Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Varn Vlog

Varn Vlog artwork

Peronism Explained with Brandon Lightly

Nov 12, 20261 hr 52 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this installment of the National Fronts series on VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by writing partner Brandon Lightly to deliver a comprehensive historical and materialist deconstruction of Peronism (Justicialism) in Argentina. Varn and Lightly trace the evolution of Juan Domingo Perón’s movement from the 1943 military coup (GOU) and his time in the Department of Labor to his 1946 democratic election and the charismatic role of Eva "Evita" Perón to his death and its aftermath. Featured Topics & Takeaways: The Rise of Justicialism: How Juan Perón leveraged labor courts, paid leave, and state-backed collective bargaining to formalize the Argentine working class. Third Positionism (Tercera Posición): Attempting to carve out national economic sovereignty independent of both US imperialism and Soviet communism. The Split of Peronism: The violent 1970s ideological rupture between the revolutionary socialist Montoneros and the orthodox, anti-communist trade union right. Work Cited: Finchelstein, F. (2014). From Fascism to Populism in History. UC Press. Germani, G. (1978). Authoritarianism, Fascism, and National Populism. Transaction. Laclau, E. (2005). On Populist Reason. Verso. Marxist Theory & Bonapartism Marx, K. (1852/1978). The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte. Norton. Peña, M. (1971). Masas, Caudillos y Elites. Fichas. Ramos, J. A. (1957). Revolución y Contrarrevolución en la Argentina. Plus Ultra. Trotsky, L. (1938-39/1973). Problems of the Latin American Revolution. Pathfinder. Gillespie, R. (1982). Soldiers of Perón: Argentina's Montoneros. Oxford UP. Hodges, D. C. (1976). Argentina, 1943-1976. UNM Press. James, D. (1988). Resistance and Integration. Cambridge UP. Political Economy, ISI, & "Stop-Go" Cycles Diamand, M. (1972). La estructura productiva desequilibrada argentina. Desarrollo Económico. Díaz-Alejandro, C. F. (1970). Essays on the Economic History of the Argentine Republic. Yale UP. Gerchunoff, P., & Llach, L. (1998). El Ciclo de la Ilusión y el Desencanto. Ariel. O'Donnell, G. (1978). State and Alliances in Argentina, 1956-1976. J. Dev. Stud. Prebisch, R. (1950). The Economic Development of Latin America. UN. Send us Fan Mail Musis by Bitterlake, Used with Permission, all rights to Bitterlake Support the show Crew: Host: C. Derick Varn Intro and Outro Music by Bitter Lake. Intro Video Design: Jason Myles Art Design: Corn and C. Derick Varn Links and Social Media: twitter: @varnvlog blue sky: @varnvlog.bsky.social You can find the additional streams on Youtube Current Patreon at the Sponsor Tier: Jordan Sheldon, Mark J. Matthews, Lindsay Kimbrough, RedWolf, DRV, Kenneth McKee, JY Chan, Matthew Monahan, Parzival, Adriel Mixon, Buddy Roark, Daniel Petrovic,Julian, Drea, Free Beer, SNT-BRCH, Joshua Parsons

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

C. Derick VarnHello. Hello, hello, hello. And welcome to BarnBlog. And today I'm with my colleague, increasing colleague, and article writing partner, Brandon Lightly. I'm gonna go ahead and out this announce this to the public so that we actually fucking do it.

SPEAKER_00No, this will that'll be good. That'll be good.

C. Derick VarnWe are working on both a commissioned commentary on the DSA program in quotation marks, and an analysis of the of the historical mergers thesis and its relationship slash non-relationship with the mass line, and then maybe theoretical problems of both. And then there may even be a third article that comes up that we write called their merger thesis and ours, which uh because I like trolling people, and I might even include Daniel Tut on this because I actually do think the merger thesis is in some ways redundant today because it's being it's happening from force of decomposition of the various social forces, anyway.

C. Derick VarnAnd there is an optimism about specialization both within the blue-collar and the white-collar workforce that is as if there is no trade-off to hyper-specialization. Hyper-specialization actually leads to de-skilling and cost of these. So these are things we might end up talking about. But at least two of those three articles are for sure happening. We've already begun them. I there's there's several pages of notes and all kinds of writing already done. So look for them to come out, they'll probably come out in Cosmonaut magazine.

C. Derick VarnThat's where I'm probably gonna pitch it with Brandon, but we'll see where they actually go. Who knows? I might even give it to like Promethean or Geese.

SPEAKER_00Ooh.

C. Derick VarnIf I want to start a fight. Uh I let I actually like the geese editors. I this is one of those things where like theoretically, I can't stand them, and then personally, I think they're comrades, and I actually do think they're more interesting than they look. They're actually not like what they actually want to do is wild. Because uh on my show, their editor literally said, you know, our aim is to get the DSA in charge of the Democrats, but also kicked out by them.

C. Derick VarnAnd I was like, I was like, Oh, okay, well, that's something. It's like like so. This is a this is a third secret option to the dirty break versus clean break theory, which is the force the other side to clean break you. Yes. But I'm like, I don't know that that's gonna go as well as you do, but like, you know, I it's actually at least to some kind of innovative thinking on our side.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. There's something there's something interesting about that framework for sure.

C. Derick VarnBut I think they're hard to figure out. But today we're not talking about any of that. No, we we we thought we were gonna do uh Peronism and Brazilian integralism together, but we're not because of a certain Southern cone South American pastry lovers' favorite topic, Peronism. And if you get that deep cut, you're you're you're gonna be one of my worst people you know us.

C. Derick VarnAlso, Peronism weirdly has become relevant again because people keep bringing up Ernesto LaClause's corpse and propping it up to bring back you know populist logic and socialism and hegemony back, and the their whole thinking is the empty signifier, and their whole model is Peron. But what I find interesting about Peron, and the reason why I wanted to separate, I think we've ultimately decided to separate him from Brazilian angroism, which will be our probably last episode in this part of this series.

C. Derick VarnI don't know what we're gonna do.

SPEAKER_00Um I think I think that's probably right. Yeah, I think that was the last move that we were gonna make.

C. Derick VarnThen we'll figure out if there's any more forms we need to talk about and talk about how nothing works. Um but Peronism is weird because it's the Schrdigger's cat of national fronts. Is it left national frontism? Is it right national frontism? Is it Cadill Nasbolism? Like and it's it's all those things until you open the box um and any given leader, and that's that makes it maddening to study and deal with.

C. Derick VarnSo let's talk about what it is. Peronism are judicialism in English. Oh my god, that is the worst word for this English.

SPEAKER_00It's also just like it's just a wild name for his party as well, because that's what it's kind of based off of is the party that came together under him.

C. Derick VarnWell, because the because the movement is judicious social, right? Uh, which is literally just social justice. But with that has a different name, and the that has a different meaning, and it actually codes right wing in Latin America, and that's something that I think is lost because of that adoption of that first by Marxist-Leninist and the Popular Front, and then later on by progressives, that social justice was taken to mean something else.

C. Derick VarnIn Latin America, social justice is usually taken to mean like, yes, in the American context, it kind of codes left-ish because it's economically corporatist, but historically, it does not code that socially left at all. You know, Pionono, the one of the most reactionary posts that ever did React was big into social justice.

SPEAKER_00Well, social justice also just means something fundamentally different when you're generally a somewhat colonized people, and economic inequality you're seeking to like break out, isn't between like your national classes, but between like an international class? It's right, it means something different. Social justice means something different, which is very important.

C. Derick VarnSocial justice also in in progressive world doesn't mean anything at all. So, like that's true, it's a lot like grassroots, right? It's it are organizing are organizing before someone tells you what they're actually doing. I'm an organizer. All right, which of the 50 things are you actually organizing? And how is it actually that you are you know? Sometimes I feel like in leftism for all of our materialist analysis, we actually believe in the prestidigitation of fucking words.

C. Derick VarnWe definitely do. Which, like, I'm like, are we all sophist after all? I'm not, but you know, I don't think I am. I mean what I say, and I define my terms, but but anyway, but so it emerged in the 1940s as a mass-based political movement that is largely defined by things that's very hard to put in our framework. One, it's rapidly anti-imperialist, see said South American pastry lover, the Greco-Argentine, the Greco Australian Argentine variety of pastry lover, if you don't know who I'm talking about.

C. Derick VarnThe guy who confuses people because he's always attacking MLs, but also hates Americans and sounds like a third worldist, but then you're trying to figure out what kind of third worldist he is, and then you're like, oh, he moved to Argentina so he could support Peronism. So weird. But then you have economic nationalism, corporatist welfare statism, and by corporatist, we do not we mean what it means in the fascist context.

C. Derick VarnWe do not mean what it means in the in the American context. It is not rule by corporation, it is it is the cooperation of classes in the state, and also depending on what period we're talking about, strong Latin social uh cultural conservatism, depending on the time period.

SPEAKER_00I mean, the the big thing to point out, even just like as Peronism is being birthed, is that Juan Peron, while in the military, as they're going about the military coup to begin with, initially supported Ori Beru, who did a military coup of and he wanted a specifically military dictatorship that ran along somewhat fascistic lines according to the Italian model. Peron then later was sent over to Italy while still in his military position to learn, I think it was like specifically, it's like mountain warfare from the Italians 1938 to 1940.

SPEAKER_00And then he came back, and a big selling point of his entrance into his like political career was that I want to take Mussolini's successes and Mussolini's failures. He was a big fan of Mussolini, not a huge fan of Nazi Germany, and completely disgusted by Francoist Spain.

C. Derick VarnYeah, he hated the phalangists. And that's also something that's weird about we haven't done our fascism episode. I've covered fascism. Way, way back, I covered the aesthetics and political economic theories around fascism, and I ultimately decided that no one can tell you what fascism is because it's a thousand things and nothing all at once. It is both the fail-son of liberalism and conservatism and reactionaryism and socialism, and the last part socialists are in denial about, but it's actually true.

C. Derick VarnThe particularly the Italian fascist leadership did come from the right wing of the Italian Communist Party, I mean socialist party, and the left-wing, what would have been considered by the Italian Socialists the ultra-left wing of the Italian Socialist Party, because it was the most left-wing thing that didn't lead with the communist, uh, the maximalist. Um, that's where Mussolini comes from. And it's that weird fusion of those three things that generated fascism.

