, and they want to offer compensation to plantation owners who side with the patriotic font, but they do know that they need to end the plantations. That's their program, which I found like dude, this group that's been raising you know protracted people's war for like 60 years and has not won.
C. Derick VarnThat's the program. That is like that.
SPEAKER_03It's wild how again I feel like I've talked about the Spanish context before a couple times, but it's wild how similar, like those demands right there were the demands of the like textile business owners in the Catalonia region. Yeah. As the UK is building out their railroad system, or not, I guess it was the British at that point. The British, the British Empire was building out their railroad system and their textile industry. They were pumping the market with stuff. And what eventually became the like the CNTs, like have like the CNT FAI, the Radical Union that ended up breaking off from the Republic of Spain during the Spanish Civil War, doing their own revolutionary actions.
SPEAKER_03But this this consciousness was being built initially because petit bourgeois, like just domestic private capital, were not able to sell on their own domestic private markets in a way. There were no Marxists involved in any in every way. This is a I'm gonna say a pre-neocolonial framework of the world, because Spain at that point was still an empire. They had colonial exploits, but their colonies had essentially just become dumping grounds for their products, so that way they could guarantee fiscal, like guarantee enough capital coming in.
SPEAKER_03But the Philippines don't have that. At the same time, it seems like the Philippine program is calling for this same thing that these Catalonia, like private business owners, these smaller communities, these textile growers, like the textile like industry itself was calling for. Yeah, there's nothing Marxist about it.
C. Derick VarnNo, this is why I've actually called it. This is why I actually agreed when uh when Black Red Guard infamously got a lot of pushback on Twitter for correctly saying that Maoism is often the anarchism of Marxism.
SPEAKER_03And yeah, Maoism is the uh Maoism is the actual uh is the is the next in line of anarchism. Anarchism no longer exists as any form. There is only Maoism and Marxism at this point.
C. Derick VarnI actually even find that somewhat true contemporaneously, because one of the things that always like used to drive like purist anarchists up the wall, and why there's a distinction, one of the ideological distinctions between AK press and PM press, if you know those uh anarchist presses, is that AK press was the one that published so much Maoist stuff and third world stuff because like often anarchists are like attracted to it. I think there's a reason for that that's deeper than anyone wants to deal with.
C. Derick VarnI also have called Badoo platonic anarcho-maoism. Um I don't know how actually Badoo stuff matters. And I think I think you know, so what happens, why doesn't this work? Because obviously the Phil the CPP or the Communist Party of the Philippines still exist.
SPEAKER_03It's they're still doing protracted people's war, although on incredibly smaller amounts of land, and like you know, and there's been some recent developments of like small ceasefires and everything in the last just two years.
C. Derick VarnYeah, yeah. Oh, yeah, there's been agreements with the government, particularly now that DeTorte is gone. I mean, like but I want to point this out. One of the problems that they had is that Filipino petite bourgeois capitalists don't actually care if they're protected by the Maoist. They need the access to global capital, there's not enough local capital to support them, and they feel like they have to work at least work with the comprador larger businesses to be able to get their products out for a global supply chain, and so the whole division between patriotic and comprador capital is incredibly blurred, and I know I'm very unpopular for for saying this, but I I've never thought the idea of comprador a comprador capital made a whole lot of fucking sense.
C. Derick VarnLike, like I'm just like, so it makes sense that you're mad at the people explicitly collaborating, and that sense I'm with you, but like capitalism's a global fucking platform, and even the petit bourgeois know that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I don't like I think uh genuinely, and just working through this already, it's coming to me, but we've we've broached this subject before, and I actually think new democracy and the national front is another example of that this this thing, this stuff might only be able to happen under certain conditions, and one of them is when there actually is a division between a collaborationist capitalist class and a comprador class that can only happen when you're actively being invaded by another empire, right?
SPEAKER_03Like that there is a real distinction there at a certain point because you actually can't have access to a global market because you're being invaded, right?
C. Derick VarnExactly. So this makes sense when you're talking about people who are who you're be when you're being colonial or occupational imperialism versus structural imperialism, yes, operates very different for this distinction to make sense, and like I totally get it. Like, you know, I mean, even the Americans got it. Like, if you were collaborating with a business as a business uh with the British as a business owner and the American Revolution, you are at best gonna get tartan feathered and at probably actually more likely to be shot.
C. Derick VarnBut when you are not under occupation, this is it structurally, it's just not a sustainable position, I don't think. And I know that's gonna make a lot of my malice listeners more mad at me, but I just don't see how it flows. No, I want to talk about the least violent, but probably saddest of these three examples of explicitly new democracy outside of China, and this is Nepal.
C. Derick VarnSo people may remember if you think back to 20 years ago. I do love that the fact that like every party in Nepal seems to be some sort of communist, and yet they all don't act like it at all. But this you had the unified communist party of Nepal Maoists come together, which took all the various factions of the various Maoists, or not all of them, most of them, and got them into one party, and they they they took power after the 2006 peace accords and did the you know internecing civil war.
C. Derick VarnThe party did the same thing that all these groupings have done and argued that Nepal lacked an industrial base. So if they tried to launch immediate socialism, they would collapse into Cambodian pulpotism and completely fall apart. So they used new democracy to justify a prolonged period of state-regulated capitalist development and capitalism.
C. Derick VarnSo they did not nationalize the commanding heights or key strategic industries, which I even point out that like the fucking British did that during the world wars, and like the Americans didn't do it, but they so close to did it in some ways, but at public-private partnerships that it was almost irrelevant. Go ahead.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, the American the American nationalization project is actually I I'm gonna make people mad, so it's fairly similar to what the Chinese like nationalization project currently is. Like triple payroll triple payrolls now, yeah. No, I'll just stay open, but everybody off.
C. Derick VarnBut I've actually pointed this out. I actually I was like listening to some it was somebody that's now related to to MAGA communism, they start off as gamers, so you know who I'm talking about. If you know, you know, but I'm not gonna cite cite otherwise, and they use like the strategic alignment of commanding heights and all this and the percentages, and I went through it and I was like, by this logic, the British Empire in 1920 had achieved full socialism.
C. Derick VarnAnd the Scandinavian countries are more communister than China, if I took this logic to its logical conclusion. And in fact, I actually pointed out because originally what people were getting mad at me was me saying that uh Bukarin did not want anywhere near the level of privatization that Dung did. And so I find it hilarious when like people are like Dung great, Bakaran bad. And I'm like, A, Dung like Bukharin, and B, the liberalization under Dung was way more extensive than anything that happened in the NEP.
C. Derick VarnSo now you're in different stages of development, there wasn't joint stock companies really in in Russia and any significant sense to build off of. I understand the distinctions, and we could we, you know, I can get into the nuances of all that, but I was just like, I'm sorry, guys. I I totally believe that like communists run China, and I totally can believe that they're trying to transition to socialism sincerely. But you're not gonna tell me that this is like fully developed socialism in any meaningful sense of the word, because I mean that's not something even they can say.
C. Derick VarnNo, and they don't. I mean, they talk about like new they they keep on adding more stages of socialism that require more necessary socialist reforms that get pushed further and further back into the future, and the timeline changes every time the leadership of the of the Politburo changes, or when they can't make a a development benchmark.
SPEAKER_00Uh-huh.
C. Derick VarnAnd I say this as a person who truly respects China as like one of the most rationally organized capitalist societies on the planet, but nonetheless. But anyway, so what happens? So you have the Malice government started to form coalitions with all the traditional bourgeois parties, and they started taking investment from both India and China, also trying to play them off each other, very NASA style.
C. Derick VarnAnd they didn't do anything about the private sector hardly at all. And they actually frame this as executing the bourgeois democratic phase under communist guidance, aka going back to stages, which I find it funny that like every like everybody's rejected stageism. I used to hear that in the 1990s, and I'm like, no, not a single communist party that actually is in power has rejected stages.
SPEAKER_03Everyone just immediately does stageism.
C. Derick VarnLike, so yeah, theoretically, we may have rejected stages, but no one's actually rejected stageism.
SPEAKER_03Um politically we have, economically we haven't, or whatever.
C. Derick VarnYeah. So what happened? Well, frankly, you know, Nepal doesn't work that differently from fucking Singapore. And the party even eventually dropped the Maoist label. And so there you go. So you have this popular frontist slash bourgeois revolutionist thing justified on national liberation, and then and with new democracy as its supposed preliminary model that usually just ends up being somewhat liquidationist into national capitalist development.
SPEAKER_03I almost feel like, and I think we like we're we're similar, but I think I probably take a stronger stance against like a popular front method. But this does remind me than me, yeah.
C. Derick VarnMaybe maybe Mr. Anti-Populist altogether? That's that's true. Actually, good point. I actually think you might stake one, but I find this funny.
unknownGo ahead.
SPEAKER_03Uh, I this feels like a popular front with more steps in a lot of ways, and I know that's good. That's that I'm not trying to delegitimize any of the movements that were actually trying to be built. That's not what I'm doing. I think what I'm trying to like just describe is that it seems to me that when communist movements start to make these alliances and there aren't they aren't able to control uh again, the thing that the Chinese like the Communist Party of China was able to do, or no, not even is there so they're basically they are not people will say they're one party state, they actually aren't, but all the other parties don't matter except for coalitionary local government, like yes, so that's actually also true for the DPRK, too.
C. Derick VarnBy the way, people don't know that, but it's there's like three parties there that aren't the main party, but anyway, go ahead.
SPEAKER_03No, and but the thing is they were able to control it, they entered into a they entered into alliance that they were able to like have control over, at least at local sectors.
C. Derick VarnThere are examples of how Yeah, the KMT, you know, murdering the fuck out of them being an example of when that didn't work. Exactly, yeah.
SPEAKER_03But there we have examples of like towns that were run by communists not abolishing, like not abolishing private businesses, actually empowering certain landlords because they were part of the patriotic bourgeoisie. Like we have examples of that, and a lot of people I think will point to that and be like, oh, like this wasn't communist at all. But we do have also examples of Chinese towns run by communists where land is abolished, money is abolished for at least a little bit before things start to like get piled up onto each other.
SPEAKER_03But in all of these other examples, it's almost an immediate compromise with capital. And I just it doesn't seem like that's an effective method of doing this.
C. Derick VarnWell, it does seem like the big difference is China won its civil war first, yes, yes, like and and its problem became we don't have enough capital to nationally develop for our population. We tried all these experiments and we're stuck, and we are so pissed off at the Soviet Union that we actually see them as dangerous as the United States, or maybe even worse. So, like, we don't have a path for development, let's become the workshop for the developed world and make peace with the US.
