In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn sits down with Dr. Ida Susser (Distinguished Professor of Anthropology at Hunter College and the CUNY Graduate Center) to explore her open-access book, The Yellow Vests and the Battle for Democracy: Taking to the Streets of Paris in the Twenty-First Century (Routledge). Dr. Susser offers an on-the-ground ethnographic account of the Gilets Jaunes (Yellow Vests) movement, contextualizing their emergence from the French peri-urban periphery against Emmanuel Macron’s diesel tax and austerity measures. Rejecting simplified Anglophone media narratives that dismissed the movement as right-wing or reactionary populism, Susser explains how the Yellow Vests operated through horizontalist, leaderless organizing across rural roundabouts and city squares. Drawing on Antonio Gramsci’s concept of the "historical bloc" and Henri Lefebvre’s urban theory, Susser outlines her framework of the Three Urban Commons (social reproduction, public space, and political imaginaries) and introduces the concept of "thresholding" - the process through which disparate groups (trade unionists, environmentalists, and anti-police brutality coalitions like Les Mutilés) intersect, build trust, and transform their shared demands. Finally, they examine the global crisis of representative democracy under financialized capitalism, the privatization of public services, and the vital necessity of face-to-face solidarity in countering authoritarianism. Featured Topics & Takeaways: The Origins of the Yellow Vests: How rural and suburban downward mobility, public transit cuts, and car dependency sparked an eruption far beyond a simple dispute over diesel taxes. Horizontalism vs. Charismatic Populism: Why the absence of top-down populist leaders distinguished the Yellow Vests from movements like MAGA or traditional party politics. The Theory of "Thresholding": How different protest movements (Nuit Debout, environmentalists, trade unions, and anti-police violence activists) interact in physical space, adopt each other's slogans ("End of the Month, End of the World"), and build cross-class trust without formal unification. The Three Urban Commons: Extending Lefebvre’s right to the city across social reproduction (nursing, care, education), public physical space (streets, roundabouts), and collective political imaginaries State Violence and Les Mutilés: The systemic use of non-lethal kinetic weapons (LBDs) in France and the solidarity forged between wounded rural demonstrators and suburban anti-racist movements. The Global Crisis of Legitimacy: How supranational financial constraints, debt management, and the dismantling of the post-war welfare state have eroded faith in national democratic institutions across the West Links & Support Patreon: Support VarnVlog on Patreon to access exclusive reading groups, video archives, and seminar series. Order: Order my mini-book with Daniel Tutt, "The People Are Not One," available via Revol Press. Guest Book: Read Dr. Ida Susser’s open-access book, The Yellow Vests and the Battle for Democracy: Taking to the Streets of Paris in the Twenty-First Century (Routledge): https://www.taylorfrancis.com/books/oa-mono/10.4324/9781003534518/yellow-vests-battle-democracy-ida-susser Send us Fan Mail Musis by Bitterlake, Used with Permission, all rights to Bitterlake Support the show Crew: Host: C. Derick Varn Intro and Outro Music by Bitter Lake. Intro Video Design: Jason Myles Art Design: Corn and C. Derick Varn Links and Social Media: twitter: @varnvlog blue sky: @varnvlog.bsky.social You can find the additional streams on Youtube Current Patreon at the Sponsor Tier: Jordan Sheldon, Mark J. Matthews, Lindsay Kimbrough, RedWolf, DRV, Kenneth McKee, JY Chan, Matthew Monahan, Parzival, Adriel Mixon, Buddy Roark, Daniel Petrovic,Julian, Drea, Free Beer, SNT-BRCH, Joshua Parsons
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
C. Derick VarnHello and welcome to Varmblog. And today I am with Dr. Ida Susser, distinguished professor of anthropology at Hunter College and the CUNY Graduate Center. For the past several decades, Dr. Susser has been one of the foremost ethnographic theorists of urban social movements and resistance movements. And she has been the author of Wounded Cities, Deconstruction, Reconstruction, and Globalized World, The Tumulus Politics of Scale, AIDS, Sex, and Culture, Global Politics and Survival in South Africa.
C. Derick VarnAnd the book we're talking about today, The Yellow Vest and the Battle for Democracy Taken Through the Streets of Paris in the 21st Century, which came out from Wart Village this year. Hi, Dr. Sessor. How are you doing today?
SPEAKER_00Hi. Very pleased to meet you.
C. Derick VarnSo the Yellow Vest phenomenon is something that is important and was very discussed as it was happening, but it's kind of fallen out of analysis today. What why the book on it now? And why do you think that this event slash movement was so important?
SPEAKER_00Well, there are a number of reasons, but really a very important one to me is I've been, as you said, studying social movements a long time, but I felt that this movement was a fundamental kind of way to begin to theorize social movements. And I I it started in 2018, but the book goes on till you know 2024, 2025, trying to see we all talk about movements that are like splash in the pan, like you said, come and gone.
SPEAKER_00But what I was much more interested in, and what I think everybody is concerned about, is what are the consequences? Yeah, does anything happen? You have Occupy, does anything happen? You know, what I'm kind of interested in movements for social transformation. And what can we do? And in what ways do these movements make changes, and in what way do they just fade away? So I wanted a long-term study.
SPEAKER_00I actually had been studying in Paris and Barcelona since like 2009, 2010, but I wanted to follow the consequences. I got to know people, I went on many, many protests, I interviewed many politicians and local people, grassroots people. I wanted to really theorize, pin down what grassroots movements do, and if they do make change.
SPEAKER_00So, and it's become to me more significant now with what we're dealing with in the US and with than I expected it to be.
C. Derick VarnUnfortunately, yes. You open up by framing the current era that we live in through Gramsci's interregnum and Polanyi's double movement. And I these are commonly invoked things, but I I was I was thinking about this because it does seem like France represents something similar and also quite different from, say, the US or Britain, where there really does seem to be a structural impasse where the old political set settlement of the Fifth Republic is pretty much dead, um, or at least dying, but it is not clear what's going to happen next.
C. Derick VarnWe, you know, every election cycle, I've been wondering like, are we going to see France Unbaud be able to take power? Or conversely, worse, is Le Pen finally going to be able to get her peep her people into office? Because it's looked structurally like that was going to happen almost for a decade. So, how is the the situation with the Yellow Best both proof of this old structure being stagnant and dying, but also that nothing really is coming out of it yet?
SPEAKER_00Well, for me, this decade has been now nobody can predict, but as you say, there are that, and as the book talks about, in France, there have been two competing growths. And and I guess for me, coming out of Gramsci, and also just from my own research and analysis, I really do think that the project in what we might call civil society, this also, you know, we can go back theoretically, but let's use Gramsci, that it is a process in which people begin to educate themselves, to experience possibilities, to be inspired by other ideas over time.
SPEAKER_00So I think the question for me was what, and especially as I was finishing the book, have we seen the development of some kind of historical block? Of some kind, have I done field work to follow the what people talk about as the creation of a historical block or a group of people in civil society that among themselves are changing their ideas about what that society should be about, changing their values.
SPEAKER_00You could, you know, the big words we say counter-hegemonic. If we imagine an ideology that is capitalism, individualism, nationalist, often patriarchal, but not, you know, that these things are kind of ingrained in the way we understand the world, right? And so is there a way through networking, through protests, through social experience, through civil education among ourselves?
SPEAKER_00Is there a way to begin to develop a different set of values and beliefs that we actually can bring together to change the way we see our society and maybe to get that social formation more in the leading, in the dominant ideas. So that's what I wanted to know. That's what I always look at when I'm looking at protests, you know, how how is it moving in that direction?
SPEAKER_00And and I think that looking at what you said of France Saints-Mise, France Unbroken, and looking also at the other side, which is with the shorthand, we'll say Marine Le Pen, the far right versus the left, looking at both those groups, for me, I was I really seriously was thought that the left was going to come out better in the like the the last snap election that Macron called in, I think it was 2024.
SPEAKER_00My night, my dates are getting fuzzy. But that election, all over the United States, and for good reason, the news, and it has been saying, as you say, for a decade, that France is moving in the direction of Marine Le Pen is in extreme right. But from what I saw on the ground, the networks, and that I document in the book, there was a very expansive emergence of a historical bloc that was not following those kind of extreme right leadership, and that was moving to generate an idea of sharing that is not nationalist, the idea that we don't have to be against immigrants, that which, you know, Marine Le Pen, the extreme right, built her movement since the 50s when her father ran it on anti-immigrant.
SPEAKER_00I mean, just to give what is Marine Le Pen, she's a cleaned up version of what her father led, which was at that time called the National Front, the same movement. She inherited it, and he was an outright anti-Muslim, anti-Semitic, nationalist, racist, completely open about it and moving in that direction. So that's like the legacy of this movement.