C. Derick VarnNazism being associated with fascism seems to be an accident of the axis, because their under their underlying operational theories are different, but they're not, I mean, they're not that different. But like when people like, oh, you'll see this even amongst right-wingers, you know, we're not Nazis because Nazis believe in an ethnostate, and I'm like, the Italian not the Italian fascists did not. So you aren't Nazis, but you're not, but you are a fascist.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, I've always said that specifically Nazism, so the like ethnostate aspects of it is actually like a more of a like a liberal injection into like the German fascist project than like a fascist project, and that's not to absolve fascism of anything, but that is to say that like Nazism was very unique and it's very race-centric and race superior focus. That is actually a lot more associated with liberalism than it is with than it is with fascism.

C. Derick VarnAlso, everybody liked eugenics until the fascists came to power. Yes. Like you even find the you know, second international vaguely pro-eugenic arguments.

SPEAKER_00This is where I do fit I find some of the I don't know if they're third world as commentators, but a few of them saying the actual atrocity of Nazi Germany was bringing the like this somewhat like this eugenics colonialist project home. I I do think there's something to be said about that. Yeah, that like that's the actual atrocity.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I mean, I mean they and they bring it from multiple places, most famously in America, because we're obsessed with ourselves, and probably for good reason. Confederate and then US racial code laws are a big founder of Nazi thought, but it's not just that. There's also codes from Latin America that we just ignore, they were pulling from everywhere, which is part of why it's so hard to figure out what fascism even fucking is, because it depends on what you're talking about. I often split the difference and use the term fascistic, our post-fascist, our para-fascist, because there's nothing in and the three movements, the three European movements, and I'm gonna bracket out the Romanian guard and whatever the fuck was going on in Ukraine, set that over there for a second.

C. Derick VarnBut the three big movements from now. Yeah, I think we are gonna have to cover fascism and all this, but anyway, the the the three big fascist movements, the phalange, which doesn't actually take part in the Axis anyway, and got hostile, was hostile to everybody, and also weirdly, people who opposed Hitler and Mussolini were able to be okay with Franco. So, like J.R. Tolkien, not the most you know left-wing guy in the world, hated hated Hitler, hated him, hated him, hated him, did not like Mussolini, did not like apartheid South Africa, interestingly enough.

C. Derick VarnSomething, something he actually believed, Catholic social doctrine and stuff just something, but he fucking loved the phalange, so like it's it's weird. It gets even weirder in Latin America, as the next two episodes are gonna cover. So basically, in night in 1930, 1943, Argentina had yet another fucking coup um in June, and the coup was led by the Grupo de Oficiales Unidos, or the group of unified officials, which is I'm sorry, one of the most scary.

C. Derick VarnLike, I know that's a super bureaucratic name, but I am actually terrified of the idea of like rule by an aggressive militarized bureaucracy.

SPEAKER_00Um and this this was a group specifically designed by Franco to be like a political opposition group to the current, like it not it wasn't it's not a it was democratically elected, but it was a military junto. It was after they threw out Uriboru, they like a bunch of conservative like members of the military got together, formed a loose coalition, and got this guy. I think it was I think it was Gustavo, and then that that kind of line came through.

C. Derick VarnYou mean by Franco, you mean Perone, right? Oh no, sorry, or do you mean Franco? Okay, because I'm like no, I do mean Perone. Yeah, because I'm like, I'm like, I don't think the phalange actually have much to do with this.

SPEAKER_00No, sorry, Perone is the one who made the GOU.

C. Derick VarnYeah, so the GOU exists. We got it, it was vaguely leaded, led by Colonel Juan Domingo Peron of Avita fame for most Americans who grew up in the 1990s. And what was interesting about how he took power is despite being a military leader, he actually took over the Department of Labor. And Perone was really heavily monitoring the import substitution industrialization model, and was dealing with a largely unorganized working class that it was largely informally employed, which is often a problem in the periphery, and specifically is focusing on a section of the working class called the cabacitas nicres, which okay.

C. Derick VarnCan you translate that for me? I have a rough idea, but I'm gonna I'm like I know it's my Spanish is worse than my French. So well, never mind. Well, it cabacitas is not a word I encounter a lot in Mexican Spanish, so I I think it means like hold on. Okay, that is why I didn't recognize it. It's slang, it means black little heads.

SPEAKER_00Oh, okay.

C. Derick VarnSo this is like it means yeah.

SPEAKER_00Like moving more into like the uh like marginalized like Afro Oh my gosh, I don't know the word for it. But that makes sense, okay.

C. Derick VarnAre there Afro?

SPEAKER_00Is there a lot of I don't feel like I feel like Argentina is always like the it's like Norteño levels of pale for Latin America They there they were a larger like Afro like Argentine descendants made up like a larger portion of kind of like the Buenos Aires area like a larger like minority, but I think like up to like 20 or 30 percent. But but I don't know if that's the case today.

C. Derick VarnI am going to do some research quickly in my Spanish dictionary. So I do know that oh, okay, yes, but it doesn't refer to actually it does not refer to Afro Latinas, it refers to mestizo and and indignados. So this is why we have to look stuff up because if that was, I was like, I've like I've never heard that term for for Afro Lotinas in my life.

C. Derick VarnI I know most of the derogatory words. Um so I when I was reading that, I was like, well, for for weird linguistic digression, I'm like, I'm pretty sure that just means little head, but that makes no sense, and so yeah, that's what it means. Uh, specifically, according to Argentine Wikipedia, and yes, I'm using Argentine Wikipedia for this. This is the advantages of having a vague notion of Spanish. Quote is it's little blackhead is a term used in Argentina referred derogatorily to a sector of the population primarily associated with dark-skinned people of indigenous or working class mestigial origin.

C. Derick VarnGenerally, it was used in the early and mid-20th century by middle and upper classes of the Buenos Aires Cuellos and the metropolitan area, and to hear to a lesser extent by the same social sectors in the major urban centers of the Pampas region, such as Rosario a la planta. The term is embedded in a complex series of conflicting relationships between the Porteños and the Buenresses of Buenos Aires, Metropolitan Air, and the provincial residents from the north from the north, European immigrants and internal migrants from rural North Argentina are neighboring countries, the upper and middle classes, and the lower classes, and is often used by both Peronist positively and anti-Poronists negatively.

C. Derick VarnSo that's interesting. And that's not something this is why you have to look the Spanish stuff up because we get because just because you speak one kind of South American or Latin American Spanish does not mean you speak all of them, as I've discovered from moving from translating poems from Mexican Spanish and trying to translate poems from the Southern Cone and being like, what the blue bleepity bleep is that? A lot.

SPEAKER_00Because I'm like, Yeah, they don't say this, but Arabic is also very similar. I could tell you this story about how I got this kafia and then a bunch of other things just through a lot of mistranslation as we're talking back and forth to each other.

C. Derick VarnUh I did not did not any speak Arabic. I didn't I know some Mazri. Oh, nice. Yeah, street Mazri. Really, you don't know. That's just a that's just Cairo Egyptian Street Arabic.

SPEAKER_00I can't speak a lick of that. And I know that for a fact because that's how different Arabic is. But that's a well, yeah.

C. Derick VarnWell, the thing is it's got it's full of Coptic, Greek, Italian, British, and French loan words. So like it's I I feel like the and then some of the and then like some of the like we're really off topic, but some of the greetings are like pre-Islamic occupation. So like like Sabar al Ker and Sabar Noir, but you're like not Islamic.

SPEAKER_00Anyway, I will say that distinguishing factor that like that was Peron's like that was per like what a lot of like at least Juan was like focusing on in his initial building capacity to run, is like this is actually important for Peronism. Is that like I think I'm gonna be, I'm not sure where you fall on Peronism. I think I fall a little more critical of it, but it is important to point out that this is like this is a social nationalism that is not ethno-chauvenist, like chauvinistic, that it's meant to be like Argent, like Argentine is a broad national category to describe a bunch of different uh races and peoples that include indigenous peoples.

C. Derick VarnIt's civic integralist, which is we're also gonna see when we talk about the Brazilian ultra-right group, the integralist who are also not racist at all, weirdly, are at least not racist in the obvious ways, like in the in the ways that you'd think, right? They were not Nazis, and they had they had no biological conception of race, or they are some of them did, but like in general, it was not part of their politics, and that's also true for Peronism. Kind of the kind of is gonna come up, uh so but Peron himself was so as part of this military group, he expands the labor courts, he enforces collective bargaining agreements both with both international and national bourgeois institutions, he institutes paid vacations, he institutes retirement pensions, and he institutes accident insurance, and all these things seem relatively manual, but they're not.

C. Derick VarnAnd one of the things that you're looking at is like what he's doing is rationalizing formal formal employment, you know, in a way that would line up with like progressive reforms or like social democratic reforms of the early to mid 20th century, but he's he's doing it probably because he cares about the people, but also. Also, because he needs to rationalize the fucking market. So, like. And that does not need to be lost. It's like when I always remind people that the most the biggest one of the biggest creators of private property in the American history was actually the New Deal, and everyone like keeps their mouth shut.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it is it's important to point out that he wasn't doing this just for the workers, that his vision essentially, like from the beginning, was some kind of harmony between the like the ruling class, the land the landlords and the bourgeoisie. Although I don't think he ever used the term bourgeoisie.

C. Derick VarnUm, he doesn't use European terms. Like, no, he does not. And it's an integralist vision, very like early early Italian fascism, which is why we went on the word fascist stuff. Alright, so Perone becomes more popular within the military because he's working on the labor issues and doing economic rationalization, and he's really helping people out.

C. Derick VarnAnd that's all very sincere. This is very real. This is not just PR. That freaks out the other generals. A rival faction within the United officials. Still weirdly terrifying name.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

C. Derick VarnIt's kind of like the the pre in Mexico, the party of the institutionalized revolution. Oh god, that's so scary. Anyway, um, rival military factions arrested him, and on October 7th, the workers marched into the Plaza de Mayo, which shut down Bruno's Ares until the military released him. And then that mass mobilization made him kind of the you know, the cadillo are the bonapart of the labor movement.

C. Derick VarnHe then becomes democratically elected in 1946, so he goes from being a minor at well, a major but not core member of a coup group to the executive. And he go ahead.

SPEAKER_00One of the things that like he conditioned upon his release was that the the courts actually oversaw the election because the military like juntas had overseen the elections in different ways so that like conservative hardliners and some of the military like institutionalists could like form their own parties. And so this was like not only did he win this election, but it is widely seen as like one of the most democratic elections in Argentina, like in recent history for Argentina at that period. Yeah.