C. Derick VarnThat's what the logic ended up being. This is also why when we talked about our various kinds of Maoism, who out of three of those forms of uh Mao Zedong thought's complicated because it is replaced by so, but there are people who claim to be Marxist Mao Zedong thought, which confuses me because they're not they actually do distinguish themselves from socialism with Chinese characteristics or whatever the current Dung Xi hybrid line is.
C. Derick VarnI I actually haven't heard it called anything new. There's not like I've not heard like I've not heard anyone formally say we're adherents of G thought. But what is G thought? I mean, if you actually look at what he did, he took some reforms from Bo Shi Lai and started to mitigate the disasters of liberalization in the countryside and to slow down the extent of neoliberalization and development in the cities.
C. Derick VarnBut other than that, he's like, there's no he's actually said multiple times we're not going back to a command economy anytime real soon, anyway, and and stuff like that. So I like G is is interesting to me because I think there's a reason why it's legitimately popular, and I've said this before I got yelled at by a bunch of people for saying this too.
SPEAKER_03But G is legitimately popular?
C. Derick VarnYeah, they're like, stick to your lane, and I'm like, Jesus Christ, guys, like you should worry about America, and I'm like, G is definitely legitimately popular, like I think we can I wasn't sure if they were like getting mad at me for being like saying that G was legitimately popular, or if they were getting mad at me for feeling like I could comment on China at all. Oh, you know, because you know, we had this time period where like no one can c no one from out. I mean, you have this shit today where people are like, I mean, in America, they're like, You're not from Maine, you can't comment on stuff here.
C. Derick VarnAnd I'm like, what the fuck are you talking about? Like, your senators need it need outside money to even be viable, yeah. Like, but anyway, I hate that shit, like more than anything else. Okay, this gets us into the national front. Do we start with the comm version or the reactionary version first, Brandon? I think two passways.
SPEAKER_03I think we got to start with the commie version because at least, and this is a little self-serving on my part. I do think the commie version of the national front actually in in a similar way that fascism grew out of some of the intellectuals of the socialists of the social democratic movement. I do think the reactionary version of the national front kind of grew out of some of the disillusionment and some of the disillusionment, the failures of the communist national fronts.
C. Derick VarnYeah, with the exceptions being Korea and Sing South Korea and Singapore, which had national fronts that were just like we want to do what the Soviets did, but like reactionary, yes, like um the bananist fronts, yeah. Those are real.
SPEAKER_03Yes.
C. Derick VarnUm, but anyway, uh early on in my career when I was still like kind of a more ultra-lefty guy, I used to piss people off by saying that the GOP was the more Leninist party than anything else in the United States.
SPEAKER_03I've I've made this argument from everything from like the Birch Society forward is that they took they took a lot of the Leninist models and then they said, What if we did this but reactionary?
C. Derick VarnYeah. Oh so okay, good. It's occurred to other people. I think it's occurred to a lot of people, but like people got mad at me when I said it uh 15 years ago. So anyway, okay, so one of the issues with national fronts that it that until its reactionary form comes up, it is almost indistinguishable from either a broad popular front from above and below at the same time or a popular front in the context of and specifically in occupations are colonized countries.
C. Derick VarnAll right. Now we've already done the history of like the unit the United Front from 19 from 1921 to 1928, as it's articulated by Trotsky. We've talked about it's the fact that's implicit in the second international strategy until 1914, where they get all collaborationist. We've also talked about the net the popular front, which comes about in France kind of vaguely between 1934 and 1936, gets adopted in 1939 by the Comintern.
C. Derick VarnWe've talked about the block of four classes and new democracy, both in China and with three examples outside of it that actually you know had governing power. There are plenty of examples that never even got that far. So we're not including them. And we've kind of avoided Latin America because that shit gets clusterfucky very fast.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, if people think the pink wave was a complicated foray into socialistism ish, yeah. I feel like just the twentieth century in Latin America is hard.
C. Derick VarnYeah, it's like it is the only thing. I've ever said was harder is Middle Eastern politics. Yes, yes. I do love when Americans discovered what Shia and Sunni were and they thought it explained everything. And I'm like, oh, you sweet summer child, it explains nothing.
SPEAKER_03Nothing. Nothing.
C. Derick VarnBut anyway, honestly, who needs to be trading with Israel at an immigrant time explains a lot more. But so we have all this. Now, what happens with the national fronts? Well, our first national fronts are not outside of Europe for once. And I think we need to start there first. The first two national fronts are our post-war two architecture in the Eastern Bloc, and it is Eastern Germany and Czechoslovakia.
SPEAKER_03So the East German National Front also did uh not the same, but their uh national front was similar in some ways in that it explicitly had some Christian socialist elements.
C. Derick VarnYeah, I was about to say it included Christian socialists and liberals, and even agrarian parties, which I was like, whoa. But they they had to have their candidate list approved by by the Communist Party and the DDR, or the GDR, depending on whether or not you want to call it Germany or Dutchland. So make make of that what you will. The National Front was also technically the ruined coalition of Czechoslovakia after the fifth after the well after 45, although really after the the QN48, the the independent political opposition was just rubber stamping, like like opposition parties doing Egypt, if you like.
C. Derick VarnSo those are technically national fronts. They use the name.
SPEAKER_03So you know in the case, the GDR or the DDR is interesting because at a certain point was in the 50s, they actually did start to then reincorporate not right parties at all. Like there was never like right parties, but more reactionary liberal parties into the mix, uh into the fold, as they realized they needed to expand their bureaucracy out and that their economy was not recovering fast enough.
C. Derick VarnYeah. And while like I hate I know that we always make a big deal out of the Americans doing this, and and that the the West German government did a fuck lot more of it. In fact, at one point there were more former Nazis in the German government and the West German government than there were during the actual Nazi rule. Yes, but and this is there were a lot of rehabilitated Nazis in the East German government, yeah, including like some of the National Bolshevik faction, and and yeah, guys, we it wasn't just us, we just did it more eviler, yeah.
SPEAKER_03I'm a I'm an East German defensist in a lot of ways, but you have to you have to admit that that happened.
C. Derick VarnYeah, no, I the DDR and I'm always thinking about the the the Soviet Bloc governments that I have an easiest time defending. I mean, outside of Kuba, which is like far away Soviet bloc, and and I don't defend them on certain policies in the 70s and 80s. But but yeah, the DDR is like not too bad. I mean, if I was in the Soviet Bloc country, I definitely would rather be in the DDR than say communist Azerbaijan or communist Turkmenistan.
C. Derick VarnYes.
SPEAKER_03Like though, just to put that out there, I probably would also have been relatively okay with with Czechlist uh with Czechoslovakia too, but nonetheless, I mean even probably even Germany to a certain extent is kind of reevaluating because I feel like after after 91, after the after your reunification, even there's there was a major shift against anything that was even remotely associated with the DDR. But now, as like AFD is gaining more popularity, there's a real question about right now because D Linka it kind of comes from this national movement, from this national front movement a little bit.
C. Derick VarnWe there although now it's just Jacobin Euro version, but yeah, yeah, but that was not true until like you're correct, yeah.
SPEAKER_03But there's a real question, like the CDU, of whether they have to like take down their firewall and actually work with D-Linka for the first time, which again that's a we're popular fronting it again, but yeah, that worked really well in France.
C. Derick VarnSo yeah, I was about to say, like, oh yeah, the communists and the Mitterrand government that worked out so well, so so incredibly well.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you're right.
C. Derick VarnTotally didn't destroy the left, and well, I mean, empowered the socialist party to do neoliberal reforms that led to Sarkozy coming to power, and then we've been bare barely avoiding the national front right-wing edition in in France for like two fucking decades. Yeah, I mean, Melishon, you know, I they did well in the municipal elections and and more power to them, but it does seem like as soon as they start getting close to real power, McClone backs like smacks them around a little bit, and the successors of Le Pen start getting closer and closer to power.
C. Derick VarnWe'll see what happens this next round. Yeah, but they do keep getting closer. Those are your national fronts that matter in the in the Warsaw Pact, and they called themselves that, which is why I mentioned it. What they kind of really were was popular fronts that kind of were quasi-allowed to formally at least day Uri exist in it was like a quasi-consultative democracy situation where right, similar to what China actually, China has the same thing.
C. Derick VarnOkay, but when everyone thinks of national fronts, what they actually think of is uh Viet Manslash National Liberation uh front and army in Vietnam, the FLN in Algeria, the F R E L I M O in Mozambique, and the M P L A in Angola. And those are the national fronts. And it's complicated to figure out sometimes what side of the Sino-Soviet split these people are on, whether or not we think they even tried to stay socialist.
C. Derick VarnI mean, not Vietnam is easy, but the other two are actually the African ones are way more complicated, yes. How they dealt with, particularly in Africa, the fact that there's tribal, religious, and racial groupings you gotta deal with, and how anti-imperialism became the the banner of development in this area. So I'm not gonna go into all these in detail because we'd be here all damn day, but basically, what these things all have in common is they won.
C. Derick VarnWhat they don't have in common is that the only one people still argue is even remotely kind of socialist is Vietnam. No one's I don't know anyone who'll try to convince me that Algeria is socialist or that Mosin is socialist or that Angola is so does people try to argue that Angola is socialist?
SPEAKER_03I I feel like if you do that, you have to argue that South Africa is socialist. I don't think anybody's willing to do that, even though the Communist Party is in the ruling government.
C. Derick VarnYeah, but they're also fighting the African People's Congress all the time.
SPEAKER_03So every election they promise to split off, and then every election they do an internal poll and find out that there's a thousand of them left.
C. Derick VarnYeah, entire and also like other left-wing forces oppose them in South Africa. You want to talk about dismal pulse Mandela South Africa is kind of a bummer. Um I'll just leave it at that. Like, but so in the F so the FLN, you have so many things you have to deal with because you have religious tensions, you have how do you what do you do with the descendants of the French who are not who are willing to side with the FLN.
C. Derick VarnYou have both North African and I'ma put in quotation marks, sub-Saharan, aka black uh elements of society. But they did, you know, kick the French out, mostly. And then Mosenbeek and Angola, the Marxist-led fronts, uh had broad swaths of population to kick out the Portuguese.
C. Derick VarnAnd they won on that front. The issue is the only one that, like I said, anyone says it's still socialist, and this is self-debatable, is Vietnam.