SPEAKER_00So, like, that's who Marine Le Pen has, what she has inherited and what she represents. And I thought that France and Semise, which is France Unbroken, and some of the rest of the left, not just them, were moving in a possible direction of building a different uh set of values and anti-hegemon that wasn't going to be in that direction. So that's why when it came to 2024, I was not, I thought that the left would win.
SPEAKER_00And as it turned out, in spite of all the things they said in the news, the left coalition, which thank God for that period was a coalition, uh, it's very hard, it probably may not be again, but that left coalition, that historical bloc, actually won the most seats in the assembly. They expanded their seats, they got the majority, they got more than Marine Le Pen, and certainly everyone got more than Macron. So to me, that was a very interesting snap election, which the news completely we were all afraid of Marine Le Pen, but which I had seen this movement growing.
SPEAKER_00And I I was kind of vindicated in a way that what I had documented what really came out in those elections. If there is a left historical block, right now, who knows if they can ever hold it together. So many things have happened. But this was in 2024.
C. Derick VarnSo one of the things that I was thinking about when reading your book, and also when I was at the time when I was following the various responses in the English-speaking world to the yellow best, which happened when I actually first came back to America. So I I was in North Africa before that. No one knew how to categorize the yellow vest in media. You know, populists, a lot of uh even some Marxists tried to claim them than other Marxist groups in the English in the Anglophone world, painting them as possible reactionaries.
C. Derick VarnSo, how do you define that the seemingly blurring left-white divide, at least as it happens in the English-speaking world? I'll be clear here. I don't think the the French were as confused under financial capitalism. And what distinguishes an emancipary inclusive commons from an exclusatory right-wing populism or territorialism today, when they often use the same language and may even have a lot of the same concerns.
SPEAKER_00I think that is like the million-dollar question. And that's what I spent the last decade or since 2018 really trying to figure out. And I was a little part of me was always worrying that, you know, if I got it wrong, would I, was I getting it right? Was I missing the people who were out there being very right wing? Was I missing the anti-immigrant movement? Was I missing the building of Le Pen by the, if it happened by this movement, you know?
SPEAKER_00So it took a lot for me to realize over time, as I followed people, as I interviewed people, I did not, you know, some of it is is I I what I didn't agree with everything that everybody said, obviously, on any side, but particularly even the with this group, the Yelvest. But I could not find, I I kept eventually comparing them, say, with uh MAGA, you know, the U the US right wing, and or with I didn't compare them with Nigel Farage in Britain, but you could have.
SPEAKER_00But like as I was going along, I thought, so how do we distinguish? First of all, they're very chaotic, you know, they did not emerge from what you call like a populist leader. Populism, to me, is pretty much defined as having some kind of charismatic leader, be it Trump or someone else, who's using that ideology, like excuse me, his his his he's using the racist whisper.
SPEAKER_00He's using, it's not so much a whisper, anti-immigrant. He's using all these tropes, all these ideas that are out there in American society, and that people get upset about. You know, people are afraid that, you know, 9-11, we're on 9-11 now, that there's some kind of Muslim terrorists or something from 9-11. There's lots of fears that populism and the charismatic leaders can pick up and and and repeat, you hear it all the time now in the Republican elections.
SPEAKER_00They repeat it again and again and again and again. And some of it you wonder how people could ever believe, but it's coming from the top down as well as other ways. I'm not saying people don't believe it, but it's being whereas when you come to the Yellow Vests, the Gilets jaunes, the Yellow Vest, they emerged out of neighborhood grassroots. They did not and never have had a populist leader. They have they don't follow the leader of France Unbroken.
SPEAKER_00In fact, when Yellow Vest ran for the French Assembly, the other Yellow Vests made fun of them. Nobody would follow them. They got no votes. The the Yellow Vests are probably, you know, you could say they're not organized. They're anti-hierarchical, they're completely horizontalist. Nobody among the Yellow Vests would let me use their names in the book because I made up the names, because they they don't want to be seen as taking the limelight.
SPEAKER_00They don't want to be representing something. I think Americans can understand this because I think the same thing happened with Black Lives Matter, that people didn't want to be seen as the leaders, right? And they don't want to be seen as somehow taking over the center and claiming they know who they're speaking for. So that there was no charismatic leader with dogmatisms and stereotypes being using the hatred and rage that can emerge in any society, nationalism or you know, whatever the uh the kind of easiest way to capture people's attention and get them on your side is whatever rage you want to adopt, if it's immigrants or religion or whatever.
SPEAKER_00They didn't have that. There might have been, and there were, in the grassroots, people whom I met who were upset about some kind of immigrants, you know, issues, or were upset about, you know, religion, but they were not coming to this movement with that as their leading idea. It wasn't even like being discussed. What they were coming at was we don't, the end of the month, we have no food.
SPEAKER_00Disabled people have not enough services, the hospitals are shutting down, the education, the teachers were out on strike, the housing is too expensive. I can give you many, many, many examples of all over the country, like even in the countryside, or more in the countryside. I was driving through the south of France and they said, don't take our maternity clinic away. They were moving the maternity clinic out of the mountains 50 kilometers down into the main towns in the valley, and people had to drive for like an hour and a half or two to get to maternity clinics.
SPEAKER_00This is the sort of thing that really people were upset. There were nurses whose own other workers were on strike because an emergency room was being shut down, but they were coming to represent their whole group among the elements. There were, you know, all these different groups, teachers who were upset, principals who were upset. They just didn't represent the kind of stereotypic rage around race, religion, or or gender that you hear from these kind of populist leaders.
SPEAKER_00You just didn't, it wasn't what was the leading demands or even what people said when they wanted to come together.
C. Derick VarnI would agree with you. The populism usually and it I'll use the vulgar Marxist terms, it tends to tend to be Bonapartist in its orientation. Um and just I literally just wrote a little pamphlet on this topic with Daniel Tutt. But one of the things that I was fascinated in your book about, and it comes up in the first chapter, but uh is you talk about how the French mobilizations, even before the Yellow Best, going all the way back to like 2014, 2015, diverged from the other left populist movement of squares movements we saw in in Europe and Latin America, etc.
C. Derick Varnlike Podemos or Sigtagma Square or Occupy Wall Street or our 15M or you know uh any of those things, or even what we saw in the Ever Spring. What made the Yellow Best different and uh like where's the continuity and rupture here? Why is the Yellow Best both kind of a continuation of this trend, but also fundamentally different from this prior movement?
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's a great. So I love that question. So, you know, in the book, my first three chapters, or I don't remember how many, four, are about this group called Nui Debu. I I start, I didn't know who would have known. I did not know that the LS were going to come about. It was completely unexpected. So I had been doing this theoretical question. I've been asking this question about what is social transformation, how do we understand the new forms in which people are protesting? We can't really, in my view, be the straight Marxist looking for industrial workers.
SPEAKER_00I don't think anybody really can. Well, people still do, but not many people think that you can go unchanged with those kind of ideas. And so I thought I still have this feeling. We're certainly, as you said, in financial capitalism, we're certainly not in another system of political economy. But the whole thing has turned upside down, you know. Nobody goes to a workplace where they meet the other people on the assembly line and they can organize a strike.
SPEAKER_00It's it's it happened, you know, it happened in Amazon in this country, and it happened maybe in UPS, but it isn't the dominating way, and we wish that it was that simple, in which you can get some transformation anymore. We have to look at what's happening, and so everything is is in flux. So I started studying these protest movements, and the first protest, there was nothing happening in France. I went to Pademis, I interviewed Perdemis in Spain, I went to the different social protests in Spain, and I'm I'm working on that again now.
SPEAKER_00But at the time, Spain was very exciting and very active, and they had just elected something called Barcelona in the Commons, where they had a mayor in Barcelona who represented these kind of commons ideas, Adical, and she was product of a coalition, which I can talk about, but nothing in France. I kept going back trying to figure out what is going to happen here. Nothing was happening. Suddenly in 2016, the youth took over the square of La Republique, the main, one of the main squares in Paris, and also other squares around France.
SPEAKER_00And this movement, even though it came in 2016, everybody among the movement and everybody who's looking at it thought of it like Occupy. It was kind of like the French Occupy. It was only four years late. But it it had the same, it was centered in the cities. It was young, it was a lot of very angry students and unemployed youth, as well as other people, but it was predominantly well educated people.
SPEAKER_00Paris, their higher rate of education than the general population. And it was, I so I started doing my field work there, and I found that a lot of the people were these people who had been students or had been graduate students or, you know, infotech and people like that. And they were very upset with the changing of the labor laws because the French labor laws had a very strong seniority issue.