C. Derick VarnSo is popularly legitimate. Let's just let's put it that way. So he has a three-pronged, you know, movement. He basically he first puts up Catholic social justice, but in an anti-imperial context, as his as his as his ethos. He talks about economic independence for Argentina, which you know this has always worked out well for Argentina, ultimately.

C. Derick VarnIt's totally gone, totally great. It's not gone badly at all. Yeah. And then he he did something called Tercera Posición, which is often translated to political sovereignty, but that's not really a good translation for that term. It means something like, you know, the position of the land. And the reason why this is important is because it was not just that they were sovereign, this was a Nasserist move before Nasser.

C. Derick VarnHe aimed to be politically independent of both US capitalism and any form of Soviet or Warsaw Pact communism, and to be able to work as a neutral party between both factions. So you have some very Nasserist Arab Arab nationalist stuff, but before that's happening. This is in 1946, not 50, not the 50s. So the state nationalizes the railways, the central banks, and public utilities, and they use this to finance industrialization.

C. Derick VarnThey do they they do a lot of uh state control of agricultural export revenue so that they so that agricultural export uh profits stay within Argentina, so it's a pr you know basically corporatist protectionism. This is particularly through an institution called the IAPI in English, or the institution, uh the Instituto Argentina, Argentino de Promoción del Intercambio.

C. Derick VarnSo the promotion of the the promotion of the Argent, the Institute of the Argentinian Exchange Bank. That's what that means. He's also he starts a foundation under the image of his wife, Eva Peron. So you start the Eva Peron Foundation, and also the kind of somewhat unique actually in Cadet in Cadelios and other cults of personality in Europe and Latin America amongst the time, or even in the United States, because FDR is kind of one of these two.

C. Derick VarnIs you have a cult of personality around the first lady as well, which is kind of unique, actually.

SPEAKER_00And it is, it's kind of fascinating because it's almost uh I actually I one of the things that I wish I had a better understanding of the timeline with is because going into his second term, Ava has terminal cancer, and they know this, but it's not publicly revealed yet. And then so I'm always I'm curious how much like when the foundation was begun, like if they had known it or anything like that. But it's very interesting that like not only was like the cult of personality around Ava strong, a lot of people would say it's stronger.

SPEAKER_00And like a lot of people, I mean, a lot of people point to the fact that when he eventually returns to power, which we'll come to eventually, uh he actually one of the ways he like brands his new relationship with his new wife after Ava passes is he calls her Isabel Ava to go like this is the next Ava, and we're gonna make her the vice president. Like it's such like a very and I mean a literally everything if you look up Peronism in English is going to be mentioning this musical, Avita, yeah, and Ava. So like even in English speaking context, Ava's definitely still the person that is like remembered.

C. Derick VarnIn high school, when Madonna played Avita and the uh musical by Andrew Lloyd Rebber. But it's interesting because Avita establishes she does the thing that like we associate with like uh I don't know, modern world minor princesses and stuff like Princess Diana, which she she goes and does charity work specifically in the in the worst parts of Argentina.

C. Derick VarnShe also becomes a a figurehead for pushing women's suffrage. Also, my favorite weird my weird thing that people miss about fascism, not and again, not the Nazis, but like fascists, even though they didn't patch women's suffrage, they actually advocated it before a lot of socialists did. Yeah, I think it's a weird historical fluke.

SPEAKER_00But and this is the thing that I like especially like with Ava and like their entire relationship is that one on one hand, you have not only Ava's like the foundation named after her that's specifically helping to provide uh funding for the poorest people, but you have universal vacation time, half of which is paid, I think it's 15 days, half of which is paid for, like the travel costs are paid for by companies and everything. You have universal healthcare in like specific ways, but then at the same time, you have like a reinstitutionalization of like pretty pretty patriarchal, like gender structures and things like that, to the point where not like homophobia was like very rampant, and part of the part of Perone's actual like rhetoric against homophobia was by legalizing brothels.

SPEAKER_00So they'd crack down on homo like on like openly gay people in the military and in government offices, and then they legalized brothels and then eventually prostitution, which led to the whole split with the Catholic Church, which we'll get to. But uh but that was like almost like this like counterweight of like we're going to like reinstitutionalize brothels, we're going to like legalize brothels while at the same time like cramping down on like LGBT activities, like clamping down on gender roles while also having universal health care. This is this is actually this is a side note. This has been my fear of the United States for at least a decade at this point, is that one day Republicans are going to figure out universal health care, but just for my people.

SPEAKER_00Um yeah.

C. Derick VarnI also thought that maybe they'd also do like student loan forgiveness in exchange for killing the student loan program. Yep, yeah. I I actually think it would be a very popular move for because it would do it would actually destroy the modern university system entirely and also do patronage politics. But weirdly, they can't they're too corrupt to do that.

SPEAKER_00But anyway, luckily for the US left, the US right is so completely incompetent they can't pull anything together.

C. Derick VarnNo, when they try to do populism, they suck at it, and then and then like when they actually have the power to do populism, they're so utterly venally corrupt that no one like has any faith in them.

SPEAKER_00So it just but yes, anyways, that was the rabbit hole to talk about Ava for a second.

C. Derick VarnWell, I mean, let's talk about Ava Perone a little bit more, though. I mean, once they legalize prostitution that leads to direct conflict with the Catholic Church, this hits at the time when when Ava dies in 1952 from a hidden authority in cancer, and then Perone starts using the military to suppress the right, which unfortunately a lot of the military is also sympathetic to the right, so they're having the military suppress people that they're sympathetic to, which usually does not go well for you.

C. Derick VarnBecause again, despite having come from the military and having control over the military, he didn't purge the military.

SPEAKER_00He didn't. In fact, he left the military when he first got into elected office, he became a civilian administrator of it, right? And this is also when Ava dies, is kind of the point where we start to have the many different Peronisms start to develop because you have Peronists now that are actively against Juan Peron, because they're like, Well, you know, if Ava were alive, she wouldn't have let this happen. There was a lot of that kind of talk, and then that's kind of what leads to like feminist Peronism, which leads like there's a left Peronism that develops from it's this is where things turn into a mess.

C. Derick VarnWe're gonna do this. So this happens in in 1952. The uh the hardened conservative opposition gets real hard because they're being authoritarianly suppressed, but you know, being also authoritarian conservatives, they they start doing what those people do and like start making inroads into the military who's sympathetic to them, and you know, forming militias in 1955, so three years later, the right part of the of the military.

C. Derick VarnWell, it's actually not, it's a little bit weird to say that it's all right wing, it's not all right wing, but it's mostly led by the right, like the further right. Then I don't there is the revolution liberadora, which is you know one of those fun, ironic names that is the liberate the liberatory revolution, um which is a violent military coup, like your third one in less than 50 years.

SPEAKER_00This one was also explicitly backed by the US. Yeah, the US, the the Eisenhower administration is backing this because Peron is fucking with their Monroe Doctrine, kind of he also that since 1945, because Argentina had been neutral in the war since they had good relationships with like Italy and Japan. Argent like in the initial ramp up of Perone's power, I think I read, and I can't I wasn't able to like confirm this, but I think I read that like wage increase like real wage increases went up by 20% for Argentinians, but then that kind of plateaued as Marshall Plan funding wasn't able to be given to Argentina or anything because they weren't they were they didn't join any sudden, yeah, yeah, and so that became like fairly unpopular as well.

SPEAKER_00So you have US backing, yeah.

C. Derick VarnYeah, also the Marshall Plan was as was pointed out by Paul Maddox Sr. at the time, remarkably ungenerous to Latin America, yes, because the US saw how they could integrate Europe into their things, into their stuff as a junior equal partner, equal bin, strong quotation marks. They did not see how they could do that in Latin America, uh, and for ways that make multipolar sense, even though that's you know, this is a part of multipolarity people don't like, but like the hegemon in a region wants to dominate their own region, they are perfectly willing to be generous to people slightly more of an ocean away to tie them into their trade networks, but they're not going to tolerate that on their own hemisphere.

C. Derick VarnYou see this, and it's not you see this in a lot of different configurations, China before China and Asia in the 19th century, Russia with all of its neighbors forever, um, you know, um, and so on and so forth. Uh the Swedish Empire when there was such a thing, yes, Virginia, there was a Swedish Empire, and apparently they were terrifying. Uh, but anyway, so you have all this go on in 1955.

C. Derick VarnThe military and actually the civilian government, too, is not it is not just a military move. They banned the Peronist Party, so no more per no more ho justice or who discipl. I how do you even say it? I don't know. I can't say that word in English, much less Spanish. Anyway, it might be easier to say in Spanish, actually, but they criminalized the symbols, and unlike Peron, they purged the state and military apparatus.

SPEAKER_00A thing that they had to do because under at least the last few years, you had to be a party member to be working in the state job. So it was very much a oh my gosh, what is it?

C. Derick VarnIraq shoot debahification, yes.

SPEAKER_00It was, yeah, they did a debafification process, which I mean, things did not go well for them.

C. Derick VarnNo, no, debafification, unfortunately, has only really worked not in the BAFIS, it's actually only really worked with the Nazis, and then it was immediately undone. Immediately undone. To the point that at one point the Western government had more Nazis in there, our former Nazis in their government offices than the actual Nazi government had actual Nazis. So even there, I said it worked, it worked in the sense that like they were able to reverse it in terrifying ways, but whatever.

C. Derick VarnSo Perone goes into exile into Madrid. I find that funny given how much he hated the phalange.

SPEAKER_00Interestingly, when he goes into exile, this is again one of the weird things about Peronism, is that when Peron goes into exile in Madrid, he immediately starts to like increase like some of his like rightist language a little bit more. He's trying to like cultivate recultivate a relationship with the Catholic Church that eventually he and his new wife Isabella a few years down the line will then like bring back together. Because Peron, one of the reasons that this happened as well is that Perone is excommunicated by the Catholic Church, and under the Argentinian Constitution, you have to be a member of the Catholic Church to be president.

SPEAKER_00Is this still true? I actually don't know if that's still true today.

C. Derick VarnI do believe it's president, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Um yeah, at the time you had a presidente. So yeah. But while he was in Madrid, moving his language to the right, shifting more rightward, probably trying like appeasing more carlists in the phalange route. Che Guevara was also privately writing him letters saying that he would support Peron returning to Argentina.