SPEAKER_03So I would argue that's probably just I think people lump Vietnam and Maoism together, probably especially I've I've heard this a lot in like left spaces in the US.
C. Derick VarnWhich is like that's dumb as fuck.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, like Ho Chi Minh and peasant communism are is a completely different branch of like your Marxist strain than than Maoism is, than Mao Zedong thought is.
C. Derick VarnAnd Ho Chi Minh is is a modified version of post-Stalin Soviet thought, yep, with some Vietnamese stuff incorporated in, and weirdly, and I know this is gonna surprise people, American stuff incorporated in.
SPEAKER_03Because he stuck he studied in front, like he studied in France, he was connected with the like exile and like emigre revolutionary movement out there, which included at that point in time parts of like parts of this like split up second international crew. There's a it's a different understanding of the national question, it's a different understanding of what the popular front is because he's getting he's not directly being inspired. And I know this I'm doing a little bit of great man stuff right now. Ho Chi Minh is not the only person who dictated or built out the popular front on its own.
SPEAKER_03That's not what I'm saying. What I am saying is that Ho Chi Minh was bringing into Vietnam a very different cultural, linguistic, and like understanding of a popular international front than Mao was doing.
C. Derick VarnIt comes from basically the early French Com well, not that early, the the the French Communist Party, it's a popular front informed by the French history, which is where the popular front comes from even before it gets incorporated into Marxism.
SPEAKER_03Exactly.
C. Derick VarnYeah, it's very much inspired by Khrushchev, and it very much believes that like the progressive elements of the like if you were to tell these people that the American Revolution was a counter-revolution, they would laugh at you. They said no, they're like it's a bourgeois revolution, and the bourgeois revolution is divided and uneven, but it is one, right?
SPEAKER_03Ho Chi Minh, what did the party not like literally almost word for word, like say, like, quote the Declaration of Independence? Was it in their declaration?
C. Derick VarnOkay, yeah, they did. And they're they are Marxism, Leninism, Hochi Min thought, which is actually codifaded really late. And but everyone, I I think it's funny that they associate with Maoism because Mao was trying to undermine them during the Sania split through Cambodia and working with the US. So a Mao thing that me personally I don't totally think is justifiable historically, aka don't entirely forgive it.
SPEAKER_03Um yeah, I think that's pretty unforgiv.
C. Derick VarnI think that China and Vietnam relations around then are pretty unforgivable, and they're still bad now, and like look, I get these other like it's a mutual badness because, like, for example, there have been purges of like uh Chinese descended ethnic minorities in Vietnam. A lot of people say the the the Viet Minh after Ho is very ethno-chauvinist, uh but there are people who claim otherwise. It's you know, I've known people from Vietnam, I have been to Ho Chi Minh City once, but I am not a specialist and I don't feel like I can speak on it with any authoritativeness, but I've read the history and like like I've always actually found it very funny that of all the kinds of Marxism that get imported exotically into the United States, you are more likely to even meet Kamir Rougis than you are to to meet Hochi Menth people, and I've always been very kind of amused by that because I'm like, I don't know if I was gonna pick a non-European Marxism to get all Stanny for and try to incorporate locally, I probably would have been picked Hochi Menthought or Castro Guevaraism, those are the two that would have appealed to me, yeah.
C. Derick VarnLike otherwise, I'm sticking with devs and Daniel De Leon fights, and that's where we're coming from. Because, like, but anyway, I find I find this so interesting. I mean, the the thing that's so depressing about it is you can argue that like there's a socialist revolution in Vietnam that's successful, they are a socialist country for the most part, but they had like China, they had to get capital by incorporating themselves in the capital onto what they feel is their terms. Uh and since they lost the Soviet Union and they still don't really trust China, they have also had to play fair, like pretty pretty concretely with the West to survive.
C. Derick VarnThe FLN, well, I mean, Nigeria just normalized into like North African politics after the French were gone. Angola and Mozambique, I feel harder to say what really happened, why they did not stay socialist, except that they were so desperately underdeveloped that they didn't have a whole lot of developmental choices.
SPEAKER_03And but I think also I can speak a little bit to Angola, not to Mozambique, but at a certain point in like in the conflict itself, in the war itself, there are so many different countries switching sides, and there are so many different individual capitalists providing funding to small groups on either end that it becomes one of those like internal dilemmas, those internal organizing dilemmas of what are the actual interests of these groups that won. And it's kind of a haw hodgepodge of like, I don't know.
C. Derick VarnRight. And so let's get us to quickly to the right reappropriations of the term, but then we can jump back into what I like to call the other trail of national frontism, and then we can talk about the third one I mentioned, which is Korea and Singapore.
SPEAKER_03Nice. Oh, real quick, would you call would you call the air like the Arab National Movement was like a national front of some sort, even though it was not a country-specific national front?
C. Derick VarnThe Arab National Front was a was a pan-national front, and then Bathism is a national front, but gotcha. Bathism is secular, but is to call it quasi-fascistic, it's actually fair, but no one likes when I do that because it makes it sound like I'm condemning them. In some ways, I'm just saying what they were.
SPEAKER_03I mean, Bathism is unique in the same way fascism is unique in that it's kind of different, and the Bathist party and different countries are not the same, like ideological.
C. Derick VarnNo, no, no. Bapism in Syria is way different than Baphism in Iraq, which in the other Bapist parties are also kind of different. I mean, it's it was basically though the successor to pan-Arabism when pan-Arabism got the boot, particularly when the United Arab state of Syria, Egypt, which had Israel in the middle, fucking that up, fell apart. But anyway, so we start seeing the right-wing national fronts.
C. Derick VarnNow, I do point out that right-wingers started picking up this popular frontist and lent in a circle cell logic. They did it in multiple countries and they didn't coordinate. The Birchers did it in America, Action National did it in Singapore, I think, or whatever they're called. I keep the national, whatever their ruling coalition party is. And the park administration, the second, the second dictatorship, did it in Korea. They took Leninist Party Central Centralism and Five Year Plans, and they ran with it, but for capitalism.
SPEAKER_03No, Varn, there are only two things: it's neoliberalism, and then it's socialism. Those are the only two things that exist.
C. Derick VarnLike, they're like, the government does stuff. I'm like, no, don't let me chunk claw you.
SPEAKER_03Um this is why we have these social democrats who are like free childcare is socialism. Good god.
C. Derick VarnWell, you know, as a side note, being in the DSA, it is weird because it has theoretically moved past that, and most people know that's bullshit now, even in the DSA. However, when confronted with outsiders, they still immediately go back to that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, the talking points have not shifted in 10 years, even though internally they are it is different, yes.
C. Derick VarnRight. No, like the the Jacobin, the reason why the Jacobin crowd is chasing the left populists is they're no longer the ideological dominance reign in the DSA on either side. So they just they just seem to tail Bernie Pack or whatever. For those of you who don't know, that's the people endorsed by our revolution, like John Fetterman and Graham Partner and and and Tom Steyr and and a bunch of other people.
SPEAKER_03The real socialists.
C. Derick VarnIt's really funny to me as a side note. This is completely off topic, but maybe it isn't because this is national front bullshit, actually. People telling me, well, well, people who voted for like progressives because they didn't want to vote for a billionaire, and I'm like, and how dumb that was. And I'm like, you had no good options, but I also don't trust Tom Steyer either. You guys are literally voting off of fucking talking points, and I don't know, I think all of it's kind of like would these people would know real governmental history.
C. Derick VarnUh it's fucking vibes, man. You're all kind of full of shit.
SPEAKER_03Like, it's not really a good I the past like month and a half has not been like a really resounding success for anybody who thinks that the current political system and working within it is going to do anything. That's like that's all I'll say. Is like, if if your choice is gonna be the bad choices and you just having to cope on Twitter and try to find reasons why the bad choice is actually it's a fine choice.
C. Derick VarnYeah, the masters are waiting for AOC to lead us to liberation, except the populists now don't like AOC because she didn't get all pro-platinner enough. And people think I hate Platinum, I think he's a cryptonazi, I don't, I think he's I think he's feckless from everything I've ever read. But I hate having to care about this because as far as my politics goes, mom donny is the only one that matters because mom donny is the only one that's a socialist cadre, and even he has disappointed me just not as badly as I was expecting him to disappoint me, to be quite honest.
C. Derick VarnI was expecting him to be even more of a collaborator than he was, given the last few socialist candidates are working class candidates I was told to care about have been. Yeah, so he's more of a Rashida Talib than AO than an AOC or a John Fetterman, but that's like damning with fame praise.
SPEAKER_03Yes, yeah. Again, not a good outlook for change, not even in the long term, just not a good outlook for change if you think this is a successful thing happening.
C. Derick VarnYes, they're not, yes, like I was actually like holy shit, these are government contracts for private corporate, god damn it!
SPEAKER_03Um like I remember looking into it a little bit and just being like, no, no, these are our socialists now.
C. Derick VarnAll right, so we have the appropriation of popular frontism, and that happens in Asia. Which is where you get the first right wing national fronts. But now we have to go backtrack in time and talk about the 19th century national fronts that turned into fascism, went away, and came back. Cause you can't keep a bad idea down.
SPEAKER_03No, you can't.
C. Derick VarnSo these are these sometimes are called national action groups or national front groups. My favorite one was the right wing ones in Mexico, the pan, which every American liberal and even some American leftists were thought were like popular movements because they were against the pre, and Vicente Fox, you know, appealed to American liberals. But I'm like, that's the right wing of the pre, my friend. Like, anyway, so National Front.
C. Derick VarnAnd then I'm gonna let I'm gonna cover this and I'm gonna let you talk about Latin America a little bit because even though I know a lot about Latin America, my especially in Latin America is Mexico. Because I live there and I've been obsessed with Mexican history for a long time. And I feel less good talking about, and you know, I have friends in Peru, and I used to date someone from Peru, but I I don't other than that, I feel like let's not do the here be dragons of all Spanish speakers who are south of me as one united thing because that's bullshit.
C. Derick VarnYep. Um and but I do think we have to talk about Peronism, and I really I that might be its own episode, actually. We might do a whole special episode on fucking Peronism.
SPEAKER_03I think that actually that's probably a good idea.
C. Derick VarnYou know what we should do, and I don't like it. We can do two things Peronism and Brazilian integritism. But now we're but Brazilian allegorism is right wing, kind. I mean, it's like fascist light, and then Peronism is gonna make our eyes bleed trying to map out where it is because you have both fascist and bad empanada all on the same side of Peronism. But yeah.
