Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Varn Vlog

Varn Vlog artwork

From Dawn to Decadence: The Decadent Society

Oct 5, 20261 hr 37 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Welcome to a special, long-form collaboration: The Regrettable Century and VarnVlog combined in our Captain Planet team of pessimism. Today, we are opening up a comprehensive multi-part investigation into New York Times columnist Ross Douthat's landmark 2020 thesis, The Decadent Society: How We Became the Victim of Our Own Success. Drawing its name and conceptual infrastructure from Jacques Barzun’s classic From Dawn to Decadence, Douthat’s work defines a decadent society not as a spectacular moral collapse, but as an advanced state of structural stasis. It is a condition where a society remains remarkably wealthy off of past advancement and technologically proficient off of prior development - what Marxists would define as the crushing weight of dead labor - yet is fundamentally unable to advance any further economically, scientifically, or culturally. Douthat paradoxically kicks off his book by quoting Marxist theorist Antonio Gramsci on the interregnum - the morbid symptoms that emerge when the old is dying and the new cannot be born. We seize on this crossover, exposing a fascinating systemic reality: modern post-liberal, distributist, and traditionalist conservatives are quietly haunted by the exact same structural trends that Marx tracked via the tendency of the rate of profit to fall. They observe secular stagnation all around them, yet must look to Aristotle, Ibn Khaldun, Adam Smith, or David Ricardo to describe it because they are ideologically barred from admitting Marx was right. We parse through the first major horseman of the book - Stagnation - and apply it to our 2026 material realities: The Let's-Pretend Economy: We re-read Douthat's pre-COVID evaluation of tech "unicorns" like Uber and WeWork. We map how this pattern of "let's pretendism" has seamlessly mutated into the massive generative AI and large language model (LLM) bubble - where over-inflated tech valuations run on billions of dollars of burning venture capital while generating zero real-world productivity growth. The Chip Monopoly Mirage: Why the only true driver of physical profitability in the Magnificent Seven stock cluster remains the actual commodity production of silicon chips, while the rest of the tech ecosystem functions as an elite real-estate leasing scam. The Demography Bomb: A preliminary look at the collapse of global social reproduction. We track why the aging out of the Baby Boomers and the severe contraction of global birth rates have left the imperial core, Europe, and China facing identical structural resource deadlocks. The Geopolitical Quagmire: How the escalating cost structures of the permanent arms economy prevent the Western core from manufacturing basic munitions efficiently, trapping modern empires into proxy-war management. We strip away the shallow, vibes-based discourse of the modern culture wars to map out the long-durée arc of a global system running out of track. Send us Fan Mail Musis by Bitterlake, Used with Permission, all rights to Bitterlake Support the show Crew: Host: C. Derick Varn Intro and Outro Music by Bitter Lake. Intro Video Design: Jason Myles Art Design: Corn and C. Derick Varn Links and Social Media: twitter: @varnvlog blue sky: @varnvlog.bsky.social You can find the additional streams on Youtube Current Patreon at the Sponsor Tier: Jordan Sheldon, Mark J. Matthews, Lindsay Kimbrough, RedWolf, DRV, Kenneth McKee, JY Chan, Matthew Monahan, Parzival, Adriel Mixon, Buddy Roark, Daniel Petrovic,Julian, Drea, Free Beer, SNT-BRCH, Joshua Parsons

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

C. Derick VarnHello and welcome to Regrettable Century and Varmblog together and our and our Captain Planet team of pessimism. Um with our powers combined. And yeah. Yeah, you know, I have a thesis that inconsistently conservatives really do actually believe in the tendency of the rate of profit the fall, because most of them believe in secular stagnation, but they'll never admit that that's what they believe in, because they would have to admit that Marx was right, although I don't know why, because they could get it from Aristotle, Ibn Kundun, Adam Smith, Ricardo, Aquinas.

C. Derick VarnI can go through people who mentioned the tendency of the rate of profits to fall in markets throughout early history, and yet they don't believe in it, and yet all of them selectively, selectively, because one of the things I'm gonna talk about when we talk about Ross Dunhat here is how frustrating he is because he's inconsistent. There's another conservativist libertarian, Tyler Cohen, who was super, super big on secular stagnation, and then like the moment AI came out, he just dropped it like a rock and pretended he never believed in it, and then you know, so people are super selective.

C. Derick VarnBut we we're gonna cover part one of this book, The Decadence Society. So you guys want to know where we're pulling from, and it is inspired by the namesake of this series. I guess we should probably talk about this book, but it's really long, which is from dawn to decadence. That's why we called it from dawn to decadence. Is it's a it's a famous book that I read probably in 1999 by the conservativist but brilliant scholar Jacques Barzon.

Regrettable ChrisIs it Daw Fat or Do that or whatever? Yeah, I don't know.

C. Derick VarnI'm gonna call him I've I used to call him Donut, but that's Dow Fat or Dooth, whatever.

Regrettable ChrisBut he references he references that book like a lot in in this book, yeah.

C. Derick VarnCorrect. This book is highly pulling from that book. You know what? Screw it. We should actually talk about that book eventually. It's just long, but it's history. That's our fields. Well, it's really yeah, and it's and we and we just should. Yeah, yeah. I mean, if we're gonna name if we're gonna name a series after somebody and then not cover his book on the topic that we're talking about, that is a little weird. Yeah. Uh I just uh haven't looked at that book in like 20 years, and it's long, it's like 700 pages, but it's not hard to read if I remember correctly.

C. Derick VarnI read it in like a month as undergrad in college, so okay. Let's talk about who Ross Doe Hat is. I mean, there's controversies about him because apparently he's you know he's a vaguely fascioid. He's a big Franco fan, apparently.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, he's a uh isn't he a Catholic sort of social conservative, but not economic conservative, which is stepping into some dicey territory to most people if they think about it, if they don't think about it enough.

C. Derick VarnRight. Well, I mean, he he comes from what I can tell from a distributist can tradition that is a type of Catholic quasi corporatist not quasi, yeah. Straight up corporatism.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, it was it was the first corporatism, I think. Right, yeah.

C. Derick VarnHe comes from that sort of like uh economic theory. However, I'm just gonna say if you read him in the New York Times, he's remarkably inconsistent. So sometimes he's a post-liberal you know, Roman Catholic who's who's advocating for distributed and sometimes he's just a blow-hard conservative. It depends on his mood that day.

Regrettable ChrisHe's a he's also gets bogged down in a lot of silly culture war nonsense too, sometimes.

Regrettable JasonYeah. Yeah. I mean, he suffers from the what is quite typical and standard for American conservatives, which is that they uh they are liberals, they don't want to be, but they just are.

C. Derick VarnHe's interesting though, because I think uh to his defense, I think he's more aware of that than a lot of the other conservatives. One of the things I'll get the post-liberals is like they're aware that they are liberals, they're also aware that they don't want to be, hence why they're post and not something else. I I I see this movement was really popular during Trump 1, Trump 2 has really discredited it. A lot of these people have either turned tail or been very quiet, do hot's not one of them, or Dunhat, or whatever the hell.

C. Derick VarnWe're gonna fight a we're gonna try to figure out. I should listen to like for a guy who's a famous New York Times planet, you think I would have listened to an interview with him if somewhere pronounces his name, and yet I haven't.

Regrettable ChrisWell, I've heard the the Chapo guys ref refer to him as Dow Fett, and then of course they also call him Donut or whatever. They just went if they're making fun of him, they'll fuck his name up on purpose. But I think it's Dow Fat.

C. Derick VarnAll right, so Dow Fat, we're gonna go with Dow Fett. If anyone actually knows, feel free to phonetically spell it in the show notes or in the comments. So he's heavily influenced by G.K. Chesterton, C. S. Lewis, and Jacques Brazon. He offers, you know, the standard critique of the of the Western secularism. I mean, I can go through his books, Privilege, Harvard and the Education of the Ruling Class, proving that even as early as 2005, conservatives realized that you could use liberal tropes to make conservative points.

C. Derick VarnAlthough that's hardly new. Grand New Party in 20 and 2008, Bad Religion, How We Became a Nation of Heretics, uh Chrysle like this. It it's basically a call for for people becoming Catholic and not and to get all this Anne Rand shit out of the GOP. And which, you know, I guess he was right about that. That happened. Bad religion.

C. Derick VarnOh no, I already mentioned that one. To change the church, Pope Francis and the future of of Catholicism, whining about how the Pope is too woke before it was cool, the decadent society, the deep places, a memoir of his illness, and believe what everyone should be religious.

Regrettable JasonSo you know that's a good example of what I mean, like Francis. Pope Francis is way more in line with traditional Catholic uh social teaching, which Ross Douthet uh is is nominally he is that that's what it means to be a conservative Catholic, but whatever. Also, I just listened to just now the interview with him, and the interviewer calls him Douthet. Dothit, okay, Douthet?

C. Derick VarnYeah, all right, there we go.

Regrettable ChrisUm I like Donut Hat better than the hat.

C. Derick VarnYeah, so most of what he's written about is like cultural stuff. I mean, to me, he's like a slightly more intellectually serious Ron Dreyer. That's who I think about him as.

Regrettable ChrisThe Benedict Option dude.

C. Derick VarnYeah. Benedict auction, crunchy conservatives, editor of the American Conservative magazine. He went he Catholicism got too woke, so he became Orthodox.

Regrettable ChrisThat guy.

C. Derick VarnYep, yeah. He went through the religions because at one time he was an evangelical, you know. Yeah, there's a lot of those guys.