C. Derick VarnYeah, it's that's why Peron is so wild. So let's talk about this. You have two wings that develop around the early 1960s, and really got more than that. But like there's two basic tendencies. People were picking up on two things. One, this return to the Catholic Church from from uh Peron while he's in Spain leads a more Catholic-centered union apparatus to come up, and they also are more they're they're also die-hard anti-communist bureaucrats.

C. Derick VarnSo you have the leaders of these anti-communist labor unions, like Augusto Vandor and uh Jose Ignacio Rucci, who basically become orthodox Peronists, the which we now refer to as right Peronists. Then you have the Montaneros and the Far who inspire uh more youthful Avita worshipping uh Peronist to incorporate more and more Marxist ideas and try to like reach out to like Guevarist and stuff like that.

C. Derick VarnAnd they saw him as like a an almost left bonapartist leader of a national liberation movement, and these hate each other, like too. This is the other issue, like so Peronism becomes self- not only is it outlawed, but in so much that it still exists, it's at war with itself, too.

SPEAKER_00Like in a way, left Peronism can really be described as like the proto-pink wave, I think.

C. Derick VarnSo then you get June 73, and there is the NZA, which I'm probably mispronouncing because that one's weird. Massacre, which there's white wing snipers and left-wing students, and the government's just not involved, and like, but the government doesn't do anything to stop the white-wing snipers from killing the left-wing students. This leads to chaos breaking out because also the government's not particularly competent in this time period.

C. Derick VarnSee the removal, the debafification of Peronists.

SPEAKER_00So to be clear, these are these are right Peronists shooting left Peronists. Like, there is not an anti-Paronist element here, right? Because uh the party had just gotten re-legalized, I think, the year before or something.

C. Derick VarnRight. So this is this is yeah, this is what's clear. It's like the the the the the military government doesn't do shit about the right polonist shooting the left peronist. But this actually tells you where they're actually are because Perone comes back to power, he's elected for a third term, and then he uh puts Isabel as the vice president, which I don't know, I don't think I don't think he did that with a Vita anyway.

SPEAKER_00No, he was going to, but because of her terminal diagnosis, he wasn't able to. So this was like kind of like a repromise of that, is what I've at least read.

C. Derick VarnSo this is why I've always interpreted Peron as a cadillo more than anything else, because I'm like, you're establishing your family as the executive branch, like and this actually happens in Peronism more than once.

SPEAKER_00It's one of the only through lines of Peronism, right?

C. Derick VarnBut what Peron immediately does is kick out the the Montaneros from the Peronist movement, so all the left is kicked out, he denounced them as quote, infiltrated, buildered use, infiltrated by communists. But then what does he do? His ass dies of natural causes. So uh within a year, yeah.

SPEAKER_00But quickly, like there were some CIA documents that say that like they were suspicious that he had that he was like not cognizant or there when he was elected, like when he entered office that year. Like it was it was a quick downturn.

C. Derick VarnAnd then it gets even worse because Isabel is not a Vita at all. Isabel Isabel Vita Isabel Eva is yeah, it was like Isabel Eva or something, yeah. Yeah, is she assumes power, but with the influence of the social welfare minister Jose Lopez Riga, but Riga is a founder of the Triple A. Now that doesn't if you're thinking that's your car insurance, you're you no no no no no no no no no. This is an anti-communist alliance.

C. Derick VarnThe Alancia Anticomunista are Argentina, which was not just not just a little bit anti-communist, these are not like Samuel Gompers or even like the American Red Scare. These are like the Contras. Uh so they have death squads that go and hunt down the Montaneros and the other left Peronists, and also the Marxists in Argentina.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, important to say that there was a socialist party, at least when he was first elected, who joined who tried to form a Popular front with the radical liberals. The radical liberals rejected it. They got destroyed, and then the Socialist Party was destroyed after that, essentially. But right.

C. Derick VarnSo the the so the AAA tries to rap them out. This time period, all shit's breaking loose. What do we have again? A fourth military coup sponsored by the U.S. In 1976. So two out of four sponsored by the US. And the AAA gets to go gangbusters. The military also launches a brutal dictatorship, but it's also not very long-lasting, very stable. It only lasts in 1983. And they target the socialist left the most, but then they also go after Peronist, including some moderate ones, which becomes you get what happens.

C. Derick VarnNow we get into the splits of the 80s post-dictatorship transformation. So the coup doesn't last but for roughly seven years. The repression stop and the Peronas come back, but now there are more than two factions. And we're gonna have to so in the 80s, you have the Revolution Ponanista, which were instant which would be like democratic institutionalists.

C. Derick VarnLike they just drop it. But there's still left wing and right wing elements to Peronism, even during this time period. And there we go. So they abandoned the military style dictatorship, partly because even though they were relegalized, they didn't win it. Like Peronism loses out to Raul Alphonsu Alfonsine, I think. Alfonsine, who I don't know much.

C. Derick VarnYou know anything about Alphonsine?

SPEAKER_00No, I don't.

C. Derick VarnI don't know much about him at this time period. I admit the the 80s is actually my weakest point on Latin American history, except for Mexico. I know I know uh Mexican history from this time period, but or in the 90s, which I remember, which is weird. So you have uh Carlos Menim, our Meninism, and what he does is exactly what you'd expect all the Keynesians and Social Democrats to do. It's he pegs the Argentine pays up to the dollar, he privatizes all the state enterprises.

C. Derick VarnThis is a Peronist who does this. Um he deregulates mar markets and he aligns with the US, so maybe they won't coup him. And this goes on for a while in the 1990s. This leads to Kircher Kirchnerism, which is what I mostly remember, uh, which is like center center to center left developmentalism.

SPEAKER_00And I actually feel like this is like the the like lasting impact of Peronism is the fact that under Perone, the state apparatus, all of them became party members, and so then it's like you that the you have so many splits because all of a sudden you have a faction that's just like let's just do institutionalism, let's just maintain what we have. You have your like left faction of students, and then you have your right like reactionary faction that kind of like got them into power in the first place. All of these factions have to exist simultaneously, and then once the once Perone dies, it just splinters out, and so Peronism can mean about anything.

C. Derick VarnSo, yeah, so we got Nestor and Christina Fernandez de Kirchner, who are interesting even in their name, because you can already hear their their uh criolos, although I think most of the leaders were criolos, but they're criolos. So they start because of the disaster pegging the peso to the dollar, making all of Argentina's debts really, really problematic for them, but also because also all their other the other thing that we have to put with Manim in context is the Soviet Union's gone, NATO and all of Europe is aligned with the US.

C. Derick VarnThere are no strong powers in Latin America that you can easily pull up to. I mean, they managed to hold on for a long time, they're still holding on right now, although I don't know how much longer that's gonna last. I hope you know, I hope for their sake it does.

SPEAKER_00I mean, you this is this is also like Minem is during the exact time period when NATO is not just like a threat, but is actively bombing like Yugoslavia. Yeah, like this is like this is happening in real time. It's like, oh, this is what happens when you defy NATO right now, right?

C. Derick VarnAnd also they all remember the 80s when like you know, bullies, whatever happen with Nicaragua, but not that Nicaragua was run by a good guy, it was run by like an awful guy, but still you have you had all kinds of stuff. So you have a reinstitutionalization of state intervention, you start seeing an expanded social welfare state, but by expanded, I mean we're talking like not even European levels, like we are more than American, less than European, probably is the way I put it.

C. Derick VarnThey try to renegotiate the debt because of the debt crisis that Argentina's been in forever now. I mean, like, this has been perpetual at this point. I remember this as and then and then once the peak tide happens, they shift over to the pink tide. They kind of run the show until recently.

SPEAKER_00So there you go. What I found in researching specifically Peronism is how much Malay was like a liberal darling that was like kind of, I mean, just like you can listen to different podcasts or anything. Like you have the econom you have the economists and a bunch of other like publications like that talking about like how these free market ideals are really going to push Argentina in the right direction. And a lot of them are very much like celebrating the downfall of Peronism. It definitely feels like it's like this is one of the last bastions of this 20th century social movement.

SPEAKER_00I wouldn't I socialist is hard to say, but social movement that is like we should be relegating to the 20th century. And this is very much like in a similar way, like Lakud's defeat of like labor Zionism. Like yeah, there's a lot of that where it's just like actually, you know, this is a perfect parallel to the downfall of Kemalism in Turkey.

C. Derick VarnOh, yeah, yeah. Like Ataturks, people, I mean, like in the rise of Erdogan's like soft Islamist faction and Urdagonism, like like Kirchner, because also the the the Kamalists are all over the place ideologically, they were just you know militant secularists, but you by that we don't mean they were militant atheists, they just didn't want Islamists, but like they were also like throwing spaghetti against the wall ideologically, so and they also had a similar like sometimes we're state interventionists, sometimes we're liberalizers, like the only thing they would really care about is keeping those damn Islamists out of power, and they managed to do it until Ordragon.

C. Derick VarnSo I mean what you do find is interesting because in the 80s the Peronists are kind of down on their luck at first, but but like they change with the times when the pink weight is dominant, they are pink wavists. When the Washington consensus is dominant, the Peronists are Washington consensus people because they're just trying to renegotiate Argentina's economic situation because, well, I mean, they've had debt problems since the yeah, they're they're entirely defined by the debt crisis and trying to get a hold on that.

C. Derick VarnSo what is interesting today is Peronism is like still important in Argentine life, but it's not really an ideological movement, even now. I mean, they're still right and left Peronist, and what they share is they're nationalists, they're regional governance, and they're they have a strong organized labor. The other thing that's happened in Argentina since the downfall of Christina de Kirchner is that the ethno-nationalism in Argentina has been the white ethno-nationalism in Argentina has been back in ascendant, and that's even come out in like they're at the way they behaved at the World Cup.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was about to say that was a very big talking point in the World Cup.

C. Derick VarnSo, so this is where we are. Also, confusingly, when we get into the Montaneros as we're talking about them, even though I you can see if you can see Kirchnerism as like Montenero is light, but also confusingly, the Monteneros called themselves socialismo nacional, which is you know national socialists, it was totally gonna go over well with everybody else. They they interpreted Peron's pop populism as anti-imperialist, as like a step towards national consolidation and socialism, and somewhat reconcilable to either new democra new democracy Maoism, which is why we group included Peronism in this national front discussion, or like popular front guaverism.