SPEAKER_03Peronism is probably the best. Oh, I'm gonna say something. This is not stupid, but I'm gonna say something that pisses people off. It's Peronism is probably the purest form of the National Front.
C. Derick VarnYeah, kinda, yeah. Which is why it's also so damn hard to place anywhere because it has both la it has both right wing and left wing fans, and it eventually split into white right wing and of the left wing variants after Perone was dead. But anyway, okay. So we're just gonna set that problem for its own episode. Uh, that'll be our next episode. Peronism and other Latin American specialties. I love it because uh in uh integral French integralism is one thing, Italian integralism is one thing, Brazilian integralism is weird.
C. Derick VarnUm but yeah, so we might talk about these other movements in Latin America there, but I'm gonna talk a little bit about national fronts and Latin America, but anyway, let's get to the right-wing ones. We had the appropriations of national front language with with uh Front National in France starting in 1972, and the British National Front starting in the 1980s, although the British National Front of the National Front UK, excuse me, which is kind of a successor organization of the Italian of the Moseleyite of the British Fascist movement, sort of.
C. Derick VarnWhat is weird about about the Moseley movement though, is they were the only like, yes, technically Italian fascists were inspired and incorporated the nationalist syndicalist movement, but the the British Moseleites, even though they never actually had any power, so we don't know what they would have actually done, but they were the only one whose theory was explicitly their economic theory was explicitly syndicalist all the way down in their program. So I was like, I was like, man, this this one's gonna be fun.
C. Derick VarnBut okay, so let's get into this. So there are two predecessors to right wing national front national frontism, and they're both proto-fascist. The first one, and they both come from France. If anyone ever wonders why I don't necessarily trust the French, I like them more than the English. No, I'm kidding, but I mean, I'm not kidding that I like them more than English, but like it's that whenever I trace really terrible ideas, um a lot of the time they come from the French reactionary movement.
C. Derick VarnUm, so there is Maurice.
SPEAKER_03No, uh my French is so bad.
C. Derick VarnYeah, all right. So my French is so bad that people who speak French do not understand what I am saying, even in English.
SPEAKER_03Okay, and they speak we're actually we're in the same boat here. We've had a I've had a lot of issues with this, especially when I've been in France.
C. Derick VarnYeah, oh yeah, me too. I tried to like do like the tourist French thing to get sympathy, it did not help, it made it worse. I should have just spoke English. I have been to Paris and to Ausson Sorraine, and the Assange-Seranians were nice to me, and I and thus France is okay, but people uh people do not know. But my least favorite city in the planet is Paris, and I uh it's is gay paris, and I think I might be the only person I know who like does not like Paris.
C. Derick VarnI'm like, yeah, I'd rather hang out in Sofia Bulgaria, quite frankly, but and I was like, Oh, weird, and I'm like, nope, don't like Paris, like you know, haven't been to a lot of the other West European cities that you know. I've I've been to I've been to Italy and Spain, but like for a day because I had a two-day layover. Hey, that counts.
SPEAKER_03That counts.
C. Derick VarnI did go out of the airport and like spend the night there, but yeah.
SPEAKER_03That's how I've discovered half of Amsterdam at this point, is that if you get out there for layovers for like 12 hours, leave the airport, explore one part, then come back.
C. Derick VarnPeople might go, how did that happen? It was mostly me going to cheaper vacations in Eastern Europe from Egypt, guys. Like, I don't have time to, I'm not, I'm not the kind of wealth, even when I was abroad, I'm not kind of wealthy, just hang out in Western Europe. My god, yeah, that's just expensive. Marxists you do that when Marxists are flying back and forth to France all the time, they get the side eye from me. I'm just like, what kind of money do you have, sir?
SPEAKER_03It's the it's the PSL money.
C. Derick VarnUh oh, you said it. I have only implied it. Oh shoot, shoot.
SPEAKER_03Oh, all right, another paywall, put it behind another paywall.
C. Derick VarnYeah, it's like the fifth paywall. Also, are it's are it's the RCP when Baba Vakian fled the country money. Yeah, anyway. So let's get back into this digression. People ask me why I started scripting my my solo shows, and I'm like, Do you see what happens on my interview shows when I talk to people I know? It it it there's the it's chaos and pandemonium.
SPEAKER_03I feel like they make the best episodes, though. That's what I'll say.
C. Derick VarnOkay, thank you for blowing smoke up my ass. So we have the national integralist or the integral nationalist, which are like the first like secular corporatist, prior forms of corporatism, and by corporatism, I do not mean corporations, I mean the corporate state were mostly Catholic distributists and stuff like that. And those people are also hard to put on the left wing, right wing thing, because frankly, their theory is quasi-medieval.
SPEAKER_03This is I this is actually why a lot of I think the Franco was fascist or the Franco like the Francoists are fascists in Spain is complicated because there were fascists who are part of the Franco coalition, but there are also some strange and like strange 18th and 19th century integralists part of that coalition.
C. Derick VarnYeah, and that's also why people like Tolkien who hated Nazis, like hated hated Nazis, and did not like the Italians either, the Italian fascists, kind of like Franco. So I don't want to want to go into the to the reactionary side of the Spanish Civil War, although I have a couple of books on it, but yeah, okay, so there's Maurice Barre, I think, but it's B-A-R-R-E accent and the other than Spanish direction s and yeah, and so unlike those the other people, he can't this guy came up on a show with the Regrettable Century Brothers actually very recently, and I couldn't remember how to say his name, and not and they forgot him, and I was just like, You mean Charles Marah, do you mean the other guy?
C. Derick VarnUm but anyway, so this guy was an integral nationalist, he was a romantic right-winger. By that I mean an organicist, anti-modern, anti-industrial. He was famous for pioneering the uh concept of La Terre e la morte, which I probably pronounced too much like Spanish, but but that is the earth and the dead, which is not blood and soil, but is like he argued that a nation is a single organic unity because your dead has merged with the earth, and your history is literally the dirt that you stand on, so it's not blood and soil, but it pretty much is.
C. Derick VarnYou have this implication and Demestra and the right wing reaction to the French Revolution, and we can say right wing because the French Revolution is when we can start using that metaphor in non-anachronistic ways. We talk about the left wing in like ancient Persia, we are pulling stuff out of her butt because all we're saying is like they were communitarians, I guess. Which I'm like, that's every society at some point, but anyway, Barnier thinks class war was bad, he wasn't talking about a class war, and he specifically was trying to take nationalism, which at the time was associated with the left, the empire, not imperialism, imperialism only comes about as as kind of a phrase for Napoleon in the middle in the middle 19th century, but he's trying to wrestle nationalism from these liberal nationalist movements, and he's explicitly appropriating the idea.
C. Derick VarnBut it was all like I said, it wasn't from nowhere. The seat had already been laid by Demastra, yeah. Okay, um, but we do have to think about like when he's talking about meeting Germans for the maestros, this is still like a cultural distinction because those people weren't didn't yet have national governments, they were still under you know, weight feudal empires, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Germany was not a thing, yeah.
C. Derick VarnGermany was not a thing, Italy was not a thing. Yeah, the the queerest European nation states were France and Britain, and Britain sort of makes sense, it's a damn island, so like, but it took a while, it took Napoleon actually for the rest of everybody else to start thinking of themselves in nation-state forms outside of like the Dutch.
SPEAKER_03Go ahead, even Italy under like Mussolini, like it's you have a North and South Italy, even to this day, a little bit, like it's not not even close to as big as it used to be.
C. Derick VarnNo, the the elite theory came out of that, like yeah, the Liga, um, which are like weirdly, weirdly blonde, like like shocking about how great it is to be blonde and how Sicily's basically Africa. Yeah, that's that's their thing. Um, those those team terms aren't gone, and Italy in particular, they're still pretty politically defining. But anyway, so Barnaz started talking about class classes alliances, specifically with French workers and petite bourgeois, and that's the phrase he would have used.
C. Derick VarnThat's not me using Marxis, he's French, that should be united against foreign capital cosmopolitanism and outside immigration. Which I'm like, was that a big problem in 1880 in France? A little bit, but it was because they're stupid empire.
SPEAKER_03Um is that even technically outside immigration?
C. Derick VarnYeah. And so he argued that the domestic proletariat and the domestic bourgeois should share an ethnic and geographic identity. This sounds a lot like national liberation stuff you saw on the left, and it was explicitly pulled from the pre-Marxist left, but it was explicitly pulled from the bourgeois left as a way to like get this organic unity, and then somewhat simultaneously, Charles Morah forms Action Francis.
C. Derick VarnAction France, as I like to talk about. So before the SPA Day, most parties were not what we would call mass membership parties.
C. Derick VarnThe America actually is where the first mass membership voter parties come from, but they're still only voter parties, but they do imply membership outside of Congress. But there were factions that we call parties in like Britain, like the Tories and the Whigs and whatnot, but they were not parties that, like, the average person, even if they could vote, were really a member of. Only people seating in parliament were members of these parties. They only start be taking on a mass character where you join and pay dues and all that shit after the espay day and after action france or action française, or because he was also an advocate for integral nationalism, but he got even broader because he was like Morat was like, Okay, we got the bourgeois, and we should get the workers together against all these dirty foreigners, but we also should allow the royalists back in the as long as they're good French royalists and not these multinational royalists, the comprador royalists, right?
C. Derick VarnAnd and we should get the Catholic Church back on board. It's the block of four classes, yeah, but you know French people, yeah. And they were specifically aimed to fight us. They were fighting the blanquiist, the Marxist, the Boyerist. Basically, they came out.
C. Derick VarnThis was a this was a even broader response to the development, not just of the communars domestically, but of the first international.
SPEAKER_03I'm not gonna call it the national front. The Portuguese uh coalition, like the reactionary coalition around the 1910s to 1940s, also is made up of these four. You have your carlists, you have your Catholic Church, you have your integralists, and you have your like petty bourgeois.
C. Derick VarnRight. What makes Marath different from Barnaz is Barnier seems to have been a reactionary but basically a democrat, as far as I can tell. Gotcha, a small D Democrat. Marat wanted to use democracy to put to put a decentralized monarchy back in charge. So, but this is also they're a mass party with membership outside of the parliament, and they also are one of the first parties that have youth squads that are militarized and engage in street violence.
C. Derick VarnSo they were called the Camelot duroi, so you know, which is funny. I'm like, so you have an authorian theme to your street thugs, yes, cool.
SPEAKER_03Also, are to your French street thugs, your French nationalist street thugs have an English authorian theme to it, yeah.