SPEAKER_00Like you could, once you got a job, you climbed, and you couldn't just be fired. And there were many laws, and they were afraid that it and they said these words, Macron is stealing our futures. Or, you know, when it was actually when Macron was the finance minister in the previous party, but it was his idea. But the, you know, they're stealing our futures because they're taking away the labor laws that we we have grown up with, that our parents grew up with, and the date of retirement was set at 62.
SPEAKER_00And and you once you got a job, you couldn't be fired very easily. And where they could see, you and I would love, and anyone would probably love to know that their job, academia, maybe I had that opportunity, that your job is kind of channeled and it will be there. And you know, the that that started to change with the new way of the economy, the flexible economy. So these kid, these young people joined the labor unions.
SPEAKER_00They were not members of the labor union, but they joined the labor unions in taking over the squares and occupying uh Spain, joined the labor. They were defending the labor laws. So that's what they were. Now, the Yellow Vest did not join that movement. And a lot of unions, even though the movement joined them, a lot of union organizers said things like, Well, these are just, you know, if you take a straight Marxist, they're not working class. To me, that's another argument.
SPEAKER_00I think they are, but uh from the union's point of view, these people are not working class, they're just these students, they're out in the streets, but they're not they're not the real vanguard of change. So they didn't get a lot of respect from the unions, even though they came out. And there were hundreds of thousands of them. But then two years later, the Yelovists came from the provinces. They were like the what some people call the old French, the people who were truckers and nurses and secretaries and you know, wage workers.
SPEAKER_00They were some of them worked in the oil factories, things like that. But they were driving into Paris. The movement started in the outside, the what we call the urban periphery. Here in New York, I don't know if you're in New York, but you know, it would be like Yonkers, the urban periphery, or I don't know other cities so well, but you know, that kind of thing. Elizabeth, New Jersey, or something like that. And they came from those areas where the transportation had been cut by the government, so they were having to have spend a lot on gas to take their children to school, to get to work, to go to the doctors.
SPEAKER_00All the public transportation routes, the trains, the buses had been cut back. And then the President Macron suddenly raised the price of diesel. Now, these people had bought diesel cars because diesel was cheaper in France. And they had been told while the gas tax went up on the regular gas that diesel was somehow okay. And they were pushed in that direction by the changes of the taxes. And they bought very small, cheap cars which went by diesel.
SPEAKER_00And suddenly, in the spring of 2018, Macron's first full year of the presidency, he decided to tax diesel. And that's when these people from the provinces, the urban periphery, came out. And as they got together, they got together on the roundabouts, not in Paris, on the roundabouts in the provinces. So they kind of represent more of what people might think of as the working class, or you know, and they had less education than anyone in Paris.
SPEAKER_00And they were older, many of them had white hair, many of them were worried about their children, their grandchildren. They were worried about the same issues of not enough food for the end of the month. Not their children weren't able to find housing. Many, I met a lot of grandmothers who were there because their daughters were nurses, their daughters were teachers, and they were not able to earn enough. Their sons were chefs or truckers, and they were not enough able to earn just to feed their families to the end of the month.
SPEAKER_00And these grandparents were helping them because they had grown up in the time like I did when it was during the welfare state was getting well-funded in the, you know, the what they call the glorious years from 1950 to 1980. And in that era, people were getting transportation, buses, good schools, access to health care. And it's been declining, as as I talk about in the book, for the last 50 years because of financial capital and debt, which I'm not going to talk about here unless you want me to, but that sort of thing I talk about in the book, why it all changed and why these new Yellow Vests actually, some of them were retired or they had a house and things like that.
SPEAKER_00And they were terrified about what was going to happen to their children who they were supporting. They and the children couldn't afford they these people had sent their kids to college, but the kids couldn't afford to send their own children to college. Things like that. Real downward mobility. And that was what the yellow vests represented. And so they were very different than Occupy movement, but they were moving and demanding over time, not just diesel tax. You know, when Macron saw 300,000 people coming into Paris, they finally came into Paris because nobody even wrote about them in the newspapers when they were in these roundabouts in the suburbs.
SPEAKER_00Nobody even saw them. They weren't, there's no discussion in the papers. But suddenly on November 17th, I think, 2018, which they call the week one of their movement, that day they all came into Paris running through the streets and these wild demonstrations with all in the street, not on the sidewalk, rushing through the streets, hardly knowing their way through Paris, because they're never some of them never been to Paris. These are not the same group as were in Occupy, who were educated, understood Paris, etc.
SPEAKER_00And they, but over time, when Macron saw this, he said, Oh, no more diesel tax. Fine, fine. And he stepped back, we'll have a conversation about this, no more diesel tax. Well, tell us your demands. But by then the people were so angry they went on for years. And they wanted a lot, lot more than just no diesel tax. They wanted their holes, they wanted a reformation of their standard of living. And they were demanding all these changes.
SPEAKER_00And just going back on the diesel tax law didn't has not helped. Everything Macron has done has been minimal and has not really helped him. And then he tried to go to the right and make laws about immigration, but that didn't help him either. So that's part of what I saw is that it isn't that, say with Auburn, where as you go to the right, you begin to begin to generate support from the right. Macron moved towards the right, trying to get some of the right wing support, but he never did.
SPEAKER_00So moving right didn't help him, certainly not with the elements.
C. Derick VarnOne of them is that there does need to be some discussion of the financialization of the post-war compact, which is a very long process. I mean, if I was going to character act it, it's been going on for your entire career, my entire life. So, you know, I was born. Yeah, I'm I am well into middle age now, and uh and I was basically born when this process started. I was born at the end of the Carter administration. And it seemed for a while that continental Europe was resisting this more than you know the UK, the US, the the Anglophone world.
C. Derick VarnBut it it hadn't that hasn't seemed true to me for about 20 years. And so how much is financialization playing in this exacerbation of the problem? And I guess the other thing is we've seen similar frustrations in the US, BLM, Occupy, etc., and you've also seen anger about affordability, but generational solidarity really has not been here, and in most of the English-speaking world, it seems to be absent.
C. Derick VarnSo I guess these are two vaguely related questions, but also why is there still more generational solidarity, at least in France, in response to this financialization than we've seen in most of the English-speaking world? And you know, that's you didn't that's maybe a little that's those huge questions, but still.
SPEAKER_00All right, let's do it. So actually, I'm not sure I accept all of what you just said, but let's go with it. Because I do think that, for example, you know, to me, when I look at the US, occupy in a way that the Yellow Mess set the stage for the French Unbroken left and other left, not just that. And that has some problems. I'm not, I actually have a lot of critiques of the French Unbroken, but the more that they can manage to coalesce on the as a historical left bloc, the better.
SPEAKER_00But it's sad to see them not doing much. But the what I would say is that in the US, even following Occupy, I I think that's when the idea that Bernie Saunders could run as a democratic socialist could not have happened before Occupy. And that's when I was still studying the US. And I went to a conference, I don't know when it was, I think it was like 2012, right after Occupy. And it was the young socialist, that one they have in New York.
SPEAKER_00And it was completely transformed. I had been going off and on to that conference since it was formed in the 1970s or the 80s, I forget when. It was so different. There were all these young people. It must have been after Sandy, because Sandy was 2012. So many of them had moved to do other things. So, but they were all, that was a product, I think, of the movement of Occupy and a change in how young Americans saw this country, even if they haven't been dominant.
SPEAKER_00You would never. I heard Bernie Sanders talk, I don't know, well, maybe earlier, like when he was just a senator. I heard him talk about public health. And you know, there were 30 people in the room. It was a huge room of 200 people. I think it was like 2004. And he was there talking, he was really clear, his brilliant self. And I went up to him afterwards because there was nobody talking to him, and he had like a sheet of paper like this in his notes, he was putting them in his pocket. And I went to like just talk to him.
SPEAKER_00He wasn't being followed. This was no leader in the in the making. But after after night, after 2011, after Occupy, the vision changed among youth in this country. And I I think that that's what the sort of social formations that I'm looking at. And it's been changing and changing. And I think, you know, what you see today with the, I'm not saying that this is, I as I said, I could give lots of critiques, but I think that there is that movement in the United States also that has come from that era and Black Lives Matter and much else.
SPEAKER_00When you say generation, you know, I think that it's true that in the US they're divided, so there's indivisible where everybody has white hair, and then there's Black Lives Matter and other groups which are all young people running through the streets. But I'm not sure that they're that divided in the kind of changes that they want to see, you know. And when I'm talking about France, I'm talking about the Yellow Vests who are like more like indivisible. They're but they're they're working class and civil service and truckers and nurses, like I said, and infotech people.