Regrettable ChrisNow he lives, now he lives in he's divorced from his wife and lives in Romania with a bunch of strapping young lads on like writing writing not gay critical commentary of the United States from Romania.

Regrettable JasonListen, if you if you don't have a parade and you don't dress like a person out of parade, then you're not really culturally homosexual. No. The decadent thing is the celebration of gay, of being gay, not so much being gay.

C. Derick VarnYou know what's funny is even though we're joking, I do think that's an argument I've really heard. Oh, yeah, definitely. So this book that we're talking about today is The Deccan Society, How We Became a Victim of Our Own Success, aka Straw Men Make Good Times, Good Times Make Weak Men, We Make Make Bad Times the Book.

Regrettable ChrisBut slightly more serious than that. Like there was, I think there's a lot to agree with in here, but yeah, that is essentially the the book.

C. Derick VarnI was really frustrated with the fact that of the you know, except for that literary piece where we went through the different theories of decadence historically, that this was my favorite thing we've read so far.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, actually, I it's very and it was a very enjoyable read, yeah.

Regrettable JasonWell, and also like there's nothing about like that that formulations, you know, the with the the good times and the weak men or whatever. That's like fine, that's true, I guess. I don't I don't think it means very much that you just that doesn't say very much, but it's like yeah, fine, that's true.

C. Derick VarnI mean it's it's it's Ibn Khumdun for for a meme, is what that is. Yeah, like if we like for those of you who don't know, the first Muslim North African sociologist, also probably the first person who invented biological racism. That's actually I know that makes a lot of people uncomfortable because we like to attribute it to Europeans, but it probably wasn't.

Regrettable JasonYeah, we don't like to think about people from North Africa or people who are Muslims as ever doing anything bad.

C. Derick VarnBut what I but other than that, the book that he wrote, which is a prologue pro-logamen in English, and I can't, I'm not even gonna try to say what it is in Arabic, is really great as far as like I mean it's sociology before the Renaissance. It's it's kind of a brilliant book. I read I read a short form of it in English, and then I read I read an English translation of the entire thing a few years ago.

C. Derick VarnBut this uh this is uh a book we uh another thing about it, I'm just gonna point this out. I do sometimes think, man, why why do conservatives sometimes take our ideas more seriously than we do? I mean, like, I that is not true for the economics of Karl Marx, where like every conservative catrique's like, if you had read more than three pages in Capitol Volume One, you would shut the hell up.

Regrettable JasonLike, you're just honestly that's very generous. It's more like if you had read even one page of Capitol Volume One, right?

C. Derick VarnBut when they're not writing about socialism or Marx, they tend to take us seriously, which I mean, and we are talking about a different group of people, like Ross Dunhat wouldn't write like that that Michael Levin book that was you know blamed at blame Marxism for everything for from like his stub toe to Ariana Grande.

Regrettable ChrisBut anyway, someone needs to pay for Ariana Grande.

C. Derick VarnI just want to read the first two damn epigrams in this book. The crisis consists precisely in the fact the old is dying and a new cannot be born. In this interregnum, a great variety of morbid symptoms appear. Who says that? Who is he quoting? He's quoting Gramsci, he's quoting Gramsci positively, I may add.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, um, and then I was like, hmm, we're not dealing with the normal conservative here. He's not mocking Gramsci, he's actually like quoting him positively, right?

C. Derick VarnAnd then pity this busy monster, menum kind, not progress is a comfortable disease, e coming. And but we start off in the book with the introduction and an anecdote about Norman Mailer talking about the assassinations of the 60s and the 70s. Then he goes through Challenger explosion, and we get this line resignation haunts our present civilization across human history.

C. Derick VarnThe most dynamic and creative societies have always been almost inevitably, that almost is actually quite interesting, expansionary, going outward from tribes and cities and nations to put their stamp on a larger world. Sometimes this has meant settlement and sometimes conquest. Sometimes this has meant missionary zills, sometimes simply exploration for the sake of commerce and curiosity. In the case of the modern West, the first the first world civilization it meant all of them: God and gold and glory, settler societies and far-frung imperial rules, races to the poles and to the peaks, the sprawls of roads and railroads and steamships, and airline routes and communication networks that have bound the world's peripheries into a universal web.

C. Derick VarnNow, I could put that beginning with the with the fact that with the trans historical generalization and this and the second sentence removed in almost any damn book written by a Marxist.

Regrettable JasonYeah. Yeah.

C. Derick VarnI could.

Regrettable JasonThe thing is, it shouldn't make people uncomfortable. What it should do is it should tell them that, like, hey, some of this stuff is worth actually engaging with, which is, I think, yeah, a big part of the the logic behind this series, actually.

C. Derick VarnYeah, right.

Regrettable ChrisI would even say fascism is gonna get in you and make you bad if you read it. You're gonna that's true.

C. Derick VarnYeah, yeah. Instead of instead of Hitler particles, it's it's it's it's Mussolini miasma, is what we're gonna be dealing with.

Regrettable ChrisUh-huh. What's his name? Damn. Shit. If I was smarter, I would remember the French guy that came up with uh the radical integralism. Charles Mora. No, he was he was the Action Francais guy. The oh, the other he was a priest, he can and he's the one who came up with uh radical integralism and like which isn't necessarily fascist, but it sure did inspire a lot of fascists.

C. Derick VarnYeah, and a lot of post-fascists go back to it too, actually. Yeah, you know, like like fascists in uh Latin America often almost never called themselves fascists, they're either phalangists or integralists.

Regrettable ChrisThat's usually what yeah, the Brazilians were integralists, and what's interesting about the Brazilians is they were like explicitly like multicultural Brazilian, like black and Native Americans, and then Portuguese. Yeah, yeah. I'm sure they were probably racist against somebody that I don't know about yet because I don't understand Brazilian unassimilated indigenous, I believe.

C. Derick VarnUh probably that makes sense. But anyway, skip a paragraph and then I'm gonna read this. Indeed, because the deep forces of modern history, industrialization, political centralization, secularization so often disrupted the rims of life, lived in stability, in place, and continuity, the ideology of exploration and discovery has been much more necessary than in many past civilizations, offering a new form of consolidation to replace what faith and tribe and family and hierarchy once applied. Now, having just read uh Alexander Dugan's uh Four Political Theory and rereading a bunch of Christopher Lash since I recently wrote a book with Daniel Tutt that mentioned Christopher Lash's change in the 1980s, I feel like I've read that line in a bunch of places.

C. Derick VarnUm now, I I would also say that it's a little bit broad and vague, but not incommensurately so. What I find very interesting about this book, I'm gonna go through I'm not gonna go through all this beginning line by line, but is one, and this is something I like about conservative theory, even if it's also a problem, they are actually very good at using anecdotes to make their point as opposed to verbiage to make their point.

C. Derick VarnAnd two, I find it quite interesting how his four hearsmen here in these first four chapters. So we have the introduction, and basically it is pull from Jarbazon, although interestingly, I could have taken Christopher Lash's 88 book, The True and Only Heaven, and also would have gotten a lot of the same things. And but the definition of decadence for Dothit, Dothat?

C. Derick VarnYeah, yeah. Doth it. Yeah, I was right the first time is is Jarc Balzon's definition, which is part of why we're gonna have to read that book, that a decadent society is a state of society where society is wealthy off of past advancement and technologically proficient off of prior development, Marxist dead labor, Marxist dead labor, but is not able to advance anymore scientifically, spiritually, economically, etc.

C. Derick VarnAnd you know, this is the whole frontiers are closed, which you know, we could go into the if we wanted to be really good leftist, we could talk about the settelo-cromonial nature of frontiers, but I'm gonna spare you for that. Institutions are are frozen, stagnated, and over bureaucratic, and culture is in a repetition compulsion because it has run out of any of new ideas, even by combining old ones. Right. That's his definition.

Regrettable ChrisSo he's uh basically quoting David Graber there when talking about technology, also. Yeah. Yeah. And he he uh he's sights graber also earlier in the introduction, which I thought is interesting, and also Thomas Pickety is less interesting because that's like a a normie leftist that conservatives take seriously.

Regrettable JasonYeah, I just thought it was interesting, not so much interesting, but like it's refreshing that there's like a smattering across the spectrum of influential ideas, like these thinkers, these are people who are worth, you know, whatever. It's just kind of nice, like, oh, this conservative book. And in the introduction, he says, including people like Piggotty and Graeber, it's like those are people that I would I would suggest or I would mention.

C. Derick VarnYeah. Although my secret, my secret contention that Graeber is actually not is actually way, way more conservative than Graeber himself realized is probably not helped by this kind of stuff.

Regrettable JasonNo, um no. I think you're right about that. It's just like how Piketty is also not really. I would mention Piketty if I was talking to somebody who I wouldn't be able to mention Marx to, but otherwise we just say he's a social media. Yeah, there we go.

C. Derick VarnYeah, he's a and he's a social democrat, not from a Marxist, even a reformist Marxist tradition. He's a social democrat from a Keynesian tradition, right?

Regrettable JasonYeah, he's he's a post-second international social democrat. Right.

C. Derick VarnWell, a post-1940 social democrat.

Regrettable JasonYeah, he's a post, he's a post-war social democrat.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, but the social democracy that was allowed to coexist with Gaulism in France, because that's he's French, I believe.

C. Derick VarnYeah, yeah. Uh that book is uh too damn long, but actually not terrible, even though I tore it up when it came out from a Marxist perspective. And I also don't feel totally I'm gonna be honest. I read that book, I did finish it, but I read it like a marathon sprint because it was so damn long, and there are whole sections that I'm like, I don't remember what that was because I just kept plowing through. So, stagnation is our first chapter, and I find this interesting because one, oh, hold on.