C. Derick VarnSo then this all goes away. You have fascism happens, but concurrently, right after this, let's get into this. You have the responses to the end of the second reich after World War I in Germany, which leads to like the esp day, it leads to both the left center and right of the esp day, including the pro-imperialist right of the espeday and the all that fun stuff.
C. Derick VarnBut you also have the conservative revolution, which were you know, whenever someone wants to cite someone fascistic but not fascist, and they want to go to Germany, they either pretend that Carl Schmid wasn't a fascist, which is just lying, or because he had, I guess, a couple of critiques of Hitler kind of, or you go to like Ernst Junger, uh Arthur Muller, von Vandenbroek, you know, and those guys.
C. Derick VarnAnd the one thing you say about the conservative revolutionaries is they like tried to assassinate Hitler multiple multiple times, but so they they didn't like Western democracy, they didn't want any of this parliamentary bullshit, and they also didn't like the Soviet Union, and so you know their predecessor was Spingler and like Prussian socialism, and some of the more conservative elements of the German historical school, okay.
C. Derick VarnUm the German historical school gave us many things, but also it included some of these like romantic nationalists like Barre. We could talk about a lot of them in the German idealist movement and the 19th century, but they really come together as like a really loose coalition. One of the things about them though is they were not organized, like they're not really an organized movement, they're a bunch of different types of vaguely conservative intellectuals in some street movements, so but they come from the soldiers front, which is all the people who come back from World War I, all shell-shocked, and you know, they actually they don't so much uh they don't so much, you know, they don't all become fascists.
C. Derick VarnLike I said, some of the most prominent non Marxist anti fascists are actually conservative revolution, but also some of them did become fascists, so there's that. There's they also are weird inspirational. Inspiration for the national Bolsheviks, which is the weirdest of things that doesn't go away.
SPEAKER_03It's still around today in although mostly in Russia. Yes.
C. Derick VarnThank you, Liminov. And a bunch of other people, actually. It's actually wrong to just blame it on Lemonov. But so first you have the National Burnaby Ernst Neckish, who called for national fronts, which combined elements of Leninism with elements of proto-fascism, and that they would come together to fight the true enemy, which was Western finance capitalism. And they like they seized on the fact that the Bolsheviks were also critiquing finance capital as the basis of fascism.
C. Derick VarnAnd they're like, aha, but we we also don't like the banks because they're rebounded Jews. And that's also where this idea that you saw in both fascist and conservative revolutionary movements that the Jews were responsible for both communism and capitalism because they ran the banks. And if we went back to I don't know, I don't know, like peasant agrarian corporatism or something, we'd be all be okay.
C. Derick VarnI do find it disturbing how much of new democracy kind of thought is really parallel to this, up to it, including, like we mentioned last time, that the proto-new democracy people, like the founders of the one of the two uh Li Hazdao, I think, came up with the idea of proletarian nations concurrently with Mussolini coming up with the idea of proletarian nations.
C. Derick VarnUh so I I when I read this stuff, it is a little bit icky. I was like how much it runs.
SPEAKER_03So it begs a lot of questions that I feel like making a more organized left would be willing to wrestle with it a little bit more. Yeah. Yeah. But at the moment, we just can't.
C. Derick VarnHonestly, I'll tell you that like it was actually a Maoist I was talking to about 17, about 15 years ago who first told me, like, hey, if you really study national Bolshevism, if you really study right deviations within Maoism, they're almost identical. It's just most he said, like, look, I'm you know, he was Latin and is like, Look, what most white people can't see is like if it if it's corporatist and brown, they just assume it must be progressive. And I was like, not feel like I can't comment on this one way or the other.
SPEAKER_03But he's not wrong, or they're not wrong, yeah.
C. Derick VarnThey're not wrong. So, yeah, so so Nekish believed the true enemy was finance capital, as did Werner Sumbart, formerly a Marxist who ended up dying a fascist. There's a lot of people who went this route, yes, and that the problems were finance capitalism run by the Jews, those damn English and their mercantilism and their American bootlickers back when the relationship was reversed from what it is now, and those dirty French and their Visay liberal bullshit.
C. Derick VarnUh we have to oppose that, and we need a total mobilization of all Germans into the nation, Prussian militarist, nationalist intellectuals, and industrial proletariat, and a united front with the Soviet Union this time. This is what makes them unique uh against the capitalist West to save true German culture. Nekich is kind of rehabilitated in the in the DDR, which is something people don't ever mention.
SPEAKER_03Well, I'll also say hit that thought is kind of what Stalin Stalin was prepping for a war with Britain, like yes, but everyone misses that the war he was prepping with was not with Hitler, it was with Britain.
C. Derick VarnYeah, Stalin thought the fascists were dangerous, but he thought they were less dangerous than the British and the French.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. It's that's and that's not discussed at all. So you're saying that, and I'm like, oh, I mean, it actually makes sense that he was rehabilitated a little bit because it does seem like that was the framework up until I mean for better and for worse, I do think Stalin was up until the up until the the Nazis literally something that yeah, that that they thought that Stalin thought they were too rational to do.
C. Derick VarnYou also have author Moeller van der Bruck, who you know is the guy that comes up with the idea, like he's a he's one of those old right hegelians, something that people forget exists. There's like people will read Smit and like Smit must have been influenced by Marxism. Like, no, he was a right hegelian. The right hegelian god damn it.
SPEAKER_03There's a there's an interesting um movement right now to like try to rehabilitate the right hegelians as well at the moment that yeah, I know one of the guys they're Christian.
C. Derick VarnI know, yeah, I I know, yeah, yes, but I like I actually interviewed this guy like a 16 years ago. It was a Brian Hacker.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah, yeah. I know who you're talking about.
C. Derick VarnYeah, yeah. But yeah, there's a lot of this, and I do think we should study the right hegelions because they're actually super influential and they're just erased after fascism for reasons, for reasons. I'll be I'll be I'm still baffled by the fact Heidegger and Carl Schmidt got out of that, but the right hegelians and like Werner Sombart didn't.
SPEAKER_03That that is wild.
C. Derick VarnLike Werner Sumbart like invented the phrase late capitalism, he's where it comes from. He wrote one of the smartest analyses of why socialism had a problem in the United States. He's basically one of the first people to study settler colonialism, but since he died a Nazi, and also his writings on Jews were never comfortable. We all just go, and we all just go, we're not gonna talk about that.
SPEAKER_03But we do we just we just selectively pick Heidegger, though.
C. Derick VarnYeah, Heidegger. I guess because he's so obscurantist, it's actually hard to figure out. He's very French in that way. Yeah. Well, that's who that's who resuscitated him was yeah, yeah, all the damn French who like took all this German reactionary theory and tied it to leftism somehow.
SPEAKER_00Yep, yep.
C. Derick VarnThank you, French. But anyway, so you have the German labor front, which is crazy, and the soldiers front, and the German labor front's established after 1933, after the Marxist and Christian trade unions are both bonds. You don't know, there are competing trade unions in Germany, the Christian Democratic ones and the Marxist ones, and then some independent ones.
C. Derick VarnSo all this was put together by fascists and the soldiers front come together, and these guys like the national Bolsheviks are like fascist adjacent, they're really inspirational to like bizarre American weirdos like Francis Yaqui, um, and also to the American Nazi Party, and like George Lee can lock roll knew about them. Also, Duganism is right has always been aimed at rehabilitating them, as has the French New Right, believe it or not, because they also don't like capitalism.
C. Derick VarnSo there's that.
SPEAKER_03Even the AF Day has been moving a little bit more towards that direction as well.
C. Derick VarnWho?
SPEAKER_03The German AFD.
C. Derick VarnOh, yeah, yeah, they have. Yeah, so we're gonna skip the Nazi stuff and the fascist stuff because oh my god, I've talked so much about it in the past. I don't want to cover it here, but yeah, they're all vaguely descendants of this early national frontism, which is why it kind of goes silent until you start. And it's actually Jay Sakaival people wrote about this weirdly in his in his late, not in Settlers, but in one of the later pieces about fascists taking up anti-imperialist guises and anti-imperialists not being able to tell the difference.
C. Derick VarnHe wrote about this in the in the 80s and 90s.
SPEAKER_03It's so frustrating how we just keep doing the same things over and over again.
C. Derick VarnThe same dumb. I mean, to be fair, it never gets like the whole red brown stuff never gets very far. Yeah, like like historically, unless unless unless the red just becomes brown, they don't go very far. It's not on the line, it's just viable, really. But oh my god, does that not stop getting people to at least pretend to try it? But anyway, so you had the right-wing anti-imperialist blocks because but their definition of imperialism is different, but they explicitly use the same words as leftists do, and they still do this today, to pull out dumb leftists.
C. Derick VarnI mean, my favorite thing was when like a bunch of third and fourth positionists or third, fourth foot, were the main maintainers of the Juice Defense League in the United States, which as everyone has forgotten, but that was a thing in the aught and the aught teams. Like there was a circle about it.
SPEAKER_03Um I had completely forgotten about that, actually. I don't I genuinely there needs to be a better, needs to be a longer analysis of the early aughts because I feel like especially post like pre-Burnie, it's just the wild west when it came to that kind of stuff. Yeah, and we still are dealing with the repercussions of that.
C. Derick VarnOh, yeah, no, James Perazzo who endorsed the ACP was an explicit and was a Duganist, but was an explicit neo-Nazi who jumped on the from third position to fourth position, and they moved from the American front line of third positionist neo-Nazis to the four uh American fourth position aka new revolt, which actually also has a presence in Brazil. Oh, I think it's dead in America because a lot of its leadership fled to Russia and Jane Farrazo died.
C. Derick VarnBut he endorsed the ACP before he died, so just so you guys know that I'm gonna have so many fucking people who hear me mentioning them in this. But yeah, this idea never goes away. I will say, like Yaquiism, we mention it, it it's interesting, it was never super influential. Uh George Week and Lockwell kind of more was and he had communist too, but he was not a capitalist at all. But I do think it's interesting how these concepts got picked up by different forms of rightist around the world in the 70s.
C. Derick VarnI mean, it's arguable that even like the Islamic Revolution is is actually an example of this because you know, I did have people who like I don't think the Islamic Revolution is it, I think it is a democratic revolution, etc. etc. etc. But it is very right wing, and it massacred his two-day party allies, and that is a historical fact.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, I was when we were talking about Indonesia earlier, I wanted to make that explicit anal like analogy because that was the two-day party line was trying to bridge these connections between Islam and communism. How do we like form this party line? And then it just like did not work at all in the same way it didn't work in Indonesia.