SPEAKER_00But they're also in there are many young people. That is true. So maybe they work together, but I also see that Occupy and the LBS were not the same. The same people did not come out in 216 as came out in 218. And the same people never, I talk about, I use the word thresholding. I'm not sure that's the best word, but I got, I didn't know what to say, and somebody else had used the word thresholding. It's good to build build a theory.
SPEAKER_00So uh Greek theorists have built it. And so thresholding is when you get a group like Occupy, and you get a group like this Yellowvis, and they meet tangentially, or and they somehow understand each other from that meeting, but then they don't all their demands are not the same, and they don't like converge and go forward together, but they're beginning to build trust. It's like they meet in the threshold, they meet in the lobby, they meet at the door, and they meet, they talk to each other across the lobby, and they begin to see what the other people are up to and why, and they build a level of trust that to me in France has helped to build a historical block that would include like the environmentalists or the anti-racists or the youth occupy people.
SPEAKER_00And and I I I saw this happen. Like, you know, I told you the Yellow Vests came from the provinces, they were a certain group. When they came, Manuel Emma Emmanuel Macron said, these guys are anti-ecological because the gas tax diesel tax was an ecological move. Like I show how it really wasn't much of that in my book, but it wasn't really all that ecological, but that's how he presented it. And then he said, these Yellow Vests are ignorant and they're anti-environment, anti-the-environment.
SPEAKER_00So then the environmental groups started to march. And by like it started in November, by January, February, I went to a march where there was environmentalists, and the yellowists joined them, and they all met together in a particular square and listened to the same speeches. And then after that event, there was the speeches, it was like two o'clock in the afternoon, and I was there with the Yellowvis, and all the environmentalists were there. And then the environmentalists marched off in a designated direction that was their demonstration.
SPEAKER_00And the Yelvests just ran off in their wild way down a different route. They did not go with the environmentalists on a special march for environment. They just went as they always did, running through the streets of Paris, and I went with them. But by five o'clock in the evening, they had all met back in that very square of Republique. And the environmentalists were making speeches about the environment in very radical ways, very angry about the, you know, the exploitation of the environment and the terrible, you know, how we're going to end up with no water and all the things we know.
SPEAKER_00But they were giving very, very dramatic speeches. Yellow of us were sitting in that square listening. They were all there again. And after those kinds of meetings, the Yellowbest changed their slogan. They used to be just, you know, we we we need money for the end of the month. We have nothing to eat, our children have nothing to eat, you know, we can't pay our rent. They added the end of the month and the end of the world. They added the end of the world to their slogans. So they began to understand these things.
SPEAKER_00And there's another story like that, which I could tell about Black Lives Matter, which the same sort of things happened. I do shall I go on a bit about so the thing is that, you know, the Yellowvests were predominantly white. There were many in France, not like in the US, you know, there's a huge North African population. And many of them, they're not necessarily of color if you look at them by US standards.
SPEAKER_00And the French won't talk about any of that, by the way. It's sort of against the law to talk about race. And the woman that opened the first email, started the first movement about the diesel gas and the elements, by our standards, the the French called her, she was born in Martinique, Martinique's. But by our sense, you would say she was of color, she was black. But they don't, she was a secretary and something like that. But the French will not say it in those terms. But so it was a mixed movement.
SPEAKER_00But the French don't look at things quite like that. Or, you know, there's a whole debate about that. But what I'm saying is that at a certain point, the people from the provinces who came into Paris or came into the center cities of Toulouse or Marseille, were attacked or were surrounded by the police and had very, very scary experiences with the police. You know, I'm I'm not going to say that they were attacked. They were, you know, you have to say it in the right way, they were kettled, they were stuck in various places.
SPEAKER_00And when they tried to get out, they couldn't. This happened to me, so I know it happened. And then when you couldn't get out of that square where you were kettled, you got tear gassed. So they were people were terrified. They'd never seen this kind of thing in the provinces. And you couldn't escape the tear gas. This happened to me. And then we were running, running, running, running. And we ended up going into a cafe to get away from it, you know, just to wipe our eyes. And everybody there was like an old lady, yellow vest with white hair, except for the there was also some old men.
SPEAKER_00You know, it was really like that. And they were all yellow vests. And I was talking to them all, they were retired, they were farmers, they were from out of town. But we were trying to get away from the tear gas. But then they started using these things called LBDs, which are a kind of gun that are not supposed to be lethal, and they fire kind of bolts, and the bolts actually can, you know, if they get you in the head, they can kill you. But mostly they don't kill you. But so they're non-lethal.
SPEAKER_00But people were hit in the eye, they lost their eyes very much. People were hit in the hand, they lost their hands. People were hitting the feet, they lost their feet. So people were going around without a foot, without a hand, without an eye, as a result of these demonstrations and these LBDs. And they started to organize, and now they have an art movement called Les Mutiles, the mutilated, the mutilated. And they have a protest sign, the mutilated. And this is Yellow Vest still now in 2025, the last time I was there.
SPEAKER_00I was there in 2026, actually. They were still there. And they have signs saying the mutilated or les mutilés, and they join the all the demonstrations, which are really anti-racist, but they're against police violence. And they're mostly in the areas on the outskirts of towns where the immigrants live and where the police are really, really violent, and they've killed some kids and stuff like that, some young men. So in that's the areas. And the Yellowvest have joined those, they've begun to understand what police violence is for their own experience.
SPEAKER_00And they joined the equivalent of Black Lives Matter movements. And actually, the in 2020 they joined the Black Lives Matter movement when it met in the Central Squares. So they're learning, this is what I call thresholding. They're not part of the Black Lives Matter movement, but they're expanding their ideas. And they also now are very much about, you know, demonstration about water and the environment, but they're also demonstrating against police violence, which in France is mostly focused on immigrants of color in the suburbs.
SPEAKER_00So this is something that these people have learned. The people I knew. They'd never much been to Paris. They'd never much joined a protest. They hardly, some of them didn't vote, they didn't have time. Things have changed for them.
C. Derick VarnIt's interesting. I live in I live in I live out in the far west. I'm in Utah. And what was interesting here is for a brief moment during the beginnings of Black Lives Matter 2, uh, because we kind of have to periodize Black Lives Matter is the first one, and then 2021 as opposed to 2014 one. Yeah. Yes, yeah. Um is you saw sympathies coming from groups that were older and considered somewhat right wing. Out here, it was Ammon Bundy, who was the successor to the Bundys, which is a Utah LDS, almost quasi-separatist, hyper-conservative movement, that started expressing sympathy with BLM.
C. Derick VarnBut as soon as it got tied into what was viewed as partisan politics, that like hard stopped. And I wonder if you think that the yellow vest avoiding that has part has been part of why they've had so much staying power. Because they they they aren't, as you said, you you can't attach them to one singular left or right-wing movement in France, they don't really fit it.
C. Derick VarnSo I I wanted to ask you about that. And then I I have some theoretical questions, but but let's just start let's start with the the kind of real one there.
SPEAKER_00That's an interesting thought. And it was a black candidate. And that we call that area, it's an immigrant area, but the actual figures I give them in my book is something like 30% immigrant.
SPEAKER_00That means 70% people who kind of you might call old France that come mostly descendants, they're intermarried and all that, but mostly descendants of the old Catholic white France, you know. So even so to win 50% for a black candidate was quite amazing. So, and they were, they worked for him, and you know, the young people did, or many people did. And when I was there when he won, and I went into the square, and it was like packed.
SPEAKER_00And of course, there were people in one corner who were old who were playing the you know, one of those Belachal communist kind of songs. And there were people in another corner who were more dressed in hijabs and things like that, different kinds. Like it was not that everybody mushed together, but all those people, and then there were many, many youth, young people, and in France, really, really, really, really, at least in Saint-Denis, these the young people together are not it's not strongly divided by by color or race.
SPEAKER_00They're kind of mushed together, the young people in the politics of it. You know, they're it's you really see them all as youth who are bringing themselves out together with whatever trouble they're cooking up, but it's it's not so divided as it is in this country, in these areas. You know, it's a different, you know, it's a different world and a different history. Uh, you know, uh France first went into Algeria in in the 19th century, so there are many uh people from North Africa, I'm sure you know very well, who French speaking and thought they were French and came to live in France and have been coming for 150 years, you know, and there's now a lot of anti-this and anti-that.
SPEAKER_00But the history, and of course, there was, I'm not saying there wasn't races, there weren't people, but it's a different way of living together. That's all I'll say.
C. Derick VarnYeah, so you mentioned or not, yeah. You mentioned thresholding, uh, which I was gonna ask you about, but but I also wanted to ask you about commoning, and then related to the concept of commoning, would be your three urban commons, which are social reproduction and the institutions around that, the public space or third space and the institutions around that, and then creative and political imaginaries as opposed to like actual existing institutions.