C. Derick VarnThose are the two kinds of things that they saw themselves as sympathetic to. They're also way more religious than the Marxist, even though they're far left wing. A lot of them are associated with the with the national liberation movement. In fact, back in the day when I was talking about Pope Francis, I actually was suspecting Pope Francis was gonna be more reactionary than people thought he was going to be or than he ended up being, because he survived the purging of the Montaneros, which is also where a lot of the national, the national liberationists who were also tied to liberation theology, including the priests, got killed.

C. Derick VarnAnd Francis survived that. So I was like, Do we know he's actually all that progressive? And kinda, but not really. I mean, like, in some ways, actually, our Chicago Pope who worked in Peru is even more left-wing than Francis, but none the left.

SPEAKER_00Um another Franco connection is that our the current Pope, not mine. I'm I'm a Protestant heathen, unfortunately. Yeah, um, but the current Pope has done more against specifically Opus Day, an organization specifically founded under Franco, to spread those like more Carlis and Phalangeus uh Catholic doctrines.

C. Derick VarnYep. And they've also banned the Legionnaires of Christ, which were which were even more than Opus Day. By the way, I am ethnically Jewish, but my brothers who do not share a parent with me, one parent with me, specifically the Jewish one, are Catholic, and one of my brothers are ethnically Catholic, as I like to say, like I am ethnically half Hebraic. But that makes sense. That's a real thing. Yeah, yeah, no, that's a real thing. But they're ethnically, they're ethnically, you know, Euro Catholic, not not Latin, Latin, not Latinidad Catholic.

C. Derick VarnBut anyway, point is one of my brothers was temporarily in the lay in the lay mission of Opus Day for a little while. Oh wow. Um uh he he lost faith, so he didn't stay there, but like and he's working class, but yeah, when the when Opus Day was like a real big mover on on even the American Catholic right in the 90s, they recruited one of my brothers as a teenager, used to wear that weird self-torturing anklet and everything.

C. Derick VarnYep, yep. So, anyway, what is crazy is when we look at what Perone did in exile, is he played both sides against each other and then purged one of the sides. So, what we do know for sure, we don't necessarily know that it was Juan Perron himself because it's unclear how cognizant he really was in the late 70s, right or early 70s, right before he dies.

C. Derick VarnBut he he actually would praise the special formations, have dialogues with Che Guevara, but then was also pushing these deeply Catholic anti-communist union bosses and even making alliances with more phalanges, the elements that he had priorly hated, the Carlist and whatnot. I don't know if that was under the influence of Isabel. I haven't read enough of the stuff in Spanish to figure that out.

SPEAKER_00So I yeah, there's like there's like some there's like multiple different stories of Isabel that like I haven't quite been able to parse. One is that she came from like a working class background, which I don't think is necessarily true. The other is that she came from a more like conservative, older money, but like not rich, but old money background, and so had inroads with the Catholic Church and was like kind of the leading push behind some of that. And then another completely different narrative is that she was completely just a puppet the entire time. She just like she was branded as like the new Ava, and Ava did come from a more like working class background, which was part of her like Cinderella story.

SPEAKER_00Like a lot of the reason why she became very popular, specifically with the working class, is that she was an actress who came up. She's not from Old Money. So there's a lot of like internal dynamics when it came to that. I don't, I can't quite parse out what exactly I saw something that said that she was like a night dancer at one point, and that like Peron met her at like a brothel-esque thing, and there's another that she was like introduced by a family member. So I don't actually know. I also need to go through the Spanish sources some more.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I the I felt like the American the English sources were like very vague.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um also just for anybody researching Peronism in English sources, it's you're gonna find one of those situations where it's a lot of like liberal academia critiquing Peronism for the wrong reasons. Right. Where I I was literally, I read a thing and it was like this academic being like appalled at the fact that like Peron would expand, like would have like guaranteed like work leave, as if that was just bad in and of itself. No, nothing about economic factors or anything. I'm just like, what okay.

C. Derick VarnSo let's talk about Peron's rejection of the left right before he dies, though, because this is actually a little more complicated than my initial story made it. So one is despite the fact it was a right-wing military, junto got rid of him, when the party's really legalized. Initially, there is a left-wingish president of Argentina, and Hector Campora, who is very, very quickly, very, very unpopular, and basically leaves office to avoid worse things happening, and that is when Peron comes back.

C. Derick VarnSo he's already coming back off of the backs of basically defeating a center-left figure who had become very unpopular very quickly.

SPEAKER_00His term was uh two months, it was less than two months, right?

C. Derick VarnBut then there is the the NZINZA massacre, which is also around the same time. 13 people get killed, uh, several hundred get wounded, and as you were saying, this was an inter-Pyronist fight. Peron seems to sit on his hands initially, despite distancing himself from the left, but then almost Kirov style, for those who know your Soviet history, one of the conservative union bosses gets assassinated by uh Montaneros, and that is Jose Ignacio Rukhi, who I mentioned before.

C. Derick VarnSo Rukhi had wanted to force Peron into more concessions to the more traditional Peronist uh position, but the but when the Montaneros killed Ruki to force Peron into concessions, that really pissed Peron off. And Peron then kicked the even the Montanerarists who had no ties to the assassin, which was most of them, out at a convention on May Day, and he called them estupidos y embeardes.

C. Derick VarnStupid and bearded infiltrators, which prompted even the moderate Montaneros who were not into assassination to just walk out of the party en masse. Then, once Peron dies, we already mentioned this, Riga founds the triple A, which became a Peronist-backed left-wing death scroll, primarily aimed at killing other Peronist. So yeah.

SPEAKER_00Something to point out about Peron, which is like probably a more sympathetic lens, is that it does seem that throughout his life, up until the kind of split there at the end, he was pretty scarred because he went through Phalanges, Spain immediately after the Civil War was over. And I think one of his public declarations that he'd never make the people of Argentina go through that. So he tried to walk this line for a while. But then it's the second he dies, the death squads come out because he picked a side.

C. Derick VarnBut he picked a side, but he was trying he was to give him fairness, he was trying to constrain how bad it gets. But what's interesting is the death crowds are are are so violent because uh Riga and Isabel basically announced by 75 that the military should annihilate, quote, subversive elements, unquote, which starts a dirty war, of which ironically they lose. Yeah, yes, but not to the but not to the left, who gets just annihilated by both sides, but to the even more right.

C. Derick VarnSo that's what starts the dirty war. It completely destroys the Montaneros and the Marxists. It's not they're not just going after the Montaneros, they're going after the Marxist, the Guevarists, all those groups. Sure, there's anarchists involved. And while you know most of Latin America went through terror campaigns of Hutas in the 70s and 80s, this one seems to have been particularly bad. Um, you know, that's where a whole lot of your liberation theologians get martyred. That's when, as we said, the revolutionary and even a lot of the reformist left is completely and totally decimated.

C. Derick VarnAnd then, you know, the more right also turns on at least the center elements of Peronism, too. And I guess the right-wing pronists can kind of make can make hay with that if they renounce Peronism, but there you go, and thus you have this. So let's actually try to parse what all this was. I mean, like, and we can deal with the modern stuff anyway. One there is a strong relationship between Peronism and Fascism, and there is a strong relationship between Peronism and Marxism, and there is a strong relationship between Peronism and both left and right populism.

C. Derick VarnAnd oh my god, does that make it difficult to talk about?

SPEAKER_00Yes.

C. Derick VarnSo Perone was very, very initially inspired by corporatism and mass mobilization, both Catholic and non-Catholic corporatism, but he clearly did not, at least early on, have a strong Catholic inclination, and so he moves towards Mussolinian corporatism, which in its early days was hostile to the Catholic Church, although that is immediately that is eventually undone because that needs to be talked about.

C. Derick VarnThey also did fascia style sectural bargaining, although, you know, as I've said, the sectoral bargaining would actually be a benefit. So the Tercera position, I missed God, I'm bad at Argentine Spanish. I said it was the position of the land because I was reading it as terra, but that's wrong. It's it they were third positionist.

SPEAKER_00Well, this is this is the thing I was gonna bring up is that he specific like one of the frameworks that he builds out in the in the early like Peronist years is that neither Yankee nor Marxist, but like a third way, like he's very explicitly like a third positionist, right?

C. Derick VarnWhich is by the way, fascism is a first third positionism.

SPEAKER_00Yes, it actually it when we're talking about fascism. One of like I like the word fascistic. I actually like third positionist to describe whatever is going on with all these movements even better because I think that actually more encapsulates when we talk about like what a fascist is. Yeah, you're trying to build that third position, right?

C. Derick VarnSo Peronism utilized Bonapartist Parismatic authority, they also had a state control media. And they were big on personality cults, as we've already mentioned. Although the one around Eva actually sticks far harder than the one around Peron Juan Peron himself, and he was really into mass wily. So you have all that mass politics and spectacle that you get. I mean, you also get it from Soviet. I mean, it's hard that like we always say this is an element of fascism. The personalist part of it is actually really interesting because at the time in the 30s and 40s, the only government that doesn't have a strong personalist leader that's like major is probably Britain.

C. Derick VarnYeah, because Churchill's out. Church is out, so like, and Churchill wasn't at Churchill was Churchill's famous ros, but he didn't run Britain in a personalist way. But FDR did.

SPEAKER_00People shouldn't look up what FDR uh wrote to Mussolini at one point. No.

C. Derick VarnVirginia, that wasn't just made up by neocons. And so uh, in fact, I also tell people to read another Wolfgang Swobelbach book. There's three cultures of the feet. There's also his book on the Three New Deals. Oh, excuse me. It's Three New Deals and it's Cultures of Defeat. And the Three New Deals actually talks it, it does a comparison contrast between High Stahl and Marxist Leninism, uh, Italian the various fascisms, and that's cool.

SPEAKER_00I'm gonna I'm going to read that.

C. Derick VarnAnd and the FDR regime. It's three new deals. It's an interesting book. It's I think it's Swivelbach. It may not be Swivelbok, usually so, but yeah, so the third position stuff that's actually clearly fashcoded. I mean, that they're the people who use it. But there's a lot of differences too. We've talked about some of them. Like most Latin American things, they were more in the like cosmic or a Raza civic nationalism. Anyone can be in Argentine. They were really pushed into multi-class welfare, so they were they were influenced by corporatism and distributism.

C. Derick VarnBut this is integrationalist theories of the state.

SPEAKER_00Their unions were also consolidated into like a state union.