C. Derick VarnYeah, they got liquidated. We just don't talk about it because that was not the West liquidating them.
SPEAKER_03Exactly, yeah. Bring it back full circle about what Bevins didn't write in the Charcada method.
C. Derick VarnRight. I think I should ban millennials from I mean, as a as a Gen Xer, I can do this. I am I am Strodigger's Gen Xer Millennial anyway. But like I think I should ban millennials from politics. This is my official stance.
SPEAKER_03As a Schrdinger's Gen Z millennial, I can I can also subscribe to this.
C. Derick VarnLike like the millennial millennials, you're disenfranchised.
SPEAKER_03No more politics for millennials.
C. Derick VarnNo, I'm kind of joking, but not entirely, because I it does feel like what we have is a caricature of anti-Leninism and a caricature of Leninism that has become predominant in response to the Bernie movement, which itself was a response to Occupy. Like, and neither have really dealt with why those things came to be in the first place. I think they are trying to now, but that's after a decade and a half of failure.
SPEAKER_03The thing I've I've had a conversation about this a few times. It literally might be too little too late. It might be trying to figure out what's going on as you're actively dying.
C. Derick VarnWell, I mean, what's weird is like everyone's like, we're back on the heyday again. And I'm like, okay, sure. But what happens when Trump goes?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
C. Derick VarnLike the DSA almost like lost a third of its membership during the Biden administration. Are you are like like outside of New York City, as I've said somewhat bitterly to some of my comrades, and why I wasn't in DSA for a long time. And almost every area outside of New York City that the DSA has made the most of is ex-DSA heirs.
SPEAKER_03Yes.
C. Derick VarnLike, like you almost meet anyone in this movement, you know, they're like, oh, I was in a DSA and I left because of X reason, and I became I got in the CPUSA, and then I realized they weren't a whole lot better. And then like I went, you know, and joined, I don't know, probably the WWP, and they didn't do very much. And the Trocious organizations are all dead except for the uh except for the RCP, but that are excuse me, RCO in America. But excuse me, that's very confusing because there's another RCP, and I couldn't join that because it's hard to get in anymore, and they're only in Berkeley.
C. Derick VarnLike in Chicago, like so, yeah. I mean, this is this is where it's at, and you know, we've also seen the trot parties all die. Yeah. With the exception of the RCO, RCI, RCO here.
SPEAKER_03I think you're right.
C. Derick VarnYeah, it's not the RCP here, or maybe it's the RCA, but that's just a corporation.
SPEAKER_03I don't know. Yeah, it might not. I don't think it's that. I think it's something else.
C. Derick VarnCan we think of a better name, though? There's like 27 revolutionary communist parties of of of like opposed ideological stripes. Like yes, because the RCP is the second RCP from Britain. The first RCP became Spike magazine.
SPEAKER_03Yep.
C. Derick VarnNot doing the whole cross too conservative thing, all that much discredit, unfortunately. Okay, so National Fronts in Latin America. I'm turning this over to you. I'm not talking. You can talk.
SPEAKER_03I so I think the one thing that I want to talk about today is literally just the shining path. We've already been talking for almost two hours, so I was going to propose what if we do a quick overview of National Fronts in Latin America and then we do our deep dive into Peronism and Brazilian integralism the next episode. But I can talk about the shining path really quickly.
C. Derick VarnOkay, talk about the shining path, and then I then let's let then let's do. I got two more gotta keep on adding episodes to this series. Also, we need to write a paper, we need to write our paper about the relationship between the merger thesis and the mass line. We do so we so we need to do that. Those of you know that's what we're working on. We uh we are working on this together. We actually finished an outline, kinda. Um so let's let's do it this way. Let's do examples of this in Latin America, both left and right, two episodes.
C. Derick VarnFirst episode, South America, really weird shit. Um integralism and Brazil, maybe the workers' party in Brazil too. Although I needed I actually need to learn more about that, believe it or not. I don't know its origins. What the nightmare morass of um Peronism, and then the various Trotskyist and Maoist movements in Colombia and Peru, but we're gonna start with China Path in a second, so we're gonna give you a little taste and we'll probably come back to it.
C. Derick VarnAnd then the next episode will be the other Latin America, and I'm gonna be a dick and say Belize Mexico because I don't know enough about El Salvador and Ecuador, except they're usually reactionary in the American, and and like somehow I always feel like the Americans are fucking around.
SPEAKER_03I can do a little bit on Ecuador for sure.
C. Derick VarnOkay, well, I was waiting, but like Guatemala and Honduras would be interesting as well, and Honduras are I actually try to have a Honduras specialist on, but they having them on would risk their life, so I decided not to. So anyway, so we and I want to talk about the other big national front, the pre in Mexico, which is kind of like how do you not talk about that? Yep, and that's something I do know the history of pretty well, so I don't have to do a lot of research.
C. Derick VarnSo we will break this up. We'll but I'll promise next episode to get into Brazil and and Brazilianism and Peronism. Oh my god, and that'll probably be its own episode. Then we'll deal with national fronts and the upper part of South America, and then maybe or maybe not, maybe this is three episodes, and then maybe we do Central America.
SPEAKER_03I think that makes sense. I think that makes a lot of sense. I like that.
C. Derick VarnSo we move from concept to region because I don't know, because Latin America. I actually think Latin American history is super important, but yeah, particularly for us, like exactly, yeah, there's direct ties, like yeah.
SPEAKER_03It's actually specifically if you're US based, I think it's important. If you're US Canada, Mexico-based. I think that probably the most important conversations you can be having are like what are the actual movements that have been happening in our backyard.
C. Derick VarnYeah, one day I'm gonna get a Canadian specialist on and be like, let's talk about the history of the Canadian left.
SPEAKER_03I feel like that it might be as bad as Peronism.
C. Derick VarnWell, I mean, it is like America, and like half the groups you're talking about never even had a single representative in anything. Like, with the exception of the NEP. But then you have all the like Canadian politics gets close. The history of Canadian politics, and man, this is gonna make a lot of my Canadian listeners a little bit uncomfortable, but I think they can handle it. I do have a large Canadian leadership. It is very distinct from American politics up until the 1980s and 90s, and then after the 1980s and 90s, it looks a lot more like American politics.
C. Derick VarnIt is still different, but like red Toryism in Canada has no parallel in the United States after like the 30s.
SPEAKER_03So go ahead. Canada did have a I think we talked about it like very briefly on our first Popular Front episode. Is that Canada did actually have a popular front with a communist and socialist party? The communists got like liquidated not as violently as other as other people.
C. Derick VarnNo, they got liquidated politely because it's Canada.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. Yeah, but they were like there wasn't it was another example of the popular front liquidation into like milk toast social democracy, mostly liberalism.
C. Derick VarnYeah, I mean similar to the United States, but even less prisony than that. I mean, we didn't kill that many people in the United States, at least not if you were as long as you weren't black. Um but but like a lot of people did go to prison. I don't think Canada and that many people went to prison, they were just still liquidated.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it was. I mean, most it was mostly like a self-liquidation. It was mostly just people left the Communist Party and joined the socialist party, and the socialist party then merged. Yeah. Sad, tragic. So Shining Path now or Shining Path Later?
C. Derick VarnLet's start Shining Path and we can come back to it. So let's introduce Shining Path as a preview for an episode that'll be two episodes away.
SPEAKER_03Hell yeah. I'll just do a quick little read then. It's also called Gonzalo Thought, and it was it's based, it's called the Shining Path. Uh, it's one of the one of the communist parties of Peru. And they're entirely yes, again, another important thing is I think a lot of people talk about Gonzalo Thought or the Shining Path as the Communist Party. That is not a good thing.
C. Derick VarnNo, it wasn't even the biggest one.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Go ahead. And essentially, the the it was uh it was a theater radical decision. It came it came to by uh intellectuals. The founders of The Shining Path were all, I believe, either university professors or members at like a university in a city. They came to the conclusion that. Mao's ideological contributions, the mass line, the block of four classes were in fact the next development universally when it comes to Marxist theory.
SPEAKER_03And they had argued by around 1980 that not only had the Soviet Union entered a revisionist period, but uh Deng Xiaoping's 1978 open door policy had betrayed the socialist movement. And so they were, they were now, the Shining Path was now literally the shining path for the world communist movement, is essentially what they were arguing. From there, yeah, they declared themselves the leaders of the true global communist movement, simultaneously putting them at odds with the ideologies of the United States, the Soviet Union, and the People's Republic of China. This also meant everybody This meant that they explicitly fought against they fought against other Latin American communist revolutionaries in Peru and rejected things like the Fokis, I'm gonna say this really badly, the Fokismo model, which was uh Che Guevara's understanding of how to do a guerrilla communist movement.
SPEAKER_03They had a concentric cellular suck structure so that the central committee, so they had a block of four classes, but they also were doing something somewhat similar to like the German National Front method, in that they had the block of four classes. These these people could all be a part of the movement, but everything was like there were concentric circles of of actual control, with the main group being Gonzalo uh being Guzman, Abby Mael Guzman.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so that inner circle where the inner one was captured, actually.
C. Derick VarnI remember because I was abroad when that happened. Like that's more recent than people think. That's that's more yeah, you're right, actually. Also, the woman I dated, who I will not say her name, but I will I will talk about it. This is before I got remarried. Her uncle was both a member of the Shining Path and was killed by them. So oh my gosh. So, like she she was a leftist from LA, but like she did not have anything good to say about Gonzalo.
SPEAKER_03Um it so I it was it's controversial because again, like we talked about China and Vietnam briefly, but the I in every sense of the word, the shining path, which and a lot of people call themselves Marxist-Leninist Maoists now, and that's what the shining path developed. But that that I mean there are two different Marxist-Leninists and Maoisms, really.
C. Derick VarnBut I was about to say it was developed by the Shining Path, but like it kind of splits off from the Shining Path in the 80s, and they're just like, Yeah, we're not with those guys, like exactly, yeah, except for like Red Guards, Austin, and a few Colts.
SPEAKER_03Yep, yep. But yeah, but they uh they did like a lot of this movement, they did a lot of stuff that other movements have done. I feel like their biggest thing was they did essentially a going to the people, which is what the SRs did before the Bolshevik Revolution. It failed in about the same way, and somebody's a little worse.
C. Derick VarnThey got a lot of their people, they got a lot of their people massacred in villages by like trying to push things too far and not following them out. Like, we we won't try to push everyone at the same speed. Um Yup.