C. Derick VarnAnd so I wanted to ask about what is the relationship between commoning and these three spheres of the urban commons, and then why you know why is it seemingly so hard to get people to focus on all these three spheres? Particularly, I mean, I know the Marxist answer is gonna always be like, well, they're all part of the you know, the the superstructure, whatever that means. You know, but but I wanted to focus in on that because I it did explain to me something that the Yellow Bests were getting about different areas of social life in urban, in urban and in their cases also rural areas of our suburban-ish areas, that I think a lot of the American political imaginary doesn't really know what to do with.
C. Derick VarnBut ask you about that.
SPEAKER_00Well, uh yes, very dogmatic Marxism might say what you said, superstructure is all super, but like Lefebvre, who I really got this idea from, Henri Lefebvre was a French Marxist. But you know, there's all varieties of Marxism today, just like Gramsci, whatever. But I tried to move with the more fluid ones. But so I got this idea. A friend of mine, Stefan Tonnell and I, we were in a seminar with David Harvey, Neil, it was run by Neil Smith.
SPEAKER_00I was the director of the seminar, and there were like 15 people at the City University of New York, and Neil Smith and David Harvey were Marxist geographers, very broad-minded, but you know, and that's where I learned about Lefebvre, actually, and sort of ideas of the city. And there were like all these people studying this kind of thing. Like there was an art historian who was studying the paintings on the Berlin Wall after it came down, but what people were doing at the edge of the Berlin Wall and what it represented.
SPEAKER_00There was a woman from China who was talking about how people were building sculptures right in the center of Beijing, just as all the metal of Beijing was being cleared out, the university was being put in the suburbs, you know, and new stuff was being brought in. So it was a very inspiring seminar. And Stefan and I decided to put it all together, and we we wanted to do a book, but people take a long time to write their articles. We gave up. So we decided to write an article, and we wrote this article, which came out of that.
SPEAKER_00I think I want to say that because, you know, one of the ideas that's so strong to me is collective intellectual, collective ways of thinking, organic, they call it maybe organic intellectuals. And I I really think that my ideas come from the miasma that we all live in. They come from talking to people, they come from working both in the streets and with the theoreticians and with people who are trying to think their way through social theory, you know?
SPEAKER_00And so this idea of the urban commons really came out of Lefebvre, if you look at it fundamentally, but it also came out of those conversations with all those students and faculty from many places. And it's interesting because when I wrote that article, practically the same year, David Sahabe, who was in that seminar, wrote his book Rebel Cities, which is really about the same kind of issues, but he doesn't use the same format. Anyway, so what I thought was that when I wrote my book on the illness, I had forgotten, I hadn't forgotten about this article, but you know, you write something that was 2012, 2013, and I wasn't thinking in those lines particularly.
SPEAKER_00I had, yeah, it's gone, it's done, it was published. And then as I started to work out what was really going on, the power of those concepts came to me. It came to me from the ethnographic experience. You know, I got Gramsci, and I people might like to be interested, I got Polanyi, but they were writing before fascism or during fascism in Europe, and that's why I used them. But then this idea of the commons, I was already talking about commoning, but this idea of the three commons became more and more powerful to me as I wrote.
SPEAKER_00And I wrote to Stefan, I said, you have to write an afterword to this book because it's really, to me, generated from our joint work. And he did, he was writing a book, but he wrote the afterward about his research. And it was using just the same concept. So we began to realize this is a very, and it's one of my most cited, most read articles. But I didn't know. It's on, it's like my book, it's open access. Everything is open access of the book and the article on the commons.
SPEAKER_00That means you can just get it, you don't have to buy it, you don't have to, you just go online and get it. So then the whole book is open access because I'm talking about the commons. I use my research money to make it open access. So I saw the unions were organizing, and they were what I saw as I did this work was that even with the very first Occupy in, well, you could go back to Perdamus in 2011, but say in France in 2016, they were it was the labor unions who started that battle around it was they were, and then the the youth followed, and they never they they like hated each other, they criticized each other, youth hated the labor unions.
SPEAKER_00I've got all these quotes in my book, and the labor unions thought the youth were chaotic and they weren't working class, all kinds of, they weren't at the mode, the point of production, they couldn't do anything. But I could see that in every movement I saw, and then when I came to the there was a huge set of demonstrations when Macron tried to, you probably heard about it in France, tried to change the retirement age. And he wanted to move it from 62 to 64. And the Yellow Vest came out in full force. It was after, it was like 2021 and then 2023.
SPEAKER_00It wasn't in the beginning. But the Yellow Vest by then were so afraid of the police that by 2023 they were not wearing their Yellow Vests, but they would walk down the marches singing Yellow Vest songs. The Yellow Vest songs were like the national anthem of the pension demonstrations over and over again. And that's how you knew it was so inspired and then joined by the Yellow Vest. And that had set off this whole movement. So I don't think the unions would have come out so strongly against the pension movement if it hadn't been the Yellow Vest before them that were pushing, pushing, pushing.
SPEAKER_00And it was the so every union at the second by 2023, it was every single union in France across the spectrum. The more conservatives, the far left, all joined the demonstrations. And it was kind of inspired, and the songs they used, and the people who joined, many, many, many of them had been Yellow Vest across the country. So I began to see that you have to understand, like you said, the people in the social reproduction, many Yellowvests were, as I said, nurses, teachers, principals, doctors.
SPEAKER_00They were part of social reproduction, but they came out in the in the Yellow Vest movement, not in the unions first. And so I began to see that while they have very different principles, when you see what moves and shakes the world, like I talk about a historical block, it's it's where they work together or come together in some process. And that's where I began to talk about the commons of social reproduction. And the urban commons in the second kind, you said public space, that comes straight out of Lefebvre, who's talked about the streets.
SPEAKER_00We share space together. Everything that we share, the the grass, the streets, the monuments, the you can't walk down as uh you can't be in the world without sharing the streets. And and Lefebvre thought that was a kind of commoning. He described that as feeling the sort of might, I don't mean that he was metaphysical, but sort of the spirit of the city. And that's what David's book, Rebel Cities, is about. The spirit of people coming together and and making, taking over space.
SPEAKER_00In England, I give an example because I grew up in England and I was part of this world where they would walk on the common footpaths to keep the common footpaths across private farmers' land to make sure the whole myth of the English, English fields is that you can walk across them, no matter who owns them, because you want to go on a walk through the countryside. This is a very important thing in Britain. So that was the kind of commoning that I used as an example. It doesn't have to be public land, can be private land, but commoning takes over and makes it useful to the public.
SPEAKER_00And there's a Woody Guthrie song, which you probably all know, you know, from New York Island to the Redwood Forest, etc. And he has a word in there, he has a part of it, which is, and I was walking and I saw this sign, and it said, no trespassing, but on the other side it didn't say nothing, so I just went on, or something like that. I couldn't, I'm not much of a singer, but that's the that's the meaning of the song.
SPEAKER_00And so there is some of that in the United States. Maybe this history here has been more violent and more repressive. You know, people don't know why countries are different, but I mean we try to analyze that year after year. But I think the US experienced a much more violent destruction of the working class movement in this country, even though you had like Roosevelt, which came out of the working class movement, and then you had McCarthyism, where people forgot what what movements were and were all very suspicious of every union that walked the street.
SPEAKER_00So we have a different history here in the US. But in France and Britain, it's an ongoing history of the idea of the Commons.
C. Derick VarnYeah, but the the Commons is an interesting is an interesting problem in the US because we I tend to think it's partially because of the the plantation mentality of the South that we immediately tried to enclose lands. And while yes, the enclosure started in Britain in the first place, blah blah blah, like we we we were much more thorough about it, I think. But but it's impossible to prove, that's just my my my suspicions.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah, so we're all trying to figure it out. Yeah, go on.
C. Derick VarnYeah, but I I was thinking about this in in um in a way that uh that is very interesting to talk about when it comes to like the way the public responded to Ulabus. And one of the reasons why I said the Anglo-Spear world seemed unable to handle exactly what it was. The French, and admittedly, as people who've heard me butcher French before know France, uh French is a language I don't speak, but the the from what I gathered from what I was able to parse together from from French sources and what I read in your book, is there was more of a working class and even public intellectual defense of the yellow vest in the French language world than there was in the English one.
C. Derick VarnAnd I I and that was despite they had they both like both of them had the same cultural lead attacking. It was just the defense was more robust in in France and the French-speaking press abroad. Uh, why is that? Well, you know, what why did why did public intellectuals align with working class writers in a way that you just don't see in the English-speaking world all that much?