C. Derick VarnYeah. Well, this is what's interesting. So the lot of people talk about classical fascism smashing the independent trade unions, but they didn't do that in Italy. They they they did set up fascist unions and union independence, but they also did that in Argentina. What they didn't do was the smashing of labor that the Nazis did. And actually, the Nazis are weird in how much they crush labor compared to the other fascists. It's like the Nazis and the Iron Guard are the people who like kill all labor organizers. Whereas the Peronists like basically put gomperist labor, I mean, for an American analogy, gomperists like labor leaders into everywhere.

C. Derick VarnBut they are big on like wage increases, sectional bargaining, and collective bargaining power, which you saw in Italy, but not in Germany. And so we got that difference. And they were anti-imperialists. It's easy to say that fascists were pro-imperialists. The thing is, though, that fascists in Europe actually used anti-imperial rhetoric too. Yes, yeah, um, particularly against the United States and Britain, and also against the Soviets, but they were also expansionist imperialists themselves, which luckily for the Argentines, they were not, so they have that plausible deniability.

C. Derick VarnBecause the fascists had this whole we're anti-imperialist and also imperialist. The Argentines were just almost third worldist in their in their orientation here.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, they really were, and I mean a lot of that comes from I mean, being colonial, like explicit colonial subjects. But it was also it was a like it was a third worldism with little asterisks because they did pretty quickly move to like I mean, one of the things that sunk Perone early, which made him go into exile in the first place, was his deal with Standard Oil that allowed almost exclusive oil rights to Standard Oil.

C. Derick VarnSo, what is interesting about Peronism in contrast to all the other fashion, because the only other fascism that really was electorally legitimate was Mussolini. The phalange wasn't, and the Nazis sure as hell weren't. So, like not even like it's it's one thing we were always like talk about the blame of the collective German people, and they were complicit in a whole lot of shit. However, the Nazis never had majority, yeah, a majority government, they just banned elections and crisis smoke, which to be fair, Perone never did.

C. Derick VarnI mean, like he was, it does seem like in all of his elections, he was legitimately elected. Now, he also legitimately lost a lot. Um so that's interesting.

SPEAKER_00But I think until Malay, it was like 10 out of the 14 leaders were Peronist or like self-declared Peronist or something. So like they were a fairly successful electoral movement even after Peron.

C. Derick VarnWhat's interesting is now though, they are viewed in Argentina as the establishment, and they seem to be now hated. Yes, yes, Malay is not loved anymore either, but what is interesting is that does not seem to have made even less Peronists popular.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, the Peronists have not had a rebound.

C. Derick VarnSo another thing about Peronism, no biological racism, anti-Semitism. I'd say standard Latin American Catholic anti-Semitism, it's not particularly bad. It's also not great. It was like sometimes it makes it seem like they were phylosemitic, they were not.

SPEAKER_00They were somewhat like at least Peron was somewhat like in his policies, partnered with like the labor Zionists on some projects and stuff like that. But yeah, yeah, it wasn't anything that was like at like that's not yeah.

C. Derick VarnBut but what's interesting about Peron is Perone formally recognizes Israel very quickly. Also, this is part of the left that people don't want to deal with. It's the fact that like both the Soviet Union and the Peronists and a whole lot of left wing groups actually recognize Israel really damn quickly.

SPEAKER_00This is this is I keep harping on it, but this is this is what happens when Marxists don't actually reckon with the national question and what that means. Yeah.

C. Derick VarnI harp on it too. And also, like, yes, there even in the second international, there's things like an understanding of settler colonialism, although they didn't use those terms. They talked about work colonies versus I forgot the other colony that they talked about, but yeah, but but it's it's interesting to see because a lot of different groups treated Israel as a quasi-national liberation movement, particularly in the late 40s and early 50s, definitely uh with the with the labor Zionists.

C. Derick VarnSo Peronism's also interesting in that like it has some of the things we associate with Bonapartist state control. They would harass political opponents, they'd use a military and political opponents, they did judicial packing, they passed like you know, legislation that barred other parties from even serving in the government, they invoked a lot of press censorship. However, they they they did this through legal and popularly uh constituted, democratically supported electoral mandates.

C. Derick VarnAnd they did this in 46, 51, and 73. Um, and so while they were they did run a single party state apparatus, they were not a single party state, and that is kind of interesting compared to a lot of the other groups, even some of the some of the some of the other national frontist groups, not just fashion, yeah, yeah, that existed. This is why it's so hard to talk about Peronism because it really truly does a lot of the whole like red-brown things are usually more brown, and the red is like just some kind of you know, like like icing on top, yeah.

C. Derick VarnIt's like, oh yeah, we did we, you know, like we had some family promotion, and like we we we had some unemployment in France, and like maybe we had some social life medicine unless we're in Nazi Germany and doing that shit. But in general, what is interesting about Peronists is like they're truly all over the place ideologically, yeah. And that only gets worse after Peron is gone. But I mean, like when we talk about like the the like the dirty war, it is important to remember what starts the dirty war is a faction of Peronists fighting the right faction of Peronists, basically getting revenge and violently purging the left faction of Peronists, only creating a space for an even more right-wing group to purge them both.

C. Derick VarnSo yeah. So it's interesting to like take the the various views of what Peronism was Marxist until Ernesto Laclau treated Peronism as a center to center left Bonapartist state. So something that may even be historically progressive, but was ultimately gonna be an enemy of so uh of communist, although communists have fought with it because of those progressive elements, the empowerment of labor, blah blah blah blah blah.

SPEAKER_00So it is interesting that Peron, like Peronist policies, like the Peronist policies of like family leave, like paid time off, all of that stuff was being implemented in East Germany in a very like similar way. Like these are very different governments, very different ideological like positions, but like you can see how if you're just looking at like a policy prescription level, you can have some socialists being like, oh, this make this is probably part of the movement, right?

C. Derick VarnHowever, what's interesting is a lot of classical Marxists noted that the imposter substitution industrialization regime is classically petite bourgeois, or you know, and you can justify it in the Maoist tradition because you know they're non-compardor bourgeois, but you can't justify it by other Marxist traditions. There's the Laclauan interpretation, which is Peronism as a modernizing populist rupture that it implicates the way politics are going to go in the future, which I'm like, okay, so it's like Bonapartism, but good, yo.

C. Derick VarnUm, that's the way I interpret Laclau because it because Laclau's obsessed with ifty signifiers, and Peronism is an empty signifier. Like, if we talk about its history of what it is, good fucking luck figuring it out.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and then there's like the Federico Finchelstein argument that proneism is a post-fascist form of populism that it takes from fascism but gets rid of the imperialism and the racism and tamps down on the extent of the totalitarianism to you know I was I was actually curious because you've done a lot more reading on Dugan uh than I have, like how similar you see, like is Peronism and Duganism, like is that any is there any similarity there?

C. Derick VarnYou could be a Peronist fourth positionist, however, I do not think you're the Eurasian elements of of Duganism have any relationship to Peronism at all, except that they don't like liberal hegemony. That would be the only thing that's like clear, but I could definitely see a center or right Peronist being a thing. My favorite thing is I remember when a certain Greco-Australian-Argentine history lover was telling me there's no such thing as right Peronism, and I just like walked away from the conversation on Twitter.

C. Derick VarnSo I'm like, what the fuck are you on? Like the dirty war is a right versus left peronist war.

SPEAKER_00Like yeah, that's complete historical revisionism.

C. Derick VarnYeah, so Laclau, and that you know, the they cur the Kirchnerite left Peronist, which are basically they're basically the center right of the pink wave, is what you would actually probably characterize them. So they're the center right of the socialist left in Latin America in the aughts and aught teens. I remember a lot of the early DSA discussions were very up on Christina de Kirchner, and I thought that was weird.

SPEAKER_00Oh, interesting. I didn't know that.

C. Derick VarnUh just like people I talked to and like when the DSA was exploding, because that's that's like when Christina de Kirchner is in power.

SPEAKER_00So that's yeah, that's fair, yeah.

C. Derick VarnAnd they like see her as like part of this pink wave, which by the way, pink wave's dead.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's it's over.

C. Derick VarnBorick is failure in Chile, pretty much like finished that. The they De Kirchner defeats, so Lulu kind of stands alone, and he's way more popular than his party is, etc. etc. etc. So those are like the three like general historical interpretations, but I I'm gonna actually point out what I think is the problem at all. Um if you look at the theory of Bonapartism as articulated in the Brumaire, the 18th Brumaire of Louis Napole of Louis Bonaparte, of Louis Napoleon, depending on which translation you look up.

C. Derick VarnYou see a couple issues here. Uh because I think it I think pronounism has three-fourths of the Bonapartist stuff, but one of the key things isn't there or isn't there cleanly. So, so yeah. The relative state autonomy created by balanced and continuous social classes does fit the Bonapartist model, and the fact that it's concentrated in a singular figure fits the model, and that the fact that it's in a state in course is fixed the model, and that the fact that it has a lot of petite bourgeois and national bourgeois support who are dealing with contentious issues otherwise fits the model.

C. Derick VarnWhat doesn't fit the model though is there's no massive valorization of a lump in, partly because the line between lumpin and proletariat and Argentina in the 1930s and early 40s is so thin as to barely exist. And if we if, however, if we do say that the like Cabasita Negras are lumping, we have a problem because then we're also basically increating the entire 19th century industrial labor movement to the same pro to the same thing because the only thing that makes them lump in is they're outside of formal employment.

C. Derick VarnBut before the 20th century, almost everybody was outside of formal employment. So the concept of formal employment did not exist. That's why we didn't have things like income taxes yet. So, like, that's not a thing.

SPEAKER_00I will, yeah. This is I feel like Peronism could have gone the route of a proletarian nation theory, but they don't do that. And that is actually probably like this is not this is tangential to what you're saying, but I think that's also like a necessary indicator of like what exactly Peronism is, is that it doesn't follow the proletarian nation theory thesis.

C. Derick VarnProletarian Nation Theories, for people who don't know, develops in two separate places. One is in the in the pre-MAO Chinese Communist Party of the Lead Dun uh Li Dun Zhao. I think I'm always he's the one member that I always forget his name. And he comes up with the idea of proletarian nationhood. The other one is uh Chindushi, who basically basically reinvents orthodox Marxism.

C. Derick VarnA lot of people call him Etroscus, although that's not really true. And he gets skate goaded for what happens with the KMT, which is really actually the Comintern's fault. Um but anyway, but proletarian nation theory happened with in China simultaneously as Mussolini's coming up with it as as the justification for what he's doing in fascist Italy. When he cared about having left-wing legitimacy, which he doesn't care for very long.