Regrettable ChrisThere was a quick bit I wanted to read from the end of the intro before we move on. And this, you know, this brings us back to square one of collaboration here. What fascinates and terrifies us about the Roman Empire is not that it finally went smash, wrote W. H. Auden of the Last World Empire and its endless autumn, but rather that it managed to last for four centuries without creativity, warmth, or hope. There was nothing left that could conquer Rome, G.K. Chesterton wrote on the same theme, but there was also nothing left that could improve it. It was the end of the world, and the worst of it was that it would never end.

unknownYeah.

Regrettable ChrisAnd of course, that is he's talking about the United States there.

unknownYeah.

Regrettable ChrisBut yeah.

C. Derick VarnBut this is this is something that I found really, really, really fascinating. I've been I was reading John John Michael Greer, who's this weird like druid who's also was in the peak oral and the aughts, and he's like a Burke and conservative quasi socialist who also like doesn't really like the Republican, you know, one of those weirdo types. And he wrote this book called The Long Descent about collapse, but like collapse.

C. Derick VarnFor most societies, it is not quick and it's uneven and it's punctuated. So there'll be periods where there seems like a lot's falling apart at once, and then there'll be decades where it seems like nothing does. But what I find fascinating about these conservatives versus I'm not even going to pit them against liberals. I mean, we can talk about the optimistic Whiggish liberals who are optimistic until their political opponents are in are in office and then they're apocalyptic until they until they go back in charge of the state, do the same things in a more rational and and and less spectacular fashion than their conservative counterparts, but continue on the same trajectory of decline, you know, but call it progress.

C. Derick VarnWe could talk about that. We also talk about like the postmodernist liberals who also don't believe in progress, but also don't know what we mean by that, and they just seem to think stuff is sometimes bad, and maybe the enlightenment was a bad idea, and animal spirits or something. We could talk about those guys. But I actually find it interesting to talk about Marxists who have lost any sense of long duray development.

C. Derick VarnLike, and I'm gonna be an asshole here, David Harvey, who seems to flip his entire conception of like development in the past, depending on the trends in the current moment on the left. So now China's good. Does he explain why it was wrong? Not really.

Regrettable JasonLike, are what's really unfortunate about that is they could just say, yeah, that's because the period of market reforms under Deng Xiaoping and Hu Jintao and Jiang Xi Man began to be transcended or overcome and left behind by the Xi Jinping administration, which is actually the Chinese Communist Party's own perspective.

C. Derick VarnRight.

Regrettable ChrisYou could just agree with that if you wanted to. Yeah.

C. Derick VarnRight. Because Xi is a dialectical synthesis of left and and right tendencies and and socialism with Chinese characteristics. I know the lines. I mean, like, and and the thing is, there's a little bit of truth to him. Sure. Because China is now establishing a 1930s US welfare state to undo some of what Dung did.

Regrettable JasonUm yeah, it really is a uh the idea is uh one step backward so that we can go two steps two steps forward kind of reasoning. And it's it there's a certain degree of it which makes some sense. It but you know whether or not you call it Marxism, and especially if you call it the the highest developed form of Marxism, is another another story.

C. Derick VarnYeah, um many people have heard me debate this. I I I I um my answers on China tend to make everybody man because I'm neither like China is a dirty capitalist just like everyone else, and nor am I like it's socialist and already there and great, which which they don't even say except in a 1982 constitution, which anyway, I'm not gonna get into it.

Regrettable JasonYeah, I think that they were they're they're in their third the the uh officially they're in the third phase of the building of socialism, which is still in the lower form of socialism, and that they're achieving a moderate moderately prosperous society by 2030, and that will enter into the next phase, whatever it's like the 2050, which will be which will they achieve necessary socialist reforms to meet a higher stage of socialism.

C. Derick VarnI don't know where they get their stages of socialism from, you know, because when I I mean I know where they get it like an an outline, which is from Critique of the Gretha program, but like I don't know how they demarcate them really, and it seems to change depending on who's the Polit Bureau, the general secretary of the Politburo at any given time.

Regrettable ChrisSo, like um, but anyway, I'm not sure that the the dingus wing would have been happy to just continue on that trajectory forever. Yeah.

C. Derick VarnSo stagnation. Right now, I have been this is another area where I piss people off where because I am generally anti-overuse of AI. I'm not anti the technology, actually, in in theory, if we engineered it like the Chinese are doing with certain limits and and both what it is deployed to do and how much energy and compute and water we're willing to put towards it.

C. Derick VarnThis is why the Chinese models are more efficient than ours.

Regrettable ChrisThey have like underwater like data centers that they build, so they could just like cool it with seawater and then use like sea currents for power. Right. Um yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

C. Derick VarnYou know, smart shit.

Regrettable ChrisIt takes a massive investment, and it probably is not going to be profitable for a really long time, but you can do that sort of thing if you're the Chinese fucking state.

Regrettable JasonWhereas we're like you you could do that sort of thing if you're any state. The question is only whether you have the political will. That's it.

C. Derick VarnWell, and the productive capacity. Well, yeah, we gotta have the productive capacity.

Regrettable JasonYeah, we can't even build fucking railroads, yeah. Okay, okay, that's true. We could have. If it was 1970, we still could have, but now we couldn't.

C. Derick VarnBut this actually gets to some of the points where where Both it is actually helpful. One, I find it fascinating because usually when we deal with any of these conservative figures, they take political economy and they throw it somewhere else. Like they're like, they're like they they they might care, you know, they might be libertarian capitalists or whatever, or I don't know what the hell Dugan was.

Regrettable JasonAnd I think Dugan believes in political economy.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I don't think he believes in economics at all. Yeah, he believes he believes in will and sorcery, yeah, will funny sorcery and and civilizations. That's what we got. Yes, civilization.

Regrettable JasonOn the first count, I'm sympathetic to Dugan's overall picture that he paints, and then the further on you go, the more I just get super frustrated with where by the end I'm just like Varnram. I'm just like, I hate this. This is dumb.

C. Derick VarnWhereas this book didn't do that to me. I was actually like, this is actually fairly accurate. Why am I having trouble getting anyone on left or right to take this seriously because it's transparently obvious? And I know people go, oh AI, but AI is a problem because it's not profitable, right? It's it it creates a lot of revenue when people confuse that, but there's no AI company that is getting anything but but large amounts of revenue from investment that they're burning and they're realizing they're burning it.

C. Derick VarnAs we're recording, there's all these IBOs opening up, which are clearly them trying to get passive investment to get their last bit of recoup back so they can get out of the market. You know, which happened in the dot-com bubble too. And yet, it's hard to tell people like the economy's been stagnant since the 70s because people people think, oh no, the 90s, the 90s were great. The 90s had a recession in 91, which we all forget happened because it wasn't as bad as the recessions in 82 or the recession in in 2000, 2001, because we had the double whammy of the dot-com bubble bursts and then 9-11.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, the the mega recession of 2007, the long massive amount of people being thrown off of welfare in the 90s that caused a massive uh yeah, economic problem at the lower end of society that people just kind of coloss over because it uh didn't really register on the on the Dow or whatever.

Regrettable JasonYeah, well and if not for the massive increase in available areas for investment in you know, basically everywhere east of uh Berlin, the 90s would have been really, really bad. The reason why people they you know in the IS tradition, economists said things like the 1990s will be like the 1930s in slow motion. The reason why they said that is because that they thought that the USSR and the Warsaw Pact were just gonna exist forever. That just didn't happen to be true, right?

C. Derick VarnWell, I mean, this is the problem that everyone has is uh everything seems to last forever until it doesn't. I will say one of the reasons why I think people think collapse is more is more quick, is that their experience of collapse is the political collapse of the USSR, but not not the 20-year social free fall that happened afterwards. Like, you know, things didn't start to stabilize in Russia till like Putin III.

C. Derick VarnYeah.

Regrettable ChrisSo he had to throw some oligarchs out the window, nationalize their nationalize and monopolize their companies, and yeah, until a bunch of those.

C. Derick VarnRight. Get rid of a bunch of liberals. Uh he really didn't consolidate everything, quite honestly, enough to even start building back a domestic economy sporadically and not really greatly, even now, until the Ukraine war forced them into having to start to make their own uh consumer goods.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, for the for literally the first time in the history of Russian society, they were like, Oh, I guess we might as well have a consumer good and goods industry, and they just laid hands on the ready-made machinery that was like left behind by all the western companies and turned McDonald's into McDougal's or whatever, and then and now you have a Russian consumer economy. Right. I know I don't remember what it's called. It's called like the Russian McDonald's is I don't know. Something incredibly Slavic.

C. Derick VarnYeah, Maxbugniks or whatever. No, no, you can actually look it up. I won't make lame jokes.

Regrettable ChrisSo V Gusno Itochka. Tasty period.

C. Derick VarnLike tasty, comma, period. So the one thing he he actually highlights is he he actually restates a thesis that was picked up by Tyler Cohen until again AI caused him to lose his fucking mind. That we have had massive investment in only one form of technology, and we have increasingly centralized our society in one form of technology.

C. Derick VarnThat is the smartphone, that is communications technology, which ironically, if you know anything about communications technologies in the past, they're not profitable. And I know people are gonna go, yes, they are, Varn. No, they're not. The reason why they're not, the only reason they make a profit, and the reason why everything got turned into intellectual property rights is because this is massive infrastructure that's once it built doesn't require commodity production.