SPEAKER_00You know, as I said, I think the United States, and you know, I think Rachel Maddows documented this, has a really bad history of fascism. I mean, you know, Trump's father was part of the uh what was the KKK when it came to New York, you know, he joined those marches. We have a really, and it was very strong before the war, the KKK, even up north. And in no, we think of it as the South, but no, that's not the only place. The second coming of the KKK was all over the country.
SPEAKER_00So these are you know long historical questions, but I do think that the levels of repression in this country were much greater. And I think that in Europe, there, you know, this country the Communist Party was banned, right? You you lost your job if you were a communist and things like that. Whereas in Europe, in in Italy and France, uh, there were very strong communist parties.
SPEAKER_00They might have fallen apart from their, you know, their own whatever. I'm not saying that they were, but they uh were allowed to run. And when you see now in France, the left coalition that I was talking about includes the Communist Party, the Greens, the Socialists, and the uh France Unbroken, among other things. They call them various diverse leftist parties sometimes. But in this country, you won't find that.
SPEAKER_00So that would be more the kind of way I understand this country. And of course, we're the centre of capitalism. Like I grew up in Britain, I wasn't born there, but I grew up there. I was born in South Africa, but uh I grew up in Britain and I was frightened to come to the United States because people in England, when I was only a teenager, they said we were already, by the way, in London in 63 or maybe 64, before I came here, because I'm old, you know.
SPEAKER_00We were demonstrating against the Vietnam War in Europe before you were here in the US. And when I came to this country in 65, people teased me. They they called me in my school an atheist. Like that was an unusual word in the suburbs of New York. It was like they could really pick me out of something like that. I don't think it would happen today. But and they're already in, and even in the suburbs in New York, when I arrived, there was still law, you know, very few black people, but also there had been laws that Jews couldn't live in those, but there'd been regulations that Jews couldn't live in those suburbs.
SPEAKER_00Not, not, not it's and there were quotas in the universities and stuff. So this country has a much more powerful reactionary history and can go much more in that direction. Although you look at Germany today, I'm not saying that Europe can't do those things, but just say between France and Britain today, I don't think at this moment that we have in those countries the same level history of repression that the United States has shared.
SPEAKER_00And it's does that answer I've now I've talked so long I forgot your question.
C. Derick VarnBut no, it answers part of it. I mean, one of the things that I was thinking about when we talk about these differences is like the kind of double-edged sword of the Vici period in France and how like that both makes you know fascism more obvious. Whereas America has had fascistic movements uh before fascism was a thing, they are rarely explicitly in power, but they also are implicitly tolerated by power a lot more.
C. Derick VarnAnd I I wonder if that's part of the the historical legacy, because you know the neo-confederates, the the you know, the the parafascist groups, the right nationalist we haven't had an explicit white nationalist government, but we've had more or less white nationalist governments in the past. Uh how does that expliciteness play into this, maybe? Because I was thinking about this too, also in the legacy of the way the repression of immigrants is tied into co It's tied into the experience of French colonialism and how ambivalent that seems to be for a lot of French people.
C. Derick VarnI mean, even on the right, it seems like. So I was going to ask about that. And it kind of ties the question together.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I guess I don't think that any country is immune at all, at all. But I I somehow, what I was trying to say when I came to the US, people saw it as the central, you know, the most, the most powerful financial capital, the richest, like, you know, our infotech guys now, the richest in the world. And even people like, you know, Peter Kateel, he came from South Africa or from Southern Africa. But you know, they brought their ideology from the old Southern Africa and the colonialism right here, and Elon Musk.
SPEAKER_00And then we've got, so these guys, there's not there's this power structure in this country that now is supported by our info people that I feel is being the center of financial capital still, although maybe we're gonna lose out in the next decade. I don't know where we're at, but also allows for makes it harder, makes it harder. But coming from the Vichy, I talked, we go back to that because I talk about that a lot in the book.
SPEAKER_00And it's still a very, you know, people that I met would still use that as their kind of measure of things, you know, especially when I was in like the rural areas and the farmers movement, which is a right-wing movement at the moment. And people said, well, those, you know, villagers don't change, or not everybody in the village changes. There are people who've been there, families that have been there for a hundred years. And they knew who was on what side under Vichy.
SPEAKER_00And they were making like these kind of divisions between the people who were kind of left historically and those who were more and who were part of the resistance. And this is like a thing in France that in certainly I met it in the villages of where you were and how their families interacted. So it's still, you know, they had in Vichy, France, they had camps along the railroad. They put people, first it was Spanish anarchists and people who were coming is fleeing from Franco.
SPEAKER_00So they were running into France and the south of France. They were put in constant in camps, in in prison, sort of prison camps. And then as these got more, as the Vichy government took over, these also the Jews were put into these camps, and then people were shipped by rail all the way to Auschwitz from these camps in these southern villages. So you're right that there's a very powerful history, which is what I was trying to say about Marine Le Pen's legacy. She is that legacy. She she comes out of that.
SPEAKER_00They changed the wording, but out of that world where the enemy is is those people, you know. And it's not only that now, it's much more complex, but that's part of it, you know, part of it. And I do believe that each, you know, the history of each nation, they can go either way. I don't believe it when Americans say, this is not America.
SPEAKER_00I wouldn't believe it if people said, this is not, we are French, we're not like this. I think in every nation, depending on the the moment and the historical forces or the leadership or the inequalities of that moment, we can slide into fascism or whatever word you want to call it. Some people like to say illiberalism or authoritarianism. To me, it's just fascism, to me, represents the brutality. Whereas illiberalism, authoritarianism, just talk about the rules.
SPEAKER_00But fascism brings to you the idea that people were shot if they disagreed, that they didn't have trials, that thousands, say in France or in say, take Franco and Spanish uh fascism, which was first 50, 60,000 people, they you know, hundreds of thousands were murdered and buried, and people still don't know where they are. So that's what fascism means to be. And I think you can't say, oh, it's not American.
SPEAKER_00And I didn't have, I grew up in a very unstable world, right? I grew up when the Afrikaners in South Africa took over the government and they had supported Hitler during the war, and they then became the government of South Africa and imposed the worst kind of anti-black racist laws and killed people. And you know, so so I grew up under that. So so I always feel that any society has that as a can move, can we're not not an it's not not American.
SPEAKER_00I can't really believe. I don't like to hear on the radio or the TV when very good liberals say things like, but that's not American, or that's not French, because to me that's that's completely absurd. That's not what the world is about.
C. Derick VarnIt's definitely American. I grew up in the deep south. You know, I'm of Mish ethnic heritage, and I grew up in Georgia when the Klan uh this was in the 80s, and the Klan was still the a real issue. Uh although I will also say, as you said about Trump and the North, I mean the third clan and the second clan were probably bigger outside of the South than in it. Exactly. The most Confederate flags I ever saw were actually in Ohio, which I was very confused by at first as a person from Georgia, because I was like, What's your excuse?
C. Derick VarnLike, how are you gonna couch this one? At least where I people lie about why they're doing this. Like, but yeah, it's it's it's interesting uh to talk about. So now the thing about like white nationalism, I I think about it all the time because uh I'm always going, well, we call it that now, but like I don't know, growing up in the in the southeast, it was kind of like that was just government kind of. I mean, you know, yes, there were black politicians, but you know, not really, they didn't have much of an effect outside of Atlanta.
C. Derick VarnSo it's it's interesting for me to think about when people say, Oh, this this is not this doesn't come from here. I'm like, no, like I mean, unfortunately, I think it comes from everywhere.
SPEAKER_00Well, right, there were civil rights workers murdered, right, in the 60s in 64 and 65, they were killed by the local people. And you know, this that so this is you know, this is possible in the United States. And Minneapolis there were activists killed, you know, these things are possible, these are like the virgins of that kind of thing. But we to me, as I wrote in the book, we have to imagine that the world the the nation or the country is a struggle, always a struggle, to maintain a democratic our democratic rights and to maintain a level of human of social justice, but also recognition of human needs.
SPEAKER_00And that that's one of the things that that has like about the environment, you know, about the I feel that now we're all communicating like you and I on media, and that we need to think about the human solidarity. That's one of the things I talk about in the book, though, with the COVID shutdown, when everything was on Zoom, you know, we all felt it. We all were kind of sitting like you and I, talking through windows. And you saw, I saw the Yellow Vests veering off in really, you know, anti-vax, very, very problematic conspiracy directions, when they were not meeting in human form with all the other groups in the center of cities or in the roundabouts or when they talk to each other.
SPEAKER_00It was really, really, that's when the anti-vax movement got so went through the yellow best. And there's still those kind of superstitions. It's not all good, you know. That's why I talked about you need the three commons because you need the hierarchical unions and the experts and the scientists and the Fauci. You need to have the respect for scientific expertise and for organization.