C. Derick VarnAnd it is true that like that that Peronism does come out of a class stalemate. The ruling class can't really rule but through ordinary parliamentary means, but there's no, you know, the working class is not organized or formalized enough to really take power. So that fits in the sense of the back room you have a charismatic executive backed by backed by an executive state apparatus in the military. Okay, that all fits, but it doesn't follow the class analysis of true bonapartism.

C. Derick VarnNow, what's interesting is you have a couple of different theories about this. So there's the Trotskyist breakdown of Bonapartisum Su Generis, which is this isn't about Perron because Trotsky's obviously dead before Perron comes to power, but it was about Cardenas in Mexico, uh Mexico. So this was a modification of Bonapartism by Trotsky to fit Latin American conditions, and then it was actually developed by Nahuel Moreno and your friend and mine, Jay Pesadas.

C. Derick VarnBut what is it? So what Trotsky says is in the imperial metropoles, and actually, this sounds a lot like common turn thing, too, bonapartism generally arises to crush a newly formed working class on the behalf of finance capital trying to integrate with the state. And that's obviously not the case, and that's obviously not the case for when Marx was writing either, because that did not exist yet.

C. Derick VarnThere's no separate finance capital to really integrate with the state and crush the workers. And in fact, what was going on in classical Bonapartism of Kony and Trotsky is pretty much what Marx said, which is like you have a contention between these decaying elements of different classes, the the petite bourgeoisie, and then unopposed set of reactionaries and bourgeois who do not share interests at the moment, and you know, you have a military figure step up our you know, take power. But what the sugenerous bonapartism says is in an industrialized periphery state, bonapartist states can actually lean on the working class and the remainders of the peasantry to resist the pressures of agrarian oligarchy and foreign and foreign capital investment, which makes this form of bonapartism for Trotsky semi-progressive.

C. Derick VarnAnd Trotsky likes you know these kinds of things, but like yeah, yeah. And so, and also since there's less difference between the lump and there's still an established peasantry, but the peasantry is under different conditions than they are in the 19th century, this actually makes more sense than a lot of other forms of bonapartism, so it doesn't have to have the same hostile relation to the working class.

C. Derick VarnThere's another theory that this comes from the national left. This is put up by Jorge Abelardo Ramos and Adolfo Pujigrios, which I have no idea if I said that last one right because it didn't look like Spanish to me. But they actually argued that you can't really import European concepts, which which you know Trotsky's trying to modify, and so was so was Moreno and Posadas after Trotsky. Like, this really gets picked up by like you know, elements of Pabloist Trotskyist thought in Latin America really picked this stuff up.

C. Derick VarnSo this would this led to like the Trotskyist, like you know, some you like critical support for the Soviet Union against the West, but we you're also critical support for these sugenerous bonapartisms in in the developing world, yeah. So Ramos and Pogrios agree with Trotsky that this is a progressive form of bonapartism, but or maybe even they go so far as to say it's a national bourgeois revolution that's not taking an immediate hostile stance towards the working classes.

C. Derick VarnAnd it's because uh the Argentine national bourgeoisie was structurally weak and super dependent. And because it was even semi-feudal in some areas, the state had to act as a surrogate for capitalist development the way it did actually in the early Soviet regime to a lot of these thinkers. For those of you who don't know, Lenin is where the concept of state capitalism came from, and he saw it as a necessary to develop towards a dictatorship of the proletariat because you that and developed all the technologies from the developed world.

C. Derick VarnAnd that's very interesting because it's ignored by both sides of the state capitalist debate. But this is interesting. So this is the idea of a national left. And this is actually somewhat where the it becomes somewhat conciliatory towards third worldism, because it's like we're supporting this national left because it's breaking up this semi-funerable and imperial dependency the way that national liberation did prior, even though Argentina is technically liberated, it is still so dependent that it might as well not be.

C. Derick VarnSo Peronism represents this national left.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, this is this is the question of like because there is an economic dependence, there can't be political autonomy.

C. Derick VarnRight. Then there are some Marxists that go that actually, usually who are more super classical, who at such as Michael Cedas Pinha, who said that no, this was actually a deliberate attempt to stop the proletariat from developing an independent politics. And so Peronism granted social reforms precisely to prevent the Argentine proletariat from developing a revolutionary socialist leadership.

SPEAKER_00Is this a take of is this a take of Peron that's like almost like Kaiser's Well, like the Kaiser's welfare reform?

C. Derick VarnYeah. Yeah. This is and also like the FDR was deaf nail socialism. It's very similar. So this is like classical almost left communist, except it doesn't come from left communists in Latin America. It's associated with Mystice Pinha and Silvino Frondizi. And they said it domesticated class struggle and bureaucratized the state and put the state actually completely subservient to national developmentalism, thus preventing any real chance of integration.

C. Derick VarnThis is also an anti-Mooist argument. And they said it was actually aimed at preserving capitalist relations by refusing to dismantle private property at all, except at a very limited part of the logistics of the commanding heights, which had even been done in the United States during World War II. So what did that really mean?

SPEAKER_00I mean that argument's def- Oh, sorry. Go ahead. In that argument's defense, that's kind of what Perrone says he wants to do, is he wants to preserve a capitalism. He wants to have a capitalism with integrity, where the workers and the owners can like live in a harmonized like society.

C. Derick VarnAnd and that's not new. The proto, the proto-Kynesian, and I say proto-Keynesian, J. A. Hobson, who's the guy who first wrote an imperialism book, wanted to save capitalism from imperialism because he thought that if you had better monetary and banking policy and you were doing national development, that he basically argued that you could do something. Again, it's ac as acro it's anachronistic to say it's Fordism, but basically what he wanted to do was save capitalism by doing proto-Kynesian Fordism, yeah.

C. Derick VarnUm, in the 19 teens. So, you know, so like the it this had occurred to other people, like so. So, how do we look at the limits of proneism? And I think pretty much all Marxist group of NVC things. One the national development just did not have this, the agrarian, our monetary, our industrial surplus to do the project they were trying to do. Yeah, uh the exchange bank could not make up for the fact that there was firing agricultural prices and constant drought.

C. Derick VarnThe state couldn't both fund industrial subsidies to build up industrialization and keep the wages uh viable because they had not priorly built up any surplus. I think almost all Marxist economists agree on this, except for National Lacrown. He's not an economist, so I don't know that I'm counting him. Then this actually led to both court foreign investment and to Paul's authority before neoliberalism, because this is what happens in in 1953 or 54 that leads to the first Peronist crisis in the first place.

C. Derick VarnBecause the state could no longer fund both industrial development and real rages and bringing people in from the countryside, you gotta get some money and investment in RD from somewhere. So you start making. I mean, Peronas austerity wasn't that austere compared to other Latin American austerities, but it was an austerity form from the way they were building out in the late 1940s, and it really broke their backs. And then the other thing is they couldn't figure out how to deal with the working class radicalism, they were engendering themselves, so they used union bureaucrats to crush it, up to and including what caused both the expulsions and massacres of the month of the Montaneros faction of the Peronist, and also the dirty war itself.

C. Derick VarnSo, yeah, so I mean that does actually indicate you know the whole like left capital uh national the national left reading has a real hard limit on the fact that like Perone clearly actually picked a side in the 70s right before he died, and it was yeah, the left side, and his decisions had major repercussions. So, yeah.

C. Derick VarnSo I find this all very interesting. Well, what do you want to add from here? I've I've talked a lot on this one, but you know, yeah, you did as much research as me.

SPEAKER_00So yeah, I feel like trying to wrap it into like what we're seeing from the rest of the series. I think this is like probably it's probably not the fairest example because I think I mentioned earlier there were there were like radical like liberals and there was a socialist party that was in like a popular front opposition or tried to be in a popular front opposition. They failed. But a lot of talks about the like left Peronism is that left Peronism was a response to the ascendancy of Peronism generally, and this, oh, we need to organize within this Peronist framework.

SPEAKER_00And I think this is just I'm gonna harp on it because I think I just keep harping on this uh over and over again. But this is like what happens when you try to like build that like populist popular front framework of it's just like it's this is like this is a very exaggerated version, but there you can very clearly say that there are some socialists that formed in with this government, hoping to like, or with this party, you can kind of quabble about which is which. And in the end, what happened is they either got purged out or they moved. So they either they were literally killed either in the dirty war, they were decimated, their ranks were decimated, or they like moved their ideologies over, these like small groups of it.

SPEAKER_00And I think like I think that's like the big takeaway again, is like once again it's this moment of once you're moving into this front frontist mode, because I think both both of these fronts failed. Uh the Socialist Party front failed, but it actually didn't fail because the socialist party failed because the radical liberals who wanted to join the pop were like they were trying to beg to join the popular front so they could actually have an opposition against Peron, they didn't want to do it. So that this whole thing failed, and then all the internal organizing also failed. So I think it's it's another like in a long list of I think failure that is helpful to learn from because it you could look at Perone and Peronism, and you could say, Well, look at all the great things that were done, and we're gonna ignore the other things that happen.

C. Derick VarnAnd I think there's plenty of people on the left, like all capitalized TM CR and not just a one tendency either, it's not just social democrats and stuff that do this, like I've mentioned third worldists who do this too. It's actually and then people who are somehow both like you see this all the time.

SPEAKER_00Go ahead. No, I I think, yeah, this is what I'm trying to say is that you have this whole spectrum, people who want to point at successful projects. And I just think by going through these projects, going through how they built out and actually understanding them. I think when you have to say we don't, we don't necessarily want to form an American Peronist front. I don't think we are at the moment. I don't think anybody's actually pushing for that, but I do think there's a risk of I'm I'm I'm pretty I think of the three options that you gave, I'm probably the most sympathetic to the third one that Peronism is some kind of attempt, is an FDR, is it Kaiser?

SPEAKER_00Not not like a not a purposeful attempt to like quash the working class, because from all the reading that I've done, it didn't seem like the working class was a viable instrument or like had any political machinations or organization before Peron. But through his like through his development and through like the military juntas that happened, it became a thing that needed to be quashed in some way. So yeah, I'm pretty sympathetic to that, that Perone is Argentina's Kaiser.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I mean it it's it's interesting where it ends. I think it's if you don't have the 74 episode, I think this is a much more contentious debate about what's actually going on. A hundred but you have 74, you also have what Peronism becomes in the 80s and in the 90s, and the in in the 80s, it's just centrism. In the 90s, it's literally Washington consensus shit.