SPEAKER_03I feel like the Yeah, go ahead. I feel like the last like little like thing about the Shining Path, because the Shining Path, it developed this method. There was a block of four classes, they were doing somewhat like there were trying to do it was intellectually led, like intellectuals were leading it, they were doing going to the people stuff. So there's a lot of pre and post-Bolshevik mentalities.
C. Derick VarnThe one thing that was like it was like it was like Narodnikis and and like hyper Bolsheviks at the same time.
SPEAKER_03Yes, that's that's actually great. Yes. The perfect example of this, in my opinion, is that they were in the Sino-Soviet split, they tried to break, they they were the ones who led the efforts to break from the pro-Soviet Peruvian Communist Party, but then later they uh sided with Albania and Hoxism.
C. Derick VarnThey became hojists. Yeah, oh Hojist, thank you. Yeah, yeah. I didn't know how to pronounce that for a long time, too. That's an Albanian had to correct me actually. I had an Albanian student, and we talked about Hoxha once, and I learned a lot.
SPEAKER_03This is good. I'm gonna say it right from now on.
C. Derick VarnBut yeah, they became Hojists, which is like and then even broke from that, like yeah.
SPEAKER_03So this is like especially like with like South America and Central America. This is like the complexity that we're talking about here.
C. Derick VarnThere's also major, I mean, people think, oh, you know, the it's only the English-speaking world that was full of Trotsky's. Wrong. No, no, Latin America was full of Trotsky's, and what and when you have the Griveris too, which are kind of their own faction, people think of it as Marxist Linaris, but they kind of become their own faction, you end up with like so many different factions because and there's also left communists in Latin America, so it's like it's like it's like if you think the if you think the uh American campuses are confusing with their sectarianism, you have that, and you in fact the fact that these people have militias and our people didn't.
SPEAKER_03This is the other thing is that there's active conflict happening while all of the factions that you'd expect on like an American university campus that are arguing with each other, but they have now they're also shooting each other, yes.
C. Derick VarnSo, which I guess kind of sort of happened in Italy for a little bit, but in general, Western Marxists don't kill each other that much. Not in Latin America, though. You are wrong, sir.
SPEAKER_03So uh but that can be our little primer for talking about South American national fronts and democracy.
C. Derick VarnDo we have to get into like Pabloism and Moonicism and all kinds of we're not gonna go into all that? I actually went, I I should get some of my Latin a conclave of Latin American socialists who are in who are in places where they can talk about this to be like, let's map all the socialist groups in Latin America so that we can talk about because I think it baffles Americans. Like, like yeah, I think that yeah.
C. Derick VarnEveryone knows about Shining Path, and I'm and I'm also like, we know them because they're weird, yeah, and violent. Like they like it's kind of like how people forget that the Naxalites aren't even the only Maoist party in India, not just the only Marxist party in India. Like although I will, I I I do have a I feel a little bit more defensive of the Naxal Bari than I do go onzo thought.
SPEAKER_03So, you know, although not one of it ended well, but I think my like the shining path is a great example of both a left and a right national front simultaneously. And I think I'm I'm I've been a defensive about a lot of different groups. I'm not very much of a defensist about the shining path.
C. Derick VarnI only met like four people who are true Shining Path defensists, even most Maoist who who intellectually come out of Marxist Linus and Maoism, they kind of distance themselves from Golanzo. Yeah. But there are there are like Red Guards Austin. If you want to read about a cult that was inspired by this in the United States in the I remember, I remember when they were releasing their videos on the Twitter and stuff.
SPEAKER_03That's that's how recent they were.
C. Derick VarnAnd how that when they were like dropping dead rats on like other Maoist scholars' door. Yep. The funny thing is that that group didn't even like fuck with the DSA, they were fucking with other Maoists. Like I remember when Jay, I don't know how I published them for years, and I can't say his name, Mouth Lob Paul. That's an indigenous name, so I've never and I've never heard it said, so I don't know how you say it. He's a writer of divided and uh continuity and rupture, which is a book that I can take pride, that I specifically had published at zero books.
C. Derick VarnNot even because I necessarily agree with it, but I thought it was the best explication of how Maoism developed in the 80s, and how when we talk about Maoism in in like North America, we're really talking about a post-82 phenomenon that really only gets reabsorbed into dungism when there's like active dummies activists in the odd teens, like the Cal Collective and Red Sailed and all that shit. Um and whatever Dominique Dominique Lacerta was up on.
C. Derick VarnBecause he was he was uh considered a right deviationist dungist in Italy, just so people know. But fascinating. That's yeah, people people don't know that. Like they think he's just like a normal Marxist Leninist. I'm like, no, the Marxist Leninists became Eurocommunist, and he like became a super dungist, and go so far as to argue that like not only is this not a transition, but like we need anti-colonial developmentalism forever, and we don't need the utopianism of thinking we could ever abolish classes, and for all is anti-liberalism, I'm like, you for all your anti-Western liberalism, what really just bothers you is they were hypocrites.
C. Derick VarnThat's yeah, that's what bothers you. It's not that you actually don't you believe a lot of the same things they do because you're a duggist, but you know, hence also his like Stalinism, and I use that in quotation. I don't like that word because it's confusing. I mean, people because there's people who I like that are Marxist-Leninists and people who I hate that are Marxist-Leninists, it's not really good. And calling all Marxist Leninists Stalinists is very confusing. I mean, Maoists barely are, yeah, particularly MLM Maoists, actually, oddly from dungist, who don't defend Stalin that hard.
C. Derick VarnIn fact, they bring up the 50s mal critiques of Stalin a lot. Yeah, they're just mad that Khrushchev did it for what they thought bad reasons and like threw the baby out with the bath water, kind of to save his own ass, is what they would say. And I think they're kind of not wrong about that. Um, even though I would also say that I will defend Khrushchev because I think Beria would have been worse.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yes, yeah.
C. Derick VarnAnd again, I'm a Khrushchev defensist when I'm talking to uh liberals, yeah, because Marxists, and then and Marxists who want to like say that Beria would have been better, or that like all the things against Beria was a slur, and I'm like everything I've ever read about that guy is terrible, yeah, like actual monster, and also his program was more liberalizing than Khrushchev's, so whatever, but like but yeah, if Stalin, if if Yizov was a monster and Stalin is, you know, a monster, then Baria is like a super monster, yeah.
C. Derick VarnLike, and I'm not big on the Stalin as a I know my my opinion on Stalin is one of those opinions that like people who like Stalin get draw sucker from, and I don't know why. And then people who hate Stalin either think I agree with them or think I'm a softie on it. I'm like, but I'm like, no, the problems of the Soviet Union are just beyond one dude.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think it's just hard. You can't really have a conversation about what the Soviet Union was if you're blaming it all on Stalin. Right. I feel a little bit about this when it comes to the fall of the Soviet Union too.
C. Derick VarnI like whatever that book is collapse, but I think it does it does a little bit of the apologia for the Soviet Union by bringing it all on Khrushchev. Yeah. Or not Khrushchev. Um, not Khrushchev, uh Gor Gorby. Good old Gorby, not Khrushchev. Because I'm also like, well, I'm just gonna say Brezhnev did not help at all. And um Dropov died. So we don't know what he would have been like. So, you know, and I yeah, I thought that too.
C. Derick VarnI it is weird to me, just as a side note, when talking and it is related to all of this, and we've been we've been trying to watch this line on like individual thinkers business movements, but how many people have like an almost idealist view of like the ideas of individual thinker Marxists are the superdeterminate factor, and I just do not believe that.
SPEAKER_03I yeah, I think this is big. Like you can you can chart a general vision or pathway as like an individual person, but like you can't actually I don't think that actually has that's not what is defining the failures of it, is you're not failing on ideas, I actually don't think. Some ideas.
C. Derick VarnI'd say the popular front, but yeah, yeah, the popular front ends up being but that's a failure of ideas at this point. You and I talk about the United Front, and I'm gonna I should actually pick up my old research on Jill Power because those are also things that I both like kind of believe in, but if I'm honest about it, I don't have a lot of examples of them working very well after like 1910 either.
SPEAKER_03So, or you know, like they they seem to have worked in very specific circumstances, but I I will say I do feel like this is, and at one point we might have to do an episode on like literally just talking about this a little bit is are these strategies only viable in the case of like international world destruction?
C. Derick VarnWell, I know so I know some Marxists who have picked up that that I have implied that are they picked it up on their own and then decided that we need a global war so that Marxism is possible again.
SPEAKER_03And I'm like, ooh boy. Yeah, that's that's not good. There needs to there has to be a different answer. There is that one Trotskyist sect that's just like after nuclear war. That's facadism, yeah.
C. Derick VarnYeah, but it's not just Prasadists.
SPEAKER_03I know some third worldists who believe this too, that like we need to engineer a world war so that and I'm like that that is indistinguishable from like the early 2000s neocons, yeah, yeah.
C. Derick VarnLike who are somewhat worse, actually. Like, because they I mean, like, it would be a nuclear war. There's not like because they they they want the proxy wars to be over in a direct confrontation between the great powers, and I'm like, that's bad. Like, I mean, like you might say that's indistinguishable from Peter Keel, like there will be no humans, but maybe communism will survive in robots, like yeah, which I don't think they believe, but like it's I'm just like, I think you're underestimating the danger of like why we have not had another world war, yeah, and why everything's in proxy wars after the 1950s because direct confrontation is just way too dangerous.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, the development of nuclear weapons is uh is is the uh is not an end, it's not the end of history, but it could be an end to history.
C. Derick VarnLike yeah. Well, it could be it can make the pre the the primo the primitive sujacent end of communization theorists, right? Like it's really easy to socialize everything when most of the world infrastructure has been destroyed and the population drops by seven billion. So although good luck growing food on irradiated land, yeah, and it doesn't do shit for climate change.
C. Derick VarnIn fact, it might make it a lot worse. So I don't know, man. I mean, like, but yeah, there we we do need to have this conversation because I have thought a lot about this because like the reasons why whenever it's like, oh, it all these revolutions happened in the periphery, and I'm like, but they all didn't just happen in a periphery, they happened in the periphery and former colonies and or large empires that were collapsing, and in the case of China, both they didn't even come from just peasants' movements internally, they came from broad scale collapse, both externally and internally simultaneously.