SPEAKER_00And you do not get that in the commoning, in the in the second urban commons. So it has to be that these groups do meet together and do have a form of cooperation and understanding and trust, or you can really see any group veering off in a in a and you see this a lot in in some kind of conspiratorial rabbit hole, you know. And I I don't think I don't think people are immune from that on the left or on the right at all.
C. Derick VarnNo. Uh all I have to do is go into X and tell you that they're absolutely not immune of it in any political ideology, even the center. It's yes. Uh we're in the we're in like the uh a dark, glory days of conspiracy thinking. But yeah, I I I your point here is really important. I was thinking this is just a fact to what I learned. I study a lot in Latin America. I lived there for a while too. I lived in Mexico, and I was looking at the countries that had successful public integration to COVID response, not the ones who were able to keep it from coming in because those generally tended to be islands.
SPEAKER_00Um Australia, New Guinea, right?
C. Derick VarnNew Guinea, New Zealand. Like I'm like, yeah, to some degree Japan, although not quite. Yeah, that's that's I guess useful. No, not helpful for most people. But uh I was looking at the places where medical expertise was respected versus where it went paranoid, and a good case study for that was actually Latin America, because there were countries where they had strong integrated like nursing clinics and stuff integrated into the local communities at all levels.
C. Derick VarnAnd the response to doctoral expertise when they were integrated into those communities and not seen as like separate professional things above them was way, way better than when the experts were seen as an outside cloistered force. And uh, you know, I often tell the you know my partner works in pharmacology and epidemiology and inf and bioinformatics, which are big words.
C. Derick VarnBut we we talked about a lot about this, like how the US experts really need to get better, not just at public communication, because they tried that, but like public integration. Because right now there's a trust deficit for good reason, because of the like, if you think about the experience of going to any healthcare anything in the US versus almost anywhere in the world, having been in hospitals on four continents, the US is the one, even though I was born here, that I dread.
C. Derick VarnAnytime I go near a medical facility in the US, I'm like, uh, this is gonna be a bad day. So, you know, I think about that when we talk about how you know we need these four, we need these three corners that you mentioned, these three commons, but they have to integrate, right? And that's what I got a lot of what I got from your book is that integration's vital when it breaks and when it breaks down, you get paranoid, you get exactly reaction. Uh so I was gonna ask you, uh, there's kind of two things that that that are the my last two big questions.
C. Derick VarnI'll just kind of ask them at once. They're only vaguely related though. I was thinking about how Macron has stayed in power seemingly for a long time now, despite the fact he's had parliamentary gridlock almost the entire time.
SPEAKER_00He continuously gets no confidence to them, yes, right.
C. Derick VarnHe continuously gets gets no confidence votes. There's been mass blockades a lot, and it does seem like the fifth republic's entire political legitimacy is kind of unraveling. But I uh what I wanted to to do to maybe to talk about how we are still in a world system, uh, is this seems to be true in a lot of the West, not just in France. Like, I can't think of a popular U.S. government since the first term of Barack Obama.
C. Derick VarnLike, you know, like that stays popular, it it even seems like mathematically impossible right now. And while opposition to the US is kind of unified Canada around Carney, and I don't I don't blame I don't blame them. The frustration with the Liberal Party there for similar reasons has also been amping up. And honestly, if Trump hadn't intervened, they might be in some real trouble. And then that there doesn't, I mean, you know, there doesn't seem to be the possibility of a popular government in Britain right now.
C. Derick VarnSo um what what do you think everywhere seems to be experiencing this political delegitimacy?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, delegitimation. Yeah, I I tried to work out some of that in the book, and one of the pieces I saw to it, yes, like I I talk about how in France, but not only in France, as you say in other places, that the mainstream parties have lost legitimacy amazingly. You know, like in France, Macron invented that party. He was supported by the banks and he was funded by the banks. And he was the only member of that party.
SPEAKER_00He invented it when he was elected that year. And he doesn't even have local elections like that. When there's local elections, there's nobody even running in Macron's party anymore, hardly. You know, it's very minimal. He doesn't have local neighborhood organizers and stuff like that. So it was definitely, he was a finance minister in the socialists and pushed the socialists. He was the one who pushed the socialists to change the labor laws.
SPEAKER_00Because you know how France was seen as the last vestige of workers' power, that they had kept those labor laws. And I really talk about them as they were the longest fighters to defend the welfare state and to keep their labor laws, which came out of the resistance against World War II. You know, and the people felt they had fought for the French in World War II. The French themselves thought that they should be, all the countries did, labor came in in Britain, but that they should be given a social welfare state because of the battles that they had fought.
SPEAKER_00The number of millions and millions of young men who had died, regular French, and they thought they were entitled. So, but France is probably one of the last standing welfare states, although, and Macron, it was this labor laws that he began to change, to fight to change in the socialist government. He was made head of finance in the socialist government and he led the battle against the labor laws. And then the banks funded him to run for the next round. And the socialists, after they changed the labor laws, they went down to like 7%.
SPEAKER_00This was a party that had won the previous elections. They went down to 7% of the vote. And because of the changing of the labor laws, and all the old socialists who had voted them felt betrayed. Everyone I interviewed felt betrayed by the previous socialist government. So that was what happened. It's the liberal, the the privatization of public services in Britain, here in the United States, in France, in Spain.
SPEAKER_00So all the things that we used to think of as entitlements, certainly in France, Spain, and Britain, were being dismantled. And so this is why, which first of all, the conservatives did it, and everybody expected the conservatives do it. But then when the socialists were voted in in Spain as well as in France, and the Labour government in Britain under what's his name? Uh the previous he was there. No, no, no. No, no, no.
SPEAKER_01Millbank. Milton.
SPEAKER_00Never mind, never mind. Whichever way. Blair, Tony Blair, Tony Blair. He did this like third way where he cut all the social, he did put money into it, but he also cut a lot of the services. So the socialists or the labor all lost their credibility with the voters. And of course, the conservatives were cutting everything too. So the voters felt very shut out. And then when you look at what I argue in that book, which has this crazy title, I wrote it with Don Nannini, it's called Edited The Tumultuous Politics of Scale.
SPEAKER_00What we mean by that is that in all of these nations, you've got this other layer of global politics. You've got the Trans-Pacific kind of agreements, you've got NAFTA. NAFTA, and even before that, these global agreements actually allow the global level to cut down on what the national level can do. So, like no, with a lot of these agreements, laws about pollution or laws about occupational safety can be undermined from the global level.
SPEAKER_00So they're a way to go one step up, these global agreements, to undermine the power of the national government. And so people no longer feel connected with the national government. It makes rules that don't come from why they voted for it, they come from the top-down, the global economy, the global partnerships. And those global partnerships are where your leaders are looking. Or, you know, we know Trump, let's not get into how Trump looks at all this, but before Trump, and certainly in France, Britain, etc.
SPEAKER_00So what it is, is there was another layer of power above what people in their own nations could vote for. So whether it was socialists or whether it was conservatives, they were following the demands of global politics and global economy, and they were trapped and they were not listening to their own population's demands. They were just, and that's where the welfare state got destroyed in that process. Because the at the global level, governments were say were told they couldn't borrow, they were told they couldn't have the level of debt that they had.
SPEAKER_00They would be, they fell under the sway of these larger kinds of global finance. And they are under the sway of global finance, but that takes away the sense of a democracy. So people no longer feel that the democracy is looking, is looking out for them. And this is part of why people are so giving up on democracy and why it's so hard to find. But with that, and and although I was against Brexit, obviously I didn't believe the British should leave the European Union.
SPEAKER_00But the European Union had started out as a union of really socialist governments with a kind of welfare state kind of initiative. But they over time became a corporate kind of world. And people in Britain they thought they could get out of it because Brexit just did them in further. But that that that impetus comes from these kind of global traps that each nation has found itself in, and that bec Greece also.
SPEAKER_00So you these are the issues that we have to face when we're talking about national democracies. Democracies were formed in nations that were formed in the 19th century or the early 20th. Now we're in the 21st century and we've got these global agreements that undermine the nations. And then people don't know whether democracy is gone. They don't know how to change it, they don't have the power. That's part of the problem. That's what I wrote in that other book, but I also bring it up talking about France.
C. Derick VarnYeah, yeah, yeah. It's a it's a double-edged sword right now, in that, like, on one hand, as good leftists, we want internationalists. On the other hand, we've seen, you know, what we could call as nebo li neoliberal and financial capital organizations limiting what all levels of government can do. I mean, I I talk about this all the time when you have socialist mayors, like in New York, where you're at, like, you're always worried about what the Bomb markets going to do.