C. Derick VarnThey do the neoliberalization, it's the same party. I remember learning about this from of all people, Naomi Klein. Why do so many leftists like Naomi Klein? I like I actually don't like if you read her shock doctrine book, it's actually one of the most self-contradictory books in the history of ever. It's actually one of the things that made me move from some social democratic, you know, Keynesian-friendly Marxian to an outright communist. Because I read that book and he's like, Well, we need to drop ideology and go back to Keynesianism.

C. Derick VarnI'm like, You just spelled out in your own history and the shock doctrine that despite your whole framing this around Milton Friedman, that the actual people who need a liberalize in Latin America were the left liberals, the the Peronists, the the Social Democrats, not the Chilean dictator, not the Colombian dictator.

C. Derick VarnIt was this in every instance, and you laid it out, and then your conclusion is we need to do Keynesianism again, but like kind of vaguely anarchistly or some shit. What the fuck?

SPEAKER_00Vaguely anarchist Keynesianism.

C. Derick VarnYeah. But you know what we get from Braver 2, you get vaguely anarchist MMT. I mean, like great vaguely anarchist state-centered monetary policy.

SPEAKER_00Yes, that was it's it's still a big thing. It's it's dying, but it's still a big thing.

C. Derick VarnNo, no, now it's just social democratic state-centered monetary policy. Aristotle in a state-centered monetary policy. It doesn't go away, it just changes its aesthetic. That's true. Looking at all of you who think that I am somehow sympathetic to all these people.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, I think I do think towards the end of Peron's life and then seeing what Peronism turned into. I'm actually you mentioned it, uh, you mentioned about Nasser, and I was like, oh, actually, the Arab National Movement is a really good example of something that Peronism is probably the most similar to, uh, and what it's doing pre-1970s, and like what its movement is like kind of pushing towards what its goals are, what its trajectory is, what its ideological characteristics are. In that, it's very I think a lot of people have described the Nasserite movement and like the Arab nationalist movement generally as like post-Marxist.

SPEAKER_00And I think that could be a an under like it's a third positionist theory, but it's also a post-Marxist theory. It's a faction. It's this this I think Peronism was one of those interesting factions of post-Marxists, of outright fascists in the European sense, also of like maybe phalange, Catholic workers' groups. It's something that's very distinctly Latin American. Shit. I just I just turned around and made the the second argument for what Peronism is.

SPEAKER_00Damn.

C. Derick VarnCadillism is codiluism.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, it is.

C. Derick VarnIt's left cadillism. But the thing is, like, then you have to get into what makes cadillism different from Caesarism and Bonapartism. Caesarism, I'll I mean that was just also from liberals in uh in the 19th century, but it gets picked up by Gramsci and Bonapartism, which for Gramsci is a specific form of Caesarism. And then you have Cadilloism, which is like some you know, Latin American thing that has elements of both, but is not really I I mean this is why I am interested in both the the this is a way to actually preserve the capitalist order and under the peripheral core argument and the trot and the Trotsky's agreement, not normally super sympathetic to Trotsky's agreements, because I don't know often like neatly into it, right?

C. Derick VarnLeft and right cadelialism has like it's like fascism in that it's not fascism. I want to be very clear, but it's like fascism in like if you look at it and put it on the bonapartist spectrum, it's got a lot of the bonapartist tendency. So does fascism. Like, I actually have said like fascism seems to be a unique mutation of bonapartism that involves a revolutionary subject, it goes wrong, and this, that, and the other. Like, whereas like what people often say, oh, well, you know, bonapartism involves a revolutionary subject.

C. Derick VarnI'm like, actually, no, it just involves a crisis uh that's severe enough to put the capitalist at odds with itself, and thus also create like a basis of other people thrown off. And I also say we see Bonapartist city, like the imperial presidency has bonapartist tendencies, but I've actually said it's more like Cadilloism, except that it's not as tied to the military than it is like European Bonapartism or European Caesarism. It's just it's something about the fact that it's a colonial state, even if it's a it's a core colonial state.

C. Derick VarnLike there's there's things that complicate the analysis.

SPEAKER_00And the other thing is I'd even argue there's something specifically out about it being a Spanish colonial state because Spain did colonialism differently.

C. Derick VarnOh, yeah, that's true. Like, I think that's there's something that has to be Spanish settled colonialism was more a racer through integration, not a racer through extermination. They did do extermination stuff, they also had indigenous slaves, but like don't don't think you get out of that by going to Latin America, by the way. Particularly Brazil, but in general. They also freed their slaves earlier than the US, but we did it by war before Brazil, so I guess that's that's not that this is a competition, but it is it it is interesting to think about what that all means for these socialists and where they all end up being and going and doing because it's when I say this, it's like this is really hard to map because it has so many traits of so many different things.

C. Derick VarnIt also happens later. Like this idea of coronism is like it's it's in the period of like high cadillism in Latin America in the 20th century version. I mean, there's also the 19th century Cadillos. And what is interesting about the the the Spanish uh revolutionary states is they're like way more prone to civil war. Like we've had one, but most Spanish states have had like three. So, you know, it I really do wish Marxists would like really dig down into to this.

C. Derick VarnAnd I tend to read Latin American Marxists. The thing is about American Marxist is they tend to be either Trotskyist or Maoist sectarians, and so they reframe all this to fit Trotskyist and Maoist Sectarian jargon language and frameworks. And sometimes that's helpful, but a lot of times it's not. As I I, you know Jareus Banaji or Banaji, I'm never quite sure how to not quite sure how to pronounce Indian names.

C. Derick VarnYou know, in his book Theory is history, he points out that like it's very, very hard to figure out like where these regimes are on a capitalist, non-capitalist spectrum. But they did that, like even calling them things like semi-feudal doesn't often like grasp where they're at because you know, sometimes you have gotten rid of the old peninsula like feudal overlords, and we're not really on a European-style peasant system, even with the incomingas and and all that, like and yet you have elements of it.

C. Derick VarnSo I just think you know, I think what I if I really want to dig into this, I'm gonna have to actually dig into it in Spanish, which I can do, it just hurts my brain.

SPEAKER_00So I feel working through the mega. My German is just good enough to read it and just bad enough that it hurts.

C. Derick VarnYeah, me too, actually. Like I can read Hegel in German and also feel like I don't understand Hegel more when I read him in German than I read him in English. Correct. But I've been told that from fluent speakers, so that makes me feel slightly better. But yeah, that's the way I am with my my Spanish and my German are both similarly that I have I'm pretty literate, I have decent oral, not oral, or oral, you know, comprehension. I can if you speak it too much in spirit, I can form words and sentences in Spanish, but I often do like if I don't recognize the conjugation, I'll often like as I did with Teresino, which I didn't recognize as a weird conjugation of third, uh, I will like make up.

C. Derick VarnI will like do cognate and get all kinds of lost. And with with German, I understand what I'm reading, but when I try to pronounce it, I just can't. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Well, I'm not bad at pronunciation, but I'm not good at it.

C. Derick VarnI well, I was better at it when I actually like I don't know, lived in Germany, but now that I haven't in literally 20 years, I pronounce German like I'm a Southern English speaker because I am, and so you get German. I think I have more of a southern accent when I'm pronouncing German than I do when I'm pronouncing English. But and not the and also it doesn't help that I was also taught German in Bavaria, which also didn't stick because it's not standard anyway.

SPEAKER_00I was about to say, I I definitely have uh kind of a Swiss German accent, which is the worst. You speak Swizel Dutch?

C. Derick VarnOh, the yeah, it's not good. Oh, that's like if your first Spanish is cubano or something, no one's gonna understand you. I mean, Mexicano Spanish is weird, but at least everyone knows it from media. So, like, yeah, the same way it's actually the same in Mazri Arabic. Like, most people know Mazre Arabic because they had a media establishment, even though it's way, way, way, way, way non-standard. Like uh we're now into the linguistics corner again, so we'll step out of that.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to the linguistic corner.

C. Derick VarnWe're gonna do Brazilian anagoralism because that's truly wild and weird, but it is clearly right wing. So, and maybe we can use that to maybe our last part of that section will be contrasting this with Peronism. And then do you want to do we have I think we have to like talk about fascism?

SPEAKER_00I think you're right, and I think that means I need to like grab some books that I haven't picked up in a really long time. But yes, I think I think we do kind of need to have a conversation about fascism.

C. Derick VarnYeah, the book on all the theories of Marxist theories of fascism, which there are a lot, is Marxism in the face of fascism.

SPEAKER_00I really love that book.

C. Derick VarnSo Umfree says, Brandon, where can people find your work?

SPEAKER_00Uh, you can find me on Twitter. You can also I write a little bit sometimes on Substack. It can be different.substack.com. Don't do a ton, but I I do that every once in a while. But yeah, Twitter's probably where you're gonna find me doing the most spicy rants.

C. Derick VarnYeah, and we are writing stuff together. Go back to the beginning of the show. And and you can find me where you know where to find me. You can like, can subscribe, hit the bell, and do all that stupid shit. Thank you all. Have a great day. Bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Yellow Vests & The Battle for Democracy with Ida Susser

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 42 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn sits down with Dr. Ida Susser (Distinguished Professor of Anthropology at Hunter College and the CUNY Graduate Center) to explore her open-access book, The Yellow Vests and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How History Gets Hijacked By Christian Nationalist Myths with Warren Throckmorton

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by author, public researcher, and retired professor of psychology Dr. Warren Throckmorton to discuss his book, The Christian Past That Wasn’t: Debunking the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Wired For Authoritarianism with Charles Derber

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 43 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by veteran sociologist, author, and activist Dr. Charles Derber (Boston College) to discuss his book Wired for Authoritarianism: American Oligarchies and How to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Anti-Politics Still Explains Politics with Tad Tietze

    Nov 5, 20261 hr 34 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by psychiatrist, writer, and political commentator Dr. Tad Tietze (co-author of Left Flank) to unpack the evolving dynamics of anti-politics and hyperpolitics across...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. How Conservative Media Moved From Magazines To Platforms with Howard Polskins

    Nov 2, 20261 hr 6 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by Howard Polskin, veteran media analyst, journalist, and founder/chief curator of The Righting. Polskin details his daily work monitoring, curating, and analyzing...

    Credit the people on this episode