C. Derick VarnEverything involved around it rotates around a rent. However, it is a centralized infrastructure that we now use for every damn thing. I was talking to somebody who wanted to get rid of their smartphone, and they're like, you know, you can't like go to a baseball game now without it because you can't get tickets. You can't go to this. So as a centralized structure, and we're seeing this with AI and cars too. So there's this bill that the conservatives and actually now some liberals are freaking out about it, was passed by the Democrats that with some, but not a lot, of Republican opposition to that, they want to put in this monitoring system that's AI-based, that they don't have that it does not exist yet.

C. Derick VarnThey they're inventing, they want the technology invented to monitor every car on the planet to turn it off if it thinks you're drunk off of your IB movement, or to pull you over, etc. etc. etc.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, that's not fucking ominous at all.

C. Derick VarnI think it's funny because I've been pointing out that, like, you know, all these liberals rediscovered free speech in the Trump administration, and all the people like enemy of the show, Doug Lane, who like used to believe in free speech, but have dropped it now. It's now that it's the Trump administration. Because no one believes any of this shit anymore.

Regrettable JasonRight.

C. Derick VarnBut I I have pointed out that like, you know, it was it was progressives who pushed for tech censorship like crazy to to fight the alt-right and to to fight Russian disinformation, yeah.

Regrettable ChrisUm yeah, right. So and like I saw I saw the election with memes. I saw the the reach that this like Serbian cyber like like disinformation farm that the Russians were funding that supposedly turned the election for Hillary Clinton reached literally hundreds of boomers, and that was it.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I mean this is this is a problem, like information warfare exists between all nations. The biggest winner who propagates it on us is Israel. People are finally noticing that, yep, and are becoming very anti-Semitic in the process, right? Unfortunately, yeah. Um, but but but at the same time, I mean it's real. Here's the but here's the other thing. Every fucking country, even our stupid allies, do it.

C. Derick VarnYeah, I mean, like, I mean, the ones that don't are like Latin American countries because they just have better things to do. Yeah, like um what most of the better things they have to do is make trade deals or avoid us.

Regrettable ChrisSo and I mean you say that Israel is the biggest, and and only probably second to Israel, which it'd be would be us on ourselves, well on ourselves, then the British, yeah, then the EU, then Russia, probably.

C. Derick VarnYeah, uh China does it. China weirdly seems to either not care or not do it very well, though. Like they do some of it, but I think Russia's really bad at it, though.

Regrettable ChrisI think they try to do it, but like the the place where they put their emphasis for informational warfare is never on things that Americans are going to care about, right? Yeah, they never never fight back against the the just ridiculous claims that are made about Russia by the Western media. They always try to like go after things that no one's going to ever believe them on, anyway.

C. Derick VarnYou know who is actually remarkably good at it? So and it surprised me how good at it they were Aran. Oh, yeah, no shit. I was I was like, Y'all are this good at this? Why haven't you been doing this before?

Regrettable ChrisWell, yeah, you should have been doing this since like 1979. Like, you're actually remarkably good at this.

C. Derick VarnBut anyway, I guess they were hoping sending us doctors would make us more copacetic or something. I don't know.

Regrettable ChrisOh, we don't care about people that like add value to society at all.

Regrettable JasonThe thing is, I think that they really were just trying really hard to get along with us, just like Russia was for like a very long time. A very long time. Yes.

Regrettable ChrisWell, I mean, Russia still tried to join NATO.

Regrettable JasonYeah, I mean Putin Putin was Putin still is trying to get along with Trump for sure. Trying to be the more rational nationalistic version of Yeltsin. Right. So it's only been in the last year or a couple of years that really since 2014, that Putin has finally started to shift away from the very conciliatory position that the Russian ruling class has had for a very long time.

C. Derick VarnAlthough he has indicated that once this Ukraine stuff is over, he would love to go back to being conciliatory.

Regrettable ChrisYeah. And like even though it is very clear that Ukraine could not do anything that they do without targeting data, intelligence and other intelligence from the United States, weapons that they are getting from the United States through European intermediaries and stuff like that, he still refuses to name the United States when lambasting the Western forces that are arrayed against him. Because he's still trying to trying to maintain a relationship with Trump.

Regrettable ChrisAnd he knows that if he starts calling Trump out for duplicitousness or helping the the uh Ukrainians get assassination targeting data, then Trump will do something like oh you never never mind, fine. I'm gonna fund Ukraine with all this money that we don't have. We're gonna go a trillion more dollars into debt to fund Ukraine.

C. Derick VarnWell, I mean this is beyond the scope of this, but uh yeah, we do that. I I would say I would say that like I mean, like our opinions on Russia are are close but slightly divergent. One of the things I think that really baffles the people with me is I've actually always thought that we were our aggression towards Russia was actually a concession towards our European allies, which I think makes people uncomfortable. Um, I mean, I can I could see that.

C. Derick VarnYeah, well, like for example, my Don. Uh, if you look at the American posture towards my Don versus the EU posture to my Don, who made that shit worse? It was actually that it was Merkel specifically, and I don't think she was acting on our behalf, I think we were just like, eh, whatever. Like, and once it once it happened, though, we were on the ground.

Regrettable ChrisOh, we had right to take it over, yeah, immediately.

C. Derick VarnBut but picking their leaders for them. But that is the that is what we have done forever, yeah. Like, we we are flies to shit to chaos. Whenever there's chaos, legitimate or otherwise, and this is what this is why like some of our more uh less sophisticated friends can claim that everything is a CAA, because if you really look, as soon as something happens, the CAA is fucking there, like but I'm like, that's a job, is to go and try to take advantage of everything, and they're actually remarkably bad at it sometimes.

Regrettable ChrisThey really are like, yeah, the flies don't cause the shit. Well, not always, yeah. I mean, sometimes they do.

C. Derick VarnLike, I think yeah, there's a dialectic between shit and flies. Um sometimes the shit, sometimes the shit is is you know, like, like when I try to explain my opinion on the on what happened with Ukraine, I'm like, well, Russia felt pinned in by NATO legitimately. He decided to ignore that we had no reason to go any further, though, because we did because it would trick Article V.

C. Derick VarnSo he went in accelerating the situation, blah blah blah blah blah.

Regrettable ChrisAnd as long as he could keep Ukraine divided, it could never enter NATO, right? Because it was always an unstable situation, and that's part of the NATO charter rules, right?

C. Derick VarnWhich is why John Marsheimer and myself did not think he was actually going to go anywhere anywhere beyond the Donbass.

Regrettable ChrisNeither, neither did the Ukrainians.

C. Derick VarnYeah, pretty much nobody did except weirdly Joe Biden, and this one time in the in the history of the world he was right about something.

Regrettable JasonWell, and also the this well, and we'll never know for sure, but the question really should be whether or not they would have, if not for the way that the that the war has actually played out. Who knows?

Regrettable ChrisI don't I think they would have. Joe Biden might have known because Anthony Blinken told Lavrolov when Lavrov said it, can I get a commitment that you're not going to put nuclear missiles in Ukraine if they join NATO? And uh Blinken said, We're gonna fucking put our missiles wherever we want to. Great, lovely. Yeah, so Biden knew that Blinken said that. And that's that recently came out as having happened because I think that what's his name? The Harvard, not Harvard guy, yeah.

Regrettable ChrisThe Harvard guy that was part of restructuring Russia, that's like a big like sort of multipolarity guy now. I don't know. But he he was talking about that for years until the like just recently that it was actually acknowledged that that conversation happened and it was in like The Guardian and everything.

C. Derick VarnJeffrey Sachs, you mean?

Regrettable ChrisSachs, there we go. Yeah, Sachs, for sure.

C. Derick VarnJeffrey Sachs, you mean? Yeah, yeah, yeah.

unknownYeah.

C. Derick VarnSo to get back to stagnation. Oh, right. Although it's I I will tie it in. So one of the things we're seeing today is that our our overhead costs and our supply chain costs are obscene. So, for example, and trying to deal with either the Russians or the Iranians, the the ability to produce enough munitions has been a major issue. Not because we don't have the technology to do it, but because our supply chain costs and our unwillingness to revert back to earlier technology and probably our inability to do so because we no longer have the factories and stuff to go back to earlier technology means that our missiles and shit are like they're the They're super effective, but they're like$60 million to build two of them or something.

C. Derick VarnSomething crazy like that. And this is part of a highly stagnated economy. I find it interesting that this came out in 2020 because he was writing about the economy when everybody thought it was hot in 2016 to 2020, or from about 2014 to 2020. Right? And you have all these economists saying GDP is great, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. But when you look at what we got for GDP, like GDP, what were GDP bro frent, the only major thing I can think of in tech that happened was the invention of the of the smartphone.

C. Derick VarnAnd then when you think about that, until AI, there was no significant new infrastructure investment beyond just tweaking smartphone tech for almost 15 years. If you think about to the 80s or the 90s when we first got internet technology, how quickly were there advances? Like, if you got uh a Commodore, like in 1984, and then you looked at like a Dell from 2002, they were light years apart.

Regrettable ChrisRight. Big difference between computers now and 10 years ago is that they're way more expensive, right?

C. Derick VarnAnd and and they need a lot more RAM for all the AI bullshit in every program that doesn't be it isn't needed to be done there, and the AI bullshit's only there, and this is another that going back to those IPOs, because investors were subsidizing their use. So when we have to start paying for the actual cost of power and production, as Microsoft found out with anthropic this very month, it's cheaper to go back to using people.

Regrettable ChrisYep. That is hold on, I'm I'm forgetting this. Uh, is the section that where he talks about Uber's business model in this chapter? Yep, it is.