C. Derick VarnLike, so it's just like, well, you know, this can be popular. You might even have the money for it, but what are what are the international investors going to do? Because they can sue your city, not even in a US court, but in an IMF one. And so that's always kind of terrifying.
SPEAKER_00But I wrote the book about the beginning of neoliberalism in the US from the 1975 New York fiscal crisis and the imposition of a financial control board by the state and by the national government imposed on New York to make, to destroy or to undermine the free hospitals that we had, to put tuition on the city university, to take the power from the people in the city and move it up to higher levels. And we were ruled by something called the Emergency Financial Control Board after 1975 and until they had turned everything around and changed the tax laws about real estate and led to where we are today, really.
SPEAKER_00That was the first neoliberal move in this country.
C. Derick VarnYeah, that understanding the New York bankruptcy, I'm putting in quotations for people who are just listening, is really important for understanding the transition to neoliberalism. And it's also it's interesting, as is another another episode. I was I should get a specialist on this because one of the interesting things about New York is a lot of these things were destroyed. However, when you compare it to like LA, there's still more of these old Fordist semi-welfare institutions left, even though they're hollowed out and absolutely.
C. Derick VarnAbsolutely. Where did you go like to California, you know, progressive landy as people tend to think it, none of that stuff exists. It's just like not there. So I think that's interesting. But I guess the the f the final question is kind of tied to this, because in some sense, you're right, democracies are organized nationally, even paradoxically, for those of us who are dirty communists. The Communist Manifesto talks about both the need to come together nationally and the need to overcome it almost simultaneously, seemingly not quite contradictorily, but at first reading it seems so.
C. Derick VarnAnd so there is a danger right now for people associating democracy with nationalism, but then giving up the democracy part for the national. That was a good way of describing it. It's like we're gonna save democracy for now, you know, by this national move, and also the national move requires us to give up democracy. Okay, that doesn't really work. And I think we see it here in the United States. Like, you know, uh it's hard for me to to even figure out what the right believes on any given day right now because uh it's now like bending in like quadruple knots to try to justify what it what it said it believed versus what it's actually doing in power.
C. Derick VarnBut how how do you how does something like Yellow Best give you hope that insisting these kind of vague, nameless, neoliberal, globalized forces that it doesn't necessarily have to be this authoritarian nationalist response? Because if anything, that's the the the I I want to give people some hope right now. It's not a very hopeful time.
SPEAKER_00Um to me, the Yellow Vest, yes, that you know, one reason I wrote the book is because I teach a lot of doctoral students and they're always feeling that you know there's so things are going in a bad direction, and they're pretty hopeless about many things. And I thought I would wanted to look at look at what we could see, uh, how transformation might take place. And I guess that the hopeful part about the illness is they really could have gone to the right.
SPEAKER_00I mean, there was nothing when they arrived. There were people in that group who voted for Marine Le Pen and there were leftists. But what happened was that after a few weeks, many leftists and unions supported the illness. Maybe they got it wrong, maybe they didn't understand all the illness, but they began to understand that they shouldn't be frightened of this movement, they should work with the people who were really meeting and talking and and and begin to understand what they were demanding and where what the fundamental precipitants were for what they were doing.
SPEAKER_00And and I think that that was absolutely crucial because they if there hadn't been this input of this somewhat, you know, not everybody in the left is is is that clear or that straightforward, you know, that was a mix. But if there hadn't been that adoption and moving in from all these other kind of more very straightforward progressive movements, I I do think that the L of S might have gone in any direction.
SPEAKER_00And there are examples in France, for example, where in 2013 people had these same in Brittany were very upset about things in agriculture and stuff. And originally they might have they were started by the socialists and socialist mayors, but the haulage companies, the trucking companies, came in and supported it. And it turned into a very nationalist right-wing movement, you know, just and the way it moved. So I think these things are possible.
SPEAKER_00And in this country, I think it's super important. I think the Minneapolis, the way everybody, people came out without like party identification, neighborhoods. I think what's happening now, maybe it's a little bit generationally divided, but I think in this country, in all the neighborhoods that I know, there are groups that are meeting that are worried about, like if they're worried about data banks, or if they're worried about ICE, or if they're worried about, you know, affordability, housing, rent.
SPEAKER_00But these movements are all over this country now, probably more than there has been in a while. And I think the more that groups work together in human form, you know, you can put out a media call, but if nobody's there on the street, if there's no bodies in the street or in the meeting, it doesn't count. You have to have people coming in and and and learning to trust one another and know where the other people are coming from. You can't have a movement that's based in virtuality. You have to understand people.
SPEAKER_00And you understand people best when you see the whole person and their reactions. And I think that's something we've lost a lot of. And I think social movements today, when they bring people in the streets, when they bring people to meetings, when you come to hear whoever it might be, you're learning who those other people really are. When you see the mix that comes to a meeting, the mix that comes to a demonstration, I think you're learning to trust that mix and not to just think that you're the only kind of group that you can believe in, you know.
SPEAKER_00So I do think that what I would say in the United States is that we have an opportunity now. We are not under fascism. We do not get shot when we not everybody, when we walk in the streets. We we so far we still have the vestiges of a democracy. And it's really, really, really, really crucial that we use those vestiges to meet in person and to march, or to it doesn't have to be march, to go to meetings, to do canvassing, to do whatever you think is important, to take over a building, to work on a rent strike, to go with a union, but in person.
SPEAKER_00I think that that is how what I talk about thresholding and commoning, build actual trust and understanding across very disparate groups. And I think Black Lives Matter did that, and I think that that's uh I think Black Lives Matter, by the way, I just say this because you brought up COVID. I think they saved minority populations from COVID. They they had the highest rate of COVID in the first year, and after people understood that they were not being recognized, people among the minority in Native American population, the black population, they became the ones who really used the masks and understood the vaccines and more.
SPEAKER_00And it was in the red states that people died of COVID because they didn't have those social movements. So I do think that social movements can save lives. And even if we don't win everything, I think we need to work as hard as we possible, meeting one another to build and maintain the vestiges. One of the things I have a problem with is the idea that let things get worse. That's an old Marxist idea, which drives me nuts. And like, no, we have to maintain.
SPEAKER_00Rosa Luxemburg said this, but she's not the only Marxist. We have to maintain the world of democracy, whatever we've got, the freedom of speech, the freedom of movement, whatever we can maintain. Other people haven't got it, even in our society, but you have to struggle to fight to keep that in order to get a social transformation where you can work together for something better. I think that's like something many Americans, maybe, and young people especially, uh, their despair with the political system leads them to feel that they they don't even want to make it better or they don't want to save it.
SPEAKER_00And that is a terrible, terrible loss to this democracy. And that's why I'm very, very, very happy about Nandani in that sense. I may not agree with all the things, but the fact that he gave people hope to move forward together and fight for this democracy in a democratic way. And his father's an anthropologist, by the way. Just so you know, I don't know where he got his ideas. I'm just teasing. But I think it's very important that people meet each other face to face and work together face to face to save whatever we have.
SPEAKER_00And if you want to do change, you have to start with some level of freedom of speech, maintaining the level of freedom of speech, freedom to vote, freedom of movement, which we're losing by the minute, and we have to fight for. That's my feeling about the hope in this country. Yeah. If that helps.
C. Derick VarnIt does. Thank you so much for for this conversation. Where can people find your work, Dr. Sosa?
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, it's open my work. I have a wiki, you can find all the articles there. And and and I did write a book about New York City and the fiscal crisis up until 2012. So that long movement from 75 to and it was on based on field work starting in 75. So those questions. But you that's not open access. But my book, this book, you just look up my name, anywhere it's sold, you can download it for free, like on Amazon, Rutledge, wherever you go, rutledge.com, or even it's sold on Amazon, there's a place to download it for free.
SPEAKER_00This book. And if you go to my wiki, there's many articles you can also download for free at those places.
C. Derick VarnI will this isn't a show not. Thank you for your time, and I hope you have a great rest of your day. Thank you so much.
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by author, public researcher, and retired professor of psychology Dr. Warren Throckmorton to discuss his book, The Christian Past That Wasn’t: Debunking the...
In this installment of the National Fronts series on VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by writing partner Brandon Lightly to deliver a comprehensive historical and materialist deconstruction of Peronism (Justicialism)...
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by veteran sociologist, author, and activist Dr. Charles Derber (Boston College) to discuss his book Wired for Authoritarianism: American Oligarchies and How to...
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by psychiatrist, writer, and political commentator Dr. Tad Tietze (co-author of Left Flank) to unpack the evolving dynamics of anti-politics and hyperpolitics across...
In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by Howard Polskin, veteran media analyst, journalist, and founder/chief curator of The Righting. Polskin details his daily work monitoring, curating, and analyzing...