C. Derick VarnAnd there are a few exceptions to that, but none of the major powers can you say there are exceptions to. I mean, like the exceptions, yes, the exceptions are the anti-colonial powers, and like when you think about that, like the ones that were able to stay actually Marxist are Cuba, DPRK, and Vietnam, and to a lesser degree Cambodia kind of, because you know, there's another Marxist party that comes into power after the Khmer Rouge is gone.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
C. Derick VarnBut in all those cases, though, like the DPRK and Cuba get this don't integrate in the into international capital because they're not allowed to, not even because they don't even want to, it's just not allowed to.
SPEAKER_03Literally, literally, one of the reasons Cuba's liberalized so much in the last 10 years is because they're trying desperately to get in, because it's just it's unlike the DPRK, which has some workaround with China and like some it has a work around with China and Russia, which they've actually liberal like one one thing I will say that people don't notice they've liberalized trade but with two nations. Yes.
C. Derick VarnLike that's why their prospects changed under Kim Jong un as opposed to Kim Jong il, as Kim Jong un was more willing to liberalize trade, but within the sphere view of the two spheres it could actually operate with, since the sunshine party with the sunshine policy with the south, which people also don't forget about, because there was there was an attempt for economic cooperation between the during the end, then the end of the Kim Jong-il period, and then like under left liberal governments in the Republic of Korea that are abandoned during the global war and terror.
C. Derick VarnAnd so an alternative path wasn't really proposed proposed other than the military first policy until Kim Jong-un came to power and started making some four way with trade liberalization with China. So even there, there is actually and Russia, and even there, there's actually like something, but when it comes to Cuba, Cuba is just too isolated to easily have an easy route to do that. It had some routes with like Venezuela, it had particularly, yeah, yeah, particularly under Chavez, and some goodwill during the pink tide, but it was never really able to do a ton about that.
C. Derick VarnAnd like when I came like right after the occupy movement, I remember everybody's like the pink tide, we're gonna have socialism in Latin America, and I'm like, I think you're naive, and I'll leave it at that. You know, the one socialist country large enough and and well, the two socialist countries large enough and productive domestically enough to really stand up to the United States or Brazil and Mexico, and even that is heavily caveatted, they still mostly cooperate, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Like, but you know there was some rhetorical stuff that they could do, but even now, like they've I I will say, like, the the future existence of Cuba is really just up in the air at the moment because it does seem that like the pink tide is over entirely, and well, I mean, the other the tensions between Brazil and Venezuela and and Guyana all made it very difficult to deal with because those are all three left-wing countries that were at odds with each other.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
C. Derick VarnWell, Guyana and Brazil against Venezuela. And you know, I I know that a lot of people don't like to hear this, but it does seem like that part of Chavismo Allowed basically did a a coup by inaction nearing American. Because I don't understand how you don't lose that many, like that most of the people like 30 percent 30 of the hundred dead are like cute are like Cubans if the if the Chavistas had really been trying to defend Maduro.
C. Derick VarnI just don't see how that happens.
SPEAKER_03I don't see how you only lose 70, you know, that's especially when we know that at least at least a dozen of them were literally just civilians who are special air forces just like shot. Yeah. Like yeah, I I'm also on this. I think there were a couple people with some left magazines and left groups who were releasing things like, no, actually the Chavismo revolution is still ongoing right now. And it's like I I do not see that at all. I see I I can I can see an administration that clearly thinks they're going to be bombed to hell if they don't.
C. Derick VarnYeah, and who also thought that they're that Maduro was leading them into massive social crisis. I think like I think both things were real, yeah. And that makes a lot of American lefties really uncomfortable. But American lefties, you know, they have heroes that they project upon, they don't do materialist analysis very often. I mean, some of them do, I shouldn't be that general, but like I I really hate this, whether it's of foreign leaders are of I understand it more with historical people because at least they're dead and cannot betray you or fuck things up.
C. Derick VarnBut like Corbin worship. Look how that worked out for you.
SPEAKER_03Corbin worship in the US has made it so that people in the US have no idea what the economic situation in the UK even is at this point.
C. Derick VarnWell, even people in the UK will argue me about how bad it is. So even though I'm like the stats back it up as do popular opinion. But actually, I would say that a couple of young Zoomers, like, because all they've ever known is bad, and they don't know that it's been better. And I'm like, no, it's real bad. And it there's no easy way out, but particularly in Britain. There's no easy way out for anybody, but Britain in particular is a goddamn island. So like, and it's one that's been like resource exhausted since like the 17th century.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
C. Derick VarnI mean, not completely, and it's pretty, but like like they were having resource problems. That's part of why British imperialism happened.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
C. Derick VarnLike it was it was getting hard to grow enough domestic food in Britain as early as like shortly after Cromwell. I don't know, like it's just not it's not that bad. It's not like there isn't British grown pro like people might think this and say I'm saying something more than I am, but like, yeah, I mean we're off topic, but I I do find it interesting. I also find it interesting, like how much hero worship there is, even from people who you know you think would know better.
C. Derick VarnSomebody asked me, like, why does your audience care so much about like progressive electoralism? I'm like, they're confused, like they really want to identify with something to give them hope.
SPEAKER_03And like I think that's the question is like people really need to grab onto something to hope for right now. I mean the last 40 minutes of our conversation has been like the out the outlook is not great at the moment.
C. Derick VarnNo, and then but the thing is it's rarely ever been great.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. This is actually this is the thing, yeah.
C. Derick VarnLike when people are like, Oh no, the the capitalists are suppressing us. I'm like, they were suppressing us always. They used to suppress us a lot more violently, frankly. Like everyone's like, oh, the camps are coming. I haven't seen it, they don't need the camps. Like, like look, like, like, look when like Trump does an enmies list. Are we on it? We're not important enough to be on it. He's more concerned about damn fucking lemon, yes, or like chorus media, or whatever Midas Touch is doing, or like or like or like Jimmy Kimball and Steven Colbert.
C. Derick VarnLike, we're not even important enough to be on a stupid enemies list. The only one of us who is is is Sam Piker, everyone's favorite Malloid dirtbag leftist.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
C. Derick VarnLike, but you know, whatever. I guess, you know, I my advice to people is make sure your heroes are dead. Because they can't betray you. At least you know they're not like you have to deal with their legacy, and a lot of it's gonna be ugly, but at least it's not gonna be added to and make you feel stupid later. Everyone else, you should treat as a potential comrade or enemy, like, but not a hero.
C. Derick VarnAnd trust me, I am saying this not just on principle, but from my own life experience. I've had to eat crow on some heroes, so I would advise you not to do it. I used to like be a Mike Gravel worshiper. I was amused back in the back in 2020 when the bird people tried to like bring Mike Gravel back. Oh, yeah, they did the Gravel Institute thing, yeah, and all the Gravel teams, and I'm like, cool.
C. Derick VarnWait, I'm waiting for people to try to bring Dennis Kucinich back to you. These those are these are deep cuts of failed progressive politicians past.
SPEAKER_03One of these days, because the circle, we just keep going faster and faster.
C. Derick VarnWell, I did sort of say, like, how is how is Bernieism just like a slightly more mass version of the rainbow coalition? Yeah, like it's just uh but but nonetheless, and you know how many of us who are radical now are gonna be Van Jones or Gene Kwan or Robert Reich? Robert Reich was part of the Revolutionary Students Union, vaguely aligned with the RCP. Just you know, gonna point that out.
C. Derick VarnAwesome. Yeah, on that note, popular frontism and national frontism will be visiting Latin America so that I don't have to talk about certain other American movements that just make me sad. And on and so we're over protect your peace, people. Brandon will be back. We will finish this series probably in three episodes because I imagine Latin America is probably gonna be a lot to bite off. But I do think Latin America is probably the reason why I think I can justify doing it regionally is not only is it super complicated, but also the lines between national popular and united fronts really blur, yeah, particularly in Latin America, and you know, part of the reason why us dirty gringos fucking everything up, but that's not the only reason why, and we're gonna make that clear.
C. Derick VarnBecause, for example, we're we're we we didn't cause the pre. That's not us.
SPEAKER_03That's yeah, yeah.
C. Derick VarnThat was yeah, you know, we did horrible things in Mexico, but we did not do the pre. The party of the revolutionary, the the part the name of that, even with it like the name of that party is a contradiction. The party of the institutionalized revolution is what it translates to in English.
SPEAKER_03Oh my gosh, I didn't actually know that.
C. Derick VarnThe party revolution institutional, it's what it's like, and the and the party verde is actually like a split-off from it, and like Obrador is from the center left faction of the like he's his family's from the center left faction of the liberal part of the Mexican Revolution, which is what his street cray kind of came from. Scheinbaum is different, comes from comes from that, you know, party, but that party actually is also a real opposition party as opposed to the greens and and the pond, which were kind of not really opposition parties.
C. Derick VarnBut yeah, but the pre's fun and and depressing. Because yeah, I mean, well, the Mexican Revolution's like it's our continent's literal 1914 and 1917, and I find it amazing how understudied the fucking Mexican Revolution is and the United States, where we played an uh played a part active role, yeah. Yeah, because truths were there, yeah.
C. Derick VarnBecause Pancho Villa was like invading Texas. Like it's it is uh it's just like because there like Pancho Villa wanted the Republica uh Dano Norte, which is like was gonna include parts of Texas and California, so like yeah, it's it it's fun, and then the zapatistas, which I think got popular for the the the stuff going on in uh chiapas, more so than the actual history of the sapatist, are the Magonists who somehow have been forgotten about in history, unless you're a weird, very niche anarchist, yes, um, etc.
C. Derick Varnetc. etc. And I'm just like, yeah, this this is super important, and it happened, it happened in the 20th century right next door to us, and nobody knows about it. Very few American leftists know a damn thing about it. Um it's it's crazy. And on that note, we are done.
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn sits down with Dr. Ida Susser (Distinguished Professor of Anthropology at Hunter College and the CUNY Graduate Center) to explore her open-access book, The Yellow Vests and...
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by author, public researcher, and retired professor of psychology Dr. Warren Throckmorton to discuss his book, The Christian Past That Wasn’t: Debunking the...
In this installment of the National Fronts series on VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by writing partner Brandon Lightly to deliver a comprehensive historical and materialist deconstruction of Peronism (Justicialism)...
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by veteran sociologist, author, and activist Dr. Charles Derber (Boston College) to discuss his book Wired for Authoritarianism: American Oligarchies and How to...
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by psychiatrist, writer, and political commentator Dr. Tad Tietze (co-author of Left Flank) to unpack the evolving dynamics of anti-politics and hyperpolitics across...