C. Derick VarnThe stuff in fact I'm looking straight at it. Okay, the story of Uber so far. This is from 20, this is from like 2019. Yeah, it isn't a pure Inagram fantasy like the Fire Fresh Festival or Naked Fraud like the Reynolds. And I think we forget during the hot economy, most of the major inventions were like we work and the Raynos, and just like literal scams. Patrick Boyle, the financial economist, has talked about how or or even let let's or even let's look at like uh SpaceX right now.

C. Derick VarnUm Elon Musk is the richest man in the world, now trillionaire. Although I'm gonna remind people that's mostly off of equity promises and and uh debt holdings. That means that until he goes to valorize that trillion dollars, we don't know if it's fictitious or not, right?

Regrettable JasonBut anyway, it's all imaginary, so we don't really know, but I think we could say it probably is. It probably is.

C. Derick VarnWell, the question is is he gonna suck enough enough money out of people's pensions and dumbass retail investors who didn't notice it it's easy to get in and very hard to get out of the trade for at least a month, yeah, and until at least after the first profitability reports come in. But even a functional I I brought this up on a live stream yesterday. Well, uh, I guess when this comes out, it will be months ago. But like Anthropic was valued at 780 billion, its revenues the one time it turned to profit at all was 20 billion.

C. Derick VarnWalmart is valued at 720 billion, its revenues are like 740 billion. What does that tell you when you're looking at like these AI companies? There is a 760 billion dollar difference between between valuation and on the one AI company that's ever turned a profit at all. We're not talking about NVIDIA, we're not talking about the data centers that have been profitable, we're talking about the actual product.

C. Derick VarnThe only one that has ever turned a profit is anthropic. And as soon as they started turning a profit and pricing correctly, what happened? Enterprise scale users started dropping them, and now they're in conflict with the United States government. So who knows again? So who knows how any of this is gonna work. Now, what I find funny is Doffitt won't admit that Donald Trump is basically proof of the extent of the decadence. This is my big problem with these posts with these post-liberals, is like who they think fit fixes the problem exacerbates all the problems that they're complaining about, like every single one of them.

C. Derick VarnYeah. But still, so let's go on uh to Uber. The story of Uber so far isn't pure fantasy. It it managed to go public and maintain its outsized valuation for a while, unlike its fellow money losing unicorn we work, whose recently attempt at an IPO hurled it into crisis. I think we're gonna see this with a lot of these tech, with these tech companies, they're gonna go into crisis again. But like like them, it is for now an example of a major 21st century company invented entirely out of surplus, less economically efficient so far than its rivals, it is supposed to leapfrog.

C. Derick VarnSustained by investors who believe its promises in defiance of existing evidence, floated by the hope that with enough money and market share, it will be profitable, it will be a profitable company will be into existence, and gold washed by an internet company identity obscures the weakness of Rear World Fundamentals, aka you can only really rationalize labor so much and it'd be profitable. Right um, I also think that's why we're things like Uber is why we're not showing up in a recession right now. There's three reasons. Gigifation still pays slightly better than unemployment insurance, which has been weakened.

C. Derick VarnWe have a third of the the male economy have no formal employment that we can tell at all if they were working age. I think the key thing is the working age. I was trying to explain it with retirees because we also have to remember the baby boomers have now finally left the workforce. That's a huge loss. And you had a million people die during COVID. That's another huge loss. And so all these things all together, it means that like you know, you know, we had good, we had decent job numbers this last go-round, although they're all low-end jobs.

C. Derick VarnSo, but the funny thing is, as soon as as soon as we had a decent job numbers, what happened to tech stocks? They tanked.

Regrettable ChrisHey man, I'm telling I'm trying to find a part-time job over the summer, you know, until school starts up again and I get my like funding back. And I gotta tell you, man, I don't know if it's just because I maybe I shouldn't put that I'm as credentialed as I am on my on my applications, but I don't I haven't gotten a single call back yet. It is fucking tough to get a job right now. No, uh maybe I should just yeah, put that I don't have any degrees or something.

C. Derick VarnI don't think it would help you. The job market, the job market right now is most growth is internal. That's why there's also like people have jobs if they already have jobs, but they're not they're not hiring that many new people, and when they are getting hired, it's in gig work or on like services, so maybe hide your credentialing. But even that, like, yeah, there's not a ton of it because the consumer economy for things like low-end fast food and whatnot has just tanked because the prices are so high relative to the bit of the I mean, like the difference between a nice dinner out, a a mid-wit, mid-brow dinner out, yeah, and a McDonald's is now about five dollars instead of about twenty dollars.

C. Derick VarnYep, yeah.

Regrettable ChrisUm, it's actually pretty wild. Like uh on road trips and stuff, it was always like, Yeah, we'll just stop and get some Taco Bell or Burger King because they've got like that the vegan patty or whatever. And getting burgers for me and my my wife, it's like we might as well just have like driven down the road and gone to some like local restaurant and gotten like a decent sit sit-down dinner, you know?

C. Derick VarnYeah, that's what I do now because it's really for the for the the difference in cost, it like you might as well uh anyway. I've actually talked about this in terms of in terms of meat. Well, this actually is related to Dufos' point, even in terms of like things like meat are vegetables, like good quality meat, good quality vegetables, right? I used to, you know, you used to buy like mid-tier stuff because that's what you can afford, but now the mid-tier stuff's so expensive that the nicer stuff is not as the it's still expensive, but the price difference between it and the low-tier stuff makes it harder to justify not just buying the better cut or the better vegetable quality or whatever.

C. Derick VarnSo I think all this is very interesting because one thing that has kept all of this together, and Dufot's actually right, is massive amounts of speculative investment. And that was true both in the 2007 and now. And I think what Dufat would argue, and I think he or Doffitt would argue, and I think he might be right about this, is that the way we were floating things uh in the 90s was private debt held by individuals and keeping consumption up that way.

C. Derick VarnThe way we did it after the Great Recession was both private debt by individuals, more and more like pay-to-purchase schemes, and then massive amounts of using securities and quantitative easing to make toxic debt not toxic by basically shielding it with with reclaimings, which put it you know at like negative interest rates, so which flow which flooded the global market with investments, because between us and between us and Japan, you could actually leverage debt to to even low profit margins and make your income go away, but also still turn a profit, which you can't do right now, but you could for about 15 years, and that's when everything started really picking up into forms of rents.

C. Derick VarnAnd you and I talked about why this isn't neo-feudalism, but there is a real problem here because these rents are dependent on there being some basis for the because when people are like, Oh, it's neo-feudalism, like okay, if it's actually feudal, how are you gonna pay for all these rents when there's no jobs? And no one has an answer at all. Yeah, like they might be like, Oh, MMT, and I'm like, Well, the thing about MMT is to have your currency as part of the world reserve currency, and that's for MMT to work, you have to pay out on your bonds, and our bonds are getting really goddamn expensive, yeah.

C. Derick VarnSo, yeah, and they're like, Well, you don't really need bonds, and I'm like, then you're more of a fantasist than I am.

Regrettable JasonI mean, some people do do say uh a UBI ought to take care of this, and uh UBI the UBI would inflate everything. Well, I mean, I don't think those people are serious, even if they do seriously believe this. I just don't think they are to be taken seriously.

Regrettable ChrisIsn't that like the Jacobin line right now? Or like one of the ones that's prominent.

Regrettable JasonYeah, yeah, yeah. It's also Elon Musk says the same thing.

C. Derick VarnYeah. So like Bernie Sammons and Bernie Sanders and Sam Altman have been together on things too. I just I've found this all like we are out of ideas.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah.

C. Derick VarnRight.

Regrettable ChrisSo doubt that or doubt it, dooth it, whatever, calls this let's pretendism. Like that's what our economy runs on, is let's pretendism. The uh idea where the cutting edge of capitalism is defined by the promises that by promises that never fully materialize and technologies that have almost arrived, or tech business models that are on the way to profitability.

C. Derick VarnWell, what amazes me, for example, Tyler Cohen, who's actually mentioned in this chapter when he talks about the limits of neoliberalism and the stagnation that comes from neoliberalism itself, Tyler Cohen immediately abandoned for all this AI garbly go because they're desperate too. But I think Duffett is actually correct that this that'll follow the same pattern. I don't know if he has said that. I feel like he's been weirdly quiet on AI, but but I don't read his column every week, so I don't know.

C. Derick VarnBut I I find it interesting how he kind of I'm like I want to compare two books. Let's compare Catherine Liu's Virtue Hoarders to this book. Which one has a better explanation for why we have such a service-driven economy? Gothit. Because Catherine Liu makes it sound like it's just the evil PMC giving themselves jobs. Yeah, that's true.

C. Derick VarnAs does David Graber.

Regrettable JasonI mean, as do most people who are like you know, on the left. That's what they say.

C. Derick VarnYeah, and most people on the right. The thing is, one if they if that class of people is so powerful, how did Elon Musk defeat them with just the president letting them fuck around with shit in a month? And two, defeat them so thoroughly, he almost sent the government in chaos. And two because I I find this fascinating when people are like, oh, we still have a PMC problem. I'm like, we do in attitudes and training and habitas, but the idea that they're in control, you can't have watched the last year and believe that.

C. Derick VarnLike seems to me like the worst, least productive elements of finance capital and technological rentierism are in control. Yeah. Still, always we really want to look at the long durée of policies. Whose fault is that? Barack Obama.

Regrettable ChrisYeah. That's not even that long of a duray. Where did you have to look at that far away?

SPEAKER_03But like where did Starbucks right not a yeah.

C. Derick VarnI was uh I mean, it's you know, it was what 16 years ago now, but yeah. How did Elon Musk become the richest man in the world? Government car track contracts with SpaceX, which led to his development of Starlink. All his other companies are just money burners, yeah, with the exception of Tesla. But how was Tesla profitable selling carbon offsets?

Regrettable JasonWell, right, and also protectionist measures when it comes to trade, because there are like two different Chinese EV audio auto manufacturers, which are like way more they're advanced and cheaper, yeah, way more advanced, and they're way cheaper, way cheaper, way cheaper, and and they're cheaper than our normal cars to be meant to be. Yeah, Tesla would would would tank overnight if China's Chinese EVs were allowed in into American markets, right?

C. Derick VarnSo we have no we we our innovation isn't all that innovative because it can't actually stand up to foreign competition, which we've seen before that happened in the late 1960s, too, and it's what part of the led to the 70s stagnation. But I think it's interesting that anyone with a brain, except for certain kinds of progressives, and I'm very serious about this because progressives who tell me everything that happened in the 70s was a policy choice. And I'm like, why did they make the policy choice though? Dipshit. Yeah, just ideology. Yeah, that's not how ideology works, it's not just a bad idea.

Regrettable JasonYeah, they actually what that does is that takes the the the basic relationship and the inverts it where like ideas kind of just exist out of nowhere, and then because of the ideas, the material conditions are transformed around them.

C. Derick VarnSo I think this is actually quite interesting to me because what we see here is this thing that both relatively smart conservatives realize and Marxists realize are why Marxists get called conservative by MMTers and other heterodox economists, because we do not think there was an easy policy out of the 70s stagnation, that it led to neoliberalism, and that was a policy choice.

C. Derick VarnIt was organized, but it was not organized. Even Vivek fucking chiver pretends like it was just a fucking political conspiracy.

Regrettable JasonI mean, that's uh that's basically um what's his name we were just talking about? Him, Harvey, David Harvey Harvey, Graeber. They they all they all do that, and while it was like neoliberalism was a political project, and I think it was a political project, but it wasn't primarily or even in the first instance, it's that it was the political project was neoliberal economic school of management because of the economic necessity, which was definitely not a political project, right?

C. Derick VarnNow, I do believe there are if we want to get really technical, neoliberal also was not inevitable because there were other policy choices you could have made to restore profitability. The problem is all of them would have been also pretty bad. Like, how do we restore profitability in the beginning of the 21st century, getting out of the Great Depression and the Long Depression? Wars, yeah.

Regrettable ChrisLike we just destroy capital, and then you can make new capital, right?

Regrettable JasonBut the permanent arms economy was already in place by because of the war. So when you have a new when you have a new crisis, you can't make a new permanent arms economy because it's already there.

C. Derick VarnRight. So uh and we have already seen that the permanent arms economy is also now inflated the shit. There's broken supply lines. Other ways you could have handled it.

Regrettable JasonYeah, the Chinese they had better play nice because we need the the material that we're gonna get from them to make the weapons to counter them. The other way you could have handled it would have been massive social infrastructure investment, but you know, well, there's also there's another thing, also, it's not it's not it, it was not inevitable because we also could have just stopped doing things for profit, but that would have meant like you know, yeah, socialism, right?

C. Derick VarnBut I mean, but the thing is, like, are the bourgeoisie gonna do most of these things? Because, like, if they did massive public sector investment, they're probably pushing us closer to the conditions where socialism is somewhat easier to achieve. Like you go back to the Kowski era contention that we like most of the ways political revolution really that's gonna be required here, and even then there's no proof that because what makes massive social investment not as good for them in a lot of ways, you're like, oh well, it gets rid of excess capital so they can restart it.

C. Derick VarnIt does, but here's the problem it also makes the labor force slacker. I mean, so slacker for them, I mean, not slacker, uh tighter for for them, not for us. So it's slack for us, so there's more jobs, so we can choose, and we have bargaining power if there's a large public sector job set uh things that we can go into that can compete or is competing with with capital.

C. Derick VarnSo I think that's true. I also think, and this this might make a lot of people uncomfortable, the dung has subsidies to us offsetting service inflation, which it really was. So the reason why our our after the 1970s we could be a reserve currency and have all these advantages in trade is that we were willing to make our production costs go up. We didn't quit producing at all, we just got rid of the labor because the labor costs were super expensive once you're the reserve currency, which is why China doesn't like do MNT policy, right?

C. Derick VarnLike, think about it. Like, if if you flirt your currency, your production's expensive. So people go into services. We've had services inflation since the 1970s. What is services inflation? Food, not food, not so much, but like education and healthcare are the biggest two services we have. Yeah, costs have skyrocketed, they never stopped, even in the periods of low inflation. So basically, if you look at the trajectory since the 70s, we got commodities under control, neoliberalization, breaking down monopolies for a while, which early neoliberals did, outsourcing the China, increasing automation.

C. Derick VarnSo you got commodity production under control, but can I be production here, which has still been happening, US is still an industrial, even now, although less so, is still an industrial productive society, just doesn't employ that many people. Yeah, right, unless unless all the time, right? And and so but that Offset everyone feeling the services inflation. I mean, we all felt it, but we didn't feel it, feel it. It didn't cause everything else to go up, too.

C. Derick VarnThat's changing now.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

C. Derick VarnI don't know how we get out of our inflation cycles easily. Because if you try to if you try to do production here with massive employment, you have to pay the cost. And if you don't have that, you have a downward spiral where things continue to go up, but the service sector that has been providing the ability for people to buy this stuff goes away. So you know, I guess I'm I'm doing the work for Doffit, but it's very true that we have a problem.

C. Derick VarnWe also have the expansion of rent of rentiers and petite rentiers, aka the PMC, aka whatever. A class that's not a class, aka whatever. Yeah. I call them the I call them the post-petite bourgeoisie and my and my well, I actually didn't end up using that. We call them the new petite bourgeoisie, but I kind of objected to that because they're not new anymore, and they're not actually petite bourgeoisie anymore either. And I explained that in the book, but we kept the category because that's what Polancis used, and Daniel likes it.

Regrettable ChrisI like post-petit bourgeoisie better. Yeah, because it's more true.

Regrettable JasonPost accurate post-bourgeoisie.

C. Derick VarnI mean, Daniel completely agrees with me on what we're describing, though. Basically, most of the professionals who used to be who used to be petite bourgeois are actually now employed for a salary. It might be quite a lucrative salary, but it's a salary. Many of them are no longer paid in stock options. So they're basically labor aristocrats. But all their institutions are geared towards them being petit bourgeois, the universities, the professional organizations, the NGOs that support them, etc., even though they're not anymore.

C. Derick VarnSo they have a potential uh pet bourgeois habitas and orientation, with the one exception that on like like real petite bourgeois, tax rates don't hurt them very much. They actually get helped by it. That's where the revenue comes from.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

C. Derick VarnSo that's a problem, right? It is actually a problem. And I mean that, like, I am all about this the public sector, but your public sector has to exist off of profitability somewhere. Right. And otherwise, I mean, even MMTers actually believe this. If you really read what they say, they say you have to have the production capacity to justify MMT policy, which is like their backdoor way of not admitting, but admitting that production actually matters.

C. Derick VarnWhat they focus on is like the circulation of capital, the circulation of capital, and they focus on it almost solely. So if you think about all this, we have no real way to grow. And Doffet goes even further. It's like there's no clear way to handle this. Even if you have like austerity, the austerity needed to like, I don't know, get the bond market under control and not have it be like the biggest thing we have to pay out on servicing the debt. And it's not just us, there's countries all over the world now getting into this situation.

C. Derick VarnThat it declines. And then he talks about that. This actually leads to constraints on all sorts of things, such as such as education debt, servicing debt. So he he says the weight of demographics and and Marxism is we call it social reproduction crises. Yeah. And then he actually even talks about the depletion and constraints in the environment, which I was also kind of surprised at.

C. Derick VarnYeah, what maybe usually.

Regrettable JasonYeah, whenever some Catholic takes a Catholic position, American Catholics usually see it as some kind of like left communism. Yeah.

C. Derick VarnExcept when it's done by the most reactionary popes ever, who aren't actually all that reactionary just perceived that way. Pope Benedict, who, if you look at his teachings on social stuff, are almost identical to Francis, but no one knows it because his emphasis was different.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, because he was like doubled down on keeping gay people out of the church and women out of the priesthood, like extra loudly, so people are like, Oh, he's a good Pope.

C. Derick VarnYeah, as opposed to Francis, who didn't double down on it but didn't change any of it at all.

Regrettable ChrisLike he was he just used less inflammatory language when talk talking about gay people saying that they needed to be involved in the church because they're sinners, just like anyone else. You know what I mean? So it's like, yeah, that's still not accepting gay people, guys.

C. Derick VarnI find it fascinating. This is this is this chapter of stagnation. There's another David Graeber quote where he talks about Star Trek and then Mark Stein, and he points out that like left and right also both realize that culturally we're stagnating. Yes. And I do feel like to bring back the ghost of Christopher Lash, where I'm sympathetic to him, Lash would say that progressives would gaslight you, and then a lot of Marxists at the time in the 1980s have become progressives, and they would gaslight you by pretending the stagnation was not real.

C. Derick VarnYeah, they still do that. Yeah, well, I mean, I was literally on a podcast yesterday with someone's like, there's no real problem for the American economy. We're still super innovative in medicine. I'm like, when's the last major medical innovation we made? China beats the shit out of us. Like, we don't need to be that's an absurd position to have.

Regrettable JasonAbsolutely absurd. Well, in any way, but especially in medicine.

Regrettable ChrisAll right, we're not even innovative with killing people anymore. Yeah, the one thing we used to be very innovative in. Uh-huh. That's exactly right. We've got, you know, we've Ukrainians and Russians are way outpacing us. Well, to be fair, the Ukrainians are testing the killing technology for us.

Regrettable JasonSo yeah. In a way, in a way, the Ukrainians are us.

C. Derick VarnYou know, although this this book also convinced me that Peter Thiel is is the vampiric evil version of a Marxist. Because he talks about secular stagnation a lot. I didn't realize that Teal did this, but like and Teal uses it to be like, no, we should be accelerationists and just you know, damn if we even save humanity at this point. I'm like, well, what is it even for then? If we're just destroying everything, yeah, he's like a comic book villain. He really is. He's now moved to Argentina, which is a comic book villain thing to do.

Regrettable JasonYeah, Argentina is like a comic book by itself.

Regrettable ChrisDoes he have like a like a fortress in the mountains that like looks like a castle on the outside, but a super high-tech on the inside? Probably. I want to read this.

Regrettable JasonHe at least definitely wants to make that castle, yeah.

C. Derick VarnSo we said we'd get through four of the horsemen. We're gonna get through one of the horsemen. That's pretty that's pretty us, which is the stagnation horseman, but of course it'd be the one that we all like because we're damn Marxists and we're all obsessed with economics anyway.

Regrettable ChrisUm, the next chapter is about population demographic collapse, which is less interesting, but it is still interesting. And this is definitely something we're not supposed to care about as Marxists.

C. Derick VarnI both do and don't. I do actually care about it, but I actually don't care about population growth being eternal, which is what most of these people want. It is a good indicator, though. No, it is. What I would say to some degree a drop in population might be good after the fact, but going through it's going to hurt. Yeah, and that's a big problem right now.

C. Derick VarnWe have we're Europe's in a worse place, but even China is going to be in a situation where there's more people who don't work than do for a little while. And I don't know how that maintains when we're also, you know, if you look at, for example, the amount of money spent per pupil versus the amount of money spent for retiree, I'm not saying let grandma die. I'm really not. But like we're not a society that believes in a future. And I was telling someone the other day, when uh when your last two presidents literally don't have a future more than like 10 years, why do you expect them to plan for it?

Regrettable JasonYeah, that's actually that's that's the single best argument for age limits on the uh elected office, even even though you could also just point to Diane Feinstein's last decade in in office as as an argument. Two decades, yeah, or two decades. But even if if for nothing else you could just say you want somebody who has to live with the consequences of their decisions, yeah.

C. Derick VarnAnd well, I find it interesting that like you have all these retirees and uh the GOP, but they're all young, whereas the Democrats are like they're bimodally distributed in in age, so you have a bunch of new young Democrats in their 30s, and then you have people in their 70s and 80s dying in office, and there's more of the dying in office kind than there is of the other. I find that interesting. But he does he he brings up the population bomb.

C. Derick VarnI do like that people on the left realize the population bomb was also racist.

Regrettable ChrisYeah.

C. Derick VarnUm, this is interesting. I want to read this chapter because uh people might say he was wrong about this. I think he might be right, and I think we might be finding out this year. Decadence is not universal, these promises do at times reflect will breakthroughs, interesting research, generally promising development. But their G Wiz spirit is consistently at odds with the general decelerated pattern of the last two generations. Let yes, there have been strides made in solar, wind, and other renewables, but real energy prices are as high as they were in the crisis atmosphere of the 1970s, and the alternative share of the energy pie is barely higher than back then, and of course, after Trump's gotten a lot worse.

C. Derick VarnYeah. Um, yes, the green revolution of the 1970s made the doom and gloom scenario of Paul Ehrlichs, the author of the population drum, and like-minded alarmists look ridiculous and enabled kind of optimist Julian Simon to win the 1980s era famous bet with Ehrlich over whether commodity prices would rise or fall. But those same prices have risen since the 1990s, while the agricultural yields return to the green revolution have recon have rec have declined, and they're declining faster now.

C. Derick VarnYeah, meanwhile, travel speeds have dropped, transportation innovations have been delayed and delayed, except for in China, and even then, I have been sort of like wondering, you know, while we may get driverless cars in some form eventually, we did, and they suck.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, they're fucking terrible. I'm so stupid.

Regrettable JasonLike even the most unashamed, even the most unashamed fanboys of the various like Elon Musk supporters, whatever, even the thousands of weird nerds who like it from the meme. Nobody thinks that driverless cars are good right now. Like, nobody, yeah.

C. Derick VarnThe Waymo suck, and there's not any indication they're gonna get a whole lot better.

Regrettable JasonI've said like when I was like watching them in LA, where at the first place I encountered them, they they were like they they they they drove like morons, like yeah, and everybody in LA already drives like a moron, so like you don't need to make you don't need to make the artificial.

C. Derick VarnIndeed, beneath the hype and scaremongering about artificial intelligence. Oh my god, you had no idea where that was gonna go in six years, buddy. There's just as much evidence that we're headed for an AI winter. Now, I actually have pointed out that we only got AI in is after 2019, a lot of this money came in that had been just sitting in the Cayman Islands, and it took them forever to figure out how to invest it. We have seen, I will say this we go ahead.

Regrettable JasonJust COVID actually really helped uh accelerate the the basically pull out all of the stops for this for the tendencies to do this.

C. Derick VarnI do think the AI has gotten much better, but the thing is it still hasn't gotten better enough to do non-clerical work any efficiently, really, at least the LLM-based kind, and it produces a ton of slop.

Regrettable JasonLike there's all kinds of downstream effects of that too, like uh television sucks now. Yeah, yep. And also uh very few people work in the jobs which made it not suck, not too long ago.

Regrettable ChrisOh yeah, we've got friends we've got friends in Hollywood, and Jason used to work for in television, and they say that there are there are just no jobs anymore. Yeah, yeah. All all of the jobs are like the all of the jobs except for the ones that cannot be are just gone. They don't exist anymore, they're just automated.

Regrettable JasonOr they're farmed out because you can pay someone in Nebraska like way less than you can pay a person in Los Angeles, yeah.

C. Derick VarnBut but but anyway, all that aside, and all the development and AI aside, you will notice where it's useful is in things that are not particularly that may be profitable, like entertainment was profitable, but they don't it doesn't have that many downstream like product, like it doesn't spur that much new industry itself, right?

Regrettable JasonRight. Like there's there's an end of the line, and the end of the line is still just the project itself.

C. Derick VarnWhich also is only profitable uh at scale because of IP protections, not because of you know commodity protection. But anyway, this is a point where I think he's right, though. Robots have actually taken some jobs, they've taken a lot of jobs, but the robots that took them weren't AI-based, they're just old-fashioned robots. Same things that automated shit in the 80s. You know, they've gotten a little better because they have some better computing to help them out, but they're still there. With particularly disruptive consequences in some industries, and no doubt they will take more, but society being fundamentally transformed by automation would have a sharp productivity growth of the kind we used to have and briefly enjoyed in the internet's first flower and and in the beginnings of automation in the 1960s and 70s, rather than productivity stagnation afflicting both the United States and Europe.

C. Derick VarnAnd by the way, we are for we are like 400% more productive than we were mid-century, but that has not been growing much since the aughts, right? And guess what? There's no evidence that AI has dramatically increased productivity because of the layoff offsets, slows it down, and the amount of hallucinations that you have to correct for. And even when you do have a model like uh like the latest, well, the most the most advanced model just got shut down by the federal government, but the latest Claude model right before that is so expensive to run that like people have just figured out it's cheaper to go back to using people in certain cases, and when they've tried to implement this AI stuff in the meat space world, not in coding and and whatnot, like at McDonald's and shit, it's been a disaster.

C. Derick VarnSo, yeah. We're also he also talks about uh secular stagnation and the medical and pharmaceutical. This is what I was like, this guy mentioned pharmaceutical stuff. We haven't had major pharmaceutical innovation.

Regrettable JasonI mean, we've had pharmaceutical innovation, we have, but we haven't had for example, of Zimbabwe didn't exist in 1990, right?

Regrettable ChrisBut but makes you skinny, destroys your bones, you know, whatever. What do you even need those for, anyways?

C. Derick VarnAnd was not invented for that reason, it was invented for treat diabetes.

Regrettable ChrisAlso, it killed the body positivity movement. Oh, yeah.

C. Derick VarnThat's funny, it kind of did, actually. Yeah, uh, even the podcast I used to listen to that was mostly about it that I listened to because it was like the body positive people were like 80% good until they started talking about science, and then I was like, no, no, as a person who has struggled with weight all my life, no, like thermodynamics exist. I will tell you, getting under 300 pounds did remarkable stuff to my joints, and now that I am consistently in the two 220 to 240 range, I'm a lot healthier, but the damage done from when I was 300 pounds is still here.

C. Derick VarnYeah, it's not as bad, it's still here, and I have x-rays to prove it.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, so you know, that's just the visible damage, too. There's all kinds of damage done to your like organs and you know, even your brain not loving your body enough.

Regrettable JasonIt's just loving it harder, yeah.

C. Derick VarnYeah, well, it's weird to me that I get when I get when I tell people you shouldn't shame people about their weight, it's counterproductive, it doesn't help them. Like, yeah, that's true, yeah. Right, like a lot of the reasons why people are fat are are social problems as food access, bad food systems. Some of the bad food systems are actively subsidized by the goddamn government, like solely for the profitability of farmers, like stuff like that. And it doesn't mean we have to pretend like it's good though, right? But but then I'm like, but it's good though.

C. Derick VarnI'm like, yes, there are outliers at any weight sense who can be perfectly healthy at any weight size, but in general, most people do suffer from a lot of excess weight, particularly you know, when they are over, I don't know, when they are morbidly obese. Like, you know, I'm not even going into the like the the outlier cases on obesity. I know the the data there is is questionable. What I get, and I know that doctors over obsess over like five to ten pounds where there's no meaningful game and longevity.

C. Derick VarnI I agree with all that, but there's this bait and switch where like you're talking about like people who are 190 pounds versus 170, and then you like talk about someone who's 400 pounds, and those are wild. That's very different.

Regrettable JasonYeah, it's a very different, it's a not just a different it's a different order of magnitude, which requires an entirely different scale.

Regrettable ChrisSo it's a different kind of conversation, and like BMI is horseshit because the amount of body, the amount of body fat that you can hold on to and be healthy varies wildly from person to person. So like going over just like height, height versus weight as like the only indicators of like whether or not you're holding on to a healthy amount of fat is totally insane. And uh, that is what they still use. Doctors still use that. Like a buddy of mine who's been lifting weights for like you know 10 years now and is an incredibly large and very strong person, his BMI says that he's morbidly obese, and then he he had to take his doctor a body scan to show him how much of his body was lean muscle compared to fat to make his doctor lay off of him about his BMI being all out of whack.

Regrettable ChrisAnd it's like you should know that, you should fucking know that. Yeah, yeah.

C. Derick VarnI mean, I think that BMI was designed to be also a population measure, not a yeah, like an aggregate statistic, not individual statistic. Like, so there's a lot of stuff in this we we need to start wrapping up. There's a lot of stuff in this, though, that I am with you, but I saw that as a sign of decadence, I saw that as a sign of left giving up. Like when people talk about family abolition and like totally utopian terms, and like, yeah, in some like loose sense, I'm probably more sympathetic to its old 19th century instantiation than maybe you guys are.

C. Derick VarnBut I've also pointed out that like with the family abolition we've got is just the working class not having the means to reproduce itself, yeah. And the high and hyper commodification of human sexuality, even by historical norms. And I don't think it makes me a conservative at all to say that that might not be good.

Regrettable ChrisNo, you know, yeah, I mean that this is actually all we something that we touch on, but have never really like dived into on the podcast. It's just the sort of tendency of the left to have it just really given up on social issues and just to accept whatever horrible shit capitalism forces down our throat as something that's good because it's something that's happening to oppressed people.

C. Derick VarnYeah, and then naturalize it. Yeah. Like and I find this all fascinating. I what it although I have to admit it was interesting reading this chapter because it like all this is pre COVID and it It seems like a million years ago and it's only five. Right. And everything he's talking about, except for AI and like stocks being insane. Like, you know, if you took the magnificent seven out of the stock market and all the AI stocks, like the stock growth is also not good.

Regrettable ChrisNo. The only driver of profitability in our economy right now is all fucking made up. It's all AI. It's gonna be bad.

C. Derick VarnAnd it doesn't like and the only the only thing that has been proven to have profits is the chips. Yeah. Yeah. Like actual profits, not stock profits. Actual profits on the product at hand is the chips. Everything else. And with these IPOs, if history is an indicator, many of these companies are about to blow up.

Regrettable ChrisSo and like, and even when companies are profitable, it's from leasing data center real estate to unprofitable companies. So that that's not something that can sustain itself.

C. Derick VarnNo, I mean, and I'll be honest with you, the this stagnation is not just here. We can talk about how China is handling it way better. They are, but they are slowing down too. They've been slowing down for 20 years. They're just doing way better than us.

Regrettable ChrisThey now have they've got mechanisms to shift things around in ways that we cannot, because that would be called socialism, right?

C. Derick VarnYeah, but there are still some pretty big limits that they're hitting, too. Yeah, there's they also have a demographic bomb that we can talk about. Like when people like, oh well, everyone's got a demographic bomb, I'm like, Yeah, they do. I'm not like blaming China, I'm not like the one child policy was probably one of the bad ideas. But I know why they did it, but I it's probably a bad idea for a variety of reasons. But the both the consumer of the world's goods and the producer of the world's goods, and then it's hanger on the in-between hanger on in Europe.

C. Derick VarnAll three of those societies are about to have demographic bombs go off at the same time. The places where climate change and shit is gonna hit the worst, have demographic expansions that are slowing down. They are they're slowing down, they're slowing down dramatically, actually, but they still exist. Like, if you think about the average age of the person in a person in Palestine or a person in Lebanon or a person in North or South Africa, something like 17, as opposed to the average age of here, which is like 39.

C. Derick VarnYeah, well, you know where the future is, and you're gonna have a bunch of people freaking out over that as well, because as things get worse in climate change, there's gonna be a great movement of peoples, and people are already freaked the fuck out about it.

Regrettable ChrisYeah, so funny how like conservatives really love war and don't want to do anything about climate change, but they also hate immigrants, yeah.

C. Derick VarnYou know, things that create immigrants, they love the things that create immigrants.

Regrettable ChrisLike don't give me the dog. I love reaping, it's so awesome. I mean, I mean, I love sowing. Damn, I fucked my own joke up. Yeah, yeah. I love sowing.

C. Derick VarnDon't give me that shit that they don't love war either. I mean, I do actually will say the average conservative person in even vets does not love war most of the time, right? 30, like 50 of them, which is about 20 of the population, can be conned into loving war consistently. Yes, but I do find it interesting that conservatives in power, even ones that say they don't love war, even ones that sincerely seem to like you like we all thought, I'm one of them, that we might see Trump do crazy shit like in the sphere of influence that he was trying to build.

C. Derick VarnNot necessarily the way he was talking about that, all felt kayfe, but in ways that wouldn't establish tensions and whatnot. I did not really see him just out of the blue thinking that he could Venezuela an Ayatollah. No, like that was not that was not on my cards of even Trump would not be that silly. I was wrong.

Regrettable ChrisUm so like I whenever liberals push back with this, like, we'll see Kamala Harris would have never bombed Iran and never gotten us into this stupid war. I'm like, that's I I don't think that's true.

Regrettable JasonI think she said, didn't she say that she would?

Regrettable ChrisYeah, she did, and so did Hillary Clinton and you know, whatever. You know, every single Democrat in the past since Obama has promised to either take a harsher line with Iran that would eventually lead to war or to actually go to war with Iran.

C. Derick VarnBut like Yeah, Obama's the only one who actually went the other direction, yeah.

Regrettable ChrisSame with Cuba, too. You know, one of the the two good things he did in his fucking presidency. But like, yeah, I I I do think that they would have been less stupid about going to a war with Iran. They wouldn't have gone off half cocked, but they should certainly would have gone to war with Iran.

Regrettable JasonOr at least we should uh maybe wrap up. It's yeah, because it's four now.

C. Derick VarnOkay, yeah. So let's in here. We'll we'll meet sometime soon and do uh let's aim for now that I know how long this actually takes. We'll be doing this book for a while. Let's aim for chapters two, three, and maybe ambitiously four, because I think I think two and three we will go through slightly quicker. Yeah, we gave everybody a preview of two today. Yeah, yeah. And three we covered three might be slow, but maybe not.

C. Derick VarnWe'll see.

Regrettable JasonWe covered a lot, we didn't just cover the first chapter, we also covered the introduction, which is that's true, the whole scope of the book. So it's it's yeah, it's good. Yeah, we did it.

Regrettable ChrisBetter than we usually do, or we don't even make it through like the first part of the introduction in the first chapter. That's that's fair.

C. Derick VarnThat's that's because I'm now taking notes per chapter as opposed to reading the book line by line again. Of fun, but we just can't sustain that. Nope, yeah, nope, not people like, well, you've spent 20 years on or uh not 20 years, but but the little 180-page book that Jason and I read over two and a half years, yeah.

Regrettable ChrisUm the series that y'all did on uh the Patreon, the the Insotraverso book, right? Or not Insotraverso, what was it? Oh uh the disaster nationalism. That took how long? Like a whole year, and it's like 120 days. Yeah, yeah.

C. Derick VarnYeah, yeah. We'll we'll speed up. All right. Yeah. See you guys later. Peace. Bye-bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Yellow Vests & The Battle for Democracy with Ida Susser

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 42 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn sits down with Dr. Ida Susser (Distinguished Professor of Anthropology at Hunter College and the CUNY Graduate Center) to explore her open-access book, The Yellow Vests and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. How History Gets Hijacked By Christian Nationalist Myths with Warren Throckmorton

    Nov 16, 20261 hr 14 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by author, public researcher, and retired professor of psychology Dr. Warren Throckmorton to discuss his book, The Christian Past That Wasn’t: Debunking the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Peronism Explained with Brandon Lightly

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 52 minAudio

    In this installment of the National Fronts series on VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by writing partner Brandon Lightly to deliver a comprehensive historical and materialist deconstruction of Peronism (Justicialism)...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Wired For Authoritarianism with Charles Derber

    Nov 9, 20261 hr 43 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by veteran sociologist, author, and activist Dr. Charles Derber (Boston College) to discuss his book Wired for Authoritarianism: American Oligarchies and How to...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Anti-Politics Still Explains Politics with Tad Tietze

    Nov 5, 20261 hr 34 minAudio

    In this episode of VarnVlog, C. Derick Varn is joined by psychiatrist, writer, and political commentator Dr. Tad Tietze (co-author of Left Flank) to unpack the evolving dynamics of anti-politics and hyperpolitics across...

    Credit the people on this episode